CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="120"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "publications.waset.org",cType: 'non-interactive',cRay: '9133b9fafbe99fd4',cH: '9oldokdq7sWkiCwJW7l2Yc7DZVB5nXkXheFvFydvwec-1739773802-1.2.1.1-mPVPkyoDQgiSe6Vm0O6_bGPJwk00l8YUNLR.Sy8WhMBJ9S4Do0CzVYoLVrIiLeYZ',cUPMDTk: "\/abstracts\/search?q=Judge%20Paul%20Smith&__cf_chl_tk=pkP5aCviWBR6HDgXdfGuQeULlFNVtRwpIKPDO99wyt0-1739773802-1.0.1.1-EHPnLSz8K4k1AL8Vo6VMBzylIj1aK.AWLKx0wdSAd80",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1739773802',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '120000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/abstracts\/search?q=Judge%20Paul%20Smith&__cf_chl_f_tk=pkP5aCviWBR6HDgXdfGuQeULlFNVtRwpIKPDO99wyt0-1739773802-1.0.1.1-EHPnLSz8K4k1AL8Vo6VMBzylIj1aK.AWLKx0wdSAd80",md: "Taf5olDslEEw2RnWIiEqrrh9jX_TE90n4XTYNwTtU1A-1739773802-1.2.1.1-V9rXmk1yOExWwPjGXZpm8NugWj2eIszuD8muQV86QQSaN24xBMI9w3fAlJfWU2InOkOWgfughIVPurEvVK14QMdRi17wqI20A0g_A1GFeNe9BCcQxkWYNFOqgWSmzaQMRL1TH2kEpP1ar2_HDezO6duLkDloP9p30HCjUTm7Y9l1MoewzLJxYH5Du257MZtytGkJ9_.XJ_JqOJcDytqCyosZavzE6vnZ3hAMB3NA04Xh6qh0EoVlt2opnTUgVg4eu944wjGzOvwc6_dK5VMno4qIkLWC.ApwnFY2b4Do3E1qcQl5PwbYmPU6M4Ejc4wVObHog.hs02.X2uwRhEWFIr6d5c5frpZVQTGCC7uhKAR9UQBPzQbFHrUmVhKmAAs4sy3zfOwAffkL.elXfNIh7FDMFlNWErUVsFTl7CQ2TSOROkx5w3BE3Wc6mKQZlIzcE5afhLwHzJbARUCYRvtYIi5Ct6OEEibNWdladu_MABmpITEksqrN4RYmpk8J2LxayAra2175ZIsi1ymRs4_UwAzCPTdBeYHtuE_DOM0L8gfDiI72fOl8cn6EspLUxsEzzil2BNBGnv7hlP6nxNV3S8dM8GzSD55hZVxsuCe1c9.r0_e5m7rgM8DswlAqinu3Gcgbi0Z_HsS5I9IBiBZatnHOjE2CZu8oOnX64fkqM1hsfrMy4jCR9.HI6BuBLDbwV1W7hasKhE_lDRou2gZpx.Tes3YdJ.pq4ND3Fbi7YpfXzVywaoV5cweTZSWn5MaoxQBbavWPjAYpPT2.rXO7i88WLkMy2m4gQjPV3zEyRYJHtEgelZGagythLyXHcyeE168mbMrZv0PGVGRaAPgCxN1rIEgTCNQJ4qqnjr1_7AOFvTJsV8Y1pW6iuLerqqcKPhSaCvWrf1KH0KsxHnDpkIPhas8Qw3kqDSBXyqRx3ftL8nvZjJDWpKNkEWkj.rSI2_msllrQI0O7mmOJY9zVU3xd49tfKRkDvJNZv.bi2s6FazrqyPHi9m2pjr58KU3_FaF78_pWkOpqAxkO8Oy8QkWwDF0McWgbEPW4yC5OaebD221KHo5dqyr.kLlHgBgPg0XQ3duZ2Hx51TsZHECQpZxx8y6hurzWmCYP6z2tvNS6LJ1BOddk4OClrpnZkJKs3hTm9CTxbKovtz.NK9BlUmnutb.xh6pvC8NMYJokSuoX9b9FAcYwEGHJKXdsn5py6Tw2Tw3npgXM8YJcd62vtFe5hr0NfgPjSJxQYy.cP7YivYqfUpR5zVqyVj2HzBAaP7NMUssRAdHmccvL7YthKieAidh9pT95jxZDJJLL3bNZkFbMCqzL2WtqdSe.f_EUnJt.SiqY8zRBPDItKn4j0DBERnJpyX91failKI2D8xSzPyIP63wWAj6w2quh_rHjw4qHqvov0xFYe5hu.gFj_OFDToU9CR4_tZrn_4xxP7g3Mpf3mA2u.QDJnIRN_5ucHuZF.s6hWm8hl.AqmFFjeQernMESRB4jChRGQYACiyXNMUErGP5IB5XVgsov9DKyWbnK9Slc8o2vEkPnTkBq7dEQEJcSce1TrVSAjJc7emGfTgU8lemgBTDAfQxkikY7mvEWiYWWddSwY1xVIQNDBsuuzlxD2og0vNvOLdUx6l8rvkOwThIu3xWbQ0poh7IF3gswwwCIXkm.6WoI8PznbAy.VwAsTO.4nukoguVl_t2nU2EtvOP2z_2dhsqLPr6_68_Az4.frzQZGlQsc.m_blkHM56EWcvo9T0wAkO9ldvJlzxDw7bgP476t0ZSi4mL3xlR7VRPL1JNduI84gxSTRUy2vWIOOQYdyp301Liv_gY7nzEsPj91ao1Q_XBiqS44au6oDYgUMZgSEl1koWOc5Jv5p6oFRw1bcZEftNOgj.TlD_s57zxIWFi3WeESWpWody4wWr6D.qtXlH2wNXcsz03aMzekTpxDqxms.mFAW8",mdrd: "voKGmW2ue7W_C0tAPr5sFanF.A3PNDVAIBJZdCPb9Bc-1739773802-1.2.1.1-cxzYu3xeWDt2ix.wnUSDAjlHaZevn.F9e2YrORPgDoGrx6poTrgq93PG.v3R..D27wxsoDCzjl.NVMtXEY2JMq2RWNAXmRKPUhDgJ9rRIOwl4XF9yo7n6LnjcCwHmauB6N7YzgOvtf_a167XzrOBtA7TLtwEL8UDOlbrtdzv_k3MMjbM6CI_fc9k7nLBx2gq8aVYtjTVc1pesqhTS9PDMcnrb8cDUsAY2dpmh2lXrg61duWMv6iucEVWMTnKTCEnFUWncGchi8Ire35GtITgkQGzoN7MEQ78oKjEiotIcVOxF4tXfrpUSzuDOoPrv9hUkp5FezaW.UAkNsF9fMUfioeVvdBr7eoKXri527w_lC2Ht9V835DaDD8SmSdwaNW6GtfjGdgZRdQDh8g6nd25KbqNmtZvqn.yFYvNVnBKIXYivQpfrqCuDIVnX_FiLaqnWV9H6biRi_Xhq1UbLhVsaQWoOGzAXoPGAhYTV7by80NYq_oDlCJfjqgCc5Q7PCo4om5Jfng44sVTZ1LoZFmwgPfEcxu1fyadLXfb.jvaFeS4RYzCY.7Ls_1fIX2DAFs4YLtxzVUtow..eFq1CTXVWcT9Goo8Rp19sN91j63yHzRyFIKoRPAFOJ6qoxax1NE4E3NLBMoogyUe8BhZSXBMwm3RecqyeQgD18BatH4ru1_6HqLv21rAq7owaM0D9EqTRJw7t.Pietf6Pw7kLtpuHcDBOhZII_on3qNXJlYlzLPiPqMHOJN63dJYM8KOUe8qGtXPcGdyxWfmiL7PV_e3dJ5WmeNzGJzt1FY4Vpa8uRYtbIBcQ7slO99L8KTB3fUTz73PYIt4ugm9jqWfWjSiWzJvPARXpIM4iN15WqQGf_QwzIVqfXqFc.lp.mAMElIjgD4oKC9xXJObBwhh5wOljnAwvlXaqxKbBm6frA8JID0ShLbudJSopxRCQKliuxc6Af3xbQ4jx.AMLvcR1pHuCWj8YuK2_ecVCjDr_lGJc0n3WltlpzM6fjb8_GqMp9JLybOmOMsxbC8Kq31XCN02kfQH.mDtnOZPT7vtpJ9u0XzSxLaUuGnr.Kkgb5_SESyKP1YDE9Izy5Y9yOGYg7d5wfbBhWEtzS7dK4fjByQBdBN9JWjMLhYTxAc_5mmVUZqCEpWrFrObquZKFYXxMek5oOFs6ATCFddZFGFTy._P4EjHppJoGlss1X_rRul0wQIKSJC1VBCQgpMxwViZ4vJL_8_GYHFn.njBhkHkdkF4eN_TbSCGJUA7nzX35E6JvOEMw7KS5kSBo60g_Z5egwV0JDwUUr5Q0hbV1YtBo1gP0yJK8dREIs5eJTxExY1Sri32hyUotW4YsboiPUqz2lGE5U4iGt3aGyZ63sZ7Kk_Q_I4agTfhl531csTqT2uRBrSyHWJ2_xNYdpyCKUpxZUhODMTOqYvbyP6CrDGYVbQOi59HS6uQpispghZxep1mBfuE8flPUhL7MrqxtSyV2zNw4szBMoJAgzhmT93qwml794ilHCyGRqrol65xHFghUg5GwvA_9OHU85D8AnxRxaOjy2b730rX7g4rnapsBtPK5GTylRM3EiA9WpLdMwY2648pgkMBU.EBCvII91DZEDp0xwYY.kDFVX.MxtP1bkYyVtvaoCot9How1YOQlFPZaZr2u3NvS02IwLdFhHd8nhN4B7DMybKANQQzfNBR_RXQJafDHl8GwskXbP5..5thI24FkXG_vzTrgGWyIlNCR6WkhRlmbYCS9bKUcUCPVHdyMcudks21IUxLr2Z7fFIjVEwwXEgCZVWBN9kPT2Jpt0nQ4RMjHqVQZGBVDjRjAhKBQoBpmlbMMoi08qxPkRDyHrDZYz6n87GPTXrOMjUz9rFVOGASnbuB7iDrgxTjERsaqsfdAHnQloo4M.paK4x3xzGzHPp.i4ZPoWVY9qW1JqNrHMz0CrfDAduQUN6L_rUaD04xmiN2EZmswtwOj1ul.WroP68qMUp1rL_sDADsNCC75g"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=9133b9fafbe99fd4';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/abstracts\/search?q=Judge%20Paul%20Smith&__cf_chl_rt_tk=pkP5aCviWBR6HDgXdfGuQeULlFNVtRwpIKPDO99wyt0-1739773802-1.0.1.1-EHPnLSz8K4k1AL8Vo6VMBzylIj1aK.AWLKx0wdSAd80" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>