CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en-US"><head> <meta charset="utf-8"/> <link rel="dns-prefetch preconnect" href="https://u.jimcdn.com/" crossorigin="anonymous"/> <link rel="dns-prefetch preconnect" href="https://assets.jimstatic.com/" crossorigin="anonymous"/> <link rel="dns-prefetch preconnect" href="https://image.jimcdn.com" crossorigin="anonymous"/> <link rel="dns-prefetch preconnect" href="https://fonts.jimstatic.com" crossorigin="anonymous"/> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1"/> <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge"/> <meta name="description" content="National AI Advisory Committee. US AI policy. AI policy, Artificial Intelligence, EU AI Act, democratic values, data protection, fairness, innovation, universal guidelines for AI, human rights, CAIDP, Marc Rotenberg, Merve Hickok"/> <meta name="robots" content="index, follow, archive"/> <meta property="st:section" content="National AI Advisory Committee. US AI policy. AI policy, Artificial Intelligence, EU AI Act, democratic values, data protection, fairness, innovation, universal guidelines for AI, human rights, CAIDP, Marc Rotenberg, Merve Hickok"/> <meta name="twitter:title" content="NAIAC"/> <meta name="twitter:description" content="National AI Advisory Committee. US AI policy. AI policy, Artificial Intelligence, EU AI Act, democratic values, data protection, fairness, innovation, universal guidelines for AI, human rights, CAIDP, Marc Rotenberg, Merve Hickok"/> <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"/> <meta property="og:url" content="https://www.caidp.org/resources/naiac/"/> <meta property="og:title" content="NAIAC"/> <meta property="og:description" content="National AI Advisory Committee. US AI policy. AI policy, Artificial Intelligence, EU AI Act, democratic values, data protection, fairness, innovation, universal guidelines for AI, human rights, CAIDP, Marc Rotenberg, Merve Hickok"/> <meta property="og:type" content="website"/> <meta property="og:locale" content="en_US"/> <meta property="og:site_name" content="Center for AI and Digital Policy"/> <meta name="twitter:image" content="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/backgroundarea/i9e4d152ac18b61f8/version/1596465197/image.png"/> <meta property="og:image" content="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/backgroundarea/i9e4d152ac18b61f8/version/1596465197/image.png"/> <meta property="og:image:width" content="2000"/> <meta property="og:image:height" content="1500"/> <meta property="og:image:secure_url" content="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/backgroundarea/i9e4d152ac18b61f8/version/1596465197/image.png"/><title>NAIAC - Center for AI and Digital Policy</title> <link rel="shortcut icon" href="https://u.jimcdn.com/cms/o/s899a9742c3d83292/img/favicon.ico?t=1596998275"/> <link rel="canonical" href="https://www.caidp.org/resources/naiac/"/> <script src="https://assets.jimstatic.com/ckies.js.1a748f48480feac0818f.js"></script> <script src="https://assets.jimstatic.com/cookieControl.js.e4d04a9362e3920040cb.js"></script> <script>window.CookieControlSet.setToOff();</script> <style>html,body{margin:0}.hidden{display:none}.n{padding:5px}#cc-website-title a {text-decoration: none}.cc-m-image-align-1{text-align:left}.cc-m-image-align-2{text-align:right}.cc-m-image-align-3{text-align:center}</style> <link href="https://u.jimcdn.com/cms/o/s899a9742c3d83292/layout/dm_11de6aa15679483822a5e8672190aa25/css/layout.css?t=1624027046" rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" id="jimdo_layout_css"/> <script> /* <![CDATA[ */ /*! loadCss [c]2014 @scottjehl, Filament Group, Inc. Licensed MIT */ window.loadCSS = window.loadCss = function(e,n,t){var r,l=window.document,a=l.createElement("link");if(n)r=n;else{var i=(l.body||l.getElementsByTagName("head")[0]).childNodes;r=i[i.length-1]}var o=l.styleSheets;a.rel="stylesheet",a.href=e,a.media="only x",r.parentNode.insertBefore(a,n?r:r.nextSibling);var d=function(e){for(var n=a.href,t=o.length;t--;)if(o[t].href===n)return e.call(a);setTimeout(function(){d(e)})};return a.onloadcssdefined=d,d(function(){a.media=t||"all"}),a}; window.onloadCSS = function(n,o){n.onload=function(){n.onload=null,o&&o.call(n)},"isApplicationInstalled"in navigator&&"onloadcssdefined"in n&&n.onloadcssdefined(o)} /* ]]> */ </script> <script> // <![CDATA[ onloadCSS(loadCss('https://assets.jimstatic.com/web.css.6171c4a35b361b9030cb24d6de8164b8.css') , function() { this.id = 'jimdo_web_css'; }); // ]]> </script> <link href="https://assets.jimstatic.com/web.css.6171c4a35b361b9030cb24d6de8164b8.css" rel="preload" as="style"/> <noscript> <link href="https://assets.jimstatic.com/web.css.6171c4a35b361b9030cb24d6de8164b8.css" rel="stylesheet"/> </noscript> <script> //<![CDATA[ var jimdoData = {"isTestserver":false,"isLcJimdoCom":false,"isJimdoHelpCenter":false,"isProtectedPage":false,"cstok":"","cacheJsKey":"988c1b5c40758eea37d91fe89d6888c9cd07cde6","cacheCssKey":"988c1b5c40758eea37d91fe89d6888c9cd07cde6","cdnUrl":"https:\/\/assets.jimstatic.com\/","minUrl":"https:\/\/assets.jimstatic.com\/app\/cdn\/min\/file\/","authUrl":"https:\/\/a.jimdo.com\/","webPath":"https:\/\/www.caidp.org\/","appUrl":"https:\/\/a.jimdo.com\/","cmsLanguage":"en_US","isFreePackage":false,"mobile":false,"isDevkitTemplateUsed":true,"isTemplateResponsive":true,"websiteId":"s899a9742c3d83292","pageId":1406637063,"packageId":3,"shop":{"deliveryTimeTexts":{"1":"Ships within 1-3 days","2":"Ships within 3-5 days","3":"Delivery in 5-8 days"},"checkoutButtonText":"Check out","isReady":false,"currencyFormat":{"pattern":"\u00a4#,##0.00","convertedPattern":"$#,##0.00","symbols":{"GROUPING_SEPARATOR":",","DECIMAL_SEPARATOR":".","CURRENCY_SYMBOL":"$"}},"currencyLocale":"en_US"},"tr":{"gmap":{"searchNotFound":"The entered address doesn't exist or couldn't be found.","routeNotFound":"The driving directions couldn't be determined. Possible reasons: The starting address is not specific enough or it is too far from the destination address."},"shop":{"checkoutSubmit":{"next":"Next step","wait":"Please wait"},"paypalError":"An error has occurred. Please try again!","cartBar":"Go to Shopping Cart","maintenance":"Sorry, this store is not available at the moment. Please try again later.","addToCartOverlay":{"productInsertedText":"This item was added to your cart.","continueShoppingText":"Continue shopping","reloadPageText":"Refresh"},"notReadyText":"This store has not been completely set up.","numLeftText":"There are not more than {:num} of this item available at this time.","oneLeftText":"There is only one more of this item available."},"common":{"timeout":"Oops, it looks like there's been an error on our end and your last change didn't go through. Please try again in a minute. "},"form":{"badRequest":"An error has occurred! This form could not be submitted. Please try again later."}},"jQuery":"jimdoGen002","isJimdoMobileApp":false,"bgConfig":{"id":54572063,"type":"slideshow","options":{"fixed":true,"speed":0},"images":[{"id":5419815563,"url":"https:\/\/image.jimcdn.com\/app\/cms\/image\/transf\/none\/path\/s899a9742c3d83292\/backgroundarea\/i9e4d152ac18b61f8\/version\/1596465197\/image.png"},{"id":5419815663,"url":"https:\/\/image.jimcdn.com\/app\/cms\/image\/transf\/none\/path\/s899a9742c3d83292\/backgroundarea\/i8c693e3d0e49c6af\/version\/1596465197\/image.png"}]},"bgFullscreen":null,"responsiveBreakpointLandscape":767,"responsiveBreakpointPortrait":480,"copyableHeadlineLinks":false,"tocGeneration":false,"googlemapsConsoleKey":false,"loggingForAnalytics":false,"loggingForPredefinedPages":false,"isFacebookPixelIdEnabled":false,"userAccountId":"2515ca28-8c90-4414-82cd-f23acfaedfe7"}; // ]]> </script> <script> (function(window) { 'use strict'; var regBuff = window.__regModuleBuffer = []; var regModuleBuffer = function() { var args = [].slice.call(arguments); regBuff.push(args); }; if (!window.regModule) { window.regModule = regModuleBuffer; } })(window); </script> <script src="https://assets.jimstatic.com/web.js.d7b5e212be5720ae22e6.js" async="true"></script> <script src="https://assets.jimstatic.com/at.js.f4680ead6f240367d9f9.js"></script> <style type="text/css"> /*<![CDATA[*/ //.jtpl-header { position: absolute; z-index: 10; top: 0; width: 100%; } //.jtpl-header.navigation-colors { position: absolute; z-index: 10; top: 0; width: 100%; } .center { text-align: center; } .center-image { display: block; margin-left: auto; margin-right: 49%; width: 50%; } /*shop items*/ .j-catalog-product-title-link { font-size: 1.5em; } .cc-product-details.j-catalog-product-details { margin-top: 12px; } .jtpl-header--image.jqbga-container { top: 82px; } .jtpl-breadcrumb.alignment-options { display:none; } //.jtpl-header.navigation-colors { display:none; } .jtpl-header { box-shadow:none; } .jtpl-header--image.jqbga-container.jdbga-web--color { display:none; top: 82px; } .jtpl-content.alignment-options.content-options-inner.cc-content-parent { max-width: 1280px; } .jtpl-header__inner.alignment-options.navigation-vertical-alignment { max-width: 1280px; } .jtpl-sidebar__inner.alignment-options { max-width: 1280px; } .jtpl-section-main.content-options-box.cc-content-parent { padding-bottom: 0px; } .j-module.n.j-imageSubtitle { padding-top: 0px; } .jtpl-content.alignment-options.content-options-inner.cc-content-parent { padding-top: 0px; } } .jtpl-logo { margin-top: 0px !important; } .jtpl-content.alignment-options.content-options-inner.cc-content-parent { padding-bottom: 0px; } //.jtpl-header--image.jqbga-container.jqbga-web--image { height: 420px; } .j-calltoaction-link.j-calltoaction-link-style-1 { padding-top: 10px; padding-bottom: 10px; } /*fade in no color*/ #cf { position:relative; height:200px; width:200px; margin:0 auto; } #cf img { position:absolute; -webkit-transition: opacity 1s ease-in-out; -moz-transition: opacity 1s ease-in-out; -o-transition: opacity 1s ease-in-out; transition: opacity 1s ease-in-out; } #cf img.top:hover { opacity:0; } /*text Animations*/ [data-animate-in] { opacity: 0; transition: transform 0.8s ease, opacity 0.8s ease } [data-animate-in="up"] { transform: translate3d(0, 34px, 0) } [data-animate-in="up1"] { transform: translate3d(0, 24px, 0) } [data-animate-in="up2"] { transform: translate3d(0, 38px, 0) } [data-animate-in="up3"] { transform: translate3d(0, 44px, 0) } [data-animate-in="up4"] { transform: translate3d(0, 4px, 0) } [data-animate-in="up5"] { transform: translate3d(0, 54px, 0) } [data-animate-in="left"] { transform: translate3d(-25%, 0, 0) } [data-animate-in="right"] { transform: translate3d(25%, 0, 0) } [data-animate-in="down"] { transform: translate3d(0, -24px, 0) } [data-animate-in="fadeIn"] { transform: translate3d(0, 0, 0) } [data-animate-in].in-view { opacity: 1; transform: translate3d(0, 0, 0); -webkit-transform: translate3d(0, 0, 0); transition: transform 0.6s ease, opacity 0.6s ease } .fade-in { opacity: 0; transition: opacity 1s ease } .page-loaded .fade-in,.page-loaded.fade-in { opacity: 1 } .isSafari.isTouch [data-animate-in],.isSafari.isTouch [data-animate-in="up"] { opacity: 1; transition: none; transform: none } /*cursors*/ div.box1:hover { cursor: hand; cursor: pointer; opacity: .9; } /*full width*/ .slider { position: relative; } .slider { width: 100vw !important; margin-left: calc(-50vw + 50% - 8px); position: relative; } /*slider*/ .slider { max-width: 1920px; height: 500px; position: relative; } .slide1,.slide2,.slide3 { position: absolute; width: 100%; height: 100%; } .slide1 { background: url(https://99designs-5f118e858db04.jimdofree.com/app/download/8219959763/shake-it-mid-slides1.jpg?t=1595503258)no-repeat center; background-size: cover; animation:fade 22s infinite; -webkit-animation:fade 22s infinite; } .slide2 { background: url(https://99designs-5f118e858db04.jimdofree.com/app/download/8219959863/shake-it-mid-slides2.jpg?t=1595503258)no-repeat center; background-size: cover; animation:fade2 22s infinite; -webkit-animation:fade2 22s infinite; } .slide3 { background: url(https://99designs-5f118e858db04.jimdofree.com/app/download/8219959963/shake-it-mid-slides3.jpg?t=1595503258)no-repeat center; background-size: cover; animation:fade3 22s infinite; -webkit-animation:fade3 22s infinite; } @keyframes fade { 0% {opacity:1} 33.333% { opacity: 0} 66.666% { opacity: 0} 100% { opacity: 1} } @keyframes fade2 { 0% {opacity:0} 33.333% { opacity: 1} 66.666% { opacity: 0 } 100% { opacity: 0} } @keyframes fade3 { 0% {opacity:0} 33.333% { opacity: 0} 66.666% { opacity: 1} 100% { opacity: 0} } /*zoom effect*/ .photo-grid { margin: auto; text-align: center; } .photo-grid .grid-item { display: inline-block; margin: auto; } .photo-grid img { display: block; height: auto; max-width: 100%; } .photo-grid figure { height: 360px; overflow: hidden; position: relative; width: 100%; } .photo-grid figcaption { background: rgba(0, 79, 143, 0.7); color: white; display: table; height: 100%; left: 0; opacity: 0; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; z-index: 100; } .photo-grid figcaption p { display: table-cell; font-size: 2.3em; position: relative; top: -40px; vertical-align: middle; } .photo-grid .grid-item:hover figcaption { opacity: 1; } .photo-grid img { display: block; height: auto; -webkit-transition: all 600ms; -moz-transition: all 600ms; transition: all 600ms; max-width: 100%; } .photo-grid .grid-item:hover img { -webkit-transform: scale(1.4); -moz-transform: scale(1.4); transform: scale(1.4); } .photo-grid figcaption p { display: table-cell; font-size: 1.9em; position: relative; top: -40px; width: 600px; -webkit-transition: all 600ms ease-out; -moz-transition: all 600ms ease-out; transition: all 600ms ease-out; vertical-align: middle; } .photo-grid .grid-item:hover figcaption p { -moz-transform: translateY(40px); -webkit-transform: translateY(40px); transform: translateY(40px); } .photo-grid figcaption { background: rgba(0, 79, 143, 0.7); color: white; display: table; height: 100%; left: 0; opacity: 0; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; -webkit-transition: all 600ms; -moz-transition: all 600ms; transition: all 600ms; -webkit-transition-delay: 100ms; -moz-transition-delay: 100ms; transition-delay: 100ms; z-index: 100; } /*fade-in effect*/ .fadein1 { opacity:0; } .fadein2 { opacity:0; } .fadein3 { opacity:0; } .fadein4 { opacity:0; } /*]]>*/ </style> <script src="https://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jquery/1.8.1/jquery.min.js" type="text/javascript"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> //<![CDATA[ $(document).ready(function() { $( "#cc-m-8224736463" ).wrap( "<div id='section1' />" ); $( "#cc-m-8224745763" ).wrap( "<div id='section2' />" ); $( "#cc-m-8224738463" ).wrap( "<div id='section3' />" ); $( "#cc-m-8224738863" ).wrap( "<div id='section4' />" ); }); /* This code for div click */ $(document).ready(function() { $(".box1").click(function(){ window.location=$(this).find("a").attr("href"); return false; }); }); /* This code for text anim*/ $(function() { var html = $('html'); // Detections if (!("ontouchstart" in window)) { html.addClass("noTouch"); } if ("ontouchstart" in window) { html.addClass("isTouch"); } if ("ontouchstart" in window) { html.addClass("isTouch"); } if (document.documentMode || /Edge/.test(navigator.userAgent)) { if (navigator.appVersion.indexOf("Trident") === -1) { html.addClass("isEDGE"); } else { html.addClass("isIE isIE11"); } } if (navigator.appVersion.indexOf("MSIE") !== -1) { html.addClass("isIE"); } if ( navigator.userAgent.indexOf("Safari") != -1 && navigator.userAgent.indexOf("Chrome") == -1 ) { html.addClass("isSafari"); } // On Screen $.fn.isOnScreen = function() { var elementTop = $(this).offset().top, elementBottom = elementTop + $(this).outerHeight(), viewportTop = $(window).scrollTop(), viewportBottom = viewportTop + $(window).height(); return elementBottom > viewportTop && elementTop < viewportBottom; }; function detection() { for (var i = 0; i < items.length; i++) { var el = $(items[i]); if (el.isOnScreen()) { el.addClass("in-view"); } else { el.removeClass("in-view"); } } } var items = document.querySelectorAll( "*[data-animate-in], *[data-detect-viewport]" ), waiting = false, w = $(window); w.on("resize scroll", function() { if (waiting) { return; } waiting = true; detection(); setTimeout(function() { waiting = false; }, 100); }); $(document).ready(function() { setTimeout(function() { detection(); }, 500); for (var i = 0; i < items.length; i++) { var d = 0, el = $(items[i]); if (items[i].getAttribute("data-animate-in-delay")) { d = items[i].getAttribute("data-animate-in-delay") / 1000 + "s"; } else { d = 0; } el.css("transition-delay", d); } }); }); /* This code for fadein */ $(document).ready(function() { $(window).scroll( function(){ $('.fadein1').each( function(i){ var bottom_of_element = $(this).offset().top + $(this).outerHeight(); var bottom_of_window = $(window).scrollTop() + $(window).height(); if( bottom_of_window > bottom_of_element ){ $(this).animate({'opacity':'1'},1000); } }); }); }); $(document).ready(function() { $(window).scroll( function(){ $('.fadein2').each( function(i){ var bottom_of_element = $(this).offset().top + $(this).outerHeight(); var bottom_of_window = $(window).scrollTop() + $(window).height(); if( bottom_of_window > bottom_of_element ){ $(this).animate({'opacity':'1'},2000); } }); }); }); $(document).ready(function() { $(window).scroll( function(){ $('.fadein3').each( function(i){ var bottom_of_element = $(this).offset().top + $(this).outerHeight(); var bottom_of_window = $(window).scrollTop() + $(window).height(); if( bottom_of_window > bottom_of_element ){ $(this).animate({'opacity':'1'},3000); } }); }); }); $(document).ready(function() { $(window).scroll( function(){ $('.fadein4').each( function(i){ var bottom_of_element = $(this).offset().top + $(this).outerHeight(); var bottom_of_window = $(window).scrollTop() + $(window).height(); if( bottom_of_window > bottom_of_element ){ $(this).animate({'opacity':'1'},4000); } }); }); }); //]]> </script> <style type="text/css"> /*<![CDATA[*/ /* This code prevents side-scrolling */ body { overflow-x: hidden;} .jtpl-main {overflow-x:hidden;} /* This is a fullwidth section - add your comment to describe it */ #section1 { margin: 0 -9999rem; padding: 0.25rem 9999rem; background: url("https://99designs-5f189c27d6be7.jimdofree.com/app/download/8229442463/blue.jpg?t=1596802219") repeat center center; } #section2 { margin: 0 -9999rem; padding: 0.25rem 9999rem; background: url("https://99designs-5f189c27d6be7.jimdofree.com/app/download/8229442963/center-mid1.jpg?t=1596802233") repeat center center; } #section3 { margin: 0 -9999rem; padding: 0.25rem 9999rem; background: url("https://99designs-5f189c27d6be7.jimdofree.com/app/download/8229446163/light-grey.jpg?t=1596802455") repeat center center; } #section4 { margin: 0 -9999rem; padding: 0.25rem 9999rem; background: url("https://99designs-5f189c27d6be7.jimdofree.com/app/download/8229446163/light-grey.jpg?t=1596802455") repeat center center; } /*]]>*/ </style> </head> <body class="body cc-page j-m-gallery-styles j-m-video-styles j-m-hr-styles j-m-header-styles j-m-text-styles j-m-emotionheader-styles j-m-htmlCode-styles j-m-rss-styles j-m-form-styles j-m-table-styles j-m-textWithImage-styles j-m-downloadDocument-styles j-m-imageSubtitle-styles j-m-flickr-styles j-m-googlemaps-styles j-m-blogSelection-styles j-m-comment-styles-disabled j-m-jimdo-styles j-m-profile-styles j-m-guestbook-styles j-m-promotion-styles j-m-twitter-styles j-m-hgrid-styles j-m-shoppingcart-styles j-m-catalog-styles j-m-product-styles-disabled j-m-facebook-styles j-m-sharebuttons-styles j-m-formnew-styles j-m-callToAction-styles j-m-turbo-styles j-m-spacing-styles j-m-googleplus-styles j-m-dummy-styles j-m-search-styles j-m-booking-styles j-footer-styles cc-pagemode-default cc-content-parent" id="page-1406637063"> <div id="cc-inner" class="cc-content-parent"> <input type="checkbox" id="jtpl-mobile-navigation__checkbox" class="jtpl-mobile-navigation__checkbox"/><div class="jtpl-main cc-content-parent">  <div class="jtpl-background-area" background-area="fullscreen"></div>   <div class="jtpl-top-bar navigation-colors">  <label for="jtpl-mobile-navigation__checkbox" class="jtpl-mobile-navigation__label navigation-colors--transparency"> <span class="jtpl-mobile-navigation__borders navigation-colors__menu-icon"></span> </label>  </div>   <nav class="jtpl-mobile-navigation navigation-colors navigation-colors--transparency"><div data-container="navigation"><div class="j-nav-variant-nested"><ul class="cc-nav-level-0 j-nav-level-0"><li id="cc-nav-view-1396341963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0"><a href="/" data-link-title="Home">Home</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403393363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/statements/" data-link-title="Statements">Statements</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1403393363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1404391663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/support-ukraine/" data-link-title="Support-Ukraine">Support-Ukraine</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1405109863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/ostp/" data-link-title="OSTP">OSTP</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406706863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/ban-facial-surveillance-technology/" data-link-title="Ban Facial Surveillance Technology">Ban Facial Surveillance Technology</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406659663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/civil-society-coe-and-eu/" data-link-title="Civil Society - COE and EU">Civil Society - COE and EU</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403393463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/reports/" data-link-title="Reports">Reports</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1403393463" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1413317763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/aidv-2025/" data-link-title="AIDV-2025">AIDV-2025</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1410983563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/reports/aidv-2023/" data-link-title="AIDV-2023">AIDV-2023</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1410983563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1411039163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/reports/aidv-2023/aidv-maps-2023/" data-link-title="AIDV Maps 2023">AIDV Maps 2023</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408147463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/reports/aidv-2022/" data-link-title="AIDV-2022">AIDV-2022</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1408147463" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1407679963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/reports/aidv-2022/aidv-maps-2022/" data-link-title="AIDV Maps 2022">AIDV Maps 2022</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403490263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/aidv-2021/" data-link-title="AIDV-2021">AIDV-2021</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1398884363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/aidv-2020/" data-link-title="AIDV-2020">AIDV-2020</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/publications/" data-link-title="Publications">Publications</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1399569363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/public-voice/" data-link-title="Public Voice">Public Voice</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1399569363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1413024663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ai-treaty-now/" data-link-title="AI-Treaty-Now">AI-Treaty-Now</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408757863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ai-action-plan-ostp-2025/" data-link-title="AI Action Plan (OSTP 2025)">AI Action Plan (OSTP 2025)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1413128363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/copyright-office-us-2023-1/" data-link-title="Copyright Office (US 2023)">Copyright Office (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409429563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/fec-us-2023/" data-link-title="FEC (US 2023)">FEC (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408827063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ftc-cloud-computing-us-2023/" data-link-title="FTC Cloud Computing (US 2023)">FTC Cloud Computing (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409321863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ntia-ai-accountability-us-2023/" data-link-title="NTIA AI Accountability (US 2023)">NTIA AI Accountability (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409913563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/omb-us-2023/" data-link-title="OMB (US 2023)">OMB (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408755263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ostp-ai-strategy-us-2023/" data-link-title="OSTP AI Strategy (US 2023)">OSTP AI Strategy (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408723963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ostp-workers-and-ai-us-2023/" data-link-title="OSTP Workers and AI (US 2023)">OSTP Workers and AI (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408637763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/pcast-us-2023/" data-link-title="PCAST (US 2023)">PCAST (US 2023)</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/" data-link-title="Events">Events</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1396342163" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1413238963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/washdc25aidv/" data-link-title="WashDC25AIDV">WashDC25AIDV</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1413238963" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1413384463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc25aidv/bios/" data-link-title="Bios">Bios</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1413384363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc25aidv/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412674163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/procurement/" data-link-title="Procurement">Procurement</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411274863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/unesco/" data-link-title="UNESCO">UNESCO</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1410875563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/russell/" data-link-title="Russell">Russell</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411140163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/washdc24aidv/" data-link-title="WashDC24AIDV">WashDC24AIDV</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1411140163" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1408215363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc24aidv/speakers/" data-link-title="Speakers">Speakers</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408446163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc24aidv/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409882163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/uk-ai-summit/" data-link-title="UK AI Summit">UK AI Summit</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/" data-link-title="Oct2023-DC-UGAI">Oct2023-DC-UGAI</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1409669663" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/agenda/" data-link-title="Agenda">Agenda</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409670163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/bios/" data-link-title="Bios">Bios</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/endorse/" data-link-title="Endorse">Endorse</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/messages/" data-link-title="Messages">Messages</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/papers/" data-link-title="Papers">Papers</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408550663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/sept2023-dc-roundtable/" data-link-title="Sept2023-DC-Roundtable">Sept2023-DC-Roundtable</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409264663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/may2023-dc-roundtable/" data-link-title="May2023-DC-Roundtable">May2023-DC-Roundtable</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1409264663" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1408550863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/may2023-dc-roundtable/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408157563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/" data-link-title="WashDC23AIDV">WashDC23AIDV</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1408157563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1411069663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411069563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/speakers/" data-link-title="Speakers">Speakers</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408321263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/photos/" data-link-title="Photos">Photos</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408062263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/in-congress-house-oversight/" data-link-title="In Congress (House Oversight)">In Congress (House Oversight)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406612363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/broussard/" data-link-title="Broussard">Broussard</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408081563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/brusselseffect/" data-link-title="BrusselsEffect">BrusselsEffect</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407078763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/dataactivism/" data-link-title="DataActivism">DataActivism</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406850363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/surveillancestate/" data-link-title="SurveillanceState">SurveillanceState</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401367363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/employment/" data-link-title="Employment">Employment</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1400789763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/perfectweapon/" data-link-title="PerfectWeapon">PerfectWeapon</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403001563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/aidvparis2021/" data-link-title="AIDVPARIS2021">AIDVPARIS2021</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1404136463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/codedbias/" data-link-title="CodedBias">CodedBias</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401189763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/geniusmakers/" data-link-title="Geniusmakers">Geniusmakers</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401831263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/chess/" data-link-title="Chess">Chess</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406378163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/cahai/" data-link-title="CAHAI">CAHAI</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children cc-nav-parent j-nav-parent jmd-nav__item--parent"><a href="/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1396342563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1404012663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/ai-policy-frameworks/" data-link-title="AI Policy Frameworks">AI Policy Frameworks</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1404791263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/coe-ai-treaty/" data-link-title="COE AI Treaty">COE AI Treaty</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1404493663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/eu-ai-act/" data-link-title="EU AI Act">EU AI Act</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407810363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/g7/" data-link-title="G7">G7</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408016863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/g20/" data-link-title="G20">G20</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406637063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 cc-nav-current j-nav-current jmd-nav__item--current"><a href="/resources/naiac/" data-link-title="NAIAC" class="cc-nav-current j-nav-current jmd-nav__link--current">NAIAC</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407161063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/trade-and-technology-council/" data-link-title="Trade and Technology Council">Trade and Technology Council</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409125663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/united-nations/" data-link-title="United Nations">United Nations</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401367463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/bookstore/" data-link-title="Bookstore">Bookstore</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401367663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/commentaries/" data-link-title="Commentaries">Commentaries</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407030363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/cases/" data-link-title="Cases">Cases</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1407030363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1407030563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/cases/gonzalez-v-google/" data-link-title="Gonzalez v. Google">Gonzalez v. Google</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408134963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/cases/openai/" data-link-title="OpenAI">OpenAI</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409431163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/cases/zoom/" data-link-title="Zoom">Zoom</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/" data-link-title="Transparency Project">Transparency Project</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1407003263" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/doj/" data-link-title="DOJ">DOJ</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/naiac/" data-link-title="NAIAC">NAIAC</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/ostp/" data-link-title="OSTP">OSTP</a></li></ul></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1397319363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/about-2/" data-link-title="About">About</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1397319363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1396343263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/team/" data-link-title="Team">Team</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409130863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/about-2/structure/" data-link-title="Structure">Structure</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1409130863" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1409670263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/about-2/structure/sff-application/" data-link-title="SFF Application">SFF Application</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406321763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-fall/" data-link-title="Research Group 2025 - Spring">Research Group 2025 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412876063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-fall-1/" data-link-title="Research Group 2024 - Fall">Research Group 2024 - Fall</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412023363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-summer-1/" data-link-title="Research Group 2024 - Summer">Research Group 2024 - Summer</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411472263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-spring/" data-link-title="Research Group 2024 - Spring">Research Group 2024 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1410566063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2023-fall/" data-link-title="Research Group 2023 - Fall">Research Group 2023 - Fall</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409196363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2023-summer/" data-link-title="Research Group 2023 - Summer">Research Group 2023 - Summer</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409196263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2023-spring/" data-link-title="Research Group 2023 - Spring">Research Group 2023 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407443163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2022-fall/" data-link-title="Research Group 2022 - Fall">Research Group 2022 - Fall</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403636063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2022-spring/" data-link-title="Research Group 2022 - Spring">Research Group 2022 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403804063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2021/" data-link-title="Research Group 2021">Research Group 2021</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/partners/" data-link-title="Partners">Partners</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406322463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/family-photo/" data-link-title="Family Photo">Family Photo</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406669063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/kudos/" data-link-title="Kudos">Kudos</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403393663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/contact/" data-link-title="Contact">Contact</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401461563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/global-academic-network/" data-link-title="Global Academic Network">Global Academic Network</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1401461563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1405583463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/global-academic-network/ai-policy-clinic/" data-link-title="AI Policy Clinic">AI Policy Clinic</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406851663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/awards/caidp-fellows/" data-link-title="CAIDP Fellows">CAIDP Fellows</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1405626663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/global-academic-network/extern-program/" data-link-title="Extern Program">Extern Program</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406851363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/awards/" data-link-title="Awards">Awards</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1406851363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1412679863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/awards/caidp-fellows-1/" data-link-title="CAIDP Fellows">CAIDP Fellows</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406868663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/awards/nominations/" data-link-title="Nominations">Nominations</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1402730363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0"><a href="/donate/" data-link-title="Donate">Donate</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409204263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0"><a href="/universal-guidelines-for-ai/" data-link-title="Universal Guidelines for AI">Universal Guidelines for AI</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411973763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/caidp-update/" data-link-title="CAIDP Update">CAIDP Update</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1411973763" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1411973663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-7-2025/" data-link-title="Volume 7 (2025)">Volume 7 (2025)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412975163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-6-2024-1/" data-link-title="Volume 6 (2024)">Volume 6 (2024)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411973963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-5-2023/" data-link-title="Volume 5 (2023)">Volume 5 (2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411979063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-4-2022/" data-link-title="Volume 4 (2022)">Volume 4 (2022)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/news/" data-link-title="News">News</a></li></ul></li></ul></div></div> </nav><header class="jtpl-header navigation-colors"><div class="jtpl-header__inner alignment-options navigation-vertical-alignment"> <div class="jtpl-logo"> <div id="cc-website-logo" class="cc-single-module-element"><div id="cc-m-8224770463" class="j-module n j-imageSubtitle"><div class="cc-m-image-container"><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-3"> <a href="https://www.caidp.org/" target="_self"><img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=280x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if596e88798f0ceda/version/1596465197/image.png 280w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if596e88798f0ceda/version/1596465197/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=560x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if596e88798f0ceda/version/1596465197/image.png 560w" sizes="(min-width: 280px) 280px, 100vw" id="cc-m-imagesubtitle-image-8224770463" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=280x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if596e88798f0ceda/version/1596465197/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="768" data-src-height="221" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=280x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if596e88798f0ceda/version/1596465197/image.png" data-image-id="5419815263"/></a> </figure> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8224770463">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_imageSubtitle", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"_blank","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8224770463,"widthEqualsContent":"1","resizeWidth":"280","resizeHeight":81},"id":8224770463}); // ]]> </script></div></div> </div>  <nav class="jtpl-navigation"><div class="jtpl-navigation__inner navigation-alignment" data-dropdown="true" data-main="true"> <div data-container="navigation"><div class="j-nav-variant-nested"><ul class="cc-nav-level-0 j-nav-level-0"><li id="cc-nav-view-1396341963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0"><a href="/" data-link-title="Home">Home</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403393363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/statements/" data-link-title="Statements">Statements</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1403393363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1404391663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/support-ukraine/" data-link-title="Support-Ukraine">Support-Ukraine</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1405109863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/ostp/" data-link-title="OSTP">OSTP</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406706863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/ban-facial-surveillance-technology/" data-link-title="Ban Facial Surveillance Technology">Ban Facial Surveillance Technology</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406659663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/civil-society-coe-and-eu/" data-link-title="Civil Society - COE and EU">Civil Society - COE and EU</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403393463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/reports/" data-link-title="Reports">Reports</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1403393463" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1413317763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/aidv-2025/" data-link-title="AIDV-2025">AIDV-2025</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1410983563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/reports/aidv-2023/" data-link-title="AIDV-2023">AIDV-2023</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1410983563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1411039163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/reports/aidv-2023/aidv-maps-2023/" data-link-title="AIDV Maps 2023">AIDV Maps 2023</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408147463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/reports/aidv-2022/" data-link-title="AIDV-2022">AIDV-2022</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1408147463" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1407679963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/reports/aidv-2022/aidv-maps-2022/" data-link-title="AIDV Maps 2022">AIDV Maps 2022</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403490263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/aidv-2021/" data-link-title="AIDV-2021">AIDV-2021</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1398884363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/aidv-2020/" data-link-title="AIDV-2020">AIDV-2020</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/publications/" data-link-title="Publications">Publications</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1399569363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/public-voice/" data-link-title="Public Voice">Public Voice</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1399569363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1413024663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ai-treaty-now/" data-link-title="AI-Treaty-Now">AI-Treaty-Now</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408757863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ai-action-plan-ostp-2025/" data-link-title="AI Action Plan (OSTP 2025)">AI Action Plan (OSTP 2025)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1413128363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/copyright-office-us-2023-1/" data-link-title="Copyright Office (US 2023)">Copyright Office (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409429563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/fec-us-2023/" data-link-title="FEC (US 2023)">FEC (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408827063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ftc-cloud-computing-us-2023/" data-link-title="FTC Cloud Computing (US 2023)">FTC Cloud Computing (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409321863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ntia-ai-accountability-us-2023/" data-link-title="NTIA AI Accountability (US 2023)">NTIA AI Accountability (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409913563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/omb-us-2023/" data-link-title="OMB (US 2023)">OMB (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408755263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ostp-ai-strategy-us-2023/" data-link-title="OSTP AI Strategy (US 2023)">OSTP AI Strategy (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408723963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ostp-workers-and-ai-us-2023/" data-link-title="OSTP Workers and AI (US 2023)">OSTP Workers and AI (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408637763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/pcast-us-2023/" data-link-title="PCAST (US 2023)">PCAST (US 2023)</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/" data-link-title="Events">Events</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1396342163" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1413238963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/washdc25aidv/" data-link-title="WashDC25AIDV">WashDC25AIDV</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1413238963" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1413384463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc25aidv/bios/" data-link-title="Bios">Bios</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1413384363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc25aidv/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412674163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/procurement/" data-link-title="Procurement">Procurement</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411274863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/unesco/" data-link-title="UNESCO">UNESCO</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1410875563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/russell/" data-link-title="Russell">Russell</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411140163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/washdc24aidv/" data-link-title="WashDC24AIDV">WashDC24AIDV</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1411140163" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1408215363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc24aidv/speakers/" data-link-title="Speakers">Speakers</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408446163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc24aidv/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409882163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/uk-ai-summit/" data-link-title="UK AI Summit">UK AI Summit</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/" data-link-title="Oct2023-DC-UGAI">Oct2023-DC-UGAI</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1409669663" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/agenda/" data-link-title="Agenda">Agenda</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409670163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/bios/" data-link-title="Bios">Bios</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/endorse/" data-link-title="Endorse">Endorse</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/messages/" data-link-title="Messages">Messages</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/papers/" data-link-title="Papers">Papers</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408550663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/sept2023-dc-roundtable/" data-link-title="Sept2023-DC-Roundtable">Sept2023-DC-Roundtable</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409264663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/may2023-dc-roundtable/" data-link-title="May2023-DC-Roundtable">May2023-DC-Roundtable</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1409264663" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1408550863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/may2023-dc-roundtable/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408157563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/" data-link-title="WashDC23AIDV">WashDC23AIDV</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1408157563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1411069663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411069563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/speakers/" data-link-title="Speakers">Speakers</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408321263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/photos/" data-link-title="Photos">Photos</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408062263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/in-congress-house-oversight/" data-link-title="In Congress (House Oversight)">In Congress (House Oversight)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406612363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/broussard/" data-link-title="Broussard">Broussard</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408081563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/brusselseffect/" data-link-title="BrusselsEffect">BrusselsEffect</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407078763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/dataactivism/" data-link-title="DataActivism">DataActivism</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406850363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/surveillancestate/" data-link-title="SurveillanceState">SurveillanceState</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401367363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/employment/" data-link-title="Employment">Employment</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1400789763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/perfectweapon/" data-link-title="PerfectWeapon">PerfectWeapon</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403001563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/aidvparis2021/" data-link-title="AIDVPARIS2021">AIDVPARIS2021</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1404136463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/codedbias/" data-link-title="CodedBias">CodedBias</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401189763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/geniusmakers/" data-link-title="Geniusmakers">Geniusmakers</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401831263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/chess/" data-link-title="Chess">Chess</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406378163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/cahai/" data-link-title="CAHAI">CAHAI</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children cc-nav-parent j-nav-parent jmd-nav__item--parent"><a href="/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1396342563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1404012663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/ai-policy-frameworks/" data-link-title="AI Policy Frameworks">AI Policy Frameworks</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1404791263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/coe-ai-treaty/" data-link-title="COE AI Treaty">COE AI Treaty</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1404493663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/eu-ai-act/" data-link-title="EU AI Act">EU AI Act</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407810363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/g7/" data-link-title="G7">G7</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408016863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/g20/" data-link-title="G20">G20</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406637063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 cc-nav-current j-nav-current jmd-nav__item--current"><a href="/resources/naiac/" data-link-title="NAIAC" class="cc-nav-current j-nav-current jmd-nav__link--current">NAIAC</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407161063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/trade-and-technology-council/" data-link-title="Trade and Technology Council">Trade and Technology Council</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409125663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/united-nations/" data-link-title="United Nations">United Nations</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401367463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/bookstore/" data-link-title="Bookstore">Bookstore</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401367663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/commentaries/" data-link-title="Commentaries">Commentaries</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407030363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/cases/" data-link-title="Cases">Cases</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1407030363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1407030563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/cases/gonzalez-v-google/" data-link-title="Gonzalez v. Google">Gonzalez v. Google</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408134963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/cases/openai/" data-link-title="OpenAI">OpenAI</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409431163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/cases/zoom/" data-link-title="Zoom">Zoom</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/" data-link-title="Transparency Project">Transparency Project</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1407003263" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/doj/" data-link-title="DOJ">DOJ</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/naiac/" data-link-title="NAIAC">NAIAC</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/ostp/" data-link-title="OSTP">OSTP</a></li></ul></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1397319363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/about-2/" data-link-title="About">About</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1397319363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1396343263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/team/" data-link-title="Team">Team</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409130863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/about-2/structure/" data-link-title="Structure">Structure</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1409130863" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1409670263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/about-2/structure/sff-application/" data-link-title="SFF Application">SFF Application</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406321763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-fall/" data-link-title="Research Group 2025 - Spring">Research Group 2025 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412876063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-fall-1/" data-link-title="Research Group 2024 - Fall">Research Group 2024 - Fall</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412023363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-summer-1/" data-link-title="Research Group 2024 - Summer">Research Group 2024 - Summer</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411472263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-spring/" data-link-title="Research Group 2024 - Spring">Research Group 2024 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1410566063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2023-fall/" data-link-title="Research Group 2023 - Fall">Research Group 2023 - Fall</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409196363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2023-summer/" data-link-title="Research Group 2023 - Summer">Research Group 2023 - Summer</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409196263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2023-spring/" data-link-title="Research Group 2023 - Spring">Research Group 2023 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407443163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2022-fall/" data-link-title="Research Group 2022 - Fall">Research Group 2022 - Fall</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403636063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2022-spring/" data-link-title="Research Group 2022 - Spring">Research Group 2022 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403804063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2021/" data-link-title="Research Group 2021">Research Group 2021</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/partners/" data-link-title="Partners">Partners</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406322463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/family-photo/" data-link-title="Family Photo">Family Photo</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406669063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/kudos/" data-link-title="Kudos">Kudos</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403393663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/contact/" data-link-title="Contact">Contact</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401461563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/global-academic-network/" data-link-title="Global Academic Network">Global Academic Network</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1401461563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1405583463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/global-academic-network/ai-policy-clinic/" data-link-title="AI Policy Clinic">AI Policy Clinic</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406851663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/awards/caidp-fellows/" data-link-title="CAIDP Fellows">CAIDP Fellows</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1405626663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/global-academic-network/extern-program/" data-link-title="Extern Program">Extern Program</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406851363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/awards/" data-link-title="Awards">Awards</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1406851363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1412679863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/awards/caidp-fellows-1/" data-link-title="CAIDP Fellows">CAIDP Fellows</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406868663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/awards/nominations/" data-link-title="Nominations">Nominations</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1402730363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0"><a href="/donate/" data-link-title="Donate">Donate</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409204263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0"><a href="/universal-guidelines-for-ai/" data-link-title="Universal Guidelines for AI">Universal Guidelines for AI</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411973763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/caidp-update/" data-link-title="CAIDP Update">CAIDP Update</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1411973763" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1411973663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-7-2025/" data-link-title="Volume 7 (2025)">Volume 7 (2025)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412975163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-6-2024-1/" data-link-title="Volume 6 (2024)">Volume 6 (2024)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411973963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-5-2023/" data-link-title="Volume 5 (2023)">Volume 5 (2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411979063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-4-2022/" data-link-title="Volume 4 (2022)">Volume 4 (2022)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/news/" data-link-title="News">News</a></li></ul></li></ul></div></div> </div> </nav> </div> </header><div class="jtpl-header--image" background-area="stripe" background-area-default=""></div>   <div class="jtpl-section-main content-options-box cc-content-parent">  <div class="jtpl-breadcrumb alignment-options"> <div class="jtpl-breadcrumb__inner flex-background-options"> <div class="jtpl-breadcrumb__title-navigation-gutter">  <div class="jtpl-title"> </div>  <div class="jtpl-breadcrumb__navigation breadcrumb-options"> <div data-container="navigation"><div class="j-nav-variant-breadcrumb"><ol itemscope="true" itemtype="http://schema.org/BreadcrumbList"><li itemscope="true" itemprop="itemListElement" itemtype="http://schema.org/ListItem"><a href="/resources/" data-link-title="Resources" itemprop="item"><span itemprop="name">Resources</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="1"/></li><li itemscope="true" itemprop="itemListElement" itemtype="http://schema.org/ListItem" class="cc-nav-current j-nav-current"><a href="/resources/naiac/" data-link-title="NAIAC" itemprop="item" class="cc-nav-current j-nav-current"><span itemprop="name">NAIAC</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="2"/></li></ol></div></div> </div> </div> </div> </div>  <div class="jtpl-content alignment-options content-options-inner cc-content-parent"> <div id="content_area" data-container="content"><div id="content_start"></div> <div id="cc-matrix-2136978463"><div id="cc-m-8417031563" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417031663" class="j-module n j-spacing "> <div class="cc-m-spacer" style="height: 50px;"> </div> </div><div id="cc-m-8417031763" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417031863" class="j-module n j-header "><h1 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417031863">National AI Advisory Committee (US)</h1></div><div id="cc-m-8417031963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417032063" class="j-module n j-hgrid "> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column" style="width: 49%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2136978563"><div id="cc-m-8417917163" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8463423263" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8463423263">News</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8463423363" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8463423663" class="j-module n j-text "><div style="box-sizing: inherit; caret-color: #293340; color: #293340; font-family: Barlow, sans-serif; font-size: 17.6px;"> <ul style="box-sizing: border-box; margin: 1.5em auto; padding-left: 20px; list-style: square; word-break: break-word; overflow-wrap: break-word;"> <li> <span style="font-size: 17.6px; box-sizing: inherit;">Meeting #7</span><span style="font-size: 17.6px; font-style: normal;">: August 3, 2023, from 12:00PM – 2:00PM ET. For more information, refer to</span><span style="font-size: 17.6px; font-style: normal;"> </span><a href="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/07/19/2023-14965/national-artificial-intelligence-advisory-committee" title="Federal Register 88 FR 46144" target="_blank" rel="noopener" style="font-size: 17.6px; font-style: normal; box-sizing: inherit; color: #8e6738; touch-action: manipulation; outline: none; font-weight: bold;">Federal Register Notice 88 FR 46144</a><span style="font-size: 17.6px; font-style: normal;">.</span> </li> </ul> <ul style="box-sizing: border-box; margin: 1.5em auto; padding-left: 20px; list-style: square; word-break: break-word; overflow-wrap: break-word;"> <li> <span style="font-size: 17.6px; font-style: normal;">Registration Link: </span><a href="https://events.nist.gov/profile/23941" title="Registration Link" style="font-size: 17.6px; font-style: normal; box-sizing: inherit; color: #8e6738; touch-action: manipulation; outline: none; font-weight: bold;" target="_top">https://events.nist.gov/profile/23941</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/NAIAC-Agenda-08032023.pdf" title="Agenda" style="font-size: 17.6px; font-style: normal; box-sizing: inherit; color: #8e6738; touch-action: manipulation; outline: none; font-weight: bold;" target="_top">Agenda</a> </li> </ul> <p> <span style="font-size: 17.6px; box-sizing: inherit; font-style: italic;"><span style="font-size: 17.6px; box-sizing: inherit; font-style: italic;">Note: there were more than 20 questions from the public submitted to the NAIAC during this open Committee Meeting but the NAIAC chose not to answer any of the questions received.</span></span> </p> </div></div><div id="cc-m-8470402163" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417032163" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417032163">Background</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417032263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417032363" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia9aa51fc089f9bbc/version/1665337633/image.png 225w" sizes="(min-width: 225px) 225px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8417032363" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia9aa51fc089f9bbc/version/1665337633/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="225" data-src-height="225" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia9aa51fc089f9bbc/version/1665337633/image.png" data-image-id="5573920663"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8417032363" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> The US <strong>National AI Advisory Committee</strong> (NAIAC) consists of expert leaders from a broad and interdisciplinary range of AI-relevant disciplines from across academia, industry, non-profits and civil society, and Federal laboratories. </p> <p> </p> <p> The NAIAC is tasked with providing an independent assessment of the Initiative and making recommendations to the President and the the National AI Initiative Office (NAIIO) on topics related to AI research and development, ethics, standards, education, technology transfer, commercial application, security, and economic competitiveness. </p> <p> </p> <p> Congress directed the NAIAC to submit a report to the President and Congress after the first year, and then again every three years, to provide the Committee’s findings and recommendations on the National AI Initiative. </p> <p> </p> <p> The National AI Advisory Committee exists within the Department of Commerce and operates in coordination with several other US agencies. The Advisory Committee was established in response to the National AI Initiative Act of 2020. The initiative directs the NAIAC to provide recommendations on topics including the current state of U.S. AI competitiveness, the state of science around AI, and AI workforce issues. The committee also is responsible for advice regarding the management and coordination of the initiative itself, including its balance of activities and funding. to the National AI Initiative Act of 2020. </p> <p> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8417032363">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8417032363,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":225,"resizeHeight":225},"id":8417032363}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8417032463" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417032563" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417032563">The Advisory Committee Charter</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417032663" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417032763" class="j-module n j-text "><p> The Advisory Committee has a <a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/84637-DOC-2021-Charter-NAIAC.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/84637-DOC-2021-Charter-NAIAC.pdf">Charter</a> that describes the work of the Committee. The Charter is divided into 14 sections: </p> <ol> <li>Committee’s Official Designation (Title) </li> <li>Authority </li> <li>Objectives and Scope of Activities </li> <li>Description of Duties </li> <li>Agency or Official to Whom the Committee Reports </li> <li>Support </li> <li>Estimated Annual Operating Costs and Staff Years </li> <li>Designated Federal Officer </li> <li>Estimated Number and Frequency of Meetings </li> <li>Duration </li> <li>Termination </li> <li>Membership and Designation </li> <li>Subcommittees </li> <li>Recordkeeping </li> </ol></div><div id="cc-m-8417032863" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417040063" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417040063">Charter - "Objectives and Scope of Activities"</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417040163" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417040263" class="j-module n j-text "><p> One of the most interesting sections of the Charter concerns the <strong>Objective and Scope of Activities.</strong> This sections states: </p> <p> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>The Committee shall provide advice to the President and the National Artificial Intelligence Initiative Office on matters related to the National Artificial Intelligence Initiative (Initiative). The purposes of the Initiative are: (1) ensuring continued United States leadership in artificial intelligence research and development; (2) leading the world in the development and use of trustworthy artificial intelligence systems in the public and private sectors; (3) preparing the present and future United States workforce for the integration of artificial intelligence systems across all sectors of the economy and society; and (4) coordinating ongoing artificial intelligence research, development, and demonstration activities among the civilian agencies, the Department of Defense, and the Intelligence Community to ensure that each informs the work of the others.</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p></div><div id="cc-m-8417040463" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417040563" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417040563">Charter - "Description of Duties"</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417040663" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417040763" class="j-module n j-text "><p> Another key section of the Charter is the Description of Duties. This section states: </p> <p> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>The Committee shall advise the President and the Initiative Office on matters related to </em><em>the Initiative, including recommendations related to:</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>a. The current state of United States competitiveness and leadership in artificial intelligence, including the scope and scale of United States investments in artificial intelligence research and development in the international context;</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>b. The progress made in implementing the Initiative, including a review of the degree to which the Initiative has achieved the goals according to the metrics established by the Interagency Committee under Section 5103(d)(2) of the Act;</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>c. The state of the science around artificial intelligence, including progress toward artificial general intelligence;</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>d. Issues related to artificial intelligence and the United States workforce, including matters relating to the potential for using artificial intelligence for workforce training, the possible consequences of technological displacement, and supporting workforce training opportunities for occupations that lead to economic self-sufficiency for individuals with barriers to employment and historically underrepresented populations, including minorities, Indians, low- income populations, and persons with disabilities;</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>e. How to leverage the resources of the Initiative to streamline and enhance operations in various areas of government operations, including health care, cybersecurity, infrastructure, and disaster recovery;</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>f. The need to update the Initiative;</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>g. The balance of activities and funding across the Initiative;</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>h. Whether the strategic plan developed or updated by the Interagency Committee </em><em> is helping to maintain United States </em><em>leadership in artificial intelligence;</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>i. The management, coordination, and activities of the Initiative;</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <span style="text-decoration: underline;"><strong><em>j. Whether ethical, legal, safety, security, and other appropriate societal issues are </em><em>adequately addressed by the Initiative;</em></strong></span> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <span style="text-decoration: underline;"><em>k. <strong>Opportunities for international cooperation with strategic allies on artificial </strong></em><strong><em>intelligence research activities, standards development, and the compatibility of </em></strong><strong><em>international regulations;</em></strong></span> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <strong><span style="text-decoration: underline;"><em>l. Accountability and legal rights, including matters relating to oversight of artificial </em></span><em><span style="text-decoration: underline;">intelligence systems using regulatory and nonregulatory approaches, the responsibility for any violations of existing laws by an artificial intelligence system, and ways to balance advancing innovation while protecting individual rights;</span> and</em></strong> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>m. How artificial intelligence can enhance opportunities for diverse geographic regions of the United States, including urban, Tribal, and rural communities.</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p> (Duties of particular interest to CAIDP are emphasized) </p></div><div id="cc-m-8417041163" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417032963" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417032963">Upcoming Events</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417033263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417033363" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417033363">Recent Events</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417033463" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8470402463" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i096dd4f6da427524/version/1691090775/image.png 224w" sizes="(min-width: 224px) 224px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8470402463" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i096dd4f6da427524/version/1691090775/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="224" data-src-height="225" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i096dd4f6da427524/version/1691090775/image.png" data-image-id="5621090863"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8470402463" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> National AI Advisory Committee (NAIAC) </p> <p> Meeting #6 </p> <p> July 19, 2023 </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/07/03/2023-14025/national-artificial-intelligence-advisory-committee" target="_blank" title="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/07/03/2023-14025/national-artificial-intelligence-advisory-committee">Federal Register Notice</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/NAIAC-Agenda-07192023.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/NAIAC-Agenda-07192023.pdf">Agenda</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="https://vimeo.com/event/3543414" target="_blank" title="https://vimeo.com/event/3543414">Video recording</a>] </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8470402463">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8470402463,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":224,"resizeHeight":225},"id":8470402463}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8470402563" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8470402763" class="j-module n j-text "><p> National AI Advisory Committee (NAIAC) </p> <p> Meetig #5 </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/06/07/2023-12164/national-artificial-intelligence-advisory-committee" target="_blank" title="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/06/07/2023-12164/national-artificial-intelligence-advisory-committee">Federal Register Notice</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/NAIAC-Agenda-06202023.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/NAIAC-Agenda-06202023.pdf">Agenda</a>] </p> <p> June 20, 22, 27, 2023 </p> <ul style="box-sizing: border-box; margin: 0px auto; padding-left: 2em; list-style-position: outside; list-style-image: initial; word-break: break-word; overflow-wrap: break-word; caret-color: #293340; color: #293340; font-family: Barlow, sans-serif; font-size: 16.5px;"> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px;"> <ul style="box-sizing: border-box; margin: 0px auto; padding-left: 20px; list-style: outside disc; word-break: break-word; overflow-wrap: break-word;"> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px; font-size: 0.8em;">Invited Experts (in alphabetical order): American Association of People with Disabilities; Asian Americans Advancing Justice; Hispanic Technology & Telecommunications Partnership; National Association for the Advancement of Colored People; National Fair Housing Alliance; The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights; UnidosUS </li> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px;"> <a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/NAIAC-Minutes-06202023.pdf" title="Minutes" target="_blank" rel="noopener" class="" tabindex="0" aria-hidden="false" style="box-sizing: inherit; color: #8e6738; touch-action: manipulation; outline: none; font-weight: bold;">Minutes</a> </li> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px;"> <a href="https://cdnapisec.kaltura.com/index.php/extwidget/preview/partner_id/684682/uiconf_id/31013851/entry_id/1_neqyihky/embed/dynamic" title="Video Recording" class="exitNotifierLink" tabindex="0" aria-hidden="false" style="box-sizing: inherit; color: #8e6738; touch-action: manipulation; outline: none; font-weight: bold;" target="_top">Video Recording</a> </li> </ul> </li> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px;">June 22, 2023: 2:00PM – 3:00PM ET. <ul style="box-sizing: border-box; margin: 0px auto; padding-left: 20px; list-style: outside disc; word-break: break-word; overflow-wrap: break-word;"> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px; font-size: 0.8em;">Invited Experts (in alphabetical order): Algorithmic Justice League; American Civil Liberties Union; Center for Democracy and Technology; Creative Commons; Fight for the Future; Greenlining; Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law; Legal Defense Fund; The People’s Tech Project </li> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px;"> <a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/NAIAC-Minutes-06222023.pdf" title="Minutes" target="_blank" rel="noopener" class="" tabindex="0" aria-hidden="false" style="box-sizing: inherit; color: #8e6738; touch-action: manipulation; outline: none; font-weight: bold;">Minutes</a> </li> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px;"> <a href="https://cdnapisec.kaltura.com/index.php/extwidget/preview/partner_id/684682/uiconf_id/31013851/entry_id/1_br83t4e5/embed/dynamic" title="Video Recording" class="exitNotifierLink" tabindex="0" aria-hidden="false" style="box-sizing: inherit; color: #8e6738; touch-action: manipulation; outline: none; font-weight: bold;" target="_top">Video Recording</a> </li> </ul> </li> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px;">June 27, 2023: 2:00PM – 3:00PM ET. <ul style="box-sizing: border-box; margin: 0px auto; padding-left: 20px; list-style: outside disc; word-break: break-word; overflow-wrap: break-word;"> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px; font-size: 0.8em;">Invited Experts (in alphabetical order): LatinX in AI; Black in AI; Queer In AI; Women in AI; Indigenous in AI </li> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px;"> <a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/NAIAC-Minutes-06272023-A.pdf" title="Minutes" target="_blank" rel="noopener" class="" tabindex="0" aria-hidden="false" style="box-sizing: inherit; color: #8e6738; touch-action: manipulation; outline: none; font-weight: bold;">Minutes</a> </li> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px;"> <a href="https://cdnapisec.kaltura.com/index.php/extwidget/preview/partner_id/684682/uiconf_id/31013851/entry_id/1_47f1l9nl/embed/dynamic" title="Video Recording" class="exitNotifierLink" tabindex="0" aria-hidden="false" style="box-sizing: inherit; color: #8e6738; touch-action: manipulation; outline: none; font-weight: bold;" target="_top">Video Recording</a> </li> </ul> </li> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px;">June 27, 2023: 3:30PM – 4:30PM ET. <ul style="box-sizing: border-box; margin: 0px auto; padding-left: 20px; list-style: outside disc; word-break: break-word; overflow-wrap: break-word;"> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px; font-size: 0.8em;">Invited Experts (in alphabetical order): American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations; American Federation of Teachers; Communications Workers of America Union; Department for Professional Employees AFL-CIO; International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers; International Federation of Professional and Technical Engineers AFL-CIO & CLC; Wessel Group </li> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px;"> <a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/NAIAC-Minutes-06272023-B.pdf" title="Minutes" target="_blank" rel="noopener" class="" tabindex="0" aria-hidden="false" style="box-sizing: inherit; color: #8e6738; touch-action: manipulation; outline: none; font-weight: bold;">Minutes</a> </li> <li style="box-sizing: inherit; margin: 8px 0px 6px;"> <a href="https://cdnapisec.kaltura.com/index.php/extwidget/preview/partner_id/684682/uiconf_id/31013851/entry_id/1_wxfcaxiv/embed/dynamic" title="Video Recording" class="exitNotifierLink" tabindex="0" aria-hidden="false" style="box-sizing: inherit; color: #8e6738; touch-action: manipulation; outline: none; font-weight: bold;" target="_top">Video Recording</a> </li> </ul> </li> </ul></div><div id="cc-m-8470402963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8455096963" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=299x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i01cf0a51a7f775c4/version/1682434481/image.jpg 299w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i01cf0a51a7f775c4/version/1682434481/image.jpg 300w" sizes="(min-width: 299px) 299px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8455096963" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=299x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i01cf0a51a7f775c4/version/1682434481/image.jpg" alt="" class="" data-src-width="300" data-src-height="168" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=299x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i01cf0a51a7f775c4/version/1682434481/image.jpg" data-image-id="5606424363"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8455096963" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> National AI Advisory Committee (NAIAC) </p> <p> Meetig #4 </p> <p> April 25, 2023 </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/03/27/2023-06271/national-artificial-intelligence-advisory-committee" target="_blank" title="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/03/27/2023-06271/national-artificial-intelligence-advisory-committee">Federal Register Notice</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/NAIAC-Agenda-04252023.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/NAIAC-Agenda-04252023.pdf">Agenda</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/NAIAC-Report-Year1.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/NAIAC-Report-Year1.pdf">(Final Draft) National Artificial Intelligence Advisory Committee (NAIAC) Report: Year l, April 2023</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="/app/download/8445403363/CAIDP-Statement-NAIAC-03032023.pdf?t=1689966221" title="CAIDP-Statement-NAIAC-03032023.pdf" target="_top">CAIDP Statement, March 30, 2023</a>] </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8455096963">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8455096963,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"299","resizeHeight":168},"id":8455096963}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8470401963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8441164663" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=268x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/id26ac9527aa34627/version/1676126992/image.png 268w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/id26ac9527aa34627/version/1676126992/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=536x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/id26ac9527aa34627/version/1676126992/image.png 536w" sizes="(min-width: 268px) 268px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8441164663" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=268x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/id26ac9527aa34627/version/1676126992/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="960" data-src-height="637" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=268x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/id26ac9527aa34627/version/1676126992/image.png" data-image-id="5594895663"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8441164663" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> National AI Advisory Committee (NAIAC) Field Hearing and Committee Meeting </p> <p> SAS Institute </p> <p> Meeting #3 </p> <p> February 10, 2023 </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2023-01-06/pdf/2023-00026.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2023-01-06/pdf/2023-00026.pdf">Federal Register notice</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/NAIAC-Agenda-02102023.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/NAIAC-Agenda-02102023.pdf">Agenda</a>] </p> <p> </p> <p> <i>No additional information regarding the activities of the Committee or the proposed recommendations to the President and the Congress were made available to the public, in a violation of the Federal Advisory Committee Act and the Federal Freedom of Information Act.</i> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8441164663">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8441164663,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"268","resizeHeight":178},"id":8441164663}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8441165663" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417041963" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4076178d727aa7c6/version/1665337527/image.jpg 271w" sizes="(min-width: 271px) 271px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8417041963" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4076178d727aa7c6/version/1665337527/image.jpg" alt="" class="" data-src-width="271" data-src-height="186" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4076178d727aa7c6/version/1665337527/image.jpg" data-image-id="5573924063"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8417041963" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> National AI Advisory Committee (NAIAC) Field Hearing and Committee Meeting </p> <p> Stanford University </p> <p> Meeting #2 </p> <p> October 12-13, 2022 </p> <p> [<a href="https://events.nist.gov/profile/form/index.cfm?PKformID=0x17861abcd" target="_blank" title="https://events.nist.gov/profile/form/index.cfm?PKformID=0x17861abcd">Registration</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/NAIAC-Agenda-10122022.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/NAIAC-Agenda-10122022.pdf">Agenda</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="https://youtu.be/wlmLuHnAD1A" target="_blank" title="https://youtu.be/wlmLuHnAD1A">Livestream - Oct 12</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="https://youtu.be/5Bs8ZrGIwV4" target="_blank" title="https://youtu.be/5Bs8ZrGIwV4">Livestream - Oct 13</a>] </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8417041963">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8417041963,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":271,"resizeHeight":186},"id":8417041963}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8418117963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417042663" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/iec69bf92bea3a167/version/1665337621/image.jpg 224w" sizes="(min-width: 224px) 224px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8417042663" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/iec69bf92bea3a167/version/1665337621/image.jpg" alt="" class="" data-src-width="224" data-src-height="225" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/iec69bf92bea3a167/version/1665337621/image.jpg" data-image-id="5573924863"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8417042663" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> National AI Advisory Committee </p> <p> Washington, DC </p> <p> Meeting #1 </p> <p> May 4, 2022 </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/NAIAC-Agenda-05042022.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/NAIAC-Agenda-05042022.pdf">Agenda</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/NAIAC-Minutes-05042022.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/NAIAC-Minutes-05042022.pdf">Minutes</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="https://www.youtube.com/embed/Uq-CydVwLDw" target="_blank" title="https://www.youtube.com/embed/Uq-CydVwLDw">Video recording</a>] </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8417042663">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8417042663,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":224,"resizeHeight":225},"id":8417042663}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8417034063" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417034563" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417034563">News</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417034663" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417044363" class="j-module n j-text "><ul> <li>Fedscoop, <a href="https://www.fedscoop.com/nist-sole-sources-ida-support-naiac/" target="_blank" title="https://www.fedscoop.com/nist-sole-sources-ida-support-naiac/">Institute for Defense Analyses expected to support National AI Advisory Committee</a> (July 22, 2022) </li> <li>Meritalk, <a href="https://www.meritalk.com/articles/national-ai-advisory-committee-sets-working-groups-vision/" target="_blank" title="https://www.meritalk.com/articles/national-ai-advisory-committee-sets-working-groups-vision/">National AI Advisory Committee Sets Working Groups, Vision</a> (May 5, 2022) </li> <li>Fedscoop, <a href="https://www.fedscoop.com/naiac-establishes-working-groups/" target="_blank" title="https://www.fedscoop.com/naiac-establishes-working-groups/">National AI Advisory Committee establishes 5 working groups</a> (May 4, 2022) </li> <li>Government Technology, <a href="https://www.govtech.com/products/who-serves-on-the-new-national-ai-advisory-committee" target="_blank" title="https://www.govtech.com/products/who-serves-on-the-new-national-ai-advisory-committee">Who Serves on the New National AI Advisory Committee?</a> (April 15, 2022) </li> </ul></div><div id="cc-m-8417034863" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417034963" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417034963">NAIAC Announcements</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417035063" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417043763" class="j-module n j-text "><ul> <li>NAIAC, <a href="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/09/26/2022-20801/national-artificial-intelligence-advisory-committee" target="_blank" title="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/09/26/2022-20801/national-artificial-intelligence-advisory-committee">Request for Public Comments</a> (September 26, 2022) </li> <li>NAIAC, <a href="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/04/19/2022-08319/national-artificial-intelligence-advisory-committee" target="_blank" title="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/04/19/2022-08319/national-artificial-intelligence-advisory-committee">Request for Public Comments</a> (April 19, 2022) </li> <li>Department of Commerce, <a href="https://www.commerce.gov/news/press-releases/2022/04/us-department-commerce-appoints-27-members-national-ai-advisory" target="_blank" title="https://www.commerce.gov/news/press-releases/2022/04/us-department-commerce-appoints-27-members-national-ai-advisory">U.S. Department of Commerce Appoints 27 Members to National AI Advisory Committee</a> (April 14, 2022) </li> <li>NAIAC, <a href="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/NAIAC-FAQ-09212021.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.ai.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/NAIAC-FAQ-09212021.pdf">Nominations FAQ</a> </li> </ul></div><div id="cc-m-8418118263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-separator" data-display="cms-only"><div></div></div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column last" style="width: 49%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2136978663"><div id="cc-m-8417917063" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417035663" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417035663">CAIDP Statements to NAIAC</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417035763" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417046963" class="j-module n j-text "><ul> <li> <a href="/app/download/8424747863/CAIDP-NAIAC-FACA-10282022.pdf?t=1708386276" title="CAIDP-NAIAC-FACA-10282022.pdf" target="_top">CAIDP Statement to the NAIAC (October 28, 2022)</a> (excerpts) </li> </ul> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>We write to you now to raise specific concerns about the NAIAC’s failure to comply with the Federal Advisory Committee Act. . . .</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>We remain in support of the mission of the NAIAC, but we are now deeply concerned about the operation of the Advisory Committee. <strong>We urge you to take the actions detailed below to provide the necessary transparency, accountability, and public participation that the development of a report for the President on AI policy requires.</strong> . . .</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <strong><em>We request a formal response to this letter by Friday, November 11, 2022</em></strong> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>1. Post All of the Documents made Available or Prepared for Advisory Committee Members </em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>2. Provide a Meaningful Opportunity for Public Participation in the Work of the Advisory Committee</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>3. Establish the AI and Law Enforcement Subcommittee</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>4. Provide a Justification for Hiring a Private Contractor to Write the NAIAC Report or Simply have Advisory Committee Members to Write their Report</em> </p> <ul> <li>C<a href="/app/download/8416257463/CAIDP-NAIAC-10042022.pdf?t=1676126938" title="CAIDP-NAIAC-10042022.pdf" target="_top">AIDP Statement to the NAIAC</a> (October 4, 2022) (excerpts) </li> </ul> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>The Center for AI and Digital Policy (CAIDP) welcomes the opportunity to express our views for the upcoming meeting of the National Artificial Intelligence Advisory Committee (NAIAC). . . .</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>We write first to express support for the Blueprint for an AI Bill of Rights, announced at the White House this week. Implementation of the AI Bill of Rights will help counter bias and protect fundamental rights in the design and deployment of AI-based systems in in the United States. We have worked for almost a year in support of the AI Bill of Rights. . . .</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>The mandate of the NAIAC includes also “opportunities for international cooperation.” . . . We believe the White House should commit to a plan to implement the OECD AI Principles and we recommend that you propose this in your report.</em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <i>We call your attention to the 2021Joint Statement by the EU-US Trade and Technology Council. Trade negotiators committed “to foster responsible stewardship of trustworthy AI” and “to ensure that AI serves our societies and economies and that it is used in ways consistent with our common democratic values and human rights.” The EU-US Joint Statement also emphasized the need to adopt “policy and regulatory measures.” </i> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>Finally, we hope you will provide a meaningful opportunity for public comment on the draft report you propose to send to the President and Congress.</em> </p></div><div id="cc-m-8417035963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417871663" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417871663">CAIDP, AI and Democratic Values report (2022)</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417871963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417878763" class="j-module n j-header "><h3 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417878763">United States country report (excerpt)</h3></div><div id="cc-m-8417878863" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417873063" class="j-module n j-text "><p> <strong>Evaluation</strong> </p> <p> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <em>The US lacks a unified national policy on AI but President Biden, and his top advisors, has expressed support for AI aligned with democratic values. The United States has endorsed the OECD/G20 AI Principles. The White House has issued two Executive Orders on AI that reflect democratic values, a federal directive encourages agencies to adopt safeguards for AI, The most recent Executive Order also establishes a process for public participation in the development of federal regulations on AI though the rulemaking has yet to occur. The overall US policy-making process remains opaque and the Federal Trade Commission has failed to act on several pending complaints concerning the deployment of AI techniques in the commercial sector. But the administration has launched new initiatives and encouraged the OSTP, NIST, and other agencies to gather public input. There is widespread objection to the use of facial recognition, and both Facebook and the IRS have cancelled facial recognition systems, following widespread protests. But concerns remain about the use of facial surveillance technology across the federal agencies by such US companies as Clearview AI. The absence of a legal framework to implement AI safeguards and a federal agency to safeguard privacy also raises concerns about the ability of the US to monitor AI practices.</em> </p></div><div id="cc-m-8417878663" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417048963" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417048963">Other Public Comments</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417036463" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417849463" class="j-module n j-text "><p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px; text-align: center;"> <i>As of October 13, 2022, it does not appear that the NAIAC has posted the the Public Comments received as required by the Federal Advisory Committee Act.</i> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px; text-align: center;"> <i>UPDATE - Following the <a href="/app/download/8420970963/CAIDP-NAIAC-FACA-10282022.pdf?t=1725365713" title="CAIDP-NAIAC-FACA-10282022.pdf" target="_top">October 28 letter from CAIDP to the NAIAC</a>, the public comments received for the October meeting were posted on the NAIAC website. According to the NAIAC, only four public comments were received for a public consultation on the nation's AI strategy. The public comments for the April meeting still have not been posted.</i> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p></div><div id="cc-m-8417038263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417849663" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417849663">Meeting Records</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417849963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417850063" class="j-module n j-text "><p style="padding-left: 30px;"> <span style="font-size: 24px;">[??]</span> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;"> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px; text-align: center;"> <em><span style="font-size: 15px;">As of October 13, 2022, it does not appear that the NAIAC has posted the Meeting Records as required by the Federal Advisory Committee Act</span></em> </p> <p style="padding-left: 30px; text-align: center;"> </p></div><div id="cc-m-8417850363" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417849263" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417849263">Federal Advisory Committee Act</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417849363" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417850763" class="j-module n j-text "><p> "The <a href="https://www.gsa.gov/policy-regulations/policy/federal-advisory-committee-management/legislation-and-regulations/the-federal-advisory-committee-act" target="_blank" title="https://www.gsa.gov/policy-regulations/policy/federal-advisory-committee-management/legislation-and-regulations/the-federal-advisory-committee-act">Federal Advisory Committee Act</a> (FACA) governs the operation of federal advisory committees and emphasizes public involvement through open meetings and reporting. Meetings must be announced in the Federal Register. Reports, transcripts, working papers, and other materials made available to or prepared for or by the committees must be made available to the public." </p> <p> </p> <p> From the Act: </p> <ul> <li>"the Congress and the public should be kept informed with respect to the number, purpose, membership, activities, and cost of advisory committees"; Sec. 2(b)(5) </li> <li>"The President may delegate responsibility for evaluating and taking action, where appropriate, with respect to all public recommendations made to him by Presidential advisory committees." Sec. 6(a) </li> <li>"Within one year after a Presidential advisory committee has submitted a public report to the President, the President or his delegate shall make a report to the Congress stating either his proposals for action or his reasons for inaction, with respect to the recommendations contained in the public report." Sec. 6(b) </li> <li>"Interested persons shall be permitted to attend, appear before, or file statements with any advisory committee, subject to such reasonable rules or regulations as the Administrator may prescribe." Sec. 10(a)(3). </li> <li>". . . the records, reports, transcripts, minutes, appendixes, working papers, drafts, studies, agenda, or other documents which were made available to or prepared for or by each advisory committee shall be available for public inspection and copying at a single location in the offices of the advisory committee or the agency to which the advisory committee reports until the advisory committee ceases to exist." Sec. (10)(b) </li> <li>"Detailed minutes of each meeting of each advisory committee shall be kept and shall contain a record of the persons present, a complete and accurate description of matters discussed and conclusions reached, and copies of all reports received, issued, or approved by the advisory committee. The accuracy of all minutes shall be certified to by the chairman of the advisory committee." Sec. 10(c) </li> </ul></div><div id="cc-m-8417850963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417916363" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8417916363">Status of AI and Law Enforcement Subcommittee [??]</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8417916563" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8417916663" class="j-module n j-text "><p> Pursuant to Section 5104(e) of the Act, the Committee’s Chairperson shall establish a subcommittee that shall provide advice to the President, through the Committee, on matters relating to the development of artificial intelligence relating to law enforcement, including advice on the following: </p> <p> </p> <p> a. <strong>Bias</strong>, including whether the use of facial recognition by government authorities, including law enforcement agencies, is taking into account ethical considerations and addressing whether such use should be subject to additional oversight, controls, and limitations. </p> <p> </p> <p> b. <strong>Security of data</strong>, including law enforcement’s access to data and the security parameters for that data. </p> <p> </p> <p> c. <strong>Adoptability</strong>, including methods to allow the United States Government and industry to take advantage of artificial intelligence systems for security or law enforcement purposes while at the same time ensuring the potential abuse of such technologies is sufficiently mitigated. </p> <p> </p> <p> d. <strong>Legal standards,</strong> including those designed to ensure the use of artificial intelligence systems are consistent with the privacy rights, civil rights and civil liberties, and disability rights issues raised by the use of these technologies. </p> <p> </p> <p style="text-align: center;"> <i>At some point in 2023, members of the Law Enforcement subcommittee were</i> <a href="https://www.ai.gov/naiac/naiac-le-member-biographies/" target="_blank" title="https://www.ai.gov/naiac/naiac-le-member-biographies/" style="font-style: italic;">posted</a> <i>to the NAIAC site, though as of August 3, 2023, there was still no information about the work of this committee which was mandated by Congress in 2020.</i> </p> <p> </p></div><div id="cc-m-8417916963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8418118963" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8418118963">Private Contractor to Develop NAIAC Recommendations [??]</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8418119163" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8418119263" class="j-module n j-imageSubtitle "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-3"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i8034aaf1f43cf827/version/1665796925/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=459x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i8034aaf1f43cf827/version/1665796925/image.png 459w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=640x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i8034aaf1f43cf827/version/1665796925/image.png 640w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=918x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i8034aaf1f43cf827/version/1665796925/image.png 918w" sizes="(min-width: 459px) 459px, 100vw" id="cc-m-imagesubtitle-image-8418119263" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=459x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i8034aaf1f43cf827/version/1665796925/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1452" data-src-height="1046" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=459x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i8034aaf1f43cf827/version/1665796925/image.png" data-image-id="5574981263"/> </figure> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8418119263">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_imageSubtitle", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8418119263,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"459","resizeHeight":331},"id":8418119263}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8418119363" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8418119463" class="j-module n j-text "><p> On July 21, 2022, the <strong>National Institute of Standards and Technology</strong> <a href="https://sam.gov/opp/6d90f3d847464460833766dc3b288124/view" target="_blank" title="https://sam.gov/opp/6d90f3d847464460833766dc3b288124/view">announced</a> that it would provide a sole source contract to the <strong>Institute for Defense Analyses, Inc</strong> (IDA) for "synthesizing meetings; conducting research; collaborating with NAIAC staff and collaborators on research; and producing technical analysis of the committee’s findings, and recommendations." Specifically: </p> <p> </p> <p> <strong>Task 1:</strong> The Contractor shall conduct research using a variety of qualitative and quantitative methods as requested by the full NAIAC, its working groups, and Subcommittee on topic areas pertaining to the duties enumerated in the Act. </p> <p> </p> <p> <strong>Task 2:</strong> The Contractor shall draft NAIAC reports that include the advice and recommendations pertaining to the statutory duties of the NAIAC and its Subcommittee, derived from Contractor research and analysis, meeting synthesis, and input from the Committee, working group, and Subcommittee members, and NAIAC support staff in an agreed upon format deemed acceptable by the COR. </p> <p> </p> <p> <strong>Task 3:</strong> The Contractor shall prepare a fact sheet or memo with pertinent information related to the meeting or topic area being discussed in advance of NAIAC, working group, or Subcommittee meetings. The COR/TPOC will advise the Contractor if a fact sheet or memo will be needed and the completion date for any deliverables will be mutually determined by the Contractor and COR. </p> <p> </p> <p> <strong>Task 4:</strong> The Contractor shall attend full NAIAC, working group, and subcommittee meetings to synthesize conclusions and consolidate findings and recommendations into an outline as a basis for the interim report for the NAIAC’s review and approval. </p> <p> </p> <p> <strong>Task 5:</strong> Once approved, the contractor shall develop an interim report based on the outline in collaboration with NAIAC for the committee’s review and approval. </p> <p> </p> <p> <strong>Task 6:</strong> (Optional Task): The contractor shall provide the interim report to a technical review board for review/comments. The contractor shall assist the Government with drafting a Request for Information (RFI) for public comments. </p> <p> </p> <p> <strong>Task 7:</strong> The contractor shall finalize the report based on the feedback gathered for the NAIAC’s review and approval. </p> <p> </p> <p style="text-align: center;"> <em>As of October 13, 2022, the NAIAC has provided no justification for the decision to hire a private contractor to write the Advisory Committee report</em> </p> <p> </p></div><div id="cc-m-8418119563" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-overlay" data-display="cms-only"></div> <br class="cc-clear"/> </div></div> </div> </div>  </div>  <div class="jtpl-section-aside"> <aside class="jtpl-sidebar sidebar-options"><div class="jtpl-sidebar__inner alignment-options"> <div data-container="sidebar"><div id="cc-matrix-2099356263"><div id="cc-m-8224769863" class="j-module n j-hgrid "> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column" style="width: 31.17%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2099356563"><div id="cc-m-8224769963" class="j-module n j-imageSubtitle "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=305x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i28ab272ab408a3ce/version/1596465196/image.png 305w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i28ab272ab408a3ce/version/1596465196/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=610x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i28ab272ab408a3ce/version/1596465196/image.png 610w" sizes="(min-width: 305px) 305px, 100vw" id="cc-m-imagesubtitle-image-8224769963" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=305x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i28ab272ab408a3ce/version/1596465196/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="768" data-src-height="221" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=305x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i28ab272ab408a3ce/version/1596465196/image.png" data-image-id="5419814763"/> </figure> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8224769963">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_imageSubtitle", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"_blank","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8224769963,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"305","resizeHeight":88},"id":8224769963}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8428107663" class="j-module n j-search "><div class="j-search-wrapper j-search-alignment-0"> <div class="j-search-content" style="width: 100%;"> <form action="/search" class="j-formnew"> <span class="cc-m-form-view-sortable"> <input type="text" class="j-search-input" aria-label="Search" name="q" placeholder="Search" value=""/> <input type="hidden" name="filter" value="0"/> <input type="hidden" name="module" value="8428107663"/> <button type="submit" style="display: none"/> </span> </form> </div> </div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8428107663">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_search", {"alignment":"0","width":"100","filter":"0","placeholder":"Search","id":8428107663}); // ]]> </script></div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-separator" data-display="cms-only"><div></div></div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column" style="width: 20.53%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2099356663"><div id="cc-m-8224770063" class="j-module n j-text "><p style="text-align: left;"> <a href="/" title="Home"><span style="font-size: 15px;">Home</span></a> </p> <p style="text-align: left;"> <a href="/news/" title="News"><span style="font-size: 15px;">News</span></a> </p> <p style="text-align: left;"> <a href="/statements/" title="Statements"><span style="font-size: 15px;">Statements</span></a> </p> <p style="text-align: left;"> <a href="/reports/" title="Reports"><span style="font-size: 15px;">Reports</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/public-voice/" title="Public Voice"><span style="font-size: 15px;">Public Voice</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/events/" title="Events"><span style="font-size: 15px;">Events</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/about-2/team/" title="Team"><span style="font-size: 15px; color: #ffffff;">Team</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/about-2/" title="About"><span style="font-size: 15px; color: #ffffff;">About</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="https://www.nfggive.org/guidestar/86-3350258" target="_blank" title="https://www.nfggive.org/guidestar/86-3350258"><span style="font-size: 15px; color: #ffffff;">Donate</span></a> </p></div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-separator" data-display="cms-only"><div></div></div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column" style="width: 26.71%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2099356763"><div id="cc-m-8224770163" class="j-module n j-text "><p> <a href="/reports/aidv-2021/" title="AIDV-2021"><span style="font-size: 15px;">AI and Democratic Values (2024)</span></a> </p> <p> <span style="font-size: 15px;"><a href="/global-academic-network/" title="Global Academic Network">Global Academic Network</a></span> </p> <p> <a href="/global-academic-network/ai-policy-clinic/" title="AI Policy Clinic">AI Policy Clinic</a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/resources/" title="Resources"><span style="font-size: 15px;">Resources</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/resources/eu-ai-act/" title="EU AI Act"><span style="font-size: 15px;">- EU AI Act</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/resources/coe-ai-treaty/" title="COE AI Treaty"><span style="font-size: 15px;">- Council of Europe AI Treaty</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <span style="font-size: 15px; color: #ffffff;">- UNESCO Recommendation on AI Ethics</span> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <span style="font-size: 15px; color: #ffffff;">- <a href="/universal-guidelines-for-ai/" title="Universal Guidelines for AI">Universal Guidelines for AI</a></span> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> </p></div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-separator" data-display="cms-only"><div></div></div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column last" style="width: 15.56%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2099356863"><div id="cc-m-8410182163" class="j-module n j-imageSubtitle "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <a href="/donate/"><img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=172x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i5e3cff7b054c4fe8/version/1661959271/image.png 172w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i5e3cff7b054c4fe8/version/1661959271/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=344x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i5e3cff7b054c4fe8/version/1661959271/image.png 344w" sizes="(min-width: 172px) 172px, 100vw" id="cc-m-imagesubtitle-image-8410182163" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=172x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i5e3cff7b054c4fe8/version/1661959271/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="598" data-src-height="388" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=172x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i5e3cff7b054c4fe8/version/1661959271/image.png" data-image-id="5567259863"/></a> </figure> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8410182163">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_imageSubtitle", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"\/app\/s899a9742c3d83292\/p6ba1de820b560af4\/","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"Donate","pinterest":"0","id":8410182163,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"172","resizeHeight":112},"id":8410182163}); // ]]> </script></div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-overlay" data-display="cms-only"></div> <br class="cc-clear"/> </div></div></div> </div> </aside><footer class="jtpl-footer footer-options"><div class="jtpl-footer__inner alignment-options"> <div id="contentfooter" data-container="footer"> <div class="j-meta-links"> <a href="/about/">About</a> | <a href="//www.caidp.org/j/privacy">Privacy Policy</a><br/>Copyright © 2020-2023 Center for AI and Digital Policy </div> <div class="j-admin-links"> <span class="loggedin"> <a rel="nofollow" id="logout" target="_top" href="https://cms.e.jimdo.com/app/cms/logout.php"> Log out </a> | <a rel="nofollow" id="edit" target="_top" href="https://a.jimdo.com/app/auth/signin/jumpcms/?page=1406637063">Edit</a> </span> </div> </div> </div> </footer> </div>  <div class="jtpl-cart"> </div>  </div>  </div> <ul class="cc-FloatingButtonBarContainer cc-FloatingButtonBarContainer-left hidden">  <li class="cc-FloatingButtonBarContainer-button-scroll"> <a href="javascript:void(0);" title="Scroll to top"> <span>Scroll to top</span> </a> </li> <script>// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("common_scrolltotop", []); // ]]> </script> </ul> <script type="text/javascript"> //<![CDATA[ addAutomatedTracking('creator.website', track_anon); //]]> </script> </body> </html>