CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "academic.oup.com",cType: 'managed',cRay: '91371a068ee1fd14',cH: 'LJd_FrNuCL6jAb.YlE.IXcjpfD8VTXPb_9Zg4Of0zZc-1739809194-1.2.1.1-wqoXV08o42f6PnHgP7vmiCOkwxlzQrGAIRNeuYw.mgC7O2Y05e1tKLlU5Rp2L9Bx',cUPMDTk: "\/jxb\/article-lookup\/doi\/10.1093\/jxb\/47.12.1833?__cf_chl_tk=Z2O_wU9.ZDxy0v2QSgej4P6Z1GraKJIL2q0g07XfFfI-1739809194-1.0.1.1-OpY8dS1Y5MPuF_AV8B1Fe4eLBPtpX7iP6EuS0z7Ngh4",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1739809194',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/jxb\/article-lookup\/doi\/10.1093\/jxb\/47.12.1833?__cf_chl_f_tk=Z2O_wU9.ZDxy0v2QSgej4P6Z1GraKJIL2q0g07XfFfI-1739809194-1.0.1.1-OpY8dS1Y5MPuF_AV8B1Fe4eLBPtpX7iP6EuS0z7Ngh4",md: "MC6z_gpzqDgE8nJbd1CEwExUFP2IKvj3VGeoN0vKPTk-1739809194-1.2.1.1-PoaMJdjlBgSvSE9Q1F_eR6U8HfEdYQIlcpyvEjSB.Qqr07onSl5eZjPfsV05DruoWf0c_6nA62CF3wbwr_dXumOBH14pRCGqkfb7l4cMLzPD4Til_Aw.Sb_SmntBp.aOy35ijdVayotX3iP_vzeVGFvMuA26e3TZwtWEiOKiWaCXtQ7NQaZHQ0zjqs3ERcMek0njJzdzE.85xbWdsMTW1vbU9pC0plNG0KhgkS3HK_Fi1F_84NbbnshzThDq3x7eoPswE9O4ogiz68nyNjGfyePUcrnIqHLjcIo1FQn6wYv6ppFivbGC9mZAaDd8nnObw7ouaBcWCFDQ.Emw_5X68FaXt7TOPP4_0Ax6R_Zn9u29GC9ub8wWB6L4oh4mK1wwUaXESLb31kPz7hJWOYk3EDI8k_SXo5TZLUBqPJN8Q9mJmkWGcIHsQoCPFoiMGZMoCkQUJ2m_p6t3DW2KDDnfwF9ai5L5JVudmsZB7rx5I_g3aiDCmm1RDG2rlA03GICVSApG.w3n4CprKNhbM4O4MFWcBwwUJVLXjdK_9piQJlB.cWZAq7Nzij6Hdjj9CeO4ZZC9tJyiFD66ftayN7thBgdw9.dXfjb6MaSPIFhCyuIyS_v.NAAlDPapPqHTLvYodiPbUyWoUM7yclZ8m_Z.vYzFOdfw5tWrXIcj5CLR207aIx3lVXR.DH5HHoC_bQ2c0LRYMFQnjdeV3EGlcaaH6tSRko0nxpcxh82JEkAYr_AbRSo5Yb01H9eb1lm85VLqCg2Ms2hg_3xkWPLqZcgMZFmAzCf29.fuaDCC5fz9BJpMwoZK.j7Bd0ll.fhL_L_qd6kjsS0prcXBcnJaRgOKXnZ14aFklFgZA12U2Xf6z8Z0Kez5JtmlYWqMppG0Rxv2oHDbQaXADC5vu5kkdh_4vlqE6OMmfowxq5p03SS7o_svtvvdqVAwyeZE2H2oDD5Yf06eI_vin2yZKhPWsyxd5aWXWzDKSb6XtUsfkSslobsPYx4d.gZqAZsScHXeSPywTf2p7FxMuDeIK5YTmvdOUQwNoMADYdNxQnCVQVfH5gAl3d9bnksr3ZqOljnvb4isV4XomipjQJVp3nFrDxKlZObcKk8XLt54ARLPl8RRsUvvT2s8BH_azMR13T8mOSqRMHvKxT.bw5VF6nUNNRQq9PHdPbqU87q58rvjMAg19KmKyjv.FJJsqKBnJUAlYMwyRTfPpWFUj1z.tg2Gvnu4PGATaMhLww9TpkwHXtMzG5s6a.pqxCBirBT1YbzcQvD56GFDTTbjgIUWHT359Cp2iHi4N1xhi03MFhpj3zdue5f.ITV6aqk4IL8jbYMtyL33nBfMlwCkUlvL3UwCWQSTmuJtwzp.V.xsRtiOA7O1JMwdJZPsGtneBebjm0_h2R5jMGybOC_2IZzU_ONvjS0oPp4qNo_jM1vJFRg0u3_kf1da4gWWRwmPu351qyDWUHCmSyODil2I9.43pNbuFlfI0VdXFYXGQYofhYS8OVpKqb.uARACQISQDLK8ptyVUXzIi8a.rprusWs1LC1GBJnNak7g.uM7VkJ2Yi2DpfjV6qh3kZ4cg9VzShjvGRumK0cxsyU1oYeuslHehuF5Ii872O2aXDM1yxhHIw4rNZg_w3PDj6ao8GR.Y8BKZ5O4AsnM.9M9Y6btGD8kIifHZzwPRp6h09yomb5CTJi9AZ7P13APdKGSWqhCuSLf62lwXN8KioObhmsgf_8GPKfG6d2W9vLFwxk4q8E_sYv74cOCxuTzOM.aqpCTo8ddmsHU0Xdh8FOZNJVpfHeEFz1Rlqcz1rXXwXatf.u9JAvNYoHR8JuPHjL4PZ.JPLh.1SB_NDPDCegxdkdovFDFhdQV.RUl0kZHsKxKG5DAGMlb1QaZwrN035Wy2uD3iTsbVf3Ma1W6KockgN9cS8c532l8szamgsHn8jnp7E_NTd3umU2u2fm7_vnAuj6OOlg09LshKeU9qo_H1BUk6dK4NwZHb84HnR0db_b5FJUbs98hnovIrjEHxySdIhV_Llu1_j3c_t.ZharK4EThGERkCfaNbE4lEyE95YTKS0aynWrp15YEQ88dw5fHXlLuBhTa7kQodp9YJkx8NB95tYZB3kzhRiB3sqzE46CDZ5MGFk23sWskdDUMNAAGQwTR07yYyw.yJJaY72cBPVgbH5D7vHrgTKcnuKOUw2__i_73ByBDncASIJ.Gqf6nPLKFs9aorTuMehMmtUaU3hpMV3a2czvZCIatOyhVexOwncdgT0A3avEKHuJsnRmX2RNci32opdl9SluGSFD9e32X_rdXv405LqosEcuxdTLlqQp6zRkF4mWEO1YVN2_1BZonRaGPQqJsVXgUXzCY4Pu7BU2CMmU9hMrhmecshLW4wfx7u_zahnbj7QUuC_cE1O5YuY2dCRctL2UcPlbjUFkrNPIW3J0gxnskAUaz2t3LvMSo0ZcWZ4M9AyvSZLdry2zkDaZCWtGPP99KW1vXe1xkBsvsF45Sfr6jRYBKVKTCHNqlLPnWXHkvUaHBGBGSFSag9BfzetGaOytMlVpUOgDrxv77tGyyjX5NS1xlDPqVv7GROq1LCvoF2fedRxvQAlqe9Uy67sp3mBf14Ud5vLztw5JPSPEmgMKV.Q",mdrd: "4dH2v6UUEDCxD7kb2dHpsEtb0OxITWcCYT3WuoAA9x4-1739809194-1.2.1.1-hrkJ6qnaELe6UYLssoBw3zJu4nEMMEZiZJ8pM8lG5vxSBxbRlXf.KEXlEbG9nV3awfzXBcelTMRQ5gVukjS7Q6WabmmIfPAX5lkRlYaz5BAEV8vZ11NCvpNq7JMqiVuoG0O.sp1LDYtQs7dzna6xHB9CTriV0nvLnhAfowAoPdPB0Oj7nj_rzOVmZiKq4NXkeeyBXgFrV7_FQGzGptZbRZ8SExZAMmzAamp1oUrEn.52ezpuOsNwjwjC4whczzkZj4eMNPHHFAIcfILSzsqhivDksen52URoNC8jJJu8X8DyKaoOyYrNCXWq8jRMqm0YZBj8pAcKBNDB3Z2nF9CGgFkrak5JyBRpr8uhdEMnEchD2fK1ezHLrybdaeStKJ1RkrisOfMgF5J8w7YeyN4_kAxEFHe.ect8YtUPxBZiv1kxYm4NE3cw9v.2SbC94ePDVWS3gy1pLKCw4Qc_XtsSncbWSG5qr.v463N1hvLINYFrcu6T36UqKBmHIIAab3.4J1llmKwdXXSC0ne2Tr5hA.I6NX3HkugNv_ny1s5zEwPPZb_weku_0A8ukUWL46SDyc7RitQ8cv5DDDBXP4RndDl_kcZ.K98TEHDiOL_jeMZi4sEc9QKH2T_PghIXF5LLCwH1_WLZuGxhsn5R9TS00QlNvIxHYAwQ1fu8EUg2UOlXgImOMhBiBsz6FgspGuDlfNFLBlV0ydhQphSeBpVtF7GvfxTEyql50h2TTw_Vhb4FmgcIOI6irktcaRs5DDSfp41QHoCXZmsvekMDxaOOx.C2DCw2F9LiqchjcTsT7QvUMwGDGDBJsUlxPrFL7mVGQD7_H.dipdcqThoguse6vzM3ppKI.kSerusccl8s50MTDVsUNj9ZTY_vYv4Vo10pDfsBej_4pfWw2cC5VRP08HQVqA0jJQQOh5YTjbXFhTAN5stBCsqEPlaDk2vb.ohVyALdfwMZPr.WrKgOy2N0___WsbNY8sShbdIrxNhh0ZVqlKV7MANR5_tIivAXO.AElQ9toJlbd_0gviAkhjqxZ3XYD1ozto37svJeWwFrvUDZicMGclNaLBtomYtS2bo9sbKoyTxIAyyOKQu7Sz6QM5nRAnRn7cr3ZdDWIuRH2nS6dbOzFXcQqPPx_78trBN8iU4nilpAB4lUVgTYaXfcyg8ZR5TwaVcrudoPShAv9ToV36DYKRkRyywoOE7Og911RIuRVNVGuJIaK3Cfw_iQATpcmQdZyxfUX0C8bhBRbqmQKYCQ4598fOg3idRMPJER2n0v7zIqSosdMjbM9g._iUrkD9LT0SDeGpAjUiqpj.M38RDtP5AI6oFuihSeQOnxOyx2Hh8Qhqg2R0.DhxVmhE2ts28ICWv3O.8QJFFXsS6J6hFW5AgoCItTH5EbzGFHch8a3C4k6U3EywW4iRobaBoy4DgHcWDcjkDCFOCO5y0gePGr.YGoRJZR9Ijr2B.zVq5BK5rYCNStXAAfHUoUpkA.vDiWQI0HWrY_DGKr3VoT2TVAvCZsgw3td7p1bh8g9ZHcAeR4OMW7lOo5YTbXcNHN7HwKkF5YJL1FGGGH31U2E6OF5GwM5dvV.mCQURNaw.VAw0gV2.CcAYURHkTOOLRso96h2O6n1gN3Ic23s7qYyi0yRtb2cKK2KMGaWOoDylmtZRGTTeZQl26uQ_AiTO5z4XbbBSbj60PZZHoWlstMIXka.22.xoV3TIWu4MyAk4zEANm9GrdZogQCEsERWKN8ndE8eMVpoc4XYDw70dD.b71m10ldTJt8OouMbZh86h7UqKXgJYKYZjOD5_o8H1iDVHeZY5xCuAdfzpJedlrpdpQ9vmLKN0Ib.RW8PepEylLjOkXhn4EYm9vyTJucWPjh7cmSmLmkEkEt.EhSqtuhnOVkCKtMl2YiXpf06iHXG.4uaUbwJlzaUPZo2Dg_38ft1W8krgUQSYdUopLejeo"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=91371a068ee1fd14';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/jxb\/article-lookup\/doi\/10.1093\/jxb\/47.12.1833?__cf_chl_rt_tk=Z2O_wU9.ZDxy0v2QSgej4P6Z1GraKJIL2q0g07XfFfI-1739809194-1.0.1.1-OpY8dS1Y5MPuF_AV8B1Fe4eLBPtpX7iP6EuS0z7Ngh4" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>