CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="120"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.annualreviews.org",cType: 'non-interactive',cRay: '8e754e7d8e58ce2f',cH: 'NM69ooI.zYvXmzTXPaRzqy7OwtYhTQGgysl1uj.9K5Q-1732408396-1.2.1.1-5aCP0im9RFl6RU1hRrIIk8628jnFPF3FXYtjyXUzWOUg2Ng7zLW40zXFmGK3DE5c',cUPMDTk: "\/doi\/10.1146\/annurev.energy.30.050504.144248?__cf_chl_tk=tU3._JXKddUTy7E7HZqnJUBj9F.2MXNI._A8xLEE.DE-1732408396-1.0.1.1-9ahlTV5ffCQ5NeDluopCqHEpF.VmVgxy7QDyqF2TiBo",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732408396',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '120000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/doi\/10.1146\/annurev.energy.30.050504.144248?__cf_chl_f_tk=tU3._JXKddUTy7E7HZqnJUBj9F.2MXNI._A8xLEE.DE-1732408396-1.0.1.1-9ahlTV5ffCQ5NeDluopCqHEpF.VmVgxy7QDyqF2TiBo",md: "FHAONsIc7m0ztjtr3M8oKpJbn8n9FvmR1ufXhDPwkfI-1732408396-1.2.1.1-qmABOL39bs_MXlHK8lMkS1sRQ4ZyArUKpsuKNGpnVuaGjrqmvcjg9YYaqhia5e7lVdyg6z4jdk1_y2yhU3_qNWdD0XLWHgNyP2L2nDg00otARBJtlZRFrbcxNwRzzOzNMhtPXP0vjsNBu14ILU2Z88pqJYMuKsRuQJCjbmrFxrPqkl8JVWb7WIFo5RsSf3VbnBl2E_lRjLalyLrmLXbLzNmVYs.sDkOvJ.Ggv5RWQfzt6VGsv_6e.3CJsINfPLeFmqCUPn9Qn7oCUBmdA9sRehKIm0rN37ADS_00vtmnHsvHsobx1bqZV89tJUrMSxUnfHCaWvvZT58n13yT5TIHQcIJbXsvNRhmmWK4zIRePtRL3_oJgm8F7XWEtzuFSsk3QBKYxzdKtCQ8qknJS5PDiDd7ldxEU5ofz2REYX.LlrVbSbFVVMHkqHIDULy9dQPR9KJ1JcvRUEzbUmFinAbf8EPWoFPI2V9A0qB8n.0dSeTVOhI.3QXkd04JLEleGa0M4Z49p23tnVc7Tqf7ThlQMgN2FBycJoMRoPKDZhcTQsPGnNHzJUAFxbI85Kd6JHlh3XHCSZ88jYsx0.7zlnBHw5mCC84PQoB9N88rbeNpKfuYBcWiBn1h6SLR6cdEXx8y6CvgPex0yBQ.GAp_ypBCPZaCqvJM2VL3cyrpabpBtr2cEK7Eqm.99BC7pAm1kqW0EHM7CPFZe3Flwl2ZXwYnBJxxF02KuNWkUKdxCVb3pJFi78lx1kJmaUjqk8D2z22wMMRokSv5j.3T9lMlh3XTNm8im8nnzBpxYSSis5ixS4QLL11IIaw83g_Pm0E2o8LZswKzz7_eJJll18k6sLitmBnBiHJRFwcL4VTxaRlq3_HdF5yMFyOt6yVgtsHySHf955F7UAyoNWPVJ9g8v46kC1i59kM20OTxWlzMIxQV5NZe0ECglEW9EJDADza.F8Q4JhyVSpH2kf_KxYL8g7Mw2ky_kEkBXLy47JBr4b4ZXzMpXiwp7_3qrHa5AxNcCOnfsOCUtQSwNmhbD5RHmb31u4XSEznsGr40QW3nI4xqPSsS.Ybqll6Dbbl087aEj.RxSPnDaxmeNMB3qeccy3D9iV3EQV4Ev91jIN9F_3GFTqLOgki_L5aq39UR0_AznIDw1lc9ci3yY4_hfk8uUwT2jujRzy0BMrTuUJKr9NKDwbjBV2jaKEgrsKfpLOTwY8Nkn5B._ppSfVMbMEKG6PCL73Ahe1_lLH3dpjOX0wwToyoq_y8IeKFoE1rEK3zkan6o5zDMYeizLi_5sb6RbjEvmcWdZfPsHhu7gqg3aXVx7K9DQ8AHCSlGqM6aXxLbmbTG0ygYJFg08GP1QNttrvGS8rxAbCoK8vXLjym_sILhUDU97L56wZeovZbJqG29FQpQElAHVsxRp5CLfN4p8sDkrqoaMw5E19.AbalfVrhXOuTWULd3OgBPMESP_HKfSVhay1t6DuXIO0Zu1vo2_Rj4QctMaTKTDygcNALj.JNu4boVwnt5N6Di6Sjx78o6lJ_KHg.kidzOBXlEmHvuGC9EgwlmDhCZB0HL7skJOK.kbkTWkhQb3thSFS1XBrcDRBQ331sL.mBMDmPPZylcVdgyeLc95MmJZChBfKC8uU9JF21Go51sOvNv12hUKGBqX_cWZitNd0FWUAgnPz.ZONmDquebUAZbq9WrrbTwnJB2PnTfemcOi60ekAbljraqYM8lC5wB_4R4kiNEguOJtciXI38HlNZqmP5b2zGycYhWr4xgQ5ZjEaeQx8jz10h5rsQeWsVtEkUaEbaszeClQA7M2116hG1wJcApHnxIhkIG2bx2kX__pvKRtZQ6skoT371t5VnDLfQRxjujRuol7UrmAn7wYsTMvVQcagefkSnEBNLdjmRxU66ow6kOaQYgTN94bz3aR8Q_5eIVVaaZA1AaUpNG9iLsUuOeIW5S8hZBvcGm6AiA0PSrG5FoL69BLRmHjRsCweCqlpBeQDkbt42vn2aph5Sh6wtMzQD0vnNmFHdGjMECGRxNxhH7Y7OcQP48",mdrd: "AnaUUr0mH_kDCSD1sKCrArnTar00fr4yDXs4A75.dt4-1732408396-1.2.1.1-KCBe2UefpFaqXc0iv1e0A6JWegOY8ZMyd6YotJEA0h7jyjSnbDXUwF9KVXJ.r3GCW89mJ2.xqRwKW0SmAjaV_5gfrxHB2HPL0HhJ7XebN48D7e8_K2ALCVzMSwtgie.tOn8YVFYkwmDoQuznol2ZC4Rk16VTgMkdGQM3jNbJ8K3DJYZax4UorCeNbPGMSHJmfhN90DIZ94V8gIaIcux1lLRf5Tw9dNHHJVmjpGAIxHtpjjuE9osF_U_an231pGiNjP5YIb._cb.AllDA79nG_LiAoh_lvLDpf6z34XiOjtuczMeXom4SkLofwd8rdLuX3t1VyHQd2OhK24Bp5XEf6uWQ5vB8YWw7LgP4FhgXAVrBmVdpIOrUfEFj3_gwV0SgwReAX3LbCZSHoi3Swulshu4sjurltyoD1JW3GfSmajS.3jgi2xeBVsVaDfr.XKBkc1vsqAKIuZg7c7vN6KGCuZnZNBVAmYA9cVzKwlNGbWFQXW1N9V4OSl8d3hkkB34vJ6rwCGMhFBJTnaUfTW.WR.3Oi0SL2ULYdMYBV0N9xcu8dq7gVCYuxsS5vcUIZM4b_..OLSbYfhlIbGDC6YdheY4DdkZqIj5xQ0WlAkWqkDXYUHvlb.XoQGbQ1CvtWvD7cEJ8pUW8mIUGsPR3dC.VncCYU0Rm.RWNJ5ssEQcnRrxZWPX3xqsPW4U6rbTqSj9.b5TgV9.S5bsMvkPE4pd1UivFvyaz0QqHSTOJuUb8nw9WMD6q4gjLhXJQYBFoBTrPXpofm2ymkUNdLki1_uvYeaYOzgjRgl7DpY8GQiCsvAJKd.PxIFdVx7QrDSkSDwsrJQy9.v33c8oJqYvFBhGvMKWTvVn_fUQjG6qH1PxbLoUDQqrVsVEB1w.q5ari_T7ZP7DZZ.WWd6rvZhoVXIYBrjigI1KXRNuauyZoQwss._K.BJ9l_awLWSQc_wNGDACG_h4PDVCyiuZN9p8cMpcgfLJn8m1NIskvnOUnQjABD3WO_IxvruLt1Gpm1by4xsxWdTh.9solUplYyIF7I1DQg.G6FKdfErr2FyHi3kLLktVgsl.hMo65d52RSy5j7cVoEnq2MwssThzm5d6.IOIrBJT1EWYtCtPYIVp7Gr09Ihh99r8yC9HeXjFg0YSMpKZBqnNQA6cj3SsAlXgJa5zyX.MxmtgozsoFTfUSFdmtUbHLKC9b3hk7p_Ke0c_a.G.uIJHzEH5dWyp7igo7z6Jarbf89ksYM00uibIKiPUK_Ab0wXaYwIYUnsOUuUWW.qh7Vwc5FMHk9y8JUMVjOpiIo4.hdPrNId6vNCctr4YwsH.At7EbcgU7jvNo9qTaU42o8K2c1Pv6bXDLduesfQFCL2lDW4VHiPyvEXFzoynZAo2vqMpGy1v6ZLAxFGQBJ83jqiBRV_vzq6z0vtibgmF39kMzEIGI_7YNpOqV81.PmJS7hVcDmLPWf1LQHHtOyPfMkyftjLltFhWTnx0Hr1u2sXabAdniDF4LNo3ec_7nmqMgEjCiz6es.EyjFjNjTMehi7c4ykW3DrNeGG_KO5J9MhHatVof64me29J2Z4fiGob55bKONnvKAgqQu_YOD46ZuhHOp11o5aGWxTaYuNKUc3E2GlPWUfX9oyY3Xh6IQhvXM0vM5f8RDXntBDH1fYRAcxVX7DWYpvJCGY4TetpBYmsGGFXzM0aMMRr_Jp4JzvALQ_gY_QThH7.PSl1jl145lGbPUgv661BmE3TDfRd3Ruy0v3rsj84usWPuy3eTiPhhBclVxGduRxHuXfuq9Rd6Dku_E_d.JNPTW0ylby6EX4Snj7gue2IEyMV6U76u79aDK.NyHvAv5qD8aalsiWTEcZS6agi6OgGdb4JobhW_yzPGtluzNmDFRYyqry49ta.nERVKzD7yE2fGnet4DHjypOw3YsZNOf._lLpqzb9gNgAlHnbPrhGI2_ICdaJHAGWBBjYuY3wxqR5iVgx.dLa6oNs5bhZL_QpFwsXv2oe1tg"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e754e7d8e58ce2f';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/doi\/10.1146\/annurev.energy.30.050504.144248?__cf_chl_rt_tk=tU3._JXKddUTy7E7HZqnJUBj9F.2MXNI._A8xLEE.DE-1732408396-1.0.1.1-9ahlTV5ffCQ5NeDluopCqHEpF.VmVgxy7QDyqF2TiBo" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>