CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "royalsocietypublishing.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e9660325b358365',cH: 'VDpZBI82uhTomQdeNBtmlZEsVXL_.6eEth8XNZegHz8-1732755151-1.2.1.1-cR9AjbWPiZHKVrYGlqcAG2fwVEW72NGFbLmdkMj2PefEPg2U7N7d1yRueN_zo9i3',cUPMDTk: "\/doi\/10.1098\/rspa.1917.0014?__cf_chl_tk=Gc5RYbmNQGCTshPaqFMvYAkmSz9IEAtz7cbaBKNGVIY-1732755151-1.0.1.1-cfALkfzJq519PRzYVh_Jlurxb7ipw2UCtT5wQKYflMw",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1732755151',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/doi\/10.1098\/rspa.1917.0014?__cf_chl_f_tk=Gc5RYbmNQGCTshPaqFMvYAkmSz9IEAtz7cbaBKNGVIY-1732755151-1.0.1.1-cfALkfzJq519PRzYVh_Jlurxb7ipw2UCtT5wQKYflMw",md: "cc86LZ2rOvjCluRRjtWPO9WZxk6R5UlLJsuM.LanLXE-1732755151-1.2.1.1-qDbWmbrtMr4GIBO.m9arvKxW8LNbrkSr.t2SjhAl6vwhE.WpXol_hpkXTd3kinGCTqwQAAQctUNI_F18cWj4mkqg.DePbzPPowOckxRvsGV9.KCsMyLHNEDQ3j8wZ8oX9QtQy3lmGjddXWmlDtiE7dl.zbYJRL8.xIeWPWrTW9j53DVcGkYhsVxvQi5Zh3y2GsmYChFaf2259v5.o61QTUEdPNE7VIku6i2XAHaYPj_3.Ve.SGNSROrgMujj28Yp_2Hg1ocem2gFIbSHnEtt309mHBMZ_CGpAnJQAkvGSztrrWzlKRMuK6KTTtHYfPboGhVBcePbPPxhFvJxXrlLZAUuarrbJVEeSdEEvy3PtJjoQCh9TxfdfQIjLBoI02wY0lDXwh9I5iW8Yd_7aXdDl3iacFw3yQm5Z7wAu9nDTdlxSIQlWFOC2M_u39Fw0mAN4Kcn7YqscaosaTthMdniMb89udtilpwQhMt8zrAN.jt65SThveFAxYLyLMCo6NWqdpYklk_aTzM3Z3PKy.HawzyGAs48hbD_9jwPEdhrimFO78tzaKyNObd1_4bFWoO7Yf2.zjEIMsR.oFzkyBb9W97qyI3D55KSZ90p5ovt4kj1tp7AGDyjQeAUAxzKFslFK05W1YlFtYENzpbD0zTUcfQEdP6yVn3778HK8b0rc6SYqM82CmfbL25i0cIXbKxqP0U6WWbVZCpreFMwUUAcmCeaOh5sAv8K4Qx8mv6dQ1JMzQVKMQygGLCXEYo9Y9V.rOrrQTDQJBnP9dm8rXgIhGsB6SIFXtA69L9E5NUedMxDeeglii81uJC12mi1Er_jC5nhI0YbfUcZwGh1RlNGZfm.vRxGBHwEbSQMsw2KCq43VkGS7XJzSD05tVDJD0SDp5Pq6fLnQewBr6_P.L7.CawvVlHY8BBkgNke7VsRag52JjMAk3L97UHyxgEuprhf47PI61CvNz2bjezK56ZPn3BOXXj1Q8OMYDme_dG_4paLOv0XBzo7r.Ub4ovFfVFw.vf6KRdPebP_aKz2MPz6iaErVlTGLPwTdr_Qa_WZRVTOL1pQTXV1KyGdeXijIngAnYfPq2L.8.viD.4kqPXItvk0ZIoH1LXFUeKkOiiG.VKLHxEe64qS7zoqYGAlsMDMUpyQqk9xUBPjh_uQrqS91RiQN7mkvk_D0.zlPivFdUsiATo_5YkJcX7YWpU2b7.ahZA3KO4PiUtYGj4AKKS06UbDzYH3ljAQ.VuieUlbYsi2XjwkK637xeC6VEICqiADyxYSGjMjWcJG0kzVwjyfbM9vkyimykoJnS9Jv6YosCHAiQ063R2PI6wJ_Zc83SKYyrEeFKggE9A4xMn6a_8Rq4KAHXJXazW.Q9cPxWRWrzWKDMYKs7J1of6ya_tijfw8ybjHaLBe0sNcLHVYjGYNYG03dBXz5j572.Yfb_er2hND8Sl9iJs1xoLJ.G_Xvn3pK9ZCrN1w9VAFUh3PH2GIr5m7p7ybrvs0FoEn_wKmN81OmyrzdhO5w6o5lOl2iql3E5krrWPiN8fo0O_DMPymjT570fv.UzcfrSNsaYXt.m1iukTE2ePQD8ulZ8jiQTeilP3QWTNqaMsMAFd_RjRGjBhLNF4c_HRlcUC9u.GdMvAEqvrEsayrfUGiy.VpSq1jH.hIh3GjHhCms3pqtUwyDoJdrtL.nkqlsxw80fS0WXsICTb4srB_u9Zi_wAAxqlRi_PrcvikOKalUgmriZsPCb_.rG04Z9MA5Gq_TPDXqnI0XO6Mr_LJu1uHnnT5rLEX5UE_1eLj5uOefl_VAUBKUXO4zRlcPgHaCc62yr5mx3BlIS._cVD6UMsnMkadCHn1E4Am4VnZd4GubGgv8EhmTsywI.KpxYQiwDMd7rvR2R.AXnoh1uv3hhgCfMoTAJIbArA47EgGlt7lI7ypEQuiDh4K3dBzsY4iX_kowlt1hjbYuOVlHee4fzgi.Tz_2_9A.1MGbu5r3HJ_JskNW8bEBGkHWxnKybT.QOSAvEuVDGzbvorUCyHBt6hVDnKwxwBlktFJq.Nz9clHETOIj3vmhSaNeCZn8toKeDWz5_nHPxjCjAvuzbB0DCQRdz0Qw_LtR0KnrYAu2lKdbgO9xXBysxKQj1bXkPV9x76ZYZTUMFB.ltPfxFsvyEBPhlAoRkxaaaAc.aNTjl3CM9V2Ui92g29h38onJ0OF_RLbakspRVs0nfKKcgF3eN_9uUQG_1R_2QFOCN.FCGvK.qPBWKc8NxyuXRKq61czreMOiR5J7WxeJYVH_WEuXvAsUU_3.diJRycHv.dC2WAMIwUmwjQCZo01TVfPzdLUJ2loqR.9l2hm4dy3NZdeV1.rxJvQTPFJ4VR16431hA.p1gCb78OIaKbFRibkbJivTJ5rW2zKftGqRZaJ8QoGpCu8U6qo5omVeeAf5VKw6Uii8f5SEo1cG53O5RltX5.I7j9QuBOEjtvIqYiTEVqfkZVo3Dv0NgyV4zlKOIjZDi.KOuhQItfcwqYSdOauvW4NXP0IhOlMD8aWu9CKr5LA_a0fIEqWP8gQCIpzlLKJaMVilidDFO1sWEdeHbu4xfFgVsiOQMy.Cw0akyxxUGQT7e1NGOkSdFmHTqQDT_jUwcBFoJ.GtU4HSgATdtniCG4SwaLWYykYQS84PJ3R0R.6LLROQIe51t.LcMnmef_t1EuhIIWUuvGD7FI5dUgq.ZkpTD2d2Jfc.Kpt_x3376SRkVDrjPuLqbHH_fEOLxgzlkrs_YpaSfWtFcdKjIJvtO1Gu6CbG0kBKpy7FfhzmVBC3g6KtZv4H.MsdZL75y4qyW7x4wIxPDP_FDeak8e6nt8tEpmZlDufTeFRQmv_exUb0duTN0JVwgtoosBblIwxnJHQ.e8emiC3Nk.8k3bl2ZU7bv1wdg.NFVe6LceplCAN5TacPfphNXf89.TKDn3YVc7F1.fHCh43IDAHZNRZD7vUUi2TP.y9WczK37oOLE9X7X7JTMBnbYZh",mdrd: "4dJOJzu3ITm3EKQcHYPft3K3akhS1TIlSbR9nqSy63E-1732755151-1.2.1.1-QANRV5DbIeaYxJ5fwZHlA8YlakBCMPiJ3I9No0._FLMNjUWhsNELiRimDuegbJfXJA.d2sG0VO4JeTMufSkULd1L1.dBNR2jIJzHxcf6metX7Ll889mV1JQuQYhZMOAKHZEnoGYLuTpfb3afdS0j2bQqmmO7cA5XT.r5amYYOIiVX2rHzW61ZSjMkB3qyb3lpVbKaqLinMxNa5N4u.5JFyAfoeYaY8Gisf.e9VJcLzn4woLzaiTeiSXGUoctM8SwHeMd8bilBkW6bZFpwDBIOiWu8INZ8KK1RpFLkZEsm7iUktBz5T70DkKNmyMtdxk6uDM5Qm7xBzuXF_uMfvZ7k_b0jsJt7hOFvS4GCf_JkhV1WfekjoCGTSpqrHVeF5rS9RRII5q_5rH7ipLjAd.XzvP8cscqiojHogwat0xpO1ZFRe2RlQZqdvM5.bxOxsoT5S6s2DbVCtLYnIxme9pvPM2XwLYT_0Bq_batpm2IVYWD110asij19sqYOYW_CkQ8cWtZtCzEOlppFvZ0ZPyDSbOdf6JZTu1iIhwitm3wgHwzayUmEHQJndu_yjJMAmV7J_qI0cBMcNZnN.SLR3Qk6aXpVfyLDyJW12ByUwrvzzfB_psBx43i2w9U72HBLH5U41o2JPT8jdwddrqvHcYYTBqDvEwxR74Y9Ei_h6awfbGdAvy2srqWKN8ogzo3_EnCLlpbBEJ3FxPog6T96nXVZCk3FHaNV5QnSJeQKpgIgFAcAmtwN6.4wVxVViUV8JNxHRzMJ0i6xDiAOe.PL9rYKke7pwi31i4SbAMcDGLdaK0tgubpWQdRqnffONrPunElIwyWzGT35cP2B9jlWCQQ4XF.UFISpEfQ9sJxzFZncz6D9QUDOfI7udvd4uUkKy0cFM_0ldIHd_Lj0dyg7jcpoBvr71y23hgwSFm1tZv5j9WZM4_swTg4V3rvLSLkWSrwO4nOHPGOSWzKcKIxwvWJmLZRdGPE4gBuKHjMbUQGq8ayiNYzNFLP0eq7bFJwurrh1gS5qX0CGzeAiaoZvqtuJZz0V8mKCGzzHKzoD3gaQzc9BKEUYpZbGsuTtilozvuZd0KuUzj_Wlqmg8HeCrpDiiDx10L8v3cFF1N_CgWlhU6GylLjzkDULvNBoswrwfNPuzXvwZ2tarqF9CRx1ypwN0EwpU9JCDgXgClDlStNmV9fiJOcFEezbpayhpuGrXkTrmVHrQyS7Kwg9rPpjbQHOLjgx4VfGuijG2LoPoi7HKra84_4RULyhxFP2_0KhNWjoeOaBmpy6eGr70DSwrqHmeBAS7_4goMf1BvZDpoMYAcyAqcBmutPCpM9zpk.u.O0_nVtU4aZ0ZhfNxkvJTf.e_ers42ku4w8Hb2ByKZqKa9DnOLK0uo7pM.ORyBkI3VSabNTYco2HNWGGdXeJU9WJavgRD1JmaBLWEH_OhI6flsQWeUiOw75AnefD87xtxYlk2N12CVUTjJquSPLNoZJLWKTTEh.068J4k_PKxSUpPO2FeBhdzcSss0ordXuOHdfSGEz9sGwNoA_QZijvURSixwoqGhYG1pZ0ih7V8WIVQp1V4m9pHvwe8xbWHPDiHvbVrUvzNOCMnr267wUkGG.TPkYuX1rKSEHYcz3pAIpz2boAQgvALzTafp9ogM8jYZ5ly3ak1JPHDlIe9x7a2pqLOZElgh4zstkaZlESpvAh2DZ.G.8RuBPxpbOv6DgJWbII5pHo28pa30A8I221uQyZqfqcGu90kWXED2Y.vOE93XnqQb_BvM1qWCbQKbmr15wH4yjPp2bRK7LudBPuzSX5qEn1kIzf.dTgdua4Po8j5yF0gXZ8MwDUYOcEI2EQ_PUogufrWgFQeioQ0vkT8DyZFQD6NuBJFzHf9iq2XgKNVw27LOmjvv4Pu2bbdpA4rcJh5_9u2NqpxtQafzqIfdh5eKqjf5DnM.hB3P30MY7IXTTCtF5pPZk.YsX2ZBKwa4yjUJ5ez0e0C6ys.cWX8uCaQ"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e9660325b358365';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/doi\/10.1098\/rspa.1917.0014?__cf_chl_rt_tk=Gc5RYbmNQGCTshPaqFMvYAkmSz9IEAtz7cbaBKNGVIY-1732755151-1.0.1.1-cfALkfzJq519PRzYVh_Jlurxb7ipw2UCtT5wQKYflMw" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>