CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.journals.uchicago.edu",cType: 'managed',cRay: '917f828acded7ae1',cH: 'zU0_NtLn7xcNP0q89uaP8cSgsOobCFxb3306rL97caw-1740568449-1.2.1.1-UZsXGcS80IfQ2wc2kr.OE0Csk9M4KjFo1rSQ9DReGBISFWq87gK1Kr9hOAQqMQF.',cUPMDTk: "\/toc\/signs\/current?__cf_chl_tk=bKHwLh0TISMiu..oY9HLFtxlCxq25X9BEesztxexdWE-1740568449-1.0.1.1-_2q0d_X_wLl9ZOHyvNHeMG5d7fZ5GS9jMCgTSzgFcrI",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1740568449',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/toc\/signs\/current?__cf_chl_f_tk=bKHwLh0TISMiu..oY9HLFtxlCxq25X9BEesztxexdWE-1740568449-1.0.1.1-_2q0d_X_wLl9ZOHyvNHeMG5d7fZ5GS9jMCgTSzgFcrI",md: "VuMgnmFxDWDeH0wqZBXNZdWhawkVWafGVXvIYnr_cbI-1740568449-1.2.1.1-8PLwF2ubNLEV.KYXyodYWyWTsO95R0EVqseTyOFCC82JifoHuPl7BTd8z7oXqZcdBmUNnKe1uszlgnZojjbJqSJtd6nglT4O_AZyZLCAwLr5kHTz_4KOs9we1MfBwcKv3G9MsuO4BvuBcSKsXTUuhypC8__3OuaPXj2bGm0RK506rc8VAvaLkjadSkrO2HlAMgyWBRkuV3Wc_c3KV6_rWpAY9HyH_08EiQ4KvCTuZD7pe3XGAtPUAVlygmADZFnhJQpMNVxxQtnUPhdUf7tSJLaOmjJ1tUYMhVJwLheoPDICbo1b0.Uuv4q.NE0QSKlCjYUcfvz54M7EbZdxeVWTa7jQuVRgbtyRfbfXS1Pj3Sh7EN5TRN4Dl7Ab4n_ImQIZYNtxPqfLcIdbxIH9zOzgyaha1zusJ2Jb2DNiTTHVwEtl4KEuGQ31WTlNZ9LvcNJbHIWFJP8qSEomDZzez1LmE1m1jI.jUoL.lJyJLG90ZdcquCe6793MBSV8MKXCfvheH5.VZ33EBL1NcsBMue4Apd0deuynhj270kPB7NYJnZwyRFKR1xbpZT5gDE8Qf69aqLDNA2iWZyzed7W0qIqmLKo0mfKp4WzS5eXObMwHU.rpVgReZ5EmsnufnK0qDXgxeNvxteUK4PnlmRuUF6aqSTcGqT262B7acyyrmcXWn96K1JQSefEoFtl66n6rdvXtOWVTCu0xKE9_bpyEnC8GC8BDkYYadIaas4kUxL.l4Ogi1m.0OwJED2WuGkZ86qLGfoax7clrXZiBw4Q8AlF4A4scfo_vlJQ3Zh2OWsRvzZL2Q.0bUrwpwp0TTabW6s86mqi.OypPMiTqCzR07TswNnlPCrwgVOoE.gy9iZVwPt6jhZgCXFYipp0Lv1XVVVNU_IMUPR9mWhRG0v7fKrjxNFZTg4PrRUsNE1GuhkYuO4ZHrJsDyrHrfgUF25X5mOUUTd2bM2nHuSXWZKAz7EwzuO5Msn3AKU2VUJNv61NM6WSnIjXM.WlYECndREPOul2vvQgJeJoPp3E7F5PHuWZ0vOdOtF89NOfGipbpIQXYobGuI9rsmZBTInyWuh3r8Zz.3zzukAlmMWa_hWC5aYwhxP65M_hLNnTihrTlsk7vCj1IQcPWuPnzJYa9e1liQgIadmzU0zgDajVWIaO1xMegAFyulsJ0guee0UbUTlMmGwhWq83BwnDYt_ESDPRsDfDZWq4mopQ4SrpdA7I8jwpVR5G1IoOo2tDwMRnqW42iAo.2CX.9y1findo6PMiX8Bm2r8GSNBjq14wXNJGKzTzRVsXQcSWRqgHGUrnggsm.5pp90FvZxRTGVOOZEPX6VJcLyBq8vryWHugfF5fg_fVkxuov7fEbJ964AsOJqyAqOMexTSTYiLKzPG_UH0sT.kGATZM9UGbvLHimpyRg2ToQQvKlcsYpPFmg5fKsFNeky6wSCFdCkW9wTDDcytwFyJ9vJr1axKOriMocRg6OXGErpEkIbVzTwtliO4mEfshXSTRpszBaODdStmm4fwcFd5aXOmjhvHYZJVj5Tv.0Nh1MSG.iYOkhmFdA2708JXAJ0bEMZ1LnCm.0Q9jpD268YiIl0RIIQTev43vEFUNa3nUCoRiYF49IPmrbp3Yja5u4KRzuKbWkksDMfupk_wqvOEX7clsjn1gkBVUtWZcE8rJsu2lMpKp550Jh1ra7i0_QPkog0o5I3vmKXwN4vgtD1b_ywbrbK4Wyvw4rmL3ZC0QWokjC6_Iuxz0AgY.HZnNqqTF91j5iih7SsWfCpkPCjfyp7_CLmYQYkQ949iFYZI7WwYlBg4a7b3FW4B1_.mgsFPnufRYNU0SBodL2dx5ApLpKi.5qKutsNbbsXiHOR1qExTNB3SJL7Q29KW35mObc6oWukMhkjWELdMTdYTHvoqPfLW.nSbNkpncMG._pwTHgwh3dLvQKs.BHgCmSn6QyUg4flg.XXV6H204yBAtpHRDpq6pBp450_nd2FLn8fMij4EY_DwsMPFe1Fb7Z.XUYqnoPJbo.s4GSI_hPHsYdWVGl7RnAijggIh6nwjKRAYPh12PrGqTCx6uMR_dTLMo30mJN6_x5S1QllUh1Jw.CtVlRvMNZ_KDwOd0xiT3_RxcMYThSSb0jqh7.QvrKEVx8uuAsXdrS4P6IvzcVx53fzhuDEMqvAmpb53lDgzR44krwTMvRBNk8rOhKQ4UH738W1D3tklKmjqgcp4eJESfsGkorTDP43XipDHDFALHv5zTTuIIVOZIt8UBaUigt5HtABKeJwl1WTpaRO4ki7jy.U8FTVCvnwCO8gS8_LeoP5fsFiIJ7leK001Fc_YTbP_rSSHYmxT0buzrpbsy49iJ0gKZYNOgH0KnKvCYcI_2ccfERDvSx9O5SRJ_aMKvBgUyqoAnDcWWcGs4Td0AlFJcFoDX1mOznCXHNioVLMNqRwCT_oAY2PelJ3.qNmZUh5FTXDdjgz2DDc0tQRg7JWrCxf9k__KgeJBPGGvENgBj9L2UKJpcUi1FPdAP8tHJVJ52pJCX182Vb7l0ZZAib539pNrOOe.tkKDP176oR3.Mbatqiug",mdrd: "oHCVuwsiwZxX2WEQvtwxQfDbnJwp8TmCPNkcwtrC9Gg-1740568449-1.2.1.1-uO8Ac3oadFTGjiKDG3YMfHqF1GeLuN6f4DkektQdMnhjtE8rB6DEyoJlX2DORtQcIgFRlTPrWEg29WnTLn0PQQ0apjvmG98.z4.KMJVHx1yoITyXGsz3cL9AX.02I.pEtCYbqB_my4zOOWU3ZSh0kH65mk6Q1PXoRChJ0VLG3hI9hnCQw8jNu7h0PbRpGiJd2TRs_V_44w5caYWWl6I2NiATbXitkbNrEnpuBW.JnTNanuczBBoDahqNXRPTlaSxt.sgNtbIYu7vomIRmxw9eSgA_f7dEKH0X.EcT_Db_XBoBtlPKJsKpiG73i08Px70OBmkDBONY33M3EnS7g4Ful9kV4lxEmhjhCx_XX0.gHLlFGcz79gPvjlSvCri_n4vGkcam9SzhtptPhhhzW9ADCSagSZ9v2OgLHRIF63ToR2Vn9zhbjiVHz0pyc1E0Mcxx_1Zy2Hhb7LdKggA0Uj6bVWx0Q9NX.xsyyGkY5ynfju3Wt5bqUC2jIP2W3HsOeJ5LqkhGxAFQILiVpXZc0.WDnb_gjHtKfrbr06BXCO_TUdrItZIbC_Cfy9huB2rNDjZ14Y7NUsgmbR.gEiDxYwQidYOHB.qszIoqm7zItbllh4PNQ_IUPFAM5U_9lacLQouE9GXilkm2bPgmHlhjkRgc9Iil9_EI1.yglsy7T6XaLfQUV608fGPB4DSBboMuXz_8FPS6J0irgygvpy0hBKM13osr6qHRFa2rA.dx8j8n1JwvZM3rQDf3W00_UBt8uZbJ5s5E186P13co38ynkvakYGK6rcBGhad7cgcQLSpeJIGWPBBuk9Jgm3R0sf_Hu8P5DWRqLiCeQRX20KpEE8CDRXPWDF.yuS1mAvFpeZa3K743IZji3SeRLigc8yS7gSM.Xth59WRcK8MLbFS28xMvgiZZ.IvXthV0ZBLjvIQhpmjEeb5nlTbdhymOdc3YjbyTDGvWdMUvx6OFgJPtE3pbjZw_oXQWealiP47z7HRVvDCta3aaRAahdkkcgFsFTu1ZhHDyCJV6gKcTCYTdgj1hKMaiHYBD6u_2oYEfg2M_.YTCK3kgzSZagHl0Pqoae9KAWGvxNkFNOSP0rD26yTDlAAKTaZws73QK9kzMkatQW91Yr2STk.Ik3PsaqZyOk_WhcP8HkBLXGKZKW0mZoMSUWxRvt24iy_FmQR6.O7oGSQAhvsrotsIW03g83szoMovFSF3EkLSW5LBWFaHYoDPNLAnfdh8_xbbmNSMNelaJRU9x4WBp0fCt6q4UePIzt6B..u2WcAgN5Hl_qVuuR979uzLNLDUQmWj61hKq2JrDPVoDn_GoR3qUBH5pYWg1OG7EsHjB4txZck.fcDWtJEvo_iETHXkulkgPDygEpUqWTzkwzfSodP5TseUX8VR7kezxLr_M9PgVv9XnoihsWB9AIBrRht.Ou3u9FGjGdyc4LMmzg9ZWcvg8hKpufnSVD6MkgtAZANQrhwKRhrNDhJ3_qhTUlE_smYlFdjUI1JSM5l5TFGzUljtv8TO_aGDyzuaMwMosrpe6bZuoln6H1ai5hZcELPH7Ckq.wogv4Fcx3mn.2Wo06M.zyCODtVDWgEBulwJIsxTwUfbqrqilYfMvqSgNZzkGBn5E3EXAHiglRV0s.ESkNJLIKpfetmqFXi6GJyqMx_5aInVHWgA7fdRp6ZuvzJSH7kdriWsLzqm7rYxPzkijIaPBi2hrm6W_pNSlPjSDr8nJTrKUqw9OdzZQD9FNFw2WdDmUe6PyBAkMWyiovoFBe095GdjvDt5JlI3beCYEOKJq9hrworT3Z4rpwjCOFEAo5OBegrNtmt5Y4bVxfqkCFT2X.2Kb88MOFZ6zz2rKK_WwTHgEDTOr1aX1ZKZQLTSnrJbTLzhskWYi_GbAJ5O4yFjsGbQXl.Y.rzUpCjhQW3aoXQVy.rJxQIsDAhlrPMAJYlw1UzxUwQlDBOL6_ErQTznQja89_5h3dyg"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=917f828acded7ae1';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/toc\/signs\/current?__cf_chl_rt_tk=bKHwLh0TISMiu..oY9HLFtxlCxq25X9BEesztxexdWE-1740568449-1.0.1.1-_2q0d_X_wLl9ZOHyvNHeMG5d7fZ5GS9jMCgTSzgFcrI" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>