CINXE.COM
Raine's sterile thunder
<!DOCTYPE html><!-- Powered by Glide Publishing Platform. https://www.gpp.io --> <html lang="en"> <head> <title>Raine's sterile thunder</title> <meta charset="UTF-8"> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0"> <meta name="description" content="TS Eliot's greatness as a poet is established beyond all doubt. So why do critics feel the need to defend him against all charges of misogyny and antisemitism?"> <meta name="author" content="Terry Eagleton"> <meta name="theme-color" media="(prefers-color-scheme: light)" content="white" /> <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="ie=edge"> <meta http-equiv="keywords" content=""> <meta http-equiv="author" content="Terry Eagleton"> <!-- meta tags --> <meta property="fb:app_id" content="567020822115044" /> <meta property="fb:pages" content="160709211871" /> <meta property="og:type" content="article" /> <meta property="og:url" content="https://dlv.prospect.gcpp.io/culture/57706/raines-sterile-thunder" /> <meta property="og:description" content="TS Eliot's greatness as a poet is established beyond all doubt. So why do critics feel the need to defend him against all charges of misogyny and anti..." /> <meta property="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image" /> <meta name="twitter:site" content="@" /> <meta name="twitter:creator" content="@" /> <meta name="twitter:description" content="TS Eliot's greatness as a poet is established beyond all doubt. So why do critics feel the need to defend him against all charges of misogyny and antisemitism?" /> <meta name="twitter:url" content="https://dlv.prospect.gcpp.io/culture/57706/raines-sterile-thunder" /> <meta property="og:title" content="Raine's sterile thunder" /> <meta name="twitter:title" content="Raine's sterile thunder" /> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://www.google-analytics.com" crossorigin> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://www.google-analytics.com"> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://www.googletagmanager.com" crossorigin> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://www.googletagmanager.com"> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://connect.facebook.net" crossorigin> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://connect.facebook.net"> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://www.facebook.com" crossorigin> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://www.facebook.com"> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://certify.alexametrics.com" crossorigin> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://certify.alexametrics.com"> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://twitter.com" crossorigin> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://twitter.com"> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://getpocket.com" crossorigin> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://getpocket.com"> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://www.reddit.com" crossorigin> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://www.reddit.com"> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://www.schema.org" crossorigin> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://www.schema.org"> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://hb.vntsm.com" crossorigin> <link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://hb.vntsm.com"> <link rel="canonical" href="https://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/culture/57706/raines-sterile-thunder"> <!-- prospect favicons --> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="180x180" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/prospect-180x180.28f7f41c97f38c37354794d5f60f9389.png"> <link rel="icon" sizes="192x192" type="image/png" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/prospect-192x192.003d52e5a92d9c0874c6e592f69b0947.png"> <link rel="icon" sizes="32x32" type="image/png" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/prospect-32x32.02860d246bab84114e485a056ffce946.png"> <!-- preload fonts --> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/SharpGroteskMedium19.613deb0d743237f2f3b3e80f93e2d065.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/SharpGroteskMediumItalic19.4fd821e52177287899ab0b3ff1044826.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/SharpGroteskSmBold18.c76b65659b941bd2b52a34474ede5a84.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/FrameDeck-Bold-Web.ff4954b8f86a55e49dd57181b4889d75.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/FrameDeck-Italic-Web.6e92e5eff247427952c6fed71b8ff1e0.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/FrameDeck-Roman-Web.92d5cae1c0d98998c2643cf8f6475dd0.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/FrameDeck-Semibold-Web.f5f7dfc20ec4cd7fed8d7083c532d76c.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/FrameHead-Bold-Web.4a03f209a48971e08cc4d1e727addd0c.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/FrameHead-Medium-Web.f562dc1bffc340b52be373ff1a446d4b.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/FrameHead-Roman-Web.69f60818d238fd2057dd35434a88e0b1.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/FrameHead-Semibold-Web.621f15b8eb26e23f13620634dace20ff.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/FrameText-Bold-Web.62fc65fb024b950ea5164ffebca947a5.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/FrameText-Roman-Web.2eaa9ca7930c82a4ab5291dd9bdbcfe1.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/FrameText-Roman-Web-Dropcap.a3633ffff5aad515bd26b730aeb33384.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <link rel="preload" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/FrameText-Semibold-Web.1b357a238c9b4b45cd826cdcfbcf4dd3.woff" as="font" type="font/woff" crossorigin="anonymous"> <script> tp = window.tp || []; tp.push(["setAid", "UCq0myh1pe"]); tp.push(["setUseTinypassAccounts", true]); tp.push(["setUsePianoIdUserProvider", true]); tp.push(["setEndpoint", "https://api-eu.piano.io/api/v3"]); function startPiano() { (function (src) { var a = document.createElement("script"); a.type = "text/javascript"; a.async = true; a.src = src; var b = document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0]; b.parentNode.insertBefore(a, b); })("//experience-eu.piano.io/xbuilder/experience/load?aid=UCq0myh1pe"); } //@ts-ignore tp = window["tp"] || []; var registrationTermId = "TMEOLBSKZTIA"; tp.push([ "init", function() { // Check if user is logged in //@ts-ignore if (tp.user.isUserValid()) { // Query API to get the list of conversions //@ts-ignore tp.api.callApi("/conversion/list", {}, function(listData) { if (listData.code != 0) { return; } var conversions = listData.conversions; // Go through user's conversions for (var i in conversions) { // Is current conversion happened on our registration term? if (conversions[i].term.term_id == registrationTermId) { return; } } // Create a conversion on registration term automatically //@ts-ignore tp.api.callApi( "/conversion/registration/create", { term_id: registrationTermId }, function(conversionData) { // Refresh access token cookie manually //@ts-ignore tp.user.refreshAccessToken(true, function(accessTokenList) { // All done, here you can close the offer or refresh the page //@ts-ignore tp.offer.close(); window.location.reload(); }); } ); }); } }, ]); window.startPiano = startPiano </script> <!-- no data layer template for this page --> <!-- google tag manager --> <script> (function (w, d, s, l, i) { w[l] = w[l] || []; w[l].push({ 'gtm.start': new Date().getTime(), event: 'gtm.js' }); var f = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0], j = d.createElement(s), dl = l != 'dataLayer' ? '&l=' + l : ''; j.async = true; j.src = 'https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=' + i + dl; f.parentNode.insertBefore(j, f); })(window, document, 'script', 'dataLayer', 'GTM-KDLSRF8'); </script> <!-- register all components that should be initialized for this page --> <script> componentsToLoad = ["MainLayout","PageFooter","ArticleTopics","RelatedArticles","HtmlSnippet","PageHeader","SocialShare","Article","BookReviewArticleHeader","ArticleAuthor","ArticleBodyImage","GdPicture","Fonts"] </script> <!-- injected component styles and scripts --> <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/9344.31d6cfe0d16ae931b73c.css"></link><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/MainLayout.7341b10223955d05a9a5.css"></link><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/PageFooter.40412dc350358890e820.css"></link><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/ArticleTopics.c33b19719b8c51ec6ae3.css"></link><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/RelatedArticles.c95a2bacd5977c50d6f6.css"></link><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/PageHeader.b492f7a36cb53859be91.css"></link><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/SocialShare.4c29373b1faa8de03378.css"></link><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/BookReviewArticleHeader.6200a4ac2462a55e7fa3.css"></link><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/ArticleAuthor.884f61209d6952cbd43a.css"></link><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/ArticleBodyImage.aeeaf50f99e3ea237de9.css"></link><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/Fonts.091b33cf1f48d1bd1285.css"></link> <script defer src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/runtime.317a8bbab5938c8734d4.js" ></script><script defer src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/main.cd0efb0694e683505fdb.js" ></script> <!-- add a bit of a fade in animation for every page --> <!-- Piano add block detector --> <script> document.cookie = "__adblocker=; expires=Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 GMT; path=/"; var setNptTechAdblockerCookie = function (adblocker) { var d = new Date(); d.setTime(d.getTime() + 60 * 5 * 1000); document.cookie = "__adblocker=" + (adblocker ? "true" : "false") + "; expires=" + d.toUTCString() + "; path=/"; }; var script = document.createElement("script"); script.setAttribute("async", true); script.setAttribute("src", "//www.npttech.com/advertising.js"); script.setAttribute("onerror", "setNptTechAdblockerCookie(true);"); document.getElementsByTagName("head")[0].appendChild(script); window.addEventListener("message", window['onMessage'], false); </script> </head> <body class="no-js no-gutters"> <!-- google tag manager, no script option --> <noscript> <iframe src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-KDLSRF8" height="0" width="0" style="display:none;visibility:hidden"></iframe> </noscript> <script>document.getElementsByTagName('body')[0].classList.replace('no-js', 'js')</script> <!-- page content --><div class="gc-col-12 gc-row"> <div class="gc-col-12 gc-row"> <!-- Twitter conversion tracking base code --> <script> !function(e,t,n,s,u,a){e.twq||(s=e.twq=function(){s.exe?s.exe.apply(s,arguments):s.queue.push(arguments); },s.version='1.1',s.queue=[],u=t.createElement(n),u.async=!0,u.src='https://static.ads-twitter.com/uwt.js', a=t.getElementsByTagName(n)[0],a.parentNode.insertBefore(u,a))}(window,document,'script'); twq('config','o2y6v'); </script> <!-- End Twitter conversion tracking base code --> <!-- Reddit Pixel --> <script> !function(w,d){if(!w.rdt){var p=w.rdt=function(){p.sendEvent?p.sendEvent.apply(p,arguments):p.callQueue.push(arguments)};p.callQueue=[];var t=d.createElement("script");t.src="https://www.redditstatic.com/ads/pixel.js",t.async=!0;var s=d.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)}}(window,document);rdt('init','a2_fampu1fn2dw7');rdt('track', 'PageVisit'); </script> <!-- DO NOT MODIFY UNLESS TO REPLACE A USER IDENTIFIER --> <!-- End Reddit Pixel --> <!-- Start of HubSpot Embed Code --> <script type="text/javascript" id="hs-script-loader" async defer src="//js-eu1.hs-scripts.com/144395798.js"></script> <!-- End of HubSpot Embed Code --> <!--facebook domain registration--> <meta name="facebook-domain-verification" content="bajojcx2chdqcq7uqz8y8agpldxj95" /> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> </div><script type="text/javascript"> var _iub = _iub || []; _iub.csConfiguration = {"askConsentAtCookiePolicyUpdate":true,"cookiePolicyInOtherWindow":true,"countryDetection":true,"enableFadp":true,"enableLgpd":true,"enableTcf":true,"enableUspr":true,"floatingPreferencesButtonColor":"#FFFFFF","floatingPreferencesButtonDisplay":"bottom-right","googleAdditionalConsentMode":true,"lang":"en-GB","lgpdAppliesGlobally":false,"perPurposeConsent":true,"preferenceCookie":{"expireAfter":180},"siteId":3571124,"tcfPurposes":{"2":"consent_only","7":"consent_only","8":"consent_only","9":"consent_only","10":"consent_only","11":"consent_only"},"tcfVendors":"755","cookiePolicyId":80865508,"i18n":{"en-GB":{"banner":{"title":"Prospect Publishing Ltd values your privacy"}}},"cookiePolicyUrl":"https://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/privacy-policy","privacyPolicyUrl":"https://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/privacy-policy", "banner":{ "acceptButtonColor":"#D74A31","acceptButtonDisplay":true,"backgroundColor":"#FFFFFF","closeButtonDisplay":false,"customizeButtonColor":"#A9A9A9","customizeButtonDisplay":true,"explicitWithdrawal":true,"fontSizeBody":"10px","listPurposes":true,"linksColor":"#000000","ownerName":"Prospect Publishing Ltd","position":"float-bottom-center","rejectButtonColor":"#D74A31","rejectButtonDisplay":true,"showPurposesToggles":true,"showTotalNumberOfProviders":true,"textColor":"#000000","acceptButtonCaption":"Accept all cookies","customizeButtonCaption":"Manage cookies" }}; </script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://cs.iubenda.com/autoblocking/3571124.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="//cdn.iubenda.com/cs/tcf/stub-v2.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="//cdn.iubenda.com/cs/tcf/safe-tcf-v2.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="//cdn.iubenda.com/cs/gpp/stub.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="//cdn.iubenda.com/cs/iubenda_cs.js" charset="UTF-8" async></script> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <!-- Start GPT Tag --> <script async src='https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/tag/js/gpt.js'></script> <!--<script async src="https://pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/js/adsbygoogle.js?client=ca-pub-9986779837491191" crossorigin="anonymous"></script>--> <script> window.googletag = window.googletag || {cmd: []}; googletag.cmd.push(function() { // 3 x banners for home and section pages with mapping var mapping1 = googletag.sizeMapping() .addSize([992, 0], [[970, 90], [ 728, 90], [ 468, 60], [ 300, 250], [ 1, 1]]) .addSize([728, 0], [[728, 90], [ 468, 60], [ 300, 250], [ 1, 1]]) .addSize([320, 0], [[300, 250], [ 1, 1]]) .build(); googletag.defineSlot('/21688349148/GPP_banner_1', [[300,250],[468,60],[728,90],[970,90],[992,0]], 'div-gpt-ad-7600949-1') .defineSizeMapping(mapping1) .addService(googletag.pubads()); googletag.defineSlot('/21688349148/GPP_banner_2', [[300,250],[468,60],[728,90],[970,90]], 'div-gpt-ad-7600949-2') .defineSizeMapping(mapping1) .addService(googletag.pubads()); googletag.defineSlot('/21688349148/GPP_banner_3', [[300,250],[468,60],[728,90],[970,90]], 'div-gpt-ad-7600949-3') .defineSizeMapping(mapping1) .addService(googletag.pubads()); // gen article 2025 header googletag.defineSlot('/21688349148/GPP_GenArt2025_header', [[728, 90], [970, 90], [970, 250]], 'div-gpt-ad-1739202760002-0').addService(googletag.pubads()); googletag.pubads().enableSingleRequest(); googletag.pubads().collapseEmptyDivs(); googletag.enableServices(); // right hand col googletag.defineSlot('/21688349148/GPP_righthandcol1', [[300, 600], [300, 250]], 'div-gpt-ad-1674469887004-0').addService(googletag.pubads()); googletag.pubads().enableSingleRequest(); googletag.pubads().collapseEmptyDivs(); googletag.pubads().setCentering(true); googletag.enableServices(); // sticky right col googletag.defineSlot('/21688349148/GPP_GenArt2025_stickysidebar', [[300, 600], [300, 250]], 'div-gpt-ad-1739203791582-0').addService(googletag.pubads()); googletag.pubads().enableSingleRequest(); googletag.pubads().collapseEmptyDivs(); googletag.enableServices(); // sticky mobile footer googletag.defineSlot('/21688349148/GPP_GenArt2025_mobile_sticky_footer', [320, 50], 'div-gpt-ad-1739204329232-0').addService(googletag.pubads()); googletag.pubads().enableSingleRequest(); googletag.pubads().collapseEmptyDivs(); googletag.enableServices(); }); </script> <!-- End GPT Tag --> </div> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> </div> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <nav id="props-header-main-menu" class="pros-global-navigation" data-configuration="{"bodyBackgroundColor":"#f0f0f0","alphaMenu":[{"id":296,"menuItemId":"ebi2zpFjr1","label":"Politics","description":"","menuId":38,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9338},"url":"/politics"},{"id":297,"menuItemId":"et7fJKjKW-","label":"World","description":"","menuId":38,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9302},"url":"/world"},{"id":298,"menuItemId":"eZF7xTHFcs","label":"Ideas","description":"","menuId":38,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":10215},"url":"/ideas"},{"id":299,"menuItemId":"eI_5L4R_2j","label":"Views","description":"","menuId":38,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":10216},"url":"/views"},{"id":300,"menuItemId":"eL4moPfKPq","label":"Culture","description":"","menuId":38,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9353},"url":"/culture"},{"id":593,"menuItemId":"eme0I5gLem","label":"Assisted dying","menuId":38,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","taxonomy":{"id":10735},"url":"/ideas/a-good-death"},{"id":301,"menuItemId":"eha_4-TkbN","label":"Latest issue","description":"","menuId":38,"url":"/issues/march-2025","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{}},{"id":302,"menuItemId":"ebf9AdhvZx","label":"Podcasts","description":"","menuId":38,"url":"/podcasts","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{}},{"id":303,"menuItemId":"eKpm5r0rmu","label":"Newsletters","description":"","menuId":38,"url":"/newsletters","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{}}],"betaMenu":[{"id":154,"menuItemId":"elufKeAlmL","label":"Hide this label","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","taxonomy":{},"children":[{"id":245,"menuItemId":"eSqG14M_Lx","parentMenuItemId":"elufKeAlmL","label":"Latest issue","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/issues/march-2025","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{"id":"74d58287d391-cover-march25","url":"https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/gm_medium_list_thumbnail/74d58287d391-cover-march25.jpg"},"taxonomy":{},"imageUrl":"https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/portrait_small_fit/74d58287d391-cover-march25.jpg"},{"id":293,"menuItemId":"eySAmohfEx","parentMenuItemId":"elufKeAlmL","label":"Newsletters","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/newsletters","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{}},{"id":294,"menuItemId":"eTjTP27cNQ","parentMenuItemId":"elufKeAlmL","label":"Podcasts","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/podcasts","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{}}]},{"id":153,"menuItemId":"evVbUXiYcV","label":"Sections","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","taxonomy":{},"children":[{"id":251,"menuItemId":"eq3PsAcMrU","parentMenuItemId":"evVbUXiYcV","label":"Politics","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/politics","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{},"children":[{"id":527,"menuItemId":"eWKSE87aMR","parentMenuItemId":"eq3PsAcMrU","label":"Election 2024","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":10627},"url":"/politics/elections/general-election-2024"},{"id":256,"menuItemId":"euuLh7qTKs","parentMenuItemId":"eq3PsAcMrU","label":"England","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9647},"url":"/politics/england"},{"id":257,"menuItemId":"e79X5JP4IU","parentMenuItemId":"eq3PsAcMrU","label":"Scotland","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9634},"url":"/politics/scotland"},{"id":258,"menuItemId":"eA2n5Hq1HP","parentMenuItemId":"eq3PsAcMrU","label":"Northern Ireland","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9385},"url":"/politics/northern-ireland"},{"id":259,"menuItemId":"eaI53oI1Lr","parentMenuItemId":"eq3PsAcMrU","label":"Wales","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":10159},"url":"/politics/wales"},{"id":260,"menuItemId":"ezZMGiHA2w","parentMenuItemId":"eq3PsAcMrU","label":"Constitution","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9461},"url":"/politics/constitution"},{"id":261,"menuItemId":"eJC_YVnZ-I","parentMenuItemId":"eq3PsAcMrU","label":"Brexit","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9395},"url":"/politics/brexit"},{"id":262,"menuItemId":"emgZYh60iz","parentMenuItemId":"eq3PsAcMrU","label":"Analysis","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9903},"url":"/politics/polling"},{"id":263,"menuItemId":"eWDsVpAdFD","parentMenuItemId":"eq3PsAcMrU","label":"Policy","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9463},"url":"/politics/policy"}]},{"id":252,"menuItemId":"eLNMVRBOyD","parentMenuItemId":"evVbUXiYcV","label":"World","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/world","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{},"children":[{"id":264,"menuItemId":"eORmQ_DBlP","parentMenuItemId":"eLNMVRBOyD","label":"Environment","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9367},"url":"/world/environment-news"},{"id":265,"menuItemId":"evphpzH1OW","parentMenuItemId":"eLNMVRBOyD","label":"United States","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9304},"url":"/world/united-states"},{"id":266,"menuItemId":"evN54kcq9U","parentMenuItemId":"eLNMVRBOyD","label":"China","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9423},"url":"/world/china"},{"id":267,"menuItemId":"erSgK-3POJ","parentMenuItemId":"eLNMVRBOyD","label":"Europe","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9414},"url":"/world/europe"},{"id":268,"menuItemId":"erhr-mrFKk","parentMenuItemId":"eLNMVRBOyD","label":"Middle East","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9323},"url":"/world/middle-east"},{"id":269,"menuItemId":"eWmztno375","parentMenuItemId":"eLNMVRBOyD","label":"The Americas","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":10221},"url":"/world/americas"},{"id":271,"menuItemId":"ePCRKRRYWm","parentMenuItemId":"eLNMVRBOyD","label":"Asia","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9397},"url":"/world/asia"},{"id":272,"menuItemId":"e2GNiuChk8","parentMenuItemId":"eLNMVRBOyD","label":"Africa","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9325},"url":"/world/africa"}]},{"id":253,"menuItemId":"ekxYAtGIix","parentMenuItemId":"evVbUXiYcV","label":"Ideas","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/ideas","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{},"children":[{"id":587,"menuItemId":"eEAbAjtaaa","parentMenuItemId":"ekxYAtGIix","label":"Top Thinker","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":10722},"url":"/ideas/worlds-top-thinker"},{"id":273,"menuItemId":"e_5yDFZ9V2","parentMenuItemId":"ekxYAtGIix","label":"Philosophy","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9311},"url":"/ideas/philosophy"},{"id":274,"menuItemId":"ei_0MA2OCR","parentMenuItemId":"ekxYAtGIix","label":"Law","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9468},"url":"/ideas/law"},{"id":275,"menuItemId":"eCBRjsVv_J","parentMenuItemId":"ekxYAtGIix","label":"Technology","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9331},"url":"/ideas/technology"},{"id":276,"menuItemId":"e9O9phxyFm","parentMenuItemId":"ekxYAtGIix","label":"Media","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9361},"url":"/ideas/media"},{"id":277,"menuItemId":"eg6TiXPm6n","parentMenuItemId":"ekxYAtGIix","label":"Religion","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9370},"url":"/ideas/religion"},{"id":278,"menuItemId":"eEcJ5rsk4t","parentMenuItemId":"ekxYAtGIix","label":"Economics","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9318},"url":"/ideas/economics"},{"id":279,"menuItemId":"enupF6Hktr","parentMenuItemId":"ekxYAtGIix","label":"Business","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9328},"url":"/ideas/business"},{"id":280,"menuItemId":"epfm1A86gJ","parentMenuItemId":"ekxYAtGIix","label":"Identity","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9326},"url":"/ideas/identity"}]},{"id":254,"menuItemId":"efALgVnKlF","parentMenuItemId":"evVbUXiYcV","label":"Views","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/views","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{},"children":[{"id":281,"menuItemId":"ecLwH7dbuV","parentMenuItemId":"efALgVnKlF","label":"Columnists","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9538},"url":"/views/columns"},{"id":282,"menuItemId":"eZeQuplykk","parentMenuItemId":"efALgVnKlF","label":"People","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":10217},"url":"/views/people"},{"id":283,"menuItemId":"e8KOmmwGw7","parentMenuItemId":"efALgVnKlF","label":"Lives","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9797},"url":"/views/lives"},{"id":284,"menuItemId":"eRXkpqoDbw","parentMenuItemId":"efALgVnKlF","label":"Letters","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":10218},"url":"/views/letters"},{"id":285,"menuItemId":"egFrjic6p7","parentMenuItemId":"efALgVnKlF","label":"Brief Encounter","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9457},"url":"/views/brief-encounter"}]},{"id":255,"menuItemId":"e4WMy0CJqA","parentMenuItemId":"evVbUXiYcV","label":"Culture","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/culture","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{},"children":[{"id":286,"menuItemId":"eHZFestl1S","parentMenuItemId":"e4WMy0CJqA","label":"Books","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9437},"url":"/culture/books"},{"id":287,"menuItemId":"eVFmtBJA8I","parentMenuItemId":"e4WMy0CJqA","label":"Film","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9456},"url":"/culture/film"},{"id":288,"menuItemId":"eC6JakKi4c","parentMenuItemId":"e4WMy0CJqA","label":"TV","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9815},"url":"/culture/tv"},{"id":289,"menuItemId":"eHEE3-E7Rt","parentMenuItemId":"e4WMy0CJqA","label":"Stage","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9579},"url":"/culture/performing-arts"},{"id":290,"menuItemId":"eDbUv_DIDZ","parentMenuItemId":"e4WMy0CJqA","label":"Music","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9443},"url":"/culture/music"},{"id":291,"menuItemId":"eibJQQGdDC","parentMenuItemId":"e4WMy0CJqA","label":"Art","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":9394},"url":"/culture/art"},{"id":292,"menuItemId":"eV8u5_BbzI","parentMenuItemId":"e4WMy0CJqA","label":"Gaming","description":"","menuId":29,"widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{"id":10220},"url":"/culture/gaming"}]}]},{"id":155,"menuItemId":"ed3RIovl_e","label":"More from Prospect","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{},"children":[{"id":324,"menuItemId":"e7sjgpGaa7","parentMenuItemId":"ed3RIovl_e","label":"App","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/try-out-our-new-and-improved-app","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{}},{"id":198,"menuItemId":"emIYUyKolt","parentMenuItemId":"ed3RIovl_e","label":"Policy Insight reports","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/special-reports","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{}},{"id":246,"menuItemId":"eqZh9_WwRk","parentMenuItemId":"ed3RIovl_e","label":"Events","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/events","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{}},{"id":295,"menuItemId":"epHDQgpXLm","parentMenuItemId":"ed3RIovl_e","label":"Past issues","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/issues","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{}},{"id":441,"menuItemId":"eG8Xn4bwfL","parentMenuItemId":"ed3RIovl_e","label":"Commercial opportunities","description":"","menuId":29,"url":"/work-with-us","widgets":[],"colour":"#ddd","image":{},"taxonomy":{}}]}],"logoImage":"https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/gm_grid_thumbnail/358ffc17208c-f4c3cddcdeda-prospect-masthead.png","userData":{"message":"User not signed in!","code":500,"error":true},"subscribeButtonUrl":"https://prospectmagazine.short.gy/Subsbutton","subscribeButtonLabel":"Subscribe","pianoStatus":"anonymous","userLogged":false,"userSubscribed":false}"><div class="pros-top-level-menu js-main-tracking"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__section--width pros-masthead "><div class="pros-page-masthead-wrapper prop-page-wrapper"><div class="pros-masthead-logo-wrapper"><div style="width:fit-content"><a aria-label="masthead logo link" href="/" class="pros-masthead-logo-link"><img class="pros-masthead-logo-image" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/gm_grid_thumbnail/358ffc17208c-f4c3cddcdeda-prospect-masthead.png" alt="masthead logo"/></a></div></div><div class="pros-masthead-cta-trigger"></div><div class="pros-masthead-cta-wrapper--regular header-logged-out"><div class="pros-masthead-cta-login">Log in</div><a href="https://prospectmagazine.short.gy/Subsbutton" class="pros-masthead-cta-subscribe">Subscribe</a></div></div><div class="pros-main-menu-wrapper prop-page-wrapper"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__list-hamburger-icon"><div id="menuToggle"><div><input id="menu-checkbox" type="checkbox" aria-label="hamburger menu"/><span></span><span></span><span></span></div><label for="menu-checkbox" class="checkbox-label">Menu</label></div></div><div class="pros-top-level-menu__list-search-bar-icon"><span class="search-icon"></span></div><div class="pros-main-menu-items-wrapper"><div class="pros-menu__list-item"><div class="pros-menu__list-item-content"><div class="pros-menu__list-parent"><a href="/politics" class="pros-top-level-menu__link ">Politics</a></div></div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-item"><div class="pros-menu__list-item-content"><div class="pros-menu__list-parent"><a href="/world" class="pros-top-level-menu__link ">World</a></div></div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-item"><div class="pros-menu__list-item-content"><div class="pros-menu__list-parent"><a href="/ideas" class="pros-top-level-menu__link ">Ideas</a></div></div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-item"><div class="pros-menu__list-item-content"><div class="pros-menu__list-parent"><a href="/views" class="pros-top-level-menu__link ">Views</a></div></div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-item"><div class="pros-menu__list-item-content"><div class="pros-menu__list-parent"><a href="/culture" class="pros-top-level-menu__link ">Culture</a></div></div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-item"><div class="pros-menu__list-item-content"><div class="pros-menu__list-parent"><a href="/ideas/a-good-death" class="pros-top-level-menu__link ">Assisted dying</a></div></div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-item"><div class="pros-menu__list-item-content"><div class="pros-menu__list-parent"><a href="/issues/march-2025" class="pros-top-level-menu__link ">Latest issue</a></div></div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-item"><div class="pros-menu__list-item-content"><div class="pros-menu__list-parent"><a href="/podcasts" class="pros-top-level-menu__link ">Podcasts</a></div></div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-item"><div class="pros-menu__list-item-content"><div class="pros-menu__list-parent"><a href="/newsletters" class="pros-top-level-menu__link ">Newsletters</a></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="pros-masthead-cta-wrapper header-logged-out"><div class="pros-masthead-cta-login">Log in</div><a href="https://prospectmagazine.short.gy/Subsbutton" class="pros-masthead-cta-subscribe">Subscribe</a></div><div class="pros-menu-navigation"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__list-search-bar-wrapper"><form action="/search" name="search-form" id="search-form"><input type="text" name="q" class="searchTerm" placeholder="Search..."/><button type="submit" value="submit" class="searchButton"><i class="fas fa-search"></i></button></form></div><div class="pros-menu__list-content-wrapper "><div class="pros-menu__list-wrapper prop-page-wrapper"><div class="pros-menu__list-item"><div class="pros-menu__list-item-content"><div class="pros-menu__list-parent has-child-image"><img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/portrait_small_fit/74d58287d391-cover-march25.jpg" class="pros-top-level-menu__link-img--column lazyload" alt="menu image"/><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link ">Hide this label</div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-children"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/portrait_small_fit/74d58287d391-cover-march25.jpg" class="pros-top-level-menu__link-img--row lazyload" alt="menu image"/><a aria-label="third level link" href="/issues/march-2025">Latest issue</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"></div></div><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><a aria-label="third level link" href="/newsletters">Newsletters</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"></div></div><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><a aria-label="third level link" href="/podcasts">Podcasts</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"></div></div></div></div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-item grandparent"><div class="pros-menu__list-item-content"><div class="pros-menu__list-parent"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link ">Sections</div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-children"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper parent"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><a aria-label="third level link" href="/politics">Politics</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"><a href="/politics/elections/general-election-2024" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Election 2024</span></a><a href="/politics/england" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->England</span></a><a href="/politics/scotland" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Scotland</span></a><a href="/politics/northern-ireland" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Northern Ireland</span></a><a href="/politics/wales" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Wales</span></a><a href="/politics/constitution" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Constitution</span></a><a href="/politics/brexit" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Brexit</span></a><a href="/politics/polling" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Analysis</span></a><a href="/politics/policy" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Policy</span></a></div></div><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper parent"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><a aria-label="third level link" href="/world">World</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"><a href="/world/environment-news" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Environment</span></a><a href="/world/united-states" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->United States</span></a><a href="/world/china" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->China</span></a><a href="/world/europe" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Europe</span></a><a href="/world/middle-east" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Middle East</span></a><a href="/world/americas" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->The Americas</span></a><a href="/world/asia" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Asia</span></a><a href="/world/africa" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Africa</span></a></div></div><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper parent"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><a aria-label="third level link" href="/ideas">Ideas</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"><a href="/ideas/worlds-top-thinker" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Top Thinker</span></a><a href="/ideas/philosophy" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Philosophy</span></a><a href="/ideas/law" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Law</span></a><a href="/ideas/technology" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Technology</span></a><a href="/ideas/media" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Media</span></a><a href="/ideas/religion" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Religion</span></a><a href="/ideas/economics" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Economics</span></a><a href="/ideas/business" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Business</span></a><a href="/ideas/identity" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Identity</span></a></div></div><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper parent"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><a aria-label="third level link" href="/views">Views</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"><a href="/views/columns" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Columnists</span></a><a href="/views/people" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->People</span></a><a href="/views/lives" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Lives</span></a><a href="/views/letters" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Letters</span></a><a href="/views/brief-encounter" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Brief Encounter</span></a></div></div><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper parent"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><a aria-label="third level link" href="/culture">Culture</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"><a href="/culture/books" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Books</span></a><a href="/culture/film" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Film</span></a><a href="/culture/tv" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->TV</span></a><a href="/culture/performing-arts" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Stage</span></a><a href="/culture/music" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Music</span></a><a href="/culture/art" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Art</span></a><a href="/culture/gaming" class="pros-third-level-child"><span> <!-- -->Gaming</span></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-item"><div class="pros-menu__list-item-content"><div class="pros-menu__list-parent"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link ">More from Prospect</div></div><div class="pros-menu__list-children"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><a aria-label="third level link" href="/try-out-our-new-and-improved-app">App</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"></div></div><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><a aria-label="third level link" href="/special-reports">Policy Insight reports</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"></div></div><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><a aria-label="third level link" href="/events">Events</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"></div></div><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><a aria-label="third level link" href="/issues">Past issues</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"></div></div><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link-wrapper"><div class="pros-top-level-menu__link "><a aria-label="third level link" href="/work-with-us">Commercial opportunities</a><div class="pros-third-level-arrow"></div></div><div class="pros-third-level-children-wrapper"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></nav> </div> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <style type="text/css"> .gpp-header-logo{ height: auto !important; width: auto !important; } </style> <script>history.scrollRestoration = "manual"</script> </div> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <style> .tp-backdrop.tp-active { opacity: .2; } </style> </div> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> </div> </div> <div class="gc-col-12 gc-row"></div> <div class="gc-col-12 gc-row"> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div id="piano_wrapper_collapsible"> <div id="piano_ribbon_collapsible_container"></div> </div> <style> #piano_wrapper_collapsible { position: fixed; bottom: 0; left: 0; width: 100%; z-index: 300000; box-shadow: 0 0 28px 0 rgba(0, 0, 20, 0.1); } </style> </div> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div id="piano_blocking_banner_wrapper"> <div id="piano_blocking_banner"></div> </div> <style> #piano_blocking_banner_wrapper { position: fixed; bottom: 0; left: 0; width: 100%; z-index: 300000; box-shadow: 0 0 28px 0 rgba(0, 0, 20, 0.1); } .html--active { overflow: hidden; } </style> </div> </div> <div class="gc-col-12 gc-row"> <div class="gc-col-12 gc-row prop-page-wrapper"> <div class="gc-col-12 gc-row prop-page-wrapper"> <div class="gc-col-3 gc-row prop-book-article-panel_side"> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div class="social-share"> <div class="social-share-cont"> <div class="social-cont social-block-visible-" data-base-url="" data-article-id="57706" data-article-headline="Raine's sterile thunder"> <div class="social-icon fb" title="Share on Facebook"></div> <div class="social-icon twitter" title="Share on Twitter"></div> <div class="social-icon linkedin" title="Share on LinkedIn"></div> <a aria-label="social share link" class="social-icon email" title="Share by Email"></a> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="gc-col-9 gc-row prop-book-article-panel_main"> <div class="gc-col-12 gc-row"> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div class="prop-book-review-header-wrapper"> <div class="prop-book-review-header-wrapper_breadcrumbs"> <div class="prop-book-review-header-wrapper_breadcrumbs-items"> <a href="/culture" aria-label="Culture tag link" class="pros-article-header__tag pros-background-color">Culture </a> </div> <a class="prop-book-review-header-wrapper_magazine" aria-label="magazine link" href="/issues/march-2007">From the March 2007 issue</a> </div> <div class="prop-mobile-social-share_header"><div class="social-share"> <div class="social-share-cont"> <div class="social-cont social-block-visible-" data-base-url="" data-article-id="57706" data-article-headline="Raine's sterile thunder"> <div class="social-icon fb" title="Share on Facebook"></div> <div class="social-icon twitter" title="Share on Twitter"></div> <div class="social-icon linkedin" title="Share on LinkedIn"></div> <a aria-label="social share link" class="social-icon email" title="Share by Email"></a> </div> </div> </div></div> <h1 class="prop-book-review-header-wrapper_headline">Raine's sterile thunder</h1> <div class="prop-book-review-header-wrapper_standfirst">TS Eliot's greatness as a poet is established beyond all doubt. So why do critics feel the need to defend him against all charges of misogyny and antisemitism?</div> <div class="prop-book-review-header-wrapper_details"> <div class="prop-book-review-header-wrapper_details-byline">By <a href="/author/1386/terry-eagleton" aria-label="Terry Eagleton author link" data-author-name="Terry Eagleton"> Terry Eagleton</a></div> <div class="prop-book-review-header-wrapper_details-date">March 22, 2007</div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="gc-col-12 gc-row pros-article-body-container"> <div class="gc-col-12 pros-article-body" style="width: 100.0%;"> <p class="pros-article-body__img-wrapper center "> <picture class="gd-picture"> <img class="gd-picture__img gpp-article-body__img lazyload gd-picture__img--responsive" data-src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/assets/placeholder-img.c06ac251611cf4ef1f2f0c8b8b038caf.svg" alt="article body image"> </picture> </p> <span>TS Eliot</span> by Craig Raine<br> (OUP, £12.99) <p id="e167199970">For a good many decades, thick fumes of incense have been wafting from the English literary establishment in the general direction of TS Eliot. The latest offering by the acolytes to the high priest is this study by Craig Raine, which admits that some of Eliot's drama isn't up to much but otherwise won't hear a cross word about the great man. "There is no evidence," Raine piously remarks, "that Eliot was either a fornicator or a homosexual," as though being homosexual was a trespass to be vigorously rebutted. Eliot was not, he rashly maintains, a misogynist either, even though the poetry is shot through from end to end with a fear and loathing of women. He even seeks to face down the charge that this ascetic ex-bank clerk was a bit of a dry old stick, although Eliot himself admitted as much.</p><div class='dfp-slot-0'></div><p id="e503082128">Why do critics feel a need to defend the authors they write on, like doting parents deaf to all criticism of their obnoxious children? Eliot's well-earned reputation is established beyond all doubt, and making him out to be as unflawed as the Archangel Gabriel does him no favours. It is true that the poet was a sourly elitist reactionary who fellow-travelled with some unsavoury political types in the 1930s, and as a Christian knew much of faith and hope but little of charity. Yet the politics of many distinguished modernist artists were just as squalid, and some—Pound and Junger, for example—were quite a lot worse. There is no need to pretend that all great writers have to be uxorious, liberal-minded, philosemitic heterosexuals. Why does Raine write as though discovering that Eliot was a paedophile would change our view of Four Quartets?</p><div class='dfp-slot-1'></div><p id="e146336511"> Neither is it just a question of "fine poetry, pity about the politics." The fact that apart from Joyce and Woolf, almost all of the major "English" modernists were radical reactionaries, askew to the orthodox liberal consensus of their age, is a condition of their achievement, not a regrettable corollary. Like a lot of poets and Oxford English dons, however, Raine doesn't really do ideas (something of a problem when tackling a poet as doctrinal as Eliot), and seems to know rather little about modernism. He dates it from 1922, which is at least two decades too late. Nor, being poor on "isms," does he grasp the complex relations between Eliot's modernism and his neoclassicism.</p><div class='dfp-slot-2'></div><p id="e216409114">Raine defends his protégé above all from the accusation of antisemitism, and in doing so produces at least one page of magisterial disingenuousness. When Eliot writes that "any large number of free-thinking Jews (is) undesirable," and that "a spirit of excessive tolerance (in this regard) is to be deprecated," Raine is able to demonstrate with his close-reading skills just what a moderate sentiment this actually is. For it is, you see, large numbers of such Jews which is undesirable, not the whole lot of them; and it is excessive tolerance, not any old tolerance, which is to be deprecated. So that's all right then.</p><div class='dfp-slot-3'></div><p id="e140020640">hankfully, however, the book steers clear of ideas for most of the time, apart from informing us that the "meaning" of Eliot's poetry lies in the theme of the buried life. It is an incapacity to live fully, Raine suggests, which is the poet's persistent concern. This is a staggeringly reductive claim. If some poor unfortunate left-wing critic were to suggest that Ted Hughes's writing is all about the destiny of Nature in the epoch of late capitalism, the literary establishment would come down on the hapless scribe like a ton of bricks. How dare one diminish the delicate complexity of Hughes's work in this crudely monolithic way? Yet Raine will get away with it, not least because we are talking about something as portentously metaphysical as life, not as trivial and prosaic as late capitalism. He believes that Eliot is a "hedgehog" rather than a "fox," in the sense of a writer who doggedly pursues one all-pervading theme. On the contrary, he is a devious Old Possum.</p><div class='dfp-slot-4'></div><p id="e713533410">Raine, then, is certain that he has the "meaning" of The Waste Land under his belt. He does not understand that Eliot's poetry is not a question of meaning in the first place. The meaning of a poem for Eliot was a fairly trifling matter. It was, he once remarked, like the piece of meat which the burglar throws to the guard dog to keep him occupied. In true symbolist fashion, Eliot was interested in what a poem did, not in what it said—in the resonance of the signifier, the echoes of its archetypes, the ghostly associations haunting its grains and textures, the stealthy, subliminal workings of its unconscious. Meaning was for the birds, or perhaps for the petit bourgeoisie. Eliot was a primitivist as well as a sophisticate, a writer who made guerrilla raids on the collective unconscious. For all his intellectualism, he was averse to rationality. Meaning in his poetry is like the mysterious figure who walks beside you in The Waste Land, vanishing when you look at it straight. When Raine enquires of a couple of lines in one of Eliot's poems whether we are supposed to be in a brothel, the only answer which would be true to Eliot's own aesthetic is that we are in a poem.</p><div class='dfp-slot-5'></div><p id="e138877889">The book, then, is really yet another reader's guide to Eliot, trawling its way doggedly through poem after poem, chasing up allusions and explicating the hard bits. Much of this is perfunctory, while some of it is brilliantly perceptive. The speaker in "Gerontion" is "a psychic wallflower, a noncombatant, an over-conscientious objector, a constitutional abstainer." The book is excellent on the influence on Eliot of Jules Laforgue, and has a poet's astute ear for the stray effects of sound and syntax. It is just that it is also given to Janet-and-John paraphrases like "God, the Word, exists; but for a variety of reasons people find it difficult to accept the Word, difficult to believe in God." It also has a problem distinguishing the smart from the smartass.</p><div class='dfp-slot-6'></div><p id="e395246525">Perhaps the best one can say of Raine's criticism, as of his poetry, is that it is scintillatingly shallow. He is a good man for the offbeat detail, but an indifferent hand at the moral vision or the overall portrait. The verbal intricacy and panache of his writing contrasts with its conceptual poverty. If there is very little stark, authentic emotion in Eliot's work, there is also a shortage of it in this commentary. The author is, however, notably generous in his comments on other critics. A review essay by Ann Pasternak Slater is, he tells us, "the best account of Eliot's marriage to be found anywhere." Fortunately, he remembers to add that Pasternak Slater is his wife.</p><div class='dfp-slot-7'></div> </div> <div class="gc-col-12 prop-book-review-article_author" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div class="pros-article-author-wrapper gd-frame"> <div class="pros-article-author"> <a class="pros-article-author-link" href="/author/1386/terry-eagleton"></a> <div class="pros-article-author__about">Terry Eagleton's "How To Read Literature" has just appeared from Yale University Press</div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div class="pros-article-topics__wrapper gd-frame"> <div class="pros-article-topics" style="color: #D74A31" > <a href="/culture" aria-label="Culture topic link" class="pros-article-topics__item">Culture</a> <a href="/culture/books/biography" aria-label="Biography topic link" class="pros-article-topics__item">Biography</a> <a href="/culture/books" aria-label="Books topic link" class="pros-article-topics__item">Books</a> <a href="/culture/books/poetry" aria-label="Poetry topic link" class="pros-article-topics__item">Poetry</a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div id="disqus_thread"></div> <script> /** * RECOMMENDED CONFIGURATION VARIABLES: EDIT AND UNCOMMENT THE SECTION BELOW TO INSERT DYNAMIC VALUES FROM YOUR PLATFORM OR CMS. * LEARN WHY DEFINING THESE VARIABLES IS IMPORTANT: https://disqus.com/admin/universalcode/#configuration-variables */ /* var disqus_config = function () { this.page.url = PAGE_URL; // Replace PAGE_URL with your page's canonical URL variable this.page.identifier = PAGE_IDENTIFIER; // Replace PAGE_IDENTIFIER with your page's unique identifier variable }; */ (function() { // DON'T EDIT BELOW THIS LINE var d = document, s = d.createElement('script'); s.src = 'https://prospect-magazine.disqus.com/embed.js'; s.setAttribute('data-timestamp', +new Date()); (d.head || d.body).appendChild(s); })(); </script> <noscript>Please enable JavaScript to view the <a href="https://disqus.com/?ref_noscript">comments powered by Disqus.</a></noscript> </div> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div id="newsletter_wrapper"> <div id="piano_newsletter_container"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="gc-col-12 gc-row prop-page-wrapper"> <div class="gc-col-4 gc-row"> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div class="pros-related-articles__wrapper gd-frame"> <div class="pros-related-articles-title__wrapper"> <span class="pros-related-articles-title">Popular in Culture</span> </div> <div class="pros-related-articles"> <a href="/culture/69346/the-extraordinary-significance-of-emilia-perez-netflix-karla-sofia-gascon-selena-gomez" aria-label="related article link" class="pros-related-articles__item"> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-image-wrapper"> <img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/square_small_fill/047223c31e84-emiliaperezimg.png" alt="related article image" class="pros-related-articles__item-image lazyload" /> </div> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-title"> The extraordinary significance of ‘Emilia Pérez’ </div> </a> <a href="/culture/69344/the-poetic-response-to-putins-war-disbelief-dislocation-julia-nemirovskaya-and-anna-krushelnitskaya" aria-label="related article link" class="pros-related-articles__item"> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-image-wrapper"> <img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/square_small_fill/445b13d2867d-chandlerheader.png" alt="related article image" class="pros-related-articles__item-image lazyload" /> </div> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-title"> The poetic response to Putin’s war </div> </a> <a href="/culture/69302/the-queer-eye-of-alice-neel-victoria-miro-hilton-als" aria-label="related article link" class="pros-related-articles__item"> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-image-wrapper"> <img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/square_small_fill/b534176e33a5-neel01.png" alt="related article image" class="pros-related-articles__item-image lazyload" /> </div> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-title"> The queer eye of Alice Neel </div> </a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="gc-col-4 gc-row"> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div class="pros-related-articles__wrapper gd-frame"> <div class="pros-related-articles-title__wrapper"> <span class="pros-related-articles-title">Related articles</span> </div> <div class="pros-related-articles"> <a href="/politics/69342/maurice-glasman-and-the-origins-of-blue-labour" aria-label="related article link" class="pros-related-articles__item"> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-image-wrapper"> <img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/square_small_fill/dd156439103c-glasmanonline.png" alt="related article image" class="pros-related-articles__item-image lazyload" /> </div> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-title"> Maurice Glasman and the origins of Blue Labour </div> </a> <a href="/culture/art/69272/one-painting-at-a-time-flying-a-kite-by-djanira-brazil-modernism-royal-academy" aria-label="related article link" class="pros-related-articles__item"> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-image-wrapper"> <img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/square_small_fill/97159b5e2fcf-vilelapainting.png" alt="related article image" class="pros-related-articles__item-image lazyload" /> </div> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-title"> One painting at a time: ‘Flying a Kite’ by Djanira </div> </a> <a href="/views/people/69233/jeff-koons-my-art-isnt-about-making-money" aria-label="related article link" class="pros-related-articles__item"> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-image-wrapper"> <img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/square_small_fill/f4b0d26f2db1-jeffkoons.jpg" alt="related article image" class="pros-related-articles__item-image lazyload" /> </div> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-title"> Jeff Koons: My art isn’t about making money </div> </a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="gc-col-4 gc-row"> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div class="pros-related-articles__wrapper gd-frame"> <div class="pros-related-articles-title__wrapper"> <span class="pros-related-articles-title">Listen to our podcast</span> </div> <div class="pros-related-articles"> <a href="/podcasts/media-confidential/69345/qa-whats-the-role-of-journalism-in-the-age-of-trump" aria-label="related article link" class="pros-related-articles__item"> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-image-wrapper"> <img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/square_small_fill/4582e9d41f3a-landingpagefeatured.jpg" alt="related article image" class="pros-related-articles__item-image lazyload" /> </div> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-title"> Q&A: What's the role of journalism in the age of Trump? </div> </a> <a href="/podcasts/media-confidential/69319/can-you-bomb-proof-the-bbc" aria-label="related article link" class="pros-related-articles__item"> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-image-wrapper"> <img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/square_small_fill/4582e9d41f3a-landingpagefeatured.jpg" alt="related article image" class="pros-related-articles__item-image lazyload" /> </div> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-title"> Can you ‘bomb-proof’ the BBC? </div> </a> <a href="/podcasts/prospect-podcast/69301/sudans-war-of-opportunity-with-yassmin-abdel-magied" aria-label="related article link" class="pros-related-articles__item"> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-image-wrapper"> <img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/square_small_fill/a57d2244c9de-yassminabdelmagied.png" alt="related article image" class="pros-related-articles__item-image lazyload" /> </div> <div class="pros-related-articles__item-title"> Sudan’s ‘war of opportunity’, with Yassmin Abdel-Magied </div> </a> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="gc-col-12 gc-row"> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> </div> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div class="pros-footer gd-frame"> <!-- footer top --> <div class="pros-footer-top prop-page-wrapper"> <div class="pros-footer-top-logo"> <a href="/" aria-label="footer logo"> <img class="lazyload" loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/gm_grid_thumbnail/912430b39857-prospectlogoregular.png" alt="footer-logo" /> </a> </div> <div class="pros-footer-top-menu-items"> <a class="pros-footer-top-menu-items__item" href="/about-us" aria-label="About us"> About us </a> <a class="pros-footer-top-menu-items__item" href="https://prospectmagazine.short.gy/Subsfooter" aria-label="Subscribe"> Subscribe </a> <a class="pros-footer-top-menu-items__item" href="/contact-us" aria-label="Contact us"> Contact us </a> <a class="pros-footer-top-menu-items__item" href="/submission-guidelines-how-to-write-for-the-prospect-website" aria-label="Submission guidelines"> Submission guidelines </a> <a class="pros-footer-top-menu-items__item" href="/jobs-and-vacancies" aria-label="Jobs and vacancies"> Jobs and vacancies </a> <a class="pros-footer-top-menu-items__item" href="https://institutions.exacteditions.com/prospect-magazine" aria-label="Corporate subscriptions"> Corporate subscriptions </a> </div> <div class="pros-footer-top-social-icons"> <a class="pros-footer-top-social-icons__link" aria-label="Facebook" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://www.facebook.com/prospectmagazineuk"> <img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/gm_list_thumbnail/1e0499963152-facebook-social-footer-bottom.png" alt="Facebook" /> </a> <a class="pros-footer-top-social-icons__link" aria-label="Twitter" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://twitter.com/prospect_uk"> <img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/gm_list_thumbnail/4a7539ee343c-twitter-social-footer-bottom.png" alt="Twitter" /> </a> <a class="pros-footer-top-social-icons__link" aria-label="Linkedin" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/prospect-magazine"> <img loading="lazy" src="https://media.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/images/gm_list_thumbnail/451441c9a06a-linkedin-social-footer-bottom.png" alt="Linkedin" /> </a> </div> </div> <!-- footer bottom --> <div class="pros-footer-bottom prop-page-wrapper"> <div class="pros-footer-bottom-bar"> <div class="pros-footer-bottom-bar-edition-notice"> © 2024 Prospect Publishing Limited </div> <div class="pros-footer-bottom-bar-menu-items"> <a class="pros-footer-bottom-bar-menu-items__item" href="/press-room" aria-label="Press Room"> Press Room </a> <a class="pros-footer-bottom-bar-menu-items__item" href="/acceptable-use-policy" aria-label="Acceptable Use"> Acceptable Use </a> <a class="pros-footer-bottom-bar-menu-items__item" href="/terms-of-use" aria-label="Terms of Use"> Terms of Use </a> <a class="pros-footer-bottom-bar-menu-items__item" href="/contributor-terms-conditions" aria-label="Contributor Terms & Conditions"> Contributor Terms & Conditions </a> <a class="pros-footer-bottom-bar-menu-items__item" href="/privacy-policy" aria-label="Privacy"> Privacy </a> <a class="pros-footer-bottom-bar-menu-items__item" href="/complaints" aria-label="Complaints"> Complaints </a> <a class="pros-footer-bottom-bar-menu-items__item" href="/work-with-us" aria-label="Advertise with us"> Advertise with us </a> <a class="pros-footer-bottom-bar-menu-items__item" href="/advertising" aria-label="Advertising Guidelines"> Advertising Guidelines </a> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> </div> <div class="gc-col-12" style="width: 100.0%;"> <div id="footer_spacer"> <div class="footer_spacer_block" style="margin-bottom:100px"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <!-- page content end --> <!-- devtools --> <div id="social-share-data" fb-app-id="567020822115044"></div> <!-- injected async component scripts --> <script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/9755.210fdca1fe353732a55d.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/1257.b5b178f4be62f94ab25b.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/MainLayout.0e655715ddd558cd7fb4.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/PageFooter.7f94ea822a8abb0f6a83.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/ArticleTopics.4157b28deca6597cba3d.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/RelatedArticles.b8d1e8ae517b28410672.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/1947.86b4c6d1e142b4ff4ed7.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/PageHeader.5a9efb7adf78c53703e0.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/SocialShare.d362862004176449f07d.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/BookReviewArticleHeader.4ec3c28ca6297e316b56.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/ArticleAuthor.2bc07b4ea5d229d60c27.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/ArticleBodyImage.62fe77a68c35f088f73f.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/Fonts.e3b97845f47d81d5c323.js" ></script><script src="https://assets.prospectmagazine.co.uk/prod/Piano.8279a5e4dd425acf418e.js" ></script> </body> </html>