CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en" data-uri="slate.com/_pages/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838@published" data-layout-uri="slate.com/_layouts/layout-one-column/instances/article@published" data-myslateUrl="https://my.slate.com" data-env="prod" data-trackingdomain=".slate.com" > <head> <meta charset="utf-8"> <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge"> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1,shrink-to-fit=no"> <link rel="preload" href="https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Register-Heavy-subset.a571c0d.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin /> <link rel="preload" href="https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Register-HeavyItalic-subset.d42bb80.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin /> <link rel="preload" href="https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Retina-Book-subset.dc123e1.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin /> <link rel="preload" href="https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Retina-BookItalic-subset.e351a4d.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin /> <link rel="preload" href="https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Retina-Bold-subset.77f1049.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin /> <link rel="preload" href="https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Retina-BoldItalic-subset.c2b4700.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin /> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://compote.slate.com/" crossorigin /> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://geolocation.onetrust.com/" /> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://cdn.cookielaw.org/" /> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://experience.piano.io" /> <script> window.slateGlobal = { abTests: {} }; (function() { "use strict";void 0===window.slateGlobal&&(window.slateGlobal={}),window.slateGlobal.injectScript=function(e,t,a){var c=document.createElement("script");c.src=e,t&&c.addEventListener("load",t),a&&c.addEventListener("error",a),document.head.appendChild(c)},window.slateGlobal.injectScriptSync=function(e){document.write('<script src="'+e+'"><\/script>')},Object.freeze(window.slateGlobal);try{var theme=localStorage.getItem("theme")}catch(e){}var matches=location.search.match(/\btheme=(\w+)/);matches&&(theme=matches[1]),-1===["light","dark","auto"].indexOf(theme)&&(theme="light"),document.documentElement.classList.add("theme-"+theme); }()) </script>   <title>When camera phones attack.</title> <meta property="og:title" content="When camera phones attack."> <meta name="twitter:title" content="When camera phones attack.">  <link rel="canonical" href="https://slate.com/technology/2007/01/when-camera-phones-attack.html"> <meta property="og:url" content="https://slate.com/technology/2007/01/when-camera-phones-attack.html"> <meta property="twitter:url" content="https://slate.com/technology/2007/01/when-camera-phones-attack.html"> <meta property="article:published_time" content="2007-01-17T23:21:00+00:00"> <meta name="robots" content="max-image-preview:large">  <meta name="description" content=" Ten years ago, Philippe Kahn was walking around a hospital with a cell phone and a digital camera. His dadly mission: to share pictures of his newborn..."> <meta name="twitter:description" content=" Ten years ago, Philippe Kahn was walking around a hospital with a cell phone and a digital camera. His dadly mission: to share pictures of his newborn..."> <meta property="og:description" content=" Ten years ago, Philippe Kahn was walking around a hospital with a cell phone and a digital camera. His dadly mission: to share pictures of his newborn...">  <meta name="twitter:image" content="https://compote.slate.com/images/83deacaf-aa20-47e0-926b-7bb85371351b.jpg?width=1560" /> <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image" /> <meta property="og:image" content="https://compote.slate.com/images/83deacaf-aa20-47e0-926b-7bb85371351b.jpg?width=1560" /> <meta property="og:image:width" content=1560 />  <meta name="news_keywords" content=""> <meta property="article:tag" content="">  <meta name="author" content="Michael Agger">  <script data-uri="slate.com/_components/permutive/instances/ck5fkydfs1w2szfm54mjf9gik@published" class="permutive" data-permutive-project-id=16d3bd5c-bf92-4bf0-815a-eac397d3aadf > !function(n,e,o,r,i){if(!e){e=e||{},window.permutive=e,e.q=[],e.config=i||{},e.config.projectId=o,e.config.apiKey=r,e.config.environment=e.config.environment||"production";for(var t=["addon","identify","track","trigger","query","segment","segments","ready","on","once","user","consent"],c=0;c<t.length;c++){var f=t[c];e[f]=function(n){return function(){var o=Array.prototype.slice.call(arguments,0);e.q.push({functionName:n,arguments:o})}}(f)}}}(document,window.permutive, "16d3bd5c-bf92-4bf0-815a-eac397d3aadf","dd4993d6-d26a-48b5-bf2d-05b09fb85de3",{consentRequired: true}); window.googletag=window.googletag||{},window.googletag.cmd=window.googletag.cmd||[],window.googletag.cmd.push(function(){if(0===window.googletag.pubads().getTargeting("permutive").length){var g=window.localStorage.getItem("_pdfps");window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("permutive",g?JSON.parse(g):[])}}); window.slatePermutiveData = {"page":{"article":{"pageType":"article","id":"cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838","title":"When camera phones attack.","authors":["Michael Agger"],"section":"Technology","rubric":"The Browser","keywords":[],"gsChannels":[],"publishedTime":"2007-01-17T23:21:00+00:00","sentiment":"positive","categories":["/fine art/digital arts","/news and politics/crime","/movies/family and children movies"],"entities":["Kahn - positive","celebrity stalkers - positive","Slate’s - positive","Philippe Kahn - positive","London bombings - positive","Sean Salisbury - neutral","Birmingham, United Kingdom - negative","Michael Richards - neutral","Camera Phone - neutral","Kalashnikov - neutral","Prince Harry - neutral","Kodak - neutral","Radio Shack - neutral","Kate Moss - neutral","Sportscaster - neutral","Mark Alan Stamaty - positive","op-eds - positive","Peeping Toms - negative","interviewer - neutral","Sophie - positive","Lens of Nostalgia - neutral","Nancy Martha West - neutral","Saddam - negative","inventor - neutral","Victorian America - negative","ESPN - neutral","matchmakers - negative","New York subway - neutral","Rodney King - negative","legislator - neutral","New York Post - neutral","Saudi Arabia - negative","YouTube - positive","Europe - positive","Chicago - neutral","California - neutral","Flickr - positive","Scoopt - positive","Susan Sontag - negative","Asbury Park - positive","Bruce Springsteen - positive","Zapruder - negative","Kennedy - neutral","Dallas - neutral"],"concepts":["Camera phone","Camera","Digital camera","Mobile phone","Philippe Kahn","Digital cameras","Sharp Corporation","Digital single-lens reflex camera"]}}}; </script>   <meta name="twitter:site" content="@slate" /> <meta property="article:publisher" content="https://www.facebook.com/Slate" /> <meta property="fb:app_id" content="142011022527753" /> <meta property="og:site_name" content="Slate Magazine" /> <meta property="og:type" content="article" /> <link rel="manifest" href="/media/sites/slate-com/web-app-manifest.json" /> <meta name="theme-color" content="#f8f8f8" media="(prefers-color-scheme: light)" /> <meta name="theme-color" content="#000000" media="(prefers-color-scheme: dark)" />  <link rel="icon" href="/favicon.ico"> <link rel="icon" href="/media/components/meta-icons/favicon.svg" type="image/svg+xml"> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="180x180" href="/media/sites/slate-com/icon.180x180.png"> <script data-uri="slate.com/_components/polyfills/instances/singleton@published">(function(){ var p='/media/components/polyfills/' function n(f){return p+f+'.min.js'} function i(f){slateGlobal.injectScriptSync(n(f))}if(typeof CSS === 'undefined' || typeof CSS.supports === 'undefined' || !CSS.supports('object-fit', 'cover'))i("object-fit-images") if(!HTMLElement.prototype.closest)i('element-closest-polyfill') if(!window.Promise||!window.URL||!window.URLSearchParams||!window.Map||!Array.from)i('core-js-bundle') if(!window.fetch)i('whatwg-fetch') if(/Trident|MSIE/.test(navigator.userAgent))slateGlobal.injectScript(n('svg4everybody'),function(){svg4everybody()}) if(!window.IntersectionObserver)i('intersection-observer')}())</script> <script data-theme-font="" data-uri="slate.com/_components/fontfaceobserver/instances/fontfaceobserver@published"> /* Font Face Observer v2.1.0 - © Bram Stein. License: BSD-3-Clause */(function(){function l(a,b){document.addEventListener?a.addEventListener("scroll",b,!1):a.attachEvent("scroll",b)}function m(a){document.body?a():document.addEventListener?document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",function c(){document.removeEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",c);a()}):document.attachEvent("onreadystatechange",function k(){if("interactive"==document.readyState||"complete"==document.readyState)document.detachEvent("onreadystatechange",k),a()})};function t(a){this.a=document.createElement("div");this.a.setAttribute("aria-hidden","true");this.a.appendChild(document.createTextNode(a));this.b=document.createElement("span");this.c=document.createElement("span");this.h=document.createElement("span");this.f=document.createElement("span");this.g=-1;this.b.style.cssText="max-width:none;display:inline-block;position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;overflow:scroll;font-size:16px;";this.c.style.cssText="max-width:none;display:inline-block;position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;overflow:scroll;font-size:16px;"; this.f.style.cssText="max-width:none;display:inline-block;position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;overflow:scroll;font-size:16px;";this.h.style.cssText="display:inline-block;width:200%;height:200%;font-size:16px;max-width:none;";this.b.appendChild(this.h);this.c.appendChild(this.f);this.a.appendChild(this.b);this.a.appendChild(this.c)} function u(a,b){a.a.style.cssText="max-width:none;min-width:20px;min-height:20px;display:inline-block;overflow:hidden;position:absolute;width:auto;margin:0;padding:0;top:-999px;white-space:nowrap;font-synthesis:none;font:"+b+";"}function z(a){var b=a.a.offsetWidth,c=b+100;a.f.style.width=c+"px";a.c.scrollLeft=c;a.b.scrollLeft=a.b.scrollWidth+100;return a.g!==b?(a.g=b,!0):!1}function A(a,b){function c(){var a=k;z(a)&&a.a.parentNode&&b(a.g)}var k=a;l(a.b,c);l(a.c,c);z(a)};function B(a,b){var c=b||{};this.family=a;this.style=c.style||"normal";this.weight=c.weight||"normal";this.stretch=c.stretch||"normal"}var C=null,D=null,E=null,F=null;function G(){if(null===D)if(J()&&/Apple/.test(window.navigator.vendor)){var a=/AppleWebKit\/([0-9]+)(?:\.([0-9]+))(?:\.([0-9]+))/.exec(window.navigator.userAgent);D=!!a&&603>parseInt(a[1],10)}else D=!1;return D}function J(){null===F&&(F=!!document.fonts);return F} function K(){if(null===E){var a=document.createElement("div");try{a.style.font="condensed 100px sans-serif"}catch(b){}E=""!==a.style.font}return E}function L(a,b){return[a.style,a.weight,K()?a.stretch:"","100px",b].join(" ")} B.prototype.load=function(a,b){var c=this,k=a||"BESbswy",r=0,n=b||3E3,H=(new Date).getTime();return new Promise(function(a,b){if(J()&&!G()){var M=new Promise(function(a,b){function e(){(new Date).getTime()-H>=n?b(Error(""+n+"ms timeout exceeded")):document.fonts.load(L(c,'"'+c.family+'"'),k).then(function(c){1<=c.length?a():setTimeout(e,25)},b)}e()}),N=new Promise(function(a,c){r=setTimeout(function(){c(Error(""+n+"ms timeout exceeded"))},n)});Promise.race([N,M]).then(function(){clearTimeout(r);a(c)}, b)}else m(function(){function v(){var b;if(b=-1!=f&&-1!=g||-1!=f&&-1!=h||-1!=g&&-1!=h)(b=f!=g&&f!=h&&g!=h)||(null===C&&(b=/AppleWebKit\/([0-9]+)(?:\.([0-9]+))/.exec(window.navigator.userAgent),C=!!b&&(536>parseInt(b[1],10)||536===parseInt(b[1],10)&&11>=parseInt(b[2],10))),b=C&&(f==w&&g==w&&h==w||f==x&&g==x&&h==x||f==y&&g==y&&h==y)),b=!b;b&&(d.parentNode&&d.parentNode.removeChild(d),clearTimeout(r),a(c))}function I(){if((new Date).getTime()-H>=n)d.parentNode&&d.parentNode.removeChild(d),b(Error(""+ n+"ms timeout exceeded"));else{var a=document.hidden;if(!0===a||void 0===a)f=e.a.offsetWidth,g=p.a.offsetWidth,h=q.a.offsetWidth,v();r=setTimeout(I,50)}}var e=new t(k),p=new t(k),q=new t(k),f=-1,g=-1,h=-1,w=-1,x=-1,y=-1,d=document.createElement("div");d.dir="ltr";u(e,L(c,"sans-serif"));u(p,L(c,"serif"));u(q,L(c,"monospace"));d.appendChild(e.a);d.appendChild(p.a);d.appendChild(q.a);document.body.appendChild(d);w=e.a.offsetWidth;x=p.a.offsetWidth;y=q.a.offsetWidth;I();A(e,function(a){f=a;v()});u(e, L(c,'"'+c.family+'",sans-serif'));A(p,function(a){g=a;v()});u(p,L(c,'"'+c.family+'",serif'));A(q,function(a){h=a;v()});u(q,L(c,'"'+c.family+'",monospace'))})})};"object"===typeof module?module.exports=B:(window.FontFaceObserver=B,window.FontFaceObserver.prototype.load=B.prototype.load);}()); !function(){"use strict";function t(e){try{return Boolean(localStorage.getItem(e))}catch(t){return console.error("Error getting "+e+" in localStorage",t),!1}}function e(t){try{localStorage.setItem(t,!0)}catch(t){console.error("Error accessing localStorage",t)}}var o,n,a=[],l="slate_site_fonts",c=(t(l)||[["Retina"],["Retina",null,"italic"],["Retina","bold"],["Retina","bold","italic"],["Register","bold"],["Register","bold","italic"]].forEach(function(t){a.push(new FontFaceObserver(t[0],{weight:t[1]||"normal",style:t[2]||"normal"}).load())}),document.currentScript.dataset.themeFont);c&&(o=c.toLowerCase().trim(),t(n="slate_theme_font_"+o)||a.push(new FontFaceObserver(c).load())),a.length?Promise.all(a).then(function(){e(l),c&&(e(n),document.documentElement.classList.add("has-theme-font")),document.documentElement.classList.add("fonts-loaded")}):(document.documentElement.classList.add("fonts-loaded"),document.documentElement.classList.toggle("has-theme-font",c))}(); </script>  <script> "use strict";window.slateCMP={oneTrust:{},TCF:{},removeTCFStub:function(){delete window.__tcfapi;var e=document.getElementsByName("__tcfapiLocator")[0];e&&e.parentNode.removeChild(e)}},window.slateCMP.oneTrust.ready=new Promise(function(e,n){window.slateCMP.oneTrust.resolve=e,window.slateCMP.oneTrust.reject=n}),window.slateCMP.TCF.ready=new Promise(function(e,n){window.slateCMP.TCF.resolve=e,window.slateCMP.TCF.reject=n}),window.slateCMP.oneTrust.ready.then(function(){"undefined"!=typeof __tcfapi&&__tcfapi("getTCData",2,function(e,n){n?window.slateCMP.TCF.resolve(e):window.slateCMP.TCF.reject(e)})});var TARGETING_CATEGORIES=["C0001","C0002","C0003","C0004","C0005","gad"];window.nonIabVendorApi={vendors:{},checkConsent:function(e){return!!window.OptanonActiveGroups&&this.vendors[e].categories.every(function(e){return-1<window.OptanonActiveGroups.indexOf(e)})},updateVendors:function(){window.OptanonActiveGroups;for(var e in this.vendors)if(n=this.checkConsent(e),this.vendors[e].initCalled)this.vendors[e].updateConsentFunc(n);else{var n=this.vendors[e].initFunc(n);if("boolean"!=typeof n)throw new Error("initFunc should return boolean. Returned "+n+".");this.vendors[e].initCalled=n}},registerVendor:function(e,n){void 0===n&&(n={categories:[],initFunc:function(e){return!1},updateConsentFunc:function(e){}});if(e in this.vendors)throw new Error(e+" already registered");if(!Array.isArray(n.categories))throw new Error("vendorOptions.categories must be an array.");if(!n.categories.length)throw new Error("vendorOptions.categories must not be empty.");for(var t=0;t<n.categories.length;t++)if(!TARGETING_CATEGORIES.includes(n.categories[t]))throw new Error(n.categories[t]+" is not a valid targeting category. Category must be one of "+TARGETING_CATEGORIES+".");if(this.vendors[e]={initCalled:!1,categories:n.categories,initFunc:n.initFunc,updateConsentFunc:n.updateConsentFunc},window.OptanonActiveGroups&&(o=this.checkConsent(e))){var o=this.vendors[e].initFunc(o);if("boolean"!=typeof o)throw new Error("initFunc should return boolean. Returned "+o+".");this.vendors[e].initCalled=o}}}; window.slateCMP.TCF.resolve({gdprApplies: false}); </script> <script src="https://cdn.cookielaw.org/scripttemplates/otSDKStub.js" data-domain-script="0e1d2de3-ec2a-48ca-8f78-11045575a199" data-ignore-ga='true'></script> <script src="https://cdn.cookielaw.org/opt-out/otCCPAiab.js" type="text/javascript" charset="UTF-8" ccpa-opt-out-ids="C0004,gad" ccpa-opt-out-geo="ca" ccpa-opt-out-lspa="true"></script> <script> function OptanonWrapper() { try { window.slateCMP.oneTrust.resolve(); window.nonIabVendorApi.updateVendors() } catch (e) { console.warn('failed to setup onetrust', e) } } </script>  <script data-uri="slate.com/_components/analytics-js-loader/instances/general@published" class="analytics-js-loader" data-amplitude-api-key="5a7cb616c0717cb7f4f0eee43d9f4e1c" data-amplitude-log-level="Error" data-amplitude-domain=".slate.com" data-parsely-script-src="https://fpa-cdn.slate.com/keys/slate.com/p.js" > // we define this ASAP beacuse lots of components call amplitude window.slateAmplitudeQueue = { _q: [], initCalled: false, instance: null, push: function(callback) { if (this.initCalled) { callback(this.instance); this.processQueue(); } else { this._q.push(callback); } }, processQueue: function() { for (var i = 0; i < this._q.length; i++) { this._q[i](this.instance); } this._q = []; }, init: function(instance, consent) { this.instance = instance; this.instance.setOptOut(!consent); if (consent) { this.processQueue(); } this.initCalled = true; } }; window.slateParsely = { leadCaptureEvents: [], trackLeadCapture(event) { if (!window.PARSELY || !window.PARSELY.loaded) { // Run through the leadCaptureEvents queue in client.js when Parsely loads this.leadCaptureEvents.push(event) return; } window.PARSELY.conversions.trackLeadCapture(event); } } </script>  <script defer src="https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/media/components/slate-ad-prebid/prebid.min.9fb13a0.js"></script> <script class="slate-ad-prebid"> window.pbjs = window.pbjs || {}; window.pbjs.que = window.pbjs.que || []; window.slateCMP.TCF.ready.then( function(tcData){ pbjs.que.push(function(){ var pbjsConfig = { bidderTimeout: 1500, debug: false, enableSendAllBids: false, useBidCache: true, bidderSequence: "random", enableTIDs: true, userSync: { userIds: [ { name: "identityLink", params: { pid: "13468", }, storage: { type: "cookie", name: "idl_env", expires: 1, refreshInSeconds: 1800, }, }, { name: "pairId", // see https://docs.prebid.org/dev-docs/modules/userid-submodules/pair.html params: { liveramp: {}, }, }, { name: "sharedId", storage: { type: "cookie", name: "_sharedid", expires: 365, }, }, ], filterSettings: { all: { bidders: '*', filter: 'include' } }, syncsPerBidder: 10, syncDelay: 5000 }, priceGranularity: { buckets: [{ 'min': 0.1, 'max': 5, 'increment': 0.01 },{ 'min': 5, 'max': 8, 'increment': 0.05 }, { 'min': 8, 'max': 20, 'increment': 0.10 },{ 'min': 20, 'max': 50, 'increment': 0.50 }] }, consentManagement: { usp: { cmpApi: 'iab', timeout: 1000, } }, targetingControls: { alwaysIncludeDeals: true, }, // pass permutive segments to selected SSPs realTimeData: { dataProviders: [{ name: 'permutive', params: { acBidders: ['appnexus', 'rubicon', 'pubmatic', 'yahoossp', 'openx'], transformations: [{ id: 'iab', config: { segtax: 4, iabIds: { 126217: '244', 121557: '243', 120811: '268', 120736: '348', 99705: '368', 120738: '406', 121824: '522', 121573: '534', 121576: '581', 121550: '583', 121575: '606', 121578: '687', 121549: '719', 126219: '245', 126220: '246', 126221: '247', 126222: '248', 126223: '249', 126224: '250', 126225: '251', 126226: '252', 126227: '253', 126228: '254', 126229: '255', 126230: '256', 126231: '257', 126232: '258', 126233: '259', 126234: '260', 126235: '261', 126236: '262', 126237: '263', 126238: '264', 126239: '265', 126240: '266', 126241: '267', 126242: '269', 126243: '295', 126244: '305', 126245: '338', 126246: '339', 126247: '340', 126248: '341', 126249: '342', 126250: '343', 126251: '344', 126252: '345', 126253: '346', 126254: '347', 126255: '350', 126256: '359', 126257: '360', 126258: '361', 126259: '362', 126260: '363', 126261: '364', 126262: '365', 126263: '366', 126264: '367', 126265: '369', 126266: '370', 126267: '371', 126268: '372', 126269: '373', 126270: '374', 126271: '375', 126272: '376', 126273: '377', 126274: '378', 126275: '379', 126276: '380', 126277: '407', 126278: '408', 126279: '411', 126280: '412', 126281: '413', 126282: '414', 126283: '415', 126284: '421', 126285: '422', 126286: '423', 126287: '424', 126288: '434', 126289: '435', 126290: '436', 126291: '437', 126292: '440', 126293: '445', 126294: '449', 126295: '450', 126296: '451', 126297: '452', 126298: '453', 126299: '454', 126300: '455', 126301: '456', 126302: '457', 126303: '458', 126304: '459', 126305: '460', 126306: '461', 126307: '462', 126308: '463', 126309: '464', 126310: '465', 126311: '466', 126312: '467', 126313: '468', 126314: '469', 126315: '470', 126316: '471', 126317: '472', 126318: '473', 126319: '474', 126320: '475', 126321: '476', 126322: '477', 126323: '478', 126324: '479', 126325: '480', 126326: '481', 126327: '482', 126328: '483', 126329: '486', 126330: '487', 126331: '488', 126332: '489', 126333: '490', 126334: '491', 126335: '492', 126336: '493', 126337: '494', 126338: '495', 126339: '496', 126340: '497', 126341: '498', 126342: '499', 126343: '500', 126344: '501', 126345: '502', 126346: '503', 126347: '504', 126348: '510', 126349: '511', 126350: '512', 126351: '513', 126352: '519', 126353: '520', 126354: '521', 126355: '523', 126356: '524', 126357: '525', 126358: '526', 126359: '527', 126360: '528', 126361: '529', 126362: '533', 126363: '535', 126364: '536', 126365: '537', 126366: '538', 126367: '539', 126368: '540', 126369: '541', 126370: '542', 126371: '543', 126372: '544', 126373: '545', 126374: '547', 126375: '548', 126376: '549', 126377: '582', 126378: '584', 126379: '585', 126380: '586', 126381: '587', 126382: '588', 126383: '589', 126384: '590', 126385: '591', 126386: '592', 126387: '593', 126388: '594', 126389: '607', 126390: '608', 126391: '609', 126392: '610', 126393: '612', 126394: '613', 126395: '614', 126396: '615', 126397: '616', 126398: '617', 126399: '618', 126400: '619', 126401: '620', 126402: '624', 126403: '625', 126404: '626', 126405: '627', 126406: '628', 126407: '629', 126408: '631', 126409: '640', 126410: '641', 126411: '642', 126412: '643', 126413: '644', 126414: '645', 126415: '646', 126416: '647', 126417: '648', 126418: '649', 126419: '650', 126420: '651', 126421: '654', 126422: '655', 126423: '656', 126424: '657', 126425: '660', 126426: '661', 126427: '662', 126428: '663', 126429: '664', 126430: '665', 126431: '666', 126432: '667', 126433: '668', 126434: '669', 126435: '670', 126436: '671', 126437: '672', 126438: '673', 126439: '674', 126440: '675', 126441: '676', 126442: '677', 126443: '678', 126444: '679', 126445: '680', 126446: '681', 126447: '682', 126448: '683', 126449: '684', 126450: '685', 126451: '686', 126452: '688', 126453: '689', 126454: '690', 126455: '703', 126456: '704', 126457: '705', 126458: '706', 126459: '707', 126460: '708', 126461: '709', 126462: '710', 126463: '711', 126464: '712', 126465: '713', 126466: '714', 126467: '715', 126468: '716', 126469: '717', 126470: '718', 126471: '720', 126472: '721', 126473: '722', 126474: '723', 126475: '724', 126476: '725', 126477: '726', 126478: '727', 126479: '728', 126480: '729', 126481: '730', 126482: '731', 126483: '732', 126484: '733', 126485: '734', 126486: '735', 126487: '736', 126488: '737', 126489: '738' } } }], }, }] } }; if(tcData.gdprApplies || tcData.gdprApplies === undefined){ // pbjsConfig.consentManagement.gdpr = { cmpApi: 'iab', timeout: 5000, defaultGdprScope: true, allowAuctionWithoutConsent: false, rules: [ { purpose: 'storage', enforcePurpose: true, enforceVendor: true, vendorExceptions: ["permutive"] } ] } // pbjsConfig.deviceAccess = false; try { pbjsConfig.deviceAccess = window.OptanonActiveGroups.indexOf('gad') > -1; }catch(e){ console.error(e); } // pbjsConfig.userSync.syncEnabled = false; } pbjs.setConfig(pbjsConfig); // enable analytics. pbjs.enableAnalytics([{ provider: 'atsAnalytics', options: { pid: '13468' } }, { provider: 'concert' }]); // allow all bidders access to cookies and local storage pbjs.bidderSettings = { standard: { storageAllowed: true } }; }) }); </script>  <script async src="https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/tag/js/gpt.js" ></script> <script> window.googletag = window.googletag || {}; window.googletag.cmd = window.googletag.cmd || []; </script>   <script> window.googletag = window.googletag || { cmd: [] }; </script> <script src="https://tagan.adlightning.com/slate/op.js" defer></script>  <meta name="dfp-cache-buster" content=98a6124821071b80359d72d5bff358a2bad22385>  <script id="amazon-aps" data-bidder-timeout="1500" async src="https://c.amazon-adsystem.com/aax2/apstag.js"></script> <script> !function(a9,a,p,s,t,A,g){if(a[a9])return;function q(c,r){a[a9]._Q.push([c,r])}a[a9]={init:function(){q("i",arguments)},fetchBids:function(){q("f",arguments)},setDisplayBids:function(){},targetingKeys:function(){return[]},dpa:function(){q("di",arguments)},rpa:function(){q("ri",arguments)},upa:function(){q("ui",arguments)},_Q:[]};}("apstag",window); </script>   <script> window._taboola = window._taboola || []; _taboola.push({'article':'auto'}); !function (e, f, u, i) { if (!document.getElementById(i)){ e.async = 1; e.src = u; e.id = i; f.parentNode.insertBefore(e, f); } }(document.createElement('script'), document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0], '//cdn.taboola.com/libtrc/slate1-network/loader.js', 'tb_loader_script'); if(window.performance && typeof window.performance.mark == 'function') {window.performance.mark('tbl_ic');} </script>  <style>/* file to fool amphora into not inlining our fonts! */ .tp-modal-open.tp-modal-open{overflow:initial!important}.tp-backdrop{--bg-color:#6b4d64;--bg-color-hsl:314deg,16.3043478261%,36.0784313725%;background-color:hsla(var(--bg-color-hsl),.2)!important}:where(.theme-dark) .tp-backdrop{--bg-color:#ab99a7;--bg-color-hsl:313.3333333333deg,9.6774193548%,63.5294117647%}.tp-close:is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close){top:2px;right:2px;border-radius:0;-webkit-box-shadow:none!important;box-shadow:none!important;background:0 0;width:40px;height:40px;padding:10px;-webkit-transition:opacity .12s ease;transition:opacity .12s ease;opacity:.6}.tp-close:is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close):enabled:hover,.tp-close:is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close):focus-visible{-webkit-box-shadow:none;box-shadow:none;opacity:1}.tp-close:is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close):focus-visible{border:none;outline:dotted var(--theme-color,#ff0e50);outline-offset:1px}.tp-close:is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close)::before{content:"";display:block;height:100%;width:100%;background:url(/media/sites/slate-com/global-sprite.svg) no-repeat;background-size:20px 20px}.tp-container-inner,.tp-iframe-wrapper:is(.tp-iframe-wrapper){height:auto!important;width:auto!important}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .tp-backdrop{--bg-color:#ab99a7;--bg-color-hsl:313.3333333333deg,9.6774193548%,63.5294117647%}:where(.theme-auto) .tp-close:is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close)::before{-webkit-filter:invert();filter:invert()}}:where(.theme-dark) .tp-close:is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close):is(.tp-close)::before{-webkit-filter:invert();filter:invert()}.tp-iframe-wrapper:is(.tp-iframe-wrapper){background:#fff;color:var(--txt-color);font-size:1rem;translate:calc(50vw - 50%) var(--dialog-top,calc(50vh - 50%));max-height:min(100vh,100vh - 30px);margin:0;border:1px solid #eae6e9!important;border-radius:3px;-webkit-box-shadow:0 4px 10px rgba(0,0,10,.15);box-shadow:0 4px 10px rgba(0,0,10,.15);max-width:min(40rem,100vw - 30px)}@-webkit-keyframes dialog-open{from{opacity:0}to{opacity:1}}@keyframes dialog-open{from{opacity:0}to{opacity:1}}.tp-iframe-wrapper:is(.tp-iframe-wrapper)[open]{-webkit-animation:.24s .12s both dialog-open;animation:.24s .12s both dialog-open}.tp-iframe-wrapper:is(.tp-iframe-wrapper)[open]::-webkit-backdrop{-webkit-animation:.12s both dialog-open;animation:.12s both dialog-open}.tp-iframe-wrapper:is(.tp-iframe-wrapper)[open]::backdrop{-webkit-animation:.12s both dialog-open;animation:.12s both dialog-open}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .tp-iframe-wrapper:is(.tp-iframe-wrapper){background:#1a0014;border-color:#56334e!important}}:where(.theme-dark) .tp-iframe-wrapper:is(.tp-iframe-wrapper){background:#1a0014;border-color:#56334e!important}#tp-recaptcha .grecaptcha-badge.grecaptcha-badge{visibility:hidden!important}.article{--theme-color:var(--theme-color-light);--theme-color-rgb:var(--theme-color-light-rgb)}:where(.theme-dark) .article{--theme-color:var(--theme-color-dark, var(--theme-color-light));--theme-color-rgb:var(--theme-color-dark-rgb, var(--theme-color-rgb))}@supports(display:grid){.article:after,.article:before{content:""}.article{margin:0 0 1.8rem}@media(min-width:768px){.article{margin-left:calc(50% - 50vw);margin-right:calc(50% - 50vw);width:100vw;display:grid;grid-column-gap:15px;grid-template-columns:1fr 620px 1fr}}@media(min-width:1024px){.article{grid-column-gap:20px;grid-template-columns:1fr 125.71px 708.57px 125.71px 1fr}}@media(min-width:1440px){.article{grid-template-columns:1fr 240px 780px 240px 1fr}}.article:before{grid-column:1}.article:after{grid-column-end:4}@media(min-width:1024px){.article:after{grid-column-end:6}}@media print{.article{display:block;max-width:40em;margin:0 auto}}}@media screen and (-ms-high-contrast:active),screen and (-ms-high-contrast:none){.article{max-width:1000px;margin:auto}}@media screen and (-ms-high-contrast:active)and (min-width:1440px),screen and (-ms-high-contrast:none)and (min-width:1440px){.article{max-width:1300px}}@supports(display:grid){@media(min-width:768px){.article__fullbleed-header{grid-column:1/span 3}}@media(min-width:1024px){.article__fullbleed-header{grid-column:1/span 5;grid-row:1}}.article__header{grid-column:2}@media(min-width:1024px){.article__header{grid-column:3;grid-row:2/span 2}}.article__top-image{grid-column:2;grid-row:4}@media(min-width:1024px){.article__top-image{grid-column:3}.article__body,.article__share-sidebar{grid-row:5}}.article__share-sidebar{grid-column:2}.article__podcast-subscribe{grid-column:1/-1;grid-row:1}.article__body{grid-column:2}@media(min-width:1024px){.article__body{grid-column:3}}.article--right-rail{overflow:initial}.article--right-rail .article__header{grid-column:2}@media(min-width:1024px)and (max-width:1439px){.article--right-rail .article__header{grid-column:3;grid-row:2/span 2}}@media(min-width:1440px){.article--right-rail{grid-column-gap:0;grid-template-columns:1fr 970px 330px 1fr}.article--right-rail .article__header{grid-column:2}.article--right-rail .article__header .article__meta{-webkit-box-pack:start;-ms-flex-pack:start;justify-content:start}.article--right-rail .article__header .article__meta .article__byline{margin-right:10px}.article--right-rail .article__top-image{grid-column:2}}.article--right-rail .article__body{grid-column:2}@media(min-width:1024px){.article--right-rail .article__body{grid-column:3}}@media(min-width:1440px){.article--right-rail .article__body{display:grid;grid-template-columns:190px 780px;grid-column:2}.article--right-rail .article__body .article__content{grid-column:2}.article--right-rail .article__body .article__content .slate-ad{margin-left:-190px}.article--right-rail .article__body .article__content .social-share{-webkit-box-pack:start;-ms-flex-pack:start;justify-content:start}.article--right-rail .article__body .article__content .pull-quote--left{margin-left:0}.article--right-rail .article__body .article__content .pull-quote--right{margin-right:0}.article--right-rail .article__body .article__content .pull-quote{width:390px}.article--right-rail .article__body .article__content .in-article-recirc{margin:0 0 20px 20px}.article--right-rail .article__body .article__content .slate-external-video--wide{width:auto;margin-left:0}.article--right-rail .article__body .article__content .image--right{margin-right:0}.article--right-rail .article__body .article__content .image--left{margin-left:0}.article--right-rail .article__body .article__content .image--wide{margin-left:0;margin-right:0;width:100%}}.article--right-rail .article__body .article__tags{-webkit-box-pack:center;-ms-flex-pack:center;justify-content:center;grid-column:2}.article--right-rail .article__left-rail{display:none}@media(min-width:1440px){.article--right-rail .article__body .article__tags{-webkit-box-pack:start;-ms-flex-pack:start;justify-content:start}.article--right-rail .article__left-rail{display:block;grid-column:1}}.article--right-rail .article__right-rail{grid-column:3;grid-row:5/span 1;display:none;margin-left:30px}.article--right-rail .article__right-rail .slate-ad{position:sticky;top:30px}.piano-paywall-visible .article--right-rail .article__right-rail{height:0}@media(min-width:1440px){.article--right-rail .article__right-rail{display:block}.article--right-rail .article__share-sidebar{display:none}}.article__sticky-alert{position:fixed;z-index:1;bottom:0;bottom:env(safe-area-inset-bottom);left:0;left:env(safe-area-inset-left);right:0;right:env(safe-area-inset-right);text-align:center;pointer-events:none;-webkit-transition:opacity .12s,-webkit-transform .12s;transition:opacity .12s,-webkit-transform .12s;transition:opacity .12s,transform .12s;transition:opacity .12s,transform .12s,-webkit-transform .12s}.article__sticky-alert:not([hidden])>*{pointer-events:initial}.article__sticky-alert[hidden]{display:block;opacity:0;-webkit-transform:translateY(200%);transform:translateY(200%)}@media(min-width:768px){.article__sticky-alert{grid-column:2}}@media(min-width:1024px){.article__sticky-alert{grid-row:6;grid-column:3}}@media(min-width:1440px){.article__sticky-alert{grid-row:6;grid-column:1/span 4}}}@media(max-width:768px){.article__fullbleed-header{margin-top:0;margin-bottom:0;margin-left:calc(50% - 50vw);margin-right:calc(50% - 50vw);width:100vw}}.article__header{margin:.7em 0 1.1em}@media(min-width:768px){.article__header{margin-bottom:2.2em}}.article__rubric{letter-spacing:.07em;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:.7230659372rem;color:#444;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.85);margin:0 0 .5em;text-decoration:none;display:inline-block;position:relative}.article__rubric:focus,.article__rubric:hover{-webkit-filter:opacity(.8);filter:opacity(.8)}.article__rubric::before{width:10px;height:10px;border-width:4.35px;border-color:#a66884;border-color:var(--bracket-color,var(--theme-color,#a66884));border-style:solid none none solid;content:"";display:inline-block;position:absolute;bottom:100%;right:100%}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .article{--theme-color:var(--theme-color-dark, var(--theme-color-light));--theme-color-rgb:var(--theme-color-dark-rgb, var(--theme-color-rgb))}:where(.theme-auto) .article__rubric::before{border-color:var(--bracket-color,var(--theme-color,#c39bad))}}:where(.theme-dark) .article__rubric::before{border-color:var(--bracket-color,var(--theme-color,#c39bad))}@media(min-width:768px){.article__rubric{font-size:.8232026157rem}.article__rubric::before{bottom:calc(100% + .3em);right:calc(100% + .3em)}}.article__rubric>img[width][height]{height:1rem;width:auto}.article--sponsored .article__rubric{display:none}.article__hed{font-family:Georgia,Times,serif;font-weight:700;font-size:1.6800234952rem;line-height:1.1;margin:0 0 .3em}.fonts-loaded .article__hed{font-family:Register,Georgia,Times,serif}@media(min-width:768px){.article__hed{font-size:2.3234720499rem}}@media(min-width:1024px){.article__hed{font-size:2.6452473706rem}}@media(min-width:1440px){.article__hed{font-size:3.0115850337rem}}@media(min-width:768px){.article--coverstory .article__hed{font-size:3.0115850337rem}.article__hed--black-film-canon{display:none}}@media(min-width:1024px){.article--coverstory .article__hed{font-size:3.4286564334rem}}@media(min-width:1440px){.article--coverstory .article__hed{font-size:3.9034876343rem}}.article__hed--black-film-canon{font-family:Georgia,Times,serif}.fonts-loaded .article__hed--black-film-canon{font-family:var(--theme-font,Register,Georgia,Times,serif)}.has-theme-font.fonts-loaded .article__hed--black-film-canon{font-size:3.6583764145rem}.article__dek{font-size:1.067rem;font-weight:400;line-height:1.2;color:#444;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.85);margin:0 0 1em}@media(min-width:768px){.article__dek{margin-bottom:1.4em}}@media(min-width:1024px){.article__dek{font-size:1.3829997357rem}}@media(min-width:1440px){.article__dek{font-size:1.475660718rem}}@media(min-width:1024px){.article__meta{font-size:.9372071228rem;display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-orient:horizontal;-webkit-box-direction:normal;-ms-flex-direction:row;flex-direction:row;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;-webkit-box-pack:justify;-ms-flex-pack:justify;justify-content:space-between}.article__byline{max-width:65%}}.article__byline,.article__dateline{letter-spacing:.07em;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:.8232026157rem}@media(max-width:768px){.article__byline{line-height:1.4}}.article__byline a{color:inherit;text-decoration:none}.article__byline a:focus,.article__byline a:hover{-webkit-filter:opacity(.8);filter:opacity(.8)}.article__dateline{color:#666;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.7)}.article__dateline>span:nth-child(2)::before{content:"•";padding:0 .4em;color:#999;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.5)}@media(max-width:1024px){.article__dateline{display:inline-block;margin-top:.5em}}@media print{.article iframe{display:none}}.article__tags{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-ms-flex-wrap:wrap;flex-wrap:wrap;font-size:.6776625465rem;gap:1em;-webkit-box-pack:center;-ms-flex-pack:center;justify-content:center;list-style:none;margin:1em 0;padding:0}@media print{.article__tags{display:none}}.article__tag{display:block;text-decoration:none;color:#666;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.7);background:rgba(0,0,0,.03);background-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.1);padding:.6em;border-radius:1px}.article__tag:focus,.article__tag:hover{background-color:rgba(0,0,0,.07);background-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.15)}.article__hr{margin:1.2em 0 0;border:none;border-top:2px solid #ccc;border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.2)}@media(min-width:768px){.article__hr{margin:2em 0}}@media screen and (-ms-high-contrast:active),screen and (-ms-high-contrast:none){.article__fullbleed-header{margin-top:0;margin-bottom:0;margin-left:calc(50% - 50vw);margin-right:calc(50% - 50vw);width:100vw}}.live-update__alert{padding:.7em 1em;display:-webkit-inline-box;display:-ms-inline-flexbox;display:inline-flex;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;gap:1em;-webkit-box-shadow:0 4px 10px rgba(0,0,10,.5);box-shadow:0 4px 10px rgba(0,0,10,.5);background:#2c0022;color:#fff;margin-bottom:1em}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .live-update__alert{background:#56334e}}:where(.theme-dark) .live-update__alert{background:#56334e}@media(max-width:767px){.live-update__alert{-webkit-box-orient:vertical;-webkit-box-direction:normal;-ms-flex-direction:column;flex-direction:column}}.live-update__btn{--button-color:#cc0b40;--button-color-hsl:343.5233160622deg,89.7674418605%,42.1568627451%}.live-update__el{-webkit-transition:background-color 1.2s;transition:background-color 1.2s;border-radius:2px}.live-update__el--new{background-color:#f0f0f0;background-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.07);-webkit-box-shadow:0 0 5px hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.07) l;box-shadow:0 0 5px hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.07) l}.slate-paragraph--drop-cap::first-letter{font-family:"Helvetica Neue",Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif;font-weight:700;float:left;line-height:.5;font-size:5.3rem;margin:.8rem .3rem 0 -.3rem;color:#a66884;color:var(--theme-color,#a66884)}.fonts-loaded .slate-paragraph--drop-cap::first-letter{font-family:Retina,"Helvetica Neue",Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif}@media(min-width:768px){.slate-paragraph--drop-cap::first-letter{margin-top:1.1rem}}@-moz-document url-prefix(){.slate-paragraph--drop-cap::first-letter{margin-top:.07em}}.slate-paragraph__drop-cap{float:left;width:6em;margin-right:.4em}.slate-paragraph__first-word{position:absolute;width:1px;height:1px;padding:0;margin:-1px;overflow:hidden;clip:rect(0,0,0,0);white-space:nowrap;border-width:0}.slate-paragraph--tombstone{display:inline-block}.slate-paragraph--tombstone::after{display:inline-block;width:14px;height:14px;border-width:6.09px;border-color:#a66884;border-color:var(--bracket-color,var(--theme-color,#a66884));border-style:none solid solid none;content:"";margin-left:.2em}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .slate-paragraph--tombstone::after{border-color:var(--bracket-color,var(--theme-color,#c39bad))}}:where(.theme-dark) .slate-paragraph--tombstone::after{border-color:var(--bracket-color,var(--theme-color,#c39bad))}@media(max-width:768px){.slate-paragraph--tombstone::after{width:10px;height:10px;border-width:4.35px}}.image{display:block;margin:0 auto 30px;max-width:100%}@media print{.image{page-break-inside:avoid;break-inside:avoid-page}}.image--edge-to-edge{max-width:none;width:100vw;margin-left:calc(-50vw + 50%)}.image--wide{max-width:none;width:100%}@media(min-width:768px),print{.image--wide{width:620px}}@media(min-width:1024px){.image--wide{width:1000px;margin:3rem auto 3rem -145.71px}}@media(min-width:1440px){.image--wide{width:1300px;margin-left:-188.57px}}@media(min-width:768px),print{.image--left{float:left;margin:0 15px 30px 0;z-index:1}}@media(min-width:1024px){.image--left{margin-right:20px;margin-left:-125.71px}}@media(min-width:1440px){.image--left{margin-left:-168.57px}}@media(min-width:768px),print{.image--right{float:right;margin:0 0 30px 15px;z-index:1}.image--left,.image--right{width:239px}}@media(min-width:1024px){.image--right{margin-right:-125.71px;margin-left:20px}}@media(min-width:1440px){.image--right{margin-right:-168.57px}}.image__meta{border-left:2px solid #ddd;border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.15);padding-left:.6em;line-height:1.1;margin-top:.5em}.image__caption{color:#444;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.85);font-size:.8232026157rem;margin-right:.35em;margin-bottom:.3em}.image__caption a{color:#666;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.7);text-decoration:none;border-bottom:1px solid hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.7);border-color:var(--theme-color,hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.7))}.image__caption a:focus,.image__caption a:hover{color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.7);--theme-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl), 0.7);color:var(--theme-color,#ff0e50);border-color:transparent}.image__credit{color:#767676;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.6);font-size:.7230659372rem}.image__credit a{color:#999;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.5);text-decoration:none;border-bottom:1px solid hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.5);border-color:var(--theme-color,hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.5))}.image__credit a:focus,.image__credit a:hover{color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.5);--theme-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl), 0.5);color:var(--theme-color,#ff0e50);border-color:transparent}.article-hotseats .image--wide{margin-left:0;margin-right:0}@media(min-width:1024px){.image--left,.image--right{width:344.29px}.article-hotseats .image--wide{width:1000px}}@media(min-width:1440px){.article-hotseats .image--wide{width:1300px}}.social-share{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-ms-flex-wrap:wrap;flex-wrap:wrap;-webkit-box-pack:center;-ms-flex-pack:center;justify-content:center;gap:1.5em 2em;margin:1.2em 0}.social-share--podcast-bottom{-webkit-box-pack:start;-ms-flex-pack:start;justify-content:start}@media print{.social-share{display:none}}.social-share__link{text-decoration:none;text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:.07em;color:#444;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.85);font-size:.7715113549rem}.social-share__link--twitter{fill:#4099ff}.social-share__link--facebook{fill:#3b5998}.social-share__link--comments{fill:#ffad10}.social-share__link--share{fill:#2c0022}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .social-share__link--share{fill:#e60d48}}:where(.theme-dark) .social-share__link--share{fill:#e60d48}.social-share__icon{width:auto;height:2.2em;vertical-align:text-bottom;margin-right:.7em;margin-bottom:-.45em;overflow:visible;color:#fff}@media(max-width:768px){.social-share--desktop-only{display:none}}@media(min-width:768px){.social-share--mobile-only{display:none}}.share-sidebar .social-share{-webkit-box-orient:vertical;-webkit-box-direction:normal;-ms-flex-direction:column;flex-direction:column;margin-top:5.5px}@media(max-width:1024px){.share-sidebar .social-share{display:none}}.share-sidebar .social-share__icon{width:2.2em}.top-player-share .social-share{gap:1.5em 1em}.top-player-share .social-share__icon{height:1.8em;margin-bottom:-.25em}.slate-ad{text-align:center;margin:25px 0;padding:0 0 20px;border-bottom:1px solid #ddd;border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.15);-webkit-box-sizing:content-box;box-sizing:content-box;contain:layout;position:relative;z-index:0}.slate-ad .slate-ad__label{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;margin-bottom:10px}.slate-ad .slate-ad__label .advertisement{text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:.07em;content:"Advertisement";font-size:.6776625465rem;color:#999;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.7);line-height:20px;margin:0 10px}.slate-ad .slate-ad__label .border{-ms-flex-item-align:center;align-self:center;background:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.15);height:1px;border:none;-webkit-box-flex:1;-ms-flex:1;flex:1}.slate-ad .slate-ad__creative{height:auto!important}.slate-ad.ad--desktopOnly .slate-ad__creative,.slate-ad.ad--desktopXl .slate-ad__creative,.slate-ad.ad--mobileOnly .ad__creative,.slate-ad.ad--tabletPortraitOnly .ad__creative{margin:0 calc((100vw - 100%)/ -2)}.article--right-rail .slate-ad.ad--desktopXl .slate-ad__creative{margin:0}.slate-ad.ad--box .slate-ad__creative,.slate-ad.ad--leaderboard .slate-ad__creative,.slate-ad.ad--native .slate-ad__creative,.slate-ad.ad--nativeFlex .slate-ad__creative,.slate-ad.ad--podcast .slate-ad__creative,.slate-ad.ad--recircLeft .slate-ad__creative,.slate-ad.ad--recircRight .slate-ad__creative,.slate-ad.ad--rightRail .slate-ad__creative,.slate-ad.ad--sticky-mobile .slate-ad__creative{margin:0 auto}@media(min-width:768px){.slate-ad{margin:25px 0}}.slate-ad.ad--native,.slate-ad.ad--nativeFlex,.slate-ad.ad--podcastTextAd,.slate-ad.ad--rightRail,.slate-ad.ad--sticky-mobile,.top-ad .slate-ad{border:none;margin:0;padding:0}.layout-homepage .slate-ad{margin-bottom:0}.slate-ad.ad--native .slate-ad__label,.slate-ad.ad--podcastTextAd .slate-ad__label,.slate-ad.ad--rightRail .slate-ad__label,.slate-ad.ad--sticky-mobile .slate-ad__label,.top-ad .slate-ad .slate-ad__label{display:none}.hp-bottom-shelf__promo-content .slate-ad.ad--nativeFlex{margin-bottom:1.2em}.hp-top-shelf .slate-ad{margin-bottom:1.8em}.slate-ad.ad--sticky-mobile{position:fixed;bottom:0;left:0;width:100%;background-color:#fff;background-color:var(--bg-color);border-top:1px solid #ddd;border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.15);-webkit-box-shadow:0 0 .2em hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.15);box-shadow:0 0 .2em hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.15)}@media print{.slate-ad{display:none!important;clear:none}}[data-type=non-standard]{height:0;border:none;margin:0;padding:0}[data-type=non-standard]>div{height:1px!important}[data-type=non-standard]>div:before{display:none}.top-ad{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-orient:vertical;-webkit-box-direction:normal;-ms-flex-direction:column;flex-direction:column;-webkit-box-pack:center;-ms-flex-pack:center;justify-content:center;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;background-color:#f8f8f8;background-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.03);height:250px;overflow:hidden}@media print{.top-ad{display:none!important}.bottom-ad{display:none}}.ad--tabletPortraitOnly,.is-edit-mode.ad--bottomOutstream{display:none}.masthead~.top-ad{margin-bottom:1.2rem}.bottom-ad{margin:0 auto;padding-left:15px;padding-right:15px}@media(min-width:1024px){.bottom-ad{max-width:1000px;padding-left:0;padding-right:0}}@media(min-width:1440px){.bottom-ad{max-width:1300px}}.bottom-ad .is-edit-mode.slate-ad{margin-bottom:20px}.top-ad .ad--leaderboard,.top-ad .ad--tabletPortraitOnly{margin-bottom:0}.top-ad .slate-ad__creative{min-height:1px}.hp-top-shelf--coverstory .ad--topShelf{-webkit-box-ordinal-group:4;-ms-flex-order:3;order:3}.ad--topShelf{grid-column:1/span 10}.is-edit-mode.slate-ad{width:100%;margin-left:auto;margin-bottom:10px}.is-edit-mode.ad--leaderboard,.is-edit-mode.ad--mobileOnly,.is-edit-mode.ad--tabletPortraitOnly{max-width:970px;width:100%;padding:10px;margin:auto}.is-edit-mode.ad--leaderboard>div,.is-edit-mode.ad--mobileOnly>div,.is-edit-mode.ad--tabletPortraitOnly>div{margin:auto}@media(max-width:727px){.ad--tabletDesktop,.top-ad{display:none}}@media(min-width:728px)and (max-width:969px){.ad--tabletPortraitOnly{display:block}}@media(max-width:969px){.top-ad{height:100px}.ad--desktopOnly{display:none}.is-edit-mode.ad--leaderboard,.is-edit-mode.ad--mobileOnly{width:100%;padding:0 20px}}@media(max-width:1023px){.ad--rightRail{display:none}}.ad--rightRail+.ad--rightRail{margin-top:500px}.ad--inArticleBanner{clear:both}@media(min-width:728px){.ad--mobileOnly{display:none}.ad--inArticleBanner .slate-ad__creative div[id^=google_ads_iframe]{min-width:620px}}.ad--box{float:right;margin:15px 0 15px 20px;border:none;padding:0;width:300px}.ad--nativeFlex{display:none}@media(max-width:767px){.ad--nativeFlex{display:block}}@media(min-width:1024px){.ad--nativeFlex{display:block}.ad--native+.ad--native{display:none}}@media(max-width:767px){.ad--native+.ad--native{display:none}}.ad--box .slate-ad__creative,.ad--desktopOnly.ad--inArticleBanner .slate-ad__creative,.ad--desktopXl .slate-ad__creative,.ad--mobileOnly.ad--inArticleBanner .slate-ad__creative,.ad--podcast .slate-ad__creative,.ad--tabletPortraitOnly.ad--inArticleBanner .slate-ad__creative,.bottom-ad .ad--desktopOnly .slate-ad__creative,.bottom-ad .ad--mobileOnly .slate-ad__creative,.layout-homepage .ad--desktopOnly .slate-ad__creative,.layout-homepage .ad--mobileOnly .slate-ad__creative,.layout-homepage .ad--nativeFlex .slate-ad__creative,.layout-teaser-list .ad--mobileOnly .slate-ad__creative{min-height:250px}.bottom-ad .ad--tabletPortraitOnly .slate-ad__creative,.layout-homepage .ad--tabletPortraitOnly .slate-ad__creative{min-height:90px}.bottom-ad .ad--sticky-mobile .slate-ad__creative{min-height:auto;max-height:50px}@media(min-width:970px){.ad--desktopOnly.ad--inArticleBanner .slate-ad__creative,.ad--desktopXl .slate-ad__creative,.bottom-ad .ad--desktopOnly .slate-ad__creative,.layout-homepage .ad--desktopOnly .slate-ad__creative{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-pack:center;-ms-flex-pack:center;justify-content:center;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center}}@media(min-width:728px)and (max-width:969px){.ad--tabletPortraitOnly.ad--inArticleBanner .slate-ad__creative{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-pack:center;-ms-flex-pack:center;justify-content:center;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center}}.ad--podcast{margin:0 auto 50px}.ad--podcastTextAd{margin:0;padding:0;border:none;text-align:left}.ad--podcastTextAd>div{margin:0;width:1px;height:1px!important}@media(min-width:1440px){.ad--box{display:none!important}.ad--desktopOnly.ad--inArticleBanner,.ad--tabletDesktop{display:none}}@media(max-width:1439px){.ad--desktopXl{display:none}}.layout-two-column__right-rail .ad--rightRail{position:sticky;top:30px}.ad--sticky-desktop{position:sticky;top:0;z-index:10000;padding:0;height:auto;background-color:#fff;background-color:var(--bg-color);border-bottom:1px solid #ddd;border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.15);-webkit-box-shadow:0 0 .2em hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.15);box-shadow:0 0 .2em hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.15)}.ad--sticky-hide{-webkit-transition:top 1s ease-out;transition:top 1s ease-out;top:-270px}.ad--box,.ad--box .slate-ad__creative{max-width:300px!important;overflow:hidden!important}.article-hotseats .slate-ad{margin-top:0;margin-bottom:68px}.ad--sticky-mobile-index{z-index:5}@media print{.slate-adnode{display:none}}@media print{.slate-analytics-js{display:none}}.masthead,.menu__content{background:var(--bg-color)}.masthead__login,.mobile-account__link,.mobile-masthead__link,.sections__link,.strapline__text[href],.widgets__item,a.mobile-sections__link{text-decoration:none}.masthead{display:block}.masthead [hidden]{display:none}.widgets,.widgets__item{display:-ms-flexbox;-webkit-box-align:center}.masthead button,.masthead input{font-family:"Helvetica Neue",Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif;font-weight:400;font-size:1em}.fonts-loaded .masthead button,.fonts-loaded .masthead input{font-family:Retina,"Helvetica Neue",Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif}.masthead__wrapper{padding:0 15px}.masthead__container{margin:0 auto}@media(min-width:1024px){.masthead__container{max-width:1000px}.masthead--sticky{position:fixed;top:0}body:has(.masthead--sticky){padding-top:40px}}@media(min-width:1440px){.masthead__container{max-width:1300px}}.masthead__login:focus,.masthead__login:hover{-webkit-filter:opacity(.8);filter:opacity(.8)}.masthead--sticky{width:100%;z-index:7}.widgets{display:-webkit-box;display:flex;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;-webkit-box-pack:end;-ms-flex-pack:end;justify-content:flex-end;height:40px;list-style:none;gap:20px;padding:0}.masthead__wrapper:has(>.widgets){background:#e9e6ea}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .masthead__wrapper:has(>.widgets){background:#2c0022}}:where(.theme-dark) .masthead__wrapper:has(>.widgets){background:#2c0022}.widgets__item{height:100%;font-size:.7715113549rem;cursor:pointer;outline-color:transparent;-webkit-transition:color .12s ease,fill .12s ease,border-color .12s ease,outline-color .12s ease,outline-style .12s ease;transition:color .12s ease,fill .12s ease,border-color .12s ease,outline-color .12s ease,outline-style .12s ease;color:#222;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),1);display:-webkit-box;display:flex;gap:.4em;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;margin:0}@media(min-width:1024px)and (max-width:1439px){.widgets__item{font-size:.8232026157rem}}.widgets__item:focus,.widgets__item:hover{color:#ff0e50;color:var(--theme-color,#ff0e50)}.widgets__item.slate-button{--button-color:#ff0e50;--button-color-hsl:343.5684647303deg,100%,52.7450980392%;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;border-radius:3px;color:#fff;display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;padding:.4em .4em .3em}.widgets__icon{fill:#666;fill:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.7);fill:#ff0e50;width:1.1em;height:1.1em;translate:0 -1px}.slate-button .widgets__icon{fill:currentColor}.widgets__dropdown{display:inline-block}.widgets__dropdown>button.dropdown__button{border:none;padding-left:0;padding-right:0}@media print{.widgets{display:none}}@media(max-width:767px){.desktop-masthead{display:none}}.skip-to-main{position:absolute;width:1px;height:1px;padding:0;margin:-1px;overflow:hidden;clip:rect(0,0,0,0);white-space:nowrap;border-width:0;background:hsla(var(--bg-color-hsl),.5);-webkit-backdrop-filter:blur(.1em);backdrop-filter:blur(.1em)}.skip-to-main:focus{width:auto;height:auto;clip:auto}.main-nav{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-align:end;-ms-flex-align:end;align-items:flex-end;height:100px;-webkit-box-sizing:content-box;box-sizing:content-box;padding-bottom:1rem;border-bottom:1px solid #ccc;border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.2)}.main-nav__logo{line-height:0;-webkit-box-flex:1;-ms-flex:1 1 200px;flex:1 1 200px;min-width:168px;max-width:240px;margin-right:.5em}@media(min-width:1440px){.main-nav__logo{max-width:258px}}.mini-nav{border-bottom:1px solid #ccc;border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.2)}.mini-nav__content{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;-webkit-box-pack:justify;-ms-flex-pack:justify;justify-content:space-between;font-size:.7715113549rem;font-size:.8232026157rem}.masthead .search-form,.sections{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox}@media(min-width:1024px)and (max-width:1439px){.mini-nav__content{font-size:.8232026157rem}}.mini-nav__logo{padding-top:2px;overflow:clip;height:40px}.mini-nav__search{-webkit-box-flex:1;-ms-flex-positive:1;flex-grow:1;-webkit-box-pack:end;-ms-flex-pack:end;justify-content:flex-end}.mini-nav__account{line-height:1;margin:0}.masthead .logo{width:100%;height:auto;max-height:80px;fill:#2c0022;translate:0 3.2%}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .masthead .logo{fill:#fff}}:where(.theme-dark) .masthead .logo{fill:#fff}.masthead .search-form{display:flex;-webkit-box-align:baseline;-ms-flex-align:baseline;align-items:baseline;position:relative;-webkit-transition:all .1s;transition:all .1s}.masthead .search-form:focus-within .search-form__input{cursor:initial;outline:0;border-bottom-color:#ff0e50;-webkit-transform:translateX(0);transform:translateX(0);width:20vw}.masthead .search-form:focus-within .search-form__input:focus:not(:-moz-placeholder-shown){min-width:10em}.masthead .search-form:focus-within .search-form__input:focus:not(:placeholder-shown){min-width:10em}.masthead .search-form:focus-within .search-form__label{opacity:0}.masthead .search-form:focus-within .search-form__submit{opacity:1;-webkit-transform:translateX(0);transform:translateX(0);z-index:1}.masthead .search-form__input,.masthead .search-form__label,.masthead .search-form__submit{-webkit-transition:all .1s;transition:all .1s}.masthead .search-form__icon{width:1.1em;height:1.1em;vertical-align:text-bottom;cursor:pointer}.masthead .search-form__label{-webkit-box-ordinal-group:2;-ms-flex-order:1;order:1;fill:#666;fill:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.7);margin-right:.2em;-webkit-transform:translateX(2em);transform:translateX(2em)}.masthead .search-form__submit{border:none;background:0 0;-webkit-box-ordinal-group:4;-ms-flex-order:3;order:3;fill:#ff0e50;opacity:0;-webkit-transform:translateX(2em);transform:translateX(2em);z-index:-5}.masthead .search-form__input{-webkit-box-ordinal-group:3;-ms-flex-order:2;order:2;background:0 0;border:none;border-bottom:1px solid transparent;padding:0;min-width:3.2em;color:inherit;cursor:pointer;-webkit-transform:translateX(2em);transform:translateX(2em);width:3.2em}.masthead .search-form__input::-webkit-input-placeholder{color:inherit;opacity:1}.masthead .search-form__input::-moz-placeholder{color:inherit;opacity:1}.masthead .search-form__input::-ms-input-placeholder{color:inherit;opacity:1}.masthead .search-form__input::placeholder{color:inherit;opacity:1}.masthead .search-form__input::-moz-selection{background-color:#e1cdd6}.masthead .search-form__input::selection{background-color:#e1cdd6}.masthead .search-form__input:-webkit-autofill{-webkit-text-fill-color:#fff}@media print{.masthead .search-form{display:none}}.sections{margin:1.5em 0 0;list-style:none;padding:0;display:flex;font-size:2vw;line-height:1cap}.sections__item{margin-left:.5em;white-space:nowrap}@media(min-width:768px){.sections__item{padding-left:.25em;padding-right:.25em}}@media(min-width:1024px){.sections{font-size:1.067rem}.sections__item{padding-left:.5em;padding-right:.5em}}.sections__link{border-bottom:4px solid transparent;padding-bottom:.2em;-webkit-transition:border .2s;transition:border .2s}.sections__link:focus,.sections__link:hover,.sections__link[aria-current]{border-color:#ff0e50}.mobile-masthead{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-pack:justify;-ms-flex-pack:justify;justify-content:space-between;height:50px;border-bottom:1px solid #ccc;border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.2)}.mobile-masthead__menu{-webkit-box-flex:0;-ms-flex:0 0 6.2em;flex:0 0 6.2em}.mobile-masthead__account{padding:15px;-webkit-box-flex:0;-ms-flex:0 0 6.2em;flex:0 0 6.2em}@media print{.mobile-masthead__account{display:none}}.mobile-masthead__mobile-link{font-size:.7715113549rem}@media(min-width:1024px)and (max-width:1439px){.mobile-masthead__mobile-link{font-size:.8232026157rem}}.mobile-masthead__link{border-bottom:2px solid #ff0e50;border-color:var(--theme-color,#ff0e50)}.mobile-masthead__link:focus,.mobile-masthead__link:hover{color:#ff0e50;color:var(--theme-color,#ff0e50);border-color:transparent}@media(min-width:768px){.mobile-masthead,.mobile-masthead__link{display:none}}.mobile-masthead__logo{line-height:0;-ms-flex-item-align:end;align-self:flex-end;overflow:hidden}@media(max-width:319px){.mobile-masthead__logo>a{display:inline-block;width:27px;overflow:hidden}.mobile-masthead__logo>a>.logo{width:auto}}.mobile-masthead #mobile-masthead-link .tp-container-inner{height:1.2rem!important}.menu-open,.menu-open>body{height:100%;overflow:hidden;position:fixed}.menu__header{height:50px;display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;-webkit-box-pack:justify;-ms-flex-pack:justify;justify-content:space-between}.menu__header::after{content:"";-webkit-box-flex:0;-ms-flex:0 0 50px;flex:0 0 50px}.menu__title{font-size:1.138489rem;font-weight:700}.menu__content{position:absolute;z-index:7;top:0;display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-orient:vertical;-webkit-box-direction:normal;-ms-flex-direction:column;flex-direction:column;height:100%;width:100vw;overflow-y:scroll;-webkit-overflow-scrolling:touch;-webkit-transition:-webkit-transform .2s ease-in-out;transition:-webkit-transform .2s ease-in-out;transition:transform .2s ease-in-out;transition:transform .2s ease-in-out,-webkit-transform .2s ease-in-out}.menu:not(.menu--open)>.menu__content{-webkit-transform:translateX(-100%);transform:translateX(-100%)}.menu__control:focus+.menu__content,.menu__control:hover+.menu__content{will-change:transform}.menu__control{-webkit-box-flex:0;-ms-flex:0 0 50px;flex:0 0 50px;position:static!important;border:none;border-radius:0;padding:15px;font-size:.878357191rem;background:0 0;color:inherit}.menu__control svg{fill:#666;fill:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.7)}.menu__control:focus svg,.menu__control:hover svg{opacity:1}.menu__control--open{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;gap:.6em}@media print{.menu{display:none}}.mobile-sections{-webkit-box-flex:1;-ms-flex:1 0 auto;flex:1 0 auto}.mobile-sections__link{padding:15px;border-width:0 0 1px;border-style:solid;border-color:#ccc;fill:currentColor}.mobile-sections__link:first-child{border-top-width:1px}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .mobile-sections__link{border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.2)}}:where(.theme-dark) .mobile-sections__link{border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.2)}.mobile-sections__link--pods{fill:#ff4900}.mobile-sections__link:empty{display:none}a.mobile-sections__link{color:#222;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),1);display:block}a.mobile-sections__link:focus,a.mobile-sections__link:hover{-webkit-filter:opacity(.8);filter:opacity(.8)}.mag-lens{vertical-align:text-bottom;fill:#666;fill:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.7);margin-right:.2em}.mobile-account{font-size:.878357191rem;border-top:1px solid rgba(255,255,255,.1)}.mobile-account__link{color:#fff;float:left;width:calc(50% - .5px);text-align:center;padding:1.3em 0}.mobile-account__link:focus,.mobile-account__link:hover{color:rgba(255,255,255,.8);--theme-color:rgba(255, 255, 255, 0.8);--theme-color-hsl:0deg,0%,100%;color:var(--theme-color,#ff0e50)}.mobile-account__link:first-child{border-right:1px solid rgba(255,255,255,.1);width:calc(50% + .5px)}.strapline{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;font-size:.6776625465rem;margin:1.2rem auto 1.8em}.strapline__asterisk{margin-right:.6em;fill:#ff0e50;-ms-flex-negative:0;flex-shrink:0;width:2.1em;height:2.3em}.strapline__text{line-height:1.5;text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:.07em;color:#666;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.7)}.strapline__text[href]{color:inherit}.strapline__text[href]:focus,.strapline__text[href]:hover{color:#999;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.5)}.strapline__search{color:#444;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.85);margin-left:auto;display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;gap:1.2em;-webkit-box-align:baseline;-ms-flex-align:baseline;align-items:baseline;font-size:.7715113549rem}@media(min-width:1024px)and (max-width:1439px){.strapline__search{font-size:.8232026157rem}}@media(max-width:767px){.strapline__search{display:none}}.theme-picker{width:5em}.theme-picker .dropdown__label>svg,.theme-picker__option>svg{fill:currentColor;vertical-align:text-bottom;opacity:.7}.theme-picker .theme-picker__button.theme-picker__button{margin:-.5em -.5714285714em}.theme-picker .dropdown__label svg{margin-right:.2em}.piano-mount__container{height:auto!important;width:100%!important}.piano-mount>.piano-id-container{height:auto!important}.piano-mount__paywall{margin-bottom:-7.8947368421rem}.piano-mount .slate-full-bleed .tp-container-inner{margin-left:calc(50% - 50vw);margin-right:calc(50% - 50vw);width:100vw}.piano-mount--in-article{display:block;grid-column:3;grid-column-gap:0!important;margin:0!important;position:relative;--theme-color:var(--theme-color-light);--theme-color-rgb:var(--theme-color-light-rgb)}:where(.theme-dark) .piano-mount--in-article{--theme-color:var(--theme-color-dark, var(--theme-color-light));--theme-color-rgb:var(--theme-color-dark-rgb, var(--theme-color-rgb))}@supports(display:grid){.piano-mount--in-article{margin:0 0 1.8rem}@media(min-width:768px){.piano-mount--in-article{margin-left:calc(50% - 50vw);margin-right:calc(50% - 50vw);width:100vw;display:grid;grid-column-gap:15px;grid-template-columns:1fr 620px 1fr}}@media(min-width:1024px){.piano-mount--in-article{grid-column-gap:20px;grid-template-columns:1fr 125.71px 708.57px 125.71px 1fr}}@media(min-width:1440px){.piano-mount--in-article{grid-template-columns:1fr 240px 780px 240px 1fr}}.piano-mount--in-article:before{grid-column:1;content:""}.piano-mount--in-article:after{content:"";grid-column-end:4}@media(min-width:1024px){.piano-mount--in-article:after{grid-column-end:6}}@media print{.piano-mount--in-article{display:block;max-width:40em;margin:0 auto}}}@media screen and (-ms-high-contrast:active),screen and (-ms-high-contrast:none){.piano-mount--in-article{max-width:1000px;margin:auto}}@media screen and (-ms-high-contrast:active)and (min-width:1440px),screen and (-ms-high-contrast:none)and (min-width:1440px){.piano-mount--in-article{max-width:1300px}}.piano-mount--in-article .tp-container-inner{width:auto!important;height:auto!important;grid-column:2;position:relative;top:-8.8947368421rem;margin-bottom:-8.8947368421rem}@media(min-width:1024px){.piano-mount--in-article .tp-container-inner{grid-column:3}}.piano-mount--fixed-bottom{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;bottom:0;-webkit-box-orient:vertical;-webkit-box-direction:normal;-ms-flex-direction:column;flex-direction:column;-webkit-box-pack:end;-ms-flex-pack:end;justify-content:flex-end;left:0;position:fixed;top:auto;z-index:6;width:100vw!important}.piano-mount--loading>.piano-mount__loader{text-align:center;display:block}.piano-mount--loading>.piano-mount__loader::before{content:"";display:inline-block;width:1.2em;height:1.2em;border-radius:50%;border:.2em solid #2c0022;border-bottom-color:transparent!important;-webkit-animation:1s spinner-spin linear infinite;animation:1s spinner-spin linear infinite}@-webkit-keyframes spinner-spin{to{-webkit-transform:rotate(360deg);transform:rotate(360deg)}}@keyframes spinner-spin{to{-webkit-transform:rotate(360deg);transform:rotate(360deg)}}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .piano-mount--in-article{--theme-color:var(--theme-color-dark, var(--theme-color-light));--theme-color-rgb:var(--theme-color-dark-rgb, var(--theme-color-rgb))}:where(.theme-auto) .piano-mount--loading>.piano-mount__loader::before{border-color:#ab99a7}}:where(.theme-dark) .piano-mount--loading>.piano-mount__loader::before{border-color:#ab99a7}.piano-mount--loading>.piano-mount__loader~.piano-mount__container{visibility:hidden}.piano-mount--error>.piano-mount__error{display:block}.piano-paywall-visible .article .article__body .article__content>*,.piano-paywall-visible .article .article__body>:not(.article__content):not(.article__left-rail),.piano-paywall-visible .article__content hr,.piano-paywall-visible .article__hr{display:none}.piano-paywall-visible .article .article__body .article__content>.slate-external-video:first-child,.piano-paywall-visible .article .article__body .article__content>figure:first-child,.piano-paywall-visible .article .article__body .article__content>p:nth-of-type(-1n+2){display:block}.piano-paywall-visible .article-quiz .article-quiz__body .article-quiz__content>*,.piano-paywall-visible .article-quiz .article-quiz__body>:not(.article-quiz__content),.piano-paywall-visible .article-quiz__content hr,.piano-paywall-visible .article-quiz__hr{display:none}.piano-paywall-visible .article-quiz .article-quiz__body .article-quiz__content>.interactive-instructions,.piano-paywall-visible .article-quiz .article-quiz__body .article-quiz__content>.newsletter-signup,.piano-paywall-visible .article-quiz .article-quiz__body .article-quiz__content>.slate-external-video:first-child,.piano-paywall-visible .article-quiz .article-quiz__body .article-quiz__content>:not(.subhead)+p,.piano-paywall-visible .article-quiz .article-quiz__body .article-quiz__content>p:first-of-type{display:block}.piano-paywall-visible .article-crossword .article-crossword__body .article-crossword__content>div>:not(.crosshare),.piano-paywall-visible .article-crossword .article-crossword__body>:not(.article-crossword__content),.piano-paywall-visible .article-crossword__content hr,.piano-paywall-visible .article-crossword__hr,.piano-paywall-visible+.l-container #cxense-recs,.piano-paywall-visible+.l-container .taboola-recirc{display:none}.piano-paywall-visible .article-crossword,.piano-paywall-visible .article-crossword .article-crossword__body .article-crossword__content>div>.crosshare{margin-bottom:0}.piano-paywall-visible .article-crossword~.piano-mount .piano-mount--in-article .tp-container-inner{grid-column:2}@media(min-width:1024px)and (max-width:1439px){.piano-paywall-visible .article-crossword~.piano-mount .piano-mount--in-article .tp-container-inner{grid-column:3}}@media(min-width:1440px){.piano-paywall-visible .article--right-rail~.piano-mount .piano-mount--in-article{grid-template-columns:1fr 190px 780px 330px 1fr}.piano-paywall-visible .article-crossword~.piano-mount .piano-mount--in-article{grid-template-columns:1fr 1080px 1fr}.piano-paywall-visible .article--coverstory~.piano-mount .piano-mount--in-article{grid-template-columns:1fr 240px 780px 240px 1fr}}.taboola-recirc{position:relative;z-index:1}@media print{.taboola-recirc{display:none}}.taboola_spotlight_overlay{z-index:2!important}.global-footer{margin-top:100px;font-size:.8232026157rem;line-height:1.5;color:#fff;background:#2c0022}@media(min-width:768px){.global-footer{font-size:.7230659372rem}}@media print{.global-footer{background:0 0;color:#2c0022}}.global-footer a{color:currentColor;text-decoration:none}.global-footer a:focus,.global-footer a:hover{-webkit-filter:opacity(.8);filter:opacity(.8)}.global-footer__main{padding:40px 15px}.global-footer__main-content{margin:0 auto;display:grid;grid-template-columns:repeat(12,1fr);grid-column-gap:10px}@media(min-width:1024px){.global-footer{font-size:.7715113549rem}.global-footer__main-content{max-width:1000px}}@media(min-width:1440px){.global-footer__main-content{max-width:1300px}}.global-footer__about,.global-footer__ad,.global-footer__sub{grid-column:span 6}@media(min-width:768px){.global-footer__about,.global-footer__ad,.global-footer__sub{grid-column:span 2}}.global-footer__heading{text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:.07em;margin-top:0;margin-bottom:.75em}@media print{.global-footer__main{padding-bottom:0}.global-footer__heading{display:none}}.global-footer__links{margin:0 0 2em;list-style:none;padding:0}.global-footer__links li{margin-bottom:.75em}.global-footer__links__cookie-prefs-link{display:-webkit-inline-box;display:-ms-inline-flexbox;display:inline-flex;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center}.global-footer__links__ccpa-logo{margin-right:4px}.global-footer__brand-section{grid-column:1/span 12}.global-footer__logo{max-width:200px;fill:currentColor}@media(min-width:768px){.global-footer__brand-section{grid-column:8/span 5}.global-footer__logo{max-width:100%}}.global-footer__brand-text{margin-top:.75em;margin-bottom:2em}@media print{.global-footer__links{display:none}.global-footer__brand-text{margin-bottom:.5em}.global-footer__social-links{display:none}}.global-footer__social-link{margin-right:1em;margin-bottom:.5em;display:inline-block}.global-footer__social-badge{fill:#56334e;margin-right:.5em;vertical-align:bottom}.global-footer__legal{background:#23001b;padding:1.5em 15px}.global-footer__legal-content{margin:0 auto}@media(min-width:1024px){.global-footer__legal-content{max-width:1000px}}@media(min-width:1440px){.global-footer__legal-content{max-width:1300px}}@media(min-width:768px){.global-footer__legal-content{display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;-webkit-box-pack:justify;-ms-flex-pack:justify;justify-content:space-between}.global-footer__legal-links{margin:0}}.global-footer__legal-links{padding-left:0;list-style:none;display:-webkit-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex}@media print{.global-footer__legal{padding-top:0}.global-footer__legal-links{display:none}}.global-footer__legal-link:first-of-type:after{content:"•";margin:0 .7em}@media(min-width:768px){.global-footer__legal-text{margin:0}}@media print{.slate-ad-prebid{display:none}}a,button:enabled{cursor:pointer}a,button,input{color:inherit}.slate-modal,body,button,input[type=checkbox]{margin:0}html{-webkit-box-sizing:border-box;box-sizing:border-box;overflow-x:hidden;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;-moz-text-size-adjust:100%;-ms-text-size-adjust:100%;text-size-adjust:100%}body{overflow-x:clip;padding:0;font-family:"Helvetica Neue",Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif;font-weight:400;background-color:var(--bg-color);color:#222;color:var(--txt-color)}.slate-button,.slate-input{padding:.5em .5714285714em}:root{--raisin-color:#2c0022;--raisin-color-hsl:313.6363636364deg,100%,8.6274509804%;--plum-color:#6a0432;--plum-color-hsl:332.9411764706deg,92.7272727273%,21.568627451%;--cherry-color:#ff0e50;--cherry-color-hsl:343.5684647303deg,100%,52.7450980392%;--clementine-color:#ffad10;--clementine-color-hsl:39.4142259414deg,100%,53.137254902%;--glacier-color:#21aaeb;--glacier-color-hsl:199.3069306931deg,83.4710743802%,52.5490196078%;--kiwi-color:#78d33d;--kiwi-color-hsl:96.4deg,63.025210084%,53.3333333333%;--mint-color:#00bfa5;--mint-color-hsl:171.832460733deg,100%,37.4509803922%;--carrot-color:#ff4900;--carrot-color-hsl:17.1764705882deg,100%,50%;--partisan-red-color:#d32f2f;--partisan-red-color-hsl:0deg,65.0793650794%,50.5882352941%;--partisan-blue-color:#1565c0;--partisan-blue-color-hsl:211.9298245614deg,80.2816901408%,41.7647058824%;--gray-2-color:#222;--gray-2-color-hsl:0deg,0%,13.3333333333%;--gray-4-color:#444;--gray-4-color-hsl:0deg,0%,26.6666666667%;--gray-6-color:#666;--gray-6-color-hsl:0deg,0%,40%;--gray-7-color:#767676;--gray-7-color-hsl:0deg,0%,46.2745098039%;--gray-9-color:#999;--gray-9-color-hsl:0deg,0%,60%;--gray-c-color:#ccc;--gray-c-color-hsl:0deg,0%,80%;--gray-d-color:#ddd;--gray-d-color-hsl:0deg,0%,86.6666666667%;--gray-f0-color:#f0f0f0;--gray-f0-color-hsl:0deg,0%,94.1176470588%;--gray-f8-color:#f8f8f8;--gray-f8-color-hsl:0deg,0%,97.2549019608%;--txt-color:#222;--txt-color-hsl:0deg,0%,13.3333333333%;--bg-color:white;--bg-color-hsl:0deg,0%,100%;--nav-color:#23001b;--nav-color-hsl:313.7142857143deg,100%,6.862745098%;--interactive-bg-color:#f0f0f0;--interactive-bg-color-hsl:0deg,0%,94.1176470588%;--interactive-scoreboard-color:#f9f9f9;--interactive-scoreboard-color-hsl:0deg,0%,97.6470588235%;--interactive-border-color:#e9e6ea;--interactive-border-color-hsl:285deg,8.6956521739%,90.9803921569%;--label-color:#88365b;--label-color-hsl:332.9268292683deg,43.1578947368%,37.2549019608%;--heading-color:#2c0022;--heading-color-hsl:313.6363636364deg,100%,8.6274509804%;font-size:17px;accent-color:var(--theme-color,var(--cherry-color))}@media(min-width:768px){:root{font-size:19px}}@media(min-width:1024px){:root{font-size:17px}}@media(min-width:1440px){:root{font-size:19px}}.theme-dark{--bg-color:#1a0014;--bg-color-hsl:313.8461538462deg,100%,5.0980392157%;--txt-color:#f8f8f8;--txt-color-hsl:0deg,0%,97.2549019608%;--nav-color:#2c0022;--nav-color-hsl:313.6363636364deg,100%,8.6274509804%;--interactive-bg-color:#2c0022;--interactive-bg-color-hsl:313.6363636364deg,100%,8.6274509804%;--interactive-scoreboard-color:#23001b;--interactive-scoreboard-color-hsl:313.7142857143deg,100%,6.862745098%;--interactive-border-color:#80667a;--interactive-border-color-hsl:313.8461538462deg,11.3043478261%,45.0980392157%;--plum-color:#a66884;--plum-color-hsl:332.9032258065deg,25.8333333333%,52.9411764706%;--raisin-color:#80667a;--raisin-color-hsl:313.8461538462deg,11.3043478261%,45.0980392157%;--heading-color:#f8f8f8;--heading-color-hsl:0deg,0%,97.2549019608%;--label-color:#c39bad;--label-color-hsl:333deg,25%,68.6274509804%;--button-color:#e60d48;--button-color-hsl:343.6866359447deg,89.3004115226%,47.6470588235%}.fonts-loaded body{font-family:Retina,"Helvetica Neue",Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif}*,:after,:before{-webkit-box-sizing:inherit;box-sizing:inherit}:focus-visible{outline:var(--theme-color,#ff0e50) dotted 3px;outline-offset:1px}a{outline-color:transparent;-webkit-transition:color .12s ease,fill .12s ease,border-color .12s ease,outline-color .12s ease,outline-style .12s ease;transition:color .12s ease,fill .12s ease,border-color .12s ease,outline-color .12s ease,outline-style .12s ease}button{font:inherit;font-size:1rem}sub,sup{vertical-align:baseline;position:relative;line-height:0}sub{top:.4em}sup{top:-.4em}img{max-width:100%}img[width][height]{height:auto}::-moz-selection{background-color:#ffcfdc;background-color:rgba(var(--theme-color-rgb,255,14,80),.2)}::selection{background-color:#ffcfdc;background-color:rgba(var(--theme-color-rgb,255,14,80),.2)}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){.theme-auto{--bg-color:#1a0014;--bg-color-hsl:313.8461538462deg,100%,5.0980392157%;--txt-color:#f8f8f8;--txt-color-hsl:0deg,0%,97.2549019608%;--nav-color:#2c0022;--nav-color-hsl:313.6363636364deg,100%,8.6274509804%;--interactive-bg-color:#2c0022;--interactive-bg-color-hsl:313.6363636364deg,100%,8.6274509804%;--interactive-scoreboard-color:#23001b;--interactive-scoreboard-color-hsl:313.7142857143deg,100%,6.862745098%;--interactive-border-color:#80667a;--interactive-border-color-hsl:313.8461538462deg,11.3043478261%,45.0980392157%;--plum-color:#a66884;--plum-color-hsl:332.9032258065deg,25.8333333333%,52.9411764706%;--raisin-color:#80667a;--raisin-color-hsl:313.8461538462deg,11.3043478261%,45.0980392157%;--heading-color:#f8f8f8;--heading-color-hsl:0deg,0%,97.2549019608%;--label-color:#c39bad;--label-color-hsl:333deg,25%,68.6274509804%;--button-color:#e60d48;--button-color-hsl:343.6866359447deg,89.3004115226%,47.6470588235%}:where(.theme-auto) ::-moz-selection{background-color:rgba(var(--theme-color-rgb,255,14,80),.4)}:where(.theme-auto) ::selection{background-color:rgba(var(--theme-color-rgb,255,14,80),.4)}:where(.theme-auto) .slate-input{--bg-color:#411a38;--bg-color-hsl:313.8461538462deg,42.8571428571%,17.8431372549%;--txt-color:#ddd;--txt-color-hsl:0deg,0%,86.6666666667%}}:where(.theme-dark) ::-moz-selection{background-color:rgba(var(--theme-color-rgb,255,14,80),.4)}:where(.theme-dark) ::selection{background-color:rgba(var(--theme-color-rgb,255,14,80),.4)}::-ms-reveal{display:none}@media print{.clay-kiln{display:none}}@font-face{font-family:Retina;font-display:swap;src:url(https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Retina-Book-subset.dc123e1.woff2) format("woff2")}@font-face{font-family:Retina;font-display:swap;src:url(https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Retina-BookItalic-subset.e351a4d.woff2) format("woff2");font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:Retina;font-display:swap;src:url(https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Retina-Bold-subset.77f1049.woff2) format("woff2");font-weight:700}@font-face{font-family:Retina;font-display:swap;src:url(https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Retina-BoldItalic-subset.c2b4700.woff2) format("woff2");font-weight:700;font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:Register;font-display:swap;src:url(https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Register-Heavy-subset.a571c0d.woff2) format("woff2");font-weight:700}@font-face{font-family:Register;font-display:swap;src:url(https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Register-HeavyItalic-subset.d42bb80.woff2) format("woff2");font-weight:700;font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:Lora;font-display:swap;src:url(https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Lora-Regular-subset.0793386.woff2) format("woff2")}@font-face{font-family:Bayard;font-display:swap;src:url(https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/Bayard-Regular.55ade9f.woff2) format("woff2")}@font-face{font-family:Sofia;font-display:swap;src:url(https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/fonts/slate-com/SofiaSansCondensed-Black-subset.8fb41d6.woff2) format("woff2");font-weight:900}[hidden]{display:none}.slate-input{--bg-color:#f8f8f8;--bg-color-hsl:0deg,0%,97.2549019608%;--txt-color:#444;--txt-color-hsl:0deg,0%,26.6666666667%;display:block;font:inherit;line-height:1;width:100%;font-size:.9372071228rem;color:var(--txt-color,#444);background-color:var(--bg-color);background-image:none;background-clip:padding-box;border:1px solid #999;border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.5);border-radius:2px;-webkit-transition:border-color ease-in-out .15s,-webkit-box-shadow ease-in-out .15s;transition:border-color ease-in-out .15s,-webkit-box-shadow ease-in-out .15s;transition:border-color ease-in-out .15s,box-shadow ease-in-out .15s;transition:border-color ease-in-out .15s,box-shadow ease-in-out .15s,-webkit-box-shadow ease-in-out .15s;-webkit-appearance:none;-moz-appearance:none;appearance:none;margin-top:.25em}.slate-input::-webkit-input-placeholder{color:#999;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.5);opacity:1}.slate-input::-moz-placeholder{color:#999;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.5);opacity:1}.slate-input::-ms-input-placeholder{color:#999;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.5);opacity:1}.slate-input::placeholder{color:#999;color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.5);opacity:1}.slate-input:disabled,.slate-input[readonly]{background-color:#f0f0f0;background-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.07);opacity:1}.slate-input:disabled{cursor:not-allowed}.slate-input[readonly]{cursor:text}.slate-input:user-invalid{background-color:hsla(var(--partisan-red-color-hsl),.15);border-color:hsla(var(--partisan-red-color-hsl),.5)}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .slate-input{border-color:#80667a}}:where(.theme-dark) .slate-input{--bg-color:#411a38;--bg-color-hsl:313.8461538462deg,42.8571428571%,17.8431372549%;--txt-color:#ddd;--txt-color-hsl:0deg,0%,86.6666666667%;border-color:#80667a}.slate-button{background-color:#2c0022;background-color:var(--button-color,#2c0022);border:1px solid transparent;border-radius:2px;color:#fff;display:inline-block;line-height:1;text-align:center;text-decoration:none;-webkit-transition:.15s ease-in-out;transition:.15s ease-in-out;-webkit-transition-property:opacity,color,background;transition-property:opacity,color,background;-webkit-user-select:none;-moz-user-select:none;-ms-user-select:none;user-select:none}.dropdown--subtle .dropdown__button,.slate-button--subtle{text-align:center;-webkit-user-select:none;-moz-user-select:none;padding:.5em .5714285714em}.slate-button:where(label:hover,a[href]:hover,:enabled:hover,:focus-visible){background-color:hsla(var(--button-color-hsl,var(--raisin-color-hsl)),.8)}.slate-button:disabled{opacity:.5;cursor:wait}.slate-button--subtle{--button-color:transparent;--button-color-hsl:0deg,0%,0%;background-color:#2c0022;background-color:var(--button-color,#2c0022);border:1px solid #ccc;border-radius:2px;color:currentColor;display:inline-block;line-height:1;text-decoration:none;-webkit-transition:.15s ease-in-out;transition:.15s ease-in-out;-webkit-transition-property:opacity,color,background;transition-property:opacity,color,background;-ms-user-select:none;user-select:none;border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.2)}.slate-notification--info,.slate-notification--success{border-radius:2px;-webkit-transition:opacity .1s,-webkit-transform .1s;text-wrap:pretty}.slate-button--subtle:where(label:hover,a[href]:hover,:enabled:hover,:focus-visible){background-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.07)}.slate-button--subtle:disabled{opacity:.5;cursor:wait}.slate-graf a,.slate-link,.slate-list a{text-decoration:none;border-bottom:2px solid #ff0e50;border-color:var(--theme-color,#ff0e50)}.slate-graf a:focus,.slate-graf a:hover,.slate-link:focus,.slate-link:hover,.slate-list a:focus,.slate-list a:hover{color:#ff0e50;color:var(--theme-color,#ff0e50);border-color:transparent}.slate-link--bold{text-decoration:none;border-bottom:4px solid #ff0e50;border-color:var(--theme-color,#ff0e50);text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:.07em;font-weight:700;font-size:.6776625465rem;white-space:nowrap;color:#2c0022;color:var(--heading-color)}.slate-link--bold:focus,.slate-link--bold:hover{color:#ff0e50;color:var(--theme-color,#ff0e50);border-color:#ff0e50;border-color:var(--theme-color,#ff0e50)}@media(min-width:768px){.slate-link--bold{font-size:.7230659372rem}}.slate-link--bold>span{position:absolute;width:1px;height:1px;padding:0;margin:-1px;overflow:hidden;clip:rect(0,0,0,0);white-space:nowrap;border-width:0}.slate-link--classic{text-decoration:underline}.slate-link--classic:focus-visible{outline:currentColor dotted 1px}.slate-link--classic:focus-visible,.slate-link--classic[href]:hover{text-decoration:underline;color:unset}button.slate-link,button.slate-link--bold{border-top:none;border-left:none;border-right:none;background:0 0;padding:0;line-height:1}.slate-graf,.slate-list{line-height:1.5;margin:0 0 1.2em}.slate-required{color:#ff0e50}.slate-notification--info{padding:1.2em;transition:opacity .1s,-webkit-transform .1s;transition:opacity .1s,transform .1s;transition:opacity .1s,transform .1s,-webkit-transform .1s;border:1px solid #f6dcaa;line-height:1.5;background-color:#ffefcf}.slate-notification--info:empty{padding:0;opacity:0;-webkit-transform:translateY(.2em);transform:translateY(.2em)}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .slate-notification--info{color:#ffefcf;background-color:#2e1e00;border-color:#a4906a}}:where(.theme-dark) .slate-notification--info{color:#ffefcf;background-color:#2e1e00;border-color:#a4906a}.slate-notification--success{padding:1.2em;transition:opacity .1s,-webkit-transform .1s;transition:opacity .1s,transform .1s;transition:opacity .1s,transform .1s,-webkit-transform .1s;border:1px solid #cbe8b8;line-height:1.5;background-color:#e4f6d8}.slate-notification--success:empty{padding:0;opacity:0;-webkit-transform:translateY(.2em);transform:translateY(.2em)}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .slate-notification--success{color:#e4f6d8;background-color:#142609;border-color:#839975}}:where(.theme-dark) .slate-notification--success{color:#e4f6d8;background-color:#142609;border-color:#839975}.slate-notification--error{padding:1.2em;border-radius:2px;-webkit-transition:opacity .1s,-webkit-transform .1s;transition:opacity .1s,-webkit-transform .1s;transition:opacity .1s,transform .1s;transition:opacity .1s,transform .1s,-webkit-transform .1s;border:1px solid #e8b6b6;line-height:1.5;text-wrap:pretty;background-color:#f6d5d5}.slate-notification--error:empty{padding:0;opacity:0;-webkit-transform:translateY(.2em);transform:translateY(.2em)}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .slate-notification--error{color:#f6d5d5;background-color:#260808;border-color:#997474}}:where(.theme-dark) .slate-notification--error{color:#f6d5d5;background-color:#260808;border-color:#997474}.slate-loading{display:inline-block;width:1.2em;height:1.2em;border-radius:50%;border:.2em solid #2c0022;border-bottom-color:transparent!important;-webkit-animation:1s spinner-spin linear infinite;animation:1s spinner-spin linear infinite;vertical-align:text-bottom;-webkit-transition:opacity .1s;transition:opacity .1s}@-webkit-keyframes spinner-spin{to{-webkit-transform:rotate(360deg);transform:rotate(360deg)}}@keyframes spinner-spin{to{-webkit-transform:rotate(360deg);transform:rotate(360deg)}}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .slate-loading{border-color:#ab99a7}}:where(.theme-dark) .slate-loading{border-color:#ab99a7}.slate-loading:not([aria-label]),.slate-loading[aria-label=""]{opacity:0}.slate-close{position:absolute;top:0;right:0;border:none;border-radius:0;padding:.7em;line-height:0;background:0 0;color:inherit;fill:currentColor;-webkit-transition:opacity .12s ease;transition:opacity .12s ease;opacity:.6}.slate-close:focus,.slate-close:hover{opacity:1}.slate-modal{background:#fff;color:var(--txt-color);font-size:1rem;width:auto;translate:calc(50vw - 50%) var(--dialog-top,calc(50vh - 50%));max-width:min(72rem,100vw - 30px);max-height:min(100vh,100vh - 30px);border:1px solid #eae6e9;border-radius:3px;-webkit-box-shadow:0 4px 10px rgba(0,0,10,.15);box-shadow:0 4px 10px rgba(0,0,10,.15)}.email-signifier--podcast,.signifier--podcast{vertical-align:top;margin-right:.17em}@-webkit-keyframes dialog-open{from{opacity:0}to{opacity:1}}@keyframes dialog-open{from{opacity:0}to{opacity:1}}.slate-modal[open]{-webkit-animation:.24s .12s both dialog-open;animation:.24s .12s both dialog-open}.slate-modal[open]::-webkit-backdrop{-webkit-animation:.12s both dialog-open;animation:.12s both dialog-open}.slate-modal[open]::backdrop{-webkit-animation:.12s both dialog-open;animation:.12s both dialog-open}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .slate-modal{background:#1a0014;border-color:#56334e}:where(.theme-auto) .slate-modal::-webkit-backdrop{--bg-color:#ab99a7;--bg-color-hsl:313.3333333333deg,9.6774193548%,63.5294117647%}:where(.theme-auto) .slate-modal::backdrop{--bg-color:#ab99a7;--bg-color-hsl:313.3333333333deg,9.6774193548%,63.5294117647%}}:where(.theme-dark) .slate-modal{background:#1a0014;border-color:#56334e}.slate-modal::-webkit-backdrop{--bg-color:#6b4d64;--bg-color-hsl:314deg,16.3043478261%,36.0784313725%;background-color:hsla(var(--bg-color-hsl),.2)}.slate-modal::backdrop{--bg-color:#6b4d64;--bg-color-hsl:314deg,16.3043478261%,36.0784313725%;background-color:hsla(var(--bg-color-hsl),.2)}:where(.theme-dark) .slate-modal::-webkit-backdrop{--bg-color:#ab99a7;--bg-color-hsl:313.3333333333deg,9.6774193548%,63.5294117647%}:where(.theme-dark) .slate-modal::backdrop{--bg-color:#ab99a7;--bg-color-hsl:313.3333333333deg,9.6774193548%,63.5294117647%}.slate-divider{border:none;height:2px;width:100%;background-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.15)}.slate-roadblock-signifier{overflow:visible;width:auto;height:1.1cap;translate:0 .05cap}.slate-roadblock-signifier--block{display:block;-ms-flex-item-align:start;align-self:flex-start;font-size:.8232026157rem;margin-bottom:calc(1lh - 1em)}.slate-roadblock-signifier__lock{fill:#999}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .slate-roadblock-signifier__lock{fill:#ccc}}:where(.theme-dark) .slate-roadblock-signifier__lock{fill:#ccc}.slate-roadblock-signifier__splus{fill:#2c0022;fill:var(--heading-color)}.lazyload-container{background:#f8f8f8;background:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.03);-webkit-backdrop-filter:blur(.1em);backdrop-filter:blur(.1em);position:relative;width:100%;height:auto;aspect-ratio:var(--img-aspect-ratio,3/2);overflow:hidden;-webkit-transition:background-color .12s;transition:background-color .12s;contain:strict}.lazyload-container>img{width:100%;height:100%;-o-object-fit:cover;object-fit:cover}.lazyload-container--loaded{background:0 0}.lazyload-container--fluid{height:auto;--img-aspect-ratio:auto;overflow:visible;contain:content}.lazyload-container--square{--img-aspect-ratio:1/1}.lazyload,.lazyloaded,.lazyloading{position:absolute;width:100%;height:auto;-webkit-transition:opacity .2s ease-in;transition:opacity .2s ease-in}.lazyload,.lazyloading{opacity:0}.dropdown--subtle .dropdown__button:where(label:hover,a[href]:hover,:enabled:hover,:focus-visible),a:focus .email-signifier--podcast,a:hover .email-signifier--podcast{opacity:.8}.signifier--podcast{fill:#ff4900}a:focus .signifier--podcast,a:hover .signifier--podcast{fill:#ff6d33}.dropdown{position:relative}.dropdown__button{font-size:inherit}.dropdown--subtle .dropdown__button{--button-color:transparent;--button-color-hsl:0deg,0%,0%;background-color:#2c0022;background-color:var(--button-color,#2c0022);border:1px solid transparent;border-radius:2px;color:inherit;display:inline-block;line-height:1;text-decoration:none;-webkit-transition:.15s ease-in-out;transition:.15s ease-in-out;-webkit-transition-property:opacity,color,background;transition-property:opacity,color,background;-ms-user-select:none;user-select:none;white-space:nowrap}.dropdown--subtle .dropdown__button:disabled{opacity:.5;cursor:wait}.dropdown__icon{fill:currentColor;vertical-align:middle}.dropdown__button[aria-expanded=true] .dropdown__icon{-webkit-transform:rotateZ(-180deg);transform:rotateZ(-180deg)}.dropdown__content{position:absolute;z-index:1;min-width:100%;top:100%;right:0;border-radius:2px;-webkit-box-shadow:.1em .1em .2em rgba(0,0,0,.3);box-shadow:.1em .1em .2em rgba(0,0,0,.3)}.dropdown__button:not([aria-expanded=true])+.dropdown__content{display:none}.dropdown--subtle .dropdown__content{background:var(--bg-color);color:#222;color:var(--txt-color);border:1px solid #ddd;border-color:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.15)}.dropdown__link{display:block;width:100%;padding:.5em .5714285714em;white-space:nowrap;border:none;background:0 0;text-decoration:none}.dropdown--subtle .dropdown__link:focus,.dropdown--subtle .dropdown__link:hover{background:#f0f0f0;background:hsla(var(--txt-color-hsl),.07)}.dropdown--vibrant .dropdown__link{color:#fff;background:#56334e}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .dropdown--vibrant .dropdown__link{background:var(--button-color)}}:where(.theme-dark) .dropdown--vibrant .dropdown__link{background:var(--button-color)}.dropdown--vibrant .dropdown__link:focus,.dropdown--vibrant .dropdown__link:hover{background:#80667a}@media(prefers-color-scheme:dark){:where(.theme-auto) .dropdown--vibrant .dropdown__link:focus,:where(.theme-auto) .dropdown--vibrant .dropdown__link:hover{background:#cc0b40}}:where(.theme-dark) .dropdown--vibrant .dropdown__link:focus,:where(.theme-dark) .dropdown--vibrant .dropdown__link:hover{background:#cc0b40}.dropdown__link:first-child{border-radius:2px 2px 0 0}.dropdown__link:last-child{border-radius:0 0 2px 2px}:root iframe[src^="https://id.piano.io/"],:root iframe[src^="https://buy.piano.io/"],:root iframe[src^="https://sandbox.piano.io/"],:root iframe[src^="https://id.tinypass.com/"],:root iframe[src^="https://buy.tinypass.com/"],:root iframe[src^="https://sandbox.tinypass.com/"]{display:block;margin:-15px!important;width:calc(100% + 30px)!important;height:2000px!important;height:var(--slate-height,100%)!important;overflow:visible!important;-webkit-transition:opacity .12s;transition:opacity .12s}html:not([data-layout-uri*="/instances/article"]):not([data-layout-uri*="/instances/package-landing"]):not([data-layout-uri*="/instances/quiz"]) .layout-one-column .main{margin-top:25px}@media(min-width:768px){html:not([data-layout-uri*="/instances/article"]):not([data-layout-uri*="/instances/package-landing"]):not([data-layout-uri*="/instances/quiz"]) .layout-one-column .main{margin-top:40px}}@media(min-width:1440px){html:not([data-layout-uri*="/instances/article"]):not([data-layout-uri*="/instances/package-landing"]):not([data-layout-uri*="/instances/quiz"]) .layout-one-column .main{margin-top:80px}}html[data-layout-uri*="/instances/package-landing"] .layout-one-column .global-footer{margin-top:0}.layout-one-column .l-wrapper{padding:0 15px}.layout-one-column .l-container{margin:0 auto}@media(min-width:1024px){.layout-one-column .l-container{max-width:1000px}}@media(min-width:1440px){.layout-one-column .l-container{max-width:1300px}}@media(prefers-color-scheme:light){:where(.theme-auto) .layout-one-column--plus-landing:not(header){background-color:#f8f8f8}}:where(.theme-light) .layout-one-column--plus-landing:not(header){background-color:#f8f8f8}.layout-one-column--plus-landing #main{background-color:inherit}.layout-one-column--plus-landing .l-container{max-width:1000px}</style></head> <body class="layout-one-column "> <section class="top-ad"> <div class="slate-ad ad--desktopOnly ad--leaderboard"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/leaderboard@published" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="leaderboard" data-zone-id = "768478" data-placement-id = "12399445" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271610" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <div class="slate-ad ad--tabletPortraitOnly ad--leaderboard"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/leaderboardTablet@published" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="leaderboard-tablet" data-zone-id = "768480" data-placement-id = "12399447" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271365" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> </section> <header data-uri="slate.com/_components/masthead/instances/default@published" class="masthead" data-via="nav" > <a href="#main" class="skip-to-main">Skip to the content</a> <div class="desktop-masthead"> <div class="masthead__wrapper"> <ul class="widgets masthead__container"> <li class="js-account--subscribe" hidden> <a class="widgets__item slate-button" data-piano-href="desktopMastheadUrl" data-piano-html="desktopMastheadText"> <svg class="widgets__icon" width="16" height="16"> <use data-piano-icon-href="iconUrl"></use> </svg> </a> </li> <li> <a href="https://shop.slate.com/" class="widgets__item"> <svg class="widgets__icon" width="16" height="16"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#shop"></use> </svg> Slate Shop </a> </li> <li> <a href="https://slate.com/tag/slate-games" class="widgets__item"> <svg class="widgets__icon" width="16" height="16"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#games"></use> </svg> Games </a> </li> <li> <a href="https://slate.com/newsletters" class="widgets__item"> <svg class="widgets__icon" width="16" height="16"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#newsletters"></use> </svg> Newsletters </a> </li> <li class="widgets__item js-account--sign-in sign-in-link" hidden> <svg class="widgets__icon" width="16" height="16"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#avatar"></use> </svg> <a href="https://slate.com/sign-in" class="masthead__login js-redirect-return">Sign In</a> </li> <li class="js-account--account" hidden> <span class="widgets__item"> <svg class="widgets__icon" width="16" height="16"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#avatar"></use> </svg> <div class="dropdown dropdown--subtle widgets__dropdown" ><button class="dropdown__button" disabled> <span class="dropdown__label">Account</span> <svg class="dropdown__icon" width="10" height="6" viewBox="0 0 10 6" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" role="img" > <title>Activating this button will toggle the display of additional content</title> <path d="M0 0l5 6 5-6z"/> </svg> </button> <div class="dropdown__content"> <a href="https://slate.com/account" class="dropdown__link js-account--account" hidden > Account </a> <a href="https://slate.com/sign-out" class="dropdown__link js-redirect-return js-account--sign-out" hidden > Sign out </a> </div> </div> </span> </li> </ul> <script> try { const mastheadChildren = document.currentScript.previousElementSibling.children; const posFromBack = document.cookie.indexOf("__utp") === -1 ? 2 : 1; mastheadChildren[mastheadChildren.length - posFromBack].hidden = false; } catch(err) { console.error("Error unhiding sign-in/account in masthead", err); } </script> </div> <div class="masthead__wrapper"> <nav class="main-nav masthead__container"> <a href="https://slate.com" class="main-nav__logo"> <svg class="logo" width="259" height="80"> <title>Slate homepage</title> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/global-sprite.453518f.svg#logo"></use> </svg> </a> <ul class="sections"> <li class="sections__item"> <a href="/news-and-politics" class="sections__link">News & Politics</a> </li> <li class="sections__item"> <a href="/culture" class="sections__link">Culture</a> </li> <li class="sections__item"> <a href="/technology" class="sections__link" aria-current="true" >Technology</a> </li> <li class="sections__item"> <a href="/business" class="sections__link">Business</a> </li> <li class="sections__item"> <a href="/life" class="sections__link">Life</a> </li> <li class="sections__item"> <a href="/advice" class="sections__link">Advice</a> </li> <li class="sections__item"> <a href="/podcasts" class="sections__link">Podcasts</a> </li> </ul> </nav> </div> </div> <div class="mobile-masthead"> <div class="mobile-masthead__menu menu"> <button class="menu__control menu__control--open js-toggle-menu"> <span aria-hidden="true">Menu</span> <svg width="16" height="15"> <title>Open menu</title> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#menu"></use> </svg> </button> <nav class="menu__content"> <header class="menu__header"> <button class="menu__control slate-close js-toggle-menu"> <svg width="21" height="21"> <title>Close menu</title> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/global-sprite.453518f.svg#back"></use> </svg> </button> <span class="menu__title">Menu</span> </header> <div class="mobile-sections"> <a href="/news-and-politics" class="mobile-sections__link">News & Politics</a> <a href="/culture" class="mobile-sections__link">Culture</a> <a href="/technology" class="mobile-sections__link">Technology</a> <a href="/business" class="mobile-sections__link">Business</a> <a href="/life" class="mobile-sections__link">Life</a> <a href="/advice" class="mobile-sections__link">Advice</a> <a href="/podcasts" class="mobile-sections__link">Podcasts</a> <a href="/search" class="mobile-sections__link"> <svg width="18" height="18" class="mag-lens"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#search"></use> </svg> Search </a> <div class="mobile-sections__link"> <div class="dropdown dropdown--subtle theme-picker" ><button class="dropdown__button theme-picker__button" disabled> <span class="dropdown__label"></span> <svg class="dropdown__icon" width="10" height="6" viewBox="0 0 10 6" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" role="img" > <title>Activating this button will toggle the display of additional content</title> <path d="M0 0l5 6 5-6z"/> </svg> </button> <div class="dropdown__content"> <button class="dropdown__link theme-picker__option" data-value="light"> <svg width="16" height="16"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#light"></use> </svg> Light </button> <button class="dropdown__link theme-picker__option" data-value="dark"> <svg width="16" height="16"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#dark"></use> </svg> Dark </button> <button class="dropdown__link theme-picker__option" data-value="auto"> <svg width="16" height="16"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#auto"></use> </svg> Auto </button> </div> </div> <script> try { var selected = localStorage.getItem('theme') || 'light'; var dd = document.currentScript.previousElementSibling; if (dd.offsetParent !== null) { dd.querySelectorAll('.dropdown__link').forEach(function(opt) { if (opt.dataset.value === selected) { dd.querySelector('.dropdown__label').innerHTML = opt.innerHTML; } }) } } catch (e) {} </script> </div> <div class="mobile-sections__link js-account--subscribe" hidden> <a href="https://slate.com/plus?utm_medium=link&utm_campaign=plus&utm_content=nav_bar&utm_source=nav" class="mobile-sections__link--subscribe"><b>Subscribe</b></a> </div> <a href="https://shop.slate.com/" class="mobile-sections__link js-redirect-return">Slate Shop</a> <a href="https://slate.com/tag/slate-games" class="mobile-sections__link js-redirect-return">Games</a> <a href="https://slate.com/newsletters" class="mobile-sections__link js-redirect-return">Newsletters</a> <a href="https://slate.com/sign-in" class="js-account--sign-in mobile-sections__link js-redirect-return" hidden>Sign in</a> <a href="https://slate.com/account" class="js-account--account mobile-sections__link" hidden>Account</a> <a href="https://slate.com/sign-out" class="js-account--sign-out mobile-sections__link js-redirect-return" hidden>Sign out</a> </div> </nav> </div> <div class="mobile-masthead__logo"> <a href="https://slate.com"> <svg class="logo" width="124" height="39"> <title>Slate homepage</title> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/global-sprite.453518f.svg#logo"></use> </svg> </a> </div> <div class='mobile-masthead__account'> <a class="mobile-masthead__link js-account--account" href="https://slate.com/account" hidden >Account</a> <div class="mobile-masthead__mobile-link js-account--sign-in" hidden><a data-piano-href="mobileMastheadUrl" data-piano-html="mobileMastheadText" class="slate-link"></span></a></div> </div> </div> <div class="masthead__wrapper"> <div class="strapline masthead__container" > <svg width="27" height="30" class="strapline__asterisk"> <title>*</title> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#asterisk"></use> </svg> <a class="strapline__text" href="https://slate.com/life/2024/11/dry-january-guides-history-december-alternative.html"> Keeping Cool in the Heat of this Particular Moment </a> <div class="strapline__search"> <form action="/search" class="search-form" data-via="search"> <input id="search-input" name="q" placeholder="Search for" class="search-form__input" /> <button class="search-form__submit"> <svg class="search-form__icon" width="16" height="16"> <title>Submit search</title> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#search"></use> </svg> </button> <label for="search-input" class="search-form__label"> <svg class="search-form__icon" width="16" height="16"> <title>Enter query</title> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#search"></use> </svg> </label> </form> <div class="dropdown dropdown--subtle theme-picker" ><button class="dropdown__button theme-picker__button" disabled> <span class="dropdown__label"></span> <svg class="dropdown__icon" width="10" height="6" viewBox="0 0 10 6" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" role="img" > <title>Activating this button will toggle the display of additional content</title> <path d="M0 0l5 6 5-6z"/> </svg> </button> <div class="dropdown__content"> <button class="dropdown__link theme-picker__option" data-value="light"> <svg width="16" height="16"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#light"></use> </svg> Light </button> <button class="dropdown__link theme-picker__option" data-value="dark"> <svg width="16" height="16"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#dark"></use> </svg> Dark </button> <button class="dropdown__link theme-picker__option" data-value="auto"> <svg width="16" height="16"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/masthead/sprite.f075295.svg#auto"></use> </svg> Auto </button> </div> </div> <script> try { var selected = localStorage.getItem('theme') || 'light'; var dd = document.currentScript.previousElementSibling; if (dd.offsetParent !== null) { dd.querySelectorAll('.dropdown__link').forEach(function(opt) { if (opt.dataset.value === selected) { dd.querySelector('.dropdown__label').innerHTML = opt.innerHTML; } }) } } catch (e) {} </script> </div> </div> </div> </header> <main role="main" id="main"> <div class="l-wrapper"> <div class="main l-container" > <article data-uri="slate.com/_components/article/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838@published" data-has-roadblock="" data-rubric="the-browser" class="article article--article article--right-rail " itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/Article" > <div itemprop="publisher" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/Organization"> <meta itemprop="name" content="Slate" /> <div itemprop="logo" itemscope itemtype="https://www.schema.org/ImageObject"> <link itemprop="url" href="https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/icon.400x400.09ec623.png"> <meta itemprop="width" content="400"> <meta itemprop="height" content="400"> </div> </div> <div class="article__fullbleed-header" ></div> <header class="article__header"> <div itemprop="image" itemscope itemtype="https://www.schema.org/ImageObject"> <meta itemprop="url" content="https://compote.slate.com/images/83deacaf-aa20-47e0-926b-7bb85371351b.jpg?width=1200"> <meta itemprop="width" content="1200"> <meta itemprop="height" content="800"> </div> <a class="article__rubric" href="/technology/the-browser" > The Browser</a> <h1 itemprop="headline" class="article__hed article__hed--" >The Camera Phone</h1> <h2 itemprop="alternativeHeadline" class="article__dek" >The gadget that perverts, vigilantes, and celebrity stalkers can all agree on.</h2> <div class="article__meta"> <div class="article__byline" > By <span itemprop="author" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/Person"> <span itemprop="name"><a href="/author/michael-agger">Michael Agger</a></span></span> </div> <time itemprop="datePublished" content="2007-01-17T23:21:00+00:00" class="article__dateline" > <span>Jan 17, 2007</span><span>6:21 PM</span> </time> </div> </header> <div class="article__top-image" > </div> <div class="article__share-sidebar share-sidebar"> <div class="social-share" aria-label="social media links" data-uri="slate.com/_components/social-share/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-14@published" > <a href="https://twitter.com/share?text=When+camera+phones+attack.&via=slate&url=https%3A%2F%2Fslate.com%2Ftechnology%2F2007%2F01%2Fwhen-camera-phones-attack.html%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_campaign%3Dtraffic%26utm_source%3Darticle%26utm_content%3Dtwitter_share" class="social-share__link social-share__link--twitter js-share-link" data-share="twitter" data-parsely-event="_twitter-tweet" target="_blank" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="social-share__icon" role="presentation"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#twitter-circle"></use> </svg>Tweet </a> <a href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fslate.com%2Ftechnology%2F2007%2F01%2Fwhen-camera-phones-attack.html%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_campaign%3Dtraffic%26utm_source%3Darticle%26utm_content%3Dfacebook_share" class="social-share__link social-share__link--facebook js-share-link" data-share="facebook" data-parsely-event="_facebook-share" aria-label="Share on Facebook" role="link" target="_blank" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="social-share__icon" role="presentation"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#facebook-circle"></use> </svg><span aria-hidden="true">Share</span> </a> <a data-share-url="https://slate.com/technology/2007/01/when-camera-phones-attack.html?utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=traffic&utm_source=article&utm_content=web_share" class="social-share__link social-share__link--share js-web-share-link" data-share="web-share" data-parsely-event="_web-share" aria-label="Share" role="link" hidden > <svg width="25" height="25" class="social-share__icon" role="presentation"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#share"></use> </svg><span aria-hidden="true">Share</span> </a> <a href="https://slate.com/comments/technology/2007/01/when-camera-phones-attack.html" class="social-share__link social-share__link--comments" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="social-share__icon" role="presentation" > <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#comments"></use> </svg>Comment </a> </div> </div> <section class="article__body"> <div class="article__podcast-subscribe"></div> <div class="article__left-rail"> <div class="article__share-sidebar-xl share-sidebar"> <div class="social-share" aria-label="social media links" data-uri="slate.com/_components/social-share/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-14@published" > <a href="https://twitter.com/share?text=When+camera+phones+attack.&via=slate&url=https%3A%2F%2Fslate.com%2Ftechnology%2F2007%2F01%2Fwhen-camera-phones-attack.html%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_campaign%3Dtraffic%26utm_source%3Darticle%26utm_content%3Dtwitter_share" class="social-share__link social-share__link--twitter js-share-link" data-share="twitter" data-parsely-event="_twitter-tweet" target="_blank" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="social-share__icon" role="presentation"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#twitter-circle"></use> </svg>Tweet </a> <a href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fslate.com%2Ftechnology%2F2007%2F01%2Fwhen-camera-phones-attack.html%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_campaign%3Dtraffic%26utm_source%3Darticle%26utm_content%3Dfacebook_share" class="social-share__link social-share__link--facebook js-share-link" data-share="facebook" data-parsely-event="_facebook-share" aria-label="Share on Facebook" role="link" target="_blank" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="social-share__icon" role="presentation"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#facebook-circle"></use> </svg><span aria-hidden="true">Share</span> </a> <a data-share-url="https://slate.com/technology/2007/01/when-camera-phones-attack.html?utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=traffic&utm_source=article&utm_content=web_share" class="social-share__link social-share__link--share js-web-share-link" data-share="web-share" data-parsely-event="_web-share" aria-label="Share" role="link" hidden > <svg width="25" height="25" class="social-share__icon" role="presentation"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#share"></use> </svg><span aria-hidden="true">Share</span> </a> <a href="https://slate.com/comments/technology/2007/01/when-camera-phones-attack.html" class="social-share__link social-share__link--comments" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="social-share__icon" role="presentation" > <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#comments"></use> </svg>Comment </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="article__content" itemprop="mainEntityOfPage"> <p class="slate-paragraph slate-graf" data-word-count="20" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-paragraph/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-0@published" ><strong><em>Listen to the MP3 audio version of this story <a data-linktype="External" href="http://media.slate.com/podcast/Slate070118_CameraPhones.mp3">here</a>, or sign up for Slate’s free daily podcast on <a data-linktype="External" href="http://phobos.apple.com/WebObjects/MZStore.woa/wa/viewPodcast?id=75089978&s=143441">iTunes</a>.</em></strong></p> <figure data-uri="slate.com/_components/image/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-1@published" class="image image--center" data-editable="imageInfo" style="width: 205px;"><figcaption class="image__meta"> <span class="image__credit"></span> </figcaption> </figure> <div data-uri="slate.com/_components/connatix/instances/default"> <script> (function(d,s,n){var js,fjs=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];js=d.createElement(s);js.className=n;js.src="//player.ex.co/player/8b7b2bed-5b69-4d70-82d5-aa335c8abe6c";fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs);}(document,"script","exco-player")); </script> <div id="8b7b2bed-5b69-4d70-82d5-aa335c8abe6c"></div> </div> <p class="slate-paragraph slate-graf" data-word-count="66" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-paragraph/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-2@published" > Ten years ago, Philippe Kahn was walking around a hospital with a cell phone and a digital camera. His dadly mission: to share pictures of his newborn baby girl. With an assist from Radio Shack, he linked the two devices together and e-mailed photos to family and friends around the world. The day marked a twin birth of sorts: the cell phone camera and daughter Sophie.</p> <p class="slate-paragraph slate-graf" data-word-count="98" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-paragraph/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-3@published" >Kahn regards his invention with paternal pride: “I built it to document the birth of my daughter. For us, it has always been a positive thing.” So he was taken aback recently when, with the Saddam-hanging video circling the globe, an interviewer compared him to the inventor of the Kalashnikov. First there was <a data-linktype="External" href="http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/4170083.stm">Prince Harry’s Nazi costume</a>, then the <a data-linktype="External" href="http://www.defamer.com/hollywood/kate-moss/kate-moss-cocaine-video-hits-the-internets-128747.php">shaming of Kate Moss</a>, then the <a data-linktype="External" href="http://www.tmz.com/2006/11/20/kramers-racist-tirade-caught-on-tape">Michael Richards racist explosion</a>, but, for some, Saddam’s hanging marks the low point for Kahn’s creation. A camera on a phone has only aided the perverted, the nosy, the violent, and the bored.</p> <div class="slate-ad ad--mobileOnly ad--inArticleBanner"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot-mobile" data-zone-id = "768494" data-placement-id = "12399462" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271366" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <div class="slate-ad ad--desktopOnly ad--inArticleBanner"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot" data-zone-id = "768486" data-placement-id = "12399452" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271363" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <div class="slate-ad ad--inArticleBanner ad--desktopXl"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot-xl" data-zone-id = "768486" data-placement-id = "12399452" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271363" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <div class="slate-ad ad--tabletPortraitOnly ad--inArticleBanner"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot-tablet" data-zone-id = "768488" data-placement-id = "12399457" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271364" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <p class="slate-paragraph slate-graf" data-word-count="93" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-paragraph/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-4@published" >That’s not exactly fair, but it’s not exactly wrong, either. As Kahn told <em>Wired </em>in 2000: “With this kind of device, you’re going to see the best and the worst of things.” The best would include photo caller-ID, <a data-linktype="External" href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GlWa7VqaduE">amateur sports highlights</a>, and the quick citizen snaps taken in the wake of the London bombings. Yet, despite the fun and occasional worthiness, the cell phone camera has launched a thousand jackasses. One representative example: Sportscaster Sean Salisbury was suspended by ESPN last month, <a data-linktype="External" href="http://deadspin.com/sports/sean-salisbury/if-sean-salisbury-asks-you-to-look-at-his-phone-dont-do-it-226599.php">reportedly</a> for showing female co-workers cell phone photos of his “equipment.” </p> <p class="slate-paragraph slate-graf" data-word-count="150" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-paragraph/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-5@published" >When video technology was added to phones (with little fanfare), the madness went up a notch. English youths devised a pleasant game called “happy slapping,” which involves assaulting random strangers while your mates record the whole thing. The happy slapping craze spread throughout Europe last year, leading to outraged op-eds and calls to ban cell phones from schools. While the phenomenon is marked by more than a touch of media hysteria, you can certainly find <a data-linktype="External" href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wt3tQjapX14">disturbing videos</a> on YouTube. (The French, naturally, replied with “<a data-linktype="External" href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HWrsrKcf3AM">Streetkissing</a>.”) There have also been news reports of graphic videos showing beatings and accidents, such as an unfortunate boy in Birmingham, United Kingdom, who <a data-linktype="External" href="http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/west_midlands/4674539.stm">impaled himself on his bicycle</a>. Teenagers have employed cell phone cameras for old-fashioned humiliation, too: The parking lot fight is now captured on video and shared. To be an adult is to be grateful to have escaped the digital hazing of high school.</p> <div class="slate-ad ad--mobileOnly ad--inArticleBanner"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot-mobile" data-zone-id = "768494" data-placement-id = "12399462" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271366" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <div class="slate-ad ad--box ad--desktopOnly"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-box" data-zone-id = "768494" data-placement-id = "12399462" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271366" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <p class="slate-paragraph slate-graf" data-word-count="136" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-paragraph/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-6@published" >In glorious retrospect, it seems like a terrifically bad idea to give the world a spy camera that looks and functions like a cell phone. Peeping Toms quickly realized the potential for upskirt pics and shower-room souvenirs. Chicago tried to block cell phones from gyms, and a California legislator has proposed a law requiring the cell phone to make a shutter snapping sound or flash a light when a picture is taken. We have trained ourselves to be wary when a cell phone is pointed at us, but the device’s relative inconspicuousness still creates problems. In Saudi Arabia, women have been taking pictures of other women unveiled at weddings and e-mailing them to matchmakers, a practice that has caused uproar in a culture in which any sort of image can be cause for loss of honor.</p> <div class="slate-ad ad--mobileOnly ad--inArticleBanner"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot-mobile" data-zone-id = "768494" data-placement-id = "12399462" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271366" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <div class="slate-ad ad--inArticleBanner ad--desktopXl"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot-xl" data-zone-id = "768486" data-placement-id = "12399452" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271363" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <p class="slate-paragraph slate-graf" data-word-count="93" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-paragraph/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-7@published" >The cell phone camera, constant companion, has also been championed as an anti-crime device. There have been several Rodney King moments, with bystanders pulling out their cameras to record sketchy police activity. One woman took a shot of a flasher on a New York subway, a photo that ended up on the cover of the <em>New York Post</em> the next day. There is also a mini-boom in sites to catch people who <a data-linktype="External" href="http://www.parkingidiots.blogspot.com/">park like idiots</a>, <a data-linktype="External" href="http://hollabacknyc.blogspot.com/">stare too long</a>, and <a data-linktype="External" href="http://isawyournanny.blogspot.com/">mistreat your kids</a>. Think of this as the positive side of living in <em>1984</em>.</p> <div class="slate-ad ad--desktopOnly ad--inArticleBanner"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot" data-zone-id = "768486" data-placement-id = "12399452" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271363" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <div class="slate-ad ad--tabletPortraitOnly ad--inArticleBanner"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot-tablet" data-zone-id = "768488" data-placement-id = "12399457" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271364" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <figure data-uri="slate.com/_components/image/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-8@published" class="image image--center" data-editable="imageInfo" style="width: 230px;"><figcaption class="image__meta"> <span class="image__credit"></span> </figcaption> </figure> <div class="slate-ad ad--mobileOnly ad--inArticleBanner"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot-mobile" data-zone-id = "768494" data-placement-id = "12399462" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271366" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <p class="slate-paragraph slate-graf" data-word-count="146" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-paragraph/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-9@published" > The more difficult question, the one that lurks outside the media glare, is how the cell phone camera is altering our private lives. In the perceptive book <em> <a data-linktype="External" href="http://www.amazon.com/Nostalgia-Cultural-Frames-Framing-Culture/dp/0813919592/sr=8-1/qid=1169060760/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/104-9346129-1333515?ie=UTF8&s=books">Kodak and the Lens of Nostalgia</a></em>, Nancy Martha West writes how Kodak, with the introduction of the personal camera, taught Americans to both conceive of their lives in terms of fondly remembered events and to edit out unpleasant memories. In Victorian America, for example, arranging to take a photo of a dead relative was not uncommon—a part of the grieving process. Under the reign of Kodak and its advertising, we became family historians of happiness. Now that digital cameras have taken over, the old photo album is giving way to the <a data-linktype="External" href="http://www.flickr.com/">personal Flickr page</a>, bringing with it a different set of assumptions of what to present (a whole lot more photos, for starters) and whom to share it with.</p> <div class="slate-ad ad--mobileOnly ad--inArticleBanner"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot-mobile" data-zone-id = "768494" data-placement-id = "12399462" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271366" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <div class="slate-ad ad--box ad--desktopOnly"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-box" data-zone-id = "768494" data-placement-id = "12399462" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271366" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <div class="slate-ad ad--inArticleBanner ad--desktopXl"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot-xl" data-zone-id = "768486" data-placement-id = "12399452" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271363" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <p class="slate-paragraph slate-graf" data-word-count="136" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-paragraph/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-10@published" >The ubiquity of the cell phone camera means that every moment in our lives is photographable. One consequence of this is an altered perception of the gravity of our day-to-day routines. We are now more aware of ourselves as observers of “history.” When a van catches fire in front of our house, we and our neighbors are now out on the lawn recording. We e-mail this to our friends, who testify to the enormity of the event, and then we all await the next sensation. This impulse can be positive, but it also fuels the increasingly destructive American habit of oversharing. The snapshot speaks with a small voice: <em>I’m alive and I saw this. </em>The cell phone camera picture or video is a shout from the rooftop: <em>Check out this crazy thing that happened to me</em>.</p> <div class="slate-ad ad--mobileOnly ad--inArticleBanner"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot-mobile" data-zone-id = "768494" data-placement-id = "12399462" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271366" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <p class="slate-paragraph slate-graf" data-word-count="115" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-paragraph/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-11@published" >Picture sharing has also made us more aggressive in situations in which we feel insecure, such as in the presence of celebrities. Susan Sontag described the essentially hostile nature of taking pictures as a form of “soft” murder. In the age of cell phones, this scalp-hunting sensibility is achieving full flower. Let’s say you’re in Asbury Park and you see Bruce Springsteen with his kids. The old impulse would have been to ask the Boss if you could take your picture with him. The new impulse is to snap the shot with a cell phone camera and sell it to a site like <a data-linktype="External" href="http://www.scoopt.com/">Scoopt</a>. No wonder famous people don’t want to hang out with us.</p> <div class="slate-ad ad--desktopOnly ad--inArticleBanner"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot" data-zone-id = "768486" data-placement-id = "12399452" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271363" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <div class="slate-ad ad--tabletPortraitOnly ad--inArticleBanner"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/inArticleAds" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mid-article-spot-tablet" data-zone-id = "768488" data-placement-id = "12399457" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271364" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> <p class="slate-paragraph slate-graf" data-word-count="112" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-paragraph/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-12@published" >So, before we move on to the next racist comedian or cocaine-snorting supermodel, let’s put the Saddam video in context. It is a weird echo of the Zapruder film, another piece of amateur footage that caught the death of a leader. The differences are stark, of course. Zapruder captured Kennedy while standing openly in the Dallas sunlight. The official who videoed Saddam did so furtively, pointing his camera to the ground at times. But they both testify to the power of first-person witnessing, and how a digital copy of that witnessing can upend neat narratives and certainties. We’ll see the best of things, we’ll see the worst of things, we’ll see everything. </p> <p class="slate-paragraph slate-graf" data-word-count="11" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-paragraph/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-13@published" ><em>The Browser would like to thank the excellent Web site <a data-linktype="External" href="http://www.picturephoning.com/">picturephoning.com</a>.</em></p> <div class="social-share" aria-label="social media links" data-uri="slate.com/_components/social-share/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-14@published" > <a href="https://twitter.com/share?text=When+camera+phones+attack.&via=slate&url=https%3A%2F%2Fslate.com%2Ftechnology%2F2007%2F01%2Fwhen-camera-phones-attack.html%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_campaign%3Dtraffic%26utm_source%3Darticle%26utm_content%3Dtwitter_share" class="social-share__link social-share__link--twitter js-share-link" data-share="twitter" data-parsely-event="_twitter-tweet" target="_blank" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="social-share__icon" role="presentation"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#twitter-circle"></use> </svg>Tweet </a> <a href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fslate.com%2Ftechnology%2F2007%2F01%2Fwhen-camera-phones-attack.html%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_campaign%3Dtraffic%26utm_source%3Darticle%26utm_content%3Dfacebook_share" class="social-share__link social-share__link--facebook js-share-link" data-share="facebook" data-parsely-event="_facebook-share" aria-label="Share on Facebook" role="link" target="_blank" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="social-share__icon" role="presentation"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#facebook-circle"></use> </svg><span aria-hidden="true">Share</span> </a> <a data-share-url="https://slate.com/technology/2007/01/when-camera-phones-attack.html?utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=traffic&utm_source=article&utm_content=web_share" class="social-share__link social-share__link--share js-web-share-link" data-share="web-share" data-parsely-event="_web-share" aria-label="Share" role="link" hidden > <svg width="25" height="25" class="social-share__icon" role="presentation"> <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#share"></use> </svg><span aria-hidden="true">Share</span> </a> <a href="https://slate.com/comments/technology/2007/01/when-camera-phones-attack.html" class="social-share__link social-share__link--comments" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="social-share__icon" role="presentation" > <use href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#comments"></use> </svg>Comment </a> </div> </div> </section> <div class="article__right-rail"> <div class="slate-ad ad--desktopOnly ad--rightRail"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/articleRrFlex" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="rr-article-flex" data-zone-id = "768502" data-placement-id = "12399463" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="271367" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> </div> </article> <hr class="article__hr"> <div class="slate-parsely" data-article-url="https://slate.com/technology/2007/01/when-camera-phones-attack.html" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-parsely/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-1@published"> <script type="application/ld+json"> {"url":"https://slate.com/technology/2007/01/when-camera-phones-attack.html","@type":"NewsArticle","image":"https://compote.slate.com/images/83deacaf-aa20-47e0-926b-7bb85371351b.jpg","author":["Michael Agger"],"creator":["Michael Agger"],"@context":"http://schema.org","headline":"When camera phones attack.","keywords":["redux","Section:technology","AdNode:technology/the_browser"],"publisher":{"logo":{"url":"https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/icon.400x400.09ec623.png","@type":"ImageObject"},"name":"Slate","@type":"Organization"},"dateCreated":"2007-01-17T23:21:00+00:00","thumbnailUrl":"https://compote.slate.com/images/83deacaf-aa20-47e0-926b-7bb85371351b.jpg","datePublished":"2007-01-17T23:21:00+00:00","articleSection":"The Browser"} </script> </div> <div class="slate-adnode" data-adnode="technology/the_browser" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-adnode/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-2@published" ></div> <script class="slate-analytics-js js-analytics-js-data" type="application+json" data-pagetype="article" data-version="2.20.22" data-web-vitals-sampling="0.5" data-web-vitals-url="https://dot.cdnslate.com/static/web-vitals/web-vitals.attribution.iife.85b704e.js" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-analytics-js/instances/cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838-component-7@published" > {"headline":"When camera phones attack.","url":"https://slate.com/technology/2007/01/when-camera-phones-attack.html","tags":[],"authors":["Michael Agger"],"section":"Technology","rubric":"The Browser","pub_date":"2007-01-17T23:21:00+00:00","page_id":"cq-article-a34c1935d16144b55f5a9ebdcfb18838","page_type":"article","commercialNode":"technology/the_browser"} </script> <div class="piano-mount" data-uri="slate.com/_components/piano-mount/instances/meterwall@published" > <div class='piano-mount__container' id="meterwall"> </div> </div> </div> <aside class="l-container" > <div class="taboola-recirc" data-uri="slate.com/_components/taboola-recirc/instances/article@published"> <div id="taboola-below-article-thumbnails"></div> <script> window._taboola = window._taboola || []; _taboola.push({ mode: 'alternating-thumbnails-a', container: 'taboola-below-article-thumbnails', placement: 'Below Article Thumbnails', target_type: 'mix' }); </script> </div>  </aside> </div> </main> <section class="bottom-ad"> <div class="slate-ad ad--sticky-mobile ad--sticky-mobile-index ad--mobileOnly"> <div class="slate-ad__label"> <span class="border"></span> <div class="advertisement">Advertisement</div> <span class="border"></span> </div> <div class="slate-ad__creative" data-uri="slate.com/_components/slate-ad/instances/stickyBottom@published" data-placeholder="settings" data-type="mob-adhesion" data-zone-id = "1121368" data-placement-id = "14423119" data-criteo-id="" data-site-id="321366" data-ll-threshold="400" > </div> </div> </section> <footer class="global-footer" role="contentinfo" data-uri="slate.com/_components/global-footer/instances/default@published" > <div class="global-footer__main"> <div class="global-footer__main-content"> <div class="global-footer__about"> <h4 class="global-footer__heading">About</h4> <ul class="global-footer__links"> <li><a href="/about">About Us</a></li> <li><a href="https://jobs.lever.co/slate">Work With Us</a></li> <li><a href="/contact">Contact</a></li> <li><a href="/pitch">Pitch Guidelines</a></li> <li><a href="/tips">Send Us Tips</a></li> <li><a href="/briefing/corrections">Corrections</a></li> <li><a href="/commenting">Commenting</a></li> <li><a href="http://www.slatereprints.com/">Reprints</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="global-footer__sub"> <h4 class="global-footer__heading">Subscriptions</h4> <ul class="global-footer__links"> <li><a href="https://slate.com/plus" >Subscribe</a></li> <li><a href="https://slate.com/sign-in">Sign In</a></li> <li><a href="https://slate.com/account">Account</a></li> <li><a href="/plus/faq">Subscription FAQs</a></li> <li><a href="/podcastfaqs">Podcast FAQs</a></li> <li><a href="/newsletters">Newsletters</a></li> <li><a href="https://slatehelp.freshdesk.com/support/solutions">Customer Support</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="global-footer__ad"> <h4 class="global-footer__heading">Advertising</h4> <ul class="global-footer__links"> <li><a href="https://optout.aboutads.info/">AdChoices</a></li> <li><a class="global-footer__links__cookie-prefs-link" onclick="(function(event){window.OneTrust && window.OneTrust.ToggleInfoDisplay(); event.preventDefault(); }(event))" href="/do-not-sell" ><img class="global-footer__links__ccpa-logo" src="/media/components/onetrust-update/ccpa-icons/privacyoptions29x14.png" width="29" height="14" alt="California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) Opt-Out Icon" loading="lazy" />Cookie Preferences</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="global-footer__brand-section"> <svg width="243" height="30" class="global-footer__logo" loading="lazy"> <title>The Slate Group logo</title> <use data-href="https://slate.com/static/media/components/global-footer/footer-sprite.5083269.svg#slategroup" ></use> </svg> <p class="global-footer__brand-text">Slate is published by The Slate Group, a Graham Holdings Company.</p> <h4 class="global-footer__heading">Follow Us</h4> <div class="global-footer__social-links"> <a href="https://www.facebook.com/Slate/" class="global-footer__social-link" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="global-footer__social-badge" loading="lazy" > <use data-href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#facebook-circle" ></use> </svg> Facebook </a> <a href="https://twitter.com/slate" class="global-footer__social-link" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="global-footer__social-badge" loading="lazy" > <use data-href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#twitter-circle" ></use> </svg> Twitter </a> <a href="https://www.instagram.com/slate/" class="global-footer__social-link" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="global-footer__social-badge" loading="lazy" > <use data-href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#instagram-circle" ></use> </svg> Instagram </a> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/slate" class="global-footer__social-link" > <svg width="25" height="25" class="global-footer__social-badge" loading="lazy" > <use data-href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#youtube-circle" ></use> </svg> YouTube </a> <a href="/rss" class="global-footer__social-link"> <svg width="25" height="25" class="global-footer__social-badge" loading="lazy" > <use data-href="https://slate.com/static/media/sites/slate-com/share-sprite.ffcb553.svg#rss-circle" ></use> </svg> RSS Feed </a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="global-footer__legal"> <div class="global-footer__legal-content"> <ul class="global-footer__legal-links"> <li class="global-footer__legal-link"><a href="/terms">User Agreement</a></li> <li class="global-footer__legal-link"><a href="/privacy">Privacy Policy</a></li> </ul> <p class="global-footer__legal-text">All contents © 2024 The Slate Group LLC. All rights reserved.</p> </div> </div> </footer> <div id="onboarding-container" class="fixin"></div> <div class="foot" > <div class='piano' data-uri="slate.com/_components/piano/instances/general@published" data-config="{"url":"https://experience.piano.io","aid":"homyv5Uzpu","endpoint":"https://buy.piano.io/api/v3","idUrl":"https://id.piano.io/","cxenseSiteId":"1129570900026411565"}"> </div>  <script type="text/javascript"> !function(f,b,e,v,n,t,s){ if(f.fbq)return;n=f.fbq=function(){n.callMethod? n.callMethod.apply(n,arguments):n.queue.push(arguments)};if(!f._fbq)f._fbq=n; n.push=n;n.loaded=!0;n.version='2.0';n.queue=[];t=b.createElement(e);t.async=!0; t.src=v;s=b.getElementsByTagName(e)[0];s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)}(window, document,'script','https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/fbevents.js'); </script>  <script> var _comscore = _comscore || []; window.slateCMP.TCF.ready.then(function(tcData) { var comscoreSettings = { c1: "2", c2: "18406752", options: {enableFirstPartyCookie: true}}; var myReferrer = document.referrer; var gNewsRef = myReferrer.indexOf('news.url.google.com') > -1 || myReferrer.indexOf('news.google.com') > -1; if(gNewsRef){ comscoreSettings.options.url_append = "comscorekw=Playnewsstand"; } _comscore.push(comscoreSettings); (function() { var s = document.createElement("script"), el = document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0]; s.async = true; s.src = "https://sb.scorecardresearch.com/cs/18406752/beacon.js"; el.parentNode.insertBefore(s, el); })(); }); </script> <noscript><img src="https://sb.scorecardresearch.com/p?c1=2&c2=18406752&cv=3.9.1&cj=1" alt="comscore beacon"></noscript>  <script type="text/javascript"> var _qevents = _qevents || []; window.slateCMP.TCF.ready.then(function(tcData) { var elem = document.createElement('script'); elem.src = (document.location.protocol == "https:" ? "https://secure" : "http://edge") + ".quantserve.com/quant.js"; elem.defer = true; elem.type = "text/javascript"; var scpt = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; scpt.parentNode.insertBefore(elem, scpt); }); _qevents.push({ qacct:"p-fw53_-Tq3MNK1" }); </script> <noscript> <div style="display:none;"> <img src="//pixel.quantserve.com/pixel/p-fw53_-Tq3MNK1.gif" border="0" height="1" width="1" alt="Quantcast"/> </div> </noscript> <div data-uri="slate.com/_components/adblock-message/instances/general@published" class="adblock-message" hidden></div> <div data-uri="slate.com/_components/webapp-serviceworker/instances/default@published" data-is-eu="false"></div>  <script> window._taboola = window._taboola || []; _taboola.push({flush: true}); </script> </div> <style> @keyframes fadeInKilnLogo{0%{opacity:0}to{opacity:1}}.clay-kiln-logo{background-color:hsla(0,0%,100%,.8);display:none;height:100vh;left:0;opacity:0;position:fixed;top:0;width:100vw;z-index:99999}.clay-kiln-logo.show{animation:.2s ease forwards fadeInKilnLogo;display:block}.clay-kiln-logo svg{box-sizing:border-box;height:110px;left:calc(50vw - 155px);position:fixed;top:calc(50vh - 55px);width:310px} </style> <div class="clay-kiln-logo"><svg width="308" height="109" viewBox="0 0 308 109" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><g fill="none"><path d="M119.973 97.014c-16.469 0-26.796-10.718-26.796-24.837V25.514c0-14.117 10.327-24.835 26.796-24.835s25.751 10.718 25.751 24.835v8.757c0 1.831-1.57 3.398-3.399 3.398h-11.242c-1.831 0-3.398-1.567-3.398-3.398v-8.757c0-4.314-2.353-8.758-7.712-8.758-5.883 0-8.365 4.444-8.365 8.758v46.663c0 4.314 2.482 8.759 8.365 8.759 5.359 0 7.712-4.445 7.712-8.759V63.42c0-1.829 1.567-3.399 3.398-3.399h11.242c1.829 0 3.399 1.57 3.399 3.399v8.757c0 14.119-9.282 24.837-25.751 24.837m70.261-1.569h-35.553c-1.831 0-3.398-1.57-3.398-3.398V5.384c0-1.831 1.567-3.268 3.398-3.268h11.764a3.236 3.236 0 0 1 3.268 3.268v70.715c0 1.831 1.567 3.268 3.398 3.268h17.123c1.829 0 3.398 1.569 3.398 3.398v9.282c0 1.828-1.569 3.398-3.398 3.398m41.038-68.624c-.13-.916-.916-1.437-1.57-1.437-.653 0-1.437.521-1.437 1.437l-4.181 30.456c-.262 1.829.913 3.268 2.874 3.268h5.621c1.829 0 2.877-1.439 2.744-3.268l-4.051-30.456zm26.274 68.624H245.65c-1.961 0-3.66-1.437-3.922-3.269l-2.745-14.77c-.391-1.829-2.09-3.398-3.922-3.398h-10.586c-1.961 0-3.66 1.569-3.922 3.398l-2.744 14.77c-.392 1.832-2.091 3.269-3.922 3.269h-11.894c-1.961 0-3.006-1.437-2.615-3.269l18.561-86.792c.391-1.831 2.09-3.268 4.051-3.268h15.556c1.829 0 3.66 1.437 4.052 3.268l18.56 86.792c.394 1.832-.783 3.269-2.612 3.269zm32.645-44.705c-.261.916-.653 2.223-.915 3.401-.13 1.175-.26 2.22-.26 3.136v34.77c0 1.828-1.439 3.398-3.4 3.398h-11.764c-1.829 0-3.398-1.57-3.398-3.398v-34.9c0-1.048-.13-2.223-.392-3.53-.13-1.046-.392-2.223-.783-3.007L252.677 5.252c-.524-1.699.392-3.136 2.223-3.136h10.719c2.482 0 4.051 1.307 4.443 3.136l8.236 28.627c.26.916.913 1.308 1.437 1.308.654 0 1.175-.392 1.437-1.308l8.366-28.627c.524-1.829 1.831-3.136 4.314-3.136h10.85c1.959 0 2.874 1.437 2.221 3.136L290.191 50.74" fill="#8F9081"/><g transform="translate(0 2)"><path d="M43.428 67.018c-.095.28-.251.78-.445 1.483a55.428 55.428 0 0 0-.928 3.95c-2.01 10.079-2.01 21.274 1.347 32.507a2.265 2.265 0 1 0 4.34-1.296c-3.123-10.444-3.123-20.917-1.242-30.325.268-1.365.56-2.58.85-3.627.102-.363.192-.677.275-.94l.09-.286a2.269 2.269 0 0 0-1.41-2.876 2.269 2.269 0 0 0-2.88 1.41h.003zm29.28 1.468a23.792 23.792 0 0 1 .364 1.222c.292 1.048.582 2.264.854 3.627 1.877 9.41 1.877 19.88-1.242 30.328a2.262 2.262 0 0 0 1.52 2.821 2.27 2.27 0 0 0 2.822-1.524c3.355-11.237 3.355-22.433 1.343-32.511a55.27 55.27 0 0 0-.927-3.95 27.541 27.541 0 0 0-.445-1.482 2.268 2.268 0 0 0-2.878-1.41 2.268 2.268 0 0 0-1.41 2.877v.002zM4.916 70.803c.426-9.235 4.204-15 10.296-18.235 2.226-1.184 4.63-1.948 7.052-2.368a24.755 24.755 0 0 1 2.401-.293c.454-.03.79-.04.984-.04h-.003a2.267 2.267 0 0 0 .08-4.533h-.036c-.31 0-.761.01-1.335.05-.88.061-1.842.174-2.865.35-2.864.497-5.72 1.402-8.407 2.83C5.602 52.538.888 59.73.384 70.593a2.27 2.27 0 0 0 2.161 2.368 2.263 2.263 0 0 0 2.368-2.159h.002zm117.064-.208c-.504-10.864-5.214-18.056-12.698-22.03-2.686-1.427-5.54-2.334-8.403-2.83a28.462 28.462 0 0 0-2.867-.349 19.32 19.32 0 0 0-1.336-.05h-.034a2.266 2.266 0 1 0 .077 4.532c.193-.003.528.007.98.037.731.05 1.539.146 2.404.295 2.418.42 4.826 1.183 7.052 2.368 6.092 3.234 9.87 9 10.296 18.235a2.266 2.266 0 1 0 4.527-.21l.002.002z" fill="#BCBBAD"/><path d="M60.769 87.022c27.784 0 50.31-8.928 50.31-36.712C111.078 22.524 84.144 0 60.768 0c-23.377 0-50.31 22.524-50.31 50.31 0 27.785 22.524 36.712 50.31 36.712z" fill="#CECDC0"/><path d="M55.803 54.52c.33 2.158 2.177 3.772 4.366 3.772 2.191 0 4.04-1.617 4.366-3.778a.677.677 0 0 0-.571-.772.675.675 0 0 0-.772.567c-.229 1.503-1.512 2.625-3.023 2.625-1.511 0-2.792-1.12-3.022-2.62a.678.678 0 0 0-.773-.567.677.677 0 0 0-.57.772v.002z" fill="#9A998C"/><ellipse fill="#9A998C" cx="37.592" cy="39.248" rx="3.625" ry="5.665"/><ellipse fill="#9A998C" cx="82.928" cy="39.248" rx="3.625" ry="5.665"/><path d="M72.024 1.68c16.925 7.673 31.495 25.085 31.495 45.338 0 27.35-22.22 36.138-49.63 36.138-11.273 0-21.665-1.489-29.997-5.141 9.212 6.654 22.587 9.218 37.478 9.218 27.782 0 50.306-8.924 50.306-36.71 0-23.619-19.461-43.432-39.652-48.844" fill="#BCBBAD"/></g></g></svg></div> <script> !function(t){function n(r){if(e[r])return e[r].exports;var o=e[r]={i:r,l:!1,exports:{}};return t[r].call(o.exports,o,o.exports,n),o.l=!0,o.exports}var e={};n.m=t,n.c=e,n.d=function(t,e,r){n.o(t,e)||Object.defineProperty(t,e,{configurable:!1,enumerable:!0,get:r})},n.n=function(t){var e=t&&t.__esModule?function(){return t.default}:function(){return t};return n.d(e,"a",e),e},n.o=function(t,n){return Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(t,n)},n.p="",n(n.s=1215)}({100:function(t,n){function e(t,n,e,r){for(var o=t.length,u=e+(r?1:-1);r?u--:++u<o;)if(n(t[u],u,t))return u;return-1}t.exports=e},1215:function(t,n,e){"use strict";var r=e(740),o=function(t){return t&&t.__esModule?t:{default:t}}(r);e(260),(0,o.default)()},137:function(t,n){function e(t){return"number"==typeof t&&t>-1&&t%1==0&&t<=r}var r=9007199254740991;t.exports=e},138:function(t,n){function e(t){if(t&&"object"==typeof t){var n=t.which||t.keyCode||t.charCode;n&&(t=n)}if("number"==typeof t)return i[t];var e=t+"",u=r[e.toLowerCase()];if(u)return u;var u=o[e.toLowerCase()];return u||(1===e.length?e.charCodeAt(0):void 0)}e.isEventKey=function(t,n){if(t&&"object"==typeof t){var e=t.which||t.keyCode||t.charCode;if(null===e||void 0===e)return!1;if("string"==typeof n){var u=r[n.toLowerCase()];if(u)return u===e;var u=o[n.toLowerCase()];if(u)return u===e}else if("number"==typeof n)return n===e;return!1}},n=t.exports=e;var r=n.code=n.codes={backspace:8,tab:9,enter:13,shift:16,ctrl:17,alt:18,"pause/break":19,"caps lock":20,esc:27,space:32,"page up":33,"page down":34,end:35,home:36,left:37,up:38,right:39,down:40,insert:45,delete:46,command:91,"left command":91,"right command":93,"numpad *":106,"numpad +":107,"numpad -":109,"numpad .":110,"numpad /":111,"num lock":144,"scroll lock":145,"my computer":182,"my calculator":183,";":186,"=":187,",":188,"-":189,".":190,"/":191,"`":192,"[":219,"\\":220,"]":221,"'":222},o=n.aliases={windows:91,"⇧":16,"⌥":18,"⌃":17,"⌘":91,ctl:17,control:17,option:18,pause:19,break:19,caps:20,return:13,escape:27,spc:32,spacebar:32,pgup:33,pgdn:34,ins:45,del:46,cmd:91};/*! * Programatically add the following */ for(u=97;u<123;u++)r[String.fromCharCode(u)]=u-32;for(var u=48;u<58;u++)r[u-48]=u;for(u=1;u<13;u++)r["f"+u]=u+111;for(u=0;u<10;u++)r["numpad "+u]=u+96;var i=n.names=n.title={};for(u in r)i[r[u]]=u;for(var c in o)r[c]=o[c]},142:function(t,n,e){function r(t,n,e){return n===n?i(t,n,e):o(t,u,e)}var o=e(100),u=e(211),i=e(212);t.exports=r},174:function(t,n,e){"use strict";function r(t){var n=void 0,e=void 0,r=void 0;t=t||window.location,n=t.protocol+"//"+t.host+t.pathname+t.search,e=n.indexOf("?edit=true"),r=n.indexOf("&edit=true"),e>-1?n=n.substring(0,e):r>-1?n=n.substring(0,r):n.indexOf("?")>-1?n+="&edit=true":n+="?edit=true",t.assign(n)}Object.defineProperty(n,"__esModule",{value:!0}),n.default=r},190:function(t,n,e){function r(t){return t?(t=o(t))===u||t===-u?(t<0?-1:1)*i:t===t?t:0:0===t?t:0}var o=e(87),u=1/0,i=1.7976931348623157e308;t.exports=r},211:function(t,n){function e(t){return t!==t}t.exports=e},212:function(t,n){function e(t,n,e){for(var r=e-1,o=t.length;++r<o;)if(t[r]===n)return r;return-1}t.exports=e},213:function(t,n,e){function r(t){return null==t?[]:o(t,u(t))}var o=e(214),u=e(42);t.exports=r},214:function(t,n,e){function r(t,n){return o(n,function(n){return t[n]})}var o=e(43);t.exports=r},260:function(t,n){},3:function(t,n){var e=Array.isArray;t.exports=e},4:function(t,n){function e(t){var n=typeof t;return null!=t&&("object"==n||"function"==n)}t.exports=e},41:function(t,n){function e(t){return null!=t&&"object"==typeof t}t.exports=e},42:function(t,n,e){var r=e(75),o=r(Object.keys,Object);t.exports=o},43:function(t,n){function e(t,n){for(var e=-1,r=null==t?0:t.length,o=Array(r);++e<r;)o[e]=n(t[e],e,t);return o}t.exports=e},44:function(t,n,e){function r(t){return null!=t&&u(t.length)&&!o(t)}var o=e(49),u=e(137);t.exports=r},49:function(t,n,e){function r(t){if(!u(t))return!1;var n=o(t);return n==c||n==f||n==i||n==a}var o=e(50),u=e(4),i="[object AsyncFunction]",c="[object Function]",f="[object GeneratorFunction]",a="[object Proxy]";t.exports=r},5:function(t,n,e){function r(t){return"string"==typeof t||!u(t)&&i(t)&&o(t)==c}var o=e(50),u=e(3),i=e(41),c="[object String]";t.exports=r},50:function(t,n){function e(t){return o.call(t)}var r=Object.prototype,o=r.toString;t.exports=e},51:function(t,n,e){function r(t){var n=o(t),e=n%1;return n===n?e?n-e:n:0}var o=e(190);t.exports=r},62:function(t,n){function e(){return!1}t.exports=e},7:function(t,n,e){function r(t,n,e,r){t=u(t)?t:f(t),e=e&&!r?c(e):0;var s=t.length;return e<0&&(e=a(s+e,0)),i(t)?e<=s&&t.indexOf(n,e)>-1:!!s&&o(t,n,e)>-1}var o=e(142),u=e(44),i=e(5),c=e(51),f=e(213),a=Math.max;t.exports=r},740:function(t,n,e){"use strict";function r(t){return t&&t.__esModule?t:{default:t}}function o(){var t=document.querySelector(".clay-kiln-logo");t&&t.classList.add("show")}function u(){document.addEventListener("keydown",function(t){var n=(0,a.default)(t);(0,c.default)(["c","l","a","y"],n)&&!0===t.shiftKey?p+=n:p="","clay"===p?o():p.length>4&&(0,c.default)(p,"clay")?(0,l.default)():p.length>4&&(p="")}),document.addEventListener("keyup",function(){"clay"===p&&(0,l.default)()})}Object.defineProperty(n,"__esModule",{value:!0});var i=e(7),c=r(i);n.default=u;var f=e(138),a=r(f),s=e(174),l=r(s),p=""},75:function(t,n){function e(t,n){return function(e){return t(n(e))}}t.exports=e},87:function(t,n,e){function r(t){if("number"==typeof t)return t;if(u(t))return i;if(o(t)){var n="function"==typeof t.valueOf?t.valueOf():t;t=o(n)?n+"":n}if("string"!=typeof t)return 0===t?t:+t;t=t.replace(c,"");var e=a.test(t);return e||s.test(t)?l(t.slice(2),e?2:8):f.test(t)?i:+t}var o=e(4),u=e(62),i=NaN,c=/^\s+|\s+$/g,f=/^[-+]0x[0-9a-f]+$/i,a=/^0b[01]+$/i,s=/^0o[0-7]+$/i,l=parseInt;t.exports=r}}); </script> <script type="text/javascript"> // <![CDATA[ window.modules=[]; window.modules["3"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";window.criteo_q=window.criteo_q||[];var accountId=92394,deviceType=/iPad/.test(navigator.userAgent)?"t":/Mobile|iP(hone|od)|Android|BlackBerry|IEMobile|Silk/.test(navigator.userAgent)?"m":"d";function sansConsent(){window._slateCriteo={trackLandingPage:function(){},trackTransaction:function(){}}}function withConsent(){window._slateCriteo={trackLandingPage:trackLandingPage,trackTransaction:trackTransaction},trackHomePage()}function criteoPush(n){injectCriteo(),window.criteo_q.push.apply(window.criteo_q,n)}var injected=!1;function injectCriteo(){injected||(window.criteo_q.push({event:"setAccount",account:accountId},{event:"setSiteType",type:deviceType}),slateGlobal.injectScript("https://dynamic.criteo.com/js/ld/ld.js?a="+accountId),injected=!0)}function trackTransaction(){criteoPush([{event:"trackTransaction",id:"TransactionID",item:[{id:"1",price:"1",quantity:1}]}])}var trackLandingPage=function(){};document.querySelector(".standalone-page .piano-mount")&&(trackLandingPage=function(){criteoPush([{event:"viewItem",item:"1"}])});var homepageTracked=!1;function trackHomePage(){homepageTracked||"/"!==location.pathname||(criteoPush([{event:"viewHome"}]),homepageTracked=!0)}function applyConsent(n){return n?withConsent():sansConsent(),n}module.exports=function(){sansConsent();try{window.nonIabVendorApi.registerVendor("criteo",{categories:["C0004"],initFunc:applyConsent,updateConsentFunc:applyConsent})}catch(n){console.warn("criteo failed",n)}}; }, {}]; window.modules["4"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var membership=require(5);module.exports=function(e){window.nonIabVendorApi.registerVendor("parsely",{categories:["C0002"],initFunc:function(r){if(!r)return!1;window.PARSELY={autotrack:!1,onReady:function(){try{return Promise.resolve(membership.isMember()).then(function(e){if(e){var r=membership.getSplusCookie(),n={membershipType:r.membershipType,resourceIds:r.resourceIds.join(",")};window.PARSELY.updateDefaults({data:n})}window.location.href.includes("/_pages/")||window.PARSELY.beacon.trackPageView();for(var i=window.slateParsely.leadCaptureEvents,t=0;t<i.length;t++)window.PARSELY.conversions.trackLeadCapture(i[t])})}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}}};var n=document.createElement("script");return n.id="parsely-cfg",n.src=e,document.body.appendChild(n),!0},updateConsentFunc:function(e){e||window.PARSELY&&(window.PARSELY=Function.prototype)}})}; }, {"5":5}]; window.modules["5"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function _catch(e,r){try{var o=e()}catch(e){return r(e)}return o&&o.then?o.then(void 0,r):o}var checkAccess=function(e){try{return e&&isLoggedIn()?Promise.resolve(_catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(userCookiesReady).then(function(){return!!getShowSlugs().slugs.includes(e)})},function(r){return console.debug("Error in checkAccess for showSlug: "+e,r),!1})):Promise.resolve(!1)}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},getMembershipInfo=function(){return Promise.resolve(userCookiesReady).then(function(){if(hasSplusCookie()){var e=document.documentElement.dataset.myslateurl,r=toUrl(e);r.pathname="/users/slate_page_info/";var o=sessionStorage.getItem(IS_PURCHASING_KEY);o&&r.searchParams.set("purchase",!0);var t=new AbortController;return setTimeout(function(){return t.abort()},5e3),_catch(function(){var e={method:"GET",credentials:"include",headers:{Accept:"application/json"},signal:t.signal};return Promise.resolve(fetch(r.href,e)).then(function(e){return Promise.resolve(e.json()).then(function(e){return o&&sessionStorage.removeItem(IS_PURCHASING_KEY),window.dispatchEvent(new Event("returnedUserInfo")),e})})},function(e){"AbortError"===e.name?console.error("getMembershipInfo timed out after 5 seconds",e):console.error("Fetch for myslate membership info failed:",e),window.dispatchEvent(new Event("userInfoError"))})}})},isQuizMember=function(){return Promise.resolve(isMember()).then(function(e){if(!e)return!1;var r=getMembershipType();return["Slate_Plus_All_Access","Quiz","Games"].some(function(e){return r.includes(e)})})},isPodcastMember=function(){return Promise.resolve(isMember()).then(function(e){return!!e&&isPodcastRid(getMembershipType())})},isMember=function(){return Promise.resolve(userCookiesReady).then(function(){return hasSplusCookie()})},maybeUpdateShowSlugs=function(){try{var e=document.documentElement.dataset.myslateurl;return Promise.resolve(fetchShowSlugsHash(e)).then(function(r){var o=getShowSlugs();o.hash&&o.hash===r||(removeShowSlugs(),o=getShowSlugs());var t=function(){if(!Object.keys(o).length)return Promise.resolve(fetchShowSlugs(e)).then(function(e){e.length&&setShowSlugs(e,r)})}();if(t&&t.then)return t.then(function(){})})}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},updateUser=function(){try{if(!isLoggedIn())return cookies.remove("splus",membershipCookieAttrs),removeShowSlugs(),Promise.resolve();var e=_catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(getUserResources()).then(function(e){setPianoMember(e)})},function(e){console.error("Error fetching user resources",e)});return Promise.resolve(e&&e.then?e.then(function(){return maybeUpdateShowSlugs()}):maybeUpdateShowSlugs())}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},pianoService=require(55),getPianoId=pianoService.getPianoId,getUserResources=pianoService.getUserResources,_require=require(23),toUrl=_require.toUrl,cookies=require(38),_require2=require(77),fetchShowSlugsHash=_require2.fetchShowSlugsHash,getShowSlugs=_require2.getShowSlugs,removeShowSlugs=_require2.removeShowSlugs,fetchShowSlugs=_require2.fetchShowSlugs,setShowSlugs=_require2.setShowSlugs,membershipCookieAttrs={domain:"."+location.hostname},IS_PURCHASING_KEY="userIsPurchasing",userCookiesReady=updateUser();function isMemberSkipLookup(){return hasSplusCookie()}function hasSplusCookie(){return!!getSplusCookie()}function getSplusCookie(){return cookies.getJSON("splus")}function setMembershipCookie(e,r){cookies.set(e,r,Object.assign({},membershipCookieAttrs,{expires:365,SameSite:"Strict",secure:"https:"===location.protocol}))}function setPianoMember(e){if(e.data instanceof Array){var r=e.data.filter(function(e){return e.granted}).map(function(e){return e.resource.rid});if((r=Array.from(new Set(r))).length>0){var o={membershipType:"piano",resourceIds:r};setMembershipCookie("splus",JSON.stringify(o))}else cookies.remove("splus",membershipCookieAttrs)}}function getMembershipType(){var e="none",r=getSplusCookie();return r&&(e=r.membershipType,r.resourceIds&&(e=e+"|"+r.resourceIds.join("|"))),e}function isPodcastRid(e){return["Slate_Plus_All_Access","Big_Mood_Plus"].some(function(r){return e.includes(r)})}function getPodcastInfo(e){if(!hasSplusCookie())throw new Error("User is not splus user.");var r=document.documentElement.dataset.myslateurl;return fetch(r+"/membership/podcasts_feeds/?feed="+e,{method:"GET",credentials:"include",headers:{Accept:"application/json"}}).then(function(e){return e.json().then(function(r){if(!e.ok)throw new Error(r.message);return r})})}function postPodcastSmsNumber(e,r){if(!hasSplusCookie())throw new Error("User is not splus user.");var o=document.documentElement.dataset.myslateurl+"/membership/podcasts_sms/",t={method:"POST",credentials:"include",headers:{Accept:"application/json"},body:JSON.stringify({phoneNumber:e,feedId:r})};return fetch(o,t).then(function(e){return e.text().then(function(r){if(!e.ok)throw new Error(r);return r})})}function isLoggedIn(){return!!getLoginId()}function getLoginId(){return getPianoId()}function getFeedUrl(e,r){for(var o=0;o<r.length;o++){var t=r[o];if(t.display_name===e)return t.feed_url}}function getUserEmail(){var e=pianoService.getPianoJwt();return e&&e.email.trim().toLowerCase()}function removeCookie(e){cookies.remove(e,membershipCookieAttrs)}module.exports.IS_PURCHASING_KEY=IS_PURCHASING_KEY,module.exports.checkAccess=checkAccess,module.exports.getLoginId=getLoginId,module.exports.getMembershipType=getMembershipType,module.exports.getMembershipInfo=getMembershipInfo,module.exports.isLoggedIn=isLoggedIn,module.exports.isMember=isMember,module.exports.isMemberSkipLookup=isMemberSkipLookup,module.exports.getFeedUrl=getFeedUrl,module.exports.setPianoMember=setPianoMember,module.exports.getSplusCookie=getSplusCookie,module.exports.updateUser=updateUser,module.exports.userCookiesReady=userCookiesReady,module.exports.getPodcastInfo=getPodcastInfo,module.exports.postPodcastSmsNumber=postPodcastSmsNumber,module.exports.getUserEmail=getUserEmail,module.exports.setMembershipCookie=setMembershipCookie,module.exports.removeCookie=removeCookie,module.exports.isPodcastMember=isPodcastMember,module.exports.isQuizMember=isQuizMember,module.exports.isPodcastRid=isPodcastRid; }, {"23":23,"38":38,"55":55,"77":77}]; window.modules["17"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var domEventData,resolveWaitForPageview,getDomEventData=function(e){if(domEventData)return domEventData;try{e=e||document.querySelectorAll("script.js-analytics-js-data")[0],domEventData=JSON.parse(e.textContent)}catch(e){console.warn("unable to get dom event data for amplitude",e)}return domEventData},track=function(e,t){var a=getDomEventData(),r={};Object.assign(r,a,t);try{return amplitude.track(e,r).promise}catch(a){console.error("FAILED amplitude.track",e,t,a)}},waitForPageview=new Promise(function(e,t){resolveWaitForPageview=e});function trackAfterPageview(){for(var e=arguments.length,t=new Array(e),a=0;a<e;a++)t[a]=arguments[a];waitForPageview.then(function(){track.apply(void 0,t)})}var page=function(e){try{return Promise.resolve(amplitude.track("Loaded a Page",e).promise).then(function(){resolveWaitForPageview()})}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}};module.exports.getDomEventData=getDomEventData,module.exports.getInstance=function(){return amplitude},module.exports.page=page,module.exports.track=track,module.exports.trackAfterPageview=trackAfterPageview,module.exports.afterPageview=waitForPageview,exports.log=function(e,t){return Promise.resolve(waitForPageview).then(function(){window.slateAmplitudeQueue.push(function(a){for(var r in t=Object.assign({},getDomEventData(),t))"boolean"==typeof t[r]&&(t[r]=(""+t[r]).toUpperCase());return a.track(e,t)})})}; }, {}]; window.modules["23"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function toUrl(r,a){var t;try{t=new URL(r),a&&(t.search=updateParams(t.search,a))}catch(r){t=null}return t}function hasParam(r,a){return!!new URL(r).searchParams.get(a)}function updateParams(r,a){var t=paramStringToObject(r),e=paramStringToObject(a);return new URLSearchParams(Object.assign({},t,e)).toString()}function paramStringToObject(r){for(var a=Array.from(new URLSearchParams(r)),t={},e=0;e<a.length;e++){var n=a[e],o=n[0],i=n[1];o=o.trim(),i=i.trim(),t[o]=i}return t}function normalizeUrl(r,a){if(r){var t=new URL(r,a.site.baseUrl);return t.host=a.site.host,t.toString()}}module.exports={toUrl:toUrl,hasParam:hasParam,paramStringToObject:paramStringToObject,normalizeUrl:normalizeUrl}; }, {}]; window.modules["24"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.getActualTheme=getActualTheme,exports.getTheme=getTheme,exports.getThemeClass=getThemeClass,exports.onThemeChange=onThemeChange,exports.setTheme=setTheme;var prefersDark=window.matchMedia("(prefers-color-scheme: dark)"),THEME_OPTIONS=["dark","light","auto"],CLASS_OPTIONS=THEME_OPTIONS.map(getThemeClass);function getActualTheme(){return resolveTheme(getTheme())}function resolveTheme(e){return"dark"===e||"auto"===e&&prefersDark.matches?"dark":"light"}function setTheme(e){var t;(t=document.documentElement.classList).remove.apply(t,CLASS_OPTIONS),document.documentElement.classList.add(getThemeClass(e));try{localStorage.setItem("theme",e)}catch(t){console.error("failed to set theme in storage",e,t)}window.dispatchEvent(makeThemeChangeEvent())}function makeThemeChangeEvent(){return new CustomEvent("theme-change",{detail:{theme:getActualTheme()}})}function getTheme(){try{var e=localStorage.getItem("theme")}catch(t){console.error("failed to get theme from storage",e,t)}return THEME_OPTIONS.includes(e)||(e="light"),e}function getThemeClass(e){return void 0===e&&(e=getTheme()),"theme-"+e}function onThemeChange(e){e(getActualTheme()),prefersDark.addEventListener("change",function(){return e(getActualTheme())}),window.addEventListener("theme-change",function(t){return e(t.detail.theme)})} }, {}]; window.modules["29"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var loaded=new Set;function executeScripts(e){e.querySelectorAll("script").forEach(function(e){var t=document.createElement("script");e.src?t.src=e.src:e.textContent&&(t.text=e.textContent),e.parentNode.insertBefore(t,e),e.parentNode.removeChild(e)})}function _load(e,t){if(void 0===t&&(t={}),!loaded.has(e)){var n=e.querySelector(".lazyload-container > noscript");if(n){var o=n.parentNode;o.innerHTML=n.innerText,loaded.add(e),executeScripts(e),o.classList.add("lazyload-container--loaded"),t.fluid&&(o.style.paddingBottom="",o.classList.add("lazyload-container--fluid")),o.hidden=!1}else console.error('cannot find "noscript" for unloaded el',e)}}function _unload(e,t){if(loaded.has(e)){var n=e.querySelector(".lazyload-container");if(n&&!n.firstElementChild.matches("noscript")){var o=n.offsetHeight;n.innerHTML="\n <noscript>\n "+n.innerHTML+"\n </noscript>\n ",loaded.delete(e),n.classList.remove("lazyload-container--loaded"),t.fluid&&(n.style.paddingBottom=o+"px",n.classList.remove("lazyload-container--fluid"))}else console.error("cannot find container to unload el",e)}}module.exports.createObserver=function(e){e=Object.assign({intersectionObserverOptions:{rootMargin:"100% 0% 100% 0%"},limit:1/0,fluid:!1,onLoad:function(){},onUnload:function(){}},e);var t=new Map,n=new IntersectionObserver(function(n){n.forEach(function(n){var o;t.has(n.target)?o=t.get(n.target):(o={el:n.target},t.set(n.target,o)),o.isIntersecting=n.isIntersecting,o.offsetTop=n.boundingClientRect.top+window.scrollY,!o.loaded&&o.isIntersecting&&(_load(n.target,e),o.loaded=!0,e.onLoad(n.target,e))});var o=[];t.forEach(function(e){e.loaded&&o.push(e)});var r=o.length-e.limit;r>0&&o.filter(function(e){return!e.isIntersecting}).map(function(e){return e.distance=Math.abs(e.offsetTop-window.scrollY),e}).sort(function(e,t){return t.distance-e.distance}).slice(0,r).forEach(function(t){_unload(t.el,e),t.loaded=!1,e.onUnload(t.el,e)})},e.intersectionObserverOptions);return{observe:function(){return n.observe.apply(n,arguments)},unobserve:function(){return n.unobserve.apply(n,arguments)},load:function(t){return _load(t,e)},unload:function(t){return _unload(t,e)}}},window.addEventListener("load",function(){var e=document.querySelectorAll(".lazyload-html--auto");if(e.length>0){var t=exports.createObserver({fluid:!0});e.forEach(function(e){return t.observe(e)})}}),module.exports.executeScripts=executeScripts; }, {}]; window.modules["31"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var slateAmplitude=require(17),slatePermutive=require(80);function getPlacement(e){return e.closest(".share-sidebar")?"sidebar":e.closest(".social-share--podcast-bottom")?"podcast-bottom":"article-bottom"}function trackShare(e){var t=e.dataset.share,a={type:t,action:e.dataset.parselyEvent,placement:getPlacement(e)};slateAmplitude.track("Clicked Social Share",a),slatePermutive.track("Social",{platform:t})}function handleSocial(e){e.preventDefault();trackShare(this),openPopupWindow(this)}function handleWebShare(e){return function(t){t.preventDefault();navigator.share&&(trackShare(this),navigator.share(e).catch(function(e){return console.log("Error sharing",e)}))}}function handleCopyUrl(e,t){return function(a){var n=e.innerHTML;a.preventDefault(),navigator.clipboard.writeText(t),e.innerHTML="Copied!",setTimeout(function(){e.innerHTML=n},5e3)}}function openPopupWindow(e){var t=e.href;window.open(t,"sharewindow","toolbar=0,status=0,width=620,height=280")}function generatePayload(e,t){var a={title:"Slate",text:t||document.title,url:e};return navigator.canShare&&navigator.canShare(a)?a:null}function setupShareButton(e,t,a){var n=generatePayload(t,a);n?e.addEventListener("click",handleWebShare(n)):e.addEventListener("click",handleCopyUrl(e,a+" "+t))}function setupSocialShareComponentButtons(e,t,a){var n=generatePayload(t.dataset.shareUrl);n&&(t.hidden=!1,t.classList.add(e+"--mobile-only"),a.forEach(function(t){t.classList.add(e+"--desktop-only")}),t.addEventListener("click",handleWebShare(n))),a.forEach(function(e){e.addEventListener("click",handleSocial)})}module.exports.trackShare=trackShare,module.exports.handleSocial=handleSocial,module.exports.handleWebShare=handleWebShare,module.exports.openPopupWindow=openPopupWindow,module.exports.setupShareButton=setupShareButton,module.exports.setupSocialShareComponentButtons=setupSocialShareComponentButtons; }, {"17":17,"80":80}]; window.modules["38"] = [function(require,module,exports){!function(e){var n;if("function"==typeof define&&define.amd&&(define(e),n=!0),"object"==typeof exports&&(module.exports=e(),n=!0),!n){var t=window.Cookies,o=window.Cookies=e();o.noConflict=function(){return window.Cookies=t,o}}}(function(){function e(){for(var e=0,n={};e<arguments.length;e++){var t=arguments[e];for(var o in t)n[o]=t[o]}return n}function n(e){return e.replace(/(%[0-9A-Z]{2})+/g,decodeURIComponent)}return function t(o){function r(){}function i(n,t,i){if("undefined"!=typeof document){"number"==typeof(i=e({path:"/"},r.defaults,i)).expires&&(i.expires=new Date(1*new Date+864e5*i.expires)),i.expires=i.expires?i.expires.toUTCString():"";try{var c=JSON.stringify(t);/^[\{\[]/.test(c)&&(t=c)}catch(e){}t=o.write?o.write(t,n):encodeURIComponent(String(t)).replace(/%(23|24|26|2B|3A|3C|3E|3D|2F|3F|40|5B|5D|5E|60|7B|7D|7C)/g,decodeURIComponent),n=encodeURIComponent(String(n)).replace(/%(23|24|26|2B|5E|60|7C)/g,decodeURIComponent).replace(/[]/g,escape);var f="";for(var u in i)i[u]&&(f+="; "+u,!0!==i[u]&&(f+="="+i[u].split(";")[0]));return document.cookie=n+"="+t+f}}function c(e,t){if("undefined"!=typeof document){for(var r={},i=document.cookie?document.cookie.split("; "):[],c=0;c<i.length;c++){var f=i[c].split("="),u=f.slice(1).join("=");t||'"'!==u.charAt(0)||(u=u.slice(1,-1));try{var a=n(f[0]);if(u=(o.read||o)(u,a)||n(u),t)try{u=JSON.parse(u)}catch(e){}if(r[a]=u,e===a)break}catch(e){}}return e?r[e]:r}}return r.set=i,r.get=function(e){return c(e,!1)},r.getJSON=function(e){return c(e,!0)},r.remove=function(n,t){i(n,"",e(t,{expires:-1}))},r.defaults={},r.withConverter=t,r}(function(){})}); }, {}]; window.modules["40"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var launchOnboarding=function(e){try{return!e.onboarding||document.documentElement.clientWidth<=1024?Promise.resolve():Promise.resolve(piano.getExtendedUserData("onboarding")).then(function(n){var r=n.email,i=piano.getCustomFields(n);if(i.onboarding_enabled)return window._ONBOARDING={user:Object.assign({},i,{email:r}),experience:e},Promise.resolve(fetch("/fixins/onboarding/index.html").then(function(e){return e.text()}).then(function(e){return(new DOMParser).parseFromString(e,"text/html")})).then(function(e){e.head.querySelectorAll("meta,title").forEach(function(e){return e.remove()});var n=document.querySelector("#onboarding-container");n.innerHTML=e.head.innerHTML+e.body.innerHTML,executeScripts(n)})})}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},membership=require(5),piano=require(55),_require=require(29),executeScripts=_require.executeScripts;exports.init=function(){membership.isLoggedIn()&&window.tp.push(["addHandler","setResponseVariable",function(e){return launchOnboarding(e.responseVariables)}])}; }, {"5":5,"29":29,"55":55}]; window.modules["47"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var dropdownSelector=".dropdown",buttonSelector=".dropdown__button",contentSelector=".dropdown__content";module.exports=function(e){(e.matches(dropdownSelector)?[e]:e.querySelectorAll(dropdownSelector)).forEach(initialize)};var x=0;function initialize(e){var t=e.querySelector(contentSelector);if(!t.id){t.id="dropdown-"+x++;var n=e.querySelector(buttonSelector);n.setAttribute("aria-controls",t.id),n.setAttribute("aria-expanded",!1);var r={click:function(t){e.contains(t.target)||o()},keyup:function(e){["Escape","Esc"].includes(e.key)&&o()}};e.addEventListener("click",function(){return"true"===n.getAttribute("aria-expanded")?o():function(){for(var e in n.setAttribute("aria-expanded","true"),r)document.body.addEventListener(e,r[e])}()}),e.hidden=!1,n.disabled=!1}function o(){for(var e in n.setAttribute("aria-expanded","false"),r)document.body.removeEventListener(e,r[e])}} }, {}]; window.modules["48"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";exports.formatArticleData=function(t){return{content_created:t.pub_date,content_author:t.authors.join(","),content_section:t.section,tags:t.tags,custom_variables:{contentRubric:t.rubric,amplitudePageType:t.page_type}}},exports.allowedOrigins=["https://sandbox.piano.io","https://id.piano.io","https://buy.piano.io","https://sandbox.tinypass.com","https://id.tinypass.com","https://buy.tinypass.com"]; }, {}]; window.modules["49"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var dropdown=require(47),darkMode=require(24);function munge(e){return e.trim().toLowerCase()}function constructThemePickers(e){var r=e.querySelectorAll(".theme-picker");function n(e){r.forEach(function(r){r.querySelector(".dropdown__label").innerHTML=e.innerHTML});var n=munge(e.innerText);darkMode.setTheme(n)}r.forEach(function(e){e.querySelectorAll(".theme-picker__option").forEach(function(e){var r=munge(e.innerText);document.documentElement.classList.contains("theme-"+r)&&n(e),e.addEventListener("click",function(e){n(e.currentTarget)})}),dropdown(e)})}module.exports=constructThemePickers; }, {"24":24,"47":47}]; window.modules["54"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function _catch(t,r){try{var e=t()}catch(t){return r(t)}return e&&e.then?e.then(void 0,r):e}var _require=require(885),get=_require.get;function constructUserEndpoint(t){var r=constructBaseEndpoint();if(t){var e=new URL(r);e.pathname=""+e.pathname+t+"/",r=e.href}return r}function constructOptOutEndpoint(t){if(!t)throw Error("You must provide an email to opt out of communication.");var r=constructBaseEndpoint(),e=new URL(r);return e.pathname=e.pathname+"optout/"+t+"/",r=e.href}function constructBaseEndpoint(){var t=document.documentElement.dataset.myslateurl;return new URL(t+"/proxies/newsletters/").href}module.exports.getSubscriptions=function(t){try{var r=constructUserEndpoint(t);return Promise.resolve(_catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(get(r))},function(t){throw Error("Error fetching user newsletter subscriptions from "+r,t)}))}catch(t){return Promise.reject(t)}},module.exports.updateSubscriptions=function(t,r,e,n){void 0===t&&(t={}),void 0===e&&(e=""),void 0===n&&(n=!1);try{if(!r)throw Error("You must provide an email to update subscriptions.");var o,i=Object.assign({},t,{token:e,isTurnstile:n});return Promise.resolve(_catch(function(){o=constructUserEndpoint(r);var t={method:"POST",credentials:"include",body:JSON.stringify(i)};return Promise.resolve(get(o,t))},function(r){throw Error("Error updating user newsletter subscriptions with endpoint "+o+" and data "+JSON.stringify(t),r)}))}catch(t){return Promise.reject(t)}},module.exports.optOutOfSubscriptions=function(t,r){try{var e=constructOptOutEndpoint(t);return Promise.resolve(_catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(get(e,{method:"GET",credentials:"include"}))},function(t){throw Error("Something went wrong while opting out.",t)}))}catch(t){return Promise.reject(t)}},module.exports.getAllNewsletters=function(){try{var t=constructBaseEndpoint(),r=new URL(t+"all/").href;return Promise.resolve(_catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(get(r))},function(t){throw Error("Unable to fetch newsletters",t)}))}catch(t){return Promise.reject(t)}}; }, {"885":885}]; window.modules["55"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var cookies=require(38),PIANOAPITIMEOUT=3e3;module.exports={getExtendedUserData:function(e){return new Promise(function(t,i){var o=setTimeout(i,PIANOAPITIMEOUT);window.tp||(window.tp=[]);window.tp.push(["init",function(){tp.pianoId.loadExtendedUser({formName:e,extendedUserLoaded:function(e){clearTimeout(o),e?t(e):i(e)}})}])})},getCustomFields:function(e){for(var t={},i=0,o=e.custom_field_values;i<o.length;i++){var n=o[i],r=n.field_name,u=n.value;try{t[r]=JSON.parse(u)}catch(e){t[r]="string"==typeof u&&u?u:null}}return t},getCustomFieldValue:function(e,t){if(e.custom_field_values)for(var i=0;i<e.custom_field_values.length;i++)if(e.custom_field_values[i].field_name===t)return e.custom_field_values[i].value},getPianoJwt:function(){var e=cookies.get("__utp");if(e)try{var t=atob(e.split(".")[1]);return JSON.parse(t)}catch(t){return void console.error("Error parsing __utp cookie: "+e,t)}},getPianoId:function(){var e=module.exports.getPianoJwt();if(e)return e.sub},getUser:function(){return new Promise(function(e,t){var i=setTimeout(t,PIANOAPITIMEOUT);window.tp||(window.tp=[]),window.tp.push(["init",function(){try{clearTimeout(i),e(window.tp.pianoId.getUser())}catch(e){t(e)}}])})},getUserResources:function(){return new Promise(function(e,t){var i=setTimeout(t,PIANOAPITIMEOUT);window.tp||(window.tp=[]),window.tp.push(["init",function(){try{window.tp.api.callApi("/access/list",{},function(t){clearTimeout(i),e(t)})}catch(e){t(e)}}])})}}; }, {"38":38}]; window.modules["56"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var newsletterService=require(54),slateAmplitude=require(17),slatePermutive=require(80);function handleSubscriptionUpdate(e,t,r,i,a){void 0===a&&(a=!1);var s={};return s[t]=1,r&&(s.Marketing=1),newsletterService.updateSubscriptions({subscribed:s},e,i,a)}function trackNewsletterSignup(e,t){try{var r=new amplitude.Identify;r.append("Newsletters",t),amplitude.identify(r)}catch(e){console.error("amplitude.identify failed",e)}try{ats.setAdditionalData({type:"email",id:e})}catch(e){console.error("Failed to add to ats",e)}slateAmplitude.track("Newsletter: Sign Up",{list_name:t}),slatePermutive.track("Newsletter",{newsletters:[t]})}module.exports.handleSubscriptionUpdate=handleSubscriptionUpdate,module.exports.trackNewsletterSignup=trackNewsletterSignup; }, {"17":17,"54":54,"80":80}]; window.modules["58"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function _catch(r,e){try{var n=r()}catch(r){return e(r)}return n&&n.then?n.then(void 0,e):n}function hashBuff2Hex(r){return Array.from(new Uint8Array(r)).map(function(r){return r.toString(16).padStart(2,"0")}).join("")}function hashBuff2Base64(r){for(var e="",n=new Uint8Array(r),t=n.byteLength,o=0;o<t;o++)e+=String.fromCharCode(n[o]);return window.btoa(e)}var hash=function(r,n){void 0===n&&(n="base64");try{var t;if(!r)return console.error("No value passed to hash"),Promise.resolve();var o=_catch(function(){var o=(new TextEncoder).encode(r);return Promise.resolve(window.crypto.subtle.digest("SHA-256",o)).then(function(r){if("hex"===n)t=hashBuff2Hex(r);else{if("base64"!==n)throw new Error("Encoding: "+n+" not supported",e);t=hashBuff2Base64(r)}})},function(r){console.error(r)});return Promise.resolve(o&&o.then?o.then(function(r){return t}):t)}catch(r){return Promise.reject(r)}};module.exports.hash=hash; }, {}]; window.modules["59"] = [function(require,module,exports){var isObject=require(598),now=require(718),toNumber=require(719),FUNC_ERROR_TEXT="Expected a function",nativeMax=Math.max,nativeMin=Math.min;function debounce(n,i,t){var e,r,o,u,a,c,v=0,f=!1,m=!1,d=!0;if("function"!=typeof n)throw new TypeError(FUNC_ERROR_TEXT);function T(i){var t=e,o=r;return e=r=void 0,v=i,u=n.apply(o,t)}function s(n){var t=n-c;return void 0===c||t>=i||t<0||m&&n-v>=o}function b(){var n=now();if(s(n))return l(n);a=setTimeout(b,function(n){var t=i-(n-c);return m?nativeMin(t,o-(n-v)):t}(n))}function l(n){return a=void 0,d&&e?T(n):(e=r=void 0,u)}function w(){var n=now(),t=s(n);if(e=arguments,r=this,c=n,t){if(void 0===a)return function(n){return v=n,a=setTimeout(b,i),f?T(n):u}(c);if(m)return clearTimeout(a),a=setTimeout(b,i),T(c)}return void 0===a&&(a=setTimeout(b,i)),u}return i=toNumber(i)||0,isObject(t)&&(f=!!t.leading,o=(m="maxWait"in t)?nativeMax(toNumber(t.maxWait)||0,i):o,d="trailing"in t?!!t.trailing:d),w.cancel=function(){void 0!==a&&clearTimeout(a),v=0,e=c=r=a=void 0},w.flush=function(){return void 0===a?u:l(now())},w}module.exports=debounce; }, {"598":598,"718":718,"719":719}]; window.modules["60"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function dispatchPianoResponseVariables(e){var s=new CustomEvent("pianoResponseVariables",{detail:{responseVariables:e.responseVariables}});window.dispatchEvent(s)}module.exports=dispatchPianoResponseVariables; }, {}]; window.modules["61"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function experienceExecute(e){var n=e.result.events.find(function(e){return"experienceExecute"===e.eventType});if(n){var t=n.eventExecutionContext,i=t.userSegments;if("COMPOSER1X"in i){var r={};i.COMPOSER1X.segments.forEach(function(e){var n=e.split(":"),t=n[0],i=n[2],s=["LTs","LTc","LTreg","CScore"];t=t.toLowerCase(),(s=s.map(function(e){return e.toLowerCase()})).includes(t)&&(r["piano_"+function(e){switch(e){case"cscore":return"ltconvert";default:return e}}(t)]=i)}),t.splitTests.length&&(r.piano_segment_id=[],r.piano_segment_name=[],t.splitTests.forEach(function(e){r.piano_segment_id.push(e.variantId),r.piano_segment_name.push(e.variantName)}));var s=new amplitude.Identify;for(var a in r)s.set(a,r[a]);amplitude.identify(s)}}}module.exports=experienceExecute; }, {}]; window.modules["62"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var supportJournalism=require(75);function showOffer(e){e.containerSelector.includes("#meterwall")&&supportJournalism.setParams(),window._slateCriteo.trackLandingPage()}module.exports=showOffer; }, {"75":75}]; window.modules["63"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var slateAmplitude=require(17);function onCheckoutStateChange(e){switch(e.stateName){case"auth":slateAmplitude.track("Slate Plus: View Checkout");break;case"state2":slateAmplitude.track("Slate Plus: Payment"),window.tfaPush({notify:"subscription",name:"subscription-form-visible",sourceurl:location.href});break;case"bankSecure":slateAmplitude.track("Display 3DS Challenge")}}module.exports=onCheckoutStateChange; }, {"17":17}]; window.modules["64"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function _catch(e,r){try{var t=e()}catch(e){return r(e)}return t&&t.then?t.then(void 0,r):t}var afterCheckout=function(e){try{return Promise.resolve(piano.getExtendedUserData("attribution-menu")).then(function(r){function t(){window._slateCriteo.trackTransaction()}var i=Object.assign({offer_ID:e.offerId,price:e.chargeAmount,plan_type:e.rid,term_ID:e.termId},getMorgioniProps()),n=piano.getCustomFieldValue(r,"attribution_menu");if(n){try{var o=JSON.parse(n);o instanceof Array&&(n=o.join())}catch(e){}var s=piano.getCustomFieldValue(r,"attribution_menu_other");s&&(n+=": "+s),i["S+ Purchase Attribution"]=n}slateAmplitude.track("Slate Plus: Purchase",i),isPodcastRid(e.rid)&&sessionStorage.setItem(IS_PURCHASING_KEY,!0);try{window.fbq("track","Purchase",{currency:e.chargeCurrency,value:e.chargeAmount})}catch(e){console.warn("fb purchase event failed",e)}var a=_catch(function(){function e(){window.gtag("event","conversion",r)}var r={send_to:"AW-794295919/I6C8CKDPrIsBEO_83_oC"},t=membership.getUserEmail(),i=function(){if(t)return Promise.resolve(hash(t,"hex")).then(function(e){r.sha256_email_address=e})}();return i&&i.then?i.then(e):e()},function(e){console.warn("google conversion event failed",e)});return a&&a.then?a.then(t):t()})}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},slateAmplitude=require(17),_require=require(71),getMorgioniProps=_require.getMorgioniProps,_require2=require(58),hash=_require2.hash,membership=require(5),piano=require(55),_require3=require(5),IS_PURCHASING_KEY=_require3.IS_PURCHASING_KEY,isPodcastRid=_require3.isPodcastRid;module.exports=afterCheckout; }, {"5":5,"17":17,"55":55,"58":58,"71":71}]; window.modules["65"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var _require=require(56),handleSubscriptionUpdate=_require.handleSubscriptionUpdate,trackNewsletterSignup=_require.trackNewsletterSignup,_require2=require(23),toUrl=_require2.toUrl,_require3=require(73),loadRecaptcha=_require3.loadRecaptcha,executeRecaptcha=_require3.executeRecaptcha;function sendPostMessageToPiano(e,r,t){document.getElementById(e).contentWindow.postMessage({piano:{success:r,managementUrl:t}},"*")}function onSuccess(e,r,t,n){sendPostMessageToPiano(e,!0,toUrl(n,{email:r}).href),trackNewsletterSignup(r,t)}function onError(e,r){sendPostMessageToPiano(e,!1,r)}function newsletterSignup(e){"email-signup"===e.eventName&&e.params&&loadRecaptcha().then(function(){try{var r=JSON.parse(e.params.params).iframeId,t=e.params.email,n=e.params.list,a="true"===e.params.marketing||!1,i=e.params.managementUrl,s=function(){if(t&&t.length>0&&r&&n)return Promise.resolve(executeRecaptcha()).then(function(e){handleSubscriptionUpdate(t,n,a,e).then(function(){return onSuccess(r,t,n,i)}).catch(function(){return onError(r,t)})});console.error("Missing information for newsletter signup.")}();return Promise.resolve(s&&s.then?s.then(function(){}):void 0)}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}}).catch(function(e){throw new Error("Couldn't load recaptcha in Piano newsletter-signup",e)})}module.exports=newsletterSignup; }, {"23":23,"56":56,"73":73}]; window.modules["66"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var _require=require(70),getRedirectUrl=_require.getRedirectUrl,isSpotifyPlus=_require.isSpotifyPlus,redirectToSpotify=_require.redirectToSpotify;function afterCheckoutClose(e){if("checkoutCompleted"===e.state||"voucherRedemptionCompleted"===e.state){if(isSpotifyPlus())return void redirectToSpotify();location.href=getRedirectUrl()||"/account"}}module.exports=afterCheckoutClose; }, {"70":70}]; window.modules["67"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function _catch(e,r){try{var t=e()}catch(e){return r(e)}return t&&t.then?t.then(void 0,r):t}var loginSuccessHandler=function(e){try{return Promise.resolve(membership.updateUser()).then(function(){var r=!1;function t(t){return r?t:(slateAmplitude.track("Account: Sign In",i),function(){if("PIANOID"===e.source){return Promise.resolve(membership.isMember()).then(function(e){var r=!1;function t(e){if(r)return e;var t=getRedirectUrl();t&&(location.href=t)}var i=function(){if(e&&isSpotifyPlus())return Promise.resolve(redirectToSpotify()).then(function(){!0})}();return i&&i.then?i.then(t):t(i)})}}())}var i={};track("loginSuccessHandlerData",e);var n=function(){if(e.registration){localStorage.removeItem("show_slugs"),slateAmplitude.track("Account: Create New",i);var t=e.params.email;return Promise.resolve(getExtendedUserData("RegistrationFields")).then(function(i){function n(){var t;"PIANOID"!==e.source||null!=(t=e.params)&&t.email_confirmation_required||(location.href=getRedirectUrl()||"/account"),r=!0}var c=getCustomFieldValue(i,"marketing_opt_in"),u=function(){if(JSON.parse(c)){var e=function(){return Promise.resolve(executeRecaptcha()).then(function(e){return Promise.resolve(updateSubscriptions({subscribed:["Marketing"]},t,e)).then(function(){})})},r=_catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(loadRecaptcha()).then(function(){})},function(e){console.error("Error loading recaptcha in login-success.js",e)});return r&&r.then?r.then(e):e()}}();return u&&u.then?u.then(n):n()})}}();return n&&n.then?n.then(t):t(n)})}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},membership=require(5),_require=require(55),getCustomFieldValue=_require.getCustomFieldValue,getExtendedUserData=_require.getExtendedUserData,_require2=require(54),updateSubscriptions=_require2.updateSubscriptions,slateAmplitude=require(17),_require3=require(70),getRedirectUrl=_require3.getRedirectUrl,isSpotifyPlus=_require3.isSpotifyPlus,redirectToSpotify=_require3.redirectToSpotify,_require4=require(73),loadRecaptcha=_require4.loadRecaptcha,executeRecaptcha=_require4.executeRecaptcha,_require5=require(74),track=_require5.track;module.exports=loginSuccessHandler; }, {"5":5,"17":17,"54":54,"55":55,"70":70,"73":73,"74":74}]; window.modules["68"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var Cookies=require(38),slateAmplitude=require(17),MAX_ADBLOCKER_DELAY=3e3;exports.getValue=function(){var e=Date.now();return new Promise(function(o){!function t(){var i=Date.now()-e,r=Cookies.get("__adblocker");void 0!==r||i>MAX_ADBLOCKER_DELAY?(o([r&&"true"===r,i]),void 0===r&&isSample()&&trackTiming(e)):setTimeout(t,500)}()})},Cookies.remove("__adblocker");var setNptTechAdblockerCookie=function(e){Cookies.set("__adblocker",!!e)};function d(e){return Math.floor(Math.random()*(e-1+1)+1)}exports.enable=function(){var e=document.createElement("script");e.src="//www.npttech.com/advertising.js",e.addEventListener("error",function(){setNptTechAdblockerCookie(!0)}),document.head.appendChild(e)};var isSample=function(){return 20===d(20)||"#adblockdebug"===location.hash};function trackTiming(e){!function o(){setTimeout(function(){var t=Cookies.get("__adblocker");void 0!==t?slateAmplitude.log("Ad Blocker Timing Sample",{adBlocker:"true"===t,adBlockerDelay:Date.now()-e}):o()},500)}()} }, {"17":17,"38":38}]; window.modules["69"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var profileFrame,sendUserDataToProfileFrame=function(){try{return Promise.resolve(piano.getExtendedUserData("attribution-menu")).then(function(e){profileFrame.source.postMessage({userData:e},profileFrame.origin)})}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},slateAmplitude=require(17),_require=require(71),getMorgioniProps=_require.getMorgioniProps,setMorgioniProps=_require.setMorgioniProps,cookies=require(38),piano=require(55),_require2=require(70),getRedirectUrl=_require2.getRedirectUrl,redirectToSpotify=_require2.redirectToSpotify,_require3=require(72),coordinateHeights=_require3.coordinateHeights;function init(){var e=window.tp;e.experience.init(),e.amplitude=slateAmplitude,e.morgioni={getMorgioniProps:getMorgioniProps,setMorgioniProps:setMorgioniProps},e.injectRunJs=function(e){var i="/piano/scripts/run-js/"+(e=e.replace(/\.js$/,""))+".js";document.querySelector("script[src*='"+i+"']")||slateGlobal.injectScript(i)},e.fireAmplitude=function(i,o){void 0===o&&(o={}),e.morgioni.setMorgioniProps();var r=e.morgioni.getMorgioniProps(),n=Object.assign({},r,o);slateAmplitude.track(i,n)},e.redirectToSpotify=redirectToSpotify,"/sign-in"===location.pathname||0===location.pathname.indexOf("/_pages/ckcwddy7w0000fhnb8lirc5ip")?signInExperience():"/create-account"!==location.pathname&&0!==location.pathname.indexOf("/_pages/ckd7owq8k00hp0mnbelmdx0lm")||createAccountExperience(),e.pianoId.isUserValid()||"/account/podcasts"!==location.pathname||addNoAccessClass(),e.pianoId.init({loggedOut:function(e){[".local.dev.slate.com",".dev.slate.com",".stage.slate.com",".slate.com"].forEach(function(e){["__utp","splus","show_slugs","sp_secure_id","coral_secure_login_token"].forEach(function(i){cookies.remove(i,{domain:e})})})},profileUpdate:function(){sendUserDataToProfileFrame()}})}function addNoAccessClass(){document.body.classList.add("js-podcast-feed--no-access")}function renderScreen(e){window.tp.pianoId.show({displayMode:"inline",screen:e,containerSelector:"#createAccountOrSignIn"})}function signInExperience(){window.tp.pianoId.getUser()?location.href=getRedirectUrl()||"/":renderScreen("login")}function createAccountExperience(){window.tp.pianoId.getUser()?location.href=getRedirectUrl()||"/account":renderScreen("register")}var accountEl=document.querySelector("#account");accountEl&&window.addEventListener("message",function(e){!e.data.profileReady||null===e.origin.match(/\bpiano\.io$/)&&null===e.origin.match(/\btinypass\.com$/)||(profileFrame={source:e.source,origin:e.origin},sendUserDataToProfileFrame())}),coordinateHeights(),module.exports=init; }, {"17":17,"38":38,"55":55,"70":70,"71":71,"72":72}]; window.modules["70"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function _catch(e,t){try{var r=e()}catch(e){return t(e)}return r&&r.then?r.then(void 0,t):r}var getSpotifyFeedUrls=function(){try{var e=function(e){if(t)return e;for(var r=[],o=0;o<n.length;o++)if(n[o].desktop_schemes&&n[o].desktop_schemes.length)for(var i=n[o].desktop_schemes,s=0;s<i.length;s++)"Spotify"===i[s]._name&&r.push(i[s]._url);return r},t=!1,r=document.documentElement.dataset.myslateurl||"https://my.slate.com",o=new URL(r);o.pathname="membership/setup_feeds/";var n,i=o.href,s=_catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(fetch(i,{method:"GET",credentials:"include",headers:{Accept:"application/json"}}).then(function(e){return e.json()})).then(function(e){n=e})},function(e){throw Error("Error getting user feeds from Supporting Cast: "+e)});return Promise.resolve(s&&s.then?s.then(e):e(s))}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},redirectToSpotify=function(e){void 0===e&&(e="/account/podcasts");try{var t=function(e){if(r)return e;location.href=o},r=!1;if(!window.confirm('You\'re about to be redirected to Spotify. Click "OK" to proceed. Click "Cancel" to sign in as another user.'))return window.tp.pianoId.logout(),location.href="/sign-in",Promise.resolve();var o=e,n=_catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(getSpotifyFeedUrls()).then(function(e){if(!e.length)throw new Error("No Spotify feed URLs retrieved from MySlate");o=e[0]})},function(e){console.error(e)});return Promise.resolve(n&&n.then?n.then(t):t(n))}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},_require=require(23),hasParam=_require.hasParam;function isValidOrigin(e){var t=new URL(e).origin;return["spotify.com","slate.com"].some(function(e){return t==="https://"+e||t.endsWith("."+e)})}function getRedirectUrl(){var e=new URL(location.href).searchParams.get("redirect_uri");if(e)return isValidOrigin(e)?e:"/"}function isSpotifyPlus(){return"/spotify-plus"===location.pathname||"/_pages/ckw5hrtr4000pz3m9pdlxohl1.html"===location.pathame||hasParam(location.href,"spotify")}module.exports={getRedirectUrl:getRedirectUrl,isSpotifyPlus:isSpotifyPlus,redirectToSpotify:redirectToSpotify}; }, {"23":23}]; window.modules["71"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var STORAGE_KEY="morgioni",PARAM_NAMES=["utm_medium","utm_campaign","utm_content","utm_source"];function setMorgioniProps(){if(location.search){var o=new URLSearchParams(location.search).get("redirect_uri"),r={};if(o)for(var e=new URLSearchParams(o),t=0,i=Array.from(e);t<i.length;t++){var s=i[t],n=s[0],a=s[1];a&&PARAM_NAMES.includes(n)&&(r[n]=a)}if(Object.keys(r).length>0){var c=Object.assign({},getMorgioniProps(),r);try{localStorage.setItem(STORAGE_KEY,JSON.stringify(c))}catch(o){console.error("failed to store event props",o)}}}}function getMorgioniProps(){try{return JSON.parse(localStorage.getItem(STORAGE_KEY))||void 0}catch(o){console.error("failed to access event props",o)}}function removeMorgioniProps(){localStorage.removeItem(STORAGE_KEY)}module.exports={getMorgioniProps:getMorgioniProps,setMorgioniProps:setMorgioniProps,removeMorgioniProps:removeMorgioniProps}; }, {}]; window.modules["72"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";module.exports.coordinateHeights=function(){var e,t,i=[],a=!1;function n(){i=i.sort(function(e,t){return t.height-e.height}),e=i[0],r(i,e.height)}function r(t,i){t.forEach(function(t){var a={offerCard:!0,isTallest:t.uid===e.uid,height:i,uid:t.uid};t.source.postMessage(a,t.origin)})}window.addEventListener("message",function(s){var u,d;s.data.offerCard&&(s.data.isResize&&i.length?r(i,s.data.height):(t=performance.now(),s.data.source=s.source,s.data.origin=s.origin,i.push(s.data),a||e||(a=!0,u=n,d=setInterval(function(){performance.now()-t>o&&(clearInterval(d),u(d))},o))))});var o=1e3}; }, {}]; window.modules["73"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function loadRecaptcha(){return new Promise(function(e,t){slateGlobal.injectScript("https://www.google.com/recaptcha/api.js?render=6LeXl6gZAAAAADIqQtfiQY8WxxgvnbZIbQV2SjHB",function(t){return function(e,t){t(!0)}(0,e)},function(e){return function(e,t){t(new Error("Error loading script "+e.target.src))}(e,t)})})}function executeRecaptcha(){return new Promise(function(e,t){window.grecaptcha.ready(function(){window.grecaptcha.execute("6LeXl6gZAAAAADIqQtfiQY8WxxgvnbZIbQV2SjHB").then(function(t){e(t)}).catch(function(e){return t(e)})})})}module.exports.loadRecaptcha=loadRecaptcha,module.exports.executeRecaptcha=executeRecaptcha; }, {}]; window.modules["74"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function track(e,t,o,n){if(void 0===o&&(o={}),!e||!e.length)throw new Error("eventName is required. Got "+e);if(e.length>255)throw new Error("eventName must be shorter than 255 characters. Got "+e);var r=new URL(document.location.protocol+"//"+document.location.hostname);if(r.pathname="analytics",r.searchParams.set("eventName",encodeURIComponent(e)),t){if("object"!=typeof t)throw new Error("eventData must be an object. Got "+t);r.searchParams.set("eventData",encodeURIComponent(JSON.stringify(t)))}return n||(n=Function.prototype),fetch(r).then(n)}module.exports.track=track; }, {}]; window.modules["75"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var _require=require(23),toUrl=_require.toUrl,_require2=require(17),afterPageview=_require2.afterPageview,hasParams=location.search.includes("support_journalism");if(hasParams){var thisUrl=toUrl(location.href);thisUrl.searchParams.delete("support_journalism"),thisUrl.searchParams.delete("pay"),history.replaceState(null,"",thisUrl.href)}exports.hasParams=function(){return hasParams},exports.setParams=function(){return Promise.resolve(afterPageview).then(function(){history.replaceState(null,"",toUrl(location.href,{pay:Date.now(),support_journalism:"please"}).href)})}; }, {"17":17,"23":23}]; window.modules["77"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function _catch(e,r){try{var s=e()}catch(e){return r(e)}return s&&s.then?s.then(void 0,r):s}var fetchShowSlugs=function(e){try{var r=toUrl(e);r.pathname="/users/user_podcast_slug/",sessionStorage.getItem(IS_PURCHASING_KEY)&&r.searchParams.set("purchase",!0);var s={method:"GET",credentials:"include",headers:{Accept:"application/json"}};return Promise.resolve(_catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(fetch(r.href,s)).then(function(e){return Promise.resolve(e.json()).then(function(e){return e.slugs})})},function(e){return console.debug("Error fetching user show slugs: "+e),[]}))}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},fetchShowSlugsHash=function(e){try{var r=toUrl(e);r.pathname="/subscriptions/podcast/show-slugs-hash/";var s={method:"GET",credentials:"include",headers:{Accept:"application/json"}};return Promise.resolve(_catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(fetch(r,s)).then(function(e){return Promise.resolve(e.json()).then(function(e){return e.hash})})},function(e){console.debug("Error fetching show slugs hash: "+e)}))}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},_require=require(5),IS_PURCHASING_KEY=_require.IS_PURCHASING_KEY,_require2=require(23),toUrl=_require2.toUrl,STORAGE_SLUGS_KEY="show_slugs";function getShowSlugs(){var e={};try{e=JSON.parse(localStorage.getItem(STORAGE_SLUGS_KEY))||{}}catch(e){console.error("Error getting show_slugs in localStorage",e)}return e}function removeShowSlugs(){try{localStorage.removeItem(STORAGE_SLUGS_KEY)}catch(e){console.error("Error accessing localStorage",e)}return null}function setShowSlugs(e,r){if(void 0===e&&(e=[]),void 0===r&&(r=""),Array.isArray(e)&&r)if(e.length){var s={hash:r,slugs:e};try{localStorage.setItem(STORAGE_SLUGS_KEY,JSON.stringify(s))}catch(e){console.error("Error accessing localStorage",e)}}else console.debug("Slugs array is empty. Not setting anything in storage.");else console.error("Slugs must be an array, hash must be a string. Passed args: slugs: "+e+", hash: "+r)}module.exports={fetchShowSlugsHash:fetchShowSlugsHash,fetchShowSlugs:fetchShowSlugs,getShowSlugs:getShowSlugs,removeShowSlugs:removeShowSlugs,setShowSlugs:setShowSlugs}; }, {"5":5,"23":23}]; window.modules["80"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";module.exports.track=function(e,t,r){try{var a,i=Object.assign({},null==(a=window.slatePermutiveData)?void 0:a.page,t);i.article&&i.article.gsChannels&&delete i.article.gsChannels,window.permutive&&window.permutive.track(e,i,r)}catch(e){console.error("failed to log permutive",e)}}; }, {}]; window.modules["81"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var STORAGE_KEY="promoline-testing",_require=require(23),toUrl=_require.toUrl;function getStorageValuePrefix(e){return toUrl(e).pathname}var storedValue=localStorage.getItem(STORAGE_KEY);if(storedValue){var prefix=getStorageValuePrefix(location.href);storedValue=0===storedValue.indexOf(prefix)?storedValue.slice(prefix.length):"",localStorage.removeItem(STORAGE_KEY)}function storePromoLineVariant(e,r){try{localStorage.setItem(STORAGE_KEY,getStorageValuePrefix(r)+e)}catch(e){console.warn("failed to store promo line testing candidate",e)}}exports.trackExperimentalPromolines=function(e){var r=e.querySelector("[data-promoline-variant]:not([hidden])"),t=null==r?void 0:r.closest("a[href]");if(t){var o=function(e){storePromoLineVariant(r.innerText,t.href)};t.addEventListener("click",o),t.addEventListener("contextmenu",o),t.addEventListener("touchstart",o,{passive:!0})}},exports.retrieveExperimentalPromoline=function(){return storedValue}; }, {"23":23}]; window.modules["83"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.getCurrentBatch=getCurrentBatch;var adService=require("ads.legacy"),_require=require(111),displayForPlus=_require.displayForPlus;function getCurrentBatch(e,r){var t=[];return e.forEach(function(e){e.isIntersecting&&(t.push(e.target),r.unobserve(e.target))}),t.map(createAd).filter(displayForPlus)}function createAd(e){return adService.createAd(e)} }, {"111":111,"ads.legacy":"ads.legacy"}]; window.modules["84"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.isBiddingEnabled=isBiddingEnabled;var _require=require(111),isPlusPage=_require.isPlusPage,biddingEnabled={leaderboard:!0,"leaderboard-tablet":!0,"mid-article-spot-mobile":!0,"mid-article-spot-tablet":!0,"mid-article-spot":!0,"mid-article-spot-xl":!0,"mid-article-box":!0,"mobile-outstream-video":!1,"outstream-video":!1,"outstream-video-xl":!1,"mobile-outstream-video-backfill":!0,"outstream-video-backfill":!0,"outstream-video-xl-backfill":!0,"rr-flex":!0,"rr-article-flex":!0,"mob-adhesion":!0,"hp-mob-mid":!0,"hp-mob-top":!0,"hp-leaderboard-mid":!0,"hp-leaderboard-mid-tablet":!0,"hp-leaderboard-bottom":!0,"hp-leaderboard-bottom-tablet":!0,"hp-native-main":!1,"hp-native-flex":!0,"rr-front-flex":!0,"mobile-front":!0,"rr-podcast":!0,"podcast-headline":!1,"mobile-only-bottom":!0,"leaderboard-mobile":!1,"hp-mob-bottom":!0,"recirc-flex-left":!0,"recirc-flex-right":!0,"recirc-mob":!0};function isBiddingEnabled(e){return!isPlusPage()&&biddingEnabled[e.type]} }, {"111":111}]; window.modules["85"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var _require=require(882),isElementInViewport=_require.isElementInViewport,_require2=require(883),isElementNotHidden=_require2.isElementNotHidden,_throttle=require(91),sticky="ad--sticky-desktop",hide="ad--sticky-hide",time=3e3,leaderboard=document.querySelector(".top-ad"),taboola=document.querySelector(".taboola-recirc"),leaderboardIds=["leaderboard-1","leaderboard-tablet-1"],throttledAvoidTaboola=_throttle(avoidTaboola,200),refresh=!1,isLeaderboardSticky=!1;function avoidTaboola(){isLeaderboardSticky&&isElementNotHidden(taboola)&&(leaderboard.getBoundingClientRect().bottom>taboola.getBoundingClientRect().top&&done(0))}function unstick(e){var t=e.slot.getSlotElementId();leaderboardIds.includes(t)&&isLeaderboardSticky&&setTimeout(function(){leaderboard.classList.add(hide),done(1e3)},time)}function stick(e){var t=e.slot.getSlotElementId();document.querySelector("#"+t);leaderboardIds.includes(t)&&(refresh||(refresh=!0,isLeaderboardSticky=!0,leaderboard.classList.add(sticky),window.addEventListener("scroll",throttledAvoidTaboola)))}function done(e){setTimeout(function(){leaderboard.classList.remove(hide),leaderboard.classList.remove(sticky),isLeaderboardSticky=!1,window.removeEventListener("scroll",throttledAvoidTaboola)},e)}module.exports.enableStickyLeaderboard=function(){window.googletag.cmd.push(function(){var e=googletag.pubads();e.addEventListener("slotOnload",function(e){return stick(e)}),e.addEventListener("impressionViewable",function(e){return unstick(e)})})}; }, {"91":91,"882":882,"883":883}]; window.modules["87"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var visitStart=!1;function isVisitStart(){try{return window.sessionStorage.getItem("visitstarted")||(window.sessionStorage.setItem("visitstarted","1"),visitStart=!0),visitStart}catch(t){console.error(t)}}module.exports.isVisitStart=isVisitStart; }, {}]; window.modules["88"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var STORAGE_KEY="via",DELIMITER="_";function store(e){if(e.length){pageType&&e.unshift(pageType);var t=e.join(DELIMITER);try{sessionStorage.setItem(STORAGE_KEY,t)}catch(e){console.warn("failed to store via",e)}}else sessionStorage.removeItem(STORAGE_KEY)}exports.retrieve=function(){try{var e=sessionStorage.getItem(STORAGE_KEY);return sessionStorage.removeItem(STORAGE_KEY),e}catch(e){console.warn("failed to retrieve via",e)}};var pageType,PREFIXES={article:"article",homepage:"homepage","vertical front":"section","rubric front":"rubric"};function collectVias(e){var t=e.target;if(t.closest("a[href],form[action]")){var a=[];for(t=t.closest("[data-via]");t;)a.push(t.dataset.via),t=t.parentElement.closest("[data-via]");store(a)}}exports.setPageType=function(e){pageType=PREFIXES[e]},document.documentElement.addEventListener("click",collectVias),document.documentElement.addEventListener("submit",collectVias); }, {}]; window.modules["89"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var TWA_PROTOCOL="android-app:",KEY_IS_TWA="isTrustedWebActivity",ANDROID_QUERY_PARAM="android-app",PACKAGE_NAME="com.wapo.slate.android";function isTrustedWebActivity(){var r=document.referrer&&document.referrer.trim()||"";if(0===r.length)return!1;var e=new URL(r);return e.protocol===TWA_PROTOCOL&&(e.hostname===PACKAGE_NAME||0===e.pathname.indexOf("//"+PACKAGE_NAME))}function hasAndroidSearchParam(){return!!location.search&&"1"===new URLSearchParams(location.search).get(ANDROID_QUERY_PARAM)}function isAndroidSession(){if("Y"===sessionStorage.getItem(KEY_IS_TWA))return!0;var r=isTrustedWebActivity()||hasAndroidSearchParam();return r&&sessionStorage.setItem(KEY_IS_TWA,"Y"),r}module.exports.isAndroidSession=isAndroidSession; }, {}]; window.modules["90"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var abStringRe=new RegExp("^([0-9]+)_([0-9]+)$");function parseAbTestString(e){return abStringRe.exec(e)}function isValidAbTestString(e){return!!parseAbTestString(e)}module.exports.parseAbTestString=parseAbTestString,module.exports.isValidAbTestString=isValidAbTestString; }, {}]; window.modules["91"] = [function(require,module,exports){var debounce=require(59),isObject=require(598),FUNC_ERROR_TEXT="Expected a function";function throttle(e,i,t){var n=!0,r=!0;if("function"!=typeof e)throw new TypeError(FUNC_ERROR_TEXT);return isObject(t)&&(n="leading"in t?!!t.leading:n,r="trailing"in t?!!t.trailing:r),debounce(e,i,{leading:n,maxWait:i,trailing:r})}module.exports=throttle; }, {"59":59,"598":598}]; window.modules["92"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var Cookies=require(38),_require=require(87),isVisitStart=_require.isVisitStart,VISIT_COOKIE_NAME="slatevisits",MONTHLY_VISIT_COOKIE_NAME="slatevisitsmon";function cookieSettings(t){var i={domain:document.documentElement.dataset.trackingdomain,secure:!0,SameSite:"Strict"};return t?Object.assign(t,i):i}function setTotalVisits(t){Cookies.set(VISIT_COOKIE_NAME,t,cookieSettings({expires:1825}))}function setMonthlyVisits(t){Cookies.set(MONTHLY_VISIT_COOKIE_NAME,t,cookieSettings({expires:30}))}function getTotalVisits(){return Cookies.get(VISIT_COOKIE_NAME)}function getMonthlyVisits(){return Cookies.get(MONTHLY_VISIT_COOKIE_NAME)}function incrementVisitCookies(){var t=getTotalVisits();setTotalVisits(t=t?parseInt(t)+1:1);var i=Cookies.get(MONTHLY_VISIT_COOKIE_NAME);setMonthlyVisits(i=i?parseInt(i)+1:1)}function getVisitCounts(){return isVisitStart()&&incrementVisitCookies(),{totalVisits:getTotalVisits()||"1",monthlyVisits:getMonthlyVisits()||"1"}}module.exports.getVisitCounts=getVisitCounts; }, {"38":38,"87":87}]; window.modules["93"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var _once=require(94),slateAmplitude=require(17);function cb(e,t){void 0===t&&(t=!1);for(var n=window.webVitals,i=n.onCLS,r=n.onLCP,a=n.onINP,o={},c={CLS:["largestShiftTarget","largestShiftTime","largestShiftValue","largestShiftEntry","largestShiftSource","loadState"],INP:["interactionTarget","interactionTime","interactionType","loadState"],LCP:["element","elementRenderDelay","url","timeToFirstByte","resourceLoadDelay","resourceLoadDuration","lcpResourceEntry"]},l=0,s=[i,r,a];l<s.length;l++){(0,s[l])(function(e){t&&console.debug("%cWeb Vitals: "+e.name,"background-color: mediumSeaGreen; color: white; padding: 2px 4px; border-radius: 2px;",JSON.stringify(e)),o[e.name]=e.value,o[e.name+"_rating"]=e.rating;var n=c[e.name];n&&n.forEach(function(t){o[e.name+"_"+t]=e.attribution[t]}),"INP"===e.name&&"GOOD"!==e.rating&&u(o,e),o.Load_event=d()})}var u=function(e,t){if(t.attribution.longAnimationFrameEntries.length){var n=t.attribution.longAnimationFrameEntries.sort(function(e,t){return t.blockingDuration-e.blockingDuration})[0];if(n.scripts.length){var i=n.scripts.toSorted(function(e,t){return t.duration-e.duration})[0];e[t.name+"_scriptUrl"]=i.sourceURL,e[t.name+"_invoker"]=i.invoker,e[t.name+"_invokerType"]=i.invokerType}}},d=function(){return Math.round(performance.getEntriesByType("navigation")[0].loadEventStart)},g=_once(function(){var t=Object.assign({},o,{version:e});slateAmplitude.track("web_vitals",t)});addEventListener("visibilitychange",function(){"hidden"===document.visibilityState&&g()}),addEventListener("pagehide",g)}module.exports.track=function(e){var t=e.dataset,n=t.version,i=t.webVitalsSampling,r=t.webVitalsUrl,a=function(e,t){slateGlobal.injectScript(r,function(){return cb(e,t)})};"true"!==new URLSearchParams(window.location.search).get("vitals_debug")?Math.random()>parseFloat(i)||a(n):a(n,!0)}; }, {"17":17,"94":94}]; window.modules["94"] = [function(require,module,exports){var before=require(716);function once(e){return before(2,e)}module.exports=once; }, {"716":716}]; window.modules["107"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.getSlotData=getSlotData,exports.saveSlotData=saveSlotData;var allSlotsData={};function saveSlotData(t){allSlotsData[t.id]=t}function getSlotData(t){return allSlotsData[t]} }, {}]; window.modules["108"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";module.exports.sizes={"mid-article-spot":{adserver:[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90],[455,256],[300,250],[300,251],[325,204],[620,366],[1,3]],bidding:[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90],[300,250],[325,204],[620,366]]},"mid-article-spot-xl":{adserver:[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90],[455,256],[300,250],[300,251],[325,204],[620,366]],bidding:[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90],[300,250],[325,204],[620,366]]},"mid-article-spot-tablet":{adserver:[[728,90],[300,250],[455,256],[300,251],[1,3],[325,204],[620,366]],bidding:[[728,90],[300,250],[325,204],[620,366]]},"mid-article-box":{adserver:[[300,250]],bidding:[[300,250]]},"mid-article-spot-mobile":{adserver:[[300,250],[300,251],[1,3],[325,508],[325,204]],bidding:[[300,250],[325,508],[325,204]]},"mobile-only-bottom":{adserver:[[300,250],[1,3]],bidding:[[300,250]]},leaderboard:{adserver:[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90],[1,3]],bidding:[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90]]},"leaderboard-tablet":{adserver:[[728,90],[1,3]],bidding:[[728,90]]},"leaderboard-mobile":{adserver:[[320,100],[320,50]],bidding:[[320,100],[320,50]]},"rr-flex":{adserver:[[300,250],[300,600],[160,600]],bidding:[[300,250],[300,600],[160,600]]},"hp-leaderboard-mid":{adserver:[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90],[1,3]],bidding:[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90]]},"hp-leaderboard-mid-tablet":{adserver:[[728,90],[1,3]],bidding:[[728,90]]},"hp-mob-mid":{adserver:[[300,250],[1,3]],bidding:[[300,250]]},"hp-leaderboard-bottom":{adserver:[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90],[1,3]],bidding:[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90]]},"hp-leaderboard-bottom-tablet":{adserver:[[728,90],[1,3]],bidding:[[728,90]]},"hp-mob-bottom":{adserver:[[300,250],[1,3]],bidding:[[300,250]]},"hp-native-main":{adserver:[[1,2]],bidding:[]},"hp-native-flex":{adserver:[[1,2],[300,250]],bidding:[[300,250]]},"hp-mob-top":{adserver:[[300,250],[1,3]],bidding:[[300,250]]},"rr-front-flex":{adserver:[[300,250],[300,600],[160,600]],bidding:[[300,250],[300,600],[160,600]]},"mobile-front":{adserver:[[300,250],[1,3]],bidding:[[300,250]]},"rr-podcast":{adserver:[[300,250]],bidding:[[300,250]]},"podcast-headline":{adserver:[[1,4]],bidding:[]},"rr-article-flex":{adserver:[[300,250],[300,600],[160,600]],bidding:[[300,250],[300,600],[160,600]]},"mob-adhesion":{adserver:[[320,50]],bidding:[[320,50]]}}; }, {}]; window.modules["109"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function getAdNode(){var e=document.querySelector("div[data-adnode]"),t="";return e&&(t=e.getAttribute("data-adnode")),t}Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.getAdNode=getAdNode; }, {}]; window.modules["110"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var getEmailHashFromMembership=function(){try{var e=getUserEmail();return Promise.resolve(e&&hash(e,"hex"))}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},_require=require(58),hash=_require.hash,_require2=require(5),getUserEmail=_require2.getUserEmail,EMAIL_HASH_PARAMS={sha256:"email",md5:"email2",sha1:"email3"};for(var type in EMAIL_HASH_PARAMS)localStorage.removeItem("email."+type);function getEmailHashesFromUrl(){var e=new URL(document.location).searchParams;return Object.values(EMAIL_HASH_PARAMS).map(function(r){return e.get(r)})}exports.getEmailHashes=function(){try{var e=getEmailHashesFromUrl();return Promise.resolve(getEmailHashFromMembership()).then(function(r){if(r){var t=Object.keys(EMAIL_HASH_PARAMS).indexOf("sha256");e[t]=r}return e.filter(function(e){return!!e})})}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}}; }, {"5":5,"58":58}]; window.modules["111"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.displayForPlus=displayForPlus;var isMember=require(5).isMemberSkipLookup(),slotsToExclude=["mid-article-spot-mobile-2","mid-article-spot-mobile-4","mid-article-spot-tablet-2","mid-article-spot-tablet-4","mid-article-spot-2","mid-article-spot-4","mid-article-spot-xl-2","mid-article-spot-xl-4","mob-adhesion-1"];function displayForPlus(e){return!isMember||!slotsToExclude.includes(e.id)||(hideSlot(e),!1)}function hideSlot(e){document.querySelector("#"+e.id).parentElement.setAttribute("hidden","")}var isPlusPage=function(){var e=document.querySelector(".article");return!!e&&e.classList.contains("article--plus")};module.exports.isPlusPage=isPlusPage; }, {"5":5}]; window.modules["112"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.enableAdRefresh=enableAdRefresh;var _require=require(882),isElementInViewport=_require.isElementInViewport,_require2=require(883),isElementNotHidden=_require2.isElementNotHidden,_require3=require(107),getSlotData=_require3.getSlotData,headerBidding=require("headerbidding.legacy"),adSlotsWithRefresh={};function enableAdRefresh(){window.googletag.pubads().addEventListener("slotRenderEnded",function(e){var t=e.slot,r=t.getSlotElementId(),i=window.document.getElementById(r),n=t.getTargeting("hb_bidder"),d=getSize(e);d&&refreshEnabled(d,r,n)&&!adSlotsWithRefresh[r]&&(updateSlotTargeting(t),addRefreshToSlot(t,getSlotData(r),i),adSlotsWithRefresh[r]=!0)})}function addRefreshToSlot(e,t,r){var i=getRefreshInterval(t);setInterval(function(){adIsInView(r)&&headerBidding.init([t],!0)},i)}function getRefreshInterval(e){return"mob-adhesion-1"===e.id?45e3:3e4}function refreshEnabled(e,t,r){return"1x2"!==e&&"1x3"!==e&&"1x4"!==e&&"300x251"!==e&&!isStickyKargoAd(e,t,r)}function adIsInView(e){return!!window.document.hasFocus()&&(isElementInViewport(e)&&isElementNotHidden(e))}function isStickyKargoAd(e,t,r){return"mob-adhesion-1"===t&&"1x1"===e&&"kargo"===r[0]}function updateSlotTargeting(e){e.clearTargeting("hb_adid"),e.clearTargeting("hb_bidder"),e.clearTargeting("hb_pb"),e.clearTargeting("hb_size"),e.setTargeting("refresh","yes")}var getSize=function(e){return null!==e.size&&("string"==typeof e.size?e.size:e.size[0]+"x"+e.size[1])}; }, {"107":107,"882":882,"883":883,"headerbidding.legacy":"headerbidding.legacy"}]; window.modules["113"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var _require=require(5),getUserEmail=_require.getUserEmail,_require2=require(58),hash=_require2.hash,hashedEmailIncluded=!1;module.exports.zoneIds={leaderboard:"1157134","leaderboard-tablet":"1157133","mid-article-spot-mobile":"1157131","hp-mob-mid":"1157131","hp-mob-top":"1157131","mobile-outstream-video-backfill":"1157131","mobile-only-bottom":"1157131","hp-mob-bottom":"1157131","recirc-mob":"1157131","mid-article-spot-tablet":"1157133","mid-article-spot":"1157134","mid-article-spot-xl":"1157134","outstream-video-backfill":"1157134","outstream-video-xl-backfill":"1157134","mid-article-box":"1157131","hp-native-flex":"1157131","rr-flex":"1157132","rr-article-flex":"1157132","recirc-flex-left":"1157132","recirc-flex-right":"1157132","mobile-front":"1157131","rr-podcast":"1157131","rr-front-flex":"1157132","hp-leaderboard-mid":"1157134","hp-leaderboard-mid-tablet":"1157133","hp-leaderboard-bottom":"1157134","hp-leaderboard-bottom-tablet":"1157133","mob-adhesion":"1362447"},module.exports.syncEmail=function(){try{var e=getUserEmail();return e?Promise.resolve(hash(e,"hex")).then(function(e){e&&(pbjs.que.push(function(){pbjs.setBidderConfig({bidders:["criteo"],config:{ortb2:{user:{ext:{data:{eids:[{source:"slate.com",uids:[{id:e,atype:3,ext:{stype:"hemsha256"}}]}]}}}}}})}),hashedEmailIncluded=!0)}):Promise.resolve()}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},module.exports.hashedEmailIncluded=hashedEmailIncluded; }, {"5":5,"58":58}]; window.modules["114"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var _window$googletag,bqLog=require(74),criteo=require(113),EVENT_NAME="Ads Performance",SAMPLING=.05,eventProperties={};function sendRequest(){bqLog.track(EVENT_NAME,eventProperties),Math.random()<SAMPLING&&window.slateAmplitudeQueue.push(function(e){e.track(EVENT_NAME,eventProperties)})}function getIncrementalValue(e){var t,n=convertToCents(e[0].cpm);1===e.length?t=n:t=n-convertToCents(e[1].cpm);return convertToDollars(t)}function sortBids(e){return e.sort(function(e,t){return e.cpm<t.cpm?1:-1})}function convertToCents(e){return Math.round(100*e)}function convertToDollars(e){return e/100}function roundCpm(e){return Math.round(100*e)/100}function containsLiveRampId(){var e=!1;return pbjs.getUserIds().idl_env&&(e=!0),e}function permutiveSegmentsExist(){var e=window.localStorage.getItem("_pdfps");return null!==e&&e.length>0}module.exports.leaderboardRequest=function(e){eventProperties.timeToLeaderboardRequest=e},module.exports.firstRequest=function(e){eventProperties.timeToFirstAdRequest=e},module.exports.firstAdLoaded=function(e,t){eventProperties.timeToFirstAdLoad=e,eventProperties.campaignId=t,sendRequest()},module.exports.prebidWinner=function(e){var t=sortBids(e),n=t[0];bqLog.track("Prebid Winning Bid",{bidder:n.bidder,cpm:roundCpm(n.cpm),adUnit:n.adUnitCode,incrementalValue:getIncrementalValue(t),liveRampId:containsLiveRampId(),criteoEmail:criteo.hashedEmailIncluded,permutiveSegments:permutiveSegmentsExist()})},module.exports.noPrebidBids=function(e){bqLog.track("Prebid No Bids",{adUnit:e,liveRampId:containsLiveRampId()})};var firstAdLoaded=!1;null==(_window$googletag=window.googletag)||_window$googletag.cmd.push(function(){var e;null==(e=window.googletag)||e.pubads().addEventListener("slotResponseReceived",function(){firstAdLoaded||(bqLog.track("Page View with Ads"),firstAdLoaded=!0)})}); }, {"74":74,"113":113}]; window.modules["115"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.assignTestGroup=assignTestGroup,exports.getTestValue=getTestValue,exports.isBidderEnabled=isBidderEnabled,exports.testGroups=void 0;var tests={},testGroups=exports.testGroups={index:"index_disabled",appnexus:"xandr_disabled",rubicon:"rubicon_disabled",pubmatic:"pubmatic_disabled",openx:"openx_disabled",taboola:"taboola_disabled",criteo:"criteo_disabled",kargo:"kargo_disabled",control:"control"};function assignTestGroup(t){var e=Math.random();tests[t]=e<.1?testGroups.index:e<.2?testGroups.appnexus:e<.3?testGroups.rubicon:e<.4?testGroups.pubmatic:e<.5?testGroups.openx:e<.6?testGroups.taboola:e<.7?testGroups.criteo:e<.8?testGroups.kargo:testGroups.control}function isBidderEnabled(t,e){return tests[t]!==testGroups[e]}function getTestValue(t){return tests[t]} }, {}]; window.modules["116"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function slotSupportsOutstream(t){return["mid-article-spot","mid-article-spot-xl","mid-article-spot-tablet","mid-article-spot-mobile"].includes(t)}Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.slotSupportsOutstream=slotSupportsOutstream; }, {}]; window.modules["117"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.videoSize=exports.oustreamRubrics=exports.displaySizes=void 0;var videoSize=exports.videoSize=[[300,250]],displaySizes=exports.displaySizes={leaderboard:[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90]],"leaderboard-tablet":[[728,90]],"mid-article-spot-mobile":[[300,250]],"hp-mob-mid":[[300,250]],"hp-mob-top":[[300,250]],"mobile-outstream-video-backfill":[[300,250]],"mobile-only-bottom":[[300,250]],"hp-mob-bottom":[[300,250]],"recirc-mob":[[300,250]],"mid-article-spot-tablet":[[728,90],[300,250]],"mid-article-spot":[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90],[300,250]],"mid-article-spot-xl":[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90],[300,250]],"outstream-video-backfill":[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90],[300,250]],"outstream-video-xl-backfill":[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90],[300,250]],"mid-article-box":[[300,250]],"hp-native-flex":[[300,250]],"rr-flex":[[300,250],[300,600],[160,600]],"rr-article-flex":[[300,250],[300,600],[160,600]],"recirc-flex-left":[[300,250],[300,600],[160,600]],"recirc-flex-right":[[300,250],[300,600],[160,600]],"mobile-front":[[300,250]],"rr-podcast":[[300,250]],"rr-front-flex":[[300,250],[300,600],[160,600]],"hp-leaderboard-mid":[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90]],"hp-leaderboard-mid-tablet":[[728,90]],"hp-leaderboard-bottom":[[970,250],[970,90],[728,90]],"hp-leaderboard-bottom-tablet":[[728,90]],"mob-adhesion":[[320,50]]},oustreamRubrics=exports.oustreamRubrics=["culture/books","news_and_politics/jurisprudence","news_and_politics/the_slatest","human_interest/dear_prudence","business/the_media"]; }, {}]; window.modules["118"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.placementIds=void 0;var placementIds=exports.placementIds={"mob-adhesion":"_yB1S81ij3k",leaderboard:"_mn5P4mLiWZ","hp-leaderboard-mid":"_mn5P4mLiWZ","hp-leaderboard-bottom":"_mn5P4mLiWZ","leaderboard-tablet":"_vFXQXj3ivh","hp-leaderboard-mid-tablet":"_vFXQXj3ivh","hp-leaderboard-bottom-tablet":"_vFXQXj3ivh","mid-article-spot-mobile":"_uG77kNNswo","hp-mob-mid":"_uG77kNNswo","hp-mob-top":"_uG77kNNswo","mobile-outstream-video-backfill":"_uG77kNNswo","mobile-only-bottom":"_uG77kNNswo","hp-mob-bottom":"_uG77kNNswo","recirc-mob":"_uG77kNNswo","mobile-front":"_uG77kNNswo","mid-article-spot-tablet":"_phl6yqtyoC","mid-article-spot":"_phl6yqtyoC","mid-article-spot-xl":"_phl6yqtyoC","outstream-video-backfill":"_phl6yqtyoC","outstream-video-xl-backfill":"_phl6yqtyoC","mid-article-box":"_phl6yqtyoC","hp-native-flex":"_phl6yqtyoC","rr-podcast":"_phl6yqtyoC","rr-flex":"_g4BCn63GiZ","rr-article-flex":"_g4BCn63GiZ","recirc-flex-left":"_g4BCn63GiZ","recirc-flex-right":"_g4BCn63GiZ","rr-front-flex":"_g4BCn63GiZ"}; }, {}]; window.modules["119"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.adSlot=adSlot,exports.publisherId=void 0;var publisherId=exports.publisherId="161864";function adSlot(){var e;switch(window.location.href.split("/")[3]){case"news-and-politics":e="4456585";break;case"culture":e="4456584";break;case"technology":e="4456587";break;case"business":e="4456588";break;case"human-interest":e="4456586";break;case"":e="4456582";break;default:e="4456583"}return e} }, {}]; window.modules["120"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.inventoryCodes=void 0;var inventoryCodes=exports.inventoryCodes={leaderboard:"slate_d_leaderboard_pb","leaderboard-tablet":"slate_d_leaderboard_pb","mid-article-spot-mobile":"slate_m_infeedrec_pb","hp-mob-mid":"slate_m_infeedrec_pb","hp-mob-top":"slate_m_infeedrec_pb","mobile-outstream-video-backfill":"slate_m_infeedrec_pb","mobile-only-bottom":"slate_m_infeedrec_pb","hp-mob-bottom":"slate_m_infeedrec_pb","recirc-mob":"slate_m_infeedrec_pb","mob-adhesion":"slate_320x50_hdx_prebid","mid-article-spot-tablet":"slate_d_leaderboard_inline_pb","mid-article-spot":"slate_d_leaderboard_inline_pb","mid-article-spot-xl":"slate_d_leaderboard_inline_pb","outstream-video-backfill":"slate_d_leaderboard_inline_pb","outstream-video-xl-backfill":"slate_d_leaderboard_inline_pb","mid-article-box":"slate_dm_inline_rec_pb","hp-native-flex":"slate_dm_inline_rec_pb","rr-flex":"slate_d_rrail_largerec_pb","rr-article-flex":"slate_d_rrail_largerec_pb","recirc-flex-left":"slate_d_rrail_largerec_pb","recirc-flex-right":"slate_d_rrail_largerec_pb","mobile-front":"Slate_NonArticle_Mobile_Prebid","rr-podcast":"Slate_NonArticle_Mobile_Prebid","rr-front-flex":"Slate_NonArticle_Desktop_Prebid","hp-leaderboard-mid":"Slate_NonArticle_Desktop_Prebid","hp-leaderboard-mid-tablet":"Slate_NonArticle_Desktop_Prebid","hp-leaderboard-bottom":"Slate_NonArticle_Desktop_Prebid","hp-leaderboard-bottom-tablet":"Slate_NonArticle_Desktop_Prebid"}; }, {}]; window.modules["121"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.domain=void 0,exports.getUnit=getUnit;var domain=exports.domain="slate-d.openx.net";function getUnit(){var e;switch(window.location.href.split("/")[3]){case"news-and-politics":e="557570604";break;case"culture":e="557570603";break;case"technology":e="557570606";break;case"business":e="557570607";break;case"human-interest":e="557570605";break;case"":e="557570601";break;default:e="557570602"}return e} }, {}]; window.modules["122"] = [function(require,module,exports){!function(t,e){var i=function(t,e){"use strict";if(!e.getElementsByClassName)return;var i,n,a=e.documentElement,r=t.Date,s=t.HTMLPictureElement,o=t.addEventListener,l=t.setTimeout,d=t.requestAnimationFrame||l,c=t.requestIdleCallback,u=/^picture$/i,f=["load","error","lazyincluded","_lazyloaded"],m={},g=Array.prototype.forEach,z=function(t,e){return m[e]||(m[e]=new RegExp("(\\s|^)"+e+"(\\s|$)")),m[e].test(t.getAttribute("class")||"")&&m[e]},v=function(t,e){z(t,e)||t.setAttribute("class",(t.getAttribute("class")||"").trim()+" "+e)},y=function(t,e){var i;(i=z(t,e))&&t.setAttribute("class",(t.getAttribute("class")||"").replace(i," "))},h=function(t,e,i){var n=i?"addEventListener":"removeEventListener";i&&h(t,e),f.forEach(function(i){t[n](i,e)})},b=function(t,n,a,r,s){var o=e.createEvent("Event");return a||(a={}),a.instance=i,o.initEvent(n,!r,!s),o.detail=a,t.dispatchEvent(o),o},p=function(e,i){var a;!s&&(a=t.picturefill||n.pf)?(i&&i.src&&!e.getAttribute("srcset")&&e.setAttribute("srcset",i.src),a({reevaluate:!0,elements:[e]})):i&&i.src&&(e.src=i.src)},A=function(t,e){return(getComputedStyle(t,null)||{})[e]},C=function(t,e,i){for(i=i||t.offsetWidth;i<n.minSize&&e&&!t._lazysizesWidth;)i=e.offsetWidth,e=e.parentNode;return i},E=(L=[],x=[],W=L,T=function(){var t=W;for(W=L.length?x:L,M=!0,N=!1;t.length;)t.shift()();M=!1},B=function(t,i){M&&!i?t.apply(this,arguments):(W.push(t),N||(N=!0,(e.hidden?l:d)(T)))},B._lsFlush=T,B),_=function(t,e){return e?function(){E(t)}:function(){var e=this,i=arguments;E(function(){t.apply(e,i)})}},w=function(t){var e,i,n=function(){e=null,t()},a=function(){var t=r.now()-i;t<99?l(a,99-t):(c||n)(n)};return function(){i=r.now(),e||(e=l(a,99))}};var M,N,L,x,W,T,B;!function(){var e,i={lazyClass:"lazyload",loadedClass:"lazyloaded",loadingClass:"lazyloading",preloadClass:"lazypreload",errorClass:"lazyerror",autosizesClass:"lazyautosizes",srcAttr:"data-src",srcsetAttr:"data-srcset",sizesAttr:"data-sizes",minSize:40,customMedia:{},init:!0,expFactor:1.5,hFac:.8,loadMode:2,loadHidden:!0,ricTimeout:0,throttleDelay:125};for(e in n=t.lazySizesConfig||t.lazysizesConfig||{},i)e in n||(n[e]=i[e]);t.lazySizesConfig=n,l(function(){n.init&&R()})}();var F=function(){var s,d,f,m,C,M,N,L,x,W,T,B,F,R,k,D,H,O,P,$=/^img$/i,I=/^iframe$/i,q="onscroll"in t&&!/(gle|ing)bot/.test(navigator.userAgent),j=0,G=0,J=-1,K=function(t){G--,(!t||G<0||!t.target)&&(G=0)},Q=function(t){return null==B&&(B="hidden"==A(e.body,"visibility")),B||"hidden"!=A(t.parentNode,"visibility")&&"hidden"!=A(t,"visibility")},U=function(t,i){var n,r=t,s=Q(t);for(L-=i,T+=i,x-=i,W+=i;s&&(r=r.offsetParent)&&r!=e.body&&r!=a;)(s=(A(r,"opacity")||1)>0)&&"visible"!=A(r,"overflow")&&(n=r.getBoundingClientRect(),s=W>n.left&&x<n.right&&T>n.top-1&&L<n.bottom+1);return s},V=function(){var t,r,o,l,c,u,f,g,z,v,y,h,b=i.elements;if((m=n.loadMode)&&G<8&&(t=b.length)){for(r=0,J++,v=!n.expand||n.expand<1?a.clientHeight>500&&a.clientWidth>500?500:370:n.expand,i._defEx=v,y=v*n.expFactor,h=n.hFac,B=null,j<y&&G<1&&J>2&&m>2&&!e.hidden?(j=y,J=0):j=m>1&&J>1&&G<6?v:0;r<t;r++)if(b[r]&&!b[r]._lazyRace)if(q)if((g=b[r].getAttribute("data-expand"))&&(u=1*g)||(u=j),z!==u&&(M=innerWidth+u*h,N=innerHeight+u,f=-1*u,z=u),o=b[r].getBoundingClientRect(),(T=o.bottom)>=f&&(L=o.top)<=N&&(W=o.right)>=f*h&&(x=o.left)<=M&&(T||W||x||L)&&(n.loadHidden||Q(b[r]))&&(d&&G<3&&!g&&(m<3||J<4)||U(b[r],u))){if(nt(b[r]),c=!0,G>9)break}else!c&&d&&!l&&G<4&&J<4&&m>2&&(s[0]||n.preloadAfterLoad)&&(s[0]||!g&&(T||W||x||L||"auto"!=b[r].getAttribute(n.sizesAttr)))&&(l=s[0]||b[r]);else nt(b[r]);l&&!c&&nt(l)}},X=(F=V,k=0,D=n.throttleDelay,H=n.ricTimeout,O=function(){R=!1,k=r.now(),F()},P=c&&H>49?function(){c(O,{timeout:H}),H!==n.ricTimeout&&(H=n.ricTimeout)}:_(function(){l(O)},!0),function(t){var e;(t=!0===t)&&(H=33),R||(R=!0,(e=D-(r.now()-k))<0&&(e=0),t||e<9?P():l(P,e))}),Y=function(t){var e=t.target;e._lazyCache?delete e._lazyCache:(K(t),v(e,n.loadedClass),y(e,n.loadingClass),h(e,tt),b(e,"lazyloaded"))},Z=_(Y),tt=function(t){Z({target:t.target})},et=function(t){var e,i=t.getAttribute(n.srcsetAttr);(e=n.customMedia[t.getAttribute("data-media")||t.getAttribute("media")])&&t.setAttribute("media",e),i&&t.setAttribute("srcset",i)},it=_(function(t,e,i,a,r){var s,o,d,c,m,z;(m=b(t,"lazybeforeunveil",e)).defaultPrevented||(a&&(i?v(t,n.autosizesClass):t.setAttribute("sizes",a)),o=t.getAttribute(n.srcsetAttr),s=t.getAttribute(n.srcAttr),r&&(d=t.parentNode,c=d&&u.test(d.nodeName||"")),z=e.firesLoad||"src"in t&&(o||s||c),m={target:t},v(t,n.loadingClass),z&&(clearTimeout(f),f=l(K,2500),h(t,tt,!0)),c&&g.call(d.getElementsByTagName("source"),et),o?t.setAttribute("srcset",o):s&&!c&&(I.test(t.nodeName)?function(t,e){try{t.contentWindow.location.replace(e)}catch(i){t.src=e}}(t,s):t.src=s),r&&(o||c)&&p(t,{src:s})),t._lazyRace&&delete t._lazyRace,y(t,n.lazyClass),E(function(){var e=t.complete&&t.naturalWidth>1;z&&!e||(e&&v(t,"ls-is-cached"),Y(m),t._lazyCache=!0,l(function(){"_lazyCache"in t&&delete t._lazyCache},9))},!0)}),nt=function(t){var e,i=$.test(t.nodeName),a=i&&(t.getAttribute(n.sizesAttr)||t.getAttribute("sizes")),r="auto"==a;(!r&&d||!i||!t.getAttribute("src")&&!t.srcset||t.complete||z(t,n.errorClass)||!z(t,n.lazyClass))&&(e=b(t,"lazyunveilread").detail,r&&S.updateElem(t,!0,t.offsetWidth),t._lazyRace=!0,G++,it(t,e,r,a,i))},at=function(){if(!d)if(r.now()-C<999)l(at,999);else{var t=w(function(){n.loadMode=3,X()});d=!0,n.loadMode=3,X(),o("scroll",function(){3==n.loadMode&&(n.loadMode=2),t()},!0)}};return{_:function(){C=r.now(),i.elements=e.getElementsByClassName(n.lazyClass),s=e.getElementsByClassName(n.lazyClass+" "+n.preloadClass),o("scroll",X,!0),o("resize",X,!0),t.MutationObserver?new MutationObserver(X).observe(a,{childList:!0,subtree:!0,attributes:!0}):(a.addEventListener("DOMNodeInserted",X,!0),a.addEventListener("DOMAttrModified",X,!0),setInterval(X,999)),o("hashchange",X,!0),["focus","mouseover","click","load","transitionend","animationend","webkitAnimationEnd"].forEach(function(t){e.addEventListener(t,X,!0)}),/d$|^c/.test(e.readyState)?at():(o("load",at),e.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",X),l(at,2e4)),i.elements.length?(V(),E._lsFlush()):X()},checkElems:X,unveil:nt}}(),S=(D=_(function(t,e,i,n){var a,r,s;if(t._lazysizesWidth=n,n+="px",t.setAttribute("sizes",n),u.test(e.nodeName||""))for(a=e.getElementsByTagName("source"),r=0,s=a.length;r<s;r++)a[r].setAttribute("sizes",n);i.detail.dataAttr||p(t,i.detail)}),H=function(t,e,i){var n,a=t.parentNode;a&&(i=C(t,a,i),(n=b(t,"lazybeforesizes",{width:i,dataAttr:!!e})).defaultPrevented||(i=n.detail.width)&&i!==t._lazysizesWidth&&D(t,a,n,i))},O=w(function(){var t,e=k.length;if(e)for(t=0;t<e;t++)H(k[t])}),{_:function(){k=e.getElementsByClassName(n.autosizesClass),o("resize",O)},checkElems:O,updateElem:H}),R=function(){R.i||(R.i=!0,S._(),F._())};var k,D,H,O;return i={cfg:n,autoSizer:S,loader:F,init:R,uP:p,aC:v,rC:y,hC:z,fire:b,gW:C,rAF:E}}(t,t.document);t.lazySizes=i,"object"==typeof module&&module.exports&&(module.exports=i)}(window); }, {}]; window.modules["541"] = [function(require,module,exports){var freeGlobal=require(700),freeSelf="object"==typeof self&&self&&self.Object===Object&&self,root=freeGlobal||freeSelf||Function("return this")();module.exports=root; }, {"700":700}]; window.modules["573"] = [function(require,module,exports){var root=require(541),Symbol=root.Symbol;module.exports=Symbol; }, {"541":541}]; window.modules["598"] = [function(require,module,exports){function isObject(t){var e=typeof t;return null!=t&&("object"==e||"function"==e)}module.exports=isObject; }, {}]; window.modules["614"] = [function(require,module,exports){var Symbol=require(573),getRawTag=require(616),objectToString=require(615),nullTag="[object Null]",undefinedTag="[object Undefined]",symToStringTag=Symbol?Symbol.toStringTag:void 0;function baseGetTag(e){return null==e?void 0===e?undefinedTag:nullTag:symToStringTag&&symToStringTag in Object(e)?getRawTag(e):objectToString(e)}module.exports=baseGetTag; }, {"573":573,"615":615,"616":616}]; window.modules["615"] = [function(require,module,exports){var objectProto=Object.prototype,nativeObjectToString=objectProto.toString;function objectToString(t){return nativeObjectToString.call(t)}module.exports=objectToString; }, {}]; window.modules["616"] = [function(require,module,exports){var Symbol=require(573),objectProto=Object.prototype,hasOwnProperty=objectProto.hasOwnProperty,nativeObjectToString=objectProto.toString,symToStringTag=Symbol?Symbol.toStringTag:void 0;function getRawTag(t){var o=hasOwnProperty.call(t,symToStringTag),r=t[symToStringTag];try{t[symToStringTag]=void 0;var a=!0}catch(t){}var e=nativeObjectToString.call(t);return a&&(o?t[symToStringTag]=r:delete t[symToStringTag]),e}module.exports=getRawTag; }, {"573":573}]; window.modules["623"] = [function(require,module,exports){function isObjectLike(e){return null!=e&&"object"==typeof e}module.exports=isObjectLike; }, {}]; window.modules["673"] = [function(require,module,exports){var baseGetTag=require(614),isObjectLike=require(623),symbolTag="[object Symbol]";function isSymbol(e){return"symbol"==typeof e||isObjectLike(e)&&baseGetTag(e)==symbolTag}module.exports=isSymbol; }, {"614":614,"623":623}]; window.modules["674"] = [function(require,module,exports){var trimmedEndIndex=require(675),reTrimStart=/^\s+/;function baseTrim(e){return e?e.slice(0,trimmedEndIndex(e)+1).replace(reTrimStart,""):e}module.exports=baseTrim; }, {"675":675}]; window.modules["675"] = [function(require,module,exports){var reWhitespace=/\s/;function trimmedEndIndex(e){for(var r=e.length;r--&&reWhitespace.test(e.charAt(r)););return r}module.exports=trimmedEndIndex; }, {}]; window.modules["700"] = [function(require,module,exports){(function (global){(function (){ var freeGlobal="object"==typeof global&&global&&global.Object===Object&&global;module.exports=freeGlobal; }).call(this)}).call(this,typeof global !== "undefined" ? global : typeof self !== "undefined" ? self : typeof window !== "undefined" ? window : {})}, {}]; window.modules["716"] = [function(require,module,exports){var toInteger=require(717),FUNC_ERROR_TEXT="Expected a function";function before(e,r){var t;if("function"!=typeof r)throw new TypeError(FUNC_ERROR_TEXT);return e=toInteger(e),function(){return--e>0&&(t=r.apply(this,arguments)),e<=1&&(r=void 0),t}}module.exports=before; }, {"717":717}]; window.modules["717"] = [function(require,module,exports){var toFinite=require(735);function toInteger(t){var e=toFinite(t),r=e%1;return e==e?r?e-r:e:0}module.exports=toInteger; }, {"735":735}]; window.modules["718"] = [function(require,module,exports){var root=require(541),now=function(){return root.Date.now()};module.exports=now; }, {"541":541}]; window.modules["719"] = [function(require,module,exports){var baseTrim=require(674),isObject=require(598),isSymbol=require(673),NAN=NaN,reIsBadHex=/^[-+]0x[0-9a-f]+$/i,reIsBinary=/^0b[01]+$/i,reIsOctal=/^0o[0-7]+$/i,freeParseInt=parseInt;function toNumber(e){if("number"==typeof e)return e;if(isSymbol(e))return NAN;if(isObject(e)){var r="function"==typeof e.valueOf?e.valueOf():e;e=isObject(r)?r+"":r}if("string"!=typeof e)return 0===e?e:+e;e=baseTrim(e);var t=reIsBinary.test(e);return t||reIsOctal.test(e)?freeParseInt(e.slice(2),t?2:8):reIsBadHex.test(e)?NAN:+e}module.exports=toNumber; }, {"598":598,"673":673,"674":674}]; window.modules["735"] = [function(require,module,exports){var toNumber=require(719),INFINITY=1/0,MAX_INTEGER=1.7976931348623157e308;function toFinite(e){return e?(e=toNumber(e))===INFINITY||e===-INFINITY?(e<0?-1:1)*MAX_INTEGER:e==e?e:0:0===e?e:0}module.exports=toFinite; }, {"719":719}]; window.modules["882"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function isElementInViewport(e){var t=e.getBoundingClientRect();return t.top>=0&&t.left>=0&&t.bottom<=(window.innerHeight||document.documentElement.clientHeight)&&t.right<=(window.innerWidth||document.documentElement.clientWidth)}Object.defineProperty(exports,"__esModule",{value:!0}),exports.isElementInViewport=isElementInViewport; }, {}]; window.modules["883"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function isElementNotHidden(e){return e&&null!==e.offsetParent&&!e.getAttribute("hidden")&&"none"!==getComputedStyle(e).display&&"hidden"!==getComputedStyle(e).visibility}module.exports.isElementNotHidden=isElementNotHidden; }, {}]; window.modules["885"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function _catch(t,e){try{var n=t()}catch(t){return e(t)}return n&&n.then?n.then(void 0,e):n}function _settle(t,e,n){if(!t.s){if(n instanceof _Pact){if(!n.s)return void(n.o=_settle.bind(null,t,e));1&e&&(e=n.s),n=n.v}if(n&&n.then)return void n.then(_settle.bind(null,t,e),_settle.bind(null,t,2));t.s=e,t.v=n;var r=t.o;r&&r(t)}}var _Pact=function(){function t(){}return t.prototype.then=function(e,n){var r=new t,i=this.s;if(i){var o=1&i?e:n;if(o){try{_settle(r,1,o(this.v))}catch(t){_settle(r,2,t)}return r}return this}return this.o=function(t){try{var i=t.v;1&t.s?_settle(r,1,e?e(i):i):n?_settle(r,1,n(i)):_settle(r,2,i)}catch(t){_settle(r,2,t)}},r},t}();function _isSettledPact(t){return t instanceof _Pact&&1&t.s}function _for(t,e,n){for(var r;;){var i=t();if(_isSettledPact(i)&&(i=i.v),!i)return o;if(i.then){r=0;break}var o=n();if(o&&o.then){if(!_isSettledPact(o)){r=1;break}o=o.s}if(e){var s=e();if(s&&s.then&&!_isSettledPact(s)){r=2;break}}}var u=new _Pact,c=_settle.bind(null,u,2);return(0===r?i.then(a):1===r?o.then(h):s.then(f)).then(void 0,c),u;function h(r){o=r;do{if(e&&(s=e())&&s.then&&!_isSettledPact(s))return void s.then(f).then(void 0,c);if(!(i=t())||_isSettledPact(i)&&!i.v)return void _settle(u,1,o);if(i.then)return void i.then(a).then(void 0,c);_isSettledPact(o=n())&&(o=o.v)}while(!o||!o.then);o.then(h).then(void 0,c)}function a(t){t?(o=n())&&o.then?o.then(h).then(void 0,c):h(o):_settle(u,1,o)}function f(){(i=t())?i.then?i.then(a).then(void 0,c):a(i):_settle(u,1,o)}}function checkStatus(t){if(t.status>=200&&t.status<300)return t;var e=new Error(t.statusText);throw e.response=t,e}module.exports.get=function(t,e){return fetch(t,e).then(checkStatus).then(function(t){var e=t.headers.get("content-type");return e.includes("json")?t.json():e.includes("text")?t.text():(console.warn("unable to guess stream reader for response"),t)})},module.exports.retry=function(t,e,n,r){void 0===n&&(n=5),void 0===r&&(r=1e3);try{var i=!1;return Promise.resolve(_for(function(){return!i&&1},void 0,function(){return _catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(t.apply(void 0,e)).then(function(t){return i=!0,t})},function(t){if(!--n)throw t;return Promise.resolve(new Promise(function(t){return setTimeout(t,r)})).then(function(){})})}))}catch(t){return Promise.reject(t)}}; }, {}]; window.modules["slate-ad.client"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var headerBidding=require("headerbidding.legacy"),sticky=require(85),_require=require(83),getCurrentBatch=_require.getCurrentBatch,_require2=require(84),isBiddingEnabled=_require2.isBiddingEnabled;sticky.enableStickyLeaderboard();var requestFromAdServer=function(e){window.googletag.cmd.push(function(){var r=e.map(function(e){return e.defineSlot()});window.googletag.pubads().refresh(r)})},slots=document.querySelectorAll(".slate-ad .slate-ad__creative"),callback=function(e,r){var i=getCurrentBatch(e,r),t=i.filter(isBiddingEnabled),n=i.filter(function(e){return!isBiddingEnabled(e)});t.length&&headerBidding.init(t,!1),n.length&&requestFromAdServer(n)},observer=new IntersectionObserver(callback,{rootMargin:"0px 0px 400px 0px"});slots.forEach(function(e){return observer.observe(e)}); }, {"83":83,"84":84,"85":85,"headerbidding.legacy":"headerbidding.legacy"}]; window.modules["ads.legacy"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var _window$googletag,loadAts=function(){try{var e=membership.getUserEmail();return Promise.resolve(getEmailHashes()).then(function(t){var i=document.createElement("script");i.onload=function(){e&&window.ats.setAdditionalData({type:"email",id:e}),t.length>0&&window.ats.setAdditionalData({type:"emailHashes",id:t})},i.src="https://ats-wrapper.privacymanager.io/ats-modules/f6ed6589-5170-40c6-98bc-a4a49ff26fa8/ats.js",document.body.appendChild(i)})}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},metrics=require(114),refresh=require(112),membership=require(5),criteo=require(113),isMember=membership.isMemberSkipLookup(),_require=require(109),getAdNode=_require.getAdNode,_require2=require(110),getEmailHashes=_require2.getEmailHashes,_require3=require(108),sizes=_require3.sizes,_require4=require(107),saveSlotData=_require4.saveSlotData,_require5=require(111),isPlusPage=_require5.isPlusPage,adIndex={},testParam=getTestParam(),pageId=getPageId(),firstRequest=!0;function getTestParam(){var e=/[?&]test_ads=([^&#?]+)/.exec(window.location.search);return e?e[1]:""}function requestAd(e){e.defineSlot(),googletag.pubads().refresh([e.gptSlot],{changeCorrelator:!1})}function createAd(e){var t=e.getAttribute("data-type"),i=e.getAttribute("data-zone-id"),a=e.getAttribute("data-placement-id"),r=e.getAttribute("data-criteo-id"),s=e.getAttribute("data-site-id"),o=parseInt(e.getAttribute("data-ll-threshold"));return adIndex[t]||(adIndex[t]=1),e.id=t+"-"+adIndex[t],adIndex[t]++,{id:e.id,type:t,adUnit:getAdUnit(),gpid:getAdNode()+"/"+e.id,dfpSizes:sizes[t].adserver,prebidSizes:sizes[t].bidding,rubiconZoneId:i,appnexusPlacementId:a,criteoZoneId:r,indexSiteId:s,threshold:o,gptSlot:null,defineSlot:function(){this.gptSlot=window.googletag.defineSlot(this.adUnit,this.dfpSizes,this.id),saveSlotData(this),this.gptSlot.addService(window.googletag.pubads()),this.gptSlot.setTargeting("refresh","no"),this.gptSlot.setTargeting("pos",this.id),this.gptSlot.setTargeting("threshold",this.threshold);return["mid-article-spot","mid-article-spot-tablet","mid-article-spot-mobile","mid-article-spot-xl","outstream-video","mobile-outstream-video","outstream-video-xl"].includes(this.type)?this.gptSlot.setTargeting("outstream_eligible","true"):this.gptSlot.setTargeting("outstream_eligible","false"),window.googletag.display(this.id),this.gptSlot}}}function getAdUnit(){return"91898098/slate.com/"+getAdNode()}function getPageId(){return window.document.documentElement.getAttribute("data-uri").split("/")[2].replace("@published","")}loadAts(),criteo.syncEmail(),null==(_window$googletag=window.googletag)||_window$googletag.cmd.push(function(){var e=document.querySelector(".js-analytics-js-data").getAttribute("data-pagetype").replace(" ","-");window.googletag.pubads().disableInitialLoad(),window.googletag.pubads().enableSingleRequest(),window.googletag.enableServices();var t=Math.floor(1e13*Math.random()),i=document.querySelectorAll('meta[name="dfp-cache-buster"]')[0];i&&i.content&&(t=i.content),window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("dfp_cache_buster",t).setTargeting("page_id",pageId).setTargeting("page_type",e).setTargeting("plus_page",isPlusPage().toString());document.cookie.match(/usprivacy=\d+[YN]Y/)&&window.googletag.pubads().setRequestNonPersonalizedAds(1),testParam&&window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("kw","test_"+testParam);var a=document.cookie.match(/AB=(\d+_\d+)/);a&&a.length>1&&window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("ab_var",a[1]);var r=document.querySelector(".article__right-rail"),s=window.innerWidth>=1440;r&&s?window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("article_right_rail","true"):window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("article_right_rail","false"),window.googletag.pubads().addEventListener("slotOnload",function(e){if(firstRequest){var t=Math.round(performance.now()),i=e.slot.getResponseInformation();metrics.firstAdLoaded(t,i.campaignId),firstRequest=!1}}),isMember&&window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("segs","plus"),refresh.enableAdRefresh()}),module.exports.createAd=createAd,module.exports.requestAd=requestAd; }, {"5":5,"107":107,"108":108,"109":109,"110":110,"111":111,"112":112,"113":113,"114":114}]; window.modules["headerbidding.legacy"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var adData,triplelift=require(120),amazon=require(117),pubmatic=require(119),kargo=require(118),criteo=require(113),openx=require(121),metrics=require(114),prebidTest=require(115),_require=require(109),getAdNode=_require.getAdNode,_require2=require(116),slotSupportsOutstream=_require2.slotSupportsOutstream,HARD_TIMEOUT=2500;function init(e,i){(adData=e).isRefreshing=i,adData.biddersManager={adserverRequestSent:!1,prebid:!1,amazon:!1},window.slateCMP.TCF.ready.then(function(e){requestBidsFromExchanges()}),setTimeout(function(){googletag.cmd.push(function(){defineGptSlot(adData),callAdServer(adData)})},HARD_TIMEOUT)}function requestBidsFromExchanges(){getBidsFromPrebidExchanges(),getBidsFromAmazon()}function getBidsFromPrebidExchanges(){var e=[],i=[];adData.forEach(function(t){e.push(createPrebidAdUnit(t)),i.push(t.id)}),pbjs.que.push(function(){pbjs.addAdUnits(e);var t=adData;pbjs.requestBids({adUnitCodes:i,bidsBackHandler:function(){googletag.cmd.push(function(){pbjs.que.push(function(){t.forEach(function(e){var i=pbjs.getBidResponsesForAdUnitCode(e.id).bids;i.length?metrics.prebidWinner(i):metrics.noPrebidBids(e.id)}),defineGptSlot(t),t.forEach(function(e){e.gptSlot.setTargeting("hb_test",prebidTest.getTestValue(e.id))}),pbjs.setTargetingForGPTAsync(e.map(function(e){return e.code})),t.forEach(function(e){return pbjs.removeAdUnit(e.id)}),t.biddersManager.prebid=!0,bidderFinished(t)})})}})})}function getBidsFromAmazon(){var e=document.querySelector("#amazon-aps"),i=[];adData.forEach(function(e){return i.push(createApsAdUnit(e))});var t=adData;apstag&&apstag.fetchBids({slots:i,timeout:e.bidderTimeout},function(e){googletag.cmd.push(function(){defineGptSlot(t),apstag.setDisplayBids(),t.biddersManager.amazon=!0,bidderFinished(t)})})}function bidderFinished(e){e.biddersManager.amazon&&e.biddersManager.prebid&&callAdServer(e)}function callAdServer(e){if(!e.biddersManager.adserverRequestSent){e.biddersManager.adserverRequestSent=!0;var i=[];e.forEach(function(e){return i.push(e.gptSlot)}),googletag.cmd.push(function(){googletag.pubads().refresh(i,{changeCorrelator:!1})})}}function defineGptSlot(e){e.forEach(function(e){e.gptSlot||e.defineSlot()})}function createPrebidAdUnit(e){var i={sizes:e.prebidSizes};return{code:e.id,ortb2Imp:{ext:{gpid:e.gpid,data:{pbadslot:e.gpid}}},mediaTypes:{banner:i},bids:getBidders(e)}}function getBidders(e){var i=[];if(prebidTest.assignTestGroup(e.id),prebidTest.isBidderEnabled(e.id,"appnexus")&&i.push(appnexus(e)),prebidTest.isBidderEnabled(e.id,"rubicon")&&i.push(rubicon(e)),prebidTest.isBidderEnabled(e.id,"openx")&&i.push(openxBidder()),prebidTest.isBidderEnabled(e.id,"pubmatic")&&i.push(pubmaticBidder()),prebidTest.isBidderEnabled(e.id,"index"))for(var t=0;t<e.prebidSizes.length;t++){var r=index(e.prebidSizes[t],e);i.push(r)}(prebidTest.isBidderEnabled(e.id,"taboola")&&i.push(taboola(e)),triplelift.inventoryCodes[e.type]&&i.push(tripleliftBidder(e)),isConcertAdAllowed(e.type)&&i.push(concert(e)),kargo.placementIds[e.type]&&prebidTest.isBidderEnabled(e.id,"kargo"))&&("mob-adhesion"===e.type&&adData.isRefreshing||i.push(kargoBidder(e)));return criteo.zoneIds[e.type]&&prebidTest.isBidderEnabled(e.id,"criteo")&&i.push(criteoBidder()),i.push(ttd(e)),isTeadsAllowed(e.type)&&i.push(teads()),i}function createApsAdUnit(e){var i={};"mob-adhesion"===e.type&&(i.ggProduct="inScreen");var t={slotID:e.id,slotName:e.adUnit};return amazon.oustreamRubrics.includes(getAdNode())&&slotSupportsOutstream(e.type)?(t.mediaType="multi-format",t.multiFormatProperties={display:{sizes:amazon.displaySizes[e.type]},video:{sizes:amazon.videoSize}}):(t.sizes=amazon.displaySizes[e.type],t.slotParams=i),t}function appnexus(e){return{bidder:"appnexusAst",params:{placementId:e.appnexusPlacementId}}}function rubicon(e){return{bidder:"rubicon",params:{accountId:"13590",siteId:"60302",zoneId:e.rubiconZoneId}}}function criteoBidder(){return{bidder:"criteo",params:{networkId:"7462"}}}function index(e,i){return{bidder:"ix",params:{siteId:i.indexSiteId,size:e}}}function kargoBidder(e){return{bidder:"kargo",params:{placementId:kargo.placementIds[e.type]}}}function tripleliftBidder(e){return{bidder:"triplelift",params:{inventoryCode:triplelift.inventoryCodes[e.type]}}}function concert(e){return{bidder:"concert",params:{partnerId:"slate",site:"slate.com",placementId:e.id,slot:e.type}}}function pubmaticBidder(){return{bidder:"pubmatic",params:{publisherId:pubmatic.publisherId,adSlot:pubmatic.adSlot()}}}function openxBidder(){return{bidder:"openx",params:{delDomain:openx.domain,unit:openx.getUnit()}}}function ttd(){return{bidder:"ttd",params:{supplySourceId:"slate",publisherId:"1"}}}function teads(){return{bidder:"teads",params:{pageId:"166966",placementId:"181798"}}}function taboola(e){return{bidder:"taboola",params:{tagId:e.id,publisherId:"1719911"}}}function isConcertAdAllowed(e){return"mid-article-spot"===e||"mid-article-spot-xl"===e||"mid-article-spot-tablet"===e||"mid-article-spot-mobile"===e}function isTeadsAllowed(e){return"mid-article-spot"===e||"mid-article-spot-xl"===e||"mid-article-spot-tablet"===e||"mid-article-spot-mobile"===e}module.exports.init=init; }, {"109":109,"113":113,"114":114,"115":115,"116":116,"117":117,"118":118,"119":119,"120":120,"121":121}]; window.modules["analytics-js-loader.client"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var initCriteo=require(3),initParsely=require(4);module.exports=function(e){void 0===e.dataset.disableClientJs&&(!function(e,t){var n=e.amplitude||{_q:[],_iq:{}};if(n.invoked)e.console&&console.error&&console.error("Amplitude snippet has been loaded.");else{var i=function(e,t){e.prototype[t]=function(){return this._q.push({name:t,args:Array.prototype.slice.call(arguments,0)}),this}},r=function(e,t,n){return function(i){e._q.push({name:t,args:Array.prototype.slice.call(n,0),resolve:i})}},o=function(e,t,n){e[t]=function(){if(n)return{promise:new Promise(r(e,t,Array.prototype.slice.call(arguments)))};!function(e,t,n){e._q.push({name:t,args:Array.prototype.slice.call(n,0)})}(e,t,Array.prototype.slice.call(arguments))}},a=function(e){for(var t=0;t<f.length;t++)o(e,f[t],!1);for(var n=0;n<m.length;n++)o(e,m[n],!0)};n.invoked=!0;var s=t.createElement("script");s.type="text/javascript",s.integrity="sha384-Dv01ylQWH3OMRpOnXgNXTEJypJSg/Si512H2KxfFik12c676LxjHoC1W2pF8xyR5",s.crossOrigin="anonymous",s.async=!0,s.src="https://cdn.amplitude.com/libs/analytics-browser-2.6.0-min.js.gz",s.onload=function(){e.amplitude.runQueuedFunctions||console.log("[Amplitude] Error: could not load SDK")};var d=t.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];d.parentNode.insertBefore(s,d);for(var u=function(){return this._q=[],this},c=["add","append","clearAll","prepend","set","setOnce","unset","preInsert","postInsert","remove","getUserProperties"],l=0;l<c.length;l++)i(u,c[l]);n.Identify=u;for(var p=function(){return this._q=[],this},g=["getEventProperties","setProductId","setQuantity","setPrice","setRevenue","setRevenueType","setEventProperties"],w=0;w<g.length;w++)i(p,g[w]);n.Revenue=p;var f=["getDeviceId","setDeviceId","getSessionId","setSessionId","getUserId","setUserId","setOptOut","setTransport","reset","extendSession"],m=["init","add","remove","track","logEvent","identify","groupIdentify","setGroup","revenue","flush"];a(n),n.createInstance=function(e){return n._iq[e]={_q:[]},a(n._iq[e]),n._iq[e]},e.amplitude=n}}(window,document),window.nonIabVendorApi.registerVendor("amplitude",{categories:["C0002"],initFunc:function(t){var n,i=e.dataset.amplitudeApiKey;try{n=window.amplitude.Types.LogLevel[e.dataset.amplitudeLogLevel]}catch(t){n={0:"None",1:"Error",2:"Warn",3:"Verbose",4:"Debug",None:0,Error:1,Warn:2,Verbose:3,Debug:4}[e.dataset.amplitudeLogLevel]}var r={logLevel:n,domain:e.dataset.amplitudeDomain,defaultTracking:{pageViews:!1}};return window.amplitude.init(i,null,r).promise.then(function(){window.slateAmplitudeQueue.init(window.amplitude,t)}),!0},updateConsentFunc:function(e){window.slateAmplitudeQueue.push(function(t){t.setOptOut(!e)})}}),initParsely(e.dataset.parselyScriptSrc),window.nonIabVendorApi.registerVendor("fbPixel",{categories:["C0002","C0003","C0004"],initFunc:function(e){return window.fbq("consent",e?"grant":"revoke"),window.fbq("set","autoConfig",!1,"166975463695820"),window.fbq("dataProcessingOptions",["LDU"]),window.fbq("init","166975463695820"),window.fbq("track","PageView"),!0},updateConsentFunc:function(e){window.fbq("consent",e?"grant":"revoke")}}),window.nonIabVendorApi.registerVendor("google-tag-manager-marketing",{categories:["C0002","C0004","gad"],initFunc:function(e){if(!e)return!1;var t=document.createElement("script");t.src="//www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=AW-794295919";var n=document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];function i(){window.dataLayer.push(arguments)}return n.parentNode.insertBefore(t,n),window.dataLayer=window.dataLayer||[],i("js",new Date),i("config","AW-794295919",{allow_enhanced_conversions:!0}),window.gtag=i,!0},updateConsentFunc:function(e){e?window.gtag||window.nonIabVendorApi.vendors["google-tag-manager-marketing"].initFunc(e):window.gtag=void 0}}),initCriteo())}; }, {"3":3,"4":4}]; window.modules["slate-ad-aps.client"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var syncEmailWithAps=function(){try{var e=membership.getUserEmail();return e?Promise.resolve(hash(e,"hex")).then(function(e){e&&(null==window.apstag.rpa||window.apstag.rpa({hashedRecords:[{type:"email",record:e}]}))}):Promise.resolve()}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},membership=require(5),_require=require(58),hash=_require.hash;try{window.__uspapi("getUSPData",1,function(e,r){var t={si_section:getApsSection()};r&&(t.us_privacy=e.uspString),window.slateCMP.TCF.ready.then(function(){window.apstag&&window.apstag.init({pubID:"3075",adServer:"googletag",params:t,deals:!0,gdpr:{cmpTimeout:200}}),syncEmailWithAps()})})}catch(e){console.warn("__uspapi failed",e)}function getApsSection(){var e=document.querySelector("div[data-adnode]"),r="";return e&&(r=e.getAttribute("data-adnode")),r.replace("/"," ").replace(/_/g," ")} }, {"5":5,"58":58}]; window.modules["global-footer.client"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var onboarding=require(40);module.exports=function(i){onboarding.init()}; }, {"40":40}]; window.modules["piano-mount.client"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var _debounce=require(59),_require=require(48),allowedOrigins=_require.allowedOrigins;function eventAllowed(e){return-1!==allowedOrigins.indexOf(e.origin)&&e.data.slate}function waitForPiano(e){e.classList.add("piano-mount--loading");var n=function(e){eventAllowed(e)&&i()},i=_debounce(function(){e.classList.remove("piano-mount--loading","piano-mount--error"),window.removeEventListener("message",n),clearTimeout(o)},200);window.addEventListener("message",n);var o=setTimeout(function(){e.classList.remove("piano-mount--loading"),e.classList.add("piano-mount--error")},3e4)}module.exports=function(e){waitForPiano(e)}; }, {"48":48,"59":59}]; window.modules["masthead.client"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var menu,membership=require(5),dropdown=require(47),initializeThemePicker=require(49),_require=require(48),allowedOrigins=_require.allowedOrigins;function toggleMenu(e){(menu=menu||e.target.closest(".menu")).classList.toggle("menu--open"),document.documentElement.classList.toggle("menu-open",menu.classList.contains("menu--open"))}function addRedirectParam(e){var r=new URL(location.href).searchParams.get("redirect_uri"),t=new URL(e.currentTarget.href),n=r||location.href;t.searchParams.set("redirect_uri",n),e.currentTarget.href=t.toString()}function injectPianoVariables(e,r){var t,n=r.desktopMastheadText,i=r.desktopMastheadUrl,a=r.mobileMastheadText,o=r.mobileMastheadUrl,s=r.iconUrl;(t=e.querySelector(".js-account--subscribe"))&&(t.hidden=!1),(t=e.querySelector("[data-piano-href='desktopMastheadUrl']"))&&(t.href=i),(t=e.querySelector("[data-piano-href='mobileMastheadUrl']"))&&(t.href=o),(t=e.querySelector("[data-piano-html='desktopMastheadText']"))&&t.insertAdjacentHTML("beforeend","<span>"+n+"</span>"),(t=e.querySelector("[data-piano-icon-href='iconUrl']"))&&t.setAttribute("href",s),(t=e.querySelector("[data-piano-html='mobileMastheadText']"))&&(t.textContent=a)}function getVisibleSelectors(){return{signedOut:["mobile-subscribe","sign-in"],signedIn:["mobile-subscribe","account","sign-out"]}[membership.isLoggedIn()?"signedIn":"signedOut"]}function eventAllowed(e){return-1!==allowedOrigins.indexOf(e.origin)&&e.data.slate}module.exports=function(e){for(var r=getVisibleSelectors(),t=0;t<r.length;t++){var n=".js-account--"+r[t];document.querySelectorAll(n).forEach(function(e){return e.hidden=!1})}e.querySelectorAll(".js-toggle-menu").forEach(function(e){e.addEventListener("click",toggleMenu)}),e.querySelectorAll(".js-redirect-return").forEach(function(e){e.addEventListener("click",addRedirectParam)}),dropdown(e),initializeThemePicker(e);window.addEventListener("pianoResponseVariables",function r(t){var n=t.detail.responseVariables;n.masthead&&(injectPianoVariables(e,n),window.removeEventListener("pianoResponseVariables",r))}),window.addEventListener("message",function(e){if(eventAllowed(e)&&"redirect"===e.data.type){var r=e.data.path,t=document.location.href,n=new URL(r,window.location.origin);n.searchParams.append("redirect_uri",t),window.location.href=n}})}; }, {"5":5,"47":47,"48":48,"49":49}]; window.modules["slate-analytics-js.client"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function _catch(e,t){try{var i=e()}catch(e){return t(e)}return i&&i.then?i.then(void 0,t):i}var logUserProperties=function(e){try{var t={};return setABUserProp(t),Promise.resolve(setMemberStatusUserProp(t)).then(function(){setUserLoginId(t),setAndroidAppUserProp(t);var i=new e.Identify;for(var r in t)i.set(r,t[r]);return e.identify(i)})}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},setMemberStatusUserProp=function(e){return Promise.resolve(getUserMembershipType()).then(function(t){t&&(e.plan=t)})},logPageView=function(e,t){try{var i=slateAmplitude.getDomEventData(t),r=new URLSearchParams(location.search),o=via.retrieve();return o&&r.set("via",o),i.search="?"+r.toString(),i.amplitude_id=e.getDeviceId()?e.getDeviceId():"no options - no deviceId",i.farejumper=castAsAmplitudeBool(supportJournalism.hasParams()),i.viewportWidth=document.documentElement.clientWidth,i.layoutBreakpoint=getLayoutBreakpoint(i.viewportWidth),i.colorScheme=localStorage.getItem("theme"),i.androidApp=castAsAmplitudeBool(isAndroidSession()),Promise.resolve(getUserMembershipType()).then(function(e){i.plan=e,loginId&&(i.signed_in_uuid=loginId),i.chumbox_loaded=castAsAmplitudeBool(isChumBoxLoaded()),i.taboola_eligible=castAsAmplitudeBool(isTaboolaEligible()),i.visitstart=castAsAmplitudeBool(isVisitStart());var t=getVisitCounts();return i.Nth_visit=t.totalVisits,i.Nth_monthly_visit=t.monthlyVisits,Promise.resolve(adblockDetection.getValue()).then(function(t){var r=t[0],o=t[1];i.adBlocker="boolean"==typeof r?castAsAmplitudeBool(r):"UNKNOWN",i.adBlockerDelay=o,getAffiliateLinks().length>0&&(i["Affiliate Link"]="✅"),findComponent("product")&&(i["Product Component"]="✅");var n=findComponent("newsletter-signup");i["Includes Newsletter Signup"]=castAsAmplitudeBool(n),n&&(i["Newsletter Signup Placement"]="In Content");var s=findComponent("slate-plus-button");if(s){var a=s.querySelector(".slate-plus-button__basic");a&&(i["Slate Plus Button Component"]=a.innerText)}var l=!e&&findComponent("slate-roadblock");i["Includes Slate Plus Roadblock"]=castAsAmplitudeBool(l),findComponent("header-promo")&&(i["Includes Header Promo"]="TRUE"),i.referrer=document.referrer;var u=promolineTesting.retrieveExperimentalPromoline();u&&(i.experimental_promoline=u),slateAmplitude.page(i)})})}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},getUserMembershipType=function(){try{var e,t=function(){if(e){var t=membership.getMembershipType(),i=_catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(getExtendedUserData("MyAccountFields")).then(function(e){getCustomFieldValue(e,"is_staff")&&(t+="|staff")})},function(){console.error("Error getting extended User data")});return i&&i.then?i.then(function(){return t}):t}},i=_catch(function(){return Promise.resolve(membership.isMember()).then(function(t){e=t})},function(){console.error("Failure to get isMember")});return Promise.resolve(i&&i.then?i.then(t):t())}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},_once=require(94),_throttle=require(91),Cookies=require(38),via=require(88),_require=require(87),isVisitStart=_require.isVisitStart,_require2=require(92),getVisitCounts=_require2.getVisitCounts,slateAmplitude=require(17),slatePermutive=require(80),_require3=require(89),isAndroidSession=_require3.isAndroidSession,_require4=require(55),getExtendedUserData=_require4.getExtendedUserData,getCustomFieldValue=_require4.getCustomFieldValue,membership=require(5),adblockDetection=require(68),promolineTesting=require(81),_require5=require(90),isValidAbTestString=_require5.isValidAbTestString,supportJournalism=require(75),webVitals=require(93),loginId=membership.getLoginId();function castAsAmplitudeBool(e){return e?"TRUE":"FALSE"}function isTaboolaLoaded(){return isTaboolaEligible()&&void 0!==window._taboola.registered}function isTaboolaEligible(){return void 0!==window._taboola}var getAffiliateLinks=_once(function(){for(var e=[],t=document.body.querySelectorAll('a[href*="amazon"]'),i=0;i<t.length;i++){var r=t[i];-1===new URL(r.href).host.indexOf("amazon")||r.matches(".product a")||e.push(r)}return e});function isChumBoxLoaded(){return isTaboolaLoaded()||!!document.querySelector(".outbrain-widget")}function trackAffiliateLinks(){getAffiliateLinks().forEach(function(e){e.addEventListener("click",function(e){slateAmplitude.track("Click - Affiliate Link")})})}function findComponent(e){var t=document.body.querySelector("."+e);if(t){var i=t.dataset.uri;if(i&&i.split("/")[2]===e)return t}}function getLayoutBreakpoint(e){for(var t=[["sm",320],["md",768],["lg",1024],["xl",1440]],i=t.length;i--;)if(e>=t[i][1])return t[i][0];return t[0][0]}function setUserLoginId(e){loginId&&(e.signed_in_uuid=loginId)}function setABUserProp(e){var t=Cookies.get("AB");e.abTest=isValidAbTestString(t)?t:"0"}function setAndroidAppUserProp(e){var t=isAndroidSession();t&&(e.androidUser=t)}function trackEndOfArticle(){var e=document.querySelector(".slate-paragraph--tombstone");if(e){var t=_once(function(){slateAmplitude.track("Completed article"),slatePermutive.track("ArticleCompletion"),document.removeEventListener("scroll",i)}),i=_throttle(function(){var i,r="scrollY"in window?window.scrollY:window.pageYOffset;!("none"===(null==(i=getComputedStyle(null==e?void 0:e.parentElement))?void 0:i.display))&&e.offsetTop+e.offsetHeight<=r+window.innerHeight&&t()},300);document.addEventListener("scroll",i)}}module.exports=function(e){window.slateAmplitudeQueue.push(function(t){trackAffiliateLinks(),trackEndOfArticle(),webVitals.track(e),logPageView(t,e),logUserProperties(t),via.setPageType(e.dataset.pagetype)})}; }, {"5":5,"17":17,"38":38,"55":55,"68":68,"75":75,"80":80,"81":81,"87":87,"88":88,"89":89,"90":90,"91":91,"92":92,"93":93,"94":94}]; window.modules["social-share.client"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var _require=require(31),setupSocialShareComponentButtons=_require.setupSocialShareComponentButtons;module.exports=function(e){try{var r=e.querySelectorAll(".js-share-link"),t=e.querySelector(".js-web-share-link");return setupSocialShareComponentButtons("social-share",t,r),Promise.resolve()}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}}; }, {"31":31}]; window.modules["permutive.client"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var _require=require(55),getPianoId=_require.getPianoId,_require2=require(58),hash=_require2.hash,membership=require(5);module.exports=function(e){var t=function(t){try{if(!t)throw new Error("Consent not provided for permutive");permutive.consent({opt_in:t,token:r}),permutive.addon("web",window.slatePermutiveData);var n={Slate_Plus_All_Access:"All Access",Slate_Plus_Audio:"Audio",Slate_Plus_Digital:"Digital",Big_Mood_Plus:"Audio"};return Promise.resolve(membership.isMember()).then(function(t){if(t){for(var r,u=membership.getSplusCookie(),a=Object.keys(n),o=u.resourceIds||[],s=0;s<o.length;s++){var c=o[s];if(a.includes(c)){r=n[c];break}}r&&i("slatePlusSubscriptionType",r)}var m=document.createElement("script");m.src="//cdn.permutive.com/"+e.dataset.permutiveProjectId+"-web.js",m.defer=!0;var d=document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];return d.parentNode.insertBefore(m,d),!0})}catch(e){return Promise.reject(e)}},r="slate-token";function i(e,t){window.slatePermutiveData.page.user||(window.slatePermutiveData.page.user={}),window.slatePermutiveData.page.user[e]=t}window.nonIabVendorApi.registerVendor("permutive",{categories:["C0002","C0003","C0004"],initFunc:function(r){if(!r)return!1;function n(e){var t=document.cookie.match("(^|[^;]+)\\s*"+e+"\\s*=\\s*([^;]+)");return t?t.pop():""}try{var u=new URL(document.location).searchParams;u.get("utm_source")&&(window.slatePermutiveData.page.utmSource=u.get("utm_source")),u.get("utm_medium")&&(window.slatePermutiveData.page.utmMedium=u.get("utm_medium")),u.get("utm_campaign")&&(window.slatePermutiveData.page.utmCampaign=u.get("utm_campaign"))}catch(e){console.error(e)}if(e.dataset.isSplusUser)try{i("slatePlus",!0)}catch(e){console.error(e)}var a=[];function o(e,t){t&&(a.push({tag:e,id:t}),i(e,t))}o("slateId",getPianoId()||n("wapo_login_id")),o("publisherUserId",n("slate-uuid")),o("sailthruId",function(e){try{return new URL(document.location).searchParams.get(e)}catch(t){console.error("could not get "+e+" url param",t)}}("sid"));var s=membership.getUserEmail();return s?hash(s,"hex").then(function(e){e&&(a.push({tag:"email_sha256",id:e}),a.length>0&&window.permutive.identify(a),t(r))}):(a.length>0&&window.permutive.identify(a),t(r)),!0},updateConsentFunc:function(e){if(permutive)try{JSON.parse(localStorage["permutive-consent"]).opt_in!=e&&permutive.consent({opt_in:e,token:r})}catch(t){permutive.consent({opt_in:e,token:r})}}}),permutive.ready(function(){window.slateAmplitudeQueue.push(function(){var e=[];permutive.context&&e.push({tag:"puid",id:permutive.context.user_id});try{var t=window.amplitude.getDeviceId();t&&e.push({tag:"amplitudeId",id:t})}catch(e){console.error("Error setting amplitudeId",e)}e.length>0&&permutive.identify(e)})})}; }, {"5":5,"55":55,"58":58}]; window.modules["piano.client"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var slateAmplitude=require(17),universalPianoService=require(48),adblockDetection=require(68),membership=require(5),loginSuccessHandler=require(67),afterCheckout=require(64),afterCheckoutClose=require(66),afterPianoInit=require(69),checkoutStateChangeHandler=require(63),showOffer=require(62),experienceExecute=require(61),newsletterSignup=require(65),setResponseVariable=require(60),script=document.createElement("script");function loadPianoExperience(e){slateGlobal.injectScript(e.url+"/api/tinypass.min.js",void 0,function(e){console.warn("piano 💩 🛏",e)})}function initPianoExperience(e){window.tp||(window.tp=[]);var t=window.tp;try{var n=slateAmplitude.getDomEventData();for(var i in n=universalPianoService.formatArticleData(n),t.push(["setContentCreated",n.content_created]),t.push(["setContentAuthor",n.content_author]),t.push(["setContentSection",n.content_section]),t.push(["setTags",n.tags]),n.custom_variables)t.push(["setCustomVariable",i,n.custom_variables[i]])}catch(e){console.warn("failed to set article metadata for piano",e)}t.push(["setAid",e.aid]),t.push(["setEndpoint",e.endpoint]),t.push(["setComposerHost",e.url]),t.push(["setPianoIdUrl",e.idUrl]),t.push(["setUsePianoIdUserProvider",!0]),t.push(["setUseTinypassAccounts",!1]),e.cxenseSiteId&&t.push(["setCxenseSiteId",e.cxenseSiteId]),t.push(["init",afterPianoInit]),t.push(["addHandler","loginSuccess",loginSuccessHandler]),t.push(["addHandler","checkoutStateChange",checkoutStateChangeHandler]),t.push(["addHandler","checkoutComplete",afterCheckout]),t.push(["addHandler","checkoutClose",afterCheckoutClose]),t.push(["addHandler","showOffer",showOffer]),t.push(["addHandler","experienceExecute",experienceExecute]),t.push(["addHandler","customEvent",newsletterSignup]),t.push(["addHandler","setResponseVariable",setResponseVariable])}function is404(){var e=document.querySelector("link[rel=canonical]");return!!e&&"/404"===new URL(e.href).pathname}script.src="/piano/scripts/resize.js",document.head.appendChild(script),module.exports=function(e){if(!is404()){membership.isMemberSkipLookup()||adblockDetection.enable();var t=JSON.parse(e.dataset.config);initPianoExperience(t),loadPianoExperience(t)}}; }, {"5":5,"17":17,"48":48,"60":60,"61":61,"62":62,"63":63,"64":64,"65":65,"66":66,"67":67,"68":68,"69":69}]; window.modules["webapp-serviceworker.client"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";var slateAmplitude=require(17);module.exports=function(e){navigator.serviceWorker?(window.addEventListener("load",function(){navigator.serviceWorker.register("/sw.js").then(function(e){},function(e){console.error("ServiceWorker registration failed: ",e)})}),window.addEventListener("beforeinstallprompt",function(e){e.userChoice.then(function(e){"dismissed"===e.outcome?slateAmplitude.track("PWA - dismissed install prompt"):slateAmplitude.track("PWA - Added to Home Screen")})})):console.debug("Service worker not supported")}; }, {"17":17}]; window.modules["lazyload.legacy"] = [function(require,module,exports){"use strict";function lazyloadSvgUseTags(e,t){for(var r=0;r<e.length;r++){var n=e[r];n.isIntersecting&&(n.target.querySelectorAll("use[data-href]").forEach(function(e){e.setAttribute("href",e.getAttribute("data-href")),e.removeAttribute("data-href")}),t.unobserve(n.target),0==--count&&t.disconnect())}}require(122),require(29);var svgio=new IntersectionObserver(lazyloadSvgUseTags,{rootMargin:"100% 0px 100% 0px"}),count=0;document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",function(){document.querySelectorAll("svg[loading=lazy]").forEach(function(e){svgio.observe(e),count++})}); }, {"29":29,"122":122}]; require=(function e(t,n,r){function s(o,u){if(!n[o]){if(!t[o]){var a=typeof require=="function"&&require;if(!u&&a)return a(o,!0);if(i)return i(o,!0);var f=new Error("Cannot find module '"+o+"'");throw f.code="MODULE_NOT_FOUND",f}var l=n[o]={exports:{}};t[o][0].call(l.exports,function(e){var n=t[o][1][e];return s(n?n:e)},l,l.exports,e,t,n,r)}return n[o].exports}var i=typeof require=="function"&&require;for(var o=0;o<r.length;o++)s(r[o]);return s})(window.modules,{},[]); /* eslint-env browser */ 'use strict'; /** * mount legacy services from _global.js, if any */ function _createForOfIteratorHelper(r, e) { var t = "undefined" != typeof Symbol && r[Symbol.iterator] || r["@@iterator"]; if (!t) { if (Array.isArray(r) || (t = _unsupportedIterableToArray(r)) || e && r && "number" == typeof r.length) { t && (r = t); var _n = 0, F = function F() {}; return { s: F, n: function n() { return _n >= r.length ? { done: !0 } : { done: !1, value: r[_n++] }; }, e: function e(r) { throw r; }, f: F }; } throw new TypeError("Invalid attempt to iterate non-iterable instance.\nIn order to be iterable, non-array objects must have a [Symbol.iterator]() method."); } var o, a = !0, u = !1; return { s: function s() { t = t.call(r); }, n: function n() { var r = t.next(); return a = r.done, r; }, e: function e(r) { u = !0, o = r; }, f: function f() { try { a || null == t.return || t.return(); } finally { if (u) throw o; } } }; } function _unsupportedIterableToArray(r, a) { if (r) { if ("string" == typeof r) return _arrayLikeToArray(r, a); var t = {}.toString.call(r).slice(8, -1); return "Object" === t && r.constructor && (t = r.constructor.name), "Map" === t || "Set" === t ? Array.from(r) : "Arguments" === t || /^(?:Ui|I)nt(?:8|16|32)(?:Clamped)?Array$/.test(t) ? _arrayLikeToArray(r, a) : void 0; } } function _arrayLikeToArray(r, a) { (null == a || a > r.length) && (a = r.length); for (var e = 0, n = Array(a); e < a; e++) n[e] = r[e]; return n; } function mountLegacyServices() { Object.keys(window.modules).filter(function (key) { return typeof key === 'string' && key.match(/\.legacy$/); }).forEach(function (key) { return window.require(key); }); } function tryToMount(fn, el, name) { try { fn(el); // init the controller } catch (e) { var elementTag = el.outerHTML.slice(0, el.outerHTML.indexOf(el.innerHTML)); console.error("Error initializing controller for \"".concat(name, "\" on \"").concat(elementTag, "\""), e); } } /** * mount client.js component controllers */ function mountComponentModules() { Object.keys(window.modules).filter(function (key) { return typeof key === 'string' && key.match(/\.client$/); }).forEach(function (key) { var controllerFn = window.require(key); if (typeof controllerFn === 'function') { var name = key.replace('.client', ''), instancesSelector = "[data-uri*=\"_components/".concat(name, "/\"]"), defaultSelector = "[data-uri$=\"_components".concat(name, "\"]"), instances = document.querySelectorAll(instancesSelector), defaults = document.querySelectorAll(defaultSelector); var _iterator = _createForOfIteratorHelper(instances), _step; try { for (_iterator.s(); !(_step = _iterator.n()).done;) { var el = _step.value; tryToMount(controllerFn, el, name); } } catch (err) { _iterator.e(err); } finally { _iterator.f(); } var _iterator2 = _createForOfIteratorHelper(defaults), _step2; try { for (_iterator2.s(); !(_step2 = _iterator2.n()).done;) { var _el = _step2.value; tryToMount(controllerFn, _el, name); } } catch (err) { _iterator2.e(err); } finally { _iterator2.f(); } } }); } // Make sure that a `window.process.env.NODE_ENV` is available in the client for any dependencies, // services, or components that could require it // note: the `` value is swapped for the actual environment variable in /lib/cmd/compile/scripts.js window.process = window.process || {}; window.process.env = window.process.env || {}; if (!window.process.env.NODE_ENV) { window.process.env.NODE_ENV = ''; } // note: legacy controllers that require legacy services (e.g. dollar-slice) must // wait for DOMContentLoaded to initialize themselves, as the files themselves must be mounted first mountLegacyServices(); mountComponentModules(); // ]] </script></body> </html>