CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "philpapers.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '913a7acc7ead5cd6',cH: 'JloZ1YlbBSxHu1LCPyaB.oKmLjs9r8l11yOmEVPVx00-1739844615-1.2.1.1-jBzdgNHGBS4JJ_XMqZeX515ybRWr.3YvmG7vF6uG4atmfKOg330LVKDcFpu5lWUv',cUPMDTk: "\/rec\/SWIWLC?__cf_chl_tk=JymQzpALrEUM8C7DmcSMR_yy0JLL7DqpMeP2MmR6TLI-1739844615-1.0.1.1-iX5mB9lgUkCs8pp21I.PT6OK4hcvTmLUpxk_yyPl518",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1739844615',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/rec\/SWIWLC?__cf_chl_f_tk=JymQzpALrEUM8C7DmcSMR_yy0JLL7DqpMeP2MmR6TLI-1739844615-1.0.1.1-iX5mB9lgUkCs8pp21I.PT6OK4hcvTmLUpxk_yyPl518",md: "np5hJ1GqoEeEnm9q4kz.X4qrx7cwwvE41G3SOR1NM1w-1739844615-1.2.1.1-WV3DCqPEJ36.ymV3kDr.5aUQIrFwd3skqdudrbNibn5hUXp9M2GcPXSGzh27_NsNdtdaSjMBTv3l2CqpDzo0qQqEsetCEtcnvHEJf3we9u5IYMI5TQHZXK31VWTak7FTBEwEzgTVXla3Ci5SsWn4rEWYy410d_zvduI1RvIDFiSPUlr9zQSMRY56j17EFp1dw.xkpITy520r0PalqYNJNt7GF_rhDN4.MbefzvHSM8BwPQ7uDcQVhjlEWHmjUFxeRSiRVICYIUrxqHJ77cQ5xpKhxB3gF1fSyfNrX2WCDbREwEaaYcXyxku1l8igr4wXqtOBwMDxVM1.3pxwA8WiFRigqdAW7.uG9PZ13v_R5wmmD6xwN8B4AG4AXSBRGGtUXuq7IzBRPbKOEekqCYpqR7zNgMtRSr1ugfNY.ckAB9CIn.I0lbenFn41BCYm71Jhs1EWjQ0JZ9OxxZeyTeUqrRz2ZNFGO0_izp4WYPkOhCB..RUxDi5e3N3b0xn91BcrC9nNBcX5Q8ToekhQQ0W0fhSAczwGHwuQxdt8XkPRVy.LRm4s.RcwHpS_jA9jYTLsM33i95.eOxY_aVQa8dtzJtF6sYhsM7ooETB934OqfqzGB2ejrF.uUdq7l6LgzWjqaqD66AAxloXqsd6ONRo06SNMWz064Hya4va60xZCYFR8ataCqC29oAE3ktoeeiUTnouDVVG33AfLTUMCanBK081rODWyonKMOVya1yG8DE.y0CiST96T1_AtVEIUFHn3exyV9z3KiCfD_RPzgYqLGWj4hMZYwhojzyrYn3xNX26tHGqmER5Z0AAfAeh7VMSWi3tN21aqog7eKs5lOJrqUARjoueyRyvg_u0NAx4mo6.yUH.2RyTT15NP4OtQDm8f4zQIOUOH7G9KlDG3_PxAIJREvCbr_Y2B0G_hxyTjQrEu4WyxVckz5TnkZmaqN4zAQGBw0VOhEqIwLeFO624qf4zPM0xnMo.PqBNFPA0OYNrhytmcknnixFjKGMTlHhONnHWm7t2kQ1UgAJB.WwK_d7YP_lAar24oG86hp0VcSnCz5BP9Jac.u4Q4oyEYPXc2GUikdoZm1B3vHXnNjrEZX7Kr41f_vXQpuj2cMHxytoNkfhe_DhDB6RihRr6gMaz18SuDOhHfOwPt0yMez1w3364PTavSeCZxEz6IbN4YZeKpiRajoXTO7flh2s5xba5ZQWKHneWS9frmcsnZfDQoiM1g_4bo084m481REi2yfI1.kX9FyhbimAwUPgb2q00_bF679PInqAnsC4z2ZNkFXIy4oXP1peCh0Rsw6Ugu1UwC282i0zKVms6WSAXudUMMNsVY65SJcS06VBnIN_PejtFAN3ONQ8uoXCucVnvPle3f22qp_lVs0M2L386W6VJF9xD2TnN01OEkBTix3byQ7KUl4wqvkaUECDvoahDYfz8yqfo4_nBEqqHiwsVilJf9xswmUagY_pHbHFeG3oMMiKiXcbacStfWpgvhdJdgigURSrMyJE7gvwzPy.TlMDw7xBkSUCK06ocSxKB_CEj7hmuiLREa8hYiF8tEQcaRtC9h4XzB551aubQZyPfIRuSbCEPK_hEbpH1yS0ySmUfAyYwsusTLcS7UFCODXm7IVh7dQ6wG8BJyLcxIiEC3yy.gXjqjnZS6k2W9ysaQHcEfx.bMGnbyozc6PI6MQj6XAh3wxC1xB22sctIE1cYRFBQzgsi3P3w6ERmrN9j_kQHkYt0IyAhZUZdEKqYqwNlqEwAnjlyfxB93FfKOBwDX06QrnsPjp9surPZmjBo4WFs3wrndUHw7MfxIVEtptyVdwim.X9suDKYOdLbO97xahpB3rgUtzRr5DG5Wt2sXFqcw20KtbG3k9AdQzfP7thE4TPJfxaWF8ZxnyjZbZjOT6.vQQ.sPNd2YYum7NaRP5SMBzN3vZSJrqU_jNWmleTkhVCK.te3usft7ytSPRFSfph8pay1JOKl.ZcKdxcHLJivunCqaYCzVsufKLp.MnuIZnTX1gCptVjSBt9lgYhmjLCysDyBOqBPH1PD58kuS3EPi2famVDzOgiXZvR.Nro5HusOdZszC4vTaSG47hSyZeWV7qShUT1ZtdiD8qgSfmxdu6ZRSkAV9q5liB36RPmoJaIt8RAFpvo3_aGkxzyA.r5wmYcuUoExyct0YW7.5ToygPPtJcdAcRVKDYMx1hZYCeeNwwjA4ZAGu8gU3lLxOt2dPkdZPFwsfLj3EWwUMNSgwUiCngIq8RwJu5TQbg2ZGOMs1Poj6lf2sqmukQ4YJr_T1piMkr5EMqo4YgzLAsSVOivK_dS72Wb2YeWi3frZ0cxzICgWWZOQ6Tw2gBG9vjJv49BnGgzydZlmGCq33t3CoQIXrqLzmG4fP8muAaz_01zfqXgDFzKp6NDZhKYJdK5rfMOUV6E.NE5ksNVT3R.FtVX2d7gUfnRy86vaWzCwCbtfnVcIneG.wb_sNF7NTVp2wpLoI3dNx4D5VMM2YMzHUiQ",mdrd: "lJPjJxvhWO0WGfnYzyFPIC8DUnmdFNFLAIrJfoEbZUk-1739844615-1.2.1.1-3g5ks1h2w6iC416lkZq65gfCMKrq7q96SSCJ5hV4hC_bgbJO.vYCQHBZex0q6qVjAqbEzDyEI34PpYx1pL4QqQPQ69oKWT2JcyQVUacD7FFxyrwIqAaFnTuGhhtUtQZwvDQG14GhvRDpVyWLcbF66BfPvTa_rvnfh80ZPiYGPKPvnbZZRzOaLnN26RA7nZD_RzqO3YGKT651AdMqFt1vRXjkqbCDU.s1bAKXvhL8Hl_y5iUCZnnGi10vwLwkZRGX2KhdIEa_QyXT8jq_JQSbE_mb1PfC2I1z.F8Lw0_koTwhDiv8CXRR1EFW.pSOBQqoexQxmYfuFYkoL5BJAI0fLT.qK4z3UB5p6chECAxJ_Qu6M40QvX54DC9mlO6br_g0Tq0ubprTWTiQB6yorf3J2kbhBRCfDAqv0DkHUfnqN0Jj0ASTGyXa_1JLdUQmp.SnQuNoI3.eHqv9JREs3Srm4hEPEuAIdjpe66HwwsThtgWHYlFeqcPE5QSET46B_9PMzQ5dN66S7Wiblst6i.6DY1ZcJWrvvVyyvbyYn6K7t.n.sPTzNzcv.zTS2i17JOaqOaCVPjTNLgX187Fh0hTZCtUVdfMLWj1AnwU4ttVpBl.RK.5nZg7HQCTOUERSEIS6SFC..PAcNFj6fDssWkyxmZtqrHHHwha5lb37t_ikv73HNVJkzQlTgkFH5ZSJAeYkCw9g1fS8EnINfmrKCYHCgJ3YGNTjkfWENEIHaHc6quoWh1LwAbAKsmhiG0QYfB_8YMXx7mswUbnvqk9dJwWalr5.Z_B71Ivg.xuYG_fcOzN.bHQOOQV4EvuYNBCyDUwlBAthZVbdPaLXHOb7lgAKe1lkWFRUGgWfloCmlRGfIxUbcwfrt3GCwvSzN4u.ZCWa407m27.pabPKKpK_NO2wzCwas6.KNfK2v1.SnilDaMkxjVRIUPVD2pZ1scwDvmvJfhG8DlpVdC03jc2gVjy8vYCktvFzyc8gQ63_dfVERc7Yi3O32NvWTd9boFSV.Ba5_nDBHfb7cZjXVVHEbL9j0vqm.wXDPQ6KUb7J_Jx5BxaSFb3Z1lelrrj.QWr.pEFw2NQNpWdOYoAuhbgMeD_rMMNchxZ4Wf8zqav.9AreGYyY3N1gpeo_DhEJQP3ikdHu9rw5McIyTQkG5ouSxDRinWUfTmCvszZyPIl2gxkk4axRjJ8DOIN8HKFdG0BG3miuy7Z2aP_0.gCt9Or_wSFA7ebFbclrafYNN6qR.UMw9PH5YDsxvahTQ83._WrjoL8G6lcOLLR0lSGdeu4_Je16Awr3y2J8qyApz_tBgqghHOlqfSH7DDYLanslA.dvI36W8tnYKArN_Pq3EMa9tv_aZjVLVGvHHOswTe_kFtwK9qrIsRF2LHe_zuyskOoH6bKOncn03tO5X4n9rt3MYRv9vW0DpSgRJ39Y6obInDDUb5AjXWRdCEnmr3aZ5BmtlWImWUHTnSpeb0GZIIbCkOIV_ye5RXZ8ucTnJkOy8YHL2CSJPT0PNUe3oeSrHs9AvCOaUX2nUNU8dSK2YfVAtE2imGWjsTnRpCheQ.Qs.vOCu5me5UXgb0RWVYtdSEehSIQ7gmk9tB.9rK_wKxVL1HONycsna5ph6evFlalPyxQGOnHWKjvbyE2Z_oQg_weMUJ5WCI0PT3LFNCmRZDIKsTI0ZB.obGxsKJczwZzEQ7SNakN_wEnl_vGS1WW2vso4ArBb.Zloeo4.z4UJUsv4u_0og47eLKnA8U01eR4U.BCpYJj7b7bZ8nTcGk2.MmTx4WwhzlWmcNVqPcL32eNjbNJNbXQzKXnFHF.jK8NqrmcxpKz5nDs3ysk7p.Fqmh0OevIAPB0VSs2Ocg2.7uxABJwpH6pn8HxbKXyu1kVEFVzMyuRc014prhou86RTLkmRtZ48KnEfzdPltK7BxeboLqxT57g_UskergO8nV1jhScCHQ8"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=913a7acc7ead5cd6';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/rec\/SWIWLC?__cf_chl_rt_tk=JymQzpALrEUM8C7DmcSMR_yy0JLL7DqpMeP2MmR6TLI-1739844615-1.0.1.1-iX5mB9lgUkCs8pp21I.PT6OK4hcvTmLUpxk_yyPl518" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>