CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "philpapers.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e89aada8f8e3e2b',cH: '9gtU9c1cr.hn9x_afk8jYh2Wa3tmI5A5R_uuCRfU32k-1732621894-1.2.1.1-.DLQPtZAfo_DGERSscV_VEyIAqAum.Ov.Q3_sgIGDalR.TbCIv9_DMUAhftUTjFQ',cUPMDTk: "\/browse\/brain-death?__cf_chl_tk=tahhAGGAHeRiglD6lMNMQcm_hjE6_8LtSJ59X8ynl94-1732621894-1.0.1.1-B7mbK7J8hPYJGiYjg7mSXNYzMafhDwUsHIXabjjk6ak",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732621894',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/browse\/brain-death?__cf_chl_f_tk=tahhAGGAHeRiglD6lMNMQcm_hjE6_8LtSJ59X8ynl94-1732621894-1.0.1.1-B7mbK7J8hPYJGiYjg7mSXNYzMafhDwUsHIXabjjk6ak",md: "oDfEKzjduLBD4b3IrqCGx8DJo5jwvYGPKsYxxS0d.vg-1732621894-1.2.1.1-WkcPNyDX9fe30nZtsp6vnIaOTwswfqVaaXdWp32FwJ1SlTwug7fUBalXdiY6EmOj6X3ei7nqrhWQ74QW86YoLPLE6TPI5FVu1xAujg8I5DOMe_Nvzh4aoOMfDNkxluL9eVUZO94o746RiulneBWlIz3giVRLelCSys2Jlle_WRTjJk9XJKFdZsOmiGpIoJjMgB3Ng_ap2f_3vauQl_qWM8mLpwcTay.rn.n12iNOUQ5VOtrShhV9HoszeC9Hpf6r9fWkjDFzzM8Hcvpqw2zpf26Q4LTonLecwx6_h9Cd3Ty6cYcNxUO6sRtEoc0VV_eeroz3g4G0WJsRlFSzJwhriNx_QMxFFI253Yki8VrOuaZVz0oG3ejj8N5etr3_i9ioKPZDVT0Brm3eBj_5jz682xAtSugbCtyI4LvYc_eRE4MGfFYnAMk_EUvY7KZRgTGVc8npi4QCik5YndTMG3v0J0jBsMKiFNOJpDBJiNP3mx8bU_noq3dx3V81WE4Ks5NUHdQzjYdtsPD4duOt0oR13xtWtNmwz.Z9aovAaetCo31jUzpyjv_iZfD1PpEeXfCu9vLnnhet9fgP0jWZF2Wi21S5aN.CswTkZO9ilK.7aTRpsZt9FcNWSh411ReqQo5pX7pUzU3qZI02M1y1nFOjW9ufOABjL6IEV9.yxuTqQf4cHZcKHTjou5NeaBoravbJnf_J4e6iUtIL9KSLZQZjgjgyUxhRhPECPF0ONP4RQ.uZArHXAYveFkkSqMniIEFsU3JXHitRkr3EK0s.GymqX9QD9Mz4Eg6ohnXvBG_s5DgwUxDI9BW7ZdGDKfvSoEPRZF2FAc1jQoPiP6wShx5IIvG5ne1T22qp68.pd2Yf0_d7FiWE0StBOdzbgjUQu9_CL8urIJxiC7_fxqG5p53pZY4Msjowv9FSyNOkT3O6lGkRpa5ExcDXm9SkWZJDAhcM3QgprhUFKxnGbqFNA9ALI1eA4i_WQr38AEPvqiPVl6SWXBipdYCHh9E66mPbIT_nJl4Mt1ZBICkokEP0sNjE18S1vtKJ3HudlSSn1V5.vUPQnBzxnBhVxHT.evwzwYjq3IxCK8V9OZ82Bl4iDh0hBlRZmTIxVH3.kJqJJEgxWoUgPUFS_D.NYjNIlkynQfwn6xWXkxIw7qclZ_V97EJKSOiUbjE3m84d3AIAsS6v11XSKcENAc.5KIVjXlY5KNf1W0927pTVv4r65AEVWDUatfE3OysayrZMtAQepRpLHT_xdY4nQ5z1g..VzDdysbpEnI0jrS2aUBq5qQ1MaBAZz52g6GA9v_WiIoWc2HYa3aGs1HJOZKlTbwGIT8BF1nY7MmQIomfVfLotDvoSIcWC_.9BnFSTSKX5tKUW3B3pQQrp38aaP603QpoJiriTa3w3.6m96mFpCxNLorpqHEI6r3GhyTqqCyalhUgy0VTICuZBUvDHnZNHzQ08csI6uK6Gn77f5yPhg6xx2kXgURG8gpyHMG3hAU6ee8t.whWaqGOAjgH0kb_AViQp.49ppNZON_uC0BPBm2f9WHuDYpFJ6pn1TWzMVYvUyWzzrctPDX_eU81kq0hLjT3oMTXbqn2GvdkeHQTSwo0w6zn0hn5SgNAs6KNCKiKUH8VQX9Y7TcUZ_nwZZVs1u6CHWFem28CrJePmOVXQpa18P1dGDbGWQwergKui8PhHSgdU6JwLNKEF23py7a7_AN0OeZjpDxjXYBaJLvDbzNe8Ovd983KFPYMULn_QeBz4VnderFa3eaH.m8ypR7VN.xaW59AJBOQX8BtMmwXEnX907l81KkSxTuNQHJo9bwPWeSAd2R1D8d7JEOZvxewNgQryNm96VwhEPuutTIP.2Qp8U3FXU59lSrfSlc1JSA7hlQCpYv1tLtVerrsjuEeWddp8MbPbr9BfTEcE2pC9C3xb6vLAggMbRw284ArbCsm9ZJAcEmFtPQ1e9AlLDFbsn2Bn_MQ54dxfA3.1jR.jfovwx_qwXpXvMl3XzJ2epwORQX_J9.gBcJlbir5oNFY86SvHT.41ZjqHbPFTMti_M4R3Nd9hYIl2Lj16aSVhz4MhBwbppahOz3NmTiF_eFHkiVS4qnhK4vcS0u4TGfD8ZwJb_5vxSPyPNI.N65jAKbLnunwhIRAPmoYroJ3ZuBZ8m172ciewHv4vREzmw8___YLUOnK7Ij46ZoOkLYIkzFOiJ86a3tNgqX188Gh1Gvg44b39FVmi9UUPijevD2fz2DjaciZod1xukVGRbvug0IZQHR._wtEprTm1EQt0P8GuaY.OWZ6DMKfjOs2J5bxpDrk8X.EWL36n4kOo9F14OnF7LVHvMm7iLJBupt.9wF69.aBy62.QOu1qA76Kdaid.phL3g22E9qrm2OCfBv9G_i7eTDkVI0BS6Kbg_GnFrquwyZ1TuSdy0..kpiYZFGV1j.HYq.avrHiDUbD8CCDxAJxHtWr2f_4.6YbFo6qOt4O5xUh486Ox8lQ3x60aKplyjb3GTLnHd.2CNULYkgD1UiOk36Kd8gDYcKbnBM1iILLCOfEAgczrkxS1Jk3yGciDV7lsOw.HE.Qc3BlbQdyz.5W2_aoq._zI8QBlmgH_xlAmb95GqKDhIDMpWd.KrJNlRq2WNQEoo1m.nt6NefASyGOqgGvahXo_Qo1FjDd7IflAb440BYLmyRUeqXIF_MU38TLWEJIOXIcdUsd7cgJMX98Jbp4bZORcTIdGAJ3MhQgulsmPLwvUYTtbVUV14.SixINPEA7Xi3fowPz4IuBILYeCT.ROJiFzrVVQeH78vQH2evefqtfPNTTAYvHZ6bah0_cVhkSNKzY7v6Fk5DWI5u_DXL5m3raOGT4D5DgFliCpgpqRZkG5.0HnOMazfeNHLxVIjFYR6TQOM0.EEYhh0ABdmhXWS1Tsfc",mdrd: "a2mWa5OnvcYssS6_9xt4CSvFNLM4fnVxG1X_0sKovbM-1732621894-1.2.1.1-GkkqAhPyBtKFdI98T4jaLk3.T5zFIlTJI11xryzqMLlVpPWxk6i1b2dkrxom7GCR408cZbVcuqLIlSIaWVme6P39yt5Ezjck44NebO6KmtSSWGPQy5x4YLGyOIxUukXEqIRfucwFYjZArpOIU.0B.6D0niphYfMRI4t_1eqkNdCQzCT7QLPn9Z7yOYvjK3xjNr7qBKMCny7b90eQOyznPJNbk.gSpjoSXaDGSHbI3SzsMOBDKPAgnyP8B9qE9sElaTLlogCJ0PUwqi8DT5C4jvjHFAUMJUT2v__mIYidbOjOiXV9LNLX8CXxbeoaqB692ngEsnUjWxDCi4jQx2sb6pQV5l18tYEdDcItYJIxK1l1oB56TbE0AalEvJ0E24GYSUObnF9Tzej2WUwCLCeWWzDfB5up_UdUPfAw3n.uM1fDbtQc9Yf0xJXYhhbltWcbEYmsOeXDT5XEgdp3Mu0Nz9hHQMUdAv3GBoswqPj6diXO2fIAQ8p0JhuwGp3bcMM7E4roWB_0g9jOAI24EqBgpsJ_VpMlRhJC6eAFZQ03Nj0HycoK73H2y_8oafcaR8pYFpBke3vIBzGQexlmoeV0B7ZQs1yUCsEOYlNJt_RVqKZLJwQR1k6xJjQJ4QhkMjrXdLOHgAP67SBhI5d3h9sxPXAEMuKB37qdGDlzWL59h9ZJpCruOq613vbZ_HbQQtlczSFTrwQDLu0OZCbO9vFOU8FvZb0WeRo.yUR52TNPh9sAJH4mlEyQgsgV0u_6_I9TwHVueEtd8aWc1vUDc_wBIaNNtME9HKss7gltfZAyeFOiFm1IaN8t3nPaCN7.jHBcHURXqLm.s7pdpra8l3ten96xKoZldoq4wnu1nG1V7zs1hjdixE8qe4BPGMASq0V6NF4v8UvnXL706FYRrzHJSRxGpE0M_GcKcC2w8C0VtN5ukAfOEIxcwOdOM65pQ4MFY40fiMnbsO2LD0MZUZBRG4npkM6mowZ9ID_j8DQFaFfqFhum32zGa4Li9jcHwi1wPuTOA5kl4XQnQO576eFoIRawW1oMx0GP3To580DTibvaL08v9rfDPPzYmuh9cbq0WCcZ5HZ27TC9UjeQKGblgT3FgcfUs2PZTdKSlhaBtx_reguAZidI53xRC4VeFMcEBkuisViwKvo6j3o5D.RJ5XMLQ1e0gRY.0A7IdVhfqVCjrR4HQCn8w8w.L1Hsphn69U0v4_O3_dcYMHdz2RiW08TzAKUVjorphtu9AGO.w4wRsjwxt.2QBFWvlE81svwEXVbDVjU7cVO6VhBdQvpu3qbfvMqoPBSDZFx.UAVHi6UaZir8.uRe0PT3FvaRvb.fmuyiY5el3Bh1bibApx.Wh7lz2FcatzJu6YiIpDc19kIS_xj0ysp7KimoZcIzrZD85RefuAwZbKBHt7FUBtui_CREIY1Jneow2PMzJ8eDZzN2MHMRtE4pStO0TrfbbGjdDt7lLFrPw58NlCmXi.ao.BMcThkZCF.f.zGULwTxlbp8h15fyQDy1A0Tj8hM3PJQQWSZ5tXWUIe1n7MK1PmrJyIRiUQqKo2yiz18tCRPgr1pn0gxflgLqZkCjUw5WLkRGDCUV5.x8W1sCnrEy2JNRiL3iG10RiK0AHln_L3gsAlxRAR7jiEVGx3eEy9_ZcURyVQXbdPwkNdOaMutDP56KrXTSZ.iv_qQwZ.nLxFLJJ98C3PB2XPClpCcoiWz_su5nQl_vMKNfcGCgAGROqpCIRlXzq8WmYIqG2DvAeY5ws1SncAGSyKDmWYrH50U8.QbwFDLo.yGtgawE7Ehb1RTzuYbwpnUGfSzLAF7AWa.R_EGCoBNNk59KRqKYKdml9eHkhGg3x_FSubuPTjCYFD6Llp117_HErWXN0yesa6xoE0aZCNScpK.mVsrcqxHWTYmPphvnM2YyA5AiR.x80OvXH3ha_YZwVDJLH6w_SE8YZo"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e89aada8f8e3e2b';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/browse\/brain-death?__cf_chl_rt_tk=tahhAGGAHeRiglD6lMNMQcm_hjE6_8LtSJ59X8ynl94-1732621894-1.0.1.1-B7mbK7J8hPYJGiYjg7mSXNYzMafhDwUsHIXabjjk6ak" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>