Are biodiversity credits doomed to repeat the voluntary carbon market’s flaws? | News | Eco-Business

<!doctype html> <html class="js-off js enhanced js-focus-visible" lang="en" > <head> <meta charset="utf-8" /> <meta http-equiv="x-ua-compatible" content="ie=edge"> <meta name="HandheldFriendly" content="True" /> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1"> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://eco-business.imgix.net"> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net" crossorigin> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://eco-business.imgix.net"> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net"> <title>Are biodiversity credits doomed to repeat the voluntary carbon market’s flaws? | News | Eco-Business | Asia Pacific</title> <meta name="description" content="As COP16 kicks off, the nascent market’s pioneers are keen to rule out offsetting and secondary market trading, while letting Indigenous peoples take the lead. But NGOs call the mechanism a “false solution to a false problem”." /> <meta name="author" content="Eco-Business" /> <meta name="keywords" content="" /> <meta name="msvalidate.01" content="408D956B04D785246F0716C2541B3974" /> <script src="https://cdn.usefathom.com/script.js" data-site="XRUMGGSJ" defer></script> <script> (function(w,d,s,l,i){w[l]=w[l]||[];w[l].push({'gtm.start': new Date().getTime(),event:'gtm.js'});var f=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0], j=d.createElement(s),dl=l!='dataLayer'?'&l='+l:'';j.async=true;j.src= 'https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id='+i+dl;f.parentNode.insertBefore(j,f); })(window,document,'script','dataLayer','GTM-NH3K3VX'); </script> <script> const djangoLanguageCode = "en"; const lazySizesStaticURL = "https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/js/libs/lazysizes.min.887075a85122.js" docClass = document.documentElement.className; document.documentElement.className = docClass.replace(/\bjs-off\b/g, 'js-on'); </script> <link rel="icon" href="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/img/favicon.6526ddc25826.ico" type="image/x-icon" />  <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="" href="/feeds/all/" /> <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="" href="/feeds/news/" /> <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="" href="/feeds/opinion/" /> <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="" href="/feeds/jobs/" /> <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="" href="/feeds/events/" /> <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="" href="/feeds/press-releases/" /> <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="" href="/feeds/research/" />  <link rel="canonical" href="https://www.eco-business.com/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/" /> <link rel="alternate" hreflang="en" href="https://www.eco-business.com/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/" /> <link rel="alternate" hreflang="zh-hans" href="https://www.eco-business.com/zh-hans/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/" /> <link rel="alternate" hreflang="id" href="https://www.eco-business.com/id/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/" /> <link rel="alternate" hreflang="ms" href="https://www.eco-business.com/ms/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/" /> <link rel="alternate" hreflang="x-default" href="https://www.eco-business.com/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/" /> <link rel="preload" href="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/img/eco-business-logo.cf191c09fb92.svg" as="image" type="image/svg+xml"> <link rel="preload" href="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-buch-py39.5a136ed5082e.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin> <link rel="preload" href="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/tiempos/tiempos-headline-web-bold-py39.072884a4136a.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin> <link rel="preload" href="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/tiempos/tiempos-headline-web-semibold-py39.81a14c06a763.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin> <link rel="preload" fetchpriority="high" as="image" type="image/avif" href="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?ar=16%3A10&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=320" imagesrcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?ar=16%3A10&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=320 640w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?ar=16%3A10&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=700 700w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?ar=16%3A10&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=480 960w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?ar=16%3A10&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=700 1400w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?ar=16%3A10&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=1100 2200w" imagesizes="(min-width: 1300px) 1100px, (min-width: 740px) 700px, 100vw" > <style type="text/css"> @font-face { font-family: "Sohne"; src: url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-buch-py39.5a136ed5082e.woff2") format("woff2"), url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-buch-py39.3f75693e169b.woff") format("woff"); font-weight: 400; font-style: normal; font-display: swap; } @font-face { font-family: "Sohne"; src: url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-buch-kursiv-py39.22734a6a16ec.woff2") format("woff2"), url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-buch-kursiv-py39.cdaa4a36b524.woff") format("woff"); font-weight: 400; font-style: italic; font-display: swap; } @font-face { font-family: "Sohne"; src: url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-kraftig-py39.edb5709d70b1.woff2") format("woff2"), url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-kraftig-py39.4d08310a9fe4.woff") format("woff"); font-weight: 500; font-style: normal; font-display: swap; } /* @font-face { font-family: "Sohne"; src: url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-kraftig-kursiv-py39.fcad75c4d5ba.woff2") format("woff2"), url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-kraftig-kursiv-py39.bb623af2b4d7.woff") format("woff"); font-weight: 500; font-style: italic; font-display: swap; } */ @font-face { font-family: "Sohne"; src: url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-halbfett-py39.40442b6cc47e.woff2") format("woff2"), url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-halbfett-py39.2964f9a36d1e.woff") format("woff"); font-weight: 600; font-style: normal; font-display: swap; } /* @font-face { font-family: "Sohne"; src: url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-halbfett-kursiv-py39.da22cda9f074.woff2") format("woff2"), url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-halbfett-kursiv-py39.0826cdb9e0ae.woff") format("woff"); font-weight: 600; font-style: italic; font-display: swap; } */ @font-face { font-family: "Sohne"; src: url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-dreiviertelfett-py39.099d29c7952a.woff2") format("woff2"), url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-dreiviertelfett-py39.bba2a665e8a2.woff") format("woff"); font-weight: 700; font-style: normal; font-display: swap; } @font-face { font-family: "Sohne"; src: url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-dreiviertelfett-kursiv-py39.7cd364a79ada.woff2") format("woff2"), url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/soehne/soehne-web-dreiviertelfett-kursiv-py39.d0e73d2633c7.woff") format("woff"); font-weight: 700; font-style: italic; font-display: swap; } @font-face { font-family: "Tiempos Headline"; src: url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/tiempos/tiempos-headline-web-regular-py39.dc43c6a41fb3.woff2") format("woff2"), url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/tiempos/tiempos-headline-web-regular-py39.4f4c92604acc.woff") format("woff"); font-weight: 400; font-style: normal; font-display: swap; } @font-face { font-family: "Tiempos Headline"; src: url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/tiempos/tiempos-headline-web-medium-py39.be28eb695ec3.woff2") format("woff2"), url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/tiempos/tiempos-headline-web-medium-py39.a95dfca46ad7.woff") format("woff"); font-weight: 500; font-style: normal; font-display: swap; } @font-face { font-family: "Tiempos Headline"; src: url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/tiempos/tiempos-headline-web-semibold-py39.81a14c06a763.woff2") format("woff2"), url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/tiempos/tiempos-headline-web-semibold-py39.733fbe0bd0f3.woff") format("woff"); font-weight: 600; font-style: normal; font-display: swap; } @font-face { font-family: "Tiempos Headline"; src: url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/tiempos/tiempos-headline-web-bold-py39.072884a4136a.woff2") format("woff2"), url("https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/fonts/tiempos/tiempos-headline-web-bold-py39.14143b21d18b.woff") format("woff"); font-weight: 700; font-style: normal; font-display: swap; } </style> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/css/eb-biosphere.f837d9a58b72.css" /> <script src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/js/libs/jquery-3.6.0.min.8fb8fee4fcc3.js"></script> <script type="text/plain" data-consent="marketing"> var googletag = googletag || {}; googletag.cmd = googletag.cmd || []; (function() { var gads = document.createElement('script'); gads.async = true; gads.type = 'text/javascript'; gads.src = 'https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/tag/js/gpt.js'; var node = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; node.parentNode.insertBefore(gads, node); })(); $(document).ready(function(){ var dfpslots=$("body").find(".ad-slot__ad").filter(":visible"), i=0, slot = new Array(); if (dfpslots.length) { googletag.cmd.push(function() { $(dfpslots).each(function(){ if ($(this).attr('data-sizes')) { var sizes = $(this).data('sizes'); for (var i=0; i < sizes.length; i++){ } } else { var sizes = [$(this).width(), $(this).height()]; } // console.log($(this).attr('data-dfp')); slot[i] = googletag.defineSlot('/16222413/'+$(this).attr('data-dfp'), sizes, $(this).attr('id')).addService(googletag.pubads()); // if ($(this).attr('data-cids')) slot[i].set("adsense_channel_ids", $(this).attr('data-cids')); i++ }); googletag.pubads().enableSingleRequest(); // Breaks channel reporting googletag.enableServices(); $(dfpslots).each(function(){ googletag.display($(this).attr('id')); }); }); } }); </script> <script type="text/javascript"> jQuery(document).ready(function($) { // use the template tags in our JavaScript call $.postCSRF("/hitcount/hit/ajax/", {hitcountPK: "60749"}) .done(function(data) { $('<i />').text(data.hit_counted).attr('id','hit-counted-value').appendTo('#hit-counted'); $('#hit-response').text(data.hit_message); }) .fail(function(data) { // console.log('POST failed'); // console.log(data); }); }); </script>  <meta property="og:site_name" content="Eco-Business"> <meta property="og:title" content="Are biodiversity credits doomed to repeat the voluntary carbon market’s flaws?"> <meta property="og:url" content="https://www.eco-business.com/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/"> <meta property="og:image" content="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?fit=crop&h=801&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&w=1200"> <meta property="og:description" content="As COP16 kicks off, the nascent market’s pioneers are keen to rule out offsetting and secondary market trading, while letting Indigenous peoples take the lead. But NGOs call the mechanism a “false solution to a false problem”."> <meta property="og:type" content="article"> <meta property="article:publisher" content="https://www.facebook.com/EcoBusinessMedia"> <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"> <meta name="twitter:site" content="@ecobusinesscom"> <meta name="twitter:title" content="Are biodiversity credits doomed to repeat the voluntary carbon market’"/> <meta name="twitter:description" content="As COP16 kicks off, the nascent market’s pioneers are keen to rule out offsetting and secondary market trading, while letting Indigenous peoples take the lead. But NGOs call the mechanism a “false solution to a false problem”."> <meta name="twitter:image:src" content="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?fit=crop&h=801&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&w=1200"> <meta name="news_keywords" content="biodiversity, carbon credits, carbon trading, financing, greenwashing, regulation, conservation, nature-based solutions, nature" /> <script type="application/ld+json">{"@context": "https://schema.org/", "@type": "NewsArticle", "articleSection": "Policy & Finance", "author": {"@type": "Person", "name": "Gabrielle See"}, "dateModified": "2024-10-26T06:41:14.142Z", "datePublished": "2024-10-22T08:12:00Z", "description": "To avoid carbon credit pitfalls, the nascent market's pioneers are keen to rule out offsetting and secondary market trading, while letting Indigenous peoples take the lead. But NGOs call the mechanism a “false solution to a false problem”.", "hasPart": [{"@type": "WebPageElement", "cssSelector": ".subscriber_wall__lede", "isAccessibleForFree": "True"}, {"@type": "WebPageElement", "cssSelector": ".subscriber-wall", "isAccessibleForFree": "True"}], "headline": "Are biodiversity credits doomed to repeat the voluntary carbon market’s flaws?", "image": "https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?fit=crop&h=960&ixlib=django-1.2.0&w=1440", "isAccessibleForFree": "True", "keywords": ["biodiversity", "carbon credits", "carbon trading", "financing", "greenwashing", "regulation", "conservation", "nature-based solutions", "nature"], "mainEntityOfPage": {"@id": "https://www.eco-business.com/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/", "@type": "WebPage"}, "publisher": {"@type": "Organization", "logo": {"@type": "ImageObject", "height": "55px", "url": "https://www.eco-business.comhttps://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/img/eb-logo-2x.e3468be02b17.png", "width": "232px"}, "name": "Eco-Business"}, "url": "https://www.eco-business.com/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/"}</script> </head> <body id="top" class=" section-news is-story topic "> <div class="eb-layout"> <div id="leaderboard"> <div class="top-banner-ad-container top-banner-ad-container--mobile top-banner-ad-container--above-nav"> <div id="dfp-ad--top-above-nav" class="js-ad-slot ad-slot ad-slot--dfp ad-slot--top-above-nav ad-slot--top-banner-ad"> <div id="div-gpt-ad-1443600587066-0" class="ad-slot__ad" data-sizes='[320,50]' data-dfp="L1-MOBILE"></div> </div> </div> <div class="top-banner-ad-container top-banner-ad-container--desktop top-banner-ad-container--above-nav"> <div id="dfp-ad--top-above-nav" class="js-ad-slot ad-slot ad-slot--dfp ad-slot--top-above-nav ad-slot--top-banner-ad"> <div id="div-gpt-ad-1362399574626-0" class="ad-slot__ad" data-sizes='[728,90]' data-dfp="TEST-L1"></div> </div> </div> </div> <header id="header" class="eb-header eb-header__search--collapsed eb-navigation--collapsed"> <div class="eb-header__row "> <div class="eb-header__container"> <div class="eb-header__top"> <div class="eb-header__top-column eb-header__top-column--left"> <button class="eb-btn-link eb-header__top-link eb-header__top-link--menu" type="button" title="Toggle menu" data-eb-component="eb-toggle" data-eb-toggle-target="#eb-header-drawer" aria-label="Toggle menu" aria-controls="eb-header-drawer" aria-expanded="false"> <span class="eb-header__top-link-label ">Menu</span> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon--menu eb-color-black" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20"> <path d="M17.5 6h-15c-0.276 0-0.5-0.224-0.5-0.5s0.224-0.5 0.5-0.5h15c0.276 0 0.5 0.224 0.5 0.5s-0.224 0.5-0.5 0.5z" fill="#000000"></path> <path d="M17.5 11h-15c-0.276 0-0.5-0.224-0.5-0.5s0.224-0.5 0.5-0.5h15c0.276 0 0.5 0.224 0.5 0.5s-0.224 0.5-0.5 0.5z" fill="#000000"></path> <path d="M17.5 16h-15c-0.276 0-0.5-0.224-0.5-0.5s0.224-0.5 0.5-0.5h15c0.276 0 0.5 0.224 0.5 0.5s-0.224 0.5-0.5 0.5z" fill="#000000"></path> </svg> </button> <button class="eb-btn-link eb-header__top-link eb-header__top-link--search" type="button" title="Toggle search" aria-controls="eb-header-search-primary" aria-label="Toggle search" aria-expanded="false"> <span class="eb-header__top-link-label ">Search</span> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon--search " width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20"> <path d="M18.869 19.162l-5.943-6.484c1.339-1.401 2.075-3.233 2.075-5.178 0-2.003-0.78-3.887-2.197-5.303s-3.3-2.197-5.303-2.197-3.887 0.78-5.303 2.197-2.197 3.3-2.197 5.303 0.78 3.887 2.197 5.303 3.3 2.197 5.303 2.197c1.726 0 3.362-0.579 4.688-1.645l5.943 6.483c0.099 0.108 0.233 0.162 0.369 0.162 0.121 0 0.242-0.043 0.338-0.131 0.204-0.187 0.217-0.503 0.031-0.706zM1 7.5c0-3.584 2.916-6.5 6.5-6.5s6.5 2.916 6.5 6.5-2.916 6.5-6.5 6.5-6.5-2.916-6.5-6.5z" fill="#000000"></path> </svg> </button> <div class="eb-header__top-link eb-header__top-link--language"> <form id="js-languagesForm" action="/i18n/setlang/" method="post"> <input type="hidden" name="csrfmiddlewaretoken" value="Q5n7bGkZfzMCDyWmSBYcSBb6ti2KpG5N35p7Dk9R9DPX4WrgywUsBVnSDbOGac1s"> <input name="next" type="hidden" value="/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/" /> <input name="language" type="hidden" value="" /> <div class="header__language eb-dropdown"> <a href="#" class="eb-dropdown-toggle" data-eb-component="eb-toggle" data-eb-toggle-target="#eb-header-dropdown-1" role="button"> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon--network " width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20"> <path d="M16.218 3.782c-1.794-1.794-4.18-2.782-6.718-2.782s-4.923 0.988-6.717 2.782-2.782 4.18-2.782 6.717c0 2.538 0.988 4.923 2.782 6.717s4.18 2.782 6.717 2.782 4.923-0.988 6.718-2.782c1.794-1.794 2.782-4.18 2.782-6.717s-0.988-4.923-2.782-6.717zM14.992 10c-0.032-1.072-0.164-2.111-0.39-3.083 0.358 0.145 0.699 0.307 1.018 0.484 1.309 0.727 2.116 1.636 2.324 2.598h-2.953zM13.992 10h-3.992v-3.992c1.227 0.038 2.405 0.217 3.471 0.521 0.305 1.066 0.483 2.243 0.521 3.471zM10 5.008v-2.953c0.963 0.208 1.871 1.015 2.598 2.324 0.177 0.319 0.339 0.66 0.484 1.018-0.972-0.226-2.011-0.358-3.083-0.389zM9 2.054v2.953c-1.072 0.032-2.111 0.164-3.083 0.389 0.145-0.358 0.307-0.699 0.484-1.018 0.727-1.309 1.636-2.116 2.598-2.324zM9 6.008v3.992h-3.992c0.038-1.227 0.217-2.405 0.521-3.471 1.066-0.305 2.243-0.483 3.471-0.521zM4.008 10h-2.953c0.208-0.963 1.015-1.871 2.324-2.598 0.319-0.177 0.66-0.339 1.018-0.484-0.226 0.972-0.358 2.011-0.389 3.083zM4.008 11c0.032 1.072 0.164 2.111 0.389 3.083-0.358-0.145-0.699-0.307-1.018-0.484-1.309-0.727-2.116-1.636-2.324-2.598h2.953zM5.008 11h3.992v3.992c-1.227-0.038-2.405-0.217-3.471-0.521-0.305-1.066-0.483-2.243-0.521-3.471zM9 15.992v2.953c-0.963-0.208-1.871-1.015-2.598-2.324-0.177-0.319-0.339-0.66-0.484-1.018 0.972 0.226 2.011 0.358 3.083 0.39zM10 18.946v-2.953c1.072-0.032 2.111-0.164 3.083-0.39-0.145 0.358-0.307 0.699-0.484 1.018-0.727 1.309-1.636 2.116-2.598 2.324zM10 14.992v-3.992h3.992c-0.038 1.227-0.217 2.405-0.521 3.471-1.066 0.305-2.243 0.483-3.471 0.521zM14.992 11h2.953c-0.208 0.963-1.015 1.871-2.324 2.598-0.319 0.177-0.66 0.339-1.018 0.484 0.226-0.972 0.358-2.011 0.389-3.083zM17.432 7.445c-0.378-0.33-0.821-0.638-1.325-0.918-0.56-0.311-1.177-0.578-1.837-0.797-0.22-0.66-0.486-1.277-0.797-1.837-0.28-0.504-0.588-0.947-0.918-1.325 2.234 0.863 4.014 2.644 4.877 4.877zM6.445 2.568c-0.33 0.378-0.638 0.821-0.918 1.325-0.311 0.56-0.578 1.177-0.797 1.837-0.66 0.22-1.277 0.486-1.837 0.797-0.504 0.28-0.947 0.588-1.325 0.918 0.863-2.234 2.644-4.014 4.877-4.877zM1.568 13.555c0.378 0.33 0.821 0.638 1.325 0.918 0.56 0.311 1.177 0.578 1.837 0.797 0.22 0.66 0.486 1.277 0.797 1.837 0.28 0.504 0.588 0.947 0.918 1.325-2.234-0.863-4.014-2.644-4.877-4.877zM12.555 18.432c0.33-0.378 0.638-0.821 0.918-1.325 0.311-0.56 0.578-1.177 0.797-1.837 0.66-0.22 1.277-0.486 1.837-0.797 0.504-0.28 0.947-0.588 1.325-0.918-0.863 2.234-2.644 4.014-4.877 4.877z" fill="#000000"></path> </svg> English<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-chevron-down eb-icon-chevron-down--header" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M5.22 8.72a.75.75 0 000 1.06l6.25 6.25a.75.75 0 001.06 0l6.25-6.25a.75.75 0 00-1.06-1.06L12 14.44 6.28 8.72a.75.75 0 00-1.06 0z"/></svg> </a> <ul class="eb-dropdown-menu eb-toggle-display" role="menu" id="eb-header-dropdown-1"> <li class="eb-dropdown-item"> <a class="eb-dropdown-item-text active" data-languagecode="en" href="#" >English</a> </li> <li class="eb-dropdown-item"> <a class="eb-dropdown-item-text " data-languagecode="zh-hans" href="#" >简体中文</a> </li> <li class="eb-dropdown-item"> <a class="eb-dropdown-item-text " data-languagecode="id" href="#" >Bahasa Indonesia</a> </li> <li class="eb-dropdown-item"> <a class="eb-dropdown-item-text " data-languagecode="ms" href="#" >Bahasa Malaysia</a> </li> </ul> </div> </form> </div> </div> <div class="eb-header__top-column eb-header__top-column--center"> <a class="eb-header__top-logo" href="/" title="Go to the Eco-Business homepage"><img src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/img/eco-business-logo.cf191c09fb92.svg" alt="Eco-Business"></a> </div> <div class="eb-header__top-column eb-header__top-column--right"> <div class="eb-header__top-link eb-header__top-link--cta"> <a href="/dashboard/eb-enterprise/" class="eb-button eb-button--medium eb-button--primary-inverse hide-until-desktop u-large-right-margin">Publish with us</a> </div> <div class="eb-header__top-link eb-header__top-link--cta"> <a href="/accounts/signup-options/" class="eb-button eb-button--medium eb-button--primary">Subscribe</a> </div> <a href="/accounts/login/" class="eb-header__top-link eb-header__top-link--account" title="Sign in or sign up"> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon--user " width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20"> <path d="M9.5 11c-3.033 0-5.5-2.467-5.5-5.5s2.467-5.5 5.5-5.5 5.5 2.467 5.5 5.5-2.467 5.5-5.5 5.5zM9.5 1c-2.481 0-4.5 2.019-4.5 4.5s2.019 4.5 4.5 4.5c2.481 0 4.5-2.019 4.5-4.5s-2.019-4.5-4.5-4.5z" fill="#000000"></path> <path d="M17.5 20h-16c-0.827 0-1.5-0.673-1.5-1.5 0-0.068 0.014-1.685 1.225-3.3 0.705-0.94 1.67-1.687 2.869-2.219 1.464-0.651 3.283-0.981 5.406-0.981s3.942 0.33 5.406 0.981c1.199 0.533 2.164 1.279 2.869 2.219 1.211 1.615 1.225 3.232 1.225 3.3 0 0.827-0.673 1.5-1.5 1.5zM9.5 13c-3.487 0-6.060 0.953-7.441 2.756-1.035 1.351-1.058 2.732-1.059 2.746 0 0.274 0.224 0.498 0.5 0.498h16c0.276 0 0.5-0.224 0.5-0.5-0-0.012-0.023-1.393-1.059-2.744-1.382-1.803-3.955-2.756-7.441-2.756z" fill="#000000"></path> </svg> <span class="hide-until-laptop">Sign in</span> </a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div id="eb-header-search-primary" class="eb-header__row eb-header__search eb-header__search--primary" data-eb-header-search="true" aria-hidden="true"> <div class="eb-header__container"> <form class="eb-header__search-form" role="search" method="get" action="/search/" id="eb-header-search-form"> <input id="eb-search-field" type="text" class="eb-header__search-term" name="q" automcomplete="off" spellcheck="false" placeholder="Search Eco-Business"> <button class="eb-button eb-button--medium eb-button--primary eb-header__search-submit" type="submit"> Search </button> <button class="eb-header__search-close" type="button" aria-controls="eb-header-search-primary" title="Close search bar" aria-expanded="false"> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" class="eb-icon eb-icon-x "><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M5.72 5.72a.75.75 0 011.06 0L12 10.94l5.22-5.22a.75.75 0 111.06 1.06L13.06 12l5.22 5.22a.75.75 0 11-1.06 1.06L12 13.06l-5.22 5.22a.75.75 0 01-1.06-1.06L10.94 12 5.72 6.78a.75.75 0 010-1.06z"/></svg> <span class="eb-header__visually-hidden">Close search bar</span> </button> <div class="eb-header__search-results" id="eb-header-search-results" aria-hidden="true"> <p class="eb-header__search-all-results"><a id="eb-header-search-all-results">Show all news, opinion, videos and press releases matching <span class="eb-header__search-query-text" id="eb-header-search-query-text"></span> →</a></p> <div class="eb-header__search-results-type u-h"> <h4 class="eb-header__search-results-heading">About Eco-Business</h4> <ul class="eb-header__search-results-list" id="eb-header-search-results-about"></ul> </div> <div class="eb-header__search-results-type u-h"> <h4 class="eb-header__search-results-heading">Topics</h4> <ul class="eb-header__search-results-list" id="eb-header-search-results-topics"></ul> </div> <div class="eb-header__search-results-type u-h"> <h4 class="eb-header__search-results-heading">Tags</h4> <ul class="eb-header__search-results-list" id="eb-header-search-results-tags"></ul> </div> <div class="eb-header__search-results-type u-h"> <h4 class="eb-header__search-results-heading">Regions</h4> <ul class="eb-header__search-results-list" id="eb-header-search-results-regions"></ul> </div> <div class="eb-header__search-results-type u-h"> <h4 class="eb-header__search-results-heading">Sustainable Development Goals</h4> <ul class="eb-header__search-results-list" id="eb-header-search-results-sdgs"></ul> </div> <div class="eb-header__search-results-type u-h"> <h4 class="eb-header__search-results-heading">Series</h4> <ul class="eb-header__search-results-list" id="eb-header-search-results-series"></ul> </div> </div> </form> </div> </div> <div class="eb-header__row"> <div class="eb-header__container"> <div class="eb-header__award-text"> <a class="eb-header__award-link" href="/news/eco-business-wins-wan-ifra-asian-digital-media-awards-for-revamped-insights-newsletter/">Winner | Asian Digital Media Awards 2024</a> </div> </div> </div> <nav class="eb-header__row eb-header__nav" id="eb-headerNav"> <div class="eb-header__container eb-header__container--nav"> <ul class="eb-header__nav-list"> <li class="eb-header__nav-item" id="eb-header-nav-news" data-mega-menu="news"> <a href="/news/" class="eb-header__nav-link">News</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item"><a href="/opinion/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Opinion</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item"><a href="/podcasts/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Podcasts</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item"><a href="/videos/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Videos</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item"><a href="/eb-studio/" class="eb-header__nav-link">EB Studio</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item hide-until-laptop"><a href="/press-releases/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Press Releases</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item hide-until-laptop" id="eb-header-nav-events" data-mega-menu="events"> <a href="/events/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Events</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item hide-until-laptop"><a href="/jobs/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Jobs</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item hide-until-laptop" id="eb-header-nav-intelligence" data-mega-menu="intelligence"><a href="/intelligence/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Intelligence</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item" id="eb-header-nav-topics" data-mega-menu="topics"><a href="#" class="eb-header__nav-link">Topics</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item" id="eb-header-nav-sdgs" data-mega-menu="sdgs"> <a href="/sustainable-development-goals/" class="eb-header__nav-link">SDGs</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item" id="eb-header-nav-more" data-mega-menu="more"> <a href="#" class="eb-header__nav-link">More+</a> </li> </ul> <div class="eb-header__nav__editions"> <form id="js-editionForm" action="/setedition/" method="post"> <input type="hidden" name="csrfmiddlewaretoken" value="Q5n7bGkZfzMCDyWmSBYcSBb6ti2KpG5N35p7Dk9R9DPX4WrgywUsBVnSDbOGac1s"> <input name="next" type="hidden" value="" /> <input name="region" type="hidden" value="" /> <div class="eb-dropdown"> <a href="#" data-eb-component="eb-toggle" data-eb-toggle-target="#eb-header-dropdown-3" class="header__account--action eb-dropdown-toggle" role="button"> <span class="eb-header__nav__edition-name hide-until-desktop">International</span> Edition<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-chevron-down eb-icon-chevron-down--header" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M5.22 8.72a.75.75 0 000 1.06l6.25 6.25a.75.75 0 001.06 0l6.25-6.25a.75.75 0 00-1.06-1.06L12 14.44 6.28 8.72a.75.75 0 00-1.06 0z"/></svg> </a> <ul class="eb-dropdown-menu eb-dropdown-menu-right eb-toggle-display" role="menu" id="eb-header-dropdown-3"> <li class="eb-dropdown-item"><a href="/" data-region="International" class="eb-dropdown-item-text editons--action">International</a></li> <li class="eb-dropdown-item"><a href="/asia-pacific/" data-region="Asia Pacific" class="eb-dropdown-item-text editons--action">Asia Pacific</a></li> <li class="eb-dropdown-item"><a href="/china/" data-region="China" class="eb-dropdown-item-text editons--action">China</a></li> <li class="eb-dropdown-item"><a href="/usa/" data-region="USA" class="eb-dropdown-item-text editons--action">USA</a></li> <li class="eb-dropdown-item"><a href="/europe/" data-region="Europe" class="eb-dropdown-item-text editons--action">Europe</a></li> </ul> </div> </form> </div> </div> </nav> </header> <header id="eb-stickyHeader" class="eb-header eb-header--simple eb-header--sticky" data-o-component="eb-header" data-eb-header--sticky="true" aria-hidden="true" data-eb-header--js=""> <div class="eb-header__row"> <div class="eb-header__container"> <div class="eb-header__top"> <div class="eb-header__top-column eb-header__top-column--left"> <button class="eb-btn-link eb-header__top-link eb-header__top-link--menu" type="button" title="Toggle menu" data-eb-component="eb-toggle" data-eb-toggle-target="#eb-header-drawer" aria-label="Toggle menu" aria-controls="eb-header-drawer" aria-expanded="false"> <span class="eb-header__top-link-label ">Menu</span> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon--menu eb-color-black" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20"> <path d="M17.5 6h-15c-0.276 0-0.5-0.224-0.5-0.5s0.224-0.5 0.5-0.5h15c0.276 0 0.5 0.224 0.5 0.5s-0.224 0.5-0.5 0.5z" fill="#000000"></path> <path d="M17.5 11h-15c-0.276 0-0.5-0.224-0.5-0.5s0.224-0.5 0.5-0.5h15c0.276 0 0.5 0.224 0.5 0.5s-0.224 0.5-0.5 0.5z" fill="#000000"></path> <path d="M17.5 16h-15c-0.276 0-0.5-0.224-0.5-0.5s0.224-0.5 0.5-0.5h15c0.276 0 0.5 0.224 0.5 0.5s-0.224 0.5-0.5 0.5z" fill="#000000"></path> </svg> </button> <a class="eb-header__top-logo--roundel" href="/" title="Go to the Eco-Business homepage"><svg width="30" height="30" viewBox="0 0 30 30" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"> <defs><linearGradient x1="0%" y1="50%" y2="50%" id="a"><stop stop-color="#006F84" offset="0%"/><stop stop-color="#6DB52D" offset="100%"/></linearGradient><linearGradient x1="0%" y1="50%" y2="50%" id="b"><stop stop-color="#38AAE1" offset="0%"/><stop stop-color="#2389C9" offset="41.41%"/><stop stop-color="#1674BA" offset="76.82%"/><stop stop-color="#116CB4" offset="100%"/></linearGradient></defs> <path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M23.6065 8.91951C25.3912 8.49589 26.6087 7.69337 27.3477 7.05402C24.7322 2.81863 20.0905 0 14.7976 0C6.6257 0 0 6.71513 0 15.0008C0 16.9879 0.384394 18.8832 1.07709 20.6184C1.21516 18.1159 2.46091 13.9676 7.46274 11.6401C13.6342 8.76654 20.3431 9.69693 23.6073 8.91951H23.6065Z" fill="url(#a)"/> <path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M7.56006 28.0827C9.76453 29.341 12.2593 30.0019 14.7977 30C22.9703 30 29.596 23.2849 29.596 15.0008C29.596 12.434 28.959 10.0186 27.8388 7.90597C26.5177 13.0247 21.581 27.3438 7.56006 28.0827Z" fill="url(#b)"/> <path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M13.8351 14.9796C14.3097 14.8478 15.1632 14.596 16.1932 14.3206C17.2185 14.0704 18.4651 13.6986 19.5351 13.2239C20.9112 12.6537 22.2529 12.0036 23.5532 11.2769C23.5563 11.2769 21.614 12.088 19.3711 12.7329C18.2376 13.0859 17.086 13.3016 16.0136 13.4632C14.9553 13.6452 14.061 13.8382 13.5668 13.977C12.6419 14.2595 7.12152 15.4974 4.11697 20.3454C3.50194 21.461 3.07518 22.622 2.77002 23.7328C3.16751 24.2945 3.60314 24.8281 4.07382 25.33C4.29583 23.9572 4.68571 22.4376 5.38468 21.042C5.90793 20.0003 6.62651 19.0675 7.48708 18.3968C8.43159 17.5958 9.30001 16.9839 10.1684 16.4874C11.8817 15.5115 13.3652 15.12 13.8351 14.9796V14.9796Z" fill="#858585"/> </svg> </a> </div> <div class="eb-header__top-column eb-header__top-column--center"> <ul class="eb-header__nav-list eb-header__nav-list--left"> <li class="eb-header__nav-item"> <a href="/news/" class="eb-header__nav-link">News</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item"><a href="/opinion/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Opinion</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item"><a href="/podcasts/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Podcasts</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item"><a href="/videos/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Videos</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item"><a href="/eb-studio/" class="eb-header__nav-link">EB Studio</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item hide-until-laptop"><a href="/press-releases/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Press Releases</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item hide-until-laptop"> <a href="/events/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Events</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item hide-until-laptop"><a href="/jobs/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Jobs</a></li> <li class="eb-header__nav-item hide-until-laptop"><a href="/research/" class="eb-header__nav-link">Research</a></li> </ul> <div class="eb-header__story-header"> <div class="eb-header__story-progress"> <div id="ebHeaderStoryProgressBar" class="eb-header__story-progress-bar"></div> </div> <h5 id="ebHeaderStoryHeadline" class="eb-header__story-headline"></h5> </div> </div> <div class="eb-header__top-column eb-header__top-column--right"> <div class="eb-header__top-link eb-header__top-link--cta"> <a href="/accounts/signup-options/" class="eb-button eb-button--medium eb-button--primary">Subscribe</a> </div> <a href="/accounts/login/" class="eb-header__top-link eb-header__top-link--account" title="Sign in or sign up"> <span class="eb-header__top-link-label ">Sign in</span> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon--user " width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20"> <path d="M9.5 11c-3.033 0-5.5-2.467-5.5-5.5s2.467-5.5 5.5-5.5 5.5 2.467 5.5 5.5-2.467 5.5-5.5 5.5zM9.5 1c-2.481 0-4.5 2.019-4.5 4.5s2.019 4.5 4.5 4.5c2.481 0 4.5-2.019 4.5-4.5s-2.019-4.5-4.5-4.5z" fill="#000000"></path> <path d="M17.5 20h-16c-0.827 0-1.5-0.673-1.5-1.5 0-0.068 0.014-1.685 1.225-3.3 0.705-0.94 1.67-1.687 2.869-2.219 1.464-0.651 3.283-0.981 5.406-0.981s3.942 0.33 5.406 0.981c1.199 0.533 2.164 1.279 2.869 2.219 1.211 1.615 1.225 3.232 1.225 3.3 0 0.827-0.673 1.5-1.5 1.5zM9.5 13c-3.487 0-6.060 0.953-7.441 2.756-1.035 1.351-1.058 2.732-1.059 2.746 0 0.274 0.224 0.498 0.5 0.498h16c0.276 0 0.5-0.224 0.5-0.5-0-0.012-0.023-1.393-1.059-2.744-1.382-1.803-3.955-2.756-7.441-2.756z" fill="#000000"></path> </svg> </a> </div> </div> </div> </div> </header> <div class="eb-header__drawer" data-eb-header-drawer="true" role="navigation" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1" id="eb-header-drawer"> <div class="eb-header__drawer-inner"> <div class="eb-header__drawer-tools"> <button type="button" class="eb-header__drawer-tools-close" data-eb-component="eb-toggle" data-eb-toggle-target="#eb-header-drawer" title="Close menu" aria-controls="eb-header-drawer" aria-expanded="false" tabindex="-1"> <span class="eb-header__visually-hidden">Close menu</span> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" class="eb-icon eb-icon-x "><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M5.72 5.72a.75.75 0 011.06 0L12 10.94l5.22-5.22a.75.75 0 111.06 1.06L13.06 12l5.22 5.22a.75.75 0 11-1.06 1.06L12 13.06l-5.22 5.22a.75.75 0 01-1.06-1.06L10.94 12 5.72 6.78a.75.75 0 010-1.06z"/></svg> </button> <a class="eb-header__drawer-tools-logo" href="/" tabindex="-1"> <img src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/img/eco-business-logo.cf191c09fb92.svg" alt="Eco-Business"> <span class="eb-header__visually-hidden">Eco-Business</span> </a> <p class="eb-header__drawer-current-edition">International Edition</p> </div> <div class="eb-header__drawer-subscribe"> <a class="eb-button eb-button--medium eb-button--primary" href="/accounts/signup-options/">Subscribe</a> </div> <div class="eb-header__drawer-search"> <form class="eb-header__drawer-search-form" role="search" method="get" action="/search/" id="js-eb-header__drawer-search"> <input type="hidden" name="cx" value="005424745066355598867:kyqeergnzii"> <input type="hidden" name="cof" value="FORID:10"> <input type="hidden" name="ie" value="UTF-8"> <input type="text" class="eb-header__drawer-search-term" name="q" automcomplete="off" placeholder="Search Eco-Business"> <label class="eb-header__visually-hidden" for="q"> Search Eco-Business </label> <button class="eb-header__drawer-search-submit" for="submit-google-search" type="submit"> <span class="eb-header__visually-hidden">Search</span> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="16" height="16" viewBox="0 0 16 16" class="eb-icon eb-icon-search "><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M11.5 7a4.499 4.499 0 11-8.998 0A4.499 4.499 0 0111.5 7zm-.82 4.74a6 6 0 111.06-1.06l3.04 3.04a.75.75 0 11-1.06 1.06l-3.04-3.04z"/></svg> </button> </form> </div> <nav class="eb-header__drawer-menu eb-header__drawer-menu--primary eb-header__drawer-menu--border"> <form id="js-main-menu-languagesForm" action="/i18n/setlang/" method="post"> <input type="hidden" name="csrfmiddlewaretoken" value="Q5n7bGkZfzMCDyWmSBYcSBb6ti2KpG5N35p7Dk9R9DPX4WrgywUsBVnSDbOGac1s"> <input name="next" type="hidden" value="/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/" /> <input name="language" type="hidden" value="" /> <ul class="eb-header__drawer-menu-list"> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item eb-header__drawer-menu-item--heading">Language</li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--selected" data-languagecode="en" href="#" >English</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link " data-languagecode="zh-hans" href="#" >简体中文</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link " data-languagecode="id" href="#" >Bahasa Indonesia</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link " data-languagecode="ms" href="#" >Bahasa Malaysia</a> </li> </ul> </form> <form id="js-main-menu-editionForm" action="/setedition/" method="post"> <input type="hidden" name="csrfmiddlewaretoken" value="Q5n7bGkZfzMCDyWmSBYcSBb6ti2KpG5N35p7Dk9R9DPX4WrgywUsBVnSDbOGac1s"> <input name="next" type="hidden" value="" /> <input name="region" type="hidden" value="" /> <ul class="eb-header__drawer-menu-list"> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item eb-header__drawer-menu-item--heading">Edition</li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a href="/" data-region="International" class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link">International</a></li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a href="/asia-pacific/" data-region="Asia Pacific" class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link">Asia Pacific</a></li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a href="/china/" data-region="China" class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link">China</a></li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a href="/usa/" data-region="USA" class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link">USA</a></li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a href="/europe/" data-region="Europe" class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link">Europe</a></li> </ul> </form> <ul class="eb-header__drawer-menu-list"> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item eb-header__drawer-menu-item--heading">Sections</li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/" tabindex="-1">Home</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <div class="eb-header__drawer-menu-toggle-wrapper"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/news/">News</a> <button class="eb-header__drawer-menu-toggle" aria-controls="eb-header-drawer-child-1" aria-expanded="false" tabindex="-1"> <span class="eb-normalise-visually-hidden">Show more News</span> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-chevron-down " width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M5.22 8.72a.75.75 0 000 1.06l6.25 6.25a.75.75 0 001.06 0l6.25-6.25a.75.75 0 00-1.06-1.06L12 14.44 6.28 8.72a.75.75 0 00-1.06 0z"/></svg> </button> </div> <ul class="eb-header__drawer-menu-list eb-header__drawer-menu-list--child" id="eb-header-drawer-child-1" aria-hidden="true"> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/news/industryspotlight/">Industry Spotlight</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/news/featureseries/">Feature Series</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/news/specialreport/">Special Reports</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/tags/">A-Z Tags</a> </li> </ul> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/opinion/">Opinion</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/podcasts/">Podcasts</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/videos/">Videos</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <div class="eb-header__drawer-menu-toggle-wrapper"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/about/">About Us</a> <button class="eb-header__drawer-menu-toggle" aria-controls="eb-header-drawer-child-2" aria-expanded="false" tabindex="-1"> <span class="eb-normalise-visually-hidden">Show more About us</span> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-chevron-down " width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M5.22 8.72a.75.75 0 000 1.06l6.25 6.25a.75.75 0 001.06 0l6.25-6.25a.75.75 0 00-1.06-1.06L12 14.44 6.28 8.72a.75.75 0 00-1.06 0z"/></svg> </button> </div> <ul class="eb-header__drawer-menu-list eb-header__drawer-menu-list--child" id="eb-header-drawer-child-2" aria-hidden="true"> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/about/team/">Our Team</a></li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/about/join-us/">Join Us</a></li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/about/advisoryboard/">Advisory Board</a></li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/about/contributors/">Contributors</a></li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/about/contact/">Contact Us</a></li> </ul> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/eb-studio/">EB Studio</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/press-releases/">Press Releases</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/events/">Events</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/jobs/">Jobs</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/intelligence/">Intelligence</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <div class="eb-header__drawer-menu-toggle-wrapper"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/category/">Topics</a> <button class="eb-header__drawer-menu-toggle" aria-controls="eb-header-drawer-child-3" aria-expanded="false" tabindex="-1"> <span class="eb-normalise-visually-hidden">Show more Topics</span> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-chevron-down " width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M5.22 8.72a.75.75 0 000 1.06l6.25 6.25a.75.75 0 001.06 0l6.25-6.25a.75.75 0 00-1.06-1.06L12 14.44 6.28 8.72a.75.75 0 00-1.06 0z"/></svg> </button> </div> <ul class="eb-header__drawer-menu-list eb-header__drawer-menu-list--child" id="eb-header-drawer-child-3" aria-hidden="true"> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/category/carbon-climate/"> Carbon & Climate </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/category/csr/"> CSR </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/category/cities/"> Cities </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/category/energy/"> Energy </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/category/food-agriculture/"> Food & Agriculture </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/category/green-buildings/"> Green Buildings </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/category/lifestyle/"> Lifestyle </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/category/manufacturing/"> Manufacturing </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/category/policy-finance/"> Policy & Finance </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/category/transport-logistics/"> Transport </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/category/waste-management/"> Waste </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/category/water/"> Water </a> </li> </ul> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <div class="eb-header__drawer-menu-toggle-wrapper"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/sustainable-development-goals/">Sustainable Development Goals</a> <button class="eb-header__drawer-menu-toggle" aria-controls="eb-header-drawer-child-4" aria-expanded="false" tabindex="-1"> <span class="eb-normalise-visually-hidden">Show more SDGs</span> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-chevron-down " width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M5.22 8.72a.75.75 0 000 1.06l6.25 6.25a.75.75 0 001.06 0l6.25-6.25a.75.75 0 00-1.06-1.06L12 14.44 6.28 8.72a.75.75 0 00-1.06 0z"/></svg> </button> </div> <ul class="eb-header__drawer-menu-list eb-header__drawer-menu-list--child" id="eb-header-drawer-child-4" aria-hidden="true"> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/no-poverty/"> 1. Poverty </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/zero-hunger/"> 2. Hunger </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/good-health-and-well-being/"> 3. Health </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/quality-education/"> 4. Education </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/gender-equality/"> 5. Gender equality </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/clean-water-and-sanitation/"> 6. Water </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/affordable-and-clean-energy/"> 7. Energy </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/decent-work-and-economic-growth/"> 8. Economic growth </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/industry-innovation-and-infrastructure/"> 9. Infrastructure </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/reduced-inequalities/"> 10. Inequality </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/sustainable-cities-and-communities/"> 11. Cities </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/responsible-consumption-and-production/"> 12. Consumption </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/climate-action/"> 13. Climate </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/oceans/"> 14. Oceans </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/life-land/"> 15. Biodiversity </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/peace-justice-and-strong-institutions/"> 16. Peace </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/sustainable-development-goals/partnerships-goals/"> 17. Partnerships </a> </li> </ul> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <div class="eb-header__drawer-menu-toggle-wrapper"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/region/">Regions</a> <button class="eb-header__drawer-menu-toggle" aria-controls="eb-header-drawer-child-5" aria-expanded="false" tabindex="-1"> <span class="eb-normalise-visually-hidden">Show more Regions</span> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-chevron-down " width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M5.22 8.72a.75.75 0 000 1.06l6.25 6.25a.75.75 0 001.06 0l6.25-6.25a.75.75 0 00-1.06-1.06L12 14.44 6.28 8.72a.75.75 0 00-1.06 0z"/></svg> </button> </div> <ul class="eb-header__drawer-menu-list eb-header__drawer-menu-list--child" id="eb-header-drawer-child-5" aria-hidden="true"> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/region/australia/"> Australia </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/region/china/"> China </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/region/europe/"> Europe </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/region/hong-kong/"> Hong Kong </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/region/india/"> India </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/region/indonesia/"> Indonesia </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/region/japan/"> Japan </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/region/malaysia/"> Malaysia </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/region/philippines/"> Philippines </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/region/singapore/"> Singapore </a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-header__drawer-menu-link--child" href="/region/thailand/"> Thailand </a> </li> </ul> </li> </ul> <ul class="eb-header__drawer-menu-list"> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item eb-header__drawer-menu-item--heading">Subscribe</li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/accounts/signup-options/">Eco-Business subscriptions</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/newsletters/subscribe/">Newsletters</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/dashboard/eb-enterprise/">EB Enterprise</a></li> </ul> <ul class="eb-header__drawer-menu-list"> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item eb-header__drawer-menu-item--heading">Follow Us</li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener" class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="https://www.facebook.com/EcoBusinessMedia">Facebook</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener" class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="https://twitter.com/ecobusinesscom">Twitter</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener" class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/eco-business/">Linkedin</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener" class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="https://www.instagram.com/ecobusinesscom">Instagram</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener" class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="https://t.me/ecobusinessnews">Telegram</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener" class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="https://vimeo.com/ecobusinesscom">Vimeo</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener" class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCagZ0j4TiZ8l-eQ-i2KZlqA">YouTube</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/feeds/">RSS</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <div class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link eb-wechat"> <img loading="lazy" class="eb-wechat-logo lazyload" data-src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/img/social_media/wechat-light-en.848a23759ae3.svg" alt="WeChat"> <img loading="lazy" class="eb-wechat-qr-code lazyload" data-src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/img/social_media/wechat-qr-code.dd9603531f57.png" alt="WeChat"> </div> </li> </ul> <ul class="eb-header__drawer-menu-list"> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item eb-header__drawer-menu-item--heading">EB Initiatives</li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="https://ebimpact.org/">EB Impact<br></a></li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/southeastasia-clean-energy-transition/">Southeast Asia's Clean Energy Transition</a></li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="/news/series/people/">People: Movers and shakers in sustainability</a></li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"><a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="https://changingcourse.eco-business.com/">Changing Course</a></li> </ul> <ul class="eb-header__drawer-menu-list"> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item eb-header__drawer-menu-item--heading">EB Events</li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="https://events.eco-business.com/events/the-highlights-and-hurdles-of-cop29-and-beyond">COP29 and beyond: Highlights and hurdles</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="http://events.eco-business.com/events/orange-forum-2024-sustainable-futures-through-orange">Orange Forum 2024: Sustainable Futures through Orange</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="https://www.unlockingcapitalforsustainability.com/hong-kong/2024?_gl=1*12cu3pp*_gcl_aw*R0NMLjE3MjcwODg2MTkuQ2owS0NRandvOFMzQmhEZUFSSXNBRlJta09QVmZTU0cxM1IzSXJKajl6c3JzVjRkdm9Pa0JxMThWSHRkVnk4X1Rja2c0U">Unlocking capital for sustainability 2024 - Hong Kong</a> </li> <li class="eb-header__drawer-menu-item"> <a class="eb-header__drawer-menu-link" href="https://events.eco-business.com/#utm_source=eb&utm_medium=nav&utm_campaign=ebevents">All Eco–Business events →</a> </li> </ul> </nav> </div> </div> <div class="eb-messages"> </div> <div class="eb-page-container" id="page-container"> <article id="storyArticle" class="eb-article "> <div class="eb-article-grid"> <div class="eb-article__section topic"> <span class="eb-article__section__label"> <a class="eb-article__section--action" href="/news/">News</a> </span> <span class="eb-article__section__divider"></span> <span class="eb-article__section__label"> <a class="eb-article__section--action" href="/news/series/decoding-sustainable-finance/">Decoding Sustainable Finance</a> </span> </div> <div class="eb-article__headline-wrapper"> <h1 id="ebStoryHeadline" class="eb-article__headline" data-eb-story-headline="Are biodiversity credits doomed to repeat the voluntary carbon market’s flaws?"> Are biodiversity credits doomed to repeat the voluntary carbon market’s flaws? </h1> </div> <div class="eb-article__standfirst-wrapper"> <h2 class="eb-article__standfirst">To avoid carbon credit pitfalls, the nascent market’s pioneers are keen to rule out offsetting and secondary market trading, while letting Indigenous peoples and local communities take the lead. But NGOs call the financing mechanism a “false solution to a false problem”.</h2> </div> <div class="eb-article__media"> <figure class="eb-article__featured-image"> <img src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?ar=16%3A10&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=320" alt="Koala NSW" srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?ar=16%3A10&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=320 640w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?ar=16%3A10&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=700 700w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?ar=16%3A10&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=480 960w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?ar=16%3A10&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=700 1400w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/koala_-_cropped.jpg?ar=16%3A10&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=1100 2200w" sizes="(min-width: 1300px) 1100px, (min-width: 740px) 700px, 100vw"> <figcaption id="eb-article-featured-image-caption" class="eb-article__featured-image__caption"> In 2017, Australia's New South Wales launched a scheme allowing developers to buy credits for koalas and threatened species to offset damage to their habitats. But an audit of scheme this year found that a third of the land set aside is in a worse state than before. Image: <a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/theocrazzolara/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Theo Crazzolara</a> via <a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/theocrazzolara/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Flickr</a>, <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">CC BY 2.0</a> </figcaption> <button data-eb-component="eb-toggle" data-eb-toggle-target="#eb-article-featured-image-caption" class="eb-article__caption-button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-device-camera " width="16" height="16" width="16" height="16" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M15 3H7c0-.55-.45-1-1-1H2c-.55 0-1 .45-1 1-.55 0-1 .45-1 1v9c0 .55.45 1 1 1h14c.55 0 1-.45 1-1V4c0-.55-.45-1-1-1zM6 5H2V4h4v1zm4.5 7C8.56 12 7 10.44 7 8.5S8.56 5 10.5 5 14 6.56 14 8.5 12.44 12 10.5 12zM13 8.5c0 1.38-1.13 2.5-2.5 2.5S8 9.87 8 8.5 9.13 6 10.5 6 13 7.13 13 8.5z"/></svg> </button> </figure> </div> <div class="eb-article__social-share"> <div class="eb-share" id="eb-share"> <ul class="eb-share__items"> <li class="eb-share__item"> <a title="Share on Twitter" class="eb-share__item--action eb-share__item--twitter" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Are%20biodiversity%20credits%20doomed%20to%20repeat%20the%20voluntary%20carbon%20market%E2%80%99s%20flaws&url=https://eb.news/Di9vs_1tSB2A&via=ecobusinesscom"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-twitter " viewBox="0 0 20 20"> <path d="M17.316,6.246c0.008,0.162,0.011,0.326,0.011,0.488c0,4.99-3.797,10.742-10.74,10.742c-2.133,0-4.116-0.625-5.787-1.697 c0.296,0.035,0.596,0.053,0.9,0.053c1.77,0,3.397-0.604,4.688-1.615c-1.651-0.031-3.046-1.121-3.526-2.621 c0.23,0.043,0.467,0.066,0.71,0.066c0.345,0,0.679-0.045,0.995-0.131c-1.727-0.348-3.028-1.873-3.028-3.703c0-0.016,0-0.031,0-0.047 c0.509,0.283,1.092,0.453,1.71,0.473c-1.013-0.678-1.68-1.832-1.68-3.143c0-0.691,0.186-1.34,0.512-1.898 C3.942,5.498,6.725,7,9.862,7.158C9.798,6.881,9.765,6.594,9.765,6.297c0-2.084,1.689-3.773,3.774-3.773 c1.086,0,2.067,0.457,2.756,1.191c0.859-0.17,1.667-0.484,2.397-0.916c-0.282,0.881-0.881,1.621-1.66,2.088 c0.764-0.092,1.49-0.293,2.168-0.594C18.694,5.051,18.054,5.715,17.316,6.246z"/> </svg> </a> </li> <li class="eb-share__item"> <a title="Share on Facebook" class="eb-share__item--action eb-share__item--facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?s=100&u=https://eb.news/Di9vs_1tSB2A"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-facebook " viewBox="0 0 20 20"> <path d="M17,1H3C1.9,1,1,1.9,1,3v14c0,1.101,0.9,2,2,2h7v-7H8V9.525h2V7.475c0-2.164,1.212-3.684,3.766-3.684l1.803,0.002v2.605 h-1.197C13.378,6.398,13,7.144,13,7.836v1.69h2.568L15,12h-2v7h4c1.1,0,2-0.899,2-2V3C19,1.9,18.1,1,17,1z"/> </svg> </a> </li> <li class="eb-share__item"> <a title="Share on LinkedIn" class="eb-share__item--action eb-share__item--linkedin" href="https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://eb.news/Di9vs_1tSB2A&title=Are%20biodiversity%20credits%20doomed%20to%20repeat%20the%20voluntary%20carbon%20market%E2%80%99s%20flaws&summary="><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-linkedin " viewBox="0 0 20 20"><path d="m5 3c0 1.062-.71 1.976-2.001 1.976-1.215 0-1.999-.862-1.999-1.924 0-1.09.76-2.052 2-2.052s1.976.91 2 2zm-4 16v-13h4v13z"/><path d="m7 10.444c0-1.545-.051-2.836-.102-3.951h3.594l.178 1.723h.076c.506-.811 1.746-2 3.822-2 2.532 0 4.432 1.695 4.432 5.342v7.442h-4v-6.861c0-1.594-.607-2.81-2-2.81-1.062 0-1.594.86-1.873 1.569-.102.254-.127.608-.127.963v7.139h-4z"/></svg> </a> </li> <li class="eb-share__item"> <a title="Share on Reddit" class="eb-share__item--action eb-share__item--reddit" href="https://www.reddit.com/submit?url=https://eb.news/Di9vs_1tSB2A"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-twitter " viewBox="0 0 172 172"> <g id="Page-1" stroke="none" stroke-width="1" fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd"> <g id="Reddit_Mark_OnWhite" transform="translate(-85.000000, -85.000000)" fill-rule="nonzero"> <g id="Artwork" transform="translate(85.400000, 85.400000)"> <g id="Group" transform="translate(0.000000, 0.000000)"> <circle id="reddit-circle" fill="#000000" cx="85.5" cy="85.5" r="85.5"></circle> <path d="M142.5,85.5 C142.5,78.6 136.9,73 130,73 C126.6,73 123.6,74.3 121.4,76.5 C112.9,70.4 101.1,66.4 88.1,65.9 L93.8,39.2 L112.3,43.1 C112.5,47.8 116.4,51.6 121.2,51.6 C126.1,51.6 130.1,47.6 130.1,42.7 C130.1,37.8 126.1,33.8 121.2,33.8 C117.7,33.8 114.7,35.8 113.3,38.8 L92.6,34.4 C92,34.3 91.4,34.4 90.9,34.7 C90.4,35 90.1,35.5 89.9,36.1 L83.6,65.9 C70.3,66.3 58.4,70.2 49.8,76.5 C47.6,74.4 44.5,73 41.2,73 C34.3,73 28.7,78.6 28.7,85.5 C28.7,90.6 31.7,94.9 36.1,96.9 C35.9,98.1 35.8,99.4 35.8,100.7 C35.8,119.9 58.1,135.4 85.7,135.4 C113.3,135.4 135.6,119.9 135.6,100.7 C135.6,99.4 135.5,98.2 135.3,97 C139.4,95 142.5,90.6 142.5,85.5 Z M57,94.4 C57,89.5 61,85.5 65.9,85.5 C70.8,85.5 74.8,89.5 74.8,94.4 C74.8,99.3 70.8,103.3 65.9,103.3 C61,103.3 57,99.3 57,94.4 Z M106.7,117.9 C100.6,124 89,124.4 85.6,124.4 C82.2,124.4 70.5,123.9 64.5,117.9 C63.6,117 63.6,115.5 64.5,114.6 C65.4,113.7 66.9,113.7 67.8,114.6 C71.6,118.4 79.8,119.8 85.7,119.8 C91.6,119.8 99.7,118.4 103.6,114.6 C104.5,113.7 106,113.7 106.9,114.6 C107.6,115.6 107.6,117 106.7,117.9 Z M105.1,103.3 C100.2,103.3 96.2,99.3 96.2,94.4 C96.2,89.5 100.2,85.5 105.1,85.5 C110,85.5 114,89.5 114,94.4 C114,99.3 110,103.3 105.1,103.3 Z" id="reddit-robot" fill="#FFFFFF"></path> </g> </g> </g> </g> </svg> </a> </li> <li class="eb-share__item"> <a title="Share on Flipboard" class="eb-share__item--action eb-share__item--flipboard" href="https://share.flipboard.com/bookmarklet/popout?url=https://eb.news/Di9vs_1tSB2A&title=Are%20biodiversity%20credits%20doomed%20to%20repeat%20the%20voluntary%20carbon%20market%E2%80%99s%20flaws"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-flipboard " viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M0,0 L0,24 L24,24 L24,0 L0,0 Z M19.2,9.6 L14.4,9.6 L14.4,14.4 L9.6,14.4 L9.6,19.2 L4.8,19.2 L4.8,4.8 L19.2,4.8 L19.2,9.6 Z"/></svg> </a> </li> <li title="Copy short URL" class="eb-share__item"> <a class="eb-share__item--action eb-share__item--link" href="#" title="Toggle shortlink URL" aria-controls="eb-share-shortlink" aria-label="Toggle search" aria-expanded="false"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="eb-icon eb-icon-link " width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M14.78 3.653a3.936 3.936 0 115.567 5.567l-3.627 3.627a3.936 3.936 0 01-5.88-.353.75.75 0 00-1.18.928 5.436 5.436 0 008.12.486l3.628-3.628a5.436 5.436 0 10-7.688-7.688l-3 3a.75.75 0 001.06 1.061l3-3z"/><path d="M7.28 11.153a3.936 3.936 0 015.88.353.75.75 0 001.18-.928 5.436 5.436 0 00-8.12-.486L2.592 13.72a5.436 5.436 0 107.688 7.688l3-3a.75.75 0 10-1.06-1.06l-3 3a3.936 3.936 0 01-5.567-5.568l3.627-3.627z"/></svg> </a> </li> <div class="eb-share__shortlink" id="eb-share-shortlink" data-eb-share-shortlink="true" aria-hidden="true"> <div class="eb-share__shortlink-url" data-short-link="https://eb.news/Di9vs_1tSB2A">https://eb.news/Di9vs_1tSB2A</div> <button class="eb-share__shortlink-copy"> <span class="eb-normalise-visually-hidden">Copy</span> <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="16" height="16" viewBox="0 0 16 16" class="eb-icon eb-icon-search "><path fill-rule="evenodd" d="M5.75 1a.75.75 0 00-.75.75v3c0 .414.336.75.75.75h4.5a.75.75 0 00.75-.75v-3a.75.75 0 00-.75-.75h-4.5zm.75 3V2.5h3V4h-3zm-2.874-.467a.75.75 0 00-.752-1.298A1.75 1.75 0 002 3.75v9.5c0 .966.784 1.75 1.75 1.75h8.5A1.75 1.75 0 0014 13.25v-9.5a1.75 1.75 0 00-.874-1.515.75.75 0 10-.752 1.298.25.25 0 01.126.217v9.5a.25.25 0 01-.25.25h-8.5a.25.25 0 01-.25-.25v-9.5a.25.25 0 01.126-.217z"/></svg> </button> </div> </ul> </div> </div> <div class="eb-article__meta"> <div class="eb-article__byline"> <div class="eb-article__byline__author"> <div class="eb-article__byline__author-name"> By <a class="author-link" href="/about/profile/45912/">Gabrielle See</a> </div> </div> <div class="eb-article__meta__time"> 10 minute read <span class="eb-article__meta__divider"></span> <time class="eb-article__byline__publish-date" datetime="Oct. 22, 2024, 4:12 p.m.">Oct. 22, 2024</time> </div> </div> </div> <div class="eb-article__body"> <section class="eb-article__body-content"> <div class="subscriber_wall__lede"> <p><span style="font-weight: 400;"><a href="https://www.eco-business.com/tags/carbon-credits/">Carbon credits</a>’ younger siblings, biodiversity credits, are having a moment.</span></p> <div class="subscriber_wall__second-paragraph-overlay"></div> </div> <div class="subscriber_wall" id="js-subscriberWall"> <div class="subscriber_wall__login"> Already subscribed? <a href="/accounts/login/?next=/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/&sw-login=true">Sign in</a> </div> <div class="subscriber_wall__subscribe"> <h3 class="subscriber_wall__subscribe-title">To continue reading, subscribe to Eco‑Business.</h3> <h4 class="subscriber_wall__subscribe-sub-title">There's something for everyone. We offer a range of subscription plans.</h4> <div class="subscriber_wall__cta"> <a class="eb-button eb-button--large eb-button--primary" href="/accounts/signup-options/?prev=/news/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/&sw-signup=true">Subscribe now → </a> </div> <ul class="subscriber_wall__feature_list"> <li class="subscriber_wall__feature_list_item">Access our stories and receive our Insights Weekly newsletter with the free EB Member plan.</li> <li class="subscriber_wall__feature_list_item">Unlock unlimited access to our content and archive with EB Circle.</li> <li class="subscriber_wall__feature_list_item">Publish your content with EB Premium.</li> </ul> </div> </div> <div class="subscriber-wall"><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Dozens of schemes for this nascent market have sprung up since 2022, after the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework (GBF) was passed at the last United Nations (UN) biodiversity summit. </span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Apart from the landmark goal to preserve 30 per cent of the Earth’s lands and oceans by 2030, the GBF text also called for “at least US$200 billion per year” to be mobilised from both public and private sources, including from novel mechanisms like biodiversity credits.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Despite not being officially on the agenda for COP16 which kicked off on Monday, the emerging instrument is set to be a key discussion topic on the sidelines.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">For instance, the United Kingdom (UK) and France-led International Advisory Panel on Biodiversity Credits (IAPB), the UN-backed Biodiversity Credit Alliance (BCA) and the World Economic Forum (WEF) are launching their finalised biodiversity crdits framework – underpinned by 21 “high-integrity” principles – on 28 October alongside 30 pilot projects worldwide, after an over a year-long consultation process. </span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">But in the environmental space, “credits” – which recalls the beleaguered voluntary carbon market (VCM) – has become a loaded and divisive term. </span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Proponents of biodiversity credits, who often overlap with carbon market supporters, argue that they must be on the table to close the GBF’s estimated annual biodiversity financing gap of US$700 billion. Meanwhile, detractors have called the novel financing mechanism a “<a href="https://www.biodmarketwatch.info/">false solution to a false problem</a>” that will delay action on biodiversity loss, just as carbon offsetting has delayed ambitious climate action.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">But there seems to be broad consensus between these two groups that biodiversity markets must avoid the pitfalls of the carbon markets – which have historically allowed the largest polluters to offset their climate-warming emissions and have not equitably shared project revenues with Indigenous peoples and local communities. </span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">What lessons should be learned from the carbon markets, and are “high-integrity” biodiversity credits within reach? We ask experts if guardrails being suggested in emerging schemes are sufficient to avoid replicating the VCM’s flaws.</span></p><h4>What is a biodiversity credit?</h4><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Biodiversity credits – which are designed to represent a unit of improvement of nature enabled by a project in a defined area, measured over a period of time – might seem like a relatively new idea adapted from the carbon markets, but developed countries have been experimenting with biodiversity markets for decades.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Even before the WEF’s 2022 initiative to explore the potential of biodiversity credits, the United States (US) has operated biodiversity markets </span><a href="https://www.ecosystemmarketplace.com/articles/biodiversity-banking-a-primer/"><span style="font-weight: 400;">worth over US$3 billion a year</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> since the mid-1980s. Regulations requiring developers to offset or compensate for any damage to the wetlands which were deemed unavoidable, created a market for wetland mitigation bankers to profit off buying wetland areas to create, enhance and restore, to generate “wetland credits” for needy developers. Canada similarly employed offsetting as a wetland conservation tool in the same period.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">In 2017, an Australian state introduced the Biodiversity Offsets Scheme, which allowed developers to buy credits for koalas and other threatened species to offset damage to their habitats. However, an </span><a href="https://www.dcceew.gov.au/sites/default/files/documents/ground-truthing-offsets-summary-report.pdf"><span style="font-weight: 400;">audit of the scheme</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> in June found that a third of the land set aside is in a worse state than before.</span></p><div class="story-image"><img alt="NSW Biodiversity Offsets Sheme" class="lazyload" data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Screenshot_2024-10-22_040124.png?auto=format&dpr=2&fit=max&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&w=680" loading="lazy" src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Screenshot_2024-10-22_040124.png?auto=format&dpr=2&fit=max&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&w=680"/> <p class="caption">Koala credits are going for A$450 (US$342) while Emu credits are being sold at A$4,000 (US$3,038) on New South Wales (NSW)’s Biodiversity Offsets Scheme. Image: <a href="https://app.powerbi.com/view?r=eyJrIjoiZWI3MmZhMTctZGVjNi00ZTdlLTkwZTEtOGY4NWNhYjc3M2RiIiwidCI6Ijk2ZWY4ODIxLTJhMzktNDcxYy1iODlhLTY3YjA4MzNkZDNiOSJ9">NSW Government</a></p> </div><p>To date, at least 10 standard setters <span style="font-weight: 400;">– including the world’s biggest carbon credits certifier Verra, which is due to publish its own nature credits framework this year – </span>and 50 schemes have emerged.</p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Climate advisory and investment firm Pollination </span><a href="https://pollinationgroup.com/global-perspectives/state-of-voluntary-biodiversity-credit-markets/"><span style="font-weight: 400;">recently estimated</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;">, through a survey with 16 major credit suppliers, that between US$325,000 and US$1.85 million worth of voluntary biodiversity credits have been sold globally.</span></p><p> </p><div class="story-image"><img alt="Map from Pollination’s State of Voluntary BIodiversity Credit Markets 2023" class="lazyload" data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Screenshot_2024-10-21_183928.png?auto=format&dpr=2&fit=max&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&w=680" loading="lazy" src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Screenshot_2024-10-21_183928.png?auto=format&dpr=2&fit=max&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&w=680"/> <p class="caption">Image: Pollination’s State of Voluntary BIodiversity Credit Markets 2023</p> </div><h4><strong>What does a “high-integrity” biodiversity market look like?</strong></h4><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Pollination’s executive director Laura Waterford, who compared eight different biodiversity credit schemes last year, told Eco-Business that she would hesitate to say that a clear winner is emerging.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“What our review found was that they each had different strengths, and some of them were doing really well in some areas of high-integrity considerations, but fell short in others,” she said.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">The majority of those reviewed lacked clarity on the specific indicators that should be used to quantify improvements in biodiversity outcomes, while some did not specify the auditing approach for the data being tracked.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Waterford noted that the UK-based GreenCollar’s NaturePlus scheme, which commissioned Pollination’s report to review its scheme alongside others, has done a thorough job addressing most high-integrity considerations, which include ensuring the scheme is supported by a registry that tracks the issuance and retirement of credits, ensures long-term, additional biodiversity outcomes, and addresses whether credits can be sold on a secondary market.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Last week, GreenCollar also announced that its scheme will now be independently administered by a third-party called Accounting for Nature, in line with Pollination’s recommendations to have separate entities acting as project developers and scheme developers to address potential conflicts of interest, said Waterford.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“In the early days, many of the project developers were also the scheme administrators when they were in the test and pilot phase. We made the point that in order to have confidence in the outcomes, we needed to see a separation between those roles.”</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">A quick scan by Eco-Business found that two of the 10 major biodiversity credit standard setters – UK’s Biodiversity Future Initiatives and Columbia’s Terrasos – who are methodology developers also double-hat as project developers:</span></p><div class="story-image"><img alt="Standard setters for biocredits" class="lazyload" data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Screenshot_2024-10-22_110123.png?auto=format&dpr=2&fit=max&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&w=680" loading="lazy" src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Screenshot_2024-10-22_110123.png?auto=format&dpr=2&fit=max&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&w=680"/> <p class="caption">Image: Gabrielle See/ Eco-Business</p> </div><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Waterford said that in ascending order of rigour, the three large buckets that most biodiversity metrics fall under are: vegetation as a proxy of overall biodiversity outcomes, habitat value of specific species as well as an ecosystem, or “basket-of-metrics”, approach, which selects a defined set of metrics most relevant to a project’s landscape.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">While a highly-specific measurement of outcomes may be ideal from an integrity perspective, she added that this also makes the project design more expensive, which may hamper the growth of demand for these credits.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“It’s probably going to be one of those three ways that becomes the dominant market approach. But we’re just not quite sure where exactly the sweet spot is going to be yet in terms of the willingness to pay versus desire for really thorough data,” she said.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">There is high-level agreement among market players as well as environmental groups that a high-integrity biodiversity credit market must depart from the voluntary carbon market by ruling out international offsetting and secondary market trading, while shifting the leadership from brokers and developers in the Global North to Indigenous peoples and local communities in the Global South.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">For instance, 88 per cent of suppliers surveyed by Pollination said their scheme is intended to support the issuance of biodiversity credits only, not biodiversity offsets. </span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">In addition, IAPB recently ruled out an international biodiversity offset market and secondary trading, and is now advocating for “regulated local to local offsets with policy-driven demand,” said Simon Zadek, co-chief executive of non-profit NatureFinance, one of the IAPB working group co-leads, in a LinkedIn post.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">While Eddie Game, lead scientist and director of conservation at US-based non-profit The Nature Conservancy (TNC), which is an active member of the IAPB, has been “really pleased” at the progress the group has made, Game said that TNC remains “uncomfortable” that their recommendations still allow for voluntary, non-regulated credit systems.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Game, who is developing TNC’s position statement on biodiversity credits, said that </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">“<a href="https://www.eco-business.com/news/there-shouldnt-be-an-international-tradeable-unit-of-biodiversity-the-nature-conservancy-ceo/">like for like offsets</a>”</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> should still be allowed to happen, albeit as a last resort and under a compliance market after following through the mitigation hierarchy where an entity has first tried to minimise its environmental impact.</span></p><p>He clarified that TNC is nonetheless in favour of a voluntary biodiversity “certificate”, as opposed to an offset, but it has to contribute to pre-identified national outcomes, like in the case of Australia’s Nature Repair Market, which is set to launch in 2025 as the world’s first government-run voluntary biodiversity market.</p><p>While Frederic Hache, lecturer in sustainable finance, Paris Institute for Political Studies and founder, Green Finance Observatory, saw IAPB’s announced ban on secondary market trading as “a very welcome development”, since local offsetting is arguably less problematic than global offsetting, he said it remains to be seen if the final guidance will follow a “like for like” or “like for better” principle. </p><p>The UK’s biodiversity credit scheme is an example of the latter, where developers are allowed to purchase offsets from preserving biodiversity elsewhere to meet its mandatory requirements to deliver at least a 10 per cent gain in biodiversity, which Hache said poses an integrity risk since it relies on weak equivalences to create tradable credits.</p><p>Hache also maintained that offsetting, which has proven to be “very problematic” in the carbon markets, should remain strictly voluntary. “If you make [offsetting] regulatory, it will arguably take a bigger space within the policy mix, which displaces environmental regulation,” he said.</p><p>Simon Counsell, an advisor to London-based human rights charity Survival International and former director of Rainforest Foundation UK, is less optimistic that IAPB will have the power to uphold some of these promises.</p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“Who exactly is going to stop there being a global market?,” said Counsell. “One of the strongest – and to me, the most concerning – similarities with the carbon markets is that some of the key players in the carbon markets are now getting very much involved in the biodiversity credit markets. Standard setters like Verra, Plan Vivo and Cercarbono.”</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“These have always been global actors, and there’s absolutely no reason why they should recognise any kind of local or regional limits to their activities,” he said, adding that secondary markets are inevitable, once various organisations become dependent on the selling and trading or credits. </span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">But Waterford said that greenwashing litigation could act as a strong deterrent for flouting what standards have stated in black and white, such as preventing the use of credits as offsets. </span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Game also emphasised the need to design biodiversity schemes from the outset such that Indigenous peoples and local communities – who have almost unanimously rejected offsets – can participate in the market on their own terms. </span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“As soon as the system becomes so difficult to navigate as you have a lot of developers taking a big revenue cut from a biodiversity project because they are bearing the upfront cost of its development, then we’re going to fall straight into the cycle that the carbon market is in,” he said.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Relatedly, the cost of monitoring and verification, which is prohibitively high in the carbon market, needs to be brought down so that smaller patches of land that are owned by communities or individuals can register as projects. </span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Game also believes that it is possible to bring down the cost of tracking more complicated ecosystem metrics through automated systems like acoustics or remote-sensing technologies.</span></p><h4><strong>Do we really need biodiversity markets?</strong></h4><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">But Counsell said that there is a cheaper solution than what Game is proposing: to recognise Indigenous lands.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“Helping local communities to protect their community forests or preserves is not that expensive. If you look at those kinds of solutions on a much bigger scale… then the cost [for biodiversity financing] will be much less than the kinds of figures that TNC are suggesting. If the costs are much lower, then perhaps they are affordable without having to resort to these very unreliable, market-based solutions,” said Counsell.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Over 270 civil society groups and academics worldwide, including Survival International and Green Finance Observatory, have </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">expressed “grave concerns”</span><span style="font-weight: 400;"> regarding biodiversity credits. Instead, they have suggested reforming and redirecting harmful subsidies – which amount to </span><a href="https://www.earthtrack.net/blog/environmentally-harmful-subsidies-update-26-trillionyear-and-continuing-threat-nature"><span style="font-weight: 400;">at least US$2.6 trillion a year</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> – as well as providing public financing in the form of grants as lower risk and more effective alternatives.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">While Game recognised that “the biggest thing” we could do for nature is to remove harmful subsidies, he believes market-based mechanisms could shift things along faster.</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“I suspect the reason why biodiversity credits are on the agenda, and massive subsidy reforms are not, is because the subsidy reforms are really difficult,” he said. “Markets are both a hope for something new that will be easier, because initially it’ll basically be people choosing to participate in it… and it will be a slightly easier lift than unpicking the global system of subsidies.”</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Counsell, however, argued that “if the likes of very influential and powerful organisations like TNC tried a little bit harder to do something about these subsidies, rather than emphasising the market solutions all the time, then perhaps we will get somewhere.”</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“And it isn’t just TNC, it’s all of the big international conservation organisations: WWF, Wildlife Conservation Society, Conservation International and so on.”</span></p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Ultimately, Hache said that biodiversity credit proponents need to answer this question: Why do we need a market?</span></p><p>Recounting an exchange he had with a Europe-based natural capital investment platform’s chief executive after he made a speech about wanting to help poor farmers in Asia, he said: “I told him, ‘Before we move there, first explain to me where is the need for a market?’ And he had no answer.”</p><p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“According to the UN, there is a need to increase funding by US$200 billion annually. This can be easily achieved by redirecting a fraction of the annual </span><a href="https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/climatechange/publication/detox-development"><span style="font-weight: 400;">US$6 trillion of implicit harmful subsidies</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;">. There is absolutely no need to create a market. End of the story, move on, this is bullshit framing.”</span></p></div> </section> <div class="eb-article__sub-meta"><div class="eb-article__meta-categories"><h3 class="eb-container__header__title"><span class="eb-container__title__text">Related to this story</span></h3><h5 class="eb-article__meta-categories__title">Topics</h5><ul class="eb-article__meta-categories__list"><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/category/carbon-climate/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">Carbon & Climate</a></li><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/category/policy-finance/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">Policy & Finance</a></li></ul><h5 class="eb-article__meta-categories__title">Regions</h5><ul class="eb-article__meta-categories__list"><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/region/asia-pacific/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">Asia Pacific</a></li></ul><h5 class="eb-article__meta-categories__title">Tags</h5><ul class="eb-article__meta-categories__list"><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/tags/biodiversity/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">biodiversity</a></li><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/tags/carbon-credits/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">carbon credits</a></li><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/tags/carbon-trading/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">carbon trading</a></li><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/tags/financing/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">financing</a></li><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/tags/greenwashing/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">greenwashing</a></li><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/tags/regulation/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">regulation</a></li><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/tags/conservation/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">conservation</a></li><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/tags/nature-based-solutions/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">nature-based solutions</a></li><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/tags/nature/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">nature</a></li></ul><h5 class="eb-article__meta-categories__title">SDGs</h5><ul class="eb-article__meta-categories__list"><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/sustainable-development-goals/climate-action/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">13. Climate</a></li><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/sustainable-development-goals/oceans/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">14. Oceans</a></li><li class="eb-article__meta-categories__list-item"><a href="/sustainable-development-goals/life-land/" class="eb-article__meta-categories__link">15. Biodiversity</a></li></ul></div></div> <div id="dfp-ad-inline1" class="js-ad-slot ad-slot ad-slot--dfp ad-slot--inline"> <div id="div-gpt-ad-1362455821085-0" class="ad-slot__ad" data-sizes='[[300,250],[300,100]]' data-dfp="TEST-R1"></div> </div> </div> <div class="eb-article__right-column"> <div id="dfp-ad-inline2" class="js-ad-slot ad-slot ad-slot--dfp ad-slot--mpu-banner-ad ad-slot--not-mobile"> <div id="div-gpt-ad-1362455907091-0" class="ad-slot__ad" data-sizes='[[300,250],[300,100]]' data-dfp="TEST-R2"></div> </div> <div class="eb-story-list"> <h3 class="eb-story-list__title"> <span class="eb-story-list__title-text">Most popular</span> </h3> <ul class="eb-story-list__items"> <li class="eb-item eb-item--has-image eb-item--list--media-square-mobile eb-item--list-media-square-tablet eb-item--section-news eb-item--news-small"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__media-wrapper"> <div class="eb-item__image-container u-responsive-ratio u-responsive-ratio--square"> <picture> <source media="(min-width: 0px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 0px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="82x" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Protester_COP29.png?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=82 82w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px)" sizes="82px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Protester_COP29.png?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=82 82w"> <img data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Protester_COP29.png?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=82" loading="lazy" class="lazyload " alt="COP29 protester"> </picture> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> News / <span class="eb-item__sub-title--normal"> Policy & Finance </span> </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/news/philippines-malaysia-stand-ground-against-accepting-bilateral-loan-offers-from-rich-countries-insist-on-climate-financing/" class="eb-item__link"> Philippines, Malaysia stand ground against accepting bilateral loan offers from rich countries; insist on climate financing </a> </h3> </div> <div class="eb-item__standfirst"> <span class="eb-labels eb-labels--inline eb-labels--exclusive">Exclusive</span> As COP29 enters the final stretch, some developing countries are being approached by rich countries to agree on … </div> </div> <a href="/news/philippines-malaysia-stand-ground-against-accepting-bilateral-loan-offers-from-rich-countries-insist-on-climate-financing/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">Philippines, Malaysia stand ground against accepting bilateral loan offers from rich countries; insist on climate financing</a> </div> </li> <li class="eb-item eb-item--has-image eb-item--list--media-square-mobile eb-item--list-media-square-tablet eb-item--section-news eb-item--news-small"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__media-wrapper"> <div class="eb-item__image-container u-responsive-ratio u-responsive-ratio--square"> <picture> <source media="(min-width: 0px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 0px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="82x" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/008_RT2024_Press_Con_.jpg?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=82 82w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px)" sizes="82px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/008_RT2024_Press_Con_.jpg?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=82 82w"> <img data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/008_RT2024_Press_Con_.jpg?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=82" loading="lazy" class="lazyload " alt="New RSPO-certified smallholder groups 2024"> </picture> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> News / <span class="eb-item__sub-title--normal"> Food & Agriculture </span> </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/news/new-sustainable-palm-oil-rules-win-consensus-amid-rspo-credit-price-slump/" class="eb-item__link"> New sustainable palm oil rules win consensus amid RSPO credit price slump </a> </h3> </div> <div class="eb-item__standfirst"> The Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil’s updated standards aim to improve smallholder inclusion as EUDR kicks in. But … </div> </div> <a href="/news/new-sustainable-palm-oil-rules-win-consensus-amid-rspo-credit-price-slump/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">New sustainable palm oil rules win consensus amid RSPO credit price slump</a> </div> </li> <li class="eb-item eb-item--has-image eb-item--list--media-square-mobile eb-item--list-media-square-tablet eb-item--section-opinion eb-item--opinion-small"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__media-wrapper"> <div class="eb-item__image-container u-responsive-ratio u-responsive-ratio--square"> <picture> <source media="(min-width: 0px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 0px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="82x" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/EBA_so-called_reforestation_in_the_Samling_Lana_LPF_Fiona_McAlpine_The_Borneo_Project_August_2024.JPG?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=82 82w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px)" sizes="82px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/EBA_so-called_reforestation_in_the_Samling_Lana_LPF_Fiona_McAlpine_The_Borneo_Project_August_2024.JPG?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=82 82w"> <img data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/EBA_so-called_reforestation_in_the_Samling_Lana_LPF_Fiona_McAlpine_The_Borneo_Project_August_2024.JPG?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=82" loading="lazy" class="lazyload " alt="Samling deforestation"> </picture> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> Opinion / <span class="eb-item__sub-title--normal"> Food & Agriculture </span> </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/opinion/plantations-are-not-forests/" class="eb-item__link"> Plantations are not forests </a> </h3> </div> <div class="eb-item__standfirst"> Sarawak's so-called green revolution is little more than a wolf in sheep’s clothing. Companies and the state government … </div> </div> <a href="/opinion/plantations-are-not-forests/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">Plantations are not forests</a> </div> </li> <li class="eb-item eb-item--has-image eb-item--list--media-square-mobile eb-item--list-media-square-tablet eb-item--section-news eb-item--news-small"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__media-wrapper"> <div class="eb-item__image-container u-responsive-ratio u-responsive-ratio--square"> <picture> <source media="(min-width: 0px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 0px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="82x" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/COP29_Day_7.jpg?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=82 82w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px)" sizes="82px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/COP29_Day_7.jpg?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=82 82w"> <img data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/COP29_Day_7.jpg?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=82" loading="lazy" class="lazyload " alt="NCQG adoption"> </picture> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> News / <span class="eb-item__sub-title--normal"> Policy & Finance </span> </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/news/climate-talks-avoid-collapse-with-last-hour-us300-billion-deal-seen-as-dissatisfactory-by-developing-states/" class="eb-item__link"> Climate talks avoid collapse with last-hour US$300 billion deal seen as dissatisfactory by developing states </a> </h3> </div> <div class="eb-item__standfirst"> COP29 talks – running into overtime – concluded over the weekend with a signed deal to triple the … </div> </div> <a href="/news/climate-talks-avoid-collapse-with-last-hour-us300-billion-deal-seen-as-dissatisfactory-by-developing-states/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">Climate talks avoid collapse with last-hour US$300 billion deal seen as dissatisfactory by developing states</a> </div> </li> <li class="eb-item eb-item--has-image eb-item--list--media-square-mobile eb-item--list-media-square-tablet eb-item--section-news eb-item--news-small"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__media-wrapper"> <div class="eb-item__image-container u-responsive-ratio u-responsive-ratio--square"> <picture> <source media="(min-width: 0px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 0px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="82x" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/54143956255_c8e3219c8c_5k.jpg?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=82 82w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px)" sizes="82px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/54143956255_c8e3219c8c_5k.jpg?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=82 82w"> <img data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/54143956255_c8e3219c8c_5k.jpg?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=82" loading="lazy" class="lazyload " alt="COP29_YACAP_Youth_Activist_Filipino"> </picture> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> News / <span class="eb-item__sub-title--normal"> Energy </span> </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/news/southeast-asias-mineral-boom-for-renewable-energy-sparks-social-unrest/" class="eb-item__link"> Southeast Asia’s mineral boom for renewable energy sparks social unrest </a> </h3> </div> <div class="eb-item__standfirst"> Global Witness warns that mining for green energy is fuelling conflict and human rights abuses in Asia and … </div> </div> <a href="/news/southeast-asias-mineral-boom-for-renewable-energy-sparks-social-unrest/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">Southeast Asia’s mineral boom for renewable energy sparks social unrest</a> </div> </li> <li class="eb-item eb-item--has-image eb-item--list--media-square-mobile eb-item--list-media-square-tablet eb-item--section-news eb-item--news-small"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__media-wrapper"> <div class="eb-item__image-container u-responsive-ratio u-responsive-ratio--square"> <picture> <source media="(min-width: 0px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 0px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="82x" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/IMG_6110_J9ySHSR.png?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=82 82w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px)" sizes="82px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/IMG_6110_J9ySHSR.png?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=82 82w"> <img data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/IMG_6110_J9ySHSR.png?ar=1%3A1&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=82" loading="lazy" class="lazyload " alt="cop29 ff phase out"> </picture> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> News / <span class="eb-item__sub-title--normal"> Carbon & Climate </span> </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/news/methane-reductions-what-southeast-asias-corporates-are-asking-for-at-cop29/" class="eb-item__link"> Methane reductions: what Southeast Asia’s corporates are asking for at COP29 </a> </h3> </div> <div class="eb-item__standfirst"> The region’s fossil fuel producers called for reduced methane emissions, even as civil society criticised the high proportion … </div> </div> <a href="/news/methane-reductions-what-southeast-asias-corporates-are-asking-for-at-cop29/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">Methane reductions: what Southeast Asia’s corporates are asking for at COP29</a> </div> </li> </ul> </div> <div class="eb-story-list eb-story-list--events"> <h3 class="eb-story-list__title"> <span class="eb-story-list__title-text">Featured Events</span> </h3> <ul class="eb-story-list__items eb-story-list__items--events"> <li class="eb-item eb-item--no-image eb-item--has-metadata eb-item--list-mobile-client-content eb-item--list-tablet-client-content eb-item--section-events" data-item-num="1"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> Sunway Resort Hotel, Malaysia </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/events/sustainable-action-conference-2024-20/" class="eb-item__link"> Sustainable Action Conference 2024 (2.0) </a> </h3> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__meta"> 21 Nov 2024 • <span class="eb-item__meta--bold">Conference</span> </div> <a href="/events/sustainable-action-conference-2024-20/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">Sustainable Action Conference 2024 (2.0)</a> </div> </li> <li class="eb-item eb-item--no-image eb-item--has-metadata eb-item--list-mobile-client-content eb-item--list-tablet-client-content eb-item--section-events" data-item-num="2"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> Singapore </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/events/orange-forum-2024-sustainable-futures-through-orange/" class="eb-item__link"> Orange Forum 2024: Sustainable Futures through Orange </a> </h3> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__meta"> 10 Dec 2024 • <span class="eb-item__meta--bold">Conference</span> </div> <a href="/events/orange-forum-2024-sustainable-futures-through-orange/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">Orange Forum 2024: Sustainable Futures through Orange</a> </div> </li> <li class="eb-item eb-item--no-image eb-item--has-metadata eb-item--list-mobile-client-content eb-item--list-tablet-client-content eb-item--section-events" data-item-num="3"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> Hong Kong </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/events/unlocking-capital-for-sustainability-2024-hong-kong/" class="eb-item__link"> Unlocking capital for sustainability 2024 - Hong Kong </a> </h3> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__meta"> 28 Feb 2025 • <span class="eb-item__meta--bold">Conference</span> </div> <a href="/events/unlocking-capital-for-sustainability-2024-hong-kong/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">Unlocking capital for sustainability 2024 - Hong Kong</a> </div> </li> </ul> <div class="eb-story-list__cta"> <a class="eb-button eb-button--small eb-button--secondary-inverse" href="/accounts/signup-options/" class="featured-cta__link">Publish your event</a> </div> </div> </div>  </div>  </article> <div class="eb-article__content-footer"> <section class="eb-grid__section"> <div class="eb-container"> <header class="eb-container__header "> <h2 class="eb-container__header__title"><span class="eb-container__title__text">More from Decoding Sustainable Finance</span> </h2> </header> <div class="eb-grid eb-grid--special-reports"> <div class="eb-item eb-item--has-image eb-item--list-media-mobile eb-item--standard-tablet eb-item--news" data-item-num="1"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__media-wrapper"> <div class="eb-item__image-container u-responsive-ratio u-responsive-ratio--hd"> <picture> <source media="(min-width: 980px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 980px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="332px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Morningstar_-_building.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=332 664w"> <source media="(min-width: 980px)" sizes="332px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Morningstar_-_building.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=332 332w"> <source media="(min-width: 740px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 740px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="340px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Morningstar_-_building.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=680 680w"> <source media="(min-width: 740px)" sizes="340px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Morningstar_-_building.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=350 340w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 0px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="140px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Morningstar_-_building.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=140 280w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px)" sizes="140px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Morningstar_-_building.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=605 605w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Morningstar_-_building.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=140 460w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Morningstar_-_building.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=445 140w"> <img data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Morningstar_-_building.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=300" loading="lazy" class="lazyload " alt="Morningstar building"> </picture> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> News / <span class="eb-item__sub-title--normal"> Policy & Finance </span> </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/news/second-party-opinions-a-greenwash-safeguard-or-just-for-show/" class="eb-item__link"> ‘Second-party opinions’: a greenwash safeguard or just for show? </a> </h3> </div> <div class="eb-item__standfirst"> The unregulated product is increasingly offered by ESG raters to gauge how “green” a bond or loan is. But “overly positive” reviews challenge their ability to bring credibility to the trillion-dollar sustainable debt market, experts say. </div> </div> <a href="/news/second-party-opinions-a-greenwash-safeguard-or-just-for-show/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">'Second-party opinions’: a greenwash safeguard or just for show?</a> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item eb-item--has-image eb-item--list-media-mobile eb-item--standard-tablet eb-item--news" data-item-num="2"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__media-wrapper"> <div class="eb-item__image-container u-responsive-ratio u-responsive-ratio--hd"> <picture> <source media="(min-width: 980px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 980px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="332px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/carl-kho-upoY4hHVbso-unsplash.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=332 664w"> <source media="(min-width: 980px)" sizes="332px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/carl-kho-upoY4hHVbso-unsplash.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=332 332w"> <source media="(min-width: 740px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 740px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="340px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/carl-kho-upoY4hHVbso-unsplash.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=680 680w"> <source media="(min-width: 740px)" sizes="340px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/carl-kho-upoY4hHVbso-unsplash.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=350 340w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 0px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="140px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/carl-kho-upoY4hHVbso-unsplash.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=140 280w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px)" sizes="140px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/carl-kho-upoY4hHVbso-unsplash.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=605 605w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/carl-kho-upoY4hHVbso-unsplash.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=140 460w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/carl-kho-upoY4hHVbso-unsplash.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=445 140w"> <img data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/carl-kho-upoY4hHVbso-unsplash.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=300" loading="lazy" class="lazyload " alt="Typhoon Rai/Odette"> </picture> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> News / <span class="eb-item__sub-title--normal"> Policy & Finance </span> </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/news/what-is-parametric-insurance-and-why-is-its-demand-growing-in-asia/" class="eb-item__link"> What is parametric insurance and why is its demand growing in Asia? </a> </h3> </div> <div class="eb-item__standfirst"> Parametric insurance helps minimise losses from climate-related disasters, to which Asia is particularly vulnerable. In Southeast Asia, this has been used to insure against typhoons, earthquakes, and crop losses. </div> </div> <a href="/news/what-is-parametric-insurance-and-why-is-its-demand-growing-in-asia/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">What is parametric insurance and why is its demand growing in Asia?</a> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item eb-item--has-image eb-item--list-media-mobile eb-item--standard-tablet eb-item--news" data-item-num="3"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__media-wrapper"> <div class="eb-item__image-container u-responsive-ratio u-responsive-ratio--hd"> <picture> <source media="(min-width: 980px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 980px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="332px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Bengal_Tiger_walking_on_the_dry_river_bed_at_Jim_Corbett_National_Park.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=332 664w"> <source media="(min-width: 980px)" sizes="332px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Bengal_Tiger_walking_on_the_dry_river_bed_at_Jim_Corbett_National_Park.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=332 332w"> <source media="(min-width: 740px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 740px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="340px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Bengal_Tiger_walking_on_the_dry_river_bed_at_Jim_Corbett_National_Park.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=680 680w"> <source media="(min-width: 740px)" sizes="340px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Bengal_Tiger_walking_on_the_dry_river_bed_at_Jim_Corbett_National_Park.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=350 340w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 0px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="140px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Bengal_Tiger_walking_on_the_dry_river_bed_at_Jim_Corbett_National_Park.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=140 280w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px)" sizes="140px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Bengal_Tiger_walking_on_the_dry_river_bed_at_Jim_Corbett_National_Park.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=605 605w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Bengal_Tiger_walking_on_the_dry_river_bed_at_Jim_Corbett_National_Park.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=140 460w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Bengal_Tiger_walking_on_the_dry_river_bed_at_Jim_Corbett_National_Park.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=445 140w"> <img data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/Bengal_Tiger_walking_on_the_dry_river_bed_at_Jim_Corbett_National_Park.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=300" loading="lazy" class="lazyload " alt="Tiger walking in dry river"> </picture> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> News / <span class="eb-item__sub-title--normal"> Policy & Finance </span> </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/news/from-rhino-bonds-to-debt-for-nature-swaps-can-these-financing-instruments-protect-asias-biodiversity/" class="eb-item__link"> From rhino bonds to debt-for-nature swaps: Can these financing instruments protect Asia’s biodiversity? </a> </h3> </div> <div class="eb-item__standfirst"> The novel mechanisms promise to mobilise more private financing for conservation, but risk distracting developing countries from addressing underlying debt issues and could ultimately be exploitative, say experts. </div> </div> <a href="/news/from-rhino-bonds-to-debt-for-nature-swaps-can-these-financing-instruments-protect-asias-biodiversity/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">From rhino bonds to debt-for-nature swaps: Can these financing instruments protect Asia's biodiversity?</a> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item eb-item--has-image eb-item--list-media-mobile eb-item--standard-tablet eb-item--news" data-item-num="4"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__media-wrapper"> <div class="eb-item__image-container u-responsive-ratio u-responsive-ratio--hd"> <picture> <source media="(min-width: 980px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 980px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="332px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/singapore_gas_power_plants.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=332 664w"> <source media="(min-width: 980px)" sizes="332px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/singapore_gas_power_plants.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=332 332w"> <source media="(min-width: 740px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 740px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="340px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/singapore_gas_power_plants.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=680 680w"> <source media="(min-width: 740px)" sizes="340px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/singapore_gas_power_plants.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=350 340w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 0px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="140px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/singapore_gas_power_plants.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=140 280w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px)" sizes="140px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/singapore_gas_power_plants.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=605 605w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/singapore_gas_power_plants.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=140 460w, https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/singapore_gas_power_plants.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=445 140w"> <img data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/ebmedia/fileuploads/singapore_gas_power_plants.jpg?ar=16%3A9&auto=format&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=300" loading="lazy" class="lazyload " alt="Natural gas supply chain Singapore"> </picture> </div> </div> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h4 class="eb-item__sub-title"> News / <span class="eb-item__sub-title--normal"> Policy & Finance </span> </h4> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> <a href="/news/can-singapores-new-taxonomy-fill-the-regulatory-vacuum-in-transition-finance-for-asia-and-beyond/" class="eb-item__link"> Can Singapore’s new taxonomy fill the regulatory vacuum in ‘transition finance’ for Asia and beyond? </a> </h3> </div> <div class="eb-item__standfirst"> While the EU Taxonomy is the "gold standard" for green finance, an equivalent for transition finance is notably absent. Market participants have welcomed the new guide from Singapore's central bank, but whether it emerges as a widely used standard remains to be seen. </div> </div> <a href="/news/can-singapores-new-taxonomy-fill-the-regulatory-vacuum-in-transition-finance-for-asia-and-beyond/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">Can Singapore’s new taxonomy fill the regulatory vacuum in ‘transition finance’ for Asia and beyond?</a> </div> </div> </div> </div> </section> <div id="eb-related-content" class="eb-article__related_content"></div> </div>  <section class="eb-banner eb-banner--sdg-co"> <div class="eb-container"> <div class="eb-banner__background"> <img data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/banners/sdgco_pattern.png?auto=format&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85" loading="lazy" class="lazyload" alt="leaf background pattern"> </div> <div class="eb-banner__body"> <div class="eb-banner__header"> <div id="eb-sdg-co-banner-logo" class="eb-banner__logo"> <img loading="lazy" class="lazyload" data-src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/img/sdg-co-white-2021.769c8a44f500.svg" alt="The SDG Co"> </div> <h2 id="eb-sdg-co-banner-title" class="eb-banner__title"> <span id="eb-sdg-co-banner-title-text">Transforming Innovation for Sustainability</span> <a id="eb-sdg-co-banner-cta" href="https://www.thesdg.co" target="_blank" rel="noopener" class="eb-button eb-button--medium eb-button--accent">Join the Ecosystem →</a> </h2> </div> </div> </div> </section> <section class="eb-grid__section" id="eb-subscribe"> <div class="eb-container"> <div class="eb-promotions eb-promotions--subscribe"> <div class="eb-promotion eb-promotion--subscribe"> <div class="eb-promotion__background"> <picture> <source media="(min-width: 1220px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 1220px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="860px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/promotions/promo_subscribe_laptop-bg-desktop.jpg?ar=&auto=format&dpr=2&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=860 860w"> <source media="(min-width: 1220px)" sizes="860px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/promotions/promo_subscribe_laptop-bg-desktop.jpg?auto=format&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=860 860w"> <source media="(min-width: 980px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 980px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="620px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/promotions/promo_subscribe_laptop-bg.jpg?ar=&auto=format&dpr=2&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=620 620w"> <source media="(min-width: 980px)" sizes="620px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/promotions/promo_subscribe_laptop-bg.jpg?auto=format&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=620 620w"> <source media="(min-width: 740px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 740px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="380px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/promotions/promo_subscribe_laptop-bg.jpg?ar=&auto=format&dpr=2&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=380 380w"> <source media="(min-width: 740px)" sizes="380px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/promotions/promo_subscribe_laptop-bg.jpg?auto=format&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=380 380w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px) and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 1.25), (min-width: 0px) and (min-resolution: 120dpi)" sizes="300" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/promotions/promo_subscribe_laptop-bg.jpg?ar=&auto=format&dpr=2&fit=crop&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=45&width=408 300w"> <source media="(min-width: 0px)" sizes="300px" data-srcset="https://eco-business.imgix.net/promotions/promo_subscribe_laptop-bg.jpg?auto=format&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=408 300w"> <img data-src="https://eco-business.imgix.net/promotions/promo_subscribe_laptop-bg.jpg?auto=format&ixlib=django-1.2.0&q=85&width=300" loading="lazy" class="lazyload" alt="Singapore Gardens by the Bay"> </picture> </div> <div class="eb-promotion__content"> <div class="eb-item eb-item--no-image eb-item--cta-mobile eb-item--cta-tablet eb-item--cta-subscribe" data-item-num="6"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> Receive the latest news in sustainability, daily or weekly. </h3> </div> <div class="eb-item__cta"> <a href="/newsletters/subscribe/" class="eb-item__link u-faux-block-link__cta"> Sign up for our newsletter → </a> </div> </div> <a href="/newsletters/subscribe/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">Sign up for our newsletter →</a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div id="dfp-ad-inline3" class="js-ad-slot ad-slot ad-slot--dfp ad-slot--inline ad-slot--container-inline"> <div id="div-gpt-ad-1362455980332-0" class="ad-slot__ad" data-sizes='[[300,250],[300,100]]' data-dfp="TEST-R3"></div> </div> </div> </div> </section> </div>  <footer class="eb-footer" id="eb-footer"> <div class="eb-container"> <div class="eb-footer__header"> <a href="/" class="eb-footer__logo" title="Eco Business"> <img loading="lazy" class="lazyload" data-src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/img/eco-business-logo-white.a2782e52ea6a.svg" alt="Eco-Business"> </a> <div class="eb-footer__top"> <a class="eb-footer__link" href="#top">Back to top ↑</a> </div> </div> <div class="eb-footer__body"> <div class="eb-footer__column"> <div class="eb-footer__award-logos"> <div class="eb-footer__award-logo"> <img loading="lazy" class="lazyload" data-src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/img/adma_logo-gold.cb8eb2cd2b8d.png" alt="Asian Digital Media Awards 2021 Best News Website or Mobile Service"> </div> <div class="eb-footer__award-logo"> <img loading="lazy" class="lazyload" data-src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/img/adma_logo-silver.ac89ec413765.png" alt="Asian Digital Media Awards 2021 Small/Medium Publisher"> </div> <div class="eb-footer__award-logo"> <div class="eb-footer__award-logo__wrapper"> <a href="https://www.bcorporation.net/en-us/find-a-b-corp/company/eco-business/" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener"><img loading="lazy" class="lazyload" data-src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/assets/img/B-Corp-Logo-White-RGB.dde7d0f984f0.svg" alt="Certified B Corporation"></a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="eb-footer__column"> <h4 class="eb-footer__heading">Sections</h4> <ul class="eb-footer__list"> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a href="/" class="eb-footer__link">Home</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a href="/news/" class="eb-footer__link">News</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a href="/opinion/" class="eb-footer__link">Opinion</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a href="/videos/" class="eb-footer__link">Videos</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" href="/podcasts/">Podcasts</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" href="/news/specialreport/">Special Reports</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" href="/news/industryspotlight/">Industry Spotlight</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" href="/news/featureseries/">Feature Series</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" href="/region/">Regions</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" href="https://changingcourse.eco-business.com/">Changing Course</a> </li> </ul> </div> <div class="eb-footer__column"> <h4 class="eb-footer__heading">Services</h4> <ul class="eb-footer__list"> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/events/">Events</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/jobs/">Jobs</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/press-releases/">Press Releases</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/eb-studio/">EB Studio</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/intelligence/">Intelligence</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="eb-footer__column"> <h4 class="eb-footer__heading">Subscribe</h4> <ul class="eb-footer__list"> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" href="/accounts/signup-options/">Eco-Business subscriptions</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" href="/newsletters/subscribe/">Newsletters</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" href="/dashboard/eb-enterprise/">EB Enterprise</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener" href="https://www.facebook.com/EcoBusinessMedia">Facebook</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener" href="http://twitter.com/ecobusinesscom">Twitter</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener" href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/eco-business/">Linkedin</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener" href="https://www.instagram.com/ecobusinesscom">Instagram</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener" href="https://t.me/ecobusinessnews">Telegram</a> </li> <li class="eb-footer__item"> <a class="eb-footer__link" href="/feeds/">RSS</a> </li> </ul> </div> <div class="eb-footer__column"> <h4 class="eb-footer__heading">About</h4> <ul class="eb-footer__list"> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/about/">About Us</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/about/team/">Our Team</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/about/join-us/">Join Us</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/about/advisoryboard/">Advisory Board</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/about/contributors/">Contributors</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/about/contact/">Contact Us</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="eb-footer__column"> <h4 class="eb-footer__heading">Policy</h4> <ul class="eb-footer__list"> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/about/republishing-guidelines/">Republishing Guidelines</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/about/editorial/">Op-ed Guidelines</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/about/pressreleases/">Press Release Guidelines</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/about/privacy-policy/">Privacy Policy</a></li> <li class="eb-footer__item"><a class="eb-footer__link" href="/about/terms-conditions/">Terms & Conditions</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> <div class="eb-footer__copyright"> © Eco-Business 2009—2024 </div> </div> </footer> </div> <div class="eb-bottom-banner eb-bottom-banner--eb-premium eb-bottom-banner--is-hidden" id="eb-bottom-banner" aria-hidden="true" data-eb-bottom-banner="true"> <div class="eb-bottom-banner__outer"> <div class="eb-bottom-banner__inner"> <div class="eb-item eb-item--no-image eb-item--cta-mobile eb-item--cta-tablet"> <div class="eb-item__container"> <div class="eb-item__content"> <div class="eb-item__header"> <h3 class="eb-item__title"> Support our independent journalism. #newsthatimpacts </h3> </div> <div class="eb-item__cta eb-item__cta--bottom-banner"> <button id="eb-bottom-banner_close" class="eb-item__cta__close"> × Close </button> <a href="/accounts/signup-options/" class="eb-item__link u-faux-block-link__cta"> Subscribe now → </a> </div> </div> <a href="/accounts/signup-options/" class="u-faux-block-link__overlay" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true">Subscribe now →</a> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/js/vendor_revamp.14d3b520c3d2.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/js/app.min.788c83c8d823.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://d11qvh2fgoiqjh.cloudfront.net/static/hitcount/jquery.postcsrf.52fbbe0e27ed.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> // Determines if the user is likely using an ad block extension async function checkAdBlocker() { // Used to cache the result let isBlocked; async function tryRequest() { try { return fetch( new Request( "https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/tag/js/gpt.js", { method: "HEAD", mode: "no-cors", } ) ) .then(function (response) { // Google Ads request succeeded, so likely no ad blocker isBlocked = false; return isBlocked; }) .catch(function (e) { // Request failed, likely due to ad blocker isBlocked = true; return isBlocked; }); } catch (error) { // fetch API error; possible fetch not supported (old browser) // Marking as a blocker since there was an error and so // we can prevent continued requests when this function is run // console.log(error); isBlocked = true; return isBlocked; } } return isBlocked !== undefined ? isBlocked : await tryRequest(); } async function postData(url = "", data = {}) { const response = await fetch(url, { method: "POST", mode: "same-origin", cache: "no-cache", credentials: "same-origin", headers: { "Content-Type": "application/json", "X-Requested-With": "XMLHttpRequest" // For Django Ajax test }, body: JSON.stringify(data), }); return response.json(); } function relatedStoriesHandler(){ var view_url = '/news/related/are-biodiversity-credits-doomed-to-repeat-the-voluntary-carbon-markets-flaws/'; $.ajax({ type: "GET", url: view_url, // dataType: 'json', success: function(data) { if(data){ $(".eb-article__related_content").html(data); var paragraphs = $(".eb-article__body-content > p").length; $(".eb-article__aside").hide(); if (paragraphs > 2) { $(".eb-article__body-content > p:nth-of-type(2)").after($('.eb-article__aside')); $(".eb-article__aside").show(); } $(".eb-article__related_content .loader").hide(); // $(".eb-article__related_content related-content").fadeIn(200); $(".eb-article__aside .u-faux-block-link__overlay").hover( function() { $(this).parent().addClass("u-faux-block-link--hover"); }, function() { $(this).parent().removeClass("u-faux-block-link--hover"); } ); $(".eb-article__related_content .u-faux-block-link__overlay").hover( function() { $(this).parent().addClass("u-faux-block-link--hover"); }, function() { $(this).parent().removeClass("u-faux-block-link--hover"); } ); // Initiliase lazy loading for images const firstRelatedStoryEl = document.getElementById("eb-first-related-story"); const relatedContentEl = document.getElementById("eb-related-content"); initLazyLoadingAjax(firstRelatedStoryEl); initLazyLoadingAjax(relatedContentEl); } else {} }, error: function(request, status, error) { // process_form_errors(request.responseText, alert_form); } }); } function add_target_blank_to_external_links() { $('.eb-article__body-content a[href^="http"]').not('.eb-article__body-content a[href*="eco-business.com"], .eb-article__body-content a[href*="eb.news"]').attr({target: "_blank", rel: "noopener"}); } $(document).ready(function() { var paragraphs = $(".eb-article__body-content > p").length; if (paragraphs > 8) { var adPara = Math.floor(paragraphs / 2); $(".eb-article__body-content > p:nth-of-type(" + adPara + ")").after($('#dfp-ad-inline1')); } add_target_blank_to_external_links(); $(".eb-button--story-lang-switch").click(function(e) { e.preventDefault(); var language = $("input[name='language']"); new_language = $(this).data("language-code"); language.val(new_language); $("#js-languagesForm").submit(); }); }); </script> </body> </html>

CINXE.COM

Are biodiversity credits doomed to repeat the voluntary carbon market’s flaws? | News | Eco-Business | Asia Pacific