CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "commonslibrary.parliament.uk",cType: 'managed',cRay: '91398485fd7a3e07',cH: '71T5jpdecS41Z.jH5hYHwhqLiK_.BDhlKORkVLXuheA-1739834527-1.2.1.1-PgeEc6fRo6ecKJqTOcRmh8cd6eFRrUP4v8uoGMVCVQytP0znblHzCEGqi65KmhJk',cUPMDTk: "\/research-briefings\/cbp-9635\/?__cf_chl_tk=x.WoHGdTApnsB1C6e_JAm.iZbJLSeU.Hk6VMssQY9qM-1739834527-1.0.1.1-B.qCuxoiVGlUXPiAhSZkKUGkr4CJViUTtKCOzVVQyO0",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1739834527',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/research-briefings\/cbp-9635\/?__cf_chl_f_tk=x.WoHGdTApnsB1C6e_JAm.iZbJLSeU.Hk6VMssQY9qM-1739834527-1.0.1.1-B.qCuxoiVGlUXPiAhSZkKUGkr4CJViUTtKCOzVVQyO0",md: "k58yvmcRskZ2nl2HwLbNdRv8kYuVf_4TV2FtUglM4yI-1739834527-1.2.1.1-UXoP9Gb80KpMKkDieLTpqrilCcHBS2RSktLs5oY6sBwOUdlU07Kv9nRkANUxd84L22cpOIpwGGFYaLjt35rqlIPJouWww1wv2mGNxHGTamjg2ftkQ5P3dLqts1GPU9Ybnv902e4VVm178XxErkusZHITRtp6KOz7owkJq73VefoS_QvYBixclUBkXPsoqO_OQcGGGLFHMS1RRnygY.r63gm5zx4QvYsBStpkL4hjwN0BJMnOWnDjVbc9pUelXhpTrcClfnuXHN8xsGP6moWaILKYQMLwPlqMX7_DxnLfWDPnocj8sUH2XskAwIxNQTK68X6wzQCWmkp.PH3YOYGdNG7QcLoBV8md3IXadW8Fwnbk2j15IP1UOVn2mP8pabebfFEu9B6UydTbS9.9WHegthRyrt3ofPtvngOetqhg1k_ohpDTiO53KL3ciG4b9jG9D1ndHSkf1sm44owBhR4sL18EMsRY2fYqMMoPjMHDaqiz90QZaHFZyUmfO5bZnemjr3H6Tw7elsRC3xxRsoyw.DRzA0jR6ih18A2k.F7KJIBmhL_OeeWnpVUQt3d1VeKSecR3HxyCBt9LuPCvgD9Mmizw1na9i.0Cb823ym3Uhx55GpkFF7OprPZCveMfUe8mve1kyptdzchQvObOSdetpUxvop2m5odAXYbrC2_MVG7Ol1NJKcjK2RZRw9V7mH5U588cqImmBH8v5wLId0zKVu93pJri44sc8UEJ00vQucHWB6uXkPtNkYCMgndP9tCxPk5aneREiTjF_T_fWXQrVvv0I0SnLNwJUx7uHVnuwATVsR0R4UHIiYmZLlfyXEQX61B.GYgAym3dTnPsJxAtGOF3xebgHgFnNriq2nNdVNkyEVV2pQAx.X56JS2HYe_Lnc1f4iGlN6cI.QG0cXSjezaA6_dCL9vXr84.qFN18PT6fC0HCbEqBxTiPS6jRTn.NaijSzW2ZwW_Tc3yeLXkPHaSFokhCZYGtIWg9W9RwkEzUveMAGbmFdATNuZUU.mNnmCyF5pe8sdk4Rqb17wKDr1eyiDqmr_Ue3Mr5Dn2U9EG7vlx08VouqQwM8VjnjGXR_W.w2UUroqrDoBim_cYbQzwyMjD1xZhBqBiC7kl_sFeRIXT9uQXhGO_ODe9mtiVa.Xdy9BHOiD6ygEIoFiTLQ1JpNaoKQ7LKpIZSNzBE2fe0O2RyXjYmWb.OoH_vRrgE8e73ZE1c8QJ.C_jaZ.x1zehj4ygM6js7W1QkcNNqzb5Z9bLAjfdyb9664G1Zw.ncGdp4wj0OYeS.0fzh7HGd5hM3rFz5q0nl.adX0EQ_8Noo0bjEYnraa9BqQSxbAkSOYUrZ5LaApHXScmS.H5xpWyla49w..LTXv9fWbIDbQIBnpMV2S8AxriiwrN_9v2.t9pxBmmaIis19btmESeDvSo2JA4768rBqLZgp2hs7Y81W36u07nuoU_t_XvQbwrkBP3r85kBgaCcx07bq6L9YJpJyUP502gcSe1RDokHQAj.KkW0RroJhFY011OnLvitft9nzHBnMkXOaUqMuGAziemnKLZJLNUNHAOJvlAY_Tqjh2kci3iCj.5MGaj.xSsFhJeeTPTjahZJ_tP8g.rgXaqWnu5mMlSYQNpCUrl00dhD8OG4TCOZVQTsGvcUuCHAypTFOluWYJJPsqq8OnIqdWx.slEhWWY1I6_ZnyET1FFN1yY0_zzgHnfP4cAQCad93rY10NKFXnGUuwnQFjTlskCMXVt_2R3nKgBrd0fB5YZ7dYqFJypX6uaPuJHtDpD0d9hq_KWbH7Z00tdR3699m2nCCLEqrCxN0ZrvO4x_fGsjfH7XSmlgWfTCU1RO4lKIkLrRDehvxDkQp0i6gR.rrSmoOcqjLqpWKWzXyAf.1sSfAtGltIAs3ZFlAott1y12kriHsGlIOlNtPQhYAT.CallIZMunOr_Rxf.KK1XYrTQ62R4EmXDePf1D3bpkSmx5RFj818WPnS3ihSaI4AMJi9MC7PcsT92iKarwXOnpFEufbzhe03zZuDMY1NvjoBahcH33TVZsFnUWAM5vm9WfQDPyE6LtCK9dlW4zt1COmWObkZ3VDlralgj3cDGXCfaYgsFosrvi6fhEjEoN3KiqCEeG4zpie.n7YUWxX2JPIdmUBQzFB7QVbk6PuOfs963kTbV.H0_TqxyDQlSpbTM1hh1kRIri7xCsHnVaZQrHUR2u985hlNmBkYtEfC.hKXuYrLvQCC04OjFOWK7X2gb_ChN2Vtn5Lb3OLLKw.e6w7p1WXt5i6apJEHCgalEvydH4IfpuD0vYS8osmJYOkmkskeQY5vu2ffk3YEY3Chnipv.0cvO62rANpnO6ILpTrzbZqIQ.8qMvHl9Lrcg0.wAKvRpoej3ASAx1iQswxCstKhOR_GxpworyrkNfue_k.7mMDFSspruLVDTqdcIjINIeiD7ODHOwf8liVVSFtTRW4uSJgkFt8XOnWvF09G7U_s7dVvp.fACfEn1USzn5rV2OTi_Vg8jfXM1FDyAVyULV0Y_RZIGubaWJKEhiFx6.3sW6ZeNAjKV4oRJZG8n2qEHMxg",mdrd: "opGOLC8Cxw1eJnrOfEcgE4YisdZFUpDEbcUHsaxZzJY-1739834527-1.2.1.1-qf2vCudUkYN3LO83_VTuU1_Sae_1ySr3Qph4fJOaqHHmP703ntAHI.eiEqZDHmaUeSzUpDWQWUvndrkRMfOp_4XJ2pBhu44.y1xIj5pMFAWGamcPVzKGkILN5Nt.CT8oztCdfFM9411nc7lHQzCOFBu_y92m37.jKNuGjH966WB1EsItonZ_IKz_i3HK4ycPkl0VK6pLC5xjQwaVFiNxC6sQI6obwgYszhXcoEab0xKrNhtqKWgk_HwKI9xQE3Yyj6puQR_ipJLcWuvxi9lEsVwtsV0DyKlbsDKGFYBAadyfvib7.f9s4zQriDjwOZdqOXxcoVVNH7XAR5xGu10v8t4LtAyIFhQJtNfFxh0m1RPT9B53B78afHLVQ.MgLj16yoRMmL_Gld8jmcipr4sdwoyKXiJXi4llO51ZmBa.K44K43YYj4wmQ22_xL8Hq0R8XcsRyOwABeNZxELnFsJAgRi_KqNVaeL_.AOanU41iJi5qO9x.U3AIUCXMgyglecFQ2.S3yjP.MjRGzR8JwPlKWJpo6P.HOXJtUiFBXu0yrNXc4kE.1uqfcC6CjIK32NamzD2fEWfKSKFkitqSEXH55VO9c58RxnxR53DayWmE3G5rANGCBKSk8PISO2LPK1V36YF8ah6w2oly_PLu27m8YYnHC95QrkuPT_Y5KeJH1EubsTQdpTWkJvv4.Dut7Fx6D4F3oSLqJGVxqSLd8bIXK5k9x7llbuCyQmZYDwwyiPJliroWptMFBY1jrkZOP_A4JiZ1K19lrNmea8jSAPWy7iEQ4rVy2O_8Yo.lV.C4LB1aIEOGkGQMgIhChNihIEW5w6rED8PXX3TpoFeo7bCIg9qUJniP4C3V8qi1pmrLJvARb.K1PFIfZydwUC6aHLDPvsOnuH1kOSi4vycFsyhl5sI56kLXH56fl36WUoWpWSZ4qDcoHwT4UIOHQKGyDNBGdEgXMg4HMRiyoUiXqsGZnODCiCddQfiWi9KeN35F.FByTZDmGk6mXlEsC4jrhm0aSXhX1RSXnbf1VU0CDCgUEpHxYn8ItctwokW7LVIHJtyWgQ3kTXP3HLpVtca_adGgEBbA6MpPM_R5P98huYjlwUR2ktSOGyPckR2IIFW87h5F7L6o7pBQYbh_ki1qii0WtSX7dCQzVPot37jhpTy_ky7.CzRTNAMbCN_GJro5SuZWFwBM5mWS0ZOvj.rorcPECosYqmGK6m8X6ivG4JHy5YhxHuUTndBO0QpoG8t_0cw235viG2XwwEui4wbRLgkpUPerxKntEsBweujdviyzG0s0PV8H4DkYxdE4aBwtiUqd5zDstbdcyWSvWLR.b6ieedLt1cZJwWrhQhaODUDURn3Kv5DRZ6ZcSfXoa3gQGRCcg3E1YDgMUgwhSeGXYAein7pghOmYbV2UQP5FkM4yADe0l7_5HLlT19J3ztaF3naKAoR4LDcQanRbGC6BYnQVfFqf_KjHN0.FGGaQRW6fun6TOTFhJxd.mWULv_xcjASPKXWYB.I8_98HzpeYHm_RmAC9N0Nk8EEP7p95pCwoYL52J1Bg0Sd3lLaHvOU2Pdifr45rRfyzw1GtvQGLjhJrK373iRdPiSNaX_ctiIVqfueIV9gEq35.n.sx7TAPo94jrFyGn6Fq3CEk7hQDSVV78R2T0R8OqWPorbuoEYgolC3YvyNRNpdoV_B2xqb8EY_V1Xlgx7dMyxO10TSI9GCQeVXGy46bBVQpKoILbAqNrgtKpHB2SiV3CVyUe6G0H6bkgyGvQK7HS9IO3innrGJiSdQxBs5wF4OaqmOaZvBkskrrdC2veCtuOvk1qLLXOztNlRr68y9u4EfzYkxeh_.m40p6mf10kvhbrh4thMHWcGhqrXCMnUp74jFXgsYEp3z_nx0ED5MLB5aM155a399wSPoH8BrRmEVfoO0O.6cn9HLvfzDlnXE2Qk5FgehZlxcZveSEKhS51fPFf4eQ8FiiIPWNlGiU6CFpziJUlxt6A"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=91398485fd7a3e07';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/research-briefings\/cbp-9635\/?__cf_chl_rt_tk=x.WoHGdTApnsB1C6e_JAm.iZbJLSeU.Hk6VMssQY9qM-1739834527-1.0.1.1-B.qCuxoiVGlUXPiAhSZkKUGkr4CJViUTtKCOzVVQyO0" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>