CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "philpapers.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '9134d473dbb74085',cH: '6M_lo1n3tJYEiIgsvVu.cMtFEwgJ11BQsQgObbHLlik-1739785372-1.2.1.1-htsZMeO7RVBRz70DZq3CDgO_eptS6.ITxWYsG9Y07I1fHS.x2bQaHBgcUqNOjEVw',cUPMDTk: "\/sep\/mohism\/?__cf_chl_tk=vzbOQxesxK3AxqrD63BlqnHI3v.qlyMCr_l6CDlLpgA-1739785372-1.0.1.1-iMF8mSX1qwY3EshBoF9tcM4WTZfwSQALy4fs9rP3Yko",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1739785372',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/sep\/mohism\/?__cf_chl_f_tk=vzbOQxesxK3AxqrD63BlqnHI3v.qlyMCr_l6CDlLpgA-1739785372-1.0.1.1-iMF8mSX1qwY3EshBoF9tcM4WTZfwSQALy4fs9rP3Yko",md: "kD1DPakUs8VaTezOsAvTX63I659iJKkMceFAOAveehY-1739785372-1.2.1.1-E8bfcVoDnedVppH98dtMlhOSrQEa1V2bSXxJPYc_TLIASdhAYOTlGNjz8UosTbsttHWWpJlUPf1JpVDzxMMMrUF6XcAI2mE_U2i17Gy9wptk5fO6kTs45cHaYIAzZQlAUbujxOZZGO_V.dtmFAMxnrOtUrBvucTRawMvBxxyjaNB.t4lUk4usJppuKHRxwyb4wTSvVtXG8nOhxUnd5wWQYKrj2bM4ccl0ZNmyuJEsfpVQr_kZlpj8S0BKyTVMiSgR0JPhzCXyKqEhBcO9K.74S3olQ8LYIn_I9O244x30e9ceojlSSinkdxBilq_AGcGZb1f74jDbr.ia.cKEVpCHWQo8zpkZ4SlZNx3qPTzAJf8RE_9r7kM.u7I3dLmpvFK7r_kbCL3i_W9thshgBv7EO6rdhRxlDrCHuWJBqx7fp9Wv2dfZyHrUgZW80aZRK7jfwIi3i.3IOnDwEnw2bCt5pHxmQx0pE8w2LWU3A5N2B8cx1flfu7NfVlGVALnZAafE2RM0wWFlcKFLWjv_ygUV2NTbRApcn8b9gV3sXOdFN5BxNFpgjrR5eWzvkJVs1y4Ep7kHeQTh6eMULoqIXM7Mwu2eU.PQucUiUfEd3JMmJD5pVM48a2IE276iwgRzridfNsrShL2s95LjD57LZU8FoYgGqOQxOntwttuK_VgmPbXGea1U597W9i8dffXfnTAdhEyb9OJ5CxPBgCou480fophRs5FzVmHd7dt.j_5OcxYXFLEvGXU.sSQ5jtox5MSXB.aiEEYJH1XRk8Gbcoy.NZqdvc5I4xuIr9yGOVOf4DmsZIb_gnBtrkuLg9EQUcvt2I.C2gtGjv6y5qRR.kRxedjaVY.OnE0iK4UH_rn.XQn0Gfm3kHDci63.JYd11H3uRBklXgk1O_whAJeTvdgMlo6u6poRsXixpy9_yZFrO1lTQ1hRZ04dkmfZYXcyVLW3uV973b0GXgEbTEjyrg8tL45Ya8rCUgvlG7KM3UREB_DsDDFQ9Un4jjcLfe_S7u1ieoahR5OA.92OrCoR3oGW2d6Y_s.7XmiWdhjGTuXBgX09xZ1W6Ter2pius9hjImVMNl71WRPC4P4NlIDhd_Xc_M8JmLYcyzr9TwW7zDMVQm6k8.wT3DYWoveLHszx3EL3afkgDRzWXqrc0PVnbZN3HQAMonn5Y1eOZxRgzrSh1DYOfIP90Rrl1BiZGj9s11F_PwOh.ETlZmi6RcnKIyzp6RCZ5ZvlNQdZ60J0iHIXN93Ap5Fo8hHD...tiwXoEaAVzmWZWUGTmOWepqd9jU1lDAfgoahJRIZHCAphjV8IWTLtguZQtKeteUXdDkg5uis7ArBul4jC9WB6z.1MCvON87pth7mXSUUCh1I3SXPbB6yctJCOP.PHphihuK49oXslm3B4oTzTk65UoTh9eWTvPK6.UnvIWgnN4FpCWjj6qUQoHv6X1Byajn7fcd2s7FjnMe3cR9jJJB8eO0p1Oz8USesah_wjoEWLBFYXPun8yUOBpb87qF_WG2AmZWpaq4VlyVIKPgu49wZysJWxgCl5TGhTyt9_f2X7L2YURD8k8Kw0sxgnAh9YL_DHa4IlbAjdqLPGxQcJroao18ZG_wVn95pQI3JcIu5dtiHuxE9frh9ytOKiGmzXaALmSJAmJSrl_XClYIwF.dHUW5YXsa8ltlycOv_1aNrKo6ZZHLQDXHPKqileC8jCndZl2FVNJJ2yeRsI5aMoOEqSCED6FwF8cRLfrHJ8btn5BBv6aFAVJ5vN2QV8KV12myyH2OPvOCRo.GJqNdHfSDErBcEG.xd60JTW8LAwrnhTS4IG8NMDxdw3IvYd3TqtDdySVOVAxubiAM55ufWiawXTuF9Ytpu5KrsJPBzKBug9Pkof5QPb1e3hGCEaTp1n6NELrnnkbzpJF4a2aAR8uxjasTrWrN2LD_nTLo6ALaPKZ.v7_e_kiNJ_xw6XMxtN.A15Fv0Omopk.lCOd5bwRGXBTTA_tWLvcrI1l9gS8_nw7W8O001Hui91sWvpxahC__KOI1aTzHoHsgFalXN2q9peE3ZoIuY8eZIgLNvn9mrw6WHYXa4vHqj3rsTrtTtH6uXxYpeU2fWWrgc2YQpqS_lBQUJN3ydC87l4RRS44BfkF961K6EErYMbNnnSNdOPWGiqSxEMO6fuhkC682PVebTwdbZ.Bs.TFd2mCIvA4uF.GxdJ_o7VTWjALBuwk_YERY7RmysnOFbnUg1zmn5iBcEVbsjTyyl92Vu5G4ol0xvAkckqC7xob7cf.gh8Myw_FHpIlwuU.GglAfpL8i76pLNXPL5aFpKhmzHCDFhv8A2ol2OGga8cRnw33BU1X6Yh80TuLh.WjZds_7.qG45Yk1G2Y2lArIG_Xfs1FCOW3Egrs5BKwo8_6L_Z2ITVYpKzPfVHjtjtdcWD1Gh8CbR8XK1AnteC4rJYHrcyh8sXjC0DBZdGd7S3vV502sAPfemsYp3JjDBXRx6bGFZOaWP96CdPaD5G1FnBA",mdrd: "L36FeSI88fQHkb0178ayUm_viHrZHKDny5_IamrOmX4-1739785372-1.2.1.1-msIS1ng68OD4KO0sPhPFhw_HBhRWtSWz0oppSrnxWpIzE5eiVsHHmdv.73nxkLq3wy2D46myqURtkK6SOA93wC0A8RKvVW0mBiE0WjVQd.oF7u7D72XxPP0ys4wfD7Xre0e9XJnTyS2p.Trh4WKMNs_cfvd3oqTrK_XM.hkMIBeraKrMcRVjrw8Si93bYQEkYc.yggUrL4_PBsVUB_yIwOyg8_oepHhI48hWgMrs6jppe1xTzFELwIvH0Dv3AI8j4fBgWP0rHGoVylM36ioiHCtgwgZVFCbOzZq874gOCIn_T7LreMfp5Bj44mfNkmh8laodqCyIrj_gjx6Q.cCOWVPCKdHw6YoQPemvxaT4.nZL0IJrJdECuidvqHioEN3d61AHMP9go5CPrOkPsfJAWtE9cEsTS32mtgGFNdPntxbMH_6r84ocy32_Cy5lWjXFd4rI4DlYVDePkO0_tNrDjOkatPFpJebYMEcjHEk4H4pzQJeblU0Q3mOirUYY..JtZQv7xrc6FunDM.3dB7depY1gVMxP5ruNsO64.xZ_RLBzTIxjX7KUmq5w8rBy.R0ZUDTnqGx9kVeIUq06R_iZSOJhSi9WoSPBBsVTgVYXe7wpG0e6tjYniGQOq0Om7G.dWukG4CO6HzB6z41Y9wB15CE8aDW2CXZeHhYfuUUm4SoFx7PmQs_nL6BehAanx2D3VAqvgCJHF7dO81vvaywZPy8cKppbhO7807_w4Lp.xiKVLD3zaONZgCDkzvSd05VO2wsNP3thPUYNRwiGjKQdPnUmSSOJAsqnEcBY_u0Cz0Gm3bI6i0_bThvv6AYc8wTdPTbWIvJLpHc.JRHrafEGiCoNqHC2z1EbYP9oLAngb_WnTtv1vIPhvkqDA_0Wc_KtHydOn2nAKzyleDeFQUQNaxqoghQIVj94Zl8bDPRjeY49IzJrExWy8aWcZHl.dj0cB0_gCeptxRJrhOdbRMSHC4aoZ1L0oErheO5aXkkifzTq3hL8PPFdPSnOQ3ImQ8FpDksN1HTsIVHNjQH0W2vaoObm6EMBV.KAt6IhCSSuCTVMmwbdVTaAVcU0z6E3JEhKBvE2Gj2zIcxtja5voIcYsBW4puDtTR9Js6peRdjkFKQ5X0gCZkhll6PO0R.fBKCvK0XUU3r37v2t45Xi7wA3S302s9IYFy75UGqEABjsZmvc.hYogVk663c05F6Y8MkZ0G3ascJTqEYCcFciF7unI0xRkqIjrA8FPqaDaQ1ppmFIEVhGPKl9H46JWZ1B2KxHYcW7aNt7YtFJ4nvPUVm6hGoeWSRJVia0ZKky_m6uKzd35hGVGsVORbsZZrH7ZrWOXSkRkhMtEsD0KZA4KsAGBwOJLfE.lj4zNn1rh3cLMr98Jc5yCAgvk63zEy.S5BbEwtAqMIJFm2VK6flY2.tspsbGLQxkQ4IMGjI2yLvaO.e3N4fRxgeox0MjbJAJ5V4V7g1VXlEO5FfGnJsJVxHcx4hKQKeGVU.eCIVR4VYvtTAc_4BaTnJ2fttu9krHv9aS7ThUf5RN4TmGBVoAVcB4qJytVA4sXKs4p4K9siCnLXIRP71zyMq5901fXjIPRUGOp09O0R27WxYKy0Nn3l1CCpEj55dxcQyUb3wuK2GQ9jSEWCT_Pc4_K.7GOtLpbSqMM6aucLfgAVe73qT6poU04NiTolrdqZ6Y8XIJXkLR9_7ZxSM3y2064fQj2z6Sw_XpsJw.R74FeIfHGSRnCRiP0kdoBwAb6Mm2Mry7HXOb.K.Q3olgGF2wjRxnYl2pf.QL10ROuBO3fCmY0ZrNcdWO_nNL5_M1zXZ4VCySrCQXNGf521X5afCASMqyb16zfjudZ0lYTHDMR.uZdPxVsVk_dBorbnTmYEb5xYaMUjxTz3cp96Y_tJgo1WgrdX.K6l4TNhKOVDqbBHXDef4WQVnXfwRAdi54K.fLVACe2bcZQN4"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=9134d473dbb74085';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/sep\/mohism\/?__cf_chl_rt_tk=vzbOQxesxK3AxqrD63BlqnHI3v.qlyMCr_l6CDlLpgA-1739785372-1.0.1.1-iMF8mSX1qwY3EshBoF9tcM4WTZfwSQALy4fs9rP3Yko" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>