CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.chronicle.com",cType: 'managed',cRay: '917732dd0f843fab',cH: 'Z3z.4HAod4Y6WBXF6Bkmdob85bIBiIyzzDmMgEadMRI-1740481300-1.2.1.1-2HcZE861UUdE9gpnEtfyqT6XU74eTjUkTbv23v_gi8tsNtI65Z81u02REkm7QjVB',cUPMDTk: "\/article\/Predatory-Online-Journals\/131047\/?__cf_chl_tk=crlX4AekAnfgKl87gd3Ga3VKIOidNfEa_fOfegrgQm8-1740481300-1.0.1.1-YmsfSr61zJW2WqD1F3g_I1iGf5E7IDlpfmLeKt_vjYw",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1740481300',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/article\/Predatory-Online-Journals\/131047\/?__cf_chl_f_tk=crlX4AekAnfgKl87gd3Ga3VKIOidNfEa_fOfegrgQm8-1740481300-1.0.1.1-YmsfSr61zJW2WqD1F3g_I1iGf5E7IDlpfmLeKt_vjYw",md: "4dnCoIGWPRp553C3FAB8TzPmrdNKknZfPL9hG1gMRXQ-1740481300-1.2.1.1-04jN9VD1y9TxuSvF5UmlZjz56PVdZBH_Faws.hsnTs8Ue874v8.a8lEjJXx.xJzygrkaO0z2bCf7sqXE8btL5ukXZSho3csKqkAAhabragrIxBfZv8GS5q2Hbw8XrSBdrv0RpaiAKIpZeBz1JozPmpKzPssMLGhsI5F435_LAlqK2lid.YonAtjsyZz53iav5lvT.5dWedAxLo7bP6zT.R_KTeoF5iRwmuFiImnORddd_3.wXgBTOt9wYp48t0AiJ8N1HzPpKAQD9pCLBpIJqJ.GY0PBLemYymdzAHhUQG2xEdaUgBJO6gwe2oB2mZmH7HdiKXre6y3aakXfJ.Wz0Kb183MrHwyqn5zGcEX00sg3YhOfxGSS54U6LE9ffwoVy7OS_X9NFgBqSa4hQx2L2mNYGWNSlNMh2KYOdI2gv73vDD32OxcdFbAkCdOYwBt9nw.VEYqtU9t44Kc7rCXUOB2BvmnKKg0Qg8q3WzZesN2c2jbNP5VieYnl8GTAellmfuUKXlHh0aEbcft_Vr7DQvdt5fem3dIeExi6ayrqgAn43mbCHtZWue6UJpYgwCgu7dI9HYUabakhwB6cuHYEs_B_mdNw6EDjnHbbeJ_J5YlGdgAJm_7x1r2LrO.U1NV8iEMqP2EHaEqrqQExjYpTQcFpTodAKWXNQ8Fmb0ciW3ajBLOiSaem_.p67JSPEb2wr1akldVTrLZQOMvaVrdG68Wvd3nlxB06ygNNsx1Re8yfuGSbuPvt5Mx13OGdu0GzlXtU3HEgnOVCOA0x2Sj6OhEzx0hJ4pyAPMcOngy3UNCg1kOFjAASVS2HwHobvNrUm4v2GGeUEykjYQcejusDSdYUam5h8CKb7MvjlU4VGL4sOayeuGUfyy0Kv7RnT6wUNlZfbVN9soN2s5rEgEYEhSrzwhlZJAnzrjYlcoVBv2u8Ng2RK3Nt2ctVoPPDvvPHkulgFaMkFhQ2Zu0ugo.iagbQgk6.2q5l3bQyGk6iqWKketY77wqxNanslt8h1xem9uWz3kVLa76WCbKGdiPibfkOSxG.D8HF6LNpSsgWZea29ExvMA0TEhiU3XmWGjazBribc7pRrx0gETEzuhwuL0ZJUFEibWvV7A9E7EmaBVdwHKNuL0aMxVEnmrgoe34t_7IsgjhIOt8s3ctq1Hy2ew5KCr6P.6W35Inst0i4sRbWinC7dZuQtSa2hOXFFFi7wT4mj9Yz2F592SFEjinSef9e5lC_cL9stXQhLR6k8.ldvleivs1WAl9c7oCRlTSfpt4k5.htPd1RdIKIcMLzNiYK8EPwaenjT1vukXUtLg9jZdtayf07EZ6BU3TiUrBCwbFzKUxeEfwlvaxWjLzE3RC8MMr.NEz_ktCdTibqw8fvZw2U.JFmB26V6ds9UU8l2lV5tSgqfqc1m6K1OWepVe_CphdPlxBHBQ8t1KrQATX7VEjHKHz87XmxkRgqQVrXhR5cFSUKCILKhuF5Y5d698TqsdAEU2bvLT8gddunKAk4rSONCmvQmQMT17j07KoGXIS8OsWTb_KZUfZ2Sg8qcC3zsfTPUqy3JI0uVeR33vPOCVS4VcmIwQA7urvYAA7IzgMStXJVvVtlG0AyjS5BJH3vTejTc7FAtYkRMMAgXrvlxTRgczdQpEkRVJKRzBO9qz_zM2vWoLsfbDHD12UPRBuf7Zp61yd3PN7oxu2MwFM2IQHgB4nD__.dfVFOlt6ZNrccwpLod5YlroJhYAcCXM8yXB9XBHGnGALO34fFU98GfvkxpKpU0OHYQ_nJd0aoolc6c5KA0gqupZVfxeWPeoZmArJSGLIaqcF64VNn5uk_QgFWxOotzDxyIhKzfsTky7Vvyhq.x4.9DpTY2u.Kbd3cPWYujyot8MDbPu5Ql_VVH8YpUzsmmiZ.2wKJQMqkbtM0olc2shMAFwGdsl5SwolatNsOHxKL0_KFv7ecl8mVqCzjp3D1GSJYbENNtqCSLxNNT7zrqYNw5SJ2xJM7wl20YyyXfv_IVtFNiBZSaATHqY3.9ytqDkbFhvfhJAd83EGXcZl1PcKoyETHp6QBfymDph_C0snvrmJh12HV1ci2GS8GDAWdCmkOpQgNQF14SQi7JbOLtTlsjNVsTvikNeN9.JpuB9G7fHXrHTz_DxaxszONRtyLX7esnbcfF_E52lb7IBppHNU.1R5jzpXoYQIlqqEmDKkP2Od5SHlIs.A.4Secg7Zmi5vNp5dR6_c.kM0eBHJuqegMSB95oiT__AQr3WwvmdfUt5_20epp3.xP0C0MN9KQvh5sVk9flwBtsrBPtPmuXN9qGvrPlo_oMlPU_WPJyjtaSfbmzmtuAL1X7dq7hBS.EBQcL.XSaCw8dq0JQbjDeNtrJrgyaBy0mvIv254jslnkHpfxyO7CkZ90SGI8n5i3QBPo3P16ZXUb60780tofRaOniOXY72Ph85UIhnVPfW35ezAV4Xgh1tppeNZo5ZLkgroLpgJvXkV06TFFGP.ifYcGdmc.WWQrlHKXk2gggZ3rFMK6cvodxjf8e0kxAEzbZWQsqWkaHaQhfRIKhXiAmF9it2YtZmg30NeTrqXuuTHIiQf07cFX1CPgQPXMTZrf3rsRWSkidNAs",mdrd: ".SF1hT2P.QNZbu.31wFlLEyC8nckTFJ_byVBOUt_qLM-1740481300-1.2.1.1-stwI_3FCdazmihoR5Il0azPEJguTBcAFuJVBAhiP4UN0zNfKfgRL4gUDi0oy4TrOSBVmxXGuwRZgjpQjsRoXPr4CrscLnoMe5mC97Hp2QFk.mwWzxLjOekAzGzP0BR5UMuONhFyGfpQaqrxvBteu5zNiPtGfbXHhVWf7XvQin1P4alzuoo2sizYvfUv6RbbLwXxuV925z4Xf0IX9X34noAH4dGupDCMub3eshWpw0zdhhVebDsxLOqjZmXbEGS17qrOVu2E4E9y.FvAMPuypZDMFZUlscnjO5gQ6YbCxqaUYyqLwpEjm5ndTnxRj9fyoc37GeWUAPGEJVP24vdsjffbGVrc9gEh0oF1tnaO.CGZYs_Ql_6yt8CQC7QNsJFW3ehZXr0bXOdkoPj84LaUpFixmckANzpNJoLJH78gmPdsIuLsb8mf1j3SVvzPSjadc28XYwlQL7RA7ZDhcB3yqUzzq3pght9BZST7SyxGEfDyo5CPf4RWri035k2uFY17vVdQUNISOq5_Fj5mXe0R8OFEVq1PZctGj6igc5VWklFGnTodSvdelbAxIdDQaKOqBnbQxK1BOrNZIGPC4dOJUSiYmGrImi_qMsonHvRFsnzSZ2BTBpmyWGawnBiyNR2sp_zNLPQQKHVLTO7MzB3ovgpPZPMXIMksRl3K_a87VIxDrbRzsN20wqkiNK4UM8Yt2PPJyiQrFr5mWLvTPKYUMRYFdKTDIWg0O162_W9O0sVCRNoSaM9imDt1jHXLDWojdmadnCiLv34sTGMCuS34VScnGnznRao8hDHHn886wium4r_2bgSJkyiCPq2XV7Il4P1uzHFXtXrrWg_.xyDAUH3oaZD8VyAMQXKVJ0dx1ftT07d4AnvQbCMRtzPis7c19l0qFuW58bQGUaIhySsyO1ZYjROKvxvP0yeVX4zP1dtWOTBs.W6rbpvYOUkfCFi_tvq.40BpRBwoKqWl9z2E_ZQsxfSVqisQydLgF.aILcTSNdLvowx_GszwGOpptw_L3HPyk7iI3pG1Ne09OFV_Q9OgzNxpBGknlt8rl5b0a7Qb87ZcgSVfNjt7_B7C2mg5F63kuF0FxiRAI_T.OHsbxDencx2kGQs_oUEn0V93N7ZyUlF9zUBjKFssAX.SCZRo19DkMu_Xf0AWmYHqXeFmzm21UlvKzLoAiB2u1nDynQi8jTDhcHiN2m70BFhk8mLB2pQ_Nhr_kDS16p2QcdBEFjxEh2rg3MqlGlszjN.GD35bU_KnYPN_bQIwc1GTEWVazdTEhfSCykVJ0NeUfzsVE98vGlnYiGjhpj9eV7JRMU2BHTKQo4TN27Weo6VCudRd3076OA1lKDD.nH2FRlp07vp9YQE1CwyLBbvNlSajyFCrs8b1qdD46oysP3ym7gM8JP.CadoOhGZOP2qM_5uvE5njV1IOYKDqMWbvF0LM2HHtgkN35JuWX16GTOJbNIFnwbbb8_RBvJiFeHBB2rFjj3Pag4ACZBSfIjHIOuSmQojGqEU2nMx4sw3Eg_0kVhwqok2hsL9mHqEUyQQcmGxTwSeP0RCPBXrPXMAOPlLspKO1eLjh.zT1Q3Zk6hEBhA5QhmxdY.umqQWJJzC5Qm_hw4niHLs1V1npAfB2ey.ArxTpwM.H2s2RmQebujWwzTcl0VBd4NkiszsAUR1v3k0aePI1_BZ4yDe.4pioETlvdqpnelnYTMJJ7qIwOE8c1WyXolJvKMYjXGPrPzsXEyB9R6ZD0cRVTdiXxvcxgyi9suhoTipkJrzNQp4M2FQ.uNGULXzgahfBq6V0V2sDeojZ7s8xT5J0PHchCd1GCTysa3wdyypkNXBqnHHF3ZiaHDM4_jjbm5jZtwWr.Upk94MByde7IkHfkEEWr3V7ncaGYKCFm.LVDt5tcqdQH1acMn3ROy.7odi9SE6F_FDhUTKdjBtvOWwuMRZdcsv8IMWs2SEC2Q_hOYUIakOCTh9SNSAcO"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=917732dd0f843fab';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/article\/Predatory-Online-Journals\/131047\/?__cf_chl_rt_tk=crlX4AekAnfgKl87gd3Ga3VKIOidNfEa_fOfegrgQm8-1740481300-1.0.1.1-YmsfSr61zJW2WqD1F3g_I1iGf5E7IDlpfmLeKt_vjYw" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>