CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "journals.aps.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8f09d887fd5ffdc4',cH: 'uqxtvGwG1g6FwPp2LT1tqbx84B.ko0GIDzNDiKlJzmY-1733965943-1.2.1.1-TMOY5vihRekL9_81cgJ2DxzGNgxdF9NWruXXU5_cADjRfQiZt8TXC5mK8V.x14m0',cUPMDTk: "\/prper\/abstract\/10.1103\/PhysRevPhysEducRes.16.010111?__cf_chl_tk=GxpujrOsDc_z02.9ylh3wTmdB5mObPyTNnxDUlmRk5g-1733965943-1.0.1.1-KTPpnFub8GG8hztaLUVR.gwPFAPQy6Cjy3dwrDK65n0",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1733965943',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/prper\/abstract\/10.1103\/PhysRevPhysEducRes.16.010111?__cf_chl_f_tk=GxpujrOsDc_z02.9ylh3wTmdB5mObPyTNnxDUlmRk5g-1733965943-1.0.1.1-KTPpnFub8GG8hztaLUVR.gwPFAPQy6Cjy3dwrDK65n0",md: "5DuSjuWSYhP2Yy91ca5aqQYK2OoFKsaOEYeu2.qb0RQ-1733965943-1.2.1.1-IJCQ4ZLZAiMXxg1do2vQGGOuJmy9zmJLyWolZ.LIEms1VP8mc7MqxyQUy13Iayopra.V8.8JiEUmxjuwsZUkfGuhYEYmibgkbxP6ydEtC2hCBLrrmX1OHdLj6NDM0tbHve2Niut6YUam3UvGfA.c096CyCAwc7vV_ddBvKImF2RAHoc_FrM1vTsLFXLYKnmb_nH8F6BoVNoLqsva6s_QrZjoi4ViTzI9bCFQjxJM7RnPu4YSaUTpcnRMybVgMRQ6cUl7fD2AMD1VUOBFEOYr3Y1kx.FDb2pkN6idvhpzDwDeX9TrCCVbkM7vSmNnyFR0WtBHQVU9BDSHcvYo1_.wxh2T.S2x8bYwqJl5Io2ucvYvmHLquqMpl7hXI8uCqVaoP1RLkvPQOS3hDNz14beOE5p.z2CJi0.rDTusT1ZIT._3iQt6.5e6lfvSkGPMWo3ubU_xNd90GmaPe8HOMUhl7KAMH2MvfpYvBcY9vlxN90YcDRD7ADhGpv4EqbJu6kDCCfFPLGYiz7tthc7KERKrUFkDeHSWKVMgbGYOfRZdwrgOfvOQ3_7vDs0UedRrDi99UB35WLfHV2HT4uZLTjVLvDIszG372G1qStmjlutAgJyTaP.Vrv6neQ6EwZgyJjtgLvirdFk8mVMTE9I3cQKKuBJsyPvaCVX1Cz9ctNraL5mGktHwVR9tcRaI28JxUJj.gjPqkWphIrO9B1kHq_VbDvxYQSheIrgm1J6iqSsU6eIqiZ1Ums04s_TiJAPcPnJPGzcSwpUj7eDH5L0u0EPRyla6UEKNKyYtzd6e67h59deZP9vlkBjJrxrrkKbltvdh0kifqv20djLzwWSTz83jDXyUZ4ZTcCJxgFgsjlPGgsmNYyJFqPJ0xvBGnE5p8s6fwJlz5uuIoUTxFjI4Qc9.RktYIT1P6DE0S6eNi1OWaFnFkG1j8V50Ev_Dmv255t7wUjXLldgzNpbKWd6LzZRLBOCsxV5RZI6l9ESTZRW8F9XNpZU0680Pc1Vdt0I1yH3gTUXROa.w5d1jy29i1Hj8ZXscDpzidxoUKTOWlGL7XVUyyZJ0oHeBhPePo2mgZBrvIWJoyeBylT9KOKd1cbQVYvCLD1_N2CziXAkC5Nx6vfpU8088wjx2iXH5GCutxH6ty3NsGPMnawOJbjKasiRJfex0m1tVrp9h9EqM0dWGnkQCLM0PFHgETPMe_rFZeHQwIA3UaCXsOYcTcM2IqA1LmLb8FwO8KRhz0WEx6RF2g9bLqm8dKb6DcjcmWL.qbWCEzUoEGPzTWbe01NmN29B_iEGYCi6eK5lAQ6jwp.Gej.OhmNVM4I141a33CQTgg6I.h0rYNulBpEO_5kzYMBXalwFmyoqikGw9q..YbSvr6Za.4ArCHShL9JyKBrrVrqDUOauY6qKs4uGG0qCrQKOf4BBNgjamD.0Pfd1gZuqHf0jQ2VdeiWeD9eevLu9nLHioNsI6uz3Zu_PFuEiMXif4QsHODFSrOJP9wiSCq_IZE9RQ540lgHkKM1uOnnojHjDs8d94uue7mn79B1rl8l7bBrqDLNnr.c4SLhSmrXcDKIIEBxaYixoT4ukwWYKFUufEq_8DOrArvuFabB4p4cwu0z_dyGOaj08airgWQ2jLV.KUZn0QVFLaQOflRWOeI9wn3Ss_jV1PnyJUlBZh84C_57Ko1P8PokzHJghCCnq05EvQHg8MG9M2tjEP9h9V.fNyLd9luBTJgYYOgknBNUT.MtKFWEBNkuJ3SH8jWFM_D8PhluoHvicMnWorLWlGYtva68TPa0ywQH9wb070tixKZ56AycwGz22Br2Uozs9JMZ9SSZJMTLGdlHL7PeD0KVxGDaOq8DnKMiTGTnECzsMyY4iG8EEjaM4ukXqJyq3wv.pxRL1UJn3iMrTo3MUGfOwiBtq8rf71nmP8ar7aqg2rmA8aP3qsDcnZ6.EDKgqmqlD5FHjvnoxoGWpG3yQwxR1dRD1BdoFXz.i4h6gEJ.3CLjO2bPhgJePd6D6RX7hdted7b_DU.Swf27D3rTXUTEW0LkC4AQKInszkp.QIVZspLAaa2erlyVcu.Y4.pqq310N9nQd27224g.4y9l.7LuXSVMvAo7u8iLzr43XyxCg1nyXj.t9_3IY6m1fpdiXpIvikeDGKv_wClc32a0c.rdzS8N6bGNgqiJQxv3bdpDr2WqmyCIY7sPVr2SpPC8UH3wDd1XLteMuETeBEagZ01lx562Ff2Tkw4oOvNb0qlQjwPqUx_J5Ftg_9xe1KMGAIaBFCh53e3WEJGcsegpi_P7i3MMhba8Bv6pw9iUf9sf3ijZ3XBKoXsj0ompzpbWN.aHTve2g2w.eSIsrv28li1apSd2hbJvjuGqbreV0MTvQnp_2Tl7PT.lPdhjlzM8IIzLwiDYLV4LDIFjOfwapzQ9UtB6WvMz34kbz_FrpHkYdoRy3NjWS_R65piHxKdFww6NoZxoRTaoIH7vWFKrIbWmijOZ2GixFLTuQ7jz6d1UHt85kDpaRHsTRoiSPgy7r2qqU6afZsMBwa1BUUkQP9Hg9kEunFWo010KekO2ljX.fU2TLjO6lJgBDfrH9vG8lY_mFF_SSwDpLtGVHPd33dV.cXncwXHT5rCqznu_Htfcrsf7lCQMACgbKqfgj49cUjIc6FQVQaSafCWAx_bJx2.TMTr.n5jFkAQsZ4VS3KnoFLkzx1cu_oeqXwLK_AzEgujK2201FNokAuo8gkeFGKIP29nRbVB7mRu4rJk5BbUpOCs6i2MjRUDg8tPm9jNIPIzfXJftziswjYdJwinhXqE4rioLjYSHbvuCXg7NaNluq5bB7LwyeZUjj6wFhox8jqsMZjTkLT2aOgjiCq8Pph2iZYX8vC6W_osbiPmUfsqIRzeUY55VltSFQOMQNzWr3nhlbVpRI.yLIUGIbw5sSFUQvzBl3dwa1iwIQExlmFgHlTKW3qJ_zMM7Copw46Mk6.wU3Xcd4ZS4VSAla1d2xxwb5FEWtar1YCw2bEEPV3xKtGNA",mdrd: "ON_hVrHIfylp0WSYQWtHgBmIZ4lfhjczWqqUVrYyF.c-1733965943-1.2.1.1-C5bCCYUQe9Q.vEwceFcpry7bfDeVpLJ8S4LmKaIiiwyWCYNrOQGtixvxapANtjOMgw7fHpGW0qFJLSIH0z74Xqufqa9Um4pBoJsxgz6tvjYOW2L3gACnqcG5H3vPRm71i9Uj9OBcOq.hE_Q86qZn1kQ31IxnCZR9D0Iq5tKdHFHHP6wZ2h2AGUYmTVMyYIFYSuiFqfQvbgpxS8txGzJI4wtBqFLd.xbpuizb9PBfHhg_OXAY3epmRepn1qxdtAdUWNtDgB4_YdekxeVIXMtpo_KAqxb7RemwOs0j6TcQl0i.TRdT3qAaWyaB.GGfWltpN.d9PgtimPah.w1ed7ac_Znds41yyk_Z8N1vgdK33jnmpfLN2ORm_3YQx8deU5Dki0Y.kkCjAsjNJbmcctOWVoJgvgCgINzAYup7UvGgPxCekhB_QphkzTcCkEhGzGNSRlZqj23DkR1nPU4Yox95U7oFiWAigeR33uTsIToyOzrcgeVy5HyI4usjB8geTISNklwdIoSyBuKg.bMKNMVeCxDMvnmO3K1l1cSVtzngA85FVMhfQvI.lvA.fX9oNqXPixkjI8mn60d7w9KSJpRZsG51EsR1efC6xjgY4o6EHbvAoDPHIFVtE31ieE68nb27NbTa.aXaL44h0pdTyvRmWeH56g0Ly20dSEMozqOZL2hfvguHi_LuZlQQ3fZahT69JaA62rgEBkEcL2HE8deQ0XLic8iDvTw7WzWNRZC5ZQzRlfSHPAG0AUbsN.2fE4XxaASOVqn5B2cAgMipW3yLO9gcXcrcUrRDBJHjrTgSBAf6TQKdvt6lKOmQf0byEB_XCcP8New54qQ0AhxLMMiNiCgnTUEF5AGzCWixvSC6z..UrvYh1YWogt_KcU.wtJiSgiv5pq02ZKkXyy5mpZcV4CidXPDyrHBTFkSLKNT.bnEtGcvZs2KYSPRZYw4c.mn1LUuyTzTFB.4bw4ZGejvKpTBiuhvAH_1bfYKSuyMEu2orMEURHVZ_9HQGUpmTHVvv_mXtWwTy7vXXSbEtzWb_lhl9bDVZauTEa9v9L8s3nmDUqP4FPNNxOWYt2xbhQowyxwNXgut2x89HnhdATau39.86bSjo.Pdw.K7aAe36zfqlWF2NpOvhPbfzsFNl.Obcx7H2izhKHwIVQk_rj5QHzDj8OgwyOyUr_dw_UX5i26QVfxVXtFIfZActnUTXaBhZxn06e.v0RrMZIrLp8xLJidcJubWjZKhy5TQ3wxmd1at1YmHdFzySgdkElQdjkw_RL.Ib4MsDb5RzCdiFEz43jQ5h03IJIt1jEo6ylnATjPUrhCIEcZUclOeh6rj84Fr3x83MT8_FC2D167QEEvASikHGWZ4SlN11u7BxJhrXZzvXrPpraEGJtdD8d7JCdgEbWjypxmnupDiJw9JVMmv8IRN3Qx3eDPFzxdVkGGU.K3px9RLQ43PTIm2A0rGo6yIsKVTGHYn0YpYQ4AbrLp5ETaX0Lzk6O.Qn92vxyNy_smG_jcVzW2uO2FHOtTEuEmw1SaFsyM3jhCGMvV_62hv2KwdtelxS0TA6gx.IouYhyZOgZ8prPCujSirqHY5tvosWovQ6PNwbrBpnX4UCyIuCyZOiaHhmzHzTmPQWnKEXwzCKF4Y5YFqd2k02EhSlW7w5CS07L1GWNZsiqO0tllMGPyXORrKvzYHEljJ8PdbD2SpLzeCBVsBLs0MU8OwDjGNU4ruf11gBwuMyggabkWvlIi9Gwqe1hPG7DsezfmwsyvEUdO_dxmdZhlz11hJBmAV2J8vGHvKQcyN9wwgXi7g7N0LQ7v8RwDXjnO9W9WpRP.0S5CDAS2yrTHWqhBG2d_ZnsbLbHxfnvMchdFQ5wXzq1Gjqbr_XoS2I0R5uBw_iHGCKVi1znX3m_RkTYZOwQLYItXq5NfTbyr5suUATMpm33d5RMz2aMLfQwyOl2RteYSk"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8f09d887fd5ffdc4';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/prper\/abstract\/10.1103\/PhysRevPhysEducRes.16.010111?__cf_chl_rt_tk=GxpujrOsDc_z02.9ylh3wTmdB5mObPyTNnxDUlmRk5g-1733965943-1.0.1.1-KTPpnFub8GG8hztaLUVR.gwPFAPQy6Cjy3dwrDK65n0" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>