CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.thebritishacademy.ac.uk",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e944c28cd76603e',cH: 'oenTcx95mrZeAfwKkKeoFHigubEEeg7HXZny.gx_mZo-1732733359-1.2.1.1-fCED2Q1mFVxt8IN5Xzp1U6TINEopcHAZPLkIPM4Y9RVmZQUTLshwtlqUOW1FHNIZ',cUPMDTk: "\/pubs\/proc\/volumes\/pba95.html?__cf_chl_tk=VHXV4QsBe8UW0KvhxO4ETwhptd497xujOZglZATybwU-1732733359-1.0.1.1-N2I6ZNYIwf6JLbEE9RGjPGENR0vi5TDjTNT2A1vUktk",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1732733359',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/pubs\/proc\/volumes\/pba95.html?__cf_chl_f_tk=VHXV4QsBe8UW0KvhxO4ETwhptd497xujOZglZATybwU-1732733359-1.0.1.1-N2I6ZNYIwf6JLbEE9RGjPGENR0vi5TDjTNT2A1vUktk",md: "nQZfeEq8kYKrqp5lV0DT2AdX_1pnN9Eu2QgH9DnfacY-1732733359-1.2.1.1-s_N648VD0tE8csFRHEMnUTJ2P1PEcgpoz4UjXPYUcmi4nzDkv7PtBH4.A13PUsEXSeFNxh0mEiCcJBq0B5iCmmzm33TZ3TCnDxcFV3z8hXKkvZizrgFWhcKBgUzmtoPw4xOz24suYRArJKYmAZwOyH3HWT.wKFS9TPUBxaKK3nFMpYY3ZBNUx8GNIBiSG0MC5b9JguCPiLQEntiVr9tjNhwjLesnMzqhZDgOGnOga3nBXBXLXCf1N2VSd.GXc51XgHKkaglLrcm8tOphDIkNmeFdfb25hRambvcA5KsBrvrDbCIBbFlXiKRpItn4IQuJPfsGfEVXtVkdxr3MCrwkRp0P0kg1b.fPP3P8y8gA5cMQnUPchwA1wHHUmkeP_LxV9WXz46R_GNq9oXg4fijnDT7NjoEVFI163Pw70A2jW5nyzC6n0MJLnZDfgCPQ.ofIVkshSHKENW7bt2mjIlhvFpOtVHArsAYquggQcXPyu3jH6lfBhdExWw6G06dvMubb34UFPcf9ZgiEXtEYRe8yAcEalFXA20qaZcCyCaLp8.03fafcL4G_aoKWhzCWij46b3UdRp_vQIH00_uk2XfKmpm8hgiwt6ucHH3q5IV3d6f8Qovx8SafZIbs5_P6MORjreAExUmLkhzUO6O0tnUZJDDEnYzNSUM5i_14SFXXwRZMhoIbCn9qfXvz637rNZ8ILGhIuq6f6P1ulc.bMN7OV2mgQitdrggGdbLNqydb3d5XVOYaHOy_886UDeCTZ0BUr1g0qtP8da.5KDL8RlzUCJlUFDsg4WDaqnfCJmAQmhfoZCsTZbTg79OYsl6jQGgMdsI0C9HlEGWBrGA07K4NRXGMHWr5MMwnjNNBSSspYEeyccDsigm0rJ_WLm00b2l.ucl.qCCFZXsDFf5R5GGmkMuwHAafpOzuuobWCTiGR4Ga0vq7DGaw4eeVpCXYV_5RUXsZrPP08GYItt8.7txMWOHiSz4kmzhswS0bVr.Sy5pAvBrE3B.yxW9caVRTrIFr2_gDKlGi1fp43JMfoemsiMSpsD6PpQnve.rZKoIRTOJQDcdf0yqsmoDkeVhkSguCVpBP4HcFLjlU75U9D5y5c_3fV2blzvkMelBLWE_HbgntD8n2zdP22MzAfkBdAVSYlm37JL_TwF5CGlhAUCuTppZdSt5t9uGkKNSgHsenwncuJeWB_awS.U6CHlWfOLJ77eV9MJ7.rebLKywEThxign4dmaEb4ovzAsI.gr2S3.bff5YN1k779l6GbPznBcmHxxiPzxQVlf846kxlmNFUDSQotpMWvllBky1bi54IVZQsxvun25QmCoy3SzopUtneelBabWWbB8.AtcsqnAG_Fa8OGbhyml4MDFfKSWASJsXTjP0TpfEntcjr6DdU5YQcKEtya1BMJwX9uQre.V_2eRWb455lpYfaZqVCZiBFIxsCM4q9DlzddOIMHEzCyxgES3Z7x3aWokPfGBmrS78AcxgwFFtAcTywG0Od68qzd9zEOPy_DgWMQxc11j6yV_UAjhgq6RQxZJnw0CGhdDnOIe8bMKGadabfox5zJqwpwzVtnXvMlUs5uijkK4U5REDp46VY7jSrLdcVEvS4hCWh2WkfXO2CPHNGJYh.DtNb9AAEtz534Pvm3sheouGphmEhezhiZ0uw8hTRDDmvMHvFJfYKg7XlZn8WfPIfk4Yp.Hx3UDutjNDqaReQvkdctbOKCwKRPEa7HXMleZeW5qrIThRaLJFQpBT.vSuWgxGKQPKBHh2NFmgBM4h_f7O8Tju7_yeMAa96DWQzvE.zJf6TgnyStTi5vMKFVymo5K3lDMZ2kvs_55Yk2bfEA06hml2wRddLpSddY90ZTQan2OixGnUEW1LWAi9PJWxOSZwApCftkekBxWuhlCZNNyr7AO79PDXf_c4MpCSdYfQ16b1bp.F2FrNEqcsptQeWy3pWRyzh_8p6RG5S0zYfMGBAEEWCQL9lPYVdu7hMuTn3mSvJTGeyw91JVz.x7b5PtjMM2KsXpQRJJG2PWDNWvRLES7PeFUFNRkBB0Vbp2l2cFntdINofRTrM_daQs9dQXFTPVria7uTX.xQJyylL3KKSp0cwZvnXGE4vw0feYlRS_HrcO9qw4Von5hwNniodDOcuCzNfVG9z67KnCR39n6SexrcBJEqHox8rhs_ISthbhRapShi3MBj7bqVUm0zGHD3.TsRbkB4dbyNOwbfbLZaTXv_quGBFWl9wY2M824RWSmldZ38ww69CLjIFOYhSlb6.skYVdAoHPD6HpJ2ZgJNcSx.rRsmD6L_DZ9nrxht7OW6N8nBRy6_x7Hyg9iv6gTCItWgGjkS_1m88MM1xFCJAlxKstpUWbzjxsU.eh3OZePylZbfAmQ_4GMWQ6wD1PwKqNjeNFpvNxfTMtStlo9NggsuhdpPTS4jQ1noPkdYmgAb1lrikcx4SHT0jl5mcog11XzBceWhJQrd.VBKGYk9tvo12_BR0zncz0WV5BDxkUw0tLzHFg8SCrQruvSyauPW70bKsXq7QDpyqtYwf00m6ocl0K4teyDyv1tYcaHRRlsuyjOpl0NmJj2wjGIZFDFJtlmM3hCCSTMfIVPVn1ihlYzFvRD_BpzFzIpQTht0oR5YMKqZkzl1BIPVYimBjp276PtgQ8GvfCrDRGk3hoaz4BdCglbbNurhOUW614slNCl7OHaSqlrBN7XO_uDnLOm3ylc34NZoXkQ0YJEiznXcXggpfYo86TeT4LwUVplyaId0cFWYy4TXo5A3AIPH6SlxpU68qE85if_8IpX_9Fwc0e5SpHn7y2iEQaj9..kk2eCHReHsgTN9qdxAhEG7dULX6nto4V16GRCY9Ngu3yyAcQVEyaSOf6jolq0hq0dQxsvIcKkJ6TtqEWCf4XKYr2Z_7fruvTHMWrmOtfc9FDhS0PoYs9EtaWK112VUDUEMbbq5z7w",mdrd: "7We3n3Igp0jB6isVmUS2GphmgELqUezBDfuRiW1H1Lc-1732733359-1.2.1.1-MH4LXKNLYehR7kMdq9UcBHyRj4oc0JGGX59AxIa_KRD0Ciy4mJfBNz6w1XCuYmAHHZiwKoqT3E0IZGN6kCcFoKnd3xsdBnUJR13Zs7eU3ECJhosHDp3UaADyvYSOJYazUj3qY76XTgXLfY1YbUYGXTdh3d88aybBXoOinvLefGpwHQt7HSoL2ubWmo2MZlqgDJ6AR.4uvBf9G.7EJdS0YbU9YD9T9GrnrOMa_mJxlFRgADsxngPmtz_4RdVd3sTZIPUJuKeoRiYo4HqpOcYlI_esBre4XwAWyxgnucciyUeBa0cjGWubzq0HCFJBLAA9vP1Rfq_rVQaTXv3JvockZ2LbX1kZ.3XqvX043B8eKw3.XfOKyms2yrXuxCGzbtYLLYPK7w_9qUNJct4btEzCGzv3TEq3ZNhlVdB4FW8EC6Iz6dUgxgqqtP9KDZtl_Xv3suI_.xcuS0sbWV7YleINgvaAkNdLd_mUdX_Cfvlg_V6qwNnAwcCdJzOSocsNFUN02wNgMYwY.HWzlgxmwPWpllkt0KT9US.MXTnqkrlQqFKBYQo.cUwzB1ukCrV534du_09xXc.1K.DVKTNPR_YlusVYz_FqTLOfb61gMf7MBxeW99sXOvjhUVgoqDxUNXBwZZ6lDJ6J0IuYeeoe4.Q14kh8nWZ.3um9oXFV4uk_2WmZ7hNoNY7zrQ2DO6e4LO0bAb36giEebxy1_NPC7WyAt1ImPeYpcN6wepyvZlNUkepiY279q43CTrAHCwrzDd5FQ90GWqGCd2OpFBto0uBvAJrG60Lrf__PGMqveLOJzn7Psxf4TBjmDW9_XwGarrmcVoDmNOw7cXxv.5FoCoV7mfxCRJNz6prSOO2V_0AFfwDZ73O8NAGH4l9ebTeHffeI1UaYzhQAAUfnuZs7ac6mVUufDjcssSSJmCJqQr.HxR9a_1aY6QCBT.uqqfsDx.sCADHzW3V7Fsgyq70BoZ_vomdthqEDHz7ZZfwjxklIc6EZ81llknF4gFrh8D52bDAKBXbkWBd208RhsiHTB1uNUrnJOPhVNBoWohO7s6Sv0hYuTnN9kDiWv6Qp4H.O7VoDgHgZIA.w_lNzj.1L8dUrUB1zbwVLAUi6oWMmA.Tt9upPMa5YoEMDuz3DLQqzS9Tu3JU5hwrwN_aP3qgCSNi39qlAfwj49lGDCm.oPg7_x3le7GHPYFv2gzXIiuqF9fbVtNe2zuMBD6zPKxbmiaPilV3ADAyH83_QSxQdmo7kii1WtrYrDy.7Fpqp2Tln_Q3x8fRDcyblXYXT0SHpZnPObNyRTGcq.4OLDXReUnBfWOd8CwlOCpJHaqqGMvuj_nM2kg0h7yli3UWjjCJsYxdXCt7wdGull6.CtEf7FFPk3kppauBhPU0XhPLlFwMwzTVh4m6VHzX2x3Z.DZKzHhL4DquxTTd9x1LVNuPNz_bCVjAs14miAnNHSfIiya9cRujE9FHsrHIkWBN7yuDZl4.5y3eO8ghOLYr91rPZM93m9pVRIpMLPBrqJ0XAC5tNiAlo7zds4IpmaNP0Noq0Qvf5rI4wdlZtTbxNEBnJ0l6855yA0TiB.ZPPTcuqKMNMc4XoGDFo43y5iVV.jnh8U11RD_ecLMnY6IRL2iLhMVrTi6oOK9Qz7yjOAFgwSfQxuQ3P2mOdBvJmzSlFR39B_Xr6It9NmCvfkUAnj6dZ6f3J.puKShieaoSRf28PASqr7mL4zIPtofQXR9yR342La7PqRnwIMMHYcDW4p3wQahqQ0WIiiCDj3UgVrlk3BkFxuXgR254VYeWQ.RE59YKrM6OiKGiak0X8DnaLOvxI_d6dnRbGckJzDy8W5gdo3EA26shMdKi8zAW1UwfHI6g.jsz8IzpsAmOC2ybhsxODlYj6tf_pG7cpnB0LvxQxtI82SLIF.xUUDGa_cHHuLTgGFXzRghjU2ICP5ho50Lduzi9vt.UB26feU9Cd8l2PaNhkzUO5dYxP5uo095aAs2CelTtDNQ"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e944c28cd76603e';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/pubs\/proc\/volumes\/pba95.html?__cf_chl_rt_tk=VHXV4QsBe8UW0KvhxO4ETwhptd497xujOZglZATybwU-1732733359-1.0.1.1-N2I6ZNYIwf6JLbEE9RGjPGENR0vi5TDjTNT2A1vUktk" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>