Cleary v. Ellis Foundry Co., 132 U.S. 612

<!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en"> <head> <meta charset="utf-8"/> <meta http-equiv="Content-Language" content="en"/> <meta name="language" content="en_us"/> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"/> <meta name="description" content="Cleary v. Ellis Foundry Co., 132 U.S. 612 — Brought to you by Free Law Project, a non-profit dedicated to creating high quality open legal information."/> <link rel="search" type="application/opensearchdescription+xml" title="CourtListener" href="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/xml/opensearch.72b938ad7809.xml" /> <meta name="application-name" content="CourtListener"/> <meta name="msapplication-tooltip" content="Create alerts, search for and browse the latest case law."/> <meta name="msapplication-starturl" content="https://www.courtlistener.com"/> <meta name="msapplication-navbutton-color" content="#6683B7"/> <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary"> <meta name="twitter:creator" content="@freelawproject"> <meta name="twitter:site" content="@courtlistener"> <meta property="og:type" content="website"/> <meta property="og:title" content="Cleary v. Ellis Foundry Co., 132 U.S. 612 – CourtListener.com"/> <meta property="og:description" content="Cleary v. Ellis Foundry Co. — Brought to you by Free Law Project, a non-profit dedicated to creating high quality open legal information. "> <meta property="og:url" content="https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/92636/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/"/> <meta property="og:site_name" content="CourtListener"/> <meta property="og:image" content="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/png/og-image-1200x630.7f25387a570b.png"/> <meta property="og:image:type" content="image/png"/> <meta property="twitter:image:alt" content="The CourtListener logo"/> <meta property="og:image:width" content="1200"/> <meta property="og:image:height" content="630"/> <link rel="icon" href="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/ico/favicon.db8385d9ed4d.ico" sizes="32x32"> <link rel="icon" href="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/svg/favicon.a124c6fa7c63.svg" type="image/svg+xml"> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" href="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/png/apple-touch-icon.bd1491b64e6d.png"> <link rel="manifest" href="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/json/manifest.ea07720093b9.json"> <link href="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/css/font-awesome.71fa7db63e3e.css" rel="stylesheet"> <title>Cleary v. Ellis Foundry Co., 132 U.S. 612 – CourtListener.com</title> <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="Atom feed for cases citing Cleary v. Ellis Foundry Co." href="/feed/search/?q=cites:(92636)"> <link rel="canonical" href="https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/92636/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/" /> <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/css/bootstrap/3.3.0/bootstrap.min.90ccf319d703.css" type="text/css"> <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/css/override.9438fab7d63c.css" type="text/css" media="screen, projection"> </head> <body class=""> <div class="container round-bottom"> <header class="row">    <div class="navbar navbar-default" role="navigation"> <div class="container-fluid"> <div class="navbar-header"> <button type="button" class="navbar-toggle collapsed" data-toggle="collapse" data-target=".navbar-collapse"> <span class="sr-only">Toggle navigation</span> <span class="icon-bar"></span> <span class="icon-bar"></span> <span class="icon-bar"></span> </button> <a class="navbar-brand" href="/" tabindex="1"> <svg class="cl-full-logo" viewBox="0 0 635.32 292.37" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"> <g id="Layer_2" data-name="Layer 2"> <g> <rect class="cls-4" x="144.69" y="260.05" width="7.44" height="26.76"/> <rect class="cls-4" x="69.06" y="260.05" width="7.44" height="26.76"/> <rect class="cls-4" x="87.97" y="260.05" width="7.44" height="26.76"/> <rect class="cls-1" x="106.88" y="260.05" width="7.44" height="26.76"/> <rect class="cls-4" x="125.78" y="260.05" width="7.44" height="26.76"/> </g> <g> <g> <path class="cls-1" d="M63.34,216.92c0-3.14.57-6.24,1.7-9.31,1.13-3.07,2.79-5.81,4.96-8.23,2.17-2.42,4.83-4.37,7.97-5.87,3.14-1.5,6.72-2.25,10.73-2.25,4.73,0,8.83,1.04,12.28,3.12,3.45,2.08,6.03,4.78,7.72,8.12l-7.68,5.29c-.68-1.45-1.5-2.67-2.46-3.66-.97-.99-2.01-1.78-3.12-2.36-1.11-.58-2.27-1-3.48-1.27-1.21-.27-2.39-.4-3.55-.4-2.51,0-4.7.51-6.56,1.52-1.86,1.02-3.41,2.33-4.64,3.95-1.23,1.62-2.16,3.46-2.79,5.51-.63,2.05-.94,4.1-.94,6.12,0,2.27.36,4.46,1.09,6.56.72,2.1,1.75,3.95,3.08,5.54,1.33,1.59,2.92,2.88,4.78,3.84,1.86.97,3.9,1.45,6.12,1.45,1.16,0,2.37-.15,3.62-.43,1.26-.29,2.45-.75,3.59-1.38,1.13-.63,2.19-1.44,3.15-2.43.97-.99,1.74-2.19,2.32-3.59l8.19,4.71c-.82,1.93-1.99,3.64-3.52,5.11-1.52,1.47-3.24,2.72-5.15,3.73-1.91,1.01-3.95,1.79-6.12,2.32-2.17.53-4.3.8-6.38.8-3.67,0-7.03-.77-10.07-2.32-3.04-1.55-5.67-3.56-7.86-6.05-2.2-2.49-3.91-5.31-5.15-8.48-1.23-3.16-1.85-6.39-1.85-9.68Z"/> <path class="cls-1" d="M138.14,243.38c-3.77,0-7.19-.74-10.26-2.21-3.07-1.47-5.7-3.43-7.9-5.87-2.2-2.44-3.9-5.23-5.11-8.37-1.21-3.14-1.81-6.35-1.81-9.64s.64-6.72,1.92-9.86c1.28-3.14,3.04-5.92,5.29-8.33,2.25-2.42,4.92-4.34,8.01-5.76,3.09-1.42,6.45-2.14,10.07-2.14s7.11.76,10.18,2.28c3.07,1.52,5.69,3.52,7.86,5.98,2.17,2.46,3.87,5.27,5.07,8.41,1.21,3.14,1.81,6.33,1.81,9.57,0,3.43-.63,6.7-1.88,9.82-1.26,3.12-3,5.87-5.22,8.26-2.22,2.39-4.88,4.3-7.97,5.73-3.09,1.43-6.45,2.14-10.07,2.14ZM123.21,217.29c0,2.22.34,4.37,1.01,6.45.68,2.08,1.65,3.91,2.94,5.51,1.28,1.59,2.85,2.88,4.71,3.84,1.86.97,3.97,1.45,6.34,1.45s4.55-.49,6.41-1.49c1.86-.99,3.43-2.31,4.71-3.95,1.28-1.64,2.25-3.49,2.9-5.54.65-2.05.98-4.14.98-6.27s-.35-4.37-1.05-6.45c-.7-2.08-1.69-3.91-2.97-5.51-1.28-1.59-2.85-2.86-4.71-3.8-1.86-.94-3.95-1.41-6.27-1.41s-4.57.5-6.45,1.49c-1.88.99-3.46,2.3-4.71,3.91-1.26,1.62-2.21,3.46-2.86,5.51-.65,2.05-.98,4.14-.98,6.27Z"/> <path class="cls-1" d="M192.71,234.54c2.37,0,4.36-.48,5.98-1.45,1.62-.97,2.92-2.22,3.91-3.77.99-1.55,1.69-3.32,2.1-5.33.41-2,.62-4.07.62-6.2v-26.24h9.93v26.24c0,3.53-.42,6.84-1.27,9.93-.85,3.09-2.17,5.8-3.99,8.12s-4.14,4.16-6.99,5.51c-2.85,1.35-6.26,2.03-10.22,2.03s-7.6-.71-10.47-2.14c-2.88-1.42-5.21-3.31-6.99-5.65-1.79-2.34-3.08-5.06-3.88-8.15-.8-3.09-1.2-6.31-1.2-9.64v-26.24h10v26.24c0,2.17.21,4.26.62,6.27.41,2.01,1.11,3.78,2.1,5.33.99,1.55,2.28,2.79,3.88,3.73s3.55,1.41,5.87,1.41Z"/> <path class="cls-1" d="M225.33,243.01v-51.46h22.76c2.37,0,4.55.5,6.56,1.49,2,.99,3.73,2.3,5.18,3.91,1.45,1.62,2.58,3.46,3.41,5.51.82,2.05,1.23,4.12,1.23,6.2,0,3.33-.83,6.37-2.5,9.1-1.67,2.73-3.93,4.7-6.78,5.91l11.74,19.35h-11.23l-10.51-17.25h-9.86v17.25h-10ZM235.33,217h12.54c.92,0,1.78-.22,2.57-.65.8-.43,1.49-1.03,2.07-1.78.58-.75,1.04-1.63,1.38-2.65.34-1.01.51-2.1.51-3.26s-.19-2.32-.58-3.33c-.39-1.01-.91-1.9-1.56-2.65-.65-.75-1.4-1.33-2.25-1.74-.85-.41-1.7-.62-2.57-.62h-12.1v16.67Z"/> </g> <path class="cls-1" d="M310.71,200.33h-16.45v42.69h-9.93v-42.69h-16.45v-8.77h42.83v8.77Z"/> <g> <path class="cls-1" d="M329.91,243.01v-51.46h5.07v46.96h29.72v4.49h-34.79Z"/> <path class="cls-1" d="M368.54,243.01v-51.46h5.07v51.46h-5.07Z"/> <path class="cls-1" d="M412.97,201.2c-1.45-1.64-3.38-2.97-5.8-3.99-2.42-1.01-5.17-1.52-8.26-1.52-4.54,0-7.85.86-9.93,2.57-2.08,1.72-3.12,4.05-3.12,6.99,0,1.55.28,2.82.83,3.81.55.99,1.41,1.85,2.57,2.57,1.16.73,2.65,1.35,4.46,1.88,1.81.53,3.95,1.06,6.41,1.59,2.75.58,5.23,1.23,7.43,1.96,2.2.72,4.07,1.63,5.62,2.72,1.55,1.09,2.73,2.4,3.55,3.95.82,1.55,1.23,3.48,1.23,5.8s-.46,4.42-1.38,6.16c-.92,1.74-2.2,3.19-3.84,4.35-1.64,1.16-3.6,2.02-5.87,2.57-2.27.55-4.76.83-7.46.83-7.97,0-14.86-2.49-20.66-7.46l2.54-4.13c.92.97,2.02,1.88,3.3,2.75,1.28.87,2.71,1.63,4.28,2.28,1.57.65,3.25,1.16,5.04,1.52,1.79.36,3.67.54,5.65.54,4.11,0,7.31-.74,9.6-2.21,2.29-1.47,3.44-3.71,3.44-6.7,0-1.59-.33-2.94-.98-4.02-.65-1.09-1.63-2.03-2.94-2.83-1.3-.8-2.92-1.49-4.86-2.07-1.93-.58-4.18-1.16-6.74-1.74-2.71-.63-5.07-1.28-7.1-1.96-2.03-.68-3.74-1.52-5.15-2.54-1.4-1.01-2.45-2.23-3.15-3.66-.7-1.42-1.05-3.18-1.05-5.25,0-2.37.45-4.48,1.34-6.34.89-1.86,2.16-3.41,3.81-4.64,1.64-1.23,3.58-2.17,5.8-2.83,2.22-.65,4.69-.98,7.39-.98,3.43,0,6.49.52,9.17,1.56,2.68,1.04,5.11,2.5,7.28,4.38l-2.46,4.06Z"/> <path class="cls-1" d="M459.79,196.05h-18.34v46.97h-5.07v-46.97h-18.34v-4.49h41.75v4.49Z"/> <path class="cls-1" d="M498.42,238.52v4.49h-34.57v-51.46h33.92v4.49h-28.85v18.55h25.15v4.28h-25.15v19.64h29.5Z"/> <path class="cls-1" d="M509.43,200.98v42.04h-5.07v-51.46h3.91l34.06,42.83v-42.76h5.07v51.39h-4.42l-33.56-42.04Z"/> <path class="cls-1" d="M591.26,238.52v4.49h-34.57v-51.46h33.92v4.49h-28.85v18.55h25.15v4.28h-25.15v19.64h29.5Z"/> <path class="cls-1" d="M597.2,243.01v-51.46h21.74c2.22,0,4.26.47,6.12,1.41,1.86.94,3.47,2.17,4.82,3.7,1.35,1.52,2.4,3.25,3.15,5.18.75,1.93,1.12,3.89,1.12,5.87s-.28,3.68-.83,5.4c-.56,1.72-1.33,3.26-2.32,4.64-.99,1.38-2.19,2.54-3.59,3.48-1.4.94-2.97,1.58-4.71,1.92l12.61,19.86h-5.73l-12.1-18.99h-15.22v18.99h-5.07ZM602.27,219.53h16.81c1.5,0,2.86-.33,4.1-.98,1.23-.65,2.28-1.53,3.15-2.65.87-1.11,1.55-2.37,2.03-3.77.48-1.4.73-2.87.73-4.42s-.28-3.03-.83-4.46c-.56-1.42-1.3-2.67-2.25-3.73-.94-1.06-2.05-1.91-3.33-2.54-1.28-.63-2.62-.94-4.02-.94h-16.38v23.48Z"/> </g> </g> <g> <path class="cls-2" d="M193.32,279.1c0,1.01-.2,1.94-.61,2.79-.41.85-.95,1.58-1.63,2.2-.68.62-1.48,1.1-2.39,1.44s-1.89.51-2.93.51h-12.73v-26.99h13c.94,0,1.79.2,2.55.61.76.41,1.41.93,1.94,1.58.53.65.94,1.38,1.24,2.2.29.82.44,1.65.44,2.49,0,1.37-.34,2.62-1.03,3.74-.68,1.13-1.63,1.97-2.85,2.53,1.55.46,2.77,1.31,3.67,2.55.9,1.24,1.35,2.69,1.35,4.33ZM175.69,261.38v9.96h9.27c.66,0,1.27-.14,1.84-.42.57-.28,1.06-.65,1.46-1.1.41-.46.72-.98.95-1.58.23-.6.34-1.22.34-1.88s-.11-1.33-.32-1.94c-.22-.61-.52-1.13-.91-1.58-.39-.44-.86-.8-1.39-1.06-.53-.27-1.12-.4-1.75-.4h-9.5ZM190.66,278.64c0-.66-.11-1.3-.34-1.92-.23-.62-.55-1.16-.97-1.63-.42-.47-.91-.85-1.48-1.14-.57-.29-1.18-.44-1.84-.44h-10.34v10.22h10.07c.68,0,1.32-.14,1.92-.42.59-.28,1.11-.65,1.56-1.12.44-.47.79-1.01,1.05-1.63.25-.62.38-1.26.38-1.92Z"/> <path class="cls-2" d="M200.05,259.07l8.82,14.52,8.89-14.52h2.89l-10.45,16.95v10.03h-2.66v-10.11l-10.41-16.88h2.93Z"/> </g> <g> <path class="cls-2" d="M238.36,286.05v-26.99h17.71v2.36h-15.05v9.92h12.69v2.2h-12.69v12.5h-2.66Z"/> <path class="cls-2" d="M263.41,286.05v-26.99h11.4c1.17,0,2.24.25,3.21.74.97.49,1.82,1.14,2.53,1.94.71.8,1.26,1.7,1.65,2.72.39,1.01.59,2.04.59,3.08s-.15,1.93-.44,2.83c-.29.9-.7,1.71-1.22,2.43-.52.72-1.15,1.33-1.88,1.82-.74.49-1.56.83-2.47,1.01l6.61,10.41h-3l-6.35-9.96h-7.98v9.96h-2.66ZM266.07,273.74h8.82c.79,0,1.5-.17,2.15-.51s1.2-.8,1.65-1.39c.46-.58.81-1.24,1.06-1.98.25-.73.38-1.51.38-2.32s-.15-1.59-.44-2.34c-.29-.75-.68-1.4-1.18-1.96-.49-.56-1.08-1-1.75-1.33-.67-.33-1.37-.49-2.11-.49h-8.59v12.31Z"/> <path class="cls-2" d="M309.02,283.7v2.36h-18.13v-26.99h17.79v2.36h-15.13v9.73h13.19v2.24h-13.19v10.3h15.47Z"/> <path class="cls-2" d="M334.82,283.7v2.36h-18.13v-26.99h17.79v2.36h-15.13v9.73h13.19v2.24h-13.19v10.3h15.47Z"/> </g> <path class="cls-2" d="M344.4,286.47c-.68,0-1.26-.22-1.75-.66-.49-.44-.74-1.05-.74-1.84,0-.67.24-1.24.7-1.72.47-.48,1.05-.72,1.74-.72s1.28.24,1.76.71c.49.48.73,1.05.73,1.73,0,.78-.24,1.39-.73,1.83-.49.44-1.06.66-1.71.66Z"/> <g> <path class="cls-2" d="M353.01,286.05v-26.99h2.66v24.63h15.58v2.36h-18.24Z"/> <path class="cls-2" d="M386.19,259.07h2.24l11.21,26.99h-2.81l-3.5-8.44h-12.13l-3.46,8.44h-2.85l11.29-26.99ZM392.73,275.52l-5.44-13.34-5.51,13.34h10.95Z"/> </g> <path class="cls-2" d="M409.07,259.26h2.51l3.8,9.58,3.84-9.58h2.55l-4.71,11.52,5.17,12.2,9.77-23.91h2.89l-11.44,26.99h-2.36l-5.66-13.34-5.7,13.34h-2.32l-11.4-26.99h2.85l9.81,23.91,5.13-12.2-4.71-11.52Z"/> <path class="cls-1" d="M108.64.25c-3.36.78-6.07,3.5-6.83,6.86-1.03,4.57,1.38,8.74,5.17,10.47v157.28h7.7V17.59c3.2-1.44,5.43-4.64,5.43-8.37,0-5.79-5.4-10.36-11.47-8.97Z"/> </g> <a xlink:href="https://free.law/" xlink:show="new"> <g id="Layer_4" data-name="Layer 4"> <rect class="free-law-link" x="64.43" y="247.23" width="399.41" height="45.14"/> </g> </a> <g id="Layer_3" data-name="Layer 3"> <g> <path class="cls-4" d="M208.79,138.68h-47.85v3.95c.02,4.78,2.93,7.71,7.69,7.71,10.42-.02,20.83-.05,31.27-.07.95-.02,1.94-.05,2.86-.3,5.75-1.52,6.81-6.28,6.03-11.29Z"/> <path class="cls-4" d="M219.07,80c-1.73-1.76-3.88-2.63-6.44-2.63-2.77,0-5.03.85-6.79,2.59-.85.83-1.5,1.8-1.92,2.89h-57.83v92.79h7.51s0-85.29,0-85.29h29.05c0,3.35,0,6.7-.05,10.05-.02.65-.12,1.34-.32,1.94-3.44,9.72-6.91,19.42-10.3,29.12-.3.85-.67,1.13-1.52,1.11-3-.05-5.98,0-8.96.02-.99,0-1.39.39-1.39,1.27s.44,1.29,1.5,1.27c2.86,0,5.7-.07,8.57-.09,12.93-.05,25.87-.12,38.82-.16,1.18,0,1.73-.44,1.71-1.29s-.51-1.22-1.66-1.22c-2.47,0-4.92,0-7.37.05-.72.02-1.04-.21-1.32-.88-4.11-9.7-8.22-19.38-12.33-29.08-.14-.3-.21-.62-.21-.95v-11.15h16.12c.39.95.97,1.85,1.71,2.7,1.64,1.85,3.93,2.79,6.88,2.79,2.61,0,4.8-.88,6.54-2.66,1.73-1.76,2.61-3.95,2.61-6.63s-.88-4.78-2.61-6.56ZM195.93,132.35h-19.61c2.93-8.27,5.87-16.56,8.8-24.83h.25c3.51,8.22,7,16.44,10.55,24.83ZM215.26,89.72c-.79.88-1.71,1.32-2.77,1.32s-2.06-.44-2.84-1.34c-.79-.9-1.18-1.99-1.18-3.26,0-1.18.42-2.17,1.2-3,.79-.85,1.73-1.27,2.82-1.27s1.99.46,2.77,1.34c.79.9,1.18,1.94,1.18,3.14s-.39,2.19-1.18,3.07Z"/> <path class="cls-4" d="M62.35,159.33H14.5c0,1.43-.02,2.68,0,3.93,0,4.78,2.93,7.71,7.67,7.71,10.42-.02,20.85-.05,31.27-.07.95,0,1.94-.05,2.86-.3,5.75-1.52,6.81-6.28,6.05-11.27Z"/> <path class="cls-4" d="M17.94,103.65c-.44-1.22-1.13-2.33-2.08-3.3-1.76-1.76-3.9-2.63-6.47-2.63-2.75,0-5.01.85-6.77,2.59s-2.63,3.97-2.63,6.7c0,2.4.81,4.53,2.45,6.4,1.64,1.85,3.93,2.79,6.88,2.79,2.61,0,4.78-.88,6.54-2.63.72-.74,1.27-1.52,1.71-2.4h18.61c0,3.28,0,6.58-.05,9.86,0,.65-.12,1.34-.32,1.94-3.42,9.72-6.88,19.4-10.3,29.12-.3.85-.65,1.11-1.52,1.11-2.98-.05-5.98,0-8.96.02-.97,0-1.39.39-1.39,1.27.02.88.46,1.27,1.52,1.27,2.84-.02,5.7-.07,8.54-.09,12.93-.07,25.89-.12,38.82-.16,1.2-.02,1.73-.44,1.71-1.32,0-.83-.49-1.2-1.66-1.2-2.45,0-4.92-.02-7.37.05-.69,0-1.04-.21-1.32-.88-4.09-9.7-8.22-19.38-12.33-29.08-.12-.3-.21-.65-.21-.97,0-3.63,0-7.3.02-10.95h29.01v64.48h7.51s0-71.98,0-71.98H17.94ZM12.06,110.07c-.81.88-1.71,1.32-2.77,1.32s-2.06-.44-2.84-1.34c-.79-.9-1.18-1.99-1.18-3.26,0-1.15.39-2.17,1.2-3,.79-.83,1.73-1.27,2.82-1.27s1.96.46,2.77,1.34c.79.9,1.18,1.94,1.18,3.14s-.39,2.22-1.18,3.07ZM49.49,152.98h-19.61c2.93-8.27,5.87-16.56,8.8-24.83.07,0,.16,0,.25-.02,3.49,8.22,6.97,16.47,10.55,24.85Z"/> <path class="cls-4" d="M99.67,26.6c-1.73-1.76-3.88-2.63-6.44-2.63-2.75,0-5.01.85-6.77,2.59-1.78,1.73-2.66,3.97-2.66,6.7,0,2.4.83,4.53,2.47,6.4.83.95,1.85,1.66,3.03,2.1v133.88h7.51V41.75c1.06-.44,2.01-1.09,2.86-1.96,1.76-1.76,2.61-3.95,2.61-6.63s-.85-4.78-2.61-6.56ZM95.86,36.33c-.79.88-1.71,1.32-2.75,1.32-1.11,0-2.06-.44-2.84-1.34-.79-.9-1.18-1.99-1.18-3.26,0-1.18.39-2.17,1.18-3,.79-.85,1.73-1.27,2.84-1.27,1.04,0,1.96.46,2.75,1.34.81.9,1.2,1.94,1.2,3.14s-.39,2.19-1.2,3.07Z"/> <path class="cls-4" d="M137.69,48.17c-1.73-1.76-3.9-2.66-6.47-2.66-2.75,0-5.01.88-6.77,2.61-1.76,1.73-2.63,3.95-2.63,6.7,0,2.4.81,4.53,2.45,6.4.83.95,1.85,1.64,3.03,2.1v112.31h7.51V63.32c1.06-.44,2.03-1.11,2.89-1.96,1.73-1.76,2.61-3.97,2.61-6.63s-.88-4.8-2.61-6.56ZM133.88,57.9c-.79.88-1.71,1.32-2.77,1.32s-2.06-.46-2.84-1.34c-.79-.9-1.18-1.99-1.18-3.26,0-1.18.39-2.17,1.2-3,.79-.85,1.73-1.27,2.82-1.27s1.99.44,2.77,1.34c.79.9,1.18,1.94,1.18,3.14s-.39,2.19-1.18,3.07Z"/> </g> </g> </svg> </a> </div> <div class="navbar-collapse collapse"> <ul class="nav navbar-nav navbar-right"> <li><a href="https://free.law/about/" tabindex="200">About</a></li> <li><a href="/faq/" tabindex="201">FAQ</a></li> <li class="visible-xs"> <a href="https://donate.free.law/forms/membership" tabindex="203">Become a Member</a> </li> <li> <a href="/sign-in/?next=/opinion/92636/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/?" tabindex="204">Sign in / Register</a> </li> </ul> </div> </div> </div>  <div class="navbar navbar-default subnav white-background" role="navigation"> <div class="container-fluid"> <div> <ul class="nav navbar-nav"> <li class="dropdown active" id="navbar-o"> <a href="#" class="dropdown-toggle" tabindex="100" data-toggle="dropdown">Case Law <span class="caret"></span> </a> <ul class="dropdown-menu" role="menu"> <li> <a href="/opinion/" tabindex="101">Search Case Law</a> </li> <li> <a href="/c/" tabindex="102">Look Up Citations</a> </li> <li> <a href="/visualizations/scotus-mapper/" tabindex="102">Citation Visualizations</a> </li> <li> <a href="/help/coverage/opinions/" tabindex="103">About this Collection</a> </li> <li> <a href="/help/api/rest/case-law/" tabindex="104">API</a> </li> </ul> </li> <li class="dropdown inactive" id="navbar-r"> <a href="#" class="dropdown-toggle" tabindex="200" data-toggle="dropdown">RECAP Archive <span class="caret"></span> </a> <ul class="dropdown-menu" role="menu"> <li> <a href="/recap/" tabindex="201">Search PACER Data</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://free.law/recap/" tabindex="202">Install RECAP</a> </li> <li> <a href="/help/alerts/#recap-alerts" tabindex="204">Get Case Alerts</a> </li> <li> <a href="/help/coverage/recap/" tabindex="205">About this Collection</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://free.law/data-consulting/" tabindex="206">Bulk Data Service</a> </li> <li> <a href="/help/api/rest/pacer/" tabindex="207">API</a> </li> </ul> </li> <li class="dropdown inactive" id="navbar-oa"> <a href="#" class="dropdown-toggle" tabindex="300" data-toggle="dropdown">Oral Arguments <span class="caret"></span></a> <ul class="dropdown-menu" role="menu"> <li> <a href="/audio/" tabindex="301">Search Oral Arguments</a> </li> <li> <a href="/help/alerts/#search-alerts" tabindex="302">Get Search Alerts</a> </li> <li> <a href="/podcasts/" tabindex="303">Custom Podcasts</a> </li> <li> <a href="/help/coverage/oral-arguments/" tabindex="304">About this Collection</a> </li> <li> <a href="/help/api/rest/oral-arguments/" tabindex="305">API</a> </li> </ul> </li> <li class="dropdown inactive" id="navbar-p"> <a href="#" class="dropdown-toggle" tabindex="400" data-toggle="dropdown">Judges <span class="caret"></span></a> <ul class="dropdown-menu" role="menu"> <li> <a href="/person/" tabindex="401">Search Judges</a> </li> <li> <a href="https://free.law/projects/judge-db" tabindex="404">About this Collection</a> </li> <li> <a href="/help/api/rest/judges/" tabindex="405">API</a> </li> </ul> </li> <li class="dropdown inactive" id="navbar-fd"> <a href="#" class="dropdown-toggle" tabindex="500" data-toggle="dropdown">Financial Disclosures <span class="caret"></span></a> <ul class="dropdown-menu" role="menu"> <li> <a href="/financial-disclosures/" tabindex="501">Search Financial Disclosures</a> </li> <li> <a href="/help/coverage/financial-disclosures/" tabindex="502">About this Collection</a> </li> <li> <a href="/help/api/rest/financial-disclosures/" tabindex="503">API</a> </li> </ul> </li> </ul> <ul class="nav navbar-nav navbar-right"> <li class="inactive hidden-xs"> <a href="https://donate.free.law/forms/membership" tabindex="600" class="donate"><i class="fa fa-heart-o"></i> Donate</a> </li> </ul> </div> </div> </div> </header> <div class="row content"> <div class="col-sm-3" id="sidebar"> <div class="hidden sidebar-section" id="sidebar-notes"> <div> <h3> <span>Your Notes</span> <span class="edit" data-toggle="modal" data-target="#modal-save-note"> (<a href="#note-editor">edit</a>) <i class="fa fa-pencil gray pointer"></i> </span> </h3> <p id="sidebar-notes-text"> (none) </p> </div> </div> <div id="cited-by" class="sidebar-section"> <h3> <span>Cited By (2) <a href="/feed/search/?type=o&q=cites%3A(92636)" rel="nofollow"> <i class="gray fa fa-rss" title="Subscribe to a feed of citations to this case."></i> </a> </span> </h3> <p class="bottom">This case has been cited by other opinions:</p> <ul> <li> <a href="/opinion/1506467/barnett-v-jaspan/">Barnett<span class="alt"> v. </span>Jaspan (1942)</a> </li> <li> <a href="/opinion/1093774/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/">Cleary<span class="alt"> v. </span>Ellis Foundry Co. (1890)</a> </li> </ul> <p> <a href="/?q=cites%3A(92636)" rel="nofollow" class="btn btn-default" >View Citing Opinions</a> </p> <div class="btn-group"> <a href="/?show_alert_modal=yes&q=cites%3A(92636)" rel="nofollow" class="btn btn-primary" ><i class="fa fa-bell-o"></i> Get Citation Alerts</a> <a class="btn btn-primary dropdown-toggle" data-toggle="dropdown" aria-haspopup="true" aria-expanded="false"> <span class="caret"></span> <span class="sr-only">Toggle Dropdown</span> </a> <ul class="dropdown-menu"> <li><a href="/help/alerts/#citation-alerts">Learn More</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> <div id="authorities" class="sidebar-section"> <h3><span>Authorities (1)</span></h3> <p class="bottom">This opinion cites:</p> <ul> <li> <a href="/opinion/1093774/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/?"> Cleary<span class="alt"> v. </span>Ellis Foundry Co., 132 U.S. 612 </a> <span class="small gray">(2 times)</span> </li> </ul> <h4> <a href="/opinion/92636/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/authorities/" class="btn btn-default"> View All Authorities </a> </h4> </div> <div class="sidebar-section"> <h3><span>Share</span></h3> <div id="share-links" class="form-inline"> <a href="mailto:?subject=Cleary%20v.%20Ellis%20Foundry%20Co.%2C%20132%20U.S.%20612%20at%20CourtListener.com&body=https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/92636/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/" title="Email this Link to a Friend or Colleague"> <i class="fa fa-envelope-o fa-lg gray"></i> </a>  <a href="https://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/92636/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/&t=Cleary v. Ellis Foundry Co., 132 U.S. 612 at CourtListener.com" target="_blank" title="Share on Facebook"> <i class="fa fa-facebook-square fa-lg gray"></i> </a>  <a href="https://x.com/home?status=https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/92636/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/" target="_blank" title="Share on X"> <i class="fa fa-twitter-square fa-lg gray"></i> </a>  <div class="form-group"> <input type="text" readonly="readonly" id="copy-input" class="form-control input-sm form-inline click-select" value="https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/92636/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/"/> </div> </div> </div> <div class="sidebar-section hidden-xs"> <h3><span>Support FLP <i class="fa fa-heart-o red"></i></span></h3> <p class="v-offset-above-1"> CourtListener is a project of <a href="https://free.law" target="_blank">Free Law Project</a>, a federally-recognized 501(c)(3) non-profit. Members help support our work and get special access to features. </p> <p>Please become a member today.</p> <p> <a href="https://donate.free.law/forms/membership" class="btn btn-danger btn-lg btn-block">Join Free.law Now</a> </p> </div> </div> <article class="col-sm-9"> <h2 class="inline">Cleary<span class="alt"> v. </span>Ellis Foundry Co., 132 U.S. 612</h2> <div id="modal-logged-out" class="modal hidden-print" role="dialog" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1"> <div class="modal-dialog modal-sm"> <div class="modal-content"> <div class="modal-body"> <button type="button" class="close" data-dismiss="modal" aria-label="Close"><span aria-hidden="true">×</span></button> <h2 class="text-center">Please Sign In or Register</h2> <p class="v-offset-above-2"> <a href="/sign-in/?next=/opinion/92636/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/" class="btn btn-primary btn-block btn-lg">Sign In</a> <a href="/register/?next=/opinion/92636/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/" class="btn btn-default btn-block btn-lg">Register</a> </p> </div> </div> </div> </div> <h3>Supreme Court of the United States</h3> <p> <div class="btn-group hidden-print"> <button id="add-note-button" class="btn btn-success pointer hidden-print" data-toggle="modal" data-target="#modal-save-note, #modal-logged-out" title="Save this record as a note in your profile"> <i class="fa fa-bookmark "></i> <span class="hidden-xs">Add Note</span></button> </div> </p> <p class="bottom"> <span class="meta-data-header">Filed:</span> <span class="meta-data-value"> January 6th, 1890 </span> </p> <p class="bottom"> <span class="meta-data-header">Precedential Status:</span> <span class="meta-data-value"> Precedential </span> </p> <p class="bottom"> <span class="meta-data-header">Citations:</span> <span class="meta-data-value"> 132 U.S. 612 </span> </p> <p class="bottom"> <span class="meta-data-header">Docket Number:</span> <span class="meta-data-value select-all"> 160 </span> </p> <p class="bottom"> <span class="meta-data-header">Supreme Court Database ID:</span> <span class="meta-data-value"> Unknown </span> </p> <p class="bottom"> <span class="meta-data-header">Judges:</span> Harlan </p> <p class="bottom"> <span class="meta-data-header">Author:</span> <span class="meta-data-value">Harlan</span> </p> <br> <div class="well well-sm"> <h4>Summary of Opinion</h4> <p><p>Avery v. Cleary,’’ante, 604, affirmed; but as the defendant did not prosecute a writ of error, the judgment below is affirmed on the ground that no error was committed to the plaintiff’s prejudice.</p> </p> </div> <div class="tab-content"> <div id="010combined1"> <div id="resource-org-text" class="v-offset-above-2"> <div id="opinion-content"> <div class="serif-text"><p class="case_cite"><span class="citation" data-id="1093774"><a href="/opinion/1093774/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/">132 U.S. 612</a></span></p> <p class="case_cite"><span class="citation" data-id="1093774"><a href="/opinion/1093774/cleary-v-ellis-foundry-co/">10 S.Ct. 223</a></span></p> <p class="case_cite"><span class="citation no-link">33 L.Ed. 473</span></p> <p class="parties">CLEARY<br>v.<br>ELLIS FOUNDRY CO.</p> <p class="date">January 6, 1890.</p> <div class="prelims"> <p class="indent"><i>Eugene M. Johnson</i>, for plaintiff in error.</p> <p class="indent"><i>Joshua D. Ball</i>, for defendant in error.</p> <p class="indent">Mr. Justice HARLAN, after stating the facts in the foregoing language, delivered the opinion of the court.</p> </div> <div class="num" id="p1"> <span class="num">1</span> <p class="indent">The statements of facts made in Avery v. Cleary, ante, 220, (just decided,) is, in the main, applicable to the present case. The additional facts necessary to be stated are these:</p> </div> <div class="num" id="p2"> <span class="num">2</span> <p class="indent">On the 21st of May, 1879, Ellis made a written assignment to the Ellis Foundry Company, a Massachusetts corporation, of policy 68,429, and all his rights under it, with all moneys payable or which might be payable thereon. That corporation, at the same time, gave a writing to Ellis showing that it received the above policy as collateral security for the payment of a debt due to it from Ellis of $5,540.14 within one year from March 1, 1879, with interest, and of all other sums of money that he might owe that company within four years thereafter. Out of the proceeds of this policy collected by Avery as administrator of Ellis the foundry company received, December 31, 1879, the sum of $5,901.64, the amount which Ellis, at his death, owed that corporation.</p> </div> <div class="num" id="p3"> <span class="num">3</span> <p class="indent">The present action was brought September 30, 1882, to recover from the company the entire amount received by it on policy 68,429. It proceeds upon the same grounds substantially as those set forth in the other suit. The defendant denied that it had collected such proceeds, and, besides controverting the material allegations of the declaration, pleaded in the bar of the action the statute of limitations of two years.</p> </div> <div class="num" id="p4"> <span class="num">4</span> <p class="indent">At the close of the evidence it claimed the right to go to the jury, and presented certain prayers for instructions, which the court declined to give. This claim was denied, and the court ruled, as matter of law, that upon the evidence the plaintiff was entitled to recover from the defendant only the amount the insurance company would have paid the assignee in bankruptcy as the cash surrender value of the policy at the date of the filing of the petition in bankruptcy, namely, July 3, 1878. It being agreed that such value was $1,200, the jury were instructed to return a verdict in favor of the plaintiff for that amount, with interest from December *31, 1879, the date of the payment by Ellis' administrator to the defendant of the sum of $5,901.64. To that instruction the plaintiff excepted, but did not present any prayers for instructions. A verdict was returned in conformity with the direction of the court, and judgment was entered thereon.</p> </div> <div class="num" id="p5"> <span class="num">5</span> <p class="indent">For the reasons given in the opinion in A very v. Cleary, the peremptory instruction to the jury to find a verdict in favor of the plaintiff for the surrender value of policy 68,429 was erroneous. But, as the defendant did not prosecute a writ of error, the judgment below must be affirmed upon the ground that no error was committed to the prejudice of the plaintiff. His action was barred by limitation, for there can be no doubt that this suit is between the assignee and a corporation claiming an adverse interest. Judgment affirmed.</p> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </article> </div> <div class="row base-newsletter hidden-print"> <div class="col-sm-6"> <p class="bold bottom">Newsletter</p> <p>Sign up to receive the Free Law Project newsletter with tips and announcements.</p> </div> <div class="col-sm-6 right"> <a href="https://donate.free.law/np/clients/freelawproject/subscribe.jsp?forwardedFromSecureDomain=1&subscription=9" class="btn btn-default" tabindex="10000"> <i class="fa fa-newspaper-o"></i> Subscribe </a> </div> </div> <footer class="row hidden-print"> <div class="col-sm-8"> <div class="row"> <div class="col-xs-6"> <div class="col-sm-6 no-gutter"> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="https://free.law/about/" tabindex="11000">About</a> </div> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="/help/" tabindex="11001">Help</a> & <a href="/faq/">FAQ</a> </div> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="https://donate.free.law/forms/membership" tabindex="11002">Donate</a> </div> </div> <div class="col-sm-6 no-gutter"> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="/help/coverage/" tabindex="11003">About Our Data</a> </div> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="/help/api/" tabindex="11004">APIs & Bulk Data</a> </div> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="/feeds/" tabindex="11005">Feeds</a> <span class="alt">&</span> <a href="/podcasts/" tabindex="11006">Podcasts</a> <i class="gray fa fa-podcast inline"></i> </div> </div> </div> <div class="col-xs-6"> <div class="col-sm-6 no-gutter"> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="https://free.law" tabindex="11007">Blog Posts</a> </div> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="/contact/" tabindex="11008">Contact</a> </div> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="https://free.law/data-consulting/" tabindex="11009">Data Services</a> </div> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="/contribute/" tabindex="11010">Contribute</a> </div> </div> <div class="col-sm-6 no-gutter"> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="/terms/" tabindex="11011">Terms & Privacy</a> </div> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="/terms/#removal" tabindex="11012">Removal</a> </div> <div class="footer-item"> <a href="https://free.law/vulnerability-disclosure-policy/" tabindex="11013">Vulnerability Policies</a> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="col-sm-4 text-right" id="donate-image"> <a href="https://donate.free.law/forms/membership" tabindex="11014"> <img src="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/png/donate-button.f21707e5ec7d.png" alt="Donate to support our work" height="75" width="227"> </a> </div> <div class="col-sm-12" id="by-line"> <p>CourtListener is sponsored by the non-profit <a href="https://free.law" tabindex="11015">Free Law Project</a>.</p> </div> </footer> </div> <div class="text-center hidden-print" id="social-container"> <a href="https://free.law/" class="fa-stack fa-lg" tabindex="12000"> <i class="fa fa-circle fa-stack-2x gray"></i> <i class="fa fa-link fa-stack-1x fa-inverse"></i> </a> <a href="https://x.com/freelawproject" rel="noreferrer" class="fa-stack fa-lg" tabindex="12001"> <i class="fa fa-circle fa-stack-2x gray"></i> <i class="fa fa-twitter fa-stack-1x fa-inverse"></i> </a> <a href="https://donate.free.law/np/clients/freelawproject/subscribe.jsp?subscription=9" class="fa-stack fa-lg" tabindex="12002"> <i class="fa fa-circle fa-stack-2x gray"></i> <i class="fa fa-newspaper-o fa-stack-1x fa-inverse"></i> </a> <a href="https://github.com/freelawproject/courtlistener" rel="noreferrer" class="fa-stack fa-lg" tabindex="12003"> <i class="fa fa-circle fa-stack-2x gray"></i> <i class="fa fa-github fa-stack-1x fa-inverse"></i> </a> </div> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/js/jquery/jquery-3.4.1.min.220afd743d9e.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/js/bootstrap.min.6c1ad0cd7c72.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/js/base.7a3fd96ab1e0.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" nonce="404jU4UKzY2fZlXMjAuxDg=="> var isMember = false, userAlertCount = 0, priceRtAlerts = parseFloat(10), maxFreeDocketAlerts = 5, recapBonusAlerts = 10; </script> <script defer type="text/javascript" src="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/js/jquery.NobleCount.min.b39270d0a2ec.js"></script> <script defer type="text/javascript" src="https://storage.courtlistener.com/static/js/save-notes.82c8dc9c4c77.js"></script> </body> </html>

CINXE.COM

Cleary v. Ellis Foundry Co., 132 U.S. 612 – CourtListener.com