CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "caselaw.findlaw.com",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e92ae83eff6cdd9',cH: 'xdJvZSF4IrIEMT8XwIHnJzi.eXnkXw8D6HGPDwXlGTE-1732716416-1.2.1.1-8XVPkKC0zb8DUwH7jlc5PsN6Esg.yQlLHt7QeNKbGOvp.6KQK5pRnHTs_IQFt7mt',cUPMDTk: "\/court\/us-dis-crt-ed-new-yor\/2146234.html?__cf_chl_tk=g61V9Q5obKbZVjNrdJ1w2aXTxofO.HGGuRRzMRjiWxk-1732716416-1.0.1.1-Gb0JAiIoPbAGQiRP76Euw69MCa34w7T_YW5BzPBO1Ko",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1732716416',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/court\/us-dis-crt-ed-new-yor\/2146234.html?__cf_chl_f_tk=g61V9Q5obKbZVjNrdJ1w2aXTxofO.HGGuRRzMRjiWxk-1732716416-1.0.1.1-Gb0JAiIoPbAGQiRP76Euw69MCa34w7T_YW5BzPBO1Ko",md: "He5EXL1dYmKvqMRs9rixv1aFqSsxS0q5Ac1vh5BzI5Y-1732716416-1.2.1.1-TXfWe.IDlYaHRCMik_f0q2ibf9Tvkr8brVOphlW8mW4BqTVay24Xnie_7gWa_Uhn0GZeYhcCtX.Dt2JeIuCxC65u_y8l1ElUalv49ZorDY1GXV2.ddjFq0xSGxXpFN_lHisEPW.ngoAOb5WlJVnHxq8P5ANvGArBHYSJnco3eTaomaStaUzrq4OCNbDlEY96flzMdb4XFRbhpHYWunVOcmheWn74KDNHt6smSiwj8oeD82UYnerwGeQlr_DalgJP7aF0Sheci6rjNoQbZAfa3vw6aTfXqlItw86Y1mJdB4yLHPd3dIc15.J2uhx7q4nSha3Yn1UzcwhRBjyODEhy5Q.DSKfVCAWnRqQaOlu06b.ZDN0_.SN_YhZYJT5im78XPbM0gYsXbcr4MhUHzpphybwoGIaevsIdViVGjHA0qJvD6aaLvlU1ocI4V1g3GC5gRxJbfD6Eij5DfSZzcOqIFfpTVTvAv6uSqE4agXQrJ0yYGwSQ572I954Vrw_81k3kNdQNw.BsUkuyxcVOJuurakLUGpKH64tHijOCGJkdWd.URnTmduHrjhWSkWTorUSiJYU.FxCiY1g.uxzVSzCgqGl4CiBBS9pNUveEEcmMvnuo3p7PtTrCFz3Axhouwx9WBP8ets6hZAWNUiNxbuhzxjyY9SZkIexh8znpSlSSkSkqAQIjyOPrtHXmFqouJ5OrT4ULH4C.sCC9iF0JcpRgEkCj2ldlzpXOtNOM186LxYtlNSMkbCVkcaglM7Pf82RcTHG64ciOxlEQ25gLdvng_poF3uss0VXU8eYMnvLZUnGXOYStx73xt_9hShHR1YoLflWlIFO3YKh6a71cRtqyf1wRzHZ2BlTk7ICG2VMO3a7wuJoRoiGv1oQeJJm9tCJlqkZzDXEkbVKfvzLrSbllETtBuDP0hrAcGd.UV44YiGNZVUrBI0I4u980z9wcps_.Xs1lS_90yED9AyQv1xt1xhKtk5hcZtL1reVLeXQH.s_jj7wTUAVUE9ZwLOT_Zr1ZQuqd7b6X5uNVL0RTFlMLytFo3nbFyrIk6cA19AoTzyX8b_FGw0cY..6SF3RMnpW8XfPV5KKBtziv6cYQjru9.tw.kmqlIWhhnPE5DKoyfeNDxMnXxzVQflCxPNwF9ekyLs_msDzEZKYg7GgJpMzLYxXkWUiIgglREstVwRgXyFfyLw085I3a0dqjSMtG7uHb4RDtNcPTgop99Wv7WeYaQvmnzc.L7j.p6saAxcWBgcqmZwGn3BVl2j1RVsN8h0bcIUIAojCD4Ca7ZL5vs8lSi9_yWtBtC50voVDi1t47PB_.b6BnkVx8MHmwebLPeTlroBWAdDeijH8c2IwTcU0nRGGlxM8R4W1JLwivli6yjAsmP5pDTMRdrHBtRq73uZvNvMYGR1k2f7z9xAcVcdVXCjIs7LgcIjF5k04ZLXgi3Ak9IdjscVXN6OceMUaC3Qj4f6g_RdjKcSKtE._T575ZRdX7q1ge5fSGGg0S7_ey5L6f494S3TYXoCwu8EzaRoQLD02HQKLfgnOiRDhPutHE2Emrpgu6uFZurzmD8MmVAO22Tr6_stGMdy1_2FncPI0K9TtHcnz2HrQucQ5wpgPzDL7SLrVuxkWd_.xzFd3yG6gmL7InU5JKfR9K2Ugh7CXoxe7TxGcUVvwLD_5itHsNdb6FN7Fzqt8PijKZq4kutMBjU_SMIYUq7XHp9BgP566wZBOHaZJDlpE9im96Ju7zZR6GjLTrajAvv61CEup0v70WOQDIk0_ZIq2WbippVqzOyGVZcM_fz8HxVGiDOuaO9zDhApY.xkz_abHMW.g5rkA2k1vaMke7iZqK9bSYVDBkk9jH6C1A7NQzGSgfTJgH5LAGBW5wYdLoDWYy35AxOnGxVaJVCGSg_9rMm0tG4G6GGMt4T7sI3DBso6eCR6XX.6mUQRp6jukjuVeYI7rUCCDWulGXlk54up2D9VScmORdkQal_bIdFv9tNhYlBmHmNK_AizDldKuKX1U0FhOhxxcNbSCRjcAylbjfXhgvp.xcnPMGupCTADPEpUJ_KRVQ95Siw5w3jJACvwb0wiyroMDsJpbbfR8acuYggA_WkZbNdDMnoWemxGbwH45BkcaMrPAj1V9XMMvbAx9...X_pVIxfS2YsaB7pV2IQhUDnMERaG5alnXsf.1rv6u9ESnkG8.65MXti7ivyab8qfpu9x5H4lYNJd3UOWa0uEb6vijq4sM6MmK55i6vEDnR5Q2cP0Uz6L4NziyERQii8MDJN9IEKHaZrXfrFxWpHPlfuubsuBEwItIvZSeq.rloScKc101X3eosksEfzjmIfUedbz5DRcQq9_en_DWfb64qvYUZbCMwInYvIsRn09dCISi8uySNA8LiQ2rkAK6MeFTfOca6CSRUp8IjEQe.E09g.SRGKajtmqFt3R0QW4kLECujVa.w1eEDQWnnnT5pQi_wL06abW1PYw1ivsOmfnrD60rLn0JVHEDeITTM1icOx_vqKaq4hPkv.6ggOBaGafufjQrx1GbiwGtgoJKqdD10q6JnGYoBr7tqAqA8BIRPT.Pd46m2OZK.RLZVqFckGXhMRhX54zYVxptRYkU9jrChNeIIdCj5Lo9SIb5O.4NNQi9NQimxt23NdzlFueq21b.zqSf588IftzXSVC_MkTjsebfkPtX5gyMOjpM.PGl77pMNys0hApJTsq_umXIOZM40uaU2DHCk_6vUkVO89I3KYuFSBsQNVjzcXV55Lo9PMXi4Diy5rcJnDXlejNs6RcdmJF54pBhq0k.nAlRyna2SvRtnIxXr_6qmq4FLIv96gkTmd8I3u6uCUmVKahgM_hZGbSWJBud8WUe3upjYOBIoKakDpZz2xzPMCSe2BKiglobU90RTyswgDxoj0Z1M9ZH5lu9xqq0bSiX3K8QZ8YSKLgJsgH3QQVy6nRl1thkyzzfpB6c5I4reB0H2SfWTbvakVyk",mdrd: "8Xb621yIBeDeS5kCu8ysRAVLpdL5LwrFM_09EI.v86Q-1732716416-1.2.1.1-8zf5QoS2w2gzCJ5APvkL5zCDkKITuzGOnVy7k_7Ig5UxuR0QLwug1P6FOwQ_CEwAA_Q8pzyNbN3vkpww9MgpxUczu1CgQZQVtf_IpVyfVsLz3iqVeAtoGdg8i.6ezb7CjqzcCdGMpVWzadwWKPi1gB1Mb_a3i0.fgsaaCY6daYAqOGKbZaaTbswsUF0uZn.U3K5utI1YXnPIS1IEKZHzzmXaF7pl6GR0mRX6VpnZ6Yjzozj2XhxVYJXCefi4ngB._9c9FulE6Nvh8hmPSIvn_Mt4x45G3X8YTY1zoQWefENlZTXQ5N.Ml_06ujVh9b_lZjGgmKKJsVwZkAgK4tHN9gZeMeAE.dQ5jLQsdrSnApwqOM2oUcuE6qrqKGcC1CTt5MM3WRh9H0rzX8.2A2_ItHDxGlIiNlBN_vQ_fTWwZ5NYH3_xmqAJNJnORCx6yW61P2dtShDNWNwGsz8SrDmQ2RGqRbv8rhvNvFGmoUOM0iVv7NkvnHjR0OnMQSTZYqyB8OGK4JgKQEK_DVdZzRhhPpDU_1_UKcVsPRPBkOOKNUiRsRtQ8c8C2OSXgMynRexjdeJBvemFC9WGQ1juXluI0RIX2eq3HZBuA59cyUoGwNol9qCf3sdG5BFQ_QKHSZYkTbyOvRFic3qofKpCP0yE0EyzL.BlAf1Tk5A.FWgvpsXVS99hwsDLRakzLo0jW0Flst4tyoxt_ZPLnc0eKTqOD0Ls5b20mA0JxEWRL9b.TZWS8QaJAOso1iXomvu5Q7lncCY4PzOmLvURAu4rSQVL.I2X5I0yN6vKBT3E80hzIAY5SHfiy28WbSfecmIGogRvv2GSkW6SLwQvwXfulC7OrVU.GdV4aTQ.Jkx2Q.6FqrNaVAIgT9xfjCuVL8rZ.oEh7JXCHTJDbHD2D3mRsow8B6iQAbRvPjVDgyy6z2oWED9Ocl9IxYj6NnYS57ffoGMDGDLG.9ocb_vmdn9J_8FXLyQ.RG.GypsgRNKWYJLOPtF33kFJo4yUL5WU_OwN3iEvfz8PCr3VjJ0MPOrbADvcxtAjBGAe8TmvbpmWXt5kA0AfDod7yH1wG5THl7n8W7nQWo6yqSMv6EeV_IlYfGNtPvtgmqJiEsvK7bOlQEefsd4ITupYYPyCnqm_8Pouz8f9lcKfqLWVjmtkRxEe7L4R76J1MB2JOtIon1TiRfQq1JoXfF_qAlZ6uG4xsf1EM4gicVnXtqD_GSnarVnafTjV26IwgNGEPS2m_UXEQIcUQAXqBemltK8Kn.ZYilyBAsDPgvdmX.zO_UtoQLMb4vFSbjpzTEns2mUhT9ee.3014eRHUTiHheXTg0dMS8_.1Xky9d2Xxnmj2GDEQupUuX.hAyV2UNew64sz1Bg7vUU5pEfrGm6arV6m5r_AH7lkGVelrtFnF_Mqsv82ktof.gHFUs1sCiZbjrRHikznVQNDzblGvrKIHb6THNKmH6b4c1q.Kleqhq7OMi2WhXnt0n0apsf1X._w5r0PhnJbjF5FHQF9ogVuciN1wtj.EfJ4E3OwBEzLpeOhAuwm7RP2SaxCtlJHrVmTR9MQkMmnuSgSxX9fmU96rJPRhCc.NBYvBER4il.WaKs1XV.Lpbm2fafmxUOaPlPc1PzzYbe7rcFmu8.wuWfqiMktbDwTCzDOiAilRMEj49yKis7abZa2VIg_HzC5ez_A5Ku5mptl9iTPzMvXZI_x6Eok4oB6YzTHrOHPx_Slj93W2Imp9JgCiURXxqQMZKK_yBf7qtZcYvqebJXQTjPmbx07HQ9qGFke4fV5PunWTr60gc8vx1Hza_AZe2NuzS8UY4PbL2PAHQtwno0LbdevKwNe_f8pRU3KUYk5vThKNqwxnw2RwSi4yWxCjoXCeSS1AF2.FLsu1sOverIMsYBjCfATbLQx_LqWFMxDzY96dMwa550Fqj0lo6LSqbJNLRLpP0G9Q5Soq8knPWvbQpmpbodZpb7dxxpz1zpV"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e92ae83eff6cdd9';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/court\/us-dis-crt-ed-new-yor\/2146234.html?__cf_chl_rt_tk=g61V9Q5obKbZVjNrdJ1w2aXTxofO.HGGuRRzMRjiWxk-1732716416-1.0.1.1-Gb0JAiIoPbAGQiRP76Euw69MCa34w7T_YW5BzPBO1Ko" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>