CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en"><head><meta charSet="utf-8" data-next-head=""/><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width" data-next-head=""/><title data-next-head="">How evolution ‘hacked’ its way to intelligence from the bottom up | Aeon Essays</title><meta name="robots" content="index,follow,max-image-preview:large" data-next-head=""/><meta name="description" content="Powerful tricks from computer science and cybernetics show how evolution ‘hacked’ its way to intelligence from the bottom up" data-next-head=""/><meta property="og:title" content="How evolution ‘hacked’ its way to intelligence from the bottom up | Aeon Essays" data-next-head=""/><meta property="og:description" content="Powerful tricks from computer science and cybernetics show how evolution ‘hacked’ its way to intelligence from the bottom up" data-next-head=""/><meta property="og:url" content="https://aeon.co/essays/how-evolution-hacked-its-way-to-intelligence-from-the-bottom-up" data-next-head=""/><meta property="og:type" content="article" data-next-head=""/><meta property="og:image" content="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto" data-next-head=""/><meta property="og:image:alt" content="<p>How do the tadpole’s facial organs know when to stop moving? <em>Photo by MYN/Seth Patterson/NPL/SPL</em></p>" data-next-head=""/><meta property="og:image:width" content="2000" data-next-head=""/><meta property="og:image:height" content="1252" data-next-head=""/><link rel="canonical" href="https://aeon.co/essays/how-evolution-hacked-its-way-to-intelligence-from-the-bottom-up" data-next-head=""/><meta name="theme-color" content="#940b52" data-next-head=""/><meta name="twitter:label1" content="Reading time" data-next-head=""/><meta name="twitter:data1" content="19 min read" data-next-head=""/><link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="Aeon | a world of ideas" href="/feed.rss" data-next-head=""/><link rel="alternate" type="application/atom+xml" title="Aeon | a world of ideas" href="/feed.atom" data-next-head=""/><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="180x180" href="/apple-touch-icon.png"/><link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="32x32" href="/favicon-32x32.png"/><link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="16x16" href="/favicon-16x16.png"/><link rel="manifest" href="/site.webmanifest"/><link rel="mask-icon" href="/safari-pinned-tab.svg" color="#025744"/><meta name="msapplication-TileColor" content="#025744"/><meta property="og:locale" content="en_GB"/><meta property="og:site_name" content="Aeon"/><meta name="twitter:site" content="aeonmag"/><meta name="twitter:creator" content="aeonmag"/><meta name="twitter:handle" content="aeonmag"/><meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"/><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/media/538aa150e70bb0e9-s.p.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin="anonymous" data-next-font="size-adjust"/><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/media/6daa5bd7fcbb74b3-s.p.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin="anonymous" data-next-font="size-adjust"/><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/media/bb8bc349fb9085d3-s.p.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin="anonymous" data-next-font="size-adjust"/><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/media/76ec520b10cf61c1-s.p.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin="anonymous" data-next-font="size-adjust"/><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/media/be1d251c3523f6c1-s.p.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin="anonymous" data-next-font="size-adjust"/><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/media/46ff188e4f14d755-s.p.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin="anonymous" data-next-font="size-adjust"/><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/media/d9a332ee39940cb2-s.p.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin="anonymous" data-next-font="size-adjust"/><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/media/ca8f97d31cafa4d7-s.p.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin="anonymous" data-next-font="size-adjust"/><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/media/6c8357f92cf4c46f-s.p.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin="anonymous" data-next-font="size-adjust"/><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/media/66d1f98d5da4f8f9-s.p.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin="anonymous" data-next-font="size-adjust"/><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/media/f6255d3e90d2d94d-s.p.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin="anonymous" data-next-font="size-adjust"/><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/css/fb828e2e309da67f.css" as="style"/><meta name="sentry-trace" content="5d07da167abc07fdca4b03db3419b309-ee27a0de654024d6-0"/><meta name="baggage" content="sentry-environment=production,sentry-release=9efc8e95a615083f456d555792b88f71d3edcab7,sentry-public_key=68076d06c1cbd5a834da0db07ee614fc,sentry-trace_id=5d07da167abc07fdca4b03db3419b309,sentry-sampled=false"/><script type="application/ld+json" data-next-head="">{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"BreadcrumbList","itemListElement":[{"@type":"ListItem","position":1,"name":"Psychology","item":"https://aeon.co/psychology"},{"@type":"ListItem","position":2,"name":"Cognition and intelligence","item":"https://aeon.co/psychology/cognition-intelligence"},{"@type":"ListItem","position":3,"name":"Modular cognition","item":"https://aeon.co/essays/how-evolution-hacked-its-way-to-intelligence-from-the-bottom-up"}]}</script><script type="application/ld+json" data-next-head="">{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"BreadcrumbList","itemListElement":[{"@type":"ListItem","position":1,"name":"Essays","item":"https://aeon.co/essays"},{"@type":"ListItem","position":2,"name":"Modular cognition","item":"https://aeon.co/essays/how-evolution-hacked-its-way-to-intelligence-from-the-bottom-up"}]}</script><script type="application/ld+json" data-next-head="">{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"Article","datePublished":"2022-03-08","description":"Powerful tricks from computer science and cybernetics show how evolution ‘hacked’ its way to intelligence from the bottom up","mainEntityOfPage":{"@type":"WebPage","@id":"https://aeon.co/essays/how-evolution-hacked-its-way-to-intelligence-from-the-bottom-up"},"headline":"How evolution ‘hacked’ its way to intelligence from the bottom up | Aeon Essays","image":["https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto"],"dateModified":"2024-08-01","author":[{"@type":"Person","name":"Michael Levin","url":"https://aeon.co/users/michael-levin"},{"@type":"Person","name":"Rafael Yuste","url":"https://aeon.co/users/rafael-yuste"}],"publisher":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Aeon Magazine","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","url":"https://aeon.co/logo.png"}},"isAccessibleForFree":true,"articleBody":"Intelligent decision-making doesn’t require a brain. You were capable of it before you even had one. Beginning life as a single fertilised egg, you divided and became a mass of genetically identical cells. They chattered among themselves to fashion a complex anatomical structure – your body. Even more remarkably, if you had split in two as an embryo, each half would have been able to replace what was missing, leaving you as one of two identical (monozygotic) twins. Likewise, if two mouse embryos are mushed together like a snowball, a single, normal mouse results. Just how do these embryos know what to do? We have no technology yet that has this degree of plasticity – recognising a deviation from the normal course of events and responding to achieve the same outcome overall. This is intelligence in action: the ability to reach a particular goal or solve a problem by undertaking new steps in the face of changing circumstances. It’s evident not just in intelligent people and mammals and birds and cephalopods, but also cells and tissues, individual neurons and networks of neurons, viruses, ribosomes and RNA fragments, down to motor proteins and molecular networks. Across all these scales, living things solve problems and achieve goals by flexibly navigating different spaces – metabolic, physiological, genetic, cognitive, behavioural. But how did intelligence emerge in biology? The question has preoccupied scientists since Charles Darwin, but it remains unanswered. The processes of intelligence are so intricate, so multilayered and baroque, no wonder some people might be tempted by stories about a top-down Creator. But we know evolution must have been able to come up with intelligence on its own, from the bottom up. Darwin’s best shot at an explanation was that random mutations changed and rearranged genes, altered the structure and function of bodies, and so produced adaptations that allowed certain organisms to thrive and reproduce in their environment. (In technical terms, they are selected for by the environment.) In the end, somehow, intelligence was the result. But there’s plenty of natural and experimental evidence to suggest that evolution doesn’t just select hardwired solutions that are engineered for a specific setting. For example, lab studies have shown that perfectly normal frog skin cells, when liberated from the instructive influence of the rest of the embryo, can reboot their cooperative activity to produce a novel proto-organism, called a ‘xenobot’. Evolution, it seems, doesn’t come up with answers so much as generate flexible problem-solving agents that can rise to new challenges and figure things out on their own. The urgency of understanding intelligence in biological terms has become more acute with the ‘omics’ revolution, where new techniques are amassing enormous amounts of fresh data on the genes, proteins and connections within each cell. Yet the deluge of information about cellular hardware isn’t yielding a better explanation of the intelligent flexibility we observe in living systems. Nor is it yielding sufficient practical insights, for example, in the realm of regenerative medicine. We think the real problem is not one of data, but of perspective. Intelligence is not something that happened at the tail end of evolution, but was discovered towards the beginning, long before brains came on the scene. From the earliest metabolic cycles that kept microbes’ chemical parameters within the right ranges, biology has been capable of achieving aims. Yet generation after generation of biologists have been trained to avoid questions about the ultimate purpose of things. Biologists are told to focus on the ‘how’, not the ‘why’, or risk falling prey to theology. Students must reduce events to their simplest components and causes, and study these mechanisms in piecemeal fashion. Talk of ‘goals’, we are told, skirts perilously close to abandoning naturalism; the result is a kind of ‘teleophobia’, a fear of purpose, based on the idea that attributing too much intelligence to a system is the worst mistake you can make. But the converse is just as bad: failing to recognise intelligence when it’s right under our noses, and could be useful. Not only is ‘why’ always present in biological systems – it is exactly what drives the ‘how’. Once we open ourselves up to that idea, we can identify two powerful tricks, inspired by computer science and cybernetics, that allowed evolution to ‘hack’ its way to intelligence from the bottom up. No skyhooks needed. Embryos aren’t the only things capable of flexible self-repair. Many species can regenerate or replace lost body parts as adults. The Mexican salamander known as the axolotl can regrow lost limbs, eyes, jaws and ovaries, as well as the spinal cord and portions of the heart and brain. The body recognises deviations from its correct anatomy as errors, and the cells work rapidly to get back to normal. Similarly, when Picasso-style tadpoles are made in the lab, with eyes and other organs randomly placed in different starting positions, they undergo novel paths of movement that nevertheless end up creating largely normal frog faces. How do the tadpole’s facial organs know when to stop moving? How does the salamander’s tissue determine that a limb of the right size and shape has been produced, and that the remodelling can stop? It’s clear that cell groups need to be able to ‘work until goal X is satisfied’, storing a memory of the goal (which might be an anatomical configuration much larger than any single cell), and course-correcting if they are perturbed along the way. One explanation of embryos’ amazing feats comes from control theory, which show us that dynamical systems (such as a thermostat) can pursue goals without magic, simply using feedback to correct for errors. Such ‘homeostasis’ in biology, as the process is known, keeps parameters such as pH within specific limits. But the same dynamic operates on a much larger scale, as long as cells are physiologically plugged into networks. Networks of cells are able to measure chemical, electrical and biomechanical properties of tissues, and make decisions about things that single cells cannot appreciate. Single cells can process local information about their environment and their own states to pursue tiny, cell-level goals (such as staying pointed in a specific direction). But networks of cells can integrate signals from across distances, store memories of patterns, and compute the outcomes of large-scale questions (such as ‘Is this finger the right length?’ or ‘Does this face look right?’) Cell networks carry out computations that can assess larger quantities (such as anatomical shape) and direct the underlying cell activity to bring the system closer to a specific desired goal (called a ‘setpoint’). Modularity means that the stakes for testing out mutations are reasonably low Achieving such intelligent, finely tuned calibration likely relies on modularity – the first step that we believe can explain the emergence of intelligent behaviour. Like a large organisation that deploys a number of specialised teams to make and sell a single product, modularity is about self-maintaining units that can cooperate or compete to achieve local outcomes, but end up collectively working towards some larger goal. Crucially, this structure avoids micromanagement – each level doesn’t need to know how the lower levels do their job, but can simply motivate them (with things like reward molecules and stress pathways) to get it done. Modularity – the presence of competent subunits, which solve problems in their own local problem space, that can cooperate and compete to achieve bigger goals – is part of what enables the emergence of intelligence in biology. The way these modules’ agendas are nested within one another in biological networks gives them the flexibility to meet goals at each level, even when conditions change at lower levels When unicellular organisms joined up to make multicellular bodies, each module didn’t lose its individual competency. Rather, cells used specific proteins to merge into ever more complex networks that could implement larger objectives, possess longer memories and look further into the future. Networks of cells began to work as a society – measuring and pursuing goals defined at the level of the collective (such as ‘organ size’ and ‘organ shape’). Stress about large-scale states (such as ‘attention: finger too short’) triggered change, which was shared across tissues to implement coordinated action. This multiscale architecture has many advantages. For one, it’s easy for evolution to simply shift the modules around and let the cycle of error reduction take care of the rest – setting new conditions as the setpoint, or the source of stress (eg, ‘wrong length of limbs’ instead of ‘misfolded proteins’). It’s similar to how you can change the setpoint of your thermostat without having to rewire it, or even know how it works. Feedback loops within feedback loops, and a nested hierarchy of incentivised modules that can be reshuffled by evolution, offer immense problem-solving power. One implication of this hierarchy of homeostatically stable, nested modules is that organisms became much more flexible while still maintaining a coherent ‘self’ in a hostile world. Evolution didn’t have to tweak everything at once in response to a new threat, because biological subunits were primed to find novel ways of compensating for changes and functioning within altered systems. For example, in planarian flatworms, which reliably regenerate every part of the body, using drugs to shift the bioelectrically stored pattern memory results in two-headed worms. Remarkably, fragments of these worms continue to regenerate two heads in perpetuity, without editing the genome. Moreover, flatworms can be induced, by brief modulation of the bioelectric circuit, to regrow heads with shape (and brain structure) appropriate to other known species of flatworms (at about 100 million years of evolutionary distance), despite their wild-type genome. Modularity means that the stakes for testing out mutations are reasonably low: competent subunits can be depended upon to meet their goals under a wide range of conditions, so evolution rarely needs to ‘worry’ that a single mutation could ruin the show. For example, if a new mutation results in an eye being in the wrong place, a hardwired organism would find it very hard to survive. However, modular systems can compensate for the change while moving the eye back to where it’s supposed to be (or enabling it to work in its new location), thus having the opportunity to explore other, possibly useful, effects of the mutation. Tadpole eyes have been shown to do this, conferring vision even if asked to form on the tail, by finding connections to the spinal cord instead of the brain. Modularity provides stability and robustness, and is the first part of the answer to how intelligence arose. When changes occur to one part of the body, its evolutionary history as a nested doll of competent, problem-solving cells means subunits can step up and modify their activity to keep the organism alive. This isn’t a separate capacity that evolved from scratch in complex organisms, but instead an inevitable consequence of the ancient ability of cells to look after themselves and the networks of which they form a part. But just how are these modules controlled? The second step on the road to the emergence of intelligence lies in knowing how modules can be manipulated. Encoding information in networks requires the ability to catalyse complex outcomes with simple signals. This is known as pattern completion: the capacity of one particular element in the module to activate the entire module. That special element, which serves as a ‘trigger’, starts the activity, kicking the other members of the module into action and completing the pattern. In this way, instead of activating the entire module, evolution needs only to activate that trigger. Pattern completion is an essential aspect of modularity which we’re just beginning to understand, thanks to work in developmental biology and neuroscience. For example, an entire eye can be created in the gut of a frog embryo by briefly altering the bioelectric state of some cells. These cells are triggered to complete the eye pattern by recruiting nearby neighbours (which were not themselves bioelectrically altered) to fill in the rest of the eye. Similar outcomes can be achieved by genetic or chemical ‘master regulators’, such as the Hox genes that specify the body plan of most bilaterally symmetrical animals. In fact, one could relabel these regulator genes as pattern completion genes, since they enable the coordinated expression of a suite of other genes from a simple signal. The key is that modules, by continuing to work until certain conditions are met, can fill in a complex pattern when given only a small part of the pattern. In doing so, they translate a simple command – the activation of the trigger – and amplify it into an entire program. Crucially, pattern completion doesn’t require defining all of the information needed to create an organ. Evolution does not have to rediscover how to specify all the cell types and get them arranged in the correct orientation – all it has to do is activate a simple trigger, and the modular organisation of development (where cells build to a specific pattern) does the rest. Pattern completion enables the emergence of developmental complexity and intelligence: simple triggers of complex cascades that make it possible for random changes to DNA to generate coherent, functional (and occasionally advantageous) bodies. Modular pattern completion is also becoming evident in recent experiments in neuroscience. The pinnacle of intelligent behaviour in biology is the human brain. Nervous systems are built with large numbers of neurons, where every neuron is typically connected to very large numbers of other neurons. Over evolutionary time, there’s been a steady progression to larger and more connected brains, reaching astronomical numbers – with close to 100 billion neurons and hundreds of thousands of connections per neuron in humans. This move towards higher numbers of neurons and connections cannot be a coincidence: a system with many interacting units is exactly what it takes to become more competent and complex. Analysing the brain by looking at a single neuron is like trying to understand a movie from an isolated pixel But what exactly do all these vast neural circuits do? While many neuroscientists would agree that the function of the nervous system is to sense the environment and generate behaviour, it’s less clear how that actually happens. The traditional view known as the ‘neuron doctrine’, proposed by Santiago Ramón y Cajal and Charles Scott Sherrington more than a century ago, is that each neuron has a specific function. This would make the brain analogous to an aeroplane, built with millions of components, each precisely designed for a particular task. Within this framing, neuroscientists have teased apart the brain and studied it one neuron at a time, linking the activity of individual neurons to the behaviour of the animal or the mental state of a person. Yet if the true goals of biological systems derive from how their subunits or modules interact, then analysing the brain by looking at a single neuron is as futile as trying to understand a movie while fixating on an isolated pixel. What type of properties might neural circuits generate? Because neurons can set each other off, neural circuits can generate internal states of activity that are independent of the outside world. A group of connected neurons could auto-excite each other and become active together for a period of time, even if nothing external is happening. This is how we might understand the existence of the concepts and abstractions that populate the human mind – as the endogenous activity of modules, made up of ensembles of neurons. Using those intrinsic activity states as symbols, evolution could then build formal representations of reality. It could manipulate those states instead of manipulating the reality, just as we do by defining mathematical terms to explore relationships between objects. From this point of view – the gist of which was already proposed by Immanuel Kant in his Critique of Pure Reason (1781, 1787) – the evolution of the nervous system represents the appearance of a new formal world, a symbolic world, that greatly expands the possibilities of the physical world because it gives us a way to explore and manipulate it mentally. Neuronal modules could also be organised in a hierarchy, where higher-level modules encode and symbolise increasingly more abstract entities. For example, lower-level groups of neurons in our spinal cord might activate muscle fibres, and be under the control of upper-level ensembles in the motor cortex that could encode the desired movement more abstractly (‘to change the position of the leg’). In turn, these motor cortex ensembles could be controlled by higher-order neurons again (‘to perform a pirouette’), which could be controlled by groups of neurons in the prefrontal cortex that represent the behavioural intention (‘to perform in a ballet’). Using modules nested in a hierarchy provides a neat solution to a tough design challenge: instead of specifying and controlling every element, one at a time, nature uses neuronal ensembles as computational building blocks to perform different functions at different levels. This progression towards increasing abstraction could help explain how cognition and consciousness might arise, as emergent functional properties, from relatively simple neural hardware. This same powerful idea of hierarchical emergence is behind the layered neural network models in computer science, named ‘neural’ because they are inspired by neural circuits. But back to Darwin’s problem: if evolution is blind and acting solely on the individual units, one mutation at a time, how can the overall architecture and function of an organism be modified for the common good? Besides generating modules, neural networks have another interesting property we’ve already discussed: pattern completion. In recent experiments, mice were induced to have artificial perceptions or visual hallucinations by activating only two neurons in their visual cortex. How is this possible, given that the mouse brain has around 100 million neurons? The answer is that those neurons can trigger a neuronal ensemble, via pattern completion. Neurons’ connectivity seems to amplify activity, so, like an avalanche, a change in one neuron ends up triggering the entire module. This means that you can activate an entire module of neurons by turning on only one key member of the group. Pattern completion shows us how a single event – say, a mutation – can change an army, or build an eye Pattern completion could be at the core of how the brain works internally – recruiting module after module, at different levels of the hierarchy, depending on the task at hand. But why wouldn’t pattern completion end up tripping the entire brain into an epileptic seizure? By adding inhibitory connections to these neural circuits – small circuit breakers – one can restrict these avalanches to small groups of neurons, instead of catastrophically activating the entire brain. By harnessing pattern completion along with inhibitory circuits, the brain has the ability to select and manipulate modules at different levels as needed. (I) Trigger stimuli allow for pattern completion, because networks can be organised such that they tend to settle in specific states (memories) from diverse positions (like the way a ball rolls down into a well from many different starting points). The topology of this landscape means that the system automatically returns to the same state when disturbed – symbolised by the ball falling to the bottom of a valley, when it is placed near the edge. This metaphor for pattern completion captures the idea of how the ‘landscape’ of the system ‘makes you do it’: it allows subunits to pursue local homeostatic goals (such as minimising a variable to move down a gradient), but enables the end result to be a higher-level pattern (II) The ability for networks to reach the same outcome from a range of partial inputs – the generalisation of pattern completion – is also exploited in computer science. For example, computational neural networks can recover an entire remembered image based on only a partial example, from which some aspect has been removed (III) The flatworm is a master of pattern completion, generating its entire anatomy from a small piece of its pattern. The bioelectric network of cells stores a pattern memory that controls individual cells in order to restore the whole (IV) Pattern completion is also present in neural circuits, where a small group of connected neurons can store associative memory. Here, you see: a) independent neurons are present without synaptic connections; b) neurons 1, 3 and 5 are activated simultaneously by external inputs, which forms and strengthens the synaptic connections between them; c) when the input ceases, neuronal activity also stops (however, the synaptic connections between the three neurons remain; these neurons have formed a module, and their interconnectivity determines how the module activates); d) an input activates just one of the original three neurons, but the connections activate all three neurons and complete the entire pattern; e) even after the input current has ended, the neurons can remain persistently active, in effect, storing a memory of the input In this way, pattern completion enables connections between modules at the same and different levels of the hierarchy, knitting them together as a single system. A key neuron in a lower-level module can be activated by an upper-level one, and vice versa. Like changing the march of an army, you don’t need to convince every soldier to do so – just convince the general, who makes the others fall into line. Consistent with the many parallels between neurons and non-neural signals, pattern completion shows us how a single event – say, a mutation – can change an army, or build an eye. From microbe cells solving problems in metabolic space, to tissues solving problems in anatomical space, to groups of people navigating the world as we know it, life has ratcheted towards intelligent designs by exploiting the ability of modules to get things done, in their own way. Homeostatic loops provide flexible responses, working until setpoints are achieved, even when things change. Modularity means that evolution can readily explore what the collective considers to be a ‘correct’ condition, and what actions it takes to get there. Hierarchies of modules mean that simple signals can trigger complex actions that don’t need to be rediscovered or micromanaged, yet can adapt when only a small piece of the puzzle triggers them to do so. We have sketched a set of approaches to biology that rely heavily on concepts from cybernetics, computer science, and engineering. But there’s still a lot of work to do in reconciling these approaches. Despite recent advances in molecular genetics, our understanding of the mapping between the genome on the one hand, and the (changeable) anatomy and physiology of the body on the other, is still at a very early stage. Much like computer science, which moved from rewiring hardware in the 1940s to a focus on algorithms and software that could control the device’s behaviour, biological sciences now need to change tack. We call on biologists to embrace the intentional stance: treating circuits and cells as problem-solving agents The impact of understanding nested intelligence across multiple scales cuts across numerous fields, from fundamental questions about our evolutionary origins to practical roadmaps for AI, regenerative medicine and biorobotics. Understanding the control systems implemented in living tissue could lead to major advances in biomedicine. If we truly grasp how to control the setpoints of bodies, we might be able to repair birth defects, induce regeneration of organs, and perhaps even defeat ageing (some cnidarians and planarian flatworms are essentially immortal, demonstrating that complex organisms without a lifespan limit are possible, using the same types of cells of which we are made). Perhaps cancer can also be addressed as a disease of modularity: the mechanisms by which body cells cooperate can occasionally break down, leading to a reversion of cells to their unicellular past – a more selfish mode in which they treat the rest of the body as an environment within which they reproduce maximally. In the field of engineering, designers have traditionally built robots from dumb but reliable parts. By contrast, biology exploits the unreliability of components, making the most of the competency of each level (molecular, cellular, tissue, organ, organism, and colony) to look after itself. This enables an incredible range of adaptive plasticity. If we break the neuronal code in biology, we could begin to program behaviour into synthetic nervous systems, and build self-repairing, flexible robots. Recent work shows that agential cells with their own local agendas can already be guided to create entirely new, autonomous biorobots. And beyond robots’ bodies, these ideas also open up new approaches to machine learning and AI: raising prospects for architectures based on ancient and diverse problem-solving ensembles beyond brains, such as those of bacteria and metazoa. This emerging confluence of developmental biology, neuroscience, biophysics, computer science and cognitive science could have profound and potentially transformative applications. Top-down strategies exploiting – in effect, collaborating with – biology’s native intelligence could enable transformative progress in areas oppressed by a narrow focus on molecular and genetic detail. With that in mind, we call on biologists to embrace the intentional stance: treating circuits, cells and cellular processes as competent problem-solving agents with agendas, and the capacity to detect and store information – no longer a metaphor, but a serious hypothesis made plausible by the emergence of intelligent behaviour in phylogenetic history. If we can come to recognise intelligence in its most unfamiliar guises, it might just revolutionise our understanding of the natural world and our very nature as cognitive beings. "}</script><link rel="preload" as="image" imageSrcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" imageSizes="(max-width: 1700px) 100vw, 1700px" data-next-head=""/><link rel="stylesheet" href="/_next/static/css/fb828e2e309da67f.css" data-n-g=""/><noscript data-n-css=""></noscript><script defer="" noModule="" src="/_next/static/chunks/polyfills-42372ed130431b0a.js"></script><script defer="" src="/_next/static/chunks/2364-d35dc790bd46d900.js"></script><script defer="" src="/_next/static/chunks/4056.74c5d8b79e6848d5.js"></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/webpack-50309bdf0b3852b4.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/framework-8089a586c32f8265.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/main-019f0422e7a1b4dd.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/pages/_app-8a1e24d76b7a975e.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/3105-8d6e4d1e5eea25c1.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/402-7cb03f9c5e1648e7.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/3199-9bfcbb7caeb6b2c5.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/5135-23ce1ea95d917382.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/5473-e2417ebcba846f10.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/5206-dc93087e6e9c6344.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/6229-7b9cc71f525cbc26.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/2262-7bea8a389c1df89b.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/981-887ac5b80c77e2e7.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/5575-5fdc8b2e8c9b59e6.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/pages/essays/%5Bid%5D-3059023585183cb1.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/uitKSFrMC3o69YICzwJS8/_buildManifest.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/uitKSFrMC3o69YICzwJS8/_ssgManifest.js" defer=""></script><style data-styled="" data-styled-version="6.1.13">.kijMKl{padding:0 1.8rem;}/*!sc*/ @media screen and (max-width:640px){.kijMKl{padding:0 0.6rem;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g1[id="sc-47bc2fa8-0"]{content:"kijMKl,"}/*!sc*/ .iPkIIN{box-sizing:border-box;max-width:140rem;padding:0 1.8rem;display:flex;flex-direction:row;margin-left:auto;margin-right:auto;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:1440px){.iPkIIN{max-width:120rem;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g2[id="sc-ae266dcd-0"]{content:"iPkIIN,"}/*!sc*/ .jnfNRX{margin-right:3.6rem;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:960px){.jnfNRX{margin-bottom:2.4rem;}}/*!sc*/ .TldsU{margin-right:0rem;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:960px){.TldsU{margin-bottom:2.4rem;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g3[id="sc-bab0e3bb-0"]{content:"jnfNRX,TldsU,"}/*!sc*/ .kDfACp{display:flex;font-size:1.6rem;flex-direction:column;line-height:1.6;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g4[id="sc-bab0e3bb-1"]{content:"kDfACp,"}/*!sc*/ .lerFoj{color:rgba(0,0,0,0.65);text-decoration:none;font-size:1.6rem;margin:0.2rem 0;padding:0.4rem 0;}/*!sc*/ .lerFoj:hover{color:#000;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g5[id="sc-9fe3192b-0"]{content:"lerFoj,"}/*!sc*/ .exRbDE{display:flex;order:0;flex-wrap:wrap;margin-right:3rem;height:100%;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g6[id="sc-1b596d24-0"]{content:"exRbDE,"}/*!sc*/ .ivgdIo{order:2;margin-right:3rem;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:960px){.ivgdIo{margin-bottom:2.4rem;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g7[id="sc-89e3ac83-0"]{content:"ivgdIo,"}/*!sc*/ .hqHrdb{display:flex;margin-top:0.5rem;}/*!sc*/ .hqHrdb a{display:flex;align-items:center;padding:0.8rem 2rem 0.8rem 0;}/*!sc*/ .hqHrdb svg{vertical-align:middle;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g9[id="sc-89e3ac83-2"]{content:"hqHrdb,"}/*!sc*/ .eHbyYZ{margin:0;font-size:1.6rem;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g10[id="sc-89e3ac83-3"]{content:"eHbyYZ,"}/*!sc*/ .floFPv{display:flex;flex-direction:row;align-items:flex-start;position:relative;}/*!sc*/ .caYqFN{display:flex;flex-direction:row;align-items:flex-start;position:relative;}/*!sc*/ @media screen and (max-width: 640px){.caYqFN{display:flex;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g20[id="sc-fd9debe5-0"]{content:"floFPv,caYqFN,"}/*!sc*/ .gDCUIo{width:18px;height:18px;cursor:pointer;flex-grow:0;stroke:currentColor;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (max-width:639px){.gDCUIo{position:relative;top:1px;height:18px;width:18px;}}/*!sc*/ @media screen and (max-width:640px){.gDCUIo{margin-top:5px;}}/*!sc*/ .bRXmuI{width:18px;height:18px;cursor:pointer;flex-grow:0;stroke:currentColor;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (max-width:639px){.bRXmuI{position:relative;top:1px;height:18px;width:18px;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g21[id="sc-fd9debe5-1"]{content:"gDCUIo,bRXmuI,"}/*!sc*/ .kEXjQT{appearance:none;background-color:transparent;border:0;color:inherit;flex-grow:0;font-size:1.6rem;height:100%;letter-spacing:0.1rem;margin:0;outline:0;padding:0 0 0 0.5rem;transition:width ease-in-out 50ms;vertical-align:top;width:15em;display:flex;position:absolute;left:23px;z-index:50;}/*!sc*/ @media screen and (max-width:1280px){.kEXjQT{width:12.5rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media screen and (max-width:640px){.kEXjQT{font-size:16px;padding:0 0 0 0.5rem;background-color:transparent;width:50vw;top:0;left:25px;background-color:white;}}/*!sc*/ .lmMgnX{appearance:none;background-color:transparent;border:0;color:inherit;flex-grow:0;font-size:1.6rem;height:100%;letter-spacing:0.1rem;margin:0;outline:0;padding:0 0 0 0.5rem;transition:width ease-in-out 50ms;vertical-align:top;width:0;display:none;position:absolute;left:23px;z-index:50;}/*!sc*/ @media screen and (max-width:640px){.lmMgnX{font-size:16px;padding:0 0 0 0.5rem;background-color:transparent;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g22[id="sc-fd9debe5-2"]{content:"kEXjQT,lmMgnX,"}/*!sc*/ .dylIji{padding:0 1.8rem;overflow-x:hidden;overflow-y:auto;height:100%;max-width:138rem;margin:0 auto;padding-top:10px;min-height:-webkit-fill-available;}/*!sc*/ @media (min-width:640px){.dylIji{padding:0 8.181818181818182rem;min-height:60vh;}}/*!sc*/ .dylIji a:hover{opacity:1;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g23[id="sc-d55b82-0"]{content:"dylIji,"}/*!sc*/ .drewAj{display:flex;position:relative;}/*!sc*/ .drewAj >*{width:50%;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.drewAj >*:first-child{width:60%;}.drewAj >*:last-child{width:40%;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g24[id="sc-d55b82-1"]{content:"drewAj,"}/*!sc*/ .fRfBtu{background-color:#fff8;color:black;position:fixed;top:0;width:100%;min-height:100vh;min-height:-webkit-fill-available;z-index:2500;opacity:0;pointer-events:none;transition:opacity 0.2s cubic-bezier(.645,.045,.355,1);}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g25[id="sc-d55b82-2"]{content:"fRfBtu,"}/*!sc*/ .bngHQt{background-color:#fff;box-shadow:rgb(0,0,0,0.25) 0px 0px 3rem;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:640px){.bngHQt{background-color:#fff;max-width:100%;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g26[id="sc-d55b82-3"]{content:"bngHQt,"}/*!sc*/ .gjLQWl{display:flex;flex-direction:column;padding:0rem 0 1.8rem 0;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g27[id="sc-d55b82-4"]{content:"gjLQWl,"}/*!sc*/ .jwvsks{color:#0c776d;font-size:4.2rem;font-weight:600;padding:0;line-height:1.2;}/*!sc*/ .jwvsks:hover{text-decoration:underline;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.jwvsks{font-size:2.4rem;line-height:1.3;}}/*!sc*/ .jjoRww{color:#035a6d;font-size:4.2rem;font-weight:600;padding:0;line-height:1.2;}/*!sc*/ .jjoRww:hover{text-decoration:underline;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.jjoRww{font-size:2.4rem;line-height:1.3;}}/*!sc*/ .EINud{color:#940b52;font-size:4.2rem;font-weight:600;padding:0;line-height:1.2;}/*!sc*/ .EINud:hover{text-decoration:underline;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.EINud{font-size:2.4rem;line-height:1.3;}}/*!sc*/ .jHnWNL{color:#9d120d;font-size:4.2rem;font-weight:600;padding:0;line-height:1.2;}/*!sc*/ .jHnWNL:hover{text-decoration:underline;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.jHnWNL{font-size:2.4rem;line-height:1.3;}}/*!sc*/ .diZTdY{color:#c16e15;font-size:4.2rem;font-weight:600;padding:0;line-height:1.2;}/*!sc*/ .diZTdY:hover{text-decoration:underline;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.diZTdY{font-size:2.4rem;line-height:1.3;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g28[id="sc-d55b82-5"]{content:"jwvsks,jjoRww,EINud,jHnWNL,diZTdY,"}/*!sc*/ .kwwdYL{display:flex;flex-direction:column;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:640px),(max-height:700px){.kwwdYL{flex-direction:row;}.kwwdYL >*{flex:1;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g29[id="sc-d55b82-6"]{content:"kwwdYL,"}/*!sc*/ .kpvHEa{padding:0rem 0 1.8rem 0;display:flex;flex-direction:column;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g30[id="sc-d55b82-7"]{content:"kpvHEa,"}/*!sc*/ .cqAtlQ{font-size:3.2rem;line-height:1.4;padding:0;}/*!sc*/ .cqAtlQ:hover{text-decoration:underline;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.cqAtlQ{font-size:2.2rem;line-height:1.5;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g31[id="sc-d55b82-8"]{content:"cqAtlQ,"}/*!sc*/ .kgAmGp{padding:2.8rem 0 0;display:flex;flex-direction:column;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g32[id="sc-d55b82-9"]{content:"kgAmGp,"}/*!sc*/ .jzkOtF >a:first-child{margin-right:3rem;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.jzkOtF >a:first-child{margin-right:1rem;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g34[id="sc-d55b82-11"]{content:"jzkOtF,"}/*!sc*/ .uZtxm{padding:10rem 0;display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;align-items:center;margin-top:auto;row-gap:0.4rem;}/*!sc*/ .uZtxm .sc-d55b82-10{font-size:1.7rem;text-transform:uppercase;margin-right:3rem;letter-spacing:0.1em;line-height:1;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width: 720px){.uZtxm .sc-d55b82-10{font-size:1.4rem;margin-right:1rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media (min-width:640px){.uZtxm{padding:4rem 0;row-gap:1rem;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g35[id="sc-d55b82-12"]{content:"uZtxm,"}/*!sc*/ .egiTBt{display:flex;margin-bottom:3.5vh;padding-top:1.2rem;}/*!sc*/ .egiTBt a{display:flex;padding-right:1rem;margin-right:1rem;}/*!sc*/ .egiTBt a:hover{opacity:0.4;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.egiTBt svg{transform:scale(0.8);}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g36[id="sc-d55b82-13"]{content:"egiTBt,"}/*!sc*/ .jSkfoz{background-color:transparent;}/*!sc*/ .jSkfoz svg{margin-top:0;}/*!sc*/ @media screen and (max-width:640px){.jSkfoz input{max-width:100px;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g37[id="sc-d55b82-14"]{content:"jSkfoz,"}/*!sc*/ .jguBq{width:94px;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.jguBq{width:70px;margin-top:0.8rem;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g38[id="sc-d55b82-15"]{content:"jguBq,"}/*!sc*/ .flZngm{width:104px;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.flZngm{width:73px;margin-top:0.8rem;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g39[id="sc-d55b82-16"]{content:"flZngm,"}/*!sc*/ .frPYwM{background-color:white;color:#000;border-bottom:1px solid rgba(0,0,0,0);height:44px;display:flex;flex-direction:column;justify-content:center;padding-top:0px;padding-bottom:-1px;top:0;visiblity:hidden;position:absolute;width:100%;z-index:1000;background:transparent;color:white;padding:0;top:0;}/*!sc*/ .frPYwM a:hover{opacity:0.7;}/*!sc*/ .frPYwM:before{content:'';background:linear-gradient(black,transparent);height:200%;opacity:0.2;pointer-events:none;position:absolute;top:0px;transition:opacity 0.5s cubic-bezier(0.19,1,0.22,1) 0s;width:100%;z-index:-1;max-width:1700px;left:50%;transform:translateX(-50%);display:none;}/*!sc*/ .frPYwM:hover:before{display:block;opacity:0.45;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:640px){.frPYwM:hover:before{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:640px){.frPYwM{background-color:white;color:black;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:640px){.frPYwM{height:42px;}}/*!sc*/ @media print{.frPYwM{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g40[id="sc-d1112dbe-0"]{content:"frPYwM,"}/*!sc*/ .cMYQbZ{box-sizing:border-box;display:grid;font-size:1.44rem;letter-spacing:0.2rem;grid-row-gap:8px;grid-template-areas:'nav-left primary-logo nav-right' 'social-links primary-logo secondary-logo';grid-template-columns:322px auto 322px;grid-template-rows:auto;margin-left:auto;margin-right:auto;max-width:140rem;padding:0 2.4rem;position:relative;width:100%;max-height:44px;grid-template-areas:'nav-left social-links primary-logo nav-right';grid-template-rows:100%;grid-template-columns:125px 245px auto 365px;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.cMYQbZ{align-content:center;justify-content:space-between;}}/*!sc*/ @media (min-width:1281px){.cMYQbZ{grid-template-areas:'nav-left social-links primary-logo nav-right secondary-logo';grid-template-columns:125px 315px auto 365px 75px;}}/*!sc*/ @media (min-width:640px){.cMYQbZ{height:calc( 44px - (0px) * 2 );}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:960px){.cMYQbZ{font-size:1.3rem;grid-template-columns:35% auto 35%;grid-template-rows:100%;grid-template-columns:110px 100px auto 220px;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.cMYQbZ{grid-template-areas:'nav-left nav-left primary-logo nav-right nav-right' 'nav-left nav-left primary-logo nav-right nav-right';}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:640px){.cMYQbZ{font-size:1.2rem;grid-template-areas:'nav-left primary-logo nav-right';grid-template-columns:auto;grid-template-columns:120px 1fr 120px;margin-top:0;padding:0 2.4rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:480px){.cMYQbZ{font-size:1.1rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:340px){.cMYQbZ{font-size:1rem;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g41[id="sc-d1112dbe-1"]{content:"cMYQbZ,"}/*!sc*/ .kyBevc{grid-area:primary-logo;text-align:center;color:#940b52;line-height:0;display:flex;flex-direction:column;justify-content:center;align-items:center;}/*!sc*/ .kyBevc:hover{opacity:1;}/*!sc*/ .kyBevc svg path{fill:white;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:640px){.kyBevc svg path{fill:#940b52;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:640px){.kyBevc svg{height:20px;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g42[id="sc-d1112dbe-2"]{content:"kyBevc,"}/*!sc*/ .cdqCqH{grid-area:secondary-logo;text-align:right;display:flex;align-items:center;justify-content:flex-end;height:auto;}/*!sc*/ .cdqCqH a{display:inline-block;margin-top:4px;}/*!sc*/ .cdqCqH a::after{padding:0 1.2rem;content:'/';opacity:0.7;vertical-align:middle;position:relative;top:-0.5em;}/*!sc*/ .cdqCqH a:last-child::after{display:none;}/*!sc*/ .cdqCqH a:first-child{display:none;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:1280px){.cdqCqH{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:640px){.cdqCqH{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g43[id="sc-d1112dbe-3"]{content:"cdqCqH,"}/*!sc*/ .dKsuKq{text-transform:uppercase;display:flex;cursor:pointer;align-items:center;line-height:1;height:100%;}/*!sc*/ .dKsuKq:after{padding:0 0.6rem;opacity:0.7;content:'/';}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:768px){.dKsuKq{display:flex;height:25px;}.dKsuKq::after{padding:0 0.4rem;}.dKsuKq:last-child::after{content:'';display:none;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:1280px){.dKsuKq:last-child::after{content:'';display:none;}}/*!sc*/ .kLEOmn{text-transform:uppercase;display:flex;cursor:pointer;align-items:center;line-height:1;height:100%;}/*!sc*/ .kLEOmn:after{padding:0 0.6rem;opacity:0.7;content:'/';}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:768px){.kLEOmn{display:none;height:25px;}.kLEOmn::after{padding:0 0.4rem;}.kLEOmn:last-child::after{content:'';display:none;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:1280px){.kLEOmn:last-child::after{content:'';display:none;}}/*!sc*/ .dBDjrs{text-transform:uppercase;display:flex;cursor:pointer;align-items:center;line-height:1;height:100%;}/*!sc*/ .dBDjrs:after{padding:0 0.6rem;opacity:0.7;content:'/';}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:768px){.dBDjrs{display:flex;height:25px;}.dBDjrs::after{padding:0 0.4rem;}.dBDjrs:last-child::after{content:'';display:none;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:1280px){.dBDjrs:last-child::after{content:'';display:none;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:639px){.dBDjrs:after{content:'';padding:0;}}/*!sc*/ .jSrgPI{text-transform:uppercase;display:flex;cursor:pointer;align-items:center;line-height:1;height:100%;}/*!sc*/ .jSrgPI:after{padding:0 0.6rem;opacity:0.7;content:'/';}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:768px){.jSrgPI{display:flex;height:25px;}.jSrgPI::after{padding:0 0.4rem;}.jSrgPI:last-child::after{content:'';display:none;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:1280px){.jSrgPI:last-child::after{content:'';display:none;}.jSrgPI:after{content:'';padding:0;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g44[id="sc-d1112dbe-4"]{content:"dKsuKq,kLEOmn,dBDjrs,jSrgPI,"}/*!sc*/ .fjaqhm{display:flex;grid-area:social-links;height:auto;}/*!sc*/ .fjaqhm a{padding-right:1.2rem;display:flex;align-items:center;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:720px){.fjaqhm{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g46[id="sc-d1112dbe-6"]{content:"fjaqhm,"}/*!sc*/ .ktTsPo{height:25px;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (max-width:640px){.ktTsPo{height:24px;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g48[id="sc-d1112dbe-8"]{content:"ktTsPo,"}/*!sc*/ .dpXXtO{max-width:90%;}/*!sc*/ .dpXXtO input{background-color:transparent;font-size:1.3rem;color:grey;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:640px){.dpXXtO input{background-color:white;position:absolute;max-width:100%;top:0;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g49[id="sc-d1112dbe-9"]{content:"dpXXtO,"}/*!sc*/ .gNSpma{padding-left:0.6rem;padding-top:0.3rem;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g50[id="sc-d1112dbe-10"]{content:"gNSpma,"}/*!sc*/ .fdbSCf{white-space:nowrap;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (max-width:639px){.fdbSCf{padding:1rem 0 1rem 1rem;}}/*!sc*/ .fdbSCf >div{display:inline;}/*!sc*/ .fdbSCf >span{display:none;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:640px){.fdbSCf >div{display:none;}.fdbSCf >span{display:inline;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g51[id="sc-d1112dbe-11"]{content:"fdbSCf,"}/*!sc*/ .hBfeSY{width:auto;order:3;margin-right:3rem;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:960px){.hBfeSY{margin-bottom:2.4rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:960px){.hBfeSY{order:4;}}/*!sc*/ .hBfeSY .newsletter-signup div{background:inherit;padding:0;}/*!sc*/ .hBfeSY .newsletter-signup form{margin-left:0;}/*!sc*/ .hBfeSY .newsletter-signup h3{color:rgba(0,0,0,0.65);font-size:2rem;margin-top:0;}/*!sc*/ .hBfeSY .newsletter-signup h4{margin-top:0;color:rgba(0,0,0,0.65);font-size:1.4rem;margin-bottom:1.4rem;font-weight:normal;}/*!sc*/ .hBfeSY .newsletter-signup label{color:rgba(0,0,0,0.65);}/*!sc*/ @media (min-width:960px){.hBfeSY .newsletter-signup .frequency h3{margin-left:-0.5rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media (min-width:960px){.hBfeSY .newsletter-signup .submit{margin-right:2rem;margin-top:0.4rem;}}/*!sc*/ .hBfeSY .newsletter-signup .submit input{padding-bottom:0.95rem;padding-top:0.95rem;}/*!sc*/ .hBfeSY .newsletter-signup input[type='checkbox']:checked{background:rgba(0,0,0,0.65);}/*!sc*/ @media (min-width:960px){.hBfeSY .newsletter-signup .email{margin-right:2rem;}}/*!sc*/ .hBfeSY .newsletter-signup .email input{background:inherit;border:1px solid rgba(0,0,0,0.65);max-width:28rem;color:#444;padding:1.2rem;padding-bottom:1rem;}/*!sc*/ .hBfeSY .newsletter-signup .email input::placeholder{color:rgba(0,0,0,0.65);}/*!sc*/ .hBfeSY .newsletter-signup .submit~h3{margin-top:2.2rem;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g66[id="sc-f1ffec09-0"]{content:"hBfeSY,"}/*!sc*/ .vEOCJ{background:rgba(0,0,0,0.03);color:rgba(0,0,0,0.65);font-size:1.4rem;line-height:1.6;margin-top:auto;overflow:hidden;padding-bottom:3.6rem;padding-top:3.6rem;position:relative;z-index:23;}/*!sc*/ @media print{.vEOCJ{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g67[id="sc-4c328164-0"]{content:"vEOCJ,"}/*!sc*/ .kvvHSZ{margin-bottom:4.8rem;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:960px){.kvvHSZ{flex-wrap:wrap;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g68[id="sc-4c328164-1"]{content:"kvvHSZ,"}/*!sc*/ .gcQpnp{flex-direction:column;gap:0.5em;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g69[id="sc-4c328164-2"]{content:"gcQpnp,"}/*!sc*/ .eVINpq{color:rgba(0,0,0,0.6);font-size:1.2rem;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g70[id="sc-4c328164-3"]{content:"eVINpq,"}/*!sc*/ .bGPrlv{position:relative;flex-grow:1;width:100%;margin:0 auto;}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.bGPrlv{width:21cm;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g74[id="sc-a70232b9-0"]{content:"bGPrlv,"}/*!sc*/ .fQIWXN{background-color:#fff;display:flex;flex-direction:column;min-height:100vh;position:relative;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g75[id="sc-a70232b9-1"]{content:"fQIWXN,"}/*!sc*/ .fcpKFE{flex-grow:0;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g76[id="sc-a70232b9-2"]{content:"fcpKFE,"}/*!sc*/ .gqhDNV{flex-grow:0;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g77[id="sc-a70232b9-3"]{content:"gqhDNV,"}/*!sc*/ .gJZPyQ{z-index:500;}/*!sc*/ .bqrDzC{z-index:500;position:fixed;left:0;bottom:0;width:100%;box-shadow:0 0 30px #00000040;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g79[id="sc-a70232b9-5"]{content:"gJZPyQ,bqrDzC,"}/*!sc*/ .bWvakG .page-mark{cursor:pointer;transition:background 0.2s linear,outline 0.2s linear;}/*!sc*/ .bWvakG .page-mark.mark-type-highlight{background:rgba(255, 125, 0, 0.5);}/*!sc*/ .bWvakG .page-mark.mark-type-annotation{background:rgba(255, 0, 125, 0.3);}/*!sc*/ .bWvakG .page-mark[data-annotation-number]::after{display:inline-block;content:attr(data-annotation-number);font-size:50%;font-weight:bold;transform:translateY(-75%);color:#9d1d20;margin-right:-1ex;}/*!sc*/ .bWvakG img.page-mark.mark-type-highlight,.bWvakG iframe.page-mark.mark-type-highlight{outline:1rem solid rgba(255, 125, 0, 0.5);}/*!sc*/ .bWvakG img.page-mark.mark-type-annotation,.bWvakG iframe.page-mark.mark-type-annotation{outline:1rem solid rgba(255, 0, 125, 0.3);}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g94[id="sc-4ebaf8b7-2"]{content:"bWvakG,"}/*!sc*/ .dTqQqJ{padding-bottom:20px;color:#444;font-size:1.6rem;line-height:1.6;}/*!sc*/ .dTqQqJ a{text-decoration:underline;}/*!sc*/ .dTqQqJ p:first-of-type{display:inline;margin-top:0;}/*!sc*/ .dTqQqJ p:last-of-type{margin-bottom:0;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g99[id="sc-2e8621ab-0"]{content:"dTqQqJ,"}/*!sc*/ .iTsAjg{display:inline;margin-right:0.7ex;color:#444;font-size:1.6rem;line-height:1.6;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g100[id="sc-2e8621ab-1"]{content:"iTsAjg,"}/*!sc*/ .gKaMBo{position:relative;overflow:hidden;}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.gKaMBo{display:flex;flex-direction:column;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g101[id="sc-d0d42ecb-0"]{content:"gKaMBo,"}/*!sc*/ .jqqAJM{position:relative;aspect-ratio:500/313;object-fit:cover;}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.jqqAJM{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g102[id="sc-d0d42ecb-1"]{content:"jqqAJM,"}/*!sc*/ .cREOiH{margin:0;color:#940b52;padding:14px 24px 0 24px;position:relative;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:768px){.cREOiH{display:flex;flex-direction:column;padding:0;grid-area:top-left;text-align:left;align-items:flex-start;justify-content:flex-start;position:relative;color:white;line-height:1.2;position:relative;z-index:1;min-width:9em;}.cREOiH >*{position:relative;}.cREOiH >*:before{content:'';display:block;position:absolute;top:-2em;left:-2em;width:calc(100% + 4em);height:calc(100% + 4em);background:rgba(0,0,0,0.6);box-shadow:0 0 140px 140px rgba(0,0,0,0.6);z-index:-1;opacity:0.3;}}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.cREOiH{color:#000;padding:0 24px;}.cREOiH svg{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g103[id="sc-d0d42ecb-2"]{content:"cREOiH,"}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:768px){.WFpNr{position:absolute;top:0;right:0;left:0;bottom:0;padding:60px 25px 60px;height:100%;box-sizing:border-box;display:grid;grid-template-areas:'top-left top-center top-right' 'center-left center-center center-right' 'bottom-left bottom-center bottom-right';max-height:100vh;max-width:100%;}}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:1280px){.WFpNr{left:50%;transform:translateX(-50%);width:140rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.WFpNr{position:static;display:block;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g104[id="sc-d0d42ecb-3"]{content:"WFpNr,"}/*!sc*/ .bXNXzL{font-size:2rem;font-weight:normal;line-height:1.4;max-width:48rem;margin:0 0 1.6rem 0;}/*!sc*/ .bXNXzL .no-wrap{white-space:nowrap;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (max-width:767px){.bXNXzL{color:#000;margin:0 0 2.4rem;font-size:1.8rem;text-align:left;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g105[id="sc-d0d42ecb-4"]{content:"bXNXzL,"}/*!sc*/ .czwQmk{color:#000;margin:0 0 2.4rem;font-size:1.8rem;text-align:left;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:640px){.czwQmk{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ .czwQmk .toggleMobileCreditBtn{cursor:pointer;font-size:1.1rem;padding-left:1rem;font-weight:bold;background:#940b5221;mix-blend-mode:multiply;padding:4px 6px 3px;border-radius:10px;white-space:nowrap;}/*!sc*/ @media print{.czwQmk .toggleMobileCreditBtn{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g106[id="sc-d0d42ecb-5"]{content:"czwQmk,"}/*!sc*/ .jWJXvn{color:currentColor;display:flex;font-size:1.1rem;justify-content:flex-end;align-items:flex-end;padding:1rem;bottom:0;position:absolute;width:100%;z-index:500;}/*!sc*/ .jWJXvn p{margin:0 0 0.25rem;text-align:left;}/*!sc*/ .jWJXvn span{align-items:center;background-color:#fff;border-radius:50%;cursor:pointer;display:flex;font-size:1.4rem;font-weight:bold;height:24px;justify-content:center;overflow:hidden;position:relative;min-width:24px;margin:0;line-height:1;color:#940b52;}/*!sc*/ .jWJXvn span:before{background:#940b5211;border-radius:50%;content:'';height:100%;left:0;pointer-events:none;position:absolute;top:0;width:100%;}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.jWJXvn span{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ .jWJXvn .sc-d0d42ecb-7{opacity:0;display:none;}/*!sc*/ @media print,screen and (min-width: 768px){.jWJXvn{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g107[id="sc-d0d42ecb-6"]{content:"jWJXvn,"}/*!sc*/ .kHSJgS{color:#999;font-size:1.2rem;margin:0;max-width:720px;padding:0rem 2rem;text-align:left;}/*!sc*/ @media (min-width:640px){.kHSJgS{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g108[id="sc-d0d42ecb-7"]{content:"kHSJgS,"}/*!sc*/ .fTMbq{position:relative;min-height:17rem;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:768px){.fTMbq{display:grid;grid-template-areas:'main-tl main-tc main-tr' 'main-cl main-cc main-cr' 'main-bl main-bc main-br' 'attribution attribution attribution';grid-template-columns:0.5fr 1fr 0.5fr;grid-template-rows:0.5fr 1fr 0.5fr auto;}}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:1280px){.fTMbq{grid-template-areas:'main-tl main-tc main-tr' 'main-cl main-cc main-cr' 'main-bl main-bc main-br' 'attribution attribution attribution';}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g110[id="sc-1da62608-1"]{content:"fTMbq,"}/*!sc*/ .cMxQBJ{grid-area:main-tl/main-tl/main-br/main-br;}/*!sc*/ @media print{.cMxQBJ{grid-area:main-br/main-br;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g111[id="sc-1da62608-2"]{content:"cMxQBJ,"}/*!sc*/ .bxykXS{grid-area:attribution;display:none;min-height:5.4rem;justify-content:flex-end;}/*!sc*/ @media (min-width:768px){.bxykXS{display:flex;}}/*!sc*/ @media print{.bxykXS{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g112[id="sc-1da62608-3"]{content:"bxykXS,"}/*!sc*/ .izyiOU{color:#999;font-size:1.2rem;justify-self:flex-end;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:1rem;max-width:720px;padding-bottom:8px;padding-right:2rem;text-align:left;transition:opacity 0.6s;opacity:1;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:1440px){.izyiOU{margin-right:0;text-align:left;justify-self:flex-end;}}/*!sc*/ .izyiOU p{margin:0.4rem 2.4rem 2rem 2.4rem;transition:opacity 0.6s;opacity:1;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:640px) and (max-width:768px){.izyiOU p{margin:0 2rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:1440px){.izyiOU p{max-width:70vw;}}/*!sc*/ @media print{.izyiOU{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g113[id="sc-1da62608-4"]{content:"izyiOU,"}/*!sc*/ .gzKrkb{color:#444;cursor:pointer;display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;max-width:30rem;}/*!sc*/ .gzKrkb div{align-items:center;justify-content:center;box-sizing:border-box;display:flex;flex:0 0 50%;font:inherit;margin:1.3rem 0;}/*!sc*/ .gzKrkb div svg,.gzKrkb div span{font-weight:normal;transition:all 0.5s cubic-bezier(0.19,1,0.22,1);}/*!sc*/ .gzKrkb div:hover svg,.gzKrkb div:hover span{color:#940b52;transition:all 0.5s cubic-bezier(0.19,1,0.22,1);}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (max-width:767px){.gzKrkb div{justify-content:flex-start;}}/*!sc*/ @media print{.gzKrkb{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g115[id="sc-809612e0-0"]{content:"gzKrkb,"}/*!sc*/ .kdkgPH{margin-right:10px;vertical-align:middle;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g116[id="sc-809612e0-1"]{content:"kdkgPH,"}/*!sc*/ .cmbDHE{line-height:1;top:0.2rem;position:relative;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g117[id="sc-809612e0-2"]{content:"cmbDHE,"}/*!sc*/ .iontxq{flex-direction:column;font-size:1.6rem;font-weight:bold;position:sticky;display:none;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:640px){.iontxq{display:flex;gap:1rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media print{.iontxq{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g118[id="sc-c3e98e6e-0"]{content:"iontxq,"}/*!sc*/ .dGyqlX{margin:0 auto;max-width:120rem;}/*!sc*/ @media (min-width:1280px){.dGyqlX{max-width:140rem;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g128[id="sc-2f963901-0"]{content:"dGyqlX,"}/*!sc*/ .fPScz{margin:0 auto;max-width:1700px;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g129[id="sc-2f963901-1"]{content:"fPScz,"}/*!sc*/ .cAIYqe{display:grid;grid-template-areas:'header' 'aside' 'main' 'social' 'appendix';padding:0 2.4rem;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:640px){.cAIYqe{grid-template-areas:"header header" "aside main" "aside appendix";grid-column-gap:48px;grid-template-columns:170px 1fr;min-height:400px;padding-bottom:30px;position:relative;}}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:768px){.cAIYqe{grid-template-columns:calc(100% * .9 / 3) 1fr;grid-column-gap:32px;grid-template-columns:calc(100% * .9 / 3) 1fr;}}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:1280px){.cAIYqe{grid-column-gap:36px;}}/*!sc*/ @media print{.cAIYqe{display:block;}}/*!sc*/ @media print,screen and (min-width:640px){.cAIYqe .SidebarWrapper{display:block;height:auto!important;}.cAIYqe .SidebarWrapper >div{display:block!important;}}/*!sc*/ .cAIYqe .editorial-info-wrapper{margin-top:5rem;}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.cAIYqe .editorial-info-wrapper{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g133[id="sc-2f963901-5"]{content:"cAIYqe,"}/*!sc*/ .iFSuyF{align-self:start;width:100%;position:relative;z-index:1;max-width:90%;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g134[id="sc-2f963901-6"]{content:"iFSuyF,"}/*!sc*/ .dqFLeN p{color:#444;font-size:1.6rem;line-height:1.6;margin:0 0 20px 0;position:relative;z-index:1;}/*!sc*/ .dqFLeN p a{margin-left:0.7ex;text-decoration:underline;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:640px){.dqFLeN p{margin-bottom:15px;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g136[id="sc-2f963901-8"]{content:"dqFLeN,"}/*!sc*/ .kIjnKO{grid-area:aside;display:flex;flex-direction:column;justify-content:flex-start;margin-bottom:0;}/*!sc*/ .kIjnKO a:hover{text-decoration:none;}/*!sc*/ @media (min-width:640px){.kIjnKO{margin-bottom:3.2rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media print{.kIjnKO{margin-bottom:0;padding:0.4cm;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g137[id="sc-2f963901-9"]{content:"kIjnKO,"}/*!sc*/ .kVaaOI{grid-area:social;align-self:start;position:sticky;top:0;min-height:100vh;margin-top:2rem;padding-bottom:4rem;z-index:0;display:none;flex-direction:column;justify-content:flex-end;grid-area:social;align-self:start;}/*!sc*/ @media (max-width:768px){.kVaaOI{margin-top:0;min-height:0;}}/*!sc*/ @media (min-width:640px){.kVaaOI{display:flex;}}/*!sc*/ @media print{.kVaaOI{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g138[id="sc-2f963901-10"]{content:"kVaaOI,"}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:640px){.hyXUEO{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g139[id="sc-2f963901-11"]{content:"hyXUEO,"}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (max-width:640px){.hVjbaC{max-width:100%;}.hVjbaC div{flex-basis:25%;margin-right:1.3rem;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g140[id="sc-2f963901-12"]{content:"hVjbaC,"}/*!sc*/ .ezPZgh{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;max-width:100%;margin-bottom:3rem;text-decoration:underline;}/*!sc*/ .ezPZgh >a{padding-right:2rem;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:640px){.ezPZgh{margin-bottom:none;max-width:75%;}}/*!sc*/ @media print{.ezPZgh{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g141[id="sc-2f963901-13"]{content:"ezPZgh,"}/*!sc*/ .fzVReM{grid-area:appendix;display:flex;flex-direction:column;row-gap:2.4rem;}/*!sc*/ .fzVReM a{text-decoration:none;border-bottom:none;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g144[id="sc-2f963901-16"]{content:"fzVReM,"}/*!sc*/ .kSvvwV{display:flex;flex-direction:column;row-gap:2rem;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:640px){.kSvvwV{flex-direction:row;justify-content:space-between;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g145[id="sc-2f963901-17"]{content:"kSvvwV,"}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.eWAsaF{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g146[id="sc-2f963901-18"]{content:"eWAsaF,"}/*!sc*/ .koSWWJ{display:flex;font-size:1.6rem;color:#444;}/*!sc*/ .koSWWJ >span{padding-right:1.4rem;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:640px){.koSWWJ{display:flex;}.koSWWJ >span{padding-right:2.4rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media print{.koSWWJ{display:none;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g147[id="sc-8abcc030-0"]{content:"koSWWJ,"}/*!sc*/ .iLHNmL{flex-grow:0;flex-shrink:0;width:100%;background-color:#c16e15;display:block;overflow:hidden;position:relative;padding-top:55.56%;}/*!sc*/ .iLHNmL img{display:block;object-fit:cover;object-position:50% 50%;height:100%;width:100%;position:absolute;top:0;}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.iLHNmL{width:calc(21cm / 3);}}/*!sc*/ .gUHfgD{flex-grow:0;flex-shrink:0;width:100%;background-color:#035a6d;display:block;overflow:hidden;position:relative;padding-top:55.56%;}/*!sc*/ .gUHfgD img{display:block;object-fit:cover;object-position:50% 50%;height:100%;width:100%;position:absolute;top:0;}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.gUHfgD{width:calc(21cm / 3);}}/*!sc*/ .hdzCGH{flex-grow:0;flex-shrink:0;width:100%;background-color:#0c776d;display:block;overflow:hidden;position:relative;padding-top:55.56%;}/*!sc*/ .hdzCGH img{display:block;object-fit:cover;object-position:50% 50%;height:100%;width:100%;position:absolute;top:0;}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.hdzCGH{width:calc(21cm / 3);}}/*!sc*/ .hDRjbu{flex-grow:0;flex-shrink:0;width:100%;background-color:#940b52;display:block;overflow:hidden;position:relative;padding-top:55.56%;}/*!sc*/ .hDRjbu img{display:block;object-fit:cover;object-position:50% 50%;height:100%;width:100%;position:absolute;top:0;}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.hDRjbu{width:calc(21cm / 3);}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g151[id="sc-31fe189a-2"]{content:"iLHNmL,gUHfgD,hdzCGH,hDRjbu,"}/*!sc*/ .Yva-Dw{transition:color 0.2s ease;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g153[id="sc-c0f26063-0"]{content:"Yva-Dw,"}/*!sc*/ .cXFFat{box-sizing:border-box;position:relative;z-index:1;display:grid;grid-template-areas:'topic-wrap topic-wrap' 'title title' 'standfirst standfirst' 'author author';align-content:center;padding-top:24px;transition:all 0.3s cubic-bezier(.645,.045,.355,1);width:100%;margin:0;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (max-width:640px){.cXFFat{padding-left:2.4rem;padding-right:2.4rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media only print{.cXFFat{padding-top:2rem;padding-right:2rem;width:100%;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g154[id="sc-c0f26063-1"]{content:"cXFFat,"}/*!sc*/ .cA-dtSP{transition:color 0.2s ease;font-size:1.35rem;margin:0;display:-webkit-box;-webkit-line-clamp:1;-webkit-box-orient:vertical;overflow:hidden;text-overflow:ellipsis;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g155[id="sc-c0f26063-2"]{content:"cA-dtSP,"}/*!sc*/ .dwDZqP{transition:color 0.2s ease;font-size:1.35rem;justify-self:end;margin:0 0.6rem 0 0;text-transform:capitalize;transition:all 0.2s ease;overflow:hidden;max-width:5.5rem;position:relative;display:inline-flex;}/*!sc*/ .dwDZqP:after{display:block;content:' / ';opacity:0.6;height:100%;padding-left:0.4rem;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g156[id="sc-c0f26063-3"]{content:"dwDZqP,"}/*!sc*/ .gLchsi{display:flex;flex-direction:column;position:absolute;top:0;right:0;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g157[id="sc-c0f26063-4"]{content:"gLchsi,"}/*!sc*/ .jQGEAp{width:2.6rem;height:2.6rem;background:white;display:flex;align-items:center;justify-content:center;border-radius:50%;margin:0.6rem 0.6rem 0 0;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g158[id="sc-c0f26063-5"]{content:"jQGEAp,"}/*!sc*/ .cJoMvV{grid-area:topic-wrap;display:flex;align-items:center;font-size:1.4rem;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g159[id="sc-c0f26063-6"]{content:"cJoMvV,"}/*!sc*/ .hZYGmo{display:flex;flex-direction:column;position:relative;cursor:pointer;}/*!sc*/ .hZYGmo img{transition:all 0.2s ease;}/*!sc*/ .hZYGmo:hover .sc-c0f26063-0{color:#c16e15;}/*!sc*/ .hZYGmo:hover .sc-c0f26063-6{color:#c16e15;}/*!sc*/ .hZYGmo:hover .sc-c0f26063-3{max-width:0;margin:0;padding-right:0;}/*!sc*/ .hZYGmo:hover img{mix-blend-mode:screen;filter:grayscale(100%);}/*!sc*/ .jQxQLA{display:flex;flex-direction:column;position:relative;cursor:pointer;}/*!sc*/ .jQxQLA img{transition:all 0.2s ease;}/*!sc*/ .jQxQLA:hover .sc-c0f26063-0{color:#035a6d;}/*!sc*/ .jQxQLA:hover .sc-c0f26063-6{color:#035a6d;}/*!sc*/ .jQxQLA:hover .sc-c0f26063-3{max-width:0;margin:0;padding-right:0;}/*!sc*/ .jQxQLA:hover img{mix-blend-mode:screen;filter:grayscale(100%);}/*!sc*/ .jZQmTA{display:flex;flex-direction:column;position:relative;cursor:pointer;}/*!sc*/ .jZQmTA img{transition:all 0.2s ease;}/*!sc*/ .jZQmTA:hover .sc-c0f26063-0{color:#0c776d;}/*!sc*/ .jZQmTA:hover .sc-c0f26063-6{color:#0c776d;}/*!sc*/ .jZQmTA:hover .sc-c0f26063-3{max-width:0;margin:0;padding-right:0;}/*!sc*/ .jZQmTA:hover img{mix-blend-mode:screen;filter:grayscale(100%);}/*!sc*/ .gTsRyU{display:flex;flex-direction:column;position:relative;cursor:pointer;}/*!sc*/ .gTsRyU img{transition:all 0.2s ease;}/*!sc*/ .gTsRyU:hover .sc-c0f26063-0{color:#940b52;}/*!sc*/ .gTsRyU:hover .sc-c0f26063-6{color:#940b52;}/*!sc*/ .gTsRyU:hover .sc-c0f26063-3{max-width:0;margin:0;padding-right:0;}/*!sc*/ .gTsRyU:hover img{mix-blend-mode:screen;filter:grayscale(100%);}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g160[id="sc-c0f26063-7"]{content:"hZYGmo,jQxQLA,jZQmTA,gTsRyU,"}/*!sc*/ .jfoikg{grid-area:author;margin:0;font-size:1.6rem;letter-spacing:0;opacity:0.65;}/*!sc*/ .jfoikg:hover{opacity:1;}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g161[id="sc-c0f26063-8"]{content:"jfoikg,"}/*!sc*/ .bYXusR{display:grid;grid-template-columns:1fr 1fr;grid-row-gap:0;grid-column-gap:2.4rem;grid-row-gap:3.6rem;padding:2.4rem;}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (min-width:960px){.bYXusR{grid-template-columns:1fr 1fr 1fr;grid-column-gap:3.6rem;grid-row-gap:5.2rem;padding:3.6rem;}}/*!sc*/ @media only screen and (max-width:640px){.bYXusR{grid-template-columns:1fr;grid-column-gap:0;grid-row-gap:6rem;padding:0;}}/*!sc*/ data-styled.g163[id="sc-c83e4c92-0"]{content:"bYXusR,"}/*!sc*/ </style></head><body><noscript><iframe title="googletagmanager" src="https://analytics.aeon.co/ns.html?id=GTM-MHVZTPR" height="0" width="0" style="display:none;visibility:hidden"></iframe></noscript><link rel="preload" as="image" imageSrcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" imageSizes="(max-width: 1700px) 100vw, 1700px"/><div id="__next"><div class="__variable_0e14eb __variable_c18c89 __variable_d289f4 font-sans"><div id="top-portal" class="sc-a70232b9-5 gJZPyQ"></div><div class="sc-a70232b9-1 fQIWXN"><header class="sc-d1112dbe-0 frPYwM"><div class="sc-d55b82-2 fRfBtu"><div class="sc-d55b82-3 bngHQt"><div class="sc-d55b82-0 dylIji"><div class="sc-d55b82-1 drewAj"><button type="button" class="mb-7 flex cursor-pointer items-center gap-3 border-none bg-transparent pt-2.5 font-mono text-grey-mid text-xs tracking-widest hover:opacity-50"><span class="text-lg">×</span> CLOSE</button><div class="sc-d55b82-13 egiTBt"><a href="https://www.facebook.com/aeonmag" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" title="Facebook"><svg viewBox="0 0 1024 1024" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="18" height="18" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><g><path d="M1024,512C1024,229.23,794.77,0,512,0S0,229.23,0,512c0,255.55,187.23,467.37,432,505.78V660H302V512H432V399.2C432,270.88,508.44,200,625.39,200c56,0,114.61,10,114.61,10V336H675.44c-63.6,0-83.44,39.47-83.44,80v96H734L711.3,660H592v357.78C836.77,979.37,1024,767.55,1024,512Z"></path><path d="M711.3,660,734,512H592V416c0-40.49,19.84-80,83.44-80H740V210s-58.59-10-114.61-10C508.44,200,432,270.88,432,399.2V512H302V660H432v357.78a517.58,517.58,0,0,0,160,0V660Z" fill="transparent"></path></g></svg></a><a href="https://www.instagram.com/aeonmag" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" title="Instagram"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 25" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M17.216.5c4.456.203 6.887 2.633 7.09 7.09v10.126c-.203 4.456-2.634 6.887-7.09 7.09H7.09C2.633 24.603.203 22.172 0 17.716V7.59C.203 3.133 2.633.703 7.09.5zm-5.063 5.874c-3.444 0-6.28 2.835-6.28 6.279 0 3.443 2.836 6.279 6.28 6.279 3.443 0 6.279-2.836 6.279-6.28 0-3.443-2.836-6.278-6.28-6.278zm0 2.228a4.063 4.063 0 0 1 4.05 4.05 4.063 4.063 0 0 1-4.05 4.052 4.063 4.063 0 0 1-4.051-4.051 4.063 4.063 0 0 1 4.05-4.051zm6.481-3.849c-.81 0-1.418.608-1.418 1.418 0 .81.608 1.418 1.418 1.418.81 0 1.418-.608 1.418-1.418 0-.81-.608-1.418-1.418-1.418z"></path></svg></a><a href="https://twitter.com/aeonmag" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" title="X (Formerly Twitter)"><svg viewBox="0 0 450 450" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M225 450C349.264 450 450 349.264 450 225C450 100.736 349.264 0 225 0C100.736 0 0 100.736 0 225C0 349.264 100.736 450 225 450ZM349.373 92L250.332 204.646L358 358H278.785L206.256 254.71L115.461 358H92L195.855 239.888L92 92H171.215L239.878 189.789L325.912 92H349.373ZM159.972 109.311H123.929L289.842 341.539H325.894L159.972 109.311Z"></path></svg></a><a href="https://www.youtube.com/@AeonVideo" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" title="YouTube"><svg viewBox="0 0 22 20" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="22" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><g><path d="M21.5,4.7c-0.3-1-1-1.7-1.9-2C17.9,2.2,11,2.2,11,2.2s-6.9,0-8.6,0.5c-1,0.3-1.7,1-1.9,2C0,6.4,0,10,0,10s0,3.6,0.5,5.3 c0.3,1,1,1.7,1.9,2c1.7,0.5,8.6,0.5,8.6,0.5s6.9,0,8.6-0.5c1-0.3,1.7-1,1.9-2C22,13.6,22,10,22,10S22,6.4,21.5,4.7z M8.8,13.3V6.7 l5.8,3.3L8.8,13.3z"></path></g></svg></a></div></div><div class="sc-d55b82-1 drewAj"><div class="sc-d55b82-4 gjLQWl"><a href="/philosophy" class="sc-d55b82-5 jwvsks">Philosophy</a><a href="/science" class="sc-d55b82-5 jjoRww">Science</a><a href="/psychology" class="sc-d55b82-5 EINud">Psychology</a><a href="/society" class="sc-d55b82-5 jHnWNL">Society</a><a href="/culture" class="sc-d55b82-5 diZTdY">Culture</a></div><div class="sc-d55b82-6 kwwdYL"><div class="sc-d55b82-7 kpvHEa"><a href="/essays" class="sc-d55b82-8 cqAtlQ">Essays</a><a href="/videos" class="sc-d55b82-8 cqAtlQ">Videos</a><a href="/audio" class="sc-d55b82-8 cqAtlQ">Audio</a><br/><br/><a href="/popular" class="sc-d55b82-8 sc-d55b82-10 cqAtlQ kxzhOn">Popular</a><br/><br/><a href="/about" class="sc-d55b82-8 sc-d55b82-10 cqAtlQ kxzhOn">About</a></div><div class="sc-d55b82-9 kgAmGp"></div></div></div><div class="sc-d55b82-1 drewAj"><div class="sc-d55b82-12 uZtxm [&_a]:font-mono"><a data-ga-select-prompt="aeon_menu_donate" href="/donate" class="sc-d55b82-8 sc-d55b82-10 cqAtlQ kxzhOn">Donate</a><a href="/newsletter" class="sc-d55b82-8 sc-d55b82-10 cqAtlQ kxzhOn">Newsletter</a><div class="sc-d55b82-11 jzkOtF"><a target="_blank" href="https://psyche.co" style="line-height:1" title="Psyche"><svg viewBox="0 0 138 28" fill="#025744" stroke="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-d55b82-15 jguBq"><path stroke="none" d="M33.4463639,1.03028697e-13 C35.4638444,1.03028697e-13 37.1784471,0.275980571 38.5905508,0.826994629 C40.0024651,1.37857694 41.1385883,2.17242359 41.999678,3.20739809 C42.7884893,4.15681924 43.3288473,5.27001901 43.620898,6.5468515 L43.6943919,6.89913545 L38.7316665,8.31123919 C38.5161099,7.28933447 38.160006,6.45533141 37.6625969,5.80979827 C37.1646196,5.16426513 36.5531815,4.69394271 35.8269567,4.39769452 C35.100732,4.10201459 34.2534697,3.95389049 33.28517,3.95389049 C31.8590494,3.95389049 30.7363748,4.25013868 29.9160098,4.84149856 C29.0952659,5.43342669 28.685557,6.29394813 28.685557,7.42363112 C28.685557,8.28472081 28.9138044,8.96359135 29.3714359,9.46100039 C29.8286886,9.95897769 30.4942999,10.3688761 31.3684594,10.6916427 C32.2424294,11.0144092 33.3253264,11.3510032 34.6165821,11.7002882 C36.7952565,12.2651297 38.5835424,12.8500494 39.9823869,13.4552367 C41.3806632,14.060424 42.4234038,14.8472622 43.1092828,15.8153725 C43.7951617,16.7838617 44.1380065,18.074928 44.1380065,19.6887608 C44.1380065,22.3250666 43.2503985,24.3688761 41.4753717,25.8213256 C39.7001556,27.2737752 37.1310928,28 33.7691304,28 C30.5679831,28 28.053283,27.3614753 26.2244619,26.0834788 C24.4782265,24.8642962 23.406295,23.1484036 23.0086672,20.9361304 L22.9564503,20.6167147 L27.9593322,19.2449568 C28.3086171,20.8322712 28.9408911,22.0223783 29.8555858,22.8154673 C30.7697122,23.6091245 32.1013137,24.0057637 33.8498221,24.0057637 C35.4094817,24.0057637 36.6268647,23.6829971 37.5012136,23.037464 C38.3749942,22.3919308 38.8123581,21.4374586 38.8123581,20.1729107 C38.8123581,19.3123892 38.60381,18.6465885 38.1869032,18.1756978 C37.7696175,17.7053754 37.1242738,17.3083573 36.2504932,16.9855908 C35.3761443,16.6628242 34.2129345,16.3135393 32.7604849,15.9365994 C31.4152454,15.5873145 30.1783523,15.1971154 29.0486693,14.7665706 C27.9189863,14.336594 26.9306084,13.8321765 26.0833462,13.2535076 C25.2358945,12.6754069 24.5835424,11.9561906 24.1264791,11.0951009 C23.6688477,10.2345794 23.4406002,9.17232888 23.4406002,7.90778098 C23.4406002,5.4870317 24.3143808,3.56425972 26.063268,2.13832853 C27.8112081,0.712965594 30.2723032,1.03028697e-13 33.4463639,1.03028697e-13 Z M80.0217694,0.564803615 C81.703603,0.564803615 83.2661038,0.796081774 84.7104085,1.25863809 C86.0096007,1.67493878 87.2353011,2.29023528 88.3869572,3.1036991 L88.7680995,3.3821921 L84.9416866,7.33494608 L84.7314338,7.33494608 C83.8063211,5.90522656 82.7971073,4.81910947 81.703603,4.07602657 C80.6104775,3.33351193 79.475112,2.96168635 78.2976959,2.96168635 C77.0920567,2.96168635 76.0616282,3.29809095 75.2069787,3.97090014 C74.3513821,4.64370933 73.6857707,5.56219237 73.2095764,6.72521276 C72.732435,7.8888014 72.4945272,9.22722193 72.4945272,10.7410426 C72.4945272,13.2364222 72.8798014,15.4020268 73.6511074,17.2378563 C74.4216558,19.0742542 75.5151601,20.4901463 76.9310522,21.4849643 C78.346376,22.4803507 79.9797189,22.9777597 81.8297547,22.9777597 C83.3153522,22.9777597 84.6819959,22.704431 85.9298751,22.1577735 C87.0808894,21.6531666 88.0354838,20.8680522 88.7932115,19.8019833 L88.9785418,19.5296126 L89.3149464,19.6557644 C88.7821163,22.3752243 87.7024394,24.4146771 86.0768627,25.7741229 C84.4507178,27.134137 82.1938142,27.8135758 79.3069097,27.8135758 C76.9520775,27.8135758 74.8495488,27.2320656 72.9991341,26.068477 C71.1490982,24.9054566 69.6983534,23.3075347 68.6470891,21.2747115 C67.5958247,19.2424565 67.0701925,16.8948222 67.0701925,14.2312403 C67.0701925,11.6241047 67.6166606,9.29029779 68.7101649,7.22981965 C69.8032904,5.16934151 71.3239301,3.5437648 73.2726522,2.35195302 C75.2208061,1.1607095 77.4705118,0.564803615 80.0217694,0.564803615 Z M53.7404825,0.943201959 L53.7404825,1.19550541 L52.8530638,4.46749469 L58.6442992,14.7876906 L63.5611858,4.46863119 L62.5288631,1.19550541 L62.5288631,0.943201959 L69.1309927,0.943201959 L69.1309927,1.19550541 L66.6106101,4.55614185 L59.6275629,17.3696337 L59.6275629,23.860765 L61.3934976,27.1827603 L61.3934976,27.4350638 L51.9743583,27.4350638 L51.9743583,27.1827603 L53.7404825,23.860765 L53.7404825,17.4272165 L46.3395814,4.4754502 L44.4893561,1.19550541 L44.4893561,0.943201959 L53.7404825,0.943201959 Z M97.7102109,0.564803615 L97.7102109,11.7002503 L108.805312,11.7002503 L108.805312,0.564803615 L114.050079,0.564803615 L114.050079,27.4351206 L108.805312,27.4351206 L108.805312,16.057599 L97.7102109,16.057599 L97.7102109,27.4351206 L92.5056,27.4351206 L92.5056,0.564803615 L97.7102109,0.564803615 Z M137.571731,0.443766151 L137.571731,5.36595635 L124.943489,5.36595635 L124.943489,11.3371379 L136.845506,11.3371379 L136.845506,16.0172532 L124.943489,16.0172532 L124.943489,22.5129304 L137.894497,22.5129304 L137.894497,27.4351206 L118.891616,27.4351206 L118.891616,0.443766151 L137.571731,0.443766151 Z M9.0778098,0.443747209 C13.0317003,0.443747209 16.0305503,1.16997199 18.074928,2.62242156 C20.1187374,4.07487113 21.1413998,6.40166958 21.1413998,9.60224865 C21.1413998,11.7544046 20.6837683,13.5095426 19.7694524,14.8672836 C18.8547577,16.2259718 17.503078,17.2276089 15.7147921,17.873142 C14.0450181,18.4756396 12.0066268,18.7969717 9.59931027,18.8371382 L9.0778098,18.8414417 L6.0518732,18.8414417 L6.0518732,27.4351017 L3.05533376e-12,27.4351017 L3.05533376e-12,0.443747209 L9.0778098,0.443747209 Z M8.87627011,5.20455413 L6.0518732,5.20455413 L6.0518732,14.0806348 L8.87627011,14.0806348 C10.1938548,14.0806348 11.3100892,13.9463382 12.2247839,13.6771766 C13.1389103,13.4085833 13.8317977,12.9509518 14.3026884,12.3054187 C14.7728214,11.6598855 15.008835,10.7590183 15.008835,9.60224865 C15.008835,8.44604727 14.7665706,7.55162019 14.2826102,6.91915682 C13.7982709,6.28745112 13.1055729,5.84383651 12.2047057,5.58793414 C11.3032701,5.3324106 10.1938548,5.20455413 8.87627011,5.20455413 Z"></path></svg></a><a style="position:relative;top:0.4em" href="https://sophiaclub.co" target="_blank" title="Sophia Club"><svg viewBox="0 0 1285 287" fill="#F74D41" stroke="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-d55b82-16 flZngm"><path d="M148.139 76.5496C147.287 53.4902 146.11 42.2773 143.633 22.1777C143.469 20.8338 142.819 19.5963 141.805 18.6992C140.792 17.8021 139.485 17.3073 138.131 17.3084H135.902C135.124 17.3099 134.354 17.4751 133.643 17.7933C132.932 18.1115 132.296 18.5756 131.776 19.1555C131.257 19.7354 130.864 20.4181 130.625 21.1594C130.386 21.9007 130.305 22.684 130.388 23.4585C121.987 17.5501 110.071 12.282 94.3009 12.282C58.6064 12.282 39.3401 38.731 39.3401 63.6336C39.3401 85.648 52.7845 97.9424 65.782 109.826L88.1285 130.366C102.455 143.591 111.079 151.577 111.079 168.064C111.079 188.393 96.3001 210.275 63.855 210.275C46.4186 210.275 32.0864 202.874 17.6516 186.333C18.6169 174.225 18.8328 162.069 18.2978 149.934C18.2311 148.51 17.6184 147.166 16.587 146.181C15.5557 145.197 14.185 144.648 12.7594 144.648H10.5489C9.79112 144.647 9.04129 144.802 8.34571 145.103C7.65013 145.403 7.02367 145.844 6.50511 146.397C5.9865 146.949 5.58686 147.603 5.33078 148.316C5.07477 149.029 4.96782 149.788 5.01658 150.544C6.31513 170.819 4.41261 194.35 0.184837 210.499C-0.0166776 211.26 -0.0539232 212.056 0.0755735 212.833C0.205071 213.61 0.498344 214.35 0.935919 215.005C1.37349 215.66 1.94535 216.214 2.6135 216.63C3.28166 217.047 4.03082 217.317 4.81123 217.422L7.0459 217.7C8.36718 217.867 9.70459 217.554 10.8136 216.816C11.9226 216.078 12.7291 214.966 13.0856 213.682C13.901 210.758 14.6982 207.091 15.4471 202.911C27.0674 213.948 42.0639 223.33 63.8673 223.33C93.951 223.33 124.409 204.349 124.409 168.076C124.409 145.554 110.518 132.97 95.817 119.643L75.6931 101.162C62.8221 89.3636 52.6513 80.0479 52.6513 63.6274C52.6513 38.7552 74.1104 25.3313 94.2953 25.3313C111.575 25.3313 126.07 34.5987 132.768 43.5883C133.831 54.1 134.332 63.8872 134.821 76.9606C134.876 78.3936 135.483 79.7496 136.516 80.7439C137.549 81.7386 138.926 82.2947 140.36 82.2952H142.594C143.34 82.2962 144.077 82.1471 144.764 81.8565C145.45 81.5654 146.07 81.139 146.587 80.6024C147.104 80.0658 147.508 79.4304 147.773 78.7339C148.039 78.0374 148.161 77.2948 148.133 76.5496H148.139Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M229.885 187.282C242.332 166.554 249.767 139.954 249.767 116.115C249.767 90.6505 236.945 74.8281 216.308 74.8281C197.736 74.8281 179.828 87.6176 165.876 110.853C153.428 131.58 145.993 158.187 145.993 182.02C145.993 207.49 158.816 223.312 179.454 223.312C198.026 223.331 215.933 210.535 229.885 187.282ZM198.835 203.231C192.42 207.846 185.717 210.287 179.454 210.287C161.939 210.287 159.311 192.592 159.311 182.038C159.311 148.267 175.83 110.013 196.932 94.9396C203.334 90.3241 210.038 87.8836 216.308 87.8836C233.823 87.8836 236.45 105.585 236.45 116.133C236.45 149.904 219.931 188.158 198.847 203.225L198.835 203.231Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M381.541 129.285C381.541 92.1608 364.629 74.8701 328.258 74.8701C327.453 74.8701 326.648 74.8824 325.842 74.9064L332.081 57.3928C332.381 56.5559 332.474 55.6595 332.355 54.779C332.235 53.8986 331.905 53.0596 331.394 52.3329C330.883 51.6061 330.204 51.0133 329.415 50.6038C328.627 50.1944 327.752 49.9804 326.863 49.98H324.629C323.484 49.9819 322.367 50.3375 321.432 50.9983C320.497 51.6589 319.788 52.5927 319.404 53.671L311.196 76.8094C286.862 83.274 265.844 102.099 256.278 117.383C255.513 118.602 255.251 120.071 255.549 121.479C255.846 122.887 256.679 124.124 257.872 124.929L259.551 126.046C260.158 126.453 260.839 126.736 261.555 126.878C262.271 127.02 263.009 127.019 263.725 126.874C264.44 126.73 265.121 126.445 265.726 126.037C266.332 125.629 266.85 125.104 267.252 124.494C274.934 112.846 289.109 99.507 305.616 92.3601L242.773 273.957H221.634C220.43 273.959 219.259 274.352 218.298 275.078C217.337 275.804 216.638 276.822 216.307 277.98L215.745 279.932C215.51 280.757 215.469 281.626 215.626 282.47C215.783 283.314 216.134 284.109 216.651 284.795C217.168 285.48 217.837 286.036 218.605 286.419C219.373 286.801 220.22 287 221.078 287H288.614C289.819 287 290.99 286.609 291.953 285.884C292.915 285.159 293.615 284.141 293.947 282.982L294.503 281.025C294.737 280.2 294.777 279.332 294.619 278.489C294.462 277.646 294.112 276.851 293.595 276.167C293.079 275.482 292.412 274.926 291.645 274.543C290.878 274.159 290.033 273.959 289.176 273.957H256.761L274.433 222.986C344.771 221.035 381.541 174.794 381.541 129.285ZM328.258 87.9075C357.019 87.9075 368.223 99.507 368.223 129.285C368.223 167.526 337.578 206.354 278.89 209.786L320.932 88.2581C323.209 88.0044 325.746 87.8835 328.258 87.8835V87.9075Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M519.5 167.949L517.825 166.832C516.692 166.079 515.319 165.769 513.972 165.96C512.624 166.151 511.396 166.832 510.517 167.871C510.306 168.118 489.608 192.676 481.799 200.76C477.806 204.753 472.135 210.021 468.161 210.293C468.584 207.599 470.764 202.071 472.715 197.135L505.378 115.124C507.189 110.574 510.245 101.767 510.245 93.7916C510.245 84.6332 504.9 74.846 489.904 74.846C472.582 74.846 449.475 91.7924 429.399 113.456L469.683 7.51545C470.001 6.67588 470.11 5.77193 470.001 4.88095C469.893 3.98999 469.57 3.13861 469.06 2.39977C468.551 1.66092 467.87 1.05663 467.076 0.638678C466.282 0.220728 465.399 0.00157566 464.501 0H462.544C461.891 0.00252852 461.243 0.119061 460.63 0.344356C452.363 3.24345 443.667 4.73223 434.907 4.7485H428.191C426.987 4.75044 425.816 5.14401 424.855 5.86977C423.895 6.59552 423.196 7.61416 422.864 8.77205L422.308 10.7234C422.073 11.5484 422.032 12.4167 422.189 13.2602C422.346 14.1036 422.696 14.8992 423.213 15.5843C423.729 16.2694 424.397 16.8253 425.164 17.2083C425.932 17.5914 426.778 17.7911 427.635 17.7917H434.056C440.201 17.7733 446.331 17.1664 452.362 15.9793L377.228 213.531C376.895 214.375 376.774 215.288 376.876 216.189C376.978 217.091 377.3 217.954 377.812 218.702C378.325 219.45 379.013 220.062 379.817 220.482C380.621 220.902 381.515 221.119 382.423 221.113H384.651C385.775 221.114 386.872 220.772 387.797 220.135C388.723 219.497 389.433 218.593 389.833 217.543L414.179 153.595C438.337 117.311 472.202 87.8835 489.904 87.8835C496.409 87.8835 496.928 90.445 496.928 93.7916C496.928 98.2442 495.587 103.899 492.858 111.01L461.016 190.906L459.808 193.927C456.988 201.019 454.765 206.614 454.765 211.073C454.765 218.28 460.141 223.318 467.847 223.318C476.508 223.318 484.426 216.564 491.094 209.901C499.223 201.485 519.782 177.138 520.689 176.105C521.186 175.508 521.55 174.812 521.76 174.063C521.97 173.315 522.021 172.531 521.913 171.762C521.801 170.993 521.524 170.256 521.109 169.599C520.694 168.942 520.146 168.38 519.5 167.949Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M597.394 33.2275C595.745 33.2264 594.136 33.7143 592.763 34.6296C591.389 35.545 590.324 36.8467 589.688 38.3699C589.058 39.8932 588.894 41.5697 589.212 43.1874C589.535 44.805 590.329 46.2911 591.492 47.4576C592.66 48.6242 594.141 49.4188 595.76 49.741C597.379 50.0632 599.054 49.8984 600.576 49.2676C602.098 48.6367 603.404 47.5682 604.316 46.197C605.233 44.8259 605.725 43.2138 605.725 41.5646C605.72 39.355 604.844 37.2363 603.281 35.6733C601.719 34.1103 599.603 33.2307 597.394 33.2275Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M598.511 167.949L596.83 166.832C595.688 166.07 594.304 165.76 592.947 165.962C591.589 166.164 590.354 166.864 589.483 167.925C589.278 168.173 568.866 192.985 561.093 201.038C555.145 206.989 550.472 210.1 547.203 210.293C547.762 207.327 550.744 200.627 552.424 196.851C552.947 195.673 553.454 194.543 553.93 193.444L589.944 108.744C593.464 100.256 596.236 93.5502 596.236 87.9137C596.236 79.8485 591.005 74.8342 582.597 74.8342C573.308 74.8342 566.012 81.3768 560.074 87.8112C551.584 97.127 542.295 111.409 530.956 129.986C530.213 131.208 529.967 132.67 530.28 134.067C530.587 135.465 531.423 136.688 532.611 137.483L534.287 138.601C534.907 139.021 535.614 139.311 536.351 139.451C537.089 139.592 537.848 139.58 538.585 139.417C539.318 139.254 540.015 138.944 540.625 138.504C541.234 138.065 541.747 137.506 542.136 136.861C553.613 117.8 562.671 104.636 569.752 96.6011C574.988 90.6443 579.077 87.8717 582.623 87.8717H582.94V87.9076C582.94 91.7985 579 100.981 577.504 104.437L541.506 189.016C540.973 190.254 540.368 191.583 539.743 192.942C536.818 199.383 533.79 206.04 533.79 211.066C533.79 218.389 539.052 223.312 546.87 223.312C553.956 223.312 561.416 219.156 570.331 210.233C578.534 202.035 598.88 177.084 599.746 176.027C600.222 175.428 600.576 174.735 600.775 173.994C600.975 173.252 601.016 172.477 600.904 171.717C600.786 170.958 600.514 170.231 600.104 169.582C599.689 168.934 599.146 168.378 598.511 167.949Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M735.157 75.0632L733.21 74.5015C731.94 74.1361 730.587 74.2355 729.383 74.7813C728.184 75.3276 727.221 76.2845 726.662 77.4801L722.23 86.9588C717.998 81.0261 710.948 76.7975 700.967 76.7975C667.818 76.7975 604.69 149.39 604.69 198.228C604.69 216.733 615.055 223.324 624.754 223.324C639.556 223.324 656.239 211.894 671.333 196.615C669.473 201.079 668.069 205.393 668.069 209.12C668.069 217.881 673.403 223.324 681.964 223.324C691.335 223.324 699.046 216.902 705.983 209.967C714.238 201.708 733.287 176.969 734.097 175.918C734.558 175.315 734.896 174.624 735.08 173.887C735.265 173.15 735.296 172.383 735.173 171.634C735.05 170.884 734.773 170.168 734.358 169.53C733.948 168.892 733.405 168.345 732.775 167.925L731.099 166.807C729.936 166.026 728.517 165.717 727.134 165.941C725.75 166.165 724.5 166.907 723.645 168.015C723.455 168.257 704.749 192.441 697.027 200.433C690.141 207.326 685.633 210.262 681.964 210.262C681.744 210.262 681.57 210.262 681.431 210.262C681.38 209.884 681.354 209.502 681.36 209.12C681.36 207.435 682.477 203.079 687.82 191.909L738.631 82.724C738.969 81.9983 739.148 81.2081 739.148 80.407C739.154 79.6065 738.985 78.8147 738.652 78.0864C738.318 77.3582 737.832 76.7109 737.227 76.1886C736.617 75.6669 735.905 75.283 735.137 75.0632H735.157ZM624.754 210.286C623.079 210.286 618.006 210.286 618.006 198.234C618.006 155.147 676.912 89.8406 700.967 89.8406C712.603 89.8406 713.853 98.4614 713.853 102.171C713.812 103.414 713.638 104.65 713.331 105.856L700.138 134.45C687.99 160.494 649.178 210.286 624.754 210.286Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M913.822 18.6198C913.53 17.2699 912.746 16.0777 911.619 15.2765C910.497 14.4754 909.113 14.1229 907.74 14.2882L905.506 14.56C904.748 14.6548 904.01 14.9065 903.354 15.2993C902.693 15.6921 902.125 16.2174 901.679 16.842C901.233 17.4666 900.921 18.1769 900.767 18.928C900.608 19.6791 900.608 20.4546 900.767 21.2055C901.525 24.7457 902.283 28.1047 903.047 31.3791C888.942 18.9037 870.246 12.2583 848.388 12.2583C791.214 12.2583 751.276 55.6473 751.276 117.776C751.276 180.891 790.753 223.3 849.505 223.3C889.557 223.3 915.943 200.827 926.41 181.585C927.102 180.312 927.266 178.819 926.872 177.425C926.472 176.032 925.55 174.849 924.289 174.13L922.337 173.006C921.697 172.639 920.985 172.404 920.252 172.316C919.514 172.227 918.771 172.287 918.059 172.492C917.347 172.696 916.681 173.041 916.107 173.506C915.528 173.971 915.051 174.547 914.698 175.199C905.342 192.647 881.559 210.239 849.505 210.239C798.71 210.288 764.602 173.121 764.602 117.806C764.602 63.362 799.028 25.3318 848.399 25.3318C879.453 25.3318 902.391 41.009 913.022 69.4818L916.373 78.4228C916.635 79.125 917.039 79.7661 917.557 80.3078C918.074 80.8495 918.699 81.2805 919.386 81.5752C920.078 81.8699 920.815 82.0221 921.569 82.0221C922.317 82.0226 923.06 81.8709 923.746 81.5768L925.698 80.7368C926.979 80.1884 928.009 79.1757 928.578 77.9006C929.146 76.626 929.213 75.1838 928.767 73.8621C923.649 58.8976 917.034 33.5299 913.822 18.6198Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M989.651 208.052H973.132V6.64567C973.132 5.91879 972.989 5.19893 972.712 4.5272C972.435 3.85549 972.031 3.24509 971.513 2.73087L970.396 1.61322C969.571 0.795123 968.511 0.257485 967.363 0.0764193C966.215 -0.104646 965.037 0.0800354 964.002 0.604319C959.678 2.76712 954.749 4.7668 948.052 4.7668C946.264 4.74176 944.476 4.59035 942.713 4.3137C941.97 4.16742 941.212 4.17305 940.474 4.33026C939.737 4.48747 939.04 4.79296 938.425 5.22815C937.81 5.66331 937.293 6.21912 936.898 6.86164C936.504 7.50416 936.247 8.21997 936.14 8.96555L935.863 10.9169C935.663 12.3188 936.007 13.7444 936.821 14.9014C937.636 16.0583 938.866 16.8591 940.254 17.1395C942.831 17.5771 945.439 17.8014 948.052 17.8101C952.023 17.7942 955.978 17.2663 959.816 16.2393V208.052H945.537C944.066 208.052 942.657 208.635 941.617 209.674C940.582 210.713 939.993 212.122 939.993 213.592V215.549C939.993 217.02 940.577 218.431 941.617 219.471C942.657 220.511 944.066 221.095 945.537 221.095H989.625C991.095 221.094 992.504 220.509 993.545 219.469C994.585 218.429 995.164 217.019 995.164 215.549V213.592C995.164 212.127 994.585 210.723 993.55 209.685C992.52 208.647 991.116 208.06 989.651 208.052Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M1139.29 203.865C1134.16 203.865 1127.18 205.073 1121.11 206.807V82.6212C1121.11 81.1503 1120.52 79.7399 1119.48 78.6996C1118.44 77.6597 1117.03 77.0754 1115.56 77.0754H1093.21C1092.49 77.0754 1091.76 77.2189 1091.09 77.4977C1090.42 77.7765 1089.81 78.185 1089.29 78.7001C1088.78 79.2151 1088.37 79.8265 1088.1 80.4995C1087.82 81.1724 1087.68 81.8929 1087.68 82.6212V84.5784C1087.68 85.3067 1087.82 86.0278 1088.1 86.7007C1088.37 87.3731 1088.78 87.9845 1089.29 88.4996C1089.81 89.0146 1090.42 89.4236 1091.09 89.7024C1091.76 89.9812 1092.49 90.1247 1093.21 90.1247H1107.77V187.886C1090.39 200.687 1075.3 210.269 1056.64 210.269C1044.02 210.269 1028.96 204.976 1028.96 179.79V82.6212C1028.96 81.8929 1028.82 81.1724 1028.54 80.4995C1028.26 79.8265 1027.85 79.2151 1027.34 78.7001C1026.82 78.185 1026.21 77.7765 1025.54 77.4977C1024.87 77.2189 1024.15 77.0754 1023.42 77.0754H1002.76C1002.03 77.0754 1001.31 77.2189 1000.64 77.4977C999.964 77.7765 999.355 78.185 998.837 78.7001C998.325 79.2151 997.915 79.8265 997.638 80.4995C997.362 81.1724 997.218 81.8929 997.218 82.6212V84.5784C997.218 85.3067 997.362 86.0278 997.638 86.7007C997.915 87.3731 998.325 87.9845 998.837 88.4996C999.355 89.0146 999.964 89.4236 1000.64 89.7024C1001.31 89.9812 1002.03 90.1247 1002.76 90.1247H1015.64V180.086C1015.64 207.164 1030.97 223.33 1056.64 223.33C1076.3 223.33 1091.94 215.054 1107.77 204.028V216.111C1107.77 216.942 1107.96 217.762 1108.32 218.511C1108.69 219.26 1109.21 219.918 1109.86 220.437L1111.25 221.554C1112.12 222.251 1113.19 222.668 1114.3 222.752C1115.41 222.836 1116.52 222.583 1117.49 222.025C1121.72 219.609 1133.11 216.902 1139.28 216.902C1140.75 216.902 1142.16 216.319 1143.19 215.28C1144.23 214.241 1144.82 212.832 1144.82 211.362V209.411C1144.82 207.942 1144.24 206.533 1143.2 205.494C1142.16 204.454 1140.76 203.868 1139.29 203.865Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M1220.26 74.8466C1214.82 74.8466 1207.57 76.0063 1201.31 77.8672C1192.25 80.6701 1183.13 84.9597 1175.54 89.0192V6.64567C1175.54 5.91879 1175.4 5.19893 1175.12 4.5272C1174.84 3.85549 1174.43 3.24509 1173.92 2.73087L1172.8 1.61322C1171.98 0.795123 1170.92 0.257485 1169.77 0.0764193C1168.62 -0.104646 1167.44 0.0800354 1166.41 0.604319C1162.09 2.76712 1157.16 4.7668 1150.46 4.7668C1148.67 4.74176 1146.88 4.59035 1145.12 4.3137C1144.38 4.16654 1143.62 4.17156 1142.88 4.32845C1142.15 4.48535 1141.45 4.79083 1140.84 5.22625C1140.22 5.66162 1139.7 6.21778 1139.31 6.86071C1138.92 7.50365 1138.66 8.21986 1138.55 8.96555L1138.28 10.9229C1138.08 12.3238 1138.43 13.7463 1139.25 14.8988C1140.07 16.0512 1141.3 16.8464 1142.69 17.1214C1145.26 17.5584 1147.87 17.7828 1150.48 17.7919C1154.46 17.7765 1158.41 17.2486 1162.25 16.2212V209.411C1162.25 210.669 1162.68 211.889 1163.46 212.873L1164.58 214.269C1165.3 215.17 1166.29 215.823 1167.4 216.135C1184.53 220.969 1199.63 223.331 1213.57 223.331C1255.63 223.331 1285 191.88 1285 146.853C1284.98 100.419 1262 74.8466 1220.26 74.8466ZM1213.55 210.288C1198.74 210.288 1185.31 207.339 1175.54 204.663V103.911C1186.92 97.2659 1196.79 92.7589 1205.63 90.1432H1205.73C1210.43 88.704 1215.31 87.943 1220.23 87.8835C1254.34 87.8835 1271.64 107.723 1271.64 146.853C1271.67 184.201 1247.77 210.288 1213.55 210.288Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> </svg></a></div></div><div class="sc-d55b82-12 uZtxm [&_a]:font-mono"><div class="sc-d55b82-14 jSkfoz"><form class="sc-fd9debe5-0 floFPv" action="/search"><svg viewBox="0 0 13 13" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-fd9debe5-1 gDCUIo"><g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd" stroke="inherit" transform="translate(.5 .5)"><path stroke-linecap="square" d="M7.487 7.467L10.5 9.975"></path><circle cx="4.2" cy="4.2" r="4.2"></circle></g></svg><input type="search" placeholder="SEARCH" autoComplete="off" spellCheck="false" autoCorrect="off" maxLength="1000" class="sc-fd9debe5-2 kEXjQT font-mono" name="q" value=""/></form></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="sc-d1112dbe-1 cMYQbZ"><div class="flex items-center justify-start text-left font-mono [grid-area:nav-left]"><span tabindex="0" role="button" on="tap:sidebar-left.toggle" class="sc-d1112dbe-4 dKsuKq">Menu</span><span class="sc-d1112dbe-4 dKsuKq"><form class="sc-fd9debe5-0 caYqFN" action="/search"><svg viewBox="0 0 13 13" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-fd9debe5-1 bRXmuI"><g fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd" stroke="inherit" transform="translate(.5 .5)"><path stroke-linecap="square" d="M7.487 7.467L10.5 9.975"></path><circle cx="4.2" cy="4.2" r="4.2"></circle></g></svg><input type="search" placeholder="SEARCH" autoComplete="off" spellCheck="false" autoCorrect="off" maxLength="1000" class="sc-fd9debe5-2 lmMgnX font-mono" name="q" value=""/></form></span></div><div class="sc-d1112dbe-6 fjaqhm"><a href="https://www.facebook.com/aeonmag" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" title="Facebook"><svg viewBox="0 0 1024 1024" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><g><path d="M1024,512C1024,229.23,794.77,0,512,0S0,229.23,0,512c0,255.55,187.23,467.37,432,505.78V660H302V512H432V399.2C432,270.88,508.44,200,625.39,200c56,0,114.61,10,114.61,10V336H675.44c-63.6,0-83.44,39.47-83.44,80v96H734L711.3,660H592v357.78C836.77,979.37,1024,767.55,1024,512Z"></path><path d="M711.3,660,734,512H592V416c0-40.49,19.84-80,83.44-80H740V210s-58.59-10-114.61-10C508.44,200,432,270.88,432,399.2V512H302V660H432v357.78a517.58,517.58,0,0,0,160,0V660Z" fill="transparent"></path></g></svg></a><a href="https://www.instagram.com/aeonmag" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" title="Instagram"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 25" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M17.216.5c4.456.203 6.887 2.633 7.09 7.09v10.126c-.203 4.456-2.634 6.887-7.09 7.09H7.09C2.633 24.603.203 22.172 0 17.716V7.59C.203 3.133 2.633.703 7.09.5zm-5.063 5.874c-3.444 0-6.28 2.835-6.28 6.279 0 3.443 2.836 6.279 6.28 6.279 3.443 0 6.279-2.836 6.279-6.28 0-3.443-2.836-6.278-6.28-6.278zm0 2.228a4.063 4.063 0 0 1 4.05 4.05 4.063 4.063 0 0 1-4.05 4.052 4.063 4.063 0 0 1-4.051-4.051 4.063 4.063 0 0 1 4.05-4.051zm6.481-3.849c-.81 0-1.418.608-1.418 1.418 0 .81.608 1.418 1.418 1.418.81 0 1.418-.608 1.418-1.418 0-.81-.608-1.418-1.418-1.418z"></path></svg></a><a href="https://twitter.com/aeonmag" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" title="X (Formerly Twitter)"><svg viewBox="0 0 450 450" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M225 450C349.264 450 450 349.264 450 225C450 100.736 349.264 0 225 0C100.736 0 0 100.736 0 225C0 349.264 100.736 450 225 450ZM349.373 92L250.332 204.646L358 358H278.785L206.256 254.71L115.461 358H92L195.855 239.888L92 92H171.215L239.878 189.789L325.912 92H349.373ZM159.972 109.311H123.929L289.842 341.539H325.894L159.972 109.311Z"></path></svg></a><a href="https://www.youtube.com/@AeonVideo" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" title="YouTube"><svg viewBox="0 0 22 20" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="22" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><g><path d="M21.5,4.7c-0.3-1-1-1.7-1.9-2C17.9,2.2,11,2.2,11,2.2s-6.9,0-8.6,0.5c-1,0.3-1.7,1-1.9,2C0,6.4,0,10,0,10s0,3.6,0.5,5.3 c0.3,1,1,1.7,1.9,2c1.7,0.5,8.6,0.5,8.6,0.5s6.9,0,8.6-0.5c1-0.3,1.7-1,1.9-2C22,13.6,22,10,22,10S22,6.4,21.5,4.7z M8.8,13.3V6.7 l5.8,3.3L8.8,13.3z"></path></g></svg></a></div><a href="/" class="sc-d1112dbe-2 kyBevc"><svg viewBox="-16 -5.118 174.65 61.413" version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-describedby="aeon-logo-title" role="img" class="sc-d1112dbe-8 ktTsPo"><title id="aeon-logo-title">Aeon</title><path fill="currentColor" d="M70.93 25.275c0 11.705 8.43 21.268 18.755 21.268 10.57 0 19.002-9.438 19.002-21.268 0-11.45-8.432-20.642-18.877-20.642-10.45 0-18.88 9.19-18.88 20.642m48.05.252c0 16.504-13.052 29.81-29.17 29.81-16.12 0-29.17-13.306-29.17-29.81 0-16.377 13.05-29.683 29.17-29.683 16.247 0 29.17 13.177 29.17 29.683M45.39 19.563c0-6.435-.266-10.854-.795-13.252-.525-2.398-1.35-4.217-2.47-5.456-.635-.72-1.48-1.08-2.535-1.08-1.575 0-2.856 1.02-3.853 3.06-1.782 3.56-2.674 8.435-2.674 14.63v2.1H45.39m11.146 4.017H33.29c.272 7.435 1.77 13.31 4.487 17.63 2.083 3.32 4.59 4.976 7.52 4.976 1.81 0 3.458-.673 4.936-2.01 1.485-1.34 3.07-3.75 4.76-7.225l1.544 1.322c-2.296 6.2-4.837 10.582-7.613 13.163-2.778 2.575-5.994 3.87-9.653 3.87-6.284 0-11.04-3.197-14.273-9.594C22.4 40.554 21.1 34.157 21.1 26.526c0-9.354 1.912-16.8 5.734-22.338 3.82-5.538 8.3-8.305 13.436-8.305 4.288 0 8.01 2.327 11.168 6.986 3.156 4.653 4.854 11.56 5.098 20.713M4.668 26.974c-6.007 2.037-9.014 5.404-9.014 9.97v4.566c0 2.88 1.323 5.046 3.967 5.046 2.883 0 5.048-2.524 5.048-5.648V26.974M14.876 55.32c-3.724 0-6.605-1.923-7.807-6.243C4.903 53.16 1.18 55.32-3.265 55.32c-6.725 0-11.29-5.165-11.29-14.05V38.5c0-10.572 8.168-15.615 19.223-19.7v-8.89c0-2.882-1.203-4.564-3.967-4.564-2.884 0-3.846 1.682-3.846 4.806V15.2h-9.73v-4.564c0-8.53 4.686-14.776 14.055-14.776 9.37 0 13.816 6.486 13.816 15.618V44.39c0 1.805.724 2.766 2.4 2.886v8.046h-2.522zM156.496 52.825v-39.79c0-7.597-.514-10.944-2.31-13.522-1.163-2.058-2.833-2.96-5.022-2.96-1.928 0-3.863 1.03-6.176 3.605-2.24 2.243-5.352 6.04-7.246 8.842.742-4.152.684-14.118.684-14.118-6.56 3.86-9.902 4.893-16.207 5.15V1.19c1.925.515 2.57.643 4.243 1.415.127 4.25.127 7.34.127 8.11v10.946l-.127 10.944V45.23c0 2.958 0 4.12-.127 7.596-1.416 1.283-1.93 1.413-3.73 2.184v1.285h18.78V55.01c-1.67-.774-2.187-1.028-3.474-2.184V10.973l.64-.64c2.063-1.933 3.99-3.092 5.28-3.092 2.697 0 3.47 2.06 3.47 8.5v37.085c-1.54 1.155-2.058 1.413-3.856 2.182v1.287h18.65v-1.542c-1.8-.643-2.315-.9-3.6-1.927"></path></svg></a><div class="flex items-center justify-end text-right font-mono [grid-area:nav-right]"><span class="sc-d1112dbe-4 kLEOmn"><a data-ga-select-prompt="aeon_topbar_button_donate" href="/donate">Donate</a></span><span data-ga-select-prompt="aeon_topbar_button_newsletter" role="button" tabindex="0" on="tap:newsletter-popup" class="sc-d1112dbe-4 sc-d1112dbe-5 dBDjrs">Newsletter</span><span role="button" tabindex="0" title="Sign in" class="sc-d1112dbe-4 jSrgPI"><span class="sc-d1112dbe-11 fdbSCf"><div class="sc-d1112dbe-10 gNSpma"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="18" height="18" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M12 12c2.21 0 4-1.79 4-4s-1.79-4-4-4-4 1.79-4 4 1.79 4 4 4zm0 2c-2.67 0-8 1.34-8 4v1c0 .55.45 1 1 1h14c.55 0 1-.45 1-1v-1c0-2.66-5.33-4-8-4z"></path></svg></div><span>SIGN IN</span></span></span></div><div class="sc-d1112dbe-3 cdqCqH"><a style="position:relative;top:0.2em" href="https://sophiaclub.co" target="_blank" title="Sophia Club"><svg viewBox="0 0 1285 287" fill="#F74D41" stroke="none" width="97" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M148.139 76.5496C147.287 53.4902 146.11 42.2773 143.633 22.1777C143.469 20.8338 142.819 19.5963 141.805 18.6992C140.792 17.8021 139.485 17.3073 138.131 17.3084H135.902C135.124 17.3099 134.354 17.4751 133.643 17.7933C132.932 18.1115 132.296 18.5756 131.776 19.1555C131.257 19.7354 130.864 20.4181 130.625 21.1594C130.386 21.9007 130.305 22.684 130.388 23.4585C121.987 17.5501 110.071 12.282 94.3009 12.282C58.6064 12.282 39.3401 38.731 39.3401 63.6336C39.3401 85.648 52.7845 97.9424 65.782 109.826L88.1285 130.366C102.455 143.591 111.079 151.577 111.079 168.064C111.079 188.393 96.3001 210.275 63.855 210.275C46.4186 210.275 32.0864 202.874 17.6516 186.333C18.6169 174.225 18.8328 162.069 18.2978 149.934C18.2311 148.51 17.6184 147.166 16.587 146.181C15.5557 145.197 14.185 144.648 12.7594 144.648H10.5489C9.79112 144.647 9.04129 144.802 8.34571 145.103C7.65013 145.403 7.02367 145.844 6.50511 146.397C5.9865 146.949 5.58686 147.603 5.33078 148.316C5.07477 149.029 4.96782 149.788 5.01658 150.544C6.31513 170.819 4.41261 194.35 0.184837 210.499C-0.0166776 211.26 -0.0539232 212.056 0.0755735 212.833C0.205071 213.61 0.498344 214.35 0.935919 215.005C1.37349 215.66 1.94535 216.214 2.6135 216.63C3.28166 217.047 4.03082 217.317 4.81123 217.422L7.0459 217.7C8.36718 217.867 9.70459 217.554 10.8136 216.816C11.9226 216.078 12.7291 214.966 13.0856 213.682C13.901 210.758 14.6982 207.091 15.4471 202.911C27.0674 213.948 42.0639 223.33 63.8673 223.33C93.951 223.33 124.409 204.349 124.409 168.076C124.409 145.554 110.518 132.97 95.817 119.643L75.6931 101.162C62.8221 89.3636 52.6513 80.0479 52.6513 63.6274C52.6513 38.7552 74.1104 25.3313 94.2953 25.3313C111.575 25.3313 126.07 34.5987 132.768 43.5883C133.831 54.1 134.332 63.8872 134.821 76.9606C134.876 78.3936 135.483 79.7496 136.516 80.7439C137.549 81.7386 138.926 82.2947 140.36 82.2952H142.594C143.34 82.2962 144.077 82.1471 144.764 81.8565C145.45 81.5654 146.07 81.139 146.587 80.6024C147.104 80.0658 147.508 79.4304 147.773 78.7339C148.039 78.0374 148.161 77.2948 148.133 76.5496H148.139Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M229.885 187.282C242.332 166.554 249.767 139.954 249.767 116.115C249.767 90.6505 236.945 74.8281 216.308 74.8281C197.736 74.8281 179.828 87.6176 165.876 110.853C153.428 131.58 145.993 158.187 145.993 182.02C145.993 207.49 158.816 223.312 179.454 223.312C198.026 223.331 215.933 210.535 229.885 187.282ZM198.835 203.231C192.42 207.846 185.717 210.287 179.454 210.287C161.939 210.287 159.311 192.592 159.311 182.038C159.311 148.267 175.83 110.013 196.932 94.9396C203.334 90.3241 210.038 87.8836 216.308 87.8836C233.823 87.8836 236.45 105.585 236.45 116.133C236.45 149.904 219.931 188.158 198.847 203.225L198.835 203.231Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M381.541 129.285C381.541 92.1608 364.629 74.8701 328.258 74.8701C327.453 74.8701 326.648 74.8824 325.842 74.9064L332.081 57.3928C332.381 56.5559 332.474 55.6595 332.355 54.779C332.235 53.8986 331.905 53.0596 331.394 52.3329C330.883 51.6061 330.204 51.0133 329.415 50.6038C328.627 50.1944 327.752 49.9804 326.863 49.98H324.629C323.484 49.9819 322.367 50.3375 321.432 50.9983C320.497 51.6589 319.788 52.5927 319.404 53.671L311.196 76.8094C286.862 83.274 265.844 102.099 256.278 117.383C255.513 118.602 255.251 120.071 255.549 121.479C255.846 122.887 256.679 124.124 257.872 124.929L259.551 126.046C260.158 126.453 260.839 126.736 261.555 126.878C262.271 127.02 263.009 127.019 263.725 126.874C264.44 126.73 265.121 126.445 265.726 126.037C266.332 125.629 266.85 125.104 267.252 124.494C274.934 112.846 289.109 99.507 305.616 92.3601L242.773 273.957H221.634C220.43 273.959 219.259 274.352 218.298 275.078C217.337 275.804 216.638 276.822 216.307 277.98L215.745 279.932C215.51 280.757 215.469 281.626 215.626 282.47C215.783 283.314 216.134 284.109 216.651 284.795C217.168 285.48 217.837 286.036 218.605 286.419C219.373 286.801 220.22 287 221.078 287H288.614C289.819 287 290.99 286.609 291.953 285.884C292.915 285.159 293.615 284.141 293.947 282.982L294.503 281.025C294.737 280.2 294.777 279.332 294.619 278.489C294.462 277.646 294.112 276.851 293.595 276.167C293.079 275.482 292.412 274.926 291.645 274.543C290.878 274.159 290.033 273.959 289.176 273.957H256.761L274.433 222.986C344.771 221.035 381.541 174.794 381.541 129.285ZM328.258 87.9075C357.019 87.9075 368.223 99.507 368.223 129.285C368.223 167.526 337.578 206.354 278.89 209.786L320.932 88.2581C323.209 88.0044 325.746 87.8835 328.258 87.8835V87.9075Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M519.5 167.949L517.825 166.832C516.692 166.079 515.319 165.769 513.972 165.96C512.624 166.151 511.396 166.832 510.517 167.871C510.306 168.118 489.608 192.676 481.799 200.76C477.806 204.753 472.135 210.021 468.161 210.293C468.584 207.599 470.764 202.071 472.715 197.135L505.378 115.124C507.189 110.574 510.245 101.767 510.245 93.7916C510.245 84.6332 504.9 74.846 489.904 74.846C472.582 74.846 449.475 91.7924 429.399 113.456L469.683 7.51545C470.001 6.67588 470.11 5.77193 470.001 4.88095C469.893 3.98999 469.57 3.13861 469.06 2.39977C468.551 1.66092 467.87 1.05663 467.076 0.638678C466.282 0.220728 465.399 0.00157566 464.501 0H462.544C461.891 0.00252852 461.243 0.119061 460.63 0.344356C452.363 3.24345 443.667 4.73223 434.907 4.7485H428.191C426.987 4.75044 425.816 5.14401 424.855 5.86977C423.895 6.59552 423.196 7.61416 422.864 8.77205L422.308 10.7234C422.073 11.5484 422.032 12.4167 422.189 13.2602C422.346 14.1036 422.696 14.8992 423.213 15.5843C423.729 16.2694 424.397 16.8253 425.164 17.2083C425.932 17.5914 426.778 17.7911 427.635 17.7917H434.056C440.201 17.7733 446.331 17.1664 452.362 15.9793L377.228 213.531C376.895 214.375 376.774 215.288 376.876 216.189C376.978 217.091 377.3 217.954 377.812 218.702C378.325 219.45 379.013 220.062 379.817 220.482C380.621 220.902 381.515 221.119 382.423 221.113H384.651C385.775 221.114 386.872 220.772 387.797 220.135C388.723 219.497 389.433 218.593 389.833 217.543L414.179 153.595C438.337 117.311 472.202 87.8835 489.904 87.8835C496.409 87.8835 496.928 90.445 496.928 93.7916C496.928 98.2442 495.587 103.899 492.858 111.01L461.016 190.906L459.808 193.927C456.988 201.019 454.765 206.614 454.765 211.073C454.765 218.28 460.141 223.318 467.847 223.318C476.508 223.318 484.426 216.564 491.094 209.901C499.223 201.485 519.782 177.138 520.689 176.105C521.186 175.508 521.55 174.812 521.76 174.063C521.97 173.315 522.021 172.531 521.913 171.762C521.801 170.993 521.524 170.256 521.109 169.599C520.694 168.942 520.146 168.38 519.5 167.949Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M597.394 33.2275C595.745 33.2264 594.136 33.7143 592.763 34.6296C591.389 35.545 590.324 36.8467 589.688 38.3699C589.058 39.8932 588.894 41.5697 589.212 43.1874C589.535 44.805 590.329 46.2911 591.492 47.4576C592.66 48.6242 594.141 49.4188 595.76 49.741C597.379 50.0632 599.054 49.8984 600.576 49.2676C602.098 48.6367 603.404 47.5682 604.316 46.197C605.233 44.8259 605.725 43.2138 605.725 41.5646C605.72 39.355 604.844 37.2363 603.281 35.6733C601.719 34.1103 599.603 33.2307 597.394 33.2275Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M598.511 167.949L596.83 166.832C595.688 166.07 594.304 165.76 592.947 165.962C591.589 166.164 590.354 166.864 589.483 167.925C589.278 168.173 568.866 192.985 561.093 201.038C555.145 206.989 550.472 210.1 547.203 210.293C547.762 207.327 550.744 200.627 552.424 196.851C552.947 195.673 553.454 194.543 553.93 193.444L589.944 108.744C593.464 100.256 596.236 93.5502 596.236 87.9137C596.236 79.8485 591.005 74.8342 582.597 74.8342C573.308 74.8342 566.012 81.3768 560.074 87.8112C551.584 97.127 542.295 111.409 530.956 129.986C530.213 131.208 529.967 132.67 530.28 134.067C530.587 135.465 531.423 136.688 532.611 137.483L534.287 138.601C534.907 139.021 535.614 139.311 536.351 139.451C537.089 139.592 537.848 139.58 538.585 139.417C539.318 139.254 540.015 138.944 540.625 138.504C541.234 138.065 541.747 137.506 542.136 136.861C553.613 117.8 562.671 104.636 569.752 96.6011C574.988 90.6443 579.077 87.8717 582.623 87.8717H582.94V87.9076C582.94 91.7985 579 100.981 577.504 104.437L541.506 189.016C540.973 190.254 540.368 191.583 539.743 192.942C536.818 199.383 533.79 206.04 533.79 211.066C533.79 218.389 539.052 223.312 546.87 223.312C553.956 223.312 561.416 219.156 570.331 210.233C578.534 202.035 598.88 177.084 599.746 176.027C600.222 175.428 600.576 174.735 600.775 173.994C600.975 173.252 601.016 172.477 600.904 171.717C600.786 170.958 600.514 170.231 600.104 169.582C599.689 168.934 599.146 168.378 598.511 167.949Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M735.157 75.0632L733.21 74.5015C731.94 74.1361 730.587 74.2355 729.383 74.7813C728.184 75.3276 727.221 76.2845 726.662 77.4801L722.23 86.9588C717.998 81.0261 710.948 76.7975 700.967 76.7975C667.818 76.7975 604.69 149.39 604.69 198.228C604.69 216.733 615.055 223.324 624.754 223.324C639.556 223.324 656.239 211.894 671.333 196.615C669.473 201.079 668.069 205.393 668.069 209.12C668.069 217.881 673.403 223.324 681.964 223.324C691.335 223.324 699.046 216.902 705.983 209.967C714.238 201.708 733.287 176.969 734.097 175.918C734.558 175.315 734.896 174.624 735.08 173.887C735.265 173.15 735.296 172.383 735.173 171.634C735.05 170.884 734.773 170.168 734.358 169.53C733.948 168.892 733.405 168.345 732.775 167.925L731.099 166.807C729.936 166.026 728.517 165.717 727.134 165.941C725.75 166.165 724.5 166.907 723.645 168.015C723.455 168.257 704.749 192.441 697.027 200.433C690.141 207.326 685.633 210.262 681.964 210.262C681.744 210.262 681.57 210.262 681.431 210.262C681.38 209.884 681.354 209.502 681.36 209.12C681.36 207.435 682.477 203.079 687.82 191.909L738.631 82.724C738.969 81.9983 739.148 81.2081 739.148 80.407C739.154 79.6065 738.985 78.8147 738.652 78.0864C738.318 77.3582 737.832 76.7109 737.227 76.1886C736.617 75.6669 735.905 75.283 735.137 75.0632H735.157ZM624.754 210.286C623.079 210.286 618.006 210.286 618.006 198.234C618.006 155.147 676.912 89.8406 700.967 89.8406C712.603 89.8406 713.853 98.4614 713.853 102.171C713.812 103.414 713.638 104.65 713.331 105.856L700.138 134.45C687.99 160.494 649.178 210.286 624.754 210.286Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M913.822 18.6198C913.53 17.2699 912.746 16.0777 911.619 15.2765C910.497 14.4754 909.113 14.1229 907.74 14.2882L905.506 14.56C904.748 14.6548 904.01 14.9065 903.354 15.2993C902.693 15.6921 902.125 16.2174 901.679 16.842C901.233 17.4666 900.921 18.1769 900.767 18.928C900.608 19.6791 900.608 20.4546 900.767 21.2055C901.525 24.7457 902.283 28.1047 903.047 31.3791C888.942 18.9037 870.246 12.2583 848.388 12.2583C791.214 12.2583 751.276 55.6473 751.276 117.776C751.276 180.891 790.753 223.3 849.505 223.3C889.557 223.3 915.943 200.827 926.41 181.585C927.102 180.312 927.266 178.819 926.872 177.425C926.472 176.032 925.55 174.849 924.289 174.13L922.337 173.006C921.697 172.639 920.985 172.404 920.252 172.316C919.514 172.227 918.771 172.287 918.059 172.492C917.347 172.696 916.681 173.041 916.107 173.506C915.528 173.971 915.051 174.547 914.698 175.199C905.342 192.647 881.559 210.239 849.505 210.239C798.71 210.288 764.602 173.121 764.602 117.806C764.602 63.362 799.028 25.3318 848.399 25.3318C879.453 25.3318 902.391 41.009 913.022 69.4818L916.373 78.4228C916.635 79.125 917.039 79.7661 917.557 80.3078C918.074 80.8495 918.699 81.2805 919.386 81.5752C920.078 81.8699 920.815 82.0221 921.569 82.0221C922.317 82.0226 923.06 81.8709 923.746 81.5768L925.698 80.7368C926.979 80.1884 928.009 79.1757 928.578 77.9006C929.146 76.626 929.213 75.1838 928.767 73.8621C923.649 58.8976 917.034 33.5299 913.822 18.6198Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M989.651 208.052H973.132V6.64567C973.132 5.91879 972.989 5.19893 972.712 4.5272C972.435 3.85549 972.031 3.24509 971.513 2.73087L970.396 1.61322C969.571 0.795123 968.511 0.257485 967.363 0.0764193C966.215 -0.104646 965.037 0.0800354 964.002 0.604319C959.678 2.76712 954.749 4.7668 948.052 4.7668C946.264 4.74176 944.476 4.59035 942.713 4.3137C941.97 4.16742 941.212 4.17305 940.474 4.33026C939.737 4.48747 939.04 4.79296 938.425 5.22815C937.81 5.66331 937.293 6.21912 936.898 6.86164C936.504 7.50416 936.247 8.21997 936.14 8.96555L935.863 10.9169C935.663 12.3188 936.007 13.7444 936.821 14.9014C937.636 16.0583 938.866 16.8591 940.254 17.1395C942.831 17.5771 945.439 17.8014 948.052 17.8101C952.023 17.7942 955.978 17.2663 959.816 16.2393V208.052H945.537C944.066 208.052 942.657 208.635 941.617 209.674C940.582 210.713 939.993 212.122 939.993 213.592V215.549C939.993 217.02 940.577 218.431 941.617 219.471C942.657 220.511 944.066 221.095 945.537 221.095H989.625C991.095 221.094 992.504 220.509 993.545 219.469C994.585 218.429 995.164 217.019 995.164 215.549V213.592C995.164 212.127 994.585 210.723 993.55 209.685C992.52 208.647 991.116 208.06 989.651 208.052Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M1139.29 203.865C1134.16 203.865 1127.18 205.073 1121.11 206.807V82.6212C1121.11 81.1503 1120.52 79.7399 1119.48 78.6996C1118.44 77.6597 1117.03 77.0754 1115.56 77.0754H1093.21C1092.49 77.0754 1091.76 77.2189 1091.09 77.4977C1090.42 77.7765 1089.81 78.185 1089.29 78.7001C1088.78 79.2151 1088.37 79.8265 1088.1 80.4995C1087.82 81.1724 1087.68 81.8929 1087.68 82.6212V84.5784C1087.68 85.3067 1087.82 86.0278 1088.1 86.7007C1088.37 87.3731 1088.78 87.9845 1089.29 88.4996C1089.81 89.0146 1090.42 89.4236 1091.09 89.7024C1091.76 89.9812 1092.49 90.1247 1093.21 90.1247H1107.77V187.886C1090.39 200.687 1075.3 210.269 1056.64 210.269C1044.02 210.269 1028.96 204.976 1028.96 179.79V82.6212C1028.96 81.8929 1028.82 81.1724 1028.54 80.4995C1028.26 79.8265 1027.85 79.2151 1027.34 78.7001C1026.82 78.185 1026.21 77.7765 1025.54 77.4977C1024.87 77.2189 1024.15 77.0754 1023.42 77.0754H1002.76C1002.03 77.0754 1001.31 77.2189 1000.64 77.4977C999.964 77.7765 999.355 78.185 998.837 78.7001C998.325 79.2151 997.915 79.8265 997.638 80.4995C997.362 81.1724 997.218 81.8929 997.218 82.6212V84.5784C997.218 85.3067 997.362 86.0278 997.638 86.7007C997.915 87.3731 998.325 87.9845 998.837 88.4996C999.355 89.0146 999.964 89.4236 1000.64 89.7024C1001.31 89.9812 1002.03 90.1247 1002.76 90.1247H1015.64V180.086C1015.64 207.164 1030.97 223.33 1056.64 223.33C1076.3 223.33 1091.94 215.054 1107.77 204.028V216.111C1107.77 216.942 1107.96 217.762 1108.32 218.511C1108.69 219.26 1109.21 219.918 1109.86 220.437L1111.25 221.554C1112.12 222.251 1113.19 222.668 1114.3 222.752C1115.41 222.836 1116.52 222.583 1117.49 222.025C1121.72 219.609 1133.11 216.902 1139.28 216.902C1140.75 216.902 1142.16 216.319 1143.19 215.28C1144.23 214.241 1144.82 212.832 1144.82 211.362V209.411C1144.82 207.942 1144.24 206.533 1143.2 205.494C1142.16 204.454 1140.76 203.868 1139.29 203.865Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> <path d="M1220.26 74.8466C1214.82 74.8466 1207.57 76.0063 1201.31 77.8672C1192.25 80.6701 1183.13 84.9597 1175.54 89.0192V6.64567C1175.54 5.91879 1175.4 5.19893 1175.12 4.5272C1174.84 3.85549 1174.43 3.24509 1173.92 2.73087L1172.8 1.61322C1171.98 0.795123 1170.92 0.257485 1169.77 0.0764193C1168.62 -0.104646 1167.44 0.0800354 1166.41 0.604319C1162.09 2.76712 1157.16 4.7668 1150.46 4.7668C1148.67 4.74176 1146.88 4.59035 1145.12 4.3137C1144.38 4.16654 1143.62 4.17156 1142.88 4.32845C1142.15 4.48535 1141.45 4.79083 1140.84 5.22625C1140.22 5.66162 1139.7 6.21778 1139.31 6.86071C1138.92 7.50365 1138.66 8.21986 1138.55 8.96555L1138.28 10.9229C1138.08 12.3238 1138.43 13.7463 1139.25 14.8988C1140.07 16.0512 1141.3 16.8464 1142.69 17.1214C1145.26 17.5584 1147.87 17.7828 1150.48 17.7919C1154.46 17.7765 1158.41 17.2486 1162.25 16.2212V209.411C1162.25 210.669 1162.68 211.889 1163.46 212.873L1164.58 214.269C1165.3 215.17 1166.29 215.823 1167.4 216.135C1184.53 220.969 1199.63 223.331 1213.57 223.331C1255.63 223.331 1285 191.88 1285 146.853C1284.98 100.419 1262 74.8466 1220.26 74.8466ZM1213.55 210.288C1198.74 210.288 1185.31 207.339 1175.54 204.663V103.911C1186.92 97.2659 1196.79 92.7589 1205.63 90.1432H1205.73C1210.43 88.704 1215.31 87.943 1220.23 87.8835C1254.34 87.8835 1271.64 107.723 1271.64 146.853C1271.67 184.201 1247.77 210.288 1213.55 210.288Z" fill="#F74D41"></path> </svg></a><a href="https://psyche.co" target="_blank" title="Psyche"><svg viewBox="0 0 138 28" fill="#025744" stroke="none" width="75" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path stroke="none" d="M33.4463639,1.03028697e-13 C35.4638444,1.03028697e-13 37.1784471,0.275980571 38.5905508,0.826994629 C40.0024651,1.37857694 41.1385883,2.17242359 41.999678,3.20739809 C42.7884893,4.15681924 43.3288473,5.27001901 43.620898,6.5468515 L43.6943919,6.89913545 L38.7316665,8.31123919 C38.5161099,7.28933447 38.160006,6.45533141 37.6625969,5.80979827 C37.1646196,5.16426513 36.5531815,4.69394271 35.8269567,4.39769452 C35.100732,4.10201459 34.2534697,3.95389049 33.28517,3.95389049 C31.8590494,3.95389049 30.7363748,4.25013868 29.9160098,4.84149856 C29.0952659,5.43342669 28.685557,6.29394813 28.685557,7.42363112 C28.685557,8.28472081 28.9138044,8.96359135 29.3714359,9.46100039 C29.8286886,9.95897769 30.4942999,10.3688761 31.3684594,10.6916427 C32.2424294,11.0144092 33.3253264,11.3510032 34.6165821,11.7002882 C36.7952565,12.2651297 38.5835424,12.8500494 39.9823869,13.4552367 C41.3806632,14.060424 42.4234038,14.8472622 43.1092828,15.8153725 C43.7951617,16.7838617 44.1380065,18.074928 44.1380065,19.6887608 C44.1380065,22.3250666 43.2503985,24.3688761 41.4753717,25.8213256 C39.7001556,27.2737752 37.1310928,28 33.7691304,28 C30.5679831,28 28.053283,27.3614753 26.2244619,26.0834788 C24.4782265,24.8642962 23.406295,23.1484036 23.0086672,20.9361304 L22.9564503,20.6167147 L27.9593322,19.2449568 C28.3086171,20.8322712 28.9408911,22.0223783 29.8555858,22.8154673 C30.7697122,23.6091245 32.1013137,24.0057637 33.8498221,24.0057637 C35.4094817,24.0057637 36.6268647,23.6829971 37.5012136,23.037464 C38.3749942,22.3919308 38.8123581,21.4374586 38.8123581,20.1729107 C38.8123581,19.3123892 38.60381,18.6465885 38.1869032,18.1756978 C37.7696175,17.7053754 37.1242738,17.3083573 36.2504932,16.9855908 C35.3761443,16.6628242 34.2129345,16.3135393 32.7604849,15.9365994 C31.4152454,15.5873145 30.1783523,15.1971154 29.0486693,14.7665706 C27.9189863,14.336594 26.9306084,13.8321765 26.0833462,13.2535076 C25.2358945,12.6754069 24.5835424,11.9561906 24.1264791,11.0951009 C23.6688477,10.2345794 23.4406002,9.17232888 23.4406002,7.90778098 C23.4406002,5.4870317 24.3143808,3.56425972 26.063268,2.13832853 C27.8112081,0.712965594 30.2723032,1.03028697e-13 33.4463639,1.03028697e-13 Z M80.0217694,0.564803615 C81.703603,0.564803615 83.2661038,0.796081774 84.7104085,1.25863809 C86.0096007,1.67493878 87.2353011,2.29023528 88.3869572,3.1036991 L88.7680995,3.3821921 L84.9416866,7.33494608 L84.7314338,7.33494608 C83.8063211,5.90522656 82.7971073,4.81910947 81.703603,4.07602657 C80.6104775,3.33351193 79.475112,2.96168635 78.2976959,2.96168635 C77.0920567,2.96168635 76.0616282,3.29809095 75.2069787,3.97090014 C74.3513821,4.64370933 73.6857707,5.56219237 73.2095764,6.72521276 C72.732435,7.8888014 72.4945272,9.22722193 72.4945272,10.7410426 C72.4945272,13.2364222 72.8798014,15.4020268 73.6511074,17.2378563 C74.4216558,19.0742542 75.5151601,20.4901463 76.9310522,21.4849643 C78.346376,22.4803507 79.9797189,22.9777597 81.8297547,22.9777597 C83.3153522,22.9777597 84.6819959,22.704431 85.9298751,22.1577735 C87.0808894,21.6531666 88.0354838,20.8680522 88.7932115,19.8019833 L88.9785418,19.5296126 L89.3149464,19.6557644 C88.7821163,22.3752243 87.7024394,24.4146771 86.0768627,25.7741229 C84.4507178,27.134137 82.1938142,27.8135758 79.3069097,27.8135758 C76.9520775,27.8135758 74.8495488,27.2320656 72.9991341,26.068477 C71.1490982,24.9054566 69.6983534,23.3075347 68.6470891,21.2747115 C67.5958247,19.2424565 67.0701925,16.8948222 67.0701925,14.2312403 C67.0701925,11.6241047 67.6166606,9.29029779 68.7101649,7.22981965 C69.8032904,5.16934151 71.3239301,3.5437648 73.2726522,2.35195302 C75.2208061,1.1607095 77.4705118,0.564803615 80.0217694,0.564803615 Z M53.7404825,0.943201959 L53.7404825,1.19550541 L52.8530638,4.46749469 L58.6442992,14.7876906 L63.5611858,4.46863119 L62.5288631,1.19550541 L62.5288631,0.943201959 L69.1309927,0.943201959 L69.1309927,1.19550541 L66.6106101,4.55614185 L59.6275629,17.3696337 L59.6275629,23.860765 L61.3934976,27.1827603 L61.3934976,27.4350638 L51.9743583,27.4350638 L51.9743583,27.1827603 L53.7404825,23.860765 L53.7404825,17.4272165 L46.3395814,4.4754502 L44.4893561,1.19550541 L44.4893561,0.943201959 L53.7404825,0.943201959 Z M97.7102109,0.564803615 L97.7102109,11.7002503 L108.805312,11.7002503 L108.805312,0.564803615 L114.050079,0.564803615 L114.050079,27.4351206 L108.805312,27.4351206 L108.805312,16.057599 L97.7102109,16.057599 L97.7102109,27.4351206 L92.5056,27.4351206 L92.5056,0.564803615 L97.7102109,0.564803615 Z M137.571731,0.443766151 L137.571731,5.36595635 L124.943489,5.36595635 L124.943489,11.3371379 L136.845506,11.3371379 L136.845506,16.0172532 L124.943489,16.0172532 L124.943489,22.5129304 L137.894497,22.5129304 L137.894497,27.4351206 L118.891616,27.4351206 L118.891616,0.443766151 L137.571731,0.443766151 Z M9.0778098,0.443747209 C13.0317003,0.443747209 16.0305503,1.16997199 18.074928,2.62242156 C20.1187374,4.07487113 21.1413998,6.40166958 21.1413998,9.60224865 C21.1413998,11.7544046 20.6837683,13.5095426 19.7694524,14.8672836 C18.8547577,16.2259718 17.503078,17.2276089 15.7147921,17.873142 C14.0450181,18.4756396 12.0066268,18.7969717 9.59931027,18.8371382 L9.0778098,18.8414417 L6.0518732,18.8414417 L6.0518732,27.4351017 L3.05533376e-12,27.4351017 L3.05533376e-12,0.443747209 L9.0778098,0.443747209 Z M8.87627011,5.20455413 L6.0518732,5.20455413 L6.0518732,14.0806348 L8.87627011,14.0806348 C10.1938548,14.0806348 11.3100892,13.9463382 12.2247839,13.6771766 C13.1389103,13.4085833 13.8317977,12.9509518 14.3026884,12.3054187 C14.7728214,11.6598855 15.008835,10.7590183 15.008835,9.60224865 C15.008835,8.44604727 14.7665706,7.55162019 14.2826102,6.91915682 C13.7982709,6.28745112 13.1055729,5.84383651 12.2047057,5.58793414 C11.3032701,5.3324106 10.1938548,5.20455413 8.87627011,5.20455413 Z"></path></svg></a></div></div></header><div class="sc-a70232b9-0 bGPrlv"><div class="h-11 bg-white sm:hidden"></div><div class="relative"><div class="sc-1da62608-1 fTMbq sc-2f963901-1 fPScz"><div class="sc-d0d42ecb-0 gKaMBo sc-1da62608-2 cMxQBJ"><div class="sc-d0d42ecb-1 jqqAJM"><img alt="Close-up of a small tadpole with a rounded head and a long, thin tail, shown against a white background." decoding="async" data-nimg="fill" style="position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;left:0;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;color:transparent" sizes="(max-width: 1700px) 100vw, 1700px" srcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" src="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto"/><div class="sc-d0d42ecb-6 jWJXvn"><div class="sc-d0d42ecb-7 kHSJgS"><p>How do the tadpole’s facial organs know when to stop moving? <em>Photo by MYN/Seth Patterson/NPL/SPL</em></p></div><span class="font-mono">i</span></div></div><div class="sc-d0d42ecb-3 WFpNr"><div class="sc-d0d42ecb-2 cREOiH"><h2 class="mt-2.5 mb-6 font-semibold font-serif text-7xl leading-none max-[767px]:text-left max-[767px]:text-black max-[960px]:text-[42px] min-[768px]:mt-11 print:text-4xl">Modular cognition</h2><h1 class="sc-d0d42ecb-4 bXNXzL">Powerful tricks from computer science and cybernetics show how evolution ‘hacked’ its way to intelligence from the bottom up</h1><p class="sc-d0d42ecb-5 czwQmk">by Michael Levin & Rafael Yuste <span class="toggleMobileCreditBtn">+ BIO</span></p></div></div></div><div class="sc-1da62608-3 bxykXS"><small class="sc-1da62608-4 izyiOU"><p>How do the tadpole’s facial organs know when to stop moving? <em>Photo by MYN/Seth Patterson/NPL/SPL</em></p></small></div></div></div><div class="sc-2f963901-0 dGyqlX"><div class="sc-2f963901-5 cAIYqe"><aside class="sc-2f963901-9 kIjnKO"><div aria-hidden="true" class="rah-static rah-static--height-zero SidebarWrapper" style="height:0;overflow:hidden"><div><div class="sc-2e8621ab-0 dTqQqJ sc-2f963901-6 iFSuyF"><a href="/users/michael-levin" class="sc-2e8621ab-1 iTsAjg">Michael Levin</a><span class="inline [&_p]:inline"><p>is the Vannevar Bush Chair and Distinguished Professor of Biology at Tufts University in Massachusetts, where he directs the Allen Discovery Center and the Tufts Center for Regenerative and Developmental Biology.</p></span></div><div class="sc-2e8621ab-0 dTqQqJ sc-2f963901-6 iFSuyF"><a href="/users/rafael-yuste" class="sc-2e8621ab-1 iTsAjg">Rafael Yuste</a><span class="inline [&_p]:inline"><p>is professor of biological sciences and neuroscience, co-director of the Kavil Institute for Brain Science, director of the NeuroTechnology Center and chair of the NeuroRights Foundation at Columbia University.</p></span></div><br/><div class="sc-2f963901-8 dqFLeN"><p>Edited by<a href="/users/sally-davies" class="sc-2e8621ab-1 iTsAjg">Sally Davies</a></p></div></div></div><div class="sc-8abcc030-0 koSWWJ"><span>3,700 words</span><div class="group z-10 inline-flex cursor-pointer items-center gap-1 sm:hidden"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="17" height="17" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M17 3H7c-1.1 0-1.99.9-1.99 2L5 21l7-3 7 3V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm0 15l-5-2.18L7 18V5h10v13z"></path></svg><span class="flex-shrink-0 font-sans">Save</span></div></div><br/><div class="mx-0 my-5 [grid-area:syndication] print:hidden max-sm:hidden"><a class="inline-flex bg-grey-light-bg p-5 text-center font-mono text-grey-mid text-xs leading-relaxed tracking-widest duration-200 hover:bg-black hover:text-white" href="/syndication?article_slug=how-evolution-hacked-its-way-to-intelligence-from-the-bottom-up&article_name=Modular cognition&author=Michael Levin, Rafael Yuste&date=8 March 2022">SYNDICATE THIS ESSAY</a></div><div class="sc-c3e98e6e-0 iontxq sc-2f963901-10 kVaaOI"><div class="sc-c3e98e6e-0 iontxq"><div><br/></div><div class="sc-809612e0-0 gzKrkb"><div><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20px" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-809612e0-1 kdkgPH"><path d="M22 6c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2H4c-1.1 0-2 .9-2 2v12c0 1.1.9 2 2 2h16c1.1 0 2-.9 2-2V6zm-2 0l-8 5-8-5h16zm0 12H4V8l8 5 8-5v10z"></path></svg><span class="sc-809612e0-2 cmbDHE font-sans">Email</span></div><div class="group z-10 inline-flex cursor-pointer items-center gap-1"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M17 3H7c-1.1 0-1.99.9-1.99 2L5 21l7-3 7 3V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm0 15l-5-2.18L7 18V5h10v13z"></path></svg><span class="flex-shrink-0 font-sans">Save</span></div><div><svg viewBox="0 0 450 450" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20px" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-809612e0-1 kdkgPH"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M225 450C349.264 450 450 349.264 450 225C450 100.736 349.264 0 225 0C100.736 0 0 100.736 0 225C0 349.264 100.736 450 225 450ZM349.373 92L250.332 204.646L358 358H278.785L206.256 254.71L115.461 358H92L195.855 239.888L92 92H171.215L239.878 189.789L325.912 92H349.373ZM159.972 109.311H123.929L289.842 341.539H325.894L159.972 109.311Z"></path></svg><span class="sc-809612e0-2 cmbDHE font-sans">Post</span></div><div><svg viewBox="0 0 1024 1024" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20px" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-809612e0-1 kdkgPH"><g><path d="M1024,512C1024,229.23,794.77,0,512,0S0,229.23,0,512c0,255.55,187.23,467.37,432,505.78V660H302V512H432V399.2C432,270.88,508.44,200,625.39,200c56,0,114.61,10,114.61,10V336H675.44c-63.6,0-83.44,39.47-83.44,80v96H734L711.3,660H592v357.78C836.77,979.37,1024,767.55,1024,512Z"></path><path d="M711.3,660,734,512H592V416c0-40.49,19.84-80,83.44-80H740V210s-58.59-10-114.61-10C508.44,200,432,270.88,432,399.2V512H302V660H432v357.78a517.58,517.58,0,0,0,160,0V660Z" fill="transparent"></path></g></svg><span class="sc-809612e0-2 cmbDHE font-sans">Share</span></div></div></div></div></aside><div id="article-content" style="--color-section:var(--color-aeon-psychology)" class="article-content [&_.pullquote]:text-section" data-highlightable-root="true"><div class="sc-4ebaf8b7-2 bWvakG has-dropcap"><p>Intelligent decision-making doesn’t require a brain. You were capable of it before you even had one. Beginning life as a single fertilised egg, you divided and became a mass of genetically identical cells. They chattered among themselves to fashion a complex anatomical structure – your body. Even more remarkably, if you had split in two as an embryo, each half would have been able to replace what was missing, leaving you as one of two identical (monozygotic) twins. Likewise, if two mouse embryos are mushed together like a snowball, a single, normal mouse results. Just how do these embryos know what to do? We have no technology yet that has this degree of plasticity – recognising a deviation from the normal course of events and responding to achieve the same outcome overall.</p> <p>This is intelligence in action: the ability to reach a particular goal or solve a problem by undertaking new steps in the face of changing circumstances. It’s evident not just in intelligent people and mammals and birds and cephalopods, but also cells and tissues, individual neurons and networks of neurons, viruses, ribosomes and RNA fragments, down to motor proteins and molecular networks. Across all these scales, living things solve problems and achieve goals by flexibly navigating different spaces – metabolic, physiological, genetic, cognitive, behavioural.</p> <p>But how did intelligence emerge in biology? The question has preoccupied scientists since Charles Darwin, but it remains unanswered. The processes of intelligence are so intricate, so multilayered and baroque, no wonder some people might be tempted by stories about a top-down Creator. But we know evolution must have been able to come up with intelligence on its own, from the <span class="ld-nowrap">bottom up.</span></p> <p>Darwin’s best shot at an explanation was that random mutations changed and rearranged genes, altered the structure and function of bodies, and so produced adaptations that allowed certain organisms to thrive and reproduce in their environment. (In technical terms, they are <em>selected</em> for by the environment.) In the end, somehow, intelligence was the result. But there’s plenty of natural and experimental evidence to suggest that evolution doesn’t just select hardwired solutions that are engineered for a specific setting. For example, lab studies have shown that perfectly normal frog skin cells, when liberated from the instructive influence of the rest of the embryo, can reboot their cooperative activity to produce a novel proto-organism, <a href="https://www.science.org/doi/pdf/10.1126/scirobotics.abf1571" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">called</a> a ‘xenobot’. Evolution, it seems, doesn’t come up with answers so much as generate flexible problem-solving agents that can rise to new challenges and figure things out on their own.</p> <p>The urgency of understanding intelligence in biological terms has become more acute with the ‘omics’ revolution, where new techniques are amassing enormous amounts of fresh data on the genes, proteins and connections within each cell. Yet the deluge of information about cellular hardware isn’t yielding a better explanation of the intelligent flexibility we observe in living systems. Nor is it yielding sufficient practical insights, for example, in the realm of regenerative medicine. We think the real problem is not one of data, but of perspective. Intelligence is not something that happened at the tail end of evolution, but was <a href="https://aeon.co/essays/the-study-of-the-mind-needs-a-copernican-shift-in-perspective" target="_blank" rel="noopener">discovered</a> towards the beginning, long before brains came on the scene.</p> <p>From the earliest metabolic cycles that kept microbes’ chemical parameters within the right ranges, biology has been capable of achieving aims. Yet generation after generation of biologists have been trained to avoid questions about the ultimate purpose of things. Biologists are told to focus on the ‘how’, not the ‘why’, or risk falling prey to theology. Students must reduce events to their simplest components and causes, and study these mechanisms in piecemeal fashion. Talk of ‘goals’, we are told, skirts perilously close to abandoning naturalism; the result is a kind of ‘teleophobia’, a fear of purpose, based on the idea that attributing too much intelligence to a system is the worst mistake you can make.</p> <p>But the converse is just as bad: failing to recognise intelligence when it’s right under our noses, and could be useful. Not only is ‘why’ always present in biological systems – it is exactly what drives the ‘how’. Once we open ourselves up to that idea, we can identify two powerful tricks, inspired by computer science and cybernetics, that allowed evolution to ‘hack’ its way to intelligence from the bottom up. No skyhooks needed.</p> <p><span class="ld-dropcap">E</span>mbryos aren’t the only things capable of flexible self-repair. Many species can regenerate or replace lost body parts as adults. The Mexican salamander known as the <a href="https://aeon.co/ideas/consider-the-axolotl-our-great-hope-of-regeneration" target="_blank" rel="noopener">axolotl</a> can regrow lost limbs, eyes, jaws and ovaries, as well as the spinal cord and portions of the heart and brain. The body recognises deviations from its correct anatomy as errors, and the cells work rapidly to get back to normal. Similarly, when Picasso-style tadpoles are made in the lab, with eyes and other organs randomly placed in different starting positions, they undergo novel paths of movement that nevertheless <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22411736/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">end up</a> creating largely normal frog faces.</p> <p>How do the tadpole’s facial organs know when to stop moving? How does the salamander’s tissue determine that a limb of the right size and shape has been produced, and that the remodelling can stop? It’s clear that cell groups need to be able to ‘work until goal X is satisfied’, storing a memory of the goal (which might be an anatomical configuration much larger than any single cell), and course-correcting if they are perturbed along the way.</p> <p>One explanation of embryos’ amazing feats comes from control theory, which show us that dynamical systems (such as a thermostat) can pursue goals without magic, simply using feedback to correct for errors. Such ‘homeostasis’ in biology, as the process is known, keeps parameters such as pH within specific limits. But the same dynamic operates on a much larger scale, as long as cells are physiologically plugged into networks. Networks of cells are able to measure chemical, electrical and biomechanical properties of tissues, and make decisions about things that single cells cannot appreciate.</p> <p>Single cells can <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25926819/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">process</a> local information about their environment and their own states to pursue tiny, cell-level goals (such as staying pointed in a specific direction). But networks of cells can integrate signals from across distances, store memories of patterns, and compute the outcomes of large-scale questions (such as ‘Is this finger the right length?’ or ‘Does this face look right?’) Cell networks carry out computations that can assess larger quantities (such as anatomical shape) and direct the underlying cell activity to bring the system closer to a specific desired goal (<a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27807271/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">called</a> a ‘setpoint’).</p> <p class="pullquote">Modularity means that the stakes for testing out mutations are reasonably low</p> <p>Achieving such intelligent, finely tuned calibration likely relies on <em>modularity</em> – the first step that we believe can explain the emergence of intelligent behaviour. Like a large organisation that deploys a number of specialised teams to make and sell a single product, modularity is about self-maintaining units that can cooperate or compete to achieve local outcomes, but end up collectively working towards some larger goal. Crucially, this structure avoids micromanagement – each level doesn’t need to know how the lower levels do their job, but can simply motivate them (with things like reward molecules and stress pathways) to get it done.</p> <figure><img alt="Illustration of biological cognition tiers, showing cytoskeleton, neural network, whole tissue, whole organism, genetic network, and group." loading="lazy" width="800" height="852" decoding="async" data-nimg="1" class="ld-image-block" style="color:transparent" sizes="(max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 1440px) 60vw, 880px" srcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1859/insert-Figure-1B.jpg?width=384&quality=75&format=auto 384w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1859/insert-Figure-1B.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1859/insert-Figure-1B.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1859/insert-Figure-1B.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1859/insert-Figure-1B.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1859/insert-Figure-1B.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1859/insert-Figure-1B.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1859/insert-Figure-1B.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1859/insert-Figure-1B.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" src="https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1859/insert-Figure-1B.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto"/><figcaption class="ld-image-caption"><p>Modularity – the presence of competent subunits, which solve problems in their own local problem space, that can cooperate and compete to achieve bigger goals – is part of what enables the emergence of intelligence in biology. The way these modules’ agendas are nested within one another in biological networks gives them the flexibility to meet goals at each level, even when conditions change at lower levels</p></figcaption></figure> <p>When unicellular organisms joined up to make multicellular bodies, each module didn’t lose its individual competency. Rather, cells used specific proteins to merge into ever more complex networks that could implement larger objectives, possess longer memories and look further into the future. Networks of cells began to work as a society – measuring and pursuing goals defined at the level of the collective (such as ‘organ size’ and ‘organ shape’). Stress about large-scale states (such as ‘attention: finger too short’) triggered change, which was shared across tissues to implement coordinated action. This multiscale architecture has many advantages. For one, it’s easy for evolution to simply shift the modules around and let the cycle of error reduction take care of the rest – setting new conditions as the setpoint, or the source of stress (eg, ‘wrong length of limbs’ instead of ‘misfolded proteins’). It’s similar to how you can change the setpoint of your thermostat without having to rewire it, or even know how it works. Feedback loops within feedback loops, and a nested hierarchy of incentivised modules that can be reshuffled by evolution, offer immense problem-solving power.</p> <p>One implication of this hierarchy of homeostatically stable, nested modules is that organisms became much more flexible while still <a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02688/full" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">maintaining</a> a coherent ‘self’ in a hostile world. Evolution didn’t have to tweak everything at once in response to a new threat, because biological subunits were primed to find novel ways of compensating for changes and functioning within altered systems. For example, in planarian flatworms, which reliably regenerate every part of the body, using drugs to shift the bioelectrically stored pattern memory <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27499881/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">results</a> in two-headed worms. Remarkably, fragments of these worms continue to regenerate two heads in perpetuity, without editing the genome. Moreover, flatworms can be <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27574538" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">induced</a>, by brief modulation of the bioelectric circuit, to regrow heads with shape (and brain structure) appropriate to other known species of flatworms (at about <span class="ld-nowrap">100 million</span> years of evolutionary distance), despite their wild-type genome.</p> <p>Modularity means that the stakes for testing out mutations are reasonably low: competent subunits can be depended upon to meet their goals under a wide range of conditions, so evolution rarely needs to ‘worry’ that a single mutation could ruin the show. For example, if a new mutation results in an eye being in the wrong place, a hardwired organism would find it very hard to survive. However, modular systems can compensate for the change while moving the eye back to where it’s supposed to be (or enabling it to work in its new location), thus having the opportunity to explore other, possibly useful, effects of the mutation. Tadpole eyes have been shown to do this, conferring vision even if asked to form on the tail, by finding connections to the spinal cord instead of the brain.</p> <p><span class="ld-dropcap">M</span>odularity provides stability and robustness, and is the first part of the answer to how intelligence arose. When changes occur to one part of the body, its evolutionary history as a nested doll of competent, problem-solving cells means subunits can step up and modify their activity to keep the organism alive. This isn’t a separate capacity that evolved from scratch in complex organisms, but instead an inevitable consequence of the ancient ability of cells to look after themselves and the networks of which they form a part.</p> <p>But just how are these modules controlled? The second step on the road to the emergence of intelligence lies in knowing how modules can be manipulated. Encoding information in networks requires the ability to catalyse complex outcomes with simple signals. This is known as <em>pattern completion</em>: the capacity of one particular element in the module to activate the entire module. That special element, which serves as a ‘trigger’, starts the activity, kicking the other members of the module into action and completing the pattern. In this way, instead of activating the entire module, evolution needs only to activate that trigger.</p> <p>Pattern completion is an essential aspect of modularity which we’re just beginning to understand, thanks to work in developmental biology and neuroscience. For example, an entire eye can be created in the gut of a frog embryo by briefly altering the bioelectric state of some cells. These cells are triggered to complete the eye pattern by recruiting nearby neighbours (which were not themselves bioelectrically altered) to fill in the rest of the eye. Similar outcomes can be achieved by genetic or chemical ‘master regulators’, such as the <em>Hox</em> genes that specify the body plan of most bilaterally symmetrical animals. In fact, one could relabel these regulator genes as pattern completion genes, since they enable the coordinated expression of a suite of other genes from a simple signal. The key is that modules, by continuing to work until certain conditions are met, can fill in a complex pattern when given only a small part of the pattern. In doing so, they translate a simple command – the activation of the trigger – and amplify it into an entire program.</p> <p>Crucially, pattern completion doesn’t require defining all of the information needed to create an organ. Evolution does not have to rediscover how to specify all the cell types and get them arranged in the correct orientation – all it has to do is activate a simple trigger, and the modular organisation of development (where cells build to a specific pattern) does the rest. Pattern completion enables the emergence of developmental complexity and intelligence: simple triggers of complex cascades that make it possible for random changes to DNA to generate coherent, functional (and occasionally advantageous) bodies.</p> <p>Modular pattern completion is also becoming evident in recent experiments in neuroscience. The pinnacle of intelligent behaviour in biology is the human brain. Nervous systems are built with large numbers of neurons, where every neuron is typically connected to very large numbers of other neurons. Over evolutionary time, there’s been a steady progression to larger and more connected brains, reaching astronomical numbers – with close to <span class="ld-nowrap">100 billion</span> neurons and hundreds of thousands of connections per neuron in humans. This move towards higher numbers of neurons and connections cannot be a coincidence: a system with many interacting units is exactly what it takes to become more competent and complex.</p> <p class="pullquote">Analysing the brain by looking at a single neuron is like trying to understand a movie from an isolated pixel</p> <p>But what exactly do all these vast neural circuits do? While many neuroscientists would agree that the function of the nervous system is to sense the environment and generate behaviour, it’s less clear how that actually happens. The traditional view <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/nrn3962#https://www.nature.com/articles/nrn3962" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">known as</a> the ‘neuron doctrine’, proposed by Santiago Ramón y Cajal and Charles Scott Sherrington more than a century ago, is that each neuron has a specific function. This would make the brain analogous to an aeroplane, built with millions of components, each precisely designed for a particular task.</p> <p>Within this framing, neuroscientists have teased apart the brain and studied it one neuron at a time, linking the activity of individual neurons to the behaviour of the animal or the mental state of a person. Yet if the true goals of biological systems derive from how their subunits or modules interact, then analysing the brain by looking at a single neuron is as futile as trying to understand a movie while fixating on an isolated pixel.</p> <p>What type of properties might neural circuits generate? Because neurons can set each other off, neural circuits can generate internal states of activity that are independent of the outside world. A group of connected neurons could auto-excite each other and become active together for a period of time, even if nothing external is happening. This is how we might understand the existence of the concepts and abstractions that populate the human mind – as the endogenous activity of modules, made up of ensembles of neurons.</p> <p>Using those intrinsic activity states as symbols, evolution could then build formal representations of reality. It could manipulate those states instead of manipulating the reality, just as we do by defining mathematical terms to explore relationships between objects. From this point of view – the gist of which was already proposed by Immanuel Kant in his <em>Critique of Pure Reason</em> (1781, 1787) – the evolution of the nervous system represents the appearance of a new formal world, a symbolic world, that greatly expands the possibilities of the physical world because it gives us a way to explore and manipulate it mentally.</p> <p>Neuronal modules could also be organised in a hierarchy, where higher-level modules encode and symbolise increasingly more abstract entities. For example, lower-level groups of neurons in our spinal cord might activate muscle fibres, and be under the control of upper-level ensembles in the motor cortex that could encode the desired movement more abstractly (‘to change the position of the leg’). In turn, these motor cortex ensembles could be controlled by higher-order neurons again (‘to perform a pirouette’), which could be controlled by groups of neurons in the prefrontal cortex that represent the behavioural intention (‘to perform in a ballet’).</p> <p>Using modules nested in a hierarchy provides a neat solution to a tough design challenge: instead of specifying and controlling every element, one at a time, nature uses neuronal ensembles as computational building blocks to perform different functions at different levels. This progression towards increasing abstraction could help explain how cognition and consciousness might arise, as emergent functional properties, from relatively simple neural hardware. This same powerful idea of hierarchical emergence is behind the layered neural network models in computer science, named ‘neural’ because they are inspired by neural circuits.</p> <p><span class="ld-dropcap">B</span>ut back to Darwin’s problem: if evolution is blind and acting solely on the individual units, one mutation at a time, how can the overall architecture and function of an organism be modified for the common good? Besides generating modules, neural networks have another interesting property we’ve already discussed: pattern completion.</p> <p>In recent <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2019.05.045" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">experiments</a>, mice were induced to have artificial perceptions or visual hallucinations by activating only two neurons in their visual cortex. How is this possible, given that the mouse brain has around <span class="ld-nowrap">100 million</span> neurons? The answer is that those neurons can trigger a neuronal ensemble, via pattern completion. Neurons’ connectivity seems to amplify activity, so, like an avalanche, a change in one neuron ends up triggering the entire module. This means that you can activate an entire module of neurons by turning on only one key member of the group.</p> <p class="pullquote">Pattern completion shows us how a single event – say, a mutation – can change an army, or build an eye</p> <p>Pattern completion could be at the core of how the brain works internally – recruiting module after module, at different levels of the hierarchy, depending on the task at hand. But why wouldn’t pattern completion end up tripping the entire brain into an epileptic seizure? By adding inhibitory connections to these neural circuits – small circuit breakers – one can restrict these avalanches to small groups of neurons, instead of catastrophically activating the entire brain. By harnessing pattern completion along with inhibitory circuits, the brain has the ability to select and manipulate modules at different levels as needed.</p> <figure><img alt="Three mesh-like 3D surfaces with a ball moving downwards, depicted in a sequence showing positions before, during, and after motion." loading="lazy" width="800" height="215" decoding="async" data-nimg="1" class="ld-image-block" style="color:transparent" sizes="(max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 1440px) 60vw, 880px" srcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1855/v1-Figure-2.jpg?width=384&quality=75&format=auto 384w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1855/v1-Figure-2.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1855/v1-Figure-2.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1855/v1-Figure-2.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1855/v1-Figure-2.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1855/v1-Figure-2.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1855/v1-Figure-2.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1855/v1-Figure-2.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1855/v1-Figure-2.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" src="https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1855/v1-Figure-2.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto"/><figcaption class="ld-image-caption"><p>(I) Trigger stimuli allow for pattern completion, because networks can be organised such that they tend to settle in specific states (memories) from diverse positions (like the way a ball rolls down into a well from many different starting points). The topology of this landscape means that the system automatically returns to the same state when disturbed – symbolised by the ball falling to the bottom of a valley, when it is placed near the edge. This metaphor for pattern completion captures the idea of how the ‘landscape’ of the system ‘makes you do it’: it allows subunits to pursue local homeostatic goals (such as minimising a variable to move down a gradient), but enables the end result to be a higher-level pattern</p></figcaption></figure> <figure><img alt="Diagram showing a three-step process where a green matrix transforms and corrects the letter ‘G’ displayed on a grid below it." loading="lazy" width="800" height="205" decoding="async" data-nimg="1" class="ld-image-block" style="color:transparent" sizes="(max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 1440px) 60vw, 880px" srcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1856/v2-Figure-2.jpg?width=384&quality=75&format=auto 384w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1856/v2-Figure-2.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1856/v2-Figure-2.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1856/v2-Figure-2.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1856/v2-Figure-2.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1856/v2-Figure-2.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1856/v2-Figure-2.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1856/v2-Figure-2.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1856/v2-Figure-2.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" src="https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1856/v2-Figure-2.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto"/><figcaption class="ld-image-caption"><p>(II) The ability for networks to reach the same outcome from a range of partial inputs – the generalisation of pattern completion – is also exploited in computer science. For example, computational neural networks can recover an entire remembered image based on only a partial example, from which some aspect has been removed</p></figcaption></figure> <figure><img alt="Illustration of a planarian, its amputation, cell processes of proliferation, differentiation, migration, apoptosis, and regeneration." loading="lazy" width="800" height="219" decoding="async" data-nimg="1" class="ld-image-block" style="color:transparent" sizes="(max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 1440px) 60vw, 880px" srcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1857/v3-Figure-2.jpg?width=384&quality=75&format=auto 384w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1857/v3-Figure-2.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1857/v3-Figure-2.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1857/v3-Figure-2.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1857/v3-Figure-2.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1857/v3-Figure-2.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1857/v3-Figure-2.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1857/v3-Figure-2.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1857/v3-Figure-2.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" src="https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1857/v3-Figure-2.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto"/><figcaption class="ld-image-caption"><p>(III) The flatworm is a master of pattern completion, generating its entire anatomy from a small piece of its pattern. The bioelectric network of cells stores a pattern memory that controls individual cells in order to restore the whole</p></figcaption></figure> <figure><img alt="Diagrams labelled A to F showing network structures with numbered nodes and connecting lines, transitioning from grey to red." loading="lazy" width="800" height="282" decoding="async" data-nimg="1" class="ld-image-block" style="color:transparent" sizes="(max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 1440px) 60vw, 880px" srcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1858/v4-Figure-2.jpg?width=384&quality=75&format=auto 384w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1858/v4-Figure-2.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1858/v4-Figure-2.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1858/v4-Figure-2.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1858/v4-Figure-2.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1858/v4-Figure-2.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1858/v4-Figure-2.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1858/v4-Figure-2.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1858/v4-Figure-2.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" src="https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1858/v4-Figure-2.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto"/><figcaption class="ld-image-caption"><p>(IV) Pattern completion is also present in neural circuits, where a small group of connected neurons can store associative memory. Here, you see: a) independent neurons are present without synaptic connections; b) neurons 1, 3 and 5 are activated simultaneously by external inputs, which forms and strengthens the synaptic connections between them; c) when the input ceases, neuronal activity also stops (however, the synaptic connections between the three neurons remain; these neurons have formed a module, and their interconnectivity determines how the module activates); d) an input activates just one of the original three neurons, but the connections activate all three neurons and complete the entire pattern; e) even after the input current has ended, the neurons can remain persistently active, in effect, storing a memory of the input</p></figcaption></figure> <p>In this way, pattern completion enables connections between modules at the same and different levels of the hierarchy, knitting them together as a single system. A key neuron in a lower-level module can be activated by an upper-level one, and vice versa. Like changing the march of an army, you don’t need to convince every soldier to do so – just convince the general, who makes the others fall into line. Consistent with the many parallels between neurons and non-neural signals, pattern completion shows us how a single event – say, a mutation – can change an army, or build <span class="ld-nowrap">an eye.</span></p> <p><span class="ld-dropcap">F</span>rom microbe cells solving problems in metabolic space, to tissues solving problems in anatomical space, to groups of people navigating the world as we know it, life has <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0006291X20320064" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">ratcheted</a> towards intelligent designs by exploiting the ability of modules to get things done, in their own way. Homeostatic loops provide flexible responses, working until setpoints are achieved, even when things change. Modularity means that evolution can readily explore what the collective considers to be a ‘correct’ condition, and what actions it takes to get there. Hierarchies of modules mean that simple signals can trigger complex actions that don’t need to be rediscovered or micromanaged, yet can adapt when only a small piece of the puzzle triggers them to <span class="ld-nowrap">do so.</span></p> <p>We have sketched a set of approaches to biology that rely heavily on concepts from cybernetics, computer science, and engineering. But there’s still a lot of work to do in reconciling these approaches. Despite recent advances in molecular genetics, our understanding of the mapping between the genome on the one hand, and the (changeable) anatomy and physiology of the body on the other, is still at a very early stage. Much like computer science, which moved from rewiring hardware in the 1940s to a focus on algorithms and software that could control the device’s behaviour, biological sciences now need to change tack.</p> <p class="pullquote">We call on biologists to embrace the intentional stance: treating circuits and cells as problem-solving agents</p> <p>The impact of understanding nested intelligence across multiple scales cuts across numerous fields, from fundamental questions about our evolutionary origins to practical roadmaps for AI, regenerative medicine and biorobotics. Understanding the control systems implemented in living tissue could <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26571046/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">lead</a> to major advances in biomedicine. If we truly grasp how to control the setpoints of bodies, we might be able to repair birth defects, induce regeneration of organs, and perhaps even defeat ageing (some cnidarians and <a href="https://aeon.co/videos/the-blob-with-a-superpower-cut-a-flatworm-in-four-pieces-and-watch-it-regenerate-four-fold" target="_blank" rel="noopener">planarian</a> flatworms are essentially immortal, demonstrating that complex organisms without a lifespan limit are possible, using the same types of cells of which we are made). Perhaps cancer can also be <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33961843/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">addressed</a> as a disease of modularity: the mechanisms by which body cells cooperate can occasionally break down, leading to a reversion of cells to their unicellular past – a more selfish mode in which they treat the rest of the body as an environment within which they reproduce maximally.</p> <p>In the field of engineering, designers have traditionally built robots from dumb but reliable parts. By contrast, biology exploits the unreliability of components, making the most of the competency of each level (molecular, cellular, tissue, organ, organism, and colony) to look after itself. This enables an incredible range of adaptive plasticity. If we break the neuronal code in biology, we could begin to program behaviour into synthetic nervous systems, and <a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fevo.2021.650726/full" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">build</a> self-repairing, flexible robots. Recent work shows that agential cells with their own local agendas can already be guided to create entirely new, autonomous biorobots. And beyond robots’ bodies, these ideas also open up new approaches to machine learning and AI: raising prospects for architectures based on ancient and diverse problem-solving ensembles beyond brains, such as those of bacteria and metazoa.</p> <p>This emerging confluence of developmental biology, neuroscience, biophysics, computer science and cognitive science could have profound and potentially transformative applications. Top-down strategies exploiting – in effect, collaborating with – biology’s native intelligence could enable transformative progress in areas oppressed by a narrow focus on molecular and genetic detail. With that in mind, we call on biologists to embrace the intentional stance: treating circuits, cells and cellular processes as competent problem-solving agents with agendas, and the capacity to detect and store information – no longer a metaphor, but a serious <a href="https://psyarxiv.com/t6e8p" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">hypothesis</a> made plausible by the emergence of intelligent behaviour in phylogenetic history. If we can come to recognise intelligence in its most unfamiliar guises, it might just revolutionise our understanding of the natural world and our very nature as cognitive beings.</p></div><div class="sc-2f963901-16 fzVReM"><div class="sc-2f963901-17 kSvvwV"><div class="sc-2f963901-13 ezPZgh"><a style="--color-section:var(--color-aeon-science)" class="mt-5 block font-mono text-section text-sm" href="/science/biology">Biology</a><a style="--color-section:var(--color-aeon-science)" class="mt-5 block font-mono text-section text-sm" href="/science/computing-artificial-intelligence">Computing and artificial intelligence</a><a style="--color-section:var(--color-aeon-psychology)" class="mt-5 block font-mono text-section text-sm" href="/psychology/cognition-intelligence">Cognition and intelligence</a></div><div class="font-mono text-grey-mid-light text-sm print:flex-row-reverse print:justify-between print:after:inline-block print:after:content-["aeon.co"] mb-8 flex flex-col sm:mt-5">8 March 2022</div><div class="sc-2f963901-11 hyXUEO"><div class="sc-809612e0-0 gzKrkb sc-2f963901-12 hVjbaC"><div><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20px" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-809612e0-1 kdkgPH"><path d="M22 6c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2H4c-1.1 0-2 .9-2 2v12c0 1.1.9 2 2 2h16c1.1 0 2-.9 2-2V6zm-2 0l-8 5-8-5h16zm0 12H4V8l8 5 8-5v10z"></path></svg><span class="sc-809612e0-2 cmbDHE font-sans">Email</span></div><div class="group z-10 inline-flex cursor-pointer items-center gap-1"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M17 3H7c-1.1 0-1.99.9-1.99 2L5 21l7-3 7 3V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm0 15l-5-2.18L7 18V5h10v13z"></path></svg><span class="flex-shrink-0 font-sans">Save</span></div><div><svg viewBox="0 0 450 450" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20px" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-809612e0-1 kdkgPH"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M225 450C349.264 450 450 349.264 450 225C450 100.736 349.264 0 225 0C100.736 0 0 100.736 0 225C0 349.264 100.736 450 225 450ZM349.373 92L250.332 204.646L358 358H278.785L206.256 254.71L115.461 358H92L195.855 239.888L92 92H171.215L239.878 189.789L325.912 92H349.373ZM159.972 109.311H123.929L289.842 341.539H325.894L159.972 109.311Z"></path></svg><span class="sc-809612e0-2 cmbDHE font-sans">Post</span></div><div><svg viewBox="0 0 1024 1024" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20px" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-809612e0-1 kdkgPH"><g><path d="M1024,512C1024,229.23,794.77,0,512,0S0,229.23,0,512c0,255.55,187.23,467.37,432,505.78V660H302V512H432V399.2C432,270.88,508.44,200,625.39,200c56,0,114.61,10,114.61,10V336H675.44c-63.6,0-83.44,39.47-83.44,80v96H734L711.3,660H592v357.78C836.77,979.37,1024,767.55,1024,512Z"></path><path d="M711.3,660,734,512H592V416c0-40.49,19.84-80,83.44-80H740V210s-58.59-10-114.61-10C508.44,200,432,270.88,432,399.2V512H302V660H432v357.78a517.58,517.58,0,0,0,160,0V660Z" fill="transparent"></path></g></svg><span class="sc-809612e0-2 cmbDHE font-sans">Share</span></div></div></div></div><div class="mx-0 my-5 [grid-area:syndication] print:hidden mt-5 mb-0 sm:mt-0 sm:mb-8"><a class="inline-flex bg-grey-light-bg p-5 text-center font-mono text-grey-mid text-xs leading-relaxed tracking-widest duration-200 hover:bg-black hover:text-white" href="/syndication?article_slug=how-evolution-hacked-its-way-to-intelligence-from-the-bottom-up&article_name=Modular cognition&author=Michael Levin, Rafael Yuste&date=8 March 2022">SYNDICATE THIS ESSAY</a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="sc-2f963901-18 eWAsaF"><div class="sc-2f963901-0 dGyqlX"><div class="sc-c83e4c92-0 bYXusR"><a href="/essays/identity-is-painfully-contingent-for-the-culturally-bereaved"><div class="sc-c0f26063-7 hZYGmo"><div type="essay" class="sc-31fe189a-2 iLHNmL"><img alt="An adult and two children in a mall atrium, dressed in winter clothing." loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-nimg="fill" style="position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;left:0;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;color:transparent" sizes="(max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 960px) 45vw, (max-width: 1440px) 30vw, 430px" srcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/3bb63de5-3eb1-403e-a010-a09c8594ed7d/v1-essay-.jpg?width=256&quality=75&format=auto 256w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/3bb63de5-3eb1-403e-a010-a09c8594ed7d/v1-essay-.jpg?width=384&quality=75&format=auto 384w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/3bb63de5-3eb1-403e-a010-a09c8594ed7d/v1-essay-.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/3bb63de5-3eb1-403e-a010-a09c8594ed7d/v1-essay-.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/3bb63de5-3eb1-403e-a010-a09c8594ed7d/v1-essay-.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/3bb63de5-3eb1-403e-a010-a09c8594ed7d/v1-essay-.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/3bb63de5-3eb1-403e-a010-a09c8594ed7d/v1-essay-.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/3bb63de5-3eb1-403e-a010-a09c8594ed7d/v1-essay-.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/3bb63de5-3eb1-403e-a010-a09c8594ed7d/v1-essay-.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/3bb63de5-3eb1-403e-a010-a09c8594ed7d/v1-essay-.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" src="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/3bb63de5-3eb1-403e-a010-a09c8594ed7d/v1-essay-.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto"/></div><div class="sc-c0f26063-1 cXFFat"><div class="sc-c0f26063-6 cJoMvV"><div class="group z-10 inline-flex cursor-pointer items-center peer gap-0 sm:gap-0"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M17 3H7c-1.1 0-1.99.9-1.99 2L5 21l7-3 7 3V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm0 15l-5-2.18L7 18V5h10v13z"></path></svg><span class="flex-shrink-0 font-sans hidden group-hover:inline">Save</span></div><p class="sc-c0f26063-3 dwDZqP font-mono peer-hover:hidden">essay</p><p class="sc-c0f26063-2 cA-dtSP font-mono peer-hover:hidden">Biography and memoir</p></div><p class="m-x-0 mt-3.5 mb-3 font-bold font-serif text-[25px] leading-[1.2] [grid-area:title] sm:text-[28px]">A grief with no name</p><p class="mt-0 mb-3.5 text-base leading-normal tracking-normal [grid-area:standfirst]">As a child, I was torn from a culture that I never knew. It is a loss that defines me, even as I struggle to define the loss</p><p class="sc-c0f26063-0 sc-c0f26063-8 Yva-Dw jfoikg">Jelena Markovic</p></div><div class="sc-c0f26063-4 gLchsi"></div></div></a><a href="/essays/how-animals-learned-to-hibernate-and-why-we-cant-do-it-yet"><div class="sc-c0f26063-7 jQxQLA"><div type="essay" class="sc-31fe189a-2 gUHfgD"><img alt="A small animal curled up asleep on brown moss against a black background illuminated by a spotlight." loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-nimg="fill" style="position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;left:0;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;color:transparent" sizes="(max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 960px) 45vw, (max-width: 1440px) 30vw, 430px" srcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/511b71b7-d68f-4fd5-abf2-106ab3668a2a/essay-hi-w7ry2p.jpg?width=256&quality=75&format=auto 256w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/511b71b7-d68f-4fd5-abf2-106ab3668a2a/essay-hi-w7ry2p.jpg?width=384&quality=75&format=auto 384w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/511b71b7-d68f-4fd5-abf2-106ab3668a2a/essay-hi-w7ry2p.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/511b71b7-d68f-4fd5-abf2-106ab3668a2a/essay-hi-w7ry2p.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/511b71b7-d68f-4fd5-abf2-106ab3668a2a/essay-hi-w7ry2p.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/511b71b7-d68f-4fd5-abf2-106ab3668a2a/essay-hi-w7ry2p.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/511b71b7-d68f-4fd5-abf2-106ab3668a2a/essay-hi-w7ry2p.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/511b71b7-d68f-4fd5-abf2-106ab3668a2a/essay-hi-w7ry2p.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/511b71b7-d68f-4fd5-abf2-106ab3668a2a/essay-hi-w7ry2p.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/511b71b7-d68f-4fd5-abf2-106ab3668a2a/essay-hi-w7ry2p.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" src="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/511b71b7-d68f-4fd5-abf2-106ab3668a2a/essay-hi-w7ry2p.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto"/></div><div class="sc-c0f26063-1 cXFFat"><div class="sc-c0f26063-6 cJoMvV"><div class="group z-10 inline-flex cursor-pointer items-center peer gap-0 sm:gap-0"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M17 3H7c-1.1 0-1.99.9-1.99 2L5 21l7-3 7 3V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm0 15l-5-2.18L7 18V5h10v13z"></path></svg><span class="flex-shrink-0 font-sans hidden group-hover:inline">Save</span></div><p class="sc-c0f26063-3 dwDZqP font-mono peer-hover:hidden">essay</p><p class="sc-c0f26063-2 cA-dtSP font-mono peer-hover:hidden">Biology</p></div><p class="m-x-0 mt-3.5 mb-3 font-bold font-serif text-[25px] leading-[1.2] [grid-area:title] sm:text-[28px]">Could humans hibernate?</p><p class="mt-0 mb-3.5 text-base leading-normal tracking-normal [grid-area:standfirst]">Hibernation allows many animals to time-travel from difficult times to plenty. Could humans learn how to do it too?</p><p class="sc-c0f26063-0 sc-c0f26063-8 Yva-Dw jfoikg">Vladyslav Vyazovskiy</p></div><div class="sc-c0f26063-4 gLchsi"><span class="sc-c0f26063-5 jQGEAp"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20px" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M21.303,16.553l1.107,3.783l-3.48-2.322c-0.689,0.234-1.422,0.371-2.193,0.371c-1.041,0-2.024-0.234-2.907-0.642 c2.034-1.697,3.333-4.275,3.333-7.166c0-1.994-0.625-3.836-1.677-5.347c0.406-0.073,0.823-0.117,1.251-0.117 c3.762,0,6.814,2.971,6.814,6.634c0,1.594-0.578,3.057-1.539,4.2L21.303,16.553z M15.255,10.684c0,3.861-3.213,6.99-7.176,6.99 c-0.812,0-1.583-0.144-2.31-0.391l-3.667,2.446l1.166-3.985l-0.744-0.638c-1.013-1.203-1.621-2.743-1.621-4.423 c0-3.858,3.215-6.987,7.176-6.987C12.042,3.696,15.255,6.825,15.255,10.684z"></path></svg></span></div></div></a><a href="/essays/why-i-want-my-deaf-daughter-to-have-the-best-of-both-worlds"><div class="sc-c0f26063-7 jZQmTA"><div type="essay" class="sc-31fe189a-2 hdzCGH"><img alt="Illustration of a child holding a shell to their ear with a bird singing on a branch amidst abstract greenery and flowers." loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-nimg="fill" style="position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;left:0;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;color:transparent" sizes="(max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 960px) 45vw, (max-width: 1440px) 30vw, 430px" srcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/614bb00f-2edc-4bd3-8157-2ce696bd67d3/essay-abi_stephenson_aeon.jpg?width=256&quality=75&format=auto 256w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/614bb00f-2edc-4bd3-8157-2ce696bd67d3/essay-abi_stephenson_aeon.jpg?width=384&quality=75&format=auto 384w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/614bb00f-2edc-4bd3-8157-2ce696bd67d3/essay-abi_stephenson_aeon.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/614bb00f-2edc-4bd3-8157-2ce696bd67d3/essay-abi_stephenson_aeon.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/614bb00f-2edc-4bd3-8157-2ce696bd67d3/essay-abi_stephenson_aeon.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/614bb00f-2edc-4bd3-8157-2ce696bd67d3/essay-abi_stephenson_aeon.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/614bb00f-2edc-4bd3-8157-2ce696bd67d3/essay-abi_stephenson_aeon.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/614bb00f-2edc-4bd3-8157-2ce696bd67d3/essay-abi_stephenson_aeon.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/614bb00f-2edc-4bd3-8157-2ce696bd67d3/essay-abi_stephenson_aeon.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/614bb00f-2edc-4bd3-8157-2ce696bd67d3/essay-abi_stephenson_aeon.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" src="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/614bb00f-2edc-4bd3-8157-2ce696bd67d3/essay-abi_stephenson_aeon.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto"/></div><div class="sc-c0f26063-1 cXFFat"><div class="sc-c0f26063-6 cJoMvV"><div class="group z-10 inline-flex cursor-pointer items-center peer gap-0 sm:gap-0"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M17 3H7c-1.1 0-1.99.9-1.99 2L5 21l7-3 7 3V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm0 15l-5-2.18L7 18V5h10v13z"></path></svg><span class="flex-shrink-0 font-sans hidden group-hover:inline">Save</span></div><p class="sc-c0f26063-3 dwDZqP font-mono peer-hover:hidden">essay</p><p class="sc-c0f26063-2 cA-dtSP font-mono peer-hover:hidden">Bioethics</p></div><p class="m-x-0 mt-3.5 mb-3 font-bold font-serif text-[25px] leading-[1.2] [grid-area:title] sm:text-[28px]">The cochlear question</p><p class="mt-0 mb-3.5 text-base leading-normal tracking-normal [grid-area:standfirst]">As the hearing parent of a deaf baby, I’m confronted with an agonising decision: should I give her an implant to help her hear?</p><p class="sc-c0f26063-0 sc-c0f26063-8 Yva-Dw jfoikg">Abi Stephenson</p></div><div class="sc-c0f26063-4 gLchsi"></div></div></a><a href="/essays/on-seeing-the-laws-of-nature-as-a-recipe-or-a-news-report"><div class="sc-c0f26063-7 jZQmTA"><div type="essay" class="sc-31fe189a-2 hdzCGH"><img alt="A solitary figure walking up misty stairs toward an unclear building, creating a mysterious atmosphere." loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-nimg="fill" style="position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;left:0;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;color:transparent" sizes="(max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 960px) 45vw, (max-width: 1440px) 30vw, 430px" srcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/293dfee5-a2e1-41f9-82d6-c8ce36645448/test-nyc27030.jpg?width=256&quality=75&format=auto 256w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/293dfee5-a2e1-41f9-82d6-c8ce36645448/test-nyc27030.jpg?width=384&quality=75&format=auto 384w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/293dfee5-a2e1-41f9-82d6-c8ce36645448/test-nyc27030.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/293dfee5-a2e1-41f9-82d6-c8ce36645448/test-nyc27030.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/293dfee5-a2e1-41f9-82d6-c8ce36645448/test-nyc27030.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/293dfee5-a2e1-41f9-82d6-c8ce36645448/test-nyc27030.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/293dfee5-a2e1-41f9-82d6-c8ce36645448/test-nyc27030.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/293dfee5-a2e1-41f9-82d6-c8ce36645448/test-nyc27030.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/293dfee5-a2e1-41f9-82d6-c8ce36645448/test-nyc27030.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/293dfee5-a2e1-41f9-82d6-c8ce36645448/test-nyc27030.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" src="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/293dfee5-a2e1-41f9-82d6-c8ce36645448/test-nyc27030.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto"/></div><div class="sc-c0f26063-1 cXFFat"><div class="sc-c0f26063-6 cJoMvV"><div class="group z-10 inline-flex cursor-pointer items-center peer gap-0 sm:gap-0"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M17 3H7c-1.1 0-1.99.9-1.99 2L5 21l7-3 7 3V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm0 15l-5-2.18L7 18V5h10v13z"></path></svg><span class="flex-shrink-0 font-sans hidden group-hover:inline">Save</span></div><p class="sc-c0f26063-3 dwDZqP font-mono peer-hover:hidden">essay</p><p class="sc-c0f26063-2 cA-dtSP font-mono peer-hover:hidden">Philosophy of science</p></div><p class="m-x-0 mt-3.5 mb-3 font-bold font-serif text-[25px] leading-[1.2] [grid-area:title] sm:text-[28px]">The nature of natural laws</p><p class="mt-0 mb-3.5 text-base leading-normal tracking-normal [grid-area:standfirst]">Physicists and philosophers today have formulated three opposing models that explain how laws work. Which is the best?</p><p class="sc-c0f26063-0 sc-c0f26063-8 Yva-Dw jfoikg">Mario Hubert</p></div><div class="sc-c0f26063-4 gLchsi"><span class="sc-c0f26063-5 jQGEAp"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20px" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M21.303,16.553l1.107,3.783l-3.48-2.322c-0.689,0.234-1.422,0.371-2.193,0.371c-1.041,0-2.024-0.234-2.907-0.642 c2.034-1.697,3.333-4.275,3.333-7.166c0-1.994-0.625-3.836-1.677-5.347c0.406-0.073,0.823-0.117,1.251-0.117 c3.762,0,6.814,2.971,6.814,6.634c0,1.594-0.578,3.057-1.539,4.2L21.303,16.553z M15.255,10.684c0,3.861-3.213,6.99-7.176,6.99 c-0.812,0-1.583-0.144-2.31-0.391l-3.667,2.446l1.166-3.985l-0.744-0.638c-1.013-1.203-1.621-2.743-1.621-4.423 c0-3.858,3.215-6.987,7.176-6.987C12.042,3.696,15.255,6.825,15.255,10.684z"></path></svg></span></div></div></a><a href="/essays/tech-vexed-how-digital-life-threatens-our-capacity-for-awe"><div class="sc-c0f26063-7 gTsRyU"><div type="essay" class="sc-31fe189a-2 hDRjbu"><img alt="A man floating in the sea beneath a dramatic, stormy sky with large, dark clouds." loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-nimg="fill" style="position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;left:0;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;color:transparent" sizes="(max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 960px) 45vw, (max-width: 1440px) 30vw, 430px" srcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/a662a4aa-bc17-426a-82bd-89e58e2f7103/essay-heat_storm.jpg?width=256&quality=75&format=auto 256w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/a662a4aa-bc17-426a-82bd-89e58e2f7103/essay-heat_storm.jpg?width=384&quality=75&format=auto 384w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/a662a4aa-bc17-426a-82bd-89e58e2f7103/essay-heat_storm.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/a662a4aa-bc17-426a-82bd-89e58e2f7103/essay-heat_storm.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/a662a4aa-bc17-426a-82bd-89e58e2f7103/essay-heat_storm.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/a662a4aa-bc17-426a-82bd-89e58e2f7103/essay-heat_storm.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/a662a4aa-bc17-426a-82bd-89e58e2f7103/essay-heat_storm.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/a662a4aa-bc17-426a-82bd-89e58e2f7103/essay-heat_storm.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/a662a4aa-bc17-426a-82bd-89e58e2f7103/essay-heat_storm.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/a662a4aa-bc17-426a-82bd-89e58e2f7103/essay-heat_storm.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" src="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/a662a4aa-bc17-426a-82bd-89e58e2f7103/essay-heat_storm.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto"/></div><div class="sc-c0f26063-1 cXFFat"><div class="sc-c0f26063-6 cJoMvV"><div class="group z-10 inline-flex cursor-pointer items-center peer gap-0 sm:gap-0"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M17 3H7c-1.1 0-1.99.9-1.99 2L5 21l7-3 7 3V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm0 15l-5-2.18L7 18V5h10v13z"></path></svg><span class="flex-shrink-0 font-sans hidden group-hover:inline">Save</span></div><p class="sc-c0f26063-3 dwDZqP font-mono peer-hover:hidden">essay</p><p class="sc-c0f26063-2 cA-dtSP font-mono peer-hover:hidden">Technology and the self</p></div><p class="m-x-0 mt-3.5 mb-3 font-bold font-serif text-[25px] leading-[1.2] [grid-area:title] sm:text-[28px]">We need raw awe</p><p class="mt-0 mb-3.5 text-base leading-normal tracking-normal [grid-area:standfirst]">In this tech-vexed age, our life on screens prevents us from experiencing the mysteries and transformative wonder of life</p><p class="sc-c0f26063-0 sc-c0f26063-8 Yva-Dw jfoikg">Kirk Schneider</p></div><div class="sc-c0f26063-4 gLchsi"><span class="sc-c0f26063-5 jQGEAp"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20px" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M21.303,16.553l1.107,3.783l-3.48-2.322c-0.689,0.234-1.422,0.371-2.193,0.371c-1.041,0-2.024-0.234-2.907-0.642 c2.034-1.697,3.333-4.275,3.333-7.166c0-1.994-0.625-3.836-1.677-5.347c0.406-0.073,0.823-0.117,1.251-0.117 c3.762,0,6.814,2.971,6.814,6.634c0,1.594-0.578,3.057-1.539,4.2L21.303,16.553z M15.255,10.684c0,3.861-3.213,6.99-7.176,6.99 c-0.812,0-1.583-0.144-2.31-0.391l-3.667,2.446l1.166-3.985l-0.744-0.638c-1.013-1.203-1.621-2.743-1.621-4.423 c0-3.858,3.215-6.987,7.176-6.987C12.042,3.696,15.255,6.825,15.255,10.684z"></path></svg></span></div></div></a><a href="/essays/how-austen-and-darwin-converged-on-the-question-of-beauty"><div class="sc-c0f26063-7 jZQmTA"><div type="essay" class="sc-31fe189a-2 hdzCGH"><img alt="Painting of two anthropomorphic peacocks in 18th-century attire in front of a stately home surrounded by trees." loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-nimg="fill" style="position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;left:0;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;color:transparent" sizes="(max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 960px) 45vw, (max-width: 1440px) 30vw, 430px" srcSet="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/67725c32-b102-4f68-adaa-0c7f06687b4e/essay-final-austen_and_darwin_5.jpg?width=256&quality=75&format=auto 256w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/67725c32-b102-4f68-adaa-0c7f06687b4e/essay-final-austen_and_darwin_5.jpg?width=384&quality=75&format=auto 384w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/67725c32-b102-4f68-adaa-0c7f06687b4e/essay-final-austen_and_darwin_5.jpg?width=640&quality=75&format=auto 640w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/67725c32-b102-4f68-adaa-0c7f06687b4e/essay-final-austen_and_darwin_5.jpg?width=750&quality=75&format=auto 750w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/67725c32-b102-4f68-adaa-0c7f06687b4e/essay-final-austen_and_darwin_5.jpg?width=828&quality=75&format=auto 828w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/67725c32-b102-4f68-adaa-0c7f06687b4e/essay-final-austen_and_darwin_5.jpg?width=1080&quality=75&format=auto 1080w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/67725c32-b102-4f68-adaa-0c7f06687b4e/essay-final-austen_and_darwin_5.jpg?width=1200&quality=75&format=auto 1200w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/67725c32-b102-4f68-adaa-0c7f06687b4e/essay-final-austen_and_darwin_5.jpg?width=1920&quality=75&format=auto 1920w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/67725c32-b102-4f68-adaa-0c7f06687b4e/essay-final-austen_and_darwin_5.jpg?width=2048&quality=75&format=auto 2048w, https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/67725c32-b102-4f68-adaa-0c7f06687b4e/essay-final-austen_and_darwin_5.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto 3840w" src="https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/67725c32-b102-4f68-adaa-0c7f06687b4e/essay-final-austen_and_darwin_5.jpg?width=3840&quality=75&format=auto"/></div><div class="sc-c0f26063-1 cXFFat"><div class="sc-c0f26063-6 cJoMvV"><div class="group z-10 inline-flex cursor-pointer items-center peer gap-0 sm:gap-0"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M17 3H7c-1.1 0-1.99.9-1.99 2L5 21l7-3 7 3V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm0 15l-5-2.18L7 18V5h10v13z"></path></svg><span class="flex-shrink-0 font-sans hidden group-hover:inline">Save</span></div><p class="sc-c0f26063-3 dwDZqP font-mono peer-hover:hidden">essay</p><p class="sc-c0f26063-2 cA-dtSP font-mono peer-hover:hidden">Beauty and aesthetics</p></div><p class="m-x-0 mt-3.5 mb-3 font-bold font-serif text-[25px] leading-[1.2] [grid-area:title] sm:text-[28px]">Is beauty natural?</p><p class="mt-0 mb-3.5 text-base leading-normal tracking-normal [grid-area:standfirst]">Charles Darwin was as fascinated by extravagant ornament in nature as Jane Austen was in culture. Did their explanations agree?</p><p class="sc-c0f26063-0 sc-c0f26063-8 Yva-Dw jfoikg">Abigail Tulenko</p></div><div class="sc-c0f26063-4 gLchsi"></div></div></a></div></div></div></div><footer class="sc-4c328164-0 vEOCJ footer"><div class="sc-ae266dcd-0 sc-4c328164-1 iPkIIN kvvHSZ"><div class="sc-1b596d24-0 exRbDE"><div class="sc-47bc2fa8-0 sc-bab0e3bb-0 kijMKl jnfNRX"><nav class="sc-bab0e3bb-1 kDfACp"><a href="/essays" class="sc-9fe3192b-0 lerFoj">Essays</a><a href="/ideas" class="sc-9fe3192b-0 lerFoj">Ideas</a><a href="/videos" class="sc-9fe3192b-0 lerFoj">Videos</a></nav></div><div class="sc-47bc2fa8-0 sc-bab0e3bb-0 kijMKl jnfNRX"><nav class="sc-bab0e3bb-1 kDfACp"><a href="/about" class="sc-9fe3192b-0 lerFoj">About</a><a href="/contact" class="sc-9fe3192b-0 lerFoj">Contact</a><a href="/support" class="sc-9fe3192b-0 lerFoj">Support</a></nav></div><div class="sc-47bc2fa8-0 sc-bab0e3bb-0 kijMKl TldsU"><nav class="sc-bab0e3bb-1 kDfACp"><a href="/feed.rss" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer" class="sc-9fe3192b-0 lerFoj">RSS Feed</a><a data-ga-select-prompt="aeon_footer_donate" href="/donate" class="sc-9fe3192b-0 lerFoj">Donate</a><a href="/community-guidelines" class="sc-9fe3192b-0 lerFoj">Community Guidelines</a></nav></div></div><div class="sc-47bc2fa8-0 sc-89e3ac83-0 kijMKl ivgdIo"><p class="sc-89e3ac83-3 eHbyYZ">Follow Aeon</p><div class="sc-89e3ac83-1 bHstOp"><p class="sc-89e3ac83-2 hqHrdb"><a href="https://www.facebook.com/aeonmag" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" title="Facebook"><svg viewBox="0 0 1024 1024" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><g><path d="M1024,512C1024,229.23,794.77,0,512,0S0,229.23,0,512c0,255.55,187.23,467.37,432,505.78V660H302V512H432V399.2C432,270.88,508.44,200,625.39,200c56,0,114.61,10,114.61,10V336H675.44c-63.6,0-83.44,39.47-83.44,80v96H734L711.3,660H592v357.78C836.77,979.37,1024,767.55,1024,512Z"></path><path d="M711.3,660,734,512H592V416c0-40.49,19.84-80,83.44-80H740V210s-58.59-10-114.61-10C508.44,200,432,270.88,432,399.2V512H302V660H432v357.78a517.58,517.58,0,0,0,160,0V660Z" fill="transparent"></path></g></svg></a><a href="https://www.instagram.com/aeonmag" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" title="Instagram"><svg viewBox="0 0 24 25" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="19" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M17.216.5c4.456.203 6.887 2.633 7.09 7.09v10.126c-.203 4.456-2.634 6.887-7.09 7.09H7.09C2.633 24.603.203 22.172 0 17.716V7.59C.203 3.133 2.633.703 7.09.5zm-5.063 5.874c-3.444 0-6.28 2.835-6.28 6.279 0 3.443 2.836 6.279 6.28 6.279 3.443 0 6.279-2.836 6.279-6.28 0-3.443-2.836-6.278-6.28-6.278zm0 2.228a4.063 4.063 0 0 1 4.05 4.05 4.063 4.063 0 0 1-4.05 4.052 4.063 4.063 0 0 1-4.051-4.051 4.063 4.063 0 0 1 4.05-4.051zm6.481-3.849c-.81 0-1.418.608-1.418 1.418 0 .81.608 1.418 1.418 1.418.81 0 1.418-.608 1.418-1.418 0-.81-.608-1.418-1.418-1.418z"></path></svg></a><a href="https://twitter.com/aeonmag" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" title="X (Formerly Twitter)"><svg viewBox="0 0 450 450" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="22" height="20.3" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M225 450C349.264 450 450 349.264 450 225C450 100.736 349.264 0 225 0C100.736 0 0 100.736 0 225C0 349.264 100.736 450 225 450ZM349.373 92L250.332 204.646L358 358H278.785L206.256 254.71L115.461 358H92L195.855 239.888L92 92H171.215L239.878 189.789L325.912 92H349.373ZM159.972 109.311H123.929L289.842 341.539H325.894L159.972 109.311Z"></path></svg></a><a href="https://www.youtube.com/@AeonVideo" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" title="YouTube"><svg viewBox="0 0 22 20" fill="currentColor" stroke="none" width="22" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" aria-hidden="true"><g><path d="M21.5,4.7c-0.3-1-1-1.7-1.9-2C17.9,2.2,11,2.2,11,2.2s-6.9,0-8.6,0.5c-1,0.3-1.7,1-1.9,2C0,6.4,0,10,0,10s0,3.6,0.5,5.3 c0.3,1,1,1.7,1.9,2c1.7,0.5,8.6,0.5,8.6,0.5s6.9,0,8.6-0.5c1-0.3,1.7-1,1.9-2C22,13.6,22,10,22,10S22,6.4,21.5,4.7z M8.8,13.3V6.7 l5.8,3.3L8.8,13.3z"></path></g></svg></a></p></div></div><div class="sc-f1ffec09-0 hBfeSY"><div class="sc-47bc2fa8-0 kijMKl"><div class="newsletter-signup"><div class="flex justify-center bg-light-pink py-16"><div class="mx-auto inline-block w-full font-sans max-w-[42rem]"><form><h3 class="mb-3 text-xl">Sign up to our newsletter</h3><h4 class="mb-0">Updates on everything new at Aeon.</h4><div class="space-y-1 text-base inline-block"><input class="appearance-none border-solid font-normal text-inherit placeholder:opacity-50 inline-block w-full min-w-60 rounded border border-grey-light px-3.5 py-3 text-base outline-none transition-colors focus:bg-grey-light-bg sm:text-base" placeholder="Your email address" id=":R2mmtm:" aria-invalid="false" name="email" value=""/></div><div class="my-5 grid grid-cols-1 gap-x-6 gap-y-2 sm:grid-cols-[min-content,auto]"><div class="space-y-1 text-base"><label class="flex items-center gap-4"><label class="after:-rotate-[48deg] after:-top-0.5 flex h-[18px] w-[18px] flex-shrink-0 items-center justify-center border border-black border-solid ring-primary ring-offset-2 after:relative after:box-content after:hidden after:h-[5px] after:w-[9px] after:border-0 after:border-white after:border-b-2 after:border-l-2 after:border-solid has-[:disabled]:opacity-50 has-[:focus-visible]:ring-2 has-[:checked]:after:block has-[:checked]:border-aeon-red has-[:checked]:bg-aeon-red"><input type="checkbox" class="absolute opacity-0" id=":Rbmmtm:" aria-invalid="false" name="frequency.daily" value="false"/></label><div><span>Daily</span></div></label></div><div class="space-y-1 text-base"><label class="flex items-center gap-4"><label class="after:-rotate-[48deg] after:-top-0.5 flex h-[18px] w-[18px] flex-shrink-0 items-center justify-center border border-black border-solid ring-primary ring-offset-2 after:relative after:box-content after:hidden after:h-[5px] after:w-[9px] after:border-0 after:border-white after:border-b-2 after:border-l-2 after:border-solid has-[:disabled]:opacity-50 has-[:focus-visible]:ring-2 has-[:checked]:after:block has-[:checked]:border-aeon-red has-[:checked]:bg-aeon-red"><input type="checkbox" class="absolute opacity-0" id=":Rjmmtm:" aria-invalid="false" name="frequency.weekly" value="false"/></label><div><span>Weekly</span></div></label></div></div><div class="mt-5 flex flex-wrap items-center gap-4"><button class="cursor-pointer appearance-none border-none text-base relative inline-flex min-w-32 items-center justify-center gap-2 overflow-hidden px-5 py-3 text-white tracking-wide transition-colors hover:enabled:bg-black disabled:cursor-default bg-aeon-red disabled:opacity-50" type="submit">Subscribe<svg fill="#fff" width="18" height="18" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path><path d="M12 4l-1.41 1.41L16.17 11H4v2h12.17l-5.58 5.59L12 20l8-8z"></path></svg></button></div><div class="mt-6 text-xs">See our <a class="underline" href="/newsletter-privacy">newsletter privacy policy</a>.</div></form></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="sc-ae266dcd-0 sc-4c328164-2 iPkIIN gcQpnp"><div class="px-[1.8rem] text-black/60 text-xs max-[640px]:px-[0.6rem]">© Aeon Media Group Ltd. 2012-2024. <a class="text-inherit hover:text-black" href="/privacy"><u>Privacy Policy</u></a>. <a class="text-inherit hover:text-black" href="/terms-of-use"><u>Terms of Use</u></a>.</div><div class="sc-47bc2fa8-0 sc-4c328164-3 kijMKl eVINpq">Aeon is published by registered charity Aeon Media Group Ltd in association with Aeon America, a 501(c)(3) charity.</div></div></footer></div><div id="bottom-portal" class="sc-a70232b9-5 bqrDzC"></div></div></div><script id="__NEXT_DATA__" type="application/json">{"props":{"pageProps":{"article":{"id":"4901","title":"Modular cognition","slug":"how-evolution-hacked-its-way-to-intelligence-from-the-bottom-up","type":"essay","body":"\u003cp\u003eIntelligent decision-making doesn’t require a brain. You were capable of it before you even had one. Beginning life as a single fertilised egg, you divided and became a mass of genetically identical cells. They chattered among themselves to fashion a complex anatomical structure – your body. Even more remarkably, if you had split in two as an embryo, each half would have been able to replace what was missing, leaving you as one of two identical (monozygotic) twins. Likewise, if two mouse embryos are mushed together like a snowball, a single, normal mouse results. Just how do these embryos know what to do? We have no technology yet that has this degree of plasticity – recognising a deviation from the normal course of events and responding to achieve the same outcome overall.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eThis is intelligence in action: the ability to reach a particular goal or solve a problem by undertaking new steps in the face of changing circumstances. It’s evident not just in intelligent people and mammals and birds and cephalopods, but also cells and tissues, individual neurons and networks of neurons, viruses, ribosomes and RNA fragments, down to motor proteins and molecular networks. Across all these scales, living things solve problems and achieve goals by flexibly navigating different spaces – metabolic, physiological, genetic, cognitive, behavioural.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eBut how did intelligence emerge in biology? The question has preoccupied scientists since Charles Darwin, but it remains unanswered. The processes of intelligence are so intricate, so multilayered and baroque, no wonder some people might be tempted by stories about a top-down Creator. But we know evolution must have been able to come up with intelligence on its own, from the \u003cspan class=\"ld-nowrap\"\u003ebottom up.\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eDarwin’s best shot at an explanation was that random mutations changed and rearranged genes, altered the structure and function of bodies, and so produced adaptations that allowed certain organisms to thrive and reproduce in their environment. (In technical terms, they are \u003cem\u003eselected\u003c/em\u003e for by the environment.) In the end, somehow, intelligence was the result. But there’s plenty of natural and experimental evidence to suggest that evolution doesn’t just select hardwired solutions that are engineered for a specific setting. For example, lab studies have shown that perfectly normal frog skin cells, when liberated from the instructive influence of the rest of the embryo, can reboot their cooperative activity to produce a novel proto-organism, \u003ca href=\"https://www.science.org/doi/pdf/10.1126/scirobotics.abf1571\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003ecalled\u003c/a\u003e a ‘xenobot’. Evolution, it seems, doesn’t come up with answers so much as generate flexible problem-solving agents that can rise to new challenges and figure things out on their own.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eThe urgency of understanding intelligence in biological terms has become more acute with the ‘omics’ revolution, where new techniques are amassing enormous amounts of fresh data on the genes, proteins and connections within each cell. Yet the deluge of information about cellular hardware isn’t yielding a better explanation of the intelligent flexibility we observe in living systems. Nor is it yielding sufficient practical insights, for example, in the realm of regenerative medicine. We think the real problem is not one of data, but of perspective. Intelligence is not something that happened at the tail end of evolution, but was \u003ca href=\"https://aeon.co/essays/the-study-of-the-mind-needs-a-copernican-shift-in-perspective\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"\u003ediscovered\u003c/a\u003e towards the beginning, long before brains came on the scene.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eFrom the earliest metabolic cycles that kept microbes’ chemical parameters within the right ranges, biology has been capable of achieving aims. Yet generation after generation of biologists have been trained to avoid questions about the ultimate purpose of things. Biologists are told to focus on the ‘how’, not the ‘why’, or risk falling prey to theology. Students must reduce events to their simplest components and causes, and study these mechanisms in piecemeal fashion. Talk of ‘goals’, we are told, skirts perilously close to abandoning naturalism; the result is a kind of ‘teleophobia’, a fear of purpose, based on the idea that attributing too much intelligence to a system is the worst mistake you can make.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eBut the converse is just as bad: failing to recognise intelligence when it’s right under our noses, and could be useful. Not only is ‘why’ always present in biological systems – it is exactly what drives the ‘how’. Once we open ourselves up to that idea, we can identify two powerful tricks, inspired by computer science and cybernetics, that allowed evolution to ‘hack’ its way to intelligence from the bottom up. No skyhooks needed.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003e\u003cspan class=\"ld-dropcap\"\u003eE\u003c/span\u003embryos aren’t the only things capable of flexible self-repair. Many species can regenerate or replace lost body parts as adults. The Mexican salamander known as the \u003ca href=\"https://aeon.co/ideas/consider-the-axolotl-our-great-hope-of-regeneration\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"\u003eaxolotl\u003c/a\u003e can regrow lost limbs, eyes, jaws and ovaries, as well as the spinal cord and portions of the heart and brain. The body recognises deviations from its correct anatomy as errors, and the cells work rapidly to get back to normal. Similarly, when Picasso-style tadpoles are made in the lab, with eyes and other organs randomly placed in different starting positions, they undergo novel paths of movement that nevertheless \u003ca href=\"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22411736/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003eend up\u003c/a\u003e creating largely normal frog faces.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eHow do the tadpole’s facial organs know when to stop moving? How does the salamander’s tissue determine that a limb of the right size and shape has been produced, and that the remodelling can stop? It’s clear that cell groups need to be able to ‘work until goal X is satisfied’, storing a memory of the goal (which might be an anatomical configuration much larger than any single cell), and course-correcting if they are perturbed along the way.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eOne explanation of embryos’ amazing feats comes from control theory, which show us that dynamical systems (such as a thermostat) can pursue goals without magic, simply using feedback to correct for errors. Such ‘homeostasis’ in biology, as the process is known, keeps parameters such as pH within specific limits. But the same dynamic operates on a much larger scale, as long as cells are physiologically plugged into networks. Networks of cells are able to measure chemical, electrical and biomechanical properties of tissues, and make decisions about things that single cells cannot appreciate.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eSingle cells can \u003ca href=\"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25926819/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003eprocess\u003c/a\u003e local information about their environment and their own states to pursue tiny, cell-level goals (such as staying pointed in a specific direction). But networks of cells can integrate signals from across distances, store memories of patterns, and compute the outcomes of large-scale questions (such as ‘Is this finger the right length?’ or ‘Does this face look right?’) Cell networks carry out computations that can assess larger quantities (such as anatomical shape) and direct the underlying cell activity to bring the system closer to a specific desired goal (\u003ca href=\"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27807271/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003ecalled\u003c/a\u003e a ‘setpoint’).\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp class=\"pullquote\"\u003eModularity means that the stakes for testing out mutations are reasonably low\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eAchieving such intelligent, finely tuned calibration likely relies on \u003cem\u003emodularity\u003c/em\u003e – the first step that we believe can explain the emergence of intelligent behaviour. Like a large organisation that deploys a number of specialised teams to make and sell a single product, modularity is about self-maintaining units that can cooperate or compete to achieve local outcomes, but end up collectively working towards some larger goal. Crucially, this structure avoids micromanagement – each level doesn’t need to know how the lower levels do their job, but can simply motivate them (with things like reward molecules and stress pathways) to get it done.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cfigure\u003e\u003cimg src=\"https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1859/insert-Figure-1B.jpg\" alt=\"Illustration of biological cognition tiers, showing cytoskeleton, neural network, whole tissue, whole organism, genetic network, and group.\" class=\"ld-image-block\" height=\"852\" width=\"800\"\u003e\u003cfigcaption class=\"ld-image-caption\"\u003e\u003cp\u003eModularity – the presence of competent subunits, which solve problems in their own local problem space, that can cooperate and compete to achieve bigger goals – is part of what enables the emergence of intelligence in biology. The way these modules’ agendas are nested within one another in biological networks gives them the flexibility to meet goals at each level, even when conditions change at lower levels\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/figcaption\u003e\u003c/figure\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eWhen unicellular organisms joined up to make multicellular bodies, each module didn’t lose its individual competency. Rather, cells used specific proteins to merge into ever more complex networks that could implement larger objectives, possess longer memories and look further into the future. Networks of cells began to work as a society – measuring and pursuing goals defined at the level of the collective (such as ‘organ size’ and ‘organ shape’). Stress about large-scale states (such as ‘attention: finger too short’) triggered change, which was shared across tissues to implement coordinated action. This multiscale architecture has many advantages. For one, it’s easy for evolution to simply shift the modules around and let the cycle of error reduction take care of the rest – setting new conditions as the setpoint, or the source of stress (eg, ‘wrong length of limbs’ instead of ‘misfolded proteins’). It’s similar to how you can change the setpoint of your thermostat without having to rewire it, or even know how it works. Feedback loops within feedback loops, and a nested hierarchy of incentivised modules that can be reshuffled by evolution, offer immense problem-solving power.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eOne implication of this hierarchy of homeostatically stable, nested modules is that organisms became much more flexible while still \u003ca href=\"https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02688/full\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003emaintaining\u003c/a\u003e a coherent ‘self’ in a hostile world. Evolution didn’t have to tweak everything at once in response to a new threat, because biological subunits were primed to find novel ways of compensating for changes and functioning within altered systems. For example, in planarian flatworms, which reliably regenerate every part of the body, using drugs to shift the bioelectrically stored pattern memory \u003ca href=\"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27499881/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003eresults\u003c/a\u003e in two-headed worms. Remarkably, fragments of these worms continue to regenerate two heads in perpetuity, without editing the genome. Moreover, flatworms can be \u003ca href=\"https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27574538\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003einduced\u003c/a\u003e, by brief modulation of the bioelectric circuit, to regrow heads with shape (and brain structure) appropriate to other known species of flatworms (at about \u003cspan class=\"ld-nowrap\"\u003e100 million\u003c/span\u003e years of evolutionary distance), despite their wild-type genome.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eModularity means that the stakes for testing out mutations are reasonably low: competent subunits can be depended upon to meet their goals under a wide range of conditions, so evolution rarely needs to ‘worry’ that a single mutation could ruin the show. For example, if a new mutation results in an eye being in the wrong place, a hardwired organism would find it very hard to survive. However, modular systems can compensate for the change while moving the eye back to where it’s supposed to be (or enabling it to work in its new location), thus having the opportunity to explore other, possibly useful, effects of the mutation. Tadpole eyes have been shown to do this, conferring vision even if asked to form on the tail, by finding connections to the spinal cord instead of the brain.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003e\u003cspan class=\"ld-dropcap\"\u003eM\u003c/span\u003eodularity provides stability and robustness, and is the first part of the answer to how intelligence arose. When changes occur to one part of the body, its evolutionary history as a nested doll of competent, problem-solving cells means subunits can step up and modify their activity to keep the organism alive. This isn’t a separate capacity that evolved from scratch in complex organisms, but instead an inevitable consequence of the ancient ability of cells to look after themselves and the networks of which they form a part.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eBut just how are these modules controlled? The second step on the road to the emergence of intelligence lies in knowing how modules can be manipulated. Encoding information in networks requires the ability to catalyse complex outcomes with simple signals. This is known as \u003cem\u003epattern completion\u003c/em\u003e: the capacity of one particular element in the module to activate the entire module. That special element, which serves as a ‘trigger’, starts the activity, kicking the other members of the module into action and completing the pattern. In this way, instead of activating the entire module, evolution needs only to activate that trigger.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003ePattern completion is an essential aspect of modularity which we’re just beginning to understand, thanks to work in developmental biology and neuroscience. For example, an entire eye can be created in the gut of a frog embryo by briefly altering the bioelectric state of some cells. These cells are triggered to complete the eye pattern by recruiting nearby neighbours (which were not themselves bioelectrically altered) to fill in the rest of the eye. Similar outcomes can be achieved by genetic or chemical ‘master regulators’, such as the \u003cem\u003eHox\u003c/em\u003e genes that specify the body plan of most bilaterally symmetrical animals. In fact, one could relabel these regulator genes as pattern completion genes, since they enable the coordinated expression of a suite of other genes from a simple signal. The key is that modules, by continuing to work until certain conditions are met, can fill in a complex pattern when given only a small part of the pattern. In doing so, they translate a simple command – the activation of the trigger – and amplify it into an entire program.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eCrucially, pattern completion doesn’t require defining all of the information needed to create an organ. Evolution does not have to rediscover how to specify all the cell types and get them arranged in the correct orientation – all it has to do is activate a simple trigger, and the modular organisation of development (where cells build to a specific pattern) does the rest. Pattern completion enables the emergence of developmental complexity and intelligence: simple triggers of complex cascades that make it possible for random changes to DNA to generate coherent, functional (and occasionally advantageous) bodies.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eModular pattern completion is also becoming evident in recent experiments in neuroscience. The pinnacle of intelligent behaviour in biology is the human brain. Nervous systems are built with large numbers of neurons, where every neuron is typically connected to very large numbers of other neurons. Over evolutionary time, there’s been a steady progression to larger and more connected brains, reaching astronomical numbers – with close to \u003cspan class=\"ld-nowrap\"\u003e100 billion\u003c/span\u003e neurons and hundreds of thousands of connections per neuron in humans. This move towards higher numbers of neurons and connections cannot be a coincidence: a system with many interacting units is exactly what it takes to become more competent and complex.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp class=\"pullquote\"\u003eAnalysing the brain by looking at a single neuron is like trying to understand a movie from an isolated pixel\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eBut what exactly do all these vast neural circuits do? While many neuroscientists would agree that the function of the nervous system is to sense the environment and generate behaviour, it’s less clear how that actually happens. The traditional view \u003ca href=\"https://www.nature.com/articles/nrn3962#https://www.nature.com/articles/nrn3962\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003eknown as\u003c/a\u003e the ‘neuron doctrine’, proposed by Santiago Ramón y Cajal and Charles Scott Sherrington more than a century ago, is that each neuron has a specific function. This would make the brain analogous to an aeroplane, built with millions of components, each precisely designed for a particular task.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eWithin this framing, neuroscientists have teased apart the brain and studied it one neuron at a time, linking the activity of individual neurons to the behaviour of the animal or the mental state of a person. Yet if the true goals of biological systems derive from how their subunits or modules interact, then analysing the brain by looking at a single neuron is as futile as trying to understand a movie while fixating on an isolated pixel.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eWhat type of properties might neural circuits generate? Because neurons can set each other off, neural circuits can generate internal states of activity that are independent of the outside world. A group of connected neurons could auto-excite each other and become active together for a period of time, even if nothing external is happening. This is how we might understand the existence of the concepts and abstractions that populate the human mind – as the endogenous activity of modules, made up of ensembles of neurons.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eUsing those intrinsic activity states as symbols, evolution could then build formal representations of reality. It could manipulate those states instead of manipulating the reality, just as we do by defining mathematical terms to explore relationships between objects. From this point of view – the gist of which was already proposed by Immanuel Kant in his \u003cem\u003eCritique of Pure Reason\u003c/em\u003e (1781, 1787) – the evolution of the nervous system represents the appearance of a new formal world, a symbolic world, that greatly expands the possibilities of the physical world because it gives us a way to explore and manipulate it mentally.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eNeuronal modules could also be organised in a hierarchy, where higher-level modules encode and symbolise increasingly more abstract entities. For example, lower-level groups of neurons in our spinal cord might activate muscle fibres, and be under the control of upper-level ensembles in the motor cortex that could encode the desired movement more abstractly (‘to change the position of the leg’). In turn, these motor cortex ensembles could be controlled by higher-order neurons again (‘to perform a pirouette’), which could be controlled by groups of neurons in the prefrontal cortex that represent the behavioural intention (‘to perform in a ballet’).\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eUsing modules nested in a hierarchy provides a neat solution to a tough design challenge: instead of specifying and controlling every element, one at a time, nature uses neuronal ensembles as computational building blocks to perform different functions at different levels. This progression towards increasing abstraction could help explain how cognition and consciousness might arise, as emergent functional properties, from relatively simple neural hardware. This same powerful idea of hierarchical emergence is behind the layered neural network models in computer science, named ‘neural’ because they are inspired by neural circuits.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003e\u003cspan class=\"ld-dropcap\"\u003eB\u003c/span\u003eut back to Darwin’s problem: if evolution is blind and acting solely on the individual units, one mutation at a time, how can the overall architecture and function of an organism be modified for the common good? Besides generating modules, neural networks have another interesting property we’ve already discussed: pattern completion.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eIn recent \u003ca href=\"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2019.05.045\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003eexperiments\u003c/a\u003e, mice were induced to have artificial perceptions or visual hallucinations by activating only two neurons in their visual cortex. How is this possible, given that the mouse brain has around \u003cspan class=\"ld-nowrap\"\u003e100 million\u003c/span\u003e neurons? The answer is that those neurons can trigger a neuronal ensemble, via pattern completion. Neurons’ connectivity seems to amplify activity, so, like an avalanche, a change in one neuron ends up triggering the entire module. This means that you can activate an entire module of neurons by turning on only one key member of the group.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp class=\"pullquote\"\u003ePattern completion shows us how a single event – say, a mutation – can change an army, or build an eye\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003ePattern completion could be at the core of how the brain works internally – recruiting module after module, at different levels of the hierarchy, depending on the task at hand. But why wouldn’t pattern completion end up tripping the entire brain into an epileptic seizure? By adding inhibitory connections to these neural circuits – small circuit breakers – one can restrict these avalanches to small groups of neurons, instead of catastrophically activating the entire brain. By harnessing pattern completion along with inhibitory circuits, the brain has the ability to select and manipulate modules at different levels as needed.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cfigure\u003e\u003cimg src=\"https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1855/v1-Figure-2.jpg\" alt=\"Three mesh-like 3D surfaces with a ball moving downwards, depicted in a sequence showing positions before, during, and after motion.\" class=\"ld-image-block\" height=\"215\" width=\"800\"\u003e\u003cfigcaption class=\"ld-image-caption\"\u003e\u003cp\u003e(I) Trigger stimuli allow for pattern completion, because networks can be organised such that they tend to settle in specific states (memories) from diverse positions (like the way a ball rolls down into a well from many different starting points). The topology of this landscape means that the system automatically returns to the same state when disturbed – symbolised by the ball falling to the bottom of a valley, when it is placed near the edge. This metaphor for pattern completion captures the idea of how the ‘landscape’ of the system ‘makes you do it’: it allows subunits to pursue local homeostatic goals (such as minimising a variable to move down a gradient), but enables the end result to be a higher-level pattern\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/figcaption\u003e\u003c/figure\u003e\n\u003cfigure\u003e\u003cimg src=\"https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1856/v2-Figure-2.jpg\" alt=\"Diagram showing a three-step process where a green matrix transforms and corrects the letter ‘G’ displayed on a grid below it.\" class=\"ld-image-block\" height=\"205\" width=\"800\"\u003e\u003cfigcaption class=\"ld-image-caption\"\u003e\u003cp\u003e(II) The ability for networks to reach the same outcome from a range of partial inputs – the generalisation of pattern completion – is also exploited in computer science. For example, computational neural networks can recover an entire remembered image based on only a partial example, from which some aspect has been removed\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/figcaption\u003e\u003c/figure\u003e\n\u003cfigure\u003e\u003cimg src=\"https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1857/v3-Figure-2.jpg\" alt=\"Illustration of a planarian, its amputation, cell processes of proliferation, differentiation, migration, apoptosis, and regeneration.\" class=\"ld-image-block\" height=\"219\" width=\"800\"\u003e\u003cfigcaption class=\"ld-image-caption\"\u003e\u003cp\u003e(III) The flatworm is a master of pattern completion, generating its entire anatomy from a small piece of its pattern. The bioelectric network of cells stores a pattern memory that controls individual cells in order to restore the whole\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/figcaption\u003e\u003c/figure\u003e\n\u003cfigure\u003e\u003cimg src=\"https://images.aeonmedia.co/user_image_upload/1858/v4-Figure-2.jpg\" alt=\"Diagrams labelled A to F showing network structures with numbered nodes and connecting lines, transitioning from grey to red.\" class=\"ld-image-block\" height=\"282\" width=\"800\"\u003e\u003cfigcaption class=\"ld-image-caption\"\u003e\u003cp\u003e(IV) Pattern completion is also present in neural circuits, where a small group of connected neurons can store associative memory. Here, you see: a) independent neurons are present without synaptic connections; b) neurons 1, 3 and 5 are activated simultaneously by external inputs, which forms and strengthens the synaptic connections between them; c) when the input ceases, neuronal activity also stops (however, the synaptic connections between the three neurons remain; these neurons have formed a module, and their interconnectivity determines how the module activates); d) an input activates just one of the original three neurons, but the connections activate all three neurons and complete the entire pattern; e) even after the input current has ended, the neurons can remain persistently active, in effect, storing a memory of the input\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/figcaption\u003e\u003c/figure\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eIn this way, pattern completion enables connections between modules at the same and different levels of the hierarchy, knitting them together as a single system. A key neuron in a lower-level module can be activated by an upper-level one, and vice versa. Like changing the march of an army, you don’t need to convince every soldier to do so – just convince the general, who makes the others fall into line. Consistent with the many parallels between neurons and non-neural signals, pattern completion shows us how a single event – say, a mutation – can change an army, or build \u003cspan class=\"ld-nowrap\"\u003ean eye.\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003e\u003cspan class=\"ld-dropcap\"\u003eF\u003c/span\u003erom microbe cells solving problems in metabolic space, to tissues solving problems in anatomical space, to groups of people navigating the world as we know it, life has \u003ca href=\"https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0006291X20320064\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003eratcheted\u003c/a\u003e towards intelligent designs by exploiting the ability of modules to get things done, in their own way. Homeostatic loops provide flexible responses, working until setpoints are achieved, even when things change. Modularity means that evolution can readily explore what the collective considers to be a ‘correct’ condition, and what actions it takes to get there. Hierarchies of modules mean that simple signals can trigger complex actions that don’t need to be rediscovered or micromanaged, yet can adapt when only a small piece of the puzzle triggers them to \u003cspan class=\"ld-nowrap\"\u003edo so.\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eWe have sketched a set of approaches to biology that rely heavily on concepts from cybernetics, computer science, and engineering. But there’s still a lot of work to do in reconciling these approaches. Despite recent advances in molecular genetics, our understanding of the mapping between the genome on the one hand, and the (changeable) anatomy and physiology of the body on the other, is still at a very early stage. Much like computer science, which moved from rewiring hardware in the 1940s to a focus on algorithms and software that could control the device’s behaviour, biological sciences now need to change tack.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp class=\"pullquote\"\u003eWe call on biologists to embrace the intentional stance: treating circuits and cells as problem-solving agents\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eThe impact of understanding nested intelligence across multiple scales cuts across numerous fields, from fundamental questions about our evolutionary origins to practical roadmaps for AI, regenerative medicine and biorobotics. Understanding the control systems implemented in living tissue could \u003ca href=\"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26571046/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003elead\u003c/a\u003e to major advances in biomedicine. If we truly grasp how to control the setpoints of bodies, we might be able to repair birth defects, induce regeneration of organs, and perhaps even defeat ageing (some cnidarians and \u003ca href=\"https://aeon.co/videos/the-blob-with-a-superpower-cut-a-flatworm-in-four-pieces-and-watch-it-regenerate-four-fold\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"\u003eplanarian\u003c/a\u003e flatworms are essentially immortal, demonstrating that complex organisms without a lifespan limit are possible, using the same types of cells of which we are made). Perhaps cancer can also be \u003ca href=\"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33961843/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003eaddressed\u003c/a\u003e as a disease of modularity: the mechanisms by which body cells cooperate can occasionally break down, leading to a reversion of cells to their unicellular past – a more selfish mode in which they treat the rest of the body as an environment within which they reproduce maximally.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eIn the field of engineering, designers have traditionally built robots from dumb but reliable parts. By contrast, biology exploits the unreliability of components, making the most of the competency of each level (molecular, cellular, tissue, organ, organism, and colony) to look after itself. This enables an incredible range of adaptive plasticity. If we break the neuronal code in biology, we could begin to program behaviour into synthetic nervous systems, and \u003ca href=\"https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fevo.2021.650726/full\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003ebuild\u003c/a\u003e self-repairing, flexible robots. Recent work shows that agential cells with their own local agendas can already be guided to create entirely new, autonomous biorobots. And beyond robots’ bodies, these ideas also open up new approaches to machine learning and AI: raising prospects for architectures based on ancient and diverse problem-solving ensembles beyond brains, such as those of bacteria and metazoa.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003cp\u003eThis emerging confluence of developmental biology, neuroscience, biophysics, computer science and cognitive science could have profound and potentially transformative applications. Top-down strategies exploiting – in effect, collaborating with – biology’s native intelligence could enable transformative progress in areas oppressed by a narrow focus on molecular and genetic detail. With that in mind, we call on biologists to embrace the intentional stance: treating circuits, cells and cellular processes as competent problem-solving agents with agendas, and the capacity to detect and store information – no longer a metaphor, but a serious \u003ca href=\"https://psyarxiv.com/t6e8p\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noreferrer noopener\"\u003ehypothesis\u003c/a\u003e made plausible by the emergence of intelligent behaviour in phylogenetic history. If we can come to recognise intelligence in its most unfamiliar guises, it might just revolutionise our understanding of the natural world and our very nature as cognitive beings.\u003c/p\u003e","standfirstShort":"How evolution ‘hacked’ its way to intelligence from the bottom up","standfirstLong":"Powerful tricks from computer science and cybernetics show how evolution ‘hacked’ its way to intelligence from the bottom up","creativeCommons":false,"license":{"name":"Aeon Permissive (syndication allowed)","short":"Aeon Permissive License","url":null,"republicationAllowed":true,"commercialUseAllowed":true},"authors":[{"id":"92984","name":"Michael Levin","authorBio":"\u003cp\u003eis the Vannevar Bush Chair and Distinguished Professor of Biology at Tufts University in Massachusetts, where he directs the Allen Discovery Center and the Tufts Center for Regenerative and Developmental Biology.\u003c/p\u003e","slug":"michael-levin"},{"id":"131662","name":"Rafael Yuste","authorBio":"\u003cp\u003eis professor of biological sciences and neuroscience, co-director of the Kavil Institute for Brain Science, director of the NeuroTechnology Center and chair of the NeuroRights Foundation at Columbia University.\u003c/p\u003e","slug":"rafael-yuste"}],"image":{"caption":"\u003cp\u003eHow do the tadpole’s facial organs know when to stop moving? \u003cem\u003ePhoto by MYN/Seth Patterson/NPL/SPL\u003c/em\u003e\u003c/p\u003e","alt":"Close-up of a small tadpole with a rounded head and a long, thin tail, shown against a white background.","url":"https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/170625cd-22ca-43cc-a596-5724f2e85f6b/essay-c0418809-tadpole_of_the_mexican_burrowing_toad.jpg","height":1252,"width":2000},"primaryTopic":{"title":"Cognition and intelligence","slug":"cognition-intelligence","url":"https://aeon.co/psychology/cognition-intelligence"},"topics":[{"slug":"biology","title":"Biology","url":"https://aeon.co/science/biology","section":{"slug":"science","title":"Science","url":"https://aeon.co/science"}},{"slug":"computing-artificial-intelligence","title":"Computing and artificial intelligence","url":"https://aeon.co/science/computing-artificial-intelligence","section":{"slug":"science","title":"Science","url":"https://aeon.co/science"}},{"slug":"cognition-intelligence","title":"Cognition and intelligence","url":"https://aeon.co/psychology/cognition-intelligence","section":{"slug":"psychology","title":"Psychology","url":"https://aeon.co/psychology"}}],"settings":{"alignX":"left","alignY":"top","backdropStrength":3,"featureImgCaptionAlign":"right"},"section":{"title":"Psychology","slug":"psychology","url":"https://aeon.co/psychology"},"editor":{"id":"18705","name":"Sally Davies","authorBio":"\u003cp\u003eis a senior editor at Aeon and a writer with interests in science, philosophy and feminism. She lives in London.\u003c/p\u003e","slug":"sally-davies"},"audio":null,"createdAt":"2022-02-16T06:07:22Z","publishedAt":"2022-03-08T11:00:00Z","scheduledAt":null,"readingTime":19,"wordCount":"3,700","updatedAt":"2024-08-01T07:44:34Z","lastUpdatedAt":null,"commentsEnabled":false,"commentsOpen":false,"commentAndRepliesCount":0,"newsletterHidden":false,"nonAudioPartners":[]},"relatedArticles":[{"id":"7644","title":"A grief with no name","slug":"identity-is-painfully-contingent-for-the-culturally-bereaved","type":"essay","audio":null,"standfirstShort":"Identity is painfully contingent for the culturally bereaved","standfirstLong":"As a child, I was torn from a culture that I never knew. It is a loss that defines me, even as I struggle to define the loss","duration":0,"creditsShort":null,"commentsEnabled":false,"settings":{"badgeColor":null,"cardPlayIconColor":null,"alignX":"center","alignY":"bottom","backdropStrength":3},"tags":[],"authors":[{"id":"221805","name":"Jelena Markovic"}],"image":{"url":"https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/3bb63de5-3eb1-403e-a010-a09c8594ed7d/v1-essay-.jpg","alt":"An adult and two children in a mall atrium, dressed in winter clothing.","height":1252,"width":2000},"primaryTopic":{"title":"Biography and memoir","slug":"biography-and-memoir"},"topics":[{"slug":"biography-and-memoir","title":"Biography and memoir"},{"slug":"demography-migration","title":"Demography and migration"},{"slug":"gender-and-identity","title":"Gender and identity"}],"section":{"title":"Culture","slug":"culture"},"createdAt":"2024-11-05T12:54:08Z"},{"id":"7638","title":"Could humans hibernate?","slug":"how-animals-learned-to-hibernate-and-why-we-cant-do-it-yet","type":"essay","audio":null,"standfirstShort":"How animals learned to hibernate and why we can’t do it (yet)","standfirstLong":"Hibernation allows many animals to time-travel from difficult times to plenty. Could humans learn how to do it too?","duration":0,"creditsShort":null,"commentsEnabled":true,"settings":{"badgeColor":null,"cardPlayIconColor":null,"alignX":"center","alignY":"top","backdropStrength":3},"tags":[],"authors":[{"id":"221273","name":"Vladyslav Vyazovskiy"}],"image":{"url":"https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/511b71b7-d68f-4fd5-abf2-106ab3668a2a/essay-hi-w7ry2p.jpg","alt":"A small animal curled up asleep on brown moss against a black background illuminated by a spotlight.","height":1252,"width":2000},"primaryTopic":{"title":"Biology","slug":"biology"},"topics":[{"slug":"biology","title":"Biology"},{"slug":"sleep-dreams","title":"Sleep and dreams"},{"slug":"evolution","title":"Evolution"}],"section":{"title":"Science","slug":"science"},"createdAt":"2024-10-31T15:09:47Z"},{"id":"7604","title":"The cochlear question","slug":"why-i-want-my-deaf-daughter-to-have-the-best-of-both-worlds","type":"essay","audio":null,"standfirstShort":"Why I want my deaf daughter to have the best of both worlds","standfirstLong":"As the hearing parent of a deaf baby, I’m confronted with an agonising decision: should I give her an implant to help her hear?","duration":0,"creditsShort":null,"commentsEnabled":false,"settings":{"badgeColor":null,"cardPlayIconColor":null,"alignX":"left","alignY":"top","backdropStrength":3},"tags":[],"authors":[{"id":"218258","name":"Abi Stephenson"}],"image":{"url":"https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/614bb00f-2edc-4bd3-8157-2ce696bd67d3/essay-abi_stephenson_aeon.jpg","alt":"Illustration of a child holding a shell to their ear with a bird singing on a branch amidst abstract greenery and flowers.","height":1252,"width":2000},"primaryTopic":{"title":"Bioethics","slug":"bioethics"},"topics":[{"slug":"bioethics","title":"Bioethics"},{"slug":"technology-the-self","title":"Technology and the self"},{"slug":"human-rights-and-justice","title":"Human rights and justice"}],"section":{"title":"Philosophy","slug":"philosophy"},"createdAt":"2024-10-07T11:16:29Z"},{"id":"7633","title":"The nature of natural laws","slug":"on-seeing-the-laws-of-nature-as-a-recipe-or-a-news-report","type":"essay","audio":null,"standfirstShort":"On seeing the laws of nature as a recipe or a news report","standfirstLong":"Physicists and philosophers today have formulated three opposing models that explain how laws work. Which is the best?","duration":0,"creditsShort":null,"commentsEnabled":true,"settings":{"badgeColor":null,"cardPlayIconColor":null,"alignX":"center","alignY":"top","backdropStrength":3},"tags":[],"authors":[{"id":"221145","name":"Mario Hubert"}],"image":{"url":"https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/293dfee5-a2e1-41f9-82d6-c8ce36645448/test-nyc27030.jpg","alt":"A solitary figure walking up misty stairs toward an unclear building, creating a mysterious atmosphere.","height":1252,"width":2000},"primaryTopic":{"title":"Philosophy of science","slug":"philosophy-of-science"},"topics":[{"slug":"philosophy-of-science","title":"Philosophy of science"},{"slug":"metaphysics","title":"Metaphysics"},{"slug":"physics","title":"Physics"}],"section":{"title":"Philosophy","slug":"philosophy"},"createdAt":"2024-10-30T04:47:13Z"},{"id":"7619","title":"We need raw awe","slug":"tech-vexed-how-digital-life-threatens-our-capacity-for-awe","type":"essay","audio":null,"standfirstShort":"Tech-vexed: how digital life threatens our capacity for awe","standfirstLong":"In this tech-vexed age, our life on screens prevents us from experiencing the mysteries and transformative wonder of life","duration":0,"creditsShort":null,"commentsEnabled":true,"settings":{"badgeColor":null,"cardPlayIconColor":null,"alignX":"center","alignY":"top","backdropStrength":3},"tags":[],"authors":[{"id":"75459","name":"Kirk Schneider"}],"image":{"url":"https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/a662a4aa-bc17-426a-82bd-89e58e2f7103/essay-heat_storm.jpg","alt":"A man floating in the sea beneath a dramatic, stormy sky with large, dark clouds.","height":1252,"width":2000},"primaryTopic":{"title":"Technology and the self","slug":"technology-the-self"},"topics":[{"slug":"technology-the-self","title":"Technology and the self"},{"slug":"meaning-the-good-life","title":"Meaning and the good life"},{"slug":"consciousness-altered-states","title":"Consciousness and altered states"}],"section":{"title":"Psychology","slug":"psychology"},"createdAt":"2024-10-22T01:24:43Z"},{"id":"7615","title":"Is beauty natural?","slug":"how-austen-and-darwin-converged-on-the-question-of-beauty","type":"essay","audio":null,"standfirstShort":"How Austen and Darwin converged on the question of beauty","standfirstLong":"Charles Darwin was as fascinated by extravagant ornament in nature as Jane Austen was in culture. Did their explanations agree?","duration":0,"creditsShort":null,"commentsEnabled":false,"settings":{"badgeColor":null,"cardPlayIconColor":null,"alignX":"left","alignY":"bottom","backdropStrength":1},"tags":[],"authors":[{"id":"188890","name":"Abigail Tulenko"}],"image":{"url":"https://images.aeonmedia.co/images/67725c32-b102-4f68-adaa-0c7f06687b4e/essay-final-austen_and_darwin_5.jpg","alt":"Painting of two anthropomorphic peacocks in 18th-century attire in front of a stately home surrounded by trees.","height":1252,"width":2000},"primaryTopic":{"title":"Beauty and aesthetics","slug":"beauty-aesthetics"},"topics":[{"slug":"beauty-aesthetics","title":"Beauty and aesthetics"},{"slug":"stories-literature","title":"Stories and literature"},{"slug":"evolution","title":"Evolution"}],"section":{"title":"Philosophy","slug":"philosophy"},"createdAt":"2024-10-18T10:17:52Z"}],"preview":false,"geolocation":null},"__N_SSG":true},"page":"/essays/[id]","query":{"id":"how-evolution-hacked-its-way-to-intelligence-from-the-bottom-up"},"buildId":"uitKSFrMC3o69YICzwJS8","isFallback":false,"isExperimentalCompile":false,"dynamicIds":[74890],"gsp":true,"scriptLoader":[]}</script></body></html>