CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="120"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "publications.waset.org",cType: 'non-interactive',cRay: '9135ab7e2ee13e14',cH: 'ij6tRGDT3SxwC72InY0Wj5wtF9as8q1ROX0Fgd.PDyU-1739794180-1.2.1.1-zk4ihXbZpAh_QOca82BqAdI184SRT4rNYwGPAs1NY7RNpG4JI5b.NUwvuAzKts9X',cUPMDTk: "\/abstracts\/search?q=civil%20service%20reforms&__cf_chl_tk=dSg4j0cSd4jM9_Gci2jaR1QcsBLtCfy7qX612z5iD9U-1739794180-1.0.1.1-rv_Qs5VtAkBPJ30KygiAVbVK9KDVXMgdpKp.2ev2prs",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1739794180',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '120000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/abstracts\/search?q=civil%20service%20reforms&__cf_chl_f_tk=dSg4j0cSd4jM9_Gci2jaR1QcsBLtCfy7qX612z5iD9U-1739794180-1.0.1.1-rv_Qs5VtAkBPJ30KygiAVbVK9KDVXMgdpKp.2ev2prs",md: "D2BhkZvwRwkHiEQ3FU2S35p0YxwkH8to1NReQX6_Fys-1739794180-1.2.1.1-Hbyk24k9BeZmX402uwC1vB.Uylbnj3QISTqup_z_9lRj_PN6As4HPo5qiXZ1Yly6_dEXsa94Jgm3sQh5xgEwSqkvn1gCk5YYjgWMt5AVcHWvZWsnOgToRlB.Uqlk1CnuqFeyCZU.HZrLnQJvVgMUc0YfQGJu_SiuX3lQnEOKK2KmIAugrob3BpBTBsfA95OlaO3vbzxXrJwt0P10kHTtb3voQNJGjABkiexV2rlswldqSXXU1rx76iTExTn_nKWKWv1lEbdmA4UtoC3oiFzrFcHP51SsHTaixn8v5MkXAcTPoK0IjxZ8q60WubdHbNEO2JOcOZ52h6pMe25DionhWTLLtWqzhWO8O9_wUbp1Odo97WqMqG71ntzLBGK4APrl7DRpfOXsbQq32F2i12K74HCbPfFx8gHff2lUnkX3pBh965UTAfHz5Xw5OKLpAplNjpfZ.QUpfjOdt2T7XJbFxnlhlcSwmGuqgpZy.udnPpjqxOjwNyo.JWrbfw2poBinv061qKskOI4OhF12BoMoT9zWp462O30Vf7RdNdktnc4nCvja9o5nAUg3B11.ZdlJ5g2uME7ePPx.4qn4qUbK3ZezfJUqsCEqIaiZpaTWgsOTY1ftqkiFzAJ6qgegm0.DRq4pw.S7eIFOacMD7.nUn4vf_E_yIFzrCOv9csx84YYCosMEUVTKpOZS7n9dANjhnC5k46YAuEasQas5_bfODNUtnY1UcLBDArpkAvBtiD5Opr8ne.vTBdi9Wmc820rl2w5.Mwx9I3gF6nQVQhQ8Le3qlKD2TqI9aZ7j2EivgfckY73Sf7WD8UHm1H0NMu2.JV.cQY1TFgOQ8HDQh.eqfNgrbbXx3Wg2_gg0i4PFqxG7VEPHX.C1KsX43d7idL6RpoxITQyxOc_I3LA4HGYJe00345QGEc_PsT2R5gpL3qQhWhq5utdxts.jrfe8WulV.bCP0qlQ5ztbnf9y2RHkSLDPO3ZRhAsBu71hsCE_JeECTtfbsyzyWa3rYK7nQOPk8PXFP6bfXysLdMwjqDZxL7Gs7qZ7MCXA93MVnFcoSbieSCoUqXPlgkIt1wW39uuoQkF4QH1DqiiKdXCJvE29fa6gY38obviPAwg2CCPRipo_0dgm8TWI5_V2cmWxxMD7cO6VupKaeEeRRpXZ6Mawm_y.SlokX4iGyOsSe9pmPF.OHCjkadeC8XZ5OJTYFc0xxZta8K6w1JALU4.seHo6re.HLB1qodhq3wd4ePYNYfckylKTH8qosm5Zvom4X9ZnPV7AR50G8kCG1T7RqXiO9FHdA5MXx2HlxPm2qAN8gSX219ai4_hSi_8glYoIQR04Yj3ZcxcpnfKeJp.TBwr8sj_qJ2.05ye0mqHw.6xPPdp2mdEIVlgK7cJnPIBgBcaqjf7HtDZRyw6RqjC8eo_M3V5DtQNXLssJT1EeM6uwKLtT3wiUrXRxZjJxMT.ol.o3iOmMcH3J7goomptlb6qebajO235qVLxaBeA3Tr6t6UKVcABa4aJX8LrkOHlbguG09q8zhREv2q8rqV_NEqzYOODYCRqPjjlekhFCEAPEfKHVqmgSrMI076bSV2a5ZBQYVjsZ7Qb7Y0iLuzpqQrzln_a5PoMUqCgzXpmX0HCz8ZZDZ4SrkPl_M419tv5yyB31jC8l8Pc2xtd.10ZIaTDYF9NTw4FndNAaW1Iwg8aSE1JkzgquRR6P8J9ihSW2.KBMGseizaDL1VHbISpy7Y4zGw2Fsa0Enrn_.PQ7CtFJvVwDryiLyTWlOdloQnS2pr9sEN9ewgymcvg9yeHi4iYNw.jw3vaiTp.lmz1Yn4_thecZ0QYc8LGX5Se92MQaIdBayUHrbCOYAtKZqvVME73qnfTbW32xc9gPI4HbtdhMBzvwwBc383HoDPUmclwU2UdWakyF5W_F22fHTG2efTT8_4cDE6MuREuxFqXl5ZEe6NgnW.tuVkUw5ut4vFdeGVDg",mdrd: "rCiMwcIJHWAiaMoFWERSkwVniK7yRFkW_u_wKagRkUg-1739794180-1.2.1.1-IfECC1GLSry2o7ENvi1JdrF0r0zZFuxxM4YOn8DaMY3zSvbMuZMlV.bAOsiqulmxpP0Y8QfD8War7NiQ_8KuF.NMy0TlNq9DWRi_Pb8.QFVfJQEyM5cU13gqESpEgr7GsRsly8Br7zYEYiVMuK2a7rJsdw7WecoJG2kLOt5GtHo_FZvlO42TNiHA7SIl4OW3ZcY8yH.vmPIIF2xDADvZUt9tZb49jJprH_bK4xC6CZDgaK7qvDJo.I0ESWU8h2j2jnDOVsq_MUtCwfAAa5Ujhd.ziin2bGs5oR9qBH3ymUipzLCjBhzVlGE.zBF3v7zDAfx72pFyOUM.u9i1cIC50W5UsMB9hGCl0HzORGQdFU1._qpmH2SoJlvVJ_4wsR.jvJbuiNWaOhS8JaCGOJsU9UeVZm6rNWAp8tJmwg4.e_67Mzc1.B6_rKEXBtQ3Yi6Y_1LktuPH9H4RhLLVv3qZ.y6kQYZEieQWoAa1AFH7RwNIikRiCiIi.ftDRfWYrJ9NlPPBvvAGQ.hpxliU_xL6KL6ca8t1umaxOnOotSyNsdP2LXPFKiGLJBW4DaXXkNsYX6bMo5Ttg6xCA1RUAYxzx.NRLPe67bARwbG1QaEogp1vTT2tnVahRns.OnWQiNLanrRLXGiz1xoI7udtqH3AFmo3C95.U8w92NqQpboNrdWoNSbeRMdH0cy.MTGitzFDs29q8N.aHve1PYRc9XpYuQvaU02LYOuJPdJLwvOOhE.Ac4ZHq3khv4CjgwtLllwRyuyc6smBjknE_CrtMdRJsvhV0pyqTy.65mJfsQBfhItj56jg0RV5xc8O4zr8zlYpYHrVuO7ThtZUMmikt3p4chTiFCie1xh2crG0jfkMnnaMh.dVY2Zt.vXDIIKZtRZB2jVnukbWgiRa8z92wvFrlQ60FsoQEZJopHEHxKltn1uqU8KiizjdRAGQPbHhOhSc9XMg74lKzyp6qjTMRzGV7uqwuNTTDKIfk16EVj0mKSI1lB5RjoHHPzlgSkceJi4jej_e.Z1ETqZnWpoQ8dIpCp8MX4wJ0vFa_ub0xV5StSRpSnxpSqzJu9WUTO3J2ZOTQXgAl96.OWWssuKJx5SMQWaMlvvHHefCbfnulCO4XyerSENq818PCm9xGPjin.dmMeGljHyf3Yh1fOyAzktnt.P5eg3uTbxk5D3e9xCbzXMGCceHbyjEgNtyhH73ounxogrgn_0Ok9J2LaOSNtaPsGK5_IIJNmu8zCahKxJyLCyvF2wSctVLTqBVLEtRGLr7RPFugipw4YfB_Ct_tP7o2o0dsXcz1_AumsRM991XpI47U6dd.OZbSy.gm2_BIbpQu8XWMbfjgcRyueqTkobxT_Xxn0AG8i4JE42tF0U72mOIldBbisBh_1x2Bh0QofVU927CxJqMLqTq3Pk_z99tULfL_vgMezNkakJqldDaUpGf1SoSRXyTU7z4ZSM2D7b5OkTxLz.bqmOP_dCTGeCB_Zs0GHEsfMr_gHjrr0G96Bfo0MUL.opNPSFybFnF5TsPk_rdCjRifJr1csmNSYS5_2x1XiyeKHumffwBzicJ_7JVhyRAKKLgVLJdQA5m7IFEdZyd.ikXvda0VJo9UOeZ2CZDPUQV9aejzCQjwAhekjwni1VHURlQruO7sGnwwf6feJc2QOdY6b_Dsccj3XOL9GHpEkh_jCFP2RbgxS9p1MOvJ0LUiLiistfsFVB3BIA_6DpORcTjfJmA7sMr1ny26tH.ptNjtIxVZB1iGmJcOIYe.sRfa8kuJyBVCmu0FruCE0kVkEBJoPDhrB.QRodr.43JVHA3U707X2EQdKAPL9arjh..IdHfkXJkM9G5EovNp2l_84AowQTXKBLYPBHFqAM8gEDqCYoA8WcLQHTfPaUK2rmTSAp4uXvux2jQhU.uxtliFgeXUPbUe9OnZ3.rHZrMwaGhm26Ga0KIq9MD7E.sHKOVT9ugFaQuViGqzypGbMcUz0XTgoO6rXEGvUP2sQ"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=9135ab7e2ee13e14';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/abstracts\/search?q=civil%20service%20reforms&__cf_chl_rt_tk=dSg4j0cSd4jM9_Gci2jaR1QcsBLtCfy7qX612z5iD9U-1739794180-1.0.1.1-rv_Qs5VtAkBPJ30KygiAVbVK9KDVXMgdpKp.2ev2prs" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>