CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "alternativeto.net",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e74772c2877cdea',cH: '6REnIC8sXOK_kA.skpgvE0j1mUNOosnE64Ow_5ljIJg-1732399576-1.2.1.1-r9.amD1lB5hz9DuUYQDYMZ91bSJlP86Dkx3vBPPq9l51Ox3Amu2agV77aQ1NZeF.',cUPMDTk: "\/software\/google-scholar?__cf_chl_tk=JHp6xNZ8ZNdXyBXKoHt5lmrasjYaqhkWdT5_v.xsZ1c-1732399576-1.0.1.1-qzlpKgbkKdFkY0tIvzLGlIOoT1KwYMhTC9Xeq2IsYhs",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732399576',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/software\/google-scholar?__cf_chl_f_tk=JHp6xNZ8ZNdXyBXKoHt5lmrasjYaqhkWdT5_v.xsZ1c-1732399576-1.0.1.1-qzlpKgbkKdFkY0tIvzLGlIOoT1KwYMhTC9Xeq2IsYhs",md: "4KkTDWplf3O2lzNaKd48t9qre0gpecXG36S6lQEofu4-1732399576-1.2.1.1-tKZt1538lEpUmKsONk64ztF9ov34FKSCiIiDt5cvz7oHNO7WRHzoEhO4XaeZaHRCGxR5xvBHjYL.wtYfOqgjl_OZxG2iqTgSDn1izCnrJ57iwsaeJAxfHlND7vGVBX5pI_8g3BXf8FVLRpkButTiLlfUa33Xtnl9jfHUlvoTG0NGNjAJTc15I2j74xOOb460QMDM4GE_dDXg5Kmo8mHAy1A5pkb5N8E.w1EGB1VwQWscIrmzQJ5dqXL09ZkTmh.oHxWh9LQWAVovetzkmHXsagC_EXS1jjZLwqGMyAY0P66.ABV8677BgBPUsfygMs25opJ7AjUgYtE6RnByDfoqADijFYNF6IYd3hv172gI7YnWpJ40Kh19gnkrB.X5b4hbTvskLZfWeum6efNRn1gWyvjcjlEUDVs94a2Objm98lWl7uV9Ke5RKv4h9ZJ2kiL7Y35GeIzxZAbtc9XmpwiRYxrdncweUUwromD7GqGwVFA9RT.WTss7jGZp6Ss1vgMC66BLG47Is.3IBa.6NT6Po0po1MjwB0pRsgl.PwrLHN3CiSL30ChNwUM0_GOK9xNXe3D1BzKwbuSsk9cFRz04MLBowWUKLQxGCA3.OURXDIAXL9aswOJbJ_nepZd.kDov5LMrYztxIG8AXNSZcWlLHpx8aipMo2oo_LRPPt3C_SJByxS8YdwWetNeEnSu7gmcG33iastlqeZ4Yt3f833535A7nbySM.63sgqkClykcugWIpBI25wlMQQ8hqA_vgHOEHOQy35N.8ka8qUVw6F7nPxkqi8FNSFwWM43F022AJNrjHMW8u3KZ50IT2Hz2F3tjREoAdw3gSoF9Hi2K7QlYyo7IS46ZJqOXqCUGVZpM8J2cRhjdc2OnQFLs9QeHvafrIbgYSzJBa5AtnZL6_EidBd0zwzrMiAS.GnyuODfwaJ8tdAT6CgwsxDOzPspZSBBfdSZp9TrrlGzyNlA7Og9pG.ZphBn8_oiJ_BwMlw2zXwpxAIXYizgPrCc8t3hu53o5SwgLffYr8xEdP.pNPdTqxa1adJ7W5PNuvGoodRFGopJRm629zjm_E63nl3ES9oT4yxiKR1mpC3LCmZUefYZ4xqb3jd40w5cr14QSRVZ8Cfrkx_KgO7mb6HUwuLc3YR4PGd4OXfVpyWXbbimR5oAH5jCaneJLURmCYNMkovJkAVzKBG0VXIKHEaAGXb2prn4qC6KR9P8Sg7ks2fSrSsBeuu_VWi8qPrWgdV5nTWoVYt46RwxVpnlg1QtJZTGhOvmR2VfS_fcpu_v4Qv6T764mXYQ7TBIkb5A9uZ2UQsF0fXGKfyr_HsLdp27NirS8EXMgb3izgD7swqOEzlT_rQwRk_aQlcDFb7axDB5wyNTNieUUpGw6HN.1kHnylyi6vlhKXDdfwBLvDQNnRjWYtDW3q7H0TV3hIeezY6E4Qitr_b1k6ljm7QLAkrdg5xe3SectksO3jEI8PMeuxfW_5DOS9WiVOivQqhViA7wuJBecr5VewS1lipfcBqmPsjir0YI7d_2RN73VZ8N28WcprBsQdQDIV1RsL5ElJxFtFDvlDZiuaNY7EzEthVnAflqITHcC6tSjf45oizj50C2v0xQkLMuQyD2ryJQIuV4pmoPeQ2cRWUEYwP37UQV5IdliuEYkYSu3vQgAMGCb_Z0FzqHFIGclTmp4I7w1kO7_kYajCZWTC8yjLxlyO2KDrjMk9hyOsUloNt0JM5a9DAZcUb5EfMk8t_6VKdCzl7IMYl07lc_uD6drk6frFzv_1ESH_ZWtOUABadqufk66xNJYcem_bVT1haS_zULZV9DVVsJ3_VgYiHBFC7F9iF.PlzIHQj8BPBA5_ku9xgh3sNDMXM0kEg6vMKCzu8YGtYTrjWOQjqoGnVsxphTAnOvh9ZLxj5vb4r0eWgjSXtLqd4wP8xbNSEBLnWsRgT6T4J1mzaNiFHEfPVHvSygDP7a.L_8JuXMYSrafWZe8IaTQkn4QLdEl.kFQV9nR.puD5kGI.n_Btj.aV_f2fuA8.hY0X3hR3hKAHuQbZnOlz42sw6XFXYcT7jvX5cU82a65h6I0gN8teMeOf_Fr9P5QqEmoV4obRNqEpstnb9pCVboTn81oj2K3K4xxG7DbOhkE20A3FHjH_03HO6_HDviknzAdXtl0jr_l4dcyMRpBFAm8TkC2SYXh.KsRApiXfTl4YM4LTdHCdpNbHpLkuiT765nn3MIDwWoJguVX5o2V8iTF87E4NzT9JzqihvwGt6tW1fq_o2xLYGm6k3g.Nhe1iiEIV.Zxx1u3fMj4yK_6GYIgpX8mHxNJS07K4m2l3TCR7CPbHb98ltVo8Zx98asSSAmQkqEfEPFNEzVaaxPVvIwcwi06dLLAY8UOqEBX18JwsF1iQUuZXxOA9uDRGQ_ibNEdvaML_ezVCRx_5KKSVzhcyRVGxRWkmO_jwYQR2U9yUr5YCOcowMAcI4Qk5Zaisgoq5sF5.WfWIY0ODT32IwNozNjBahzM1JI0H8mKROIB3_iXHtCX5qhdTX7mKgdqwe1.w1XKLeMs57rEzuiO_BPRH7_XEGjaMui6uAcFVl_UefDw8ySNI6Rs5eLmMTE0V4KPCtXDM78.bTpEh04SijkkceJQGqCBf.AUeOa8.TVE.Gd_bQk.QsIOI9aZUKiWOR7ZvGovgEgEIGGNTOb1uRiVsEX5syusQBf7J8eqpTHG39kyyETUXJGF_yNC8.T7HPz3ke1nInoKEcBmAlAgFl4xy9eAf___xQO0wAER6oVDmSOTyc5A.yQTgPAMrCuliDlCwWDHbBUxMy770r7.Jk7swLH4laV.At_C73wvBAFuXqbwFEvK9x29I_MPjdo.FCZYhGqSgPtEWDBeAWCD8hkNUtcV0UJg2cOnKNL9gJPPg0Ha9WlkbHwOJCJH9E08GsKnhAVj04.",mdrd: "2JKMs.RD4F_InJLZXQyIK4fm9OZpj0YRsB4DTbR5T4M-1732399576-1.2.1.1-S6h.zNRhRsTtqZkjW8Ub8oR2MaeJMCTBYqE3PoYHWU6Az0.oO2xMF8UyjRvuD5qM7qLUn1JK0lMDXbkbTJ_741unRKmf2lvmrbfcfrULw2Vp4i1dQEKOuA8KKwcHOkPEjMlT8jAqsf02w9w3G5PvMyVTnmz4dt2aEYfwnOQrcnBzGvdkoL.cglLnQ13pNK1Ndkm7T3P9zv9DzgFXRAiOaR7YezNYADZdXuLI6XHkhuWmaKrEsOsijkCZhjpe5u.2P3dNyPY_zfYWkIDlj4eyuwADSvANVA9sazCekWboST3ADWsjOw3WNEpMaHzPlRwpCh_t6OaPkrVc2UngMSMLlsHA7qCUt8M3I5oGBouvMOqlqetpEWRwau6pWe8b0MTaM6Xm.JCzj7RGRcXg_W4_Zm_nu1_nuduJk5X7ZaX4KSTNMiVg7cQCH72b.Oc.xqhG.i5xqZkGalSURH8iFv82YEDrAhNxbbzvFhULe0z2rZgkSQhCCoEsFEwl2KoOdG14YtajJuptlCmJwUGmBeJXIeYLVMBBTvd8u6tOVmw81D4gq2dPyH1eTr2NUY13jyt5AXOj_bp.PimHbroi9Ta3cmkMqneN5pZJLs0Sp6du2P15KytZdbmrozC_CzKAv8L6k.MPQQuX5kjTcQjY14NtqjKKPV6dCPL48_3ZZEsuO6aPVfFZbkDDXitYE4.CctlOJnV.FI4PrkRkYiwnM.asDuA1vMOAxxN2llZ76oNEZPuI56V0NB_htN.VmhbBA7Iw5pR2uPS7j_8a227eHAVQXHmyjzcLcipshA1egJmvU79tScsvydB3d2vIIG9kFiFcDYecKPjg9AcwfbwY8dHefDW2SdVPQLOj0Hb2bEryUYFWZlyPdNmT9.Q76X_aXo1oer9udUdPHdWl_QV7VpzPab4idFWj1_6oMk.wRrXl8zgzLwzjnMRJ.Wl9fO18ekNBrmDpCIoUol51sMa7wBDf1dPZpOWJDUe7txZvv2Hh4X6E8qKayiQKuZE6E4xocrdGKrwEjQgK23ZaI_djw8KjoGGdUbSRdomIRTrxjDxnf6cuZCFei8V4K1FFhFwDxZv8lMnPwoOrmLq2JmN8G4PqHXpd4k6gaKs7GlvyYx5KTBpQ3LHaWct293v75cppwcZ62B1yLEQrUq9ne0Bkahbq_TL9eKY7HoNl.YD9jwq5.mvwqi_MSnZcBR83mVDeMep4HA6LbRI5XqgfPdZ5XTjPZ9PrnhLWSvyjolNuD6cGUBYt53F5Hvjqm.VjbuqJj1kbCrkMUDxx_FHbuxwQtNBbLhkyPWYER.RP35gHOtRzxO_pkyE.g7WETuF5IZ9uMiBARdS8BHqoXt1TEMRRqFg7xFM1fVgnIfArOKxr5DFh1xcyylVhi4XBWp5K4g16NSxhM1BzTqItTORdfz86LZShygZ979py8WH47mW55dCD0vmcSzWjAb8aQKsEjN0ZeNHxap0AW46X67l7_I9_Kw2CX5VouowNJZe6q0ORBfbBS4t2Y.TEJ2M1_I6ome4CdlG81uJaS7iRnU9falZnQILtqVEOwiPkEzFyQG1f9v8YMTwqU5VA4NejVxBlpfPCOWEDwOphba31AWInjf7TJNuqaxOZHizBTXUcovTN6CNcJ7oT6HPglDO4t88bHDQG6iI3YCh9HimXV8iTgNC.T..D8b9e1qvZ_lNU84xkY4XvrJO.aADkMIXbASq8iadHd7Mipf4j2XqlR57.O.5EtvUGuakuDJpMPn3CwGsCJfHI4oehY2Ytmf20Uwo2FuhWjRE1C5lIHwp264dfl1i_GMmG20teWijl5p6qwTAulV0BJEfuC6p4higO4JZpF92Nl6V04QkVSgP8U0W4oR9z41m2dVJQex_ugtiqOxByk4bq8OqkoZ.TAuNQ_6tmbkAvRfaPh.foSwZmzU.VBGMRgkCtDsUPn6GV_PTYEDN9a9OGLTlli5CuiLDGvT50O5UZ0Tyb"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e74772c2877cdea';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/software\/google-scholar?__cf_chl_rt_tk=JHp6xNZ8ZNdXyBXKoHt5lmrasjYaqhkWdT5_v.xsZ1c-1732399576-1.0.1.1-qzlpKgbkKdFkY0tIvzLGlIOoT1KwYMhTC9Xeq2IsYhs" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>