CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en-US"><head> <meta charset="utf-8"/> <link rel="dns-prefetch preconnect" href="https://u.jimcdn.com/" crossorigin="anonymous"/> <link rel="dns-prefetch preconnect" href="https://assets.jimstatic.com/" crossorigin="anonymous"/> <link rel="dns-prefetch preconnect" href="https://image.jimcdn.com" crossorigin="anonymous"/> <link rel="dns-prefetch preconnect" href="https://fonts.jimstatic.com" crossorigin="anonymous"/> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1"/> <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge"/> <meta name="description" content="AI policy, Artificial Intelligence, EU AI Act, democratic values, data protection, fairness, innovation, universal guidelines for AI, human rights, CAIDP, Marc Rotenberg, Merve Hickok"/> <meta name="robots" content="index, follow, archive"/> <meta property="st:section" content="AI policy, Artificial Intelligence, EU AI Act, democratic values, data protection, fairness, innovation, universal guidelines for AI, human rights, CAIDP, Marc Rotenberg, Merve Hickok"/> <meta name="twitter:title" content="Commentaries"/> <meta name="twitter:description" content="AI policy, Artificial Intelligence, EU AI Act, democratic values, data protection, fairness, innovation, universal guidelines for AI, human rights, CAIDP, Marc Rotenberg, Merve Hickok"/> <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"/> <meta property="og:url" content="https://www.caidp.org/resources/commentaries/"/> <meta property="og:title" content="Commentaries"/> <meta property="og:description" content="AI policy, Artificial Intelligence, EU AI Act, democratic values, data protection, fairness, innovation, universal guidelines for AI, human rights, CAIDP, Marc Rotenberg, Merve Hickok"/> <meta property="og:type" content="website"/> <meta property="og:locale" content="en_US"/> <meta property="og:site_name" content="Center for AI and Digital Policy"/> <meta name="twitter:image" content="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/backgroundarea/i9e4d152ac18b61f8/version/1596465197/image.png"/> <meta property="og:image" content="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/backgroundarea/i9e4d152ac18b61f8/version/1596465197/image.png"/> <meta property="og:image:width" content="2000"/> <meta property="og:image:height" content="1500"/> <meta property="og:image:secure_url" content="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/backgroundarea/i9e4d152ac18b61f8/version/1596465197/image.png"/><title>Commentaries - Center for AI and Digital Policy</title> <link rel="shortcut icon" href="https://u.jimcdn.com/cms/o/s899a9742c3d83292/img/favicon.ico?t=1596998275"/> <link rel="canonical" href="https://www.caidp.org/resources/commentaries/"/> <script src="https://assets.jimstatic.com/ckies.js.54abd4eb87c8e3e6186f.js"></script> <script src="https://assets.jimstatic.com/cookieControl.js.e8e4baf1fbac126ff67a.js"></script> <script>window.CookieControlSet.setToOff();</script> <style>html,body{margin:0}.hidden{display:none}.n{padding:5px}#cc-website-title a {text-decoration: none}.cc-m-image-align-1{text-align:left}.cc-m-image-align-2{text-align:right}.cc-m-image-align-3{text-align:center}</style> <link href="https://u.jimcdn.com/cms/o/s899a9742c3d83292/layout/dm_11de6aa15679483822a5e8672190aa25/css/layout.css?t=1624027046" rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" id="jimdo_layout_css"/> <script> /* <![CDATA[ */ /*! loadCss [c]2014 @scottjehl, Filament Group, Inc. Licensed MIT */ window.loadCSS = window.loadCss = function(e,n,t){var r,l=window.document,a=l.createElement("link");if(n)r=n;else{var i=(l.body||l.getElementsByTagName("head")[0]).childNodes;r=i[i.length-1]}var o=l.styleSheets;a.rel="stylesheet",a.href=e,a.media="only x",r.parentNode.insertBefore(a,n?r:r.nextSibling);var d=function(e){for(var n=a.href,t=o.length;t--;)if(o[t].href===n)return e.call(a);setTimeout(function(){d(e)})};return a.onloadcssdefined=d,d(function(){a.media=t||"all"}),a}; window.onloadCSS = function(n,o){n.onload=function(){n.onload=null,o&&o.call(n)},"isApplicationInstalled"in navigator&&"onloadcssdefined"in n&&n.onloadcssdefined(o)} /* ]]> */ </script> <script> // <![CDATA[ onloadCSS(loadCss('https://assets.jimstatic.com/web.css.6171c4a35b361b9030cb24d6de8164b8.css') , function() { this.id = 'jimdo_web_css'; }); // ]]> </script> <link href="https://assets.jimstatic.com/web.css.6171c4a35b361b9030cb24d6de8164b8.css" rel="preload" as="style"/> <noscript> <link href="https://assets.jimstatic.com/web.css.6171c4a35b361b9030cb24d6de8164b8.css" rel="stylesheet"/> </noscript> <script> //<![CDATA[ var jimdoData = {"isTestserver":false,"isLcJimdoCom":false,"isJimdoHelpCenter":false,"isProtectedPage":false,"cstok":"","cacheJsKey":"71824522e789e082b8b9210fef58f8d2a2fbed11","cacheCssKey":"71824522e789e082b8b9210fef58f8d2a2fbed11","cdnUrl":"https:\/\/assets.jimstatic.com\/","minUrl":"https:\/\/assets.jimstatic.com\/app\/cdn\/min\/file\/","authUrl":"https:\/\/a.jimdo.com\/","webPath":"https:\/\/www.caidp.org\/","appUrl":"https:\/\/a.jimdo.com\/","cmsLanguage":"en_US","isFreePackage":false,"mobile":false,"isDevkitTemplateUsed":true,"isTemplateResponsive":true,"websiteId":"s899a9742c3d83292","pageId":1401367663,"packageId":3,"shop":{"deliveryTimeTexts":{"1":"Ships within 1-3 days","2":"Ships within 3-5 days","3":"Delivery in 5-8 days"},"checkoutButtonText":"Check out","isReady":false,"currencyFormat":{"pattern":"\u00a4#,##0.00","convertedPattern":"$#,##0.00","symbols":{"GROUPING_SEPARATOR":",","DECIMAL_SEPARATOR":".","CURRENCY_SYMBOL":"$"}},"currencyLocale":"en_US"},"tr":{"gmap":{"searchNotFound":"The entered address doesn't exist or couldn't be found.","routeNotFound":"The driving directions couldn't be determined. Possible reasons: The starting address is not specific enough or it is too far from the destination address."},"shop":{"checkoutSubmit":{"next":"Next step","wait":"Please wait"},"paypalError":"An error has occurred. Please try again!","cartBar":"Go to Shopping Cart","maintenance":"Sorry, this store is not available at the moment. Please try again later.","addToCartOverlay":{"productInsertedText":"This item was added to your cart.","continueShoppingText":"Continue shopping","reloadPageText":"Refresh"},"notReadyText":"This store has not been completely set up.","numLeftText":"There are not more than {:num} of this item available at this time.","oneLeftText":"There is only one more of this item available."},"common":{"timeout":"Oops, it looks like there's been an error on our end and your last change didn't go through. Please try again in a minute. "},"form":{"badRequest":"An error has occurred! This form could not be submitted. Please try again later."}},"jQuery":"jimdoGen002","isJimdoMobileApp":false,"bgConfig":{"id":54572063,"type":"slideshow","options":{"fixed":true,"speed":0},"images":[{"id":5419815563,"url":"https:\/\/image.jimcdn.com\/app\/cms\/image\/transf\/none\/path\/s899a9742c3d83292\/backgroundarea\/i9e4d152ac18b61f8\/version\/1596465197\/image.png"},{"id":5419815663,"url":"https:\/\/image.jimcdn.com\/app\/cms\/image\/transf\/none\/path\/s899a9742c3d83292\/backgroundarea\/i8c693e3d0e49c6af\/version\/1596465197\/image.png"}]},"bgFullscreen":null,"responsiveBreakpointLandscape":767,"responsiveBreakpointPortrait":480,"copyableHeadlineLinks":false,"tocGeneration":false,"googlemapsConsoleKey":false,"loggingForAnalytics":false,"loggingForPredefinedPages":false,"isFacebookPixelIdEnabled":false,"userAccountId":"2515ca28-8c90-4414-82cd-f23acfaedfe7"}; // ]]> </script> <script> (function(window) { 'use strict'; var regBuff = window.__regModuleBuffer = []; var regModuleBuffer = function() { var args = [].slice.call(arguments); regBuff.push(args); }; if (!window.regModule) { window.regModule = regModuleBuffer; } })(window); </script> <script src="https://assets.jimstatic.com/web.js.2a142273794813e6f1d1.js" async="true"></script> <script src="https://assets.jimstatic.com/at.js.f4680ead6f240367d9f9.js"></script> <style type="text/css"> /*<![CDATA[*/ //.jtpl-header { position: absolute; z-index: 10; top: 0; width: 100%; } //.jtpl-header.navigation-colors { position: absolute; z-index: 10; top: 0; width: 100%; } .center { text-align: center; } .center-image { display: block; margin-left: auto; margin-right: 49%; width: 50%; } /*shop items*/ .j-catalog-product-title-link { font-size: 1.5em; } .cc-product-details.j-catalog-product-details { margin-top: 12px; } .jtpl-header--image.jqbga-container { top: 82px; } .jtpl-breadcrumb.alignment-options { display:none; } //.jtpl-header.navigation-colors { display:none; } .jtpl-header { box-shadow:none; } .jtpl-header--image.jqbga-container.jdbga-web--color { display:none; top: 82px; } .jtpl-content.alignment-options.content-options-inner.cc-content-parent { max-width: 1280px; } .jtpl-header__inner.alignment-options.navigation-vertical-alignment { max-width: 1280px; } .jtpl-sidebar__inner.alignment-options { max-width: 1280px; } .jtpl-section-main.content-options-box.cc-content-parent { padding-bottom: 0px; } .j-module.n.j-imageSubtitle { padding-top: 0px; } .jtpl-content.alignment-options.content-options-inner.cc-content-parent { padding-top: 0px; } } .jtpl-logo { margin-top: 0px !important; } .jtpl-content.alignment-options.content-options-inner.cc-content-parent { padding-bottom: 0px; } //.jtpl-header--image.jqbga-container.jqbga-web--image { height: 420px; } .j-calltoaction-link.j-calltoaction-link-style-1 { padding-top: 10px; padding-bottom: 10px; } /*fade in no color*/ #cf { position:relative; height:200px; width:200px; margin:0 auto; } #cf img { position:absolute; -webkit-transition: opacity 1s ease-in-out; -moz-transition: opacity 1s ease-in-out; -o-transition: opacity 1s ease-in-out; transition: opacity 1s ease-in-out; } #cf img.top:hover { opacity:0; } /*text Animations*/ [data-animate-in] { opacity: 0; transition: transform 0.8s ease, opacity 0.8s ease } [data-animate-in="up"] { transform: translate3d(0, 34px, 0) } [data-animate-in="up1"] { transform: translate3d(0, 24px, 0) } [data-animate-in="up2"] { transform: translate3d(0, 38px, 0) } [data-animate-in="up3"] { transform: translate3d(0, 44px, 0) } [data-animate-in="up4"] { transform: translate3d(0, 4px, 0) } [data-animate-in="up5"] { transform: translate3d(0, 54px, 0) } [data-animate-in="left"] { transform: translate3d(-25%, 0, 0) } [data-animate-in="right"] { transform: translate3d(25%, 0, 0) } [data-animate-in="down"] { transform: translate3d(0, -24px, 0) } [data-animate-in="fadeIn"] { transform: translate3d(0, 0, 0) } [data-animate-in].in-view { opacity: 1; transform: translate3d(0, 0, 0); -webkit-transform: translate3d(0, 0, 0); transition: transform 0.6s ease, opacity 0.6s ease } .fade-in { opacity: 0; transition: opacity 1s ease } .page-loaded .fade-in,.page-loaded.fade-in { opacity: 1 } .isSafari.isTouch [data-animate-in],.isSafari.isTouch [data-animate-in="up"] { opacity: 1; transition: none; transform: none } /*cursors*/ div.box1:hover { cursor: hand; cursor: pointer; opacity: .9; } /*full width*/ .slider { position: relative; } .slider { width: 100vw !important; margin-left: calc(-50vw + 50% - 8px); position: relative; } /*slider*/ .slider { max-width: 1920px; height: 500px; position: relative; } .slide1,.slide2,.slide3 { position: absolute; width: 100%; height: 100%; } .slide1 { background: url(https://99designs-5f118e858db04.jimdofree.com/app/download/8219959763/shake-it-mid-slides1.jpg?t=1595503258)no-repeat center; background-size: cover; animation:fade 22s infinite; -webkit-animation:fade 22s infinite; } .slide2 { background: url(https://99designs-5f118e858db04.jimdofree.com/app/download/8219959863/shake-it-mid-slides2.jpg?t=1595503258)no-repeat center; background-size: cover; animation:fade2 22s infinite; -webkit-animation:fade2 22s infinite; } .slide3 { background: url(https://99designs-5f118e858db04.jimdofree.com/app/download/8219959963/shake-it-mid-slides3.jpg?t=1595503258)no-repeat center; background-size: cover; animation:fade3 22s infinite; -webkit-animation:fade3 22s infinite; } @keyframes fade { 0% {opacity:1} 33.333% { opacity: 0} 66.666% { opacity: 0} 100% { opacity: 1} } @keyframes fade2 { 0% {opacity:0} 33.333% { opacity: 1} 66.666% { opacity: 0 } 100% { opacity: 0} } @keyframes fade3 { 0% {opacity:0} 33.333% { opacity: 0} 66.666% { opacity: 1} 100% { opacity: 0} } /*zoom effect*/ .photo-grid { margin: auto; text-align: center; } .photo-grid .grid-item { display: inline-block; margin: auto; } .photo-grid img { display: block; height: auto; max-width: 100%; } .photo-grid figure { height: 360px; overflow: hidden; position: relative; width: 100%; } .photo-grid figcaption { background: rgba(0, 79, 143, 0.7); color: white; display: table; height: 100%; left: 0; opacity: 0; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; z-index: 100; } .photo-grid figcaption p { display: table-cell; font-size: 2.3em; position: relative; top: -40px; vertical-align: middle; } .photo-grid .grid-item:hover figcaption { opacity: 1; } .photo-grid img { display: block; height: auto; -webkit-transition: all 600ms; -moz-transition: all 600ms; transition: all 600ms; max-width: 100%; } .photo-grid .grid-item:hover img { -webkit-transform: scale(1.4); -moz-transform: scale(1.4); transform: scale(1.4); } .photo-grid figcaption p { display: table-cell; font-size: 1.9em; position: relative; top: -40px; width: 600px; -webkit-transition: all 600ms ease-out; -moz-transition: all 600ms ease-out; transition: all 600ms ease-out; vertical-align: middle; } .photo-grid .grid-item:hover figcaption p { -moz-transform: translateY(40px); -webkit-transform: translateY(40px); transform: translateY(40px); } .photo-grid figcaption { background: rgba(0, 79, 143, 0.7); color: white; display: table; height: 100%; left: 0; opacity: 0; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; -webkit-transition: all 600ms; -moz-transition: all 600ms; transition: all 600ms; -webkit-transition-delay: 100ms; -moz-transition-delay: 100ms; transition-delay: 100ms; z-index: 100; } /*fade-in effect*/ .fadein1 { opacity:0; } .fadein2 { opacity:0; } .fadein3 { opacity:0; } .fadein4 { opacity:0; } /*]]>*/ </style> <script src="https://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jquery/1.8.1/jquery.min.js" type="text/javascript"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> //<![CDATA[ $(document).ready(function() { $( "#cc-m-8224736463" ).wrap( "<div id='section1' />" ); $( "#cc-m-8224745763" ).wrap( "<div id='section2' />" ); $( "#cc-m-8224738463" ).wrap( "<div id='section3' />" ); $( "#cc-m-8224738863" ).wrap( "<div id='section4' />" ); }); /* This code for div click */ $(document).ready(function() { $(".box1").click(function(){ window.location=$(this).find("a").attr("href"); return false; }); }); /* This code for text anim*/ $(function() { var html = $('html'); // Detections if (!("ontouchstart" in window)) { html.addClass("noTouch"); } if ("ontouchstart" in window) { html.addClass("isTouch"); } if ("ontouchstart" in window) { html.addClass("isTouch"); } if (document.documentMode || /Edge/.test(navigator.userAgent)) { if (navigator.appVersion.indexOf("Trident") === -1) { html.addClass("isEDGE"); } else { html.addClass("isIE isIE11"); } } if (navigator.appVersion.indexOf("MSIE") !== -1) { html.addClass("isIE"); } if ( navigator.userAgent.indexOf("Safari") != -1 && navigator.userAgent.indexOf("Chrome") == -1 ) { html.addClass("isSafari"); } // On Screen $.fn.isOnScreen = function() { var elementTop = $(this).offset().top, elementBottom = elementTop + $(this).outerHeight(), viewportTop = $(window).scrollTop(), viewportBottom = viewportTop + $(window).height(); return elementBottom > viewportTop && elementTop < viewportBottom; }; function detection() { for (var i = 0; i < items.length; i++) { var el = $(items[i]); if (el.isOnScreen()) { el.addClass("in-view"); } else { el.removeClass("in-view"); } } } var items = document.querySelectorAll( "*[data-animate-in], *[data-detect-viewport]" ), waiting = false, w = $(window); w.on("resize scroll", function() { if (waiting) { return; } waiting = true; detection(); setTimeout(function() { waiting = false; }, 100); }); $(document).ready(function() { setTimeout(function() { detection(); }, 500); for (var i = 0; i < items.length; i++) { var d = 0, el = $(items[i]); if (items[i].getAttribute("data-animate-in-delay")) { d = items[i].getAttribute("data-animate-in-delay") / 1000 + "s"; } else { d = 0; } el.css("transition-delay", d); } }); }); /* This code for fadein */ $(document).ready(function() { $(window).scroll( function(){ $('.fadein1').each( function(i){ var bottom_of_element = $(this).offset().top + $(this).outerHeight(); var bottom_of_window = $(window).scrollTop() + $(window).height(); if( bottom_of_window > bottom_of_element ){ $(this).animate({'opacity':'1'},1000); } }); }); }); $(document).ready(function() { $(window).scroll( function(){ $('.fadein2').each( function(i){ var bottom_of_element = $(this).offset().top + $(this).outerHeight(); var bottom_of_window = $(window).scrollTop() + $(window).height(); if( bottom_of_window > bottom_of_element ){ $(this).animate({'opacity':'1'},2000); } }); }); }); $(document).ready(function() { $(window).scroll( function(){ $('.fadein3').each( function(i){ var bottom_of_element = $(this).offset().top + $(this).outerHeight(); var bottom_of_window = $(window).scrollTop() + $(window).height(); if( bottom_of_window > bottom_of_element ){ $(this).animate({'opacity':'1'},3000); } }); }); }); $(document).ready(function() { $(window).scroll( function(){ $('.fadein4').each( function(i){ var bottom_of_element = $(this).offset().top + $(this).outerHeight(); var bottom_of_window = $(window).scrollTop() + $(window).height(); if( bottom_of_window > bottom_of_element ){ $(this).animate({'opacity':'1'},4000); } }); }); }); //]]> </script> <style type="text/css"> /*<![CDATA[*/ /* This code prevents side-scrolling */ body { overflow-x: hidden;} .jtpl-main {overflow-x:hidden;} /* This is a fullwidth section - add your comment to describe it */ #section1 { margin: 0 -9999rem; padding: 0.25rem 9999rem; background: url("https://99designs-5f189c27d6be7.jimdofree.com/app/download/8229442463/blue.jpg?t=1596802219") repeat center center; } #section2 { margin: 0 -9999rem; padding: 0.25rem 9999rem; background: url("https://99designs-5f189c27d6be7.jimdofree.com/app/download/8229442963/center-mid1.jpg?t=1596802233") repeat center center; } #section3 { margin: 0 -9999rem; padding: 0.25rem 9999rem; background: url("https://99designs-5f189c27d6be7.jimdofree.com/app/download/8229446163/light-grey.jpg?t=1596802455") repeat center center; } #section4 { margin: 0 -9999rem; padding: 0.25rem 9999rem; background: url("https://99designs-5f189c27d6be7.jimdofree.com/app/download/8229446163/light-grey.jpg?t=1596802455") repeat center center; } /*]]>*/ </style> </head> <body class="body cc-page j-m-gallery-styles j-m-video-styles j-m-hr-styles j-m-header-styles j-m-text-styles j-m-emotionheader-styles j-m-htmlCode-styles j-m-rss-styles j-m-form-styles j-m-table-styles j-m-textWithImage-styles j-m-downloadDocument-styles j-m-imageSubtitle-styles j-m-flickr-styles j-m-googlemaps-styles j-m-blogSelection-styles j-m-comment-styles-disabled j-m-jimdo-styles j-m-profile-styles j-m-guestbook-styles j-m-promotion-styles j-m-twitter-styles j-m-hgrid-styles j-m-shoppingcart-styles j-m-catalog-styles j-m-product-styles-disabled j-m-facebook-styles j-m-sharebuttons-styles j-m-formnew-styles j-m-callToAction-styles j-m-turbo-styles j-m-spacing-styles j-m-googleplus-styles j-m-dummy-styles j-m-search-styles j-m-booking-styles j-footer-styles cc-pagemode-default cc-content-parent" id="page-1401367663"> <div id="cc-inner" class="cc-content-parent"> <input type="checkbox" id="jtpl-mobile-navigation__checkbox" class="jtpl-mobile-navigation__checkbox"/><div class="jtpl-main cc-content-parent">  <div class="jtpl-background-area" background-area="fullscreen"></div>   <div class="jtpl-top-bar navigation-colors">  <label for="jtpl-mobile-navigation__checkbox" class="jtpl-mobile-navigation__label navigation-colors--transparency"> <span class="jtpl-mobile-navigation__borders navigation-colors__menu-icon"></span> </label>  </div>   <nav class="jtpl-mobile-navigation navigation-colors navigation-colors--transparency"><div data-container="navigation"><div class="j-nav-variant-nested"><ul class="cc-nav-level-0 j-nav-level-0"><li id="cc-nav-view-1396341963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0"><a href="/" data-link-title="Home">Home</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403393363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/statements/" data-link-title="Statements">Statements</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1403393363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1404391663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/support-ukraine/" data-link-title="Support-Ukraine">Support-Ukraine</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1405109863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/ostp/" data-link-title="OSTP">OSTP</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406706863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/ban-facial-surveillance-technology/" data-link-title="Ban Facial Surveillance Technology">Ban Facial Surveillance Technology</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406659663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/civil-society-coe-and-eu/" data-link-title="Civil Society - COE and EU">Civil Society - COE and EU</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403393463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/reports/" data-link-title="Reports">Reports</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1403393463" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1410983563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/reports/aidv-2023/" data-link-title="AIDV-2023">AIDV-2023</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1410983563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1411039163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/reports/aidv-2023/aidv-maps-2023/" data-link-title="AIDV Maps 2023">AIDV Maps 2023</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408147463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/reports/aidv-2022/" data-link-title="AIDV-2022">AIDV-2022</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1408147463" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1407679963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/reports/aidv-2022/aidv-maps-2022/" data-link-title="AIDV Maps 2022">AIDV Maps 2022</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403490263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/aidv-2021/" data-link-title="AIDV-2021">AIDV-2021</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1398884363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/aidv-2020/" data-link-title="AIDV-2020">AIDV-2020</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/publications/" data-link-title="Publications">Publications</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1399569363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/public-voice/" data-link-title="Public Voice">Public Voice</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1399569363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1413024663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ai-treaty-now/" data-link-title="AI-Treaty-Now">AI-Treaty-Now</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408757863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ai-action-plan-ostp-2025/" data-link-title="AI Action Plan (OSTP 2025)">AI Action Plan (OSTP 2025)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1413128363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/copyright-office-us-2023-1/" data-link-title="Copyright Office (US 2023)">Copyright Office (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409429563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/fec-us-2023/" data-link-title="FEC (US 2023)">FEC (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408827063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ftc-cloud-computing-us-2023/" data-link-title="FTC Cloud Computing (US 2023)">FTC Cloud Computing (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409321863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ntia-ai-accountability-us-2023/" data-link-title="NTIA AI Accountability (US 2023)">NTIA AI Accountability (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409913563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/omb-us-2023/" data-link-title="OMB (US 2023)">OMB (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408755263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ostp-ai-strategy-us-2023/" data-link-title="OSTP AI Strategy (US 2023)">OSTP AI Strategy (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408723963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ostp-workers-and-ai-us-2023/" data-link-title="OSTP Workers and AI (US 2023)">OSTP Workers and AI (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408637763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/pcast-us-2023/" data-link-title="PCAST (US 2023)">PCAST (US 2023)</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/" data-link-title="Events">Events</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1396342163" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1412674163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/procurement/" data-link-title="Procurement">Procurement</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411274863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/unesco/" data-link-title="UNESCO">UNESCO</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1410875563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/russell/" data-link-title="Russell">Russell</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411140163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/washdc24aidv/" data-link-title="WashDC24AIDV">WashDC24AIDV</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1411140163" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1408215363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc24aidv/speakers/" data-link-title="Speakers">Speakers</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408446163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc24aidv/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409882163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/uk-ai-summit/" data-link-title="UK AI Summit">UK AI Summit</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/" data-link-title="Oct2023-DC-UGAI">Oct2023-DC-UGAI</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1409669663" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/agenda/" data-link-title="Agenda">Agenda</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409670163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/bios/" data-link-title="Bios">Bios</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/endorse/" data-link-title="Endorse">Endorse</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/messages/" data-link-title="Messages">Messages</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/papers/" data-link-title="Papers">Papers</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408550663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/sept2023-dc-roundtable/" data-link-title="Sept2023-DC-Roundtable">Sept2023-DC-Roundtable</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409264663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/may2023-dc-roundtable/" data-link-title="May2023-DC-Roundtable">May2023-DC-Roundtable</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1409264663" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1408550863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/may2023-dc-roundtable/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408157563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/" data-link-title="WashDC23AIDV">WashDC23AIDV</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1408157563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1411069663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411069563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/speakers/" data-link-title="Speakers">Speakers</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408321263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/photos/" data-link-title="Photos">Photos</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408062263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/in-congress-house-oversight/" data-link-title="In Congress (House Oversight)">In Congress (House Oversight)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406612363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/broussard/" data-link-title="Broussard">Broussard</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408081563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/brusselseffect/" data-link-title="BrusselsEffect">BrusselsEffect</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407078763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/dataactivism/" data-link-title="DataActivism">DataActivism</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406850363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/surveillancestate/" data-link-title="SurveillanceState">SurveillanceState</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401367363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/employment/" data-link-title="Employment">Employment</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1400789763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/perfectweapon/" data-link-title="PerfectWeapon">PerfectWeapon</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403001563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/aidvparis2021/" data-link-title="AIDVPARIS2021">AIDVPARIS2021</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1404136463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/codedbias/" data-link-title="CodedBias">CodedBias</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401189763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/geniusmakers/" data-link-title="Geniusmakers">Geniusmakers</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401831263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/chess/" data-link-title="Chess">Chess</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406378163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/cahai/" data-link-title="CAHAI">CAHAI</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children cc-nav-parent j-nav-parent jmd-nav__item--parent"><a href="/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1396342563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1404012663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/ai-policy-frameworks/" data-link-title="AI Policy Frameworks">AI Policy Frameworks</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1404791263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/coe-ai-treaty/" data-link-title="COE AI Treaty">COE AI Treaty</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1404493663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/eu-ai-act/" data-link-title="EU AI Act">EU AI Act</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407810363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/g7/" data-link-title="G7">G7</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408016863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/g20/" data-link-title="G20">G20</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406637063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/naiac/" data-link-title="NAIAC">NAIAC</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407161063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/trade-and-technology-council/" data-link-title="Trade and Technology Council">Trade and Technology Council</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409125663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/united-nations/" data-link-title="United Nations">United Nations</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401367463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/bookstore/" data-link-title="Bookstore">Bookstore</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401367663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 cc-nav-current j-nav-current jmd-nav__item--current"><a href="/resources/commentaries/" data-link-title="Commentaries" class="cc-nav-current j-nav-current jmd-nav__link--current">Commentaries</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407030363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/cases/" data-link-title="Cases">Cases</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1407030363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1407030563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/cases/gonzalez-v-google/" data-link-title="Gonzalez v. Google">Gonzalez v. Google</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408134963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/cases/openai/" data-link-title="OpenAI">OpenAI</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409431163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/cases/zoom/" data-link-title="Zoom">Zoom</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/" data-link-title="Transparency Project">Transparency Project</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1407003263" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/doj/" data-link-title="DOJ">DOJ</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/naiac/" data-link-title="NAIAC">NAIAC</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/ostp/" data-link-title="OSTP">OSTP</a></li></ul></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1397319363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/about-2/" data-link-title="About">About</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1397319363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1396343263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/team/" data-link-title="Team">Team</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409130863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/about-2/structure/" data-link-title="Structure">Structure</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1409130863" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1409670263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/about-2/structure/sff-application/" data-link-title="SFF Application">SFF Application</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406321763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-fall/" data-link-title="Research Group 2025 - Spring">Research Group 2025 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412876063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-fall-1/" data-link-title="Research Group 2024 - Fall">Research Group 2024 - Fall</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412023363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-summer-1/" data-link-title="Research Group 2024 - Summer">Research Group 2024 - Summer</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411472263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-spring/" data-link-title="Research Group 2024 - Spring">Research Group 2024 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1410566063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2023-fall/" data-link-title="Research Group 2023 - Fall">Research Group 2023 - Fall</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409196363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2023-summer/" data-link-title="Research Group 2023 - Summer">Research Group 2023 - Summer</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409196263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2023-spring/" data-link-title="Research Group 2023 - Spring">Research Group 2023 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407443163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2022-fall/" data-link-title="Research Group 2022 - Fall">Research Group 2022 - Fall</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403636063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2022-spring/" data-link-title="Research Group 2022 - Spring">Research Group 2022 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403804063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2021/" data-link-title="Research Group 2021">Research Group 2021</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/partners/" data-link-title="Partners">Partners</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406322463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/family-photo/" data-link-title="Family Photo">Family Photo</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406669063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/kudos/" data-link-title="Kudos">Kudos</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403393663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/contact/" data-link-title="Contact">Contact</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401461563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/global-academic-network/" data-link-title="Global Academic Network">Global Academic Network</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1401461563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1405583463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/global-academic-network/ai-policy-clinic/" data-link-title="AI Policy Clinic">AI Policy Clinic</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406851663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/awards/caidp-fellows/" data-link-title="CAIDP Fellows">CAIDP Fellows</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1405626663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/global-academic-network/extern-program/" data-link-title="Extern Program">Extern Program</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406851363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/awards/" data-link-title="Awards">Awards</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1406851363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1412679863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/awards/caidp-fellows-1/" data-link-title="CAIDP Fellows">CAIDP Fellows</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406868663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/awards/nominations/" data-link-title="Nominations">Nominations</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1402730363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0"><a href="/donate/" data-link-title="Donate">Donate</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409204263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0"><a href="/universal-guidelines-for-ai/" data-link-title="Universal Guidelines for AI">Universal Guidelines for AI</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411973763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/caidp-update/" data-link-title="CAIDP Update">CAIDP Update</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1411973763" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1411973663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-7-2025/" data-link-title="Volume 7 (2025)">Volume 7 (2025)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412975163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-6-2024-1/" data-link-title="Volume 6 (2024)">Volume 6 (2024)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411973963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-5-2023/" data-link-title="Volume 5 (2023)">Volume 5 (2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411979063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-4-2022/" data-link-title="Volume 4 (2022)">Volume 4 (2022)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/news/" data-link-title="News">News</a></li></ul></li></ul></div></div> </nav><header class="jtpl-header navigation-colors"><div class="jtpl-header__inner alignment-options navigation-vertical-alignment"> <div class="jtpl-logo"> <div id="cc-website-logo" class="cc-single-module-element"><div id="cc-m-8224770463" class="j-module n j-imageSubtitle"><div class="cc-m-image-container"><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-3"> <a href="https://www.caidp.org/" target="_self"><img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=280x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if596e88798f0ceda/version/1596465197/image.png 280w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if596e88798f0ceda/version/1596465197/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=560x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if596e88798f0ceda/version/1596465197/image.png 560w" sizes="(min-width: 280px) 280px, 100vw" id="cc-m-imagesubtitle-image-8224770463" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=280x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if596e88798f0ceda/version/1596465197/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="768" data-src-height="221" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=280x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if596e88798f0ceda/version/1596465197/image.png" data-image-id="5419815263"/></a> </figure> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8224770463">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_imageSubtitle", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"_blank","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8224770463,"widthEqualsContent":"1","resizeWidth":"280","resizeHeight":81},"id":8224770463}); // ]]> </script></div></div> </div>  <nav class="jtpl-navigation"><div class="jtpl-navigation__inner navigation-alignment" data-dropdown="true" data-main="true"> <div data-container="navigation"><div class="j-nav-variant-nested"><ul class="cc-nav-level-0 j-nav-level-0"><li id="cc-nav-view-1396341963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0"><a href="/" data-link-title="Home">Home</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403393363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/statements/" data-link-title="Statements">Statements</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1403393363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1404391663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/support-ukraine/" data-link-title="Support-Ukraine">Support-Ukraine</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1405109863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/ostp/" data-link-title="OSTP">OSTP</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406706863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/ban-facial-surveillance-technology/" data-link-title="Ban Facial Surveillance Technology">Ban Facial Surveillance Technology</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406659663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/statements/civil-society-coe-and-eu/" data-link-title="Civil Society - COE and EU">Civil Society - COE and EU</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403393463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/reports/" data-link-title="Reports">Reports</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1403393463" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1410983563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/reports/aidv-2023/" data-link-title="AIDV-2023">AIDV-2023</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1410983563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1411039163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/reports/aidv-2023/aidv-maps-2023/" data-link-title="AIDV Maps 2023">AIDV Maps 2023</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408147463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/reports/aidv-2022/" data-link-title="AIDV-2022">AIDV-2022</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1408147463" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1407679963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/reports/aidv-2022/aidv-maps-2022/" data-link-title="AIDV Maps 2022">AIDV Maps 2022</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403490263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/aidv-2021/" data-link-title="AIDV-2021">AIDV-2021</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1398884363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/aidv-2020/" data-link-title="AIDV-2020">AIDV-2020</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/reports/publications/" data-link-title="Publications">Publications</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1399569363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/public-voice/" data-link-title="Public Voice">Public Voice</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1399569363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1413024663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ai-treaty-now/" data-link-title="AI-Treaty-Now">AI-Treaty-Now</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408757863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ai-action-plan-ostp-2025/" data-link-title="AI Action Plan (OSTP 2025)">AI Action Plan (OSTP 2025)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1413128363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/copyright-office-us-2023-1/" data-link-title="Copyright Office (US 2023)">Copyright Office (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409429563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/fec-us-2023/" data-link-title="FEC (US 2023)">FEC (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408827063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ftc-cloud-computing-us-2023/" data-link-title="FTC Cloud Computing (US 2023)">FTC Cloud Computing (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409321863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ntia-ai-accountability-us-2023/" data-link-title="NTIA AI Accountability (US 2023)">NTIA AI Accountability (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409913563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/omb-us-2023/" data-link-title="OMB (US 2023)">OMB (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408755263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ostp-ai-strategy-us-2023/" data-link-title="OSTP AI Strategy (US 2023)">OSTP AI Strategy (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408723963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/ostp-workers-and-ai-us-2023/" data-link-title="OSTP Workers and AI (US 2023)">OSTP Workers and AI (US 2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408637763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/public-voice/pcast-us-2023/" data-link-title="PCAST (US 2023)">PCAST (US 2023)</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/" data-link-title="Events">Events</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1396342163" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1412674163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/procurement/" data-link-title="Procurement">Procurement</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411274863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/unesco/" data-link-title="UNESCO">UNESCO</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1410875563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/russell/" data-link-title="Russell">Russell</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411140163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/washdc24aidv/" data-link-title="WashDC24AIDV">WashDC24AIDV</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1411140163" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1408215363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc24aidv/speakers/" data-link-title="Speakers">Speakers</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408446163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc24aidv/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409882163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/uk-ai-summit/" data-link-title="UK AI Summit">UK AI Summit</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/" data-link-title="Oct2023-DC-UGAI">Oct2023-DC-UGAI</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1409669663" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/agenda/" data-link-title="Agenda">Agenda</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409670163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/bios/" data-link-title="Bios">Bios</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/endorse/" data-link-title="Endorse">Endorse</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/messages/" data-link-title="Messages">Messages</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409669963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/oct2023-dc-ugai/papers/" data-link-title="Papers">Papers</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408550663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/sept2023-dc-roundtable/" data-link-title="Sept2023-DC-Roundtable">Sept2023-DC-Roundtable</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409264663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/may2023-dc-roundtable/" data-link-title="May2023-DC-Roundtable">May2023-DC-Roundtable</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1409264663" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1408550863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/may2023-dc-roundtable/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408157563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/" data-link-title="WashDC23AIDV">WashDC23AIDV</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1408157563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1411069663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411069563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/speakers/" data-link-title="Speakers">Speakers</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408321263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/events/washdc23aidv/photos/" data-link-title="Photos">Photos</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408062263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/in-congress-house-oversight/" data-link-title="In Congress (House Oversight)">In Congress (House Oversight)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406612363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/broussard/" data-link-title="Broussard">Broussard</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408081563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/brusselseffect/" data-link-title="BrusselsEffect">BrusselsEffect</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407078763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/dataactivism/" data-link-title="DataActivism">DataActivism</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406850363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/surveillancestate/" data-link-title="SurveillanceState">SurveillanceState</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401367363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/employment/" data-link-title="Employment">Employment</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1400789763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/perfectweapon/" data-link-title="PerfectWeapon">PerfectWeapon</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403001563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/aidvparis2021/" data-link-title="AIDVPARIS2021">AIDVPARIS2021</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1404136463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/codedbias/" data-link-title="CodedBias">CodedBias</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401189763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/geniusmakers/" data-link-title="Geniusmakers">Geniusmakers</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401831263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/chess/" data-link-title="Chess">Chess</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406378163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/events/cahai/" data-link-title="CAHAI">CAHAI</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children cc-nav-parent j-nav-parent jmd-nav__item--parent"><a href="/resources/" data-link-title="Resources">Resources</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1396342563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1404012663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/ai-policy-frameworks/" data-link-title="AI Policy Frameworks">AI Policy Frameworks</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1404791263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/coe-ai-treaty/" data-link-title="COE AI Treaty">COE AI Treaty</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1404493663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/eu-ai-act/" data-link-title="EU AI Act">EU AI Act</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407810363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/g7/" data-link-title="G7">G7</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408016863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/g20/" data-link-title="G20">G20</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406637063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/naiac/" data-link-title="NAIAC">NAIAC</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407161063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/trade-and-technology-council/" data-link-title="Trade and Technology Council">Trade and Technology Council</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409125663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/united-nations/" data-link-title="United Nations">United Nations</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401367463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/resources/bookstore/" data-link-title="Bookstore">Bookstore</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401367663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 cc-nav-current j-nav-current jmd-nav__item--current"><a href="/resources/commentaries/" data-link-title="Commentaries" class="cc-nav-current j-nav-current jmd-nav__link--current">Commentaries</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407030363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/cases/" data-link-title="Cases">Cases</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1407030363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1407030563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/cases/gonzalez-v-google/" data-link-title="Gonzalez v. Google">Gonzalez v. Google</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1408134963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/cases/openai/" data-link-title="OpenAI">OpenAI</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409431163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/cases/zoom/" data-link-title="Zoom">Zoom</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/" data-link-title="Transparency Project">Transparency Project</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1407003263" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/doj/" data-link-title="DOJ">DOJ</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/naiac/" data-link-title="NAIAC">NAIAC</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407003463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/cases/transparency-project/ostp/" data-link-title="OSTP">OSTP</a></li></ul></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1397319363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/about-2/" data-link-title="About">About</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1397319363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1396343263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/team/" data-link-title="Team">Team</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409130863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/about-2/structure/" data-link-title="Structure">Structure</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1409130863" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-2 j-nav-level-2"><li id="cc-nav-view-1409670263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-2"><a href="/about-2/structure/sff-application/" data-link-title="SFF Application">SFF Application</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406321763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-fall/" data-link-title="Research Group 2025 - Spring">Research Group 2025 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412876063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-fall-1/" data-link-title="Research Group 2024 - Fall">Research Group 2024 - Fall</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412023363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-summer-1/" data-link-title="Research Group 2024 - Summer">Research Group 2024 - Summer</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411472263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2024-spring/" data-link-title="Research Group 2024 - Spring">Research Group 2024 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1410566063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2023-fall/" data-link-title="Research Group 2023 - Fall">Research Group 2023 - Fall</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409196363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2023-summer/" data-link-title="Research Group 2023 - Summer">Research Group 2023 - Summer</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409196263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2023-spring/" data-link-title="Research Group 2023 - Spring">Research Group 2023 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1407443163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2022-fall/" data-link-title="Research Group 2022 - Fall">Research Group 2022 - Fall</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403636063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2022-spring/" data-link-title="Research Group 2022 - Spring">Research Group 2022 - Spring</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403804063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/research-group-2021/" data-link-title="Research Group 2021">Research Group 2021</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/partners/" data-link-title="Partners">Partners</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406322463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/family-photo/" data-link-title="Family Photo">Family Photo</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406669063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/kudos/" data-link-title="Kudos">Kudos</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1403393663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/about-2/contact/" data-link-title="Contact">Contact</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1401461563" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/global-academic-network/" data-link-title="Global Academic Network">Global Academic Network</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1401461563" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1405583463" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/global-academic-network/ai-policy-clinic/" data-link-title="AI Policy Clinic">AI Policy Clinic</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406851663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/awards/caidp-fellows/" data-link-title="CAIDP Fellows">CAIDP Fellows</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1405626663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/global-academic-network/extern-program/" data-link-title="Extern Program">Extern Program</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406851363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/awards/" data-link-title="Awards">Awards</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1406851363" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1412679863" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/awards/caidp-fellows-1/" data-link-title="CAIDP Fellows">CAIDP Fellows</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1406868663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/awards/nominations/" data-link-title="Nominations">Nominations</a></li></ul></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1402730363" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0"><a href="/donate/" data-link-title="Donate">Donate</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1409204263" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0"><a href="/universal-guidelines-for-ai/" data-link-title="Universal Guidelines for AI">Universal Guidelines for AI</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411973763" class="jmd-nav__list-item-0 j-nav-has-children"><a href="/caidp-update/" data-link-title="CAIDP Update">CAIDP Update</a><span data-navi-toggle="cc-nav-view-1411973763" class="jmd-nav__toggle-button"></span><ul class="cc-nav-level-1 j-nav-level-1"><li id="cc-nav-view-1411973663" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-7-2025/" data-link-title="Volume 7 (2025)">Volume 7 (2025)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1412975163" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-6-2024-1/" data-link-title="Volume 6 (2024)">Volume 6 (2024)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411973963" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-5-2023/" data-link-title="Volume 5 (2023)">Volume 5 (2023)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1411979063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/caidp-update/volume-4-2022/" data-link-title="Volume 4 (2022)">Volume 4 (2022)</a></li><li id="cc-nav-view-1396342063" class="jmd-nav__list-item-1"><a href="/news/" data-link-title="News">News</a></li></ul></li></ul></div></div> </div> </nav> </div> </header><div class="jtpl-header--image" background-area="stripe" background-area-default=""></div>   <div class="jtpl-section-main content-options-box cc-content-parent">  <div class="jtpl-breadcrumb alignment-options"> <div class="jtpl-breadcrumb__inner flex-background-options"> <div class="jtpl-breadcrumb__title-navigation-gutter">  <div class="jtpl-title"> </div>  <div class="jtpl-breadcrumb__navigation breadcrumb-options"> <div data-container="navigation"><div class="j-nav-variant-breadcrumb"><ol itemscope="true" itemtype="http://schema.org/BreadcrumbList"><li itemscope="true" itemprop="itemListElement" itemtype="http://schema.org/ListItem"><a href="/resources/" data-link-title="Resources" itemprop="item"><span itemprop="name">Resources</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="1"/></li><li itemscope="true" itemprop="itemListElement" itemtype="http://schema.org/ListItem" class="cc-nav-current j-nav-current"><a href="/resources/commentaries/" data-link-title="Commentaries" itemprop="item" class="cc-nav-current j-nav-current"><span itemprop="name">Commentaries</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="2"/></li></ol></div></div> </div> </div> </div> </div>  <div class="jtpl-content alignment-options content-options-inner cc-content-parent"> <div id="content_area" data-container="content"><div id="content_start"></div> <div id="cc-matrix-2118500663"><div id="cc-m-8318382563" class="j-module n j-spacing "> <div class="cc-m-spacer" style="height: 50px;"> </div> </div><div id="cc-m-8318382663" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8318382763" class="j-module n j-header "><h1 class="" id="cc-m-header-8318382763">COMMENTARIES</h1></div><div id="cc-m-8318382863" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8318382963" class="j-module n j-hgrid "> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column" style="width: 31.99%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2118501263"><div id="cc-m-8359001263" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8359001263">Recent Publications</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8359002463" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8438504663" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8438504663">2024</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8438504763" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8529815063" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia21d5d8190d04999/version/1727293454/image.jpg 193w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia21d5d8190d04999/version/1727293454/image.jpg 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=386x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia21d5d8190d04999/version/1727293454/image.jpg 386w" sizes="(min-width: 193px) 193px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8529815063" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia21d5d8190d04999/version/1727293454/image.jpg" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1200" data-src-height="675" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia21d5d8190d04999/version/1727293454/image.jpg" data-image-id="5672529563"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8529815063" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Christabel Randolph and Marc Rotenberg, <em>The AI Red Line Challenge,</em> <strong>Tech Policy Press</strong> (Sept. 3, 2024) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8529815063">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8529815063,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"193","resizeHeight":109},"id":8529815063}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8529815263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8524320963" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i1fba83d4a98b4b53/version/1723819063/image.png 193w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i1fba83d4a98b4b53/version/1723819063/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=386x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i1fba83d4a98b4b53/version/1723819063/image.png 386w" sizes="(min-width: 193px) 193px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8524320963" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i1fba83d4a98b4b53/version/1723819063/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="705" data-src-height="705" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i1fba83d4a98b4b53/version/1723819063/image.png" data-image-id="5668211963"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8524320963" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Rotenberg, M. and Randolph, C, <em>International Frameworks for AI Governance</em> in <strong>Commentary to the AI Act and Related Acts</strong>, (Kluwer forthcoming)聽 </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8524320963">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8524320963,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"193","resizeHeight":193},"id":8524320963}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8524321363" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8524320663" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia8251759e6f84c67/version/1723819063/image.jpg 193w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia8251759e6f84c67/version/1723819063/image.jpg 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=386x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia8251759e6f84c67/version/1723819063/image.jpg 386w" sizes="(min-width: 193px) 193px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8524320663" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia8251759e6f84c67/version/1723819063/image.jpg" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1320" data-src-height="1056" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia8251759e6f84c67/version/1723819063/image.jpg" data-image-id="5668211263"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8524320663" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Rotenberg, M., Randolph, C, Kelawan, <em>A.I. and Our Data</em>, <strong>The New York Times</strong>, June 27, 2024 https://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/27/opinion/jamaal-bowman-defeat.html </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8524320663">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8524320663,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"193","resizeHeight":155},"id":8524320663}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8524320763" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8524319263" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/iaf3a045b0b0d324f/version/1723819063/image.png 193w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/iaf3a045b0b0d324f/version/1723819063/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=386x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/iaf3a045b0b0d324f/version/1723819063/image.png 386w" sizes="(min-width: 193px) 193px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8524319263" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/iaf3a045b0b0d324f/version/1723819063/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="568" data-src-height="757" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/iaf3a045b0b0d324f/version/1723819063/image.png" data-image-id="5668209963"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8524319263" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p class="MsoNormal" style="margin: 0in; font-size: medium; font-family: Aptos, sans-serif; caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> Rotenberg, M.聽<i>US Supreme Court: NetChoice Cases Explore AI and the First Amendment,</i>聽<b>Journal of AI Law and Regulation,</b>聽Volume 1, Issue 2 (2024), pp. 254 - 257, DOI:聽<span lang="EN-GB" xml:lang="EN-GB"><span lang="EN-US" xml:lang="EN-US" style="color: #96607d; text-decoration: underline;"><a href="https://doi.org/10.21552/aire/2024/2/1" style="color: #96607d; text-decoration: underline;" target="_top">https://doi.org/10.21552/aire/2024/2/1</a>3</span></span> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8524319263">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8524319263,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"193","resizeHeight":258},"id":8524319263}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8524320063" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8524320163" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i994ecd3f54f9d8bc/version/1723819063/image.png 193w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i994ecd3f54f9d8bc/version/1723819063/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=386x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i994ecd3f54f9d8bc/version/1723819063/image.png 386w" sizes="(min-width: 193px) 193px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8524320163" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i994ecd3f54f9d8bc/version/1723819063/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="567" data-src-height="756" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i994ecd3f54f9d8bc/version/1723819063/image.png" data-image-id="5668210663"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8524320163" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Rotenberg, M., <em>The Imperative for a UN Special Rapporteur on AI and Human Rights,</em> <strong>Journal of AI Law and Regulation</strong>, Volume 1, Issue 1 (2024), pp. 110 - 112, DOI: https://doi.org/10.21552/aire/2024/1/13 </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8524320163">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8524320163,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"193","resizeHeight":258},"id":8524320163}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8524320363" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8492049963" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=170x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/idc782aa49ec41a8b/version/1703957069/image.png 170w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/idc782aa49ec41a8b/version/1703957069/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=340x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/idc782aa49ec41a8b/version/1703957069/image.png 340w" sizes="(min-width: 170px) 170px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8492049963" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=170x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/idc782aa49ec41a8b/version/1703957069/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="827" data-src-height="1246" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=170x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/idc782aa49ec41a8b/version/1703957069/image.png" data-image-id="5641495063"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8492049963" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Rotenberg, M. (2024). <a href="https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-45304-5_38" target="_blank" title="https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-45304-5_38"><em>Human Rights Alignment: The Challenge Ahead for AI Lawmakers</em>.</a> In: Werthner, H., et al. <strong>Introduction to Digital Humanism.</strong> Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-45304-5_38</span> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8492049963">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8492049963,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"170","resizeHeight":257},"id":8492049963}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8492050063" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8492050163" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8492050163">2023</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8492050263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8492061463" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=170x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i769de49fdaa8fee0/version/1703703856/image.png 170w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i769de49fdaa8fee0/version/1703703856/image.png 204w" sizes="(min-width: 170px) 170px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8492061463" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=170x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i769de49fdaa8fee0/version/1703703856/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="204" data-src-height="192" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=170x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i769de49fdaa8fee0/version/1703703856/image.png" data-image-id="5641499463"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8492061463" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Okezue Bell and Marc Rotenberg,聽<a href="https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/4346437-the-false-choice-holding-up-congressional-action-on-ai/" target="_blank" title="https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/4346437-the-false-choice-holding-up-congressional-action-on-ai/"><em>The false choice holding up congressional action on AI,</em></a> <strong>The Hill</strong>, Dec. 7, 2023</span> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8492061463">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8492061463,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"170","resizeHeight":160},"id":8492061463}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8492061563" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8487300163" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie4fa57dfe736a25c/version/1700856390/image.png 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie4fa57dfe736a25c/version/1700856390/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=388x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie4fa57dfe736a25c/version/1700856390/image.png 388w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8487300163" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie4fa57dfe736a25c/version/1700856390/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1098" data-src-height="1558" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie4fa57dfe736a25c/version/1700856390/image.png" data-image-id="5637614963"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8487300163" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg, <em>An AI Oversight</em> (response to Ian Bremmer and聽Mustafa Suleyman鈥檚 "The AI Power Paradox"), <strong>Foreign Affairs</strong></span> (Nov-Dec. 2023) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8487300163">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8487300163,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":276},"id":8487300163}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8487300463" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8459975663" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9f8cc42c7c6b7679/version/1700833438/image.png 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9f8cc42c7c6b7679/version/1700833438/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=388x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9f8cc42c7c6b7679/version/1700833438/image.png 388w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8459975663" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9f8cc42c7c6b7679/version/1700833438/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1200" data-src-height="1200" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9f8cc42c7c6b7679/version/1700833438/image.png" data-image-id="5611210663"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8459975663" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://cacm.acm.org/blogs/blog-cacm/277863-that-was-the-week-that-was/fulltext" target="_blank" title="https://cacm.acm.org/blogs/blog-cacm/277863-that-was-the-week-that-was/fulltext">That Was The Week That Was</a>,聽聽<strong>BLOG@CACM</strong></span> (Nov 6, 2023) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8459975663">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8459975663,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":194},"id":8459975663}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8487299263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8487298463" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4a66471095ac82d9/version/1700856390/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=367x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4a66471095ac82d9/version/1700856390/image.png 367w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=640x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4a66471095ac82d9/version/1700856390/image.png 640w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=734x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4a66471095ac82d9/version/1700856390/image.png 734w" sizes="(min-width: 367px) 367px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8487298463" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=367x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4a66471095ac82d9/version/1700856390/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1598" data-src-height="908" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=367x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4a66471095ac82d9/version/1700856390/image.png" data-image-id="5637612863"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8487298463" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Jocelyn Benson, Secretary of State, State of Michigan and Marc Rotenberg, CAIDP,聽<a href="https://www.cfr.org/event/elections-ai-era" target="_blank" title="https://www.cfr.org/event/elections-ai-era">Elections in the AI Era</a>, <strong>Council on Foreign Relations</strong></span> (Oct. 26, 2023) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8487298463">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8487298463,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"367","resizeHeight":209},"id":8487298463}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8487297863" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8487466263" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i44732dcdac59c280/version/1700932302/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=367x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i44732dcdac59c280/version/1700932302/image.png 367w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=640x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i44732dcdac59c280/version/1700932302/image.png 640w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=734x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i44732dcdac59c280/version/1700932302/image.png 734w" sizes="(min-width: 367px) 367px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8487466263" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=367x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i44732dcdac59c280/version/1700932302/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="798" data-src-height="540" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=367x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i44732dcdac59c280/version/1700932302/image.png" data-image-id="5637697363"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8487466263" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Merve Hickok and Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://www.cfr.org/blog/uk-ai-summit-time-elevate-democratic-values" target="_blank" title="https://www.cfr.org/blog/uk-ai-summit-time-elevate-democratic-values">The UK AI Summit: Time to Elevate Democratic Values</a> -</span><span><span size="4" style="font-size: large;">聽</span><em><span size="4" style="font-size: large;">the United Kingdom needs to bring its AI policy back in line with the values of freedom, democracy, and rule of law,</span></em> <strong><span size="4" style="font-size: large;">Council on Foreign Relations</span></strong><em><span size="4" style="font-size: large;">聽</span></em></span>聽(Sept. 27 2023) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8487466263">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8487466263,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"367","resizeHeight":249},"id":8487466263}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8487297363" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8487298963" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i811a81f2cf2af215/version/1700833314/image.png 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i811a81f2cf2af215/version/1700833314/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=388x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i811a81f2cf2af215/version/1700833314/image.png 388w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8487298963" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i811a81f2cf2af215/version/1700833314/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1200" data-src-height="1200" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i811a81f2cf2af215/version/1700833314/image.png" data-image-id="5637613263"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8487298963" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg,聽<a href="https://cacm.acm.org/blogs/blog-cacm/275742-everything-everywhere-all-at-once-ai-policy-when-congress-returns/fulltext" target="_blank" title="https://cacm.acm.org/blogs/blog-cacm/275742-everything-everywhere-all-at-once-ai-policy-when-congress-returns/fulltext">聽Everything. Everywhere. All at Once: AI Policy When Congress Returns,</a>聽 <strong>BLOG@CACM</strong></span> (Aug.聽24, 2023) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8487298963">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8487298963,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":194},"id":8487298963}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8475122463" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8448781163" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i2c0d9fcabd2449d3/version/1694178355/image.png 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i2c0d9fcabd2449d3/version/1694178355/image.png 251w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8448781163" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i2c0d9fcabd2449d3/version/1694178355/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="251" data-src-height="201" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i2c0d9fcabd2449d3/version/1694178355/image.png" data-image-id="5601327463"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8448781163" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span size="4" style="font-size: large;">Merve Hickok,聽</span><span size="4" style="font-size: large;">Lorraine Kisselburgh, and聽</span><span><span size="4" style="font-size: large;">Marc Rotenberg聽</span><span color="#1E73B6" size="4" style="color: #1e73b6; font-size: large;"><span style="caret-color: #1e73b6;"><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/24/opinion/trump-biden-2024-election.html" target="_blank" title="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/24/opinion/trump-biden-2024-election.html">Perils of A.I., and Limits on Its Development</a>,聽</span></span><span size="4" style="font-size: large;">The New York Times</span></span> (July 24, 2023) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8448781163">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8448781163,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":156},"id":8448781163}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8475122963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8475122363" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i51a693a01565657d/version/1694177916/image.png 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i51a693a01565657d/version/1694177916/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=388x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i51a693a01565657d/version/1694177916/image.png 388w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8475122363" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i51a693a01565657d/version/1694177916/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1200" data-src-height="1200" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i51a693a01565657d/version/1694177916/image.png" data-image-id="5625430463"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8475122363" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg,聽<a href="https://cacm.acm.org/blogs/blog-cacm/273011-a-turning-point-for-us-ai-policy-senate-explores-solutions/fulltext" target="_blank" title="https://cacm.acm.org/blogs/blog-cacm/273011-a-turning-point-for-us-ai-policy-senate-explores-solutions/fulltext#">A Turning Point for U.S. AI Policy: Senate Explores Solutions,</a> <strong>BLOG@CACM</strong></span> (May 17, 2023) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8475122363">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8475122363,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":194},"id":8475122363}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8459976263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8492060663" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=319x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i636789449e704595/version/1703556569/image.png 319w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i636789449e704595/version/1703556569/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=638x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i636789449e704595/version/1703556569/image.png 638w" sizes="(min-width: 319px) 319px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8492060663" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=319x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i636789449e704595/version/1703556569/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1424" data-src-height="801" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=319x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i636789449e704595/version/1703556569/image.png" data-image-id="5641499263"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8492060663" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Merve Hickok, Lorraine Kisselburgh, and Marc Rotenberg, <em>A Foundational Framework for AI Policy</em>, <strong>The Economist,</strong> May 13, 2023</span> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8492060663">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8492060663,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"319","resizeHeight":180},"id":8492060663}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8492060763" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8475122863" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic3d4ca30a541c605/version/1694178308/image.png 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic3d4ca30a541c605/version/1694178308/image.png 251w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8475122863" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic3d4ca30a541c605/version/1694178308/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="251" data-src-height="201" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic3d4ca30a541c605/version/1694178308/image.png" data-image-id="5625430663"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8475122863" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg and Merve Hickok, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/06/opinion/letters/alex-murdaugh.html#link-7f9159ab" target="_blank" title="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/06/opinion/letters/alex-murdaugh.html#link-7f9159ab">Regulating A.I.: The U.S. Needs to Act,</a> <strong>The New York Times</strong></span> (March 6, 2023) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8475122863">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8475122863,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":156},"id":8475122863}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8448781463" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8438504963" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=191x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i13d4c1a67aef68c2/version/1694178296/image.jpg 191w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i13d4c1a67aef68c2/version/1694178296/image.jpg 300w" sizes="(min-width: 191px) 191px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8438504963" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=191x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i13d4c1a67aef68c2/version/1694178296/image.jpg" alt="" class="" data-src-width="300" data-src-height="300" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=191x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i13d4c1a67aef68c2/version/1694178296/image.jpg" data-image-id="5592961863"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8438504963" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Hickok, Merve, Rotenberg, Marc, & Caunes, Karine,聽<a href="https://verfassungsblog.de/coe-black-box-ai/" target="_blank" title="https://verfassungsblog.de/coe-black-box-ai/">The Council of Europe Creates a Black Box for AI Polic</a>y, <strong>Verfassungsblog</strong></span>,聽(Jan. 24, 2023) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8438504963">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8438504963,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"191","resizeHeight":191},"id":8438504963}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8438504863" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8413562163" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8413562163">2022</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8413562263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8429527863" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ib25c90bf2d9e9c84/version/1670866885/image.png 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ib25c90bf2d9e9c84/version/1670866885/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=388x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ib25c90bf2d9e9c84/version/1670866885/image.png 388w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8429527863" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ib25c90bf2d9e9c84/version/1670866885/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1000" data-src-height="562" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ib25c90bf2d9e9c84/version/1670866885/image.png" data-image-id="5585305763"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8429527863" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg and Merve Hikcok,聽<a href="https://techonomy.com/can-the-u-s-and-europe-agree-on-rules-for-ai/" target="_blank" title="https://techonomy.com/can-the-u-s-and-europe-agree-on-rules-for-ai/">Can the U.S. and Europe Agree on Rules for AI?</a> <strong>Techonomy</strong>,</span> Nov. 30, 2022 </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8429527863">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8429527863,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":110},"id":8429527863}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8429529563" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8426226163" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=190x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i25ae4ebb13536cf6/version/1669315460/image.png 190w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i25ae4ebb13536cf6/version/1669315460/image.png 248w" sizes="(min-width: 190px) 190px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8426226163" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=190x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i25ae4ebb13536cf6/version/1669315460/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="248" data-src-height="203" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=190x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i25ae4ebb13536cf6/version/1669315460/image.png" data-image-id="5582420863"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8426226163" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/3743208-will-congress-kill-the-push-for-data-privacy/" target="_blank" title="https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/3743208-will-congress-kill-the-push-for-data-privacy/">Will Congress Kill the Push for Data Privacy?</a> <strong>The Hill,</strong> Nov. 19, 2022</span> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8426226163">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8426226163,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"190","resizeHeight":156},"id":8426226163}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8426226263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8421506263" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i6a82433e6cbd5700/version/1667414614/image.jpg 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i6a82433e6cbd5700/version/1667414614/image.jpg 225w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8421506263" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i6a82433e6cbd5700/version/1667414614/image.jpg" alt="" class="" data-src-width="225" data-src-height="225" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i6a82433e6cbd5700/version/1667414614/image.jpg" data-image-id="5577965263"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8421506263" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://cacm.acm.org/blogs/blog-cacm/265535-fair-ai-practices/fulltext" target="_blank" title="https://cacm.acm.org/blogs/blog-cacm/265535-fair-ai-practices/fulltext">Fair AI Practices</a></span>, <strong>BLOG@CACM</strong>, (Oct. 12, 2022) (comparing聽the OSTP "Blueprint for an AI Bill of Rights" and the 1973 report "Records, Computers, and the Rights of Citizens." </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8421506263">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8421506263,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":194},"id":8421506263}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8421506463" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8421506563" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i393c1e7452967091/version/1667414672/image.png 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i393c1e7452967091/version/1667414672/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=388x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i393c1e7452967091/version/1667414672/image.png 388w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8421506563" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i393c1e7452967091/version/1667414672/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="964" data-src-height="1282" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i393c1e7452967091/version/1667414672/image.png" data-image-id="5577965563"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8421506563" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://edpl.lexxion.eu/article/EDPL/2022/3/15" target="_blank" title="https://edpl.lexxion.eu/article/EDPL/2022/3/15">CJEU PNR Decision Unplugs the 'Black Box,"</a></span> <strong>European Data Protection Law Review</strong> (Fall 2022) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8421506563">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8421506563,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":258},"id":8421506563}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8416920963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8413564963" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i96e1621b39d37de0/version/1663512835/image.png 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i96e1621b39d37de0/version/1663512835/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=388x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i96e1621b39d37de0/version/1663512835/image.png 388w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8413564963" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i96e1621b39d37de0/version/1663512835/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="584" data-src-height="826" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i96e1621b39d37de0/version/1663512835/image.png" data-image-id="5570619163"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8413564963" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg, <em>The Law of Artificial Intelligence and the</em></span> </p> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;"><em>Protection of Fundamental Rights: The Role</em></span> </p> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;"><em>of the ELI Guiding Principles on Automated Decisionmaking in the EU</em>,</span> <strong>ELI Newsletter</strong> (July-August 2022) </p> <p> [<a href="https://europeanlawinstitute.eu/fileadmin/user_upload/p_eli/Newsletter/2022/Newsletter_Jul-Aug_2022.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://europeanlawinstitute.eu/fileadmin/user_upload/p_eli/Newsletter/2022/Newsletter_Jul-Aug_2022.pdf">PDF</a>] </p> <p> [<a href="https://europeanlawinstitute.eu/fileadmin/user_upload/p_eli/Newsletter/2022/Flip_Jul-Aug/" target="_blank" title="https://europeanlawinstitute.eu/fileadmin/user_upload/p_eli/Newsletter/2022/Flip_Jul-Aug/">FlipBook</a>] </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8413564963">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8413564963,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":275},"id":8413564963}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8413565763" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8413670363" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9935da793c8a0f29/version/1663554154/image.png 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9935da793c8a0f29/version/1663554154/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=388x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9935da793c8a0f29/version/1663554154/image.png 388w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8413670363" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9935da793c8a0f29/version/1663554154/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="2048" data-src-height="1365" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9935da793c8a0f29/version/1663554154/image.png" data-image-id="5570681763"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8413670363" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg and聽Sabrina Talukder,聽<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/01/opinion/letters/trump-prosecution.html#link-4ec4168" target="_blank" title="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/01/opinion/letters/trump-prosecution.html#link-4ec4168"><em>Abortion Prosecutions Show the Need for Data Privacy</em></a>,</span> <strong>New York Times</strong> (September 1, 2022) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8413670363">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8413670363,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":130},"id":8413670363}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8413670563" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8409785963" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1 cc-m-width-maxed"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie36f87cf59f7a0e7/version/1661700448/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=387x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie36f87cf59f7a0e7/version/1661700448/image.png 387w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie36f87cf59f7a0e7/version/1661700448/image.png 406w" sizes="(min-width: 387px) 387px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8409785963" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=387x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie36f87cf59f7a0e7/version/1661700448/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="406" data-src-height="306" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=387x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie36f87cf59f7a0e7/version/1661700448/image.png" data-image-id="5566906163"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8409785963" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;"><a href="https://www.cfr.org/blog/artificial-intelligence-and-democratic-values-next-steps-united-states" target="_blank" title="https://www.cfr.org/blog/artificial-intelligence-and-democratic-values-next-steps-united-states">Artificial Intelligence and Democratic Values: Next Steps for the United States</a>,</span> Marc Rotenberg and Merve Hickok, <strong>Council on Foreign Relations</strong> (August 22, 2022) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8409785963">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8409785963,"widthEqualsContent":"1","resizeWidth":"387","resizeHeight":292},"id":8409785963}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8409786763" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8407950863" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=204x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia98f03b9e577ab5c/version/1663512564/image.png 204w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia98f03b9e577ab5c/version/1663512564/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=408x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia98f03b9e577ab5c/version/1663512564/image.png 408w" sizes="(min-width: 204px) 204px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8407950863" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=204x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia98f03b9e577ab5c/version/1663512564/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="440" data-src-height="360" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=204x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia98f03b9e577ab5c/version/1663512564/image.png" data-image-id="5565124663"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8407950863" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg and Sneha Revanur, <a href="https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/3566180-time-to-act-now-on-ai-bill-of-rights/" target="_blank" title="https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/3566180-time-to-act-now-on-ai-bill-of-rights/">Time to act now on AI Bill of Rights,</a></span> <strong>The Hill,</strong> July 19, 2022 </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8407950863">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8407950863,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"204","resizeHeight":167},"id":8407950863}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8407951063" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8390618663" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=213x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i97b49783e1219d7a/version/1663512573/image.png 213w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i97b49783e1219d7a/version/1663512573/image.png 275w" sizes="(min-width: 213px) 213px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8390618663" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=213x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i97b49783e1219d7a/version/1663512573/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="275" data-src-height="183" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=213x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i97b49783e1219d7a/version/1663512573/image.png" data-image-id="5548783363"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8390618663" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">GASTKOMMENTAR: Marc Rotenberg,聽</span> </p> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;"><a href="https://www.wienerzeitung.at/meinung/gastkommentare/2146130-Im-Daten-Algorithmen-und-Ueberwachungsdschungel.html" target="_blank" title="https://www.wienerzeitung.at/meinung/gastkommentare/2146130-Im-Daten-Algorithmen-und-Ueberwachungsdschungel.html">Im Daten-, Algorithmen- und 脺berwachungsdschungel,</a></span> <strong>Wiener Zeitung</strong>, 3-5-22 </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8390618663">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8390618663,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"213","resizeHeight":142},"id":8390618663}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8390618963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8390619063" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i47d3e4ac247472b5/version/1652145777/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=327x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i47d3e4ac247472b5/version/1652145777/image.png 327w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=640x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i47d3e4ac247472b5/version/1652145777/image.png 640w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=654x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i47d3e4ac247472b5/version/1652145777/image.png 654w" sizes="(min-width: 327px) 327px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8390619063" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=327x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i47d3e4ac247472b5/version/1652145777/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1200" data-src-height="628" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=327x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i47d3e4ac247472b5/version/1652145777/image.png" data-image-id="5548783463"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8390619063" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/04/04/federal-privacy-law-is-desperately-needed/" target="_blank" title="https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/04/04/federal-privacy-law-is-desperately-needed/">Opinion 聽A federal privacy law is desperately needed,</a></span> Washington Post, Apr. 4, 2022 </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8390619063">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8390619063,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"327","resizeHeight":172},"id":8390619063}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8390619163" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8359002663" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i34fc8a01f81782c5/version/1661700500/image.png 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i34fc8a01f81782c5/version/1661700500/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=388x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i34fc8a01f81782c5/version/1661700500/image.png 388w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8359002663" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i34fc8a01f81782c5/version/1661700500/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="538" data-src-height="678" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i34fc8a01f81782c5/version/1661700500/image.png" data-image-id="5521850063"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8359002663" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;">Marc Rotenberg, <em>Artificial Intelligence and the right to algorithmic transparency</em></span> in M. Ienca, et al, <strong>The Cambridge Handbook of Life Science, Information Technology and Human Rights</strong> (2022) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8359002663">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8359002663,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":245},"id":8359002663}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8390618563" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8378872963" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=254x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i24e097eb16adc4cd/version/1646832898/image.jpg 254w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i24e097eb16adc4cd/version/1646832898/image.jpg 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i24e097eb16adc4cd/version/1646832898/image.jpg 360w" sizes="(min-width: 254px) 254px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8378872963" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=254x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i24e097eb16adc4cd/version/1646832898/image.jpg" alt="" class="" data-src-width="360" data-src-height="483" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=254x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i24e097eb16adc4cd/version/1646832898/image.jpg" data-image-id="5537807263"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8378872963" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <a href="http://turkishpolicy.com" target="_blank" title="http://turkishpolicy.com"><span style="font-size: 18px;">Artiticial Intelligence and Democratic Values</span>,</a> <strong>Turkish Policy Quarterly</strong> (Winter 21/22) with contributions by Ramos, Nemitz, Timmers, Sourdin, Hickok/Rotenberg, and others </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8378872963">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8378872963,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"254","resizeHeight":341},"id":8378872963}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8378873263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8371362763" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic8b8879082006e6e/version/1661700546/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=367x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic8b8879082006e6e/version/1661700546/image.png 367w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=640x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic8b8879082006e6e/version/1661700546/image.png 640w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=734x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic8b8879082006e6e/version/1661700546/image.png 734w" sizes="(min-width: 367px) 367px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8371362763" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=367x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic8b8879082006e6e/version/1661700546/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1698" data-src-height="954" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=367x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic8b8879082006e6e/version/1661700546/image.png" data-image-id="5531899963"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8371362763" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 18px;"><a href="https://techonomy.com/the-biden-administration-embraces-democracy-affirming-technologies/" target="_blank" title="https://techonomy.com/the-biden-administration-embraces-democracy-affirming-technologies/"><em>DEMOCRACY聽The Biden Administration Embraces 鈥淒emocracy Affirming Technologies,"</em></a></span> Marc Rotenberg, <strong>Techonomy</strong>, Jan. 19, 2022 </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8371362763">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8371362763,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"367","resizeHeight":207},"id":8371362763}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8358797863" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-separator" data-display="cms-only"><div></div></div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column" style="width: 31.99%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2118501463"><div id="cc-m-8318383163" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8413560263" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8413560263">2021</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8413563963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8363684463" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ib8d6e939bd355b00/version/1643731335/image.png 194w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ib8d6e939bd355b00/version/1643731335/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=388x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ib8d6e939bd355b00/version/1643731335/image.png 388w" sizes="(min-width: 194px) 194px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8363684463" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ib8d6e939bd355b00/version/1643731335/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="826" data-src-height="1108" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=194x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ib8d6e939bd355b00/version/1643731335/image.png" data-image-id="5526150563"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8363684463" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://edpl.lexxion.eu/article/EDPL/2021/4/6" target="_blank" title="https://edpl.lexxion.eu/article/EDPL/2021/4/6"><em>Foreword: Artificial Intelligence and Democratic Values: The Role of Data Protection,</em></a> <strong>European Data Protection Law Review</strong> (Winter聽2021) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8363684463">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8363684463,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"194","resizeHeight":261},"id":8363684463}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8413564863" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8362393363" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <a href="https://issues.org/artificial-intelligence-age-of-ai-review-rotenberg/" target="_blank"><img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if4dfa9e9efc5eea3/version/1642298772/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=367x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if4dfa9e9efc5eea3/version/1642298772/image.png 367w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=640x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if4dfa9e9efc5eea3/version/1642298772/image.png 640w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=734x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if4dfa9e9efc5eea3/version/1642298772/image.png 734w" sizes="(min-width: 367px) 367px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8362393363" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=367x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if4dfa9e9efc5eea3/version/1642298772/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1780" data-src-height="1140" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=367x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/if4dfa9e9efc5eea3/version/1642298772/image.png" data-image-id="5524990463"/></a> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8362393363" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p style="text-align: center;"> <a href="https://issues.org/artificial-intelligence-age-of-ai-review-rotenberg/" target="_blank" title="https://issues.org/artificial-intelligence-age-of-ai-review-rotenberg/"><span style="font-size: 18px;">Artificial Intelligence and Galileo's Telescope</span></a> </p> <p style="text-align: center;"> review of the <em>Age of AI</em> by Henry Kissinger, Eric Schmidt, and Douglas Huttenlocher </p> <p style="text-align: center;"> <strong>Issues in Science and Technology</strong> </p> <p style="text-align: center;"> Marc Rotenberg </p> <p style="text-align: center;"> 聽 </p> <p style="text-align: center;"> (<a href="https://www.cfr.org/event/malcolm-and-carolyn-wiener-annual-lecture-science-and-technology-henry-kissinger-and-eric" target="_blank" title="https://www.cfr.org/event/malcolm-and-carolyn-wiener-annual-lecture-science-and-technology-henry-kissinger-and-eric">Brief exchange</a> with Marc Rotenberg, Henry Kissinger, and Eric Schmidt about the book at the Council on Foreign Relations, December 20, 2021) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8362393363">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"https:\/\/issues.org\/artificial-intelligence-age-of-ai-review-rotenberg\/","hyperlink_target":"_blank","hyperlinkAsString":"https:\/\/issues.org\/artificial-intelligence-age-of-ai-review-rotenberg\/","pinterest":"0","id":8362393363,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"367","resizeHeight":236},"id":8362393363}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8413564763" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8358492563" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=196x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia4a900fcc668bf40/version/1660701567/image.png 196w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia4a900fcc668bf40/version/1660701567/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=392x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia4a900fcc668bf40/version/1660701567/image.png 392w" sizes="(min-width: 196px) 196px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8358492563" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=196x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia4a900fcc668bf40/version/1660701567/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="440" data-src-height="360" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=196x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ia4a900fcc668bf40/version/1660701567/image.png" data-image-id="5521308063"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8358492563" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 15px;">Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/582774-future-of-the-internet-requires-willingness-to-change-here-in-the-us" target="_blank" title="https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/582774-future-of-the-internet-requires-willingness-to-change-here-in-the-us">'Future of the internet' requires willingness to change here in the US,</a> <strong>The Hill,</strong> November 23, 2021</span> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8358492563">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8358492563,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"196","resizeHeight":161},"id":8358492563}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8413564663" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8354273763" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=196x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/idc42f8174dace0ac/version/1638211104/image.jpg 196w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/idc42f8174dace0ac/version/1638211104/image.jpg 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=392x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/idc42f8174dace0ac/version/1638211104/image.jpg 392w" sizes="(min-width: 196px) 196px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8354273763" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=196x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/idc42f8174dace0ac/version/1638211104/image.jpg" alt="" class="" data-src-width="800" data-src-height="536" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=196x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/idc42f8174dace0ac/version/1638211104/image.jpg" data-image-id="5516406263"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8354273763" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 15px;"><a href="https://washingtonspectator.org/author/lorraine-marc/" target="_blank" title="https://washingtonspectator.org/author/lorraine-marc/">Next Steps on the AI Bill Of Rights,</a> by Lorraine Kisselburgh and Marc Rotenberg, <strong>Washington Spectator</strong> (Nov. 2021)</span> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8354273763">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8354273763,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"196","resizeHeight":132},"id":8354273763}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8413564463" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8358537063" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=196x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i417295aca181794b/version/1638210852/image.jpg 196w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i417295aca181794b/version/1638210852/image.jpg 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=392x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i417295aca181794b/version/1638210852/image.jpg 392w" sizes="(min-width: 196px) 196px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8358537063" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=196x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i417295aca181794b/version/1638210852/image.jpg" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1200" data-src-height="1536" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=196x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i417295aca181794b/version/1638210852/image.jpg" data-image-id="5521361063"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8358537063" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 15px;">Maintaining Control Over AI, <a href="https://issues.org/debating-human-control-over-artificial-intelligence-forum-shneiderman/#forum-response-block_60abe0409efce" target="_blank" title="https://issues.org/debating-human-control-over-artificial-intelligence-forum-shneiderman/#forum-response-block_60abe0409efce">Marc Rotenberg responds to Ben Shneiderman on Human-Centered AI,</a> <strong>Issues in Science and Technology</strong> (Spring 2021)</span> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8358537063">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8358537063,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"196","resizeHeight":251},"id":8358537063}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8413564363" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8303014663" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=196x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i86071b0f1a8e2689/version/1638210117/image.png 196w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i86071b0f1a8e2689/version/1638210117/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=392x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i86071b0f1a8e2689/version/1638210117/image.png 392w" sizes="(min-width: 196px) 196px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8303014663" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=196x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i86071b0f1a8e2689/version/1638210117/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1651" data-src-height="2048" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=196x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i86071b0f1a8e2689/version/1638210117/image.png" data-image-id="5474737863"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8303014663" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 15px;">Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/15/opinion/letters/privacy-data.html" target="_blank" title="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/15/opinion/letters/privacy-data.html">The Need for Strong Privacy Law,</a> <strong>The New York Times,聽</strong>March, 15, 2021</span> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8303014663">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8303014663,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"196","resizeHeight":244},"id":8303014663}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8413564263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8358858163" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=199x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i443bf04855510a92/version/1638242759/image.jpg 199w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i443bf04855510a92/version/1638242759/image.jpg 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=398x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i443bf04855510a92/version/1638242759/image.jpg 398w" sizes="(min-width: 199px) 199px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8358858163" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=199x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i443bf04855510a92/version/1638242759/image.jpg" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1038" data-src-height="576" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=199x1024:format=jpg/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i443bf04855510a92/version/1638242759/image.jpg" data-image-id="5521597363"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8358858163" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://jnslp.com/2021/01/25/from-9-11-to-january-6-the-limits-of-surveillance-authority-and-the-democratic-state/" target="_blank" title="https://jnslp.com/2021/01/25/from-9-11-to-january-6-the-limits-of-surveillance-authority-and-the-democratic-state/">From 9-11 to January 6: The Limits of Surveillance Authority and the Democratic State,</a> <strong>Journal of National Security Law and Policy,</strong> January 25, 2021 </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8358858163">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8358858163,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"199","resizeHeight":111},"id":8358858163}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8413564163" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8413560663" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8413560663">2020</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8413560563" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8268811863" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1 cc-m-width-maxed"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/id5ccd3e5d63678dd/version/1638106420/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=598x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/id5ccd3e5d63678dd/version/1638106420/image.png 598w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=640x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/id5ccd3e5d63678dd/version/1638106420/image.png 640w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=960x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/id5ccd3e5d63678dd/version/1638106420/image.png 960w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/id5ccd3e5d63678dd/version/1638106420/image.png 1188w" sizes="(min-width: 598px) 598px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8268811863" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=598x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/id5ccd3e5d63678dd/version/1638106420/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1188" data-src-height="476" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=598x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/id5ccd3e5d63678dd/version/1638106420/image.png" data-image-id="5450584663"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8268811863" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <div class="" style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000; font-family: Helvetica; font-size: 12px;"> <span style="font-size: 18px;"><i class=""><a href="https://cacm.acm.org/blogs/blog-cacm/248921-time-to-assess-national-ai-policies/fulltext" target="_blank" title="https://cacm.acm.org/blogs/blog-cacm/248921-time-to-assess-national-ai-policies/fulltext">Time to Assess National AI Policies</a>,聽</i>Marc Rotenberg, <em>Communications of the ACM</em>, Nov. 24, 2020</span> </div> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8268811863">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8268811863,"widthEqualsContent":"1","resizeWidth":"598","resizeHeight":240},"id":8268811863}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8358799763" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8255286863" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=190x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4c4b825a69a2fbb3/version/1605364368/image.png 190w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4c4b825a69a2fbb3/version/1605364368/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=380x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4c4b825a69a2fbb3/version/1605364368/image.png 380w" sizes="(min-width: 190px) 190px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8255286863" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=190x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4c4b825a69a2fbb3/version/1605364368/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="602" data-src-height="862" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=190x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i4c4b825a69a2fbb3/version/1605364368/image.png" data-image-id="5439487363"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8255286863" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Nazli Choucri, Nguyen Ann Tuan, Marc Rotenberg,<a href="https://www.rigaconference.lv/wp-content/uploads/Social-Contract-for-the-Artificial-Intelligence-Age.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.rigaconference.lv/wp-content/uploads/Social-Contract-for-the-Artificial-Intelligence-Age.pdf">聽<strong>鈥淪ocial Contract for the Artificial Intelligence Age - Safety, Security, & Sustainability for AI World,"</strong></a> <em>Proceedings of the Riga Conference</em> (November 2020) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8255286863">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8255286863,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"190","resizeHeight":273},"id":8255286863}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8358797363" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8226184663" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic67ab12e4e659086/version/1638210318/image.png 192w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic67ab12e4e659086/version/1638210318/image.png 306w" sizes="(min-width: 192px) 192px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8226184663" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic67ab12e4e659086/version/1638210318/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="306" data-src-height="462" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic67ab12e4e659086/version/1638210318/image.png" data-image-id="5420320463"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8226184663" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 15px;">Marc Rotenberg, <em><a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/share/author/3ZGQE2SVF3KEXI4AKI9A?target=10.1111/eulj.12370" target="_blank" title="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/share/author/3ZGQE2SVF3KEXI4AKI9A?target=10.1111/eulj.12370">Schrems II, from Snowden to China: Toward a聽New Alignment on Transatlantic Data Protection,</a>聽</em><strong>European Law Journal</strong> (September 2020)</span> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8226184663">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8226184663,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"192","resizeHeight":290},"id":8226184663}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8359003663" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8358537263" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9bf51039e25440d5/version/1638210348/image.png 192w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9bf51039e25440d5/version/1638210348/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=384x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9bf51039e25440d5/version/1638210348/image.png 384w" sizes="(min-width: 192px) 192px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8358537263" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9bf51039e25440d5/version/1638210348/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1332" data-src-height="1278" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i9bf51039e25440d5/version/1638210348/image.png" data-image-id="5521361163"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8358537263" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 15px;">Marc Rotenberg,聽<em>Il futuro della privacy e la vivacit脿 della democrazia in <a href="https://www.gpdp.it/documents/10160/0/Privacy+2030+-+Un+manifesto+per+il+nostro+futuro+-+Volume.pdf/8a243e2f-53e9-8dfa-a3be-0e80347499d3?version=2.1" target="_blank" title="https://www.gpdp.it/documents/10160/0/Privacy+2030+-+Un+manifesto+per+il+nostro+futuro+-+Volume.pdf/8a243e2f-53e9-8dfa-a3be-0e80347499d3?version=2.1">Privacy 2030:聽</a></em><i><a href="https://www.gpdp.it/documents/10160/0/Privacy+2030+-+Un+manifesto+per+il+nostro+futuro+-+Volume.pdf/8a243e2f-53e9-8dfa-a3be-0e80347499d3?version=2.1" target="_blank" title="https://www.gpdp.it/documents/10160/0/Privacy+2030+-+Un+manifesto+per+il+nostro+futuro+-+Volume.pdf/8a243e2f-53e9-8dfa-a3be-0e80347499d3?version=2.1">Una nuova visione per l鈥橢uropa</a>聽</i>(The Mainfesto of Giovanni Butarelli) (Sept. 2020) (<a href="https://www.epic.org/giovanni_manifesto.pdf" target="_blank" title="https://www.epic.org/giovanni_manifesto.pdf">in English</a>)</span> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8358537263">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8358537263,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"192","resizeHeight":185},"id":8358537263}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8359003863" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8233243563" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie6995b4bb117c5e0/version/1597585888/image.png 192w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie6995b4bb117c5e0/version/1597585888/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=384x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie6995b4bb117c5e0/version/1597585888/image.png 384w" sizes="(min-width: 192px) 192px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8233243563" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie6995b4bb117c5e0/version/1597585888/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1094" data-src-height="1104" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie6995b4bb117c5e0/version/1597585888/image.png" data-image-id="5424417363"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8233243563" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://washingtonspectator.org/tech-giants-rotenberg/" target="_blank" title="https://washingtonspectator.org/tech-giants-rotenberg/"><em>The Tech Giants Come to Congress, and Democracy Wins a Round,</em></a> <strong>Washington Spectator</strong> (August 12, 2020) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8233243563">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8233243563,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"192","resizeHeight":194},"id":8233243563}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8358858063" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-separator" data-display="cms-only"><div></div></div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column last" style="width: 31.99%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2118501363"><div id="cc-m-8413562563" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8413561163" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8413561163">2019</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8413562763" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8233244863" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i680a244d6d96598c/version/1597586169/image.png 192w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i680a244d6d96598c/version/1597586169/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=384x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i680a244d6d96598c/version/1597586169/image.png 384w" sizes="(min-width: 192px) 192px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8233244863" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i680a244d6d96598c/version/1597586169/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1196" data-src-height="804" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i680a244d6d96598c/version/1597586169/image.png" data-image-id="5424417663"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8233244863" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/19/opinion/letters/surveillance-china.html" target="_blank" title="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/19/opinion/letters/surveillance-china.html">Marc Rotenberg, <em>Surveillance in China: Implications for Americans,聽</em><strong>New York Times</strong> (December 20,聽2019)</a> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8233244863">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8233244863,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"192","resizeHeight":130},"id":8233244863}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8413562863" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8233351263" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic8584b53095e7bc3/version/1597626491/image.png 192w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic8584b53095e7bc3/version/1597626491/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=384x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic8584b53095e7bc3/version/1597626491/image.png 384w" sizes="(min-width: 192px) 192px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8233351263" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic8584b53095e7bc3/version/1597626491/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1328" data-src-height="752" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ic8584b53095e7bc3/version/1597626491/image.png" data-image-id="5424472563"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8233351263" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg,聽<a href="https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/473537-save-the-org-domain-and-all-it-symbolizes" target="_blank" title="https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/473537-save-the-org-domain-and-all-it-symbolizes"><em>Save the .ORG domain and all it symbolizes,</em></a> <strong>The Hill</strong> (December 8, 2019) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8233351263">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8233351263,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"192","resizeHeight":109},"id":8233351263}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8413562963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8233248563" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i3a0099497cef442f/version/1597586606/image.png 192w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i3a0099497cef442f/version/1597586606/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=384x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i3a0099497cef442f/version/1597586606/image.png 384w" sizes="(min-width: 192px) 192px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8233248563" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i3a0099497cef442f/version/1597586606/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1210" data-src-height="806" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i3a0099497cef442f/version/1597586606/image.png" data-image-id="5424419063"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8233248563" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/18/opinion/letters/artificial-intelligence.html" target="_blank" title="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/18/opinion/letters/artificial-intelligence.html"><em>The Battle Over Artificial Intelligence,</em></a>聽<strong>New York Times</strong> (April 16, 2019) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8233248563">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8233248563,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"192","resizeHeight":128},"id":8233248563}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8413563063" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8413561663" class="j-module n j-header "><h2 class="" id="cc-m-header-8413561663">2018</h2></div><div id="cc-m-8413563163" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8233251163" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i098d405a2de20fd0/version/1597587053/image.png 192w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i098d405a2de20fd0/version/1597587053/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=384x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i098d405a2de20fd0/version/1597587053/image.png 384w" sizes="(min-width: 192px) 192px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8233251163" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i098d405a2de20fd0/version/1597587053/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1202" data-src-height="800" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i098d405a2de20fd0/version/1597587053/image.png" data-image-id="5424419763"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8233251163" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/25/opinion/letters/data-privacy-united-states.html" target="_blank" title="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/25/opinion/letters/data-privacy-united-states.html"><em>America Needs a Privacy Law</em></a>, <strong>New York Times</strong> (December 25, 2018) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8233251163">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8233251163,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"192","resizeHeight":128},"id":8233251163}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8358796463" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8233304563" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i797f86e4e67aac44/version/1597600818/image.png 193w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i797f86e4e67aac44/version/1597600818/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=386x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i797f86e4e67aac44/version/1597600818/image.png 386w" sizes="(min-width: 193px) 193px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8233304563" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i797f86e4e67aac44/version/1597600818/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="478" data-src-height="642" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i797f86e4e67aac44/version/1597600818/image.png" data-image-id="5424445563"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8233304563" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://techonomy.com/2018/12/after-latest-facebook-fiasco-focus-falls-on-federal-commission/" target="_blank" title="https://techonomy.com/2018/12/after-latest-facebook-fiasco-focus-falls-on-federal-commission/"><em>After Latest Facebook Fiasco, Focus Falls on Federal Commission,</em></a> <strong>Techonomy</strong> (December 21, 2018) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8233304563">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8233304563,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"193","resizeHeight":260},"id":8233304563}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8359003063" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8233252063" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i023ab0e513d0c98a/version/1597587629/image.png 193w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i023ab0e513d0c98a/version/1597587629/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=386x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i023ab0e513d0c98a/version/1597587629/image.png 386w" sizes="(min-width: 193px) 193px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8233252063" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i023ab0e513d0c98a/version/1597587629/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="959" data-src-height="833" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i023ab0e513d0c98a/version/1597587629/image.png" data-image-id="5424420263"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8233252063" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/03/opinion/letters/democracy-internet.html" target="_blank" title="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/03/opinion/letters/democracy-internet.html"><em>Democracy and the Internet,</em></a> <strong>New York Times</strong> (October 8, 2018) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8233252063">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8233252063,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"193","resizeHeight":168},"id":8233252063}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8359002863" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8233303363" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i8543e3c9a3cfc51f/version/1597600617/image.png 193w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i8543e3c9a3cfc51f/version/1597600617/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=386x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i8543e3c9a3cfc51f/version/1597600617/image.png 386w" sizes="(min-width: 193px) 193px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8233303363" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i8543e3c9a3cfc51f/version/1597600617/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1220" data-src-height="820" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i8543e3c9a3cfc51f/version/1597600617/image.png" data-image-id="5424445163"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8233303363" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg,聽<a href="https://techonomy.com/2018/05/facebook-whatsapp-lesson-privacy-protection-necessary-innovation/" target="_blank" title="https://techonomy.com/2018/05/facebook-whatsapp-lesson-privacy-protection-necessary-innovation/"><em>The Facebook-WhatsApp Lesson: Privacy Protection Necessary for Innovation,</em></a> <strong>Techonomy</strong> (May 4, 2018) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8233303363">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8233303363,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"193","resizeHeight":130},"id":8233303363}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8318383363" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8233251563" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie75da28c28991d13/version/1597587263/image.png 192w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie75da28c28991d13/version/1597587263/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=384x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie75da28c28991d13/version/1597587263/image.png 384w" sizes="(min-width: 192px) 192px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8233251563" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie75da28c28991d13/version/1597587263/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1206" data-src-height="804" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/ie75da28c28991d13/version/1597587263/image.png" data-image-id="5424419963"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8233251563" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/06/opinion/letters/regulating-privacy.html" target="_blank" title="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/06/opinion/letters/regulating-privacy.html"><em>Regulating Privacy</em></a>, <strong>New York Times</strong> (May 6, 2018) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8233251563">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8233251563,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"192","resizeHeight":128},"id":8233251563}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8358796863" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8358857863" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=179x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i397a1f26e62513c4/version/1638242447/image.png 179w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i397a1f26e62513c4/version/1638242447/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=358x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i397a1f26e62513c4/version/1638242447/image.png 358w" sizes="(min-width: 179px) 179px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8358857863" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=179x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i397a1f26e62513c4/version/1638242447/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="610" data-src-height="610" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=179x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i397a1f26e62513c4/version/1638242447/image.png" data-image-id="5521597263"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8358857863" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg,聽<a href="https://techonomy.com/2018/03/how-the-ftc-could-have-avoided-the-facebook-mess/" target="_blank" title="https://techonomy.com/2018/03/how-the-ftc-could-have-avoided-the-facebook-mess/">How the FTC Could Have Prevented the Facebook Mess</a>, <strong>Techonomy,</strong> March 22, 2018 </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8358857863">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8358857863,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"179","resizeHeight":179},"id":8358857863}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8358857963" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8358490863" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i0f2eb3a8afc5511f/version/1638210173/image.png 192w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i0f2eb3a8afc5511f/version/1638210173/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=384x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i0f2eb3a8afc5511f/version/1638210173/image.png 384w" sizes="(min-width: 192px) 192px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8358490863" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i0f2eb3a8afc5511f/version/1638210173/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="1376" data-src-height="940" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i0f2eb3a8afc5511f/version/1638210173/image.png" data-image-id="5521303763"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8358490863" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> <span style="font-size: 15px;">Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/let-rsquo-s-use-government-data-to-make-better-policy/" target="_blank" title="https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/let-rsquo-s-use-government-data-to-make-better-policy/">Let鈥檚 Use Government Data to Make Better Policy</a>聽<em>Scientific American,</em> October 17, 2017</span> </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8358490863">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8358490863,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"192","resizeHeight":132},"id":8358490863}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8358796263" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8233254763" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i748692c3902efa42/version/1597587855/image.png 192w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i748692c3902efa42/version/1597587855/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i748692c3902efa42/version/1597587855/image.png 332w" sizes="(min-width: 192px) 192px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8233254763" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i748692c3902efa42/version/1597587855/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="332" data-src-height="244" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=192x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i748692c3902efa42/version/1597587855/image.png" data-image-id="5424421263"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8233254763" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/28/opinion/when-the-government-is-watching-you.html" target="_blank" title="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/28/opinion/when-the-government-is-watching-you.html"><em>When the Government is Watching You,</em></a> <strong>New York Times</strong> (March 28, 2017) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8233254763">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8233254763,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"192","resizeHeight":142},"id":8233254763}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8318383763" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div><div id="cc-m-8233250463" class="j-module n j-textWithImage "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i22bd85531cc9b2f4/version/1597587698/image.png 193w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i22bd85531cc9b2f4/version/1597587698/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/none/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i22bd85531cc9b2f4/version/1597587698/image.png 332w" sizes="(min-width: 193px) 193px, 100vw" id="cc-m-textwithimage-image-8233250463" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i22bd85531cc9b2f4/version/1597587698/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="332" data-src-height="244" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=193x1024:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i22bd85531cc9b2f4/version/1597587698/image.png" data-image-id="5424419563"/> </figure> <div> <div id="cc-m-textwithimage-8233250463" data-name="text" data-action="text" class="cc-m-textwithimage-inline-rte"> <p> Marc Rotenberg, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/11/opinion/bias-by-computer.html" target="_blank" title="https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/11/opinion/bias-by-computer.html"><em>Bias by Computer,</em>聽</a><strong>New York Times</strong> (August 10, 2016) </p> </div> </div> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8233250463">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_textWithImage", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8233250463,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"193","resizeHeight":142},"id":8233250463}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8318384163" class="j-module n j-hr "> <hr/> </div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-overlay" data-display="cms-only"></div> <br class="cc-clear"/> </div></div> </div> </div>  </div>  <div class="jtpl-section-aside"> <aside class="jtpl-sidebar sidebar-options"><div class="jtpl-sidebar__inner alignment-options"> <div data-container="sidebar"><div id="cc-matrix-2099356263"><div id="cc-m-8224769863" class="j-module n j-hgrid "> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column" style="width: 31.17%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2099356563"><div id="cc-m-8224769963" class="j-module n j-imageSubtitle "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=305x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i28ab272ab408a3ce/version/1596465196/image.png 305w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i28ab272ab408a3ce/version/1596465196/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=610x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i28ab272ab408a3ce/version/1596465196/image.png 610w" sizes="(min-width: 305px) 305px, 100vw" id="cc-m-imagesubtitle-image-8224769963" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=305x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i28ab272ab408a3ce/version/1596465196/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="768" data-src-height="221" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=305x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i28ab272ab408a3ce/version/1596465196/image.png" data-image-id="5419814763"/> </figure> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8224769963">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_imageSubtitle", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"","hyperlink_target":"_blank","hyperlinkAsString":"","pinterest":"0","id":8224769963,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"305","resizeHeight":88},"id":8224769963}); // ]]> </script></div><div id="cc-m-8428107663" class="j-module n j-search "><div class="j-search-wrapper j-search-alignment-0"> <div class="j-search-content" style="width: 100%;"> <form action="/search" class="j-formnew"> <span class="cc-m-form-view-sortable"> <input type="text" class="j-search-input" aria-label="Search" name="q" placeholder="Search" value=""/> <input type="hidden" name="filter" value="0"/> <input type="hidden" name="module" value="8428107663"/> <button type="submit" style="display: none"/> </span> </form> </div> </div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8428107663">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_search", {"alignment":"0","width":"100","filter":"0","placeholder":"Search","id":8428107663}); // ]]> </script></div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-separator" data-display="cms-only"><div></div></div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column" style="width: 20.53%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2099356663"><div id="cc-m-8224770063" class="j-module n j-text "><p style="text-align: left;"> <a href="/" title="Home"><span style="font-size: 15px;">Home</span></a> </p> <p style="text-align: left;"> <a href="/news/" title="News"><span style="font-size: 15px;">News</span></a> </p> <p style="text-align: left;"> <a href="/statements/" title="Statements"><span style="font-size: 15px;">Statements</span></a> </p> <p style="text-align: left;"> <a href="/reports/" title="Reports"><span style="font-size: 15px;">Reports</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/public-voice/" title="Public Voice"><span style="font-size: 15px;">Public Voice</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/events/" title="Events"><span style="font-size: 15px;">Events</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/about-2/team/" title="Team"><span style="font-size: 15px; color: #ffffff;">Team</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/about-2/" title="About"><span style="font-size: 15px; color: #ffffff;">About</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="https://www.nfggive.org/guidestar/86-3350258" target="_blank" title="https://www.nfggive.org/guidestar/86-3350258"><span style="font-size: 15px; color: #ffffff;">Donate</span></a> </p></div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-separator" data-display="cms-only"><div></div></div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column" style="width: 26.71%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2099356763"><div id="cc-m-8224770163" class="j-module n j-text "><p> 聽<a href="/reports/aidv-2021/" title="AIDV-2021"><span style="font-size: 15px;">AI and Democratic Values (2022)</span></a> </p> <p> <span style="font-size: 15px;"><a href="/global-academic-network/" title="Global Academic Network">Global Academic Network</a></span> </p> <p> <a href="/global-academic-network/ai-policy-clinic/" title="AI Policy Clinic">AI Policy Clinic</a> </p> <p> <a href="javascript:void(0);" title="Law Fellows">Law Fellows</a> </p> <p> <a href="/global-academic-network/extern-program/" title="Extern Program">Extern Program</a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/resources/" title="Resources"><span style="font-size: 15px;">Resources</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/resources/eu-ai-act/" title="EU AI Act"><span style="font-size: 15px;">- EU AI Act</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/resources/coe-ai-treaty/" title="COE AI Treaty"><span style="font-size: 15px;">- Council of Europe AI Treaty</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/resources/naiac/" title="NAIAC"><span style="font-size: 15px;">- National AI Advisory Committee</span></a> </p> <p style="caret-color: #000000; color: #000000;"> <a href="/resources/trade-and-technology-council/" title="Trade and Technology Council"><span style="font-size: 15px;">- EU-US Trade and Technology Council</span></a> </p></div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-separator" data-display="cms-only"><div></div></div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-column last" style="width: 15.56%;"> <div id="cc-matrix-2099356863"><div id="cc-m-8410182163" class="j-module n j-imageSubtitle "><figure class="cc-imagewrapper cc-m-image-align-1"> <a href="/donate/"><img srcset="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=172x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i5e3cff7b054c4fe8/version/1661959271/image.png 172w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=320x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i5e3cff7b054c4fe8/version/1661959271/image.png 320w, https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=344x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i5e3cff7b054c4fe8/version/1661959271/image.png 344w" sizes="(min-width: 172px) 172px, 100vw" id="cc-m-imagesubtitle-image-8410182163" src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=172x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i5e3cff7b054c4fe8/version/1661959271/image.png" alt="" class="" data-src-width="598" data-src-height="388" data-src="https://image.jimcdn.com/app/cms/image/transf/dimension=172x10000:format=png/path/s899a9742c3d83292/image/i5e3cff7b054c4fe8/version/1661959271/image.png" data-image-id="5567259863"/></a> </figure> <div class="cc-clear"></div> <script id="cc-m-reg-8410182163">// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("module_imageSubtitle", {"data":{"imageExists":true,"hyperlink":"\/app\/s899a9742c3d83292\/p6ba1de820b560af4\/","hyperlink_target":"","hyperlinkAsString":"Donate","pinterest":"0","id":8410182163,"widthEqualsContent":"0","resizeWidth":"172","resizeHeight":112},"id":8410182163}); // ]]> </script></div></div> </div> <div class="cc-m-hgrid-overlay" data-display="cms-only"></div> <br class="cc-clear"/> </div></div></div> </div> </aside><footer class="jtpl-footer footer-options"><div class="jtpl-footer__inner alignment-options"> <div id="contentfooter" data-container="footer"> <div class="j-meta-links"> <a href="/about/">About</a> | <a href="//www.caidp.org/j/privacy">Privacy Policy</a><br/>Copyright 漏 2020-2023 Center for AI and Digital Policy </div> <div class="j-admin-links"> <span class="loggedin"> <a rel="nofollow" id="logout" target="_top" href="https://cms.e.jimdo.com/app/cms/logout.php"> Log out </a> | <a rel="nofollow" id="edit" target="_top" href="https://a.jimdo.com/app/auth/signin/jumpcms/?page=1401367663">Edit</a> </span> </div> </div> </div> </footer> </div>  <div class="jtpl-cart"> </div>  </div>  </div> <ul class="cc-FloatingButtonBarContainer cc-FloatingButtonBarContainer-left hidden">  <li class="cc-FloatingButtonBarContainer-button-scroll"> <a href="javascript:void(0);" title="Scroll to top"> <span>Scroll to top</span> </a> </li> <script>// <![CDATA[ window.regModule("common_scrolltotop", []); // ]]> </script> </ul> <script type="text/javascript"> //<![CDATA[ addAutomatedTracking('creator.website', track_anon); //]]> </script> </body> </html>