Texas curriculum glosses over racism, slavery, critics say

<!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en" class="no-js"> <head> <title>Texas curriculum glosses over racism, slavery, critics say | The Texas Tribune</title> <meta charset="utf-8"> <link href="//cdnjs.cloudflare.com" rel="dns-prefetch"> <link href="//cdn.texastribune.org" rel="dns-prefetch"> <link href="//static.texastribune.org" rel="dns-prefetch"> <link href="//www.googletagmanager.com" rel="dns-prefetch"> <link href="//www.googletagservices.com" rel="dns-prefetch"> <link href="//ajax.googleapis.com" rel="dns-prefetch"> <link href="https://www.google.com" rel="preconnect"> <link href="https://www.gstatic.com" rel="preconnect" crossorigin>  <link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="48x48" href="/static/images/favicon-48x48.7388fd83b75b.png"> <link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="32x32" href="/static/images/favicon-32x32.ebd14081da36.png"> <link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="16x16" href="/static/images/favicon-16x16.d0e640fbf205.png"> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="180x180" href="/static/images/apple-touch-icon.358661eab2b3.png"> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0"> <link rel="canonical" href="https://www.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/"> <script type="application/ld+json"> {"@context": "https://schema.org/", "@type": "ReportageNewsArticle", "url": "https://www.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/", "mainEntityOfPage": {"@type": "WebPage", "@id": "https://www.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/"}, "inLanguage": "en_US", "isAccessibleForFree": true, "headline": "Texas curriculum glosses over racism, slavery, critics say", "alternativeHeadline": "How some Texas parents and historians say a new state curriculum glosses over slavery and racism", "description": "Education officials say the materials were designed to be age appropriate but critics argue they repeatedly omit key context and oversimplify history.", "datePublished": "2024-11-18T11:00:00+00:00", "dateModified": "2024-11-18T11:07:22.041435+00:00", "author": [{"@type": "Person", "name": "Jaden Edison", "url": "https://www.texastribune.org/about/staff/jaden-edison/", "affiliation": {"@type": "NewsMediaOrganization", "name": "The Texas Tribune"}, "sameAs": ["https://twitter.com/edisonjaden"], "knowsAbout": [{"@type": "Thing", "name": "public education"}, {"@type": "Thing", "name": "politics"}, {"@type": "Thing", "name": "state government"}, {"@type": "Thing", "name": "criminal justice"}], "image": "https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/R2syILE0rD7b9gRWpybCLkfrUw0=/105x155/smart/filters:quality(85)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/profiles/Jaden-Edison_headshot.jpeg", "jobTitle": "Public Education Reporter", "description": "Jaden Edison is the public education reporter for The Texas Tribune, where he previously worked as a reporting fellow in summer 2022. Before returning to the Tribune full time, he served as the justice reporter for The Connecticut Mirror, another nonprofit newsroom covering government, politics and public policy. He also interned at Poynter, a nonprofit media institute. Jaden has a master's degree from the Toni Stabile Center for Investigative Journalism at Columbia University and a bachelor's degree from the School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Texas State University, where he was editor-in-chief of the The University Star, the campus' student-run newspaper.", "workLocation": {"@type": "Place", "name": "Texas, United States"}}], "articleSection": "public education", "image": {"@type": "ImageObject", "url": "https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/eDJ8Q6Dc1YzbAizFzYiRRumtIRk=/450x300/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg", "width": 450, "height": 300, "caption": "A U.S. History classroom at Akins High School in Austin, on October 2018."}, "keywords": ["history textbooks", "public education"], "publisher": {"@type": "NewsMediaOrganization", "name": "The Texas Tribune", "publishingPrinciples": "https://www.texastribune.org/about/", "logo": {"@type": "ImageObject", "url": "https://www.texastribune.org/static/images/logo.png"}}, "thumbnailUrl": "https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/eDJ8Q6Dc1YzbAizFzYiRRumtIRk=/450x300/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg", "creator": [{"@type": "Person", "name": "Jaden Edison", "url": "https://www.texastribune.org/about/staff/jaden-edison/", "affiliation": {"@type": "NewsMediaOrganization", "name": "The Texas Tribune"}, "sameAs": ["https://twitter.com/edisonjaden"], "knowsAbout": [{"@type": "Thing", "name": "public education"}, {"@type": "Thing", "name": "politics"}, {"@type": "Thing", "name": "state government"}, {"@type": "Thing", "name": "criminal justice"}], "image": "https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/R2syILE0rD7b9gRWpybCLkfrUw0=/105x155/smart/filters:quality(85)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/profiles/Jaden-Edison_headshot.jpeg", "jobTitle": "Public Education Reporter", "description": "Jaden Edison is the public education reporter for The Texas Tribune, where he previously worked as a reporting fellow in summer 2022. Before returning to the Tribune full time, he served as the justice reporter for The Connecticut Mirror, another nonprofit newsroom covering government, politics and public policy. He also interned at Poynter, a nonprofit media institute. Jaden has a master's degree from the Toni Stabile Center for Investigative Journalism at Columbia University and a bachelor's degree from the School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Texas State University, where he was editor-in-chief of the The University Star, the campus' student-run newspaper.", "workLocation": {"@type": "Place", "name": "Texas, United States"}}], "contributors": []} </script> <meta name="copyright" content="© The Texas Tribune" /> <meta name="publisher" content="The Texas Tribune" /> <meta name="robots" content="index,follow,max-image-preview:large" /> <meta name="siteinfo" content="http://www.texastribune.org/robots.txt" /> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" href="/static/images/apple-touch-icon.358661eab2b3.png" /> <meta name="google-site-verification" content="3EMut9KLnb_7fohrI_bDaR4py76QIWAt4uPidjagbzI" /> <meta name="y_key" content="36169ff9ee60f3ab" /> <meta name="msvalidate.01" content="DB22C31255557D1E219990CA92192CBB" /> <meta name="pocket-site-verification" content="a03da537417a06100ceed0ab61a3d2" /> <meta property="fb:app_id" content="154122474650943"> <meta property="og:site_name" content="The Texas Tribune" /> <meta property="fb:pages" content="124434790836"> <meta name="twitter:site" content="@TexasTribune"> <meta name="twitter:dnt" content="on"> <meta property="og:url" content="https://www.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/"> <meta name="description" content="Education officials say the materials were designed to be age appropriate but critics argue they repeatedly omit key context and oversimplify history."> <meta name="keywords" content="texas news, texas politics, texas policy, texas government, history textbooks, public education"> <meta name="author" content="By Jaden Edison"> <meta property="og:title" content="How some Texas parents and historians say a new state curriculum glosses over slavery and racism"> <meta property="og:description" content="Education officials say the materials were designed to be age appropriate but critics argue they repeatedly omit key context and oversimplify history."> <meta property="og:type" content="article"> <meta property="og:image" content="https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/NMalMbZ-nVTe3NY-hYN1a6544kI=/1200x630/filters:quality(95):focal(0x0:5472x3131)/static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg"> <meta property="og:image:alt" content="A U.S. History classroom at Akins High School in Austin, on October 2018."> <meta property="article:publisher" content="https://www.facebook.com/texastribune/"> <meta property="article:published_time" content="2024-11-18T11:00:00+00:00"> <meta name="twitter:title" content="How some Texas parents and historians say a new state curriculum glos…"> <meta name="twitter:description" content="Education officials say the materials were designed to be age appropriate but critics argue they repeatedly omit key context and oversimplify history."> <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"> <meta name="twitter:image" content="https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/NMalMbZ-nVTe3NY-hYN1a6544kI=/1200x630/filters:quality(95):focal(0x0:5472x3131)/static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg"> <meta name="twitter:image:alt" content="A U.S. History classroom at Akins High School in Austin, on October 2018."> <meta name="twitter:creator" content="@edisonjaden"> <meta name="twitter:label1" content="By" /> <meta name="twitter:data1" content="By Jaden Edison" /> <meta name="twitter:label2" content="Published on" /> <meta name="twitter:data2" content="Nov. 18, 2024" /> <meta name="parsely-tags" content="history textbooks, public education" /> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/static/css/chz-story.821287601a7ccf3625512f817a9bf3b6.css"> <script> /** Promises https://github.com/bramstein/fontfaceobserver */ (function(){'use strict';var f,g=[];function l(a){g.push(a);1==g.length&&f()}function m(){for(;g.length;)g[0](),g.shift()}f=function(){setTimeout(m)};function n(a){this.a=p;this.b=void 0;this.f=[];var b=this;try{a(function(a){q(b,a)},function(a){r(b,a)})}catch(c){r(b,c)}}var p=2;function t(a){return new n(function(b,c){c(a)})}function u(a){return new n(function(b){b(a)})}function q(a,b){if(a.a==p){if(b==a)throw new TypeError;var c=!1;try{var d=b&&b.then;if(null!=b&&"object"==typeof b&&"function"==typeof d){d.call(b,function(b){c||q(a,b);c=!0},function(b){c||r(a,b);c=!0});return}}catch(e){c||r(a,e);return}a.a=0;a.b=b;v(a)}} function r(a,b){if(a.a==p){if(b==a)throw new TypeError;a.a=1;a.b=b;v(a)}}function v(a){l(function(){if(a.a!=p)for(;a.f.length;){var b=a.f.shift(),c=b[0],d=b[1],e=b[2],b=b[3];try{0==a.a?"function"==typeof c?e(c.call(void 0,a.b)):e(a.b):1==a.a&&("function"==typeof d?e(d.call(void 0,a.b)):b(a.b))}catch(h){b(h)}}})}n.prototype.g=function(a){return this.c(void 0,a)};n.prototype.c=function(a,b){var c=this;return new n(function(d,e){c.f.push([a,b,d,e]);v(c)})}; function w(a){return new n(function(b,c){function d(c){return function(d){h[c]=d;e+=1;e==a.length&&b(h)}}var e=0,h=[];0==a.length&&b(h);for(var k=0;k<a.length;k+=1)u(a[k]).c(d(k),c)})}function x(a){return new n(function(b,c){for(var d=0;d<a.length;d+=1)u(a[d]).c(b,c)})};window.Promise||(window.Promise=n,window.Promise.resolve=u,window.Promise.reject=t,window.Promise.race=x,window.Promise.all=w,window.Promise.prototype.then=n.prototype.c,window.Promise.prototype["catch"]=n.prototype.g);}()); </script> <script async src="https://www.google.com/recaptcha/enterprise.js?render=6Lf8phUgAAAAALezDJzYqEW07ZDmac978f9zIfup"></script> <script> var dataLayer = window.dataLayer || []; dataLayer.push({ contentType: 'article', contentCategory: 'News' }); </script> <script> dataLayer.push({ author: 'Jaden Edison', contentID: '45665', contentSeries: 'None', primaryTags: 'public education', publishDate: '11-18-2024', tags: 'history textbooks,public education', title: 'How some Texas parents and historians say a new state curriculum glosses over slavery and racism' }); </script> <script>(function(w,d,s,l,i){w[l]=w[l]||[];w[l].push({'gtm.start': new Date().getTime(),event:'gtm.js'});var f=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0], j=d.createElement(s),dl=l!='dataLayer'?'&l='+l:'';j.async=true;j.src= 'https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id='+i+dl;f.parentNode.insertBefore(j,f); })(window,document,'script','dataLayer','GTM-P5L2Z5Z');</script> <script> window.ttGlobal = { pageType: 'generic' }; </script> <script> document .documentElement .classList .remove('no-js'); </script>  <script type="text/javascript" src="//cdn-4.convertexperiments.com/v1/js/100413043-100414470.js?environment=staging"></script>  </head> <body class="tt_body storypage"> <a href="#main-tt-content" class="c-button c-button--skip has-bg-teal has-text-white button button--s button--teal">Skip to main content</a> <aside id="prompt" class="c-prompt-container c-prompt-container--box c-prompt-container--livestream" aria-hidden="true"> <div class="c-prompt c-prompt--box c-prompt--livestream" onclick="event.stopPropagation();"> <button class="c-prompt__esc"><span class="is-sr-only">Close this element</span><span aria-hidden="true">×</span></button> <div class="c-prompt__content t-align-center"> <div class="c-prompt__newsletter" id="newsletter-subscribe-1839"> <div class="loading loading--s c-loading c-loading--s" aria-hidden="true"></div> </div> <p class="t-size-xxs c-prompt__disclosure">This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google <a class="t-links-unset" href="https://policies.google.com/privacy">Privacy Policy</a> and <a class="t-links-unset" href="https://policies.google.com/terms">Terms of Service</a> apply.</p> </div> </div> </aside> <noscript> <iframe src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-P5L2Z5Z" height="0" width="0" style="display:none;visibility:hidden"></iframe> </noscript> <div style="display:none;"> <svg><symbol id="arrow-up" viewBox="0 0 26 28"><path d="M25.172 15.172c0 .531-.219 1.031-.578 1.406l-1.172 1.172c-.375.375-.891.594-1.422.594s-1.047-.219-1.406-.594L16 13.172v11C16 25.297 15.062 26 14 26h-2c-1.062 0-2-.703-2-1.828v-11L5.406 17.75a1.96 1.96 0 01-2.812 0l-1.172-1.172c-.375-.375-.594-.875-.594-1.406s.219-1.047.594-1.422L11.594 3.578C11.953 3.203 12.469 3 13 3s1.047.203 1.422.578L24.594 13.75c.359.375.578.891.578 1.422z"/></symbol><symbol id="bars" viewBox="0 0 24 28"><path d="M24 21v2c0 .547-.453 1-1 1H1c-.547 0-1-.453-1-1v-2c0-.547.453-1 1-1h22c.547 0 1 .453 1 1zm0-8v2c0 .547-.453 1-1 1H1c-.547 0-1-.453-1-1v-2c0-.547.453-1 1-1h22c.547 0 1 .453 1 1zm0-8v2c0 .547-.453 1-1 1H1c-.547 0-1-.453-1-1V5c0-.547.453-1 1-1h22c.547 0 1 .453 1 1z"/></symbol><symbol id="bug" viewBox="0 0 174.9 200"><path d="M0 0v200l40.2-25.1h134.6V0H0zm125.2 139.7l-38.3-25.2-38.3 25.2 12.1-44.2L25 66.8l45.8-2.1L87 21.8l16.2 42.9 45.8 2.1-35.8 28.6 12 44.3z"/></symbol><symbol id="camera" viewBox="0 0 30 28"><path d="M15 10.5c2.484 0 4.5 2.016 4.5 4.5s-2.016 4.5-4.5 4.5-4.5-2.016-4.5-4.5 2.016-4.5 4.5-4.5zM26 4c2.203 0 4 1.797 4 4v14c0 2.203-1.797 4-4 4H4c-2.203 0-4-1.797-4-4V8c0-2.203 1.797-4 4-4h3.5l.797-2.125C8.688.844 9.906 0 11 0h8c1.094 0 2.312.844 2.703 1.875L22.5 4H26zM15 22c3.859 0 7-3.141 7-7s-3.141-7-7-7-7 3.141-7 7 3.141 7 7 7z"/></symbol><symbol id="caret-down" viewBox="0 0 16 28"><path d="M16 11a.99.99 0 01-.297.703l-7 7C8.516 18.89 8.265 19 8 19s-.516-.109-.703-.297l-7-7A.996.996 0 010 11c0-.547.453-1 1-1h14c.547 0 1 .453 1 1z"/></symbol><symbol id="close" viewBox="0 0 22 28"><path d="M20.281 20.656c0 .391-.156.781-.438 1.062l-2.125 2.125c-.281.281-.672.438-1.062.438s-.781-.156-1.062-.438L11 19.249l-4.594 4.594c-.281.281-.672.438-1.062.438s-.781-.156-1.062-.438l-2.125-2.125c-.281-.281-.438-.672-.438-1.062s.156-.781.438-1.062L6.751 15l-4.594-4.594c-.281-.281-.438-.672-.438-1.062s.156-.781.438-1.062l2.125-2.125c.281-.281.672-.438 1.062-.438s.781.156 1.062.438L11 10.751l4.594-4.594c.281-.281.672-.438 1.062-.438s.781.156 1.062.438l2.125 2.125c.281.281.438.672.438 1.062s-.156.781-.438 1.062L15.249 15l4.594 4.594c.281.281.438.672.438 1.062z"/></symbol><symbol id="comments" viewBox="0 0 28 28"><path d="M22 12c0 4.422-4.922 8-11 8-.953 0-1.875-.094-2.75-.25a13.114 13.114 0 01-4.344 2 11.58 11.58 0 01-1.344.25h-.047c-.234 0-.453-.187-.5-.453-.063-.297.141-.484.313-.688.609-.688 1.297-1.297 1.828-2.594C1.625 16.796 0 14.531 0 11.999c0-4.422 4.922-8 11-8s11 3.578 11 8zm6 4c0 2.547-1.625 4.797-4.156 6.266.531 1.297 1.219 1.906 1.828 2.594.172.203.375.391.313.688-.063.281-.297.484-.547.453a11.58 11.58 0 01-1.344-.25 13.114 13.114 0 01-4.344-2c-.875.156-1.797.25-2.75.25-2.828 0-5.422-.781-7.375-2.063a20.4 20.4 0 001.375.063c3.359 0 6.531-.969 8.953-2.719C22.562 17.376 24 14.798 24 12.001c0-.812-.125-1.609-.359-2.375C26.282 11.079 28 13.392 28 16.001z"/></symbol><symbol id="envelope" viewBox="0 0 28 28"><path d="M28 11.094V23.5c0 1.375-1.125 2.5-2.5 2.5h-23A2.507 2.507 0 010 23.5V11.094c.469.516 1 .969 1.578 1.359 2.594 1.766 5.219 3.531 7.766 5.391 1.313.969 2.938 2.156 4.641 2.156h.031c1.703 0 3.328-1.188 4.641-2.156 2.547-1.844 5.172-3.625 7.781-5.391a9.278 9.278 0 001.563-1.359zM28 6.5c0 1.75-1.297 3.328-2.672 4.281-2.438 1.687-4.891 3.375-7.313 5.078-1.016.703-2.734 2.141-4 2.141h-.031c-1.266 0-2.984-1.437-4-2.141-2.422-1.703-4.875-3.391-7.297-5.078-1.109-.75-2.688-2.516-2.688-3.938 0-1.531.828-2.844 2.5-2.844h23c1.359 0 2.5 1.125 2.5 2.5z"/></symbol><symbol id="facebook" viewBox="0 0 16 28"><path d="M14.984.187v4.125h-2.453c-1.922 0-2.281.922-2.281 2.25v2.953h4.578l-.609 4.625H10.25v11.859H5.469V14.14H1.485V9.515h3.984V6.109C5.469 2.156 7.891 0 11.422 0c1.687 0 3.141.125 3.563.187z"/></symbol><symbol id="file-text-o" viewBox="0 0 24 28"><path d="M22.937 5.938c.578.578 1.062 1.734 1.062 2.562v18a1.5 1.5 0 01-1.5 1.5h-21a1.5 1.5 0 01-1.5-1.5v-25a1.5 1.5 0 011.5-1.5h14c.828 0 1.984.484 2.562 1.062zM16 2.125V8h5.875c-.094-.266-.234-.531-.344-.641L16.64 2.468c-.109-.109-.375-.25-.641-.344zM22 26V10h-6.5A1.5 1.5 0 0114 8.5V2H2v24h20zM6 12.5c0-.281.219-.5.5-.5h11c.281 0 .5.219.5.5v1c0 .281-.219.5-.5.5h-11a.494.494 0 01-.5-.5v-1zM17.5 16c.281 0 .5.219.5.5v1c0 .281-.219.5-.5.5h-11a.494.494 0 01-.5-.5v-1c0-.281.219-.5.5-.5h11zm0 4c.281 0 .5.219.5.5v1c0 .281-.219.5-.5.5h-11a.494.494 0 01-.5-.5v-1c0-.281.219-.5.5-.5h11z"/></symbol><symbol id="flag" viewBox="0 0 29 28"><path d="M5 4c0 .719-.391 1.359-1 1.719V25.5c0 .266-.234.5-.5.5h-1a.514.514 0 01-.5-.5V5.719c-.609-.359-1-1-1-1.719 0-1.109.891-2 2-2s2 .891 2 2zm23 1v11.922c0 .578-.359.797-.812 1.031-1.766.953-3.719 1.813-5.766 1.813-2.875 0-4.25-2.188-7.656-2.188-2.484 0-5.094 1.125-7.25 2.281A1.023 1.023 0 016 20c-.547 0-1-.453-1-1V7.406c0-.375.187-.641.484-.859.375-.25.828-.469 1.234-.672C8.687 4.875 11.077 4 13.296 4c2.453 0 4.375.812 6.547 1.828.438.219.891.297 1.375.297C23.671 6.125 26.312 4 26.999 4c.547 0 1 .453 1 1z"/></symbol><symbol id="info" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M12 2c5.514 0 10 4.486 10 10s-4.486 10-10 10-10-4.486-10-10 4.486-10 10-10zm0-2c-6.627 0-12 5.373-12 12s5.373 12 12 12 12-5.373 12-12-5.373-12-12-12zm1 18h-2v-8h2v8zm-1-12.25c.69 0 1.25.56 1.25 1.25s-.56 1.25-1.25 1.25-1.25-.56-1.25-1.25.56-1.25 1.25-1.25z"/></symbol><symbol id="instagram" viewBox="0 0 24 28"><path d="M16 14c0-2.203-1.797-4-4-4s-4 1.797-4 4 1.797 4 4 4 4-1.797 4-4zm2.156 0c0 3.406-2.75 6.156-6.156 6.156S5.844 17.406 5.844 14 8.594 7.844 12 7.844s6.156 2.75 6.156 6.156zm1.688-6.406c0 .797-.641 1.437-1.437 1.437S16.97 8.39 16.97 7.594s.641-1.437 1.437-1.437 1.437.641 1.437 1.437zM12 4.156c-1.75 0-5.5-.141-7.078.484-.547.219-.953.484-1.375.906s-.688.828-.906 1.375c-.625 1.578-.484 5.328-.484 7.078s-.141 5.5.484 7.078c.219.547.484.953.906 1.375s.828.688 1.375.906c1.578.625 5.328.484 7.078.484s5.5.141 7.078-.484c.547-.219.953-.484 1.375-.906s.688-.828.906-1.375c.625-1.578.484-5.328.484-7.078s.141-5.5-.484-7.078c-.219-.547-.484-.953-.906-1.375s-.828-.688-1.375-.906C17.5 4.015 13.75 4.156 12 4.156zM24 14c0 1.656.016 3.297-.078 4.953-.094 1.922-.531 3.625-1.937 5.031s-3.109 1.844-5.031 1.937c-1.656.094-3.297.078-4.953.078s-3.297.016-4.953-.078c-1.922-.094-3.625-.531-5.031-1.937S.173 20.875.08 18.953C-.014 17.297.002 15.656.002 14s-.016-3.297.078-4.953c.094-1.922.531-3.625 1.937-5.031s3.109-1.844 5.031-1.937c1.656-.094 3.297-.078 4.953-.078s3.297-.016 4.953.078c1.922.094 3.625.531 5.031 1.937s1.844 3.109 1.937 5.031C24.016 10.703 24 12.344 24 14z"/></symbol><symbol id="link" viewBox="0 0 72 72"><path d="M67.6 25.5L55 38.1c-1.2 1.2-3.1 1.2-4.2 0s-1.2-3.1 0-4.2l12.7-12.7c3.5-3.5 3.5-9.2 0-12.7s-9.2-3.5-12.7 0l-16.9 17c-1 1.1-6 6.7 0 12.7 1.2 1.2 1.2 3.1 0 4.2s-3.1 1.2-4.2 0c-8.3-8.3-3.6-17.4 0-21.1L46.5 4.4c5.8-5.8 15.3-5.8 21.1 0s5.9 15.2 0 21.1zm-25.3 4.2c-1.2-1.2-3.1-1.2-4.2 0-1.2 1.2-1.2 3.1 0 4.2 6 6 1 11.6 0 12.7L21.2 63.4c-3.5 3.5-9.2 3.5-12.7 0s-3.5-9.2 0-12.7L21.2 38c1.2-1.2 1.2-3.1 0-4.2s-3.1-1.2-4.2 0L4.4 46.5c-5.8 5.8-5.8 15.3 0 21.1 5.8 5.8 15.3 5.8 21.1 0l16.9-16.9c3.6-3.6 8.3-12.7-.1-21z"/></symbol><symbol id="linkedin" viewBox="0 0 24 28"><path d="M5.453 9.766V25.25H.297V9.766h5.156zm.328-4.782c.016 1.484-1.109 2.672-2.906 2.672h-.031C1.11 7.656 0 6.468 0 4.984c0-1.516 1.156-2.672 2.906-2.672 1.766 0 2.859 1.156 2.875 2.672zM24 16.375v8.875h-5.141v-8.281c0-2.078-.75-3.5-2.609-3.5-1.422 0-2.266.953-2.641 1.875-.125.344-.172.797-.172 1.266v8.641H8.296c.063-14.031 0-15.484 0-15.484h5.141v2.25h-.031c.672-1.062 1.891-2.609 4.672-2.609 3.391 0 5.922 2.219 5.922 6.969z"/></symbol><symbol id="long-arrow-left" viewBox="0 0 29 28"><path d="M28 12.5v3c0 .281-.219.5-.5.5H8v3.5c0 .203-.109.375-.297.453s-.391.047-.547-.078l-6-5.469A.508.508 0 011 14.047c0-.141.063-.281.156-.375l6-5.531A.5.5 0 118 8.5V12h19.5c.281 0 .5.219.5.5z"/></symbol><symbol id="long-arrow-right" viewBox="0 0 27 28"><path d="M27 13.953a.549.549 0 01-.156.375l-6 5.531A.5.5 0 1120 19.5V16H.5a.494.494 0 01-.5-.5v-3c0-.281.219-.5.5-.5H20V8.5c0-.203.109-.375.297-.453s.391-.047.547.078l6 5.469a.508.508 0 01.156.359z"/></symbol><symbol id="reddit" viewBox="0 0 28 28"><path d="M17.109 18.234c.141.141.141.359 0 .484-.891.891-2.609.969-3.109.969s-2.219-.078-3.109-.969c-.141-.125-.141-.344 0-.484a.34.34 0 01.469 0c.562.578 1.781.766 2.641.766s2.063-.187 2.641-.766a.34.34 0 01.469 0zm-4.796-2.828c0 .766-.625 1.391-1.391 1.391a1.397 1.397 0 01-1.406-1.391A1.4 1.4 0 0110.922 14c.766 0 1.391.625 1.391 1.406zm6.171 0c0 .766-.625 1.391-1.406 1.391a1.394 1.394 0 01-1.391-1.391c0-.781.625-1.406 1.391-1.406a1.4 1.4 0 011.406 1.406zm3.922-1.875a1.867 1.867 0 00-1.875-1.859c-.531 0-1 .219-1.344.562-1.266-.875-2.969-1.437-4.859-1.5l.984-4.422 3.125.703c0 .766.625 1.391 1.391 1.391.781 0 1.406-.641 1.406-1.406s-.625-1.406-1.406-1.406a1.42 1.42 0 00-1.25.781l-3.453-.766c-.172-.047-.344.078-.391.25l-1.078 4.875c-1.875.078-3.563.641-4.828 1.516a1.877 1.877 0 00-1.359-.578 1.867 1.867 0 00-1.875 1.859c0 .75.438 1.375 1.062 1.687a4.024 4.024 0 00-.094.875c0 2.969 3.344 5.375 7.453 5.375 4.125 0 7.469-2.406 7.469-5.375 0-.297-.031-.609-.109-.891a1.878 1.878 0 001.031-1.672zM28 14c0 7.734-6.266 14-14 14S0 21.734 0 14 6.266 0 14 0s14 6.266 14 14z"/></symbol><symbol id="rss" viewBox="0 0 32 32"><path d="M4.259 23.467A4.265 4.265 0 000 27.719a4.25 4.25 0 004.259 4.244 4.25 4.25 0 004.265-4.244 4.265 4.265 0 00-4.265-4.252zM.005 10.873v6.133c3.993 0 7.749 1.562 10.577 4.391A14.897 14.897 0 0114.966 32h6.16c0-11.651-9.478-21.127-21.121-21.127zM.012 0v6.136C14.255 6.136 25.848 17.74 25.848 32H32C32 14.36 17.648 0 .012 0z"/></symbol><symbol id="search" viewBox="0 0 26 28"><path d="M18 13c0-3.859-3.141-7-7-7s-7 3.141-7 7 3.141 7 7 7 7-3.141 7-7zm8 13c0 1.094-.906 2-2 2a1.96 1.96 0 01-1.406-.594l-5.359-5.344a10.971 10.971 0 01-6.234 1.937c-6.078 0-11-4.922-11-11s4.922-11 11-11 11 4.922 11 11c0 2.219-.672 4.406-1.937 6.234l5.359 5.359c.359.359.578.875.578 1.406z"/></symbol><symbol id="sign-in" viewBox="0 0 24 28"><path d="M18.5 14a.99.99 0 01-.297.703l-8.5 8.5A.996.996 0 019 23.5c-.547 0-1-.453-1-1V18H1c-.547 0-1-.453-1-1v-6c0-.547.453-1 1-1h7V5.5c0-.547.453-1 1-1a.99.99 0 01.703.297l8.5 8.5A.996.996 0 0118.5 14zM24 8.5v11c0 2.484-2.016 4.5-4.5 4.5h-5a.514.514 0 01-.5-.5c0-.438-.203-1.5.5-1.5h5c1.375 0 2.5-1.125 2.5-2.5v-11C22 7.125 20.875 6 19.5 6H15c-.391 0-1 .078-1-.5 0-.438-.203-1.5.5-1.5h5C21.984 4 24 6.016 24 8.5z"/></symbol><symbol id="sign-out" viewBox="0 0 25 28"><path d="M10 22.5c0 .438.203 1.5-.5 1.5h-5A4.502 4.502 0 010 19.5v-11C0 6.016 2.016 4 4.5 4h5c.266 0 .5.234.5.5 0 .438.203 1.5-.5 1.5h-5A2.507 2.507 0 002 8.5v11C2 20.875 3.125 22 4.5 22H9c.391 0 1-.078 1 .5zM24.5 14a.99.99 0 01-.297.703l-8.5 8.5A.996.996 0 0115 23.5c-.547 0-1-.453-1-1V18H7c-.547 0-1-.453-1-1v-6c0-.547.453-1 1-1h7V5.5c0-.547.453-1 1-1a.99.99 0 01.703.297l8.5 8.5A.996.996 0 0124.5 14z"/></symbol><symbol id="twitter" viewBox="0 0 1200 1227"><path d="M714.163 519.284 1160.89 0h-105.86L667.137 450.887 357.328 0H0l468.492 681.821L0 1226.37h105.866l409.625-476.152 327.181 476.152H1200L714.137 519.284h.026ZM569.165 687.828l-47.468-67.894-377.686-540.24h162.604l304.797 435.991 47.468 67.894 396.2 566.721H892.476L569.165 687.854v-.026Z"/></symbol><symbol id="user" viewBox="0 0 20 28"><path d="M20 21.859C20 24.14 18.5 26 16.672 26H3.328C1.5 26 0 24.141 0 21.859 0 17.75 1.016 13 5.109 13a6.979 6.979 0 009.782 0C18.985 13 20 17.75 20 21.859zM16 8c0 3.313-2.688 6-6 6s-6-2.688-6-6 2.688-6 6-6 6 2.688 6 6z"/></symbol><symbol id="volume-up" viewBox="0 0 26 28"><path d="M12 5.5v17c0 .547-.453 1-1 1a.99.99 0 01-.703-.297L5.094 18H1c-.547 0-1-.453-1-1v-6c0-.547.453-1 1-1h4.094l5.203-5.203A.996.996 0 0111 4.5c.547 0 1 .453 1 1zm6 8.5c0 1.563-.953 3.078-2.422 3.672a.869.869 0 01-.391.078c-.547 0-1-.438-1-1 0-1.188 1.813-.859 1.813-2.75s-1.813-1.563-1.813-2.75c0-.562.453-1 1-1 .125 0 .266.016.391.078C17.047 10.906 18 12.437 18 14zm4 0c0 3.172-1.906 6.125-4.844 7.359a1.158 1.158 0 01-.391.078 1.01 1.01 0 01-1.016-1c0-.438.25-.734.609-.922.422-.219.812-.406 1.188-.688 1.547-1.125 2.453-2.922 2.453-4.828s-.906-3.703-2.453-4.828c-.375-.281-.766-.469-1.188-.688-.359-.187-.609-.484-.609-.922 0-.547.453-1 1-1 .141 0 .281.031.406.078 2.938 1.234 4.844 4.188 4.844 7.359zm4 0c0 4.797-2.859 9.141-7.266 11.031a1.172 1.172 0 01-.406.078c-.547 0-1-.453-1-1 0-.453.234-.703.609-.922.219-.125.469-.203.703-.328.438-.234.875-.5 1.281-.797 2.562-1.891 4.078-4.875 4.078-8.062s-1.516-6.172-4.078-8.062a11.006 11.006 0 00-1.281-.797c-.234-.125-.484-.203-.703-.328-.375-.219-.609-.469-.609-.922 0-.547.453-1 1-1 .141 0 .281.031.406.078A12.009 12.009 0 0126 14z"/></symbol><symbol id="your-texas" viewBox="0 0 500 500"><path d="M270.19 448.13l-79.76-143.39-66.32 42.04L15 211h127.16V23.6h114.9v96.95l195.47 19.06L485 259.33l-11.46 53.57-124.58 87.57 9.54 75.93z"/></symbol><symbol id="youtube" viewBox="0 0 24 28"><path d="M15.172 19.437v3.297c0 .703-.203 1.047-.609 1.047-.234 0-.469-.109-.703-.344v-4.703c.234-.234.469-.344.703-.344.406 0 .609.359.609 1.047zm5.281.016v.719h-1.406v-.719c0-.703.234-1.062.703-1.062s.703.359.703 1.062zM5.359 16.047h1.672v-1.469H2.156v1.469h1.641v8.891H5.36v-8.891zm4.5 8.891h1.391v-7.719H9.859v5.906c-.313.438-.609.656-.891.656-.187 0-.297-.109-.328-.328-.016-.047-.016-.219-.016-.547v-5.688H7.233v6.109c0 .547.047.906.125 1.141.125.391.453.578.906.578.5 0 1.031-.313 1.594-.953v.844zm6.703-2.313v-3.078c0-.719-.031-1.234-.141-1.547-.172-.578-.562-.875-1.109-.875-.516 0-1 .281-1.453.844v-3.391h-1.391v10.359h1.391v-.75c.469.578.953.859 1.453.859.547 0 .938-.297 1.109-.859.109-.328.141-.844.141-1.563zm5.282-.156v-.203h-1.422c0 .562-.016.875-.031.953-.078.375-.281.562-.625.562-.484 0-.719-.359-.719-1.078v-1.359h2.797v-1.609c0-.828-.141-1.422-.422-1.813-.406-.531-.953-.797-1.656-.797-.719 0-1.266.266-1.672.797-.297.391-.438.984-.438 1.813v2.703c0 .828.156 1.437.453 1.813.406.531.953.797 1.687.797s1.313-.281 1.687-.828a1.8 1.8 0 00.328-.844c.031-.141.031-.453.031-.906zm-9.5-14.266V4.922c0-.719-.203-1.078-.672-1.078-.453 0-.672.359-.672 1.078v3.281c0 .719.219 1.094.672 1.094.469 0 .672-.375.672-1.094zm11.234 11.735c0 1.797-.016 3.719-.406 5.469-.297 1.234-1.297 2.141-2.5 2.266-2.875.328-5.781.328-8.672.328s-5.797 0-8.672-.328c-1.203-.125-2.219-1.031-2.5-2.266-.406-1.75-.406-3.672-.406-5.469 0-1.813.016-3.719.406-5.469.297-1.234 1.297-2.141 2.516-2.281 2.859-.313 5.766-.313 8.656-.313s5.797 0 8.672.313c1.203.141 2.219 1.047 2.5 2.281.406 1.75.406 3.656.406 5.469zM7.984 0h1.594L7.687 6.234v4.234H6.124V6.234c-.141-.766-.453-1.859-.953-3.313-.344-.969-.688-1.953-1.016-2.922h1.656L6.92 4.108zm5.782 5.203v2.734c0 .828-.141 1.453-.438 1.844-.391.531-.938.797-1.656.797-.703 0-1.25-.266-1.641-.797-.297-.406-.438-1.016-.438-1.844V5.203c0-.828.141-1.437.438-1.828.391-.531.938-.797 1.641-.797.719 0 1.266.266 1.656.797.297.391.438 1 .438 1.828zM19 2.672v7.797h-1.422V9.61c-.562.656-1.094.969-1.609.969-.453 0-.781-.187-.922-.578-.078-.234-.125-.609-.125-1.172V2.673h1.422v5.734c0 .328 0 .516.016.547.031.219.141.344.328.344.281 0 .578-.219.891-.672V2.673h1.422z"/></symbol></svg> </div> <div style="display:none;"> <svg><symbol id="arrow-right" viewBox="0 0 14 13"><path d="M13.0043 6.79589L7.0778 12.7393L5.51837 11.1799L8.56281 8.15912H0.339447V5.43266H8.57296L5.52852 2.42881L7.0778 0.869385L13.0043 6.79589Z"/></symbol><symbol id="close-thin" viewBox="0 0 14 15"><path stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" d="M13 1.5L1 13.5M13 13.5L1.00001 1.5"/></symbol><symbol id="plus" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M24 10h-10v-10h-4v10h-10v4h10v10h4v-10h10z"/></symbol><symbol id="tick-in-circle" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M12 0c-6.627 0-12 5.373-12 12s5.373 12 12 12 12-5.373 12-12-5.373-12-12-12zm-1.959 17l-4.5-4.319 1.395-1.435 3.08 2.937 7.021-7.183 1.422 1.409-8.418 8.591z"/></symbol><symbol id="tick" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M9 22l-10-10.598 2.798-2.859 7.149 7.473 13.144-14.016 2.909 2.806z"/></symbol></svg> </div> <nav class="c-navbar c-navbar--dark has-bg-black-off" aria-label="sitewide"> <div class="c-navbar__top l-align-center-x c-navbar__top--standard"> <a href="/" class="c-navbar__logo l-align-center-self" aria-label="The Texas Tribune Homepage"> <svg aria-hidden="true" xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg' viewBox='0 0 585.7 64.51' class="l-display-block l-width-full"><path fill="#fff" d='M84.94 10.23v45.85H74.63V10.23H64.49V1.16H95v9.07zM120.08 56.08V33.57h-11.46v22.51H98.39V1.16h10.23v23.25h11.46V1.16h10.31v54.92zM136.78 56.08V1.16H163V10h-16v13.59h11.05v8.08H147v15.26h16v9.15zM198.62 10.23v45.85h-10.31V10.23h-10.14V1.16h30.51v9.07zM213.1 56.08V1.16h26.23V10h-16v13.59h11v8.08h-11v15.26h16v9.15zM265.89 56.08l-6.44-19-7 19h-10l11.29-27.71-10.62-27.21h10.73l6 19 6.59-19h10.07l-11 26.39 11.05 28.53zM301.7 56.08l-1.81-10.8h-9.73l-2 10.8h-9.57l11.07-54.92h11.47l11 54.92zM295.27 16l-3.71 21.2h7zM328.66 57.32c-9.4 0-15.25-5.61-15.25-14.19v-3.79h9.4v3.22c0 4 1.9 6.26 5.61 6.26s5.44-2.14 5.44-5.52c0-4.37-2.8-7.34-8.25-11.38-5.6-4-11.71-9.49-11.71-17.15C313.9 6.85 319 0 328.91 0c8.66 0 14.43 5.94 14.43 14.1v3.55H334v-3.3c0-3.38-1.72-5.85-5.19-5.85a4.63 4.63 0 0 0-4.95 4.94c0 4.62 2.72 7 8.82 11.47 6.52 4.86 11.14 9.81 11.14 17.23.02 8.86-6.08 15.18-15.16 15.18zM377.84 10.23v45.85h-10.31V10.23h-10.15V1.16h30.52v9.07zM417.57 56.41c-4.05 0-5.61-3.3-5.61-8.08V38c0-2.56-1.32-4.7-4.21-4.7h-5.36v22.78h-10.22V1.16h16.9c7.51 0 12.54 4.29 12.54 12v7.76c0 4.12-1.9 7.17-6.19 8.49a8.42 8.42 0 0 1 6.35 8.33v10.01a7.69 7.69 0 0 0 2 5.61v3zm-5.94-42.88c0-2.48-1.07-4-3.63-4h-5.61v16.2h5.2c2.64 0 4-1.4 4-4.37zM429.8 56.08V1.16H440v54.92zM465.59 56.08h-17.32V1.16h17.16c7.5 0 12.12 4 12.12 11.62v5.94c0 4.7-1.81 8.25-6.51 9.24 4.95 1.32 6.76 4.7 6.76 9.32v7.17c0 7.67-4.7 11.63-12.21 11.63zm2.15-42.55c0-2.48-1.08-4-3.63-4h-5.53v15.13h5.12c2.63 0 4-1.4 4-4.29zm.16 23c0-2.89-1.4-4.37-4-4.37h-5.28v15.5h5.78c2.55 0 3.54-1.4 3.54-4zM499.34 57.32c-8.9 0-15.5-5.69-15.5-13.94V1.16h10.39v42.22c0 3.22 1.81 5 5.11 5s5.2-1.81 5.2-5V1.16h10v42.22c-.02 8.25-6.29 13.94-15.2 13.94zM544.66 56.08L534 32.66l-3.87-8.74v32.16h-9.4V1.16h8.82L539.71 25l3.63 8.74V1.16h9.24v54.92zM559.48 56.08V1.16h26.22V10h-16v13.59h11v8.08h-11v15.26h16v9.15z'/><path d='M0 .6v63.91l12.85-8h43V.6zm40 44.63l-12.22-8.06-12.24 8.06 3.88-14.13L8 22l14.63-.68 5.15-13.76L33 21.27l14.58.73-11.44 9.1z' fill='#ffc200'/></svg> </a> <div class="c-navbar__content "> <ul class="c-navbar__items t-uppercase t-size-xxs hide_until--l is-hidden-until-bp-l js-toggle-on-search "> <li class="c-navbar__item"> <a class="c-navbar__item-content c-navbar__clickable c-navbar__clickable--animated " href="/series/investigations/" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="investigations">Investigations</a> </li> <li class="c-navbar__item"> <a class="c-navbar__item-content c-navbar__clickable c-navbar__clickable--animated " href="/series/guides/" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="guides">Guides</a> </li> <li class="c-navbar__item"> <a class="c-navbar__item-content c-navbar__clickable c-navbar__clickable--animated " href="/newsletters/" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="subscribe intent" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="not frontpage">Newsletters</a> </li> <li class="c-navbar__item"> <a class="c-navbar__item-content c-navbar__clickable c-navbar__clickable--animated " href="/events/" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="events">Events</a> </li> <li class="c-navbar__item"> <a class="c-navbar__item-content c-navbar__clickable c-navbar__clickable--animated " href="/series/news-apps-graphics-databases/" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="data">Data</a> </li> </ul> <ul class="c-navbar__items c-navbar__items--no-space js-toggle-on-search hide_until--l is-hidden-until-bp-l"> <li class="c-navbar__item"> <a id="nav-donate-sidekick" class="t-uppercase t-size-xxs c-navbar__item-content c-navbar__clickable c-navbar__clickable--animated " href="/about/?utm_medium=top-nav-about" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="about">About</a> </li> <li class="c-navbar__item"> <a id="nav-donate" class="t-uppercase t-size-xxs c-navbar__item-content c-navbar__clickable" href="https://support.texastribune.org/donate?installmentPeriod=yearly&amount=200&campaignId=7016f000002Gv2vAAC" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="donations" ga-event-action="membership-intent" ga-event-label="c-navbar"><span class="has-text-black c-button c-button--s has-bg-yellow t-links-unset">Donate</span></a> </li> <li class="c-navbar__item"> <button id="nav-search-open" class="c-navbar__item-content c-navbar__clickable" aria-label="Show site search form" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="search-open"> <span class="c-icon t-size-s"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#search"></use></svg></span> </button> </li> </ul> <ul class="c-navbar__items t-size-xxs hide_from--l is-hidden-from-bp-l"> <li id="nav-menu-open" class="c-navbar__item c-navbar__item--no-space"> <button class="c-navbar__item-content c-navbar__text c-navbar__clickable has-text-gray-light t-uppercase" aria-label="Show menu" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="menu-open"> <span class="c-icon c-icon--yellow t-size-s"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#bars"></use></svg></span> <span> Menu</span> </button> </li> <li id="nav-menu-close" class="c-navbar__item hidden"> <button class="c-navbar__item-content c-navbar__text c-navbar__clickable has-text-gray-light t-uppercase" aria-label="Hide menu" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="menu-close"> <span class="c-icon c-icon--yellow t-size-s"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#close"></use></svg></span> <span> Close</span> </button> </li> </ul> </div> <div id="nav-search-form" class="c-navbar__search hidden hide_until--l is-hidden-until-bp-l"> <form class="c-navbar__search-form" method="get" action="/search/"> <button class="c-navbar__search-button c-navbar__clickable" type="submit" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="search-submit"> <span class="c-icon t-size-s"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#search"></use></svg></span> </button> <input class="js-search-input c-navbar__search-input" name="q" type="text" placeholder="Search The Texas Tribune" aria-label="Search The Texas Tribune"> <button id="nav-search-close" class="c-navbar__clickable" type="button" aria-label="Close site search form" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="search-close"> <span class="c-icon t-size-s"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#close"></use></svg></span> </button> </form> </div> </div> <div id="nav-dropdown" class="c-navbar__dropdown hide_from--l is-hidden-from-bp-l hidden"> <div class="c-navbar__dropdown-search grid_separator has-b-btm-marg l-width-full"> <form class="c-navbar__search-form" method="get" action="/search/"> <button class="c-navbar__search-button c-navbar__clickable" type="submit" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="search-submit"> <span class="c-icon t-size-s"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#search"></use></svg></span> </button> <input class="js-search-input c-navbar__search-input" name="q" type="text" placeholder="Search The Texas Tribune" aria-label="Search The Texas Tribune"> </form> </div> <ul class="c-navbar__dropdown-items t-uppercase t-size-xxs"> <li class="c-navbar__dropdown-item"> <a class="c-navbar__clickable" href="https://support.texastribune.org/donate?installmentPeriod=yearly&amount=200&campaignId=7016f000002Gv2vAAC" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="donations" ga-event-action="membership-intent" ga-event-label="c-navbar"><span class="has-text-yellow">Donate</span></a> </li> <li class="c-navbar__dropdown-item"> <a class="c-navbar__clickable c-navbar__clickable--animated " href="/about/?utm_medium=top-nav-about" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="about">About</a> </li> <li class="c-navbar__dropdown-item"> <a class="c-navbar__clickable" href="/series/investigations/" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="investigations">Investigations</a> </li> <li class="c-navbar__dropdown-item"> <a class="c-navbar__clickable" href="/series/guides/" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="guides">Guides</a> </li> <li class="c-navbar__dropdown-item"> <a class="c-navbar__clickable " href="/newsletters/" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="subscribe intent" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="not frontpage">Newsletters</a> </li> <li class="c-navbar__dropdown-item"> <a class="c-navbar__clickable " href="/events/" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="events">Events</a> </li> <li class="c-navbar__dropdown-item"> <a class="c-navbar__clickable " href="/series/news-apps-graphics-databases/" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="top nav click" ga-event-label="data">Data</a> </li> </ul> <ul id="mobile-greeting" class="c-navbar__dropdown-items t-uppercase t-size-xxs"></ul> </div> </nav> <script> (function() { function bindSearchOpen(elements) { var searchOpen = elements.searchOpen; var searchForm = elements.searchForm; var searchInput = elements.searchInput; var toggleOnSearch = elements.toggleOnSearch; searchOpen.addEventListener('click', function () { searchForm.classList.remove('hidden'); toggleOnSearch.forEach(function (el) { el.classList.add('hidden'); searchInput.focus(); }); }); } function bindSearchClose(elements) { var searchClose = elements.searchClose; var searchForm = elements.searchForm; var toggleOnSearch = elements.toggleOnSearch; searchClose.addEventListener('click', function () { searchForm.classList.add('hidden'); toggleOnSearch.forEach(function (el) { el.classList.remove('hidden'); }); }); } function bindMenuOpen(elements) { var menuOpen = elements.menuOpen; var menuClose = elements.menuClose; var dropdown = elements.dropdown; menuOpen.addEventListener('click', function () { menuOpen.classList.add('hidden'); menuClose.classList.remove('hidden'); dropdown.classList.remove('hidden'); }); } function bindMenuClose(elements) { var menuOpen = elements.menuOpen; var menuClose = elements.menuClose; var dropdown = elements.dropdown; menuClose.addEventListener('click', function () { menuOpen.classList.remove('hidden'); menuClose.classList.add('hidden'); dropdown.classList.add('hidden'); }); } function getElements() { var toggleOnSearch = document.querySelectorAll('.js-toggle-on-search'); var menuOpen = document.querySelector('#nav-menu-open'); var menuClose = document.querySelector('#nav-menu-close'); var searchForm = document.querySelector('#nav-search-form'); var searchInput = document.querySelector('.js-search-input'); var searchOpen = document.querySelector('#nav-search-open'); var searchClose = document.querySelector('#nav-search-close'); var dropdown = document.querySelector('#nav-dropdown'); return { toggleOnSearch: toggleOnSearch, menuOpen: menuOpen, menuClose: menuClose, searchForm: searchForm, searchInput: searchInput, searchOpen: searchOpen, searchClose: searchClose, dropdown: dropdown }; } function bindNavEvents() { const elements = getElements(); bindSearchOpen(elements); bindSearchClose(elements); bindMenuOpen(elements); bindMenuClose(elements); } bindNavEvents(); }()); </script> <aside class="c-topic-bar c-topic-bar--btm-border c-topic-bar--sticky t-links-underlined-hover t-size-xs t-align-center has-bg-white" aria-labelledby="topic-bar-label" data-test-name="topicbar"> <h2 id="topic-bar-label" class="is-sr-only">Key coverage</h2> <div class="c-topic-bar__inner"> <div class="flatblock block-homepage-topic-bar"> <div class="flatblock-content"><ul> <li> <a href="https://support.texastribune.org/donate?installmentPeriod=yearly&amount=200&campaignId=7016f000002GvB9AAK" class="c-button c-button--s has-bg-yellow t-links-unset">Donate</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://www.texastribune.org/2025/02/19/university-texas-austin-jim-davis/">UT-Austin President</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://www.texastribune.org/2025/02/17/texas-undocumented-immigrants-trump-deportation-demographics/">Undocumented Texans</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://www.texastribune.org/2025/02/18/texas-measles-outbreak-climbs/">Measles Outbreak</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://www.texastribune.org/2025/02/18/texas-senate-teacher-pay/">Teacher Raises</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://www.texastribune.org/series/texas-legislature-2025/">2025 Legislative Session</a> </li> </ul></div> </div> </div> </aside> <div class="has-l-btm-marg" aria-hidden="true"></div> <div class="has-xl-btm-marg is-hidden-print"> <div id="ad-unit-8989" class="js-ad-unit t-align-center"> <div class="c-ad-ldbd"> <div class="c-ad-ldbd__unit"></div> </div> </div> </div> <main id="main-tt-content" class="has-xxxl-btm-marg"> <article>  <section class="l-container l-container--l"> <header class="has-page-padding has-s-btm-marg"> <div id="article-hed-byline" class="t-links">  <h1 itemprop="headline" class="t-headline t-serif t-lh-s has-b-btm-marg">How some Texas parents and historians say a new state curriculum glosses over slavery and racism</h1>  <div class="has-notch is-hidden-from-bp-s has-b-btm-marg has-bg-yellow"></div> <p class="has-s-btm-marg has-vert-bar has-vert-bar--from-bp-s t-size-b has-text-yellow"> <span class="has-text-gray-dark">Education officials say the materials were designed to be age appropriate but critics argue they repeatedly omit key context and oversimplify history.</span> </p>   <div class="c-details l-flex t-size-xs t-uppercase t-lsp-m t-lh-b has-text-black-off has-text-vert-padding has-s-btm-marg">  <div>By <a href="/about/staff/jaden-edison/">Jaden Edison</a></div> <div class="c-details__wrapper l-flex l-align-end-self">  <time class="byline--item t-byline__item l-display-ib" datetime="Mon, 18 Nov 2024 05:00:00 -0600" title="2024-11-18 05:00 CST">Nov. 18, 2024</time><time class="byline--item t-byline__item l-display-ib" datetime="Mon, 18 Nov 2024 05:00:00 -0600" title="2024-11-18 05:00 CST">5 AM Central</time>  <div class="c-details__spacer"></div>  <div class="c-details__social-share"> <details class="c-social-share"> <summary class="c-social-share__btn" id="native-share"> <span class="c-details__icon-link t-weight-bold has-text-hover-teal" ga-event-category="social-share" ga-event-action="share-intent">Share</span> </summary> <ul class="c-social-share__dropdown has-border t-titlecase has-text-gray-dark"> <li><a class="t-links-unset l-flex t-weight-bold has-text-hover-teal" href="https://www.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/?utm_campaign=trib-social-buttons&utm_source=copy&utm_medium=social" ga-event-category="social-share" ga-event-action="copy-url-intent" aria-label="Copy URL" id="copy-url"><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#link"></use></svg></span> <span id="copy-url-text">Copy URL</span></a></li> <li class="is-hidden-from-bp-l"> <a class="t-links-unset l-flex t-weight-bold has-text-hover-teal" href="/republish?article=/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/" ga-event-category="Republish" ga-event-action="republish-intent" aria-label="Republish this story"> <span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline"> <svg width="21" height="20" viewBox="0 0 21 20" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="M10.94 2.11L17.1001 2.13L0.7 18.53L2.17 20L18.5701 3.6L18.5901 9.76L20.68 9.74V0L18.25 0.00999999H10.9501L10.94 2.11Z"/></svg> </span> Republish </a> </li> <li><a class="t-links-unset l-flex t-weight-bold has-text-hover-teal" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/%3Futm_campaign%3Dtrib-social-buttons%26utm_source%3Dtwitter%26utm_medium%3Dsocial&text=How%20some%20Texas%20parents%20and%20historians%20say%20a%20new%20state%20curriculum%20glosses%20over%20slavery%20and%20racism&via=TexasTribune" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" ga-event-category="social-share" ga-event-action="twitter-intent" aria-label="Share on Twitter"><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#twitter"></use></svg></span> Twitter</a></li> <li> <a class="t-links-unset l-flex t-weight-bold has-text-hover-teal" href="https://bsky.app/intent/compose?text=How%20some%20Texas%20parents%20and%20historians%20say%20a%20new%20state%20curriculum%20glosses%20over%20slavery%20and%20racism https%3A%2F%2Fwww.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/%3Futm_campaign%3Dtrib-social-buttons%26utm_source%3Dbluesky%26utm_medium%3Dsocial via @texastribune.org" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" ga-event-category="social-share" ga-event-action="bluesky-intent" aria-label="Share on Bluesky"> <span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline"> <svg fill="none" viewBox="0 0 64 57"><path d="M13.873 3.805C21.21 9.332 29.103 20.537 32 26.55v15.882c0-.338-.13.044-.41.867-1.512 4.456-7.418 21.847-20.923 7.944-7.111-7.32-3.819-14.64 9.125-16.85-7.405 1.264-15.73-.825-18.014-9.015C1.12 23.022 0 8.51 0 6.55 0-3.268 8.579-.182 13.873 3.805ZM50.127 3.805C42.79 9.332 34.897 20.537 32 26.55v15.882c0-.338.13.044.41.867 1.512 4.456 7.418 21.847 20.923 7.944 7.111-7.32 3.819-14.64-9.125-16.85 7.405 1.264 15.73-.825 18.014-9.015C62.88 23.022 64 8.51 64 6.55c0-9.818-8.578-6.732-13.873-2.745Z"></path></svg> </span> Bluesky </a> </li> <li><a class="t-links-unset l-flex t-weight-bold has-text-hover-teal" href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/%3Futm_campaign%3Dtrib-social-buttons%26utm_source%3Dfacebook%26utm_medium%3Dsocial" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" ga-event-category="social-share" ga-event-action="facebook-intent" aria-label="Share on Facebook"><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#facebook"></use></svg></span> Facebook</a></li> <li><a class="t-links-unset l-flex t-weight-bold has-text-hover-teal" href="https://www.reddit.com/submit?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/%3Futm_campaign%3Dtrib-social-buttons%26utm_source%3Dreddit%26utm_medium%3Dsocial&title=How%20some%20Texas%20parents%20and%20historians%20say%20a%20new%20state%20curriculum%20glosses%20over%20slavery%20and%20racism" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" ga-event-category="social-share" ga-event-action="reddit-intent" aria-label="Share on Reddit"><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#reddit"></use></svg></span> Reddit</a></li> <li><a class="t-links-unset l-flex t-weight-bold has-text-hover-teal" href="https://www.linkedin.com/sharing/share-offsite/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/%3Futm_campaign%3Dtrib-social-buttons%26utm_source%3Dlinkedin%26utm_medium%3Dsocial&title=How%20some%20Texas%20parents%20and%20historians%20say%20a%20new%20state%20curriculum%20glosses%20over%20slavery%20and%20racism" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" ga-event-category="social-share" ga-event-action="linkedin-intent" aria-label="Share on LinkedIn"><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#linkedin"></use></svg></span> LinkedIn</a></li> <li><a class="t-links-unset l-flex t-weight-bold has-text-hover-teal" href="mailto:?subject=How%20some%20Texas%20parents%20and%20historians%20say%20a%20new%20state%20curriculum%20glosses%20over%20slavery%20and%20racism&body=https://www.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/%3Futm_campaign%3Dtrib-social-buttons%26utm_source%3Demail%26utm_medium%3Dsocial" ga-event-category="social-share" ga-event-action="email-intent" aria-label="Share this story by email"><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#envelope"></use></svg></span> Email</a></li> </ul> </details> </div>  <a href="/republish?article=/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/" class="c-details__icon-link c-details__icon-link--spaced t-weight-bold t-links-unset has-text-hover-teal is-hidden-until-bp-l" ga-event-category="Republish" ga-event-action="republish-intent" aria-label="Republish this story"> Republish <span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline"> <svg width="21" height="20" viewBox="0 0 21 20" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="M10.94 2.11L17.1001 2.13L0.7 18.53L2.17 20L18.5701 3.6L18.5901 9.76L20.68 9.74V0L18.25 0.00999999H10.9501L10.94 2.11Z"/></svg> </span> </a> </div> </div> </div> </header> </section> <div class="l-container l-container--l has-page-padding-at-bp-l has-xl-btm-marg is-hidden-print"> <figure class="l-pos-rel"> <div class="c-image"> <div class="c-image__placeholder has-bg-white-off"> <picture> <source sizes="(min-width: 845px) 845px, 100vw" srcset="https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/M99JmTtGoYjUCnrneHYqDdcFAUI=/3000x2010/smart/filters:format(webp):quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 3000w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/4vTA7nekFS3g0dJYHTUURI02p3s=/2500x1675/smart/filters:format(webp):quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 2500w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/ZXbIQTMbSt6wm4ia_ptnkVVv46w=/1550x1038/smart/filters:format(webp):quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 1550w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/pcbPaJAR_wSojyrmPDy0dKDD_tI=/1200x804/smart/filters:format(webp):quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 1200w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/jNiWbgtlSX6yH5Kx0vGNNweCSQo=/1000x670/smart/filters:format(webp):quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 1000w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/b_top4ir0fKesFQaZ91xmXk_Nac=/850x570/smart/filters:format(webp):quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 850w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/TSEyAO-vVwo8DjqBDUzoOzg0ekM=/640x429/smart/filters:format(webp):quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 640w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/ysjSz7rKbLWjuU051Oce1mD6a5U=/375x251/smart/filters:format(webp):quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 375w" type="image/webp"> <source sizes="(min-width: 845px) 845px, 100vw" srcset="https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/fIxaMm_z1vYZ5Bdiad94_5xhmzc=/3000x2010/smart/filters:quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 3000w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/hzgBpWr03OgRef9rC2wIdoK8vhE=/2500x1675/smart/filters:quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 2500w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/ouKWGQBcuptyayNOPENB4pgdX_c=/1550x1038/smart/filters:quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 1550w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/Py5YC_qeIx6XHe1ZWDGEucZOp5Q=/1200x804/smart/filters:quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 1200w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/8DiIKE2ZDTRMtEmiiIVG_u7mmrA=/1000x670/smart/filters:quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 1000w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/U3rA4cgB5wCUizH8UdjsogOGcbw=/850x570/smart/filters:quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 850w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/1tg80Bck5EPkqMnCsBcv_asXSyk=/640x429/smart/filters:quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 640w, https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/QvnJEtF26DDML9UuQbG-qFYMPD8=/375x251/smart/filters:quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg 375w"> <img src="https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/U3rA4cgB5wCUizH8UdjsogOGcbw=/850x570/smart/filters:quality(75)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/files/0b3381e6c62589897a51cae1aa839e60/Laredo%20History%20TEKS%20RZ%20TT%2022.jpg" alt="A U.S. History classroom at Akins High School in Austin, on October 2018." class="did-load c-image__img"> </picture> </div> </div> <figcaption class="c-caption t-links-underlined l-display-block t-size-xs"> <span> Texas parents and historians say a new state curriculum's lessons on the country's history of slavery, racism and civil rights omit key context. The teaching materials are currently under review. </span> <cite> <span class="is-sr-only">Credit:</span><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#camera"></use></svg></span> Rachel Zein for The Texas Tribune </cite> </figcaption> </figure> </div>  <div class="story_body c-story-body t-size-b has-giant-btm-marg"> <div class="c-story-body"> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--default c-plugin--narrow is-hidden-print c-plugin--seamless"> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <figure> <iframe title="Article narration" style="width: 100%; height: 100px; border: none; display: none;" data-project-id="kJdMwATp9zKnrhK0cHGq" allowfullscreen="false" allowtransparency allow="clipboard-read; clipboard-write" frameborder="0" id="ad-auris-iframe" scrolling="no"></iframe> <figcaption class="has-text-gray-dark t-links-underlined t-size-xs" aria-hidden="true">Audio recording is automated for accessibility. Humans wrote and edited the story. See our <a href="https://www.texastribune.org/about/ethics/#ai-policy" tabindex="-1">AI policy</a>, and give us <a href="https://airtable.com/appFeleeKVUN0Iytx/pagPG40gbkU0EfjIr/form?prefill_Where+did+you+view+the+content%3F=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/" tabindex="-1">feedback</a>.</figcaption> </figure> </div> </div> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left"><em><a href="https://www.texastribune.org/newsletters/the-brief/?utm_medium=website&utm_source=trib-ads-owned&utm_campaign=trib-marketing&utm_term=inline-CTA-brief">Sign up for The Brief</a>, The Texas Tribune’s daily newsletter that keeps readers up to speed on the most essential Texas news.</em> </p> <hr class="t-copy has-xxl-vert-marg"> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">A new Texas curriculum seeks to captivate first-grade students with a lesson on Monticello, Thomas Jefferson’s historic estate long revered for its French neoclassical architecture and as a symbol of the founding father’s genius.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">The lesson teaches about the Virginia property’s pulley system that opened doors, the mechanical clock that kept track of the days and the dumbwaiter that transported dinner from the kitchen to the dining room.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">However, if the State Board of Education approves the curriculum when it meets this week, children could miss out on a more crucial aspect of Monticello’s history: It was built using the labor of enslaved people and occupied by hundreds of humans whom Jefferson enslaved.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Since it was proposed by the Texas Education Agency earlier this year, the elementary school reading and language arts curriculum has faced<a href="https://www.texastribune.org/2024/07/19/texas-christianity-school-curriculum-worries/"> strong opposition</a> from parents, advocates and faith leaders for its heavy use of biblical teachings, which critics say could lead to the bullying and isolation of non-Christian students, undermine church-state separation and grant the state far-reaching control over how children learn about religion.</p> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--flush "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div id="ad-unit-8172" class="js-ad-unit"> <div class="c-ad-flex"> <div class="c-ad-flex__inner"> <div class="c-ad-flex__unit"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">But less attention has been given to how the curriculum teaches America’s history of racism, slavery and civil rights.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Some parents, academics and concerned Texans argue that the lessons strip key historical figures of their complexities and flaws while omitting certain context they say would offer children a more accurate understanding of America’s past and present.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">A Texas Tribune analysis of the <a href="https://tea.texas.gov/state-board-of-education/imra/imra-2024-public-error-reports.pdf">public input</a> Texans have provided to the Texas Education Agency as feedback to the curriculum and its sections on American history raises questions about why certain historical information was excluded and the impact the omissions could have on elementary school kids’ education.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">“The lack of specificity is striking,” said Julia Brookins, senior program analyst of teaching and learning for the American Historical Association with whom the Tribune shared several of the curriculum’s excerpts.</p> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--seamless c-plugin--flush "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div class="c-prompt c-prompt--box c-prompt--livestream" onclick="event.stopPropagation();"> <div class="c-prompt__content t-align-center"> <img class="c-prompt__img" src="https://static.texastribune.org/media/prompts/promo-brief-logo.png" alt="Logo for The Brief newsletter."/> <div class="c-prompt__txt t-size-b t-lsp-s t-lh-m">The most important Texas news,<br />sent weekday mornings.</div> <div class="c-prompt__newsletter" id="newsletter-subscribe-8666"> <div class="loading loading--s c-loading c-loading--s" aria-hidden="true"></div> </div> <p class="t-size-xxs c-prompt__disclosure">This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google <a class="t-links-unset" href="https://policies.google.com/privacy">Privacy Policy</a> and <a class="t-links-unset" href="https://policies.google.com/terms">Terms of Service</a> apply.</p> </div> </div> </div> </div> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">A kindergarten lesson titled “Our Great Country,” for example, instructs teachers to tell students that founding fathers like George Washington and Thomas Jefferson “realized that slavery was wrong and founded the country so that Americans could be free.” The passage omits the fact that many of them enslaved people.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">A second grade lesson called “Fighting for a Cause” notes that “slavery was wrong, but it was practiced in most nations throughout history.” It does not detail the race-based nature of slavery in America that made it distinct from other parts of the world.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Another second grade lesson covering the U.S. Civil War focuses heavily on Robert E. Lee’s “excellent abilities” as general of the Confederate Army, which fought to maintain slavery, and his desire to find “a peaceful way to end the disagreement” with the North. It does not teach that Lee <a href="https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Gazetteer/People/Robert_E_Lee/FREREL/4/21*.html">enslaved people or highlight his racist views</a> that Black people were neither intelligent nor qualified to hold political power.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">A lesson on Martin Luther King Jr. mostly emphasizes his nonviolent advocacy without acknowledging his <a href="https://www.gphistorical.org/mlk/mlkspeech/">swift criticism and recognition of the conditions</a> that pushed people to violence or his belief that “large segments of white society” were more concerned about “tranquility and the status quo than about justice and humanity,” according to one of his speeches.</p> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--flush "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div id="ad-unit-1992" class="js-ad-unit"> <div class="c-ad-flex"> <div class="c-ad-flex__inner"> <div class="c-ad-flex__unit"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Moreover, a fifth grade lesson on World War II describes how Nazi Germany’s Nuremberg laws “were created to dehumanize and target Jewish people.” But it does not teach how those laws <a href="https://www.history.com/news/how-the-nazis-were-inspired-by-jim-crow">drew inspiration</a> from Jim Crow and the dehumanization of Black people in America.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Texas school districts have the freedom to choose their own lesson plans. If the state-authored curriculum receives approval this week, the choice to adopt the materials will remain with districts. But the state will offer an incentive of $60 per student to districts that choose to adopt the lessons, which could appeal to some as schools struggle financially after several years without a significant raise in state funding.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">The Texas Education Agency has told the Tribune that many of the curriculum’s historical references are meant to build “a strong foundation for students to understand the more complex concepts” as they get older.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">The curriculum was designed with a cross-disciplinary approach that uses reading and language arts lessons to advance or cement concepts in other disciplines, such as history and social studies. While the curriculum makes it clear that the state does not intend for these materials to replace grade-level social studies instruction, it also states that certain specifics about American history are necessary “so that students can understand and retell the story of our nation’s birth.”</p> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--flush "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div id="ad-unit-2085" class="js-ad-unit"> <div class="c-ad-flex"> <div class="c-ad-flex__inner"> <div class="c-ad-flex__unit"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">In response to concerns Texans shared through public input about vague and inaccurate historical references, the Texas Education Agency made minor revisions to certain texts but largely defended its choices by saying that “the content in these instructional materials is written in an age-appropriate and suitable manner.”</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Several of the nearly a dozen parents, historians and educators whom the Tribune interviewed about the curriculum agree that age appropriateness is an important factor to consider when teaching history.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Teaching elementary school kids about slavery in a meaningful way “can build on children’s instincts and help students apply them to their classrooms, communities and study of the United States,” according to Learning for Justice, a community education program of the Southern Poverty Law Center, which created <a href="https://www.learningforjustice.org/sites/default/files/2023-04/LFJ-Quick-Reference-Guide-Teaching-Hard-History-K-12-Framework-WEB-April2023-04202023.pdf">a guide </a>for history teachers.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Rather than poring over the gruesome details of the Transatlantic Slave Trade, for instance, the organization recommends intentionally building instruction “that prepares students to understand the long, multidimensional history of slavery and its enduring consequences,” similar to how math instructors teach the basics of addition and subtraction long before students learn algebra.</p> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--flush "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div id="ad-unit-9149" class="js-ad-unit"> <div class="c-ad-flex"> <div class="c-ad-flex__inner"> <div class="c-ad-flex__unit"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">That includes teaching that many of the founding fathers enslaved people, that enslavers often separated entire families for profit and as a form of punishment, and that the forced labor of enslaved people built many important buildings and institutions, according to Learning for Justice.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Historians interviewed by the Tribune also say that if the state is unwilling to use the materials it designed as a vehicle to provide students a more comprehensive picture of the country’s history, then education officials should reconsider its cross-disciplinary approach and whether the proposed reading and language arts curriculum is the appropriate venue for such lessons.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">“I would just start, as a basic premise, that you not lie to kids,” said Michael Oberg, a history professor at the State University of New York College at Geneseo who previously taught in Texas and <a href="https://ageofrevolutions.com/2018/10/15/texas-and-the-great-white-washing-of-the-american-revolution/">followed debates</a> over the state’s social studies standards. Oberg pointed to excerpts of the state curriculum about the founding fathers’ desire for liberty and equality and Robert E. Lee’s leadership as lessons he believes leave out significant historical context.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">How the curriculum covers other major historical chapters also calls into question why lessons on some events are considered age appropriate and others are not.</p> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--flush "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div id="ad-unit-5314" class="js-ad-unit"> <div class="c-ad-flex"> <div class="c-ad-flex__inner"> <div class="c-ad-flex__unit"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">In stark contrast to the state curriculum’s lack of detail when covering American slavery, for example, a fifth-grade lesson on World War II is clear and precise about the horrors of the Holocaust, which it defines as “the state-sponsored and systematic persecution and murder of six million Jewish people by the Nazi regime and its collaborators.” The lesson further highlights how Jewish people “were dehumanized, imprisoned, attacked and murdered” and “stripped of their rights, dignity and lives.”</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">How Texas schools teach U.S. history to children has been the focus of intense political conflict in recent years. The state <a href="https://www.texastribune.org/2021/12/02/texas-critical-race-theory-law/">passed legislation</a> in 2021 making it illegal for schools to teach slavery and racism as part of the “true founding” of the country.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">The legislation came about after the summer of mass protests for racial justice in response to the murder of George Floyd, a Black man killed by a Minneapolis police officer in 2020. In the years that followed, Republican state lawmakers across the country pushed for legislation outlawing what Texas Lt. Gov. <a href="https://www.texastribune.org/directory/dan-patrick/">Dan Patrick</a> once described as “woke philosophies” maintaining that people, by virtue of their race or sex, are either oppressed or inherently racist. Many State Board of Education members have <a href="https://www.texastribune.org/2022/03/02/critical-race-theory-state-board-education/">successfully campaigned</a> on similar ideas in recent years.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Now, the 2021 law prompts Texas schools to teach children that slavery and racism are “deviations from, betrayals of, or failures to live up to the authentic founding principles of the United States, which include liberty and equality.”</p> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--flush "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div id="ad-unit-4775" class="js-ad-unit"> <div class="c-ad-flex"> <div class="c-ad-flex__inner"> <div class="c-ad-flex__unit"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">The law has <a href="https://www.texastribune.org/2021/10/15/Texas-critical-race-theory-law-confuses-educators/">sowed fear and confusion</a> about what teachers are allowed to teach, while causing others to stray away or move quickly past certain topics like slavery and civil rights, said Jerrica Liggins, secondary education curriculum director for the Paris school district. Students are the ones who ultimately suffer, she said.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">“Left out of the curriculum, I would say it would be anyone of color. But if you think about left out in the classroom, it's everyone. Because we're not giving them everything the way it happened,” Liggins said. “I'd say we were kind of sugar-coating it to make it seem to be more pleasant when it was really horrific.”</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Caleb McDaniel, a Pulitzer Prize-winning historian who teaches at Rice University, worries the state curriculum’s framing of American slavery could diminish its significance and make it difficult for students to understand. The Civil War lesson he reviewed, for instance, doesn't detail the legal mechanisms built into the Constitution that enabled slavery to expand in the decades leading up to the war. The lessons about the founding fathers, he said, also fail to provide students a full picture of who the men were.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">George Washington is quoted in the curriculum, for example, as saying “there is not a man living who wishes more sincerely than I do, to see a plan adopted for the abolition” of slavery. But the quote is cherry-picked from <a href="https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Washington/04-04-02-0019">a longer letter</a> in which Washington criticizes Quaker abolitionists in Philadelphia who are working to free enslaved people, McDaniel noted.</p> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--flush "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div id="ad-unit-3739" class="js-ad-unit"> <div class="c-ad-flex"> <div class="c-ad-flex__inner"> <div class="c-ad-flex__unit"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">McDaniel added that the materials he reviewed reflect how history curricula have come a long way from a time when some would question whether slavery was the cause of the Civil War. But he said their evolution has not quite “reached its ending point.”</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">“I think the serious study of the American past reveals a lot of inequality and a lot of failures to live up to the ideals of democracy, and racial injustice is a key example of that,” McDaniel said. “I would challenge the idea that calling attention to that and helping students understand that part of our history is ideological in some way.”</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Mark Chancey, a religious studies professor at Southern Methodist University, was one of several people who provided public input about how the curriculum addresses slavery and religion.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Chancey said the materials’ whitewashing of the nation's founders stood out to him, as did the repeated insistence that they sought freedom for all Americans. He also pointed out that for a curriculum that its defenders claim will teach children about the role Christianity played in the nation’s founding, it fails to address the fact that many people used the religion to justify their support of slavery.</p> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--flush "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div id="ad-unit-8277" class="js-ad-unit"> <div class="c-ad-flex"> <div class="c-ad-flex__inner"> <div class="c-ad-flex__unit"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">“Public schools are educating for civic purposes. We're developing our citizenry. We're preparing students to function in a pluralistic democracy and to deliberate about different ideas,” Chancey said. “Students need to have an accurate understanding of history to do that, and many of these lessons work against that goal by oversimplifying American history to the point of distortion.”</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">The state cannot afford to produce another generation of children who don’t have an accurate understanding of history, added Susan Nayak, a mother of an Austin school district graduate who provided public input to the Texas Education Agency on the curriculum.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">“You can't just, ‘Oh, this person is just a hero, and we're just going to talk about their good parts, and that's it.’ I just don’t think that’s helpful for kids,” Nayak said. “They understand that they are not all good and all bad. And experiencing these people, historical figures, as true, complex humans, is actually helpful for them.”</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Public education advocates plan to continue calling on the State Board of Education to reject the materials, said Emily Witt, senior communications and media strategist for the Texas Freedom Network, which <a href="https://tfn.org/cms/assets/uploads/2024/08/OER-Report-2024.pdf">produced a report</a> on the curriculum and raised concerns about the religious emphasis and whitewashing of American history.</p> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--flush "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div id="ad-unit-2911" class="js-ad-unit"> <div class="c-ad-flex"> <div class="c-ad-flex__inner"> <div class="c-ad-flex__unit"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Board members have also raised concerns about the curriculum, though some of their worries are different.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Patricia Hardy, a Fort Worth Republican serving on the board, said she’s still reviewing the materials. But thus far, she doesn't think they do an adequate job of merging reading and social studies lessons. The history lessons are scattered and not in chronological order, she said, which could make it difficult for students to retain the information. Nor does she find the history lessons — like a second grader learning about the Emancipation Proclamation — age appropriate.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">“It does need to be taught, but it's got to be taught at the right place,” said Hardy, a former history teacher and social studies coordinator.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Some parents told the Tribune it’s crucial that their children see themselves accurately reflected in the state’s history lessons.</p> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--flush "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div id="ad-unit-5764" class="js-ad-unit"> <div class="c-ad-flex"> <div class="c-ad-flex__inner"> <div class="c-ad-flex__unit"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">Keiawnna Pitts, a Round Rock community activist and mother of four, who is Black, acknowledged that kids are impressionable but said they’re exposed early in their lives to topics like race outside of their homes and classrooms. She also said children start asking questions from a young age. Glossing over the difficult parts of history, she said, does not help them to make sense of the world around them.</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left">“Why do we need to introduce it to our kids early? Because I need them to think critically past what is being told to them,” Pitts said. “We're gonna have to be the ones teaching our kids, because this is what we're gonna always get — what they're comfortable with.”</p> <p class="t-copy t-links-underlined t-align-left"><i>Disclosure: Rice University, Southern Methodist University, Southern Poverty Law Center and Texas Freedom Network have been financial supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan news organization that is funded in part by donations from members, foundations and corporate sponsors. Financial supporters play no role in the Tribune's journalism. Find a complete <a href="https://www.texastribune.org/support-us/corporate-sponsors/">list of them here</a>.</i></p> </div> </div>  <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--default c-plugin--narrow is-hidden-print "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div class="has-vert-bar has-vert-bar--padded-xxl has-vert-bar--thin has-text-yellow"> <h2 class="t-headline t-serif t-lh-s t-size-l has-b-btm-marg has-text-black-off"><em id="articleCounter"></em></h2> <div class="flatblock block-donations-cta"> <div class="flatblock-content"><h2 class="t-headline t-serif t-lh-s t-size-l has-b-btm-marg has-text-black-off">  Texans need truth. Help us report it. </h2> <p class="t-size-b t-serif t-links-underlined has-b-btm-marg has-text-black-off">  Independent Texas reporting needs your support. The Texas Tribune delivers fact-based journalism for Texans, by Texans — and our community of members, the readers who donate, make our work possible. Help us bring you and millions of others in-depth news and information. Will you support our nonprofit newsroom with a donation of any amount? </p> </div> </div> <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--default c-plugin--narrow is-hidden-print "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <section class="c-cta-block has-border is-rounded-b c-cta-block--horiz-from-bp-m has-xl-padding has-giant-btm-marg"> <div class="c-cta-block__msg t-size-s"> <h2 class="t-size-s t-uppercase t-lsp-m t-lh-b has-text-gray-dark has-xxs-btm-marg"> Support independent Texas news </h2> <p class="has-text-gray-dark has-xxs-btm-marg t-size-m"><strong>Become a member. Join today.</strong></p> <p class="has-text-gray-dark t-links-underlined">Choose an amount or <a href="https://support.texastribune.org/donate?installmentPeriod=yearly&campaignId=" class="l-display-ib" ga-event-category="donations" ga-event-action="membership-intent" ga-event-label="story-inline-link">learn more about membership</a>.</p> </div> <div class="c-cta-block__btns t-align-center c-cta-block__btns--4 c-cta-block__btns--2-from-bp-m"> <a id="cta-button-quad-1" class="c-button is-rounded-l has-reset-padding l-align-center-children has-bg-yellow" href="https://support.texastribune.org/donate?installmentPeriod=monthly&campaignId=701Pe00000PCH0KIAX&amount=18#join-today" ga-event-category='donations' ga-event-action='membership-intent' ga-event-label='story-inline-dollars'> <span class="c-button__inner has-text-black t-titlecase">$18</span> </a> <a id="cta-button-quad-2" class="c-button is-rounded-l has-reset-padding l-align-center-children has-bg-yellow" href="https://support.texastribune.org/donate?installmentPeriod=monthly&campaignId=701Pe00000PCHDCIA5&amount=20#join-today" ga-event-category='donations' ga-event-action='membership-intent' ga-event-label='story-inline-dollars'> <span class="c-button__inner has-text-black t-titlecase">$20</span> </a> <a id="cta-button-quad-3" class="c-button is-rounded-l has-reset-padding l-align-center-children has-bg-yellow" href="https://support.texastribune.org/donate?installmentPeriod=monthly&campaignId=701Pe00000PCOTBIA5&amount=25#join-today" ga-event-category='donations' ga-event-action='membership-intent' ga-event-label='story-inline-dollars'> <span class="c-button__inner has-text-black t-titlecase">$25</span> </a> <a id="cta-button-quad-4" class="c-button is-rounded-l has-reset-padding l-align-center-children c-button--outline has-bg-white has-text-yellow" href="https://support.texastribune.org/donate?installmentPeriod=yearly&campaignId=701Pe00000PCOszIAH&amount=250#join-today" ga-event-category='donations' ga-event-action='membership-intent' ga-event-label='story-inline-dollars'> <span class="c-button__inner has-text-black t-titlecase">Other</span> </a> </div> <a id="cta-button-main" href="https://support.texastribune.org/donate?installmentPeriod=yearly&amount=200&campaignId=7016f000002GvLdAAK" class="c-button has-bg-yellow has-text-black-off l-display-block" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="donations" ga-event-action="membership-intent" ga-event-label="story-cta-button"><span class="t-size-s">Donate now</span></a> </section> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div>  <section class="t-copy t-links-underlined is-hidden-print"> <hr class="has-bg-gray-light has-giant-btm-marg"></hr> <h2 class="is-sr-only">Information about the authors</h2> <div class="c-author-info__container l-flex l-flex-column has-giant-btm-marg"> <div id="staff-author" class="c-author-info__container l-flex l-flex-column"> <div class="c-author-info__trib-author-container l-flex l-ai-center"> <a class="t-links-unset" href="/about/staff/jaden-edison/"> <noscript> <img width="68" height="100" alt="Jaden Edison’s staff photo" src="https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/R2syILE0rD7b9gRWpybCLkfrUw0=/105x155/smart/filters:quality(85)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/profiles/Jaden-Edison_headshot.jpeg"> </noscript> <img alt="Jaden Edison’s staff photo" class="l-display-block js-lazy-image js-lazy-image--target has-bg-gray-dark" data-src="https://thumbnails.texastribune.org/R2syILE0rD7b9gRWpybCLkfrUw0=/105x155/smart/filters:quality(85)/https://static.texastribune.org/media/profiles/Jaden-Edison_headshot.jpeg" width="68" height="100" > </a> <div> <h3 class="has-xxxs-btm-marg t-weight-bold t-size-m"> <a href="/about/staff/jaden-edison/"> Jaden Edison </a> </h3> <h4 class="has-text-gray-dark t-weight-normal has-b-btm-marg t-size-xs t-sans t-lsp-m t-uppercase">Public Education Reporter</h4> <div class="c-author-info__contacts-container l-flex l-flex-column t-size-xs t-sans"> <p class="l-flex l-ai-center"> <a tabindex="-1" href="mailto:jaden.edison@texastribune.org" class="c-icon t-links-unset has-text-teal c-author-info__contact-icon"> <span class="c-icon"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#envelope"></use></svg></span> </a> <a href="mailto:jaden.edison@texastribune.org"> jaden.edison@texastribune.org </a> </p> <p class="l-flex l-ai-center"> <a tabindex="-1" href="https://twitter.com/edisonjaden" class="c-icon t-links-unset t-size-xs c-author-info__contact-icon"> <svg aria-hidden="true"> <use xlink:href="#twitter"></use> </svg> </a> <a href="https://twitter.com/edisonjaden">@edisonjaden</a> </p> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </section>  <p class="t-copy t-size-b t-links-underlined t-lh-m"> <span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline t-size-m has-tiny-right-marg"><svg aria-hidden="true" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 64 64"><path fill="#fff" d="M60.2 53.8c0 3.5-2.9 6.4-6.4 6.4H10.2c-3.5 0-6.4-2.9-6.4-6.4V10.2c0-3.5 2.9-6.4 6.4-6.4h43.5c3.5 0 6.4 2.9 6.4 6.4v43.6z"/><g fill="#121212"><path d="M53.8 0H10.2C4.6 0 0 4.6 0 10.2v43.5C0 59.4 4.6 64 10.2 64h43.5C59.4 64 64 59.4 64 53.8V10.2C64 4.6 59.4 0 53.8 0zm6.4 53.8c0 3.5-2.9 6.4-6.4 6.4H10.2c-3.5 0-6.4-2.9-6.4-6.4V10.2c0-3.5 2.9-6.4 6.4-6.4h43.5c3.5 0 6.4 2.9 6.4 6.4v43.6z"/><path d="M38.3 49.3H25.7c-.3 0-.5-.2-.5-.5V27.3c0-.3-.3-.6-.6-.6H13.5c-.3 0-.5-.2-.5-.5v-11c0-.3.2-.5.5-.5h37.1c.3 0 .5.2.5.5v11.1c0 .3-.2.5-.5.5H39.3c-.3 0-.5.2-.5.5v21.6c0 .2-.2.4-.5.4z"/></g></svg></span> <em><a href="/about/privacy-policy/">Learn about The Texas Tribune’s policies</a>, including our partnership with <a href="/about/#trust-project" class="l-display-ib">The Trust Project</a> to increase transparency in news.</em> </p>  <section class="c-plugin c-plugin--default c-plugin--narrow is-hidden-print"> <h2 class="t-size-s has-xs-btm-marg">Explore related story topics</h2> <p class="c-tags l-flex"> <a href="/topics/public-education/" ga-event-category="article-tag" class="c-tag c-tag__inner has-bg-white-off is-rounded-b">Public education</a> </p> </section>  <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--default c-plugin--narrow is-hidden-print "> <div class="c-plugin__inner"> <div id="article-recs-2360"> <div class="loading loading--s" aria-hidden="true"></div> </div> </div> </div>  <div class="c-plugin c-plugin--default c-plugin--narrow is-hidden-print"> <div id="ad-unit-9256" class="js-ad-unit"> <div class="c-ad-fluid"></div> </div> </div> </article> </main> <aside class="c-story-bottom has-bg-white-off has-giant-btm-marg is-hidden-print" aria-label="Latest Texas Tribune events and articles"> <h2 class="is-sr-only">Latest Texas Tribune events and articles</h2> <div class="l-container l-container--xxl has-m-btm-marg is-hidden-print"> <div id="rug"> <div class="c-rug"> <div class="c-rug__featured"> <section aria-label="Upcoming events"> <h3 class="is-sr-only">Upcoming events</h3> <p class="is-sr-only">Loading content …</p> <div aria-hidden="true">  <svg aria-labelledby="block-loader-796" role="img" viewBox="0 0 400 300" style="max-width: 100%;"> <title id="block-loader-796">Loading indicator</title> <rect role="presentation" x="0" y="0" width="100%" height="100%" clip-path="url(#block-loader-clip-4412)" style="fill: url("#block-loader-gradient-8348");"></rect> <defs role="presentation"> <clipPath id="block-loader-clip-4412"> <circle cx="30" cy="258" r="30"></circle> <rect x="75" y="233" rx="4" ry="4" width="35%" height="13"></rect> <rect x="75" y="260" rx="4" ry="4" width="20%" height="8"></rect> <rect x="0" y="210" rx="5" ry="5" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="0" y="0" rx="5" ry="5" width="100%" height="200"></rect> </clipPath> <linearGradient id="block-loader-gradient-8348"> <stop offset="0%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="50%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="100%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> </linearGradient> </defs> </svg> <div class="c-block-grid">  <svg aria-labelledby="block-loader-2202" role="img" viewBox="0 0 400 300" style="max-width: 100%;"> <title id="block-loader-2202">Loading indicator</title> <rect role="presentation" x="0" y="0" width="100%" height="100%" clip-path="url(#block-loader-clip-9675)" style="fill: url("#block-loader-gradient-1655");"></rect> <defs role="presentation"> <clipPath id="block-loader-clip-9675"> <circle cx="30" cy="258" r="30"></circle> <rect x="75" y="233" rx="4" ry="4" width="35%" height="13"></rect> <rect x="75" y="260" rx="4" ry="4" width="20%" height="8"></rect> <rect x="0" y="210" rx="5" ry="5" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="0" y="0" rx="5" ry="5" width="100%" height="200"></rect> </clipPath> <linearGradient id="block-loader-gradient-1655"> <stop offset="0%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="50%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="100%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> </linearGradient> </defs> </svg>  <svg aria-labelledby="block-loader-3705" role="img" viewBox="0 0 400 300" style="max-width: 100%;"> <title id="block-loader-3705">Loading indicator</title> <rect role="presentation" x="0" y="0" width="100%" height="100%" clip-path="url(#block-loader-clip-2173)" style="fill: url("#block-loader-gradient-1832");"></rect> <defs role="presentation"> <clipPath id="block-loader-clip-2173"> <circle cx="30" cy="258" r="30"></circle> <rect x="75" y="233" rx="4" ry="4" width="35%" height="13"></rect> <rect x="75" y="260" rx="4" ry="4" width="20%" height="8"></rect> <rect x="0" y="210" rx="5" ry="5" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="0" y="0" rx="5" ry="5" width="100%" height="200"></rect> </clipPath> <linearGradient id="block-loader-gradient-1832"> <stop offset="0%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="50%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="100%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> </linearGradient> </defs> </svg> </div> </div> </section> </div> <div class="c-rug__reporters"> <section aria-label="Latest from our reporters"> <h3 class="is-sr-only">Latest from our reporters</h3> <p class="is-sr-only">Loading content …</p> <div aria-hidden="true">  <svg aria-labelledby="list-loader-8284" role="img" viewBox="0 0 400 130" style="max-width: 100%;"> <title id="list-loader-8284">Loading indicator</title> <rect role="presentation" x="0" y="0" width="100%" height="100%" clip-path="url(#list-loader-clip-2223)" style="fill: url("#list-loader-gradient-5694");"></rect> <defs role="presentation"> <clipPath id="list-loader-clip-2223"> <rect x="0" y="0" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="20" rx="3" ry="3" width="90%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="40" rx="3" ry="3" width="70%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="0" y="60" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="80" rx="3" ry="3" width="80%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="100" rx="3" ry="3" width="20%" height="10"></rect> </clipPath> <linearGradient id="list-loader-gradient-5694"> <stop offset="0%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="50%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="100%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> </linearGradient> </defs> </svg>  <svg aria-labelledby="list-loader-7891" role="img" viewBox="0 0 400 130" style="max-width: 100%;"> <title id="list-loader-7891">Loading indicator</title> <rect role="presentation" x="0" y="0" width="100%" height="100%" clip-path="url(#list-loader-clip-761)" style="fill: url("#list-loader-gradient-757");"></rect> <defs role="presentation"> <clipPath id="list-loader-clip-761"> <rect x="0" y="0" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="20" rx="3" ry="3" width="90%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="40" rx="3" ry="3" width="70%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="0" y="60" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="80" rx="3" ry="3" width="80%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="100" rx="3" ry="3" width="20%" height="10"></rect> </clipPath> <linearGradient id="list-loader-gradient-757"> <stop offset="0%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="50%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="100%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> </linearGradient> </defs> </svg>  <svg aria-labelledby="list-loader-6558" role="img" viewBox="0 0 400 130" style="max-width: 100%;"> <title id="list-loader-6558">Loading indicator</title> <rect role="presentation" x="0" y="0" width="100%" height="100%" clip-path="url(#list-loader-clip-347)" style="fill: url("#list-loader-gradient-8320");"></rect> <defs role="presentation"> <clipPath id="list-loader-clip-347"> <rect x="0" y="0" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="20" rx="3" ry="3" width="90%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="40" rx="3" ry="3" width="70%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="0" y="60" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="80" rx="3" ry="3" width="80%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="100" rx="3" ry="3" width="20%" height="10"></rect> </clipPath> <linearGradient id="list-loader-gradient-8320"> <stop offset="0%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="50%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="100%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> </linearGradient> </defs> </svg>  <svg aria-labelledby="list-loader-1362" role="img" viewBox="0 0 400 130" style="max-width: 100%;"> <title id="list-loader-1362">Loading indicator</title> <rect role="presentation" x="0" y="0" width="100%" height="100%" clip-path="url(#list-loader-clip-1992)" style="fill: url("#list-loader-gradient-2803");"></rect> <defs role="presentation"> <clipPath id="list-loader-clip-1992"> <rect x="0" y="0" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="20" rx="3" ry="3" width="90%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="40" rx="3" ry="3" width="70%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="0" y="60" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="80" rx="3" ry="3" width="80%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="100" rx="3" ry="3" width="20%" height="10"></rect> </clipPath> <linearGradient id="list-loader-gradient-2803"> <stop offset="0%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="50%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="100%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> </linearGradient> </defs> </svg>  <svg aria-labelledby="list-loader-5612" role="img" viewBox="0 0 400 130" style="max-width: 100%;"> <title id="list-loader-5612">Loading indicator</title> <rect role="presentation" x="0" y="0" width="100%" height="100%" clip-path="url(#list-loader-clip-362)" style="fill: url("#list-loader-gradient-5079");"></rect> <defs role="presentation"> <clipPath id="list-loader-clip-362"> <rect x="0" y="0" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="20" rx="3" ry="3" width="90%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="40" rx="3" ry="3" width="70%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="0" y="60" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="80" rx="3" ry="3" width="80%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="100" rx="3" ry="3" width="20%" height="10"></rect> </clipPath> <linearGradient id="list-loader-gradient-5079"> <stop offset="0%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="50%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="100%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> </linearGradient> </defs> </svg>  <svg aria-labelledby="list-loader-4975" role="img" viewBox="0 0 400 130" style="max-width: 100%;"> <title id="list-loader-4975">Loading indicator</title> <rect role="presentation" x="0" y="0" width="100%" height="100%" clip-path="url(#list-loader-clip-718)" style="fill: url("#list-loader-gradient-78");"></rect> <defs role="presentation"> <clipPath id="list-loader-clip-718"> <rect x="0" y="0" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="20" rx="3" ry="3" width="90%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="40" rx="3" ry="3" width="70%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="0" y="60" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="80" rx="3" ry="3" width="80%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="100" rx="3" ry="3" width="20%" height="10"></rect> </clipPath> <linearGradient id="list-loader-gradient-78"> <stop offset="0%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="50%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="100%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> </linearGradient> </defs> </svg>  <svg aria-labelledby="list-loader-4901" role="img" viewBox="0 0 400 130" style="max-width: 100%;"> <title id="list-loader-4901">Loading indicator</title> <rect role="presentation" x="0" y="0" width="100%" height="100%" clip-path="url(#list-loader-clip-7649)" style="fill: url("#list-loader-gradient-3250");"></rect> <defs role="presentation"> <clipPath id="list-loader-clip-7649"> <rect x="0" y="0" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="20" rx="3" ry="3" width="90%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="40" rx="3" ry="3" width="70%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="0" y="60" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="80" rx="3" ry="3" width="80%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="100" rx="3" ry="3" width="20%" height="10"></rect> </clipPath> <linearGradient id="list-loader-gradient-3250"> <stop offset="0%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="50%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="100%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> </linearGradient> </defs> </svg>  <svg aria-labelledby="list-loader-2097" role="img" viewBox="0 0 400 130" style="max-width: 100%;"> <title id="list-loader-2097">Loading indicator</title> <rect role="presentation" x="0" y="0" width="100%" height="100%" clip-path="url(#list-loader-clip-741)" style="fill: url("#list-loader-gradient-4517");"></rect> <defs role="presentation"> <clipPath id="list-loader-clip-741"> <rect x="0" y="0" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="20" rx="3" ry="3" width="90%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="40" rx="3" ry="3" width="70%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="0" y="60" rx="3" ry="3" width="100%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="80" rx="3" ry="3" width="80%" height="10"></rect> <rect x="20" y="100" rx="3" ry="3" width="20%" height="10"></rect> </clipPath> <linearGradient id="list-loader-gradient-4517"> <stop offset="0%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="50%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> <stop offset="100%" stop-color="#d0d0d0" stop-opacity="1"></stop> </linearGradient> </defs> </svg> </div> </section> </div> </div> </div> </div> </aside> <div class="grid_separator has-giant-btm-marg is-hidden-print"> <div id="ad-unit-388" class="js-ad-unit"> <div class="c-ad-ldbd-then-cube"> <div class="c-ad-ldbd-then-cube__unit"></div> </div> </div> </div> <footer id="site_footer" class="c-site-footer has-bg-black-off has-text-white t-size-xs is-hidden-print"> <div class="l-container grid_container c-site-footer__inner c-site-footer__inner--standard"> <div class="c-site-footer__col c-site-footer__col--1"> <span class="c-icon c-icon--yellow c-site-footer__logo has-giant-btm-marg" style="font-size: 4rem;"> <svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#bug"></use></svg> </span> <div class="border--yellow_notch has-notch has-notch--thin has-bg-yellow has-b-btm-marg"></div> <ul class="c-site-footer__links c-site-footer__links--standard"> <li class="has-text-blue">  <a href="https://support.texastribune.org/donate?installmentPeriod=yearly&amount=200&campaignId=7016f000002Gv2vAAC" title="Donate" class="donate" ga-on="click" ga-event-category="donations" ga-event-action="membership-intent" ga-event-label="footer">Donate</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://support.texastribune.org/account/" title="View your giving history" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="view your giving history">View your giving history</a> </li> <li> <a href="/contact/" title="Contact us" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="contact us">Contact us</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://mediakit.texastribune.org/" title="Advertise" class="advertise" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="advertise">Advertise</a> </li> <li> <a href="/about/tips/" title="Send a Tip" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="send us a confidential tip">Send us a confidential tip</a> </li> <li><a href="/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="copyright">© 2025 The Texas Tribune</a></li> </ul> </div> <section id="footer-sections" class="hide_until--m is-hidden-until-bp-m c-site-footer__col c-site-footer__col--2"> <h2 class="c-site-footer__header t-size-xs has-text-yellow t-uppercase has-xxs-btm-marg"> Topics </h2> <ul class="c-site-footer__links c-site-footer__links--standard"> <li> <a href="/topics/congress/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="Congress"> Congress </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/courts/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="courts"> Courts </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/criminal-justice/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="criminal justice"> Criminal justice </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/demographics/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="demographics"> Demographics </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/economy/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="economy"> Economy </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/energy/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="energy"> Energy </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/environment/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="environment"> Environment </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/health-care/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="health care"> Health care </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/higher-education/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="higher education"> Higher education </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/immigration/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="immigration"> Immigration </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/politics/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="politics"> Politics </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/public-education/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="public education"> Public education </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/state-government/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="state government"> State government </a> </li> <li> <a href="/topics/transportation/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="transportation"> Transportation </a> </li> <li><a href="/topics/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="topics">View all</a></li> </ul> </section> <section class="c-site-footer__col c-site-footer__col--3"> <h2 class="c-site-footer__header t-size-xs has-text-yellow t-uppercase has-xxs-btm-marg"><span class="is-sr-only">Company </span>Info</h2> <ul class="c-site-footer__links c-site-footer__links--standard"> <li> <a href="/about/" title="About Us" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="about us">About Us</a> </li> <li> <a href="/about/staff/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="our staff">Our Staff</a> </li> <li> <a href="/jobs/" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="jobs">Jobs</a> </li> <li> <a href="/support-us/donors-and-members/" title="Who Funds Us?" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="who funds us">Who Funds Us?</a> </li> <li> <a href="/about/texas-tribune-strategic-plan/" title="Strategic Plan" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="strategic plan">Strategic Plan</a> </li> <li> <a href="/republishing-guidelines/" title="Republishing Guidelines" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="republishing guidelines">Republishing Guidelines</a> </li> <li> <a href="/about/ethics" title="Code of Ethics" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="code of ethics">Code of Ethics</a> </li> <li> <a href="/about/terms-of-service/" title="Terms of Service" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="terms of service">Terms of Service</a> </li> <li> <a href="/about/privacy-policy/" title="Privacy Policy" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="privacy policy">Privacy Policy</a> </li> <li> <a href="/corrections/" title="Corrections" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="corrections">Corrections</a> </li> <li> <a href="/about/feeds/" title="Feeds" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="feeds">Feeds</a> </li> <li> <a href="/newsletters/" title="Newsletters" ga-event-category="subscribe intent" ga-event-action="footer link">Newsletters</a> </li> <li> <a href="/audio/" title="Audio" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="audio">Audio</a> </li> <li> <a href="/video/" title="Video" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="video">Video</a> </li> </ul> </section> <section class="c-site-footer__col c-site-footer__col--4"> <h2 class="c-site-footer__header t-size-xs has-text-yellow t-uppercase has-xxs-btm-marg">Social Media</h2> <ul class="c-site-footer__links c-site-footer__links--standard"> <li> <a href="https://facebook.com/texastribune" title="Facebook" class="external" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="facebook"><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline c-site-footer__icon"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#facebook"></use></svg></span> Facebook</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://twitter.com/texastribune" title="Twitter" class="external" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="twitter"><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline c-site-footer__icon"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#twitter"></use></svg></span> Twitter</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://youtube.com/user/thetexastribune?sub_confirmation=1" title="YouTube" class="external" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="youtube"><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline c-site-footer__icon"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#youtube"></use></svg></span> YouTube</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://instagram.com/texas_tribune" title="Instagram" class="external" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="instagram"><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline c-site-footer__icon"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#instagram"></use></svg></span> Instagram</a> </li> <li> <a href="http://www.linkedin.com/company/texas-tribune" title="LinkedIn" class="external" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="linkedin"><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline c-site-footer__icon"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#linkedin"></use></svg></span> LinkedIn</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://www.reddit.com/user/texastribune" title="Reddit" class="external has-xxs-btm-marg l-display-ib" ga-event-category="navigation" ga-event-action="footer link click" ga-event-label="reddit"><span class="c-icon c-icon--baseline c-site-footer__icon"><svg aria-hidden="true"><use xlink:href="#reddit"></use></svg></span> Reddit</a> </li> </ul> </section> </div> </footer> <script defer src="/static/build/runtime.51f5e7bf651d4b2f5158.js"></script> <script defer src="/static/build/445.80a21269288aacf3076f.js"></script> <script defer src="/static/build/324.37c7784a7e60296f5541.js"></script> <script defer src="/static/build/353.7024fd01bc69529125ab.js"></script> <script defer src="/static/build/252.8c0ae6e498d1d1e734a8.js"></script> <script defer src="/static/build/100.393631e48e2234d97528.js"></script> <script defer src="/static/build/162.f726a48511ea9294d297.js"></script> <script defer src="/static/build/165.e305269b6e9d71452ee9.js"></script> <script defer src="/static/build/content.4d2fe58672cb26aa1dcf.js"></script>  <div id="parsely-root" style="display: none"> <div id="parsely-cfg" data-parsely-site="texastribune.org"></div> </div> <script> (function(s, p, d) { var h=d.location.protocol, i=p+"-"+s, e=d.getElementById(i), r=d.getElementById(p+"-root"), u=h==="https:"?"d1z2jf7jlzjs58.cloudfront.net" :"static."+p+".com"; if (e) return; e = d.createElement(s); e.id = i; e.async = true; e.src = h+"//"+u+"/p.js"; r.appendChild(e); })("script", "parsely", document); </script>  <a href="/test/hotbots/" aria-hidden="true" rel="nofollow" tabindex="-1"> </a> <script> (function() { var gutenTags = [], authors = [], series = []; gutenTags.push('subject-history-textbooks'); gutenTags.push('subject-public-education'); authors.push('jaden-edison'); var updates = { contentId: 45665, authors: authors, pageType: 'article', gutenTags: gutenTags, series: series }; Object.keys(updates).forEach(function(key) { window.ttGlobal[key] = updates[key]; }); }()); </script> <script> window.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() { jsBundle.buildSignUp({ interestId: '', selectorSuffix: '1839', title: '', display: { isVertical: true, skipSecondaryForm: true, hideImage: true, }, gaLabel: "prompt-mgoYrJ8S", isAuto: true, }); jsBundle.initPrompt({ identifier: 'mgoYrJ8S', mode: 'MD', modeDisplay: 'box', styleDisplay: 'livestream', resetHours: 0, previewMode: false, BANNER: 'BN', MODAL: 'MD', }); jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '8989', slot: 'roofline', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '8172', slot: 'first', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildSignUp({ interestId: '20c921ee0a', selectorSuffix: '8666', title: 'The Brief', display: { isVertical: true, skipSecondaryForm: true, hideImage: true, }, gaLabel: "prompt-Ay3HTYkZ", }); window.dataLayer?.push({ event: 'promptShow', gaAction: 'box', gaCategory: 'livestream', gaValue: 'Ay3HTYkZ', }); jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '1992', slot: 'flex', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '2085', slot: 'flex', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '9149', slot: 'flex', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '5314', slot: 'flex', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '4775', slot: 'flex', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '3739', slot: 'flex', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '8277', slot: 'flex', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '2911', slot: 'flex', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '5764', slot: 'flex', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildArticleRecs({ selectorSuffix: '2360', recCount: 4, articleId: 45665, }) jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '9256', slot: 'paidPost', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildRug({ featuredType: 'UpcomingEvents', ga: { label: 'story page' } }); jsBundle.buildAdUnit({ selectorSuffix: '388', slot: 'footer', collapseOnFail: true }); jsBundle.buildLazyImages(); jsBundle.makeVidsResponsive(); }); </script>  <script> const copy = document.querySelector("#copy-url"); const copyText = document.querySelector("#copy-url-text"); copy.onclick = function(e) { e.preventDefault(); if (navigator.clipboard) { navigator.clipboard.writeText(copy.href); copyText.innerHTML = "Copied!"; setTimeout(function() { copyText.innerHTML = "Copy URL"; }, 1000); } else { alert("Copying to clipboard is not available."); } } </script>  <script> const share = document.querySelector("#native-share"); share.onclick = function(e) { const isMobileDevice = window.matchMedia("(max-width: 845px)").matches; if (navigator.share && isMobileDevice) { e.preventDefault(); window.dataLayer.push({ event: 'customSocialShare', gaCategory: 'social-share', gaAction: 'native-share', }); navigator.share({ title: "How some Texas parents and historians say a new state curriculum glosses over slavery and racism", url: "https://www.texastribune.org/2024/11/18/texas-curriculum-history-social-studies-slavery-racism/?utm_campaign=trib-social-buttons&utm_source=native-share&utm_medium=social", }); } } </script> <script src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/npm/ad-auris-iframe-distribution-nextgen@latest/location-href-script.production.js" integrity="sha384-0ItnuJ+xx2noj8kRX5gxxpZTWVP3/4EYJGf0ZXn31VvIksKLXRiExKuJmdiLtfBH" crossorigin="anonymous"></script> <script> (function () { // Get counter. const counterKey = 'counter'; try { data = JSON.parse(localStorage.getItem(counterKey)) || {}; } catch { data = {}; } // Init counter or reset if new month. let today = new Date(); if (!('firstRead' in data) || new Date(data.firstRead).getMonth() != today.getMonth()) { data.firstRead = new Date().toISOString(); data.articles = []; } // Update counter. data.lastRead = new Date().toISOString(); const identifier = "XVH9phiM"; if (!data.articles.includes(identifier)) data.articles.push(identifier); // Save counter. localStorage.setItem(counterKey, JSON.stringify(data)); // Update DOM. const articleCounter = document.getElementById('articleCounter'); const count = data.articles.length; if (articleCounter) { articleCounter.appendChild(document.createTextNode("You've read ")); const mark = document.createElement('mark'); mark.textContent = `${count} article${count > 1 ? "s": " "}`; articleCounter.appendChild(mark); articleCounter.appendChild(document.createTextNode(" this month. You have unlimited free articles remaining because we don't have a paywall.")); } })(); </script> </body> </html>

CINXE.COM

Texas curriculum glosses over racism, slavery, critics say | The Texas Tribune