CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "commonslibrary.parliament.uk",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e71e6fe7f7181ce',cH: 'Vci2RkLMYYHZxDz54KM7RdJKSjSwxQNE9fFEj6l.C8U-1732372699-1.2.1.1-3_QWPUQKpNdl4Wzq_LayKZLyPCEmfJe9H6PQX771mX82ut1ncLrRahLYacmXSnBv',cUPMDTk: "\/research-briefings\/cbp-8951\/?__cf_chl_tk=0uSOuPqr4quQL2lh1xhNM5QsA3n.UUehQA0nEVvSaII-1732372699-1.0.1.1-NMEgvW1i2c5ZjeA64BSkhWXz5ZrTLCxY0KODJkaJ_AQ",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732372699',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/research-briefings\/cbp-8951\/?__cf_chl_f_tk=0uSOuPqr4quQL2lh1xhNM5QsA3n.UUehQA0nEVvSaII-1732372699-1.0.1.1-NMEgvW1i2c5ZjeA64BSkhWXz5ZrTLCxY0KODJkaJ_AQ",md: "3G8FsAfL9KWtB9fOBuVXtR8eMthQBqf5a7mmFyIQnZk-1732372699-1.2.1.1-LmmkP7r8l1vlYN1pHqDXuGeepKEwkEdM0PER7Zy1goetDFkAz2Csgeb1x.fnKYKJXJJxj22VrFy.HDxu5Gf69bM4ZSIrrxnjM.8e15_Xp8OduUvDjJEbVBwstHyXJ58QGyE4MN5Ma1.5tu31tw8I1d4o5r0Dj4SZU_IE4x1zNHGCJPdrJyebzpYIzdGL7x_7dLW9BboNeJdifqyoig_qCMJ8RX2y5Gjdrgdgq3D4XTFkpqxxXsr_E3IGApFJvsfoR8MXWSaEbQgDOftPVeodqrEDT7mDqeO0Y9Rj6BTSX75GoUrWV9.g91zqbDkSfFnN1FSOnjMkYEl7M7cADU5oGiH.K.hlYkFZS3XYUm.PreB3QszScDIVojUgCOUvcfNgDF3zmmiQucV3GlecEajPxPu.m2NwcK0Lz1JrUCQiSDS0f3bcvkJI.uzWNJWqEnUTFw6FG._lQqMexjAZ.DvAK2gycM0EjBxkNzTb.cfI_.0n9vgx_CDH8VhixnKNwk9.2g2zBDFghoxGn2NsXKBbspOHqs.I_3iaByF2ryxBIIPQ1O9vSF9cGrnMcfgcfcB3fPPugY3DcH9oBo8ngnWGLcVIBNBNXuNakpIxmiR4gVfKJ.EEOfph6sTBIPKIzoVpi8iUbtzG.NArkeA7VXJoWWTy7XpceIiJoUz6YgwkC_CP8NbK7_oM1J_aT_Pa4SGhx0GKdOenRSL6WZh9xgXLTDDWboc6L8DnONAh0voZO9CRE9YMNj73uhVb2USmFIbibI0QzCZa7G.uDr_OS6Pr_l74PWbLjEGzENvc2.Qp5ttQ8h0qlpcUtvoCfnpUnLRuLyxrHEgZMioU96BibtRx8qG7pFTqW25X.rN7uUb1P9ClLldvxduOmnkE61OE8QtPoNegMP.K3z2UeMgZQ9lfwLSgGiDRfk6.yCyz6QYEGGx0u7P3q5YQ7IJJRvhFgvd10h2OWMqfZlz1zAR7a0IvOSfF00x32k5qskMXU0Mce60hngLvhAPjCTGkhOW93o9fonFBpAogLU9hxn2zCvnIGorV2V.Y0Xky_Vp4xAZ82VsOc6m13BLqJuBJ2LLm_KsSExxcBpq_Nf10cKJAuSZlirMkWKIEdmLIMy_keaXcXXdWJcM1cO8_OVziH5dKn1AM2NUX3_t.0dZqlGwmkj05B1sqFioEkDjIEnBXeRzVKaErIlKulRpY2ubV9tdw63FunC5AeZvsXKeFSm_ta6OlVRxJ3lNZ52DotCixd1LFYyFdx3xAOi4OkLlqSdnftjBwq5CMqoZI_rn_F.ChTECpz.Lvxd1F8fTNjtyr1bAA_NdtC6WD5N14uoGbE_Mh0qgeno2BuJAfZBFfaik7OL4DRlvlKl0Mr5t0sEVJJXOOrSBOB52fFzuJTBVSwJC286.egTV3KUXRZIDdvIE7_rMU7Yp8DiDKq_.vJV9J1qGS6QbJMaeuN5HazqbmK.7yyT9vE7VdYOCeUCjZ7rf3ot5U.7I6uaoeWGBb1lN3jCYJf6Ex4jVupmPBiktxY5GuO4vk4aU9YTx5exopxxVlzcdDkVO5B4Hb0nDHXucqq2Tb323z5m68jrFr57MpMBQCXf25av1c4QmSYq1w25CzQPnMT2wzRn60HCu2hmAIEUlJCUjJTg0nJ_wKoC3cYmar.jH3BXAwXqCpBRibN7ujGyAb9dUhMPyJrbS34wKJddsUMpOJTOGTDgqloyc8iCyZAg2M6tmx1srqppm8YRZdGL.o9Mi29qNI35pdVrGsX5.QIkUygMB9w6X9.uMZ7ex7rxc5bkh_Jwr4tZ19sEW_8aBCnTiKf7hyYrd_qylbdqV._1Por60TEPpHl3FcHBUL3pzmr.1Ww0XL1BJBJ3nvGaQWm3_CIrts4DyiNzLrJvC9cUpH.8u44NB2fLo7aTmcVIDaroJV0tNU17CFy6rGx_YR1eicw8AwP_RMmg.yEsRFxmFsYo3XpZIh4NfcpKCQLu7RZpkTORfPAKBoMJzMo17jNG9IhD4A65r5Pt15leafERA8Pk2sglX1k71tbPrWO.3BdUqguv3yFqrarBURPg.hoCakqIdDjCFT5FqGQ.W5zoivuy0P7tCDBA1Oi9rAF4TY9dRH.U7f6yR9Gr7I3COBOM2EconJDz6rw8sC_ak1E24LWIX5X19wnIImUCzwQHmZJTrZ22kTCeHebEu5O8EqbjDN5HcZ4S6f3jx6.ZnrG7x_BmYPdg5PM0OY8BvqGMNeQRny3hJjxg97kv5elzSwmBn5eTC3KZbJZ2iZ527XhCYvoG3XPyZ7r17JHpQ5utUbTLH61A8YegpLpgNX1ba32C0xa.E.DNg7Ne6gz7kJnGho.vEVqQPaNEsuKmf4ryJPp8DHHJEQGNdwYKeRe5klUsraC0c4eyORI.hRk2E7UXqFY0ZQcLvSA4Rngpec6y0rNuaxMQDm1qKdGHjB8Vs.sAjVcbhBLFyRznHyJ92RW0qL03umIPoJOTvPye7U5PODYn0nMWLaE3BmiO3OPp194numCWPUadMEnreQI9SwDXeGe5118bU2tZwBLWVGE8xbEVWa1RrXjRSbTPPSX3fbw5hRoosBaECZ2aipPq8Tma8vFqurrGD7v8_hUeKt3e8Hr_LsKqsFFiH8rPJZB2NGS4SpUcLhBlNVwYet_tzolNEeT5yFA2QeuvbJNcslO06hCC398xXCnImr3YG.1jb9uV5p.OjFuyYKdKgEetEwXMxLsrQjULQi2sj9JpSE6iIKsyEDTeq7Zos5hdHGH6R7Yli7lDCTaKhpxnJMMYPGmhYxZMJfmRxCz0vYktxYagGoXy0d8sWsHoIxZTzyFbWLW0RrFUSQnzJuS3fUYfPOhP_giIYpo_V6yND1TtpRHu9bgKTeUkPmqttO4POa2qd8pd01soGDuPVB74jC4VtIdh9IztxLGbKuOxNPsWP8eV.CEy4p4l2XJzlbKAlcU85WlPGfV.BHTBKorCEfPt5gtzM",mdrd: "4pK5GcDu4JDc5eJXqNdUmab6jzn4iJ7U3_mWUO0lnjY-1732372699-1.2.1.1-dB.fQeXZNS2STaubqkOym2YhEyckWcmnAZr.GYpB2MRMShzvnNs.V_Clixwl027CuDK.tM.UzDEOY7iJvXueWTiay3OkF4riTU7x9.DJoEuMs9DnqnFs6AJSDlseWSLV9oOUcairXPDv5PD_Ev5SteW00yIRYX6Gq2IZX6biUCjn_1dL7T1AqREsEEmE7P_H6BIFPomJ3AfiYhwWqzf0y1dAFS5fTRAvMazZYafCAhBxbd2yzsR8WCOCMbkOOB3DIfQ0Lukc68O_RI2WoBLFHoE8vau5IAVfgjUU7vFKxzB0nRG05W4R54_WB1pZajGD2JXrCtuObibx9_0uGj99P7sjirRO1GEmPLeJdRiVZRye.grh_Li0j7w51T6f0AZBGK_l5_eRFpfwF9Vpqx.IMp_SSxWaW6FNiJZuSB4RP.1DJUuuXKPGCalV8rmN1s_Ibw2I_GXjhy4E.aWQhWm9o_d6sx8uoXI8xoNmnJjDYum7XeJOMUKJJHC5KVefipQzMngRSAwe2hzbsqzJOlMyWC7vVRv_diq7VgWFosXntqYhtC.keqObI4rpZQpgBYhEcBCfK51a.xeV3zdKsFXKR5H4rWgVu_ZsZ5wDZYRo_umWuKBlUILwzfon55srnTM0Q6ZNzdsKmgIjOFhCByojli73Rtp87mPWPruLHvtd4jLFvBY2xHxd9VPNLEOql8tIwCJbFxceFdyaHZ3XOAZp6aV6CBIFLr0hfqU4yXFNAnjIi.yvC2qR2ixLfdjhQCj2_.m2JwbjtFQtC6fTsjO3APpH2roUfFbRUjtVjCStX_L0zGVDfoD6RSocPLBrHHfe875G8ADRS6pKRuNgyq6BkV_O.o_6UvUXK9Qd3xX_m8JodDorvLEzoRbipFrXLMvUMYhoPu_tVMogdAVhthaG_MNpPi3e3b55T2Hb8oD4exfFVklUrQnntfNKQ97Psd97G4PLDzNp1NdTbj6ye2WUaSv87H3aYTxv.CXK9RBpoaPPRWH79H3LkzKKRw7H4jD7i3LS1Oo6TGEZEH9eS_YLIWr0BvSLBSoCjCmscD5la6RsLlhUwRU.t3FAQrXd55tbRWHwn5YFLivIybmqneZu5X7flp8xIete3SMpIMsTH8V9vemjknD.u2ESXZEMv3x3eggtNYKi4giojgSFapQ2vXHfIQlh_Y7iy.tyglXlw4dsB2hAG9IstHooInR1dpbMXtAc18ct5V6ziXdNp6.tPwD3IGXmCOc9LknYgeA_4Dw9E5kEr23lXcbgzjMc7A986fCsJk3yRfTZPFO_tdI7CTTRGSRQEpW0Luq9nXcdbEcUVzOh9aN0N0heh1gNPTuS0sYedXk_Z988oVeI94cT6ingGINF1FZqkc7L4McobAPuP9x4VwLM.Qy1knfIlzBHIaBXgr8Fr1PJ1EtI_L6BZDfA07k7KDyELSDY.oiTwdN.EuPUGE4cyHiuuyCSlEjSucBI.5Hj_yBI5Wbjeu_znxkTY_735fOretj1Pg4za6OXbVlBo1Nw8DJrCDkT6Xtk0D_seEW0YXtOM3eDVtsn0dlif7jjaZrMrvzX7f_9dOcjwQxZpCqNB212OccxOfbzyNpEOSvlMLTVVAMevOcCLQvm7UztUzdQoSOc6LUvysvOjIh77IFYs.eCnX_OQTywiCqNCo3W.2ylZeBXy5tJ2cblFQxcxPlocRthEbJ5rqxbB0Kf4JWkbi.FZBjQyCplEbEzPFiofJgoBAIw_bOSSrisF4fn4l2M3uDNCUmyc5uaIkLgij5LjttCkMgOoFwCecmr.G58qTv7XjEp7p7DZOa.dnGv9OU8zRK1AejL_4I9WazMkpkyUnvO8X4_WEBBtvd_3LDUuOEAnJVP7nGOIljqRVr7Cx0e2fJbMvdzvxMeF39Mpiq9TooV2dWxY8Wm1J3.yH2lTkvXCWji3p953oLqMiVJbLtb0siRNLSeGAWFJyXzUAO6TeWD2qLe0OZdsJ4Ycg40AVi06m6CCezwRg"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e71e6fe7f7181ce';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/research-briefings\/cbp-8951\/?__cf_chl_rt_tk=0uSOuPqr4quQL2lh1xhNM5QsA3n.UUehQA0nEVvSaII-1732372699-1.0.1.1-NMEgvW1i2c5ZjeA64BSkhWXz5ZrTLCxY0KODJkaJ_AQ" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>