CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.science.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e72654858a9ce73',cH: 's4l.yE5OyphmcfuJMSNvTPsMyCdCNp7pYHNztj.MGmc-1732377872-1.2.1.1-T18jEK1_ECvx.X1yklWL.exGLHREPd96H_oPS92eezAeBAGF3XtcUjKs_.2Q4E3d',cUPMDTk: "\/doi\/10.1126\/science.289.5483.1307?__cf_chl_tk=mI1huyr2bvzuwLtb1sMQ1Jud4M0_RPHJp8mCUDWroyY-1732377872-1.0.1.1-NGfy64l0Hx4Y5tDipyS63qpOkAKZmfsKJ8KaqWv1N.I",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732377872',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/doi\/10.1126\/science.289.5483.1307?__cf_chl_f_tk=mI1huyr2bvzuwLtb1sMQ1Jud4M0_RPHJp8mCUDWroyY-1732377872-1.0.1.1-NGfy64l0Hx4Y5tDipyS63qpOkAKZmfsKJ8KaqWv1N.I",md: "Q7nncQjRy0Y.zcF3Z.VBAf3mr7U2.N64Rk6drBAUfB0-1732377872-1.2.1.1-X6Lq0mv1ALDlsYviT4a4rNEFtkTvfiSJZ43muJjfSyHjDx6VBL_EdaHSERiEil348TNxM8Kwxd8_qs36MFsTKOp.tyLQKVANutY8xb1HXpHf73AGRvXHORJbn9dBFbi8LRZqVFEKZ8sB9uAaQEituuyEieDkM7g.WBGwq_DzVW15p2clmOwGlL07lLGauKetfoaOE69jCG7pi792uBSYHvkSrMf_iurk2sETNQA3dgGPekHbS_DVnQm8RJOZgnBqN9pEpjZjIjuS03LjHM8.LR3uEaPpYpIQylokJysLI6hE1zHXabGw1tREonviAUmtXu7JnMubRHtCTQiWD.6Nxy9XYMbx251c0WA0uitH56lTZMh4XaDwH7DMy4ABTsn8sui19ftgddUXXQD2pkrBj_9R5A5XGC1G3Cc_7Lkr6.xnPR4sy.STW81RRs5f529FisMRRJS6rb7MRIsagad_dIdV6_YD.pEZcuA_si8S2GsnY6gR6AOhcPCEtAu0pJY7lNBto9VG_0crvlZ.vaHE3Eha82_a9eVD3PAZrCdl93kU1r1k4IKSekrWCJzhTLcmZ0sbiTPJULFlFF9gb2H_6V3mbtvcJJ22SvTJIBfOKJBBsvJFKaVAnMDCQhCobsQt6K0Y58GkZPlLjbsTT2ZulGIt8Mt5v70H9QSg11vwUj1Eq6.nltMLymudWv.4d8lqjN_LzPAPwpUeITJsWs9ijIPlsTPcSd9MnNG_kX_DMLaAzPovQxVwed2Pu09aVuzKuNa0KDXkwk1NiKHY_Qx1KxCaZenmCp5tg0g.BWMxibJMEP4tphhl6xvsmMTbmcviuW4UCHR_g9cSPnAmUwgbLtC1SeKX5eQD5wbXu98BXy8o_uxlFYalLC8ooqcrbPYF44V8ko6.8SgADwCcruP2Hm_9ohyCCIEE6r.STNM7U0XrCnsH9DRGPtb6Jsrqpvwzrgu0wvLRmhkgt..Nk3Jd3jdZuN7fsU65o_z8cubIgDh9D6Fg14h.D4mtoz7ann2HARLi3jUwmT_K_arrtLRDlghHOc8yDB4TGfECTdJnPH8zZmbdPo2zQrd1qr.vVza5F5EFY_r2MpBvvYmRgr5nPGS_MhgOgF_6PIlCH66opODBLBBBo7Y4sj_8gNywrkb9xYJpD4esdv2Jc.wEFME486LuzBp3waK4lPbWm80JP98zJ6h.bJ84USzbOp2JrR9.u1_aQ2Vd7TLxBrmqGYofBfW9wcWgChbJiMuQd2p0PaTkg_deOeUv8dYLw_E2_.jC8p58XAZdm9gtUO6GkG6GY9xjmKZ1sw6vHT3tQeWViNftSyDlJKfjLXhaVIwKu2swhVPgAPuCpmhfmStFN8pj3BvHYo4CLGCD2T.pdoudpg90vu_XzplO1r.CEVm7nzi021OoF6mcOuphOPcR33Fr8u4i9uyzajzf75R95spKLDU5Soo6g0AYWeLZDKpOFWECigLPe7HI0dfG2y1BXk73X_LYNja.8fUdsKKUQSdP6_Dsf5xYU2vXxpVKmlnpSdPPyUmuJu2tS1YBuSttQumhKgqA07D7k9NYRsIB20s3lB7PDosKnlsSIaOrN8509L5cCudiTvGOhoAn7t2c4nv6kfOW.iBMTMuFhcsUNyZBIu5sDdiovvv7EOhJ.d_X1TzF15Wu6Dleqh8TvqCgMaxophIZlEG5Aj.uFgp1nKjKz8vOPMUOxGLn0Mu5l7lOV6Z47itsJcpHuZ63NiZQ1Qi7Iw7QMirt1yjqQxzrZjAY8hgBhuAM26L4bFk5sl_LRXAOjtQVNmWM8c7qXcRELE_MA_Q1I05c7KYfJggtX7C7.CgdxFjucy6Yi2Q0zRHqynsl0cz0dlTTbjLITtVD0LaLaW7ieOIKfSd20x3TuJEit1pF5rzCq9Ep9PBKSejOYADyOy_pzYuIDCOD0iHDjBopQAPQmN5BojV9_glvc_p6AkkwVU5YYsTXz2hI_PIcTnUy811fvTyOtQyml8IkXdDOrfcAStXegU3hf8yH11th82b51I_ZVBzVi.dvAVXlBT_C49PmyT7QpYXQmVCIxTmxWpXjSfv2grrrN4RsE_3sYpLpgLXR0p8vT9QqqxwbNcI5fzFwAjQ26wOl8j4iwrriWwkU7rs_KdLNOxWIDdjfCYz2bM3m5vVAnOYiylE1SPrwGw43uFzVn9TOJKScT.JltTYNbEPMCIAtb.m8OklEaKDMZzzTloSnqj1hwvqlr.LLCO64n3RGiu41ampLogasrdMxc7VTJFwPmmL3oBSge7sn6JCXSyYpRd9pvvuPIQ8T_RPtLC3tfIEXJv0cTd6Mt5XeT7QEYJz_5yhJb69Bbs_81efDis02vF9TC8hTHs_L_HV6ZMO65XIojL0FsJMvJPqb2aLsHcpzAnXD3cagrdE9AS63HhzJkHQMKWv_HpTLuM1VgfjyZK2kKr6fc5ZGaMAk44yemIlsSxNEJQh6hIjQVTGpkQ6qOqMMfhG6nEvWzSZ5_JgGsjPhozkQ1BwzL3XW93q8megOsDsuqymSD9VHEUPovgumDHwEUYFpNobMdTaa6Lav39xDxLFEL3GWZEChbqW195AQddHkdzBjqoLYYbptGLaCyWxKDYsDYkzNgAGYGcW.0ssxymoDwhnil99YzFfddATa36c8aS61VWFh1cFVWHGNPALmqTBJA_UioMMv3y7jovjNn8o8RC0X_fwUr_5UmRynDTmNmE970uHghR66kfPoAYrHQGZIOiRfOOhMgK4P93oCExHYqg3_InlmpXzvJ1eIZYCBfhC5zGADAH3E3CLnx432affKFPjBTHYjHsCuM9pC5eq6TYDnZ5.5Qlmu8NF_LRrhCwlPKN2H_acCWQCc6RYxPcNCgIrzNfPP._D6j8lCqIsPeSA63Zu45TBKTY0FR9Mdyhkc666ErCf5hc8lcl00dD3Yk.5kxUkG3bVl.N4fEdAdNrHtZCrslGP2FHyV01Va1hFUz5T35KJuOL7.NML8JDxEB8a8",mdrd: "DYZ4eqo4ZJ4RyE0f6yMdXgFnjIBuXJLedSYNqdcPMlQ-1732377872-1.2.1.1-b2cbSegKO7kD7CZzkepfgDOLewWRsTXevqhOQMmTvN_i3Uhs_US_NenrQLLgGP1qCSvEw.K34LwZ219QD8gA5.mM_Azxq6HFMv8NYe3rOeCfA4KAJ0QR7aMK499rzF7cG7_SVXJ2KYvvR35j6qZiLlEiAx_v5w34BlxiracMtxj082PmGNLkdjQjx_ro0hEkBbo72WaXDkXvhiqIbeeD3YthuKGoNhovJ_9q9b8q3vlL8M.fsr0TNuGytKDgb0WMtBmKNmcggu3Z_t6yGSM0ul_BN88UbTCfqeTpSWPEn3tAxadj3ZkjjvGjtAfzl0EMidzC.mk_NQBXX3mOp2pK5uWGHxWKmBN7Py1xOs12fhTA.hH3RF5lNEPAr7y_gUNXeu0KQDj5vH39N4CjxZKugVSSkmBN48Slm4dVKQjzeMSuqAeS4rx_IqGgVMGk.fWgUJzLto3CQq5ox0r7tTowDgyH7iX9prNk34NRYnoZmHjcKHycpQAfd2vUuk50Y_NeWUxGS4kOBCP8qhGvW15UH5IS6P_C4kCyOY1r8QksdrUFTWALmoEikcNSFkuz2UcTETQHvD84t22XB_.oc_O8aJ4_KyTebwQifBE8PhTEpv_Icq3PXVVbTMAVxs8Y783uewZ0unZMkeKvS5g3ZljeZYB4dulAvCo77nVUnZQNavC97rvnJOfuYc4obBgQCReFMSkIdKMFgjbB9dyLbxOZwNQwNmSTf5WBtaDRcHNNHpkXvQ.t6FjGColoFUOYJXxDCPC_b.LLQe2mljomPF7Z88Zmxl_.UxyiDE28PRqH1uPKl3Bobs4pBbhQ5c00tUr01jyydv20IEsXH4Q_nkz4_fSwIL8TTDCoKjkAG8yjZ_55ehazoVedJQIo68kHNsVLZJe9AcWt7Kr_3vgTt22QYM87hoNA942exyfXDMtmJ_RomMn20q1dXibxljCWP3qA78ZaKFydiPa2UGuB8pcFm.h14ZA0M46.qxK3NfPgbillg8v6769bwsZgJpD6K9tU.7LMO8x.8odkGIkXHNIWpzeDIJN6jSYEiUBfGH.WwGrNDmfBznjkrR6S2VTtNuhDTaox9Eg.Lg_Z6ipLUtPWKuvJvQvnVAmpMJeN5H1QIC2D0K6lmiDx4vZ5uqIWFndRzVK0DUioMWqsVX3mt9f3SHm8iAyMtTZFVamxtthb7FwiG8I8GFI4Gw8VLbsXPG9woj5nYUpTjSF_1m.u6y8.IZa2aNnHc_A3_CKn9S.gJSAg.PAGU1YjLg1T7IAAReeGQTpt4GugIwC1L_4JnHEoEr3IQ8ubqdS0vuMByQDlAXejr7Us39b8LPcPXwRNajBC.nKTcdri0oGnI70Wd524VGbIiHdLvvC59GXL8Uotr4oCti8WzwYkUuXlt7XLxNTnDS5FM2UT2OOtPO8DwmGj0Z7tlVyKva5ucZneSU1Zf3LDDceTp8Ot0Ed53vhCkWLYfqkrdisZqOrahbgmOlyP2hjGi1YVx9_vyVUfI7ll5x3CyXSfWYr6Yg7FCXDn9k3VXJiNYkt.128WB1g4SpHjK.q348k.7Nek.zqfJGbAHoz1oyYDwDxzF9cg.YZl0QeXh5U4lyIsbn2MpLpnOqVgqkYgEW0YhdaLhaDiXP7h51_A4FgDS.3geeuzXP1U_eM3uiaf1wF3eJM2Ro4I4kmZ_gqpIYNJfE1XDPaUFrnu1tohd34jQxHXlSTYlWH760AaEhgC1PdP01XuowJGCNAUlQZmQkdD9fOybqJ860IAwo.ehMzN52UXE8KddYqKGyebbs1sN5DT6YWw_Dt5clrqZVOBTb7oJ9YNKWhuTKDAHFTFuhOIpr2_YNTZyxFmIP9iQ__lv3_hJorLMaJu2VA4XboCaPTgUq4vhEEuvorVfw0v7LPcTpGfF4zxZ6bY3IXcWiAuhHkA2ujIRpqwqRw1N6PVkskggmg5wDI_VQMJeng"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e72654858a9ce73';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/doi\/10.1126\/science.289.5483.1307?__cf_chl_rt_tk=mI1huyr2bvzuwLtb1sMQ1Jud4M0_RPHJp8mCUDWroyY-1732377872-1.0.1.1-NGfy64l0Hx4Y5tDipyS63qpOkAKZmfsKJ8KaqWv1N.I" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>