CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en" class="grade-c"> <head> <title>Carotenoid metabolism strengthens the link between feather coloration and individual quality | Nature Communications</title> <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" href="https://www.nature.com/ncomms.rss"/> <script id="save-data-connection-testing"> function hasConnection() { return navigator.connection || navigator.mozConnection || navigator.webkitConnection || navigator.msConnection; } function createLink(src) { var preloadLink = document.createElement("link"); preloadLink.rel = "preload"; preloadLink.href = src; preloadLink.as = "font"; preloadLink.type = "font/woff2"; preloadLink.crossOrigin = ""; document.head.insertBefore(preloadLink, document.head.firstChild); } var connectionDetail = { saveDataEnabled: false, slowConnection: false }; var connection = hasConnection(); if (connection) { connectionDetail.saveDataEnabled = connection.saveData; if (/\slow-2g|2g/.test(connection.effectiveType)) { connectionDetail.slowConnection = true; } } if (!(connectionDetail.saveDataEnabled || connectionDetail.slowConnection)) { createLink("/static/fonts/HardingText-Regular-Web-cecd90984f.woff2"); } else { document.documentElement.classList.add('save-data'); } </script> <link rel="preconnect" href="https://cmp.nature.com" crossorigin> <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge"> <meta name="applicable-device" content="pc,mobile"> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1.0,maximum-scale=5,user-scalable=yes"> <meta name="360-site-verification" content="5a2dc4ab3fcb9b0393241ffbbb490480" /> <script data-test="dataLayer"> window.dataLayer = [{"content":{"category":{"contentType":"article","legacy":{"webtrendsPrimaryArticleType":"research","webtrendsSubjectTerms":"behavioural-ecology;sexual-selection","webtrendsContentCategory":null,"webtrendsContentCollection":null,"webtrendsContentGroup":"Nature Communications","webtrendsContentGroupType":null,"webtrendsContentSubGroup":"Article","status":null}},"article":{"doi":"10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z"},"attributes":{"cms":null,"deliveryPlatform":"oscar","copyright":{"open":true,"legacy":{"webtrendsLicenceType":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"}}},"contentInfo":{"authors":["Ryan J. Weaver","Eduardo S. A. Santos","Anna M. Tucker","Alan E. Wilson","Geoffrey E. Hill"],"publishedAt":1515369600,"publishedAtString":"2018-01-08","title":"Carotenoid metabolism strengthens the link between feather coloration and individual quality","legacy":null,"publishedAtTime":null,"documentType":"aplusplus","subjects":"Behavioural ecology,Sexual selection"},"journal":{"pcode":"ncomms","title":"nature communications","volume":"9","issue":"1","id":41467,"publishingModel":"Open Access"},"authorization":{"status":true},"features":[{"name":"furtherReadingSection","present":true}],"collection":null},"page":{"category":{"pageType":"article"},"attributes":{"template":"mosaic","featureFlags":[{"name":"nature-onwards-journey","active":false}],"testGroup":null},"search":null},"privacy":{},"version":"1.0.0","product":null,"session":null,"user":null,"backHalfContent":true,"country":"HK","hasBody":true,"uneditedManuscript":false,"twitterId":["o3xnx","o43y9","o3ef7"],"baiduId":"d38bce82bcb44717ccc29a90c4b781ea","japan":false}]; window.dataLayer.push({ ga4MeasurementId: 'G-ERRNTNZ807', ga360TrackingId: 'UA-71668177-1', twitterId: ['3xnx', 'o43y9', 'o3ef7'], baiduId: 'd38bce82bcb44717ccc29a90c4b781ea', ga4ServerUrl: 'https://collect.nature.com', imprint: 'nature' }); </script> <script> (function(w, d) { w.config = w.config || {}; w.config.mustardcut = false; if (w.matchMedia && w.matchMedia('only print, only all and (prefers-color-scheme: no-preference), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: light), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: dark)').matches) { w.config.mustardcut = true; d.classList.add('js'); d.classList.remove('grade-c'); d.classList.remove('no-js'); } })(window, document.documentElement); </script> <style>@media only print, only all and (prefers-color-scheme: no-preference), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: light), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: dark) { .c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__article-title,.c-card--major .c-card__title,.c-card__title,.u-h2,.u-h3,h2,h3{-webkit-font-smoothing:antialiased;font-family:Harding,Palatino,serif;font-weight:700;letter-spacing:-.0117156rem}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__article-title,.c-card__title,.u-h3,h3{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.4rem}.c-reading-companion__figure-title,.u-h4,h4{-webkit-font-smoothing:antialiased;font-weight:700;line-height:1.4rem}html{text-size-adjust:100%;box-sizing:border-box;font-size:100%;height:100%;line-height:1.15;overflow-y:scroll}body{background:#eee;color:#222;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.76;margin:0;min-height:100%}details,main{display:block}h1{font-size:2em;margin:.67em 0}a,sup{vertical-align:baseline}a{background-color:transparent;color:#069;overflow-wrap:break-word;text-decoration:underline;text-decoration-skip-ink:auto;word-break:break-word}b{font-weight:bolder}sup{font-size:75%;line-height:0;position:relative;top:-.5em}img{border:0;height:auto;max-width:100%;vertical-align:middle}button,input,select{font-family:inherit;font-size:100%;line-height:1.15;margin:0}button,input{overflow:visible}button,select{text-transform:none}[type=submit],button{-webkit-appearance:button}[type=checkbox]{box-sizing:border-box;padding:0}summary{display:list-item}[hidden]{display:none}button{border-radius:0;cursor:pointer;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif}h1{-webkit-font-smoothing:antialiased;font-family:Harding,Palatino,serif;font-size:2rem;font-weight:700;letter-spacing:-.0390625rem;line-height:2.25rem}.c-card--major .c-card__title,.u-h2,.u-h3,h2{font-family:Harding,Palatino,serif;letter-spacing:-.0117156rem}.c-card--major .c-card__title,.u-h2,h2{-webkit-font-smoothing:antialiased;font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:700;line-height:1.6rem}.u-h3{font-size:1.25rem}.c-card__title,.c-reading-companion__figure-title,.u-h3,.u-h4,h4,h5,h6{-webkit-font-smoothing:antialiased;font-weight:700;line-height:1.4rem}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__article-title,.c-card__title,h3{font-family:Harding,Palatino,serif;font-size:1.25rem}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__article-title,h3{-webkit-font-smoothing:antialiased;font-weight:700;letter-spacing:-.0117156rem;line-height:1.4rem}.c-reading-companion__figure-title,.u-h4,h4{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1.125rem;letter-spacing:-.0117156rem}button:focus{outline:3px solid #fece3e;will-change:transform}input+label{padding-left:.5em}nav ol,nav ul{list-style:none none}p:empty{display:none}.sans-serif{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif}.article-page{background:#fff}.c-article-header{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;margin-bottom:40px}.c-article-identifiers{color:#6f6f6f;display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;font-size:1rem;line-height:1.3;list-style:none;margin:0 0 8px;padding:0}.c-article-identifiers__item{border-right:1px solid #6f6f6f;list-style:none;margin-right:8px;padding-right:8px}.c-article-identifiers__item:last-child{border-right:0;margin-right:0;padding-right:0}.c-article-title{font-size:1.5rem;line-height:1.25;margin:0 0 16px}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.c-article-title{font-size:1.875rem;line-height:1.2}}.c-article-author-list{display:inline;font-size:1rem;list-style:none;margin:0 8px 0 0;padding:0;width:100%}.c-article-author-list__item{display:inline;padding-right:0}.c-article-author-list svg{margin-left:4px}.c-article-author-list__show-more{display:none;margin-right:4px}.c-article-author-list__button,.js .c-article-author-list__item--hide,.js .c-article-author-list__show-more{display:none}.js .c-article-author-list--long .c-article-author-list__show-more,.js .c-article-author-list--long+.c-article-author-list__button{display:inline}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.js .c-article-author-list__item--hide-small-screen{display:none}.js .c-article-author-list--short .c-article-author-list__show-more,.js .c-article-author-list--short+.c-article-author-list__button{display:inline}}#uptodate-client,.js .c-article-author-list--expanded .c-article-author-list__show-more{display:none!important}.js .c-article-author-list--expanded .c-article-author-list__item--hide-small-screen{display:inline!important}.c-article-author-list__button,.c-button-author-list{background:#ebf1f5;border:4px solid #ebf1f5;border-radius:20px;color:#666;font-size:.875rem;line-height:1.4;padding:2px 11px 2px 8px;text-decoration:none}.c-article-author-list__button svg,.c-button-author-list svg{margin:1px 4px 0 0}.c-article-author-list__button:hover,.c-button-author-list:hover{background:#069;border-color:transparent;color:#fff}.c-article-info-details{font-size:1rem;margin-bottom:8px;margin-top:16px}.c-article-info-details__cite-as{border-left:1px solid #6f6f6f;margin-left:8px;padding-left:8px}.c-article-metrics-bar{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;font-size:1rem;line-height:1.3}.c-article-metrics-bar__wrapper{margin:16px 0}.c-article-metrics-bar__item{align-items:baseline;border-right:1px solid #6f6f6f;margin-right:8px}.c-article-metrics-bar__item:last-child{border-right:0}.c-article-metrics-bar__count{font-weight:700;margin:0}.c-article-metrics-bar__label{color:#626262;font-style:normal;font-weight:400;margin:0 10px 0 5px}.c-article-metrics-bar__details{margin:0}.c-article-main-column{font-family:Harding,Palatino,serif;margin-right:8.6%;width:60.2%}@media only screen and (max-width:1023px){.c-article-main-column{margin-right:0;width:100%}}.c-article-extras{float:left;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;width:31.2%}@media only screen and (max-width:1023px){.c-article-extras{display:none}}.c-article-associated-content__container .c-article-associated-content__title,.c-article-section__title{border-bottom:2px solid #d5d5d5;font-size:1.25rem;margin:0;padding-bottom:8px}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.c-article-associated-content__container .c-article-associated-content__title,.c-article-section__title{font-size:1.5rem;line-height:1.24}}.c-article-associated-content__container .c-article-associated-content__title{margin-bottom:8px}.c-article-body p{margin-bottom:24px;margin-top:0}.c-article-section{clear:both}.c-article-section__content{margin-bottom:40px;padding-top:8px}@media only screen and (max-width:1023px){.c-article-section__content{padding-left:0}}.c-article-authors-search{margin-bottom:24px;margin-top:0}.c-article-authors-search__item,.c-article-authors-search__title{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif}.c-article-authors-search__title{color:#626262;font-size:1.05rem;font-weight:700;margin:0;padding:0}.c-article-authors-search__item{font-size:1rem}.c-article-authors-search__text{margin:0}.c-article-license__badge,c-card__section{margin-top:8px}.c-code-block{border:1px solid #eee;font-family:monospace;margin:0 0 24px;padding:20px}.c-code-block__heading{font-weight:400;margin-bottom:16px}.c-code-block__line{display:block;overflow-wrap:break-word;white-space:pre-wrap}.c-article-share-box__no-sharelink-info{font-size:.813rem;font-weight:700;margin-bottom:24px;padding-top:4px}.c-article-share-box__only-read-input{border:1px solid #d5d5d5;box-sizing:content-box;display:inline-block;font-size:.875rem;font-weight:700;height:24px;margin-bottom:8px;padding:8px 10px}.c-article-share-box__button--link-like{background-color:transparent;border:0;color:#069;cursor:pointer;font-size:.875rem;margin-bottom:8px;margin-left:10px}.c-article-editorial-summary__container{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1rem}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__content p:last-child{margin-bottom:0}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__content--less{max-height:9.5rem;overflow:hidden}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__button{background-color:#fff;border:0;color:#069;font-size:.875rem;margin-bottom:16px}.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__button.active,.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__button.hover,.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__button:active,.c-article-editorial-summary__container .c-article-editorial-summary__button:hover{text-decoration:underline;text-decoration-skip-ink:auto}.c-article-associated-content__container .c-article-associated-content__collection-label{font-size:.875rem;line-height:1.4}.c-article-associated-content__container .c-article-associated-content__collection-title{line-height:1.3}.c-context-bar{box-shadow:0 0 10px 0 rgba(51,51,51,.2);position:relative;width:100%}.c-context-bar__title{display:none}.c-reading-companion{clear:both;min-height:389px}.c-reading-companion__sticky{max-width:389px}.c-reading-companion__scroll-pane{margin:0;min-height:200px;overflow:hidden auto}.c-reading-companion__tabs{display:flex;flex-flow:row nowrap;font-size:1rem;list-style:none;margin:0 0 8px;padding:0}.c-reading-companion__tabs>li{flex-grow:1}.c-reading-companion__tab{background-color:#eee;border:1px solid #d5d5d5;border-image:initial;border-left-width:0;color:#069;font-size:1rem;padding:8px 8px 8px 15px;text-align:left;width:100%}.c-reading-companion__tabs li:first-child .c-reading-companion__tab{border-left-width:1px}.c-reading-companion__tab--active{background-color:#fff;border-bottom:1px solid #fff;color:#222;font-weight:700}.c-reading-companion__sections-list{list-style:none;padding:0}.c-reading-companion__figures-list,.c-reading-companion__references-list{list-style:none;min-height:389px;padding:0}.c-reading-companion__references-list--numeric{list-style:decimal inside}.c-reading-companion__sections-list{margin:0 0 8px;min-height:50px}.c-reading-companion__section-item{font-size:1rem;padding:0}.c-reading-companion__section-item a{display:block;line-height:1.5;overflow:hidden;padding:8px 0 8px 16px;text-overflow:ellipsis;white-space:nowrap}.c-reading-companion__figure-item{border-top:1px solid #d5d5d5;font-size:1rem;padding:16px 8px 16px 0}.c-reading-companion__figure-item:first-child{border-top:none;padding-top:8px}.c-reading-companion__reference-item{border-top:1px solid #d5d5d5;font-size:1rem;padding:8px 8px 8px 16px}.c-reading-companion__reference-item:first-child{border-top:none}.c-reading-companion__reference-item a{word-break:break-word}.c-reading-companion__reference-citation{display:inline}.c-reading-companion__reference-links{font-size:.813rem;font-weight:700;list-style:none;margin:8px 0 0;padding:0;text-align:right}.c-reading-companion__reference-links>a{display:inline-block;padding-left:8px}.c-reading-companion__reference-links>a:first-child{display:inline-block;padding-left:0}.c-reading-companion__figure-title{display:block;margin:0 0 8px}.c-reading-companion__figure-links{display:flex;justify-content:space-between;margin:8px 0 0}.c-reading-companion__figure-links>a{align-items:center;display:flex}.c-reading-companion__figure-full-link svg{height:.8em;margin-left:2px}.c-reading-companion__panel{border-top:none;display:none;margin-top:0;padding-top:0}.c-cod,.c-reading-companion__panel--active{display:block}.c-cod{font-size:1rem;width:100%}.c-cod__form{background:#ebf0f3}.c-cod__prompt{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.3;margin:0 0 24px}.c-cod__label{display:block;margin:0 0 4px}.c-cod__row{display:flex;margin:0 0 16px}.c-cod__row:last-child{margin:0}.c-cod__input{border:1px solid #d5d5d5;border-radius:2px;flex-basis:75%;flex-shrink:0;margin:0;padding:13px}.c-cod__input--submit{background-color:#069;border:1px solid #069;color:#fff;flex-shrink:1;margin-left:8px;transition:background-color .2s ease-out 0s,color .2s ease-out 0s}.c-cod__input--submit-single{flex-basis:100%;flex-shrink:0;margin:0}.c-cod__input--submit:focus,.c-cod__input--submit:hover{background-color:#fff;color:#069}.c-pdf-download__link .u-icon{padding-top:2px}.c-pdf-download{display:flex;margin-bottom:16px;max-height:48px}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-pdf-download{max-height:none}}@media only screen and (min-width:1024px){.c-pdf-download{max-height:48px}}.c-pdf-download__link{display:flex;flex:1 1 0%}.c-pdf-download__link:hover{text-decoration:none}.c-pdf-download__text{padding-right:4px}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.c-pdf-download__text{text-transform:capitalize}}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-pdf-download__text{padding-right:8px}}.c-context-bar--sticky .c-pdf-download{display:block;margin-bottom:0;white-space:nowrap}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.c-pdf-download .u-sticky-visually-hidden{clip:rect(0,0,0,0);border:0;height:1px;margin:-100%;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:absolute!important;width:1px}}.c-pdf-container{display:flex;justify-content:flex-end}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.c-pdf-container .c-pdf-download{display:flex;flex-basis:100%}}.c-pdf-container .c-pdf-download+.c-pdf-download{margin-left:16px}.c-article-extras .c-pdf-container .c-pdf-download{width:100%}.c-article-extras .c-pdf-container .c-pdf-download+.c-pdf-download{margin-left:0}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-context-bar--sticky .c-pdf-download__link{align-items:center;flex:1 1 183px}}@media only screen and (max-width:320px){.c-context-bar--sticky .c-pdf-download__link{padding:16px}}.article-page--commercial .c-article-main-column .c-pdf-button__container .c-pdf-download{display:none}@media only screen and (max-width:1023px){.article-page--commercial .c-article-main-column .c-pdf-button__container .c-pdf-download{display:block}}.c-status-message--success{border-bottom:2px solid #00b8b0;justify-content:center;margin-bottom:16px;padding-bottom:8px}.c-recommendations-list__item .c-card{flex-basis:100%}.c-recommendations-list__item .c-card__image{align-items:baseline;flex:1 1 40%;margin:0 0 0 16px;max-width:150px}.c-recommendations-list__item .c-card__image img{border:1px solid #cedbe0;height:auto;min-height:0;position:static}@media only screen and (max-width:1023px){.c-recommendations-list__item .c-card__image{display:none}}.c-card__layout{display:flex;flex:1 1 auto;justify-content:space-between}.c-card__title-recommendation{-webkit-box-orient:vertical;-webkit-line-clamp:4;display:-webkit-box;font-size:1rem;font-weight:700;line-height:1.4;margin:0 0 8px;max-height:5.6em;overflow:hidden!important;text-overflow:ellipsis}.c-card__title-recommendation .c-card__link{color:inherit}.c-card__title-recommendation .c-card__link:hover{text-decoration:underline}.c-card__title-recommendation .MathJax_Display{display:inline!important}.c-card__link:not(.c-card__link--no-block-link):before{z-index:1}.c-article-metrics__heading a,.c-article-metrics__posts .c-card__title a,.c-article-recommendations-card__link{color:inherit}.c-recommendations-column-switch .c-meta{margin-top:auto}.c-article-recommendations-card__meta-type,.c-meta .c-meta__item:first-child{font-weight:700}.c-article-body .c-article-recommendations-card__authors{display:none;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:.875rem;line-height:1.5;margin:0 0 8px}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.c-article-body .c-article-recommendations-card__authors{display:block;margin:0}}.c-article-metrics__posts .c-card__title{font-size:1.05rem}.c-article-metrics__posts .c-card__title+span{color:#6f6f6f;font-size:1rem}p{overflow-wrap:break-word;word-break:break-word}.c-ad{text-align:center}@media only screen and (min-width:320px){.c-ad{padding:8px}}.c-ad--728x90{background-color:#ccc;display:none}.c-ad--728x90 .c-ad__inner{min-height:calc(1.5em + 94px)}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.js .c-ad--728x90{display:none}}.c-ad__label{color:#333;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:.875rem;font-weight:400;line-height:1.5;margin-bottom:4px}.c-author-list{color:#6f6f6f;font-family:inherit;font-size:1rem;line-height:inherit;list-style:none;margin:0;padding:0}.c-author-list>li,.c-breadcrumbs>li,.c-footer__links>li,.js .c-author-list,.u-list-comma-separated>li,.u-list-inline>li{display:inline}.c-author-list>li:not(:first-child):not(:last-child):before{content:", "}.c-author-list>li:not(:only-child):last-child:before{content:" & "}.c-author-list--compact{font-size:.875rem;line-height:1.4}.c-author-list--truncated>li:not(:only-child):last-child:before{content:" ... "}.js .c-author-list__hide{display:none;visibility:hidden}.js .c-author-list__hide:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}.c-meta{color:inherit;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:.875rem;line-height:1.4;list-style:none;margin:0;padding:0}.c-meta--large{font-size:1rem}.c-meta--large .c-meta__item{margin-bottom:8px}.c-meta__item{display:inline-block;margin-bottom:4px}.c-meta__item:not(:last-child){border-right:1px solid #d5d5d5;margin-right:4px;padding-right:4px}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.c-meta__item--block-sm-max{display:block}.c-meta__item--block-sm-max:not(:last-child){border-right:none;margin-right:0;padding-right:0}}@media only screen and (min-width:1024px){.c-meta__item--block-at-lg{display:block}.c-meta__item--block-at-lg:not(:last-child){border-right:none;margin-right:0;padding-right:0}}.c-meta__type{font-weight:700;text-transform:none}.c-skip-link{background:#069;bottom:auto;color:#fff;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:.875rem;padding:8px;position:absolute;text-align:center;transform:translateY(-100%);z-index:9999}@media (prefers-reduced-motion:reduce){.c-skip-link{transition:top .3s ease-in-out 0s}}@media print{.c-skip-link{display:none}}.c-skip-link:link{color:#fff}.c-status-message{align-items:center;box-sizing:border-box;display:flex;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1rem;position:relative;width:100%}.c-card__summary>p:last-child,.c-status-message :last-child{margin-bottom:0}.c-status-message--boxed{background-color:#fff;border:1px solid #eee;border-radius:2px;line-height:1.4;padding:16px}.c-status-message__heading{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1rem;font-weight:700}.c-status-message__icon{fill:currentcolor;display:inline-block;flex:0 0 auto;height:1.5em;margin-right:8px;transform:translate(0);vertical-align:text-top;width:1.5em}.c-status-message__icon--top{align-self:flex-start}.c-status-message--info .c-status-message__icon{color:#003f8d}.c-status-message--boxed.c-status-message--info{border-bottom:4px solid #003f8d}.c-status-message--error .c-status-message__icon{color:#c40606}.c-status-message--boxed.c-status-message--error{border-bottom:4px solid #c40606}.c-status-message--success .c-status-message__icon{color:#00b8b0}.c-status-message--boxed.c-status-message--success{border-bottom:4px solid #00b8b0}.c-status-message--warning .c-status-message__icon{color:#edbc53}.c-status-message--boxed.c-status-message--warning{border-bottom:4px solid #edbc53}.c-breadcrumbs{color:#000;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1rem;list-style:none;margin:0;padding:0}.c-breadcrumbs__link{color:#666}svg.c-breadcrumbs__chevron{fill:#888;height:10px;margin:4px 4px 0;width:10px}@media only screen and (max-width:539px){.c-breadcrumbs .c-breadcrumbs__item{display:none}.c-breadcrumbs .c-breadcrumbs__item:last-child,.c-breadcrumbs .c-breadcrumbs__item:nth-last-child(2){display:inline}}.c-card{background-color:transparent;border:0;box-shadow:none;display:flex;flex-direction:column;font-size:14px;min-width:0;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:relative}.c-card--no-shape{background:0 0;border:0;box-shadow:none}.c-card__image{display:flex;justify-content:center;overflow:hidden;padding-bottom:56.25%;position:relative}@supports (aspect-ratio:1/1){.c-card__image{padding-bottom:0}}.c-card__image img{left:0;min-height:100%;min-width:100%;position:absolute}@supports ((-o-object-fit:cover) or (object-fit:cover)){.c-card__image img{height:100%;object-fit:cover;width:100%}}.c-card__body{flex:1 1 auto;padding:16px}.c-card--no-shape .c-card__body{padding:0}.c-card--no-shape .c-card__body:not(:first-child){padding-top:16px}.c-card__title{letter-spacing:-.01875rem;margin-bottom:8px;margin-top:0}[lang=de] .c-card__title{hyphens:auto}.c-card__summary{line-height:1.4}.c-card__summary>p{margin-bottom:5px}.c-card__summary a{text-decoration:underline}.c-card__link:not(.c-card__link--no-block-link):before{bottom:0;content:"";left:0;position:absolute;right:0;top:0}.c-card--flush .c-card__body{padding:0}.c-card--major{font-size:1rem}.c-card--dark{background-color:#29303c;border-width:0;color:#e3e4e5}.c-card--dark .c-card__title{color:#fff}.c-card--dark .c-card__link,.c-card--dark .c-card__summary a{color:inherit}.c-header{background-color:#fff;border-bottom:5px solid #000;font-size:1rem;line-height:1.4;margin-bottom:16px}.c-header__row{padding:0;position:relative}.c-header__row:not(:last-child){border-bottom:1px solid #eee}.c-header__split{align-items:center;display:flex;justify-content:space-between}.c-header__logo-container{flex:1 1 0px;line-height:0;margin:8px 24px 8px 0}.c-header__logo{transform:translateZ(0)}.c-header__logo img{max-height:32px}.c-header__container{margin:0 auto;max-width:1280px}.c-header__menu{align-items:center;display:flex;flex:0 1 auto;flex-wrap:wrap;font-weight:700;gap:8px 8px;line-height:1.4;list-style:none;margin:0 -8px;padding:0}@media print{.c-header__menu{display:none}}@media only screen and (max-width:1023px){.c-header__menu--hide-lg-max{display:none;visibility:hidden}}.c-header__menu--global{font-weight:400;justify-content:flex-end}.c-header__menu--global svg{display:none;visibility:hidden}.c-header__menu--global svg:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__menu--global svg{display:block;visibility:visible}}.c-header__menu--journal{font-size:.875rem;margin:8px 0 8px -8px}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__menu--journal{flex-wrap:nowrap;font-size:1rem}}.c-header__item{padding-bottom:0;padding-top:0;position:static}.c-header__item--pipe{border-left:2px solid #eee;padding-left:8px}.c-header__item--padding{padding-bottom:8px;padding-top:8px}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__item--dropdown-menu{position:relative}}@media only screen and (min-width:1024px){.c-header__item--hide-lg{display:none;visibility:hidden}}@media only screen and (max-width:767px){.c-header__item--hide-md-max{display:none;visibility:hidden}.c-header__item--hide-md-max:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}}.c-header__link{align-items:center;color:inherit;display:inline-flex;gap:4px 4px;padding:8px;white-space:nowrap}.c-header__link svg{transition-duration:.2s}.c-header__show-text{display:none;visibility:hidden}.has-tethered .c-header__heading--js-hide:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__show-text{display:inline;visibility:visible}}.c-header__dropdown{background-color:#000;border-bottom:1px solid #2f2f2f;color:#eee;font-size:.875rem;line-height:1.2;padding:16px 0}@media print{.c-header__dropdown{display:none}}.c-header__heading{display:inline-block;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:1.25rem;font-weight:400;line-height:1.4;margin-bottom:8px}.c-header__heading--keyline{border-top:1px solid;border-color:#2f2f2f;margin-top:16px;padding-top:16px;width:100%}.c-header__list{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;gap:0 16px;list-style:none;margin:0 -8px}.c-header__flush{margin:0 -8px}.c-header__visually-hidden{clip:rect(0,0,0,0);border:0;height:1px;margin:-100%;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:absolute!important;width:1px}.c-header__search-form{margin-bottom:8px}.c-header__search-layout{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;gap:16px 16px}.c-header__search-layout>:first-child{flex:999 1 auto}.c-header__search-layout>*{flex:1 1 auto}.c-header__search-layout--max-width{max-width:720px}.c-header__search-button{align-items:center;background-color:transparent;background-image:none;border:1px solid #fff;border-radius:2px;color:#fff;cursor:pointer;display:flex;font-family:sans-serif;font-size:1rem;justify-content:center;line-height:1.15;margin:0;padding:8px 16px;position:relative;text-decoration:none;transition:all .25s ease 0s,color .25s ease 0s,border-color .25s ease 0s;width:100%}.u-button svg,.u-button--primary svg{fill:currentcolor}.c-header__input,.c-header__select{border:1px solid;border-radius:3px;box-sizing:border-box;font-size:1rem;padding:8px 16px;width:100%}.c-header__select{-webkit-appearance:none;background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg height='16' viewBox='0 0 16 16' width='16' xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%3E%3Cpath d='m5.58578644 3-3.29289322-3.29289322c-.39052429-.39052429-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356s1.02368927-.39052429 1.41421356 0l4 4c.39052429.39052429.39052429 1.02368927 0 1.41421356l-4 4c-.39052429.39052429-1.02368927.39052429-1.41421356 0s-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356z' fill='%23333' fill-rule='evenodd' transform='matrix(0 1 -1 0 11 3)'/%3E%3C/svg%3E");background-position:right .7em top 50%;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:1em;box-shadow:0 1px 0 1px rgba(0,0,0,.04);display:block;margin:0;max-width:100%;min-width:150px}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__menu--journal .c-header__item--dropdown-menu:last-child .c-header__dropdown.has-tethered{left:auto;right:0}}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.c-header__menu--journal .c-header__item--dropdown-menu:last-child .c-header__dropdown.has-tethered{left:0;right:auto}}.c-header__dropdown.has-tethered{border-bottom:0;border-radius:0 0 2px 2px;left:0;position:absolute;top:100%;transform:translateY(5px);width:100%;z-index:1}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__dropdown.has-tethered{transform:translateY(8px);width:auto}}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.c-header__dropdown.has-tethered{min-width:225px}}.c-header__dropdown--full-width.has-tethered{padding:32px 0 24px;transform:none;width:100%}.has-tethered .c-header__heading--js-hide{display:none;visibility:hidden}.has-tethered .c-header__list--js-stack{flex-direction:column}.has-tethered .c-header__item--keyline,.has-tethered .c-header__list~.c-header__list .c-header__item:first-child{border-top:1px solid #d5d5d5;margin-top:8px;padding-top:8px}.c-header__item--snid-account-widget{display:flex}.c-header__container{padding:0 4px}.c-header__list{padding:0 12px}.c-header__menu .c-header__link{font-size:14px}.c-header__item--snid-account-widget .c-header__link{padding:8px}.c-header__menu--journal{margin-left:0}@media only screen and (min-width:540px){.c-header__container{padding:0 16px}.c-header__menu--journal{margin-left:-8px}.c-header__menu .c-header__link{font-size:16px}.c-header__link--search{gap:13px 13px}}.u-button{align-items:center;background-color:transparent;background-image:none;border:1px solid #069;border-radius:2px;color:#069;cursor:pointer;display:inline-flex;font-family:sans-serif;font-size:1rem;justify-content:center;line-height:1.3;margin:0;padding:8px;position:relative;text-decoration:none;transition:all .25s ease 0s,color .25s ease 0s,border-color .25s ease 0s;width:auto}.u-button--primary{background-color:#069;background-image:none;border:1px solid #069;color:#fff}.u-button--full-width{display:flex;width:100%}.u-display-none{display:none}.js .u-js-hide,.u-hide{display:none;visibility:hidden}.u-hide:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}.u-visually-hidden{clip:rect(0,0,0,0);border:0;height:1px;margin:-100%;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:absolute!important;width:1px}@media print{.u-hide-print{display:none}}@media only screen and (min-width:1024px){.u-hide-at-lg{display:none;visibility:hidden}.u-hide-at-lg:first-child+*{margin-block-start:0}}.u-clearfix:after,.u-clearfix:before{content:"";display:table}.u-clearfix:after{clear:both}.u-color-open-access{color:#b74616}.u-float-left{float:left}.u-icon{fill:currentcolor;display:inline-block;height:1em;transform:translate(0);vertical-align:text-top;width:1em}.u-full-height{height:100%}.u-list-reset{list-style:none;margin:0;padding:0}.u-sans-serif{font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif}.u-container{margin:0 auto;max-width:1280px;padding:0 16px}.u-justify-content-space-between{justify-content:space-between}.u-mt-32{margin-top:32px}.u-mb-8{margin-bottom:8px}.u-mb-16{margin-bottom:16px}.u-mb-24{margin-bottom:24px}.u-mb-32{margin-bottom:32px}.c-nature-box svg+.c-article__button-text,.u-ml-8{margin-left:8px}.u-pa-16{padding:16px}html *,html :after,html :before{box-sizing:inherit}.c-article-section__title,.c-article-title{font-weight:700}.c-card__title{line-height:1.4em}.c-article__button{background-color:#069;border:1px solid #069;border-radius:2px;color:#fff;display:flex;font-family:-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Oxygen-Sans,Ubuntu,Cantarell,Helvetica Neue,sans-serif;font-size:.875rem;line-height:1.4;margin-bottom:16px;padding:13px;transition:background-color .2s ease-out 0s,color .2s ease-out 0s}.c-article__button,.c-article__button:hover{text-decoration:none}.c-article__button--inverted,.c-article__button:hover{background-color:#fff;color:#069}.c-article__button--inverted:hover{background-color:#069;color:#fff}.c-header__link{text-decoration:inherit}.grade-c-hide{display:block}.u-lazy-ad-wrapper{background-color:#ccc;display:none;min-height:137px}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.u-lazy-ad-wrapper{display:block}}.c-nature-box{background-color:#fff;border:1px solid #d5d5d5;border-radius:2px;box-shadow:0 0 5px 0 rgba(51,51,51,.1);line-height:1.3;margin-bottom:24px;padding:16px 16px 3px}.c-nature-box__text{font-size:1rem;margin-bottom:16px}.c-nature-box .c-pdf-download{margin-bottom:16px!important}.c-nature-box--version{background-color:#eee}.c-nature-box__wrapper{transform:translateZ(0)}.c-nature-box__wrapper--placeholder{min-height:165px}.c-pdf-download__link{padding:13px 24px} } </style> <link data-test="critical-css-handler" data-inline-css-source="critical-css" rel="stylesheet" href="/static/css/enhanced-article-nature-branded-68c4876c28.css" media="print" onload="this.media='only print, only all and (prefers-color-scheme: no-preference), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: light), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: dark)';this.onload=null"> <noscript> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/static/css/enhanced-article-nature-branded-68c4876c28.css" media="only print, only all and (prefers-color-scheme: no-preference), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: light), only all and (prefers-color-scheme: dark)"> </noscript> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/static/css/article-print-122346e276.css" media="print"> <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="180x180" href=/static/images/favicons/nature/apple-touch-icon-f39cb19454.png> <link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="48x48" href=/static/images/favicons/nature/favicon-48x48-b52890008c.png> <link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="32x32" href=/static/images/favicons/nature/favicon-32x32-3fe59ece92.png> <link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="16x16" href=/static/images/favicons/nature/favicon-16x16-951651ab72.png> <link rel="manifest" href=/static/manifest.json crossorigin="use-credentials"> <link rel="mask-icon" href=/static/images/favicons/nature/safari-pinned-tab-69bff48fe6.svg color="#000000"> <link rel="shortcut icon" href=/static/images/favicons/nature/favicon.ico> <meta name="msapplication-TileColor" content="#000000"> <meta name="msapplication-config" content=/static/browserconfig.xml> <meta name="theme-color" content="#000000"> <meta name="application-name" content="Nature"> <script> (function () { if ( typeof window.CustomEvent === "function" ) return false; function CustomEvent ( event, params ) { params = params || { bubbles: false, cancelable: false, detail: null }; var evt = document.createEvent( 'CustomEvent' ); evt.initCustomEvent( event, params.bubbles, params.cancelable, params.detail ); return evt; } CustomEvent.prototype = window.Event.prototype; window.CustomEvent = CustomEvent; })(); </script>  <script data-test="gtm-head"> window.initGTM = function() { if (window.config.mustardcut) { (function (w, d, s, l, i) { w[l] = w[l] || []; w[l].push({'gtm.start': new Date().getTime(), event: 'gtm.js'}); var f = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0], j = d.createElement(s), dl = l != 'dataLayer' ? '&l=' + l : ''; j.async = true; j.src = 'https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=' + i + dl; f.parentNode.insertBefore(j, f); })(window, document, 'script', 'dataLayer', 'GTM-MRVXSHQ'); } } </script>  <script> (function(w,d,t) { function cc() { var h = w.location.hostname; if (h.indexOf('preview-www.nature.com') > -1) return; var e = d.createElement(t), s = d.getElementsByTagName(t)[0]; if (h.indexOf('nature.com') > -1) { if (h.indexOf('test-www.nature.com') > -1) { e.src = 'https://cmp.nature.com/production_live/en/consent-bundle-8-68.js'; e.setAttribute('onload', "initGTM(window,document,'script','dataLayer','GTM-MRVXSHQ')"); } else { e.src = 'https://cmp.nature.com/production_live/en/consent-bundle-8-68.js'; e.setAttribute('onload', "initGTM(window,document,'script','dataLayer','GTM-MRVXSHQ')"); } } else { e.src = '/static/js/cookie-consent-es5-bundle-cb57c2c98a.js'; e.setAttribute('data-consent', h); } s.insertAdjacentElement('afterend', e); } cc(); })(window,document,'script'); </script> <script id="js-position0"> (function(w, d) { w.idpVerifyPrefix = 'https://verify.nature.com'; w.ra21Host = 'https://wayf.springernature.com'; var moduleSupport = (function() { return 'noModule' in d.createElement('script'); })(); if (w.config.mustardcut === true) { w.loader = { index: 0, registered: [], scripts: [ {src: '/static/js/global-article-es6-bundle-c8a573ca90.js', test: 'global-article-js', module: true}, {src: '/static/js/global-article-es5-bundle-d17603b9e9.js', test: 'global-article-js', nomodule: true}, {src: '/static/js/shared-es6-bundle-606cb67187.js', test: 'shared-js', module: true}, {src: '/static/js/shared-es5-bundle-e919764a53.js', test: 'shared-js', nomodule: true}, {src: '/static/js/header-150-es6-bundle-5bb959eaa1.js', test: 'header-150-js', module: true}, {src: '/static/js/header-150-es5-bundle-994fde5b1d.js', test: 'header-150-js', nomodule: true} ].filter(function (s) { if (s.src === null) return false; if (moduleSupport && s.nomodule) return false; return !(!moduleSupport && s.module); }), register: function (value) { this.registered.push(value); }, ready: function () { if (this.registered.length === this.scripts.length) { this.registered.forEach(function (fn) { if (typeof fn === 'function') { setTimeout(fn, 0); } }); this.ready = function () {}; } }, insert: function (s) { var t = d.getElementById('js-position' + this.index); if (t && t.insertAdjacentElement) { t.insertAdjacentElement('afterend', s); } else { d.head.appendChild(s); } ++this.index; }, createScript: function (script, beforeLoad) { var s = d.createElement('script'); s.id = 'js-position' + (this.index + 1); s.setAttribute('data-test', script.test); if (beforeLoad) { s.defer = 'defer'; s.onload = function () { if (script.noinit) { loader.register(true); } if (d.readyState === 'interactive' || d.readyState === 'complete') { loader.ready(); } }; } else { s.async = 'async'; } s.src = script.src; return s; }, init: function () { this.scripts.forEach(function (s) { loader.insert(loader.createScript(s, true)); }); d.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function () { loader.ready(); var conditionalScripts; conditionalScripts = [ {match: 'div[data-pan-container]', src: '/static/js/pan-zoom-es6-bundle-464a2af269.js', test: 'pan-zoom-js', module: true }, {match: 'div[data-pan-container]', src: '/static/js/pan-zoom-es5-bundle-98fb9b653b.js', test: 'pan-zoom-js', nomodule: true }, {match: 'math,span.mathjax-tex', src: '/static/js/math-es6-bundle-23597ae350.js', test: 'math-js', module: true}, {match: 'math,span.mathjax-tex', src: '/static/js/math-es5-bundle-6532c6f78b.js', test: 'math-js', nomodule: true} ]; if (conditionalScripts) { conditionalScripts.filter(function (script) { return !!document.querySelector(script.match) && !((moduleSupport && script.nomodule) || (!moduleSupport && script.module)); }).forEach(function (script) { loader.insert(loader.createScript(script)); }); } }, false); } }; loader.init(); } })(window, document); </script> <meta name="robots" content="noarchive"> <meta name="access" content="Yes"> <link rel="search" href="https://www.nature.com/search"> <link rel="search" href="https://www.nature.com/opensearch/opensearch.xml" type="application/opensearchdescription+xml" title="nature.com"> <link rel="search" href="https://www.nature.com/opensearch/request" type="application/sru+xml" title="nature.com"> <script type="application/ld+json">{"mainEntity":{"headline":"Carotenoid metabolism strengthens the link between feather coloration and individual quality","description":"Thirty years of research has made carotenoid coloration a textbook example of an honest signal of individual quality, but tests of this idea are surprisingly inconsistent. Here, to investigate sources of this heterogeneity, we perform meta-analyses of published studies on the relationship between carotenoid-based feather coloration and measures of individual quality. To create color displays, animals use either carotenoids unchanged from dietary components or carotenoids that they biochemically convert before deposition. We hypothesize that converted carotenoids better reflect individual quality because of the physiological links between cellular function and carotenoid metabolism. We show that feather coloration is an honest signal of some, but not all, measures of quality. Where these relationships exist, we show that converted, but not dietary, carotenoid coloration drives the relationship. Our results have broad implications for understanding the evolutionary role of carotenoid coloration and the physiological mechanisms that maintain signal honesty of animal ornamental traits. Studies of honest signaling have found an inconsistent relationship between carotenoid coloration and individual quality. Here, Weaver et al. compare dietary and biochemically converted carotenoid coloration using meta-analyses and show that converted carotenoids drive relationships with quality measures.","datePublished":"2018-01-08T00:00:00Z","dateModified":"2018-01-08T00:00:00Z","pageStart":"1","pageEnd":"9","license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","sameAs":"https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z","keywords":["Behavioural ecology","Sexual selection","Science","Humanities and Social Sciences","multidisciplinary"],"image":["https://media.springernature.com/lw1200/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_Fig1_HTML.jpg","https://media.springernature.com/lw1200/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_Fig2_HTML.jpg","https://media.springernature.com/lw1200/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_Fig3_HTML.jpg"],"isPartOf":{"name":"Nature Communications","issn":["2041-1723"],"volumeNumber":"9","@type":["Periodical","PublicationVolume"]},"publisher":{"name":"Nature Publishing Group UK","logo":{"url":"https://www.springernature.com/app-sn/public/images/logo-springernature.png","@type":"ImageObject"},"@type":"Organization"},"author":[{"name":"Ryan J. Weaver","url":"http://orcid.org/0000-0002-6160-4735","affiliation":[{"name":"Auburn University","address":{"name":"Department of Biological Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, USA","@type":"PostalAddress"},"@type":"Organization"}],"email":"rjw0019@auburn.edu","@type":"Person"},{"name":"Eduardo S. A. Santos","affiliation":[{"name":"Universidade de São Paulo","address":{"name":"BECO do Departamento de Zoologia, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil","@type":"PostalAddress"},"@type":"Organization"}],"@type":"Person"},{"name":"Anna M. Tucker","affiliation":[{"name":"Auburn University","address":{"name":"School of Forestry and Wildlife Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, USA","@type":"PostalAddress"},"@type":"Organization"}],"@type":"Person"},{"name":"Alan E. Wilson","affiliation":[{"name":"Auburn University","address":{"name":"School of Fisheries, Aquaculture, and Aquatic Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, USA","@type":"PostalAddress"},"@type":"Organization"}],"@type":"Person"},{"name":"Geoffrey E. Hill","affiliation":[{"name":"Auburn University","address":{"name":"Department of Biological Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, USA","@type":"PostalAddress"},"@type":"Organization"}],"@type":"Person"}],"isAccessibleForFree":true,"@type":"ScholarlyArticle"},"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"WebPage"}</script> <link rel="canonical" href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-017-02649-z"> <meta name="journal_id" content="41467"/> <meta name="dc.title" content="Carotenoid metabolism strengthens the link between feather coloration and individual quality"/> <meta name="dc.source" content="Nature Communications 2017 9:1"/> <meta name="dc.format" content="text/html"/> <meta name="dc.publisher" content="Nature Publishing Group"/> <meta name="dc.date" content="2018-01-08"/> <meta name="dc.type" content="OriginalPaper"/> <meta name="dc.language" content="En"/> <meta name="dc.copyright" content="2017 The Author(s)"/> <meta name="dc.rights" content="2017 The Author(s)"/> <meta name="dc.rightsAgent" content="journalpermissions@springernature.com"/> <meta name="dc.description" content="Thirty years of research has made carotenoid coloration a textbook example of an honest signal of individual quality, but tests of this idea are surprisingly inconsistent. Here, to investigate sources of this heterogeneity, we perform meta-analyses of published studies on the relationship between carotenoid-based feather coloration and measures of individual quality. To create color displays, animals use either carotenoids unchanged from dietary components or carotenoids that they biochemically convert before deposition. We hypothesize that converted carotenoids better reflect individual quality because of the physiological links between cellular function and carotenoid metabolism. We show that feather coloration is an honest signal of some, but not all, measures of quality. Where these relationships exist, we show that converted, but not dietary, carotenoid coloration drives the relationship. Our results have broad implications for understanding the evolutionary role of carotenoid coloration and the physiological mechanisms that maintain signal honesty of animal ornamental traits. Studies of honest signaling have found an inconsistent relationship between carotenoid coloration and individual quality. Here, Weaver et al. compare dietary and biochemically converted carotenoid coloration using meta-analyses and show that converted carotenoids drive relationships with quality measures."/> <meta name="prism.issn" content="2041-1723"/> <meta name="prism.publicationName" content="Nature Communications"/> <meta name="prism.publicationDate" content="2018-01-08"/> <meta name="prism.volume" content="9"/> <meta name="prism.number" content="1"/> <meta name="prism.section" content="OriginalPaper"/> <meta name="prism.startingPage" content="1"/> <meta name="prism.endingPage" content="9"/> <meta name="prism.copyright" content="2017 The Author(s)"/> <meta name="prism.rightsAgent" content="journalpermissions@springernature.com"/> <meta name="prism.url" content="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-017-02649-z"/> <meta name="prism.doi" content="doi:10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z"/> <meta name="citation_pdf_url" content="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-017-02649-z.pdf"/> <meta name="citation_fulltext_html_url" content="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-017-02649-z"/> <meta name="citation_journal_title" content="Nature Communications"/> <meta name="citation_journal_abbrev" content="Nat Commun"/> <meta name="citation_publisher" content="Nature Publishing Group"/> <meta name="citation_issn" content="2041-1723"/> <meta name="citation_title" content="Carotenoid metabolism strengthens the link between feather coloration and individual quality"/> <meta name="citation_volume" content="9"/> <meta name="citation_issue" content="1"/> <meta name="citation_online_date" content="2018/01/08"/> <meta name="citation_firstpage" content="1"/> <meta name="citation_lastpage" content="9"/> <meta name="citation_article_type" content="Article"/> <meta name="citation_fulltext_world_readable" content=""/> <meta name="citation_language" content="en"/> <meta name="dc.identifier" content="doi:10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z"/> <meta name="DOI" content="10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z"/> <meta name="size" content="217627"/> <meta name="citation_doi" content="10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z"/> <meta name="citation_springer_api_url" content="http://api.springer.com/xmldata/jats?q=doi:10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z&api_key="/> <meta name="description" content="Thirty years of research has made carotenoid coloration a textbook example of an honest signal of individual quality, but tests of this idea are surprisingly inconsistent. Here, to investigate sources of this heterogeneity, we perform meta-analyses of published studies on the relationship between carotenoid-based feather coloration and measures of individual quality. To create color displays, animals use either carotenoids unchanged from dietary components or carotenoids that they biochemically convert before deposition. We hypothesize that converted carotenoids better reflect individual quality because of the physiological links between cellular function and carotenoid metabolism. We show that feather coloration is an honest signal of some, but not all, measures of quality. Where these relationships exist, we show that converted, but not dietary, carotenoid coloration drives the relationship. Our results have broad implications for understanding the evolutionary role of carotenoid coloration and the physiological mechanisms that maintain signal honesty of animal ornamental traits. Studies of honest signaling have found an inconsistent relationship between carotenoid coloration and individual quality. Here, Weaver et al. compare dietary and biochemically converted carotenoid coloration using meta-analyses and show that converted carotenoids drive relationships with quality measures."/> <meta name="dc.creator" content="Weaver, Ryan J."/> <meta name="dc.creator" content="Santos, Eduardo S. A."/> <meta name="dc.creator" content="Tucker, Anna M."/> <meta name="dc.creator" content="Wilson, Alan E."/> <meta name="dc.creator" content="Hill, Geoffrey E."/> <meta name="dc.subject" content="Behavioural ecology"/> <meta name="dc.subject" content="Sexual selection"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Behaviour; citation_title=Carotenoid-based signals in behavioural ecology: a review; citation_author=PA Svensson, BBM Wong; citation_volume=148; citation_publication_date=2011; citation_pages=131-189; citation_doi=10.1163/000579510X548673; citation_id=CR1"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="Hill, G. E. in: Bird.Coloration Vol. 2 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) 137–200 (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006)."/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="Hill, G. E. in Reproductive Biology and Phylogeny of Birds Vol 6B (ed Jamieson, B. G. M.) 41–74 (Science Publishers, Endfield, New Hampshire, 2007)."/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="Blount, J. & McGraw, K. in Carotenoids (eds Britton, G., Liaaen-Jensen, S. H. C., & Pfander, H.) 213–236 (Birkhäuser, Basel, Switzerland, 2008)."/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Proc. Biol. Sci.; citation_title=Oxidative stress and condition-dependent sexual signals: more than just seeing red; citation_author=M Garratt, RC Brooks; citation_volume=279; citation_publication_date=2012; citation_pages=3121-3130; citation_doi=10.1098/rspb.2012.0568; citation_id=CR5"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=PLoS ONE; citation_title=What does carotenoid-dependent coloration tell? Plasma carotenoid level signals immunocompetence and oxidative stress state in birds-A meta-analysis; citation_author=MJP Simons, AA Cohen, S Verhulst; citation_volume=7; citation_publication_date=2012; citation_pages=e43088; citation_doi=10.1371/journal.pone.0043088; citation_id=CR6"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Integr. Comp. Biol.; citation_title=Cellular respiration: The nexus of stress, condition, and ornamentation; citation_author=GE Hill; citation_volume=54; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=645-657; citation_doi=10.1093/icb/icu029; citation_id=CR7"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=J. Evol. Biol.; citation_title=The oxidation handicap hypothesis and the carotenoid allocation trade-off; citation_author=C Alonso-Alvarez, L Pérez-Rodríguez, R Mateo, O Chastel, J Viñuela; citation_volume=21; citation_publication_date=2008; citation_pages=1789-1797; citation_doi=10.1111/j.1420-9101.2008.01591.x; citation_id=CR8"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.; citation_title=What maintains signal honesty in animal colour dispays used in mate choice?; citation_author=RJ Weaver, RE Koch, GE Hill; citation_volume=372; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_pages=20160343; citation_doi=10.1098/rstb.2016.0343; citation_id=CR9"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=J. Nutr.; citation_title=Carotenoid action on the immune response; citation_author=BP Chew, JS Park; citation_volume=134; citation_publication_date=2004; citation_pages=257S-261S; citation_id=CR10"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=FASEB J.; citation_title=Structure and properties of carotenoids in relation to function; citation_author=G Britton; citation_volume=9; citation_publication_date=1995; citation_pages=1551-1558; citation_id=CR11"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. Nat.; citation_title=The vitamin A-redox hypothesis: A biochemical basis for honest signaling via carotenoid pigmentation; citation_author=GE Hill, JD Johnson; citation_volume=180; citation_publication_date=2012; citation_pages=E127-E150; citation_doi=10.1086/667861; citation_id=CR12"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Oecologia; citation_title=Accumulation of dietary carotenoids, retinoids and tocopherol in the internal tissues of a bird: a hypothesis for the cost of producing colored ornaments; citation_author=E García-de Blas, R Mateo, C Alonso-Alvarez; citation_volume=177; citation_publication_date=2015; citation_pages=259-271; citation_doi=10.1007/s00442-014-3163-8; citation_id=CR13"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Methods Enzymol.; citation_title=Distribution of carotenoids; citation_author=T Goodwin; citation_volume=213; citation_publication_date=1992; citation_pages=167-172; citation_doi=10.1016/0076-6879(92)13119-I; citation_id=CR14"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Annu. Rev. Nutr.; citation_title=Metabolism, nutrition, and function of carotenoids; citation_author=T Goodwin; citation_volume=6; citation_publication_date=1986; citation_pages=237-297; citation_doi=10.1146/annurev.nu.06.070186.001421; citation_id=CR15"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="McGraw, K. J. in Bird Coloration Vol. 1 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006)."/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Funct. Ecol.; citation_title=Influence of dietary carotenoids on plasma and plumage colour in the house finch: intra- and intersexual variation; citation_author=GE Hill, R Montgomerie, CY Inouye, J Dale; citation_volume=8; citation_publication_date=1994; citation_pages=343-350; citation_doi=10.2307/2389827; citation_id=CR17"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Oikos; citation_title=Carotenoids, parasites, and sexual selection; citation_author=G Lozano; citation_volume=70; citation_publication_date=1994; citation_pages=309-312; citation_doi=10.2307/3545643; citation_id=CR18"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.; citation_title=Good genes, oxidative stress and condition–dependent sexual signals; citation_author=T Schantz, S Bensch, M Grahn, D Hasselquist, H Wittzell; citation_volume=266; citation_publication_date=1999; citation_pages=1-12; citation_doi=10.1098/rspb.1999.0597; citation_id=CR19"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Avian Poult. Biol. Rev.; citation_title=Carotenoid-dependent signals: Indicators of foraging efficiency, immunocompetence or detoxification ability?; citation_author=AP Møller; citation_volume=11; citation_publication_date=2000; citation_pages=137-159; citation_id=CR20"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Ecol. Lett.; citation_title=Condition-dependent traits as signals of the functionality of vital cellular processes; citation_author=GE Hill; citation_volume=14; citation_publication_date=2011; citation_pages=625-634; citation_doi=10.1111/j.1461-0248.2011.01622.x; citation_id=CR21"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Biochimie; citation_title=Is carotenoid ornamentation linked to the inner mitochondria membrane potential? A hypothesis for the maintenance of signal honesty; citation_author=JD Johnson, GE Hill; citation_volume=95; citation_publication_date=2013; citation_pages=436-444; citation_doi=10.1016/j.biochi.2012.10.021; citation_id=CR22"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. Nat.; citation_title=Is there an immunological cost to carotenoid-based ornamental coloration?; citation_author=GE Hill; citation_volume=154; citation_publication_date=1999; citation_pages=589-595; citation_id=CR23"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Anim. Behav.; citation_title=Melanin- versus carotenoid-based sexual signals: is the difference really so black and red?; citation_author=SC Griffith, TH Parker, VA Olson; citation_volume=71; citation_publication_date=2006; citation_pages=749-763; citation_doi=10.1016/j.anbehav.2005.07.016; citation_id=CR24"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. Nat.; citation_title=Carotenoid-dependent signals and the evolution of plasma carotenoid levels in birds; citation_author=MJP Simons, R Maia, B Leenknegt, S Verhulst; citation_volume=184; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=741-751; citation_doi=10.1086/678402; citation_id=CR25"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Ecol. Indic.; citation_title=Copper exposure reduces production of red carotenoids in a marine copepod; citation_author=RJ Weaver, GE Hill, PL Kuan, YC Tseng; citation_volume=70; citation_publication_date=2016; citation_pages=393-400; citation_doi=10.1016/j.ecolind.2016.06.040; citation_id=CR26"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Curr. Biol.; citation_title=Genetic basis for red coloration in birds; citation_author=RJ Lopes; citation_volume=26; citation_publication_date=2016; citation_pages=1427-1434; citation_doi=10.1016/j.cub.2016.03.076; citation_id=CR27"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Br. Med. J.; citation_title=Measuring inconsistency in knowledgebases; citation_author=JPT Higgins, SG Thompson, JJ Deeks, DG Altman; citation_volume=327; citation_publication_date=2003; citation_pages=557-560; citation_doi=10.1136/bmj.327.7414.557; citation_id=CR28"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=J. Stat. Softw.; citation_title=Conducting meta-analyses in R with the metafor package; citation_author=W Viechtbauer; citation_volume=36; citation_publication_date=2010; citation_pages=1-48; citation_doi=10.18637/jss.v036.i03; citation_id=CR29"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Curr. Biol.; citation_title=Sexual selection and condition-dependent mate preferences; citation_author=S Cotton, J Small, A Pomiankowski; citation_volume=16; citation_publication_date=2006; citation_pages=R755-R765; citation_doi=10.1016/j.cub.2006.08.022; citation_id=CR30"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Oecologia; citation_title=Carotenoid-based plumage coloration reflects hemoparasite infection and local survival in breeding great tits; citation_author=P Hõrak, I Ots, H Vellau, C Spottiswoode, AP Møller; citation_volume=126; citation_publication_date=2001; citation_pages=166-173; citation_doi=10.1007/s004420000513; citation_id=CR31"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Parus Major. Funct. Ecol.; citation_title=Carotenoid pigmentation does not reflect total non-enzymatic antioxidant activity in plasma of adult and nestling great tits; citation_author=C Isaksson, P McLaughlin, P Monaghan, S Andersson; citation_volume=21; citation_publication_date=2007; citation_pages=1123-1129; citation_doi=10.1111/j.1365-2435.2007.01317.x; citation_id=CR32"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Proc. Biol. Sci.; citation_title=Oxidative stress does not influence carotenoid mobilization and plumage pigmentation; citation_author=C Isaksson, S Andersson; citation_volume=275; citation_publication_date=2008; citation_pages=309-314; citation_doi=10.1098/rspb.2007.1474; citation_id=CR33"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Evolution; citation_title=Natural selection on color patterns in Poecilia reticulata; citation_author=JA Endler; citation_volume=34; citation_publication_date=1980; citation_pages=76-91; citation_doi=10.1111/j.1558-5646.1980.tb04790.x; citation_id=CR34"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol.; citation_title=Dietary carotenoids and male mating success in the guppy: an environmental component to female choice; citation_author=A Kodric-Brown; citation_volume=25; citation_publication_date=1989; citation_pages=393-401; citation_doi=10.1007/BF00300185; citation_id=CR35"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Auk; citation_title=Proximate basis of variation in carotenoid pigmentation in male house finches; citation_author=GE Hill; citation_volume=109; citation_publication_date=1992; citation_pages=1-12; citation_doi=10.2307/4088262; citation_id=CR36"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Auk; citation_title=House finches are what they eat: a reply to Hudon; citation_author=GE Hill; citation_volume=111; citation_publication_date=1994; citation_pages=221-225; citation_doi=10.2307/4088530; citation_id=CR37"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Auk; citation_title=Showiness, carotenoids, and captivity: A comment on Hill (1992); citation_author=J Hudon; citation_volume=111; citation_publication_date=1994; citation_pages=218-221; citation_doi=10.2307/4088529; citation_id=CR38"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. Nat.; citation_title=High parasite load in house finches (Carpodacus mexicanus) is correlated with reduced expression of a sexually selected trait; citation_author=C Thompson, N Hillgarth, M Leu, H McClure; citation_volume=149; citation_publication_date=1997; citation_pages=270-294; citation_doi=10.1086/285990; citation_id=CR39"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Redox Rep.; citation_title=Bioactive carotenoids: potent antioxidants and regulators of gene expression; citation_author=LM Hix, SF Lockwood, JS Bertram; citation_volume=9; citation_publication_date=2004; citation_pages=181-191; citation_doi=10.1179/135100004225005967; citation_id=CR40"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Free Radic. Biol. Med.; citation_title=Antioxidant functions of carotenoids; citation_author=NI Krinsky; citation_volume=7; citation_publication_date=1989; citation_pages=617-635; citation_doi=10.1016/0891-5849(89)90143-3; citation_id=CR41"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Funct. Ecol.; citation_title=Carotenoids are minor antioxidants for birds; citation_author=D Costantini, AP Møller; citation_volume=22; citation_publication_date=2008; citation_pages=367-370; citation_doi=10.1111/j.1365-2435.2007.01366.x; citation_id=CR42"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Ecol. Lett.; citation_title=Oxidative stress in ecology and evolution: lessons from avian studies; citation_author=D Costantini; citation_volume=11; citation_publication_date=2008; citation_pages=1238-1251; citation_id=CR43"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Trends Ecol. Evol.; citation_title=Are carotenoids a red herring in sexual display?; citation_author=RC Hartley, MW Kennedy; citation_volume=19; citation_publication_date=2004; citation_pages=353-354; citation_doi=10.1016/j.tree.2004.04.002; citation_id=CR44"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=BioEssays; citation_title=Carotenoids in evolutionary ecology: Re-evaluating the antioxidant role; citation_author=L Pérez-Rodríguez; citation_volume=31; citation_publication_date=2009; citation_pages=1116-1126; citation_doi=10.1002/bies.200900070; citation_id=CR45"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Science; citation_title=Heritable true fitness and bright birds: a role for parasites?; citation_author=WD Hamilton, M Zuk; citation_volume=218; citation_publication_date=1982; citation_pages=384-387; citation_doi=10.1126/science.7123238; citation_id=CR46"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Biol. Rev.; citation_title=Mitochondrial function, ornamentation, and immunocompetence; citation_author=RE Koch, CC Josefson, GE Hill; citation_volume=92; citation_publication_date=2016; citation_pages=1459-1474; citation_doi=10.1111/brv.12291; citation_id=CR47"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. Nat.; citation_title=Sexual selection for aesthetic traits in species with biparental care; citation_author=N Burley; citation_volume=127; citation_publication_date=1986; citation_pages=415-445; citation_doi=10.1086/284493; citation_id=CR48"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. Biol. Sci.; citation_title=Reproductive investment when mate quality varies: differential allocation versus reproductive compensation; citation_author=WE Harris, T Uller; citation_volume=364; citation_publication_date=2009; citation_pages=1039-1048; citation_doi=10.1098/rstb.2008.0299; citation_id=CR49"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Behav. Ecol.; citation_title=Differential allocation and compensation: Who deserves the silver spoon?; citation_author=II Ratikainen, H Kokko; citation_volume=21; citation_publication_date=2010; citation_pages=195-200; citation_doi=10.1093/beheco/arp168; citation_id=CR50"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. Nat.; citation_title=Most colorful example of genetic assimilation? Exploring the evolutionary destiny of recurrent phenotypic accommodation; citation_author=AV Badyaev, AL Potticary, ES Morrison; citation_volume=190; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_pages=266-280; citation_doi=10.1086/692327; citation_id=CR51"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Nature; citation_title=Plumage coloration is a sexually selected indicator of male quality; citation_author=G Hill; citation_volume=350; citation_publication_date=1991; citation_pages=337-338; citation_doi=10.1038/350337a0; citation_id=CR52"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Auk; citation_title=The role of bare parts in avian signaling; citation_author=ENK Iverson, J Karubian; citation_volume=134; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_pages=587-611; citation_doi=10.1642/AUK-16-136.1; citation_id=CR53"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Naturwissenschaften; citation_title=Astaxanthin and papilioerythrinone in the skin of birds: A chromatic convergence of two metabolic routes with different precursors?; citation_author=EG Blas, R Mateo, FJ Guzman Bernardo, RC Rodríguez Martín-Doimeadios, C Alonso-Alvarez; citation_volume=101; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=407-416; citation_doi=10.1007/s00114-014-1169-z; citation_id=CR54"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Fish Shellfish Immunol.; citation_title=Immune response and disease resistance of carotenoids supplementation diet in Cyprinus carpio against Aeromonas hydrophila; citation_author=SM Anbazahan; citation_volume=40; citation_publication_date=2014; citation_pages=9-13; citation_doi=10.1016/j.fsi.2014.06.011; citation_id=CR55"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=PLoS. One.; citation_title=Carotenoid-based colours reflect the stress response in the common lizard; citation_author=PS Fitze; citation_volume=4; citation_publication_date=2009; citation_pages=e5111; citation_doi=10.1371/journal.pone.0005111; citation_id=CR56"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=PLoS Med.; citation_title=Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement; citation_author=D Moher, A Liberati, J Tetzlaff, DG Altman, TP Group; citation_volume=6; citation_publication_date=2009; citation_pages=e1000097; citation_doi=10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097; citation_id=CR57"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="Jennions, M. D., Lortie, C. J., Rosenberg, M. S. & Rothstein, H. R. In Handbook of Meta-Analysis in Ecology and Evolution (eds Koricheva, J., Gurevitch, J., & Mengersen, K.) 207–236 (Princeton University Press,  Princeton, NJ, 2013)."/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=J. Exp. Biol.; citation_title=Carotenoid-based coloration predicts resistance to oxidative damage during immune challenge; citation_author=L Pérez-Rodríguez, F Mougeot, C Alonso-Alvarez; citation_volume=213; citation_publication_date=2010; citation_pages=1685-9160; citation_doi=10.1242/jeb.039982; citation_id=CR59"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Proc. R. Soc. B-Biol. Sci.; citation_title=Testosterone and oxidative stress: the oxidation handicap hypothesis; citation_author=C Alonso-Alvarez, S Bertrand, B Faivre, O Chastel, G Sorci; citation_volume=274; citation_publication_date=2007; citation_pages=819-825; citation_doi=10.1098/rspb.2006.3764; citation_id=CR60"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Physiol. Biochem. Zool.; citation_title=Free and esterified carotenoids in ornaments of an avian species: the relationship to color expression and sources of variability; citation_author=E García-de Blas, R Mateo, J Viñuela, L Pérez-Rodríguez, C Alonso-Alvarez; citation_volume=86; citation_publication_date=2013; citation_pages=483-498; citation_doi=10.1086/671812; citation_id=CR61"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Comp. Biochem. Physiol. A Mol. Integr. Physiol.; citation_title=Function and occurrence of facial flushing in birds; citation_author=JJ Negro, JH Sarasola, F Fariñas, I Zorrilla; citation_volume=143; citation_publication_date=2006; citation_pages=78-84; citation_doi=10.1016/j.cbpa.2005.10.028; citation_id=CR62"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Curr. Biol.; citation_title=Red carotenoid coloration in the zebra finch is controlled by a cytochrome P450 gene cluster; citation_author=NI Mundy; citation_volume=26; citation_publication_date=2016; citation_pages=1435-1440; citation_doi=10.1016/j.cub.2016.04.047; citation_id=CR63"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="Lipsey, M. W. & Wilson, D. B. Practical Meta-analysis. Applied Social Research Methods Series Vol. 49 (Sage Publications, Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA, 2001)."/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="Cohen, J. Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. (Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ, 1988)."/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Proc. R. Soc. Biol. Sci. Ser. B; citation_title=Differential effects of endoparasitism on the expression of carotenoid- and melanin-based ornamental coloration; citation_author=KJ McGraw, GE Hill; citation_volume=267; citation_publication_date=2000; citation_pages=1525-1531; citation_doi=10.1098/rspb.2000.1174; citation_id=CR66"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Evol. Ecol.; citation_title=Methodological issues and advances in biological meta-analysis; citation_author=S Nakagawa, ESA Santos; citation_volume=26; citation_publication_date=2012; citation_pages=1253-1274; citation_doi=10.1007/s10682-012-9555-5; citation_id=CR67"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Faseb. J.; citation_title=Metabolism of carotenoid pigments in birds; citation_author=A Brush; citation_volume=4; citation_publication_date=1990; citation_pages=2969-2977; citation_id=CR68"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="Montgomerie, R. in Bird Coloration Vol. 1 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006)."/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Biol. Lett.; citation_title=Carotenoids need structural colours to shine; citation_author=MD Shawkey, GE Hill; citation_volume=1; citation_publication_date=2005; citation_pages=121-124; citation_doi=10.1098/rsbl.2004.0289; citation_id=CR70"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=J. Stat. Softw.; citation_title=MCMC methods for multi-response generalized linear mixed models: The MCMCglmm R package; citation_author=JD Hadfield; citation_volume=33; citation_publication_date=2010; citation_pages=1-22; citation_doi=10.18637/jss.v033.i02; citation_id=CR71"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=J. Evol. Biol.; citation_title=General quantitative genetic methods for comparative biology: Phylogenies, taxonomies and multi-trait models for continuous and categorical characters; citation_author=JD Hadfield, S Nakagawa; citation_volume=23; citation_publication_date=2010; citation_pages=494-508; citation_doi=10.1111/j.1420-9101.2009.01915.x; citation_id=CR72"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="R Core Team. R: a language and environment for statistical computing (R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria, 2017)."/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Biol. Rev.; citation_title=Facultative adjustment of the offspring sex ratio and male attractiveness: a systematic review and meta-analysis; citation_author=I Booksmythe, B Mautz, J Davis, S Nakagawa, MD Jennions; citation_volume=92; citation_publication_date=2017; citation_pages=108-134; citation_doi=10.1111/brv.12220; citation_id=CR74"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Nature; citation_title=The global diversity of birds in space and time; citation_author=W Jetz, GH Thomas, JB Joy, K Hartmann, AO Mooers; citation_volume=491; citation_publication_date=2012; citation_pages=444-448; citation_doi=10.1038/nature11631; citation_id=CR75"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Am. Nat.; citation_title=The phylogenetic mixed model; citation_author=EA Housworth, EP Martins, M Lynch; citation_volume=163; citation_publication_date=2004; citation_pages=84-96; citation_doi=10.1086/380570; citation_id=CR76"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Br. Med. J.; citation_title=Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test; citation_author=M Egger, GD Smith, M Schneider, C Minder; citation_volume=315; citation_publication_date=1997; citation_pages=629-634; citation_doi=10.1136/bmj.315.7109.629; citation_id=CR77"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="Weaver, R. J., Santos E.S.A., & Tucker, A.M. Carotenoid Metabolism Strengthens the Link Between Feather Coloration and Individual Quality https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5675431.v2 (2017)."/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Comp. Biochem. Physiol. Part B Biochem. Mol. Biol.; citation_title=Carotenoids in bird plumage: The pattern in a series of red-pigmented carduelinae; citation_author=R Stradi, G Celentano, M Boles, F Mercato; citation_volume=117; citation_publication_date=1997; citation_pages=85-91; citation_doi=10.1016/S0305-0491(96)00271-4; citation_id=CR79"/> <meta name="citation_reference" content="citation_journal_title=Comp. Biochem. Physiol. Part B Biochem. Mol. Biol.; citation_title=Carotenoids in bird plumage: the complement of yellow and red pigments in true woodpeckers (Picinae); citation_author=R Stradi, J Hudon, G Celentano, E Pini; citation_volume=120; citation_publication_date=1998; citation_pages=223-230; citation_doi=10.1016/S0305-0491(98)10033-0; citation_id=CR80"/> <meta name="citation_author" content="Weaver, Ryan J."/> <meta name="citation_author_institution" content="Department of Biological Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, USA"/> <meta name="citation_author" content="Santos, Eduardo S. A."/> <meta name="citation_author_institution" content="BECO do Departamento de Zoologia, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil"/> <meta name="citation_author" content="Tucker, Anna M."/> <meta name="citation_author_institution" content="School of Forestry and Wildlife Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, USA"/> <meta name="citation_author" content="Wilson, Alan E."/> <meta name="citation_author_institution" content="School of Fisheries, Aquaculture, and Aquatic Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, USA"/> <meta name="citation_author" content="Hill, Geoffrey E."/> <meta name="citation_author_institution" content="Department of Biological Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, USA"/> <meta name="access_endpoint" content="https://www.nature.com/platform/readcube-access"/> <meta name="twitter:site" content="@NatureComms"/> <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"/> <meta name="twitter:image:alt" content="Content cover image"/> <meta name="twitter:title" content="Carotenoid metabolism strengthens the link between feather coloration and individual quality"/> <meta name="twitter:description" content="Nature Communications - Studies of honest signaling have found an inconsistent relationship between carotenoid coloration and individual quality. Here, Weaver et al. compare dietary and..."/> <meta name="twitter:image" content="https://media.springernature.com/full/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_Fig1_HTML.jpg"/> <meta property="og:url" content="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-017-02649-z"/> <meta property="og:type" content="article"/> <meta property="og:site_name" content="Nature"/> <meta property="og:title" content="Carotenoid metabolism strengthens the link between feather coloration and individual quality - Nature Communications"/> <meta property="og:description" content="Studies of honest signaling have found an inconsistent relationship between carotenoid coloration and individual quality. Here, Weaver et al. compare dietary and biochemically converted carotenoid coloration using meta-analyses and show that converted carotenoids drive relationships with quality measures."/> <meta property="og:image" content="https://media.springernature.com/m685/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_Fig1_HTML.jpg"/> <script> window.eligibleForRa21 = 'false'; </script> </head> <body class="article-page"> <noscript><iframe src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-MRVXSHQ" height="0" width="0" style="display:none;visibility:hidden"></iframe></noscript> <div class="position-relative cleared z-index-50 background-white" data-test="top-containers"> <a class="c-skip-link" href="#content">Skip to main content</a> <div class="c-grade-c-banner u-hide"> <div class="c-grade-c-banner__container"> <p>Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.</p> </div> </div> <div class="u-hide u-show-following-ad"></div> <aside class="c-ad c-ad--728x90"> <div class="c-ad__inner" data-container-type="banner-advert"> <p class="c-ad__label">Advertisement</p> <div id="div-gpt-ad-top-1" class="div-gpt-ad advert leaderboard js-ad text-center hide-print grade-c-hide" data-ad-type="top" data-test="top-ad" data-pa11y-ignore data-gpt data-gpt-unitpath="/285/nature_communications/article" data-gpt-sizes="728x90" data-gpt-targeting="type=article;pos=top;artid=s41467-017-02649-z;doi=10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z;techmeta=141;subjmeta=158,181,2470,631,856;kwrd=Behavioural+ecology,Sexual+selection"> <noscript> <a href="//pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?iu=/285/nature_communications/article&sz=728x90&c=661656220&t=pos%3Dtop%26type%3Darticle%26artid%3Ds41467-017-02649-z%26doi%3D10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z%26techmeta%3D141%26subjmeta%3D158,181,2470,631,856%26kwrd%3DBehavioural+ecology,Sexual+selection"> <img data-test="gpt-advert-fallback-img" src="//pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/ad?iu=/285/nature_communications/article&sz=728x90&c=661656220&t=pos%3Dtop%26type%3Darticle%26artid%3Ds41467-017-02649-z%26doi%3D10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z%26techmeta%3D141%26subjmeta%3D158,181,2470,631,856%26kwrd%3DBehavioural+ecology,Sexual+selection" alt="Advertisement" width="728" height="90"></a> </noscript> </div> </div> </aside> <header class="c-header" id="header" data-header data-track-component="nature-150-split-header" style="border-color:#e63323"> <div class="c-header__row"> <div class="c-header__container"> <div class="c-header__split"> <div class="c-header__logo-container"> <a href="/ncomms" data-track="click" data-track-action="home" data-track-label="image"> <picture class="c-header__logo"> <source srcset="https://media.springernature.com/full/nature-cms/uploads/product/ncomms/header-03d2e325c0a02f6df509e5730e9be304.svg" media="(min-width: 875px)"> <img src="https://media.springernature.com/full/nature-cms/uploads/product/ncomms/header-7001f06bc3fe2437048388e9f2f44215.svg" height="32" alt="Nature Communications"> </picture> </a> </div> <ul class="c-header__menu c-header__menu--global"> <li class="c-header__item c-header__item--padding c-header__item--hide-md-max"> <a class="c-header__link" href="https://www.nature.com/siteindex" data-test="siteindex-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="open nature research index" data-track-label="link"> <span>View all journals</span> </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item c-header__item--padding c-header__item--pipe"> <a class="c-header__link c-header__link--search" href="#search-menu" data-header-expander data-test="search-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="open search tray" data-track-label="button"> <svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="22" width="22" viewBox="0 0 18 18" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="M16.48 15.455c.283.282.29.749.007 1.032a.738.738 0 01-1.032-.007l-3.045-3.044a7 7 0 111.026-1.026zM8 14A6 6 0 108 2a6 6 0 000 12z"/></svg><span>Search</span> </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item c-header__item--padding c-header__item--snid-account-widget c-header__item--pipe"> <a class="c-header__link eds-c-header__link" id="identity-account-widget" href='https://idp.nature.com/auth/personal/springernature?redirect_uri=https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-017-02649-z?error=cookies_not_supported&code=0daa5cb5-5829-41d3-a1b1-d78293b447d8'><span class="eds-c-header__widget-fragment-title">Log in</span></a> </li> </ul> </div> </div> </div> <div class="c-header__row"> <div class="c-header__container" data-test="navigation-row"> <div class="c-header__split"> <ul class="c-header__menu c-header__menu--journal"> <li class="c-header__item c-header__item--dropdown-menu" data-test="explore-content-button"> <a href="#explore" class="c-header__link" data-header-expander data-test="menu-button--explore" data-track="click" data-track-action="open explore expander" data-track-label="button"> <span><span class="c-header__show-text">Explore</span> content</span><svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="16" viewBox="0 0 16 16" width="16" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="m5.58578644 3-3.29289322-3.29289322c-.39052429-.39052429-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356s1.02368927-.39052429 1.41421356 0l4 4c.39052429.39052429.39052429 1.02368927 0 1.41421356l-4 4c-.39052429.39052429-1.02368927.39052429-1.41421356 0s-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356z" transform="matrix(0 1 -1 0 11 3)"/></svg> </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item c-header__item--dropdown-menu"> <a href="#about-the-journal" class="c-header__link" data-header-expander data-test="menu-button--about-the-journal" data-track="click" data-track-action="open about the journal expander" data-track-label="button"> <span>About <span class="c-header__show-text">the journal</span></span><svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="16" viewBox="0 0 16 16" width="16" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="m5.58578644 3-3.29289322-3.29289322c-.39052429-.39052429-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356s1.02368927-.39052429 1.41421356 0l4 4c.39052429.39052429.39052429 1.02368927 0 1.41421356l-4 4c-.39052429.39052429-1.02368927.39052429-1.41421356 0s-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356z" transform="matrix(0 1 -1 0 11 3)"/></svg> </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item c-header__item--dropdown-menu" data-test="publish-with-us-button"> <a href="#publish-with-us" class="c-header__link c-header__link--dropdown-menu" data-header-expander data-test="menu-button--publish" data-track="click" data-track-action="open publish with us expander" data-track-label="button"> <span>Publish <span class="c-header__show-text">with us</span></span><svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="16" viewBox="0 0 16 16" width="16" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="m5.58578644 3-3.29289322-3.29289322c-.39052429-.39052429-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356s1.02368927-.39052429 1.41421356 0l4 4c.39052429.39052429.39052429 1.02368927 0 1.41421356l-4 4c-.39052429.39052429-1.02368927.39052429-1.41421356 0s-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356z" transform="matrix(0 1 -1 0 11 3)"/></svg> </a> </li> </ul> <ul class="c-header__menu c-header__menu--hide-lg-max"> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="https://idp.nature.com/auth/personal/springernature?redirect_uri=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nature.com%2Fmy-account%2Falerts%2Fsubscribe-journal%3Flist-id%3D264%26journal-link%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fwww.nature.com%252Fncomms%252F" rel="nofollow" data-track="click" data-track-action="Sign up for alerts" data-track-label="link (desktop site header)" data-track-external> <span>Sign up for alerts</span><svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="18" viewBox="0 0 18 18" width="18" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="m4 10h2.5c.27614237 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-3.08578644l-1.12132034 1.1213203c-.18753638.1875364-.29289322.4418903-.29289322.7071068v.1715729h14v-.1715729c0-.2652165-.1053568-.5195704-.2928932-.7071068l-1.7071068-1.7071067v-3.4142136c0-2.76142375-2.2385763-5-5-5-2.76142375 0-5 2.23857625-5 5zm3 4c0 1.1045695.8954305 2 2 2s2-.8954305 2-2zm-5 0c-.55228475 0-1-.4477153-1-1v-.1715729c0-.530433.21071368-1.0391408.58578644-1.4142135l1.41421356-1.4142136v-3c0-3.3137085 2.6862915-6 6-6s6 2.6862915 6 6v3l1.4142136 1.4142136c.3750727.3750727.5857864.8837805.5857864 1.4142135v.1715729c0 .5522847-.4477153 1-1 1h-4c0 1.6568542-1.3431458 3-3 3-1.65685425 0-3-1.3431458-3-3z" fill="#222"/></svg> </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item c-header__item--pipe"> <a class="c-header__link" href="https://www.nature.com/ncomms.rss" data-track="click" data-track-action="rss feed" data-track-label="link"> <span>RSS feed</span> </a> </li> </ul> </div> </div> </div> </header> <nav class="u-mb-16" aria-label="breadcrumbs"> <div class="u-container"> <ol class="c-breadcrumbs" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/BreadcrumbList"> <li class="c-breadcrumbs__item" id="breadcrumb0" itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem"><a class="c-breadcrumbs__link" href="/" itemprop="item" data-track="click" data-track-action="breadcrumb" data-track-category="header" data-track-label="link:nature"><span itemprop="name">nature</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="1"> <svg class="c-breadcrumbs__chevron" role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="10" viewBox="0 0 10 10" width="10" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"> <path d="m5.96738168 4.70639573 2.39518594-2.41447274c.37913917-.38219212.98637524-.38972225 1.35419292-.01894278.37750606.38054586.37784436.99719163-.00013556 1.37821513l-4.03074001 4.06319683c-.37758093.38062133-.98937525.38100976-1.367372-.00003075l-4.03091981-4.06337806c-.37759778-.38063832-.38381821-.99150444-.01600053-1.3622839.37750607-.38054587.98772445-.38240057 1.37006824.00302197l2.39538588 2.4146743.96295325.98624457z" fill="#666" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(0 -1 1 0 0 10)"/> </svg> </li><li class="c-breadcrumbs__item" id="breadcrumb1" itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem"><a class="c-breadcrumbs__link" href="/ncomms" itemprop="item" data-track="click" data-track-action="breadcrumb" data-track-category="header" data-track-label="link:nature communications"><span itemprop="name">nature communications</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="2"> <svg class="c-breadcrumbs__chevron" role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="10" viewBox="0 0 10 10" width="10" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"> <path d="m5.96738168 4.70639573 2.39518594-2.41447274c.37913917-.38219212.98637524-.38972225 1.35419292-.01894278.37750606.38054586.37784436.99719163-.00013556 1.37821513l-4.03074001 4.06319683c-.37758093.38062133-.98937525.38100976-1.367372-.00003075l-4.03091981-4.06337806c-.37759778-.38063832-.38381821-.99150444-.01600053-1.3622839.37750607-.38054587.98772445-.38240057 1.37006824.00302197l2.39538588 2.4146743.96295325.98624457z" fill="#666" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(0 -1 1 0 0 10)"/> </svg> </li><li class="c-breadcrumbs__item" id="breadcrumb2" itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem"><a class="c-breadcrumbs__link" href="/ncomms/articles?type=article" itemprop="item" data-track="click" data-track-action="breadcrumb" data-track-category="header" data-track-label="link:articles"><span itemprop="name">articles</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="3"> <svg class="c-breadcrumbs__chevron" role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="10" viewBox="0 0 10 10" width="10" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"> <path d="m5.96738168 4.70639573 2.39518594-2.41447274c.37913917-.38219212.98637524-.38972225 1.35419292-.01894278.37750606.38054586.37784436.99719163-.00013556 1.37821513l-4.03074001 4.06319683c-.37758093.38062133-.98937525.38100976-1.367372-.00003075l-4.03091981-4.06337806c-.37759778-.38063832-.38381821-.99150444-.01600053-1.3622839.37750607-.38054587.98772445-.38240057 1.37006824.00302197l2.39538588 2.4146743.96295325.98624457z" fill="#666" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(0 -1 1 0 0 10)"/> </svg> </li><li class="c-breadcrumbs__item" id="breadcrumb3" itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem"> <span itemprop="name">article</span><meta itemprop="position" content="4"></li> </ol> </div> </nav> </div> <div class="u-container u-mt-32 u-mb-32 u-clearfix" id="content" data-component="article-container" data-container-type="article"> <main class="c-article-main-column u-float-left js-main-column" data-track-component="article body"> <div class="c-context-bar u-hide" data-test="context-bar" data-context-bar aria-hidden="true"> <div class="c-context-bar__container u-container" data-track-context="sticky banner"> <div class="c-context-bar__title"> Carotenoid metabolism strengthens the link between feather coloration and individual quality </div> <div class="c-pdf-download u-clear-both js-pdf-download"> <a href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z.pdf" class="u-button u-button--full-width u-button--primary u-justify-content-space-between c-pdf-download__link" data-article-pdf="true" data-readcube-pdf-url="true" data-test="download-pdf" data-draft-ignore="true" data-track="content_download" data-track-type="article pdf download" data-track-action="download pdf" data-track-label="link" data-track-external download> <span class="c-pdf-download__text">Download PDF</span> <svg aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" width="16" height="16" class="u-icon"><use xlink:href="#icon-download"/></svg> </a> </div> </div> </div> <article lang="en"> <div class="c-pdf-button__container u-mb-16 u-hide-at-lg js-context-bar-sticky-point-mobile"> <div class="c-pdf-container" data-track-context="article body"> <div class="c-pdf-download u-clear-both js-pdf-download"> <a href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z.pdf" class="u-button u-button--full-width u-button--primary u-justify-content-space-between c-pdf-download__link" data-article-pdf="true" data-readcube-pdf-url="true" data-test="download-pdf" data-draft-ignore="true" data-track="content_download" data-track-type="article pdf download" data-track-action="download pdf" data-track-label="link" data-track-external download> <span class="c-pdf-download__text">Download PDF</span> <svg aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" width="16" height="16" class="u-icon"><use xlink:href="#icon-download"/></svg> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="c-article-header"> <header> <ul class="c-article-identifiers" data-test="article-identifier"> <li class="c-article-identifiers__item" data-test="article-category">Article</li> <li class="c-article-identifiers__item"> <a href="https://www.springernature.com/gp/open-research/about/the-fundamentals-of-open-access-and-open-research" data-track="click" data-track-action="open access" data-track-label="link" class="u-color-open-access" data-test="open-access">Open access</a> </li> <li class="c-article-identifiers__item">Published: <time datetime="2018-01-08">08 January 2018</time></li> </ul> <h1 class="c-article-title" data-test="article-title" data-article-title="">Carotenoid metabolism strengthens the link between feather coloration and individual quality</h1> <ul class="c-article-author-list c-article-author-list--short" data-test="authors-list" data-component-authors-activator="authors-list"><li class="c-article-author-list__item"><a data-test="author-name" data-track="click" data-track-action="open author" data-track-label="link" href="#auth-Ryan_J_-Weaver-Aff1" data-author-popup="auth-Ryan_J_-Weaver-Aff1" data-author-search="Weaver, Ryan J." data-corresp-id="c1">Ryan J. Weaver<svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-mail-medium"></use></svg></a><span class="u-js-hide"> <a class="js-orcid" href="http://orcid.org/0000-0002-6160-4735"><span class="u-visually-hidden">ORCID: </span>orcid.org/0000-0002-6160-4735</a></span><sup class="u-js-hide"><a href="#Aff1">1</a></sup>, </li><li class="c-article-author-list__item"><a data-test="author-name" data-track="click" data-track-action="open author" data-track-label="link" href="#auth-Eduardo_S__A_-Santos-Aff2" data-author-popup="auth-Eduardo_S__A_-Santos-Aff2" data-author-search="Santos, Eduardo S. A.">Eduardo S. A. Santos</a><sup class="u-js-hide"><a href="#Aff2">2</a></sup>, </li><li class="c-article-author-list__item c-article-author-list__item--hide-small-screen"><a data-test="author-name" data-track="click" data-track-action="open author" data-track-label="link" href="#auth-Anna_M_-Tucker-Aff3" data-author-popup="auth-Anna_M_-Tucker-Aff3" data-author-search="Tucker, Anna M.">Anna M. Tucker</a><sup class="u-js-hide"><a href="#Aff3">3</a></sup>, </li><li class="c-article-author-list__item c-article-author-list__item--hide-small-screen"><a data-test="author-name" data-track="click" data-track-action="open author" data-track-label="link" href="#auth-Alan_E_-Wilson-Aff4" data-author-popup="auth-Alan_E_-Wilson-Aff4" data-author-search="Wilson, Alan E.">Alan E. Wilson</a><sup class="u-js-hide"><a href="#Aff4">4</a></sup> & </li><li class="c-article-author-list__show-more" aria-label="Show all 5 authors for this article" title="Show all 5 authors for this article">…</li><li class="c-article-author-list__item"><a data-test="author-name" data-track="click" data-track-action="open author" data-track-label="link" href="#auth-Geoffrey_E_-Hill-Aff1" data-author-popup="auth-Geoffrey_E_-Hill-Aff1" data-author-search="Hill, Geoffrey E.">Geoffrey E. Hill</a><sup class="u-js-hide"><a href="#Aff1">1</a></sup> </li></ul><button aria-expanded="false" class="c-article-author-list__button"><svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-chevron-down-medium"></use></svg><span>Show authors</span></button> <p class="c-article-info-details" data-container-section="info"> <a data-test="journal-link" href="/ncomms" data-track="click" data-track-action="journal homepage" data-track-category="article body" data-track-label="link"><i data-test="journal-title">Nature Communications</i></a> <b data-test="journal-volume"><span class="u-visually-hidden">volume</span> 9</b>, Article number: <span data-test="article-number">73</span> (<span data-test="article-publication-year">2018</span>) <a href="#citeas" class="c-article-info-details__cite-as u-hide-print" data-track="click" data-track-action="cite this article" data-track-label="link">Cite this article</a> </p> <div class="c-article-metrics-bar__wrapper u-clear-both"> <ul class="c-article-metrics-bar u-list-reset"> <li class=" c-article-metrics-bar__item" data-test="access-count"> <p class="c-article-metrics-bar__count">13k <span class="c-article-metrics-bar__label">Accesses</span></p> </li> <li class="c-article-metrics-bar__item" data-test="citation-count"> <p class="c-article-metrics-bar__count">135 <span class="c-article-metrics-bar__label">Citations</span></p> </li> <li class="c-article-metrics-bar__item" data-test="altmetric-score"> <p class="c-article-metrics-bar__count">62 <span class="c-article-metrics-bar__label">Altmetric</span></p> </li> <li class="c-article-metrics-bar__item"> <p class="c-article-metrics-bar__details"><a href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z/metrics" data-track="click" data-track-action="view metrics" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">Metrics <span class="u-visually-hidden">details</span></a></p> </li> </ul> </div> </header> <div class="u-js-hide" data-component="article-subject-links"> <h3 class="c-article__sub-heading">Subjects</h3> <ul class="c-article-subject-list"> <li class="c-article-subject-list__subject"><a href="/subjects/behavioural-ecology" data-track="click" data-track-action="view subject" data-track-label="link">Behavioural ecology</a></li><li class="c-article-subject-list__subject"><a href="/subjects/sexual-selection" data-track="click" data-track-action="view subject" data-track-label="link">Sexual selection</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> <div class="c-article-body"> <section aria-labelledby="Abs1" data-title="Abstract" lang="en"><div class="c-article-section" id="Abs1-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Abs1">Abstract</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Abs1-content"><p>Thirty years of research has made carotenoid coloration a textbook example of an honest signal of individual quality, but tests of this idea are surprisingly inconsistent. Here, to investigate sources of this heterogeneity, we perform meta-analyses of published studies on the relationship between carotenoid-based feather coloration and measures of individual quality. To create color displays, animals use either carotenoids unchanged from dietary components or carotenoids that they biochemically convert before deposition. We hypothesize that converted carotenoids better reflect individual quality because of the physiological links between cellular function and carotenoid metabolism. We show that feather coloration is an honest signal of some, but not all, measures of quality. Where these relationships exist, we show that converted, but not dietary, carotenoid coloration drives the relationship. Our results have broad implications for understanding the evolutionary role of carotenoid coloration and the physiological mechanisms that maintain signal honesty of animal ornamental traits.</p></div></div></section> <noscript> </noscript> <section aria-labelledby="inline-recommendations" data-title="Inline Recommendations" class="c-article-recommendations" data-track-component="inline-recommendations"> <h3 class="c-article-recommendations-title" id="inline-recommendations">Similar content being viewed by others</h3> <div class="c-article-recommendations-list"> <div class="c-article-recommendations-list__item"> <article class="c-article-recommendations-card" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/ScholarlyArticle"> <div class="c-article-recommendations-card__img"><img src="https://media.springernature.com/w215h120/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41598-021-88106-w/MediaObjects/41598_2021_88106_Fig1_HTML.jpg" loading="lazy" alt=""></div> <div class="c-article-recommendations-card__main"> <h3 class="c-article-recommendations-card__heading" itemprop="name headline"> <a class="c-article-recommendations-card__link" itemprop="url" href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-88106-w?fromPaywallRec=false" data-track="select_recommendations_1" data-track-context="inline recommendations" data-track-action="click recommendations inline - 1" data-track-label="10.1038/s41598-021-88106-w">Microstructures amplify carotenoid plumage signals in tanagers </a> </h3> <div class="c-article-meta-recommendations" data-test="recommendation-info"> <span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__item-type">Article</span> <span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__access-type">Open access</span> <span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__date">21 April 2021</span> </div> </div> </article> </div> <div class="c-article-recommendations-list__item"> <article class="c-article-recommendations-card" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/ScholarlyArticle"> <div class="c-article-recommendations-card__img"><img src="https://media.springernature.com/w215h120/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41598-023-45348-0/MediaObjects/41598_2023_45348_Fig1_HTML.png" loading="lazy" alt=""></div> <div class="c-article-recommendations-card__main"> <h3 class="c-article-recommendations-card__heading" itemprop="name headline"> <a class="c-article-recommendations-card__link" itemprop="url" href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-45348-0?fromPaywallRec=false" data-track="select_recommendations_2" data-track-context="inline recommendations" data-track-action="click recommendations inline - 2" data-track-label="10.1038/s41598-023-45348-0">Plumage color degradation indicates reproductive effort: an experiment </a> </h3> <div class="c-article-meta-recommendations" data-test="recommendation-info"> <span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__item-type">Article</span> <span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__access-type">Open access</span> <span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__date">31 October 2023</span> </div> </div> </article> </div> <div class="c-article-recommendations-list__item"> <article class="c-article-recommendations-card" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/ScholarlyArticle"> <div class="c-article-recommendations-card__img"><img src="https://media.springernature.com/w215h120/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41437-021-00453-6/MediaObjects/41437_2021_453_Fig1_HTML.png" loading="lazy" alt=""></div> <div class="c-article-recommendations-card__main"> <h3 class="c-article-recommendations-card__heading" itemprop="name headline"> <a class="c-article-recommendations-card__link" itemprop="url" href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41437-021-00453-6?fromPaywallRec=false" data-track="select_recommendations_3" data-track-context="inline recommendations" data-track-action="click recommendations inline - 3" data-track-label="10.1038/s41437-021-00453-6">Variability, heritability and condition-dependence of the multidimensional male colour phenotype in a passerine bird </a> </h3> <div class="c-article-meta-recommendations" data-test="recommendation-info"> <span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__item-type">Article</span> <span class="c-article-meta-recommendations__date">29 June 2021</span> </div> </div> </article> </div> </div> </section> <script> window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || []; window.dataLayer.push({ recommendations: { recommender: 'semantic', model: 'specter', policy_id: 'NA', timestamp: 1732791439, embedded_user: 'null' } }); </script> <div class="main-content"> <section data-title="Introduction"><div class="c-article-section" id="Sec1-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Sec1">Introduction</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Sec1-content"><p>Red, yellow, and orange carotenoid-based color displays are among the most widespread and conspicuous ornamental traits in animals. Carotenoid coloration is frequently an important criterion in mate choice<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 1" title="Svensson, P. A. & Wong, B. B. M. Carotenoid-based signals in behavioural ecology: a review. Behaviour 148, 131–189 (2011)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR1" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e415">1</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 2" title="Hill, G. E. in: Bird.Coloration Vol. 2 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) 137–200 (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR2" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e418">2</a></sup>, and researchers have found associations between carotenoid coloration and various measures of individual quality in studies of fish, reptiles, and birds<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Hill, G. E. in Reproductive Biology and Phylogeny of Birds Vol 6B (ed Jamieson, B. G. M.) 41–74 (Science Publishers, Endfield, New Hampshire, 2007)." href="#ref-CR3" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e422">3</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Blount, J. & McGraw, K. in Carotenoids (eds Britton, G., Liaaen-Jensen, S. H. C., & Pfander, H.) 213–236 (Birkhäuser, Basel, Switzerland, 2008)." href="#ref-CR4" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e422_1">4</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Garratt, M. & Brooks, R. C. Oxidative stress and condition-dependent sexual signals: more than just seeing red. Proc. Biol. Sci. 279, 3121–3130 (2012)." href="#ref-CR5" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e422_2">5</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 6" title="Simons, M. J. P., Cohen, A. A. & Verhulst, S. What does carotenoid-dependent coloration tell? Plasma carotenoid level signals immunocompetence and oxidative stress state in birds-A meta-analysis. PLoS ONE 7, e43088 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR6" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e425">6</a></sup>. On the basis of these observations, researchers hypothesized that assessment of the carotenoid coloration of prospective mates provides key information about individual quality and enables choices that increase fitness<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 7" title="Hill, G. E. Cellular respiration: The nexus of stress, condition, and ornamentation. Integr. Comp. Biol. 54, 645–657 (2014)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR7" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e429">7</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 8" title="Alonso-Alvarez, C., Pérez-Rodríguez, L., Mateo, R., Chastel, O. & Viñuela, J. The oxidation handicap hypothesis and the carotenoid allocation trade-off. J. Evol. Biol. 21, 1789–1797 (2008)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR8" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e432">8</a></sup>. However, the mechanism that links carotenoid coloration to individual quality, and hence the specific information content of carotenoid displays, remains unresolved and contentious<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 5" title="Garratt, M. & Brooks, R. C. Oxidative stress and condition-dependent sexual signals: more than just seeing red. Proc. Biol. Sci. 279, 3121–3130 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR5" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e436">5</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 9" title="Weaver, R. J., Koch, R. E. & Hill, G. E. What maintains signal honesty in animal colour dispays used in mate choice? Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 372, 20160343 (2017)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR9" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e439">9</a></sup>.</p><p>In addition to being colorful, carotenoids are thought to be relevant and essential molecules used in cellular processes such as immunocompetence and vitamin A synthesis, as well as antioxidants<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 10" title="Chew, B. P. & Park, J. S. Carotenoid action on the immune response. J. Nutr. 134, 257S–261S (2004)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR10" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e446">10</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 11" title="Britton, G. Structure and properties of carotenoids in relation to function. FASEB J. 9, 1551–1558 (1995)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR11" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e449">11</a></sup>. Understanding the connections between individual quality and carotenoid ornamentation demands an understanding of the biochemistry of the pigments involved (Supplementary Note <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">1</a>,<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 12" title="Hill, G. E. & Johnson, J. D. The vitamin A-redox hypothesis: A biochemical basis for honest signaling via carotenoid pigmentation. Am. Nat. 180, E127–E150 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR12" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e456">12</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 13" title="García-de Blas, E., Mateo, R. & Alonso-Alvarez, C. Accumulation of dietary carotenoids, retinoids and tocopherol in the internal tissues of a bird: a hypothesis for the cost of producing colored ornaments. Oecologia 177, 259–271 (2015)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR13" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e459">13</a></sup>). Carotenoids cannot be synthesized by animals de novo<i>;</i> whether they are used as external colorants or serve functions in cellular pathways, all carotenoids must ultimately be obtained from the diet<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 14" title="Goodwin, T. Distribution of carotenoids. Methods Enzymol. 213, 167–172 (1992)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR14" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e466">14</a></sup>. Moreover, animals typically ingest only the yellow carotenoid pigments (e.g., lutein and zeaxanthin; Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig1">1</a>). To display carotenoid-based red coloration, most animals have to bio-convert yellow pigments to red<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 15" title="Goodwin, T. Metabolism, nutrition, and function of carotenoids. Annu. Rev. Nutr. 6, 237–297 (1986)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR15" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e474">15</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 16" title="McGraw, K. J. in Bird Coloration Vol. 1 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR16" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e477">16</a></sup>. The quality of an individual color display is a product of the biochemical pathways by which carotenoids are absorbed, transported, metabolized, and deposited<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 17" title="Hill, G. E., Montgomerie, R., Inouye, C. Y. & Dale, J. Influence of dietary carotenoids on plasma and plumage colour in the house finch: intra- and intersexual variation. Funct. Ecol. 8, 343–350 (1994)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR17" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e481">17</a></sup>, so it follows that these biochemical pathways are central in creating the connections between ornamental coloration and individual condition<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 7" title="Hill, G. E. Cellular respiration: The nexus of stress, condition, and ornamentation. Integr. Comp. Biol. 54, 645–657 (2014)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR7" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e485">7</a></sup>.</p><div class="c-article-section__figure js-c-reading-companion-figures-item" data-test="figure" data-container-section="figure" id="figure-1" data-title="Fig. 1"><figure><figcaption><b id="Fig1" class="c-article-section__figure-caption" data-test="figure-caption-text">Fig. 1</b></figcaption><div class="c-article-section__figure-content"><div class="c-article-section__figure-item"><a class="c-article-section__figure-link" data-test="img-link" data-track="click" data-track-label="image" data-track-action="view figure" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z/figures/1" rel="nofollow"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="//media.springernature.com/lw685/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_Fig1_HTML.jpg?as=webp"><img aria-describedby="Fig1" src="//media.springernature.com/lw685/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_Fig1_HTML.jpg" alt="figure 1" loading="lazy"></picture></a></div><div class="c-article-section__figure-description" data-test="bottom-caption" id="figure-1-desc"><p>Carotenoids used for feather coloration. To produce feather coloration, passerine birds either use dietary carotenoids unaltered or use carotenoid pigments that are metabolically derived from dietary pigments. Depicted are the proposed metabolic pathways by which the common dietary carotenoids in the diets of passerine birds can be converted into the red and yellow ketolated carotenoids found in feathers<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 16" title="McGraw, K. J. in Bird Coloration Vol. 1 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR16" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e499">16</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 79" title="Stradi, R., Celentano, G., Boles, M. & Mercato, F. Carotenoids in bird plumage: The pattern in a series of red-pigmented carduelinae. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. Part B Biochem. Mol. Biol. 117, 85–91 (1997)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR79" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e502">79</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 80" title="Stradi, R., Hudon, J., Celentano, G. & Pini, E. Carotenoids in bird plumage: the complement of yellow and red pigments in true woodpeckers (Picinae). Comp. Biochem. Physiol. Part B Biochem. Mol. Biol. 120, 223–230 (1998)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR80" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e505">80</a></sup> . Birds shown are representative of coloration from converted and dietary carotenoids. House finch (lower) use converted red carotenoids, American goldfinch (upper) display converted yellow carotenoids, and wood warblers (middle) display dietary yellow carotenoids. A few bird species directly ingest red carotenoids, such as astaxanthin, from their diet (not shown)</p></div></div><div class="u-text-right u-hide-print"><a class="c-article__pill-button" data-test="article-link" data-track="click" data-track-label="button" data-track-action="view figure" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z/figures/1" data-track-dest="link:Figure1 Full size image" aria-label="Full size image figure 1" rel="nofollow"><span>Full size image</span><svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-chevron-right-small"></use></svg></a></div></figure></div><p>The dual role of carotenoids, both as colorants and potentially as important components of core cellular processes, is the foundation of the resource allocation trade-off hypothesis<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 9" title="Weaver, R. J., Koch, R. E. & Hill, G. E. What maintains signal honesty in animal colour dispays used in mate choice? Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 372, 20160343 (2017)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR9" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e520">9</a></sup>, which proposes that carotenoid coloration links to individual quality through tradeoffs in use of carotenoids for body maintenance versus ornamentation<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Lozano, G. Carotenoids, parasites, and sexual selection. Oikos 70, 309–312 (1994)." href="#ref-CR18" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e524">18</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="von Schantz, T., Bensch, S., Grahn, M., Hasselquist, D. & Wittzell, H. Good genes, oxidative stress and condition–dependent sexual signals. Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 266, 1–12 (1999)." href="#ref-CR19" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e524_1">19</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 20" title="Møller, A. P. et al. Carotenoid-dependent signals: Indicators of foraging efficiency, immunocompetence or detoxification ability? Avian Poult. Biol. Rev. 11, 137–159 (2000)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR20" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e527">20</a></sup>. Under this hypothesis, carotenoids are needed both for body maintenance and for ornamentation, and thus only individuals with large stores of carotenoids or with low demands for body maintenance due to superior health can afford to allocate sufficient carotenoids for production of full ornamentation. The resource allocation trade-off hypothesis does not predict a difference in the signal content of coloration derived from metabolically modified versus dietary pigments.</p><p>Alternatively, carotenoid coloration may serve as a reliable signal of individual quality because the mechanisms involved in the metabolic conversion of carotenoid pigments (Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig1">1</a>; Supplementary Note <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">1</a>) are intimately linked to vital cellular pathways<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 9" title="Weaver, R. J., Koch, R. E. & Hill, G. E. What maintains signal honesty in animal colour dispays used in mate choice? Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 372, 20160343 (2017)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR9" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e540">9</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 12" title="Hill, G. E. & Johnson, J. D. The vitamin A-redox hypothesis: A biochemical basis for honest signaling via carotenoid pigmentation. Am. Nat. 180, E127–E150 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR12" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e543">12</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 21" title="Hill, G. E. Condition-dependent traits as signals of the functionality of vital cellular processes. Ecol. Lett. 14, 625–634 (2011)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR21" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e546">21</a></sup>. This shared pathway hypothesis predicts that, regardless of the carotenoid resources that are available, disruption of core cellular processes, and particularly cellular respiration, will reduce production of carotenoid ornamentation<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 7" title="Hill, G. E. Cellular respiration: The nexus of stress, condition, and ornamentation. Integr. Comp. Biol. 54, 645–657 (2014)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR7" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e550">7</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 22" title="Johnson, J. D. & Hill, G. E. Is carotenoid ornamentation linked to the inner mitochondria membrane potential? A hypothesis for the maintenance of signal honesty. Biochimie 95, 436–444 (2013)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR22" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e553">22</a></sup>. Moreover, under the shared pathway hypothesis, metabolism of dietary carotenoids for ornamentation should create stronger connections between cellular processes that give rise to quality and carotenoid-based signals because the pathways required for carotenoid metabolism are sensitive to the cellular environment<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 12" title="Hill, G. E. & Johnson, J. D. The vitamin A-redox hypothesis: A biochemical basis for honest signaling via carotenoid pigmentation. Am. Nat. 180, E127–E150 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR12" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e557">12</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 23" title="Hill, G. E. Is there an immunological cost to carotenoid-based ornamental coloration? Am. Nat. 154, 589–595 (1999)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR23" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e560">23</a></sup>. The process of transforming dietary carotenoids to ketocarotenoids (Supplementary Note <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">1</a>) could be a key mechanism responsible for maintaining honesty from converted yellow and red carotenoid-based feather coloration, but this idea has not been rigorously tested.</p><p>Studies of the function and evolution of carotenoid coloration have frequently focused on birds and particularly on plumage. Sufficient studies have now been published to evaluate patterns among studies for associations between individual quality and feather coloration resulting from carotenoid pigments that emerge from fundamentally different biochemical processing. In this quantitative synthesis, we categorize carotenoids used for feather coloration as ‘dietary’ if the pigments are present in food and deposited in feathers without further modifications (Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig1">1</a>). Pigments in this category are absorbed, transported, and deposited but they undergo no metabolic conversion. The two most common dietary pigments used as colorants in birds are lutein and zeaxanthin. Alternatively, we categorize carotenoids as ‘converted’ if they are derived from dietary carotenoids that are metabolically oxidized internally by the bird to form ketocarotenoids before deposition to feathers (Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig1">1</a>; Supplementary Note <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">1</a>). Common examples of converted carotenoids include echinenone, canthaxanthin, and canary xanthophylls<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 16" title="McGraw, K. J. in Bird Coloration Vol. 1 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR16" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e581">16</a></sup>.</p><p>Previous reviews of condition dependence of carotenoid pigmentation in birds have not considered whether the biochemical processes involved in carotenoid pigmentation—and specifically whether or not dietary carotenoids are metabolically converted—affects the relationship between coloration and quality<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 6" title="Simons, M. J. P., Cohen, A. A. & Verhulst, S. What does carotenoid-dependent coloration tell? Plasma carotenoid level signals immunocompetence and oxidative stress state in birds-A meta-analysis. PLoS ONE 7, e43088 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR6" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e588">6</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 24" title="Griffith, S. C., Parker, T. H. & Olson, V. A. Melanin- versus carotenoid-based sexual signals: is the difference really so black and red? Anim. Behav. 71, 749–763 (2006)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR24" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e591">24</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 25" title="Simons, M. J. P., Maia, R., Leenknegt, B. & Verhulst, S. Carotenoid-dependent signals and the evolution of plasma carotenoid levels in birds. Am. Nat. 184, 741–751 (2014)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR25" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e594">25</a></sup>. We hypothesized that the strength of the relationship between coloration signal and individual quality is dependent on whether the color display involved metabolic conversion of dietary carotenoids. We predicted that if the mechanisms of carotenoid metabolism are linked to basic cellular function that comprise individual quality<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 9" title="Weaver, R. J., Koch, R. E. & Hill, G. E. What maintains signal honesty in animal colour dispays used in mate choice? Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 372, 20160343 (2017)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR9" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e598">9</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 26" title="Weaver, R. J., Hill, G. E., Kuan, P.-L. & Tseng, Y.-C. Copper exposure reduces production of red carotenoids in a marine copepod. Ecol. Indic. 70, 393–400 (2016)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR26" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e601">26</a></sup>, feather coloration requiring carotenoid metabolism would have a stronger positive relationship with measures of individual quality than feather coloration derived from deposition of unaltered dietary carotenoids<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 12" title="Hill, G. E. & Johnson, J. D. The vitamin A-redox hypothesis: A biochemical basis for honest signaling via carotenoid pigmentation. Am. Nat. 180, E127–E150 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR12" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e605">12</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 23" title="Hill, G. E. Is there an immunological cost to carotenoid-based ornamental coloration? Am. Nat. 154, 589–595 (1999)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR23" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e608">23</a></sup>. Additionally, metabolism of carotenoids requires the maintenance of enzyme systems (Supplementary Note <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">1</a>;<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 27" title="Lopes, R. J. et al. Genetic basis for red coloration in birds. Curr. Biol. 26, 1427–1434 (2016)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR27" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e615">27</a></sup>) and perhaps additional transport of carotenoids<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 13" title="García-de Blas, E., Mateo, R. & Alonso-Alvarez, C. Accumulation of dietary carotenoids, retinoids and tocopherol in the internal tissues of a bird: a hypothesis for the cost of producing colored ornaments. Oecologia 177, 259–271 (2015)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR13" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e620">13</a></sup> that may create stronger links between coloration and system performance for ornaments produced from converted pigments versus unaltered dietary pigments.</p><p>We tested our hypothesis that carotenoid metabolism strengthens the link between feather coloration and individual quality using meta-analysis. We quantitatively synthesized published results on the relationships between individual quality and plumage coloration of passerines produced via dietary versus converted carotenoids. Overall, we find that, without partitioning between carotenoid types, carotenoid-based feather coloration is positively associated with individual quality. However, including carotenoid type as a predictor reveals that converted, and not dietary, carotenoids are driving the relationship between coloration and quality. Thus, the physiological processes involved in carotenoid metabolism may be an important mediator in maintaining honesty from carotenoid-based coloration.</p></div></div></section><section data-title="Results"><div class="c-article-section" id="Sec2-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Sec2">Results</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Sec2-content"><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec3">Final data set of included studies and assessment of publication bias</h3><p>The final data set included 191 effect size estimates (Supplementary Data <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM4">1</a>) from 50 published studies of 19 passerine bird species (Supplementary Data <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM5">2</a>). Detailed results from models assuming effect sizes are correlated are listed in Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="table anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Tab1">1</a>. Results from models assuming no effect size correlations are reported in Supplementary Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">1</a>. Mean effect size estimates and 95% credible intervals (CI) are reported unless otherwise noted. Mean estimates with credible intervals that do not include zero are a statistically significant effect at <i>α</i> = 0.05. Using sampling variance as a predictor, results from the Egger’s regression did not imply funnel plot asymmetry from the residuals of the overall meta-analytic model (Supplementary Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">1</a>; weighted linear regression: <i>t</i><sub>189</sub> = 1.98, <i>p</i> = 0.05).</p><div class="c-article-table" data-test="inline-table" data-container-section="table" id="table-1"><figure><figcaption class="c-article-table__figcaption"><b id="Tab1" data-test="table-caption">Table 1 Results from mixed-effects multi-level phylogenetic meta-analyses that assume effect sizes within studies are correlated (<i>r</i> = 0.5)</b></figcaption><div class="u-text-right u-hide-print"><a class="c-article__pill-button" data-test="table-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view table" data-track-label="button" rel="nofollow" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z/tables/1" aria-label="Full size table 1"><span>Full size table</span><svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-chevron-right-small"></use></svg></a></div></figure></div><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec4">Carotenoid coloration as an honest signal of quality</h3><p>Consistent with previous quantitative and qualitative reviews that did not account for carotenoid type, we found a small positive correlation between richness of coloration and individual quality overall, but note that the 95% CI slightly overlaps zero (weighted linear regression: Zr = 0.161, 95% CI: −0.079 to 0.368; <i>I</i><sup><i>2</i></sup> = 98.10%). However, when we parsed the data between species with plumage coloration resulting from converted versus dietary carotenoids, we found that the relationship between richness of coloration and individual quality held only for species that used converted pigments (weighted linear regression: Converted: Zr = 0.263, 95% CI: 0.062–0.491; Dietary: <i>Zr</i> = 0.089, 95% CI: −0.123 to 0.292; Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig2">2a</a>). On average, we found that dietary carotenoid coloration is a weaker predictor of overall quality than converted carotenoid coloration (weighted linear regression: <i>β</i><sub>(Dietary)</sub> = −0.158, 95% CI: −0.388 to 0.097), though the credible intervals from this comparison slightly overlap zero.</p><div class="c-article-section__figure js-c-reading-companion-figures-item" data-test="figure" data-container-section="figure" id="figure-2" data-title="Fig. 2"><figure><figcaption><b id="Fig2" class="c-article-section__figure-caption" data-test="figure-caption-text">Fig. 2</b></figcaption><div class="c-article-section__figure-content"><div class="c-article-section__figure-item"><a class="c-article-section__figure-link" data-test="img-link" data-track="click" data-track-label="image" data-track-action="view figure" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z/figures/2" rel="nofollow"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="//media.springernature.com/lw685/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_Fig2_HTML.jpg?as=webp"><img aria-describedby="Fig2" src="//media.springernature.com/lw685/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_Fig2_HTML.jpg" alt="figure 2" loading="lazy"></picture></a></div><div class="c-article-section__figure-description" data-test="bottom-caption" id="figure-2-desc"><p>Results of the multilevel phylogenetic meta-analyses. The weighted mean correlation (Zr) betwen feather color richness and measures of individual quality. <b>a</b> The strength of the association was calculated for all published studies without consideration of the carotenoid type in the feathers of the study bird (Combined, gray circles, number of effect sizes (<i>n</i>) = 191), for only studies of bird species with plumage coloration derived from converted carotenoids (red circles, <i>n</i> = 92), and for only studies of bird species with plumage coloration derived from dietary carotenoids (yellow circles, <i>n</i> = 99). Proxies of quality were divided into (<b>b</b>), body condition (overall: <i>n</i> = 35, converted: <i>n</i> = 18, dietary: <i>n</i> = 17), (<b>c</b>) immune and oxidative physiology (overall: <i>n</i> = 42, converted: <i>n</i> = 21, dietary: <i>n</i> = 21), (<b>d</b>) parasite resistance (overall: <i>n</i> = 49, converted: <i>n</i> = 30, dietary: <i>n</i> = 19), and (<b>e</b>) aspects of parental and reproductive quality (overall: <i>n</i> = 65, converted: <i>n</i> = 23, dietary: <i>n</i> = 42). Circle size is inversely proportional to the variance of the mean effect size. Horizontal lines are error bars that represent 95% credible intervals. Effect size estimates with credible intervals that do not include zero are statistically significant effects (<i>α</i> = 0.05)</p></div></div><div class="u-text-right u-hide-print"><a class="c-article__pill-button" data-test="article-link" data-track="click" data-track-label="button" data-track-action="view figure" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z/figures/2" data-track-dest="link:Figure2 Full size image" aria-label="Full size image figure 2" rel="nofollow"><span>Full size image</span><svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-chevron-right-small"></use></svg></a></div></figure></div><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec5">Body condition</h3><p>Measures of body condition were not reliably positively correlated with carotenoid-based feather coloration (weighted linear regression: Zr = 0.065, 95% CI: −0.218 to 0.352, Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig2">2b</a>), and we found no clear difference in the relationship between carotenoid types (weighted linear regression: Converted: Zr = 0.084, 95% CI: −0.158 to 0.358; Dietary: Zr = 0.107, 95% CI: −0.186 to 0.388).</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec6">Immune function and oxidative physiology</h3><p>On average across all measures of immune function and oxidative physiology, we found that feather coloration was not a reliable predictor (weighted linear regression: Zr = 0.102, 95% CI: −0.210 to 0.362; Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig2">2c</a>) with no clear difference in the relationship between carotenoid types (weighted linear regression: Converted: <i>Zr</i> = 0.098, 95% CI: −0.186 to 0.367; Dietary: Zr = 0.113, 95% CI: −0.135 to 0.371). When we treated these two categories separately, the results were qualitatively similar (Supplementary Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">2</a>); neither dietary nor converted carotenoids were robust signals of immune function or measures of oxidative physiology.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec7">Parasite resistance</h3><p>When no distinction was made between carotenoid types, richness of coloration was positively correlated with parasite resistance (weighted linear regression: Zr = 0.243, 95% CI: −0.074 to 0.510). When we added carotenoid type as a moderator to our model we found that coloration from dietary carotenoids was weakly correlated with parasite resistance (weighted linear regression: Zr = 0.009, 95% CI: −0.242 to 0.371; Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig2">2d</a>). In contrast, coloration from converted carotenoid-based plumage was strongly positively associated with parasite resistance (weighted linear regression: Zr = 0.435, 95% CI: 0.175–0.689; Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig2">2d</a>) and was a more reliable signal than coloration from dietary carotenoid-pigmented feathers (weighted linear regression: <i>β</i><sub>(Dietary)</sub> = −0.420, 95% CI: −0.692 to −0.162). When measures of parasite resistance were pooled with the immune category, our model return qualitatively similar results (Supplementary Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">3</a>); effect sizes from dietary coloration were not robustly associated with measures of immune function, but effect sizes from converted coloration strongly correlated with measures of immune function.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec8">Reproductive and parental quality</h3><p>We found that, overall, carotenoid coloration positively correlated with aspects of reproductive and parental quality (weighted linear regression: Zr = 0.223, 95% CI: −0.099 to 0.462; Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig2">2e</a>), but that the pattern was driven by converted carotenoid feather coloration (weighted linear regression: Converted: Zr = 0.337, 95% CI: 0.021–0.618; Dietary: Zr = 0.0.09, 95% CI: −0.183 to 0.312). However, converted feather color was only a marginally better predictor of quality than dietary feather color (weighted linear regression: <i>β</i><sub>(Dietary)</sub> = −0.227, 95% CI: −0.536 to 0.077).</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec9">Species-level analysis</h3><p>The strength of the relationship between feather coloration and combined measures of individual quality was dependent on the individual species (Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig3">3</a>). However, we found only a weak phylogenetic signal among carotenoid types (<i>I</i><sup>2</sup> = 2.24%<i>)</i> in the overall analysis (Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="table anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Tab1">1</a>).</p><div class="c-article-section__figure js-c-reading-companion-figures-item" data-test="figure" data-container-section="figure" id="figure-3" data-title="Fig. 3"><figure><figcaption><b id="Fig3" class="c-article-section__figure-caption" data-test="figure-caption-text">Fig. 3</b></figcaption><div class="c-article-section__figure-content"><div class="c-article-section__figure-item"><a class="c-article-section__figure-link" data-test="img-link" data-track="click" data-track-label="image" data-track-action="view figure" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z/figures/3" rel="nofollow"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="//media.springernature.com/lw685/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_Fig3_HTML.jpg?as=webp"><img aria-describedby="Fig3" src="//media.springernature.com/lw685/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_Fig3_HTML.jpg" alt="figure 3" loading="lazy"></picture></a></div><div class="c-article-section__figure-description" data-test="bottom-caption" id="figure-3-desc"><p>The contribution of each species to the overall relationship between feather color richness and measures of individual quality. Number of effect sizes per species are in parentheses. Circles represent weighted mean correlation (Zr) effect sizes for species with plumage coloration from converted (red) and dietary carotenoids (yellow). Circle size is inversely proportional to the variance of the mean effect size. Horizontal lines represent 95% credible intervals. Effect size estimates with credible intervals that do not include zero are statistically significant effects (<i>α</i> = 0.05)</p></div></div><div class="u-text-right u-hide-print"><a class="c-article__pill-button" data-test="article-link" data-track="click" data-track-label="button" data-track-action="view figure" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z/figures/3" data-track-dest="link:Figure3 Full size image" aria-label="Full size image figure 3" rel="nofollow"><span>Full size image</span><svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-chevron-right-small"></use></svg></a></div></figure></div><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec10">The role of sex on effect size estimates</h3><p>We found that the sex from which effect sizes were calculated did not influence the magnitude of the meta-analytic mean (weighted linear regression: Dietary female vs male: <i>β</i> = 0.008, 95% CI: −0.140 to 0.170; Converted female vs male: <i>β</i> = 0.101, 95% CI: −0.07 to 0.29).</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec11">Residual heterogeneity</h3><p>Heterogeneity in our overall meta-analytic model was high (<i>I</i><sup><i>2</i></sup> = 98.12%; see ref. <sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 28" title="Higgins, J. P. T., Thompson, S. G., Deeks, J. J. & Altman, D. G. Measuring inconsistency in knowledgebases. Br. Med. J. 327, 557–560 (2003)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR28" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1831">28</a></sup> for benchmarks). Including carotenoid type as a moderator in our overall model reduced heterogeneity (<i>I</i><sup>2</sup> = 72.43; Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="table anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Tab1">1</a>). More variance was partitioned from the model by the addition of quality category and carotenoid type as model moderators (<i>I</i><sup>2</sup> = 72.40; Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="table anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Tab1">1</a>). A high degree of heterogeneity remained after we included carotenoid type and quality category as moderators in the model indicating that other variables not included in this analysis may be influencing the relationship between feather coloration and aspects of individual quality<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 29" title="Viechtbauer, W. Conducting meta-analyses in R with the metafor package. J. Stat. Softw. 36, 1–48 (2010)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR29" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1850">29</a></sup>.</p></div></div></section><section data-title="Discussion"><div class="c-article-section" id="Sec12-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Sec12">Discussion</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Sec12-content"><p>Carotenoid coloration is among the most frequently cited examples of a condition-dependent signal of quality assessed during mate choice<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 1" title="Svensson, P. A. & Wong, B. B. M. Carotenoid-based signals in behavioural ecology: a review. Behaviour 148, 131–189 (2011)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR1" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1863">1</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 30" title="Cotton, S., Small, J. & Pomiankowski, A. Sexual selection and condition-dependent mate preferences. Curr. Biol. 16, R755–R765 (2006)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR30" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1866">30</a></sup>, but the relationship between various measures of quality and different forms of carotenoid coloration is not consistent across studies<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Hõrak, P., Ots, I., Vellau, H., Spottiswoode, C. & Møller, A. P. Carotenoid-based plumage coloration reflects hemoparasite infection and local survival in breeding great tits. Oecologia 126, 166–173 (2001)." href="#ref-CR31" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1870">31</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Isaksson, C., McLaughlin, P., Monaghan, P. & Andersson, S. Carotenoid pigmentation does not reflect total non-enzymatic antioxidant activity in plasma of adult and nestling great tits. Parus Major. Funct. Ecol. 21, 1123–1129 (2007)." href="#ref-CR32" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1870_1">32</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 33" title="Isaksson, C. & Andersson, S. Oxidative stress does not influence carotenoid mobilization and plumage pigmentation. Proc. Biol. Sci. 275, 309–314 (2008)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR33" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1873">33</a></sup>. We hypothesized that some of the noise in the comparative data might be due to a failure to consider whether the color display under study was derived from unmodified dietary pigments or pigments that had been metabolically converted from dietary pigments. We predicted that feather displays derived from converted carotenoids would be better signals of quality if carotenoid metabolism creates stronger connections between color displays and the cellular processes that underlie the state of condition in the animal.<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 12" title="Hill, G. E. & Johnson, J. D. The vitamin A-redox hypothesis: A biochemical basis for honest signaling via carotenoid pigmentation. Am. Nat. 180, E127–E150 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR12" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1877">12</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 21" title="Hill, G. E. Condition-dependent traits as signals of the functionality of vital cellular processes. Ecol. Lett. 14, 625–634 (2011)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR21" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1880">21</a></sup> The patterns we observed in our meta-analyses indicate that converted carotenoid feather coloration indeed had stronger relationships with measures of individual quality than dietary carotenoid feather coloration.</p><p>The results of our meta-analyses show that whether the carotenoid coloration is dietary or converted is an important predictor of the likelihood that a plumage color display will be correlated to a measure of individual quality. When we assessed all studies of carotenoid feather coloration, without regard for whether the pigments were dietary or converted, there was a non-significant trend across studies for a positive association between carotenoid coloration and individual quality (Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig2">2a</a>). When we examined whether the type of carotenoid (converted or dietary) used for plumage coloration had an effect on the strength of the relationship between carotenoid coloration and condition, we found that there was a strong and statistically significant correlation between measures of quality and coloration for birds that deposit converted carotenoids to feathers. In contrast, there was much weaker condition dependency for birds that deposited only dietary carotenoids to feathers, and the relationship was not significantly different from zero. We did not observe a clear phylogenetic pattern in the strength of the relationship between coloration and quality (Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig3">3</a>). These results support our hypothesis that carotenoid metabolism is a meaningful factor that predicts the strength of correlation between coloration and measures of individual quality.</p><p>Our findings have important implications for understanding the mechanisms that link carotenoid coloration and individual condition. Endler<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 34" title="Endler, J. A. Natural selection on color patterns in Poecilia reticulata. Evolution 34, 76–91 (1980)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR34" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1896">34</a></sup> first proposed that carotenoid coloration in animals could serve as an honest signal of quality because carotenoids are scarce resources that are challenging to accrue. Experiments with guppies (<i>Poecilia reticulata</i>)<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 35" title="Kodric-Brown, A. Dietary carotenoids and male mating success in the guppy: an environmental component to female choice. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 25, 393–401 (1989)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR35" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1903">35</a></sup> and house finches (<i>Haemorhous mexicanus</i>)<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 36" title="Hill, G. E. Proximate basis of variation in carotenoid pigmentation in male house finches. Auk 109, 1–12 (1992)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR36" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1910">36</a></sup> showed that depriving individuals of carotenoids during ornament production caused loss of color, but whether resource limitation was the basis for signal honesty in natural environments remained contentious<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Hill, G. E. House finches are what they eat: a reply to Hudon. Auk 111, 221–225 (1994)." href="#ref-CR37" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1915">37</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Hudon, J. Showiness, carotenoids, and captivity: A comment on Hill (1992). Auk 111, 218–221 (1994)." href="#ref-CR38" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1915_1">38</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 39" title="Thompson, C., Hillgarth, N., Leu, M. & McClure, H. High parasite load in house finches (Carpodacus mexicanus) is correlated with reduced expression of a sexually selected trait. Am. Nat. 149, 270–294 (1997)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR39" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1918">39</a></sup>. The patterns revealed in our meta-analysis suggest that honest signaling arises from more than simply access to carotenoid resources, whereby all forms of carotenoid pigmentation should serve as signals of quality. Rather, the strong association between display of converted carotenoid pigments and individual quality suggests that something about the process of carotenoid modification creates a link between pigmentation and individual condition<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 7" title="Hill, G. E. Cellular respiration: The nexus of stress, condition, and ornamentation. Integr. Comp. Biol. 54, 645–657 (2014)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR7" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1922">7</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 9" title="Weaver, R. J., Koch, R. E. & Hill, G. E. What maintains signal honesty in animal colour dispays used in mate choice? Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 372, 20160343 (2017)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR9" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1925">9</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 21" title="Hill, G. E. Condition-dependent traits as signals of the functionality of vital cellular processes. Ecol. Lett. 14, 625–634 (2011)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR21" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1928">21</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 22" title="Johnson, J. D. & Hill, G. E. Is carotenoid ornamentation linked to the inner mitochondria membrane potential? A hypothesis for the maintenance of signal honesty. Biochimie 95, 436–444 (2013)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR22" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1931">22</a></sup>.</p><p>Perhaps one of the most ubiquitous statements made of carotenoids is their capacity to serve as powerful antioxidants and immune boosters<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 10" title="Chew, B. P. & Park, J. S. Carotenoid action on the immune response. J. Nutr. 134, 257S–261S (2004)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR10" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1938">10</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 40" title="Hix, L. M., Lockwood, S. F. & Bertram, J. S. Bioactive carotenoids: potent antioxidants and regulators of gene expression. Redox Rep. 9, 181–191 (2004)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR40" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1941">40</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 41" title="Krinsky, N. I. Antioxidant functions of carotenoids. Free Radic. Biol. Med. 7, 617–635 (1989)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR41" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1944">41</a></sup>. However, the specific roles that carotenoids might play in vivo in free radical scavenging or immune system function are uncertain and contentious<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Costantini, D. & Møller, A. P. Carotenoids are minor antioxidants for birds. Funct. Ecol. 22, 367–370 (2008)." href="#ref-CR42" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1948">42</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Costantini, D. Oxidative stress in ecology and evolution: lessons from avian studies. Ecol. Lett. 11, 1238–1251 (2008)." href="#ref-CR43" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1948_1">43</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Hartley, R. C. & Kennedy, M. W. Are carotenoids a red herring in sexual display? Trends Ecol. Evol. 19, 353–354 (2004)." href="#ref-CR44" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1948_2">44</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 45" title="Pérez-Rodríguez, L. Carotenoids in evolutionary ecology: Re-evaluating the antioxidant role. BioEssays 31, 1116–1126 (2009)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR45" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1951">45</a></sup>. A previous meta-analysis by Simons et al.<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 6" title="Simons, M. J. P., Cohen, A. A. & Verhulst, S. What does carotenoid-dependent coloration tell? Plasma carotenoid level signals immunocompetence and oxidative stress state in birds-A meta-analysis. PLoS ONE 7, e43088 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR6" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1955">6</a></sup> examined the relationship between carotenoid content and multiple measures of immunocompetence and oxidative stress in birds to test the idea that carotenoid content or coloration is an honest signal of these qualities. They found that circulating carotenoid levels in the plasma related to only two out of seven measures: PHA response—a commonly used skin swelling assay of immunocompetence—and antioxidant capacity. Additionally, carotenoid coloration of feathers or skin was not a reliable signal for six out of seven proxies of immune function or oxidative stress<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 6" title="Simons, M. J. P., Cohen, A. A. & Verhulst, S. What does carotenoid-dependent coloration tell? Plasma carotenoid level signals immunocompetence and oxidative stress state in birds-A meta-analysis. PLoS ONE 7, e43088 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR6" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1959">6</a></sup>. Our results are generally consistent with those of Simons et al.<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 6" title="Simons, M. J. P., Cohen, A. A. & Verhulst, S. What does carotenoid-dependent coloration tell? Plasma carotenoid level signals immunocompetence and oxidative stress state in birds-A meta-analysis. PLoS ONE 7, e43088 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR6" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1963">6</a></sup> in that feather coloration was weakly correlated with measures of immune function and oxidative physiology, and was not a robust signal on average (Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig2">2c</a>). Furthermore, whether coloration was derived from dietary or converted carotenoids had no effect on the honesty of coloration as a signal of immune function. The complex pathways involved in innate and acquired immunity may obscure meaningful interpretation of immunocompetence when it is measured only as the relative abundances of different types of white blood cells in circulation.</p><p>Unlike measures of immune function, studies on internal or surface parasites in birds benefit from a simple methodology that is straightforward to interpret. One of the earliest and widely cited examples of honest signaling of parasite resistance from feather coloration was Hamilton and Zuk’s<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 46" title="Hamilton, W. D. & Zuk, M. Heritable true fitness and bright birds: a role for parasites? Science 218, 384–387 (1982)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR46" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1975">46</a></sup> study that proposed that ‘bright’ feather coloration evolved to signal heritable parasite resistance. This seminal study served as the cornerstone for new ideas about why ornaments are assessed during mate choice. We found that birds with converted carotenoid feather coloration had a strong relationship with parasite resistance. In contrast, birds that directly deposited carotenoids from their diet showed a weak and unreliable correlation with parasite resistance (Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="figure anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Fig2">2d</a>). The mechanisms involved in the transformation of dietary carotenoids might act as a signal of the underlying genetic or physiological mechanisms that provide parasite resistance<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 47" title="Koch, R. E., Josefson, C. C. & Hill, G. E. Mitochondrial function, ornamentation, and immunocompetence. Biol. Rev. 92, 1459–1474 (2016)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR47" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1982">47</a></sup>.</p><p>The stronger associations between reproduction and plumage color derived from converted versus dietary pigments could be a consequence of stronger associations between individual condition and ornamentation produced by converted versus dietary carotenoids. The proxies for reproductive and parental quality that were used in this study are a composite of the strategies and performances of both the ornamented male bird and its mate<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Burley, N. Sexual selection for aesthetic traits in species with biparental care. Am. Nat. 127, 415–445 (1986)." href="#ref-CR48" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1989">48</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Harris, W. E. & Uller, T. Reproductive investment when mate quality varies: differential allocation versus reproductive compensation. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. Biol. Sci. 364, 1039–1048 (2009)." href="#ref-CR49" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1989_1">49</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 50" title="Ratikainen, I. I. & Kokko, H. Differential allocation and compensation: Who deserves the silver spoon? Behav. Ecol. 21, 195–200 (2010)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR50" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e1992">50</a></sup>. Mate choice for feather coloration should be stronger when the signal of quality is stronger, so the stronger association between reproduction and converted carotenoids could arise through stronger choice for such signals. Moreover, if the stronger preference for coloration resulting from converted carotenoids means that such birds attract higher quality mates then color based on converted carotenoids would be more strongly linked to reproductive success. For example, in many species of perching birds, males directly participate in nesting so there should also be direct effects of male condition on reproductive success. Any of these factors could have contributed to the stronger associations of color produced by converted carotenoids and reproduction.</p><p>The proxies for quality used in nearly every study of carotenoid coloration are rooted in the ability to efficiently produce ATP via oxidative phosphorylation at a level necessary to meet physiological demand. Thus far, the mechanism by which carotenoid coloration links to quality has remained speculative. Direct measures of both the allocation of specific pools of carotenoids to physiological function versus ornament production and the effects of direct manipulation of mitochondrial performance on carotenoid production are needed to definitively test the resource allocation and shared pathway hypotheses.</p><p>The patterns that we revealed though our meta-analysis indicate that feather coloration from converted carotenoids are better indicators of individual condition than dietary carotenoids. One could reasonably extrapolate from this observation to propose that metabolism of feather carotenoids evolved in response to mate preferences for the best indicators of condition. But the conversion of yellow dietary to yellow converted pigments, which present the same visual display, presents an enigma. Why don’t males that display with converted yellow pigments just skip the conversion and load up on dietary pigments? Badyaev et al.<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 51" title="Badyaev, A. V., Potticary, A. L. & Morrison, E. S. Most colorful example of genetic assimilation? Exploring the evolutionary destiny of recurrent phenotypic accommodation. Am. Nat. 190, 266–280 (2017)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR51" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2002">51</a></sup> examined patterns of feather growth and coloration and hypothesized that metabolized carotenoids caused less stochastic variation in feather structure than dietary carotenoids. In other words, dietary pigments can affect the integrity of feathers and perhaps the stochastic variation they engender can undermine the quality of the sexual signal. In light of our finding that converted pigments provide a better indicator of condition, it will be interesting to further test such hypotheses for how developmental pathways might favor converted over dietary carotenoids.</p><p>Using a meta-analysis and meta-regressions of bird studies that investigated the association between carotenoid-based feather coloration and individual condition, we found support for the hypothesis that this type of plumage coloration serves as an honest indicator of individual quality<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 52" title="Hill, G. Plumage coloration is a sexually selected indicator of male quality. Nature 350, 337–338 (1991)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR52" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2009">52</a></sup>. The strength of this signal, however, is greater for species that convert dietary carotenoids to ketolated carotenoids before utilizing them for feather coloration.</p><p>Our results are not consistent with the resource allocation hypothesis because dietary carotenoids are the pigments primarily implicated in immune enhancement and free radical scavenging, and yet they were not consistently associated with proxies for individual quality. Our results are consistent, however, with the hypothesis that conversion of dietary carotenoids acts to strengthen the relationship between feather coloration and measures of quality and may be an important mechanism in maintaining honesty from carotenoid-based ornaments.</p><p>Feathers are not the only structures that are colored by carotenoids. Many bird, reptile, and fish taxa exhibit bare-part carotenoid color signals<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Iverson, E. N. K. & Karubian, J. The role of bare parts in avian signaling. Auk 134, 587–611 (2017)." href="#ref-CR53" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2020">53</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="De Blas, E. G., Mateo, R., Guzman Bernardo, F. J., Rodríguez Martín-Doimeadios, R. C. & Alonso-Alvarez, C. Astaxanthin and papilioerythrinone in the skin of birds: A chromatic convergence of two metabolic routes with different precursors? Naturwissenschaften 101, 407–416 (2014)." href="#ref-CR54" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2020_1">54</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Anbazahan, S. M. et al. Immune response and disease resistance of carotenoids supplementation diet in Cyprinus carpio against Aeromonas hydrophila. Fish Shellfish Immunol. 40, 9–13 (2014)." href="#ref-CR55" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2020_2">55</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 56" title="Fitze, P. S. et al. Carotenoid-based colours reflect the stress response in the common lizard. PLoS. One. 4, e5111 (2009)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR56" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2023">56</a></sup>. Future work could focus on understanding the differences in signal honesty from bare-part carotenoid coloration among different taxa to test alternative predictions of our hypothesis that carotenoid metabolism strengthens the link between coloration and individual quality.</p></div></div></section><section data-title="Methods"><div class="c-article-section" id="Sec13-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Sec13">Methods</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Sec13-content"><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="Sec14">Literature search</h3><p>A literature search of the <i>Web of Science</i> and <i>Google Scholar</i> databases using alternative spellings and combinations of the keywords, including “carotenoid”, “color”, “condition”, “signal”, “feather”, and “quality”, returned over 1600 potentially eligible published articles. This search was based on the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses statement (PRISMA<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 57" title="Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., Altman, D. G. & Group, T. P. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. PLoS Med. 6, e1000097 (2009)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR57" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2045">57</a></sup>; Supplementary Fig. <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">2</a>). We also considered as potentially eligible articles, data from studies included in published meta-analyses of bird coloration<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 6" title="Simons, M. J. P., Cohen, A. A. & Verhulst, S. What does carotenoid-dependent coloration tell? Plasma carotenoid level signals immunocompetence and oxidative stress state in birds-A meta-analysis. PLoS ONE 7, e43088 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR6" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2052">6</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 24" title="Griffith, S. C., Parker, T. H. & Olson, V. A. Melanin- versus carotenoid-based sexual signals: is the difference really so black and red? Anim. Behav. 71, 749–763 (2006)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR24" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2055">24</a></sup> and references therein. The online database search was last performed on 11 April 2017 on titles, abstracts and keywords in both databases. We did not request the unpublished data sets from colleagues, because of the risk of biasing the estimates of effect size (see ref. <sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 58" title="Jennions, M. D., Lortie, C. J., Rosenberg, M. S. & Rothstein, H. R. In Handbook of Meta-Analysis in Ecology and Evolution (eds Koricheva, J., Gurevitch, J., & Mengersen, K.) 207–236 (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 2013)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR58" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2060">58</a></sup>).</p><p>It is important to note that carotenoid coloration is not limited to feathers; indeed, carotenoid coloration from bare-parts, including beaks, legs, and combs of birds has been the focus of excellent research on the evolution of honest signaling<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 53" title="Iverson, E. N. K. & Karubian, J. The role of bare parts in avian signaling. Auk 134, 587–611 (2017)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR53" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2067">53</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Pérez-Rodríguez, L., Mougeot, F. & Alonso-Alvarez, C. Carotenoid-based coloration predicts resistance to oxidative damage during immune challenge. J. Exp. Biol. 213, 1685–9160 (2010)." href="#ref-CR59" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2070">59</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" title="Alonso-Alvarez, C., Bertrand, S., Faivre, B., Chastel, O. & Sorci, G. Testosterone and oxidative stress: the oxidation handicap hypothesis. Proc. R. Soc. B-Biol. Sci. 274, 819–825 (2007)." href="#ref-CR60" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2070_1">60</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 61" title="García-de Blas, E., Mateo, R., Viñuela, J., Pérez-Rodríguez, L. & Alonso-Alvarez, C. Free and esterified carotenoids in ornaments of an avian species: the relationship to color expression and sources of variability. Physiol. Biochem. Zool. 86, 483–498 (2013)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR61" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2073">61</a></sup>. However, to best address how carotenoid metabolism affects honest signaling, we focused our study on a single trait, feather coloration, to avoid confounding biological factors such as blood flow<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 62" title="Negro, J. J., Sarasola, J. H., Fariñas, F. & Zorrilla, I. Function and occurrence of facial flushing in birds. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. A Mol. Integr. Physiol. 143, 78–84 (2006)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR62" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2077">62</a></sup>, carotenoid esterification<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 61" title="García-de Blas, E., Mateo, R., Viñuela, J., Pérez-Rodríguez, L. & Alonso-Alvarez, C. Free and esterified carotenoids in ornaments of an avian species: the relationship to color expression and sources of variability. Physiol. Biochem. Zool. 86, 483–498 (2013)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR61" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2081">61</a></sup>, and differences in requisite enzymes<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 27" title="Lopes, R. J. et al. Genetic basis for red coloration in birds. Curr. Biol. 26, 1427–1434 (2016)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR27" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2085">27</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 63" title="Mundy, N. I. et al. Red carotenoid coloration in the zebra finch is controlled by a cytochrome P450 gene cluster. Curr. Biol. 26, 1435–1440 (2016)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR63" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2088">63</a></sup> that are relevant to bare-part coloration, but not feather coloration. These factors could obscure meaningful interpretation of the relationship among coloration measures, carotenoid metabolism, and individual quality from bare-part coloration.</p><p>Because we were interested in the signal content of carotenoid-based plumage, we focused on studies that quantified feather color using standardized color metrics (see ‘Color metrics’ below) of natural (i.e., un-supplemented) adult bird color levels. Therefore, we excluded studies from our meta-analysis for any of the following reasons: only coloration of non-feathered structures was measured (e.g., wattles, legs, beaks); a non-passerine species was studied; only plasma concentrations of carotenoids were measured; or only nestling or juvenile coloration was studied. We did not include measures of feather brightness as it is sensitive to factors unrelated to pigmentation (see below). Additionally, to be included in our meta-analysis, studies must have investigated at least one of the following proxies of individual quality: (1) nutritional condition, (2) immune function or oxidative capacity, (3) parasite resistance, or (4) reproductive or parental quality (Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="table anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#Tab2">2</a>).</p><div class="c-article-table" data-test="inline-table" data-container-section="table" id="table-2"><figure><figcaption class="c-article-table__figcaption"><b id="Tab2" data-test="table-caption">Table 2 Commonly used proxies for quality to evaluate the relationship between carotenoid-based feather coloration and individual quality</b></figcaption><div class="u-text-right u-hide-print"><a class="c-article__pill-button" data-test="table-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view table" data-track-label="button" rel="nofollow" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z/tables/2" aria-label="Full size table 2"><span>Full size table</span><svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-chevron-right-small"></use></svg></a></div></figure></div><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading c-article__sub-heading--divider" id="Sec15">Data extraction and coding</h3><p>We used the correlation coefficient, Pearson’s <i>r</i>, as the effect size metric to describe the association between measurements of feather coloration and aspects of individual quality. The effect size metric was extracted directly from each study when available (<i>n</i> = 9). For cases in which studies did not provide Pearson’s <i>r</i> (<i>n</i> = 41), the reported test statistics (<i>F</i>, <i>ρ</i>, <i>χ</i><sup>2</sup>, τ, <i>t</i>, and means and standard deviations or standard errors) were used to estimate <i>r</i><sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 64" title="Lipsey, M. W. & Wilson, D. B. Practical Meta-analysis. Applied Social Research Methods Series Vol. 49 (Sage Publications, Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA, 2001)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR64" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2499">64</a></sup>. Pearson’s <i>r</i> was transformed to Fisher’s <i>Z</i> for statistical analyses to meet normality assumptions of linear models. Researchers commonly refer to <i>r</i> = 0.1, 0.3 and 0.5 as small, medium, and large effect sizes (<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 65" title="Cohen, J. Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. (Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ, 1988)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR65" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2513">65</a></sup>; these benchmarks are equivalent for Zr values), respectively. The sign of the correlation coefficient was changed in some cases to facilitate comparisons across metrics of individual quality; for example, some measures—such as parasite load—were often negatively correlated with richness of coloration but indicated a positive relationship with quality<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 66" title="McGraw, K. J. & Hill, G. E. Differential effects of endoparasitism on the expression of carotenoid- and melanin-based ornamental coloration. Proc. R. Soc. Biol. Sci. Ser. B 267, 1525–1531 (2000)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR66" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2517">66</a></sup>.</p><p>Original studies often include multiple effect size estimates because of the measurement of several life history traits associated with individual condition or performance (<i>e.g</i>., immune function or fledging success) and/or from different color metrics (see below). When more than one effect size is reported these data points cannot be assumed to be independent. To deal with this issue, we ran multi-level, random-effects meta-analytic models that allowed us to include multiple, non-independent effect sizes per study. This was accomplished by including the study identity and species identity as random effects<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 67" title="Nakagawa, S. & Santos, E. S. A. Methodological issues and advances in biological meta-analysis. Evol. Ecol. 26, 1253–1274 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR67" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2527">67</a></sup>.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading c-article__sub-heading--divider" id="Sec16">Carotenoid type</h3><p>Coloration of feathers was categorized as dietary if feather carotenoids identified for that species were only those that are typically found in passerine diets (e.g., lutein or zeaxanthin)<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 16" title="McGraw, K. J. in Bird Coloration Vol. 1 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR16" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2539">16</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 68" title="Brush, A. Metabolism of carotenoid pigments in birds. Faseb. J. 4, 2969–2977 (1990)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR68" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2542">68</a></sup>. Carotenoids were categorized as converted if feather carotenoids identified for that species were those that are oxidative products of dietary carotenoids, typically 4-keto-carotenoids and canary xanthophylls (Supplementary Note <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">1</a> <sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 16" title="McGraw, K. J. in Bird Coloration Vol. 1 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR16" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2549">16</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 68" title="Brush, A. Metabolism of carotenoid pigments in birds. Faseb. J. 4, 2969–2977 (1990)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR68" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2552">68</a></sup>). We referenced published studies that characterized the carotenoids present in feathers of each species included in our meta-analysis (Supplementary Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">4</a>). For instances in which we could not identify the feather carotenoids of a particular species (<i>n</i> = 3), we used the published data from a sister-species of the same genus that displayed the same feather color.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading c-article__sub-heading--divider" id="Sec17">Color metrics</h3><p>Standing variation in richness of color between individuals is requisite for assessing quality from carotenoid-based ornaments. Common metrics used to quantify this variation in feather reflectance include comparisons to standard color charts (e.g., Munsel), calculations of hue, chroma and brightness or composite metrics such as principal components (PCA) from spectrophotometer data or digital photographs. Hue describes the unique spectral color (e.g., “red”, “orange”, “yellow”) and chroma describes the saturation or spectral purity of the color display relative to total reflectance across the visible range of the electromagnetic spectrum<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 69" title="Montgomerie, R. in Bird Coloration Vol. 1 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR69" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2570">69</a></sup>. We extracted the response of all color variables used to assess the relationship between color and a measure of quality (e.g., condition, immune function) from each study. We did not include measures of brightness in our analyses because it is strongly influenced by the physical structure of the feather which may be altered by abrasion and wear and is difficult to interpret for carotenoid content<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 70" title="Shawkey, M. D. & Hill, G. E. Carotenoids need structural colours to shine. Biol. Lett. 1, 121–124 (2005)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR70" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2574">70</a></sup>.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading c-article__sub-heading--divider" id="Sec18">Meta-analysis technique</h3><p>To evaluate the strength of correlation between all measures of individual quality and overall feather color richness, we first used a Bayesian mixed-effects meta-analytic model without distinguishing between carotenoid types (i.e., “Combined”; intercept only model). To further partition heterogeneity, we conducted a Bayesian meta-regression analysis with carotenoid type included as a categorical moderator to test the effect of the source of ornamental coloration (either dietary or converted carotenoids) on the overall relationship between color and quality. We then performed a second meta-regression analysis to test the strength of association of each quality category with both dietary and converted carotenoid-based plumage. We used a third meta-regression model to quantify the relationship between coloration and quality for each bird species examined in the data set. Lastly, we used a fourth meta-regression model that included an interaction between the carotenoid-type and sex to investigate the role of sex in the relationship between color measures and quality. We used the MCMCglmm package<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 71" title="Hadfield, J. D. MCMC methods for multi-response generalized linear mixed models: The MCMCglmm R package. J. Stat. Softw. 33, 1–22 (2010)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR71" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2587">71</a>,<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 72" title="Hadfield, J. D. & Nakagawa, S. General quantitative genetic methods for comparative biology: Phylogenies, taxonomies and multi-trait models for continuous and categorical characters. J. Evol. Biol. 23, 494–508 (2010)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR72" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2590">72</a></sup> in program R version 3.3.0<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 73" title="R Core Team. R: a language and environment for statistical computing (R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria, 2017)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR73" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2594">73</a></sup> to conduct the Bayesian mixed-effects meta-analyses (Supplementary Data <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM6">3</a>).</p><p>To adequately correct for non-independence, it is necessary to model the correlations among effect sizes. For instance, effect sizes for immune response and fledging success are likely to be correlated when the traits were measured from the same group of individuals. Unfortunately, such correlations are almost never reported in the original studies, and are seldom accounted for in meta-analytic models (but see ref.<a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 74" title="Booksmythe, I., Mautz, B., Davis, J., Nakagawa, S. & Jennions, M. D. Facultative adjustment of the offspring sex ratio and male attractiveness: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Biol. Rev. 92, 108–134 (2017)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR74" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2603">74</a>), potentially biasing general findings. Thus, to conservatively account for such correlations, we report multi-level models that assume all correlations to be 0.5. Additionally, in Supplementary Table <a data-track="click" data-track-label="link" data-track-action="supplementary material anchor" href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#MOESM1">1</a>, we report the results of the same models assuming correlations of zero. We note that qualitatively the results are very similar among these meta-analytic models.</p><p>We also accounted for the evolutionary history of the bird species used in the study by including a phylogenetic random effect to the models. Our meta-analytic models used avian phylogenetic trees with the Ericson backbone from ref. <sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 75" title="Jetz, W., Thomas, G. H., Joy, J. B., Hartmann, K. & Mooers, A. O. The global diversity of birds in space and time. Nature 491, 444–448 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR75" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2613">75</a></sup>. To account for uncertainty in the phylogenetic reconstruction, we used a sample of 1000 trees, so that each tree was sampled at iteration, <i>t</i>. We calculated phylogenetic heritability, <i>H</i><sup>2</sup>, as an index of phylogenetic signal. <i>H</i><sup><i>2</i></sup> can be defined as the proportion of phylogenetic variance in relation to the sum of all other variance components, with the exception of sample error variance. When the unit of analysis is at the species level, <i>H</i><sup>2</sup> is equivalent to Pagel’s <i>λ</i><sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 76" title="Housworth, E. A., Martins, E. P. & Lynch, M. The phylogenetic mixed model. Am. Nat. 163, 84–96 (2004)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR76" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2637">76</a></sup>.</p><p>For all multi-level models, we used parameter expanded priors (<i>V</i> = 1, nu = 1, alpha.mu = 0, alpha.<i>V</i> = 1000) for all random effects. We used a combination of total iterations and burn-in period so that the posterior distributions consisted of 1000 samples for the model parameters. We report point estimates from the models based on the posterior means, and considered moderator estimates to be statistically significant if the 95% credible interval (95% CI) did not overlap zero. We calculated an modified version of the <i>I</i><sup>2</sup> statistics (following ref. <sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 67" title="Nakagawa, S. & Santos, E. S. A. Methodological issues and advances in biological meta-analysis. Evol. Ecol. 26, 1253–1274 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR67" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2654">67</a></sup>) to estimate heterogeneity in multi-level meta-analytic models. This procedure allocates the proportion of variance not attributable to sampling variance to the random factors of the model. In our models, these are the variance in effect sizes due to the following four components: phylogenetic relatedness, differences among species, differences among studies, and differences residual variation (within-study variation). Adding the total variation (percentages) from each of these components yields the original <i>I</i><sup>2</sup> proposed by ref. <sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 28" title="Higgins, J. P. T., Thompson, S. G., Deeks, J. J. & Altman, D. G. Measuring inconsistency in knowledgebases. Br. Med. J. 327, 557–560 (2003)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR28" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2663">28</a></sup>.</p><p>To test for potential publication bias, we visually evaluated funnel plot asymmetry of effect size as a function of sample size. Then, we conducted an Egger’s regression<sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 77" title="Egger, M., Smith, G. D., Schneider, M. & Minder, C. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. Br. Med. J. 315, 629–634 (1997)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR77" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2671">77</a></sup> to test statistically for publication bias. The analyses of bias for the multi-level models was conducted on the meta-analytic residuals (see ref. <sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 67" title="Nakagawa, S. & Santos, E. S. A. Methodological issues and advances in biological meta-analysis. Evol. Ecol. 26, 1253–1274 (2012)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR67" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2675">67</a></sup>), as this safeguards that we meet the assumption of independence.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading c-article__sub-heading--divider" id="Sec19">Code availability</h3><p>The code used to perform the meta-analyses that support the findings of this study are available in figshare repository with the identifier: https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5675431.v2 (ref. <sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 78" title="Weaver, R. J., Santos E.S.A., & Tucker, A.M. Carotenoid Metabolism Strengthens the Link Between Feather Coloration and Individual Quality 
 https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5675431.v2
 
 (2017)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR78" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2687">78</a></sup>).</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading c-article__sub-heading--divider" id="Sec20">Data availability</h3><p>The effect size data that support the findings of this study are available in figshare repository with the identifier: https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5675431.v2 (ref. <sup><a data-track="click" data-track-action="reference anchor" data-track-label="link" data-test="citation-ref" aria-label="Reference 78" title="Weaver, R. J., Santos E.S.A., & Tucker, A.M. Carotenoid Metabolism Strengthens the Link Between Feather Coloration and Individual Quality 
 https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5675431.v2
 
 (2017)." href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z#ref-CR78" id="ref-link-section-d94474230e2699">78</a></sup>). The authors declare that all the data supporting the findings of this study are available within the paper and its supplementary information files.</p></div></div></section> </div> <div> <div id="MagazineFulltextArticleBodySuffix"><section aria-labelledby="Bib1" data-title="References"><div class="c-article-section" id="Bib1-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Bib1">References</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Bib1-content"><div data-container-section="references"><ol class="c-article-references" data-track-component="outbound reference" data-track-context="references section"><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="1."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR1">Svensson, P. A. & Wong, B. B. M. Carotenoid-based signals in behavioural ecology: a review. <i>Behaviour</i> <b>148</b>, 131–189 (2011).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1163/000579510X548673" data-track-item_id="10.1163/000579510X548673" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1163%2F000579510X548673" aria-label="Article reference 1" data-doi="10.1163/000579510X548673">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 1" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoid-based%20signals%20in%20behavioural%20ecology%3A%20a%20review&journal=Behaviour&doi=10.1163%2F000579510X548673&volume=148&pages=131-189&publication_year=2011&author=Svensson%2CPA&author=Wong%2CBBM"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="2."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR2">Hill, G. E. in: <i>Bird.Coloration</i> Vol. 2 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) 137–200 (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="3."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR3">Hill, G. E. in <i>Reproduc</i>tive Biolog<i>y and Phylogeny of Birds</i> Vol 6B (ed Jamieson, B. G. M.) 41–74 (Science Publishers, Endfield, New Hampshire, 2007).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="4."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR4">Blount, J. & McGraw, K. in <i>Carotenoids</i> (eds Britton, G., Liaaen-Jensen, S. H. C., & Pfander, H.) 213–236 (Birkhäuser, Basel, Switzerland, 2008).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="5."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR5">Garratt, M. & Brooks, R. C. Oxidative stress and condition-dependent sexual signals: more than just seeing red. <i>Proc. Biol. Sci.</i> <b>279</b>, 3121–3130 (2012).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1098/rspb.2012.0568" data-track-item_id="10.1098/rspb.2012.0568" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1098%2Frspb.2012.0568" aria-label="Article reference 5" data-doi="10.1098/rspb.2012.0568">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=22648155" aria-label="PubMed reference 5">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3385731" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 5">PubMed Central</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 5" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Oxidative%20stress%20and%20condition-dependent%20sexual%20signals%3A%20more%20than%20just%20seeing%20red&journal=Proc.%20Biol.%20Sci.&doi=10.1098%2Frspb.2012.0568&volume=279&pages=3121-3130&publication_year=2012&author=Garratt%2CM&author=Brooks%2CRC"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="6."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR6">Simons, M. J. P., Cohen, A. A. & Verhulst, S. What does carotenoid-dependent coloration tell? Plasma carotenoid level signals immunocompetence and oxidative stress state in birds-A meta-analysis. <i>PLoS ONE</i> <b>7</b>, e43088 (2012).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1371/journal.pone.0043088" data-track-item_id="10.1371/journal.pone.0043088" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0043088" aria-label="Article reference 6" data-doi="10.1371/journal.pone.0043088">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2012PLoSO...743088S" aria-label="ADS reference 6">ADS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BC38Xht1ejt7vI" aria-label="CAS reference 6">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=22905205" aria-label="PubMed reference 6">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3419220" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 6">PubMed Central</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 6" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=What%20does%20carotenoid-dependent%20coloration%20tell%3F%20Plasma%20carotenoid%20level%20signals%20immunocompetence%20and%20oxidative%20stress%20state%20in%20birds-A%20meta-analysis&journal=PLoS%20ONE&doi=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0043088&volume=7&publication_year=2012&author=Simons%2CMJP&author=Cohen%2CAA&author=Verhulst%2CS"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="7."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR7">Hill, G. E. Cellular respiration: The nexus of stress, condition, and ornamentation. <i>Integr. Comp. Biol.</i> <b>54</b>, 645–657 (2014).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1093/icb/icu029" data-track-item_id="10.1093/icb/icu029" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1093%2Ficb%2Ficu029" aria-label="Article reference 7" data-doi="10.1093/icb/icu029">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=24791751" aria-label="PubMed reference 7">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 7" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Cellular%20respiration%3A%20The%20nexus%20of%20stress%2C%20condition%2C%20and%20ornamentation&journal=Integr.%20Comp.%20Biol.&doi=10.1093%2Ficb%2Ficu029&volume=54&pages=645-657&publication_year=2014&author=Hill%2CGE"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="8."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR8">Alonso-Alvarez, C., Pérez-Rodríguez, L., Mateo, R., Chastel, O. & Viñuela, J. The oxidation handicap hypothesis and the carotenoid allocation trade-off. <i>J. Evol. Biol.</i> <b>21</b>, 1789–1797 (2008).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1111/j.1420-9101.2008.01591.x" data-track-item_id="10.1111/j.1420-9101.2008.01591.x" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fj.1420-9101.2008.01591.x" aria-label="Article reference 8" data-doi="10.1111/j.1420-9101.2008.01591.x">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:STN:280:DC%2BD1cjkvV2ktw%3D%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 8">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=18713241" aria-label="PubMed reference 8">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 8" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=The%20oxidation%20handicap%20hypothesis%20and%20the%20carotenoid%20allocation%20trade-off&journal=J.%20Evol.%20Biol.&doi=10.1111%2Fj.1420-9101.2008.01591.x&volume=21&pages=1789-1797&publication_year=2008&author=Alonso-Alvarez%2CC&author=P%C3%A9rez-Rodr%C3%ADguez%2CL&author=Mateo%2CR&author=Chastel%2CO&author=Vi%C3%B1uela%2CJ"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="9."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR9">Weaver, R. J., Koch, R. E. & Hill, G. E. What maintains signal honesty in animal colour dispays used in mate choice? <i>Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.</i> <b>372</b>, 20160343 (2017).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1098/rstb.2016.0343" data-track-item_id="10.1098/rstb.2016.0343" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1098%2Frstb.2016.0343" aria-label="Article reference 9" data-doi="10.1098/rstb.2016.0343">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 9" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=What%20maintains%20signal%20honesty%20in%20animal%20colour%20dispays%20used%20in%20mate%20choice%3F&journal=Philos.%20Trans.%20R.%20Soc.%20B%20Biol.%20Sci.&doi=10.1098%2Frstb.2016.0343&volume=372&publication_year=2017&author=Weaver%2CRJ&author=Koch%2CRE&author=Hill%2CGE"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="10."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR10">Chew, B. P. & Park, J. S. Carotenoid action on the immune response. <i>J. Nutr.</i> <b>134</b>, 257S–261S (2004).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2cXitlCqsQ%3D%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 10">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=14704330" aria-label="PubMed reference 10">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 10" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoid%20action%20on%20the%20immune%20response&journal=J.%20Nutr.&volume=134&pages=257S-261S&publication_year=2004&author=Chew%2CBP&author=Park%2CJS"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="11."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR11">Britton, G. Structure and properties of carotenoids in relation to function. <i>FASEB J.</i> <b>9</b>, 1551–1558 (1995).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DyaK28XhsVCksw%3D%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 11">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=8529834" aria-label="PubMed reference 11">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 11" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Structure%20and%20properties%20of%20carotenoids%20in%20relation%20to%20function&journal=FASEB%20J.&volume=9&pages=1551-1558&publication_year=1995&author=Britton%2CG"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="12."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR12">Hill, G. E. & Johnson, J. D. The vitamin A-redox hypothesis: A biochemical basis for honest signaling via carotenoid pigmentation. <i>Am. Nat.</i> <b>180</b>, E127–E150 (2012).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1086/667861" data-track-item_id="10.1086/667861" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1086%2F667861" aria-label="Article reference 12" data-doi="10.1086/667861">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=23070328" aria-label="PubMed reference 12">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 12" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=The%20vitamin%20A-redox%20hypothesis%3A%20A%20biochemical%20basis%20for%20honest%20signaling%20via%20carotenoid%20pigmentation&journal=Am.%20Nat.&doi=10.1086%2F667861&volume=180&pages=E127-E150&publication_year=2012&author=Hill%2CGE&author=Johnson%2CJD"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="13."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR13">García-de Blas, E., Mateo, R. & Alonso-Alvarez, C. Accumulation of dietary carotenoids, retinoids and tocopherol in the internal tissues of a bird: a hypothesis for the cost of producing colored ornaments. <i>Oecologia</i> <b>177</b>, 259–271 (2015).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="noopener" data-track-label="10.1007/s00442-014-3163-8" data-track-item_id="10.1007/s00442-014-3163-8" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://link.springer.com/doi/10.1007/s00442-014-3163-8" aria-label="Article reference 13" data-doi="10.1007/s00442-014-3163-8">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2015Oecol.177..259G" aria-label="ADS reference 13">ADS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=25421097" aria-label="PubMed reference 13">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 13" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Accumulation%20of%20dietary%20carotenoids%2C%20retinoids%20and%20tocopherol%20in%20the%20internal%20tissues%20of%20a%20bird%3A%20a%20hypothesis%20for%20the%20cost%20of%20producing%20colored%20ornaments&journal=Oecologia&doi=10.1007%2Fs00442-014-3163-8&volume=177&pages=259-271&publication_year=2015&author=Garc%C3%ADa-de%20Blas%2CE&author=Mateo%2CR&author=Alonso-Alvarez%2CC"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="14."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR14">Goodwin, T. Distribution of carotenoids. <i>Methods Enzymol.</i> <b>213</b>, 167–172 (1992).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/0076-6879(92)13119-I" data-track-item_id="10.1016/0076-6879(92)13119-I" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2F0076-6879%2892%2913119-I" aria-label="Article reference 14" data-doi="10.1016/0076-6879(92)13119-I">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DyaK3sXhsVaju7s%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 14">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 14" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Distribution%20of%20carotenoids&journal=Methods%20Enzymol.&doi=10.1016%2F0076-6879%2892%2913119-I&volume=213&pages=167-172&publication_year=1992&author=Goodwin%2CT"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="15."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR15">Goodwin, T. Metabolism, nutrition, and function of carotenoids. <i>Annu. Rev. Nutr.</i> <b>6</b>, 237–297 (1986).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1146/annurev.nu.06.070186.001421" data-track-item_id="10.1146/annurev.nu.06.070186.001421" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1146%2Fannurev.nu.06.070186.001421" aria-label="Article reference 15" data-doi="10.1146/annurev.nu.06.070186.001421">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 15" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Metabolism%2C%20nutrition%2C%20and%20function%20of%20carotenoids&journal=Annu.%20Rev.%20Nutr.&doi=10.1146%2Fannurev.nu.06.070186.001421&volume=6&pages=237-297&publication_year=1986&author=Goodwin%2CT"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="16."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR16">McGraw, K. J. in <i>Bird Coloration</i> Vol. 1 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="17."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR17">Hill, G. E., Montgomerie, R., Inouye, C. Y. & Dale, J. Influence of dietary carotenoids on plasma and plumage colour in the house finch: intra- and intersexual variation. <i>Funct. Ecol.</i> <b>8</b>, 343–350 (1994).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.2307/2389827" data-track-item_id="10.2307/2389827" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.2307%2F2389827" aria-label="Article reference 17" data-doi="10.2307/2389827">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 17" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Influence%20of%20dietary%20carotenoids%20on%20plasma%20and%20plumage%20colour%20in%20the%20house%20finch%3A%20intra-%20and%20intersexual%20variation&journal=Funct.%20Ecol.&doi=10.2307%2F2389827&volume=8&pages=343-350&publication_year=1994&author=Hill%2CGE&author=Montgomerie%2CR&author=Inouye%2CCY&author=Dale%2CJ"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="18."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR18">Lozano, G. Carotenoids, parasites, and sexual selection. <i>Oikos</i> <b>70</b>, 309–312 (1994).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.2307/3545643" data-track-item_id="10.2307/3545643" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.2307%2F3545643" aria-label="Article reference 18" data-doi="10.2307/3545643">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 18" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoids%2C%20parasites%2C%20and%20sexual%20selection&journal=Oikos&doi=10.2307%2F3545643&volume=70&pages=309-312&publication_year=1994&author=Lozano%2CG"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="19."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR19">von Schantz, T., Bensch, S., Grahn, M., Hasselquist, D. & Wittzell, H. Good genes, oxidative stress and condition–dependent sexual signals. <i>Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.</i> <b>266</b>, 1–12 (1999).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1098/rspb.1999.0597" data-track-item_id="10.1098/rspb.1999.0597" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1098%2Frspb.1999.0597" aria-label="Article reference 19" data-doi="10.1098/rspb.1999.0597">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 19" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Good%20genes%2C%20oxidative%20stress%20and%20condition%E2%80%93dependent%20sexual%20signals&journal=Proc.%20R.%20Soc.%20B%20Biol.%20Sci.&doi=10.1098%2Frspb.1999.0597&volume=266&pages=1-12&publication_year=1999&author=Schantz%2CT&author=Bensch%2CS&author=Grahn%2CM&author=Hasselquist%2CD&author=Wittzell%2CH"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="20."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR20">Møller, A. P. et al. Carotenoid-dependent signals: Indicators of foraging efficiency, immunocompetence or detoxification ability? <i>Avian Poult. Biol. Rev.</i> <b>11</b>, 137–159 (2000).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 20" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoid-dependent%20signals%3A%20Indicators%20of%20foraging%20efficiency%2C%20immunocompetence%20or%20detoxification%20ability%3F&journal=Avian%20Poult.%20Biol.%20Rev.&volume=11&pages=137-159&publication_year=2000&author=M%C3%B8ller%2CAP"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="21."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR21">Hill, G. E. Condition-dependent traits as signals of the functionality of vital cellular processes. <i>Ecol. Lett.</i> <b>14</b>, 625–634 (2011).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1111/j.1461-0248.2011.01622.x" data-track-item_id="10.1111/j.1461-0248.2011.01622.x" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fj.1461-0248.2011.01622.x" aria-label="Article reference 21" data-doi="10.1111/j.1461-0248.2011.01622.x">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=21518211" aria-label="PubMed reference 21">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 21" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Condition-dependent%20traits%20as%20signals%20of%20the%20functionality%20of%20vital%20cellular%20processes&journal=Ecol.%20Lett.&doi=10.1111%2Fj.1461-0248.2011.01622.x&volume=14&pages=625-634&publication_year=2011&author=Hill%2CGE"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="22."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR22">Johnson, J. D. & Hill, G. E. Is carotenoid ornamentation linked to the inner mitochondria membrane potential? A hypothesis for the maintenance of signal honesty. <i>Biochimie</i> <b>95</b>, 436–444 (2013).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/j.biochi.2012.10.021" data-track-item_id="10.1016/j.biochi.2012.10.021" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.biochi.2012.10.021" aria-label="Article reference 22" data-doi="10.1016/j.biochi.2012.10.021">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BC38Xhs12ksrrF" aria-label="CAS reference 22">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=23131590" aria-label="PubMed reference 22">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 22" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Is%20carotenoid%20ornamentation%20linked%20to%20the%20inner%20mitochondria%20membrane%20potential%3F%20A%20hypothesis%20for%20the%20maintenance%20of%20signal%20honesty&journal=Biochimie&doi=10.1016%2Fj.biochi.2012.10.021&volume=95&pages=436-444&publication_year=2013&author=Johnson%2CJD&author=Hill%2CGE"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="23."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR23">Hill, G. E. Is there an immunological cost to carotenoid-based ornamental coloration? <i>Am. Nat.</i> <b>154</b>, 589–595 (1999).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:STN:280:DC%2BC2sbhtFWgsA%3D%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 23">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=10561131" aria-label="PubMed reference 23">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 23" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Is%20there%20an%20immunological%20cost%20to%20carotenoid-based%20ornamental%20coloration%3F&journal=Am.%20Nat.&volume=154&pages=589-595&publication_year=1999&author=Hill%2CGE"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="24."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR24">Griffith, S. C., Parker, T. H. & Olson, V. A. Melanin- versus carotenoid-based sexual signals: is the difference really so black and red? <i>Anim. Behav.</i> <b>71</b>, 749–763 (2006).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/j.anbehav.2005.07.016" data-track-item_id="10.1016/j.anbehav.2005.07.016" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.anbehav.2005.07.016" aria-label="Article reference 24" data-doi="10.1016/j.anbehav.2005.07.016">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 24" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Melanin-%20versus%20carotenoid-based%20sexual%20signals%3A%20is%20the%20difference%20really%20so%20black%20and%20red%3F&journal=Anim.%20Behav.&doi=10.1016%2Fj.anbehav.2005.07.016&volume=71&pages=749-763&publication_year=2006&author=Griffith%2CSC&author=Parker%2CTH&author=Olson%2CVA"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="25."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR25">Simons, M. J. P., Maia, R., Leenknegt, B. & Verhulst, S. Carotenoid-dependent signals and the evolution of plasma carotenoid levels in birds. <i>Am. Nat.</i> <b>184</b>, 741–751 (2014).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1086/678402" data-track-item_id="10.1086/678402" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1086%2F678402" aria-label="Article reference 25" data-doi="10.1086/678402">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=25438174" aria-label="PubMed reference 25">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 25" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoid-dependent%20signals%20and%20the%20evolution%20of%20plasma%20carotenoid%20levels%20in%20birds&journal=Am.%20Nat.&doi=10.1086%2F678402&volume=184&pages=741-751&publication_year=2014&author=Simons%2CMJP&author=Maia%2CR&author=Leenknegt%2CB&author=Verhulst%2CS"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="26."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR26">Weaver, R. J., Hill, G. E., Kuan, P.-L. & Tseng, Y.-C. Copper exposure reduces production of red carotenoids in a marine copepod. <i>Ecol. Indic.</i> <b>70</b>, 393–400 (2016).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/j.ecolind.2016.06.040" data-track-item_id="10.1016/j.ecolind.2016.06.040" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.ecolind.2016.06.040" aria-label="Article reference 26" data-doi="10.1016/j.ecolind.2016.06.040">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BC28XhtFensbjL" aria-label="CAS reference 26">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 26" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Copper%20exposure%20reduces%20production%20of%20red%20carotenoids%20in%20a%20marine%20copepod&journal=Ecol.%20Indic.&doi=10.1016%2Fj.ecolind.2016.06.040&volume=70&pages=393-400&publication_year=2016&author=Weaver%2CRJ&author=Hill%2CGE&author=Kuan%2CPL&author=Tseng%2CYC"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="27."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR27">Lopes, R. J. et al. Genetic basis for red coloration in birds. <i>Curr. Biol.</i> <b>26</b>, 1427–1434 (2016).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/j.cub.2016.03.076" data-track-item_id="10.1016/j.cub.2016.03.076" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.cub.2016.03.076" aria-label="Article reference 27" data-doi="10.1016/j.cub.2016.03.076">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BC28Xotlensbs%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 27">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=27212400" aria-label="PubMed reference 27">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5125026" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 27">PubMed Central</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 27" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Genetic%20basis%20for%20red%20coloration%20in%20birds&journal=Curr.%20Biol.&doi=10.1016%2Fj.cub.2016.03.076&volume=26&pages=1427-1434&publication_year=2016&author=Lopes%2CRJ"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="28."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR28">Higgins, J. P. T., Thompson, S. G., Deeks, J. J. & Altman, D. G. Measuring inconsistency in knowledgebases. <i>Br. Med. J.</i> <b>327</b>, 557–560 (2003).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1136/bmj.327.7414.557" data-track-item_id="10.1136/bmj.327.7414.557" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1136%2Fbmj.327.7414.557" aria-label="Article reference 28" data-doi="10.1136/bmj.327.7414.557">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 28" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Measuring%20inconsistency%20in%20knowledgebases&journal=Br.%20Med.%20J.&doi=10.1136%2Fbmj.327.7414.557&volume=327&pages=557-560&publication_year=2003&author=Higgins%2CJPT&author=Thompson%2CSG&author=Deeks%2CJJ&author=Altman%2CDG"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="29."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR29">Viechtbauer, W. Conducting meta-analyses in R with the metafor package. <i>J. Stat. Softw.</i> <b>36</b>, 1–48 (2010).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.18637/jss.v036.i03" data-track-item_id="10.18637/jss.v036.i03" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.18637%2Fjss.v036.i03" aria-label="Article reference 29" data-doi="10.18637/jss.v036.i03">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 29" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Conducting%20meta-analyses%20in%20R%20with%20the%20metafor%20package&journal=J.%20Stat.%20Softw.&doi=10.18637%2Fjss.v036.i03&volume=36&pages=1-48&publication_year=2010&author=Viechtbauer%2CW"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="30."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR30">Cotton, S., Small, J. & Pomiankowski, A. Sexual selection and condition-dependent mate preferences. <i>Curr. Biol.</i> <b>16</b>, R755–R765 (2006).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/j.cub.2006.08.022" data-track-item_id="10.1016/j.cub.2006.08.022" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.cub.2006.08.022" aria-label="Article reference 30" data-doi="10.1016/j.cub.2006.08.022">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BD28XptFSku70%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 30">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=16950102" aria-label="PubMed reference 30">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 30" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Sexual%20selection%20and%20condition-dependent%20mate%20preferences&journal=Curr.%20Biol.&doi=10.1016%2Fj.cub.2006.08.022&volume=16&pages=R755-R765&publication_year=2006&author=Cotton%2CS&author=Small%2CJ&author=Pomiankowski%2CA"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="31."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR31">Hõrak, P., Ots, I., Vellau, H., Spottiswoode, C. & Møller, A. P. Carotenoid-based plumage coloration reflects hemoparasite infection and local survival in breeding great tits. <i>Oecologia</i> <b>126</b>, 166–173 (2001).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="noopener" data-track-label="10.1007/s004420000513" data-track-item_id="10.1007/s004420000513" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://link.springer.com/doi/10.1007/s004420000513" aria-label="Article reference 31" data-doi="10.1007/s004420000513">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2001Oecol.126..166H" aria-label="ADS reference 31">ADS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=28547614" aria-label="PubMed reference 31">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 31" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoid-based%20plumage%20coloration%20reflects%20hemoparasite%20infection%20and%20local%20survival%20in%20breeding%20great%20tits&journal=Oecologia&doi=10.1007%2Fs004420000513&volume=126&pages=166-173&publication_year=2001&author=H%C3%B5rak%2CP&author=Ots%2CI&author=Vellau%2CH&author=Spottiswoode%2CC&author=M%C3%B8ller%2CAP"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="32."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR32">Isaksson, C., McLaughlin, P., Monaghan, P. & Andersson, S. Carotenoid pigmentation does not reflect total non-enzymatic antioxidant activity in plasma of adult and nestling great tits. <i>Parus Major. Funct. Ecol.</i> <b>21</b>, 1123–1129 (2007).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1111/j.1365-2435.2007.01317.x" data-track-item_id="10.1111/j.1365-2435.2007.01317.x" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fj.1365-2435.2007.01317.x" aria-label="Article reference 32" data-doi="10.1111/j.1365-2435.2007.01317.x">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 32" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoid%20pigmentation%20does%20not%20reflect%20total%20non-enzymatic%20antioxidant%20activity%20in%20plasma%20of%20adult%20and%20nestling%20great%20tits&journal=Parus%20Major.%20Funct.%20Ecol.&doi=10.1111%2Fj.1365-2435.2007.01317.x&volume=21&pages=1123-1129&publication_year=2007&author=Isaksson%2CC&author=McLaughlin%2CP&author=Monaghan%2CP&author=Andersson%2CS"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="33."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR33">Isaksson, C. & Andersson, S. Oxidative stress does not influence carotenoid mobilization and plumage pigmentation. <i>Proc. Biol. Sci.</i> <b>275</b>, 309–314 (2008).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1098/rspb.2007.1474" data-track-item_id="10.1098/rspb.2007.1474" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1098%2Frspb.2007.1474" aria-label="Article reference 33" data-doi="10.1098/rspb.2007.1474">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1cXhvFGktL4%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 33">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=18029305" aria-label="PubMed reference 33">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 33" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Oxidative%20stress%20does%20not%20influence%20carotenoid%20mobilization%20and%20plumage%20pigmentation&journal=Proc.%20Biol.%20Sci.&doi=10.1098%2Frspb.2007.1474&volume=275&pages=309-314&publication_year=2008&author=Isaksson%2CC&author=Andersson%2CS"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="34."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR34">Endler, J. A. Natural selection on color patterns in <i>Poecilia reticulata</i>. <i>Evolution</i> <b>34</b>, 76–91 (1980).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1111/j.1558-5646.1980.tb04790.x" data-track-item_id="10.1111/j.1558-5646.1980.tb04790.x" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fj.1558-5646.1980.tb04790.x" aria-label="Article reference 34" data-doi="10.1111/j.1558-5646.1980.tb04790.x">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=28563214" aria-label="PubMed reference 34">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 34" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Natural%20selection%20on%20color%20patterns%20in%20Poecilia%20reticulata&journal=Evolution&doi=10.1111%2Fj.1558-5646.1980.tb04790.x&volume=34&pages=76-91&publication_year=1980&author=Endler%2CJA"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="35."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR35">Kodric-Brown, A. Dietary carotenoids and male mating success in the guppy: an environmental component to female choice. <i>Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol.</i> <b>25</b>, 393–401 (1989).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="noopener" data-track-label="10.1007/BF00300185" data-track-item_id="10.1007/BF00300185" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://link.springer.com/doi/10.1007/BF00300185" aria-label="Article reference 35" data-doi="10.1007/BF00300185">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 35" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Dietary%20carotenoids%20and%20male%20mating%20success%20in%20the%20guppy%3A%20an%20environmental%20component%20to%20female%20choice&journal=Behav.%20Ecol.%20Sociobiol.&doi=10.1007%2FBF00300185&volume=25&pages=393-401&publication_year=1989&author=Kodric-Brown%2CA"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="36."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR36">Hill, G. E. Proximate basis of variation in carotenoid pigmentation in male house finches. <i>Auk</i> <b>109</b>, 1–12 (1992).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.2307/4088262" data-track-item_id="10.2307/4088262" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.2307%2F4088262" aria-label="Article reference 36" data-doi="10.2307/4088262">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 36" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Proximate%20basis%20of%20variation%20in%20carotenoid%20pigmentation%20in%20male%20house%20finches&journal=Auk&doi=10.2307%2F4088262&volume=109&pages=1-12&publication_year=1992&author=Hill%2CGE"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="37."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR37">Hill, G. E. House finches are what they eat: a reply to Hudon. <i>Auk</i> <b>111</b>, 221–225 (1994).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.2307/4088530" data-track-item_id="10.2307/4088530" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.2307%2F4088530" aria-label="Article reference 37" data-doi="10.2307/4088530">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 37" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=House%20finches%20are%20what%20they%20eat%3A%20a%20reply%20to%20Hudon&journal=Auk&doi=10.2307%2F4088530&volume=111&pages=221-225&publication_year=1994&author=Hill%2CGE"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="38."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR38">Hudon, J. Showiness, carotenoids, and captivity: A comment on Hill (1992). <i>Auk</i> <b>111</b>, 218–221 (1994).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.2307/4088529" data-track-item_id="10.2307/4088529" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.2307%2F4088529" aria-label="Article reference 38" data-doi="10.2307/4088529">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 38" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Showiness%2C%20carotenoids%2C%20and%20captivity%3A%20A%20comment%20on%20Hill%20%281992%29&journal=Auk&doi=10.2307%2F4088529&volume=111&pages=218-221&publication_year=1994&author=Hudon%2CJ"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="39."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR39">Thompson, C., Hillgarth, N., Leu, M. & McClure, H. High parasite load in house finches (<i>Carpodacus mexicanus</i>) is correlated with reduced expression of a sexually selected trait. <i>Am. Nat.</i> <b>149</b>, 270–294 (1997).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1086/285990" data-track-item_id="10.1086/285990" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1086%2F285990" aria-label="Article reference 39" data-doi="10.1086/285990">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 39" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=High%20parasite%20load%20in%20house%20finches%20%28Carpodacus%20mexicanus%29%20is%20correlated%20with%20reduced%20expression%20of%20a%20sexually%20selected%20trait&journal=Am.%20Nat.&doi=10.1086%2F285990&volume=149&pages=270-294&publication_year=1997&author=Thompson%2CC&author=Hillgarth%2CN&author=Leu%2CM&author=McClure%2CH"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="40."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR40">Hix, L. M., Lockwood, S. F. & Bertram, J. S. Bioactive carotenoids: potent antioxidants and regulators of gene expression. <i>Redox Rep.</i> <b>9</b>, 181–191 (2004).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1179/135100004225005967" data-track-item_id="10.1179/135100004225005967" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1179%2F135100004225005967" aria-label="Article reference 40" data-doi="10.1179/135100004225005967">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2cXhtVyit7rI" aria-label="CAS reference 40">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=15479561" aria-label="PubMed reference 40">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 40" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Bioactive%20carotenoids%3A%20potent%20antioxidants%20and%20regulators%20of%20gene%20expression&journal=Redox%20Rep.&doi=10.1179%2F135100004225005967&volume=9&pages=181-191&publication_year=2004&author=Hix%2CLM&author=Lockwood%2CSF&author=Bertram%2CJS"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="41."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR41">Krinsky, N. I. Antioxidant functions of carotenoids. <i>Free Radic. Biol. Med.</i> <b>7</b>, 617–635 (1989).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/0891-5849(89)90143-3" data-track-item_id="10.1016/0891-5849(89)90143-3" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2F0891-5849%2889%2990143-3" aria-label="Article reference 41" data-doi="10.1016/0891-5849(89)90143-3">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DyaK3MXkt1Cmsrw%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 41">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=2695406" aria-label="PubMed reference 41">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 41" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Antioxidant%20functions%20of%20carotenoids&journal=Free%20Radic.%20Biol.%20Med.&doi=10.1016%2F0891-5849%2889%2990143-3&volume=7&pages=617-635&publication_year=1989&author=Krinsky%2CNI"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="42."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR42">Costantini, D. & Møller, A. P. Carotenoids are minor antioxidants for birds. <i>Funct. Ecol.</i> <b>22</b>, 367–370 (2008).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1111/j.1365-2435.2007.01366.x" data-track-item_id="10.1111/j.1365-2435.2007.01366.x" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fj.1365-2435.2007.01366.x" aria-label="Article reference 42" data-doi="10.1111/j.1365-2435.2007.01366.x">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 42" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoids%20are%20minor%20antioxidants%20for%20birds&journal=Funct.%20Ecol.&doi=10.1111%2Fj.1365-2435.2007.01366.x&volume=22&pages=367-370&publication_year=2008&author=Costantini%2CD&author=M%C3%B8ller%2CAP"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="43."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR43">Costantini, D. Oxidative stress in ecology and evolution: lessons from avian studies. <i>Ecol. Lett.</i> <b>11</b>, 1238–1251 (2008).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=18803642" aria-label="PubMed reference 43">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 43" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Oxidative%20stress%20in%20ecology%20and%20evolution%3A%20lessons%20from%20avian%20studies&journal=Ecol.%20Lett.&volume=11&pages=1238-1251&publication_year=2008&author=Costantini%2CD"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="44."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR44">Hartley, R. C. & Kennedy, M. W. Are carotenoids a red herring in sexual display? <i>Trends Ecol. Evol.</i> <b>19</b>, 353–354 (2004).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/j.tree.2004.04.002" data-track-item_id="10.1016/j.tree.2004.04.002" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.tree.2004.04.002" aria-label="Article reference 44" data-doi="10.1016/j.tree.2004.04.002">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=16701285" aria-label="PubMed reference 44">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 44" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Are%20carotenoids%20a%20red%20herring%20in%20sexual%20display%3F&journal=Trends%20Ecol.%20Evol.&doi=10.1016%2Fj.tree.2004.04.002&volume=19&pages=353-354&publication_year=2004&author=Hartley%2CRC&author=Kennedy%2CMW"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="45."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR45">Pérez-Rodríguez, L. Carotenoids in evolutionary ecology: Re-evaluating the antioxidant role. <i>BioEssays</i> <b>31</b>, 1116–1126 (2009).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1002/bies.200900070" data-track-item_id="10.1002/bies.200900070" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1002%2Fbies.200900070" aria-label="Article reference 45" data-doi="10.1002/bies.200900070">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=19705366" aria-label="PubMed reference 45">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 45" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoids%20in%20evolutionary%20ecology%3A%20Re-evaluating%20the%20antioxidant%20role&journal=BioEssays&doi=10.1002%2Fbies.200900070&volume=31&pages=1116-1126&publication_year=2009&author=P%C3%A9rez-Rodr%C3%ADguez%2CL"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="46."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR46">Hamilton, W. D. & Zuk, M. Heritable true fitness and bright birds: a role for parasites? <i>Science</i> <b>218</b>, 384–387 (1982).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1126/science.7123238" data-track-item_id="10.1126/science.7123238" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1126%2Fscience.7123238" aria-label="Article reference 46" data-doi="10.1126/science.7123238">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=1982Sci...218..384H" aria-label="ADS reference 46">ADS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:STN:280:DyaL3s%2Fhs1Kgsw%3D%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 46">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=7123238" aria-label="PubMed reference 46">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 46" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Heritable%20true%20fitness%20and%20bright%20birds%3A%20a%20role%20for%20parasites%3F&journal=Science&doi=10.1126%2Fscience.7123238&volume=218&pages=384-387&publication_year=1982&author=Hamilton%2CWD&author=Zuk%2CM"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="47."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR47">Koch, R. E., Josefson, C. C. & Hill, G. E. Mitochondrial function, ornamentation, and immunocompetence. <i>Biol. Rev.</i> <b>92</b>, 1459–1474 (2016).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1111/brv.12291" data-track-item_id="10.1111/brv.12291" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fbrv.12291" aria-label="Article reference 47" data-doi="10.1111/brv.12291">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=27455896" aria-label="PubMed reference 47">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 47" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Mitochondrial%20function%2C%20ornamentation%2C%20and%20immunocompetence&journal=Biol.%20Rev.&doi=10.1111%2Fbrv.12291&volume=92&pages=1459-1474&publication_year=2016&author=Koch%2CRE&author=Josefson%2CCC&author=Hill%2CGE"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="48."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR48">Burley, N. Sexual selection for aesthetic traits in species with biparental care. <i>Am. Nat.</i> <b>127</b>, 415–445 (1986).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1086/284493" data-track-item_id="10.1086/284493" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1086%2F284493" aria-label="Article reference 48" data-doi="10.1086/284493">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=1986Natur.320..415B" aria-label="ADS reference 48">ADS</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 48" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Sexual%20selection%20for%20aesthetic%20traits%20in%20species%20with%20biparental%20care&journal=Am.%20Nat.&doi=10.1086%2F284493&volume=127&pages=415-445&publication_year=1986&author=Burley%2CN"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="49."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR49">Harris, W. E. & Uller, T. Reproductive investment when mate quality varies: differential allocation versus reproductive compensation. <i>Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. Biol. Sci.</i> <b>364</b>, 1039–1048 (2009).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1098/rstb.2008.0299" data-track-item_id="10.1098/rstb.2008.0299" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1098%2Frstb.2008.0299" aria-label="Article reference 49" data-doi="10.1098/rstb.2008.0299">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=19324609" aria-label="PubMed reference 49">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2666688" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 49">PubMed Central</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 49" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Reproductive%20investment%20when%20mate%20quality%20varies%3A%20differential%20allocation%20versus%20reproductive%20compensation&journal=Philos.%20Trans.%20R.%20Soc.%20Lond.%20B.%20Biol.%20Sci.&doi=10.1098%2Frstb.2008.0299&volume=364&pages=1039-1048&publication_year=2009&author=Harris%2CWE&author=Uller%2CT"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="50."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR50">Ratikainen, I. I. & Kokko, H. Differential allocation and compensation: Who deserves the silver spoon? <i>Behav. Ecol.</i> <b>21</b>, 195–200 (2010).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1093/beheco/arp168" data-track-item_id="10.1093/beheco/arp168" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1093%2Fbeheco%2Farp168" aria-label="Article reference 50" data-doi="10.1093/beheco/arp168">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 50" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Differential%20allocation%20and%20compensation%3A%20Who%20deserves%20the%20silver%20spoon%3F&journal=Behav.%20Ecol.&doi=10.1093%2Fbeheco%2Farp168&volume=21&pages=195-200&publication_year=2010&author=Ratikainen%2CII&author=Kokko%2CH"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="51."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR51">Badyaev, A. V., Potticary, A. L. & Morrison, E. S. Most colorful example of genetic assimilation? Exploring the evolutionary destiny of recurrent phenotypic accommodation. <i>Am. Nat.</i> <b>190</b>, 266–280 (2017).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1086/692327" data-track-item_id="10.1086/692327" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1086%2F692327" aria-label="Article reference 51" data-doi="10.1086/692327">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=28731798" aria-label="PubMed reference 51">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 51" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Most%20colorful%20example%20of%20genetic%20assimilation%3F%20Exploring%20the%20evolutionary%20destiny%20of%20recurrent%20phenotypic%20accommodation&journal=Am.%20Nat.&doi=10.1086%2F692327&volume=190&pages=266-280&publication_year=2017&author=Badyaev%2CAV&author=Potticary%2CAL&author=Morrison%2CES"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="52."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR52">Hill, G. Plumage coloration is a sexually selected indicator of male quality. <i>Nature</i> <b>350</b>, 337–338 (1991).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1038/350337a0" data-track-item_id="10.1038/350337a0" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1038%2F350337a0" aria-label="Article reference 52" data-doi="10.1038/350337a0">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=1991Natur.350..337H" aria-label="ADS reference 52">ADS</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 52" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Plumage%20coloration%20is%20a%20sexually%20selected%20indicator%20of%20male%20quality&journal=Nature&doi=10.1038%2F350337a0&volume=350&pages=337-338&publication_year=1991&author=Hill%2CG"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="53."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR53">Iverson, E. N. K. & Karubian, J. The role of bare parts in avian signaling. <i>Auk</i> <b>134</b>, 587–611 (2017).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1642/AUK-16-136.1" data-track-item_id="10.1642/AUK-16-136.1" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1642%2FAUK-16-136.1" aria-label="Article reference 53" data-doi="10.1642/AUK-16-136.1">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 53" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=The%20role%20of%20bare%20parts%20in%20avian%20signaling&journal=Auk&doi=10.1642%2FAUK-16-136.1&volume=134&pages=587-611&publication_year=2017&author=Iverson%2CENK&author=Karubian%2CJ"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="54."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR54">De Blas, E. G., Mateo, R., Guzman Bernardo, F. J., Rodríguez Martín-Doimeadios, R. C. & Alonso-Alvarez, C. Astaxanthin and papilioerythrinone in the skin of birds: A chromatic convergence of two metabolic routes with different precursors? <i>Naturwissenschaften</i> <b>101</b>, 407–416 (2014).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="noopener" data-track-label="10.1007/s00114-014-1169-z" data-track-item_id="10.1007/s00114-014-1169-z" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://link.springer.com/doi/10.1007/s00114-014-1169-z" aria-label="Article reference 54" data-doi="10.1007/s00114-014-1169-z">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2014NW....101..407G" aria-label="ADS reference 54">ADS</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 54" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Astaxanthin%20and%20papilioerythrinone%20in%20the%20skin%20of%20birds%3A%20A%20chromatic%20convergence%20of%20two%20metabolic%20routes%20with%20different%20precursors%3F&journal=Naturwissenschaften&doi=10.1007%2Fs00114-014-1169-z&volume=101&pages=407-416&publication_year=2014&author=Blas%2CEG&author=Mateo%2CR&author=Guzman%20Bernardo%2CFJ&author=Rodr%C3%ADguez%20Mart%C3%ADn-Doimeadios%2CRC&author=Alonso-Alvarez%2CC"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="55."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR55">Anbazahan, S. M. et al. Immune response and disease resistance of carotenoids supplementation diet in <i>Cyprinus carpio</i> against <i>Aeromonas hydrophila</i>. <i>Fish Shellfish Immunol.</i> <b>40</b>, 9–13 (2014).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/j.fsi.2014.06.011" data-track-item_id="10.1016/j.fsi.2014.06.011" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.fsi.2014.06.011" aria-label="Article reference 55" data-doi="10.1016/j.fsi.2014.06.011">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2cXhtlCltL7L" aria-label="CAS reference 55">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=24954837" aria-label="PubMed reference 55">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 55" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Immune%20response%20and%20disease%20resistance%20of%20carotenoids%20supplementation%20diet%20in%20Cyprinus%20carpio%20against%20Aeromonas%20hydrophila&journal=Fish%20Shellfish%20Immunol.&doi=10.1016%2Fj.fsi.2014.06.011&volume=40&pages=9-13&publication_year=2014&author=Anbazahan%2CSM"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="56."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR56">Fitze, P. S. et al. Carotenoid-based colours reflect the stress response in the common lizard. <i>PLoS. One.</i> <b>4</b>, e5111 (2009).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1371/journal.pone.0005111" data-track-item_id="10.1371/journal.pone.0005111" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0005111" aria-label="Article reference 56" data-doi="10.1371/journal.pone.0005111">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2009PLoSO...4.5111F" aria-label="ADS reference 56">ADS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=19352507" aria-label="PubMed reference 56">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2663031" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 56">PubMed Central</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 56" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoid-based%20colours%20reflect%20the%20stress%20response%20in%20the%20common%20lizard&journal=PLoS.%20One.&doi=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0005111&volume=4&publication_year=2009&author=Fitze%2CPS"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="57."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR57">Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., Altman, D. G. & Group, T. P. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. <i>PLoS Med.</i> <b>6</b>, e1000097 (2009).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097" data-track-item_id="10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1371%2Fjournal.pmed.1000097" aria-label="Article reference 57" data-doi="10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=19621072" aria-label="PubMed reference 57">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2707599" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 57">PubMed Central</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 57" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Preferred%20reporting%20items%20for%20systematic%20reviews%20and%20meta-analyses%3A%20The%20PRISMA%20statement&journal=PLoS%20Med.&doi=10.1371%2Fjournal.pmed.1000097&volume=6&publication_year=2009&author=Moher%2CD&author=Liberati%2CA&author=Tetzlaff%2CJ&author=Altman%2CDG&author=Group%2CTP"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="58."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR58">Jennions, M. D., Lortie, C. J., Rosenberg, M. S. & Rothstein, H. R. In <i>Handbook of Meta-Analysis in Ecology and Evolution</i> (eds Koricheva, J., Gurevitch, J., & Mengersen, K.) 207–236 (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 2013).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="59."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR59">Pérez-Rodríguez, L., Mougeot, F. & Alonso-Alvarez, C. Carotenoid-based coloration predicts resistance to oxidative damage during immune challenge. <i>J. Exp. Biol.</i> <b>213</b>, 1685–9160 (2010).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1242/jeb.039982" data-track-item_id="10.1242/jeb.039982" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1242%2Fjeb.039982" aria-label="Article reference 59" data-doi="10.1242/jeb.039982">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=20435819" aria-label="PubMed reference 59">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 59" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoid-based%20coloration%20predicts%20resistance%20to%20oxidative%20damage%20during%20immune%20challenge&journal=J.%20Exp.%20Biol.&doi=10.1242%2Fjeb.039982&volume=213&pages=1685-9160&publication_year=2010&author=P%C3%A9rez-Rodr%C3%ADguez%2CL&author=Mougeot%2CF&author=Alonso-Alvarez%2CC"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="60."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR60">Alonso-Alvarez, C., Bertrand, S., Faivre, B., Chastel, O. & Sorci, G. Testosterone and oxidative stress: the oxidation handicap hypothesis. <i>Proc. R. Soc. B-Biol. Sci.</i> <b>274</b>, 819–825 (2007).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1098/rspb.2006.3764" data-track-item_id="10.1098/rspb.2006.3764" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1098%2Frspb.2006.3764" aria-label="Article reference 60" data-doi="10.1098/rspb.2006.3764">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2sXktFOis7k%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 60">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 60" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Testosterone%20and%20oxidative%20stress%3A%20the%20oxidation%20handicap%20hypothesis&journal=Proc.%20R.%20Soc.%20B-Biol.%20Sci.&doi=10.1098%2Frspb.2006.3764&volume=274&pages=819-825&publication_year=2007&author=Alonso-Alvarez%2CC&author=Bertrand%2CS&author=Faivre%2CB&author=Chastel%2CO&author=Sorci%2CG"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="61."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR61">García-de Blas, E., Mateo, R., Viñuela, J., Pérez-Rodríguez, L. & Alonso-Alvarez, C. Free and esterified carotenoids in ornaments of an avian species: the relationship to color expression and sources of variability. <i>Physiol. Biochem. Zool.</i> <b>86</b>, 483–498 (2013).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1086/671812" data-track-item_id="10.1086/671812" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1086%2F671812" aria-label="Article reference 61" data-doi="10.1086/671812">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=23995480" aria-label="PubMed reference 61">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 61" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Free%20and%20esterified%20carotenoids%20in%20ornaments%20of%20an%20avian%20species%3A%20the%20relationship%20to%20color%20expression%20and%20sources%20of%20variability&journal=Physiol.%20Biochem.%20Zool.&doi=10.1086%2F671812&volume=86&pages=483-498&publication_year=2013&author=Garc%C3%ADa-de%20Blas%2CE&author=Mateo%2CR&author=Vi%C3%B1uela%2CJ&author=P%C3%A9rez-Rodr%C3%ADguez%2CL&author=Alonso-Alvarez%2CC"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="62."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR62">Negro, J. J., Sarasola, J. H., Fariñas, F. & Zorrilla, I. Function and occurrence of facial flushing in birds. <i>Comp. Biochem. Physiol. A Mol. Integr. Physiol.</i> <b>143</b>, 78–84 (2006).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/j.cbpa.2005.10.028" data-track-item_id="10.1016/j.cbpa.2005.10.028" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.cbpa.2005.10.028" aria-label="Article reference 62" data-doi="10.1016/j.cbpa.2005.10.028">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=16337158" aria-label="PubMed reference 62">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 62" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Function%20and%20occurrence%20of%20facial%20flushing%20in%20birds&journal=Comp.%20Biochem.%20Physiol.%20A%20Mol.%20Integr.%20Physiol.&doi=10.1016%2Fj.cbpa.2005.10.028&volume=143&pages=78-84&publication_year=2006&author=Negro%2CJJ&author=Sarasola%2CJH&author=Fari%C3%B1as%2CF&author=Zorrilla%2CI"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="63."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR63">Mundy, N. I. et al. Red carotenoid coloration in the zebra finch is controlled by a cytochrome P450 gene cluster. <i>Curr. Biol.</i> <b>26</b>, 1435–1440 (2016).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/j.cub.2016.04.047" data-track-item_id="10.1016/j.cub.2016.04.047" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.cub.2016.04.047" aria-label="Article reference 63" data-doi="10.1016/j.cub.2016.04.047">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BC28Xotlensbc%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 63">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=27212402" aria-label="PubMed reference 63">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 63" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Red%20carotenoid%20coloration%20in%20the%20zebra%20finch%20is%20controlled%20by%20a%20cytochrome%20P450%20gene%20cluster&journal=Curr.%20Biol.&doi=10.1016%2Fj.cub.2016.04.047&volume=26&pages=1435-1440&publication_year=2016&author=Mundy%2CNI"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="64."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR64">Lipsey, M. W. & Wilson, D. B. <i>Practical Meta-analysis. Applied Social Research Methods Series</i> Vol. 49 (Sage Publications, Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA, 2001).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="65."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR65">Cohen, J. <i>Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences</i>. (Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ, 1988).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="66."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR66">McGraw, K. J. & Hill, G. E. Differential effects of endoparasitism on the expression of carotenoid- and melanin-based ornamental coloration. <i>Proc. R. Soc. Biol. Sci. Ser. B</i> <b>267</b>, 1525–1531 (2000).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1098/rspb.2000.1174" data-track-item_id="10.1098/rspb.2000.1174" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1098%2Frspb.2000.1174" aria-label="Article reference 66" data-doi="10.1098/rspb.2000.1174">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:STN:280:DC%2BD3MrgslCgsA%3D%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 66">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 66" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Differential%20effects%20of%20endoparasitism%20on%20the%20expression%20of%20carotenoid-%20and%20melanin-based%20ornamental%20coloration&journal=Proc.%20R.%20Soc.%20Biol.%20Sci.%20Ser.%20B&doi=10.1098%2Frspb.2000.1174&volume=267&pages=1525-1531&publication_year=2000&author=McGraw%2CKJ&author=Hill%2CGE"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="67."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR67">Nakagawa, S. & Santos, E. S. A. Methodological issues and advances in biological meta-analysis. <i>Evol. Ecol.</i> <b>26</b>, 1253–1274 (2012).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="noopener" data-track-label="10.1007/s10682-012-9555-5" data-track-item_id="10.1007/s10682-012-9555-5" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://link.springer.com/doi/10.1007/s10682-012-9555-5" aria-label="Article reference 67" data-doi="10.1007/s10682-012-9555-5">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 67" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Methodological%20issues%20and%20advances%20in%20biological%20meta-analysis&journal=Evol.%20Ecol.&doi=10.1007%2Fs10682-012-9555-5&volume=26&pages=1253-1274&publication_year=2012&author=Nakagawa%2CS&author=Santos%2CESA"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="68."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR68">Brush, A. Metabolism of carotenoid pigments in birds. <i>Faseb. J.</i> <b>4</b>, 2969–2977 (1990).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DyaK3MXjvFCltw%3D%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 68">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=2394316" aria-label="PubMed reference 68">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 68" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Metabolism%20of%20carotenoid%20pigments%20in%20birds&journal=Faseb.%20J.&volume=4&pages=2969-2977&publication_year=1990&author=Brush%2CA"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="69."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR69">Montgomerie, R. in <i>Bird Coloration</i> Vol. 1 (eds Hill, G. E. & McGraw, K. J.) (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2006).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="70."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR70">Shawkey, M. D. & Hill, G. E. Carotenoids need structural colours to shine. <i>Biol. Lett.</i> <b>1</b>, 121–124 (2005).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1098/rsbl.2004.0289" data-track-item_id="10.1098/rsbl.2004.0289" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1098%2Frsbl.2004.0289" aria-label="Article reference 70" data-doi="10.1098/rsbl.2004.0289">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2MXpsVaqurc%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 70">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=17148144" aria-label="PubMed reference 70">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed central reference" data-track-action="pubmed central reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1626226" aria-label="PubMed Central reference 70">PubMed Central</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 70" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoids%20need%20structural%20colours%20to%20shine&journal=Biol.%20Lett.&doi=10.1098%2Frsbl.2004.0289&volume=1&pages=121-124&publication_year=2005&author=Shawkey%2CMD&author=Hill%2CGE"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="71."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR71">Hadfield, J. D. MCMC methods for multi-response generalized linear mixed models: The MCMCglmm R package. <i>J. Stat. Softw.</i> <b>33</b>, 1–22 (2010).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.18637/jss.v033.i02" data-track-item_id="10.18637/jss.v033.i02" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.18637%2Fjss.v033.i02" aria-label="Article reference 71" data-doi="10.18637/jss.v033.i02">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 71" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=MCMC%20methods%20for%20multi-response%20generalized%20linear%20mixed%20models%3A%20The%20MCMCglmm%20R%20package&journal=J.%20Stat.%20Softw.&doi=10.18637%2Fjss.v033.i02&volume=33&pages=1-22&publication_year=2010&author=Hadfield%2CJD"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="72."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR72">Hadfield, J. D. & Nakagawa, S. General quantitative genetic methods for comparative biology: Phylogenies, taxonomies and multi-trait models for continuous and categorical characters. <i>J. Evol. Biol.</i> <b>23</b>, 494–508 (2010).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1111/j.1420-9101.2009.01915.x" data-track-item_id="10.1111/j.1420-9101.2009.01915.x" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fj.1420-9101.2009.01915.x" aria-label="Article reference 72" data-doi="10.1111/j.1420-9101.2009.01915.x">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:STN:280:DC%2BC3czkvFWlsw%3D%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 72">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=20070460" aria-label="PubMed reference 72">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 72" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=General%20quantitative%20genetic%20methods%20for%20comparative%20biology%3A%20Phylogenies%2C%20taxonomies%20and%20multi-trait%20models%20for%20continuous%20and%20categorical%20characters&journal=J.%20Evol.%20Biol.&doi=10.1111%2Fj.1420-9101.2009.01915.x&volume=23&pages=494-508&publication_year=2010&author=Hadfield%2CJD&author=Nakagawa%2CS"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="73."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR73">R Core Team. R: a language and environment for statistical computing (R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria, 2017).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="74."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR74">Booksmythe, I., Mautz, B., Davis, J., Nakagawa, S. & Jennions, M. D. Facultative adjustment of the offspring sex ratio and male attractiveness: a systematic review and meta-analysis. <i>Biol. Rev.</i> <b>92</b>, 108–134 (2017).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1111/brv.12220" data-track-item_id="10.1111/brv.12220" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fbrv.12220" aria-label="Article reference 74" data-doi="10.1111/brv.12220">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=26405787" aria-label="PubMed reference 74">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 74" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Facultative%20adjustment%20of%20the%20offspring%20sex%20ratio%20and%20male%20attractiveness%3A%20a%20systematic%20review%20and%20meta-analysis&journal=Biol.%20Rev.&doi=10.1111%2Fbrv.12220&volume=92&pages=108-134&publication_year=2017&author=Booksmythe%2CI&author=Mautz%2CB&author=Davis%2CJ&author=Nakagawa%2CS&author=Jennions%2CMD"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="75."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR75">Jetz, W., Thomas, G. H., Joy, J. B., Hartmann, K. & Mooers, A. O. The global diversity of birds in space and time. <i>Nature</i> <b>491</b>, 444–448 (2012).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1038/nature11631" data-track-item_id="10.1038/nature11631" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1038%2Fnature11631" aria-label="Article reference 75" data-doi="10.1038/nature11631">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="ads reference" data-track-action="ads reference" href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?link_type=ABSTRACT&bibcode=2012Natur.491..444J" aria-label="ADS reference 75">ADS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:CAS:528:DC%2BC38Xhs1ajtrjJ" aria-label="CAS reference 75">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=23123857" aria-label="PubMed reference 75">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 75" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=The%20global%20diversity%20of%20birds%20in%20space%20and%20time&journal=Nature&doi=10.1038%2Fnature11631&volume=491&pages=444-448&publication_year=2012&author=Jetz%2CW&author=Thomas%2CGH&author=Joy%2CJB&author=Hartmann%2CK&author=Mooers%2CAO"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="76."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR76">Housworth, E. A., Martins, E. P. & Lynch, M. The phylogenetic mixed model. <i>Am. Nat.</i> <b>163</b>, 84–96 (2004).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1086/380570" data-track-item_id="10.1086/380570" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1086%2F380570" aria-label="Article reference 76" data-doi="10.1086/380570">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="pubmed reference" data-track-action="pubmed reference" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=14767838" aria-label="PubMed reference 76">PubMed</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 76" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=The%20phylogenetic%20mixed%20model&journal=Am.%20Nat.&doi=10.1086%2F380570&volume=163&pages=84-96&publication_year=2004&author=Housworth%2CEA&author=Martins%2CEP&author=Lynch%2CM"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="77."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR77">Egger, M., Smith, G. D., Schneider, M. & Minder, C. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. <i>Br. Med. J.</i> <b>315</b>, 629–634 (1997).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1136/bmj.315.7109.629" data-track-item_id="10.1136/bmj.315.7109.629" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1136%2Fbmj.315.7109.629" aria-label="Article reference 77" data-doi="10.1136/bmj.315.7109.629">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" data-track-value="cas reference" data-track-action="cas reference" href="/articles/cas-redirect/1:STN:280:DyaK2svls1KjtA%3D%3D" aria-label="CAS reference 77">CAS</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 77" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Bias%20in%20meta-analysis%20detected%20by%20a%20simple%2C%20graphical%20test&journal=Br.%20Med.%20J.&doi=10.1136%2Fbmj.315.7109.629&volume=315&pages=629-634&publication_year=1997&author=Egger%2CM&author=Smith%2CGD&author=Schneider%2CM&author=Minder%2CC"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="78."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR78">Weaver, R. J., Santos E.S.A., & Tucker, A.M. <i>Carotenoid Metabolism Strengthens the Link Between Feather Coloration and Individual Quality</i> <a href="https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5675431.v2" data-track="click_references" data-track-action="external reference" data-track-value="external reference" data-track-label="10.6084/m9.figshare.5675431.v2">https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5675431.v2</a> (2017).</p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="79."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR79">Stradi, R., Celentano, G., Boles, M. & Mercato, F. Carotenoids in bird plumage: The pattern in a series of red-pigmented carduelinae. <i>Comp. Biochem. Physiol. Part B Biochem. Mol. Biol.</i> <b>117</b>, 85–91 (1997).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/S0305-0491(96)00271-4" data-track-item_id="10.1016/S0305-0491(96)00271-4" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2FS0305-0491%2896%2900271-4" aria-label="Article reference 79" data-doi="10.1016/S0305-0491(96)00271-4">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 79" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoids%20in%20bird%20plumage%3A%20The%20pattern%20in%20a%20series%20of%20red-pigmented%20carduelinae&journal=Comp.%20Biochem.%20Physiol.%20Part%20B%20Biochem.%20Mol.%20Biol.&doi=10.1016%2FS0305-0491%2896%2900271-4&volume=117&pages=85-91&publication_year=1997&author=Stradi%2CR&author=Celentano%2CG&author=Boles%2CM&author=Mercato%2CF"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li><li class="c-article-references__item js-c-reading-companion-references-item" data-counter="80."><p class="c-article-references__text" id="ref-CR80">Stradi, R., Hudon, J., Celentano, G. & Pini, E. Carotenoids in bird plumage: the complement of yellow and red pigments in true woodpeckers (Picinae). <i>Comp. Biochem. Physiol. Part B Biochem. Mol. Biol.</i> <b>120</b>, 223–230 (1998).</p><p class="c-article-references__links u-hide-print"><a data-track="click_references" rel="nofollow noopener" data-track-label="10.1016/S0305-0491(98)10033-0" data-track-item_id="10.1016/S0305-0491(98)10033-0" data-track-value="article reference" data-track-action="article reference" href="https://doi.org/10.1016%2FS0305-0491%2898%2910033-0" aria-label="Article reference 80" data-doi="10.1016/S0305-0491(98)10033-0">Article</a> <a data-track="click_references" data-track-action="google scholar reference" data-track-value="google scholar reference" data-track-label="link" data-track-item_id="link" rel="nofollow noopener" aria-label="Google Scholar reference 80" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?&title=Carotenoids%20in%20bird%20plumage%3A%20the%20complement%20of%20yellow%20and%20red%20pigments%20in%20true%20woodpeckers%20%28Picinae%29&journal=Comp.%20Biochem.%20Physiol.%20Part%20B%20Biochem.%20Mol.%20Biol.&doi=10.1016%2FS0305-0491%2898%2910033-0&volume=120&pages=223-230&publication_year=1998&author=Stradi%2CR&author=Hudon%2CJ&author=Celentano%2CG&author=Pini%2CE"> Google Scholar</a> </p></li></ol><p class="c-article-references__download u-hide-print"><a data-track="click" data-track-action="download citation references" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow" href="https://citation-needed.springer.com/v2/references/10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z?format=refman&flavour=references">Download references<svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-download-medium"></use></svg></a></p></div></div></div></section></div><section data-title="Acknowledgements"><div class="c-article-section" id="Ack1-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Ack1">Acknowledgements</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Ack1-content"><p>Thanks to Shinichi Nakagawa for sharing R script files. Feedback from the Hill-Hood-Wada lab group improved previous drafts of this manuscript. G.E.H. was supported by the Department of Biological Sciences and the College of Science and Mathematics at Auburn University. A.E.W. was supported by the School of Fisheries, Aquaculture, and Aquatic Sciences and the College of Agriculture at Auburn University.</p></div></div></section><section aria-labelledby="author-information" data-title="Author information"><div class="c-article-section" id="author-information-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="author-information">Author information</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="author-information-content"><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="affiliations">Authors and Affiliations</h3><ol class="c-article-author-affiliation__list"><li id="Aff1"><p class="c-article-author-affiliation__address">Department of Biological Sciences, Auburn University, 331 Funchess Hall, Auburn, AL, 36849, USA</p><p class="c-article-author-affiliation__authors-list">Ryan J. Weaver & Geoffrey E. Hill</p></li><li id="Aff2"><p class="c-article-author-affiliation__address">BECO do Departamento de Zoologia, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, 05508-090, Brazil</p><p class="c-article-author-affiliation__authors-list">Eduardo S. A. Santos</p></li><li id="Aff3"><p class="c-article-author-affiliation__address">School of Forestry and Wildlife Sciences, Auburn University, 3301 SFWS Building, Auburn, AL, 36849, USA</p><p class="c-article-author-affiliation__authors-list">Anna M. Tucker</p></li><li id="Aff4"><p class="c-article-author-affiliation__address">School of Fisheries, Aquaculture, and Aquatic Sciences, Auburn University, 203 Swingle Hall, Auburn, AL, 36849, USA</p><p class="c-article-author-affiliation__authors-list">Alan E. Wilson</p></li></ol><div class="u-js-hide u-hide-print" data-test="author-info"><span class="c-article__sub-heading">Authors</span><ol class="c-article-authors-search u-list-reset"><li id="auth-Ryan_J_-Weaver-Aff1"><span class="c-article-authors-search__title u-h3 js-search-name">Ryan J. Weaver</span><div class="c-article-authors-search__list"><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--left"><a href="/search?author=Ryan%20J.%20Weaver" class="c-article-button" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - publication" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">View author publications</a></div><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--right"><p class="search-in-title-js c-article-authors-search__text">You can also search for this author in <span class="c-article-identifiers"><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=search&term=Ryan%20J.%20Weaver" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - pubmed" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">PubMed</a><span class="u-hide"> </span><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?as_q=&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=%22Ryan%20J.%20Weaver%22&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - scholar" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">Google Scholar</a></span></p></div></div></li><li id="auth-Eduardo_S__A_-Santos-Aff2"><span class="c-article-authors-search__title u-h3 js-search-name">Eduardo S. A. Santos</span><div class="c-article-authors-search__list"><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--left"><a href="/search?author=Eduardo%20S.%20A.%20Santos" class="c-article-button" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - publication" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">View author publications</a></div><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--right"><p class="search-in-title-js c-article-authors-search__text">You can also search for this author in <span class="c-article-identifiers"><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=search&term=Eduardo%20S.%20A.%20Santos" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - pubmed" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">PubMed</a><span class="u-hide"> </span><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?as_q=&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=%22Eduardo%20S.%20A.%20Santos%22&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - scholar" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">Google Scholar</a></span></p></div></div></li><li id="auth-Anna_M_-Tucker-Aff3"><span class="c-article-authors-search__title u-h3 js-search-name">Anna M. Tucker</span><div class="c-article-authors-search__list"><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--left"><a href="/search?author=Anna%20M.%20Tucker" class="c-article-button" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - publication" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">View author publications</a></div><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--right"><p class="search-in-title-js c-article-authors-search__text">You can also search for this author in <span class="c-article-identifiers"><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=search&term=Anna%20M.%20Tucker" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - pubmed" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">PubMed</a><span class="u-hide"> </span><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?as_q=&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=%22Anna%20M.%20Tucker%22&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - scholar" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">Google Scholar</a></span></p></div></div></li><li id="auth-Alan_E_-Wilson-Aff4"><span class="c-article-authors-search__title u-h3 js-search-name">Alan E. Wilson</span><div class="c-article-authors-search__list"><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--left"><a href="/search?author=Alan%20E.%20Wilson" class="c-article-button" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - publication" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">View author publications</a></div><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--right"><p class="search-in-title-js c-article-authors-search__text">You can also search for this author in <span class="c-article-identifiers"><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=search&term=Alan%20E.%20Wilson" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - pubmed" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">PubMed</a><span class="u-hide"> </span><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?as_q=&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=%22Alan%20E.%20Wilson%22&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - scholar" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">Google Scholar</a></span></p></div></div></li><li id="auth-Geoffrey_E_-Hill-Aff1"><span class="c-article-authors-search__title u-h3 js-search-name">Geoffrey E. Hill</span><div class="c-article-authors-search__list"><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--left"><a href="/search?author=Geoffrey%20E.%20Hill" class="c-article-button" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - publication" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">View author publications</a></div><div class="c-article-authors-search__item c-article-authors-search__list-item--right"><p class="search-in-title-js c-article-authors-search__text">You can also search for this author in <span class="c-article-identifiers"><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=search&term=Geoffrey%20E.%20Hill" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - pubmed" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">PubMed</a><span class="u-hide"> </span><a class="c-article-identifiers__item" href="http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?as_q=&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=%22Geoffrey%20E.%20Hill%22&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en" data-track="click" data-track-action="author link - scholar" data-track-label="link" rel="nofollow">Google Scholar</a></span></p></div></div></li></ol></div><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="contributions">Contributions</h3><p>R.J.W., G.E.H. and A.E.W.: Designed the study. R.J.W.: Collected the data. R.J.W., A.M.T. and E.S.A.S.S.: Performed the meta-analyses. R.J.W. and G.E.H.: Wrote the first draft of the manuscript, and all authors contributed substantially to revisions.</p><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="corresponding-author">Corresponding author</h3><p id="corresponding-author-list">Correspondence to <a id="corresp-c1" href="mailto:rjw0019@auburn.edu">Ryan J. Weaver</a>.</p></div></div></section><section data-title="Ethics declarations"><div class="c-article-section" id="ethics-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="ethics">Ethics declarations</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="ethics-content"> <h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="FPar1">Competing interests</h3> <p>The authors declare no competing financial interests.</p> </div></div></section><section data-title="Additional information"><div class="c-article-section" id="additional-information-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="additional-information">Additional information</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="additional-information-content"><p><b>Publisher's note:</b> Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.</p></div></div></section><section data-title="Electronic supplementary material"><div class="c-article-section" id="Sec21-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="Sec21">Electronic supplementary material</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="Sec21-content"><div data-test="supplementary-info"><div id="figshareContainer" class="c-article-figshare-container" data-test="figshare-container"></div><div class="c-article-supplementary__item" data-test="supp-item" id="MOESM1"><h3 class="c-article-supplementary__title u-h3"><a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view supplementary info" data-test="supp-info-link" data-track-label="supplementary information" href="https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_MOESM1_ESM.pdf" data-supp-info-image="">Supplementary Information</a></h3></div><div class="c-article-supplementary__item" data-test="supp-item" id="MOESM2"><h3 class="c-article-supplementary__title u-h3"><a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view supplementary info" data-test="supp-info-link" data-track-label="peer review file" href="https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_MOESM2_ESM.pdf" data-supp-info-image="">Peer Review File</a></h3></div><div class="c-article-supplementary__item" data-test="supp-item" id="MOESM3"><h3 class="c-article-supplementary__title u-h3"><a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view supplementary info" data-test="supp-info-link" data-track-label="description of additional supplementary files" href="https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_MOESM3_ESM.pdf" data-supp-info-image="">Description of Additional Supplementary Files</a></h3></div><div class="c-article-supplementary__item" data-test="supp-item" id="MOESM4"><h3 class="c-article-supplementary__title u-h3"><a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view supplementary info" data-test="supp-info-link" data-track-label="supplementary data 1" href="https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_MOESM4_ESM.csv" data-supp-info-image="">Supplementary Data 1</a></h3></div><div class="c-article-supplementary__item" data-test="supp-item" id="MOESM5"><h3 class="c-article-supplementary__title u-h3"><a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view supplementary info" data-test="supp-info-link" data-track-label="supplementary data 2" href="https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_MOESM5_ESM.xlsx" data-supp-info-image="">Supplementary Data 2</a></h3></div><div class="c-article-supplementary__item" data-test="supp-item" id="MOESM6"><h3 class="c-article-supplementary__title u-h3"><a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view supplementary info" data-test="supp-info-link" data-track-label="supplementary data 3" href="https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z/MediaObjects/41467_2017_2649_MOESM6_ESM.txt" data-supp-info-image="">Supplementary Data 3</a></h3></div></div></div></div></section><section data-title="Rights and permissions"><div class="c-article-section" id="rightslink-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="rightslink">Rights and permissions</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="rightslink-content"> <p><b>Open Access</b> This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit <a href="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" rel="license">http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/</a>.</p> <p class="c-article-rights"><a data-track="click" data-track-action="view rights and permissions" data-track-label="link" href="https://s100.copyright.com/AppDispatchServlet?title=Carotenoid%20metabolism%20strengthens%20the%20link%20between%20feather%20coloration%20and%20individual%20quality&author=Ryan%20J.%20Weaver%20et%20al&contentID=10.1038%2Fs41467-017-02649-z&copyright=The%20Author%28s%29&publication=2041-1723&publicationDate=2018-01-08&publisherName=SpringerNature&orderBeanReset=true&oa=CC%20BY">Reprints and permissions</a></p></div></div></section><section aria-labelledby="article-info" data-title="About this article"><div class="c-article-section" id="article-info-section"><h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="article-info">About this article</h2><div class="c-article-section__content" id="article-info-content"><div class="c-bibliographic-information"><div class="u-hide-print c-bibliographic-information__column c-bibliographic-information__column--border"><a data-crossmark="10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z" target="_blank" rel="noopener" href="https://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z" data-track="click" data-track-action="Click Crossmark" data-track-label="link" data-test="crossmark"><img loading="lazy" width="57" height="81" alt="Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark" src=""></a></div><div class="c-bibliographic-information__column"><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading" id="citeas">Cite this article</h3><p class="c-bibliographic-information__citation">Weaver, R.J., Santos, E.S.A., Tucker, A.M. <i>et al.</i> Carotenoid metabolism strengthens the link between feather coloration and individual quality. <i>Nat Commun</i> <b>9</b>, 73 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z</p><p class="c-bibliographic-information__download-citation u-hide-print"><a data-test="citation-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="download article citation" data-track-label="link" data-track-external="" rel="nofollow" href="https://citation-needed.springer.com/v2/references/10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z?format=refman&flavour=citation">Download citation<svg width="16" height="16" focusable="false" role="img" aria-hidden="true" class="u-icon"><use xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xlink:href="#icon-eds-i-download-medium"></use></svg></a></p><ul class="c-bibliographic-information__list" data-test="publication-history"><li class="c-bibliographic-information__list-item"><p>Received<span class="u-hide">: </span><span class="c-bibliographic-information__value"><time datetime="2017-08-24">24 August 2017</time></span></p></li><li class="c-bibliographic-information__list-item"><p>Accepted<span class="u-hide">: </span><span class="c-bibliographic-information__value"><time datetime="2017-12-15">15 December 2017</time></span></p></li><li class="c-bibliographic-information__list-item"><p>Published<span class="u-hide">: </span><span class="c-bibliographic-information__value"><time datetime="2018-01-08">08 January 2018</time></span></p></li><li class="c-bibliographic-information__list-item c-bibliographic-information__list-item--full-width"><p><abbr title="Digital Object Identifier">DOI</abbr><span class="u-hide">: </span><span class="c-bibliographic-information__value">https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z</span></p></li></ul><div data-component="share-box"><div class="c-article-share-box u-display-none" hidden=""><h3 class="c-article__sub-heading">Share this article</h3><p class="c-article-share-box__description">Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:</p><button class="js-get-share-url c-article-share-box__button" type="button" id="get-share-url" data-track="click" data-track-label="button" data-track-external="" data-track-action="get shareable link">Get shareable link</button><div class="js-no-share-url-container u-display-none" hidden=""><p class="js-c-article-share-box__no-sharelink-info c-article-share-box__no-sharelink-info">Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.</p></div><div class="js-share-url-container u-display-none" hidden=""><p class="js-share-url c-article-share-box__only-read-input" id="share-url" data-track="click" data-track-label="button" data-track-action="select share url"></p><button class="js-copy-share-url c-article-share-box__button--link-like" type="button" id="copy-share-url" data-track="click" data-track-label="button" data-track-action="copy share url" data-track-external="">Copy to clipboard</button></div><p class="js-c-article-share-box__additional-info c-article-share-box__additional-info"> Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative </p></div></div><div data-component="article-info-list"></div></div></div></div></div></section> </div> <section> <div class="c-article-section js-article-section" id="further-reading-section" data-test="further-reading-section"> <h2 class="c-article-section__title js-section-title js-c-reading-companion-sections-item" id="further-reading">This article is cited by</h2> <div class="c-article-section__content js-collapsible-section" id="further-reading-content"> <ul class="c-article-further-reading__list" id="further-reading-list"> <li class="c-article-further-reading__item js-ref-item"> <h3 class="c-article-further-reading__title" data-test="article-title"> <a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view further reading article" data-track-label="link:A bird’s-eye view reveals no fixed differences in plumage coloration between divergent populations of Painted Buntings" href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s10336-024-02232-6"> A bird’s-eye view reveals no fixed differences in plumage coloration between divergent populations of Painted Buntings </a> </h3> <ul data-test="author-list" class="c-author-list c-author-list--compact c-author-list--truncated u-sans-serif u-mb-4 u-mt-auto"> <li>Pawel Podkowa</li><li>Benedict G. Hogan</li><li>Geoffrey E. Hill</li> </ul> <p class="c-article-further-reading__journal-title"><i>Journal of Ornithology</i> (2024)</p> </li> <li class="c-article-further-reading__item js-ref-item"> <h3 class="c-article-further-reading__title" data-test="article-title"> <a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view further reading article" data-track-label="link:Plumage color degradation indicates reproductive effort: an experiment" href="https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-45348-0"> Plumage color degradation indicates reproductive effort: an experiment </a> </h3> <ul data-test="author-list" class="c-author-list c-author-list--compact c-author-list--truncated u-sans-serif u-mb-4 u-mt-auto"> <li>Gergely Hegyi</li><li>Miklós Laczi</li><li>János Török</li> </ul> <p class="c-article-further-reading__journal-title"><i>Scientific Reports</i> (2023)</p> </li> <li class="c-article-further-reading__item js-ref-item"> <h3 class="c-article-further-reading__title" data-test="article-title"> <a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view further reading article" data-track-label="link:Colouration matters in dull toads: ultraviolet adornment for ladies and agrochemicals fading effects" href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-023-05482-y"> Colouration matters in dull toads: ultraviolet adornment for ladies and agrochemicals fading effects </a> </h3> <ul data-test="author-list" class="c-author-list c-author-list--compact c-author-list--truncated u-sans-serif u-mb-4 u-mt-auto"> <li>Sabrina Tartu</li><li>Léa Lorrain-Soligon</li><li>François Brischoux</li> </ul> <p class="c-article-further-reading__journal-title"><i>Oecologia</i> (2023)</p> </li> <li class="c-article-further-reading__item js-ref-item"> <h3 class="c-article-further-reading__title" data-test="article-title"> <a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view further reading article" data-track-label="link:Delayed plumage signals social status in a mutually ornamented bird" href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s10336-022-02035-7"> Delayed plumage signals social status in a mutually ornamented bird </a> </h3> <ul data-test="author-list" class="c-author-list c-author-list--compact c-author-list--truncated u-sans-serif u-mb-4 u-mt-auto"> <li>Bruna Araújo-Silva</li><li>Marcello Barcellos</li><li>Pedro Diniz</li> </ul> <p class="c-article-further-reading__journal-title"><i>Journal of Ornithology</i> (2023)</p> </li> <li class="c-article-further-reading__item js-ref-item"> <h3 class="c-article-further-reading__title" data-test="article-title"> <a class="print-link" data-track="click" data-track-action="view further reading article" data-track-label="link:Integument colouration and circulating carotenoids in relation to urbanisation in Eurasian kestrels (Falco tinnunculus)" href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s00114-023-01874-5"> Integument colouration and circulating carotenoids in relation to urbanisation in Eurasian kestrels (Falco tinnunculus) </a> </h3> <ul data-test="author-list" class="c-author-list c-author-list--compact c-author-list--truncated u-sans-serif u-mb-4 u-mt-auto"> <li>Petra Sumasgutner</li><li>Tom Nilles</li><li>Leonida Fusani</li> </ul> <p class="c-article-further-reading__journal-title"><i>The Science of Nature</i> (2023)</p> </li> </ul> </div> </div> </section> </div> </article> </main> <aside class="c-article-extras u-hide-print" aria-label="Article navigation" data-component-reading-companion data-container-type="reading-companion" data-track-component="reading companion"> <div class="js-context-bar-sticky-point-desktop" data-track-context="reading companion"> <div class="c-pdf-download u-clear-both js-pdf-download"> <a href="/articles/s41467-017-02649-z.pdf" class="u-button u-button--full-width u-button--primary u-justify-content-space-between c-pdf-download__link" data-article-pdf="true" data-readcube-pdf-url="true" data-test="download-pdf" data-draft-ignore="true" data-track="content_download" data-track-type="article pdf download" data-track-action="download pdf" data-track-label="link" data-track-external download> <span class="c-pdf-download__text">Download PDF</span> <svg aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" width="16" height="16" class="u-icon"><use xlink:href="#icon-download"/></svg> </a> </div> </div> <div class="c-reading-companion"> <div class="c-reading-companion__sticky" data-component="reading-companion-sticky" data-test="reading-companion-sticky"> <div class="c-reading-companion__panel c-reading-companion__sections c-reading-companion__panel--active" id="tabpanel-sections"> <div class="u-lazy-ad-wrapper u-mt-16 u-hide" data-component-mpu> <div class="c-ad c-ad--300x250"> <div class="c-ad__inner"> <p class="c-ad__label">Advertisement</p> <div id="div-gpt-ad-right-2" class="div-gpt-ad advert medium-rectangle js-ad text-center hide-print grade-c-hide" data-ad-type="right" data-test="right-ad" data-pa11y-ignore data-gpt data-gpt-unitpath="/285/nature_communications/article" data-gpt-sizes="300x250" data-gpt-targeting="type=article;pos=right;artid=s41467-017-02649-z;doi=10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z;techmeta=141;subjmeta=158,181,2470,631,856;kwrd=Behavioural+ecology,Sexual+selection"> <noscript> <a href="//pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/jump?iu=/285/nature_communications/article&sz=300x250&c=-528619353&t=pos%3Dright%26type%3Darticle%26artid%3Ds41467-017-02649-z%26doi%3D10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z%26techmeta%3D141%26subjmeta%3D158,181,2470,631,856%26kwrd%3DBehavioural+ecology,Sexual+selection"> <img data-test="gpt-advert-fallback-img" src="//pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/ad?iu=/285/nature_communications/article&sz=300x250&c=-528619353&t=pos%3Dright%26type%3Darticle%26artid%3Ds41467-017-02649-z%26doi%3D10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z%26techmeta%3D141%26subjmeta%3D158,181,2470,631,856%26kwrd%3DBehavioural+ecology,Sexual+selection" alt="Advertisement" width="300" height="250"></a> </noscript> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="c-reading-companion__panel c-reading-companion__figures c-reading-companion__panel--full-width" id="tabpanel-figures"></div> <div class="c-reading-companion__panel c-reading-companion__references c-reading-companion__panel--full-width" id="tabpanel-references"></div> </div> </div> </aside> </div> <nav class="c-header__dropdown" aria-labelledby="Explore-content" data-test="Explore-content" id="explore" data-track-component="nature-150-split-header"> <div class="c-header__container"> <h2 id="Explore-content" class="c-header__heading c-header__heading--js-hide">Explore content</h2> <ul class="c-header__list c-header__list--js-stack"> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/research-articles" data-track="click" data-track-action="research articles" data-track-label="link" data-test="explore-nav-item"> Research articles </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/reviews-and-analysis" data-track="click" data-track-action="reviews & analysis" data-track-label="link" data-test="explore-nav-item"> Reviews & Analysis </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/news-and-comment" data-track="click" data-track-action="news & comment" data-track-label="link" data-test="explore-nav-item"> News & Comment </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/video" data-track="click" data-track-action="videos" data-track-label="link" data-test="explore-nav-item"> Videos </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/collections" data-track="click" data-track-action="collections" data-track-label="link" data-test="explore-nav-item"> Collections </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/browse-subjects" data-track="click" data-track-action="subjects" data-track-label="link" data-test="explore-nav-item"> Subjects </a> </li> </ul> <ul class="c-header__list c-header__list--js-stack"> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="https://www.facebook.com/NatureCommunications" data-track="click" data-track-action="facebook" data-track-label="link">Follow us on Facebook </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="https://twitter.com/NatureComms" data-track="click" data-track-action="twitter" data-track-label="link">Follow us on Twitter </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item c-header__item--hide-lg"> <a class="c-header__link" href="https://www.nature.com/my-account/alerts/subscribe-journal?list-id=264" rel="nofollow" data-track="click" data-track-action="Sign up for alerts" data-track-external data-track-label="link (mobile dropdown)">Sign up for alerts<svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="18" viewBox="0 0 18 18" width="18" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="m4 10h2.5c.27614237 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-3.08578644l-1.12132034 1.1213203c-.18753638.1875364-.29289322.4418903-.29289322.7071068v.1715729h14v-.1715729c0-.2652165-.1053568-.5195704-.2928932-.7071068l-1.7071068-1.7071067v-3.4142136c0-2.76142375-2.2385763-5-5-5-2.76142375 0-5 2.23857625-5 5zm3 4c0 1.1045695.8954305 2 2 2s2-.8954305 2-2zm-5 0c-.55228475 0-1-.4477153-1-1v-.1715729c0-.530433.21071368-1.0391408.58578644-1.4142135l1.41421356-1.4142136v-3c0-3.3137085 2.6862915-6 6-6s6 2.6862915 6 6v3l1.4142136 1.4142136c.3750727.3750727.5857864.8837805.5857864 1.4142135v.1715729c0 .5522847-.4477153 1-1 1h-4c0 1.6568542-1.3431458 3-3 3-1.65685425 0-3-1.3431458-3-3z" fill="#fff"/></svg> </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item c-header__item--hide-lg"> <a class="c-header__link" href="https://www.nature.com/ncomms.rss" data-track="click" data-track-action="rss feed" data-track-label="link"> <span>RSS feed</span> </a> </li> </ul> </div> </nav> <nav class="c-header__dropdown" aria-labelledby="About-the-journal" id="about-the-journal" data-test="about-the-journal" data-track-component="nature-150-split-header"> <div class="c-header__container"> <h2 id="About-the-journal" class="c-header__heading c-header__heading--js-hide">About the journal</h2> <ul class="c-header__list c-header__list--js-stack"> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/aims" data-track="click" data-track-action="aims & scope" data-track-label="link"> Aims & Scope </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/editors" data-track="click" data-track-action="editors" data-track-label="link"> Editors </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/journal-information" data-track="click" data-track-action="journal information" data-track-label="link"> Journal Information </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/open-access" data-track="click" data-track-action="open access fees and funding" data-track-label="link"> Open Access Fees and Funding </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/calls-for-papers" data-track="click" data-track-action="calls for papers" data-track-label="link"> Calls for Papers </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/editorial-values-statement" data-track="click" data-track-action="editorial values statement" data-track-label="link"> Editorial Values Statement </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/journal-impact" data-track="click" data-track-action="journal metrics" data-track-label="link"> Journal Metrics </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/editorshighlights" data-track="click" data-track-action="editors' highlights" data-track-label="link"> Editors' Highlights </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/contact" data-track="click" data-track-action="contact" data-track-label="link"> Contact </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/editorial-policies" data-track="click" data-track-action="editorial policies" data-track-label="link"> Editorial policies </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/top-articles" data-track="click" data-track-action="top articles" data-track-label="link"> Top Articles </a> </li> </ul> </div> </nav> <nav class="c-header__dropdown" aria-labelledby="Publish-with-us-label" id="publish-with-us" data-test="publish-with-us" data-track-component="nature-150-split-header"> <div class="c-header__container"> <h2 id="Publish-with-us-label" class="c-header__heading c-header__heading--js-hide">Publish with us</h2> <ul class="c-header__list c-header__list--js-stack"> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/submit" data-track="click" data-track-action="for authors" data-track-label="link"> For authors </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/ncomms/for-reviewers" data-track="click" data-track-action="for reviewers" data-track-label="link"> For Reviewers </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item"> <a class="c-header__link" data-test="nature-author-services" data-track="nav_language_services" data-track-context="header publish with us dropdown menu" data-track-action="manuscript author services" data-track-label="link manuscript author services" href="https://authorservices.springernature.com/go/sn/?utm_source=For+Authors&utm_medium=Website_Nature&utm_campaign=Platform+Experimentation+2022&utm_id=PE2022"> Language editing services </a> </li> <li class="c-header__item c-header__item--keyline"> <a class="c-header__link" href="https://mts-ncomms.nature.com/" data-track="click_submit_manuscript" data-track-context="submit link in Nature header dropdown menu" data-track-action="submit manuscript" data-track-label="link (publish with us dropdown menu)" data-track-external>Submit manuscript<svg role="img" aria-hidden="true" focusable="false" height="18" viewBox="0 0 18 18" width="18" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="m15 0c1.1045695 0 2 .8954305 2 2v5.5c0 .27614237-.2238576.5-.5.5s-.5-.22385763-.5-.5v-5.5c0-.51283584-.3860402-.93550716-.8833789-.99327227l-.1166211-.00672773h-9v3c0 1.1045695-.8954305 2-2 2h-3v10c0 .5128358.38604019.9355072.88337887.9932723l.11662113.0067277h7.5c.27614237 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-7.5c-1.1045695 0-2-.8954305-2-2v-10.17157288c0-.53043297.21071368-1.0391408.58578644-1.41421356l3.82842712-3.82842712c.37507276-.37507276.88378059-.58578644 1.41421356-.58578644zm-.5442863 8.18867991 3.3545404 3.35454039c.2508994.2508994.2538696.6596433.0035959.909917-.2429543.2429542-.6561449.2462671-.9065387-.0089489l-2.2609825-2.3045251.0010427 7.2231989c0 .3569916-.2898381.6371378-.6473715.6371378-.3470771 0-.6473715-.2852563-.6473715-.6371378l-.0010428-7.2231995-2.2611222 2.3046654c-.2531661.2580415-.6562868.2592444-.9065605.0089707-.24295423-.2429542-.24865597-.6576651.0036132-.9099343l3.3546673-3.35466731c.2509089-.25090888.6612706-.25227691.9135302-.00001728zm-.9557137-3.18867991c.2761424 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.2238576.5-.5.5h-6c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5zm-8.5-3.587-3.587 3.587h2.587c.55228475 0 1-.44771525 1-1zm8.5 1.587c.2761424 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.2238576.5-.5.5h-6c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5z" fill="#fff"/></svg> </a> </li> </ul> </div> </nav> <div id="search-menu" class="c-header__dropdown c-header__dropdown--full-width" data-track-component="nature-150-split-header"> <div class="c-header__container"> <h2 class="c-header__visually-hidden">Search</h2> <form class="c-header__search-form" action="/search" method="get" role="search" autocomplete="off" data-test="inline-search"> <label class="c-header__heading" for="keywords">Search articles by subject, keyword or author</label> <div class="c-header__search-layout c-header__search-layout--max-width"> <div> <input type="text" required="" class="c-header__input" id="keywords" name="q" value=""> </div> <div class="c-header__search-layout"> <div> <label for="results-from" class="c-header__visually-hidden">Show results from</label> <select id="results-from" name="journal" class="c-header__select"> <option value="" selected>All journals</option> <option value="ncomms">This journal</option> </select> </div> <div> <button type="submit" class="c-header__search-button">Search</button> </div> </div> </div> </form> <div class="c-header__flush"> <a class="c-header__link" href="/search/advanced" data-track="click" data-track-action="advanced search" data-track-label="link"> Advanced search </a> </div> <h3 class="c-header__heading c-header__heading--keyline">Quick links</h3> <ul class="c-header__list"> <li><a class="c-header__link" href="/subjects" data-track="click" data-track-action="explore articles by subject" data-track-label="link">Explore articles by subject</a></li> <li><a class="c-header__link" href="/naturecareers" data-track="click" data-track-action="find a job" data-track-label="link">Find a job</a></li> <li><a class="c-header__link" href="/authors/index.html" data-track="click" data-track-action="guide to authors" data-track-label="link">Guide to authors</a></li> <li><a class="c-header__link" href="/authors/editorial_policies/" data-track="click" data-track-action="editorial policies" data-track-label="link">Editorial policies</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> <footer class="composite-layer" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/Periodical"> <meta itemprop="publisher" content="Springer Nature"> <div class="u-mt-16 u-mb-16"> <div class="u-container"> <div class="u-display-flex u-flex-wrap u-justify-content-space-between"> <p class="c-meta u-ma-0 u-flex-shrink"> <span class="c-meta__item"> Nature Communications (<i>Nat Commun</i>) </span> <span class="c-meta__item"> <abbr title="International Standard Serial Number">ISSN</abbr> <span itemprop="onlineIssn">2041-1723</span> (online) </span> </p> </div> </div> </div> <div class="c-footer"> <div class="u-hide-print" data-track-component="footer"> <h2 class="u-visually-hidden">nature.com sitemap</h2> <div class="c-footer__container"> <div class="c-footer__grid c-footer__group--separator"> <div class="c-footer__group"> <h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">About Nature Portfolio</h3> <ul class="c-footer__list"> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/npg_/company_info/index.html" data-track="click" data-track-action="about us" data-track-label="link">About us</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/npg_/press_room/press_releases.html" data-track="click" data-track-action="press releases" data-track-label="link">Press releases</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://press.nature.com/" data-track="click" data-track-action="press office" data-track-label="link">Press office</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://support.nature.com/support/home" data-track="click" data-track-action="contact us" data-track-label="link">Contact us</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="c-footer__group"> <h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Discover content</h3> <ul class="c-footer__list"> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/siteindex" data-track="click" data-track-action="journals a-z" data-track-label="link">Journals A-Z</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/subjects" data-track="click" data-track-action="article by subject" data-track-label="link">Articles by subject</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.protocols.io/" data-track="click" data-track-action="protocols.io" data-track-label="link">protocols.io</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.natureindex.com/" data-track="click" data-track-action="nature index" data-track-label="link">Nature Index</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="c-footer__group"> <h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Publishing policies</h3> <ul class="c-footer__list"> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/authors/editorial_policies" data-track="click" data-track-action="Nature portfolio policies" data-track-label="link">Nature portfolio policies</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/nature-research/open-access" data-track="click" data-track-action="open access" data-track-label="link">Open access</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="c-footer__group"> <h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Author & Researcher services</h3> <ul class="c-footer__list"> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/reprints" data-track="click" data-track-action="reprints and permissions" data-track-label="link">Reprints & permissions</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.springernature.com/gp/authors/research-data" data-track="click" data-track-action="data research service" data-track-label="link">Research data</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://authorservices.springernature.com/language-editing/" data-track="click" data-track-action="language editing" data-track-label="link">Language editing</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://authorservices.springernature.com/scientific-editing/" data-track="click" data-track-action="scientific editing" data-track-label="link">Scientific editing</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://masterclasses.nature.com/" data-track="click" data-track-action="nature masterclasses" data-track-label="link">Nature Masterclasses</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://solutions.springernature.com/" data-track="click" data-track-action="research solutions" data-track-label="link">Research Solutions</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="c-footer__group"> <h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Libraries & institutions</h3> <ul class="c-footer__list"> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.springernature.com/gp/librarians/tools-services" data-track="click" data-track-action="librarian service and tools" data-track-label="link">Librarian service & tools</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.springernature.com/gp/librarians/manage-your-account/librarianportal" data-track="click" data-track-action="librarian portal" data-track-label="link">Librarian portal</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/openresearch/about-open-access/information-for-institutions" data-track="click" data-track-action="open research" data-track-label="link">Open research</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.springernature.com/gp/librarians/recommend-to-your-library" data-track="click" data-track-action="Recommend to library" data-track-label="link">Recommend to library</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="c-footer__group"> <h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Advertising & partnerships</h3> <ul class="c-footer__list"> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://partnerships.nature.com/product/digital-advertising/" data-track="click" data-track-action="advertising" data-track-label="link">Advertising</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://partnerships.nature.com/" data-track="click" data-track-action="partnerships and services" data-track-label="link">Partnerships & Services</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://partnerships.nature.com/media-kits/" data-track="click" data-track-action="media kits" data-track-label="link">Media kits</a> </li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://partnerships.nature.com/product/branded-content-native-advertising/" data-track-action="branded content" data-track-label="link">Branded content</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="c-footer__group"> <h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Professional development</h3> <ul class="c-footer__list"> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/naturecareers/" data-track="click" data-track-action="nature careers" data-track-label="link">Nature Careers</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://conferences.nature.com" data-track="click" data-track-action="nature conferences" data-track-label="link">Nature<span class="u-visually-hidden"> </span> Conferences</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="c-footer__group"> <h3 class="c-footer__heading u-mt-0">Regional websites</h3> <ul class="c-footer__list"> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/natafrica" data-track="click" data-track-action="nature africa" data-track-label="link">Nature Africa</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="http://www.naturechina.com" data-track="click" data-track-action="nature china" data-track-label="link">Nature China</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/nindia" data-track="click" data-track-action="nature india" data-track-label="link">Nature India</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/natitaly" data-track="click" data-track-action="nature Italy" data-track-label="link">Nature Italy</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.natureasia.com/ja-jp" data-track="click" data-track-action="nature japan" data-track-label="link">Nature Japan</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/nmiddleeast" data-track="click" data-track-action="nature middle east" data-track-label="link">Nature Middle East</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> </div> <div class="c-footer__container"> <ul class="c-footer__links"> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/info/privacy" data-track="click" data-track-action="privacy policy" data-track-label="link">Privacy Policy</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/info/cookies" data-track="click" data-track-action="use of cookies" data-track-label="link">Use of cookies</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"> <button class="optanon-toggle-display c-footer__link" onclick="javascript:;" data-cc-action="preferences" data-track="click" data-track-action="manage cookies" data-track-label="link">Your privacy choices/Manage cookies </button> </li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/info/legal-notice" data-track="click" data-track-action="legal notice" data-track-label="link">Legal notice</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/info/accessibility-statement" data-track="click" data-track-action="accessibility statement" data-track-label="link">Accessibility statement</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.nature.com/info/terms-and-conditions" data-track="click" data-track-action="terms and conditions" data-track-label="link">Terms & Conditions</a></li> <li class="c-footer__item"><a class="c-footer__link" href="https://www.springernature.com/ccpa" data-track="click" data-track-action="california privacy statement" data-track-label="link">Your US state privacy rights</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> <div class="c-footer__container"> <a href="https://www.springernature.com/" class="c-footer__link"> <img src="/static/images/logos/sn-logo-white-ea63208b81.svg" alt="Springer Nature" loading="lazy" width="200" height="20"/> </a> <p class="c-footer__legal" data-test="copyright">© 2024 Springer Nature Limited</p> </div> </div> <div class="u-visually-hidden" aria-hidden="true"> <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><!DOCTYPE svg PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD SVG 1.1//EN" "http://www.w3.org/Graphics/SVG/1.1/DTD/svg11.dtd"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><defs><path id="a" d="M0 .74h56.72v55.24H0z"/></defs><symbol id="icon-access" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m14 8c.5522847 0 1 .44771525 1 1v7h2.5c.2761424 0 .5.2238576.5.5v1.5h-18v-1.5c0-.2761424.22385763-.5.5-.5h2.5v-7c0-.55228475.44771525-1 1-1s1 .44771525 1 1v6.9996556h8v-6.9996556c0-.55228475.4477153-1 1-1zm-8 0 2 1v5l-2 1zm6 0v7l-2-1v-5zm-2.42653766-7.59857636 7.03554716 4.92488299c.4162533.29137735.5174853.86502537.226108 1.28127873-.1721584.24594054-.4534847.39241464-.7536934.39241464h-14.16284822c-.50810197 0-.92-.41189803-.92-.92 0-.30020869.1464741-.58153499.39241464-.75369337l7.03554714-4.92488299c.34432015-.2410241.80260453-.2410241 1.14692468 0zm-.57346234 2.03988748-3.65526982 2.55868888h7.31053962z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-account" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m10.2379028 16.9048051c1.3083556-.2032362 2.5118471-.7235183 3.5294683-1.4798399-.8731327-2.5141501-2.0638925-3.935978-3.7673711-4.3188248v-1.27684611c1.1651924-.41183641 2-1.52307546 2-2.82929429 0-1.65685425-1.3431458-3-3-3-1.65685425 0-3 1.34314575-3 3 0 1.30621883.83480763 2.41745788 2 2.82929429v1.27684611c-1.70347856.3828468-2.89423845 1.8046747-3.76737114 4.3188248 1.01762123.7563216 2.22111275 1.2766037 3.52946833 1.4798399.40563808.0629726.81921174.0951949 1.23790281.0951949s.83226473-.0322223 1.2379028-.0951949zm4.3421782-2.1721994c1.4927655-1.4532925 2.419919-3.484675 2.419919-5.7326057 0-4.418278-3.581722-8-8-8s-8 3.581722-8 8c0 2.2479307.92715352 4.2793132 2.41991895 5.7326057.75688473-2.0164459 1.83949951-3.6071894 3.48926591-4.3218837-1.14534283-.70360829-1.90918486-1.96796271-1.90918486-3.410722 0-2.209139 1.790861-4 4-4s4 1.790861 4 4c0 1.44275929-.763842 2.70711371-1.9091849 3.410722 1.6497664.7146943 2.7323812 2.3054378 3.4892659 4.3218837zm-5.580081 3.2673943c-4.97056275 0-9-4.0294373-9-9 0-4.97056275 4.02943725-9 9-9 4.9705627 0 9 4.02943725 9 9 0 4.9705627-4.0294373 9-9 9z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-alert" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m4 10h2.5c.27614237 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-3.08578644l-1.12132034 1.1213203c-.18753638.1875364-.29289322.4418903-.29289322.7071068v.1715729h14v-.1715729c0-.2652165-.1053568-.5195704-.2928932-.7071068l-1.7071068-1.7071067v-3.4142136c0-2.76142375-2.2385763-5-5-5-2.76142375 0-5 2.23857625-5 5zm3 4c0 1.1045695.8954305 2 2 2s2-.8954305 2-2zm-5 0c-.55228475 0-1-.4477153-1-1v-.1715729c0-.530433.21071368-1.0391408.58578644-1.4142135l1.41421356-1.4142136v-3c0-3.3137085 2.6862915-6 6-6s6 2.6862915 6 6v3l1.4142136 1.4142136c.3750727.3750727.5857864.8837805.5857864 1.4142135v.1715729c0 .5522847-.4477153 1-1 1h-4c0 1.6568542-1.3431458 3-3 3-1.65685425 0-3-1.3431458-3-3z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-arrow-broad" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m6.10307866 2.97190702v7.69043288l2.44965196-2.44676915c.38776071-.38730439 1.0088052-.39493524 1.38498697-.01919617.38609051.38563612.38643641 1.01053024-.00013864 1.39665039l-4.12239817 4.11754683c-.38616704.3857126-1.01187344.3861062-1.39846576-.0000311l-4.12258206-4.11773056c-.38618426-.38572979-.39254614-1.00476697-.01636437-1.38050605.38609047-.38563611 1.01018509-.38751562 1.4012233.00306241l2.44985644 2.4469734v-8.67638639c0-.54139983.43698413-.98042709.98493125-.98159081l7.89910522-.0043627c.5451687 0 .9871152.44142642.9871152.98595351s-.4419465.98595351-.9871152.98595351z" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(-1 0 0 -1 14 15)"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-arrow-down" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m3.28337502 11.5302405 4.03074001 4.176208c.37758093.3912076.98937525.3916069 1.367372-.0000316l4.03091977-4.1763942c.3775978-.3912252.3838182-1.0190815.0160006-1.4001736-.3775061-.39113013-.9877245-.39303641-1.3700683.003106l-2.39538585 2.4818345v-11.6147896l-.00649339-.11662112c-.055753-.49733869-.46370161-.88337888-.95867408-.88337888-.49497246 0-.90292107.38604019-.95867408.88337888l-.00649338.11662112v11.6147896l-2.39518594-2.4816273c-.37913917-.39282218-.98637524-.40056175-1.35419292-.0194697-.37750607.3911302-.37784433 1.0249269.00013556 1.4165479z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-arrow-left" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m4.46975946 3.28337502-4.17620792 4.03074001c-.39120768.37758093-.39160691.98937525.0000316 1.367372l4.1763942 4.03091977c.39122514.3775978 1.01908149.3838182 1.40017357.0160006.39113012-.3775061.3930364-.9877245-.00310603-1.3700683l-2.48183446-2.39538585h11.61478958l.1166211-.00649339c.4973387-.055753.8833789-.46370161.8833789-.95867408 0-.49497246-.3860402-.90292107-.8833789-.95867408l-.1166211-.00649338h-11.61478958l2.4816273-2.39518594c.39282216-.37913917.40056173-.98637524.01946965-1.35419292-.39113012-.37750607-1.02492687-.37784433-1.41654791.00013556z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-arrow-right" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m11.5302405 12.716625 4.176208-4.03074003c.3912076-.37758093.3916069-.98937525-.0000316-1.367372l-4.1763942-4.03091981c-.3912252-.37759778-1.0190815-.38381821-1.4001736-.01600053-.39113013.37750607-.39303641.98772445.003106 1.37006824l2.4818345 2.39538588h-11.6147896l-.11662112.00649339c-.49733869.055753-.88337888.46370161-.88337888.95867408 0 .49497246.38604019.90292107.88337888.95867408l.11662112.00649338h11.6147896l-2.4816273 2.39518592c-.39282218.3791392-.40056175.9863753-.0194697 1.3541929.3911302.3775061 1.0249269.3778444 1.4165479-.0001355z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-arrow-sub" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m7.89692134 4.97190702v7.69043288l-2.44965196-2.4467692c-.38776071-.38730434-1.0088052-.39493519-1.38498697-.0191961-.38609047.3856361-.38643643 1.0105302.00013864 1.3966504l4.12239817 4.1175468c.38616704.3857126 1.01187344.3861062 1.39846576-.0000311l4.12258202-4.1177306c.3861843-.3857298.3925462-1.0047669.0163644-1.380506-.3860905-.38563612-1.0101851-.38751563-1.4012233.0030624l-2.44985643 2.4469734v-8.67638639c0-.54139983-.43698413-.98042709-.98493125-.98159081l-7.89910525-.0043627c-.54516866 0-.98711517.44142642-.98711517.98595351s.44194651.98595351.98711517.98595351z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-arrow-up" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m12.716625 4.46975946-4.03074003-4.17620792c-.37758093-.39120768-.98937525-.39160691-1.367372.0000316l-4.03091981 4.1763942c-.37759778.39122514-.38381821 1.01908149-.01600053 1.40017357.37750607.39113012.98772445.3930364 1.37006824-.00310603l2.39538588-2.48183446v11.61478958l.00649339.1166211c.055753.4973387.46370161.8833789.95867408.8833789.49497246 0 .90292107-.3860402.95867408-.8833789l.00649338-.1166211v-11.61478958l2.39518592 2.4816273c.3791392.39282216.9863753.40056173 1.3541929.01946965.3775061-.39113012.3778444-1.02492687-.0001355-1.41654791z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-article" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m13 15v-12.9906311c0-.0073595-.0019884-.0093689.0014977-.0093689l-11.00158888.00087166v13.00506804c0 .5482678.44615281.9940603.99415146.9940603h10.27350412c-.1701701-.2941734-.2675644-.6357129-.2675644-1zm-12 .0059397v-13.00506804c0-.5562408.44704472-1.00087166.99850233-1.00087166h11.00299537c.5510129 0 .9985023.45190985.9985023 1.0093689v2.9906311h3v9.9914698c0 1.1065798-.8927712 2.0085302-1.9940603 2.0085302h-12.01187942c-1.09954652 0-1.99406028-.8927712-1.99406028-1.9940603zm13-9.0059397v9c0 .5522847.4477153 1 1 1s1-.4477153 1-1v-9zm-10-2h7v4h-7zm1 1v2h5v-2zm-1 4h7v1h-7zm0 2h7v1h-7zm0 2h7v1h-7z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-audio" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m13.0957477 13.5588459c-.195279.1937043-.5119137.193729-.7072234.0000551-.1953098-.193674-.1953346-.5077061-.0000556-.7014104 1.0251004-1.0168342 1.6108711-2.3905226 1.6108711-3.85745208 0-1.46604976-.5850634-2.83898246-1.6090736-3.85566829-.1951894-.19379323-.1950192-.50782531.0003802-.70141028.1953993-.19358497.512034-.19341614.7072234.00037709 1.2094886 1.20083761 1.901635 2.8250555 1.901635 4.55670148 0 1.73268608-.6929822 3.35779608-1.9037571 4.55880738zm2.1233994 2.1025159c-.195234.193749-.5118687.1938462-.7072235.0002171-.1953548-.1936292-.1954528-.5076613-.0002189-.7014104 1.5832215-1.5711805 2.4881302-3.6939808 2.4881302-5.96012998 0-2.26581266-.9046382-4.3883241-2.487443-5.95944795-.1952117-.19377107-.1950777-.50780316.0002993-.70141031s.5120117-.19347426.7072234.00029682c1.7683321 1.75528196 2.7800854 4.12911258 2.7800854 6.66056144 0 2.53182498-1.0120556 4.90597838-2.7808529 6.66132328zm-14.21898205-3.6854911c-.5523759 0-1.00016505-.4441085-1.00016505-.991944v-3.96777631c0-.54783558.44778915-.99194407 1.00016505-.99194407h2.0003301l5.41965617-3.8393633c.44948677-.31842296 1.07413994-.21516983 1.39520191.23062232.12116339.16823446.18629727.36981184.18629727.57655577v12.01603479c0 .5478356-.44778914.9919441-1.00016505.9919441-.20845738 0-.41170538-.0645985-.58133413-.184766l-5.41965617-3.8393633zm0-.991944h2.32084805l5.68047235 4.0241292v-12.01603479l-5.68047235 4.02412928h-2.32084805z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-block" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="m0 0h24v24h-24z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-book" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m4 13v-11h1v11h11v-11h-13c-.55228475 0-1 .44771525-1 1v10.2675644c.29417337-.1701701.63571286-.2675644 1-.2675644zm12 1h-13c-.55228475 0-1 .4477153-1 1s.44771525 1 1 1h13zm0 3h-13c-1.1045695 0-2-.8954305-2-2v-12c0-1.1045695.8954305-2 2-2h13c.5522847 0 1 .44771525 1 1v14c0 .5522847-.4477153 1-1 1zm-8.5-13h6c.2761424 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.2238576.5-.5.5h-6c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5zm1 2h4c.2761424 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.2238576.5-.5.5h-4c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-broad" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="m9.18274226 7.81v7.7999954l2.48162734-2.4816273c.3928221-.3928221 1.0219731-.4005617 1.4030652-.0194696.3911301.3911301.3914806 1.0249268-.0001404 1.4165479l-4.17620796 4.1762079c-.39120769.3912077-1.02508144.3916069-1.41671995-.0000316l-4.1763942-4.1763942c-.39122514-.3912251-.39767006-1.0190815-.01657798-1.4001736.39113012-.3911301 1.02337106-.3930364 1.41951349.0031061l2.48183446 2.4818344v-8.7999954c0-.54911294.4426881-.99439484.99778758-.99557515l8.00221246-.00442485c.5522847 0 1 .44771525 1 1s-.4477153 1-1 1z" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(-1 0 0 -1 20.182742 24.805206)"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-calendar" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m12.5 0c.2761424 0 .5.21505737.5.49047852v.50952148h2c1.1072288 0 2 .89451376 2 2v12c0 1.1072288-.8945138 2-2 2h-12c-1.1072288 0-2-.8945138-2-2v-12c0-1.1072288.89451376-2 2-2h1v1h-1c-.55393837 0-1 .44579254-1 1v3h14v-3c0-.55393837-.4457925-1-1-1h-2v1.50952148c0 .27088381-.2319336.49047852-.5.49047852-.2761424 0-.5-.21505737-.5-.49047852v-3.01904296c0-.27088381.2319336-.49047852.5-.49047852zm3.5 7h-14v8c0 .5539384.44579254 1 1 1h12c.5539384 0 1-.4457925 1-1zm-11 6v1h-1v-1zm3 0v1h-1v-1zm3 0v1h-1v-1zm-6-2v1h-1v-1zm3 0v1h-1v-1zm6 0v1h-1v-1zm-3 0v1h-1v-1zm-3-2v1h-1v-1zm6 0v1h-1v-1zm-3 0v1h-1v-1zm-5.5-9c.27614237 0 .5.21505737.5.49047852v.50952148h5v1h-5v1.50952148c0 .27088381-.23193359.49047852-.5.49047852-.27614237 0-.5-.21505737-.5-.49047852v-3.01904296c0-.27088381.23193359-.49047852.5-.49047852z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-cart" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m5 14c1.1045695 0 2 .8954305 2 2s-.8954305 2-2 2-2-.8954305-2-2 .8954305-2 2-2zm10 0c1.1045695 0 2 .8954305 2 2s-.8954305 2-2 2-2-.8954305-2-2 .8954305-2 2-2zm-10 1c-.55228475 0-1 .4477153-1 1s.44771525 1 1 1 1-.4477153 1-1-.44771525-1-1-1zm10 0c-.5522847 0-1 .4477153-1 1s.4477153 1 1 1 1-.4477153 1-1-.4477153-1-1-1zm-12.82032249-15c.47691417 0 .88746157.33678127.98070211.80449199l.23823144 1.19501025 13.36277974.00045554c.5522847.00001882.9999659.44774934.9999659 1.00004222 0 .07084994-.0075361.14150708-.022474.2107727l-1.2908094 5.98534344c-.1007861.46742419-.5432548.80388386-1.0571651.80388386h-10.24805106c-.59173366 0-1.07142857.4477153-1.07142857 1 0 .5128358.41361449.9355072.94647737.9932723l.1249512.0067277h10.35933776c.2749512 0 .4979349.2228539.4979349.4978051 0 .2749417-.2227336.4978951-.4976753.4980063l-10.35959736.0041886c-1.18346732 0-2.14285714-.8954305-2.14285714-2 0-.6625717.34520317-1.24989198.87690425-1.61383592l-1.63768102-8.19004794c-.01312273-.06561364-.01950005-.131011-.0196107-.19547395l-1.71961253-.00064219c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385762-.5-.5 0-.27614237.22385763-.5.5-.5zm14.53193359 2.99950224h-13.11300004l1.20580469 6.02530174c.11024034-.0163252.22327998-.02480398.33844139-.02480398h10.27064786z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-chevron-less" viewBox="0 0 10 10"><path d="m5.58578644 4-3.29289322-3.29289322c-.39052429-.39052429-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356s1.02368927-.39052429 1.41421356 0l4 4c.39052429.39052429.39052429 1.02368927 0 1.41421356l-4 4c-.39052429.39052429-1.02368927.39052429-1.41421356 0s-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356z" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(0 -1 -1 0 9 9)"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-chevron-more" viewBox="0 0 10 10"><path d="m5.58578644 6-3.29289322-3.29289322c-.39052429-.39052429-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356s1.02368927-.39052429 1.41421356 0l4 4c.39052429.39052429.39052429 1.02368927 0 1.41421356l-4 4.00000002c-.39052429.3905243-1.02368927.3905243-1.41421356 0s-.39052429-1.02368929 0-1.41421358z" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(0 1 -1 0 11 1)"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-chevron-right" viewBox="0 0 10 10"><path d="m5.96738168 4.70639573 2.39518594-2.41447274c.37913917-.38219212.98637524-.38972225 1.35419292-.01894278.37750606.38054586.37784436.99719163-.00013556 1.37821513l-4.03074001 4.06319683c-.37758093.38062133-.98937525.38100976-1.367372-.00003075l-4.03091981-4.06337806c-.37759778-.38063832-.38381821-.99150444-.01600053-1.3622839.37750607-.38054587.98772445-.38240057 1.37006824.00302197l2.39538588 2.4146743.96295325.98624457z" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(0 -1 1 0 0 10)"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-circle-fill" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m8 14c-3.3137085 0-6-2.6862915-6-6s2.6862915-6 6-6 6 2.6862915 6 6-2.6862915 6-6 6z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-circle" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m8 12c2.209139 0 4-1.790861 4-4s-1.790861-4-4-4-4 1.790861-4 4 1.790861 4 4 4zm0 2c-3.3137085 0-6-2.6862915-6-6s2.6862915-6 6-6 6 2.6862915 6 6-2.6862915 6-6 6z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-citation" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m8.63593473 5.99995183c2.20913897 0 3.99999997 1.79084375 3.99999997 3.99996146 0 1.40730761-.7267788 2.64486871-1.8254829 3.35783281 1.6240224.6764218 2.8754442 2.0093871 3.4610603 3.6412466l-1.0763845.000006c-.5310008-1.2078237-1.5108121-2.1940153-2.7691712-2.7181346l-.79002167-.329052v-1.023992l.63016577-.4089232c.8482885-.5504661 1.3698342-1.4895187 1.3698342-2.51898361 0-1.65683828-1.3431457-2.99996146-2.99999997-2.99996146-1.65685425 0-3 1.34312318-3 2.99996146 0 1.02946491.52154569 1.96851751 1.36983419 2.51898361l.63016581.4089232v1.023992l-.79002171.329052c-1.25835905.5241193-2.23817037 1.5103109-2.76917113 2.7181346l-1.07638453-.000006c.58561612-1.6318595 1.8370379-2.9648248 3.46106024-3.6412466-1.09870405-.7129641-1.82548287-1.9505252-1.82548287-3.35783281 0-2.20911771 1.790861-3.99996146 4-3.99996146zm7.36897597-4.99995183c1.1018574 0 1.9950893.89353404 1.9950893 2.00274083v5.994422c0 1.10608317-.8926228 2.00274087-1.9950893 2.00274087l-3.0049107-.0009037v-1l3.0049107.00091329c.5490631 0 .9950893-.44783123.9950893-1.00275046v-5.994422c0-.55646537-.4450595-1.00275046-.9950893-1.00275046h-14.00982141c-.54906309 0-.99508929.44783123-.99508929 1.00275046v5.9971821c0 .66666024.33333333.99999036 1 .99999036l2-.00091329v1l-2 .0009037c-1 0-2-.99999041-2-1.99998077v-5.9971821c0-1.10608322.8926228-2.00274083 1.99508929-2.00274083zm-8.5049107 2.9999711c.27614237 0 .5.22385547.5.5 0 .2761349-.22385763.5-.5.5h-4c-.27614237 0-.5-.2238651-.5-.5 0-.27614453.22385763-.5.5-.5zm3 0c.2761424 0 .5.22385547.5.5 0 .2761349-.2238576.5-.5.5h-1c-.27614237 0-.5-.2238651-.5-.5 0-.27614453.22385763-.5.5-.5zm4 0c.2761424 0 .5.22385547.5.5 0 .2761349-.2238576.5-.5.5h-2c-.2761424 0-.5-.2238651-.5-.5 0-.27614453.2238576-.5.5-.5z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-close" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m2.29679575 12.2772478c-.39658757.3965876-.39438847 1.0328109-.00062148 1.4265779.39651227.3965123 1.03246768.3934888 1.42657791-.0006214l4.27724782-4.27724787 4.2772478 4.27724787c.3965876.3965875 1.0328109.3943884 1.4265779.0006214.3965123-.3965122.3934888-1.0324677-.0006214-1.4265779l-4.27724787-4.2772478 4.27724787-4.27724782c.3965875-.39658757.3943884-1.03281091.0006214-1.42657791-.3965122-.39651226-1.0324677-.39348875-1.4265779.00062148l-4.2772478 4.27724782-4.27724782-4.27724782c-.39658757-.39658757-1.03281091-.39438847-1.42657791-.00062148-.39651226.39651227-.39348875 1.03246768.00062148 1.42657791l4.27724782 4.27724782z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-collections" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m15 4c1.1045695 0 2 .8954305 2 2v9c0 1.1045695-.8954305 2-2 2h-8c-1.1045695 0-2-.8954305-2-2h1c0 .5128358.38604019.9355072.88337887.9932723l.11662113.0067277h8c.5128358 0 .9355072-.3860402.9932723-.8833789l.0067277-.1166211v-9c0-.51283584-.3860402-.93550716-.8833789-.99327227l-.1166211-.00672773h-1v-1zm-4-3c1.1045695 0 2 .8954305 2 2v9c0 1.1045695-.8954305 2-2 2h-8c-1.1045695 0-2-.8954305-2-2v-9c0-1.1045695.8954305-2 2-2zm0 1h-8c-.51283584 0-.93550716.38604019-.99327227.88337887l-.00672773.11662113v9c0 .5128358.38604019.9355072.88337887.9932723l.11662113.0067277h8c.5128358 0 .9355072-.3860402.9932723-.8833789l.0067277-.1166211v-9c0-.51283584-.3860402-.93550716-.8833789-.99327227zm-1.5 7c.27614237 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-5c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5zm0-2c.27614237 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-5c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5zm0-2c.27614237 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-5c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-compare" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m12 3c3.3137085 0 6 2.6862915 6 6s-2.6862915 6-6 6c-1.0928452 0-2.11744941-.2921742-2.99996061-.8026704-.88181407.5102749-1.90678042.8026704-3.00003939.8026704-3.3137085 0-6-2.6862915-6-6s2.6862915-6 6-6c1.09325897 0 2.11822532.29239547 3.00096303.80325037.88158756-.51107621 1.90619177-.80325037 2.99903697-.80325037zm-6 1c-2.76142375 0-5 2.23857625-5 5 0 2.7614237 2.23857625 5 5 5 .74397391 0 1.44999672-.162488 2.08451611-.4539116-1.27652344-1.1000812-2.08451611-2.7287264-2.08451611-4.5460884s.80799267-3.44600721 2.08434391-4.5463015c-.63434719-.29121054-1.34037-.4536985-2.08434391-.4536985zm6 0c-.7439739 0-1.4499967.16248796-2.08451611.45391156 1.27652341 1.10008123 2.08451611 2.72872644 2.08451611 4.54608844s-.8079927 3.4460072-2.08434391 4.5463015c.63434721.2912105 1.34037001.4536985 2.08434391.4536985 2.7614237 0 5-2.2385763 5-5 0-2.76142375-2.2385763-5-5-5zm-1.4162763 7.0005324h-3.16744736c.15614659.3572676.35283837.6927622.58425872 1.0006671h1.99892988c.23142036-.3079049.42811216-.6433995.58425876-1.0006671zm.4162763-2.0005324h-4c0 .34288501.0345146.67770871.10025909 1.0011864h3.79948181c.0657445-.32347769.1002591-.65830139.1002591-1.0011864zm-.4158423-1.99953894h-3.16831543c-.13859957.31730812-.24521946.651783-.31578599.99935097h3.79988742c-.0705665-.34756797-.1771864-.68204285-.315786-.99935097zm-1.58295822-1.999926-.08316107.06199199c-.34550042.27081213-.65446126.58611297-.91825862.93727862h2.00044041c-.28418626-.37830727-.6207872-.71499149-.99902072-.99927061z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-download-file" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m10.0046024 0c.5497429 0 1.3179837.32258606 1.707238.71184039l4.5763192 4.57631922c.3931386.39313859.7118404 1.16760135.7118404 1.71431368v8.98899651c0 1.1092806-.8945138 2.0085302-1.9940603 2.0085302h-12.01187942c-1.10128908 0-1.99406028-.8926228-1.99406028-1.9950893v-14.00982141c0-1.10185739.88743329-1.99508929 1.99961498-1.99508929zm0 1h-7.00498742c-.55709576 0-.99961498.44271433-.99961498.99508929v14.00982141c0 .5500396.44491393.9950893.99406028.9950893h12.01187942c.5463747 0 .9940603-.4506622.9940603-1.0085302v-8.98899651c0-.28393444-.2150684-.80332809-.4189472-1.0072069l-4.5763192-4.57631922c-.2038461-.20384606-.718603-.41894717-1.0001312-.41894717zm-1.5046024 4c.27614237 0 .5.21637201.5.49209595v6.14827645l1.7462789-1.77990922c.1933927-.1971171.5125222-.19455839.7001689-.0069117.1932998.19329992.1910058.50899492-.0027774.70277812l-2.59089271 2.5908927c-.19483374.1948337-.51177825.1937771-.70556873-.0000133l-2.59099079-2.5909908c-.19484111-.1948411-.19043735-.5151448-.00279066-.70279146.19329987-.19329987.50465175-.19237083.70018565.00692852l1.74638684 1.78001764v-6.14827695c0-.27177709.23193359-.49209595.5-.49209595z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-download" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m12.9975267 12.999368c.5467123 0 1.0024733.4478567 1.0024733 1.000316 0 .5563109-.4488226 1.000316-1.0024733 1.000316h-9.99505341c-.54671233 0-1.00247329-.4478567-1.00247329-1.000316 0-.5563109.44882258-1.000316 1.00247329-1.000316zm-4.9975267-11.999368c.55228475 0 1 .44497754 1 .99589209v6.80214418l2.4816273-2.48241149c.3928222-.39294628 1.0219732-.4006883 1.4030652-.01947579.3911302.39125371.3914806 1.02525073-.0001404 1.41699553l-4.17620792 4.17752758c-.39120769.3913313-1.02508144.3917306-1.41671995-.0000316l-4.17639421-4.17771394c-.39122513-.39134876-.39767006-1.01940351-.01657797-1.40061601.39113012-.39125372 1.02337105-.3931606 1.41951349.00310701l2.48183446 2.48261871v-6.80214418c0-.55001601.44386482-.99589209 1-.99589209z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-editors" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m8.72592184 2.54588137c-.48811714-.34391207-1.08343326-.54588137-1.72592184-.54588137-1.65685425 0-3 1.34314575-3 3 0 1.02947485.5215457 1.96853646 1.3698342 2.51900785l.6301658.40892721v1.02400182l-.79002171.32905522c-1.93395773.8055207-3.20997829 2.7024791-3.20997829 4.8180274v.9009805h-1v-.9009805c0-2.5479714 1.54557359-4.79153984 3.82548288-5.7411543-1.09870406-.71297106-1.82548288-1.95054399-1.82548288-3.3578652 0-2.209139 1.790861-4 4-4 1.09079823 0 2.07961816.43662103 2.80122451 1.1446278-.37707584.09278571-.7373238.22835063-1.07530267.40125357zm-2.72592184 14.45411863h-1v-.9009805c0-2.5479714 1.54557359-4.7915398 3.82548288-5.7411543-1.09870406-.71297106-1.82548288-1.95054399-1.82548288-3.3578652 0-2.209139 1.790861-4 4-4s4 1.790861 4 4c0 1.40732121-.7267788 2.64489414-1.8254829 3.3578652 2.2799093.9496145 3.8254829 3.1931829 3.8254829 5.7411543v.9009805h-1v-.9009805c0-2.1155483-1.2760206-4.0125067-3.2099783-4.8180274l-.7900217-.3290552v-1.02400184l.6301658-.40892721c.8482885-.55047139 1.3698342-1.489533 1.3698342-2.51900785 0-1.65685425-1.3431458-3-3-3-1.65685425 0-3 1.34314575-3 3 0 1.02947485.5215457 1.96853646 1.3698342 2.51900785l.6301658.40892721v1.02400184l-.79002171.3290552c-1.93395773.8055207-3.20997829 2.7024791-3.20997829 4.8180274z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-email" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m16.0049107 2c1.1018574 0 1.9950893.89706013 1.9950893 2.00585866v9.98828264c0 1.1078052-.8926228 2.0058587-1.9950893 2.0058587h-14.00982141c-1.10185739 0-1.99508929-.8970601-1.99508929-2.0058587v-9.98828264c0-1.10780515.8926228-2.00585866 1.99508929-2.00585866zm0 1h-14.00982141c-.54871518 0-.99508929.44887827-.99508929 1.00585866v9.98828264c0 .5572961.44630695 1.0058587.99508929 1.0058587h14.00982141c.5487152 0 .9950893-.4488783.9950893-1.0058587v-9.98828264c0-.55729607-.446307-1.00585866-.9950893-1.00585866zm-.0049107 2.55749512v1.44250488l-7 4-7-4v-1.44250488l7 4z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-error" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m9 0c4.9705627 0 9 4.02943725 9 9 0 4.9705627-4.0294373 9-9 9-4.97056275 0-9-4.0294373-9-9 0-4.97056275 4.02943725-9 9-9zm2.8630343 4.71100931-2.8630343 2.86303426-2.86303426-2.86303426c-.39658757-.39658757-1.03281091-.39438847-1.4265779-.00062147-.39651227.39651226-.39348876 1.03246767.00062147 1.4265779l2.86303426 2.86303426-2.86303426 2.8630343c-.39658757.3965875-.39438847 1.0328109-.00062147 1.4265779.39651226.3965122 1.03246767.3934887 1.4265779-.0006215l2.86303426-2.8630343 2.8630343 2.8630343c.3965875.3965876 1.0328109.3943885 1.4265779.0006215.3965122-.3965123.3934887-1.0324677-.0006215-1.4265779l-2.8630343-2.8630343 2.8630343-2.86303426c.3965876-.39658757.3943885-1.03281091.0006215-1.4265779-.3965123-.39651227-1.0324677-.39348876-1.4265779.00062147z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-ethics" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m6.76384967 1.41421356.83301651-.8330165c.77492941-.77492941 2.03133823-.77492941 2.80626762 0l.8330165.8330165c.3750728.37507276.8837806.58578644 1.4142136.58578644h1.3496361c1.1045695 0 2 .8954305 2 2v1.34963611c0 .53043298.2107137 1.03914081.5857864 1.41421356l.8330165.83301651c.7749295.77492941.7749295 2.03133823 0 2.80626762l-.8330165.8330165c-.3750727.3750728-.5857864.8837806-.5857864 1.4142136v1.3496361c0 1.1045695-.8954305 2-2 2h-1.3496361c-.530433 0-1.0391408.2107137-1.4142136.5857864l-.8330165.8330165c-.77492939.7749295-2.03133821.7749295-2.80626762 0l-.83301651-.8330165c-.37507275-.3750727-.88378058-.5857864-1.41421356-.5857864h-1.34963611c-1.1045695 0-2-.8954305-2-2v-1.3496361c0-.530433-.21071368-1.0391408-.58578644-1.4142136l-.8330165-.8330165c-.77492941-.77492939-.77492941-2.03133821 0-2.80626762l.8330165-.83301651c.37507276-.37507275.58578644-.88378058.58578644-1.41421356v-1.34963611c0-1.1045695.8954305-2 2-2h1.34963611c.53043298 0 1.03914081-.21071368 1.41421356-.58578644zm-1.41421356 1.58578644h-1.34963611c-.55228475 0-1 .44771525-1 1v1.34963611c0 .79564947-.31607052 1.55871121-.87867966 2.12132034l-.8330165.83301651c-.38440512.38440512-.38440512 1.00764896 0 1.39205408l.8330165.83301646c.56260914.5626092.87867966 1.3256709.87867966 2.1213204v1.3496361c0 .5522847.44771525 1 1 1h1.34963611c.79564947 0 1.55871121.3160705 2.12132034.8786797l.83301651.8330165c.38440512.3844051 1.00764896.3844051 1.39205408 0l.83301646-.8330165c.5626092-.5626092 1.3256709-.8786797 2.1213204-.8786797h1.3496361c.5522847 0 1-.4477153 1-1v-1.3496361c0-.7956495.3160705-1.5587112.8786797-2.1213204l.8330165-.83301646c.3844051-.38440512.3844051-1.00764896 0-1.39205408l-.8330165-.83301651c-.5626092-.56260913-.8786797-1.32567087-.8786797-2.12132034v-1.34963611c0-.55228475-.4477153-1-1-1h-1.3496361c-.7956495 0-1.5587112-.31607052-2.1213204-.87867966l-.83301646-.8330165c-.38440512-.38440512-1.00764896-.38440512-1.39205408 0l-.83301651.8330165c-.56260913.56260914-1.32567087.87867966-2.12132034.87867966zm3.58698944 11.4960218c-.02081224.002155-.04199226.0030286-.06345763.002542-.98766446-.0223875-1.93408568-.3063547-2.75885125-.8155622-.23496767-.1450683-.30784554-.4531483-.16277726-.688116.14506827-.2349677.45314827-.3078455.68811595-.1627773.67447084.4164161 1.44758575.6483839 2.25617384.6667123.01759529.0003988.03495764.0017019.05204365.0038639.01713363-.0017748.03452416-.0026845.05212715-.0026845 2.4852814 0 4.5-2.0147186 4.5-4.5 0-1.04888973-.3593547-2.04134635-1.0074477-2.83787157-.1742817-.21419731-.1419238-.5291218.0722736-.70340353.2141973-.17428173.5291218-.14192375.7034035.07227357.7919032.97327203 1.2317706 2.18808682 1.2317706 3.46900153 0 3.0375661-2.4624339 5.5-5.5 5.5-.02146768 0-.04261937-.0013529-.06337445-.0039782zm1.57975095-10.78419583c.2654788.07599731.419084.35281842.3430867.61829728-.0759973.26547885-.3528185.419084-.6182973.3430867-.37560116-.10752146-.76586237-.16587951-1.15568824-.17249193-2.5587807-.00064534-4.58547766 2.00216524-4.58547766 4.49928198 0 .62691557.12797645 1.23496.37274865 1.7964426.11035133.2531347-.0053975.5477984-.25853224.6581497-.25313473.1103514-.54779841-.0053975-.65814974-.2585322-.29947131-.6869568-.45606667-1.43097603-.45606667-2.1960601 0-3.05211432 2.47714695-5.50006595 5.59399617-5.49921198.48576182.00815502.96289603.0795037 1.42238033.21103795zm-1.9766658 6.41091303 2.69835-2.94655317c.1788432-.21040373.4943901-.23598862.7047939-.05714545.2104037.17884318.2359886.49439014.0571454.70479387l-3.01637681 3.34277395c-.18039088.1999106-.48669547.2210637-.69285412.0478478l-1.93095347-1.62240047c-.21213845-.17678204-.24080048-.49206439-.06401844-.70420284.17678204-.21213844.49206439-.24080048.70420284-.06401844z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-expand"><path d="M7.498 11.918a.997.997 0 0 0-.003-1.411.995.995 0 0 0-1.412-.003l-4.102 4.102v-3.51A1 1 0 0 0 .98 10.09.992.992 0 0 0 0 11.092V17c0 .554.448 1.002 1.002 1.002h5.907c.554 0 1.002-.45 1.002-1.003 0-.539-.45-.978-1.006-.978h-3.51zm3.005-5.835a.997.997 0 0 0 .003 1.412.995.995 0 0 0 1.411.003l4.103-4.103v3.51a1 1 0 0 0 1.001 1.006A.992.992 0 0 0 18 6.91V1.002A1 1 0 0 0 17 0h-5.907a1.003 1.003 0 0 0-1.002 1.003c0 .539.45.978 1.006.978h3.51z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-explore" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m9 17c4.418278 0 8-3.581722 8-8s-3.581722-8-8-8-8 3.581722-8 8 3.581722 8 8 8zm0 1c-4.97056275 0-9-4.0294373-9-9 0-4.97056275 4.02943725-9 9-9 4.9705627 0 9 4.02943725 9 9 0 4.9705627-4.0294373 9-9 9zm0-2.5c-.27614237 0-.5-.2238576-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5c2.969509 0 5.400504-2.3575119 5.497023-5.31714844.0090007-.27599565.2400359-.49243782.5160315-.48343711.2759957.0090007.4924378.2400359.4834371.51603155-.114093 3.4985237-2.9869632 6.284554-6.4964916 6.284554zm-.29090657-12.99359748c.27587424-.01216621.50937715.20161139.52154336.47748563.01216621.27587423-.20161139.50937715-.47748563.52154336-2.93195733.12930094-5.25315116 2.54886451-5.25315116 5.49456849 0 .27614237-.22385763.5-.5.5s-.5-.22385763-.5-.5c0-3.48142406 2.74307146-6.34074398 6.20909343-6.49359748zm1.13784138 8.04763908-1.2004882-1.20048821c-.19526215-.19526215-.19526215-.51184463 0-.70710678s.51184463-.19526215.70710678 0l1.20048821 1.2004882 1.6006509-4.00162734-4.50670359 1.80268144-1.80268144 4.50670359zm4.10281269-6.50378907-2.6692597 6.67314927c-.1016411.2541026-.3029834.4554449-.557086.557086l-6.67314927 2.6692597 2.66925969-6.67314926c.10164107-.25410266.30298336-.45544495.55708602-.55708602z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-filter" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m14.9738641 0c.5667192 0 1.0261359.4477136 1.0261359 1 0 .24221858-.0902161.47620768-.2538899.65849851l-5.6938314 6.34147206v5.49997973c0 .3147562-.1520673.6111434-.4104543.7999971l-2.05227171 1.4999945c-.45337535.3313696-1.09655869.2418269-1.4365902-.1999993-.13321514-.1730955-.20522717-.3836284-.20522717-.5999978v-6.99997423l-5.69383133-6.34147206c-.3731872-.41563511-.32996891-1.0473954.09653074-1.41107611.18705584-.15950448.42716133-.2474224.67571519-.2474224zm-5.9218641 8.5h-2.105v6.491l.01238459.0070843.02053271.0015705.01955278-.0070558 2.0532976-1.4990996zm-8.02585008-7.5-.01564945.00240169 5.83249953 6.49759831h2.313l5.836-6.499z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-home" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m9 5-6 6v5h4v-4h4v4h4v-5zm7 6.5857864v4.4142136c0 .5522847-.4477153 1-1 1h-5v-4h-2v4h-5c-.55228475 0-1-.4477153-1-1v-4.4142136c-.25592232 0-.51184464-.097631-.70710678-.2928932l-.58578644-.5857864c-.39052429-.3905243-.39052429-1.02368929 0-1.41421358l8.29289322-8.29289322 8.2928932 8.29289322c.3905243.39052429.3905243 1.02368928 0 1.41421358l-.5857864.5857864c-.1952622.1952622-.4511845.2928932-.7071068.2928932zm-7-9.17157284-7.58578644 7.58578644.58578644.5857864 7-6.99999996 7 6.99999996.5857864-.5857864z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-image" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m10.0046024 0c.5497429 0 1.3179837.32258606 1.707238.71184039l4.5763192 4.57631922c.3931386.39313859.7118404 1.16760135.7118404 1.71431368v8.98899651c0 1.1092806-.8945138 2.0085302-1.9940603 2.0085302h-12.01187942c-1.10128908 0-1.99406028-.8926228-1.99406028-1.9950893v-14.00982141c0-1.10185739.88743329-1.99508929 1.99961498-1.99508929zm-3.49645283 10.1752453-3.89407257 6.7495552c.11705545.048464.24538859.0751995.37998328.0751995h10.60290092l-2.4329715-4.2154691-1.57494129 2.7288098zm8.49779013 6.8247547c.5463747 0 .9940603-.4506622.9940603-1.0085302v-8.98899651c0-.28393444-.2150684-.80332809-.4189472-1.0072069l-4.5763192-4.57631922c-.2038461-.20384606-.718603-.41894717-1.0001312-.41894717h-7.00498742c-.55709576 0-.99961498.44271433-.99961498.99508929v13.98991071l4.50814957-7.81026689 3.08089884 5.33809539 1.57494129-2.7288097 3.5875735 6.2159812zm-3.0059397-11c1.1045695 0 2 .8954305 2 2s-.8954305 2-2 2-2-.8954305-2-2 .8954305-2 2-2zm0 1c-.5522847 0-1 .44771525-1 1s.4477153 1 1 1 1-.44771525 1-1-.4477153-1-1-1z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-info" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m9 0c4.9705627 0 9 4.02943725 9 9 0 4.9705627-4.0294373 9-9 9-4.97056275 0-9-4.0294373-9-9 0-4.97056275 4.02943725-9 9-9zm0 7h-1.5l-.11662113.00672773c-.49733868.05776511-.88337887.48043643-.88337887.99327227 0 .47338693.32893365.86994729.77070917.97358929l.1126697.01968298.11662113.00672773h.5v3h-.5l-.11662113.0067277c-.42082504.0488782-.76196299.3590206-.85696816.7639815l-.01968298.1126697-.00672773.1166211.00672773.1166211c.04887817.4208251.35902055.761963.76398144.8569682l.1126697.019683.11662113.0067277h3l.1166211-.0067277c.4973387-.0577651.8833789-.4804365.8833789-.9932723 0-.4733869-.3289337-.8699473-.7707092-.9735893l-.1126697-.019683-.1166211-.0067277h-.5v-4l-.00672773-.11662113c-.04887817-.42082504-.35902055-.76196299-.76398144-.85696816l-.1126697-.01968298zm0-3.25c-.69035594 0-1.25.55964406-1.25 1.25s.55964406 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25-.55964406 1.25-1.25-.55964406-1.25-1.25-1.25z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-institution" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m7 16.9998189v-2.0003623h4v2.0003623h2v-3.0005434h-8v3.0005434zm-3-10.00181122h-1.52632364c-.27614237 0-.5-.22389817-.5-.50009056 0-.13995446.05863589-.27350497.16166338-.36820841l1.23156713-1.13206327h-2.36690687v12.00217346h3v-2.0003623h-3v-1.0001811h3v-1.0001811h1v-4.00072448h-1zm10 0v2.00036224h-1v4.00072448h1v1.0001811h3v1.0001811h-3v2.0003623h3v-12.00217346h-2.3695309l1.2315671 1.13206327c.2033191.186892.2166633.50325042.0298051.70660631-.0946863.10304615-.2282126.16169266-.3681417.16169266zm3-3.00054336c.5522847 0 1 .44779634 1 1.00018112v13.00235456h-18v-13.00235456c0-.55238478.44771525-1.00018112 1-1.00018112h3.45499992l4.20535144-3.86558216c.19129876-.17584288.48537447-.17584288.67667324 0l4.2053514 3.86558216zm-4 3.00054336h-8v1.00018112h8zm-2 6.00108672h1v-4.00072448h-1zm-1 0v-4.00072448h-2v4.00072448zm-3 0v-4.00072448h-1v4.00072448zm8-4.00072448c.5522847 0 1 .44779634 1 1.00018112v2.00036226h-2v-2.00036226c0-.55238478.4477153-1.00018112 1-1.00018112zm-12 0c.55228475 0 1 .44779634 1 1.00018112v2.00036226h-2v-2.00036226c0-.55238478.44771525-1.00018112 1-1.00018112zm5.99868798-7.81907007-5.24205601 4.81852671h10.48411203zm.00131202 3.81834559c-.55228475 0-1-.44779634-1-1.00018112s.44771525-1.00018112 1-1.00018112 1 .44779634 1 1.00018112-.44771525 1.00018112-1 1.00018112zm-1 11.00199236v1.0001811h2v-1.0001811z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-location" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m9.39521328 16.2688008c.79596342-.7770119 1.59208152-1.6299956 2.33285652-2.5295081 1.4020032-1.7024324 2.4323601-3.3624519 2.9354918-4.871847.2228715-.66861448.3364384-1.29323246.3364384-1.8674457 0-3.3137085-2.6862915-6-6-6-3.36356866 0-6 2.60156856-6 6 0 .57421324.11356691 1.19883122.3364384 1.8674457.50313169 1.5093951 1.53348863 3.1694146 2.93549184 4.871847.74077492.8995125 1.53689309 1.7524962 2.33285648 2.5295081.13694479.1336842.26895677.2602648.39521328.3793207.12625651-.1190559.25826849-.2456365.39521328-.3793207zm-.39521328 1.7311992s-7-6-7-11c0-4 3.13400675-7 7-7 3.8659932 0 7 3.13400675 7 7 0 5-7 11-7 11zm0-8c-1.65685425 0-3-1.34314575-3-3s1.34314575-3 3-3c1.6568542 0 3 1.34314575 3 3s-1.3431458 3-3 3zm0-1c1.1045695 0 2-.8954305 2-2s-.8954305-2-2-2-2 .8954305-2 2 .8954305 2 2 2z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-minus" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m2.00087166 7h11.99825664c.5527662 0 1.0008717.44386482 1.0008717 1 0 .55228475-.4446309 1-1.0008717 1h-11.99825664c-.55276616 0-1.00087166-.44386482-1.00087166-1 0-.55228475.44463086-1 1.00087166-1z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-newsletter" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m9 11.8482489 2-1.1428571v-1.7053918h-4v1.7053918zm-3-1.7142857v-2.1339632h6v2.1339632l3-1.71428574v-6.41967746h-12v6.41967746zm10-5.3839632 1.5299989.95624934c.2923814.18273835.4700011.50320827.4700011.8479983v8.44575236c0 1.1045695-.8954305 2-2 2h-14c-1.1045695 0-2-.8954305-2-2v-8.44575236c0-.34479003.1776197-.66525995.47000106-.8479983l1.52999894-.95624934v-2.75c0-.55228475.44771525-1 1-1h12c.5522847 0 1 .44771525 1 1zm0 1.17924764v3.07075236l-7 4-7-4v-3.07075236l-1 .625v8.44575236c0 .5522847.44771525 1 1 1h14c.5522847 0 1-.4477153 1-1v-8.44575236zm-10-1.92924764h6v1h-6zm-1 2h8v1h-8z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-orcid" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m9 1c4.418278 0 8 3.581722 8 8s-3.581722 8-8 8-8-3.581722-8-8 3.581722-8 8-8zm-2.90107518 5.2732337h-1.41865256v7.1712107h1.41865256zm4.55867178.02508949h-2.99247027v7.14612121h2.91062487c.7673039 0 1.4476365-.1483432 2.0410182-.445034s1.0511995-.7152915 1.3734671-1.2558144c.3222677-.540523.4833991-1.1603247.4833991-1.85942385 0-.68545815-.1602789-1.30270225-.4808414-1.85175082-.3205625-.54904856-.7707074-.97532211-1.3504481-1.27883343-.5797408-.30351132-1.2413173-.45526471-1.9847495-.45526471zm-.1892674 1.07933542c.7877654 0 1.4143875.22336734 1.8798852.67010873.4654977.44674138.698243 1.05546001.698243 1.82617415 0 .74343221-.2310402 1.34447791-.6931277 1.80315511-.4620874.4586773-1.0750688.6880124-1.8389625.6880124h-1.46810075v-4.98745039zm-5.08652545-3.71099194c-.21825533 0-.410525.08444276-.57681478.25333081-.16628977.16888806-.24943341.36245684-.24943341.58071218 0 .22345188.08314364.41961891.24943341.58850696.16628978.16888806.35855945.25333082.57681478.25333082.233845 0 .43390938-.08314364.60019916-.24943342.16628978-.16628977.24943342-.36375592.24943342-.59240436 0-.233845-.08314364-.43131115-.24943342-.59240437s-.36635416-.24163862-.60019916-.24163862z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-plus" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m2.00087166 7h4.99912834v-4.99912834c0-.55276616.44386482-1.00087166 1-1.00087166.55228475 0 1 .44463086 1 1.00087166v4.99912834h4.9991283c.5527662 0 1.0008717.44386482 1.0008717 1 0 .55228475-.4446309 1-1.0008717 1h-4.9991283v4.9991283c0 .5527662-.44386482 1.0008717-1 1.0008717-.55228475 0-1-.4446309-1-1.0008717v-4.9991283h-4.99912834c-.55276616 0-1.00087166-.44386482-1.00087166-1 0-.55228475.44463086-1 1.00087166-1z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-print" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m16.0049107 5h-14.00982141c-.54941618 0-.99508929.4467783-.99508929.99961498v6.00077002c0 .5570958.44271433.999615.99508929.999615h1.00491071v-3h12v3h1.0049107c.5494162 0 .9950893-.4467783.9950893-.999615v-6.00077002c0-.55709576-.4427143-.99961498-.9950893-.99961498zm-2.0049107-1v-2.00208688c0-.54777062-.4519464-.99791312-1.0085302-.99791312h-7.9829396c-.55661731 0-1.0085302.44910695-1.0085302.99791312v2.00208688zm1 10v2.0018986c0 1.103521-.9019504 1.9981014-2.0085302 1.9981014h-7.9829396c-1.1092806 0-2.0085302-.8867064-2.0085302-1.9981014v-2.0018986h-1.00491071c-1.10185739 0-1.99508929-.8874333-1.99508929-1.999615v-6.00077002c0-1.10435686.8926228-1.99961498 1.99508929-1.99961498h1.00491071v-2.00208688c0-1.10341695.90195036-1.99791312 2.0085302-1.99791312h7.9829396c1.1092806 0 2.0085302.89826062 2.0085302 1.99791312v2.00208688h1.0049107c1.1018574 0 1.9950893.88743329 1.9950893 1.99961498v6.00077002c0 1.1043569-.8926228 1.999615-1.9950893 1.999615zm-1-3h-10v5.0018986c0 .5546075.44702548.9981014 1.0085302.9981014h7.9829396c.5565964 0 1.0085302-.4491701 1.0085302-.9981014zm-9 1h8v1h-8zm0 2h5v1h-5zm9-5c-.5522847 0-1-.44771525-1-1s.4477153-1 1-1 1 .44771525 1 1-.4477153 1-1 1z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-search" viewBox="0 0 22 22"><path d="M21.697 20.261a1.028 1.028 0 01.01 1.448 1.034 1.034 0 01-1.448-.01l-4.267-4.267A9.812 9.811 0 010 9.812a9.812 9.811 0 1117.43 6.182zM9.812 18.222A8.41 8.41 0 109.81 1.403a8.41 8.41 0 000 16.82z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-social-facebook" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="m6.00368507 20c-1.10660471 0-2.00368507-.8945138-2.00368507-1.9940603v-12.01187942c0-1.10128908.89451376-1.99406028 1.99406028-1.99406028h12.01187942c1.1012891 0 1.9940603.89451376 1.9940603 1.99406028v12.01187942c0 1.1012891-.88679 1.9940603-2.0032184 1.9940603h-2.9570132v-6.1960818h2.0797387l.3114113-2.414723h-2.39115v-1.54164807c0-.69911803.1941355-1.1755439 1.1966615-1.1755439l1.2786739-.00055875v-2.15974763l-.2339477-.02492088c-.3441234-.03134957-.9500153-.07025255-1.6293054-.07025255-1.8435726 0-3.1057323 1.12531866-3.1057323 3.19187953v1.78079225h-2.0850778v2.414723h2.0850778v6.1960818z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-social-twitter" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="m18.8767135 6.87445248c.7638174-.46908424 1.351611-1.21167363 1.6250764-2.09636345-.7135248.43394112-1.50406.74870123-2.3464594.91677702-.6695189-.73342162-1.6297913-1.19486605-2.6922204-1.19486605-2.0399895 0-3.6933555 1.69603749-3.6933555 3.78628909 0 .29642457.0314329.58673729.0942985.8617704-3.06469922-.15890802-5.78835241-1.66547825-7.60988389-3.9574208-.3174714.56076194-.49978171 1.21167363-.49978171 1.90536824 0 1.31404706.65223085 2.47224203 1.64236444 3.15218497-.60350999-.0198635-1.17401554-.1925232-1.67222562-.47366811v.04583885c0 1.83355406 1.27302891 3.36609966 2.96411421 3.71294696-.31118484.0886217-.63651445.1329326-.97441718.1329326-.2357461 0-.47149219-.0229194-.69466516-.0672303.47149219 1.5065703 1.83253297 2.6036468 3.44975116 2.632678-1.2651707 1.0160946-2.85724264 1.6196394-4.5891906 1.6196394-.29861172 0-.59093688-.0152796-.88011875-.0504227 1.63450624 1.0726291 3.57548241 1.6990934 5.66104951 1.6990934 6.79263079 0 10.50641749-5.7711113 10.50641749-10.7751859l-.0094298-.48894775c.7229547-.53478659 1.3516109-1.20250585 1.8419628-1.96190282-.6632323.30100846-1.3751855.50422736-2.1217148.59590507z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-social-youtube" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="m10.1415 14.3973208-.0005625-5.19318431 4.863375 2.60554491zm9.963-7.92753362c-.6845625-.73643756-1.4518125-.73990314-1.803375-.7826454-2.518875-.18714178-6.2971875-.18714178-6.2971875-.18714178-.007875 0-3.7861875 0-6.3050625.18714178-.352125.04274226-1.1188125.04620784-1.8039375.7826454-.5394375.56084773-.7149375 1.8344515-.7149375 1.8344515s-.18 1.49597903-.18 2.99138042v1.4024082c0 1.495979.18 2.9913804.18 2.9913804s.1755 1.2736038.7149375 1.8344515c.685125.7364376 1.5845625.7133337 1.9850625.7901542 1.44.1420891 6.12.1859866 6.12.1859866s3.78225-.005776 6.301125-.1929178c.3515625-.0433198 1.1188125-.0467854 1.803375-.783223.5394375-.5608477.7155-1.8344515.7155-1.8344515s.18-1.4954014.18-2.9913804v-1.4024082c0-1.49540139-.18-2.99138042-.18-2.99138042s-.1760625-1.27360377-.7155-1.8344515z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-subject-medicine" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m12.5 8h-6.5c-1.65685425 0-3 1.34314575-3 3v1c0 1.6568542 1.34314575 3 3 3h1v-2h-.5c-.82842712 0-1.5-.6715729-1.5-1.5s.67157288-1.5 1.5-1.5h1.5 2 1 2c1.6568542 0 3-1.34314575 3-3v-1c0-1.65685425-1.3431458-3-3-3h-2v2h1.5c.8284271 0 1.5.67157288 1.5 1.5s-.6715729 1.5-1.5 1.5zm-5.5-1v-1h-3.5c-1.38071187 0-2.5-1.11928813-2.5-2.5s1.11928813-2.5 2.5-2.5h1.02786405c.46573528 0 .92507448.10843528 1.34164078.31671843l1.13382424.56691212c.06026365-1.05041141.93116291-1.88363055 1.99667093-1.88363055 1.1045695 0 2 .8954305 2 2h2c2.209139 0 4 1.790861 4 4v1c0 2.209139-1.790861 4-4 4h-2v1h2c1.1045695 0 2 .8954305 2 2s-.8954305 2-2 2h-2c0 1.1045695-.8954305 2-2 2s-2-.8954305-2-2h-1c-2.209139 0-4-1.790861-4-4v-1c0-2.209139 1.790861-4 4-4zm0-2v-2.05652691c-.14564246-.03538148-.28733393-.08714006-.42229124-.15461871l-1.15541752-.57770876c-.27771087-.13885544-.583937-.21114562-.89442719-.21114562h-1.02786405c-.82842712 0-1.5.67157288-1.5 1.5s.67157288 1.5 1.5 1.5zm4 1v1h1.5c.2761424 0 .5-.22385763.5-.5s-.2238576-.5-.5-.5zm-1 1v-5c0-.55228475-.44771525-1-1-1s-1 .44771525-1 1v5zm-2 4v5c0 .5522847.44771525 1 1 1s1-.4477153 1-1v-5zm3 2v2h2c.5522847 0 1-.4477153 1-1s-.4477153-1-1-1zm-4-1v-1h-.5c-.27614237 0-.5.2238576-.5.5s.22385763.5.5.5zm-3.5-9h1c.27614237 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-1c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-success" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m9 0c4.9705627 0 9 4.02943725 9 9 0 4.9705627-4.0294373 9-9 9-4.97056275 0-9-4.0294373-9-9 0-4.97056275 4.02943725-9 9-9zm3.4860198 4.98163161-4.71802968 5.50657859-2.62834168-2.02300024c-.42862421-.36730544-1.06564993-.30775346-1.42283677.13301307-.35718685.44076653-.29927542 1.0958383.12934879 1.46314377l3.40735508 2.7323063c.42215801.3385221 1.03700951.2798252 1.38749189-.1324571l5.38450527-6.33394549c.3613513-.43716226.3096573-1.09278382-.115462-1.46437175-.4251192-.37158792-1.0626796-.31842941-1.4240309.11873285z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-table" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m16.0049107 2c1.1018574 0 1.9950893.89706013 1.9950893 2.00585866v9.98828264c0 1.1078052-.8926228 2.0058587-1.9950893 2.0058587l-4.0059107-.001.001.001h-1l-.001-.001h-5l.001.001h-1l-.001-.001-3.00391071.001c-1.10185739 0-1.99508929-.8970601-1.99508929-2.0058587v-9.98828264c0-1.10780515.8926228-2.00585866 1.99508929-2.00585866zm-11.0059107 5h-3.999v6.9941413c0 .5572961.44630695 1.0058587.99508929 1.0058587h3.00391071zm6 0h-5v8h5zm5.0059107-4h-4.0059107v3h5.001v1h-5.001v7.999l4.0059107.001c.5487152 0 .9950893-.4488783.9950893-1.0058587v-9.98828264c0-.55729607-.446307-1.00585866-.9950893-1.00585866zm-12.5049107 9c.27614237 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-1c-.27614237 0-.5-.2238576-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5zm12 0c.2761424 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.2238576.5-.5.5h-2c-.2761424 0-.5-.2238576-.5-.5s.2238576-.5.5-.5zm-6 0c.27614237 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-2c-.27614237 0-.5-.2238576-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5zm-6-2c.27614237 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-1c-.27614237 0-.5-.2238576-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5zm12 0c.2761424 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.2238576.5-.5.5h-2c-.2761424 0-.5-.2238576-.5-.5s.2238576-.5.5-.5zm-6 0c.27614237 0 .5.2238576.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-2c-.27614237 0-.5-.2238576-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5zm-6-2c.27614237 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-1c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5zm12 0c.2761424 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.2238576.5-.5.5h-2c-.2761424 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.2238576-.5.5-.5zm-6 0c.27614237 0 .5.22385763.5.5s-.22385763.5-.5.5h-2c-.27614237 0-.5-.22385763-.5-.5s.22385763-.5.5-.5zm1.499-5h-5v3h5zm-6 0h-3.00391071c-.54871518 0-.99508929.44887827-.99508929 1.00585866v1.99414134h3.999z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-tick-circle" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="m12 2c5.5228475 0 10 4.4771525 10 10s-4.4771525 10-10 10-10-4.4771525-10-10 4.4771525-10 10-10zm0 1c-4.97056275 0-9 4.02943725-9 9 0 4.9705627 4.02943725 9 9 9 4.9705627 0 9-4.0294373 9-9 0-4.97056275-4.0294373-9-9-9zm4.2199868 5.36606669c.3613514-.43716226.9989118-.49032077 1.424031-.11873285s.4768133 1.02720949.115462 1.46437175l-6.093335 6.94397871c-.3622945.4128716-.9897871.4562317-1.4054264.0971157l-3.89719065-3.3672071c-.42862421-.3673054-.48653564-1.0223772-.1293488-1.4631437s.99421256-.5003185 1.42283677-.1330131l3.11097438 2.6987741z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-tick" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m6.76799012 9.21106946-3.1109744-2.58349728c-.42862421-.35161617-1.06564993-.29460792-1.42283677.12733148s-.29927541 1.04903009.1293488 1.40064626l3.91576307 3.23873978c.41034319.3393961 1.01467563.2976897 1.37450571-.0948578l6.10568327-6.660841c.3613513-.41848908.3096572-1.04610608-.115462-1.4018218-.4251192-.35571573-1.0626796-.30482786-1.424031.11366122z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-update" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m1 13v1c0 .5522847.44771525 1 1 1h14c.5522847 0 1-.4477153 1-1v-1h-1v-10h-14v10zm16-1h1v2c0 1.1045695-.8954305 2-2 2h-14c-1.1045695 0-2-.8954305-2-2v-2h1v-9c0-.55228475.44771525-1 1-1h14c.5522847 0 1 .44771525 1 1zm-1 0v1h-4.5857864l-1 1h-2.82842716l-1-1h-4.58578644v-1h5l1 1h2l1-1zm-13-8h12v7h-12zm1 1v5h10v-5zm1 1h4v1h-4zm0 2h4v1h-4z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-upload" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m10.0046024 0c.5497429 0 1.3179837.32258606 1.707238.71184039l4.5763192 4.57631922c.3931386.39313859.7118404 1.16760135.7118404 1.71431368v8.98899651c0 1.1092806-.8945138 2.0085302-1.9940603 2.0085302h-12.01187942c-1.10128908 0-1.99406028-.8926228-1.99406028-1.9950893v-14.00982141c0-1.10185739.88743329-1.99508929 1.99961498-1.99508929zm0 1h-7.00498742c-.55709576 0-.99961498.44271433-.99961498.99508929v14.00982141c0 .5500396.44491393.9950893.99406028.9950893h12.01187942c.5463747 0 .9940603-.4506622.9940603-1.0085302v-8.98899651c0-.28393444-.2150684-.80332809-.4189472-1.0072069l-4.5763192-4.57631922c-.2038461-.20384606-.718603-.41894717-1.0001312-.41894717zm-1.85576936 4.14572769c.19483374-.19483375.51177826-.19377714.70556874.00001334l2.59099082 2.59099079c.1948411.19484112.1904373.51514474.0027906.70279143-.1932998.19329987-.5046517.19237083-.7001856-.00692852l-1.74638687-1.7800176v6.14827687c0 .2717771-.23193359.492096-.5.492096-.27614237 0-.5-.216372-.5-.492096v-6.14827641l-1.74627892 1.77990922c-.1933927.1971171-.51252214.19455839-.70016883.0069117-.19329987-.19329988-.19100584-.50899493.00277731-.70277808z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-video" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m16.0049107 2c1.1018574 0 1.9950893.89706013 1.9950893 2.00585866v9.98828264c0 1.1078052-.8926228 2.0058587-1.9950893 2.0058587h-14.00982141c-1.10185739 0-1.99508929-.8970601-1.99508929-2.0058587v-9.98828264c0-1.10780515.8926228-2.00585866 1.99508929-2.00585866zm0 1h-14.00982141c-.54871518 0-.99508929.44887827-.99508929 1.00585866v9.98828264c0 .5572961.44630695 1.0058587.99508929 1.0058587h14.00982141c.5487152 0 .9950893-.4488783.9950893-1.0058587v-9.98828264c0-.55729607-.446307-1.00585866-.9950893-1.00585866zm-8.30912922 2.24944486 4.60460462 2.73982242c.9365543.55726659.9290753 1.46522435 0 2.01804082l-4.60460462 2.7398224c-.93655425.5572666-1.69578148.1645632-1.69578148-.8937585v-5.71016863c0-1.05087579.76670616-1.446575 1.69578148-.89375851zm-.67492769.96085624v5.5750128c0 .2995102-.10753745.2442517.16578928.0847713l4.58452283-2.67497259c.3050619-.17799716.3051624-.21655446 0-.39461026l-4.58452283-2.67497264c-.26630747-.15538481-.16578928-.20699944-.16578928.08477139z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-warning" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m9 11.75c.69035594 0 1.25.5596441 1.25 1.25s-.55964406 1.25-1.25 1.25-1.25-.5596441-1.25-1.25.55964406-1.25 1.25-1.25zm.41320045-7.75c.55228475 0 1.00000005.44771525 1.00000005 1l-.0034543.08304548-.3333333 4c-.043191.51829212-.47645714.91695452-.99654578.91695452h-.15973424c-.52008864 0-.95335475-.3986624-.99654576-.91695452l-.33333333-4c-.04586475-.55037702.36312325-1.03372649.91350028-1.07959124l.04148683-.00259031zm-.41320045 14c-4.97056275 0-9-4.0294373-9-9 0-4.97056275 4.02943725-9 9-9 4.9705627 0 9 4.02943725 9 9 0 4.9705627-4.0294373 9-9 9z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-checklist-banner" viewBox="0 0 56.69 56.69"><path style="fill:none" d="M0 0h56.69v56.69H0z"/><clipPath id="b"><use xlink:href="#a" style="overflow:visible"/></clipPath><path d="M21.14 34.46c0-6.77 5.48-12.26 12.24-12.26s12.24 5.49 12.24 12.26-5.48 12.26-12.24 12.26c-6.76-.01-12.24-5.49-12.24-12.26zm19.33 10.66 10.23 9.22s1.21 1.09 2.3-.12l2.09-2.32s1.09-1.21-.12-2.3l-10.23-9.22m-19.29-5.92c0-4.38 3.55-7.94 7.93-7.94s7.93 3.55 7.93 7.94c0 4.38-3.55 7.94-7.93 7.94-4.38-.01-7.93-3.56-7.93-7.94zm17.58 12.99 4.14-4.81" style="clip-path:url(#b);fill:none;stroke:#01324b;stroke-width:2;stroke-linecap:round"/><path d="M8.26 9.75H28.6M8.26 15.98H28.6m-20.34 6.2h12.5m14.42-5.2V4.86s0-2.93-2.93-2.93H4.13s-2.93 0-2.93 2.93v37.57s0 2.93 2.93 2.93h15.01M8.26 9.75H28.6M8.26 15.98H28.6m-20.34 6.2h12.5" style="clip-path:url(#b);fill:none;stroke:#01324b;stroke-width:2;stroke-linecap:round;stroke-linejoin:round"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-chevron-down" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m5.58578644 3-3.29289322-3.29289322c-.39052429-.39052429-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356s1.02368927-.39052429 1.41421356 0l4 4c.39052429.39052429.39052429 1.02368927 0 1.41421356l-4 4c-.39052429.39052429-1.02368927.39052429-1.41421356 0s-.39052429-1.02368927 0-1.41421356z" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(0 1 -1 0 11 1)"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-arrow-right-medium" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="m12.728 3.293 7.98 7.99a.996.996 0 0 1 .281.561l.011.157c0 .32-.15.605-.384.788l-7.908 7.918a1 1 0 0 1-1.416-1.414L17.576 13H4a1 1 0 0 1 0-2h13.598l-6.285-6.293a1 1 0 0 1-.082-1.32l.083-.095a1 1 0 0 1 1.414.001Z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-chevron-down-medium" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m2.00087166 7h4.99912834v-4.99912834c0-.55276616.44386482-1.00087166 1-1.00087166.55228475 0 1 .44463086 1 1.00087166v4.99912834h4.9991283c.5527662 0 1.0008717.44386482 1.0008717 1 0 .55228475-.4446309 1-1.0008717 1h-4.9991283v4.9991283c0 .5527662-.44386482 1.0008717-1 1.0008717-.55228475 0-1-.4446309-1-1.0008717v-4.9991283h-4.99912834c-.55276616 0-1.00087166-.44386482-1.00087166-1 0-.55228475.44463086-1 1.00087166-1z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-chevron-down-small" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="M13.692 5.278a1 1 0 0 1 .03 1.414L9.103 11.51a1.491 1.491 0 0 1-2.188.019L2.278 6.692a1 1 0 0 1 1.444-1.384L8 9.771l4.278-4.463a1 1 0 0 1 1.318-.111l.096.081Z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-chevron-right-medium" viewBox="0 0 10 10"><path d="m5.96738168 4.70639573 2.39518594-2.41447274c.37913917-.38219212.98637524-.38972225 1.35419292-.01894278.37750606.38054586.37784436.99719163-.00013556 1.37821513l-4.03074001 4.06319683c-.37758093.38062133-.98937525.38100976-1.367372-.00003075l-4.03091981-4.06337806c-.37759778-.38063832-.38381821-.99150444-.01600053-1.3622839.37750607-.38054587.98772445-.38240057 1.37006824.00302197l2.39538588 2.4146743.96295325.98624457z" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(0 -1 1 0 0 10)"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-chevron-right-small" viewBox="0 0 10 10"><path d="m5.96738168 4.70639573 2.39518594-2.41447274c.37913917-.38219212.98637524-.38972225 1.35419292-.01894278.37750606.38054586.37784436.99719163-.00013556 1.37821513l-4.03074001 4.06319683c-.37758093.38062133-.98937525.38100976-1.367372-.00003075l-4.03091981-4.06337806c-.37759778-.38063832-.38381821-.99150444-.01600053-1.3622839.37750607-.38054587.98772445-.38240057 1.37006824.00302197l2.39538588 2.4146743.96295325.98624457z" fill-rule="evenodd" transform="matrix(0 -1 1 0 0 10)"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-chevron-up-medium" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m2.00087166 7h11.99825664c.5527662 0 1.0008717.44386482 1.0008717 1 0 .55228475-.4446309 1-1.0008717 1h-11.99825664c-.55276616 0-1.00087166-.44386482-1.00087166-1 0-.55228475.44463086-1 1.00087166-1z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-close-medium" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m2.29679575 12.2772478c-.39658757.3965876-.39438847 1.0328109-.00062148 1.4265779.39651227.3965123 1.03246768.3934888 1.42657791-.0006214l4.27724782-4.27724787 4.2772478 4.27724787c.3965876.3965875 1.0328109.3943884 1.4265779.0006214.3965123-.3965122.3934888-1.0324677-.0006214-1.4265779l-4.27724787-4.2772478 4.27724787-4.27724782c.3965875-.39658757.3943884-1.03281091.0006214-1.42657791-.3965122-.39651226-1.0324677-.39348875-1.4265779.00062148l-4.2772478 4.27724782-4.27724782-4.27724782c-.39658757-.39658757-1.03281091-.39438847-1.42657791-.00062148-.39651226.39651227-.39348875 1.03246768.00062148 1.42657791l4.27724782 4.27724782z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-download-medium" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path d="m12.9975267 12.999368c.5467123 0 1.0024733.4478567 1.0024733 1.000316 0 .5563109-.4488226 1.000316-1.0024733 1.000316h-9.99505341c-.54671233 0-1.00247329-.4478567-1.00247329-1.000316 0-.5563109.44882258-1.000316 1.00247329-1.000316zm-4.9975267-11.999368c.55228475 0 1 .44497754 1 .99589209v6.80214418l2.4816273-2.48241149c.3928222-.39294628 1.0219732-.4006883 1.4030652-.01947579.3911302.39125371.3914806 1.02525073-.0001404 1.41699553l-4.17620792 4.17752758c-.39120769.3913313-1.02508144.3917306-1.41671995-.0000316l-4.17639421-4.17771394c-.39122513-.39134876-.39767006-1.01940351-.01657797-1.40061601.39113012-.39125372 1.02337105-.3931606 1.41951349.00310701l2.48183446 2.48261871v-6.80214418c0-.55001601.44386482-.99589209 1-.99589209z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-info-filled-medium" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m9 0c4.9705627 0 9 4.02943725 9 9 0 4.9705627-4.0294373 9-9 9-4.97056275 0-9-4.0294373-9-9 0-4.97056275 4.02943725-9 9-9zm0 7h-1.5l-.11662113.00672773c-.49733868.05776511-.88337887.48043643-.88337887.99327227 0 .47338693.32893365.86994729.77070917.97358929l.1126697.01968298.11662113.00672773h.5v3h-.5l-.11662113.0067277c-.42082504.0488782-.76196299.3590206-.85696816.7639815l-.01968298.1126697-.00672773.1166211.00672773.1166211c.04887817.4208251.35902055.761963.76398144.8569682l.1126697.019683.11662113.0067277h3l.1166211-.0067277c.4973387-.0577651.8833789-.4804365.8833789-.9932723 0-.4733869-.3289337-.8699473-.7707092-.9735893l-.1126697-.019683-.1166211-.0067277h-.5v-4l-.00672773-.11662113c-.04887817-.42082504-.35902055-.76196299-.76398144-.85696816l-.1126697-.01968298zm0-3.25c-.69035594 0-1.25.55964406-1.25 1.25s.55964406 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25-.55964406 1.25-1.25-.55964406-1.25-1.25-1.25z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-mail-medium" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="m19.462 0c1.413 0 2.538 1.184 2.538 2.619v12.762c0 1.435-1.125 2.619-2.538 2.619h-16.924c-1.413 0-2.538-1.184-2.538-2.619v-12.762c0-1.435 1.125-2.619 2.538-2.619zm.538 5.158-7.378 6.258a2.549 2.549 0 0 1 -3.253-.008l-7.369-6.248v10.222c0 .353.253.619.538.619h16.924c.285 0 .538-.266.538-.619zm-.538-3.158h-16.924c-.264 0-.5.228-.534.542l8.65 7.334c.2.165.492.165.684.007l8.656-7.342-.001-.025c-.044-.3-.274-.516-.531-.516z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-menu-medium" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M21 4a1 1 0 0 1 0 2H3a1 1 0 1 1 0-2h18Zm-4 7a1 1 0 0 1 0 2H3a1 1 0 0 1 0-2h14Zm4 7a1 1 0 0 1 0 2H3a1 1 0 0 1 0-2h18Z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-search-medium" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M11 1c5.523 0 10 4.477 10 10 0 2.4-.846 4.604-2.256 6.328l3.963 3.965a1 1 0 0 1-1.414 1.414l-3.965-3.963A9.959 9.959 0 0 1 11 21C5.477 21 1 16.523 1 11S5.477 1 11 1Zm0 2a8 8 0 1 0 0 16 8 8 0 0 0 0-16Z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-user-single-medium" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M12 1a5 5 0 1 1 0 10 5 5 0 0 1 0-10Zm0 2a3 3 0 1 0 0 6 3 3 0 0 0 0-6Zm-.406 9.008a8.965 8.965 0 0 1 6.596 2.494A9.161 9.161 0 0 1 21 21.025V22a1 1 0 0 1-1 1H4a1 1 0 0 1-1-1v-.985c.05-4.825 3.815-8.777 8.594-9.007Zm.39 1.992-.299.006c-3.63.175-6.518 3.127-6.678 6.775L5 21h13.998l-.009-.268a7.157 7.157 0 0 0-1.97-4.573l-.214-.213A6.967 6.967 0 0 0 11.984 14Z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-eds-i-warning-filled-medium" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m9 11.75c.69035594 0 1.25.5596441 1.25 1.25s-.55964406 1.25-1.25 1.25-1.25-.5596441-1.25-1.25.55964406-1.25 1.25-1.25zm.41320045-7.75c.55228475 0 1.00000005.44771525 1.00000005 1l-.0034543.08304548-.3333333 4c-.043191.51829212-.47645714.91695452-.99654578.91695452h-.15973424c-.52008864 0-.95335475-.3986624-.99654576-.91695452l-.33333333-4c-.04586475-.55037702.36312325-1.03372649.91350028-1.07959124l.04148683-.00259031zm-.41320045 14c-4.97056275 0-9-4.0294373-9-9 0-4.97056275 4.02943725-9 9-9 4.9705627 0 9 4.02943725 9 9 0 4.9705627-4.0294373 9-9 9z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-expand-image" viewBox="0 0 18 18"><path d="m7.49754099 11.9178212c.38955542-.3895554.38761957-1.0207846-.00290473-1.4113089-.39324695-.3932469-1.02238878-.3918247-1.41130883-.0029047l-4.10273549 4.1027355.00055454-3.5103985c.00008852-.5603185-.44832171-1.006032-1.00155062-1.0059446-.53903074.0000852-.97857527.4487442-.97866268 1.0021075l-.00093318 5.9072465c-.00008751.553948.44841131 1.001882 1.00174994 1.0017946l5.906983-.0009331c.5539233-.0000875 1.00197907-.4486389 1.00206646-1.0018679.00008515-.5390307-.45026621-.9784332-1.00588841-.9783454l-3.51010549.0005545zm3.00571741-5.83449376c-.3895554.38955541-.3876196 1.02078454.0029047 1.41130883.393247.39324696 1.0223888.39182478 1.4113089.00290473l4.1027355-4.10273549-.0005546 3.5103985c-.0000885.56031852.4483217 1.006032 1.0015506 1.00594461.5390308-.00008516.9785753-.44874418.9786627-1.00210749l.0009332-5.9072465c.0000875-.553948-.4484113-1.00188204-1.0017499-1.00179463l-5.906983.00093313c-.5539233.00008751-1.0019791.44863892-1.0020665 1.00186784-.0000852.53903074.4502662.97843325 1.0058884.97834547l3.5101055-.00055449z" fill-rule="evenodd"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-github" viewBox="0 0 100 100"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M48.854 0C21.839 0 0 22 0 49.217c0 21.756 13.993 40.172 33.405 46.69 2.427.49 3.316-1.059 3.316-2.362 0-1.141-.08-5.052-.08-9.127-13.59 2.934-16.42-5.867-16.42-5.867-2.184-5.704-5.42-7.17-5.42-7.17-4.448-3.015.324-3.015.324-3.015 4.934.326 7.523 5.052 7.523 5.052 4.367 7.496 11.404 5.378 14.235 4.074.404-3.178 1.699-5.378 3.074-6.6-10.839-1.141-22.243-5.378-22.243-24.283 0-5.378 1.94-9.778 5.014-13.2-.485-1.222-2.184-6.275.486-13.038 0 0 4.125-1.304 13.426 5.052a46.97 46.97 0 0 1 12.214-1.63c4.125 0 8.33.571 12.213 1.63 9.302-6.356 13.427-5.052 13.427-5.052 2.67 6.763.97 11.816.485 13.038 3.155 3.422 5.015 7.822 5.015 13.2 0 18.905-11.404 23.06-22.324 24.283 1.78 1.548 3.316 4.481 3.316 9.126 0 6.6-.08 11.897-.08 13.526 0 1.304.89 2.853 3.316 2.364 19.412-6.52 33.405-24.935 33.405-46.691C97.707 22 75.788 0 48.854 0z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-springer-arrow-left"><path d="M15 7a1 1 0 000-2H3.385l2.482-2.482a.994.994 0 00.02-1.403 1.001 1.001 0 00-1.417 0L.294 5.292a1.001 1.001 0 000 1.416l4.176 4.177a.991.991 0 001.4.016 1 1 0 00-.003-1.42L3.385 7H15z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-springer-arrow-right"><path d="M1 7a1 1 0 010-2h11.615l-2.482-2.482a.994.994 0 01-.02-1.403 1.001 1.001 0 011.417 0l4.176 4.177a1.001 1.001 0 010 1.416l-4.176 4.177a.991.991 0 01-1.4.016 1 1 0 01.003-1.42L12.615 7H1z"/></symbol><symbol id="icon-submit-open" viewBox="0 0 16 17"><path d="M12 0c1.10457 0 2 .895431 2 2v5c0 .276142-.223858.5-.5.5S13 7.276142 13 7V2c0-.512836-.38604-.935507-.883379-.993272L12 1H6v3c0 1.10457-.89543 2-2 2H1v8c0 .512836.38604.935507.883379.993272L2 15h6.5c.276142 0 .5.223858.5.5s-.223858.5-.5.5H2c-1.104569 0-2-.89543-2-2V5.828427c0-.530433.210714-1.039141.585786-1.414213L4.414214.585786C4.789286.210714 5.297994 0 5.828427 0H12Zm3.41 11.14c.250899.250899.250274.659726 0 .91-.242954.242954-.649606.245216-.9-.01l-1.863671-1.900337.001043 5.869492c0 .356992-.289839.637138-.647372.637138-.347077 0-.647371-.285256-.647371-.637138l-.001043-5.869492L9.5 12.04c-.253166.258042-.649726.260274-.9.01-.242954-.242954-.252269-.657731 0-.91l2.942184-2.951303c.250908-.250909.66127-.252277.91353-.000017L15.41 11.14ZM5 1.413 1.413 5H4c.552285 0 1-.447715 1-1V1.413ZM11 3c.276142 0 .5.223858.5.5s-.223858.5-.5.5H7.5c-.276142 0-.5-.223858-.5-.5s.223858-.5.5-.5H11Zm0 2c.276142 0 .5.223858.5.5s-.223858.5-.5.5H7.5c-.276142 0-.5-.223858-.5-.5s.223858-.5.5-.5H11Z" fill-rule="nonzero"/></symbol></svg> </div> </footer> <div class="c-site-messages message u-hide u-hide-print c-site-messages--nature-briefing c-site-messages--nature-briefing-email-variant c-site-messages--nature-briefing-redesign-2020 sans-serif " data-component-id="nature-briefing-banner" data-component-expirydays="30" data-component-trigger-scroll-percentage="15" data-track="in-view" data-track-action="in-view" data-track-category="nature briefing" data-track-label="Briefing banner visible: Flagship"> <div class="c-site-messages__banner-large"> <div class="c-site-messages__close-container"> <button class="c-site-messages__close" data-track="click" data-track-category="nature briefing" data-track-label="Briefing banner dismiss: Flagship"> <svg width="25px" height="25px" focusable="false" aria-hidden="true" viewBox="0 0 25 25" version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"> <title>Close banner</title> <defs></defs> <g stroke="none" stroke-width="1" fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd"> <rect opacity="0" x="0" y="0" width="25" height="25"></rect> <path d="M6.29679575,16.2772478 C5.90020818,16.6738354 5.90240728,17.3100587 6.29617427,17.7038257 C6.69268654,18.100338 7.32864195,18.0973145 7.72275218,17.7032043 L12,13.4259564 L16.2772478,17.7032043 C16.6738354,18.0997918 17.3100587,18.0975927 17.7038257,17.7038257 C18.100338,17.3073135 18.0973145,16.671358 17.7032043,16.2772478 L13.4259564,12 L17.7032043,7.72275218 C18.0997918,7.32616461 18.0975927,6.68994127 17.7038257,6.29617427 C17.3073135,5.89966201 16.671358,5.90268552 16.2772478,6.29679575 L12,10.5740436 L7.72275218,6.29679575 C7.32616461,5.90020818 6.68994127,5.90240728 6.29617427,6.29617427 C5.89966201,6.69268654 5.90268552,7.32864195 6.29679575,7.72275218 L10.5740436,12 L6.29679575,16.2772478 Z" fill="#ffffff"></path> </g> </svg> <span class="visually-hidden">Close</span> </button> </div> <div class="c-site-messages__form-container"> <div class="grid grid-12 last"> <div class="grid grid-4"> <img alt="Nature Briefing" src="/static/images/logos/nature-briefing-logo-n150-white-d81c9da3ec.svg" width="250" height="40"> <p class="c-site-messages--nature-briefing__strapline extra-tight-line-height">Sign up for the <em>Nature Briefing</em> newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.</p> </div> <div class="grid grid-8 last"> <form action="https://www.nature.com/briefing/briefing" method="post" data-location="banner" data-track="signup_nature_briefing_banner" data-track-action="transmit-form" data-track-category="nature briefing" data-track-label="Briefing banner submit: Flagship"> <input id="briefing-banner-signup-form-input-track-originReferralPoint" type="hidden" name="track_originReferralPoint" value="MainBriefingBanner"> <input id="briefing-banner-signup-form-input-track-formType" type="hidden" name="track_formType" value="DirectEmailBanner"> <input type="hidden" value="false" name="gdpr_tick" id="gdpr_tick_banner"> <input type="hidden" value="false" name="marketing" id="marketing_input_banner"> <input type="hidden" value="false" name="marketing_tick" id="marketing_tick_banner"> <input type="hidden" value="MainBriefingBanner" name="brieferEntryPoint" id="brieferEntryPoint_banner"> <label class="nature-briefing-banner__email-label" for="emailAddress">Email address</label> <div class="nature-briefing-banner__email-wrapper"> <input class="nature-briefing-banner__email-input box-sizing text14" type="email" id="emailAddress" name="emailAddress" value="" placeholder="e.g. jo.smith@university.ac.uk" required data-test-element="briefing-emailbanner-email-input"> <input type="hidden" value="true" name="N:nature_briefing_daily" id="defaultNewsletter_banner"> <button type="submit" class="nature-briefing-banner__submit-button box-sizing text14" data-test-element="briefing-emailbanner-signup-button">Sign up</button> </div> <div class="nature-briefing-banner__checkbox-wrapper grid grid-12 last"> <input class="nature-briefing-banner__checkbox-checkbox" id="gdpr-briefing-banner-checkbox" type="checkbox" name="gdpr" value="true" data-test-element="briefing-emailbanner-gdpr-checkbox" required> <label class="nature-briefing-banner__checkbox-label box-sizing text13 sans-serif block tighten-line-height" for="gdpr-briefing-banner-checkbox">I agree my information will be processed in accordance with the <em>Nature</em> and Springer Nature Limited <a href="https://www.nature.com/info/privacy">Privacy Policy</a>.</label> </div> </form> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="c-site-messages__banner-small"> <div class="c-site-messages__close-container"> <button class="c-site-messages__close" data-track="click" data-track-category="nature briefing" data-track-label="Briefing banner dismiss: Flagship"> <svg width="25px" height="25px" focusable="false" aria-hidden="true" viewBox="0 0 25 25" version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"> <title>Close banner</title> <defs></defs> <g stroke="none" stroke-width="1" fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd"> <rect opacity="0" x="0" y="0" width="25" height="25"></rect> <path d="M6.29679575,16.2772478 C5.90020818,16.6738354 5.90240728,17.3100587 6.29617427,17.7038257 C6.69268654,18.100338 7.32864195,18.0973145 7.72275218,17.7032043 L12,13.4259564 L16.2772478,17.7032043 C16.6738354,18.0997918 17.3100587,18.0975927 17.7038257,17.7038257 C18.100338,17.3073135 18.0973145,16.671358 17.7032043,16.2772478 L13.4259564,12 L17.7032043,7.72275218 C18.0997918,7.32616461 18.0975927,6.68994127 17.7038257,6.29617427 C17.3073135,5.89966201 16.671358,5.90268552 16.2772478,6.29679575 L12,10.5740436 L7.72275218,6.29679575 C7.32616461,5.90020818 6.68994127,5.90240728 6.29617427,6.29617427 C5.89966201,6.69268654 5.90268552,7.32864195 6.29679575,7.72275218 L10.5740436,12 L6.29679575,16.2772478 Z" fill="#ffffff"></path> </g> </svg> <span class="visually-hidden">Close</span> </button> </div> <div class="c-site-messages__content text14"> <span class="c-site-messages--nature-briefing__strapline strong">Get the most important science stories of the day, free in your inbox.</span> <a class="nature-briefing__link text14 sans-serif" data-track="click" data-track-category="nature briefing" data-track-label="Small-screen banner CTA to site" data-test-element="briefing-banner-link" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener" href="https://www.nature.com/briefing/signup/?brieferEntryPoint=MainBriefingBanner">Sign up for Nature Briefing </a> </div> </div> </div> <noscript> <img hidden src="https://verify.nature.com/verify/nature.png" width="0" height="0" style="display: none" alt=""> </noscript> <script src="//content.readcube.com/ping?doi=10.1038/s41467-017-02649-z&format=js&last_modified=2018-01-08" async></script> </body> </html>