CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="120"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.annualreviews.org",cType: 'non-interactive',cRay: '8e74401f6ba43f57',cH: 'ULEFPnY1Dpf.0usDtyEKuky0GsMcyOfrUixUFgwUII8-1732397322-1.2.1.1-RiaD8v.3ZYHxKjnOME2a7w3nv0VNrKshOU0YW54UCJnCNF17BM1Zrl6k7c4dhQpK',cUPMDTk: "\/doi\/10.1146\/annurev-polisci-052217-104957?__cf_chl_tk=EgGtqQL1VFn3T6S23M3lM1XdqXzclCrH9Moo0UsNyzM-1732397322-1.0.1.1-H9uIVw6LHAT6n6As1fZC.vVaTOLkrFahxiHzptptNPc",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732397322',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '120000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/doi\/10.1146\/annurev-polisci-052217-104957?__cf_chl_f_tk=EgGtqQL1VFn3T6S23M3lM1XdqXzclCrH9Moo0UsNyzM-1732397322-1.0.1.1-H9uIVw6LHAT6n6As1fZC.vVaTOLkrFahxiHzptptNPc",md: "x68ryl0j6obnK4CQytZ_t1.du1_stpq3sWjtPy34Mfc-1732397322-1.2.1.1-jptDnE6Iql3.DVPcGUW83ENWUKTR0jwn1DXbT2pcctrsy1oJA3Ige9aCCi1QkRkEr.t60h0eBGtOgn5ewOfXJQCDBdp16VOuIhBXPTlVMHpseTrvl7PRDkocSZHjayilaM1JPZaQ32awPDfi64Whb9wBRJUIFsj8Z.iMbAy1MwbDxgmLjmIsOBtdEMWuKBC_HUf9ZNprpzbG_g_Orh69HSvZmb0NJuVd9IX7GRkQ2LkWfg4FVOVK81KoUrpm70eYPe80LzNQZ16OylPgzSMHYzJ3rFlP4u1di1Dx3nMowcdNTXloFeq_q09m3ksq1mEBi1zgeQEidcbpfoZUOojGgpIuG0JzHmtlFLkM.d.F6JP_4Nh3A_Jnq.QSNtYcZvdBiWTVxSFs3XsDLDuB94iJiMfHNo_WLU1nGerXXHZF2plE1ywoH_FrEnxBm9PF_P1VKgxPDQ8oNUbIAxpCr0sNBYNVQOIi6sv2o0kgm3R7WjBTw4LAVU1F73GnSBfwckgkxSgaiuULFHMtejch_jC88XYpvSPP6ZvEinwVNypQppp6x69rPHqp_SnkcjtMGnNV.xxsai.r33lKhv_995HfRJ0V09W5sQ7x2dlksje6dnO13m36tPJg9GJTjOveWhSYeVQjg4XW17BPFAtIDSogzLpMwhmrY0DPaUErcP2rEmV8BpYaqNk9NswFB1s2BFesnmBH_ArnzTS0zt5Xb_SKNg.pwhYdvB3WkqPSsBROGcvbAuRlKFABP_YlzJczFT5k6ty3qNKH4Bw2xk2I2GGewPsIaNHl0KVlGsps4mBqujNZmULv3MIf3Q3TV69sVF8RqZLhlskq8A2keEMoGwIi57azMy6tFW2uZGBnHy0EKn67XDy503dXBDKFSQE1nFWH4RVKMbeGBcidjiI0EareUp7Z2q1RId1iuIASzPVrcQpMXMmO3nS09xxmCv_GsfxLhEJH3mKzcUREG4rGg72CtHm_u9W9Lf1I1xonzd51ae2VIZQ7dm8HypY9Yax4cReR8cEak5fU.vPemlWT57bHNuPpzKPlaDYnUGoS.POXLT2GhzH7eZdXZZuLa3VVlDB_Yf_6crTqoL_6i4xTfmuBVM2kLOMLZEMLVWTzsyJfRYjsy1boGaIQ1tHhqL2TC2dfRG5FNe9qf5TLaZglg1oa2hvQ82w5ZYPIWmGScOAh6T_F.DGtHSvonwOLwR54OJNp9H0.AZ3zsCWKPUl5WNNL1LumFdFBUUe4dWEt992IXoHPZBOXbEatZ6FMk5E.ENQQhK0LQ4XOcYIR7js3enwqEcpjoVNylcUech2lDWaIk5U1RgEC7xA62fW6gC_YluOdCbyLrkR0SFxloECEqB9JyOhivr7QsiPBFWiJI17xjOiQUdKJ6jJmpWCbPDbW7fo1muHk.hRHhIlEhjhWZzeZRpUYSOX7ikSkebnqixYnjeP0rFFSTBjp8cg3uWgAPfPpYLrZskYTRrk2LmKyphYwYyqwmoom2bkn4MBNShs8g5_b8T1cB9WmXt5zqykJvnr05XJmFdWg.M9dCiQ4s1ohnfvz9cfiVpdkcH4FRnmGRvR92QoBsFM0FnR7bOLtlGu_ZfzXmzWDWW3LDSKVYSZw2n6cEFwMG7ZzX5zoeN5ZXH040p32rR68rPXplq3jwFf32zWxQZDajtkg3UjICITJkaOZWV1JTWJ2TdO2OufoUO9pCFKDXiQxAtXk6_H24byf4YKs3wSUHUPCYiLrVT4iVQ8vD26nsAVIdPrK9rOIBE.W3tuszJIGxxw4RV9_OEF58pKq3D_wQ4gsvL7Q5qZ9Jo4pXn3LRmY4IAjjMv6nIQ0TKlBCCjL5T8OT7JNn1QAv5uvlFbx5yr2KFesBkx4CXP0lJlSRtZVcxBT3jQmXCDA4Spr6iTKNARweXETj4le0HZFWDIma1yTbVgUuT010L7rLZ5Dk_fXDQ29eKZwpcE0Ff5DUrVxQNX_5EgdcI3zjyta7bGN_NDliDBMLSkYjJGecVaaKql1ycOBlHd.IW3rEw5H6mcATP5iz_pTVJNxl",mdrd: "IIun3TMVq839yo55d466L7a2zDt1JRpj3SFB9qYAtuE-1732397322-1.2.1.1-0Mr78U1mItXp71wJusr_XQDr3ex5vwFjTTiZ3F3ke4Z3Mds3mTQ71SxLx6REWB8yor.cHGzMMjvVOsrNBTSzDRqP2l8OfxhR6PjmwEv4ZOvsZNW_H6GvPuWEASZ5D1XMiqQFldkZtWOZicsFbujbhQDfPCdpNT3icfrKMxfAYH_kuT3UPt1yFBB676euZQWAbjG5K._Pn7ltCgzRseMCptYwoOnHIrIkow6aLDMPWnmbi0hfNgwsnwarrxF.QLlcyqurhA0OVKvVEsLJMnENfwqWgldqqhty6q2XyQwifYI_QsvDVT4Yiqi4nONaxtDdHhjIp3.BW.8IGKnyIckuygP1F59eeBUBxVd37ZQ0QjGOEUtbB9brbTxaCMY9LHXu.8lZh3mO5l_bXn08q.Vysl2LaLclPycZbSMDyOvHbyi9IrFlRb1MEt1yi8rSUMfoRFgnIUyHXVMZl7XUNPokiu2n8Q_njo9lqPzstHgbcfuyxoEPbRYSmfunuFTmqEwM7jzvWrDuQx6pQ8o0y9IXCeFgS1FMF_vunBDvavfV_lCltIfaNNgkJVFoR3xfbn7fCu0F3ycdhNtCd_JMrLDcp8D7re3oKGZZgHPeLY4yhgt05oLtgT3wIgkpftfwf4jSfH5jSacxN0hYd9KWU.wZK4yYuipNZFwVZp04i5XvxqOO7WCHulB6BrG3usAWKUHgvkZiQdGO4EGp.9_gxgDyX2WPM78yOqVoGSnGHVhegdMmF3bLFcupifDuZkvJZrlrqFSLffJH62Zze1qSaaDlvKPDqF06BtiwMWc7nCnQRIz0K.az30QdcPTdKajrzuMKP97thm0.3P_LL5Cha22_CRCWWVQpkwbIkI2SQF9mBm4TVYXqL3J64Qasp6hLuWYXzaL74cW5Kvb2kSGfdSNfVGlP1ZjsUO6gcNu2pBmO3nYuyAAsORPFb0GjeawU28hzdX00ZydDv7UQj4sTOxf4k47igDTNIA_7zNsMKh16t4PzFMSV4vUmgfMoGzrco.3lbKf6eFeGowTCbjm6EyloFxpGPN_tWNjy3c5cGVxmjkMVbhcBRh0YDrT4s99mGqNksE6fApTnrWDuV3ocfjd47nho7eTUGQtdbKZYd6Yw0PDgvgnpn7gDM29MIMIjyAoI_usg6Ui6dfRHu.JwW6dazlPYqefociUewOz_eQtL19PNG999BbtbAUTJ4upEJR1ba6V1JgbUzO3f4Tz2yesmR2x9sfyJfaskpYrd18ezhBWqEGZRM05zUcxURRF0t2oW731l8PDmWZZIgYDQpPxT1Uk9hzmaHj537qpHKfEd_dmJefY7pShKbTiX3NPzNA3o3HA73N1nCRqOh1CvFMNlKo8XjrDHwQehV5dG1Gds0E6asn38p9Mee9Q7anULgF7zgD.pgmWk1bIrAEx.w3Q33j4QZZaHunMnjNTRiCrP4XgsFyze2a9Js61m6ppYliw04XUh9J_lQnHLgDdOCK6o1ShzX.qgmq_PzEYMvKF_mMD2Vs9DioMJ3T2alF538A.W1Cxzt210l3j.KhZBgOvLw4bG.LheqTxBcgyjuZIo6Vld1P2DQoDlZQ6g5qLo_vSydEeUvNkGmbvw7iWN37ehF_2KMjl.qfvn.KvoY907.m8AUJ6ze_sM26jDHVQs5y5crKX9xt06Tzr5_7SAHvX4duvtBMcWuq_1q_lEQKzfDHM02fGNs.xDbErPLYCxbsHGYqKlA3FwfUt4btiF7SndCxg3jjayUwzW1oD3sRkWalBuS_P.sabI8J487ssV1wleroZ2L7.GFgLkU4wLhEakzFge6teUn0KJyjnx1czab1wRKxI0iWl9m2c1BCTEtdZ.jXKJqUEVLta0EzFCjiZyJBJh_IcZapCZsi4g_GvZawp9E6g6fWVmgyt994xTKeKU4e3xVSzxjUf_pyXvhaB6dJ3JFIGfXyHFNgeB9B3fNxO0ntuW3ZdQPSv3RlMu6bOZimr8GLug0s.pEXihi2ygjw"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e74401f6ba43f57';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/doi\/10.1146\/annurev-polisci-052217-104957?__cf_chl_rt_tk=EgGtqQL1VFn3T6S23M3lM1XdqXzclCrH9Moo0UsNyzM-1732397322-1.0.1.1-H9uIVw6LHAT6n6As1fZC.vVaTOLkrFahxiHzptptNPc" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>