CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.patreon.com",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8ebe69ceca0ece5f',cH: 'XWMoKl4uEQ9UKDy2xRqAa_RmMxfy0HAOpRcbct__eA8-1733174975-1.2.1.1-JfgNNbtcd.078.TOUufJ_3SOuPHRvhZfKiKEWwfvFHsR2GtpMK3_PQ.Axa_t0bdE',cUPMDTk: "\/Nadeem_Walayat?__cf_chl_tk=TUdnHAm4NmtAU8gjISp1nDytd7pbLL1a1VJI5WGidgY-1733174975-1.0.1.1-oVtgDAPczQSs7aDXeYNAOee5kLOJmG6K1A0_qxFnkS8",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1733174975',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/Nadeem_Walayat?__cf_chl_f_tk=TUdnHAm4NmtAU8gjISp1nDytd7pbLL1a1VJI5WGidgY-1733174975-1.0.1.1-oVtgDAPczQSs7aDXeYNAOee5kLOJmG6K1A0_qxFnkS8",md: "Ae1O1YJ_4z5WXRhchXrlhrAiSFW.MiKsH3.ePOKXV2M-1733174975-1.2.1.1-r47BcUbSR7DM1lX2BSPSdLH77_BCvok.djp1IB1CKviKpurdz2BYAu9Cmkmxa0RSTrbg.5UipUBgzN2kdU1EToEn6HLbGF6O5D6T1WFsf..R_Bcvb.SD4pgLaIRpqVqKUlBbuU9ETySP9kDLC2G.ecYtJrWMovfQRk0y8MBq57qcyc2N1JGHQ.FQVn1oA201suu5qbr84B96sMTmmiBxLQgLLa4KOZF4Yha3hZomLLB2ba9Ni05XVLyQna.cBMFWSpcbLzs8CrTV0ZimpP5M4J6f1xSiz83_.0eSm8LA5Nvgz5lTf2G3aqX63toeM5ufOLWWWsNchDHZ6USPDmEHlONz0CcXt1.B4dvuLTXrlm1d7P8ZSmdHPcVgIK.7ta7j5Upb7GOOeqrLoPbKqxiqDejuDTtPtWfq4taJudd_e73bYQbk_wmNofJo_6dlDmu_UmLvH1ufvem651YrWAQayhSV1IZkD2xJSvr8TSbIy2M.46kz9dBaprsfD1mhRSfxOCXsMhhWZQY9oh8ksrmyZD_AHCBMO_fzxN9o_j_.vGsXVM_yLxO6O7.HkfAaIBZyVDahJlp6_FTMSl52Y3CzBpqE7nnS5MDTKxChikgDaNQdwuhbngMWwH0xjVik6tzwB16IdbVY_Z2uv7s.8hdnArLQ9qWVxui2dPgP6QdOVmU.NnqBVJ2zbu5hWPu4rY.feZJd16lS0Gv3pdo5sy294ovt4zxeq0ev34TRhwRBuJGEZkewFhhN_EDlIzCys5D0VUs65Sj_NbTxG1mwnGdvnHI_bXJombG5PEMfYsd4bCqiBRXxir.pSjfyuuMz8vazp3psUHoftfNbIYbS1bp5lzxN5yAfsDVQ62PCyazUC.gWPCK9NtlNwRiHD44RQQj5W_1xAQnNbUH53zRQvD2sY8xbeLSI7Xrb4syHdzpDbm1vnt4v3kKluZczldgYymsQ1hM.sf7B4xMKQO45GkAVjBfqFU2EJapwdGK5Rt.YSNTIFrqwfiLYEUzk8FGi7kMNFYnIVTaIZZao.myCuukefA_jCB1_37.IRfNlEETZLPjlBvZ2b2vc_OsT1AGaBvwNtIL9CCdASG.ryb2iyjZgSQeGXqo.0h4HTKTbTcZBwtYOBC82RHfoRSl1mUr0C74s_nACEkrBVuIJW2PnPS2lTVLNr.QF5BhM9or8mRI0i8DrsA.8NuR0TYMfzSSbUayIcOtflFNeLwW_2w1EPSJHf02jd4.lSVBaY1nC0O0s0dfvnu_88zfA2CmwnL8JqNwZ7eOMNTPcUCBzhSf5mGGxBhNpCsCdJtTiLBz203fbfMRMRT3wouHvopiLyuzZ1SdE0kyxHUWeqKmW9C1qFe6tlunansZwaDjzlzYDLQcCyXpSO93LMyEtDNZtK.nXDuuaZou6ZYHnwS4sokADE7eCj39WH_4Kb5iwkwafsTQ2R911NZsxyDFpXKm6ArQ1DyuJOXtZqmn246aAkywmSY1MaNaBwYMoxtI9tGDzWS11RiSB2nv1xvDs9HLZUMqo35Oh_RxfQvHKycARjkMzZIW6cG.dTORtQYF1w5fgWQUwe68hXQXSAl5x9BdGoxPNd.37uqpYqLdWPfM_WFev08crnsgivHOyQH1JkxlNhzruTtwZGCw8vJmzZKY9Lc8vhULPES6eGfxXsy6UcUXsq3Q.9ySifq23Qq.JlYy1ddvZ5aqa4FNbPcShHIlz._FWXcdsl567IrfX_Bc3T3nNE.5x5RaekfKzIid2TcillMqLTIbrIwTbW_nJnPr2QTksAzUPN0RodDLwNSY1jVbvSywN84CYA34dKR.aKkt1qbLFwzT4EST5Bp4_iA5UYDeECghv.swaKI4cO9X00oZGuXg2ebqbb_bSWDrTichrq.7Npneyobh2T5SRX.RnkObwylXseSJLwBSHRjICSfGJxjAzcuvzeMLO7YsCbMu1tPgnbWU6u3AC9B5HKnnb..eUokQ.xdUToY4bTkMB4ypIFh.HuhRJzKMdwHHyTj12lrsT9ufv1CEGqgzEHsikbt4aUOucOuDcq9dH5GohFjpqXqzSCB_bXp9dP4R2vfLbgzK..7jqy4UIrRIB2k8zI_9PtjtM.ANTwcsTBsu.r08mBC5ckY_FQa4DBxbAMtIrsVKjPmxG3WGve.L4XKiIsfh5wkQROK9gt4vkGjrAey50WGH6FvTGscdGN7QMSeltI.XK3jlS3BNYxulskmsCbW6W.YrGFZn_d5wg.5gPaBnztLAI9Ury8l8pQEnx17VBQ87rnJ9LS29VVJAstdMnDjHINYq.lwo5in5OF0OEL1QJ.doaVPzMUXkEr_cO9o_x0wJ1NC4OsdIKgLCnJpIU7dVBvebgc3pQr50r_Y0FF6uQknFxnm6RVtclKiWRhv2jCh03hu3I24zIb_sTNNs0uiB0dLxutZgeoWEZpHR_3Tnua_AAsSUeJd.tL0yQ8Kadu4ixeycwMWa4K2EY6iIHjKQA_87GJ1UcL9X2NZ2IF_n5VfUejZIYaG6_D17T19uKAWBvkOL6Y5MRCPXRcmXYc4Win0qKxKTnF7W7mhm5Zz0epmsDSok12aYZtw5bNvI3tNzSw_Xcq0ZSkJNBEYvz42i26YYL11spZ04.VALWYY8dj8Dcp8gTxzag8043mDN9wMCya2gsgWtHpLZHnqryQrMN_Ib15h0Y.SBY58Mw7.841RG7zVm2axsV7H0RAd08azPdxCFbW4bBUdjkNqIqf4p44rNbmIjw9usBGqHWdvPDvT2igTT3Asr1V0R0gk9qh9jIXMaSecM3ARIe2v2p1IcoHuoPdKpn3jxukGw5_sdzKf1bb5MioEdP3DaXnnuRDVcHdpbyvVVA37Ome3hFBFHDydRuOmN.AEZZ02psBHtEJY3e3ckrAftrr21gN26Hewyz7slr0Vrv.xgU.9mBnImxBrkHAEOUTDqXuyAezZ_QqhQ2CA",mdrd: "zfvtBZ2f2rTQAodlxC_7Pzmyzt0zvmwzCQOOBSWjQTE-1733174975-1.2.1.1-Z0euYFrUSLq4pD19z4e4BSoqJGlzvKvfQEraGelJDOPxdPwtIi76rvVx2bQUFLKIppIJYJUtU_aMCAovFndsmdvRlm1jSvgr900DAzgkQHYSUlcr4lYRCXFi7_GFE8BFqIW99yNq_.n7AoqOO2lkvhINH4nI3sjaedZ1IAIFxvN23ez3_VGwTLMjJHunH_4apttaJjV1ujlZ.KSXjj6UN6x1EXV5uNXgZBwhW7r4OXqff6NO5z7ciex.S9Dsohv3AepYJNtrZ.FAHQ_H0wxXD7s1o8ZbZU1q5FdApxMyMbOa.z7HvKmNl8YmtpRjm8EnAP7sFryuUJO3htcIIxJOXPKHALLhZ2FQ1OU3nYrC18hGNxBebdBk8_b9VtgrC1EKWe7BIAx_pqijcjvIkv5UTPkVxcd3YMbT8SxQFamNZpCxr6UTiKoCPQ3M97.Eya03VY72KiMggB4.65isfp1AFiwkbrEO0l7NvNcY.7WlNLtTbUy1t2_j83jb1tF7iKkwC0J.X59SpuWk1VhgbkP9O5Kzi8bW2uhA3rY1gXQWnCWvu5d13i0bp35owuSG9Dk1BO_t1n_BoIKRJIvC1U8aHbZl4a35ZIinLHdPfedz7v10Ya101ooT3NSr_uOW1EyJLdNivDtSN6etGRBBeaj24HD3jAImTwt2HkTsrniJktuJnvKb8UvBCuhc_UemeNK6obET3S5edMC_bmeXR2TXt5G0SJbf2iwgGApswtH_a4C43HbT0WJNzaDxLkHD3jCGHJ.TbdEXsjehuSxENpoT8HqSq2FvWqipLjrvMob3phnmZ0h0vTc9.gegyXhYkv_EeRyXJP0NKr9CCUgtFjvfBf3QEo_Ib5.3UDGtuQ5ImuyfK1Li9WD3cMQYRHvcwkkO2SGQGgqoxf1_S5.L6WToSKNwz_303NAERp0OzRzTBzkq4BeIwfwmFQCV8tlj7vbt4Avwj18XaZ.hHnuMACjAU.xt8youOYhQlFL5kEHDBW1jpDKQoRgZfSK.8ahPcsuPaasJ_eTjBAvqxdhpIFjqUrp9uljrn7oroOWxbixt_rnNlXO3OC1BLaa2uwJJ283rj9fjpU8HvkgFkOs1pikRdkSk.kPY8DyssaSbXgCj8Kp2xuFNxUXU25ZEValM4PZBtr2zMVZMj0y1rs4tYpK11jyBLEXU8x56vxfnoo1QQ0wDWK8cQzTMzuiyroXdGUhAnEXKVNPabaFBNzbC_tWOBIlhGggD9YKSVWgwpgxmdOiHc2GbfdjWVeCuAawtfkbqJX0FiP5i02xc6S38AQnNspOXVs8wDv4cUrL4OVzNwRGYy4fWR.ccdOhB_q1iEmccTkoAu2eNdfUtHvgmrCXE5OMXwj99nPN5noA6ALDVnhXkknN5zFade.GE8Xr8deu_kSCexLO6p9Ix2YOL6a8c3aIDbY7jJuGZ2LW709mSPIcYKMdcNfbnQ5XHsjOpb1x58iXDplH8ZwvSPzvi1lnvMknHRpZS291zG.hHTdyLA2hXFx5g6exFJnnCTae.Azo82xMfwXig8hXkkd6pbcvhu7GFLDOXv8IPDtYh76M2a_1NfCDRk59_bga99Tq7NtpgLwCsHENIVYan7B0owC67kv9PZi0H_K7SE22dtG47NITypxjefFZpLIkNHCxVV8o8dAUKrxrHrnjNsCWHZQOLPqGxjLDUFVWz7xSGZeczFFqPZQ8lhHfNX8paX4sgimo4xoVgROebPUc2EecBFLilXm23vTaoEu3UAlh5zhl.EjtwW1dRvVvwlbaxgBohFUBYAFZnNo9sZrNfuLt3zNr1V9hkRh7.pa7SP1t3PphPa9HS3Hdd4sLs6ZTKWT78J9gAQHbvMC3iN4Va7B2Dr3jHV4CmAzb4PQKQ5shngYui_sTvfTEliCleJ7xxWgPRPffpm0qZXh8nAJfZTJkT39XeZzCZH7HReTkJAXtl974zFpc"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8ebe69ceca0ece5f';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/Nadeem_Walayat?__cf_chl_rt_tk=TUdnHAm4NmtAU8gjISp1nDytd7pbLL1a1VJI5WGidgY-1733174975-1.0.1.1-oVtgDAPczQSs7aDXeYNAOee5kLOJmG6K1A0_qxFnkS8" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>