CINXE.COM

<!doctype html> <html xmlns:umbraco="http://umbraco.org"> <head>  <meta charset="utf-8"> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0, minimum-scale=1" /> <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge"> <meta name="google-site-verification" content="YC-yPSebwVXh2NMiLTX4k7VLDxVpAW8jt0kYouz6Mgo" /> <meta name="apple-itunes-app" content="app-id=938087502" /> <title>Columnists</title><link rel='canonical' href='https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/comment/columnists' /><meta name='og:title' content='Columnists' /><meta name='og:url' content='https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/comment/columnists' /><meta property='og:url' content='https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/comment/columnists' /><meta property='og:title' content='Columnists' /><meta name='description' content='The Church Times' /><meta name='og:description' content='The Church Times' /><meta property='og:description' content='The Church Times' /><meta name='og:image' content="https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/media/5630989/image-holder.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=600&height=314&rnd=131393381790000000"><meta property='og:image' content="https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/media/5630989/image-holder.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=600&height=314&rnd=131393381790000000"><meta name="fb:app_id" content="1929242603975784"><meta property="fb:app_id" content="1929242603975784"><meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"><meta name="twitter:title" content="Columnists"><meta name="twitter:description" content="The Church Times"><meta name="twitter:text:description" content="The Church Times"><meta name="twitter:image" content="https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/media/5630989/image-holder.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=600&height=314&rnd=131393381790000000">  <meta name='keywords' content='' />  <script>(function (w, d, s, l, i) { w[l] = w[l] || []; w[l].push({ 'gtm.start': new Date().getTime(), event: 'gtm.js' }); var f = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0], j = d.createElement(s), dl = l != 'dataLayer' ? '&l=' + l : ''; j.async = true; j.src = 'https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=' + i + dl; f.parentNode.insertBefore(j, f); })(window, document, 'script', 'dataLayer', 'GTM-WSZ4J26');</script>  <script> window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || []; function gtag() { dataLayer.push(arguments); } </script>  <script> (function (d) { var config = { kitId: 'qgx8jbi', scriptTimeout: 3000, async: true }, h = d.documentElement, t = setTimeout(function () { h.className = h.className.replace(/\bwf-loading\b/g, "") + " wf-inactive"; }, config.scriptTimeout), tk = d.createElement("script"), f = false, s = d.getElementsByTagName("script")[0], a; h.className += " wf-loading"; tk.src = 'https://use.typekit.net/' + config.kitId + '.js'; tk.async = true; tk.onload = tk.onreadystatechange = function () { a = this.readyState; if (f || a && a != "complete" && a != "loaded") return; f = true; clearTimeout(t); try { Typekit.load(config) } catch (e) { } }; s.parentNode.insertBefore(tk, s) })(document); </script>  <script> window.fbAsyncInit = function () { FB.init({ appId: '1929242603975784', xfbml: true, version: 'v2.8' }); FB.AppEvents.logPageView(); }; (function (d, s, id) { var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) { return; } js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; js.src = "//connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js"; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); }(document, 'script', 'facebook-jssdk')); </script>  <script async src="/Scripts/hamAnalytics.js" type="text/javascript"></script>  <link href="/bundles/css?v=20240326" rel="stylesheet"/> <link href="/bundles/slickcss?v=gRoGrwglYjZ4hGtH1z3Eww-Kl_uTaztpleDvVKiUZK81" rel="stylesheet"/> <link href="/bundles/slickthemecss?v=xVQnHhbhxfk5-YwJqdjaFiuRL-t4IQs1_Pk75Fvuu4U1" rel="stylesheet"/> <link href="https://checkout.hymnsam.co.uk/css/global-checkout-styles.css" rel="stylesheet"> <link rel="stylesheet" media="screen and (max-width: 768px)" type="text/css" href="https://checkout.hymnsam.co.uk/css/global-checkout-mobile-styles.css">  <script src="/bundles/jquery?v=l_2JQLDpEf4NHz4ob7KHLjmeRFnOogKHIQKkMQQ4Chs1"></script>  <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="57x57" href="/apple-icon-57x57.png"> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="60x60" href="/apple-icon-60x60.png"> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="72x72" href="/apple-icon-72x72.png"> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="76x76" href="/apple-icon-76x76.png"> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="114x114" href="/apple-icon-114x114.png"> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="120x120" href="/apple-icon-120x120.png"> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="144x144" href="/apple-icon-144x144.png"> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="152x152" href="/apple-icon-152x152.png"> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="180x180" href="/apple-icon-180x180.png"> <link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="192x192" href="/android-icon-192x192.png"> <link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="32x32" href="/favicon-32x32.png"> <link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="96x96" href="/favicon-96x96.png"> <link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="16x16" href="/favicon-16x16.png"> <link rel="manifest" href="/manifest.json"> <meta name="msapplication-TileColor" content="#ffffff"> <meta name="msapplication-TileImage" content="/ms-icon-144x144.png"> <meta name="theme-color" content="#ffffff">  <link href="/Content/ChurchTimes.Web/stylesheets/print.css" media="print" rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" /> <style> .grecaptcha-badge { visibility: collapse !important; } </style> <script async id="ebx" src="//applets.ebxcdn.com/ebx.js"></script> </head> <body>  <noscript> <iframe src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-WSZ4J26" height="0" width="0" style="display: none; visibility: hidden"></iframe> </noscript>  <form method="post" action="/comment/columnists" id="form1"> <div class="aspNetHidden"> <input type="hidden" name="__EVENTTARGET" id="__EVENTTARGET" value="" /> <input type="hidden" name="__EVENTARGUMENT" id="__EVENTARGUMENT" value="" /> <input type="hidden" name="__VIEWSTATE" id="__VIEWSTATE" value="5d+rsiZ1ic549FJJJ3le9Fw6t38r6nIT5GjkA4vK8eS4onOtyrr8eiko2WgsIm23dO3+By9QFj/Bxz2GE+52ui6Qsj8q81e9I8TPL9jhVPKxsmDV2VlCNwLVo+FMusTQo3EPADvj6UGqdVhMU59zAjg8yVdwYHGSRD2oEcU15Vh/zbTph0XJpHGMIn9BmE+PhgUkcH2x0j+pdXZc1qP0t7DXgtNF+A+H9e7kHr3NuoV3d6jrzmiG2OWM3d0SHVtkOWsApbGRqxb83MUMK9epu7RYpcjuw7Yq00pK5Pt6mGbpr/pOK5uo8WnsG610GOL3VNFgSspfBPlbudhknRnUzCRgSKb6jq8hoDf7Xuo9q5EMg1iT0LWqj14YW6zGk/QzK2sZK/FLn2OUYAeTUB5SpinCU7S5Fns1JVhIPdDqAgDUvi2Bdf6F0H9Z0FuoYs3d7zr55A5zQT0hpVHpqhFXc9b2vo1qzH7ZTtbYDfDlUMSnUlZQSfYF4ZdNX1Wn+Jd5qMu0ESvp97HAF+aOrRRAAx3szjnTFWPWsaRIFQI3GUjtoi5n471wWGcHFitxp7z7H865jg3oQeXcu7qtEn7304hLBmwhRoP/evVko+NI6bDweOxX4rukd1hnFbw8VPSIQ/DFEyreWSJIgyBvFJo6GxdgRDOsX2e8JdzGdqmnRk6rjpXSJxb7mFQTh1xwyotNrYmR7mbMDLcHDbDFD7za/ArgveR+9tYLS8yHY8dSLAdE8g297aKh8AQGdWmIVpAccn1ev7+7TTe935O3BjfX24gwyXW0ndYdPz2d/X73aSNVFvEPpeAEbNfXQbjbaEFqWzyIHHxVh7caithSiYdk4N75BXid72HM/8J4BYeFAq/gQP3FTgyBox/P1LpDaaojmLPNl4z4POEZbAMeuBKeRZcfsud7xJtGtcZCZySggw1ChWVJzFcyOQ1e48HpiKtpWgeQgDcK8VgPF2wR2qrBN6xOWGaqjpePE+icwnxgEdkB3xnRFymNwi8lkBtG0VHFZ2YrrS+Epy7WJcRLculvCVsVb+AcwL0wM22daHeYuNEi2ikH9kNK7yxFOEZcnbV2Hf5PjlXOKD+TdBdJgzhEr3AGLVZs2NMq1DMNggnJU6G29gSEcQa02NHFLS/TPxoYZNEZTyfRPz+219JA7lXFWI5IiuHu+yCdHGzOeWI0UD3qAfGL0AMgno3Ln8qbOlS6wRSKyzmiK1hD6Fz9nUJfqVuHdzUw0VdGIycsNoYA2ygyKGfLfEYTIKlmraDEDVUFhoIRG467bYh9zj7tSvx3WA2bLWVxFMq8sFqlNOW0xBPUtdHe93mhpVrXkeYPhJss1OYL+HhZybLCnHoBE382IrVBeYywf0vPNv0orqu1qzli1RwZYJxC4XbUbafeiuBNZg3/rv+ouq4lnLUzMfRhlAPfcgzEKhBHyamiwgmdd0YHKQF24Hc2K2JqgSkHtSh2HN0Cb8tJSrJCyfkC0ZVosVURf+G6xh1ZDNdCo1HRblqcExrAc2xhybLefrTdb9FRocTWpwBAzrUu5IY0MUlGtVz6ClvlFhcTkPBskp5/0p791BPOng5vyY20Lt164yeV6sxk/cmArZya5HMeVZkLVNLAgSHvjhYqbyA5qH4vULPIndb7mlSEx0xln0cT3zsVAGwna0sZuK2mZo7lX7sD0X6+JYb7cEP960gbcSXKwPJRfviASUVjs7ltM7J2WLhtoExLdS+Opzd59pT/VpS3pbM0Z52ezM5x2GlWc+J4hg+Cu6/8MrfWjO0TZn8/K8wiLOw2AV/n2+xVkXrdUJRPTV99LMZot0WaD1dEmqnpbVAYI1zuZLFn0cFXAi4ALhuhAsNYWgyLfXKJ+Nrd0Uel3gK9ubPUPLQObLXcUqb2m79nEFrxMZsEh8KUNlcrt07F4Kr8KLo2nf/2igh5zEp/JjURDzwGLCB7VdY2wmzihcUda0Z6WRkh9I4LI6R6A2tnt6QaLy6pSpkO+HF6Xp4MxeBBrVOCeRf/2nhfYJ4IIkgHvM1mvKF+WQE/twM4gMoiDy8+LDv59YxDvQn3HTOq1rHIqU6k06cmzCicJ2TgcFAU0a0ZP7UXQwcYlnKYWgtuBIar2hTJUTZSrMWYaCU8Y/MqhvLxiffEzXWTWLoarFTY2xL9fVFeAKnEaiiDfFFxtwkM5EzgK4lClKi3PgU4yErocZ9jvw1/+OAGwSudbC/DLi++nMmHal6LxTfTLUFGXiWFnOpTgj8o9rt6612bH3WdF9UetlG4aOzVyeF2MFkWV3SmjIQrYzqPychTp5OfsiRChO40sNjow/ho2TomZPd/uu6v46sxxk9wr8AZSWtpBaBQEDgrbAOcKUXMb6rZ7UZWV6qQL2n8d/JsWQu13qH1Mpgr/Lku0zvRwiMNO4IZAMt+Sk9rm71VuQdVX+aO58Fl2X+YQNdZvUVdGLa2rg2QqT6MrRSAxhYs+TEhn68JBp8sprTpXZ5HbfwYqmUDCGZDfoGlfo4zAeuVkpKJq7wxj0lzabWM0TA8nl+mUPwfKLLyWKjEjnp7Ao0c2pVNvJclU3AEet/uj2LlwV0vj7Vat60D+ETME8iQcaavUWBU9yZnkFmzuRL5f9S7LrHp8R9/Q7P7Zu2b7oz6ey7xmmAR23DHAQFGQdOxZ1y9S9tBE5sXtCQfPY+cAvr2GkZyp1uhf74b5qSMMYf76vBdmxCiaMlbbhZRfIwFFldKgkLa7EYV/bBOEpTrqVaO98g5rmmAcgr3ommlIQr8FD1rgVOTJ7i2xfWYkTISdiC/SPufU0AlEMbfRUknsPs3f1okJ+0UUkC+lYCeSHpD/6lg9+R2BnIEm3PP5VcTwaDnXjiOiFHcq79zQwehAyYOje0PAw9k4V64H82NL3gpYUASJq2igeIa9WjVnMHBvvKZ1qm+EO3eGSiXz/YDkI+nxWntNioU+phVbEt6JSq5ZkPCwPs63L37ZDb2qZEXmsP4zq/A2t2m4ihnWSNf+Vyh+ZwgoxrvSD1GR1OnZHc8LOB/oFQxFZ+W/bZxtTPU8cRhJuihYQbV0XMSGWVLLyYZgTtH6SGKdv3cAIa1e/wp30k3vHn5hlUTfIjtC85n7x5cc6i8KvHpFLlf2f951IU2sMejwIKWd3LpzD3pC7jpmXb/RhkO1FLMQ+oUptqJqXSXTBk+qPFnSyAy5C1/B3AsTNG0BGKlxTWayoAtnqLuM3fU2/erDkz+MIWJyLU6ugUrnHhvzOIlBfo+oa/bIAsypZfPieR0BCKjEJoJPFYFDRZXvApMCfgnw+TMSnZ44no6Pz/P85eJ9EulY4tmv/UGsZ7mbH1k55Ce7iopYFeCjGb44ThANnidjYg1Et5nJFR+fM3BhSDWYX7/hwLNfP4i4oe3F7sXeU8SAp/sfB38aVNmPz9ynVwFM9Udu+NA3mxxzXm/rqg1WyzN19SfDBkSk9OFypAFmJNCp6TwdBYjCGTsxVKvWBAaoKoHIEPCAjn39wGitK3P0nWTPqVJQfthh3w/xXHg8MlhMZUZvS3UUTxl2FLKCjqT//kCpO+3wK2gET+VTUGxsB/5OOOn2Tqvta5a4SkyznHaXVdJ3Jny6oRlVzZHn0FagNgq+574Lu+A6q7geUhrqI8EW4ABvGR6wSMw/f5anHxmP+YkUubWEL4+MsgRzTieHiPRcOpxhHLSaZhOcPPpRpntKtBuK0RW98F5HRqskzju63oB2AX93HnTD0EqFQ+O26fvDr9Tz3p5dz5hpOgcpruMrIIlrWgOLdiT4wGt//qqdZodYHr9yUEXlRc7l9kqXvGT1HiiJegQwL5qDYhQzdHmojiwW53ggJ+YzTX/WtWMsfrHT51gRq3RFowgHQQKoGMcdwZJT1ebBIde2Frbx0/l0J4nFnBlPdOU2VyR8gg0LyWe950voVvcbO5xIb3dnGnpVNc9lZrr5fmaWfvwF+n5XAV9F5Gz585/RKPl+68Zn8B3sFBpv1mOJ12YZsA0k5EiPlEmMUmendT01UoQzr0WgOupTJ5QJJkQPgHEEEH3C4vxiCayQqp9ZhNYwV+0n1+edxL+iBzYPBU1kbPAYtOAojmMsjne6pCQDh6nVKFAId0zo1mOs0swl2S4BP0zIpdbE9I6Ca0hAQepQo7qn3Z26OxrMgPztlPxKnuVkfBu8cbhyPHepaQP3tvkdt5WbEniR5EQGaohN1UFdMV0xdPh9BsksoltSsoliSzPgQwvVznMSymJaKvOlM2KR8p5tx+xphv6yZA5rLXygRaypcNnFhQNMP2uKC+nfw86VJ0a6+YeazcqLVzoU6FUSmGdmt/DmxvatnkmWlPXVeUwGEXHnwyzuVWaH1dIBAgllmAxLxbeBVy7gBRIKlfYrdPDQD9DFxGLfOyyqY1CxIsMAtrxmXypcnH5iqPFqUrvFB5ZwYSDqRra8FrvNaZ9cifIkc+tndLZZLf6PdIbSu9lozirRjvg/cDgo5SL7d4k82EWRTIuNh3GwfVrpQh9isgB/LOREIDijVXAnYAT18+qf8ufYl2+mGWSsalTP09ax5qVefFWPmPCtsjZxjuSZUx4X9Rk6pSrO5Y+KnfqS65sHD75FmEzLg0UDfl0UPQYaUc3O2Uc4UWG+zY/ZZUcnGgzsKUiiP211z8/GbArpSWyqaMF/H9po2BNf0hcQLhMEsk2P1qhC9a3r0AjMRwXlmmrEV63E9DGoF7pck8iWnWX74DZ+bR7PKl6EaxqNbTSXG2JyBSGM5yWly7F1cf/6Ma/jgwdbABUmg1CLSLh7vY4JYk5C2SiXZnYOWuLuAamsnY6ee2EcHRZkynty+5BNOSLwHCwTB6CzUlkH8DT4WRd1/vNAx8aTe9cd29kK7HZFhs2e6Fyip/h/NTZbKbo7MtNKqEb+PBaTpELIW4MguzTf/+U90RcXT+u7T2pJOH4NnmZyeiMxJz3tOE96TGiFEkrshAZSYr8+qcQPXa1a5ud6cSBi+wgNY9li4ibyG1Ntdgci8bCDIk0IMJFRgyEwJO1jssoHOUt8qrFnwcWnV9W1u6sL3cNJ9dkC939r4Z23n3JotKdvUJtawfdPcOaD9kmfvgd5EGpYu0NXDdSBaiTVbmM9v0tsDTQ+xUtb/98LUeGrootvnaQd0OmvzpThW08dIBYl9YJHDL9e3E1mtWDnHL30D5zDFgBA4uAzoYw6gu50HKy1wLomAm1SG0MPPMW6kJWMAwP7z2QBSF6jrQflmRS+7L8wKAIgtSV8t1pgCXTSBMD5Wwl3JrsrOdHWIbN+BM+zhUVY8SO3nZ4pH1u5AsK2rfsVdvnCvpa1BmD3tjqSVv8Y/xlzyONy+LOTI50FURTDhbdLRw+cSzce50ChALiHp3jxd5R7QRKhZueYA0GoWXoeEJwcnHxEew1aYAfcBum95tCz2P8H95cBGlNBXXaAYJ9rloK/g3Wjtp6IiTpwr+CmTvDMIN/Q5YG0n/4rTGS7QhdEKlX7S1G8guitivbmqxUWueydi16wyaPKmXq57XfHhUYVCV31ml4bZ9aaXw6O0rj9tD6dqYi8mJzd/HduTc9H56n9YY4w1AQVePK+Ft6hk3I8GTwwWNHVakNz5Bb9AV5HLnTKp198u1CSPEi/GyC/DLYP1/Fcmg+imU/NBzzUmhA/5KPuchlq+sbeie65eMwXYyDAAqycFuEJhgA4c7ZACBZdAOtQu8H9NgDgjMBIe6TtlUs5aKfUCTs3JoeklM22xOz5nkhy0W9KPYUoiVdiMb70cVKuMs93BphXOogZEFV6yodXmfaEhvXNxr5H3yORVq2Uby9ravu+Xa254vX/ExGpVxjnrVVklnv5eNxkiwZZ2ozIOWN/KYRpgHMa08g9yhklroCU7nJ3PaDkk/CyVbcOUjZMDYZopNPeL/ZtgYjL/nNXk0VH+456vRiHyt5d3qGFUoTrHYV6yoilTNERjNSOXM5VM41ku3mKVlotLpddtqXZIFQ/LtAxOS390ApwADWsuVn752w1TLuxpn/DzgGF7LXcPFihs5jdnkgNq/rf2ovMmW/x8M4+XiagW0koZpzZ01ktzgfrg7jmJI2iTxS50+7TyVLhqcwG4vX38vedPGKpmC3pXAYxLeiq2l1tUjTki4/AiaCSd9nfjqrJmmpzLqb7hr3N4CtCUIePnbbQ3B69rXMm1Qfms9k/zTR/LPLIMj3PLJD0QeUYq+YVWoXYZzdCzdUvYFMwRd8W+uNi/BZ2dih9Cs9ROK0MbbiFedZ6m2SzidXZNfh+SMp3/OPoz6e11TQ2YalP8cDPiLmVnlLYCKQqIswnrCxR55K/roGDZIY+atxPRAig4NMS+qYyKJXl2/FI7yLS9KMREtm7NBXEU4SmRixpgyWlzbRpd8l/XSntXBt3F08xhOo/BXo2MmjQeU8L8mgL1Ee0MmMlQMWdr7L6onn55UCUx6GI6dKG9ErD3I5j9Z7Ya4eYicXDDZID323NpOeIrhR7AQeSbtxalcwsKzK7vDVVFNUtaEk1nikkQm75KRxHWqiC1lj1yvUqJChajwSC+d4cTDYdS10JTfV1Z12IlDjlGHl/ebz8AybFyy5jBzpXQqs2BaxfzHOqCMU20X8L70OzLwRa4+0IuFofMJ5Oo1lJck8eGJzvubEx0o7tewqJtPIxnJIO6GAgkzgeJ2aNJtFN3WG5WY5iFBK5Pl/Ft0qSqecEkOjQQH0brJPAEPwnXj1q91ZDaCK3N09rDjQjMu0AXuPEdXFKZRoKAt1iOZpWFjVpzgJ+LU1mrwh0KdWz6KoIxqDprj2Y7iRCwDRGAaMTIp31Fx8PO7WWiR7vpJaApu8YisuGiy5YdobnwGYxIFaR9SOVu6Iwg0FOdY7ymQQGmqibflYocSAnqC/4fWj+rNI0rDxAwUcgMjOFhEz+m1U5b6hfz2iVq8H1KDnkTDdpfxUKkoJcEAzEPCKEzKDSeUq++dqRQyKoRxPVsrex8n2o2BI241F4mXOXI6DjBRGpKTlauerqsm11ks+Bpe9v4mJQUdnhDUQyFLV+EnAAk6r09K3RvbSHVw3qRcnlNH6AIJLpqtztILKeiQvss3ZP1wddtSV2alPi1ICjh4GH2RtiHMJAC/h7WavmyFsmasYtxoxcMEA0MXxfcT6Qbvnx0QQ7e/kcHDsJx6xFXuNXWiKTSylXuxNVsKYTJ30MP0RNWSRtFiJqgvHLfr6+ypVxAzebuaPVILPyu8PggBMRQ/q2RjYGULn3Fq+w8NlTL1VtLYq9H2pXE0p5PQhhdrX3XvTMSfkwP5CPylTb6bjvqZBp+GXIXDoQFf/jUmKfP1fIEdfFHbdVh0+Ch4kjnQMF3DAQTDi21J8uWedii1SVvjLHUmVLtn3Akk0jZL9i39pT+BX3Qx38+PFz7QHC+uZ+NTnQAmgAT5z7wIlvgzKF8l39mFxsHWS9DzP7dce3mpvlw6qzQD+2ES9H0RpsUGVfb4APs6R91bPbP1whh5AA7x8YYSpu9add5JXz0xbWbwfe+QPCvGGaJMCvMcqqbs5J1j2HZsXogWaioiVbSXlDpTu52YWctBYELn6Wjn/KcGYm1QG+yA9IsD9MYp+0+TuR0KEFFSOyaAd3JDVdpQRdUtcRCna+x6M1VO5QDXJi3NDQww/n/4qNQn2jupk8GaLVE0k61HbdIPtQn3Z59X/KueD+t1oKpHK7XFgC5qfqgmflG6P5YWcQ+cwPhZQFbswPEOT+xk7FnVFgZ/wQ+V2ngHiPqXCbfPnL7mQBkQGh4jsHcmsX8NLl/RiT3R7SM0sQ7rj9t1o/vSNdCPu0HTdY8yG8LlEoq/ITRZDduiJjQDqvIdzsQ3KBhxBESCX51ccpXXtHYZyygMVQITdPMy+lMWsaD4kB9Hf2wuCRDby/Q3MtMH+GOtonxiCCu0/Ec9rURNxmc50fVEuJhi5Z0gdqP1rS3Iz8BIuxYsY+PVTryMMsWoxfW+9nI50v3Pb5oaCeZ314FEVChIzY0YIPnDoD8i877ARJ8rGTDHBhr02vvDHAxfSf9Ie24MGhVInNzh1e5/0m3Uf5MhbBcM8QZkPS0HN+Nf1RhUynsYZjvpnM+rHfZH0Ml5LV/YFJ9yWiI6Dbg8bg42aGTGfawy38dT1u+IpjIlaYGUuj/WxLGP7p3Bdcr2cqyow2yqzHLzH8qpPyC3644T7+NMMfh1kJWCxA8jofDMvS1yJsQYQTgbuRix5mkYSp2meQUBwKA7YmDzAblE/4IgRypNNoSvULwV9RSPWB/0q+me1Xg2yBQz3xX/cWey+EIk7iJsStwfBYXS9ibS7IDzdQetAcRkzZVPmqKdXMj590CGg1YT7H/S/Xb3L7KuQbT4N0lNtQ88ngEkfG0zqzns9ZVMXSDh9o2DfjgqI1EMNTuiMvGxKO098/XOHzs66BMntE4yAvexZbQ/0vE30hdmecde1vGKlVCqPFPb2MAztH7Z2nmWKLDovKIjjAgL3oxClBCKg8LhPha2qPvRwVoHrAKC/hQDNw9v/5H6hbZgAP479272cdhATpb1H3PP0Yp5S7N79Sq1zq3qELD8xl3jqYSpHoVccnY47T40PG0S7HkfPupg+LsAsfLJFrz1qZZJQ9J439HI31CA1/VF9qupW4NhgravkvyMUT+URcaED0wPXAMmWdMJBAvCL/+Ieru4Xj6HcNgx3Wken0F8ufxTDZU01e3M+GEDePfeje7FL1Oi/ULisYOlLRqnO6NGKqeadcy121zaR7V+FOb+dklnrnBFO3alplZki01bTJlaD2NLV27bGONIMXuJO8onQgH5qRrQM8+MVtRcOSEoWf7b8SwoWBxG3HISvASksRQHXvTURuAfM5bhJPOvm1Ux8n1y34+9dLNMdwOkPwd2ggn+SCo050QG6tcnIELeZ+GwI8EWbUUZ8gjFPnfzpqTaBRs0uKGqleVhI3PeIoYyIHeCrmDKA37GI4ygbujOIg04ZQ4MY1YmWRjE4UWYTfBTyeKOQOEIbvXyKdMXpdG6Z1/07gGrJd6S+tAfOXALY2HPr4iZxGZ0AToM0t1LpjtjxoRDzEohEWCV6sw0M+LByNF2XXZwKR4lXEKw+gRbozhtUxTBVjmS6buFEnYRDUrca6s+QqoQ9krpexE+YXRIyZgUmtrVUAc4nDgCZyHXaE9O1kWzclQIxptWj74lmolIR9wYEw5eES8SZj+fbbSD/CZa+nm/gz88iHs75WZRrEsbR8elhrPUUY1iqFlq7oeh2PHyPem4UeR9ilfksi48bSSR0EUzgUWp5vgQw2C7yTH3Gvxmtr4Fim5BsSStFhFVp+Sad2GWIUauI9I1FdUcHgNx/klD95k0GlTYjUk39JPncd5IJqU5KH4eloFs5g9HrOEBcnk0PkNFG7Ifmu++xXpXHWyah2G+OB4uExKJP92Rlna7rbf0m+ITOxE1uOTeOCqQxNUurgVKiRZ8l44miW1GgYiLzkruXDPHslYxL22AtciHqHdyGivR6EeQq4wc64PbvhekWL9KoF5UBGcsR9S2VVE10LVn+2WZVJV1XWkP+Gc8PBTkqnfTdAWUVb3zyrk2EVx/N+pO4f9pc1A55zM/8+k4T7SGL8iNcEqUQVuBrhgAQ815Glb4EBho+9aSr7O07FJ3M4hJGie2qylf0/NVF3yw++UzITLBqF4Fp2fig10r6R67GWj28PH4NTKfarkhxa1Qm15XErec9VAsD/g76uhWhIgG0NOv3LV5dXldADYgoSngO1Zy+8vOh7+UV6jiDNOqDEkEXGU9nzrsO4zNEbj4F4DuG0audvlMSPcd2aEbaKQjxNAT+XNAmq+Mja5aLtYavYOmsNUhzTCDE55LHIhFIj1zb6siYHyPkal+exfdZetNH1q3xw8DsHGreBmKktWI8+S3dxHYBP5ElS7ZfLo1Crl0GvTOVofjTqKKpQ/E7r7DPpw2uJV/OYSEQdKSc2SN2b6GoWYdjrjTgVWT93ZGug1514NY2yfqiy0aUqCowo45uuTTPO5GXgkbDXJMLVLs5wgQi8bth494k/NIusrnIYAgIxU7TnAncf4p7rz3ZQKQc1GetKAqy6aJD3aW/6tEVhOCxcL+XbdfF8YCEaTIuwJ5b2QtcR9m72/NHTb9kbzaphMRv91AIm1EkcpLPtgojFV2AcjM/5X4lmrCJ5U0/VKf+ClxCpedD/JqEedzCdkGuhWU3gEgHVNSbJItVrKq6lMHX38yiLUf6HuWIVqGfDIgrqupF1C+OxTYFuulN0SGMRXvmFMfdR0bQqO7Nn+/SShFVRJ7BEx9iFKwgqA8ZbEe/rCxF+N8y6vsTPmmkwDUZ38mFQzZ7fDxS1EU37yQT9gHZoUapVf5FFCQkeq/MMB3eQxcVE7zTK3X5oPCuOW/tmPmKRaU2QberwrrPoiDwx3xaLVOFZpDU2hZjh7uhJJj5ZBI/4IAZYqM9knOXpAU1T5JVzXlM9gk5VRP6oNHIRgCyD0MjiHf3s/CUAusOxWLYMI9qKw5okq9qYyZRJSxNObIxU0Aca3zcYuR+uo3/ePH0FdElK9Yb/LEOqBZO8UF3cJKm4tqX3IqqgIE7KiGPTWh0nV3w2IiZ49Qjfk6Je+GZpy/9jh+F9VU0Ud86+kCjQ95LuZAtbN424jsXoeCNH3qHssq76IEXgCCRSyyHOFXXWmlwyJgB76LhV81PjOUbV8TjuDFZ1rQ/0veLH5dpx6tS3Rh46QfbTfqVHwA3IRbgXfhL95TuV1wnwy62WAdhhHIkj/TNlsMGhp5JkEZVKESzG+Hzj+TWwnXl20Up16CjvPAwH+INY9+9JmPOy4WJoBjOxPD5FdF+b5cPumZhXtg0MTwkvF8pCQhrtpS+wnzSm/pWu0SLTmtBbvrclurP2hld51F/UlgSG5jZtgb7fCAxH9wi5nUb5EVLIKXt3C4ShCs6YX9yJMppC9xyKXbAsQL+gbkU0+LSs0ZG/YVIUaPs48NZgMg675qE/Vz/OUeFs4N/FeTvkyS1reTB3M6NsGJ5xzxd4FrHKy+vd5+hZBJ1tTXPF3VqSiR+dR00cswsF36mYVt/y2Zi+nNHmfWwA+HoPw0gzvl3NDvQGOuRdHPesufOXm1FZzH1GCuE7C1aQGYZSuQrLZsz+63lVzIU+Gf/Wu0pQVIPV8RhFlFNH36/eLDz7bHsUdCXyghjKFrZbRena8zsJyZjbwGi+Sds4A9WaKjkTlmQOhqem2jhFVPsMAGKhavGrU44Y3tOJcSEWVXi0ayBv2KOCVO581DP3aMIYC9Q/8VjQIusvkQYnChowBGFti3iMqGEjN3uRFEZIRv9uKCFBkmVOetDrin3u0nTuq40Kgx9VQdrHRYGUkPgtPgSn7pvwmjlHbmsQNuAjCI5437wIOoWxsv7EN/dUrgFtoO4mc/tB+mErTf4DruamRanBs29NkfYi8UHVoCIZ+Sh0sYL4Zc6CKuuKTaZ+1Wzje0/5Cw6XqYRNVbs39OzAUVZkzBGm/NX8+nzFo2dLYRLafTKYWmyMtIB2PAogsW6N63XNtinWJ6skr1IuIzmTX9Hu3LjRqae02I2hrw/r+M4sNpKHLo4U1mEm8PNBXTr1uN9aQQq0/dp/mz+j7a6RF32eKPLHqH0qyfUHZfaqp6F4DeGJBw/gHX7sAcxEQgXhbE5pO4PC7pj7Q2W6ePiYo92akNVluftpovODKCCL8Zh+YvlOe9E+FnIadj7+C/+UNhQ+YBFsiyB6pJS4kQ23dcsUitmBr3YV65UAIugHdM8RK4hAQMiKypYfx/OT88XpxODR+j/cBwNe6g5nxAQLWJFocDQPnV+/z9aBLqmTVPaF4MmuVEVrieWlcGOO+x4guaxdvHwmWWw7NbLSZPWTjxT3naBa+Awm8ZjkpTMsKvMI6po0wxRYPcaaWde9GdvlnSWeli3PsArlOmWnHhf2nb5xHIsvz/uvLgPUSp56NxPfXZJjxjTcab/obUSpuserRZeYzpbaTwrowBDm3dx7J0VrioUAb0fjhuIANWtesaG9lX7+YdOEkZqvetjAZGHLrTgED0hkWhx/cF4aHlMDFk5K1QjkaOTbst6aa8ksNWpznHy/Ct7qItfcPQ5unvFZzH9GPK2F92+uXRy9TBq0QmXskTNCTQEAkDAYwmSfx76Ua6SS3+x0CacLMIiuGfggRSgrCoG+TICb3FeshQB3yjfoSghpP+61DA6BSFiMqhgw57preDVuzm3UQF6LqCoMRmLEBOmQ9nEUaEk9Bc6zRB6gcufkW37Ue4sG25GX4HElm8+88zI66Uxib4gGFKLZfOZ82G60pnHN6D5prq32eY3dhXV13KuNmxb7ForKEqwHEmklDSAS5L7kKNSgGgppJXb2oDdn1warnA9DABXKonvmHjlBFSmsUE74YtTVTYkXhsAPhDCdBOZO85JIoHPpvC+Bi5gN87NSaW7HLzaS2uepPZoSzBq0UOB/0Gdf1OvBN+kh11fW4A5vE0v1OkDT09DP1bQ4M35hFDE8iWv9cJRaImK9OnfAq71rvgKJj2m5z1P+UKEcy4FVmONG7TEaOgxyaq2plnYF5DrNCBiibxv0Arn+eT2WegMggtT96oo+UFa8fFwCYHwY8eJSRlnPwK6GhiaLVN1sdrhW/SaZKlOhK+fmu3Z4d89D+l8uSxQ6+QTx9h0eFmpXPr7+zHNZ1RLyNH0tgM+jmsBz8sXBQRq3bbZW/gKCsFVsp4v05M68bTnO81yW10UqW7HIe3+TyGKAQuU73Y1O0/DvmE+Q4nLe1t/ig9tFdNCGUNGxAfekwVURoEepgkcZUqsoCxRl2FM/u4ObSnhdQRC3koVE8XrXZ8nD81WLfzI9qJ3rY/AI/WZpMS8lr/Qo/OtYOJO8znz7FOqIJ2YvimDDiIFluSplE6chJAccq+52aCHphlpuFUQCVx2rJb5qcSbHV4b6WeQPQbOefdTrYXcEA7Ws9iu7yIW6mzN4avhJNu1zrklqGnCu4FSv2fv/fU/QDF2gRYKkc8MNoxNxjD1E/AZ/RAkocfySgKnudUu0f2Ld7K7u6wQC5UcENUvdA5iW+IJYeA4mOR5HwEtC5uRGxKhZBgz3WE2+nuzP+S5gzKsiixqDzFNqqylJPalEfPPmt9GBR1+9rV8T85wQg9vAREqFblfZwjdHOtg9bTNdtKyUy9ChQhP/Hra0cGt9oPHB0gM88zAS8OfQA9gw7zero4gbahrA9OqatgLjCHqnRgqVY/ux+R3dOJFXAPi/Jr8ua1dxh3VKWRZIb4vzdfXM5foAXm1Att8qtfWq/NvG01cKaAhFmhZblSTFv4i/etMP8yDYmgkRcHgjJLni3FUruxnRjjA3b+EXHvspvmJk81zehvJ6hZULN/fu1ntqMpA93cc3BgYbBXSPx906tb5HFDQ6pZc0AbQ6CDUOaQG9Hc71T6QxA4k9iLEltQM8KuDadqAglybFtic7UniSob1PaoAWhz23F3fbogGmVEhC2FhBgoPlTXMXPjBwBaswKa/6KPkGaW/eXKRrMF8r80yPXUhdFWnrzJWfmhm1sylIz1XMK62tCVkhkpb5iXL3nyviHBobl1UigZQ5fHGHG95Rh6F8KI6HRSvQqP9BQO9i63hO//tEGUoDmKj84vF8XOdJsNWG+ylrbJNgX6i0qjgR7e7i8g1fSgMJQ2fB/Uww4KG/SwP7bm+1v7pYpa6oFPFU1P0ieYWpXFiQ6iuCkchUO2yFLr8zNUFNjF/JphY+Hmf1zA5dw7MLXmE/PC8Tx7WmmgbVVRUurPLicah8SvE8ECkbmITg3wue3poF2Tos3lzLGSozxA2LLrCTRdN+qbno2n7dYzzSOrKnmHktDJHlqXn0BBndQ+D2l+cNaFic/5Ejyunb+u/hr1cPgJl4TnXRNtTABJAttVlEqCK/AIkNtnx0Vtdc2+cM8D0wU/tUBkR2Yt9xCoAcFqDiagpzCVjCkgSrR0Gw9t0cXvgdRwD+rVD8IY9pPGBYLn+gRKHMWn9IPGgoTJMqgqFH5y6GyufbQy8dkI+PZYb/wa+13bmlQ0Vf+s78AlLLUWJofgw0sz9y2Vofq/gjzTdOyzSzhRpgJ6HKcMtJcaQfUHE6pUAieS1/xtqCDfBbmELGhEQEzb4IRskcmkhbz+va4y9/HjFFZ1V2WxsELySf8eE31SEMJA/L64riytmixSsRg5DcR1w4dwmn1/iAn+8uXGOjk/nu2ZX3pHnY3ozKMJfN9Xl2LtecSozWV2Zl/n6Al3q17WaC567Bbr0jlYkGY/UEKqcl5czJtb1lEk2z7IWxb4oZIGAPmNF/rEg27aYqJkARm5m8+pq57b3M00JlFMDvXQ8fjc66u06cJgIOnGvl7H98lxmtttvmj8WEGZDKLLWb/hYQploJ8B6fRTHk1JPJyDmYNMu35s5GcK7VkgE1JOL74jPwfuR+YxV4pLbxnEWqlI+kOBDDSYCYkqEyIbH3867bpG7spovADZ79Yrhhlty3+MZyJe1XQQQcQcQSI4+ndZ93tIlr51UrjShOeVXMbJlpvkZcyiecYcWwIodlEQm605VNkXC0N5m+BJfwe5LqPA51ZJqEw6/lkp4TlzFm6qWuwyHPfyS8AEtf2yhXrwLFm6RL9W9R5BNGImHQZGHGPllYkticH20M8binaBzXWfqXeTCcEI8ob8M5m1dkXiW1zb4UwMgkErsEssZDLMZFkza8Xtesvfm7zykb+DX3fjIr9+f7xeYOeK2zhqrKm2IL7KAC8buLEi9rO9zUWGZ016nP/vbz6mr7CduGme9TcADmC6qJTv96WicO+ku/bb6rkMnWjW9DeXJxEHi+esayzCtqdnY4iKui/DOVVW9hQbd4LqxtbStZgFVqSjwS89XmHPKMM5OzEVDaA1fdFbvH3EBY+7/2rBeaob5HRpV2a5spNdRRL+zV8dramTIEUlh3ky1VlNTBLgeqeOpkZmIQwHnNCyr5wnHf44WCXu2TumJJ+fiFIhCAiki6nHKcbTyd07Fx96B14wCl3EXovqIMaEb0bDtOciqX7dajNeyZ837iP5S8vlUaI5drAIEGmpa79DVrFOFp3FBteUZ/T3bjw+4iMAMxZOygaVD5XdebcgUZk+j8RKd+ZBwTvFKj1acMC+W6NCD16+6bw1ZyIy71kj8AWlXGSsqilRR8DFhHZ7KRuTEAWB88W+ZdwHUR0IxXHc5+hqru6Jykp7hdQgqJX1DmX/p9y6Hr4uocW2PUfiGwzaS9irVsWPb0mEknfnLCo4IEvR+baKOysmY7stGAmsY7Ul4YsWCJpvrA9AiogORMu/F8M/PaTtelgoNpMS6bk2TfYB+3QVK2sgPPJA5n0LeNzGEuBJEtPBVLChIp5P34m8QQQ8AS3di3jdYbOXnTvMHnLyL60OpOV9zgWk62i235Ldq1+ARK02flTRmiTjjdSpTm3gPxOnb6ZgUNf//YBGDj75dB/xuVEeUz2fiaHoYTL6WZsOrGfGcHaQ6Wi/vykgPkVFlfwfGoyT7Buu3C3h+HTtEA7EOM5HYpRiYi8LlLUWAahAQJ2Qp5e6bGeOvCpvFu1VMi++twRHO55mKglSw26MN2OLPq+VYkJFYvEHA+yB+O8/PIoG+tGu6ouGbzXjUga0ZyFCfagLobd8e9lCZEriTeTjEOnyMpRFBylL/iZ3ig1ErqE8hYc6dN22RPC1+c7G9ktKi7lbVp00wii42nHNrtyWi8Hl02qB40xFcNFrZzQKt0/KNiV3tgapvZz1ygxpVX/QjX9Oujw3utMVDSAM74F95l2xadOK96Jpn5y6cTjRbTV2xwjNC/y2hXI1oZTAEAKWvejjJM8yiVcUNBCzgQN+HHJm5IbEOh491N9JM7Gs2OwBbpY57TcP3PwOljdldaZDmF6lpPsA7S9r8tNVmUOcLOTbBpgV2EiNYA/XtUIBdP5SpLahzfxKrhIys93svwo+Mq22o/PX04yBrxc9S+V3snWoNpvtsbdXuzrS8tgBiWYhUV3k4RLmwQBIOwL45xKytd4nY58AphRBCohlWaPKJhnRhpaRT1ef5XXIjcIz+zaKbkyFdB+SNUEjPke3TxZ7kvDgyptzLOM617E91H7ngLP+866D4Lonf8An/TIbfIRPU+5pFrgY+mc8hQvmw2HuHSKVqrfoaGhTEpB1CMyAhCvkqhwt2gihcj67GknL+Gfx2ZeQNksL9TMFYuYt18oTdS8cYj3qKl4Rh5Vm2UYIuKFMCk5wNqApudHFytMA/DGfHAPPrKTysrSZoBkYClpJ4JTfLQeg210Drel3WeRuEzjv3P2/weAYZ6VnoeNQjkGVU7tdlZSp993X9tFmlR6X9BqwS3l+7g/Yw5Z2mNGLb5G7KbLgfXsehtiLUclOD6NvdeoKZC5gU8N5jABhw4RreZ9QBTFj3czghz2uhagaSJrhA4XYpLeyar1xPFqjplrTZL0fkJZeqz0t0JGerpPSOdN+ZzP98HdU+AwicqiXXVGmsP+7ByzAEeScGvB8NuSz+RsonVhJYtMINMZ8pY9meXtgpUREYadgOiIwo2wxABB1skw6G26Zm2rwQiX49IyxEjn3UHO9U0yOm2EPglPdj0IjPSNIfchH04rYTXr0L/OGcBrY/1shl/Igkx0DUIdMjOxC2Hw7ZbCZWIUpgqC0Z5UDbfOCgOyRjk0rAgimrXOeuurowRlq1wVPrRcBP/R2P4+bO7UTMopnjBQG86ADMuwIlZfbX+IJTk69/z3GnTVslNwWl9+KgidKe3/ApoeKbx/c88+hklAgZS/Lf0RJ1m3E4g/IdK6AJ04+kxU1dU386EcOmtUatEdH1GhZIo/JAHtEP0rcNY7rrJvQfM5eB3FshdwGgR9UC2tfN77Kt9EluZQNVtkxZRlSEvKGvoJPBBaoU8m/Mp98ffuC6gQWCRMfpwYsXRKDREHs1RXW/5wBlYADk0irD6nb70/laLxcV5iN5/ZgKXt/ysSzpjl6TaItbfnOxe0dhkkoAZ7x88oPuJIJ/fyTwXbjggClbVQVmwuh+zFLTBJAehRhTgUmRYQE9sEOdkyg2Hx9HNlsA9zjPsSDNW6WLht3fXEdCrbGNtSl1F8Q/CxCl1rnbQOBTylzLetMWB2p4I1MrPX5Oh14ukSI9rQctH7XB5zjgFabcos3KnQ+SWVJqo7649Mcl6IinorZWgLdCG/lRPJiKLQipu7LjAxQ90WA5eopcFH1Dpk6LDSsrZsTIjLIwpD5YnyNyxlrBZ+Z302cXSZ/KQ92N9EVCER8d6Pb9znu/y11yn7g3DM6o8LTSQdeKtmmW+vdHgDqEEJs2DII/HLdh69Z4vaRW1jFeMgU1o77oxA8rkofeDjV+sbOAYESJ5ZqRu1vSdPXIuhecx3+mwEmbAglBKRfP0wUYWa4NdllWlgPolKZbh/hENYEkDwgo7jI5scPMS5JAdHw+j6Wad3PcrGfj7qXKIi9w2WhBAO0qvG/cp1qElJwN01IhR1WdzCUKk0DAw4VXk4qtfhZ/LbsZvVcWyaZuhrfsApAUe1iQ9SiK7Nr1O70L3Ecv3pwohJwPr5e1k+dCRM6sgx84O2I6duAshIIGW82DiQb6qW6nTW2IjuFd9nkr+bK9du7vBYj83/wOyKY7PqyxlT1sG3QKemp9HdbxdTXEhcdVtea7046foYwK0SKmi2WjSUjdrhqRH6eye+E4gsFgVfuk+DIOZ9mJfrhUZHBCw6xn4xBP/ZZKf30KPxVT4bVwthGJp84M7fJEVZPgUDuJzRrE5GS7EzkBbLpaP7jKIBHxYFVL3JpIQKUGa7DVPzYR8UxN8RcgGItsNYut2thWyqFrAQ3CzTh5dFTDlyn5nTIDXmZF0aEIzr9Axl7W0YzbQden05i0lm76cZLzNcb3ZGoqAs7syKWq7yK3Q/ZYe2e4fSxCv1BAW2ihS4WIdrFVVCp7cDqG3enmgzxpeVYJXoHPwFpEnAbcMZfeEo8Ttm/kvtFktKoAt22tTWuf4cyws+bT59YY+ENVmsv892QrSAt8RnoDddn2BwVgnNvYlrsdoZo2kUYk4khO26z/dGr0Q6rxG6u5cS6RVKHbUnKCQvsn6b55nsAsIqSjqrbawoS7cFCrf1JwrPqhKA3VrDJq623Iw6Mp2eTtpSoUPXpozGso2TMOsTXeyOesVAKmNzQnV+tYqlhU7waGGPRPfGWQz4PjKQMOldnqoZ9NrP38puzgniBIyxtQKsWhAnQiHvK+wKr9YYNBjBAVY0rmPHKvC4WmeI1WRfnIo8HLNtR2FvDy1Ljon+YIPsH0bvsrtNpVNK+uVqh+JNXOYoloGxKTrgrQcnvwQkC7e3kAtwYn2GPxZ73KM/pR+Q5zJnPkmZhNaJ6P+nsqgSmUyKVnUg/ImzRGa51bVd09XVCgzg6Xzmq5SvMpUEIPx7nZIk+m0GbV5/YyJzdhYnisy9ub69jfJfm3AjT3fNe7tVaB0hAYrPAYA8Tl8Yw71As4gd0RtggUmsodMZ/mJE14DtmMgQPIpaT7w+kiFTPZ6tYX6N1wWNVuSQcjUP1gp0BCcasewMFs58RVVpHTn1MT305WP7oEzpEzD0sIUZ1RAILrcHEI5i8A1pGpJAa2bgz3Xw9NmzaJkTHxtJFF3n67MzQKu8fXsfC6ua5JbZXbBrow/u+cmo5zYg0di/ghKWhx5A8wPZ/KWlpD64JPWSMB/sClsQI6/lwba4hmevEfPOR+NW/yZY53L8uKC9pkM5wJtA3YxFeO8ZDoSZDYoDuq+a8f0sVWTPxVfkwxhyCfgCqXDUWLsstMqEkftxOVLxYbuiOacNJyMgOAY6VSdnDhdSJn+Y2oM7qOG7wb3SneN6EzKIS8UOZ17fktnTCBt9/iZZBiW3Sc5z1JngJMUxRokZ3N5p1CO+5vjjBdcdSsn0hIKUgutQfBp0W+wF2aq47NtL62GO1E3MC4MxlOPv4jBuY8602mFmv0BnKRGsPqhIxtiQr2wQOiz3/bA2qlr4acAfhVoM7lr2E8uTdvL0o6w417lt5qqNUz/N453xgya7f1VdvJr/WJ4zOQPyF3CvyKHdGlLGCUoUuhM1AsTfFbhZUF55gj+S02er4Vq7hq5cbyJM17uZxanTGU2YBJKPfnidz/tS7QQFliijMyFKqn860zSwSPOxjLGUvY1VX689frqtOT0gmu9iRENvqxP6fQFSBvIWc8ZDCaQaab+l+KtxA/7OETEeOcP8YCkEeXAgzSW32ZYI0VsWbBdTJnk4DGtRsaMMy5a0JKcIttAWFEreic+D+8oMZM0UzbnOnKvE8SYqYgLHq+D+li5rzHpEITSibBZ+sNN15wIbDgVxVpDKFn8aWsP8PelObeM+jZuqFoJEdRamntuetbw+B/MYVnSb895rJtV6W7nPr/xwBjgmIwvH+GOwlWFD6QflWsSG/njTCQdL5QfVuFlcs4PH4EUsmh3geoTZphobefO0UAMhWyi696c1f+QcasJkSfgiaFYXKdo2QKD44ll6bV/+p5cMN+6Vp9cHFtTiLMCHKNuQmnmY3CR6eAkOtP9L90Dxf82PYKrUpV6jJOzapaskY2QbMM831Me6RjZy8+AXIkl9ho7lXgoPtGlvXPiffxm9Thj+TtX5vxINBqeibAiWU4BTOlmnc1mtOtGhOy11hU1jDe9NXL25blf22qyhMTW7nhrtAN4uP5D1AnVZpMLWtYbFYmB82a8mcQM0/LmbZ5HaVpjWrrwiXOeiza3NntPtlC8E3elL16KF+lf6vlx03bka8HK5QodhAzdzeg5xyW4x8xc2Phk59vFi7N7jbflUvuk1w1wzKZlW4PHbWRTuuOzXdAftmJqzt1PV7+No2pVnrFUN5lH8Eg5+NtfHmWUMvTFYG+WjQ7rswsE+pP+jPhc7Y2xys+D9waU0ZhiE9Qf/bshoEmz6tVQQwmSZ9CS5HrbO9Vlc2jSsjn1zLAQ/eqVzbEp3vrXQRLT+zOPuhD6WS1JYDwaKsgGO2WUVgCRLvvFd1aZjY4KG5EzfM3kF9269FBgDeiyV9L/yfuTqWgZs2HRFy2YRfOv98OGvtN/pnV9ckPUL01Y0rwnOoLmrZd1cobvRWPY6T18qwDz50RTazlNumJx9H3EFzvdVoK8tshGRn7QQAPYU0WNCnPJ0TRzVh1T89+L4s+7LClTfm5YMOHEcxiUpMyxnXWgiUvrfRYSbgobpgRkTo4p+L8LQ/4d+0EYPU3F4vhYOPrypWSVJLNtMCv7F0cInIkLgzs34p4kuiVheHNEjjcCltHh048SFuUelNFgZG8GCapXoO+NXhywSzW6aQUSTjjJOQpPUKVkaDr3K2o1o5tNXLZ2kJVFf6UdsiKx/U2sIpLFsWdqg7tNjLmMkEaG0PqbS+XudCSuFCwZ2ZCtjxe248x9S0i9D+B3OxEUqwSlIXSFR3JTSQwaM8dBbc605QMxD03AVjtsPkAhwAAKt+xo+9M1jTAvTIV0iTD6WnbR/s+pNXGryrS+c9j+JcPu5FwVMjYcPdkDEquZnus527st+LdLjiMyJFKSb6tRa9a7btUVXVv3goYbcNtqRQFiQpTKqciLzdcJhHcKJlANuLv8S8h8OzpKoBtTB6BDeLP2XkDOnMxaeJMgYLyDIy515g2V5iMraZ2CWcxhBu/+cBwls2ad1vkFWjuxsgp6AMRFLIiEdgIJTiiJExtVequyQNJ9d78Mu3OuVad2L9J2vhe0cYLUOXRzAuZrUPp+mEO98oSpus7UIwHbzWGnNIvhPU5ZdRDxgpFgV2BnuDGmbaDcc598le9/cINNCy86i/ZePzCg1eUJPJr+/1B6pN/OFJHFAG/qFyetbKnh0TwO4eYnFcS2FccHFdCmWMUC9yKxuU85F7Tl70IpsQ6a9qTVB96rTLIFDGF90mRYkmMUEiEnTFmcUCkQCHM6qLArwvNeDj96rf0DQ5hx6vYCt2+7hfQElfs+fPNcMXCBSVv6K23pIwx9TqTKkD42WkaJwQt+TqzxR3ivJTwLgnwuIBGeL50PQqDfccbCz2gBQygsasOPEvMQagh894uh1hvBpt668JODGcDnLNKlf72CS49nJQxtQMXVb8bdCVLKAINyg45JQul4Byhrsn1U6y808xNtuaeNNOv/sB9tNj4w4NHCbrM4wksKtzUlPiGpxaYEwDGt/EIY3qwKzQ/TGSKfwOA/q9yhi1Chq8DqR3zIkCZbNkqlYmx/oaxUJNtGeykKjSHfQ/cIUYuUQ+AsEDnAFFU95HYetNXxRmGdwZQwPZua8Nom0ZafYFNL7qFHIUe92FxjU3qk1wYgZEw/zvquba8/j88xgSIg8glnas2wnYoWWkH2pOSNtIKvy9BsJ0lns7fdeks6f0ls/vSF+KjOaip3r1sPY7+Spw370SXaY/KX0Rcq5tMn1DaC8bCmL/oGCTlXT2mko6xdhEqEOxrKq6N5X8iHHmimrFOLBDv9wefSyKxbOM7u2RYOGZBf7hqfC4pv/aRPyJFNOHFelV/EWPMyVcAN9Xewc+UqS3W+zsHTPif2FgUyHrdk2TMJMPnz56iBeKo0DTaSg+Bgi4utcejozaUHdMb5qDVzKRTCa145y7btb5xlyJEogSg4mw5iFqD5X1N7DvxQRvrg0la7l0NCG5D+ymnruqgiu8wVTuKKdZslBvRCM1i6QXu582gCsAYVrSToe6aQcT5FY1sCiRHur8z2jygADJJLAoOGN3X8YHG8QUaiGDxTziWIiV1ZpRHzvI3iMx5IWBmaqXTuSs2N9iSkmu1bAlfHW5GVWii+nBKt1vDl0hxnefSYje+fY5PtZwzkoW4Fw2cvItDIEFScmRLtJmwZh4YzNv82QsLdiQn5XisQZBo89E4ZKtOdo6oNBW/wtN/zkp80GrrvE+deq7+6FbvyAPq0CtG6WHKDTOcnLZSg1nzd+a2dcdLglzvP1pm8di1vayLFxFytXD9b8zi+vGMTvUk5/snbjULa2FAschdVcJmplf0EseEOxZCbQZDd9kzzarDhJlF0LJbrTTSDR9WQWyYqltH1ZG5GJTu3BE+xka4oBWDi0x2C8u3kjaKk9h3lMGvnRu4xwRjYROyXzT4wpJOXMcFc5c6a7KCC8CEHVXJ6STfU5Nelsw9GP7dfN38UA1mHJtaY103sluyRslXL60Rn6VoFefsofh+ohUI5oLENVDuy+1DO5eKPB31edwk/QBLAHu2fLECEeJd+YRqmREu8q5grolkWJs6Rnw5NEd130gTVXQ5ee0dwtG+CqtPnet6CASxgH0iZmqa3HcnsqV0TnTmCMBIs1sbo6oWPvqomf+RnxagJF+1Kzj7qlFOGjOju5pZEmIpheU2gLvdL9pDmyTsLAPpt1ghomBLw5QopBKRizCHSNdF/OG4cbJQTI0Yp8c53FCuNT+JgReqJTuCYhaXc5ElF7QLPArZaxBV/cq+LSZyBeZjLvetWhA3igLo44Cxaqc4qQdZUbLZ8O3PpBJLSt7eQE+0uMKKylFSIfINE4LSAzMqPZLEPVCFkfeTyiwzp9ASWY5hV2vZPtjY498qa6FzflRqtyT0P+F6wbEiE1v5HUcwqc/fQq/O7pFLR+4tRxs+HMV9WyTNPW6tjdFrzQGn+ssxcSAswHdJvU67NWGRm7f8xvw0Nu6F606x8c9NpMXq424w9PHW8HMP+HzIGavUI3f3tSx8EB+Nbp7e1Qg4DMLbNgz6dnuE9/KXcyk/58dmn//Gt53S0kSBRm8izFECpcvG9KbXHAQZ+A2BQdKf/E0N+VzdirC5tzTWjhxKj7eHwEAHffJEwRfRFoHGSmafmihyMxynXfwhzH/Vi1oMiYJzn4R7MPKVu2hRyN0oFnerMEMWpskJ7kGF8S8h6FCdVaqN+N4raK/Q3PAVgyS4w2yNLJgnrN/IRUtvspQGRzTNshGvmnxt0IL/L1rM/gleDMEB6ruu6C555njgDdqhaYWL3dVOSPSmRTNSCx0EHjkqfJefdLT+dtzSMIlwcx10fSy1WsD7S2qSN/lPDP3vFMLkX75vkfB4dMWVsBiKER/9g5t4x2x17m+Psi87RVkDx9NAiNsA40MvgM+vecPTxber14VfoIkOxeuwJib3HJyIXsN3XZ+/gkfeGcBDYVHKDCRagSDR2bGx/259l00VGpKU4DmktdgWtyCx/cxaLiTgU/9nGdzabPYESYDY5cxuSd8dnOdjA8zPdnoy/pTnn61iihQyWZEf5+ACt+YPmU/jM0IgBzHL0bDvk2JPmJZvQ9isIiJLOCiMRvHUd0kTHtS0Jl2TaPOcEiFTGwdVTAktAmyKU9QKe/jZDE/5dNh8Pn9IHh+GDADrbtC5UqzFiQDzJwZEhPUyqI7NnC7z0dP2ku9EK0waDMvXh8s1ezrLVkN1tBrzdItlgwTqEkdOjj4Sy46mwr37w9FU4zVN/3bTcVMbdI2NNx5XFpPmr9rcTFMY+k2zdHEw+CNwPtBlkuE2oS8AGJZmEGPzpPhf4w6Om/BJ69CUlAPNLiN4Y25arZcxlT0WZb/c500jXwi9gl0y5fzuNIsNZUdSzrDnNZhbQNiF1asCj5S+wcz0ucKGEdBFJbbaKz0Kr95Czr9Iiw81llVd0pJ1H9oRT7+yclApovIvBNyxxtur5UhMi2uwTRkQ3Nj9DkupHaAITtDrzWaTYaL9AYk2B7tB7cykD2Kkr5JFBmJKPlrB+yqmTCiPWYiLDhEZdBXDcrB3h//sbC6cDivK5o6ugT10NabsluUxFKEG40k8N9EjvFEJRUTwQHIXnYCZP2Jzt4pj3KM9jKlJSaPwJh3aerHByCi2yCEIjlu0RxEozSM+ya695kAIDyQE9DDA7qoj1Wyzi7tE4kmBs+Yz6LteB7MhhBoxV9b2BBoZJ/SUeDoinMGWyT0ERXZZS64dBORbhrdkxcwIP4IhW6atyy339doqRA3DJKbTi7HURaaEpkMmCBG9WfZH7va4IsAX2Oec6JgB/55JDxMU9fxSSX/JI75lSge/HbSW42uujcKEpK24yZrFWATEoLXkoiG+H5YMslIJG2Gm24J5CIP+QOjbXxfaKAhs0mL27hrc/EvgKSTvXfIqHemHhgU4kHvB10zIMbEcAdXMESeqE/g7cmt7tjepaX2zbP3DJtFwmdvUIG+H56o0PbTY4qt16/Jk45BqbwxVol55Yhkg7UElzDrOYSC6LfWizrCznBFX0fLzeZB9L1QFzl+YDa5CyYrVXjU8N2gnsES0QHBJAEUrW0FE0QmSehGncpSbgjzf9F4z75lHi6slFwO+1S+eUSu5XViGHTK4csOfJOtgSpO334NVSRBbtT3KuJ2bUApYJPorYGL6c8/hG0AeNrAu0H8zhZda2zkEWi8j3bq+7bT1EXgUXkkcoj9tVquu01QlM6vqDoETOsI4+X+Im5A4D7lpCe0yLxEJGZ011qqK7f+NUWq35Jhlbfvhj4WyczjyJ8EDdC777Znsqka/NPbNZiVahT8ywKj22Em4EqEgLDZHMDuXR/i8k1FqQ+pmxSSrX0O8XVEgHLIvaBMs6q4rHX+B7cu8JqDVueroE/pDgUL47HB0FneeOllemppRF4nH05HoptnDN/ObibzdHfKDnWhiCa/MJAiYUjvG5k+rm2EeQX3TYW9JwdXlXtih2O51JqRd+y+zOAjWtHR+Vubmh4Sw0vnsRzYRJUb72RlsdK4/KLp9PIZc1myuLLMn0vqedR3ckLa9/maVy7Hy5XcOkVVQmmrM7eGnTAacMQoNEtUxtI46tVGkZD1kNtRznvg9AhUX7pmV+HqAXtGMrzqTjYsHkjfJHIxRWG+CsJy22DhFtaHPMMn1zjMC1CycBgc96BOyHKT8OaGZEe77dDhQo/0R2op+cw4fLhVnr53Wn8jRLOVsEp3Ro02jHh7fJys9fK7yfLxa3UDkwSdNTVPBodGxfow/ia7OpGa07qOrlKHM5PVrbkwokWsJ3+mDwDLK9baiYlwgl0kHonKJI5cxTy9cnSfknwA27R8Mv3W5gikw93I6FrHTyM2o2g0Usz+K19Lzq8SDVUpW+KLqgum/ZMm4IUdgRi9/lxRX6zE2/Xy1tLdWhymit76aaJpuJZIMmkS2NQpXKPYHyTXIf8xaSLq60SIGdHU/jAy2OajB+r0TAvOvGxpwhfawKEBBARtJNutlqXAtGjhtfjWD9hzjnoxUtRi4Rjfi0gALQecISHBkjOCUfyAhVFn/zqoxl8hQ7p0YqTqZDGDAa8Qcbo9fMbsb/upr2SHOQkEjGclLdp+MyfRqd8+amBcpF2EA+/OBfusL8OL1RvJgDCjFXGqS2JP94KkPJ7MaIuAvXjHOmUDxsWvrQY8MQq/Te84VuY4vx7yceGv1U7LQhg0XsjOa8sry51a4Oqm04PV2IqzdxXm3hYrUtL0JmhwJL6qvPUL7/YtJP7twmYBZIfsBjs2qy7Yrr0Ai0vwfYl+LmwFIHxqXKe/xdkemrs32j6h5mquJQ0Tsv7hxSHDNo/wBgqN/LWLgtWYypLOn+IECe409zT5/e91ZJkDvK8Xsm+F3mOCiYcCT+jRZc2YWjScW0AJm+6fHywTTM/Fk/TLBaHIJZJqWTLQUtTIL31xVpuLKfTX4SwkIVQ8DzZZWm8E6+s7NMG324HHwv8JHEGzrHZCm5P6tRAk/xj2jgrv5Xbe3TU86IRJOPh7ifshHADTAfVOjyjoLwQ9NH/YkU46PbrbcYMCpc+yF0KUfCdNzxesNGI05xPHKoVnI7UWHctUKRt/YKYQK3bUMYP/dBCD3zCZSyv00LdhFGBuORzeWHluFso68A9ZTghBqkbfVaX1WWpIXAsJbsfWuJu/U+vsyovF4Sqlx2YbUSRgldDQBBZEd+975HhqOV8SeIsdYS4tslsMxsvDRjWErCDf/H0PtKuvVlyHrZSCyOoZbeYPjI1PuEXuTXID0dw5C364ECL2phCieBtFfFhjYn+VZ8jFB91Ss3yDtSSwgCXv9tbeJhNPMfYT2CZbKRJb9LYIiHw4aI2AjFvcXk2FIcs3MZZtCSW6cKPvMOJkVKFXDJiZ8e33RuS9cXPCxDr6+9fVZxdYUVg1VALC++q0n2Co9zDdpR7W+XnmdDSOjMdtvJlEp2kl/OZXf1OQtqiM0BqTVIN8c/qBKZcdvQpJsGK0FXXQZ/JyttMs5xbV3osOhwHvXCGtUwHXe6LlTdcPH8AyOiQEbgx7k6Husf3n8+d3x9oS+tHepAoqX3AU2O3NgX1QT7TLJFHwI/Md/fPNuXKnWh0IdeUskwyEJDBeLZJV9akNN04HE4gDGAE8jXOD2bvZf1WFXCRu66PhNFnrIEgY8lrv6RYyHOwUS7XvS0uIIYXzSRnxoviazIjxm4irAGqTnFzPMvBRpqQkqZSBVwt4wxboIgmTKb2c5HW3F1BX8VRFNdGwuZ4prxNyl7kWiaxrSFtZriBFlj8cjwZAchbZBujg4B5E8eyjqLB6nKBzzvuMD6NnIfSAGPKwPLoMSEP5wOmjcJAZ6xETBubGeu+cAcIBYrxvlTrxGH/vqq9QlscgkffCLDg0vQfejN2FQCUysEHe4z0KlIpqfwsTNvqdzIpU5DsIWBaOV8399laq398dumBxO8nGxVxd7mcQgjBg6mRh0Rno8Mv144bJRep66FsAUf3CXy9Jx2G1eWilQPG8Y1xJRki1cYDF4yJu8855nTKwNEuKeVOu/Ydb70PKggO/YQCKxHh6sKop5tECFolfFdQiEKcfrjzLUEqWlbXa58KsZpeCXAAWQuqPffcwPB+LlMYTaAYIJv0kuBOLwJvjW9jPlxqvYzHGDPu6zQV19j0YFc06IR/vKx+g1A1Ak2gYEqhoB9GF/AYFduqgLE8tsgXr+OJW6V+VbO7qjQ+etER9akgBp1dv6u32Uuv+hQ1MX7xAqGpLIoaGRX+e7lonvQz0orVxLYOsGwS7sED1az1KhkYeP0S7zjNPaicVsoZSzsW33Lkxr6qlgs3TlM5G+OrvY9OyN8aF4iEf20KagVK9+dHlks27rSVHWc3mexTy037p+RrsEDIXrE4iPI/lJ22Qmy4lJyhqdnTfxmPJSUhRz86ETFyYnUH9tomRranFPaO4U9fErjnl0YaqQcyEt9AdPvzyM1vRsk9l0cqbih1l70jQLL1O91+L6b1I+LDGfESggjSv5R/fqiZHYks0cFPAd81J3Vxac1WhRa/+saaApdVNF+zI2Y8dmB6Jq2Gyk6HP5OoXFv7f0pe6I3MANQ38zhkiKvf9GVO/Pi13FPgY2rQWF0pZXpR994zihd7DjT4FBfmWApB3kaNHnS8sH/V3YrvMz7ri8pzSi2zqIq06y//vQKeUzqq70eKKVU+yDRVa+cjRJb8NcJRC8o4UfU0Fwv+sce9c3sqDkVelv5KCFJMnSHnuPEU+NGAbnukEq61m2StriGLcMxFo3b65eMTwgvXDehcMIjnhuKVyYw8oDX0jj1vfSiRII1LZqzlWjMK9ydm9eGarc0M1j1kLM2XKMuoyg8isTH5aUmrOk6UuoaVpATS1hZiaxAaAyoXuheJIllSDwDLuJyML5RssJGcFtleuFoFGCsHgcZgLXgYa68nCgFHgqLqu95NRzZ808TolMXRsLFPZMSiGCp5jUHBxMigoh3m9//i4lNWykyB0eUNihI9y8x736viF9LA3BiYwBbBjqBYvDwTanaF/dY+PA8raKNyAKGNwO4NybhU6jMJ6C7XyCC/4NpbRsKmNlfASwMR0K1oqEvaishjlifu4YB3veO/P9YqNGTAqmjWSkyXnUkXecmyomr+IJiQlmXMFA/TjLcbVfFoAiS7CdunlekppYooYKWWwDwbxGAuQJBHfPUz7hJpfy9QQqilPALhXH1Fd+KXybZ02m6N6hqLb3Ql/bbZD58X3Ciqlj+ETRTJ5BAU6ZDdI8IRQUxKrF6RnROn9oCpB6MBxIdx1xbNnOlpZ2KkB+KZtwQDutKWRvnKKvzHlAWGKofM1NBa/grdmk8XQJyQQxOuhvNQkVMMOFYzfKNqlzgHg0iDO4BBjk9G3eqwaW/GJFbfXwEKi65K4BSNuFhspdQ7h2B6aWwqRcv9Yf1wXxRItDox44wTYkrQsw3PD5YT4PVbQ93nFMXLvakpVOPbLxdXuJ4WdcmoeoZeefR/2EL9/cfDKM36cM1xN+1RJSeWgZ3ajRIFo/OGLG5OyrKsutQM1WNyjDLr0aF7tP9SU4Y4uM+Vzr221mkSEvuVFUwPN1Vyy5Lia5cGE3rOpPSpB/rQAWlgrnGEOl1Dqr7G//+eY=" /> </div> <script type="text/javascript"> //<![CDATA[ var theForm = document.forms['form1']; if (!theForm) { theForm = document.form1; } function __doPostBack(eventTarget, eventArgument) { if (!theForm.onsubmit || (theForm.onsubmit() != false)) { theForm.__EVENTTARGET.value = eventTarget; theForm.__EVENTARGUMENT.value = eventArgument; theForm.submit(); } } //]]> </script> <script src="/WebResource.axd?d=pynGkmcFUV13He1Qd6_TZEZHRDBANxsovMVEf3J7iNvz1eLsDHfJ_SNPskCVmh8eGTp1Ng2&t=638568640745067788" type="text/javascript"></script> <script src="/ScriptResource.axd?d=NJmAwtEo3Ipnlaxl6CMhvi1jZFkpBAj0kmk6Fbn1nZpcC-LbeF1kllusA6V5247OiTC7GI0X158jALnUDLutB14kes7anACqIX6d4IhoMcgExwM_tq0qXmXpbVSX4lKkyy8OVtS_s9LTD2QLbkvSMI2OPSY1&t=ffffffffc820c398" type="text/javascript"></script> <script src="/ScriptResource.axd?d=dwY9oWetJoJoVpgL6Zq8ON5KLG1KxuZv_TGWJzAHEmR1jtVUlMpl8oIOrd9fzvHUiXSNEDaJcnFbDuwaAcseEz7gVhf5ftJ2-5U3R_qpdEL-RNd6oWltE0VgNnK_e1ptGBK5cE14XWEyTPzYSc3gA9WZEVs1&t=ffffffffc820c398" type="text/javascript"></script>  <script type="text/javascript"> //<![CDATA[ Sys.WebForms.PageRequestManager._initialize('ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$ScriptManager1', 'form1', [], [], [], 90, 'ctl00$ctl00$ctl00'); //]]> </script> <div id="opaque"></div> <div id="desktopMenuCatch"></div> <div class="accountContainer"> <div class="content"> <a class='topPanelImage' href='/'><img src='/Images/ct-masthead-alternate.png' class='topPanelImg' /></a><a href='https://login.hymnsam.co.uk?websiteid=4&returnurl=https%3a%2f%2fwww.churchtimes.co.uk%2fcomment%2fcolumnists' class='login' id='topPanelLoginLink' role='button'>Sign In</a><a href='/subscribe' class='subscribe' role='button'>Subscribe</a><a href='/basket'>View Basket</a><div class='topSearchBar'><input type='text' placeholder='Search' id='dtSearchBox' aria-label='Search field' /><span class='fa fa-search' id='dtSearchIcon' onclick='searchDT()'></span></div> </div> </div> <div class="accountMobile"> <div class="content"> <a href='https://login.hymnsam.co.uk?websiteid=4&returnurl=https%3a%2f%2fwww.churchtimes.co.uk%2fcomment%2fcolumnists' class='login' role='button'>Sign In</a><a href='/subscribe' class='subscribe' role='button'>Subscribe</a><a href='/basket'>View Basket</a> </div> </div> <div style="padding: 20px; display:none;"> *** DEBUG START *** <br /> *** DEBUG END *** </div> <input type="submit" name="ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$LoginTopPanel_3$btnSignOut" value="" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_LoginTopPanel_3_btnSignOut" class="btnSignOut" style="display: none;" /> <script type="text/javascript"> function searchDT() { var txtSearchDT = document.getElementById('dtSearchBox'); if (txtSearchDT !== undefined && txtSearchDT !== null) { var searchQuery = txtSearchDT.value; if (searchQuery !== "") { window.location.href = "/search-results?query=" + encodeURIComponent(searchQuery); } } } $("#dtSearchBox").keyup(function (event) { if (event.keyCode == 13) { $("#dtSearchIcon").click(); } }); // Document load $(document).ready(function () { // Replace old login links throughout page with new link to central login $(".openLoginPanelLink").each(function (i) { $(this).attr("href", $('#topPanelLoginLink').attr("href")); }); }); </script> <div class="headerContainer"> <div id="header"> <div class="search"> <i class="fa fa-2x fa-search" id="faSearch" onclick="expandSearch()"></i> </div> <div class="logo"> <div class="ctLogo"> <a href="/" aria-label="Church Times"> <img src="/Images/churchtimeslogo.png?height=55" data-rjs="/Images/churchtimeslogo.png?height=110" alt="Church Times" /> </a> </div> <div class="hymnsLogo"> <a href='https://www.hymnsam.co.uk' target='_blank' aria-label='Hymns Ancient & Modern'><img src='/Images/hymns-logo-CT.png?width=130' data-rjs='/Images/hymns-logo-CT.png?width=260' alt='Hymns Ancient & Modern' /> </a> <p>Friday 29 November 2024</p> </div> </div> <div class="menu"> <div id="slideMenu"> <span></span> <span></span> <span></span> <span></span> </div> </div> <div class="srchBar" id="srchBar"> <div class='measuringWrapper'> <div class="text"> <input type="text" placeholder="Enter your search here..." id="searchBox" /> <span class="fa fa-search" id="searchIcon" onclick="search()"></span> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class='desktopMenu' role='menubar'><ul role='menu'><li class='topLevel' role='menuitem'><a class='home' href='/' aria-label='Home'>Home</a></li><li class='topLevel' role='menuitem'><a class='uk' href='/news/uk' aria-label='UK'>UK</a></li><li class='topLevel' role='menuitem'><a class='world' href='/news/world' aria-label='World'>World</a></li><li class='topLevel' role='menuitem'><a class='comment active' href='/comment' aria-label='Comment'>Comment</a><ul class='desktopSubMenu commentSubmenu' role='submenu'><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='commentSub' href='/comment/opinion' aria-label='Opinion'>Opinion</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='commentSub' href='/comment/leader-comment' aria-label='Leader comment'>Leader comment</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='commentSub' href='/comment/columnists' aria-label='Columnists'>Columnists</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='commentSub' href='/comment/letters-to-the-editor' aria-label='Letters to the editor'>Letters to the editor</a></li></ul></li><li class='topLevel' role='menuitem'><a class='features' href='/features' aria-label='Features'>Features</a><ul class='desktopSubMenu featuresSubmenu' role='submenu'><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='featuresSub' href='/features/features' aria-label='Features'>Features</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='featuresSub' href='/features/interviews' aria-label='Interviews'>Interviews</a></li></ul></li><li class='topLevel' role='menuitem'><a class='faith' href='/faith' aria-label='Faith'>Faith</a><ul class='desktopSubMenu faithSubmenu' role='submenu'><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='faithSub' href='/faith/sunday-s-readings' aria-label='Sunday’s readings'>Sunday’s readings</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='faithSub' href='/faith/faith-features' aria-label='Faith features'>Faith features</a></li></ul></li><li class='topLevel' role='menuitem'><a class='booksarts' href='/books-arts' aria-label='Books & Arts'>Books & Arts</a><ul class='desktopSubMenu booksartsSubmenu' role='submenu'><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='booksartsSub' href='/books-arts/book-reviews' aria-label='Book reviews'>Book reviews</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='booksartsSub' href='/books-arts/new-titles' aria-label='New titles'>New titles</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='booksartsSub' href='/books-arts/book-club' aria-label='Book club'>Book club</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='booksartsSub' href='/books-arts/visual-arts' aria-label='Visual arts'>Visual arts</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='booksartsSub' href='/books-arts/music' aria-label='Music'>Music</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='booksartsSub' href='/books-arts/performing-arts' aria-label='Performing arts'>Performing arts</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='booksartsSub' href='/books-arts/film' aria-label='Film'>Film</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='booksartsSub' href='/books-arts/tv' aria-label='TV'>TV</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='booksartsSub' href='/books-arts/radio' aria-label='Radio'>Radio</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='booksartsSub' href='/books-arts/week-ahead' aria-label='Week ahead'>Week ahead</a></li></ul></li><li class='topLevel' role='menuitem'><a class='regulars' href='/regulars' aria-label='Regulars'>Regulars</a><ul class='desktopSubMenu regularsSubmenu' role='submenu'><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='regularsSub' href='/gazette' aria-label='Gazette'>Gazette</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='regularsSub' href='/regulars/cartoons' aria-label='Cartoons'>Cartoons</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='regularsSub' href='/regulars/caption-competition' aria-label='Caption competition'>Caption competition</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='regularsSub' href='/regulars/crossword' aria-label='Crossword'>Crossword</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='regularsSub' href='/regulars/out-of-the-question' aria-label='Out of the question'>Out of the question</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='regularsSub' href='/regulars/diary' aria-label='Diary'>Diary</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='regularsSub' href='/regulars/100-years-ago' aria-label='100 years ago'>100 years ago</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='regularsSub' href='/regulars/quotes' aria-label='Quotes'>Quotes</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='regularsSub' href='/regulars/holidays' aria-label='Holidays'>Holidays</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='regularsSub' href='/regulars/links' aria-label='Links'>Links</a></li></ul></li><li class='topLevel' role='menuitem'><a class='audiovideo' href='/audio-video' aria-label='Audio & Video'>Audio & Video</a><ul class='desktopSubMenu audiovideoSubmenu' role='submenu'><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='audiovideoSub' href='/audio-video/podcast' aria-label='Podcast'>Podcast</a></li><li class='subMenuItem' role='menuitem' tabindex='1'><a class='audiovideoSub' href='/audio-video/video' aria-label='Video'>Video</a></li></ul></li><li class='topLevel' role='menuitem'><a class='archive' href='/archive' aria-label='Archive'>Archive</a></li><li class='topLevel' role='menuitem'><div class='jobsLink'><a class='jobs' target='_blank' href='https://jobs.churchtimes.co.uk/' aria-label='Jobs'>Jobs</a></div></li><li class='topLevel' role='menuitem'><a class='events' href='/events' aria-label='Events'>Events</a></li></ul></div> <div id='churchtimesMenu' role='menubar'><ul class='menuItems' role='menu'><li class='home' role='menuitem'><a class='menuSection' href='/' aria-label='Home'>Home</a><i class='icon'></i></li><li class='uk' role='menuitem'><a class='menuSection' href='/news/uk' aria-label='UK'>UK</a><i class='icon'></i></li><li class='world' role='menuitem'><a class='menuSection' href='/news/world' aria-label='World'>World</a><i class='icon'></i></li><li class='comment' role='menuitem'><a class='menuSection' href='/comment' aria-label='Comment'>Comment</a><i class='icon'></i><ul class='subItems' role='submenu'><li role='menuitem'><a href='/comment/opinion' aria-label='Opinion'>Opinion</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/comment/leader-comment' aria-label='Leader comment'>Leader comment</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/comment/columnists' aria-label='Columnists'>Columnists</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/comment/letters-to-the-editor' aria-label='Letters to the editor'>Letters to the editor</a></li></ul></li><li class='features' role='menuitem'><a class='menuSection' href='/features' aria-label='Features'>Features</a><i class='icon'></i><ul class='subItems' role='submenu'><li role='menuitem'><a href='/features/features' aria-label='Features'>Features</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/features/interviews' aria-label='Interviews'>Interviews</a></li></ul></li><li class='faith' role='menuitem'><a class='menuSection' href='/faith' aria-label='Faith'>Faith</a><i class='icon'></i><ul class='subItems' role='submenu'><li role='menuitem'><a href='/faith/sunday-s-readings' aria-label='Sunday’s readings'>Sunday’s readings</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/faith/faith-features' aria-label='Faith features'>Faith features</a></li></ul></li><li class='booksarts' role='menuitem'><a class='menuSection' href='/books-arts' aria-label='Books & Arts'>Books & Arts</a><i class='icon'></i><ul class='subItems' role='submenu'><li role='menuitem'><a href='/books-arts/book-reviews' aria-label='Book reviews'>Book reviews</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/books-arts/new-titles' aria-label='New titles'>New titles</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/books-arts/book-club' aria-label='Book club'>Book club</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/books-arts/visual-arts' aria-label='Visual arts'>Visual arts</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/books-arts/music' aria-label='Music'>Music</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/books-arts/performing-arts' aria-label='Performing arts'>Performing arts</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/books-arts/film' aria-label='Film'>Film</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/books-arts/tv' aria-label='TV'>TV</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/books-arts/radio' aria-label='Radio'>Radio</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/books-arts/week-ahead' aria-label='Week ahead'>Week ahead</a></li></ul></li><li class='regulars' role='menuitem'><a class='menuSection' href='/regulars' aria-label='Regulars'>Regulars</a><i class='icon'></i><ul class='subItems' role='submenu'><li role='menuitem'><a href='/gazette' aria-label='Gazette'>Gazette</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/regulars/cartoons' aria-label='Cartoons'>Cartoons</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/regulars/caption-competition' aria-label='Caption competition'>Caption competition</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/regulars/crossword' aria-label='Crossword'>Crossword</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/regulars/out-of-the-question' aria-label='Out of the question'>Out of the question</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/regulars/diary' aria-label='Diary'>Diary</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/regulars/100-years-ago' aria-label='100 years ago'>100 years ago</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/regulars/quotes' aria-label='Quotes'>Quotes</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/regulars/holidays' aria-label='Holidays'>Holidays</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/regulars/links' aria-label='Links'>Links</a></li></ul></li><li class='audiovideo' role='menuitem'><a class='menuSection' href='/audio-video' aria-label='Audio & Video'>Audio & Video</a><i class='icon'></i><ul class='subItems' role='submenu'><li role='menuitem'><a href='/audio-video/podcast' aria-label='Podcast'>Podcast</a></li><li role='menuitem'><a href='/audio-video/video' aria-label='Video'>Video</a></li></ul></li><li class='archive' role='menuitem'><a class='menuSection' href='/archive' aria-label='Archive'>Archive</a><i class='icon'></i></li><li class='jobs' role='menuitem'><a class='jobs' target='_blank' href='https://jobs.churchtimes.co.uk/' aria-label='Jobs'>Jobs</a></li></li><li class='events' role='menuitem'><a class='menuSection' href='/events' aria-label='Events'>Events</a><i class='icon'></i></li></ul><ul class='hymns' role='menu'><li role='menuitem'><a href='https://www.hymnsam.co.uk' target='_blank' aria-label='Hymns Ancient & Modern'><img src='/Images/hymns-logo-CT.png?width=150' data-rjs='/Images/hymns-logo-CT.png?width=300' alt='Hymns Ancient & Modern' /></a></li></ul></div> <div class="site-background"> <div id="container">  <div id="pageContainer"> <div class="mainContent"> <div id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_pnlCategory"> <div class='categoryContainer commentPage'><h1>Columnists</h1><div class='categoryMainArticle'><a href='/articles/2024/29-november/comment/columnists/paul-vallely-what-band-aid-s-critics-get-wrong'><div class='content'><img src='/media/5698969/2yj2w7b.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=605&height=292&rnd=133772778280000000' /><h2>Paul Vallely: What Band Aid’s critics get wrong </h2><p>Charges of ‘white saviour syndrome’ miss the mark, argues <em>Paul Vallely</em></p><div class='dateSeperatorMain'></div><p class='articleDate articleDateMain'>29 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='seperator'></div><div class='categorySubArticles'><a href='/articles/2024/29-november/comment/columnists/angela-tilby-laud-s-lesson-for-a-church-in-crisis'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5663404/p27-20191024164747968_web.jpg?center=0.27952755905511811,0.46192893401015228&mode=crop&width=572&height=292&rnd=133772779150000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Angela Tilby: Laud’s lesson for a Church in crisis</h2><p>AS SHAME about the state of the Church deepened last week, we had this prayer by Archbishop Laud three times at choral evensong</p><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>29 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categorySubArticles'><a href='/articles/2024/29-november/comment/columnists/press-this-case-for-assisted-dying-is-hard-to-dismiss'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5630583/press.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=572&height=292&rnd=133681922850000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Press: This case for assisted dying is hard to dismiss</h2><p>THERE are so many bad and windy arguments in favour of assisted dying that it’s almost a shock to come across good and compelling ones</p><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>29 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='seperator'></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/29-november/comment/columnists/malcolm-guite-poet-s-corner'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5631298/poets-corner.jpg?center=0.51525423728813557,0.54831932773109249&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133766599530000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Malcolm Guite: Poet’s Corner</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>29 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/22-november/comment/columnists/paul-vallely-assisted-dying-debate-needs-clarity'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698833/2yax42y.jpg?center=0.35504885993485341,0.51193058568329719&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133766642980000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Paul Vallely: Assisted-dying debate needs clarity </h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>22 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/22-november/comment/columnists/angela-tilby-what-the-crown-nominations-commission-needs-to-ask'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698834/istock-969755330.jpg?center=0.32846715328467152,0.53610503282275712&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133766646780000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Angela Tilby: What the Crown Nominations Commission needs to ask</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>22 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='seperator'></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/22-november/comment/columnists/press-orwellian-take-on-who-knew-what-and-when'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5630583/press.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133681922850000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Press: Orwellian take on who knew what and when</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>22 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/22-november/comment/columnists/malcolm-guite-poet-s-corner'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5631298/poets-corner.jpg?center=0.51525423728813557,0.54831932773109249&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133766599530000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Malcolm Guite: Poet’s Corner</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>22 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/15-november/comment/columnists/paul-vallely-politics-has-changed-not-only-in-us'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698703/2yj5fwd.jpg?center=0.271875,0.51559251559251562&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133760554620000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Paul Vallely: Politics has changed — not only in US</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>15 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryInline seperator'><div class='hymnsMarketingPlaceholder' data-advert-type='5' data-is-homepage='0' style='display:none'></div><div class='hymnsMarketingPlaceholder' data-advert-type='5' data-is-homepage='0' style='display:none'></div></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/15-november/comment/columnists/angela-tilby-beware-the-habits-that-lead-to-abuse'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698680/smythc4-20241113145726196_web.jpg?center=0.34010152284263961,0.50857142857142856&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133760548030000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Angela Tilby: Beware the habits that lead to abuse</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>15 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/15-november/comment/columnists/press-media-mob-helps-welby-s-foes-to-get-their-way'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5630583/press.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133681922850000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Press: Media mob helps Welby’s foes to get their way</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>15 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/15-november/comment/columnists/malcolm-guite-poet-s-corner'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5631298/poets-corner.jpg?center=0.51525423728813557,0.54831932773109249&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133766599530000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Malcolm Guite: Poet’s Corner</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>15 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='seperator'></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/8-november/comment/columnists/paul-vallely-pope-s-listening-exercise-draws-to-end'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698611/2ydy1g5.jpg?center=0.42105263157894735,0.49344978165938863&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133754407980000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Paul Vallely: Pope’s listening exercise draws to end </h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>08 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/8-november/comment/columnists/angela-tilby-kemi-badenoch-is-an-antidote-to-groupthink'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698610/2yg1xg8.jpg?center=0.43506493506493504,0.49783549783549785&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133754407120000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Angela Tilby: Kemi Badenoch is an antidote to groupthink</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>08 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/8-november/comment/columnists/press-nyt-strikers-would-make-print-unions-blush'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5630583/press.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133681922850000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Press: <em>NYT </em>strikers would make print unions blush</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>08 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='seperator'></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/8-november/comment/columnists/malcolm-guite-poet-s-corner'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5631298/poets-corner.jpg?center=0.51525423728813557,0.54831932773109249&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133766599530000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Malcolm Guite: Poet’s Corner</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>08 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/1-november/comment/columnists/paul-vallely-does-it-matter-to-the-world-who-wins-the-us-election'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698508/2ybcm7r.jpg?center=0.46486486486486489,0.49819494584837543&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133748413440000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Paul Vallely: Does it matter to the world who wins the US election?</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>01 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/1-november/comment/columnists/angela-tilby-all-souls-reminds-us-of-our-mortality-and-of-hope-beyond-death'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698510/istock-1731266939.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133748414440000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Angela Tilby: All Souls reminds us of our mortality — and of hope beyond death</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>01 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryInline seperator'><div class='hymnsMarketingPlaceholder' data-advert-type='5' data-is-homepage='0' style='display:none'></div><div class='hymnsMarketingPlaceholder' data-advert-type='5' data-is-homepage='0' style='display:none'></div></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/1-november/comment/columnists/press-how-to-lose-readers-by-not-printing-an-article'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5630583/press.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133681922850000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Press: How to lose readers by <em>not </em>printing an article</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>01 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/1-november/comment/columnists/malcolm-guite-poet-s-corner'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5631298/poets-corner.jpg?center=0.51525423728813557,0.54831932773109249&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133766599530000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Malcolm Guite: Poet’s Corner</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>01 Nov 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/25-october/comment/columnists/paul-vallely-government-should-look-at-hs2-lite'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698406/2xrbchc.jpg?center=0.41692789968652039,0.58368200836820083&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133742436300000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Paul Vallely: Government should look at ‘HS2 Lite’</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>25 Oct 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='seperator'></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/25-october/comment/columnists/angela-tilby-miranda-is-honest-with-her-chums'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698405/2y9jcjh.jpg?center=0.3652694610778443,0.39121338912133891&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133742430230000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Angela Tilby: Miranda is honest with her chums</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>25 Oct 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/25-october/comment/columnists/press-grown-ups-join-the-assisted-dying-debate'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5630583/press.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133681922850000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Press: Grown-ups join the assisted-dying debate</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>25 Oct 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/25-october/comment/columnists/malcolm-guite-poet-s-corner'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5631298/poets-corner.jpg?center=0.51525423728813557,0.54831932773109249&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133766599530000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Malcolm Guite: Poet’s Corner</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>25 Oct 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='seperator'></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/18-october/comment/columnists/paul-vallely-palliative-care-needs-to-improve-fast'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698314/istock-800395010.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133736384500000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Paul Vallely: Palliative care needs to improve, fast </h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>18 Oct 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/18-october/comment/columnists/angela-tilby-do-not-scrap-vat-lifeline-for-church-buildings'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698313/istock-172143668.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133736377420000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Angela Tilby: Do not scrap VAT lifeline for church buildings</h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>18 Oct 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='categoryArticleSnippets'><a href='/articles/2024/18-october/comment/columnists/press-why-public-opinion-is-like-a-rubik-s-cube'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5630583/press.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=292&height=168&rnd=133681922850000000' /></div><div class='content'><h2>Press: Why public opinion is like a Rubik’s cube </h2><div class='dateSeperator'></div><p class='articleDate'>18 Oct 2024</p></div></a></div><div class='seperator'></div><div id='showMoreArticles' style='display:none'></div><div id='showMore' style='display:none'><a id='showMoreArticlesButton' class='showMoreArticlesButton' onclick='showMoreArticles()'>Show more</a></div></div> <input type="hidden" name="ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$MasterContentPlaceHolder$Category_6$hfdArticleCount" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdArticleCount" value="27" /> <input type="hidden" name="ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$MasterContentPlaceHolder$Category_6$hfdCurrentNodeId" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdCurrentNodeId" value="1130" /> <input type="hidden" name="ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$MasterContentPlaceHolder$Category_6$hfdShowMoreArticlesNumber" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdShowMoreArticlesNumber" value="9" /> <input type="hidden" name="ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$MasterContentPlaceHolder$Category_6$hfdDebugInformation" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdDebugInformation" value="Test 2: 252128 - " /> <input type="hidden" name="ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$MasterContentPlaceHolder$Category_6$hfdIsTopicPage" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdIsTopicPage" value="0" /> <input type="hidden" name="ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$MasterContentPlaceHolder$Category_6$hfdCategoryNodeIds" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdCategoryNodeIds" value="1130" /> <input type="hidden" name="ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$MasterContentPlaceHolder$Category_6$hfdCurrentArticleCount" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdCurrentArticleCount" value="27" /> <input type="hidden" name="ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$MasterContentPlaceHolder$Category_6$hfdIsBooksAndArtsCategory" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdIsBooksAndArtsCategory" value="False" /> <input type="hidden" name="ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$MasterContentPlaceHolder$Category_6$hfdIsPreview" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdIsPreview" value="False" /> </div> <script> // Hidden field variables var hfdArticleCount = document.getElementById('ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdArticleCount'); var currentNodeId = document.getElementById('ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdCurrentNodeId').value; var showMoreArticleNumber = document.getElementById('ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdShowMoreArticlesNumber').value; var categoryNodeIds = document.getElementById('ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdCategoryNodeIds').value; var currentArticleCount = document.getElementById('ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdCurrentArticleCount').value; var isTopicPage = document.getElementById('ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdIsTopicPage').value === "1" ? true : false; var isBooksAndArtsCategory = document.getElementById('ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdIsBooksAndArtsCategory').value === "1" ? true : false; var isPreview = document.getElementById('ContentPlaceHolderDefault_MasterContentPlaceHolder_Category_6_hfdIsPreview').value === "1" ? true : false; // Call "isShowMoreAvailable" isShowMoreAvailable(); function isShowMoreAvailable() { // If show more div exists if ($('#showMore').length) { // Check if there are more articles to show $.ajax({ url: "/WebServices/Articles.asmx/IsShowMoreAvailable", contentType: "application/json; charset=utf-8", dataType: "json", type: "GET", data: 'categoryNodeIds=' + JSON.stringify(categoryNodeIds) + '&currentArticleCount=' + currentArticleCount + '&isBooksAndArtsCategory=' + isBooksAndArtsCategory + '&isTopicPage=' + isTopicPage, success: function (response) { var showMoreAvailable = response.d; // If "Show more" is available then show button if (!isPreview && showMoreAvailable) { $('#showMoreArticles').show(); $('#showMore').show(); } } }); } } function showMoreArticles() { if (hfdArticleCount !== "" && hfdArticleCount != undefined) { var articlecount = hfdArticleCount.value; $.ajax({ url: "/WebServices/Articles.asmx/GetArticlesForWebService", contentType: "application/json; charset=utf-8", dataType: "json", type: "GET", data: 'articleCount=' + articlecount + "&currentNodeId=" + currentNodeId + "&isPortraitCategoryPage=false" + "&isTopicPage=" + isTopicPage, success: function (response) { // remove current show more button (this gets readded in code if more articles are available) // $('#showMore').remove(); $('#showMoreArticles').replaceWith(response.d); $('.categoryArticleSnippets').not('.shown').hide().delay(50).slideDown(); // update article count after results have been added // articlecount = (parseInt(articlecount) + parseInt(showMoreArticleNumber)); hfdArticleCount.value = articlecount; } }); } $('.categoryArticleSnippets').addClass('shown'); } </script> </div> <div class="sideContent"> <div class="masonryGutter"></div> <div class="masonryColumn"></div> <div id="freeTextWidget" class="masonry"> <h2>Letters to the editor</h2><div class='freeText'><p><span>Letters for publication should be sent to </span><a href="mailto:letters@churchtimes.co.uk">letters@churchtimes.co.uk</a><span>.</span></p> <p><span>Letters should be exclusive to the </span><em>Church Times, </em><span>and include a full postal address. Your name and address will appear below your letter unless requested otherwise.</span></p></div> </div> <div class='widgetContainer adverts masonry'><div class='hymnsMarketingPlaceholder' data-advert-type='5' data-is-homepage='0' style='display:none'></div></div> <div class="widgetContainer masonry" id="topFeatures"> <h2>Top Feature</h2> <a href='/articles/2024/29-november/features/features/ronald-blythe-and-ian-collins-an-etiquette-to-our-friendship'><div class='topFeature'><div class='content'><div class='image'><img src='/media/5698735/photocreditkeithroberts-20241023115910187_web.jpg?center=0.43489583333333331,0.48958333333333331&mode=crop&width=572&height=292&rnd=133772787070000000' /></div><h3>Ronald Blythe and Ian Collins: ‘An etiquette to our friendship’</h3><p>Reserve characterised a biography’s genesis, Malcolm Doney hears</p></div></div></a> </div> <style type="text/css"> #jobWidgetContainer { color: #fdf8d4; /*width:100%;*/ } #jobWidgetContainer .widgetHeader{ width:100%; /*background-color:#35647e;*/ text-align:center; background-color:#f7f7f7; } #jobWidgetContainer .widgetHeader .heading { color: white; font-family: 'Times New Roman', Times, serif; font-size:25px; padding: 20px 20px 0 20px; } @media (max-width: 325px){ #jobWidgetContainer .widgetHeader .heading { font-size: 20px; } } #jobWidgetContainer .logoStart{ font-family: Arial; text-transform: lowercase; color:#af0208; font-weight: 600; } #jobWidgetContainer .logoEnd{ font-family: 'Times New Roman'; text-transform: uppercase; color:#af0208; font-weight: 600; } #jobWidgetContainer .logoSubText{ color: #a5a49f; font-size: 0.6em; font-style: italic; font-family: 'Times New Roman'; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobContentContainer{ background-color: #f7f7f7; padding: 15px 0; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobContent { background-color: #f7f7f7; margin:0 10px; padding: 0 10px 0 10px; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobOfTheWeekContent { border: 1px #b11008 solid; margin-bottom:20px; padding-top:20px; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobOfTheWeekCategoryName h3 { text-align:center; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobContent a { color: #000000; text-decoration: none; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobOfTheWeekContent a { text-decoration: none; } #jobWidgetContainer .categoryName { background-color: #b11008; color: #ffffff; text-transform: uppercase; margin:0 10px; } #jobWidgetContainer .categoryName h3 { margin:0; padding: 5px 10px; font-size:1em; } #jobWidgetContainer .seperator { border-bottom: 1px solid #ccc; margin: 5px 0 0 0; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobTitle h3{ margin:0; font-weight: normal; font-size: 1.3em; padding: 5px 0 4px 0; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobLocation h4{ margin:0; font-weight: normal; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobDescription { padding:0 0 5px 0; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobDescription p{ margin:0; padding:5px 0; font-weight: normal; font-size: 15px; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobContentContainer .jobLink{ background-color: #b11008; color: white; text-align: center; padding: 4px 5px 4px 5px; margin: 0 60px; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobContentContainer .jobLink a{ color: white; text-decoration: none; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobContentContainer .jobLink a:hover{ text-decoration: none; } #jobWidgetContainer .jobContentContainer .jobLink p{ margin:0; } </style> <div class="widgetContainer masonry" id="jobWidget"> <div id="jobWidgetContainer"> <div class='widgetHeader'><div class='heading'><a target='_blank' href='https://jobs.churchtimes.co.uk'><span class='logoStart'>jobs.</span><span class='logoEnd'>CHURCHTIMES</span></a></div></div><div class='jobContentContainer'><div class='categoryName jobOfTheWeekCategoryName'><h3>Job of the Week</h3></div><div class='jobContent jobOfTheWeekContent'><a href='https://jobs.churchtimes.co.uk/jobs/Director-of-Mission-and-Ministry-in-West-Midlands-jn13142' target='_blank'><div class='jobTitle'><h3>Director of Mission and Ministry</h3></div><div class='jobLocation'><h4>West Midlands</h4></div><div class='jobDescription'><p>Could God be calling you to shape the future of Mission and Ministry across the Diocese of Worcester?  </p></div></a></div><div class='categoryName'><h3>Appointments</h3></div><div class='jobContent'><a href='https://jobs.churchtimes.co.uk/jobs/Director-of-Contextual-Formation-in-Scotland-jn13136' target='_blank'><div class='jobTitle'><h3>Director of Contextual Formation</h3></div><div class='jobLocation'><h4>Scotland</h4></div><div class='jobDescription'><p>The Scottish Episcopal Institute (SEI) seeks to appoint a Director of Contextual Formation.</p></div></a></div><div class='jobLink'><a href='https://jobs.churchtimes.co.uk' target='_blank'><p>Find more jobs</p></a></div></div> </div> </div> <div class='widgetContainer adverts masonry'><div class='hymnsMarketingPlaceholder' data-advert-type='5' data-is-homepage='0' style='display:none'></div></div> <div id="freeTextWidget" class="masonry"> <h2>Forthcoming Events</h2><div class='freeText'><h2><a href="/can-a-good-death-be-assisted-a-church-times-webinar">Can a ‘Good Death‘ be Assisted?</a></h2> <p><strong>28 November 2024</strong></p> <p>A webinar in collaboration with Modern Church</p> <p><a href="/can-a-good-death-be-assisted-a-church-times-webinar">tickets available</a></p> <p> </p> <h2><a href="/through-darkness-to-light-advent-journeys">Through Darkness To Light: Advent Journeys</a></h2> <p><strong>30 November 2024</strong></p> <p><a href="/through-darkness-to-light-advent-journeys">tickets available</a></p> <p> </p> <h2><a href="/women-mystics-female-theologians-through-christian-history">Women Mystics: Female Theologians through Christian History</a></h2> <p><strong>13 January - 19 May 2025</strong></p> <p>An online evening lecture series, run jointly by Sarum College and The Church Times</p> <p><a href="/women-mystics-female-theologians-through-christian-history">tickets available</a></p> <p> </p> <h2><a href="https://faithandliterature.hymnsam.co.uk/">Festival of Faith and Literature</a></h2> <p><strong>28 February - 2 March 2025</strong></p> <p><a href="https://faithandliterature.hymnsam.co.uk/tickets/">tickets available</a></p> <p> </p> <h2>Visit our <a href="/events">Events</a> page for upcoming and past events </h2></div> </div> <div id="freeTextWidget" class="masonry"> <h2>The Church Times Archive</h2><div class='freeText'><img src='/media/5604329/chtm_1994_03_18_001b.jpg?anchor=center&mode=crop&width=292&height=400&rnd=131333726080000000' /><p><span>Read reports from issues stretching back to 1863, search for your parish or see if any of the clergy you know get a mention.</span></p> <p>FREE for <em>Church Times</em> subscribers.</p> <p><a data-id="3979" href="/archive" title="Archive">Explore the archive</a></p></div> </div> <div class='widgetContainer adverts masonry'><div class='hymnsMarketingPlaceholder' data-advert-type='5' data-is-homepage='0' style='display:none'></div></div> </div> </div>  </div> </div> <footer> <div class="newsletter"> <div id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_SiteFooter_15_pnlNewsletterSignup" onkeypress="javascript:return WebForm_FireDefaultButton(event, 'ContentPlaceHolderDefault_SiteFooter_15_btnSubscribeToNewsletter')"> <h3>Subscribe to newsletter</h3> <input name="ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$SiteFooter_15$txtNewsletterSignupEmail" type="text" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_SiteFooter_15_txtNewsletterSignupEmail" placeholder="Your email" /> <input type="button" name="ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$SiteFooter_15$btnSubscribeToNewsletter" value="Subscribe" onclick="javascript:__doPostBack('ctl00$ctl00$ctl00$ContentPlaceHolderDefault$SiteFooter_15$btnSubscribeToNewsletter','')" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_SiteFooter_15_btnSubscribeToNewsletter" /> </div> </div> <div class="subFooter"> <div class="socialMedia"> <a href="https://twitter.com/churchtimes" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_SiteFooter_15_twitterLink" target="_blank" aria-label="Twitter link" role="button"> <i class="fa fa-2x fa-twitter socialIcon"></i> </a> <a href="https://www.facebook.com/churchtimes" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_SiteFooter_15_facebookLink" target="_blank" aria-label="Facebook link" role="button"> <i class="fa fa-2x fa-facebook-official socialIcon"></i> </a> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/ChurchTimesVideo" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_SiteFooter_15_youtubeLink" target="_blank" aria-label="YouTube link" role="button"> <i class="fa fa-2x fa-youtube-play socialIcon"></i> </a> <a href="https://www.instagram.com/thechurchtimes/" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_SiteFooter_15_instagramLink" target="_blank" aria-label="Instagram link" role="button"> <i class="fa fa-2x fa-instagram socialIcon"></i> </a> <a href="/rss/" id="ContentPlaceHolderDefault_SiteFooter_15_rssLink" target="_blank" aria-label="Rss link" role="button"> <i class="fa fa-2x fa-rss socialIcon"></i> </a> </div> <div class="subFooterLink"> <a href='/about-us'>About us</a> <a href='/contact-us'>Contact us</a> <a href='/subscribe'>Subscribe</a> <a href='/advertise'>Advertise</a> <a href='/sitemap'>Sitemap</a> <a href='/topics'>Topics</a> <a href='/faq'>FAQ</a> <a href='https://myaccount.hymnsam.co.uk/privacy-policy' target="_blank">Privacy policy</a> </div> </div> <div class="footer"> <a href='https://www.hymnsam.co.uk' target='_blank' aria-label='Hymns Ancient & Modern'><img src='/media/5617498/hymns-logo-ct.png?width=150' data-rjs='/media/5617498/hymns-logo-ct.png?width=300' alt='Hymns Ancient & Modern' /></a><p>© Church Times 2024. All rights reserved.</p> <span class="imprezaLink">Website by <a href="https://imprezait.co.uk/enabling" target="_blank">Impreza IT</a> </span> </div> <a href="#" class="back-to-top"> <i class="fa fa-2x fa-angle-up"></i> </a> </footer> <div id="subscribePopup" class="white-popup mfp-hide"> <h1>Welcome to the Church Times</h1> <p style="text-align: center;"><img style="width: 277px;" src="/media/5684535/ctgroupjan22.png?width=277" alt="" /></p> <p> </p> <p style="text-align: center;">To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.</p> <p style="text-align: center;">Non-subscribers can read four articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)</p> <div class="subscribePopupActions"> <a href='/subscribe'>Subscribe now</a> <a href='https://login.hymnsam.co.uk?websiteid=4&returnUrl=https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/comment/columnists'>Sign in/Register</a> <br /> <a href="javascript:void(0)" class="continueLink" onclick="$.magnificPopup.close();">Continue to article</a> </div> </div> <script src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/jquery.sidr/2.2.1/jquery.sidr.min.js"></script>  <script src="/bundles/siteScripts?v=I4gtWdBv_3y0YS5GuUD-doQskCxZTa4rTC9g1q8hH2Y1"></script> <script src="/bundles/pageScripts?v=VGkLIxWeI39Vnt47C8yv0JRxNqgjT2U1M0OonRapcHg1"></script>  <script> function linkifyDiv(classOrId) { $(classOrId).linkify({ target: { url: '_blank', email: null } }); } </script> <script type="text/javascript"> $("#dtSearchBox").keyup(function (event) { if (event.keyCode == 13) { $("#dtSearchIcon").click(); } }); $("#searchBox").keyup(function (event) { if (event.keyCode == 13) { $("#searchIcon").click(); } }); </script>  <script> $("a[href^='http://']").attr("target", "_blank"); $("a[href^='https://']").attr("target", "_blank"); // Remove targets from login links // $("a[href^='https://testlogin.hymnsam.co.uk']").attr("target", "_self"); $("a[href^='https://login.hymnsam.co.uk']").attr("target", "_self"); </script> <script type="text/javascript" src="/Scripts/retina.min.js"></script> <div class="aspNetHidden"> <input type="hidden" name="__VIEWSTATEGENERATOR" id="__VIEWSTATEGENERATOR" value="CA0B0334" /> </div></form> <script> $(function () { retinajs(); }); </script>  <script src="https://www.google.com/recaptcha/api.js?render=6LduibkUAAAAANpBYyAVuKNd9R5Ggl_rgjV9UKyg"></script>  <script src="https://adverts.hymnsam.co.uk/scripts/hymns.ads.min.js"></script> <script> window.twttr = (function (d, s, id) { var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0], t = window.twttr || {}; if (d.getElementById(id)) return t; js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; js.src = "https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js"; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); t._e = []; t.ready = function (f) { t._e.push(f); }; return t; }(document, "script", "twitter-wjs")); </script> </body> </html>