CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "hansard.parliament.uk",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e9a9a9df8c901f6',cH: 'SIX5tiTYmMiLe33vYbo8qe6H3LVPym28hjokluEFyDc-1732799487-1.2.1.1-YVh6BsRnNVVUovgA8UGXixfR6JzgHLBjIbRGUwtcC_.Pqtp7UBw7NjxvvCH.eI0u',cUPMDTk: "\/search\/MemberContributions?memberId=4634&__cf_chl_tk=5ocQHKXtGNT5eUOWqFCw7_d2aQhPjySTJTAV6kbEwG4-1732799487-1.0.1.1-DDpXQFkECk6nWZIs7cCr3pycAaUNuq5Cc34d1sHJvDE",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1732799487',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/search\/MemberContributions?memberId=4634&__cf_chl_f_tk=5ocQHKXtGNT5eUOWqFCw7_d2aQhPjySTJTAV6kbEwG4-1732799487-1.0.1.1-DDpXQFkECk6nWZIs7cCr3pycAaUNuq5Cc34d1sHJvDE",md: "EGO7YkmZAdQJwiPp7vwJ33zO1ZYnRUWwcCZiffoSk6o-1732799487-1.2.1.1-JVBz7p2zMTAE9G4561CmU4xj0dL1Nox_O.HwhRl.3DF1E0BjRuW4KcavXO8hd0raVFYiZELAaL.b0_LR61j1PNfVn2T1RbGJL2aBDixJ_glO9egRC598yHVowAOEvYCdHjozOmhGzB05xaT6n2IJj_K5NCFouMV3jncSXc4mkkuUeM1PEIaDSCkUyD2m8PDkO35OjcCPGfQN6VdBaARkzwvB.88cqxNPP6Y.3vCMQaTJqKtjaJYRln9vxOQVxrWyYStxILCEXvguTcnzhF9rEqIXqeCsZEl.Zl5F9qNwbYUd7ny.Lq7b2igcfKIgXA0LnD6LXt.m.PVVgqxnrQlKzDjUVB4_WtTtwEWHGS8n5oX0vPiPC6QQ_Orj.o7.wz0hfp7U2lB1YH_XbbuM4LmTog2lWQbTJGmsK5yZzxD.v8iGAQiJbsFn6de9a5Q4PUsbspouIylGey_8BHIKu.aoE_.1HIO.zqSOWEwg3yaeicmrSNGltn_f3knL.lttr6wE61WpsB3HUs1aDxf2X.RjHq99CLn0js0zKG2X0AdFHaScuzmRXZZeFpJy8e3nNWdsOt5OLUMAJEqRtM1W3bgV9xrGFyRTBWhE4gw2SP8tOS77OzEqm7tP4kxIrU8qdDotnR7AynUU8TgFbMpM1cYndXFNtQ1ZIeZdSS5nrM7wNBYJhZBKlXCF64gJnYLtkY6GZxu_EcovcSy6lQtYTic6z5VmiLcQtxlsJSaOYJOyh4IR3mEVRge06wpk6I_OTs5_wlPoNwwL.XrBMpuRVF.1g4monpd0TH_eApvLTtmqYaoo4tJL.ghAJ88eBLBXN5Xp4dPmwHi_g6XVyqg.oW18sH_pi_9atH2kXJzJMrOIcieSwardcfBZRr8_Vr4TcR7wUebxx096rpmp0YuwkSLcfpDuXePOC6PAzKj1pcVnLk5orQ1gAK01ybIz8mVqu7jU5J9jiE4O7VCAuouTKKD5KTpMKSB0j4v8cwixrfwDkiMzJ29fKkrCKCslNsj9mer_W0PgPigwkJcKlQGiH0ym8xCqqpG28SQgH7bz56by7FKhAmmrFn79Z8oZhTelmSyo8B6z5QjWVKm_6YyO9Az7FvEXwxhu8V5O10Fk6BUJ1laBzMjwMXtmOTWEup86dVQuWUnYYYQYoL2McmgGF1GHPzqPsCyNDT8FLuHjg4yALc9B4g7gVHrU9CnQ9jXXcFIGOPPJuOFj6ZzImDrNz.RGFLI1JJ8fKlCDue9fuQUFPr.jw462nfb8DiHYRU1f0GCdfSZNCl5XkhIWsrpM4xurmXJIiBaLFOe_.XRcpEGoj8WE2riZiCk6.RuyYk2F43I.ohjhus5GH_1bQ7pYfRPklUjh8Oa.i8mxj3x.Z0YhMJfq06JQmzre_8rBWpi3TU0GBWAM_dAdRX.xyB2Uxu7XNnbqv2xNrXI9UPuyZpqS1bWLbZ1..HakIXK7clhQTrdQ9600SZuf7JmFzwXQKu5tmE.aDvL.pYFfLRmfleCz5sdkElJFlSLM3kj6w7uWG.Y9MWqPX7UZE_pfEfwAQ5W4KFOz92HMM9z5m.cW3Ll2FHMufBl_JVY1Zv7UfbR3M9U4KPq1EvqSGyKqkCOUy0NyzVuiAUkpRNsfxY_vYnwGTWyzf6vhRY6QaM5vgsQj8af3KKTyL.sJoc.m7UBND5B16.ltmwRLEZ5XYNRm9sL99FhZV.l.vNSqb6X4CUhCPMZ1gNvJQdmsA7tAuJhTuLcOegYZxSwfwctlcIRjWUqgBcB59koYtnEq4Um961ejnP9nml4I8uQfObMuAIZmFBQ9gkgcoC6T950qyiZw8pBdbruWplXDVOo2Jmnq9jfBQO3TUokilcohiz9wfDptar32Xs8yB.Kq2GnlqPRBqfJiixk733BHQqykC6rysaknJQeHakdHnip3IS2.4zjh90QwwEUsgWur5H1BNX_i2ZRYOBry9Cee9QINWmJEOzW_Q4FWe4xJs8d6lcQ2Cg.HObt6tiBDKxFP6r4Vj6TxgH_E70AEiyKfp9hrkTZKTw84ZFR5eXnfw6o_N3kh3d1imodc0vimAkBmQ_ClkuWzGrQ4EfJ7zlYoE_nCYqRkBhoxIJG5UZu3CPIiP_V2cZvYVK1GvcnN876lqQWr3aUWP08XbUfInBA3ykezlw1JjY4NfgcnteQsDAu_unig_b5QaOciqOQeSJ8QnZoOGxkaQFzyjcdYh4Iu3FT4K0VsQ0iYNq_BeXBqCaaPT2ba8W0anPEbLYE1qKJdLG6pTC7Eyt3d22GKOAGNilmkpKqLb3VIF.FFbztL.7mRfbvesylcpbpN_J0Ck1_fkn9XKChzCRROc9iuGhUs6XbpbaGIKkV85py2BWcxXOAALGoSP4wQufJvaEbODbX8UdJ5YCqbuKEptPTMGqWT6vIXpxTnHB75Doi9SOw06ERIFOpSlK3Jl966O25RxIyVs6Adhj334AMd2vnQIKjwemy.UOZXckXoEuB68znUgzipr5FznsfOMVojf4wpU8hMum764va_cS7cXEwS4ArYLWfJyUlExU9bhHwC0yrhTwLHuAS_ZGKMg98LQzS8FzIzAOv7G5evNX08hg5Bpu1eizvmt7OeZvB5yPDFONHQV1YhmimwnQrNKNHiDvlwVhKb_BqufxVSlhsmoY3qkhLIoZSMcpOHfOI3wOV1QQDzT0qM4wQYN9MH5oXa6ysDBVMT0mkZ9GBeUxu0Jst6Do4amrZvfCRIdkVrSGh3TWfRc7BlL8gfc0EXn3Iyczykutlji4q13OC7KdBbeCHICVVE2d.gKH2LBiYDTTupToClOl5lQ9DIok3lzEKUXnylQjgMJo8t_ogczB5UGI1QjnTiyLD_QOWocnw5WhIQDbLEM5qBWV1cxOSfuCei.J3zQCkk1I.MIuBHw9_w1ekUbY6FZe112nuE68v6UjMqyb3014GAqm4F6Orc6z2r4OyUlCTGKT0DPYqD9i8oua8yvBi6MV8aWMfIUAOL7ySI",mdrd: "xzbqEmVti37iesC9S9T6oIXXUWbfLIlkCTQIUX6pBx0-1732799487-1.2.1.1-bRFjPvJHX05zd8KVWLTx5Dm1H1g373uWD0x_YraazsLwqTlFN3Dby7S3zhfzrrkOQwnMKL2cZ9NAMshbRYwtnD.evZ4InC54SDqvEr0a4XMK1ErU1sHi6NuMBOMBXVVoFKQN05hen_ln52REb0YTdPxi4AsPDrp5Jv3pIJaujBrkgiPrZwLCV10uMw1437.FJtQhJtM1Fff1MxKvMGbVsanlBSxEx09i3RN1fRRZo02dqe.BHNrB1couiOpm3p8VzVmA.oeIWTpmAnzYuQ8WumRxEvD2_irv4eVuif7jYSAcfwlxVERTooY8l_UhBeMTQul.Gf94KDfAQ7pbHlty_Q.Pz.hS78qdvWO53.fWSLu_mtwM9KUSXprA7vPDClPOtXuNiwqOlKOrMmhCwanrlpMz3QdlFPSLF12HyGdquBNk2ld1J1.b1sAUivkpxf6R8YjK_PPv6QoYJdpI9EcFy590XoYJd6ZJKfTSAo5KB_VWz4OhH2CG5BdJ597jrFl5VY0m4trekYKhxM2x_UbhM08.3SIER2RVGMU_PF.Tumpi9.jURt8PmjMdgd6jjDvA.4pt9yxQJbES.2xYHmebvdf9Z_bHan45mgW8EhukB34V9RrvxbuSL2EJ4DSH5F.gwVNkCWlflWe09jH2l3SThYkUGwatuhzviCOJHHsjhbBsKZaYZgfGcrh6XzgVKqHPdlbs7lRrdb.qYfkpWuIuGqkwn.mwCMZHSFXiVJ4FHEREWGsMg.KZFJofLFXDi7mziArCMhjK3pUrSusGIHylRFFi3BoQzPDdNrn3s4hAYdWwqQgK7yr9MpmDM0qoQjhIiFNRlDwi0N4SzzsOuG36wyCidsWvgrS5ZbSca3CbilvAOSqkSFhmZ0q3E3lRtIRXjMmZJk44B4nsgmKrNUT5Xf6xJlz4GmKLk1wx4WF5VwGyjkV1DIM2D0_wou2Q0OF4754iduBKl_h5DtQZ4uS34P7MmomzmkK5KE1sW173Ahci.wjs_gq1rGpXEqCzSHofWPQkDzCcyQAljqH6r7jdAtBiggXtA2Eh1tfHYVV4EnHS1eTZ0Z3sWsC.AVFmAC1b74tVGG5KXqkpaF26hvwXO.J0nFEuNhy7YqUnQqF5Zb571JzPRPNQdDd0Mwd1DcXLVMY0f5ZaSEyZdy5bzQgGGcKhvrb7IkulyBlTjtOBDlT2d1mt0mBUjF4n25yXJlarHE2qFDWPJFFsnPAQhCkmqAdzT2JIBXfmZdZUYemJXkWJwDe6q66unY4sY2QWVPuxqryV3hlRT44M48pqgMWQNlfKMmOg371kSOZDRROTUWBpyp9aQcsmzHXx.I93mZQ9YGHo_m3Glrtx2ufcXOEdoA5aCjCo2ArbMZZQB2ep_f0XEf.L3imNGbQ9DmNxwBxcM69SeBIo1jJ3jyOGhFOkfzoAg01Yn4ZUmWHDvFnx5xRJxks3Ie8FvhueTbxFl.Iml.1OtJVtdt29TY_Xqab5Iw23Uq0PmUmBCXhvBogeaPOKmpTK_JP17Hii94JWCGqTVt1h1moTPerE712eDZPQyCgptezOibl16WrFb28IXEJvfme6tsZHpU7q2GdS3V4VN0IxEgoYJOiDyEAGpZKjsKHjwPGYetL6xpjSfGQRL5EbgL8c6A3N9Hl5lUtQldRglfd2AGo2cEljSWHrf7f6RHmHplgKR9.2pu4dzM56M2PqTNJ55HysbIwKoZ13V598.pS2AVNMTUINp40poqbIS2xE1EDeBNI2mDMFwjal6nQj1UsUdM7LRQic_vI87hdY3uD6uC_Fl33yp2xymvHc560sjARRcPFehrYf.G1Pw8YIPhsVl_7cRGGIVIQhOBXe_Fl5__TVzld9akJYeVER3sll9lnag4EwbSRkM1.iE3.l31MyvW2tjUT5hRBCUllnH.K6ympwG20mpH1TIVgRDaeFRGL9tw8vPtZCf6DKzM3rWWxJe9Oqyk97FJ1ej8p4"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e9a9a9df8c901f6';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/search\/MemberContributions?memberId=4634&__cf_chl_rt_tk=5ocQHKXtGNT5eUOWqFCw7_d2aQhPjySTJTAV6kbEwG4-1732799487-1.0.1.1-DDpXQFkECk6nWZIs7cCr3pycAaUNuq5Cc34d1sHJvDE" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>