CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "royalsocietypublishing.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e97dd0d2a2d3f5e',cH: 'pcndkBopipJ1ilBVF85UEUX1HnTXXuq1OHPNV2k2hUY-1732770751-1.2.1.1-4388ImAF97ySG1C_X9ewsjXQN6fl3oYcTQNNKuA8SDxPNDOvRcaXdWvP431aOefA',cUPMDTk: "\/doi\/10.1098\/rsta.1954.0003?__cf_chl_tk=28DAUmrqmrWG712s1Rq.PipU32QO7stf4wOs1JzMJfE-1732770751-1.0.1.1-MlFqRXq5VuYsly8PpwmGg0.ke8MlZoFxpslYTJFAlrw",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1732770751',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/doi\/10.1098\/rsta.1954.0003?__cf_chl_f_tk=28DAUmrqmrWG712s1Rq.PipU32QO7stf4wOs1JzMJfE-1732770751-1.0.1.1-MlFqRXq5VuYsly8PpwmGg0.ke8MlZoFxpslYTJFAlrw",md: "stJraSP7TpITyU.RyGvJrJAZxPClqTFS0S4DMBcGWII-1732770751-1.2.1.1-rrEUxNzLFVwuYttJokKzxBIfHi3Of_ZAu2WTj.szoLRWGn0Lu.xstMGJiPBLB5v08IyW5WqNtmQf.NEkK7cf_XuKlVje1DvkZ1BsmXGbKX.5iO72SotvLoefYfMlB4y..Ub9fjJQ0sMpgk6t3b6l2LLn1319Kx4cFCbaZQ8ylGrC3p4UWmZDu4XTUlmgdgl2U5OKO9L9tcKD877snNJJBS.YT81yV7U3mln4EPlQ.bogKsd1C4JQDZURAlo1Xgs.iNqImzPmheIJ0zGRBQtVSaqQIk7jIPsWz4WH1bfp3C9p.q_zHGDc1.fFNF4JvRfzakPylUD90G8cGgKZe5aPcKZSvnUdcGFjn905cGalf5knrTEk4En1XUjyxBtmktjLHbm5DOPs_.8d_pogOviTlW.B1.ZVZ6b5eqT_4HHcxziNQ5_wDzbgPoryuojxkbybyQgySe9ypcWAekEHu5bRdGvN7RD2tzPHGphKzL4stRksqZuAWtd.D2dNi0NxNd.NYHOPnA4K_V5sYlL8W65gUnIwfNzQwU1m5qcMpsMFEf.lFUhwhcEZoRvjj4FfR55wZ8MQkNH3A8gpqRGY6OdTglYfVJrjz4KWDP7tlD0LSLt3IYyfkAciJYzeWgsFBQ1XJBOWx8lKnTcBbYQJC_GCpYAI9ss5eEmsqvJDkgD1A3iBlBgZT0Y7f80Fz3.A__9ToLXphVaE.Gq44uRP5anPESLVx1zQyyO.rtIpJ0MAuhj4HT2Wuck2td7Ka93vYyWATL4sZywUQdHbowoQB7DOMuRxTjmJv67UeCUFmVV0tVpzX.qM.JvTBPsNL0JKnhOxQCRfPAcGQ6PNLuHe0l5eKhIK9kZ0DFhQOa8oUyh3Ie0GjASBW0Q1dnsetwAiuYUQWXRiG9oSk1dYlNYpDPILEDtMHu2N38__YY52pSJEgHIolBfc9H4allBdUjMMVJBngzaVEn5wHd8QKsssYpGylfR6qUfLVnGCT9WSpAWWOwG6VjwgZ7aFwrUNmpuGu9Sg1S2T2.KIjTxuxHmxtFlmTOOfs2NmRmJuRsgz5NslUmai0dap6SfvJaTkJTZd85bkJ9wK6eFzryaBsKiA6ujIBGfhjAdHtdqZcdC0MslUptt39AEPNLtLAHsBW6XVjyFkSzn4MqyokYFbCKm4dNEQYdVrwAcvxkmeVCynhIkHKxTWGC8WuEOBYSL9NjUzd6nQsME7FUo.Wfj5zjVvk_pox_gjX2OwrhzS9m1e6pGksRhw75_2OWqdKKcxTS66mS8QAVBHXklXdJAk7uOBhIGkDOjylk.3jEPTit1se_MVbla9_xa_AvuIT5uEJX7DxeYPLUe4kuonmYDb22krTcgFHVWD1qU7_S8ju2i5TqUPzbY1xYdrKTzH42eO1M1tPttB8nm9Iww_zmDxx4QFrZNv31KofJ_UP.ft1KsYxx3zy_CbofBsfG4pAvXqgrC4jF3XvWCzKJdNxLcVD3Ky9FtORV.Kp0_4WQKenULq6d3b69.OgPRovI.0bb3tSXdApt8bfhZvlVVhXF1Nf4_zLgfvEd6FWy3bV5W9MN86OD9HXxhej67mYlZj03boTO0tnghUC0ucfarxz7NlN0PovEtFKf2OZLJbXPZrqjZCCAHIw._bo6ZL7arsGw7cyCO3lco6Gu9jBbWzl_qdR32usojNb4rm_h.rZf.Ezjtj0jlKPOQC5NKTCXmSwJC4fjtjiLJ2rHTECQEc8fvIMx6yeoUG6pay0LDr99tl3xDmAjcsE3p4jEuLGqT8NmL74siITDwj7gGc5KzqdmGT0._siyes3ky7qx9kJIDaetsERowHVpcEaOyijgka.ur4XFa9X3mWxDXAbdpjruy_AWrLmFLQGsyYWzURL_lXk6wlpQVzXnRHC741O1U_8GfG_bUzagVtAv3MgePVmyGDJozOq7nHvXYk2JL.PYB6MmhQPykgeWEd9UB8dYm4qDWXL_Y_IB0BzQ3ioYU5bDAI.PXTBsIST7oSgaz5UbhcRuxWqJ26BrSLFvaCgSnm0jkp5ekTuS6uYRK.x9s.FixvmHNPudRXv7eao.PWOXEa24CbstG4B16evDQS4jZJtnMRatVwbRehKvR8OwwYIIQ7OLDy4cdvrO.YJmbRQEoDs9r9vhBTrOi7K.UQ0bO1tn4drOMJE8ACk7r6W6kPkOlV1P2Jwg83B_Tde0YZPIEktreUS1_RHzKYbBRXbjyyu7v9_LkVO8I0EWaLdzvrXcUZtidFy0LUhCr9Vu125sQHCR3KUvvKXh_5SemhznKTxEbN4TIikH9QbVCFtyUg6H813oEcKlAX7SQPdjdSF2R1Lk9LJPYbUjYiAY4.ebIksQKOjWzUJkuIRFitTbuQrdhlyKZUUWYorxCKpMnONYRNko0Ya8yIrQY0.Sr2s2ffpei_9H_mgRA19MBKR4vHXqkHGYWIMWit9cVbaZoZ0M08h0RKNDI7wWAvk6aRXWaEWxOB62l5tXU5FHl4nQx22CKllmNyKXOxnGn5PGmNtQelWKF12yxczx_NVBBfvOWoPt9I4xXPFz6Pyb0aWEAtWG4LBOVKpWgF40RC2f93yF1IygKEgdjYAYuvPivcTHY90GZdXhJBxMmDbtRUIMvdTI6V8KrlmbZOOILdOnjRqKwoOgy.v74d3KefzdqPEsman46pny0Jx2z6QB60xIZxsq0rEGDP0DolTnjuwrqnKf6FD1UdIpWB.9JEcqWE5xXWwVkcC3ZBP0zQvsxuDrz3XC3Qj4kHs6XTl5mHexaefeXBSCzgxGf_gzm1Fz8vVGYDAcWHa1j9maiD_wSKeiOcdTBnB9yyC9gJNDBuMv6QY_L9ygym2lgIr6ThX6Y.CuhcWBHlIXQg_E7Hog_DFI8rnmcNIUlMuw8_nAhWtq1ZC1H7bZNSNBxuQlPdGiSd446V6GyGdZYywKzI2oRWpeFIkLVh4jJkrLrhJWmDAZaqlDxGqLb6O0jRhwWjdvCgGm4TPs3s8I7cAHWm",mdrd: "l3l4S6kckawDtAWa3WurtJsaDdwHTlywo0pbHOvKvLM-1732770751-1.2.1.1-TUCWf0lV0w6U5TeENA05Luwpvcfawvv3_tho_OYMgsT8Afxj6MkdowylnJz_UJ8qutUndi9S3P1J9sn3XvlBjA2iA5IV8hPhnBxES71cMJvYo1D9wi6KPQNFWDZcYJqqS005UHfcPAAZk.qZIX5vihShbSKbnT3vKEk7fDyfRdRWrMwPdSyUNVEREF3b7_i7.N.vEebmZotBuQ2nFB5WzaUvlSACKwfJymflBnSgYEhSUV3ykS4S5Zxl6T5xLUINmm3ecjCoPGc3suT8kvSTyTd0gwC83GGR6uMXXYime6dEUwzBXvPObEUIMTBm2atrcSKLr0Nx4DLgRTazDkbHMWeF2dg10FfFs1D4xhRMhExy57XefJd9GF44T0sEIwzkVBq2GeNziNdOQbLLuiJFRCLciay2qr3f_9jMLy_Yfhmujadpoe3_KpJ47st2TH6KF93Rrn6vFyjUXuE2VG4kaWe14G7rJC_sYvs.o_.zJJ1SUIWkHe6fkJJ9H9Xz1MVUJvQlVP8efvAqQ4Ae4Ta_Ouh3XaCTy7KkpXQOHoq.l_KtmPhqk17eFL_YD60trlwlrL.z1KR7KD_t8P69mEHqnx4W3DUVbxhL_kfM4y8WeHa2Ylm6_zEys1aSN4leUq8fvyRqCR7cX6FNBoDF0o7d9o4Z02vcX_LlUle8u_2yKHcdehmg3xofxGQl.puDbTIpUbs6DC1ELyo25vGsW1YrkooZ6ndwrs3OZvq4nocNxf22MsnzqDx11lSv3xlGpO.E7aMqNLW7Tc8DyAVqPL2zi4xow7tN0GYhpCiKoQFd7v1U.w9X_uMVPxtOs59SmuRSADBRttCkAYj1Z03aTmhppzUb9UBht6a6VZR4u1sOEG2z271oSMX6NEYgdrtTlwD4PtstrGCOuIr96ampiEWN7nfdtDlZkaB0VcRfyTLmblf7RagMxS0p.6c2xHf7HCHTUDz0zj34qep5cseEIs47hzBdeXjT4IlWp7VjjIswsOvhEPFvBp.3YOTT_bNMAQUqUV4LnXDuSzP26kjsacGpNKq0hUR8vYf_43tnzVxbnFiZOMcIImLu81cqfwjNgLpeQawP7T5WlV1RrsEjiJnXkmj3UAalMtI8DyRkbin30CA8qBI5BxvRC8Jo.vRzczUooN6bwJ1Oeiml48oGTfjnDkoYJk_mcgCniN3FOKXQQEyFqcr6nj0qAlaxUdtWpk6o7l.opUKB4YphEnN4w1ZSwiKzWTcmwa_yvc3JcXiZqU6i5EsIqSQ79XMuuXD86omHutM3_j7M9gNBPtEOf1uOuf8.pu6tyC8lg2uxQV46mX2nfQN_nNnaV39dRKBENc_RlSvN9i7P.lOOZI524cNXfgsuDBSgCIhF52lPg66BQU.NucwqbsrEzDL.aaQF6AOW366_q9lyuEjlzI9rXZ9zpxGkjvHD5eX5h_aZ6qRs39PogAAPIBt17XI95e.t4YmvmdUQHACKLW36PyvxqS7Mx6SgyLKbXlxaI2GzYe.L5fmJsfwVUONhhDCIgnuOLEep.xoI2VVucweuHbCsnrxZBadFJXX.H2DOrk9mYg6zlc_LbjLe2n8vEGhbsQzSSziXtFVsb9JKXJ13BG7THrqZ.Im5v9UEBxdL2YG6EiME9wqesb_g2T16ZgvRJsdOUVngcKAFUW5DO8AcY8yUdef5ZQrnRbUKxRl7VTFhZ0gb.yoqIT.rCK2LHRB2P5AZaRLmda.w0D96v8TBl_tWQbjkCnU68nZbd5WupG6gauzYTFj2Tr6GcIigHBhCWeXdgV30aVoHQliO9fkmFLAwk9i5eDmmuTerI3aW9PC7TYpLtZxMVAHOGT7eI9AGT3Lcls5DyhuhBYG5_6wVyl4njhWbbCUeyLRgC9zKeNxEQsKtLNU3JkZG.w1mrX.z9TkUNqrbR2HNu1qL6isYyyOOEJgUTUaAStX7zl4Y1RZdbip89OGgITaYWgwkKjcASDtqI85Z58y5tisOA4dDpqgllpj1R4qzesbaJV_ET4bWrbLoPA0"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e97dd0d2a2d3f5e';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/doi\/10.1098\/rsta.1954.0003?__cf_chl_rt_tk=28DAUmrqmrWG712s1Rq.PipU32QO7stf4wOs1JzMJfE-1732770751-1.0.1.1-MlFqRXq5VuYsly8PpwmGg0.ke8MlZoFxpslYTJFAlrw" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>