CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="120"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "publications.waset.org",cType: 'non-interactive',cRay: '91369c9d6c0da1b5',cH: 'rOO4oV3YzWmuJo0.rXKKJG4ocqVtilI7E5RXKznfvp8-1739804057-1.2.1.1-4d8wUKstSGOLPhKn.5VDxy9hcy0i4gCPYWOtXrv_Izj_9CCnpBxm9IkFQfpJPZya',cUPMDTk: "\/1830\/comparison-of-the-garden-city-conceptand-green-belt-concept-in-major-asian-and-oceanic-cities?__cf_chl_tk=9vmGa5PoH33n.z_2Mja8UwiRPyCZ4sh6ql8CUSOLxZU-1739804057-1.0.1.1-LGQj4P44SRxHDQUX3v.UGg_S4w6v1BbV.jON1LC8Hmw",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1739804057',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '120000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/1830\/comparison-of-the-garden-city-conceptand-green-belt-concept-in-major-asian-and-oceanic-cities?__cf_chl_f_tk=9vmGa5PoH33n.z_2Mja8UwiRPyCZ4sh6ql8CUSOLxZU-1739804057-1.0.1.1-LGQj4P44SRxHDQUX3v.UGg_S4w6v1BbV.jON1LC8Hmw",md: "Cxvhe4tVoahywpT1j6MrO_hp455_KGNXURqJliy4opI-1739804057-1.2.1.1-zI7XkLUsBa.8.oLQsw7qopnWvKM6e9.2chUqeNnwkGiCd0pwXloJvCRo8ZliRbwV8UUEz6o_EUwunrP8tN0adGziWnHnBzOV1Z6XopbpQTPjjYMGBGI2OdUWjeRf8z2.f_pOlrP2qAUgxKajWEEWYdoGeulV1Aat6ubsfVoyVSH2hGBMqzwY0g0pRC2EEcRYR0D0qPRYs54NVwXYUKoTKBJ55B.Xu96iiQLiQYDFaRVU7X95FCWMKZYzlQG_4DzBSwC9r3PYx2TpjjwCXIUlaMpucCkVxlkv7FMH_fMRvLcn6MRp5bnqxTD6JikjHYotDpwOBYRsWd0vvb6cKchFgYXvU4p3NNwkV9HATreCwy5tSjFTNHuTzkrYpVYfW3hbNqnHYL9TjxY7vB5UWNuoE8E7aAVBtf66I7e6IvfS1KTEUo8d4etV8qgLIpxOMDFW4pahSkaOMgfMAaDhOV9WM5PBscMp8IkVv7saFEnZEigtfRe7qZzJkHpS._xMyQnyh6LHG9R1FwJxbRVZF9WsNMv07cURVA9vrWfyt5_v54wwh9wO50tfzl3eMrYxL_RaJOEekyVbZcuJlVb8CsgYT01Xx2k5ux80pfXx4meVc7xhl0JhnVcWLoO8qw3tQ0mO2bbS.j368sW.X8AM5VeSFVLvKe_XCMffVFwbQ.YW_UIiOC2Owe0J0XVQFP.XBK1ZmWBAn.zYw7WxtUpc9BXbJXMKtcQ4nunJIM6qtJ2Yma6e8DXZTmLHB5N5fwIlubF9BCruMxDj_21lqgR6NwMI9xUQipKWfvcc09d8Gqvbnx3kfYWebAKX2fhmFzXjR4T8Fu66Q3.wmcejiMDt2IQ21Xxr0nV6T.ODX_GrxgG_IPpAs8SJz2rmx435Q99uozpzcWT1wf11..Fm42IFfh1lDzHpQ_.Eqyn41XifLtFt0QyzPlybxDyI1WrkHn.jq41ULDIkP.EicGmo7FxAUlZEQ50ediMlYKw0XqeLZzdPQt9ltGyRlmqOrzGV06jpjkiGYMKc.pg8vLdRHZnwwYktM7mtarjdir2G1hak8PCAKbNLG5b4JVvCyQd_JA5HwHi6il_TUYrvTV6wQ.4xJ9oRn7WezwljPJcj0hB1gYY.sVtbQQUYwiPASmmr.EO99i2bWOfbdGuBlVwugyLauk7To3_TA5_TtXnpJGKFdUMAGQwy6Bl1317_7Zks.JcmaIx6LZJAQSHwbCX1SpXZf49JYsUUKN4757A0kqi8mWOMuIFYE3mPgy2YyLgqopWG1OubPPtz_urRul5LtE9owlqsyzjNsun_Wzl_TkqaeaUPta8J763845pVeo2tfeQWnIUNInoipnBMKoIDLjt2DFCVpcfdVUUoJJ2omRI675TsR2ndWXB3yxYWzUzEkAOGkr4wX2756WbJoNdwM58U1e.2WUbekm4_.IaZkSRssVYzzqA2dUckC53rmUGQhGWMVPaATY6_6cmCHTvRn1MfvbtVtYOtVTmK2vC1Gg3w1lNMXus9vPZTmTdsXOaleNYSxiALihs3yGqyd_ebo1kImBJPVF7XO.sdpzYrOigEZiVdyKKpr7Swik3C_EdT.ak7Nt2V79RzrDaTHYAf5VEvSY.iHksoKw3HNHXisNR6xko7xMqGap1DVnJP..eDodRlRcSI1yGdoCgLLi6y6MFP_YjrJCQZ4ZGXexiApvBxr5fC2u3LzkkSUw9aG8bKUKO0pu2XW035_YlpaJGl0gWUazKhuTtXO5McMYOw6In9lZYu0Kjt872uAdE.zfKF63yXCbf_QkMFmn56nuwWoOeInQLA5LcrpsL6K_aVUDgtf9NuxaKHEu._n06W0czC_I_R4pdOAREyrhZh3OAE6hQFRgONoLBwB2u92ANUvPKLj1Tk64SQBNWCihP2O8a52GNs4cQ2zVnWZ3O.lUGVB.ItmW..Sv2foX9kV_gj_PLqTYRWghQ0pawibua.MQrv6CZ7n_MKgYtmNjfl0TgqBUptxwDEJvcf45j44sInAlwxkOQsGBgalMxZw_ETnERklAQd9cruuxCupANJSUfTJvZSbvSl6pMuug46crzLZpfCS12NAtcTULPAG3VoCZ5hSLjAM2L5zyCxxtSvr2J0EBE7njCM4Q",mdrd: ".iW6j3vR9XXoBkZStkMZsQz87e3q4u5oJMPxex0e83I-1739804057-1.2.1.1-hTuvxWq0PBRKvRwoO3lzY_6ob7BgjHig7GbQ34CW6CoJXd5G03uKgHxTbKmHCugfa.kHtiwtob9nBtoZKIHgM.vZsF1N23KiLeJTgJ6MW8d6EXivCHTJobXxBCeWNikXOF6LUQVJPaSUvbdQ670em0NGV39W9jTtWSkHjYc9_J8mwG_x7k19a3n2s8OFIK10aIZyqDQ69B39seJ4b47oAvIEIQhM01J8mEIpCglb9BkjFTAyZjMtHbPYnid3_ARrm2LvbS5x2vtCnFu07IDvudyszQsXEdWFQFmUk4CglyYljE11x_V0C9BKg_1DieIJi_DC1Y7LHgu75_tpgpSNe.o19YdFSkgSBo2X3aKBljDkNjIG7KxQTjoi7Aklk3Qbupq0U2QZvJEV4kdzjgWcfJl302LbS.6PEGqjeTbBZYUj_KZH_aXgk6jrq0tAvAFGZxhxFNZ11Zu8mb7sBprqz4__I063eeedHMQK3ITMIXMK5mTcgnQFdvB23baEd.dZRD_BvafAfRqHVfscV.AO2tPfqrk3.B_XjXbqwrcOjx3.WAjTD6eB.qwbsIOhWBcP7q9.qPrLWHD1DKQ7x6rC8J2SP22hXJL9P.ro9ejkGebs2wxSl1HZAOTSsQozzX4BTgNzizBnTVbUfUOycC.qutcWLGDebuFsaChetuAlB4DpcHY3hLGqFK5oIk9j9vCaRLoxrwhzGDL3.NZmCY3E0ggnSnLNLX5TvSPX4R9pjIfBltSI1S_KyeFvQyF120Fec6qWD1Bzyes5BC9FJUSMgzP_mid1ymSWvEwRg_OsnUiR3pioJE4F5MydCK6m1pgXSeEI4lPeplmhGfNPMoHy..I26ybVt_5ocO0yJ7uxL8eocB6vILok0QDcwMzWqUuK_gAQE_2hLsF7jOkkFGAWzlhXFzcabh.RU2jJnzf.c3qS0VE0.Z_c9hpN1ibYLqYpsOzij3fHISMk4dnJ7P2YolE.2dLETF8E8EVN8sTP3qAPLDU2SlbqvZmWjduF3Z7qu2Lnx0Wp11XcY40vVSZdnS7LUmU3xHTCGXqxZxgjDTV0CErcTQbVRsen10LzgE4Fzx4E5XvKAIZXrCmCzjDRuJuwEMLmnoAAOBisqmqT_u8DKzT8Mcg3Eez.e4F3b2h58y7ZtGwRdcYPlkvYZWqNXhhpd_j3hFKM3YoRUdbJK2DRxEzdit2PSdVg6bx3nOIrm4QxteD0xuuHwZ4Jm6w.PZtGspUVp1vPKFfVS32sg.7RoSi7L_bo6YNPwS8zH76Qq8sdchk6Z8VqTq3jBvw2sEQbG.KjdJG06KRWmbkad51dE.W9RDynbCqTx7EOfQ4tX9sHW8qSSwEDhLNgSP4heox9_.VvaboVV68UfdrG2C3g2Phczc2kRSYTKsk1IBL71ujq9Ey61CUXd5HZZRhFgeuT5icf5OzPzJuAyMzDtkB3cfjBlMamOA6g1_KXVtScPQpX7LSkFe17UPDVlgNxrvoHSMfG._4K6MiIp7lTRk5AvRCPB4BS_eeZtHdJQEllVLmsRMWMxQautz69YL9M1HGmW.Yc6c7ZZu20D6eeL76mj2dDhlcTNkhOEwDerH5BGAcqXy7NsUUzCf8NNwyr0cuepzTvBdzKtBe9pMd5wZHpfRC75c7znBZXc838he361W_S4SJLoAgouH.EoQDL2.FJFAfElpvHtccqzUKdLtyWh3ymM73n_08ohaGe3TCvj9FCbPMuifztxM5Nm8BP.S3FP0Cuh6mC9KhxvuW0r2aXr6ZBKDnZ.2ThbUY2wgFbRZlS7.A_eRFPaFF_snDIklCoa2YZAfx7zaP506jBYpI42xQ.KeZWe2yTeA1kg3R2mh_mVwVClwL.lizomLwvMpBkPh.O52ATkRh.24DP7_GpfzCFSS2pLWqHGCBrQzftFBGj21.MNsCiNLONeUqW1PK83SUqO6prsEISiGd2WKiaRZc4RcpGJKbd9IAKSfa7Kp9Ifv.HtKnM7X193PRkDQ"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=91369c9d6c0da1b5';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/1830\/comparison-of-the-garden-city-conceptand-green-belt-concept-in-major-asian-and-oceanic-cities?__cf_chl_rt_tk=9vmGa5PoH33n.z_2Mja8UwiRPyCZ4sh6ql8CUSOLxZU-1739804057-1.0.1.1-LGQj4P44SRxHDQUX3v.UGg_S4w6v1BbV.jON1LC8Hmw" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>