CINXE.COM

<!doctype html> <html lang='en' class=' is-darkModeAdminSetting-enabled '> <head> <meta charset='utf-8'> <title>Language co-option in the open space</title> <meta name='viewport' content='width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0'> <link rel='preconnect' href='https://fonts.gstatic.com'> <link rel='preconnect' href='https://fonts.gstatic.com' crossorigin> <link rel='preload' as='style' href='https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Inter:wght@400;500;600;700&display=swap'> <link rel='stylesheet' href='https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Inter:wght@400;500;600;700&display=swap' media='print' onload="this.media='all'"> <link rel='preload' as='style' href='https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Source+Serif+Pro:ital,wght@0,400;0,600;0,700;1,400;1,600;1,700&display=swap'> <link rel='stylesheet' href='https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Source+Serif+Pro:ital,wght@0,400;0,600;0,700;1,400;1,600;1,700&display=swap' media='print' onload="this.media='all'"> <style> @charset "UTF-8";:root{--color-headerCard-light:#FFF;--color-headerCard-dark:#000;--color-text-headerCardStyleLight:var(--color-headerCard-dark);--color-background-headerCardStyleLight:var(--color-headerCard-light);--color-text-button-headerCardStyleLight:var(--color-headerCard-light);--color-background-button-headerCardStyleLight:var(--color-headerCard-dark);--color-text-button-hover-headerCardStyleLight:var(--color-headerCard-light);--color-background-button-hover-headerCardStyleLight:var(--color-headerCard-dark);--color-text-headerCardStyleDark:var(--color-headerCard-light);--color-background-headerCardStyleDark:var(--color-headerCard-dark);--color-text-button-headerCardStyleDark:var(--color-headerCard-dark);--color-background-button-headerCardStyleDark:var(--color-headerCard-light);--color-text-button-hover-headerCardStyleDark:var(--color-headerCard-dark);--color-background-button-hover-headerCardStyleDark:var(--color-headerCard-light);--color-text-headerCardStyleAccent:var(--color-background-primary);--color-background-headerCardStyleAccent:var(--color-accent);--color-text-button-headerCardStyleAccent:var(--color-text-primary);--color-background-button-headerCardStyleAccent:var(--color-background-primary);--color-text-button-hover-headerCardStyleAccent:var(--color-text-primary);--color-background-button-hover-headerCardStyleAccent:var(--color-background-primary);--color-text-headerCardStyleImage:var(--color-headerCard-light);--color-background-headerCardStyleImage:var(--color-headerCard-dark);--color-text-button-headerCardStyleImage:var(--color-headerCard-light);--color-background-button-headerCardStyleImage:var(--color-headerCard-dark);--color-text-button-hover-headerCardStyleImage:var(--color-headerCard-dark);--color-background-button-hover-headerCardStyleImage:var(--color-headerCard-light)}:root{--color-text-button:var(--color-background-primary);--color-background-button:var(--color-accent);--color-text-button-hover:var(--color-background-primary);--color-background-button-hover:var(--color-text-primary)}:root{--content-width:708px;--content-flow:var(--space-32)}:root{--html-symbol-dark:"☾";--html-symbol-light:"☼";--html-symbol-em-dash:"—";--html-symbol-checkmark:"✓";--html-symbol-multiplication:"✕"}:root{--motion-duration-slow:.5s;--motion-duration-fast:.25s}:root{--ratio-1:1;--ratio-3x2:3/2;--ratio-16x9:16/9}:root{--focus-outline-size:var(--space-2);--focus-outline-style:solid;--focus-outline-color:currentColor;--focus-outline-offset:var(--space-2)}:root{--border-radius:var(--space-4);--border-radius-circle:50%}:root{--border-width:.5px;--border-style:solid;--border-vertical-offset:calc(calc(var(--grid-gap) / 2) * -1)}:root{--grid-width:1400px;--grid-gap:var(--space-32);--grid-margin:var(--space-20);--grid-margin-large:var(--space-32)}:root{--space-2:2px;--space-4:4px;--space-8:8px;--space-12:12px;--space-16:16px;--space-20:20px;--space-24:24px;--space-32:32px;--space-40:40px;--space-48:48px;--space-56:56px;--space-64:64px;--space-80:80px;--space-96:96px;--space-128:128px;--space-160:160px;--space-168:168px}:root{--font-size-scale-0:12px;--line-height-scale-0:16px;--font-size-scale-1:14px;--line-height-scale-1:16px;--font-size-scale-2:16px;--line-height-scale-2:20px;--font-size-scale-3:18px;--line-height-scale-3:20px;--font-size-scale-4:20px;--line-height-scale-4:24px;--font-size-scale-5:24px;--line-height-scale-5:28px;--font-size-scale-6:28px;--line-height-scale-6:32px;--font-size-scale-7:32px;--line-height-scale-7:32px;--font-size-scale-8:40px;--line-height-scale-8:40px;--font-size-scale-9:48px;--line-height-scale-9:48px;--font-size-scale-10:72px;--line-height-scale-10:72px;--font-size-scale-body-copy:20px;--line-height-scale-body-copy:32px;--line-height-scale-tight:1;--font-weight-normal:400;--font-weight-medium:500;--font-weight-semibold:600;--font-weight-bold:700;--font-letter-spacing-brevier:.7px;--font-letter-spacing-long-primer:.25px;--font-letter-spacing-tiny:.6px;--font-letter-spacing-small:1.2px;--font-letter-spacing-base:1.6px;--font-letter-spacing-large:2.8px;--font-letter-spacing-negative:-.5px;--font-family-serif:"Source Serif Pro",Georgia,serif;--font-family-sansSerif:"Inter",-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,"Segoe UI",Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif}:root{--color-mode:"light";--color-accent:var(--ghost-accent-color);--color-text-primary:#000000;--color-text-secondary:#4E5965;--color-border-primary:#000000;--color-border-secondary:#D9D9D9;--color-background-primary:#FFFFFF;--color-background-secondary:#EFF8FA}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){:root.is-darkModeAdminSetting-enabled{--color-mode:"dark"}:root:not([data-user-color-scheme]).is-darkModeAdminSetting-enabled{--color-mode:"dark";--color-accent:var(--dark-mode-accent-color);--color-text-primary:#FFFFFF;--color-text-secondary:#B3B3B3;--color-border-primary:#525252;--color-border-secondary:#303030;--color-background-primary:#181818;--color-background-secondary:#212121}}[data-user-color-scheme=dark]{--color-mode:"dark";--color-accent:var(--dark-mode-accent-color);--color-text-primary:#FFFFFF;--color-text-secondary:#B3B3B3;--color-border-primary:#525252;--color-border-secondary:#303030;--color-background-primary:#181818;--color-background-secondary:#212121}/*! modern-normalize v1.1.0 | MIT License | https://github.com/sindresorhus/modern-normalize */*,::after,::before{box-sizing:border-box}html{-moz-tab-size:4;-o-tab-size:4;tab-size:4}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%}body{margin:0}body{font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,"Segoe UI",Roboto,Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif,"Apple Color Emoji","Segoe UI Emoji"}hr{height:0;color:inherit}abbr[title]{-webkit-text-decoration:underline dotted;text-decoration:underline dotted}b,strong{font-weight:bolder}code,kbd,pre,samp{font-family:ui-monospace,SFMono-Regular,Consolas,"Liberation Mono",Menlo,monospace;font-size:1em}small{font-size:80%}sub,sup{font-size:75%;line-height:0;position:relative;vertical-align:baseline}sub{bottom:-.25em}sup{top:-.5em}table{text-indent:0;border-color:inherit}button,input,optgroup,select,textarea{font-family:inherit;font-size:100%;line-height:1.15;margin:0}button,select{text-transform:none}[type=button],[type=reset],[type=submit],button{-webkit-appearance:button}::-moz-focus-inner{border-style:none;padding:0}:-moz-focusring{outline:1px dotted ButtonText}:-moz-ui-invalid{box-shadow:none}legend{padding:0}progress{vertical-align:baseline}::-webkit-inner-spin-button,::-webkit-outer-spin-button{height:auto}[type=search]{-webkit-appearance:textfield;outline-offset:-2px}::-webkit-search-decoration{-webkit-appearance:none}::-webkit-file-upload-button{-webkit-appearance:button;font:inherit}summary{display:list-item}code[class*=language-],pre[class*=language-]{color:#000;background:0 0;text-shadow:0 1px #fff;font-family:Consolas,Monaco,"Andale Mono","Ubuntu Mono",monospace;font-size:1em;text-align:left;white-space:pre;word-spacing:normal;word-break:normal;word-wrap:normal;line-height:1.5;-moz-tab-size:4;-o-tab-size:4;tab-size:4;-webkit-hyphens:none;hyphens:none}code[class*=language-] ::-moz-selection,code[class*=language-]::-moz-selection,pre[class*=language-] ::-moz-selection,pre[class*=language-]::-moz-selection{text-shadow:none;background:#b3d4fc}code[class*=language-] ::-moz-selection,code[class*=language-]::-moz-selection,pre[class*=language-] ::-moz-selection,pre[class*=language-]::-moz-selection{text-shadow:none;background:#b3d4fc}code[class*=language-] ::selection,code[class*=language-]::selection,pre[class*=language-] ::selection,pre[class*=language-]::selection{text-shadow:none;background:#b3d4fc}@media print{code[class*=language-],pre[class*=language-]{text-shadow:none}}pre[class*=language-]{padding:1em;margin:.5em 0;overflow:auto}:not(pre)>code[class*=language-],pre[class*=language-]{background:#f5f2f0}:not(pre)>code[class*=language-]{padding:.1em;border-radius:.3em;white-space:normal}.token.cdata,.token.comment,.token.doctype,.token.prolog{color:#708090}.token.punctuation{color:#999}.token.namespace{opacity:.7}.token.boolean,.token.constant,.token.deleted,.token.number,.token.property,.token.symbol,.token.tag{color:#905}.token.attr-name,.token.builtin,.token.char,.token.inserted,.token.selector,.token.string{color:#690}.language-css .token.string,.style .token.string,.token.entity,.token.operator,.token.url{color:#9a6e3a;background:hsla(0,0%,100%,.5)}.token.atrule,.token.attr-value,.token.keyword{color:#07a}.token.class-name,.token.function{color:#dd4a68}.token.important,.token.regex,.token.variable{color:#e90}.token.bold,.token.important{font-weight:700}.token.italic{font-style:italic}.token.entity{cursor:help}body .fslightbox-image-wrap{display:block}body .fslightbox-container{font-family:var(--font-family-sansSerif);background:var(--color-background-primary)}body .fslightbox-nav{height:var(--space-48)}body .fslightbox-toolbar{right:var(--space-12)}body [data-fslightbox] img{cursor:zoom-in}body .fslightbox-invalid-file-wrapper{color:var(--color-text-secondary)}body .fslightbox-slide-number-container{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2);left:var(--space-12);color:var(--color-text-secondary)}body .fslightbox-slash{background:var(--color-text-secondary)}body .fslightbox-toolbar>.fslightbox-toolbar-button:first-child{display:none}body .fslightbox-svg-path{fill:var(--color-text-secondary)}body .fslightbox-toolbar{background:var(--color-background-primary)}body .fslightbox-toolbar:hover .fslightbox-svg-path{fill:var(--color-text-secondary)}body .fslightbox-slide-btn{background:var(--color-background-primary)}body .fslightbox-slide-btn-container{padding-left:var(--space-16)}body .fslightbox-slide-btn-container:hover .fslightbox-svg-path{fill:var(--color-text-secondary)}body .fslightbox-slide-btn-container-next{padding-right:var(--space-16)}@keyframes spin{100%{transform:rotate(360deg)}}.icon{position:relative;display:inline-block;width:25px;height:25px;overflow:hidden;fill:currentColor}.icon__cnt{width:100%;height:100%;background:inherit;fill:inherit;pointer-events:none;transform:translateX(0);-ms-transform:translate(.5px,-.3px)}.icon--m{width:50px;height:50px}.icon--l{width:100px;height:100px}.icon--xl{width:150px;height:150px}.icon--xxl{width:200px;height:200px}.icon__spinner{position:absolute;top:0;left:0;width:100%;height:100%}.icon--ei-spinner .icon__spinner,.icon--ei-spinner-2 .icon__spinner{animation:spin 1s steps(12) infinite}.icon--ei-spinner-3 .icon__spinner{animation:spin 1.5s linear infinite}.icon--ei-sc-facebook{fill:#3b5998}.icon--ei-sc-github{fill:#333}.icon--ei-sc-google-plus{fill:#dd4b39}.icon--ei-sc-instagram{fill:#3f729b}.icon--ei-sc-linkedin{fill:#0976b4}.icon--ei-sc-odnoklassniki{fill:#ed812b}.icon--ei-sc-skype{fill:#00aff0}.icon--ei-sc-soundcloud{fill:#f80}.icon--ei-sc-tumblr{fill:#35465c}.icon--ei-sc-twitter{fill:#55acee}.icon--ei-sc-vimeo{fill:#1ab7ea}.icon--ei-sc-vk{fill:#45668e}.icon--ei-sc-youtube{fill:#e52d27}.icon--ei-sc-pinterest{fill:#bd081c}.icon--ei-sc-telegram{fill:#08c}.icon{width:var(--space-24);height:var(--space-24)}.icon--m{width:var(--space-48);height:var(--space-48)}:where(body,h1,h2,h3,h4,h5,h6,blockquote,p,pre,dl,dd,ol,ul,figure,hr,fieldset,legend){margin:0;padding:0}li>ol,li>ul{margin-bottom:0}table{border-collapse:collapse;border-spacing:0}:is(a,button,input,textarea,summary):focus-visible{outline:var(--focus-outline-size) var(--focus-outline-style) var(--focus-outline-color);outline-offset:var(--focus-outline-offset)}@media (prefers-reduced-motion:reduce){*{animation:none;transition:none}}.o-grid{width:100%;margin:auto;display:grid;max-width:var(--grid-width);padding:0 var(--grid-margin)}@media (min-width:64em){.o-grid{padding:0 var(--grid-margin-large)}}.o-grid[class*=-columns]{grid-gap:var(--grid-gap)}@media (min-width:40em){.o-grid--2-columns{grid-template-columns:repeat(2,minmax(0,1fr))}}@media (min-width:40em){.o-grid--3-columns{grid-template-columns:repeat(2,minmax(0,1fr))}}@media (min-width:64em){.o-grid--3-columns{grid-template-columns:repeat(3,minmax(0,1fr))}}@media (min-width:40em){.o-grid--4-columns{grid-template-columns:repeat(2,minmax(0,1fr))}}@media (min-width:64em){.o-grid--4-columns{grid-template-columns:repeat(4,minmax(0,1fr))}}@media (min-width:40em){.o-grid--2-1-columns{grid-template-columns:repeat(2,minmax(0,1fr))}}@media (min-width:64em){.o-grid--2-1-columns{grid-template-columns:2fr 1fr}}.u-font-size-scale-0{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-0);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-0)}.u-font-size-scale-1{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-1);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-1)}.u-font-size-scale-2{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2)}.u-font-size-scale-3{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-3);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-3)}.u-font-size-scale-4{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-4);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4)}.u-font-size-scale-5{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-5);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-5)}.u-font-size-scale-6{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-6);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-6)}.u-font-size-scale-7{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-7);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-7)}.u-font-size-scale-8{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-8);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-8)}.u-font-size-scale-9{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-9);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-9)}.u-font-size-scale-10{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-10);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-10)}.u-font-family-serif{font-family:var(--font-family-serif)!important}.u-font-family-sansSerif{font-family:var(--font-family-sansSerif)!important}.u-font-weight-normal{font-weight:var(--font-weight-normal)}.u-font-weight-medium{font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium)}.u-font-weight-semibold{font-weight:var(--font-weight-semibold)}.u-font-weight-bold{font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold)}.kg-header-card-header,.u-font-headline{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-6);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-6);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium)}@media (min-width:64em){.kg-header-card-header,.u-font-headline{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-8);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-8);letter-spacing:var(--font-letter-spacing-negative)}}.kg-header-card-subheader,.u-font-standfirst{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-5);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-5);font-weight:var(--font-weight-normal)}@media (min-width:64em){.kg-header-card-subheader,.u-font-standfirst{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-5);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-6)}}.u-font-uppercase{text-transform:uppercase}.u-link{text-decoration:underline}.u-link:hover{text-decoration:none}.u-link:focus-visible{text-decoration:none}.u-align-auto{margin:auto}.u-align-center{text-align:center}.u-color-text-brand{color:var(--color-accent)}.u-color-text-secondary{color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.u-color-background-secondary{background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}.u-drop-cap-large:first-letter,.u-drop-cap-small:first-letter{float:left;margin-top:var(--space-8);margin-right:var(--space-8);color:var(--color-accent);font-weight:var(--font-weight-semibold)}.u-drop-cap-small::first-letter{font-size:70px;line-height:52px}.u-drop-cap-large::first-letter{font-size:118px;line-height:86px}.js-on .lazyload,.js-on .lazyloading{opacity:0}.js-on .lazyloaded{opacity:1;transition:opacity var(--motion-duration-slow) ease}.u-hidden{display:none}.u-block{display:block}.u-screenreader{position:absolute;width:1px;height:1px;padding:0;margin:-1px;overflow:hidden;clip:rect(0 0 0 0);border:0}@media (max-width:63.99em){.u-visible-on-desktop{display:none!important}}.u-mt-8{margin-top:var(--space-8)}.u-mr-8{margin-right:var(--space-8)}.u-mt-16{margin-top:var(--space-16)}.u-mb-16{margin-bottom:var(--space-16)}.u-p-32{padding:var(--space-32)}.u-plain-list{margin:0;padding:0;list-style:none}.u-flex{display:flex}body,html{height:100%}body{font-family:var(--font-family-sansSerif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2);font-weight:var(--font-weight-normal);direction:ltr;color:var(--color-text-primary);background-color:var(--color-background-primary);-webkit-font-smoothing:antialiased;-moz-osx-font-smoothing:grayscale}a{color:inherit;text-decoration:none}:where(dd,ol,ul){margin-left:var(--space-16)}img{height:auto;display:block;max-width:100%;font-style:italic}hr{border:0;height:auto;border-top:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}:where(h1,h2,h3,strong){font-weight:var(--font-weight-semibold)}:where(h1){font-size:var(--font-size-scale-6);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-6)}@media (min-width:64em){:where(h1){font-size:var(--font-size-scale-7);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-7)}}:where(h1)+h2,:where(h1)+h3{margin-top:var(--space-16)}:where(h2){font-size:var(--font-size-scale-5);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-5)}@media (min-width:64em){:where(h2){font-size:var(--font-size-scale-6);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-6)}}:where(h2)+h3{margin-top:var(--space-16)}:where(h3){font-size:var(--font-size-scale-4);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4)}@media (min-width:64em){:where(h3){font-size:var(--font-size-scale-5);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-5)}}blockquote{font-style:italic}blockquote:not(.kg-blockquote-alt){padding-left:var(--space-20);border-left:var(--space-2) solid var(--color-accent)}li code,p code{padding:var(--space-4) var(--space-8);border-radius:var(--border-radius);border:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}code,code[class*=language-]{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-1);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-1);text-shadow:none;color:var(--color-text-primary)}.kg-code-card,pre,pre[class*=language-]{width:100%;overflow-x:auto;border-radius:var(--border-radius)}pre,pre[class*=language-]{margin-bottom:0;margin-top:var(--content-flow);padding:var(--space-32);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}.kg-code-card pre{margin-top:0}.token.operator{background-color:transparent}input[type=color],input[type=date],input[type=datetime-local],input[type=datetime],input[type=email],input[type=month],input[type=number],input[type=password],input[type=search],input[type=tel],input[type=text],input[type=time],input[type=url],input[type=week],select,textarea{font-family:var(--font-family-sansSerif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium);width:100%;display:block;color:var(--color-text-primary);padding:var(--space-12) var(--space-24);background:0 0;border:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}input[type=color]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=date]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=datetime-local]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=datetime]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=email]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=month]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=number]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=password]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=search]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=tel]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=text]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=time]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=url]::-moz-placeholder,input[type=week]::-moz-placeholder,select::-moz-placeholder,textarea::-moz-placeholder{opacity:1;color:var(--color-text-secondary)}input[type=color]::placeholder,input[type=date]::placeholder,input[type=datetime-local]::placeholder,input[type=datetime]::placeholder,input[type=email]::placeholder,input[type=month]::placeholder,input[type=number]::placeholder,input[type=password]::placeholder,input[type=search]::placeholder,input[type=tel]::placeholder,input[type=text]::placeholder,input[type=time]::placeholder,input[type=url]::placeholder,input[type=week]::placeholder,select::placeholder,textarea::placeholder{opacity:1;color:var(--color-text-secondary)}table{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2);width:100%;max-width:100%;background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}table caption{padding:var(--space-16);border-style:var(--border-style);border-width:var(--border-width) var(--border-width) 0 var(--border-width);border-color:var(--color-border-secondary);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}table td,table th{text-align:left;padding:var(--space-16);white-space:nowrap;border:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}table tbody+tbody{border-top:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}.responsive-table{display:block;width:100%;overflow-x:auto;word-break:initial}:lang(ar) *{letter-spacing:initial}.c-skip{position:absolute;top:calc(var(--space-96) * -1);left:var(--space-32);padding:var(--space-4) var(--space-16);background-color:var(--color-background-primary)}.c-skip:focus{z-index:10;top:var(--space-32)}.c-header{margin-bottom:var(--space-32);box-shadow:rgba(0,0,0,.08) 0 0 var(--space-4) var(--space-2)}[data-user-color-scheme=dark] .c-header{border-bottom:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){:root:not([data-user-color-scheme]).is-darkModeAdminSetting-enabled .c-header{border-bottom:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}}.c-header__top{padding:var(--space-20) 0;border-bottom:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-header__top-block{display:flex;align-items:center;gap:var(--space-8)}@media (min-width:64em){.c-header__top-block{gap:var(--space-16)}}.c-header__top-inner{display:grid;gap:var(--space-16);align-items:center;grid-template-columns:auto 2fr auto}@media (min-width:40em){.c-header__top-inner{grid-template-columns:1fr 2fr 1fr}}@media (max-width:39.99em){.c-header__top-left{order:2;margin-left:auto}.c-header__top-center{order:1}.c-header__top-right{order:3}}.c-header__top-right{justify-self:end}.c-header__button{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-0);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-0);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium);text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:var(--font-letter-spacing-brevier);padding:0;border:none;cursor:pointer;background:0 0;color:var(--color-text-primary);display:flex;align-items:center;gap:var(--space-4)}.c-header__button:hover{text-decoration:underline}.c-header__button svg{width:var(--space-16);height:var(--space-16);fill:var(--color-text-primary)}.c-footer{position:sticky;top:100vh;padding:var(--space-64) 0;margin-top:var(--space-64);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}.c-footer__content{display:flex;flex-direction:column;align-items:center}.c-footer__content>*+*{margin-top:var(--space-32)}.c-footer-nav{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;justify-content:center}.c-footer-nav .c-nav__item{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-1);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4);font-weight:var(--font-weight-normal);text-transform:initial;color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-footer-nav .c-nav__item:not(:first-child)::before{display:none}.c-footer-nav li:not(:last-child){margin:0}.c-footer-nav a{text-decoration:underline}.c-footer-nav a:hover{text-decoration:none}.c-footer-nav a:focus-visible{text-decoration:none}.c-footer-copy{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-1);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2);text-align:center;color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-footer-copy a{text-decoration:underline}.c-footer-copy a:hover{text-decoration:none}.c-footer-copy a:focus-visible{text-decoration:none}@media (min-width:40em){.c-logo{margin:auto}}.c-logo__link{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-6);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-6);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium)}@media (min-width:40em){.c-logo__link{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-8);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-8)}}.c-logo__img{max-height:var(--space-32)}@media (min-width:40em){.c-logo__img{max-height:var(--space-48)}}.c-logo__dark{display:none}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){:root:not([data-user-color-scheme]).is-darkModeAdminSetting-enabled .c-logo__dark{display:block}:root:not([data-user-color-scheme]).is-darkModeAdminSetting-enabled .c-logo__light{display:none}}[data-user-color-scheme=dark] .c-logo__dark{display:block}[data-user-color-scheme=dark] .c-logo__light{display:none}.c-nav-wrap{min-width:0}.c-nav{display:flex;gap:var(--space-16);padding:var(--space-16) 0;overflow-x:scroll;-ms-overflow-style:none;scrollbar-width:none}.c-nav::-webkit-scrollbar{display:none}@media (min-width:64em){.c-nav--main{justify-content:center}}.c-nav__item{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-0);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-0);font-weight:var(--font-weight-semibold);text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:var(--font-letter-spacing-brevier);white-space:nowrap}.c-nav__item:not(:first-child){padding-left:var(--space-16);position:relative}.c-nav__item:not(:first-child):before{border-left:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-accent);content:"";height:var(--space-16);left:0;width:1px;overflow:hidden;position:absolute}.c-nav__link{display:block}.c-nav__link--current{text-decoration:underline}.c-nav__link--current:hover{text-decoration:none}.c-nav__link--current:focus-visible{text-decoration:none}.home-template .c-nav__link--current{text-decoration:none}.c-nav__link:hover{text-decoration:underline}.c-author__media{width:var(--space-96);height:var(--space-96);border-radius:var(--border-radius-circle);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}.c-author__image{-o-object-fit:cover;object-fit:cover;width:var(--space-96);height:var(--space-96);min-width:var(--space-96);border-radius:var(--border-radius-circle)}.c-btn,.c-content .kg-product-card .kg-product-card-button,.kg-btn,.kg-btn-accent,.kg-header-card-button{--focus-outline-offset:calc(var(--space-4) * -1);font-family:var(--font-family-sansSerif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium);height:auto;width:-moz-fit-content;width:fit-content;min-width:-moz-fit-content;min-width:fit-content;text-align:center;border:none;cursor:pointer;overflow:hidden;padding:var(--space-16) var(--space-24);border-radius:var(--space-4);color:var(--color-text-button);background-color:var(--color-background-button)}.c-btn:is(:hover,:active,:focus),.c-content .kg-product-card .kg-product-card-button:is(:hover,:active,:focus),.kg-btn-accent:is(:hover,:active,:focus),.kg-btn:is(:hover,:active,:focus),.kg-header-card-button:is(:hover,:active,:focus){color:var(--color-text-button-hover);background-color:var(--color-background-button-hover)}.c-btn--disabled{opacity:.5;cursor:not-allowed}.c-btn--full{width:100%}.c-btn--small{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-1);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-1);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium);letter-spacing:var(--font-letter-spacing-brevier);padding:var(--space-8) var(--space-16)}.c-btn--uppercase{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-0);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-0);text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:var(--font-letter-spacing-brevier)}.c-btn--fit-content{width:-moz-fit-content;width:fit-content}.c-btn--loading,.c-btn.loading,.c-content .kg-product-card .c-subscribe-form .kg-product-card-button,.c-content .kg-product-card .loading.kg-product-card-button,.c-subscribe-form .c-btn,.c-subscribe-form .c-content .kg-product-card .kg-product-card-button,.c-subscribe-form .kg-btn,.c-subscribe-form .kg-btn-accent,.c-subscribe-form .kg-header-card-button,.loading.kg-btn,.loading.kg-btn-accent,.loading.kg-header-card-button{display:flex;align-items:center;justify-content:center}@keyframes spin{0%{transform:rotate(0)}100%{transform:rotate(360deg)}}.c-btn--loading:after,.c-btn.loading:after,.c-content .kg-product-card .c-subscribe-form .kg-product-card-button:after,.c-content .kg-product-card .loading.kg-product-card-button:after,.c-subscribe-form .c-btn:after,.c-subscribe-form .c-content .kg-product-card .kg-product-card-button:after,.c-subscribe-form .kg-btn-accent:after,.c-subscribe-form .kg-btn:after,.c-subscribe-form .kg-header-card-button:after,.loading.kg-btn-accent:after,.loading.kg-btn:after,.loading.kg-header-card-button:after{margin-left:var(--space-12);content:"";display:block;height:var(--space-16);width:var(--space-16);border-width:1px;border-style:var(--border-style);border-top-color:transparent;border-right-color:transparent;border-bottom-color:var(--color-text-button);border-left-color:var(--color-text-button);border-radius:var(--border-radius-circle);animation:spin var(--motion-duration-slow) infinite linear}.c-btn--loading:is(:hover,:active,:focus):after,.c-btn.loading:is(:hover,:active,:focus):after,.c-content .kg-product-card .c-subscribe-form .kg-product-card-button:is(:hover,:active,:focus):after,.c-content .kg-product-card .loading.kg-product-card-button:is(:hover,:active,:focus):after,.c-subscribe-form .c-btn:is(:hover,:active,:focus):after,.c-subscribe-form .c-content .kg-product-card .kg-product-card-button:is(:hover,:active,:focus):after,.c-subscribe-form .kg-btn-accent:is(:hover,:active,:focus):after,.c-subscribe-form .kg-btn:is(:hover,:active,:focus):after,.c-subscribe-form .kg-header-card-button:is(:hover,:active,:focus):after,.loading.kg-btn-accent:is(:hover,:active,:focus):after,.loading.kg-btn:is(:hover,:active,:focus):after,.loading.kg-header-card-button:is(:hover,:active,:focus):after{border-bottom-color:var(--color-background-primary);border-left-color:var(--color-background-primary)}.c-post{margin:0 auto;padding:0 var(--grid-margin);max-width:var(--content-width)}.c-post>*+*{margin-top:var(--content-flow)}.c-content{display:flex;align-items:center;flex-direction:column}.c-content:empty{display:none}.c-content--has-shadow{-webkit-mask-image:linear-gradient(to bottom,var(--color-text-primary) 30%,transparent 100%);mask-image:linear-gradient(to bottom,var(--color-text-primary) 30%,transparent 100%)}.c-content>*{min-width:100%}.c-content>*+*{margin-top:var(--content-flow)}.c-content :where(p,ol,ul,blockquote){font-family:var(--font-family-serif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-body-copy);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-body-copy)}.c-content :where(h1,h2,h3)+*{margin-top:calc(var(--content-flow)/ 2)}.c-content a:not([class]){text-decoration:underline;color:var(--color-accent)}.c-content a:not([class]):hover{text-decoration:none}.c-content a:not([class]):focus-visible{text-decoration:none}.c-content :where(hr){margin:var(--content-flow) 0}.c-content :where(hr)+*{margin-top:0}.c-content :is(dd,ol,ul){padding-left:var(--space-16);padding-right:var(--space-16)}.c-content .gh-post-upgrade-cta{display:none;visibility:hidden}.c-section{margin-top:var(--space-64)}.c-section--editors-pick{padding-top:var(--space-64);padding-bottom:var(--space-64);background:var(--color-background-secondary)}.c-section-heading{display:flex;align-items:baseline;justify-content:space-between;padding-bottom:var(--space-8);margin-bottom:var(--space-24);border-bottom:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-primary)}.c-section-heading__title{font-family:var(--font-family-serif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-7);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-8);font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold)}.c-section-heading__title a:hover{text-decoration:underline}.c-section-heading__title--small{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-3);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4)}.c-section-heading__all{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-0);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-0);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium);text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:var(--font-letter-spacing-brevier)}.c-section-heading__all:hover{text-decoration:underline}.c-subscribe-form .c-alert{display:none}.c-content .kg-product-card .c-subscribe-form .kg-product-card-button:after,.c-subscribe-form .c-btn:after,.c-subscribe-form .c-content .kg-product-card .kg-product-card-button:after,.c-subscribe-form .kg-btn-accent:after,.c-subscribe-form .kg-btn:after,.c-subscribe-form .kg-header-card-button:after{display:none}.c-content .kg-product-card .c-subscribe-form.loading .kg-product-card-button:after,.c-subscribe-form.loading .c-btn:after,.c-subscribe-form.loading .c-content .kg-product-card .kg-product-card-button:after,.c-subscribe-form.loading .kg-btn-accent:after,.c-subscribe-form.loading .kg-btn:after,.c-subscribe-form.loading .kg-header-card-button:after{display:block}.c-subscribe-form.error .c-alert--error,.c-subscribe-form.invalid .c-alert--invalid,.c-subscribe-form.success .c-alert--success{display:block}.c-form-group{display:flex;gap:var(--space-16)}.c-alert{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-1);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-1);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium);margin-top:var(--space-16)}.c-alert:empty{display:none}.c-alert:before{font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold);margin-right:var(--space-8)}.c-alert--success:before{content:var(--html-symbol-checkmark)}.c-alert--error:before,.c-alert--invalid:before{content:var(--html-symbol-multiplication)}.c-teaser{display:flex}.c-teaser--large{display:grid;grid-template-columns:1fr 2fr;-moz-column-gap:var(--grid-gap);column-gap:var(--grid-gap)}.c-teaser__media{width:var(--space-80);height:var(--space-64);flex-basis:var(--space-80);margin-left:var(--space-16);position:relative;aspect-ratio:var(--ratio-3x2);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}.c-teaser__media:after{content:"";position:absolute;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;left:0;background-color:rgba(0,0,0,.1);opacity:0;transition:ease opacity var(--motion-duration-fast)}.c-teaser__media:hover:after{opacity:1}@media (min-width:64em){.c-teaser--large .c-teaser__media{width:auto;height:auto;flex-basis:auto;margin:0}}.c-teaser__image{position:absolute;inset:0;width:100%;height:100%;-o-object-fit:cover;object-fit:cover}.c-teaser__content{flex:1}.c-teaser__content>*+*{margin-top:var(--space-8)}.c-teaser--large .c-teaser__content{order:2}.c-teaser__headline{font-family:var(--font-family-serif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2);font-weight:var(--font-weight-semibold)}.c-teaser__headline:hover{text-decoration:underline}@media (min-width:64em){.c-teaser--large .c-teaser__headline{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-6);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-6);font-weight:var(--font-weight-semibold)}}.c-teaser__standfirst{font-family:var(--font-family-serif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-3);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4)}.c-teaser__meta{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;align-items:center;gap:var(--space-8)}.c-teaser__timestamp{white-space:nowrap}.c-card--center *{text-align:center;justify-content:center}.c-card__media{display:block;position:relative;padding-bottom:66%;aspect-ratio:var(--ratio-3x2);margin-bottom:var(--space-16);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}.c-card__media:after{content:"";position:absolute;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;left:0;background-color:rgba(0,0,0,.1);opacity:0;transition:ease opacity var(--motion-duration-fast)}.c-card__media:hover:after{opacity:1}.c-card__image{position:absolute;inset:0;width:100%;height:100%;-o-object-fit:cover;object-fit:cover}.c-card__content>*+*{margin-top:var(--space-8)}@media (min-width:64em){.c-card--center .c-card__content{padding:0 var(--space-32)}}.c-card__headline{font-family:var(--font-family-serif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-5);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-5);font-weight:var(--font-weight-semibold)}.c-card__headline:hover{text-decoration:underline}@media (min-width:64em){.c-card--large .c-card__headline{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-8);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-9)}}.c-card__standfirst{font-family:var(--font-family-serif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-3)}.c-card--large .c-card__standfirst{font-family:var(--font-family-serif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-3);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4)}@media (min-width:64em){.c-card--large .c-card__standfirst{font-family:var(--font-family-serif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-4);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-5)}}.c-card__meta{display:flex;flex-direction:column;gap:var(--space-8)}.c-hero{display:grid}@media (max-width:63.99em){.c-hero>*{margin-top:var(--content-flow)}.c-hero .center{margin-top:0}.c-hero .left{order:2}.c-hero .center{order:1}.c-hero .right{order:3}}@media (min-width:64em){.c-hero{-moz-column-gap:var(--grid-gap);column-gap:var(--grid-gap);grid-template-columns:repeat(12,1fr);grid-template-rows:minmax(2rem,auto) repeat(2,1fr)}.c-hero .left{grid-column:1/span 3;grid-row-start:1;position:relative}.c-hero .left:after{content:"";position:absolute;top:0;bottom:0;left:auto;right:var(--border-vertical-offset);border-right:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-hero .center{grid-column:4/span 6}.c-hero .right{grid-column:10/span 3;position:relative}.c-hero .right:after{content:"";position:absolute;top:0;bottom:0;right:auto;left:var(--border-vertical-offset);border-right:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}}.c-tag{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-0);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-0);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium);text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:var(--font-letter-spacing-brevier);color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-tag a{color:var(--color-accent)}.c-tag a:hover{text-decoration:underline}.c-tag-card{display:block;padding:var(--space-24);border-radius:var(--border-radius);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary);border-left:var(--space-4) solid var(--color-accent-tag,var(--color-accent))}.c-tag-card__name{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-3);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-3)}.c-card-archive{position:relative;padding-top:var(--space-24);margin-top:var(--space-24)}@media (min-width:64em){.c-card-archive{padding-top:var(--space-40);margin-top:var(--space-40)}}.c-card-archive:before{content:"";display:block;width:100%;height:1px;position:absolute;top:0;background-color:var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-card-archive:first-child{margin-top:0;padding-top:0}.c-card-archive:first-child:before{background-color:transparent}.c-card-archive:last-child{margin-bottom:var(--space-32)}@media (min-width:40em){.c-card-archive{display:grid;grid-template-columns:repeat(8,1fr);grid-template-rows:1fr;grid-column-gap:var(--space-40);grid-template-areas:"meta meta content content content content content content"}.c-card-archive__meta{grid-area:meta}.c-card-archive__content{grid-area:content}}.c-card-archive--date-1+.c-card-archive--date-1,.c-card-archive--date-10+.c-card-archive--date-10,.c-card-archive--date-11+.c-card-archive--date-11,.c-card-archive--date-12+.c-card-archive--date-12,.c-card-archive--date-2+.c-card-archive--date-2,.c-card-archive--date-3+.c-card-archive--date-3,.c-card-archive--date-4+.c-card-archive--date-4,.c-card-archive--date-5+.c-card-archive--date-5,.c-card-archive--date-6+.c-card-archive--date-6,.c-card-archive--date-7+.c-card-archive--date-7,.c-card-archive--date-8+.c-card-archive--date-8,.c-card-archive--date-9+.c-card-archive--date-9,.c-card-archive--date-١+.c-card-archive--date-١,.c-card-archive--date-١٠+.c-card-archive--date-١٠,.c-card-archive--date-١١+.c-card-archive--date-١١,.c-card-archive--date-١٢+.c-card-archive--date-١٢,.c-card-archive--date-٢+.c-card-archive--date-٢,.c-card-archive--date-٣+.c-card-archive--date-٣,.c-card-archive--date-٤+.c-card-archive--date-٤,.c-card-archive--date-٥+.c-card-archive--date-٥,.c-card-archive--date-٦+.c-card-archive--date-٦,.c-card-archive--date-٧+.c-card-archive--date-٧,.c-card-archive--date-٨+.c-card-archive--date-٨,.c-card-archive--date-٩+.c-card-archive--date-٩{padding-top:0;margin-top:0}.c-card-archive--date-1+.c-card-archive--date-1:before,.c-card-archive--date-10+.c-card-archive--date-10:before,.c-card-archive--date-11+.c-card-archive--date-11:before,.c-card-archive--date-12+.c-card-archive--date-12:before,.c-card-archive--date-2+.c-card-archive--date-2:before,.c-card-archive--date-3+.c-card-archive--date-3:before,.c-card-archive--date-4+.c-card-archive--date-4:before,.c-card-archive--date-5+.c-card-archive--date-5:before,.c-card-archive--date-6+.c-card-archive--date-6:before,.c-card-archive--date-7+.c-card-archive--date-7:before,.c-card-archive--date-8+.c-card-archive--date-8:before,.c-card-archive--date-9+.c-card-archive--date-9:before,.c-card-archive--date-١+.c-card-archive--date-١:before,.c-card-archive--date-١٠+.c-card-archive--date-١٠:before,.c-card-archive--date-١١+.c-card-archive--date-١١:before,.c-card-archive--date-١٢+.c-card-archive--date-١٢:before,.c-card-archive--date-٢+.c-card-archive--date-٢:before,.c-card-archive--date-٣+.c-card-archive--date-٣:before,.c-card-archive--date-٤+.c-card-archive--date-٤:before,.c-card-archive--date-٥+.c-card-archive--date-٥:before,.c-card-archive--date-٦+.c-card-archive--date-٦:before,.c-card-archive--date-٧+.c-card-archive--date-٧:before,.c-card-archive--date-٨+.c-card-archive--date-٨:before,.c-card-archive--date-٩+.c-card-archive--date-٩:before{background-color:transparent}.c-card-archive--date-1+.c-card-archive--date-1 .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-10+.c-card-archive--date-10 .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-11+.c-card-archive--date-11 .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-12+.c-card-archive--date-12 .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-2+.c-card-archive--date-2 .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-3+.c-card-archive--date-3 .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-4+.c-card-archive--date-4 .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-5+.c-card-archive--date-5 .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-6+.c-card-archive--date-6 .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-7+.c-card-archive--date-7 .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-8+.c-card-archive--date-8 .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-9+.c-card-archive--date-9 .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-١+.c-card-archive--date-١ .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-١٠+.c-card-archive--date-١٠ .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-١١+.c-card-archive--date-١١ .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-١٢+.c-card-archive--date-١٢ .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-٢+.c-card-archive--date-٢ .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-٣+.c-card-archive--date-٣ .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-٤+.c-card-archive--date-٤ .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-٥+.c-card-archive--date-٥ .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-٦+.c-card-archive--date-٦ .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-٧+.c-card-archive--date-٧ .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-٨+.c-card-archive--date-٨ .c-card-archive__meta,.c-card-archive--date-٩+.c-card-archive--date-٩ .c-card-archive__meta{display:none}.c-card-archive--date-1+.c-card-archive--date-1 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-10+.c-card-archive--date-10 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-11+.c-card-archive--date-11 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-12+.c-card-archive--date-12 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-2+.c-card-archive--date-2 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-3+.c-card-archive--date-3 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-4+.c-card-archive--date-4 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-5+.c-card-archive--date-5 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-6+.c-card-archive--date-6 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-7+.c-card-archive--date-7 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-8+.c-card-archive--date-8 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-9+.c-card-archive--date-9 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-١+.c-card-archive--date-١ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-١٠+.c-card-archive--date-١٠ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-١١+.c-card-archive--date-١١ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-١٢+.c-card-archive--date-١٢ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٢+.c-card-archive--date-٢ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٣+.c-card-archive--date-٣ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٤+.c-card-archive--date-٤ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٥+.c-card-archive--date-٥ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٦+.c-card-archive--date-٦ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٧+.c-card-archive--date-٧ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٨+.c-card-archive--date-٨ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٩+.c-card-archive--date-٩ .c-card-archive__content{position:relative;padding-top:var(--space-16);margin-top:var(--space-16)}@media (min-width:64em){.c-card-archive--date-1+.c-card-archive--date-1 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-10+.c-card-archive--date-10 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-11+.c-card-archive--date-11 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-12+.c-card-archive--date-12 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-2+.c-card-archive--date-2 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-3+.c-card-archive--date-3 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-4+.c-card-archive--date-4 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-5+.c-card-archive--date-5 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-6+.c-card-archive--date-6 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-7+.c-card-archive--date-7 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-8+.c-card-archive--date-8 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-9+.c-card-archive--date-9 .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-١+.c-card-archive--date-١ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-١٠+.c-card-archive--date-١٠ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-١١+.c-card-archive--date-١١ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-١٢+.c-card-archive--date-١٢ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٢+.c-card-archive--date-٢ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٣+.c-card-archive--date-٣ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٤+.c-card-archive--date-٤ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٥+.c-card-archive--date-٥ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٦+.c-card-archive--date-٦ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٧+.c-card-archive--date-٧ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٨+.c-card-archive--date-٨ .c-card-archive__content,.c-card-archive--date-٩+.c-card-archive--date-٩ .c-card-archive__content{padding-top:var(--space-24);margin-top:var(--space-24)}}.c-card-archive--date-1+.c-card-archive--date-1 .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-10+.c-card-archive--date-10 .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-11+.c-card-archive--date-11 .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-12+.c-card-archive--date-12 .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-2+.c-card-archive--date-2 .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-3+.c-card-archive--date-3 .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-4+.c-card-archive--date-4 .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-5+.c-card-archive--date-5 .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-6+.c-card-archive--date-6 .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-7+.c-card-archive--date-7 .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-8+.c-card-archive--date-8 .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-9+.c-card-archive--date-9 .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-١+.c-card-archive--date-١ .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-١٠+.c-card-archive--date-١٠ .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-١١+.c-card-archive--date-١١ .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-١٢+.c-card-archive--date-١٢ .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-٢+.c-card-archive--date-٢ .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-٣+.c-card-archive--date-٣ .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-٤+.c-card-archive--date-٤ .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-٥+.c-card-archive--date-٥ .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-٦+.c-card-archive--date-٦ .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-٧+.c-card-archive--date-٧ .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-٨+.c-card-archive--date-٨ .c-card-archive__content:before,.c-card-archive--date-٩+.c-card-archive--date-٩ .c-card-archive__content:before{content:"";display:block;width:100%;height:1px;position:absolute;top:0;background-color:var(--color-border-secondary)}@media (max-width:39.99em){.c-card-archive__meta{margin-bottom:var(--space-16)}}@media (max-width:39.99em){.c-card-archive__content{padding-left:var(--space-16)}}.c-card-archive__date{color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-card-archive__title{font-family:var(--font-family-sansSerif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium)}.c-card-archive__date-mini{display:none;font-weight:var(--font-weight-normal);color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-card-archive__url:hover{text-decoration:underline}.c-timestamp{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-0);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-0);color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-reading-time{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-0);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-0);color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-byline{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-byline a{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-0);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-0);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium);text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:var(--font-letter-spacing-brevier)}.c-byline a:hover{text-decoration:underline}.c-byline span{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-0);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-0);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium)}.c-topper{margin:0 auto;margin-top:var(--space-40);padding:0 var(--grid-margin);max-width:var(--content-width);margin-bottom:var(--space-32)}.c-topper__content{padding-bottom:var(--space-32);border-bottom:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-topper__content>*+*{margin-top:var(--space-8)}.c-topper__headline{font-family:var(--font-family-serif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-6);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-6);font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold)}@media (min-width:64em){.c-topper__headline{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-8);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-9);font-weight:var(--font-weight-semibold)}}.c-topper__standfirst{font-family:var(--font-family-serif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-4);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-5)}@media (min-width:64em){.c-topper__standfirst{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-5);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-6)}}.c-topper__meta{display:flex;flex-direction:column;margin-top:var(--space-16)}@media (min-width:64em){.c-topper__meta{flex-direction:row}}.c-topper__timestamp{display:inline-block;margin-top:var(--space-8)}.c-topper__timestamp:after{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-0);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-0);color:var(--color-text-secondary);content:var(--html-symbol-em-dash)}.c-topper__reading-time{display:inline}.c-feature-image-figure{margin-top:var(--space-32)}.c-feature-image-wrap{position:relative;aspect-ratio:var(--ratio-3x2);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}.c-feature-image{position:absolute;inset:0;width:100%;height:100%;-o-object-fit:cover;object-fit:cover}.c-feature-image-caption{width:100%;padding-top:var(--space-8);color:var(--color-text-secondary);background-color:var(--color-background-primary);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-1);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-1);letter-spacing:var(--font-letter-spacing-long-primer)}.c-feature-image-caption a{text-decoration:underline}.c-feature-image-caption a:hover{text-decoration:none}.c-feature-image-caption a:focus-visible{text-decoration:none}.c-stack-stories>:not(:last-child){margin-bottom:var(--space-16);padding-bottom:var(--space-16);border-bottom:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-stack-stories--large>:not(:last-child){margin-bottom:var(--space-32);padding-bottom:var(--space-32)}.c-editors-pick{display:grid;grid-template-rows:auto 1fr;grid-template-columns:var(--space-80) 2fr;grid-template-areas:"number media" "content content"}.c-editors-pick__media{grid-area:media;position:relative;aspect-ratio:var(--ratio-3x2);background-color:var(--color-background-primary)}.c-editors-pick__media:after{content:"";position:absolute;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;left:0;background-color:rgba(0,0,0,.1);opacity:0;transition:ease opacity var(--motion-duration-fast)}.c-editors-pick__media:hover:after{opacity:1}.c-editors-pick__image{position:absolute;inset:0;width:100%;height:100%;-o-object-fit:cover;object-fit:cover}.c-editors-pick__content{grid-area:content}.c-editors-pick__content>*+*{margin-top:var(--space-8)}.c-editors-pick__content{margin-top:var(--space-24)}.c-editors-pick__headline{font-family:var(--font-family-serif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-5);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-5);font-weight:var(--font-weight-semibold)}.c-editors-pick__headline:hover{text-decoration:underline}.c-editors-picks-wrapper{counter-reset:list-items}.c-editors-picks-wrapper .c-editors-pick::before{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-10);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-10);font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold);grid-area:number;counter-increment:list-items;content:counter(list-items);-webkit-text-stroke-width:1px;-webkit-text-fill-color:transparent;margin-top:auto;margin-bottom:calc(var(--space-8) * -1)}.c-page-header{margin-bottom:var(--space-32)}.c-color-mode-btn:before{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2)}@media (max-width:39.99em){.c-color-mode-btn:before{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-3);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-3)}}.c-color-mode-btn:hover{text-decoration:none}.c-color-mode-btn:hover span{text-decoration:underline}[title=Dark]:before{content:var(--html-symbol-dark)}[title=Light]:before{content:var(--html-symbol-light)}.c-card-author{width:100%;padding:var(--space-32);border-radius:var(--border-radius);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}.c-card-author>*+*{margin-top:var(--space-20);padding-top:var(--space-20);border-top:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-card-author__url{display:block}.c-card-author__url:hover{text-decoration:underline}.c-card-author__media{display:block;margin-bottom:var(--space-16);width:var(--space-96);height:var(--space-96);border-radius:var(--border-radius-circle);background-color:var(--color-background-primary)}.c-card-author__image{-o-object-fit:cover;object-fit:cover;width:var(--space-96);height:var(--space-96);min-width:var(--space-96);border-radius:var(--border-radius-circle)}.c-card-author__name{font-family:var(--font-family-sansSerif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-4);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4);font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold)}.c-card-author__bio{font-family:var(--font-family-sansSerif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4);margin-top:var(--space-8);color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-card-author__posts>*+*{margin-top:var(--space-8)}.c-card-author__posts a:hover{text-decoration:underline}.c-card-author__posts-title{font-family:var(--font-family-sansSerif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium);position:relative;padding-left:var(--space-24)}.c-card-author__posts-title:before{position:absolute;left:0;content:var(--html-symbol-em-dash);color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-social-icons{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;gap:var(--space-16)}.c-social-icons__link{display:flex;align-items:center;justify-content:center;width:var(--space-40);height:var(--space-40);border-radius:var(--border-radius-circle);background-color:var(--color-background-primary)}.c-social-icons__link:is(:hover,:active,:focus) .c-social-icons__icon{fill:var(--color-text-primary)}.c-social-icons__icon{fill:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-share{display:flex;gap:var(--space-16)}@media (max-width:39.99em){.c-share{margin-top:var(--space-16);justify-content:flex-start}}@media (min-width:40em){.c-share{margin-left:auto}}.c-share__link{display:flex;align-items:center;justify-content:center;width:var(--space-40);height:var(--space-40);border-radius:var(--border-radius-circle);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}.c-share__link:is(:hover,:active,:focus) .c-share__icon{fill:var(--color-text-primary)}.c-share__icon{fill:var(--color-text-secondary)}.instagram-media{margin-top:var(--content-flow)!important;margin-bottom:0!important}.instagram-media:before{content:""}.c-newsletters-labels{margin-bottom:var(--space-32)}.c-newsletters-label__input{position:absolute;top:0;left:0;opacity:0}.c-newsletters-label__input+label{display:flex;flex-direction:row;cursor:pointer;padding:var(--space-32);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary);border-bottom:var(--border-width) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-newsletters-label:first-child .c-newsletters-label__input+label{border-top-left-radius:var(--border-radius);border-top-right-radius:var(--border-radius)}.c-newsletters-label:last-child .c-newsletters-label__input+label{border-bottom:none;border-bottom-left-radius:var(--border-radius);border-bottom-right-radius:var(--border-radius)}.c-newsletters-label__input+label .c-newsletters-label__checkbox{--focus-outline-color:var(--color-accent);cursor:pointer;display:inline-block;text-align:center;width:var(--space-24);height:var(--space-24);min-width:var(--space-24);margin-right:var(--space-12);border-radius:var(--border-radius);border:var(--space-2) var(--border-style) var(--color-border-primary)}.c-newsletters-label__input:checked+label .c-newsletters-label__checkbox{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-3);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-3);font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold);border-color:var(--color-accent)}.c-newsletters-label__input:checked+label .c-newsletters-label__checkbox:after{color:var(--color-accent);content:var(--html-symbol-checkmark)}.c-newsletters-label__input:focus-visible+label .c-newsletters-label__checkbox{outline:var(--focus-outline-size) var(--focus-outline-style) var(--focus-outline-color);outline-offset:var(--focus-outline-offset)}.c-newsletters-label__title{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4);font-weight:var(--font-weight-semibold)}.c-newsletters-label__description{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-3);margin-top:var(--space-4)}.kg-card figcaption{width:100%;padding-top:var(--space-8);color:var(--color-text-secondary);background-color:var(--color-background-primary);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-1);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-1);letter-spacing:var(--font-letter-spacing-long-primer)}.kg-card figcaption a{text-decoration:underline}.kg-card figcaption a:hover{text-decoration:none}.kg-card figcaption a:focus-visible{text-decoration:none}.kg-width-wide{width:100%}@media (min-width:40em){.kg-width-wide{width:calc(100vw - calc(var(--grid-margin) * 2));max-width:calc(var(--grid-width) - calc(var(--grid-margin) * 2))}}.kg-width-full figcaption{padding-left:var(--space-16)}.kg-width-full :is(video,.kg-image){max-width:100vw}.c-content .kg-toggle-card{padding:0;border-radius:var(--border-radius);background-color:var(--color-background-secondary);box-shadow:inset 0 0 0 var(--border-width) var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-content .kg-toggle-card .kg-toggle-heading{align-items:center;padding:var(--space-32)}.c-content .kg-toggle-card h4.kg-toggle-heading-text{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-4);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4);font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold)}.c-content .kg-toggle-card .kg-toggle-card-icon{margin-top:0}.c-content .kg-toggle-card .kg-toggle-heading svg{color:var(--color-text-primary)}.c-content .kg-toggle-card[data-kg-toggle-state=open] .kg-toggle-content{padding:0 var(--space-32) var(--space-32) var(--space-32)}.c-content .kg-toggle-card[data-kg-toggle-state] .kg-toggle-content{transition:none}.c-content .kg-toggle-card[data-kg-toggle-state] .kg-toggle-content>*+*{margin-top:var(--space-16)!important}.c-content .kg-toggle-card[data-kg-toggle-state] .kg-toggle-content p,.c-content .kg-toggle-card[data-kg-toggle-state] .kg-toggle-content ul{font-family:var(--font-family-sansSerif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-3);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-5);margin-top:0}.kg-image{margin:auto}.kg-image-card{min-width:-moz-min-content;min-width:min-content;background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}.kg-gallery-container{display:flex;flex-direction:column}.kg-gallery-row{display:flex;flex-direction:row;justify-content:center}.kg-gallery-row:not(:first-of-type){margin-top:var(--content-flow)}.kg-gallery-image{background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}.kg-gallery-image:not(:first-of-type){margin-left:var(--content-flow)}.kg-gallery-image img{width:100%;height:100%}.kg-embed-card{display:flex;align-items:center;flex-direction:column}iframe[src*="pinterest.com"]{min-width:auto;max-width:100%}.c-content .kg-nft-card{border-bottom-left-radius:var(--border-radius);border-bottom-right-radius:var(--border-radius)}.c-content .kg-nft-card a.kg-nft-card-container{font-family:var(--font-family-sansSerif);font-size:var(--font-size-scale-1);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-1);font-weight:var(--font-weight-normal);max-width:100%;color:var(--color-text-primary);box-shadow:inset 0 0 0 var(--border-width) var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-content .kg-ntf-image-container{background-color:var(--color-background-secondary)}.c-content .kg-nft-image{aspect-ratio:var(--ratio-3x2);border-top-left-radius:var(--border-radius);border-top-right-radius:var(--border-radius)}.c-content .kg-nft-metadata{padding:var(--space-32)}.c-content .kg-nft-header h4.kg-nft-title{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-4);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4);font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold);color:var(--color-text-primary)}.c-content .kg-nft-creator{margin:var(--space-8) 0 0}.c-content .kg-nft-creator span{font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium);color:var(--color-text-primary)}.c-content .kg-nft-creator{color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-content .kg-nft-card p.kg-nft-description{color:var(--color-text-primary)}.c-content .kg-nft-creator{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-1);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-1)}.c-content .kg-nft-card p.kg-nft-description{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4)}.c-content .kg-audio-card{padding:var(--space-32);border-radius:var(--border-radius);box-shadow:inset 0 0 0 var(--border-width) var(--color-border-secondary)}@media (max-width:39.99em){.c-content .kg-audio-card{flex-wrap:wrap}}.c-content .kg-audio-title{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-4);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4);font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold)}.c-content .kg-audio-player *{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2)}@media (max-width:63.99em){.c-content .kg-audio-seek-slider{display:none}}.c-content .kg-audio-time{color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-content .kg-audio-thumbnail{width:var(--space-96);min-width:var(--space-96);margin:0 var(--space-8) 0 0;border-radius:var(--border-radius)}.c-content .kg-video-player *{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2)}.c-content .kg-file-card a.kg-file-card-container{border:0;transition:none;padding:var(--space-32);border-radius:var(--border-radius);box-shadow:inset 0 0 0 var(--border-width) var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-content .kg-file-card a.kg-file-card-container:hover{border:0;box-shadow:inset 0 0 0 var(--space-2) var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-content .kg-file-card .kg-file-card-contents{margin:0;margin-right:var(--space-8)}.c-content .kg-file-card .kg-file-card-contents>*+*{margin-top:var(--space-4)}.c-content .kg-file-card .kg-file-card-title{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-4);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4);font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold)}.c-content .kg-file-card :is(.kg-file-card-caption,.kg-file-card-metadata,.kg-file-card-filename,.kg-file-card-filesize){font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2);font-weight:var(--font-weight-normal)}.c-content .kg-file-card :is(.kg-file-card-caption,.kg-file-card-filesize){opacity:1}.c-content .kg-file-card .kg-file-card-metadata{color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.c-content .kg-file-card .kg-file-card-icon svg{color:var(--color-text-primary)}.twitter-tweet{min-width:auto;margin-bottom:0!important;margin-top:var(--content-flow)!important}.kg-embed-card .twitter-tweet{margin-top:0!important}.twitter-tweet iframe{max-width:100%!important}.kg-button-card{display:flex}.kg-button-card.kg-align-center{justify-content:center}.kg-button-card.kg-align-left{justify-content:start}.c-content .kg-callout-card{padding:var(--space-32);border-radius:var(--border-radius);background:var(--color-background-secondary)}.c-content .kg-callout-card+.kg-callout-card{margin-top:var(--content-flow)}.c-content .kg-callout-card div.kg-callout-emoji{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-4);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4);padding-right:var(--space-16)}.c-content .kg-callout-card .kg-callout-text{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-3);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-5)}.c-content .kg-callout-card-white{box-shadow:inset 0 0 0 var(--border-width) var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-content .kg-product-card .kg-product-card-container{padding:var(--space-32);border-radius:var(--border-radius);box-shadow:inset 0 0 0 var(--border-width) var(--color-border-secondary)}.c-content .kg-product-card h4.kg-product-card-title{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-4);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-4);font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold)}.c-content .kg-product-card .kg-product-card-rating-star{text-align:right;width:var(--space-24);height:var(--space-32)}.c-content .kg-product-card .kg-product-card-description *{font-family:var(--font-family-sansSerif);opacity:1}.c-content .kg-product-card .kg-product-card-button{width:100%}.kg-header-card{width:100vw;display:flex;flex-direction:column;align-items:center;justify-content:center;text-align:center}.kg-header-card+.kg-header-card{margin-top:0}.kg-header-card>*{max-width:var(--content-width)}.kg-header-card:not(.kg-style-light) a:not([class]){color:inherit}.kg-header-card :is(.kg-header-card-header,.kg-header-card-subheader){padding-left:var(--grid-margin);padding-right:var(--grid-margin)}.kg-header-card :is(.kg-header-card-button){margin-left:var(--grid-margin);margin-right:var(--grid-margin)}.kg-header-card-subheader{margin-top:var(--space-16)}.kg-header-card-button{margin-top:var(--space-32)}.kg-size-small{padding:var(--space-64) 0}.kg-size-medium{padding:var(--space-96) 0}.kg-size-large{padding:var(--space-128) 0}.kg-style-light{--color-text-button:var(--color-text-button-headerCardStyleLight);--color-background-button:var(--color-background-button-headerCardStyleLight);--color-text-button-hover:var(--color-text-button-hover-headerCardStyleLight);--color-background-button-hover:var(--color-background-button-hover-headerCardStyleLight);color:var(--color-text-headerCardStyleLight);background-color:var(--color-background-headerCardStyleLight)}.kg-style-dark{--color-text-button:var(--color-text-button-headerCardStyleDark);--color-background-button:var(--color-background-button-headerCardStyleDark);--color-text-button-hover:var(--color-text-button-hover-headerCardStyleDark);--color-background-button-hover:var(--color-background-button-hover-headerCardStyleDark);color:var(--color-text-headerCardStyleDark);background-color:var(--color-background-headerCardStyleDark)}.kg-style-accent{--color-text-button:var(--color-text-button-headerCardStyleAccent);--color-background-button:var(--color-background-button-headerCardStyleAccent);--color-text-button-hover:var(--color-text-button-hover-headerCardStyleAccent);--color-background-button-hover:var(--color-background-button-hover-headerCardStyleAccent);color:var(--color-text-headerCardStyleAccent);background-color:var(--color-background-headerCardStyleAccent)}.kg-style-image{--color-text-button:var(--color-text-button-headerCardStyleImage);--color-background-button:var(--color-background-button-headerCardStyleImage);--color-text-button-hover:var(--color-text-button-hover-headerCardStyleImage);--color-background-button-hover:var(--color-background-button-hover-headerCardStyleImage);color:var(--color-text-headerCardStyleImage);background-color:var(--color-background-headerCardStyleImage);background-size:cover;background-position:center;position:relative}.kg-style-image:before{position:absolute;content:"";inset:0;background:linear-gradient(0,transparent,rgba(0,0,0,.5))}.kg-style-image *{z-index:1}.kg-bookmark-card{width:100%}.kg-bookmark-container{display:flex;min-height:144px;text-decoration:none;color:var(--color-text-primary);border-radius:var(--border-radius);box-shadow:inset 0 0 0 var(--border-width) var(--color-border-secondary)}.kg-bookmark-container:hover .kg-bookmark-title{text-decoration:underline}.kg-bookmark-content{display:flex;flex-grow:1;flex-direction:column;align-items:flex-start;justify-content:flex-start;padding:var(--space-24)}@media (min-width:64em){.kg-bookmark-content{padding:var(--space-32)}}.kg-bookmark-title{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-2);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2);font-weight:var(--font-weight-semibold)}.kg-bookmark-description{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-1);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2);margin-top:var(--space-4);max-height:var(--space-48);overflow-y:hidden;display:-webkit-box;-webkit-line-clamp:2;-webkit-box-orient:vertical}.kg-bookmark-metadata{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-1);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-2);display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;align-items:center;margin-top:var(--space-8);color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.kg-bookmark-icon{width:var(--space-24);height:var(--space-24);margin-right:var(--space-8);border-radius:var(--border-radius-circle)}.kg-bookmark-author{color:var(--color-text-secondary)}.kg-bookmark-publisher{overflow:hidden;text-overflow:ellipsis;white-space:nowrap;max-width:240px}.kg-bookmark-publisher:before{content:"•";margin:0 var(--space-8)}.kg-bookmark-thumbnail{position:relative;min-width:33%;max-height:100%}.kg-bookmark-thumbnail img{position:absolute;inset:0;width:100%;height:100%;-o-object-fit:cover;object-fit:cover}@media (max-width:39.99em){.kg-bookmark-thumbnail img{border-top-left-radius:var(--border-radius);border-top-right-radius:var(--border-radius)}}@media (min-width:40em){.kg-bookmark-thumbnail img{border-top-right-radius:var(--border-radius);border-bottom-right-radius:var(--border-radius)}}@media (max-width:39.99em){.kg-bookmark-container{flex-direction:column}.kg-bookmark-thumbnail{order:1;width:100%;min-height:160px}.kg-bookmark-content{order:2}}.kg-blockquote-alt{font-size:var(--font-size-scale-5);line-height:var(--line-height-scale-8);font-weight:var(--font-weight-medium);text-align:center;font-style:italic;padding:0 var(--space-20)} </style> <style> :root { --dark-mode-accent-color: #8cbfd0; } </style> <script> // ===================== // Dark Mode Toogle 🌒 ☀️ - Inspired by: // Thttps://hankchizljaw.com/wrote/create-a-user-controlled-dark-or-light-mode/ // ===================== var user_color_scheme = localStorage.getItem('user-color-scheme'); function initial_mode_set(mode) { if (mode) { document.documentElement.setAttribute('data-user-color-scheme', mode); } } initial_mode_set(user_color_scheme); window.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', (event) => { var STORAGE_KEY = 'user-color-scheme'; var COLOR_MODE_KEY = '--color-mode'; var modeToggleButton = document.querySelector('.js-mode-toggle'); var modeToggleText = document.querySelector('.js-mode-toggle-text'); var modeToggleTitle = document.querySelector('.js-mode-toggle-title'); var getCSSCustomProp = function getCSSCustomProp(propKey) { var response = getComputedStyle(document.documentElement).getPropertyValue(propKey); if (response.length) { response = response.replace(/\"/g, '').trim(); } return response; }; var applySetting = function applySetting(passedSetting) { var currentSetting = passedSetting || localStorage.getItem(STORAGE_KEY); if (currentSetting) { document.documentElement.setAttribute('data-user-color-scheme', currentSetting); setButtonLabelAndStatus(currentSetting); } else { setButtonLabelAndStatus(getCSSCustomProp(COLOR_MODE_KEY)); } }; var setButtonLabelAndStatus = function setButtonLabelAndStatus(currentSetting) { modeToggleText.innerText = currentSetting === 'dark' ? 'Light' : 'Dark'; modeToggleTitle.title = currentSetting === 'dark' ? 'Light' : 'Dark'; }; var toggleSetting = function toggleSetting() { var currentSetting = localStorage.getItem(STORAGE_KEY); switch (currentSetting) { case null: currentSetting = getCSSCustomProp(COLOR_MODE_KEY) === 'dark' ? 'light' : 'dark'; break; case 'light': currentSetting = 'dark'; break; case 'dark': currentSetting = 'light'; break; } localStorage.setItem(STORAGE_KEY, currentSetting); return currentSetting; }; modeToggleButton.addEventListener('click', function (evt) { evt.preventDefault(); applySetting(toggleSetting()); }); applySetting(); }); </script> <script> var pagination_next_page_number = '', pagination_available_pages_number = '', pagination_loading_text = 'Loading', pagination_more_posts_text = 'Load More'; document.documentElement.classList.add('js-on'); </script> <meta name="citation_doi" content="https://doi.org/10.54900/n5epb-45613"> <meta name="citation_title" content="Language co-option in the open space"> <meta name="citation_abstract" content="Coming down from the recent FORCE11 Scholarly Communication Institute (FSCI) and FORCE2024 conference at UCLA has allowed reflection on some of the recurring themes from the two events. One of these was the issue of language appropriation in the open scholarship space. In the process of attempting to write some"> <meta name="citation_author" content="Danny Kingsley"> <meta name="citation_date" content="2024-09-03"/> <meta name="citation_keywords" content="Meetings"/> <meta name="citation_keywords" content="Thought Pieces"/> <meta name="citation_journal_title" content="Upstream"/> <meta name="citation_language" content="en"> <meta name="dc.identifier" content="https://doi.org/10.54900/n5epb-45613"> <meta name="dc.creator" content="Danny Kingsley" /> <meta name="dc.title" content="Language co-option in the open space" /> <meta name="dc.description" content="Coming down from the recent FORCE11 Scholarly Communication Institute (FSCI) and FORCE2024 conference at UCLA has allowed reflection on some of the recurring themes from the two events. One of these was the issue of language appropriation in the open scholarship space. In the process of attempting to write some" /> <meta name="dc.date" content="2024-09-03" /> <meta name="dc.subject" content="Meetings" /> <meta name="dc.subject" content="Thought Pieces" /> <meta name="dc.language" content="en" /> <meta name="dc.format" content="text/html" /> <meta name="dc.source" content="Upstream" /> <meta name="dc.type" content="article" /> <meta name="dc.rights" content="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode" /> <link rel="icon" href="https://upstream.force11.org/content/images/size/w256h256/2022/09/force11-avatar.png" type="image/png"> <link rel="canonical" href="https://doi.org/10.54900/n5epb-45613"> <meta name="referrer" content="no-referrer-when-downgrade"> <link rel="amphtml" href="https://upstream.force11.org/language-co-option-in-the-open-space/amp/"> <meta property="og:site_name" content="Upstream"> <meta property="og:type" content="article"> <meta property="og:title" content="Language co-option in the open space"> <meta property="og:description" content="Coming down from the recent FORCE11 Scholarly Communication Institute (FSCI) and FORCE2024 conference at UCLA has allowed reflection on some of the recurring themes from the two events. One of these was the issue of language appropriation in the open scholarship space. In the process of attempting to write some"> <meta property="og:url" content="https://doi.org/10.54900/n5epb-45613"> <meta property="og:image" content="https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1535572290543-960a8046f5af?crop=entropy&cs=tinysrgb&fit=max&fm=jpg&ixid=M3wxMTc3M3wwfDF8c2VhcmNofDF8fGxldHRlciUyMGJsb2NrJTIwdG95fGVufDB8fHx8MTcyNDg3NjM4NXww&ixlib=rb-4.0.3&q=80&w=2000"> <meta property="article:published_time" content="2024-09-03T09:50:36.000Z"> <meta property="article:modified_time" content="2024-09-17T18:22:29.000Z"> <meta property="article:tag" content="Meetings"> <meta property="article:tag" content="Thought Pieces"> <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"> <meta name="twitter:title" content="Language co-option in the open space"> <meta name="twitter:description" content="Coming down from the recent FORCE11 Scholarly Communication Institute (FSCI) and FORCE2024 conference at UCLA has allowed reflection on some of the recurring themes from the two events. One of these was the issue of language appropriation in the open scholarship space. In the process of attempting to write some"> <meta name="twitter:url" content="https://doi.org/10.54900/n5epb-45613"> <meta name="twitter:image" content="https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1535572290543-960a8046f5af?crop=entropy&cs=tinysrgb&fit=max&fm=jpg&ixid=M3wxMTc3M3wwfDF8c2VhcmNofDF8fGxldHRlciUyMGJsb2NrJTIwdG95fGVufDB8fHx8MTcyNDg3NjM4NXww&ixlib=rb-4.0.3&q=80&w=2000"> <meta name="twitter:label1" content="Written by"> <meta name="twitter:data1" content="Danny Kingsley"> <meta name="twitter:label2" content="Filed under"> <meta name="twitter:data2" content="Meetings, Thought Pieces"> <meta property="og:image:width" content="1200"> <meta property="og:image:height" content="800"> <script type="application/ld+json"> { "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "Article", "publisher": { "@type": "Organization", "name": "Upstream", "url": "https://upstream.force11.org/", "logo": { "@type": "ImageObject", "url": "https://upstream.force11.org/content/images/2022/06/Upstream-logo--light-mode-.png" } }, "author": { "@type": "Person", "name": "Danny Kingsley", "image": { "@type": "ImageObject", "url": "https://upstream.force11.org/content/images/2024/09/1517666441886.jpeg", "width": 400, "height": 400 }, "url": "https://upstream.force11.org/author/danny/", "sameAs": [ "https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3636-5939" ] }, "headline": "Language co-option in the open space", "url": "https://upstream.force11.org/language-co-option-in-the-open-space/", "datePublished": "2024-09-03T09:50:36.000Z", "dateModified": "2024-09-17T18:22:29.000Z", "image": { "@type": "ImageObject", "url": "https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1535572290543-960a8046f5af?crop=entropy&cs=tinysrgb&fit=max&fm=jpg&ixid=M3wxMTc3M3wwfDF8c2VhcmNofDF8fGxldHRlciUyMGJsb2NrJTIwdG95fGVufDB8fHx8MTcyNDg3NjM4NXww&ixlib=rb-4.0.3&q=80&w=2000", "width": 1200, "height": 800 }, "keywords": "Meetings, Thought Pieces", "description": "Coming down from the recent FORCE11 Scholarly Communication Institute (FSCI) and FORCE2024 conference at UCLA has allowed reflection on some of the recurring themes from the two events. One of these was the issue of language appropriation in the open scholarship space. In the process of attempting to write some of these issues up, it became clear that this requires something of a wander down history lane. So here for your reading enjoyment is my potted history of the language games we have been,", "mainEntityOfPage": "https://upstream.force11.org/language-co-option-in-the-open-space/" } </script> <meta name="generator" content="Ghost 5.80"> <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="Upstream" href="https://upstream.force11.org/latest/rss/"> <script defer src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/ghost/portal@~2.37/umd/portal.min.js" data-i18n="false" data-ghost="https://upstream.force11.org/" data-key="5c1b6ee01f44f70c7feb624aab" data-api="https://upstream.force11.org/ghost/api/content/" crossorigin="anonymous"></script><style id="gh-members-styles">.gh-post-upgrade-cta-content, .gh-post-upgrade-cta { display: flex; flex-direction: column; align-items: center; font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif; text-align: center; width: 100%; color: #ffffff; font-size: 16px; } .gh-post-upgrade-cta-content { border-radius: 8px; padding: 40px 4vw; } .gh-post-upgrade-cta h2 { color: #ffffff; font-size: 28px; letter-spacing: -0.2px; margin: 0; padding: 0; } .gh-post-upgrade-cta p { margin: 20px 0 0; padding: 0; } .gh-post-upgrade-cta small { font-size: 16px; letter-spacing: -0.2px; } .gh-post-upgrade-cta a { color: #ffffff; cursor: pointer; font-weight: 500; box-shadow: none; text-decoration: underline; } .gh-post-upgrade-cta a:hover { color: #ffffff; opacity: 0.8; box-shadow: none; text-decoration: underline; } .gh-post-upgrade-cta a.gh-btn { display: block; background: #ffffff; text-decoration: none; margin: 28px 0 0; padding: 8px 18px; border-radius: 4px; font-size: 16px; font-weight: 600; } .gh-post-upgrade-cta a.gh-btn:hover { opacity: 0.92; }</style> <script defer src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/ghost/sodo-search@~1.1/umd/sodo-search.min.js" data-key="5c1b6ee01f44f70c7feb624aab" data-styles="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/ghost/sodo-search@~1.1/umd/main.css" data-sodo-search="https://upstream.force11.org/" crossorigin="anonymous"></script> <link href="https://upstream.force11.org/webmentions/receive/" rel="webmention"> <script defer src="/public/cards.min.js?v=5d40bd7a9a"></script> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/public/cards.min.css?v=5d40bd7a9a"> <script defer src="/public/comment-counts.min.js?v=5d40bd7a9a" data-ghost-comments-counts-api="https://upstream.force11.org/members/api/comments/counts/"></script> <script async="" defer="" data-domain="upstream.force11.org" src="https://plausible.io/js/plausible.js"></script> <script>window.plausible = window.plausible || function() { (window.plausible.q = window.plausible.q || []).push(arguments) }</script><style>:root {--ghost-accent-color: #8cbfd0;}</style> </head> <body class='post-template tag-meetings tag-thought-pieces'> <a href='#main' class='c-skip'>Skip to content</a> <header class='c-header'> <div class='c-header__top'> <div class='o-grid c-header__top-inner'> <div class='c-header__top-block c-header__top-left'> <button class='c-header__button c-header__button--colorMode c-color-mode-btn js-mode-toggle js-mode-toggle-title' title='Dark'> <span class='js-mode-toggle-text u-visible-on-desktop'>Dark</span> </button> <button class='c-header__button c-header__button--search' data-ghost-search><svg fill="" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 30 30" width="30px" height="30px"><path d="M 13 3 C 7.4889971 3 3 7.4889971 3 13 C 3 18.511003 7.4889971 23 13 23 C 15.396508 23 17.597385 22.148986 19.322266 20.736328 L 25.292969 26.707031 A 1.0001 1.0001 0 1 0 26.707031 25.292969 L 20.736328 19.322266 C 22.148986 17.597385 23 15.396508 23 13 C 23 7.4889971 18.511003 3 13 3 z M 13 5 C 17.430123 5 21 8.5698774 21 13 C 21 17.430123 17.430123 21 13 21 C 8.5698774 21 5 17.430123 5 13 C 5 8.5698774 8.5698774 5 13 5 z"/></svg><span class='u-visible-on-desktop'>Search</span></button> </div> <div class='c-header__top-block c-header__top-center'> <div class='c-logo'> <div class='c-logo__dark'> <a href='https://upstream.force11.org' class='u-block'> <img class='c-logo__img' src='https://upstream.force11.org/content/images/2022/06/Upstream-logo--dark-mode-.png' alt='Upstream' width='' height=''> </a> </div> <div class='c-logo__light'> <a href='https://upstream.force11.org' class='u-block'> <img class='c-logo__img' src='https://upstream.force11.org/content/images/2022/06/Upstream-logo--light-mode-.png' alt='Upstream' width='' height=''> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class='c-header__top-block c-header__top-right'> <a href='#/portal/signin' class='c-header__button u-visible-on-desktop'>Sign In</a> <a href='#/portal/signup' class='c-btn c-btn--small'>Subscribe</a> </div> </div> </div> <div class='c-header__bottom'> <div class='o-grid'> <nav class='c-nav-wrap'> <ul class='c-nav c-nav--main u-plain-list'> <li class='c-nav__item c-nav__item--primary'> <a href='https://upstream.force11.org/about/' class='c-nav__link '>About</a> </li> <li class='c-nav__item c-nav__item--primary'> <a href='https://upstream.force11.org/author-guidelines/' class='c-nav__link '>Submission guidelines</a> </li> <li class='c-nav__item c-nav__item--primary'> <a href='https://upstream.force11.org/authors/' class='c-nav__link '>Authors</a> </li> <li class='c-nav__item c-nav__item--primary'> <a href='https://upstream.force11.org/latest/' class='c-nav__link '>Latest Posts</a> </li> </ul> </nav> </div> </div> </header> <main id='main'> <div class='c-topper'> <div class='c-topper__content'> <div class='c-topper__tag c-tag'> <a href="/tag/meetings/">Meetings</a> — <a href="/tag/thought-pieces/">Thought Pieces</a> </div> <h1 class='c-topper__headline'>Language co-option in the open space</h1> <div class='c-topper__meta'> <div> <div class='c-byline c-topper__byline'> <span class='u-hidden u-hidden'>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/danny/'>Danny Kingsley</a> </div> <time class='c-timestamp c-topper__timestamp' datetime='2024-09-03'> September 3, 2024 <span class='c-timestamp__detail'> . 9:50 AM</span> </time> <div class='c-reading-time c-topper__reading-time'>5 min read</div> <a class="c-nav" href="https://doi.org/10.54900/n5epb-45613">https://doi.org/10.54900/n5epb-45613</a> </div> <ul class='c-share u-plain-list'> <li class='c-share__item'> <a class='c-share__link' href="https://twitter.com/share?text=Language%20co-option%20in%20the%20open%20space&url=https://upstream.force11.org/language-co-option-in-the-open-space/" onclick="window.open(this.href, 'twitter-share', 'width=550, height=235'); return false;"> <span data-icon='ei-sc-twitter' data-size='s' class='c-share__icon'></span> <span class='u-screenreader'>Share on Twitter</span> </a> </li> <li class='c-share__item'> <a class='c-share__link' href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://upstream.force11.org/language-co-option-in-the-open-space/" onclick="window.open(this.href, 'facebook-share', 'width=580, height=296'); return false;"> <span data-icon='ei-sc-facebook' data-size='s' class='c-share__icon'></span> <span class='u-screenreader'>Share on Facebook</span> </a> </li> <li class='c-share__item'> <a class='c-share__link' href="http://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https://upstream.force11.org/language-co-option-in-the-open-space/&media=https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1535572290543-960a8046f5af?crop=entropy&cs=tinysrgb&fit=max&fm=jpg&ixid=M3wxMTc3M3wwfDF8c2VhcmNofDF8fGxldHRlciUyMGJsb2NrJTIwdG95fGVufDB8fHx8MTcyNDg3NjM4NXww&ixlib=rb-4.0.3&q=80&w=2000&description=Language%20co-option%20in%20the%20open%20space" onclick="window.open(this.href, 'pinterest-share', 'width=580, height=296'); return false;"> <span data-icon='ei-sc-pinterest' data-size='s' class='c-share__icon'></span> <span class='u-screenreader'>Share on Pinterest</span> </a> </li> <li class='c-share__item'> <a class='c-share__link' href="https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://upstream.force11.org/language-co-option-in-the-open-space/&title=Language%20co-option%20in%20the%20open%20space" onclick="window.open(this.href, 'linkedin-share', 'width=580, height=296'); return false;"> <span data-icon='ei-sc-linkedin' data-size='s' class='c-share__icon'></span> <span class='u-screenreader'>Share on LinkedIn</span> </a> </li> <li class='c-share__item'> <a class='c-share__link' href="whatsapp://send?text=Language%20co-option%20in%20the%20open%20space https://upstream.force11.org/language-co-option-in-the-open-space/"> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class='c-share__icon icon' enable-background="new 0 0 20 20" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M16.6 14c-.2-.1-1.5-.7-1.7-.8-.2-.1-.4-.1-.6.1-.2.2-.6.8-.8 1-.1.2-.3.2-.5.1-.7-.3-1.4-.7-2-1.2-.5-.5-1-1.1-1.4-1.7-.1-.2 0-.4.1-.5.1-.1.2-.3.4-.4.1-.1.2-.3.2-.4.1-.1.1-.3 0-.4-.1-.1-.6-1.3-.8-1.8-.1-.7-.3-.7-.5-.7h-.5c-.2 0-.5.2-.6.3-.6.6-.9 1.3-.9 2.1.1.9.4 1.8 1 2.6 1.1 1.6 2.5 2.9 4.2 3.7.5.2.9.4 1.4.5.5.2 1 .2 1.6.1.7-.1 1.3-.6 1.7-1.2.2-.4.2-.8.1-1.2l-.4-.2m2.5-9.1C15.2 1 8.9 1 5 4.9c-3.2 3.2-3.8 8.1-1.6 12L2 22l5.3-1.4c1.5.8 3.1 1.2 4.7 1.2 5.5 0 9.9-4.4 9.9-9.9.1-2.6-1-5.1-2.8-7m-2.7 14c-1.3.8-2.8 1.3-4.4 1.3-1.5 0-2.9-.4-4.2-1.1l-.3-.2-3.1.8.8-3-.2-.3c-2.4-4-1.2-9 2.7-11.5S16.6 3.7 19 7.5c2.4 3.9 1.3 9-2.6 11.4"/></svg> <span class='u-screenreader'>Share on WhatsApp</span> </a> </li> <li class='c-share__item'> <a class='c-share__link' href="mailto:?subject=Language%20co-option%20in%20the%20open%20space&body=https://upstream.force11.org/language-co-option-in-the-open-space/"> <span data-icon='ei-envelope' data-size='s' class='c-share__icon'></span> <span class='u-screenreader'>Share via Email</span> </a> </li> </ul> </div> </div> <figure class='c-feature-image-figure'> <div class='c-feature-image-wrap'> <img alt="" class='c-feature-image lazyload' data-src='https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1535572290543-960a8046f5af?crop=entropy&cs=tinysrgb&fit=max&fm=jpg&ixid=M3wxMTc3M3wwfDF8c2VhcmNofDF8fGxldHRlciUyMGJsb2NrJTIwdG95fGVufDB8fHx8MTcyNDg3NjM4NXww&ixlib=rb-4.0.3&q=80&w=1304' > </div> <figcaption class='c-feature-image-caption'><span style="white-space: pre-wrap;">Photo by </span><a href="https://unsplash.com/@shs521?utm_source=ghost&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=api-credit"><span style="white-space: pre-wrap;">Susan Holt Simpson</span></a><span style="white-space: pre-wrap;"> / </span><a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=ghost&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=api-credit"><span style="white-space: pre-wrap;">Unsplash</span></a></figcaption> </figure> </div> <article class='c-post post tag-meetings tag-thought-pieces'> <div class='c-content '> <p>Coming down from the recent <a href="https://force11.org/fsci-2024/">FORCE11 Scholarly Communication Institute</a> (FSCI) and <a href="https://force11.org/force2024/">FORCE2024</a> conference at UCLA has allowed reflection on some of the recurring themes from the two events. One of these was the issue of language appropriation in the open scholarship space. In the process of attempting to write some of these issues up, it became clear that this requires something of a wander down history lane. So here for your reading enjoyment is my potted history of the language games we have been, and continue to, play in this space. They range from arguments about different colours used to describe open, through to how we describe open infrastructure. </p><p>Lately, the challenge has moved into how the words ‘risk’, ‘trust’ and ‘sustainability’ are being weaponised – but that is a discussion for a different post…</p><h2 id="colourblindness">Colourblindness</h2><p>The ‘colours’ used around open access have been problematic from the get-go. For reasons somewhat lost in time, in the early 2000s we called putting a copy of the work into a repository “green” open access, and those articles that were published open access were described as “gold”.</p><p>The challenge was that gold OA came in multiple forms. There were fully gold journals that charged an APC such as those published by PLOS and BioMed Central (which also ran a membership program for discounting - they were ahead of their time). Note this was before BioMed Central was <a href="https://blogs.biomedcentral.com/bmcblog/2008/10/21/biomed-central-acquired-by-springer-sciencebusiness-media/"><u>bought out by Springer in 2008</u></a>. But there were also many fully gold OA journals that did not charge anything – they were free to publish, free to read. The availability from 2001 of open journal platforms such as Open Journal Systems (OJS), developed by the Public Knowledge Project was hugely helpful for this model. There was a third type of gold OA - where an author publishing in a subscription journal had the ‘opportunity’ to pay a fee to make their paper open access. This hybrid open access began at scale with Springer offering the option for their whole portfolio, called<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5624290/"> <u>‘Open Choice’ in 2004</u></a>.</p><p>Over the second half of the noughties there was a battle over the interpretation of gold. The word itself is problematic - with the double implication of ‘the best’ and ‘expensive’. In an attempt to reduce the confusion libraries often made the distinction that gold OA can mean publishing in a fully OA journal which *sometimes* attracts a fee, or in a hybrid journal when it *always* costs.</p><p>This started a cascade of new types of ‘open’ all with attendant colours. Towards the end of the 2010’s ‘bronze’ OA was established. This is not a type of open that is recognised by the 2002 <a href="https://www.budapestopenaccessinitiative.org/read/"><u>Budapest Declaration on Open Access</u></a>. These <a href="https://www.nature.com/nature-index/news/bronze-open-access-supersedes-green-and-gold"><u>articles are available on websites hosted by their publisher — either immediately or following an embargo</u></a>. The lack of formal licensing for reuse (and the fact the works can be withdrawn at any time) preclude their inclusion in a ‘true’ open access classification.</p><p>By the middle of the 2010s ‘gold OA’ was generally understood to mean ‘pay to publish’ (even now libraries still attempt to <a href="https://www.library.yorku.ca/web/research-learn/research/oapublishing/publishoa/"><u>make the original distinction</u></a>). I cannot pinpoint where the term Diamond OA originated, but <a href="https://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2017/06/01/diamond-open-access-societies-mission/"><u>it was established enough to be discussed in 2017 without a great deal of explanation</u></a>. It is now so messy we have different (and yes, complicated) ways of explaining the whole taxonomy, ranging from <a href="https://researchtips.ugent.be/en/tips/00000461/"><u>decision trees</u></a> to <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=125787281"><u>Venn diagrams</u></a>. Arguments are still occurring between players on the field, with multiple recent exchanges described in this 2021 discussion <a href="http://musingsaboutlibrarianship.blogspot.com/2021/04/why-open-access-definitions-are.html"><u>Why Open Access definitions are confusing</u></a>.</p><p>While the term ‘Diamond OA’ is relatively recent, the concept actually started in 1994 with Stephen Harnard’s <a href="https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/253351/"><u>Subversive Proposal</u></a>. Indeed, as an openly available tool for the purposes of publishing open access, the Open Journal Systems (OJS) option has been extraordinarily successful, with <a href="https://pkp.sfu.ca/software/ojs/usage-data/#:~:text=More%20than%208%20million%20items,View%20source."><u>over 8 million items published through the platform.</u></a> However the grassroots nature of much of OJS publishing - occurring at an individual institutional or society level - has meant the scale of the publishing has been somewhat hidden. This has allowed the narrative that diamond OA publishing is somehow disorganised and disaggregated. It has until recently, ironically, been treated as something ‘new’, and there has been a narrative of ‘diamond OA is amateurish so you can’t trust it’.</p><p>But diamond OA is now starting to get organised, with an <a href="https://www.scienceeurope.org/our-resources/action-plan-for-diamond-open-access/"><u>Action Plan for Diamond Open Access</u></a> published in 2022 by Science Europe, cOAlition S, OPERAS, and the French National Research Agency (ANR), which was subsequently <a href="https://www.dfg.de/en/news/news-topics/announcements-proposals/2022/info-wissenschaft-22-26"><u>endorsed by the German funding body DFG</u></a>. Earlier this year, the <a href="https://zenodo.org/records/12721408"><u>Operational Diamond OA Criteria for Journals</u></a> was published.</p><p>This is a potential threat to the ‘gold OA means pay to publish’ narrative. After all, diamonds are ‘fancier’ than gold, so a recent attempt has been to <a href="https://deltathink.com/news-views-diamonds-in-the-rough-societies-shine-under-pressure/"><u>start describing these journals as ‘sponsored’</u></a> with the subsequent implication they are ‘charity’ cases, and at risk of folding. It is an attempt to associate a pejorative to what looks like an expanding and increasingly successful model.</p><h2 id="the-%E2%80%98open-infrastructure%E2%80%99-battleground">The ‘open infrastructure’ battleground</h2><p>Moving on from descriptions of open, the word ‘open’ itself is being coopted into the infrastructure space. As one example (of many), in May 2024, Digital Science published a paper on ‘<a href="https://www.timeshighereducation.com/campus/leveraging-open-research-infrastructure-digital-transformation">Leveraging open research infrastructure for digital transformation</a>’. I responded to figshare’s <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/figshare_leveraging-open-research-infrastructure-for-activity-7195725520997625858-cpjN?utm_source=share&utm_medium=member_ios"><u>announcement about this in LinkedIn</u></a> with a small comment: “<em>Hi guys sorry to split hairs but figshare is not ‘open research infrastructure’. It is commercial infrastructure that supports open research</em>.” This triggered a lively exchange, with Mark Hahnel pointing to the definitions from <a href="https://openscience.cern/index.php/infrastructure"><u>CERN</u></a>, <a href="https://www.unesco-floods.eu/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/379949eng.pdf"><u>UNESCO</u></a> and <a href="https://zenodo.org/records/4159838"><u>SPARC Europe</u></a>, noting that “<em>everyone is entitled to their own opinions</em>”.</p><p>This is not a matter of ‘opinion’.</p><p>Mark is correct, those definitions do not make the distinction between commercially owned and community supported infrastructure. But this creates problems for non-commercial infrastructure. I subsequently responded to Mark: “<em>I think [at risk of major nerdism] this is something worth more discussion. Is there a *different* term that infrastructure supporting open research that is openly (non-commercially) owned and managed should call itself?</em></p><p>The distinction here is the difference between OPEN research INFRASTRUCTURE and OPEN RESEARCH infrastructure. Figshare is the latter - infrastructure that supports open research. But there needs to be awareness that the former (open infrastructure) is a specific part of the ecosystem. It operates differently.</p><p>Another slightly different angle in the infrastructure space is the need to distinguish between open and ‘fauxpen’, discussed by <a href="https://zenodo.org/records/13254190"><u>Geoffrey Bilder</u></a> in a plenary at the FORCE2024 conference. This specifically refers to commercial organisations acquiring research tools that were originally open, but are now behind a paywall, perhaps still appearing to be open.</p><p>Confused? I am not surprised.</p><h2 id="where-to-from-here">Where to from here?</h2><p>These are just a couple of examples of the obfuscation around language in the open world. The stakes have risen more recently with weaponisation of the words ‘trust’, ‘risk’ and ‘sustainability’ (the subject of future discussion). </p><p>This language appropriation is irritating at best but fundamentally it is deeply concerning. There are echoes of ‘newspeak’ as described in George Orwell’s <em>Nineteen Eighty Four.</em> Newspeak changed the meaning of words and was ‘<a href="https://www.britannica.com/art/newspeak">designed to diminish the range of thought</a>’. We need to remain aware of these issues and listen carefully to what is being said, and by whom. </p><p>Words matter. It is very hard to have meaningful conversations and make informed decisions when we cannot agree what we are talking about.</p> <p> Copyright © 2024 Danny Kingsley. Distributed under the terms of the <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode">Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.</a> </p> </div> <div class='c-section-heading'> <h2 class='c-section-heading__title'>Comments <script data-ghost-comment-count="66cf859ca7883574535fb22b" data-ghost-comment-count-empty="" data-ghost-comment-count-singular="" data-ghost-comment-count-plural="" data-ghost-comment-count-tag="span" data-ghost-comment-count-class-name="u-font-size-scale-5" data-ghost-comment-count-autowrap="true" > </script></h2> </div> <script defer src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/ghost/comments-ui@~0.16/umd/comments-ui.min.js" data-ghost-comments="https://upstream.force11.org/" data-api="https://upstream.force11.org/ghost/api/content/" data-admin="https://upstream.force11.org/ghost/" data-key="5c1b6ee01f44f70c7feb624aab" data-title="" data-count="false" data-post-id="66cf859ca7883574535fb22b" data-color-scheme="auto" data-avatar-saturation="60" data-accent-color="#8cbfd0" data-comments-enabled="all" data-publication="Upstream" crossorigin="anonymous"></script> </article> <div class='c-section c-section--related'> <div class='o-grid'> <div class='c-section-heading'> <h2 class='c-section-heading__title'>Related</h2> </div> </div> <div class='o-grid o-grid--4-columns'> <article class='js-card c-card c-card-- c-card-- post tag-meetings tag-news'> <a href='/advancing-data-sharing-and-reuse-barriers-solutions-and-recommendations-from-a-data-workshop/' class='c-card__media'> <img class='c-card__image lazyload' alt="Advancing data sharing and reuse: Barriers, solutions, and recommendations from a data workshop" data-src='/content/images/size/w1304/2024/08/Upstream-data-Figure-2-1.png' > </a> <div class='c-card__content'> <div class='c-card__tag c-tag'> <a href="/tag/meetings/">Meetings</a> </div> <h3 class='c-card__headline'><a href='/advancing-data-sharing-and-reuse-barriers-solutions-and-recommendations-from-a-data-workshop/' class='c-card__link'>Advancing data sharing and reuse: Barriers, solutions, and recommendations from a data workshop</a></h3> <div class='c-card__meta'> <div class='c-byline c-card__byline'> <span class='u-hidden u-hidden'>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/iratxe/'>Iratxe Puebla</a> </div> <time class='c-timestamp c-card__timestamp' datetime='2024-08-21'> August 21, 2024 </time> </div> </div> </article> <article class='js-card c-card c-card-- c-card-- post tag-meetings tag-news'> <a href='/high-quality-metadata/' class='c-card__media'> <img class='c-card__image lazyload' alt="High-Quality Metadata: A Collective Responsibility and Opportunity" data-src='https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1711427686399-67e98ab5ada1?crop=entropy&cs=tinysrgb&fit=max&fm=jpg&ixid=M3wxMTc3M3wwfDF8c2VhcmNofDE4fHxsb3MlMjBhbmdlbGVzfGVufDB8fHx8MTcyMzU3NTAwNXww&ixlib=rb-4.0.3&q=80&w=1304' > </a> <div class='c-card__content'> <div class='c-card__tag c-tag'> <a href="/tag/meetings/">Meetings</a> </div> <h3 class='c-card__headline'><a href='/high-quality-metadata/' class='c-card__link'>High-Quality Metadata: A Collective Responsibility and Opportunity</a></h3> <div class='c-card__meta'> <div class='c-byline c-card__byline'> <span class='u-hidden u-hidden'>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/adam-buttrick/'>Adam Buttrick</a> </div> <time class='c-timestamp c-card__timestamp' datetime='2024-08-13'> August 13, 2024 </time> </div> </div> </article> <article class='js-card c-card c-card-- c-card-- post tag-thought-pieces tag-meetings featured'> <a href='/defining-the-roles-of-research-software/' class='c-card__media'> <img class='c-card__image lazyload' alt="Defining the roles of research software" data-src='/content/images/size/w1304/2023/03/rob-v2-table-6.jpg' > </a> <div class='c-card__content'> <div class='c-card__tag c-tag'> <a href="/tag/thought-pieces/">Thought Pieces</a> </div> <h3 class='c-card__headline'><a href='/defining-the-roles-of-research-software/' class='c-card__link'>Defining the roles of research software</a></h3> <div class='c-card__meta'> <div class='c-byline c-card__byline'> <span class='u-hidden '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/rob/'>Rob van Nieuwpoort</a> <span class=' u-hidden'>, </span> <span class='u-hidden u-block'> and </span> <a href='/author/danielskatz/'>Daniel S. Katz</a> </div> <time class='c-timestamp c-card__timestamp' datetime='2023-03-14'> March 14, 2023 </time> </div> </div> </article> <article class='js-card c-card c-card-- c-card-- post tag-news tag-meetings featured'> <a href='/preprints-and-open-preprint-review-a-workshop/' class='c-card__media'> <img class='c-card__image lazyload' alt="Logos of preprint servers around the globe" data-src='/content/images/size/w1304/2022/10/Overview-preprint-servers.png' > </a> <div class='c-card__content'> <div class='c-card__tag c-tag'> <a href="/tag/news/">News</a> </div> <h3 class='c-card__headline'><a href='/preprints-and-open-preprint-review-a-workshop/' class='c-card__link'>Preprints and open preprint review: a workshop on innovations in scholarly publishing</a></h3> <div class='c-card__meta'> <div class='c-byline c-card__byline'> <span class='u-hidden '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/bianca/'>Bianca Kramer</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/ludo/'>Ludo Waltman</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/jeroen/'>Jeroen Sondervan</a> <span class=' u-hidden'>, </span> <span class='u-hidden u-block'> and </span> <a href='/author/jeroen-bosman/'>Jeroen Bosman</a> </div> <time class='c-timestamp c-card__timestamp' datetime='2022-10-25'> October 25, 2022 </time> </div> </div> </article> </div> </div> <div class='c-section c-section--latest'> <div class='o-grid'> <div class='c-section-heading'> <h2 class='c-section-heading__title'>Latest</h2> </div> </div> <div class='o-grid o-grid--4-columns'> <article class='js-card c-card c-card-- c-card-- post'> <a href='/open-science-call-to-act/' class='c-card__media'> <img class='c-card__image lazyload' alt="Eight hands comes together placed one on top of another as a sign of togetherness" data-src='/content/images/size/w1304/2025/02/hannah-busing-Zyx1bK9mqmA-unsplash.jpg' > </a> <div class='c-card__content'> <h3 class='c-card__headline'><a href='/open-science-call-to-act/' class='c-card__link'>Science is Under Siege: The Open Science Community Must Act and Lead by Example</a></h3> <div class='c-card__meta'> <div class='c-byline c-card__byline'> <span class='u-hidden '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/mayank/'>Mayank Chugh</a> <span class=' u-hidden'>, </span> <span class='u-hidden u-block'> and </span> <a href='/author/jonny-coates/'>Jonny Coates</a> </div> <time class='c-timestamp c-card__timestamp' datetime='2025-02-12'> February 12, 2025 </time> </div> </div> </article> <article class='js-card c-card c-card-- c-card-- post tag-original-research featured'> <a href='/the-time-is-now-vertical-interoperability-between-research-tools-an-essential-enabler-for-the-fairification-of-data/' class='c-card__media'> <img class='c-card__image lazyload' alt="The time is now! Vertical interoperability between research tools: an essential enabler for the FAIRification of data" data-src='https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1676911809759-77bb68b691c9?crop=entropy&cs=tinysrgb&fit=max&fm=jpg&ixid=M3wxMTc3M3wwfDF8c2VhcmNofDZ8fGludGVyb3BlcmFiaWxpdHl8ZW58MHx8fHwxNzM3OTk3OTM4fDA&ixlib=rb-4.0.3&q=80&w=1304' > </a> <div class='c-card__content'> <div class='c-card__tag c-tag'> <a href="/tag/original-research/">Original Research</a> </div> <h3 class='c-card__headline'><a href='/the-time-is-now-vertical-interoperability-between-research-tools-an-essential-enabler-for-the-fairification-of-data/' class='c-card__link'>The time is now! Vertical interoperability between research tools: an essential enabler for the FAIRification of data</a></h3> <div class='c-card__meta'> <div class='c-byline c-card__byline'> <span class='u-hidden '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/rory/'>Rory Macneil</a> <span class=' u-hidden'>, </span> <span class='u-hidden u-block'> and </span> <a href='/author/vaida/'>Vaida Plankytė</a> </div> <time class='c-timestamp c-card__timestamp' datetime='2025-02-04'> February 4, 2025 </time> </div> </div> </article> <article class='js-card c-card c-card-- c-card-- post tag-thought-pieces featured'> <a href='/criteria-for-bibliographic-databases/' class='c-card__media'> <img class='c-card__image lazyload' alt="Criteria for Bibliographic Databases in a Well-Functioning Scholarly Communication and Research Assessment Ecosystem" data-src='/content/images/size/w1304/2025/01/pexels-tima-miroshnichenko-6550462.jpg' > </a> <div class='c-card__content'> <div class='c-card__tag c-tag'> <a href="/tag/thought-pieces/">Thought Pieces</a> </div> <h3 class='c-card__headline'><a href='/criteria-for-bibliographic-databases/' class='c-card__link'>Criteria for Bibliographic Databases in a Well-Functioning Scholarly Communication and Research Assessment Ecosystem</a></h3> <div class='c-card__meta'> <div class='c-byline c-card__byline'> <span class='u-hidden '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/ginny-barbour/'>Ginny Barbour</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/caitlin/'>Caitlin Carter</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/jonny/'>Jonny Coates - ASAPBio</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/kelly/'>Kelly D. Cobey</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/katie/'>Katherine S. Corker</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/elizabeth/'>Elizabeth Gadd</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/bianca/'>Bianca Kramer</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/rebecca/'>Rebecca Lawrence</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/eva/'>Eva Méndez</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/cameron/'>Cameron Neylon</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/janne/'>Janne Pölönen</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/bodo/'>Bodo Stern</a> <span class=' u-hidden'>, </span> <span class='u-hidden u-block'> and </span> <a href='/author/ludo/'>Ludo Waltman</a> </div> <time class='c-timestamp c-card__timestamp' datetime='2025-01-14'> January 14, 2025 </time> </div> </div> </article> <article class='js-card c-card c-card-- c-card-- post tag-news tag-thought-pieces'> <a href='/cultivating-openness-from-community-resources-to-institutional-acceptance/' class='c-card__media'> <img class='c-card__image lazyload' alt="Cultivating Openness: From Community Resources to Institutional Acceptance" data-src='/content/images/size/w1304/2024/11/Screenshot-2024-11-09-at-14-07-25-All-sizes-2024-10-22-Open-Science-Festival-Maastricht---291-Flickr---Photo-Sharing-.png' > </a> <div class='c-card__content'> <div class='c-card__tag c-tag'> <a href="/tag/news/">News</a> </div> <h3 class='c-card__headline'><a href='/cultivating-openness-from-community-resources-to-institutional-acceptance/' class='c-card__link'>Cultivating Openness: From Community Resources to Institutional Acceptance</a></h3> <div class='c-card__meta'> <div class='c-byline c-card__byline'> <span class='u-hidden '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/chris/'>Chris Hartgerink</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/lena/'>Lena Karvovskaya</a> <span class=' '>, </span> <span class='u-hidden '> and </span> <a href='/author/esther/'>Esther Plomp</a> <span class=' u-hidden'>, </span> <span class='u-hidden u-block'> and </span> <a href='/author/dorienhuijser/'>Dorien Huijser</a> </div> <time class='c-timestamp c-card__timestamp' datetime='2024-11-19'> November 19, 2024 </time> </div> </div> </article> </div> </div> </main> <footer class='c-footer'> <div class='o-grid c-footer__content'> <div class='c-logo'> <div class='c-logo__dark'> <a href='https://upstream.force11.org' class='u-block'> <img class='c-logo__img' src='https://upstream.force11.org/content/images/2022/06/Upstream-logo--dark-mode-.png' alt='Upstream' width='' height=''> </a> </div> <div class='c-logo__light'> <a href='https://upstream.force11.org' class='u-block'> <img class='c-logo__img' src='https://upstream.force11.org/content/images/2022/06/Upstream-logo--light-mode-.png' alt='Upstream' width='' height=''> </a> </div> </div> <ul class='c-social-icons u-plain-list'> <li class='c-social-icons__item'> <a href='/latest/rss/' class='c-social-icons__link'> <span class='c-social-icons__icon'><svg xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg' width='12' height='12' viewBox='0 0 24 24'><path d='M6.503 20.752c0 1.794-1.456 3.248-3.251 3.248-1.796 0-3.252-1.454-3.252-3.248 0-1.794 1.456-3.248 3.252-3.248 1.795.001 3.251 1.454 3.251 3.248zm-6.503-12.572v4.811c6.05.062 10.96 4.966 11.022 11.009h4.817c-.062-8.71-7.118-15.758-15.839-15.82zm0-3.368c10.58.046 19.152 8.594 19.183 19.188h4.817c-.03-13.231-10.755-23.954-24-24v4.812z'/></svg></span> <span class='u-screenreader'>RSS</span> </a> </li> </ul> <div class='c-footer-copy'> © 2025 Upstream <span> – Published with <a href='https://ghost.org'>Ghost</a> & <a href='https://aspirethemes.com/themes/tripoli'>Tripoli</a></span> </div> </div> </footer> <script src='/assets/js/app.min.js?v=5d40bd7a9a'></script> </body> </html>