CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html><head><meta charSet="utf-8"/><meta name="viewport" content="initial-scale=1.0, width=device-width"/><meta name="robots" content="index,follow"/><meta name="googlebot" content="index,follow"/><meta name="description" content="The pseudo-left’s hostility to public health and support for imperialism found sharp expression in their universal demand—echoing that of the Western corporate media and political establishment—that China abandon its Zero-COVID strategy."/><meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"/><meta name="twitter:site" content="@WSWS_Updates"/><meta property="og:title" content="The international pseudo-left and the lifting of Zero-COVID in China: Part 1"/><meta property="og:description" content="The pseudo-left’s hostility to public health and support for imperialism found sharp expression in their universal demand—echoing that of the Western corporate media and political establishment—that China abandon its Zero-COVID strategy."/><meta property="og:url" content="https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2023/03/23/ljwc-m23.html"/><meta property="og:image" content="https://www.wsws.org/asset/0117e946-da0a-4ea5-8bfd-a00495f3c69a?rendition=1600x900"/><meta property="og:site_name" content="World Socialist Web Site"/><link rel="canonical" href="https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2023/03/23/ljwc-m23.html"/><title>The international pseudo-left and the lifting of Zero-COVID in China: Part 1 - World Socialist Web Site</title><meta name="id" content="4a897772-8dd7-4e59-a75e-c40c21d33297"/><meta name="language" content="en"/><meta name="keywords" content="China, COVID-19, Zero-COVID, pseudo-left, Pabloism, International Viewpoint, Trotskyism, herd immunity, Jacobin, Stalinism, Maoism"/><meta name="next-head-count" content="17"/><meta charSet="utf-8"/><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/css/nprogress.css"/><script type="text/javascript"> var _paq = window._paq || []; _paq.push(["setCookieDomain", "*.wsws.org"]); _paq.push(['trackVisibleContentImpressions']); _paq.push(['enableHeartBeatTimer']); (function() { var u="https://piwik.wsws.org/analytics/piwik/"; _paq.push(['setTrackerUrl', u+'matomo.php']); _paq.push(['setSiteId', '1']); var d=document, g=d.createElement('script'), s=d.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; g.type='text/javascript'; g.async=true; g.defer=true; g.src=u+'matomo.js'; s.parentNode.insertBefore(g,s); })(); </script><script type="text/javascript"> (function(w,d,t,u,n,a,m){w['MauticTrackingObject']=n; w[n]=w[n]||function(){(w[n].q=w[n].q||[]).push(arguments)},a=d.createElement(t), m=d.getElementsByTagName(t)[0];a.async=1;a.src=u;m.parentNode.insertBefore(a,m) })(window,document,'script','https://mautic.wsws.org/mtc.js','mt'); </script><script async="" src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=UA-121098080-1"></script><script type="text/javascript"> window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || []; function gtag(){dataLayer.push(arguments);} gtag('js', new Date()); gtag('config', 'UA-121098080-1', { send_page_view: false, anonymize_ip: true }); </script><script type="text/javascript"> !function(t,e) { if (!e.documentMode) { var n = function() { (n.q = n.q || []).push(arguments) }; t.gsc = t.gsc || n; } }(window,document); </script><script type="text/javascript"> (function() { var host = 'wsws.org'; var element = document.createElement('script'); var firstScript = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; var url = 'https://cmp.inmobi.com'.concat('/choice/', 'JH3fNnZC0zWt-', '/', host, '/choice.js?tag_version=V3'); var uspTries = 0; var uspTriesLimit = 3; element.async = true; element.type = 'text/javascript'; element.src = url; firstScript.parentNode.insertBefore(element, firstScript); function makeStub() { var TCF_LOCATOR_NAME = '__tcfapiLocator'; var queue = []; var win = window; var cmpFrame; function addFrame() { var doc = win.document; var otherCMP = !!(win.frames[TCF_LOCATOR_NAME]); if (!otherCMP) { if (doc.body) { var iframe = doc.createElement('iframe'); iframe.style.cssText = 'display:none'; iframe.name = TCF_LOCATOR_NAME; doc.body.appendChild(iframe); } else { setTimeout(addFrame, 5); } } return !otherCMP; } function tcfAPIHandler() { var gdprApplies; var args = arguments; if (!args.length) { return queue; } else if (args[0] === 'setGdprApplies') { if ( args.length > 3 && args[2] === 2 && typeof args[3] === 'boolean' ) { gdprApplies = args[3]; if (typeof args[2] === 'function') { args[2]('set', true); } } } else if (args[0] === 'ping') { var retr = { gdprApplies: gdprApplies, cmpLoaded: false, cmpStatus: 'stub' }; if (typeof args[2] === 'function') { args[2](retr); } } else { if(args[0] === 'init' && typeof args[3] === 'object') { args[3] = Object.assign(args[3], { tag_version: 'V3' }); } queue.push(args); } } function postMessageEventHandler(event) { var msgIsString = typeof event.data === 'string'; var json = {}; try { if (msgIsString) { json = JSON.parse(event.data); } else { json = event.data; } } catch (ignore) {} var payload = json.__tcfapiCall; if (payload) { window.__tcfapi( payload.command, payload.version, function(retValue, success) { var returnMsg = { __tcfapiReturn: { returnValue: retValue, success: success, callId: payload.callId } }; if (msgIsString) { returnMsg = JSON.stringify(returnMsg); } if (event && event.source && event.source.postMessage) { event.source.postMessage(returnMsg, '*'); } }, payload.parameter ); } } while (win) { try { if (win.frames[TCF_LOCATOR_NAME]) { cmpFrame = win; break; } } catch (ignore) {} if (win === window.top) { break; } win = win.parent; } if (!cmpFrame) { addFrame(); win.__tcfapi = tcfAPIHandler; win.addEventListener('message', postMessageEventHandler, false); } }; makeStub(); function makeGppStub() { const CMP_ID = 10; const SUPPORTED_APIS = [ '2:tcfeuv2', '6:uspv1', '7:usnatv1', '8:usca', '9:usvav1', '10:uscov1', '11:usutv1', '12:usctv1' ]; window.__gpp_addFrame = function (n) { if (!window.frames[n]) { if (document.body) { var i = document.createElement("iframe"); i.style.cssText = "display:none"; i.name = n; document.body.appendChild(i); } else { window.setTimeout(window.__gpp_addFrame, 10, n); } } }; window.__gpp_stub = function () { var b = arguments; __gpp.queue = __gpp.queue || []; __gpp.events = __gpp.events || []; if (!b.length || (b.length == 1 && b[0] == "queue")) { return __gpp.queue; } if (b.length == 1 && b[0] == "events") { return __gpp.events; } var cmd = b[0]; var clb = b.length > 1 ? b[1] : null; var par = b.length > 2 ? b[2] : null; if (cmd === "ping") { clb( { gppVersion: "1.1", // must be “Version.Subversion”, current: “1.1” cmpStatus: "stub", // possible values: stub, loading, loaded, error cmpDisplayStatus: "hidden", // possible values: hidden, visible, disabled signalStatus: "not ready", // possible values: not ready, ready supportedAPIs: SUPPORTED_APIS, // list of supported APIs cmpId: CMP_ID, // IAB assigned CMP ID, may be 0 during stub/loading sectionList: [], applicableSections: [-1], gppString: "", parsedSections: {}, }, true ); } else if (cmd === "addEventListener") { if (!("lastId" in __gpp)) { __gpp.lastId = 0; } __gpp.lastId++; var lnr = __gpp.lastId; __gpp.events.push({ id: lnr, callback: clb, parameter: par, }); clb( { eventName: "listenerRegistered", listenerId: lnr, // Registered ID of the listener data: true, // positive signal pingData: { gppVersion: "1.1", // must be “Version.Subversion”, current: “1.1” cmpStatus: "stub", // possible values: stub, loading, loaded, error cmpDisplayStatus: "hidden", // possible values: hidden, visible, disabled signalStatus: "not ready", // possible values: not ready, ready supportedAPIs: SUPPORTED_APIS, // list of supported APIs cmpId: CMP_ID, // list of supported APIs sectionList: [], applicableSections: [-1], gppString: "", parsedSections: {}, }, }, true ); } else if (cmd === "removeEventListener") { var success = false; for (var i = 0; i < __gpp.events.length; i++) { if (__gpp.events[i].id == par) { __gpp.events.splice(i, 1); success = true; break; } } clb( { eventName: "listenerRemoved", listenerId: par, // Registered ID of the listener data: success, // status info pingData: { gppVersion: "1.1", // must be “Version.Subversion”, current: “1.1” cmpStatus: "stub", // possible values: stub, loading, loaded, error cmpDisplayStatus: "hidden", // possible values: hidden, visible, disabled signalStatus: "not ready", // possible values: not ready, ready supportedAPIs: SUPPORTED_APIS, // list of supported APIs cmpId: CMP_ID, // CMP ID sectionList: [], applicableSections: [-1], gppString: "", parsedSections: {}, }, }, true ); } else if (cmd === "hasSection") { clb(false, true); } else if (cmd === "getSection" || cmd === "getField") { clb(null, true); } //queue all other commands else { __gpp.queue.push([].slice.apply(b)); } }; window.__gpp_msghandler = function (event) { var msgIsString = typeof event.data === "string"; try { var json = msgIsString ? JSON.parse(event.data) : event.data; } catch (e) { var json = null; } if (typeof json === "object" && json !== null && "__gppCall" in json) { var i = json.__gppCall; window.__gpp( i.command, function (retValue, success) { var returnMsg = { __gppReturn: { returnValue: retValue, success: success, callId: i.callId, }, }; event.source.postMessage(msgIsString ? JSON.stringify(returnMsg) : returnMsg, "*"); }, "parameter" in i ? i.parameter : null, "version" in i ? i.version : "1.1" ); } }; if (!("__gpp" in window) || typeof window.__gpp !== "function") { window.__gpp = window.__gpp_stub; window.addEventListener("message", window.__gpp_msghandler, false); window.__gpp_addFrame("__gppLocator"); } }; makeGppStub(); var uspStubFunction = function() { var arg = arguments; if (typeof window.__uspapi !== uspStubFunction) { setTimeout(function() { if (typeof window.__uspapi !== 'undefined') { window.__uspapi.apply(window.__uspapi, arg); } }, 500); } }; var checkIfUspIsReady = function() { uspTries++; if (window.__uspapi === uspStubFunction && uspTries < uspTriesLimit) { console.warn('USP is not accessible'); } else { clearInterval(uspInterval); } }; if (typeof window.__uspapi === 'undefined') { window.__uspapi = uspStubFunction; var uspInterval = setInterval(checkIfUspIsReady, 6000); } })(); </script><link rel="preload" href="/_next/static/css/9f99d90987bb43af.css" as="style"/><link rel="stylesheet" href="/_next/static/css/9f99d90987bb43af.css" data-n-g=""/><noscript data-n-css=""></noscript><script defer="" nomodule="" src="/_next/static/chunks/polyfills-5cd94c89d3acac5f.js"></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/webpack-f962eb33e34e2dbc.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/framework-3f6ca6aeff951304.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/main-44c556c415e0b01a.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/pages/_app-6915a01813c40d13.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/1350-b3d56d9126eca1e0.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/6391-b9f9ce76b0abdd6b.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/1674-c8ea272ffddabb63.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/3836-68ec2a2016aa1209.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/3255-0918ccf11f7313b0.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/4431-f2a82eb544d70f7c.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/4649-4e1d68df57025e05.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/6151-ecd6540231869dd1.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/4584-47078904d75ce335.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/3925-8f23ab0fb649e2f3.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/1021-40676decc7bf388a.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/chunks/pages/%5Blocale%5D/articles/%5B...path%5D-b85dfb17a515e4ba.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/bba5cf3e/_buildManifest.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/bba5cf3e/_ssgManifest.js" defer=""></script><script src="/_next/static/bba5cf3e/_middlewareManifest.js" defer=""></script></head><body><div id="__next" data-reactroot=""><div lang="en"><style> .topnav-enter { opacity: 0; } .topnav-enter .wsws-header { opacity: 0; } .topnav-enter.topnav-enter-active { opacity: 1; transition: opacity 200ms ease-out ; } .topnav-enter.topnav-enter-active .wsws-header { opacity: 1; transition: opacity 300ms ease-out; transition-delay: 200ms; } .topnav-exit { opacity: 1; } .topnav-exit .wsws-header { opacity: 1; } .topnav-exit.topnav-exit-active { opacity: 0; transition: opacity 250ms ease-in; } .topnav-exit.topnav-exit-active .wsws-header { opacity: 0; transition: opacity 250ms ease-in; } </style><style> .headroom { top: 0; left: 0; right: 0; zIndex: 1; z-index: 2147483647; } .headroom--unfixed { position: relative; // transform: translateY(0); transform: translateY(-100%); } .headroom--scrolled { transition: transform 200ms ease-in-out; } .headroom--unpinned { position: fixed; transform: translateY(-100%); } .headroom--pinned { position: fixed; transform: translateY(0%); } </style><div style="position:absolute" class="headroom-wrapper"><div class="headroom headroom--unfixed"><div class="dn-p bg-white w-100 shadow-2 bb b--black-10 pv1 _pv2-m"><div class="wsws-header mw9-m center"><section><div class="mw-75rem-m center"><div class="w-100 flex items-center ph3 ph4-m ph1-xl"><div class="dn-p flex items-center"><a class="db items-center-l f4 b lh-solid black no-underline pointer flex-l"><svg class="db dn-l" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="menu-hamburger"><path d="M13,18.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5h-21 c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V18.5z M13,25.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5 h-21c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V25.5z M13,32.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3 c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5h-21c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V32.5z"></path></g></svg><svg class="dn db-l" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="menu-hamburger"><path d="M13,18.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5h-21 c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V18.5z M13,25.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5 h-21c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V25.5z M13,32.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3 c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5h-21c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V32.5z"></path></g></svg><span class="dn _dib-xl ml2-l avenir f7 b lh-solid black ttu tracked-half">Menu</span></a><a class="dn _db-ns _flex-l items-center-l f4 b lh-solid black no-underline pointer ml3-ns ml4-m" href="/en/search"><svg class="db dn-l" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="search"><path d="M35.602,32.755l-5.878-5.879c0.956-1.481,1.521-3.24,1.521-5.132c0-5.235-4.262-9.494-9.496-9.494 c-5.236,0-9.494,4.259-9.494,9.494c0,5.236,4.258,9.495,9.494,9.495c1.891,0,3.649-0.562,5.132-1.519l5.878,5.878 c0.195,0.196,0.518,0.196,0.712,0l2.132-2.132C35.799,33.271,35.799,32.951,35.602,32.755z M15.269,21.744 c0-3.571,2.906-6.479,6.479-6.479c3.573,0,6.479,2.907,6.479,6.479c0,3.573-2.905,6.479-6.479,6.479 C18.176,28.224,15.269,25.317,15.269,21.744z"></path></g></svg><svg class="dn db-l" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="search"><path d="M35.602,32.755l-5.878-5.879c0.956-1.481,1.521-3.24,1.521-5.132c0-5.235-4.262-9.494-9.496-9.494 c-5.236,0-9.494,4.259-9.494,9.494c0,5.236,4.258,9.495,9.494,9.495c1.891,0,3.649-0.562,5.132-1.519l5.878,5.878 c0.195,0.196,0.518,0.196,0.712,0l2.132-2.132C35.799,33.271,35.799,32.951,35.602,32.755z M15.269,21.744 c0-3.571,2.906-6.479,6.479-6.479c3.573,0,6.479,2.907,6.479,6.479c0,3.573-2.905,6.479-6.479,6.479 C18.176,28.224,15.269,25.317,15.269,21.744z"></path></g></svg><span class="dn dib-xl ml2-l avenir f7 b lh-solid black ttu tracked-half">Search</span></a></div><div class="w-100 flex flex-column flex-row-p items-center pv3 pv3-p ph3 ph4-m ph0-p"><a class="db no-underline " href="/en"><img class="db dn-m _pb1" src="/static/img/wswslogo4red.png" style="max-height:1.0rem"/><img class="dn db-m dn-l" src="/static/img/wswslogo4red.png" style="max-height:1.0rem"/><img class="dn db-l" src="/static/img/wswslogo4red.png" style="max-height:1.0rem"/></a></div><div class="dn-p flex items-center"><a class="dn _db-ns _flex-l items-center-l f4 b lh-solid black no-underline pointer"><svg class="db dn-l _hover-dark-red" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="clock"><path d="M24,12c-6.617,0-12,5.383-12,12s5.383,12,12,12c6.617,0,12-5.383,12-12S30.617,12,24,12z M24,33c-4.971,0-9-4.029-9-9 s4.029-9,9-9c4.971,0,9,4.029,9,9S28.971,33,24,33z M25,22.277v-4.762C25,17.24,24.758,17,24.483,17h-0.982 c-0.274,0-0.5,0.24-0.5,0.516L23,22.277C22.7,22.452,22.452,22.7,22.277,23H19.5c-0.275,0-0.5,0.273-0.5,0.548V24.5 c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h2.777c0.346,0.595,0.984,1,1.723,1c1.105,0,2-0.896,2-2C26,23.262,25.595,22.624,25,22.277z"></path></g></svg><svg class="dn db-l _hover-dark-red" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="clock"><path d="M24,12c-6.617,0-12,5.383-12,12s5.383,12,12,12c6.617,0,12-5.383,12-12S30.617,12,24,12z M24,33c-4.971,0-9-4.029-9-9 s4.029-9,9-9c4.971,0,9,4.029,9,9S28.971,33,24,33z M25,22.277v-4.762C25,17.24,24.758,17,24.483,17h-0.982 c-0.274,0-0.5,0.24-0.5,0.516L23,22.277C22.7,22.452,22.452,22.7,22.277,23H19.5c-0.275,0-0.5,0.273-0.5,0.548V24.5 c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h2.777c0.346,0.595,0.984,1,1.723,1c1.105,0,2-0.896,2-2C26,23.262,25.595,22.624,25,22.277z"></path></g></svg><span class="dn dib-xl ml2-xl avenir f7 b ttu tracked-half nowrap">Latest</span></a><a class="db items-center-l f4 b lh-solid black no-underline pointer ml3-ns ml4-m flex-l" href="/en/profile"><svg class="db dn-l _hover-dark-red" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="4 4 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="user-rounded"><path d="M16,4A12,12,0,1,0,28,16,12.01312,12.01312,0,0,0,16,4ZM12,14.18628V12a4,4,0,0,1,8,0v2.18628a.67538.67538,0,0,1,.18378.76245l-.36756,1.10254a1.491,1.491,0,0,1-.93255.87939L18.719,18.24805A1.99992,1.99992,0,0,1,16.73444,20H15.26556a1.99992,1.99992,0,0,1-1.98455-1.752l-.16468-1.31739a1.491,1.491,0,0,1-.93255-.87939l-.36756-1.10254A.67538.67538,0,0,1,12,14.18628ZM16,25a8.97812,8.97812,0,0,1-6.85107-3.178,1.98667,1.98667,0,0,1,.70416-.91919l1.78656-1.25049A3.99566,3.99566,0,0,0,15.26562,22h1.46876a3.99566,3.99566,0,0,0,3.626-2.34766l1.78656,1.25049a1.98621,1.98621,0,0,1,.70423.91919A8.97828,8.97828,0,0,1,16,25Z"></path></g></svg><svg class="dn db-l _hover-dark-red" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="4 4 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="user-rounded"><path d="M16,4A12,12,0,1,0,28,16,12.01312,12.01312,0,0,0,16,4ZM12,14.18628V12a4,4,0,0,1,8,0v2.18628a.67538.67538,0,0,1,.18378.76245l-.36756,1.10254a1.491,1.491,0,0,1-.93255.87939L18.719,18.24805A1.99992,1.99992,0,0,1,16.73444,20H15.26556a1.99992,1.99992,0,0,1-1.98455-1.752l-.16468-1.31739a1.491,1.491,0,0,1-.93255-.87939l-.36756-1.10254A.67538.67538,0,0,1,12,14.18628ZM16,25a8.97812,8.97812,0,0,1-6.85107-3.178,1.98667,1.98667,0,0,1,.70416-.91919l1.78656-1.25049A3.99566,3.99566,0,0,0,15.26562,22h1.46876a3.99566,3.99566,0,0,0,3.626-2.34766l1.78656,1.25049a1.98621,1.98621,0,0,1,.70423.91919A8.97828,8.97828,0,0,1,16,25Z"></path></g></svg><span class="dn _dib-xl ml2-xl avenir f7 b ttu tracked-half">Profile</span></a></div></div></div></section></div></div></div></div><div class="z-max bg-white relative bt bw1 bn-p shadow-1 shadow-0-p"><div class="_bb b--black-10 "><div class="wsws-header bb bn-m bn-p b--black-10"><section><div class="dn-p mw-75rem-l center relative"><div class="dn db-m absolute top-1 left-1"><div class="avenir f7 f6-l lh-solid black _hover-dark-red nowrap _pt1 _pt2-l _mt1 _mt2-m no-underline pointer _pa2 _ba _b--black-10 _br2"><div class="dib w-auto flex items-center"><svg class="dib mr1" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:0.75rem;fill:#000;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="globe"><path d="M24.253,16.074c-0.281,0.143-0.464,0.462-0.688,0.673c-0.217,0.046-0.426-0.029-0.565-0.202 c0.022,0.418-0.536,0.677-0.645,1.109c0.7,0.469,1.792,0.47,2.595,0.644C24.906,17.547,24.262,16.87,24.253,16.074z M24,12.417c-6.397,0-11.583,5.187-11.583,11.583S17.603,35.583,24,35.583S35.583,30.396,35.583,24S30.397,12.417,24,12.417 z M30.33,31.812c-1.025,1.122-2.896,2.225-4.438,2.188c-0.307-0.389,0.022-0.541,0.035-0.895c-0.833-0.174-1.319-0.93-1.745-1.598 c-0.134-0.843,1.017-1.558,0.708-2.255c-0.547,0.073-1.102-0.064-1.535-0.412c-0.219-0.175-0.399-0.396-0.539-0.638 c-0.328-0.166-0.668-0.307-1.01-0.441c-1.07-0.423-2.235-0.802-3.042-1.667c0.066-0.804-0.399-1.24-0.92-1.763 c-0.547-0.548-0.289-0.974-0.535-1.693c-0.166-0.484-0.429-0.883-0.394-1.41c0.035-0.517,0.154-1.021,0.338-1.505 c0.35-0.923,0.854-1.767,0.944-2.771c0.071-0.42-0.607-0.539-0.089-1.027c0.547-0.516,1.23-1.092,2.027-1.092 c0.406,0,0.625,0.208,1.022,0.11c0.382-0.094,0.773-0.157,1.162-0.218c0.797-0.123,1.578-0.273,2.229-0.783L24.604,14h0.627 l0.056-0.055c0.883,0.731,3.048,0.447,2.754,2.103l-0.026,0.136c-0.75,0.059-1.448-0.047-2.159-0.294 c-0.011,0.286,0.042,0.604-0.029,0.886c1.152,0.66,2.66,1.155,3.244,2.46c-0.495,0.621-1.124,0.341-1.791,0.341 c-0.215,0.236-0.293,0.414-0.209,0.731c-0.539,0.273-1.04,0.562-1.21,1.18c-0.089,0.322-0.024,0.756-0.145,1.052 c-0.166,0.406-0.611,0.653-0.781,1.072c-0.048,0.554,0.255,1.025-0.264,1.466c-0.801-0.002-0.87-0.648-1.479-0.85 c-0.543-0.178-1.171-0.025-1.733-0.135c-0.758,0.292-0.681,2.246,0.384,1.878c0.491-0.17,0.531-0.538,1.16-0.416 c0.514,0.261,0.21,0.859,0.166,1.271c0.334,0.201,0.831,0.065,1.034,0.489c0.044,0.273-0.102,0.8,0.064,1.024 c0.368,0.59,1.529-0.381,1.833-0.486c0.882-0.305,1.877-0.21,2.794-0.248c0.691,0.545,1.792,0.267,2.392,0.973 c0.406-0.068,0.734-0.298,1.098,0.037C32.246,29.955,31.25,30.928,30.33,31.812z"></path></g></svg><span class="dib _b _ttu _tracked-quarter v-mid _pv1">English</span><svg class="dib ml1" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:0.625rem;fill:#000;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="chevron-down"><path d="M24,31.17L13.507,20.677l3.672-3.672L24,23.816L30.816,17l3.676,3.676L24,31.17z"></path></g></svg></div></div></div><div class="dn db-m absolute top-1 right-1"><div class="avenir f7 f6-l lh-solid black _hover-dark-red nowrap _pt1 _pt2-l _mt1 _mt2-m no-underline pointer _pa2 _ba _b--black-10 _br2"><a class="no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/special/pages/contact.html">Contact</a><span class="dib black-20 mh2">|</span><a class="no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/special/pages/icfi/wsws.html">About</a><span class="dib black-20 mh2">|</span><a class="relative no-underline underline-hover pointer" title="Profile" style="top:3px" href="/en/profile"><svg version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="4 4 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="user-rounded"><path d="M16,4A12,12,0,1,0,28,16,12.01312,12.01312,0,0,0,16,4ZM12,14.18628V12a4,4,0,0,1,8,0v2.18628a.67538.67538,0,0,1,.18378.76245l-.36756,1.10254a1.491,1.491,0,0,1-.93255.87939L18.719,18.24805A1.99992,1.99992,0,0,1,16.73444,20H15.26556a1.99992,1.99992,0,0,1-1.98455-1.752l-.16468-1.31739a1.491,1.491,0,0,1-.93255-.87939l-.36756-1.10254A.67538.67538,0,0,1,12,14.18628ZM16,25a8.97812,8.97812,0,0,1-6.85107-3.178,1.98667,1.98667,0,0,1,.70416-.91919l1.78656-1.25049A3.99566,3.99566,0,0,0,15.26562,22h1.46876a3.99566,3.99566,0,0,0,3.626-2.34766l1.78656,1.25049a1.98621,1.98621,0,0,1,.70423.91919A8.97828,8.97828,0,0,1,16,25Z"></path></g></svg></a></div></div></div><div class="mw-75rem-m center pv2-m"><div class="dn _db dn-m pv2 ph3 bb b--black-10 tc"><a class="db avenir f8 f7-ns f6-m f5-l lh-solid black-70 ttu nowrap overflow-hidden no-underline" href="/en/special/pages/icfi/about.html"><span>International Committee of the Fourth International (ICFI)</span></a></div><div class="w-100 flex items-center ph3 ph4-m ph1-xl"><div class="dn-p flex items-center"><a class="db items-center-l f4 b lh-solid black no-underline pointer dn-m"><svg class="db dn-l" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="menu-hamburger"><path d="M13,18.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5h-21 c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V18.5z M13,25.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5 h-21c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V25.5z M13,32.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3 c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5h-21c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V32.5z"></path></g></svg><svg class="dn db-l" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1.25rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="menu-hamburger"><path d="M13,18.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5h-21 c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V18.5z M13,25.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5 h-21c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V25.5z M13,32.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3 c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5h-21c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V32.5z"></path></g></svg><span class="dn _dib-xl ml2-l avenir f7 b lh-solid black ttu tracked-half">Menu</span></a><a class="dn _db-ns _flex-l items-center-l f4 b lh-solid black no-underline pointer ml3-ns ml4-m" href="/en/search"><svg class="db dn-l" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="search"><path d="M35.602,32.755l-5.878-5.879c0.956-1.481,1.521-3.24,1.521-5.132c0-5.235-4.262-9.494-9.496-9.494 c-5.236,0-9.494,4.259-9.494,9.494c0,5.236,4.258,9.495,9.494,9.495c1.891,0,3.649-0.562,5.132-1.519l5.878,5.878 c0.195,0.196,0.518,0.196,0.712,0l2.132-2.132C35.799,33.271,35.799,32.951,35.602,32.755z M15.269,21.744 c0-3.571,2.906-6.479,6.479-6.479c3.573,0,6.479,2.907,6.479,6.479c0,3.573-2.905,6.479-6.479,6.479 C18.176,28.224,15.269,25.317,15.269,21.744z"></path></g></svg><svg class="dn db-l" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1.25rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="search"><path d="M35.602,32.755l-5.878-5.879c0.956-1.481,1.521-3.24,1.521-5.132c0-5.235-4.262-9.494-9.496-9.494 c-5.236,0-9.494,4.259-9.494,9.494c0,5.236,4.258,9.495,9.494,9.495c1.891,0,3.649-0.562,5.132-1.519l5.878,5.878 c0.195,0.196,0.518,0.196,0.712,0l2.132-2.132C35.799,33.271,35.799,32.951,35.602,32.755z M15.269,21.744 c0-3.571,2.906-6.479,6.479-6.479c3.573,0,6.479,2.907,6.479,6.479c0,3.573-2.905,6.479-6.479,6.479 C18.176,28.224,15.269,25.317,15.269,21.744z"></path></g></svg><span class="dn dib-xl ml2-l avenir f7 b lh-solid black ttu tracked-half">Search</span></a></div><div class="w-100 flex flex-column flex-row-p items-center pv3 pv3-p ph3 ph4-m ph0-p"><a class="dn db-m avenir f8 f7-ns f6-m f5-l black-70 lh-solid nowrap pb1 mb1 mb2-m overflow-hidden no-underline" href="/en/special/pages/icfi/about.html"><span>International Committee of the Fourth International (ICFI)</span></a><a class="db no-underline pv1 pv0-m" href="/en"><img class="db dn-m _pb1" src="/static/img/wswslogo4red.png" style="max-height:1.25rem"/><img class="dn db-m dn-l" src="/static/img/wswslogo4red.png" style="max-height:1.5rem"/><img class="dn db-l" src="/static/img/wswslogo4red.png" style="max-height:2rem"/></a></div><div class="dn-p flex items-center"><a class="dn _db-ns _flex-l items-center-l f4 b lh-solid black no-underline pointer"><svg class="db dn-l _hover-dark-red" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="clock"><path d="M24,12c-6.617,0-12,5.383-12,12s5.383,12,12,12c6.617,0,12-5.383,12-12S30.617,12,24,12z M24,33c-4.971,0-9-4.029-9-9 s4.029-9,9-9c4.971,0,9,4.029,9,9S28.971,33,24,33z M25,22.277v-4.762C25,17.24,24.758,17,24.483,17h-0.982 c-0.274,0-0.5,0.24-0.5,0.516L23,22.277C22.7,22.452,22.452,22.7,22.277,23H19.5c-0.275,0-0.5,0.273-0.5,0.548V24.5 c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h2.777c0.346,0.595,0.984,1,1.723,1c1.105,0,2-0.896,2-2C26,23.262,25.595,22.624,25,22.277z"></path></g></svg><svg class="dn db-l _hover-dark-red" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1.25rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="clock"><path d="M24,12c-6.617,0-12,5.383-12,12s5.383,12,12,12c6.617,0,12-5.383,12-12S30.617,12,24,12z M24,33c-4.971,0-9-4.029-9-9 s4.029-9,9-9c4.971,0,9,4.029,9,9S28.971,33,24,33z M25,22.277v-4.762C25,17.24,24.758,17,24.483,17h-0.982 c-0.274,0-0.5,0.24-0.5,0.516L23,22.277C22.7,22.452,22.452,22.7,22.277,23H19.5c-0.275,0-0.5,0.273-0.5,0.548V24.5 c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h2.777c0.346,0.595,0.984,1,1.723,1c1.105,0,2-0.896,2-2C26,23.262,25.595,22.624,25,22.277z"></path></g></svg><span class="dn dib-xl ml2-xl avenir f7 b ttu tracked-half nowrap">Latest</span></a><a class="db items-center-l f4 b lh-solid black no-underline pointer ml3-ns ml4-m dn-m" href="/en/profile"><svg class="db dn-l _hover-dark-red" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="4 4 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="user-rounded"><path d="M16,4A12,12,0,1,0,28,16,12.01312,12.01312,0,0,0,16,4ZM12,14.18628V12a4,4,0,0,1,8,0v2.18628a.67538.67538,0,0,1,.18378.76245l-.36756,1.10254a1.491,1.491,0,0,1-.93255.87939L18.719,18.24805A1.99992,1.99992,0,0,1,16.73444,20H15.26556a1.99992,1.99992,0,0,1-1.98455-1.752l-.16468-1.31739a1.491,1.491,0,0,1-.93255-.87939l-.36756-1.10254A.67538.67538,0,0,1,12,14.18628ZM16,25a8.97812,8.97812,0,0,1-6.85107-3.178,1.98667,1.98667,0,0,1,.70416-.91919l1.78656-1.25049A3.99566,3.99566,0,0,0,15.26562,22h1.46876a3.99566,3.99566,0,0,0,3.626-2.34766l1.78656,1.25049a1.98621,1.98621,0,0,1,.70423.91919A8.97828,8.97828,0,0,1,16,25Z"></path></g></svg><svg class="dn db-l _hover-dark-red" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="4 4 24 24" style="width:1.25rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="user-rounded"><path d="M16,4A12,12,0,1,0,28,16,12.01312,12.01312,0,0,0,16,4ZM12,14.18628V12a4,4,0,0,1,8,0v2.18628a.67538.67538,0,0,1,.18378.76245l-.36756,1.10254a1.491,1.491,0,0,1-.93255.87939L18.719,18.24805A1.99992,1.99992,0,0,1,16.73444,20H15.26556a1.99992,1.99992,0,0,1-1.98455-1.752l-.16468-1.31739a1.491,1.491,0,0,1-.93255-.87939l-.36756-1.10254A.67538.67538,0,0,1,12,14.18628ZM16,25a8.97812,8.97812,0,0,1-6.85107-3.178,1.98667,1.98667,0,0,1,.70416-.91919l1.78656-1.25049A3.99566,3.99566,0,0,0,15.26562,22h1.46876a3.99566,3.99566,0,0,0,3.626-2.34766l1.78656,1.25049a1.98621,1.98621,0,0,1,.70423.91919A8.97828,8.97828,0,0,1,16,25Z"></path></g></svg><span class="dn _dib-xl ml2-xl avenir f7 b ttu tracked-half">Profile</span></a></div></div></div><div class="dn db-m dn-p bt bb-m b--black-10 _ph3-ns _ph4-m"><nav class="dn db-m relative flex justify-center w-100 tc _pv1 b"><ul class="list flex avenir pv0 _ph2 ph0 ma0 nowrap _bl b--black-10" style="font-size:0"><li class="dib flex f7 f6-ns lh-solid"><a class="relative dib pv2 ph3 no-underline underline-hover pointer" title="Menu" style="top:8px"><svg version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="menu-hamburger"><path d="M13,18.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5h-21 c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V18.5z M13,25.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5 h-21c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V25.5z M13,32.5c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h21c0.275,0,0.5-0.225,0.5-0.5v-3 c0-0.275-0.225-0.5-0.5-0.5h-21c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5V32.5z"></path></g></svg></a></li><li class="dib flex f7 f6-ns lh-solid _mr2"><div class="bg-black-20 mv2" style="width:1px;height:2rem"></div><a class="relative dib pv2 ph3 no-underline underline-hover pointer" title="Latest" style="top:8px" href="/en/archive/recent"><svg version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="clock"><path d="M24,12c-6.617,0-12,5.383-12,12s5.383,12,12,12c6.617,0,12-5.383,12-12S30.617,12,24,12z M24,33c-4.971,0-9-4.029-9-9 s4.029-9,9-9c4.971,0,9,4.029,9,9S28.971,33,24,33z M25,22.277v-4.762C25,17.24,24.758,17,24.483,17h-0.982 c-0.274,0-0.5,0.24-0.5,0.516L23,22.277C22.7,22.452,22.452,22.7,22.277,23H19.5c-0.275,0-0.5,0.273-0.5,0.548V24.5 c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h2.777c0.346,0.595,0.984,1,1.723,1c1.105,0,2-0.896,2-2C26,23.262,25.595,22.624,25,22.277z"></path></g></svg></a><div class="bg-black-20 mv2" style="width:1px;height:2rem"></div></li></ul><div class="relative overflow-hidden"><div class="absolute left-0 top-0 z-max pv2 ph1 tl db" style="left:-2px;min-width:1rem;height:100%;background:linear-gradient(270deg, rgba(255,255,255,0), rgba(255,255,255,1) 100%)"></div><ul class="relative z-0 list avenir flex _bl b--black-10 pv0 ph2 ma0 nowrap overflow-x-scroll overflow-y-hidden scrollbar-width-none scroll-touch" style="height:3rem;font-size:0"><li class="dib f7 f6-ns _b lh-solid pv1"><a class="dib pa2 no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/topics/site_area/perspectives"><span class="dib pv1">Perspectives</span></a></li><li class="dib f7 f6-ns _b lh-solid pv1"><a class="dib pa2 no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/topics/region/namerica"><span class="dib pv1">World</span></a></li><li class="dib f7 f6-ns _b lh-solid pv1"><a class="dib pa2 no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/topics/site_area/workers"><span class="dib pv1">Global class struggle</span></a></li><li class="dib f7 f6-ns _b lh-solid pv1"><a class="dib pa2 no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/topics/event/coronavirus"><span class="dib pv1">Pandemic</span></a></li><li class="dib f7 f6-ns _b lh-solid pv1"><a class="dib pa2 no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/topics/site_area/arts"><span class="dib pv1">Arts & Culture</span></a></li><li class="dib f7 f6-ns _b lh-solid pv1"><a class="dib pa2 no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/topics/site_area/history"><span class="dib pv1">History</span></a></li><li class="dib f7 f6-ns _b lh-solid pv1"><a class="dib pa2 no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/topics/socialIssuesCategory/ineq-us"><span class="dib pv1">Capitalism & Inequality</span></a></li><li class="dib f7 f6-ns _b lh-solid pv1"><a class="dib pa2 no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/topics/militarismCategory/us-milit"><span class="dib pv1">Anti-Imperialism</span></a></li><li class="dib f7 f6-ns _b lh-solid pv1"><a class="dib pa2 no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/topics/site_area/videos"><span class="dib pv1">Videos</span></a></li><li class="dib f7 f6-ns _b lh-solid pv1"><a class="dib pa2 no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/special/podcast"><span class="dib pv1">Podcast</span></a></li><li class="dib f7 f6-ns _b lh-solid pv1"><a class="dib pa2 no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/special/pages/library.html"><span class="dib pv1">Marxist Library</span></a></li>); }</ul><div class="absolute right-0 top-0 z-max pointer pv2 ph1 tr db" style="right:-2px;min-width:1rem;height:100%;background:linear-gradient(90deg, rgba(255,255,255,0), rgba(255,255,255,1) 100%)"></div></div><ul class="list flex avenir pv0 _ph2 ph0 ma0 nowrap _bl b--black-10" style="font-size:0"><li class="dib flex f7 f6-ns lh-solid"><div class="bg-black-20 mv2" style="width:1px;height:2rem"></div><a class="relative dib pv2 ph3 no-underline underline-hover pointer" title="Search" style="top:8px" href="/en/search"><svg version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="search"><path d="M35.602,32.755l-5.878-5.879c0.956-1.481,1.521-3.24,1.521-5.132c0-5.235-4.262-9.494-9.496-9.494 c-5.236,0-9.494,4.259-9.494,9.494c0,5.236,4.258,9.495,9.494,9.495c1.891,0,3.649-0.562,5.132-1.519l5.878,5.878 c0.195,0.196,0.518,0.196,0.712,0l2.132-2.132C35.799,33.271,35.799,32.951,35.602,32.755z M15.269,21.744 c0-3.571,2.906-6.479,6.479-6.479c3.573,0,6.479,2.907,6.479,6.479c0,3.573-2.905,6.479-6.479,6.479 C18.176,28.224,15.269,25.317,15.269,21.744z"></path></g></svg></a></li></ul></nav><style> .subnav-enter { opacity: 0; height: 0; } .subnav-enter .content { opacity: 0; } .subnav-enter.subnav-enter-active { opacity: 1; transition: opacity 200ms ease-out; height: 40rem; transition: height 200ms ease-out; } .subnav-enter.subnav-enter-active .content { opacity: 1; transition: opacity 300ms ease-out; transition-delay: 200ms; } .subnav-exit { opacity: 1; height: 40rem; } .subnav-exit .content { opacity: 1; } .subnav-exit.subnav-exit-active { opacity: 0; transition: opacity 250ms ease-in; height: 0; transition: height 250ms ease-in; } .subnav-exit.subnav-exit-active .content { opacity: 0; transition: opacity 250ms ease-in; } @media screen and (min-width: 48em) { .subnav-enter.subnav-enter-active, .subnav-exit { height: 30rem; } } @media screen and (min-width: 64em) { .subnav-enter.subnav-enter-active, .subnav-exit { height: 20rem; } } </style></div></section></div></div></div><style> .menu { -webkit-overflow-scrolling: touch; } .menu-enter { left: -20rem; } .menu-enter.menu-enter-active { left: 0; transition: left 200ms ease-out ; } .menu-exit { left: 0; } .menu-exit.menu-exit-active { left: -20rem; transition: left 200ms ease-in; /*transition-delay: 300ms;*/ } .right { -webkit-overflow-scrolling: touch; } .right-enter { right: -20rem; } .right-enter.right-enter-active { right: 0; transition: right 200ms ease-out ; } .right-exit { right: 0; } .right-exit.right-exit-active { right: -20rem; transition: right 200ms ease-in; /*transition-delay: 300ms;*/ } .webkit-overflow-scrolling { -webkit-overflow-scrolling: touch; } /* .menu-enter .collections { opacity: 0; } .menu-enter.menu-enter-active .collections { opacity: 1; transition: opacity 200ms ease-out; transition-delay: 300ms; } .menu-exit .collections { opacity: 1; } .menu-exit.menu-exit-active .collections { opacity: 0; transition: opacity 200ms ease-in; } */ /* @media screen and (min-width: 48em) { .menu-enter.menu-enter-active, .menu-exit { height: 32rem; } } */ .get-involved-link { box-shadow: inset 0 -2px 0 #ff4136; } .get-involved-link:hover { background: #ff4136; transition: background-color 350ms ease-out; } </style><div></div><div></div><div class="dn db-m dn-p _ph2 _ph4-ns"><div class="_mw6 _mw-75rem-m center _mt2 mb2 _mt3-ns _mb0-ns _br2 tc" style="background:#f7f7f7"><div class="relative z-0 _flex-m justify-center avenir f7 ttu tracked-half lh-title nowrap overflow-hidden"><div class="absolute left-0 top-0 z-max pv3 ph2tl db" style="left:-2px;min-width:1rem;height:100%;background:linear-gradient(270deg, rgba(247,247,247,0), rgba(247,247,247,1) 100%)"></div><ul class="list pa0 ma0 nowrap overflow-x-scroll overflow-y-hidden scrollbar-width-none scroll-touch" style="height:3rem"><li class="dib pv3 pl3 ph3-ns nowrap"><a class="no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/special/pages/icfi/about.html">Fourth International</a></li><li class="dib pv3 pl3 ph3-ns nowrap"><a class="no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/special/pages/sep">Socialist Equality Party</a></li><li class="dib pv3 pl3 ph3-ns nowrap"><a class="no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/special/pages/iysse/about.html">IYSSE</a></li><li class="dib pv3 pl3 ph3-ns nowrap"><a class="no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/special/pages/icfi/wsws.html">About the WSWS</a></li><li class="dib pv3 pl3 ph3-ns nowrap"><a class="no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/special/pages/contact.html">Contact</a></li><li class="dib pv3 pl3 ph3-ns nowrap"><a class="no-underline underline-hover pointer" href="/en/special/pages/donate.html">Donate</a></li></ul><div class="absolute right-0 top-0 z-max pointer pv3 ph2 tr db" style="right:-2px;min-width:1rem;height:100%;background:linear-gradient(90deg, rgba(247,247,247,0), rgba(247,247,247,1) 100%)"></div></div></div></div><div class="dn-p"></div><main class="relative" style="min-height:100vH"><section class="article ph3 ph4-m mt3 mt4-m _mt5-xl"><article id="article" class=""><style> .header-content { padding: 0; } /* 768px and more */ @media screen and (min-width: 48em) { .header-content { padding: 0; } } /* 1024px and more */ @media screen and (min-width: 64em) { .header-content { padding: 0 6rem 0 6rem; } } /* 1280px and more */ @media screen and (min-width: 80em) { .header-content { padding: 0 8rem 0 8rem; } } </style><header class=""><div class="absolute top-0 left-0 w-30 _bt bw1"></div><div class="georgia _avenir mw6-ns mw7-l center pv3-ns pv4-l pt3-l _pb4-l"><h4 class=" f5 f4-ns f4-m f4-l normal black-60 lh-title pl1 ma0 mb2 mb3-ns">Accomplices to social murder</h4><h2 class="f2-p _balance-text f3 f2-ns f1-l lh-title ma0" style="line-height:1.2em">The international pseudo-left and the lifting of Zero-COVID in China: Part 1</h2></div><div class="mw6-ns mw7-l center"><h5 class="avenir lh-title bb b--black-10 bn-p pb3 ma0 mt3"><div class="f7 f6-ns f5-l b"><span><a class="no-underline underline-hover" href="/en/authors/Evan-Blake">Evan Blake</a></span><a class="ml2 dib no-underline underline-hover" href="https://twitter.com/evanblake17" target="_blank"><span class="relative dib _mr1" style="width:1rem;height:1rem;color:#00A6E4;top:0.25rem"><svg id="iconset-twitter" viewBox="0 0 18 18" width="100%" height="100%" style="fill:currentColor"><path d="M12.077 2c-1.812 0-3.282 1.582-3.282 3.534 0 .277.03.547.085.806-2.728-.148-5.147-1.555-6.766-3.693a3.727 3.727 0 0 0-.445 1.777c0 1.226.58 2.308 1.46 2.942a3.093 3.093 0 0 1-1.49-.443v.045c0 1.712 1.13 3.14 2.634 3.465a3.07 3.07 0 0 1-1.483.06c.42 1.407 1.632 2.427 3.07 2.457-1.124.946-2.54 1.51-4.077 1.51A6.22 6.22 0 0 1 1 14.413 8.818 8.818 0 0 0 6.032 16c6.038 0 9.34-5.385 9.34-10.056 0-.153-.004-.306-.01-.457A6.98 6.98 0 0 0 17 3.657a6.2 6.2 0 0 1-1.885.557 3.51 3.51 0 0 0 1.443-1.956c-.634.405-1.337.7-2.085.858C13.875 2.43 13.023 2 12.077 2"></path></svg></span><span class="f7 f6-ns normal">@evanblake17</span></a></div><div class="f7 normal black-60 mt1"><span class="relative" style="top:1px"><svg class="relative dib mr1" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="12 12 24 24" style="width:0.9em;fill:currentColor;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="clock"><path d="M24,12c-6.617,0-12,5.383-12,12s5.383,12,12,12c6.617,0,12-5.383,12-12S30.617,12,24,12z M24,33c-4.971,0-9-4.029-9-9 s4.029-9,9-9c4.971,0,9,4.029,9,9S28.971,33,24,33z M25,22.277v-4.762C25,17.24,24.758,17,24.483,17h-0.982 c-0.274,0-0.5,0.24-0.5,0.516L23,22.277C22.7,22.452,22.452,22.7,22.277,23H19.5c-0.275,0-0.5,0.273-0.5,0.548V24.5 c0,0.275,0.225,0.5,0.5,0.5h2.777c0.346,0.595,0.984,1,1.723,1c1.105,0,2-0.896,2-2C26,23.262,25.595,22.624,25,22.277z"></path></g></svg></span><time dateTime="2023-03-23T21:51:22.000Z">23 March 2023</time></div></h5></div></header><section class="relative mw-75rem-m center mt3 mt4-m _mt5-xl" itemProp="articleBody"><ul class="dn-p flex flex-column-m db-m list absolute-m left-0 top-2 z-1 mw6 center tc ba b--black-20 pl0 mb3 mb0-m" style="font-size:0"><li class="dib db-m w-20 w-100-m"><a class="db _pa3 hover-bg-black-10 tc" href="https://facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsws.org%2Fen%2Farticles%2F2023%2F03%2F23%2Fljwc-m23.html&t=The%20international%20pseudo-left%20and%20the%20lifting%20of%20Zero-COVID%20in%20China%3A%20Part%201" target="_blank" title="Share via Facebook" styyle="[object Object]"><svg class="db center pa2 pa3-m _pa2-m" width="1.25rem" data-icon="facebook" viewBox="0 0 32 32" style="width:1.25rem;fill:#000"><title>facebook icon</title><path d="M8 12 L13 12 L13 8 C13 2 17 1 24 2 L24 7 C20 7 19 7 19 10 L19 12 L24 12 L23 18 L19 18 L19 30 L13 30 L13 18 L8 18 z"></path></svg></a></li><li class="dib db-m w-20 w-100-m bl bl-0-m bt-m b--black-20"><a class="db _pa3 hover-bg-black-10" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?original_referer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsws.org%2Fen%2Farticles%2F2023%2F03%2F23%2Fljwc-m23.html&text=The%20international%20pseudo-left%20and%20the%20lifting%20of%20Zero-COVID%20in%20China%3A%20Part%201&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsws.org%2Fen%2Farticles%2F2023%2F03%2F23%2Fljwc-m23.html" target="_blank" title="Share via Twitter" styyle="[object Object]"><svg class="db center pa2 pa3-m _pa2-m" data-icon="twitter" width="1.25rem" viewBox="0 0 32 32" style="width:1.25rem;fill:#000"><path d="M2 4 C6 8 10 12 15 11 A6 6 0 0 1 22 4 A6 6 0 0 1 26 6 A8 8 0 0 0 31 4 A8 8 0 0 1 28 8 A8 8 0 0 0 32 7 A8 8 0 0 1 28 11 A18 18 0 0 1 10 30 A18 18 0 0 1 0 27 A12 12 0 0 0 8 24 A8 8 0 0 1 3 20 A8 8 0 0 0 6 19.5 A8 8 0 0 1 0 12 A8 8 0 0 0 3 13 A8 8 0 0 1 2 4"></path></svg></a></li><li class="dib db-m w-20 w-100-m bl bl-0-m bt-m b--black-20"><a class="db _pa3 hover-bg-black-10" href="whatsapp://send?text=The%20international%20pseudo-left%20and%20the%20lifting%20of%20Zero-COVID%20in%20China%3A%20Part%201 - https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsws.org%2Fen%2Farticles%2F2023%2F03%2F23%2Fljwc-m23.html" target="_blank" title="Share via Whatsapp"><svg class="db center pa2 pa3-m _pa2-m" data-icon="whatsapp" width="1.25rem" viewBox="0 0 24 24" style="width:1.25rem;fill:#000"><path d="M.057 24l1.687-6.163c-1.041-1.804-1.588-3.849-1.587-5.946.003-6.556 5.338-11.891 11.893-11.891 3.181.001 6.167 1.24 8.413 3.488 2.245 2.248 3.481 5.236 3.48 8.414-.003 6.557-5.338 11.892-11.893 11.892-1.99-.001-3.951-.5-5.688-1.448l-6.305 1.654zm6.597-3.807c1.676.995 3.276 1.591 5.392 1.592 5.448 0 9.886-4.434 9.889-9.885.002-5.462-4.415-9.89-9.881-9.892-5.452 0-9.887 4.434-9.889 9.884-.001 2.225.651 3.891 1.746 5.634l-.999 3.648 3.742-.981zm11.387-5.464c-.074-.124-.272-.198-.57-.347-.297-.149-1.758-.868-2.031-.967-.272-.099-.47-.149-.669.149-.198.297-.768.967-.941 1.165-.173.198-.347.223-.644.074-.297-.149-1.255-.462-2.39-1.475-.883-.788-1.48-1.761-1.653-2.059-.173-.297-.018-.458.13-.606.134-.133.297-.347.446-.521.151-.172.2-.296.3-.495.099-.198.05-.372-.025-.521-.075-.148-.669-1.611-.916-2.206-.242-.579-.487-.501-.669-.51l-.57-.01c-.198 0-.52.074-.792.372s-1.04 1.016-1.04 2.479 1.065 2.876 1.213 3.074c.149.198 2.095 3.2 5.076 4.487.709.306 1.263.489 1.694.626.712.226 1.36.194 1.872.118.571-.085 1.758-.719 2.006-1.413.248-.695.248-1.29.173-1.414z"></path></svg></a></li><li class="dib db-m w-20 w-100-m bl bl-0-m bt-m b--black-20"><a class="db _pa3 hover-bg-black-10" href="https://t.me/share/url?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsws.org%2Fen%2Farticles%2F2023%2F03%2F23%2Fljwc-m23.html&text=The%20international%20pseudo-left%20and%20the%20lifting%20of%20Zero-COVID%20in%20China%3A%20Part%201" target="_blank" title="Share via Telegram"><svg class="db center pa2 pa3-m _pa2-m" data-icon="telegram" width="1.25rem" viewBox="200 200 600 600" style="width:1.25rem;fill:#000"><path d="M226.328419,494.722069 C372.088573,431.216685 469.284839,389.350049 517.917216,369.122161 C656.772535,311.36743 685.625481,301.334815 704.431427,301.003532 C708.567621,300.93067 717.815839,301.955743 723.806446,306.816707 C728.864797,310.92121 730.256552,316.46581 730.922551,320.357329 C731.588551,324.248848 732.417879,333.113828 731.758626,340.040666 C724.234007,419.102486 691.675104,610.964674 675.110982,699.515267 C668.10208,736.984342 654.301336,749.547532 640.940618,750.777006 C611.904684,753.448938 589.856115,731.588035 561.733393,713.153237 C517.726886,684.306416 492.866009,666.349181 450.150074,638.200013 C400.78442,605.66878 432.786119,587.789048 460.919462,558.568563 C468.282091,550.921423 596.21508,434.556479 598.691227,424.000355 C599.00091,422.680135 599.288312,417.758981 596.36474,415.160431 C593.441168,412.561881 589.126229,413.450484 586.012448,414.157198 C581.598758,415.158943 511.297793,461.625274 375.109553,553.556189 C355.154858,567.258623 337.080515,573.934908 320.886524,573.585046 C303.033948,573.199351 268.692754,563.490928 243.163606,555.192408 C211.851067,545.013936 186.964484,539.632504 189.131547,522.346309 C190.260287,513.342589 202.659244,504.134509 226.328419,494.722069 Z"></path></svg></a></li><li class="dib db-m w-20 w-100-m bl bl-0-m bt-m b--black-20"><a class="db _pa3 hover-bg-black-10" href="mailto:?subject=The%20international%20pseudo-left%20and%20the%20lifting%20of%20Zero-COVID%20in%20China%3A%20Part%201&body=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsws.org%2Fen%2Farticles%2F2023%2F03%2F23%2Fljwc-m23.html" target="_blank" title="Share via email"><svg class="db center pa2 pa3-m _pa2-m" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="10 10 26 26" style="width:1.25rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="envelope"><path d="M24,28L12,16h24L24,28z M24,30l-5-5l-7,7h24l-7-7L24,30z M30,24l6,6V18L30,24z M12,18v12l6-6L12,18z"></path></g></svg></a></li><li class="dib db-m w-20 w-100-m bl bl-0-m bt-m b--black-20"><a class="db _pa3 hover-bg-black-10" href="https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2023/03/23/ljwc-m23.pdf" target="_blank" title="Download as leaflet"><svg class="db center pa2 pa3-m _pa2-m" data-icon="pdf" width="1.25rem" viewBox="0 0 550.801 550.801" style="width:1.25rem;fill:#000"><g><path d="M160.381,282.225c0-14.832-10.299-23.684-28.474-23.684c-7.414,0-12.437,0.715-15.071,1.432V307.6 c3.114,0.707,6.942,0.949,12.192,0.949C148.419,308.549,160.381,298.74,160.381,282.225z"></path><path d="M272.875,259.019c-8.145,0-13.397,0.717-16.519,1.435v105.523c3.116,0.729,8.142,0.729,12.69,0.729 c33.017,0.231,54.554-17.946,54.554-56.474C323.842,276.719,304.215,259.019,272.875,259.019z"></path><path d="M488.426,197.019H475.2v-63.816c0-0.398-0.063-0.799-0.116-1.202c-0.021-2.534-0.827-5.023-2.562-6.995L366.325,3.694 c-0.032-0.031-0.063-0.042-0.085-0.076c-0.633-0.707-1.371-1.295-2.151-1.804c-0.231-0.155-0.464-0.285-0.706-0.419 c-0.676-0.369-1.393-0.675-2.131-0.896c-0.2-0.056-0.38-0.138-0.58-0.19C359.87,0.119,359.037,0,358.193,0H97.2 c-11.918,0-21.6,9.693-21.6,21.601v175.413H62.377c-17.049,0-30.873,13.818-30.873,30.873v160.545 c0,17.043,13.824,30.87,30.873,30.87h13.224V529.2c0,11.907,9.682,21.601,21.6,21.601h356.4c11.907,0,21.6-9.693,21.6-21.601 V419.302h13.226c17.044,0,30.871-13.827,30.871-30.87v-160.54C519.297,210.838,505.47,197.019,488.426,197.019z M97.2,21.605 h250.193v110.513c0,5.967,4.841,10.8,10.8,10.8h95.407v54.108H97.2V21.605z M362.359,309.023c0,30.876-11.243,52.165-26.82,65.333 c-16.971,14.117-42.82,20.814-74.396,20.814c-18.9,0-32.297-1.197-41.401-2.389V234.365c13.399-2.149,30.878-3.346,49.304-3.346 c30.612,0,50.478,5.508,66.039,17.226C351.828,260.69,362.359,280.547,362.359,309.023z M80.7,393.499V234.365 c11.241-1.904,27.042-3.346,49.296-3.346c22.491,0,38.527,4.308,49.291,12.928c10.292,8.131,17.215,21.534,17.215,37.328 c0,15.799-5.25,29.198-14.829,38.285c-12.442,11.728-30.865,16.996-52.407,16.996c-4.778,0-9.1-0.243-12.435-0.723v57.67H80.7 V393.499z M453.601,523.353H97.2V419.302h356.4V523.353z M484.898,262.127h-61.989v36.851h57.913v29.674h-57.913v64.848h-36.593 V232.216h98.582V262.127z"></path></g></svg></a></li><li class="dib db-m w-20 w-100-m bl bl-0-m bt-m b--black-20"><a class="db _pa3 hover-bg-black-10" href="#comments" styyle="[object Object]" title="Leave a comment"><svg class="db center pa2 pa3-m _pa2-m" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="10 10 26 26" style="width:1.25rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="comments"><path d="M33,13H15c-1.65,0-3,1.35-3,3v11c0,1.65,1.35,3,3,3h2v6l6-6h10c1.65,0,3-1.35,3-3V16C36,14.35,34.65,13,33,13z"></path></g></svg></a></li><li class="dib db-m w-20 w-100-m bl bl-0-m bt-m b--black-20"><a class="db _pa3 hover-bg-black-10" href="#" style="fill:#000" title="Add to reading list"><svg class="db center pa2 pa3-m _pa2-m" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="10 10 26 26" style="width:1.25rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="bookmark"><path d="M31.5,12h-14c-0.275,0-0.5,0.225-0.5,0.5v22.875c0,0.274,0.28,0.353,0.475,0.158l7.086-6.283l6.908,6.172 C31.663,35.616,32,35.578,32,35.125V12.5C32,12.225,31.775,12,31.5,12z"></path></g></svg></a></li></ul><div class="mw6-ns mw7-l center"><style> .body { padding: 0; } .content > h4 { /* font-family: 'avenir next', avenir, sans-serif; */ font-family: 'Source Sans Pro', 'Helvetica Neue', Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif; font-size: 1.5rem; line-height: 1.25; margin: 3rem 0 2rem 0; } .content > h6 { /* font-family: 'avenir next', avenir, sans-serif; */ font-family: 'Source Sans Pro', 'Helvetica Neue', Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif; font-size: 1.25rem; line-height: 1.25; margin: 3rem 0 2rem 0; } .content > p { /* max-width: 30em; */ margin: 0 0 1.5rem 0; } .content > ol > li, .content > ul > li { margin: 0 0 1.5rem 0; } .content > p a { color: #000; text-decoration: none; box-shadow: inset 0 -7px 0 #b4e7f8; box-shadow: inset 0 -2px 0 #99ccff; box-shadow: inset 0 -1px 0 #999; transition: background-color 350ms ease-out, box-shadow 200ms ease-out, color 200ms ease-out; } .content > p a:hover { box-shadow: inset 0 -1px 0 #e7040f; color: #e7040f; } .content > blockquote { padding: 0 2rem; margin: 2rem 0; border-left: 2px solid #dfdfdf; } .content > blockquote > p { font-size: 1rem; color: rgba(0,0,0,0.8); margin: 0 0 1rem 0; max-width: 40em; } .content > figure { margin: 2rem 0; } .content > .imageFull, .content > .imageLeft, .content > .imageRight { margin: 2rem 0; } .content > .imageFull > img, .content > .imageLeft > img, .content > .imageRight > img { display: block; margin: 0 auto; } .content > .imageFull > span, .content > .imageLeft > span, .content > .imageRight > span { display: block; /* font-family: Source Sans Pro,sans-serif; */ font-family: 'Source Sans Pro', 'Helvetica Neue', Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif; font-size: .875rem; line-height: 1.25; color: rgba(0,0,0,.6); text-align: center; padding-top: 1rem; padding-left: 1rem; padding-right: 1rem; } .content > .aside-left { float: left; margin: 1rem 2rem 2rem -4rem; float: none; margin: 2rem 0; } .content > .aside-right { float: right; margin: 1rem -4rem 2rem 2rem; float: none; margin: 2rem 0; } .content > .aside-40 { width: 40%; width: 100%; /* padding: 0 25%; */ /* background: #000; */ box-sizing: border-box; } .content > .extra { max-width: 30em; width: 100%; margin: 2rem 0 2rem 0; } .footnotes { font-family: 'Source Sans Pro', 'Helvetica Neue', Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif; font-size: 1rem; line-height: 1.4; padding-left: 2rem; } /* 768px and more */ @media screen and (min-width: 48em) { .body { padding: 0 4rem; padding: 0 6rem; padding: 0; } /* .content > figure, */ .content > .ad { margin: 2rem -4rem; margin: 2rem 2rem 2rem -4rem; margin: 2rem -4rem; margin: 2rem 0; } .content > .aside-left { float: left; margin: 1rem 2rem 2rem -4rem; } .content > .aside-right { float: right; margin: 1rem -4rem 2rem 2rem; } .content > .aside-40 { width: 50%; padding: 0; } } /* 1024px and more */ @media screen and (min-width: 64em) { .body { padding: 0 24rem 0 4rem; padding: 0 10rem; padding: 0 16rem 0 4rem; padding: 0 10rem 0 10rem; padding: 0; } .content > h4 { font-size: 1.75rem; } .content > h6 { font-size: 1.5rem; line-height: 1.25; } .content > p { font-size: 1.125rem; font-size: 1.25rem; line-height: 1.5; } /* .content > figure, */ .content > .ad { margin: 2rem -4rem; } .content > .aside-40 { width: 40%; } .content > .extra { float: right; width: 20rem; margin: 1rem -24rem 0 0; margin: 0.5rem -4rem 1rem 2rem; margin: 0.5rem -8rem 1rem 2rem; } } /* 1280px and more */ @media screen and (min-width: 80em) { .body { padding: 0 10rem; padding: 0 18rem 0 18rem; padding: 0; } .content > p { max-width: 34em; } /* .content > figure { margin: 2rem 2rem 2rem -6rem; margin: 2rem 0 2rem 0; } */ .content > .extra { max-width: 34em; margin: 2rem -26rem 0 0; margin: 0.5rem -4rem 1rem 2rem; margin: 0.5rem -16rem 1rem 2rem; } } /* 1600px and more */ /* @media screen and (min-width: 100em) { .body { padding: 0 16rem; padding: 0 28rem 0 4rem; padding: 0; } .content > p { max-width: 34em; } .content > .extra { max-width: 34em; margin: 2rem -26rem 0 0; margin: 0.5rem -4rem 1rem 2rem; margin: 0.5rem -28rem 1rem 2rem; } } */ @media print { .content > p { margin-bottom: 1rem; } .content > ol > li, .content > ul > li { margin-bottom: 1rem; } .footnotes { font-family: 'Source Sans Pro', 'Helvetica Neue', Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif; font-size: 0.75rem; line-height: 1.2; } } </style><div class="body relative"><div class="content georgia _avenir f5 f4-m f4-l f5-p lh-copy _measure-wide"><p><em>This is the first part of a two-part article. Part two </em><a href="/en/articles/2023/03/24/ljwc-m24.html"><em>can be read here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Since its outbreak more than three years ago, in January 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic has killed over 20 million people, disabled tens of millions more with Long COVID, pushed health care systems to the brink of collapse, exacerbated social inequality, and accelerated the outbreak of war in Ukraine, the antechamber to World War III.</p><p>For the first time since World War II, life expectancy declined globally in 2020 and 2021. Despite US President Joe Biden’s claim that “the pandemic is over,” echoed by capitalist politicians throughout the world, this social catastrophe continues. Every week, there are nearly 100,000 excess deaths attributable to the pandemic globally, or roughly 1 million deaths every three months. With the ending of Zero-COVID in China and the worldwide scrapping of all mitigation measures that slow the spread of the coronavirus, it is mutating and evolving into new, potentially more dangerous variants.</p><p>For the ruling class, the pandemic was seized upon as an opportunity to enrich itself and deepen its decades-long assault on the living conditions of the international working class. While refusing to implement the necessary public health measures to stop the transmission of the virus, in March 2020 the advanced capitalist governments passed unprecedented financial bailouts. As deaths rose by the millions, the collective fortunes of the corporate-financial pandemic profiteers increased by <em>trillions</em>.</p><p>The ruling classes, anxious to suppress public health protocols that interfered with the capitalist production process from which surplus value and profit is derived, promoted ignorance, superstition and irrational fears of science, while whipping up far-right forces to agitate against lockdowns, mask-wearing, remote learning, and all other measures necessary to stop the pandemic. Their motto was: Better that several thousand workers in a factory should be infected than suffer one week of lost production time!</p><figure class="relative ma0 overflow-hidden dn-p"><div class="relative overflow-hidden"><div class=""><img class="db relative center" loading="lazy" src="https://www.wsws.org/asset/c6f6f484-b8bd-4808-86b8-ef95a9f42406?rendition=image1280" style="max-height:100%"/></div></div><figcaption class="db avenir f7 f6-m lh-title black-60 tc pt3 ph3">Then-President Donald Trump watches as White House coronavirus adviser and "herd immunity" promoter Dr. Scott Atlas speaks during a September 2020 news conference on the pandemic. <span className="black-40 nowrap" style="font-size:80%">[AP Photo/Alex Brandon]</span></figcaption></figure><p>For decades, the capitalist governments have viewed the gradual increase in life expectancy with dismay and alarm. The ability of the elderly to obtain subsidized medical care as they made it into their 70s, 80s and even 90s has been seen as a budgetary calamity.</p><p>During the pandemic, the capitalist elites have viewed the deaths of “non-productive” elderly workers, as well as declines in life expectancy, as positive outcomes for reducing pension obligations and other social welfare spending. They have revived the eugenicist and Social Darwinist conceptions that dominated in ruling circles during the first half of the 20th century and motivated the Holocaust. The Nazi concept of <em>lebensunwertes Leben</em>, or “life unworthy of life,” is now applied to elderly and immunocompromised people left to die en masse.</p><p>Scientists have warned that climate change and unplanned urbanization are forcing animals to migrate outside their native habitats, bringing with them thousands of pathogens that have the potential to spill over into human populations, making future pandemics all but inevitable. But there is absolutely no indication that governments are seeking to prevent or prepare for this near-term danger. Just the opposite: to the extent that the ruling elites have drawn any lessons from the catastrophe of the past three years, it is that nature should be left to run its course, that the production process and financial interests of corporations should not be disrupted, and that the accumulation of profits and wealth must not be interfered with. The deaths of millions will be accepted as the “price of doing business” during future pandemics. The infamous words of former British Prime Minister Boris Johnson—“Let the bodies pile high”—will define public policy.</p><p>For the working class, the pandemic has been a traumatic shock that has upended social life and revealed the brutality of class relations. It has accelerated and intensified the ongoing radicalization of workers globally, precipitating numerous struggles against the homicidal policies of the ruling elites. In the US, Canada, Italy and other countries, the belated lockdowns in March 2020 were only implemented after the working class mounted wildcat strikes, independent of the pro-capitalist unions, to save lives.</p><p>Beginning in China, growing opposition among workers forced several governments to implement comprehensive Zero-COVID policies in the early stages of the pandemic. Grounded in mass working class solidarity, these Zero-COVID policies were highly successful at saving lives. The death toll in China, New Zealand, Vietnam and other countries remained an infinitesimal fraction of that of the US and other imperialist powers. However, confronted with relentless pressure from global finance capital, these governments eventually lifted their Zero-COVID policies in 2021 and 2022, with catastrophic consequences in each country.</p><p>Throughout the pandemic, the International Committee of the Fourth International (ICFI) and the <em>World Socialist Web Site</em> have articulated the interests of the working class and advocated a <a href="/en/articles/2021/08/21/pers-a21.html">global public health strategy</a> to eliminate COVID-19 in every country. The WSWS has published over 5,000 articles on the pandemic during the past three years, analyzing every major scientific and political development related to the pandemic throughout the world.</p><p>A markedly different response arose within substantial sections of the upper-middle class and political parties that express their interests. To a great extent, these social layers were able to isolate or work safely at home throughout 2020, with the pandemic generally viewed as a serious but only temporary disruption. Moreover, small business owners and self-employed professionals who received inadequate support during the initial lockdowns, as well as layers more heavily invested in the stock market, largely embraced the anti-lockdown propaganda pushed by the ruling class. Once vaccinated in early 2021, the affluent middle class was anxious to resume its pre-pandemic mode of wealth accumulation and amusement and proceed as if nothing too serious had happened.</p><p>The social interests and political conceptions of the affluent middle class are articulated by various political parties that comprise what the ICFI has defined as the “<a href="/en/special/pages/pseudoleft.html">pseudo-left</a>.” This term is justified by the fact that these organizations have nothing in common—in terms of their political program, their practice and the social constituency to which they appeal—with what the term “left” has signified since the dawn of the socialist movement in the first half of the 19th century.</p><p>Some of these organizations retain—as a result of either a long-past historical association with Marxism and even Trotskyism or, more commonly, the most cynical opportunism—the words “socialism” and “workers” on their political calling cards. But this sort of false advertising does not determine the objective social content of their program and practice. The essential nature of these organization is defined by politics of personal identity, centered on race, ethnicity, nationality, gender and sexual orientation.</p><p>The focus of their activities, therefore, is not the class struggle, the development of socialist consciousness and the revolutionary overthrow of capitalism by the working class. Their “leftism” is, instead, aimed at achieving a broader distribution of wealth presently monopolized by the richest 1 or 2 percent of society. The social program of their “leftism” would be satisfied if a somewhat larger share of the money sloshing around at the top would be allowed to trickle down into the less fortunate layers of the wealthiest top 10 percent.</p><p>Included among the pseudo-left are the Pabloites of <em>International Viewpoint</em>; the Morenoite tendencies, led by Trotskyist Fraction—Fourth International (FT) and International Workers League—Fourth International (IWLfi); the state capitalists, led by International Socialist Tendency (IST); as well as International Marxist Tendency (IMT), Committee for a Workers’ International (CWI), International Socialist Alternative (ISA) and the International Socialist League (ISL). Prominent national pseudo-left groups include Syriza in Greece, Podemos in Spain, the Left Party in Germany, the Socialism and Liberty Party in Brazil and others.</p><p>The pseudo-left responded to the COVID-19 pandemic with a collective shrug. After ignoring the early signs of the developing global crisis in January-February 2020, starting in March 2020 they each published a few news articles monthly throughout the first year of the pandemic. Amid the roll-out of vaccines in 2021, they gradually stopped covering the pandemic altogether.</p><p>Over the past three years, these parties have collectively written just a few hundred articles on the pandemic. Not a single one has issued a programmatic statement outlining a scientific strategy to eliminate COVID-19 globally. As noted in a <a href="https://twitter.com/useless_priest/status/1618566431398068227" target="_blank" rel="noopener">recent Twitter thread</a>, they also maintain silence on the catastrophic impacts of Long COVID.</p><p>The pseudo-left’s hostility to public health and support for imperialism found its sharpest expression in their demand—echoing that of the Western corporate media and political establishment—that China abandon its Zero-COVID strategy. This reached a climax over the past four months, during which every pseudo-left tendency in the world supported this catastrophic policy shift in China.</p><p>This essay will provide a representative sampling of the response of these organizations, ostensibly claiming to be on the left, socialist and even Trotskyist, to this latest manifestation of the greatest health crisis of modern history, in which they became the unabashed advocates of mass infection. It is a political biopsy, which exposes the malignant cells of a deeply sick and politically reactionary social milieu. This can be a laborious process because one is dealing with an alphabet soup of organizations, but there is no way around it. They must be identified and their positions memorialized. Their culpability in this social crime cannot be forgotten.</p><h4>Who is responsible for the lifting of Zero-COVID in China?</h4><p>January 23, 2020 marked the beginning of the first Zero-COVID policy in the world, as 13 million people entered a citywide lockdown in Wuhan, China. This was soon expanded to all 15 other cities in Hubei province, affecting 57 million people in total. These lockdowns, unprecedented in world history, were combined with a program of regular mass testing, rigorous contact tracing, the safe isolation of infected patients, and travel restrictions and universal masking—public health measures that mankind had accumulated since the Black Death in the 14th century.</p><figure class="relative ma0 overflow-hidden dn-p"><div class="relative overflow-hidden"><div class=""><img class="db relative center" loading="lazy" src="https://www.wsws.org/asset/f7050a62-f2b7-479c-9f6e-eac655146dbb?rendition=image1280" style="max-height:100%"/></div></div><figcaption class="db avenir f7 f6-m lh-title black-60 tc pt3 ph3">In this April 15, 2020, file photo, government workers stand outside a blue tent used to coordinate transportation of travelers from Wuhan to designated quarantine sites in Beijing. <span className="black-40 nowrap" style="font-size:80%">[AP Photo/Sam McNeil, File]</span></figcaption></figure><p>After 76 days of immense self-sacrifice and determination by Chinese workers that led to the elimination of the coronavirus across China, on April 17, 2020, the lockdowns were lifted and daily life for the Chinese population returned to normal.</p><p>Public health officials and scientists in other countries who had been skeptical of the ability to eliminate COVID-19, including Dr. Michael Baker in New Zealand, watched what happened in China and decided to replicate this Zero-COVID program. This led to the elimination of the virus in many countries, particularly in the Asia-Pacific region. Whenever an outbreak of COVID-19 broke through border management systems, these same measures were able to quickly stop viral transmission.</p><p>Over the next two years, the political establishment and corporate media of the imperialist powers, above all the United States, continuously demanded the lifting of Zero-COVID wherever this policy was in place. Themselves guilty of killing millions of their citizens, they could not tolerate the living proof that mass infections and deaths were the unnecessary outcome of their socially criminal policies.</p><p>In tandem with the concoction of the Wuhan Lab Lie—which falsely laid blame on China for deliberately or accidentally unleashing COVID-19 on the world—the Western media issued a steady stream of propaganda denouncing Zero-COVID, and, in particular, lockdowns as “authoritarian” and “anti-democratic,” libels later adopted by the pseudo-left.</p><aside data-track-content="true" data-content-name="33% of article" data-content-piece="/en/articles/2023/03/23/ljwc-m23.html"></aside><p>The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) maintains an authoritarian regime. But the application of this term to its initial Zero-COVID policy towards the pandemic is false, intended to discredit essential and life-saving public health measures. Throughout the pandemic, the lockdowns were always <a href="/en/articles/2021/12/13/chin-d13.html">temporary and targeted</a>, contrary to the myth that cities were permanently shut down and cut off from access to necessary resources.</p><p>The inescapable problem of the Chinese response was the impossibility of applying Zero-COVID on a purely national scale. It was not possible to construct and maintain an impenetrable anti-COVID “Great Wall of China” that would prevent the incessant episodes of viral penetration from external sources. To this fundamental problem was the added economic impact upon China’s capitalist economy of imperialist pressure to abandon Zero-COVID.</p><p>Last October and November, Wall Street and the world’s major corporations exerted intense economic pressure on the CCP to lift Zero-COVID, with Apple, Google, Samsung, Microsoft and other companies threatening to shift production away from China unless even limited lockdowns and other basic public health measures were abandoned. At the same time, opposition to Zero-COVID mounted in the Chinese bourgeoisie and upper-middle class, whose wealth was increasingly impacted by these same measures. The CCP finally relented on November 11, <a href="/en/articles/2022/11/16/d485-n16.html">announcing 20 measures</a> that loosened every aspect of Zero-COVID, under conditions in which official infections were already surging across the country.</p><p>On November 24, an apartment fire took place in Ürümqi which tragically claimed the lives of 10 people. Without any evidence, claims were made that the Zero-COVID policy was responsible. In reality, the neighborhood where the fire took place was <a href="/en/articles/2022/11/28/tspr-n28.html">not under strict lockdown</a>, and residents were not prevented from leaving their apartments and the building. Barriers that blocked a firetruck from reaching the building were installed before the pandemic, the product of poor city planning, not as part of a lockdown.</p><p>Nevertheless, the fire in Ürümqi prompted a series of choreographed anti-Zero-COVID protests at universities and cities across China, involving primarily upper-middle class students and no more than a few thousand protesters out of a population of 1.4 billion. After a <a href="/en/articles/2022/11/30/chin-n30.html">veritable tsunami of news reports</a> and editorials in the Western press hailing these protests, on December 7 the CCP scrapped all remaining public health measures.</p><p>The abrupt abandonment of Zero-COVID had catastrophic consequences. Over 1 billion people are believed to have fallen ill in the country’s first wave of mass infection. While official figures are now entirely inaccurate, the health analytics firm Airfinity estimates that over 1.6 million people have likely died from COVID-19 since December 1, more than the three-year US death toll of over 1.1 million condensed into just four months. </p><p>Contrary to the lies of the CCP that this will be a one-time “exit wave” which will return the country to a pre-pandemic “normal,” China is in fact now integrated in the global “forever COVID” <a href="/en/articles/2022/12/28/pers-d28.html">nightmare of perpetual waves</a> of mass infection, death, and debilitation with Long COVID.</p><p>The lifting of Zero-COVID in China amounts to a massive social crime against the Chinese and international working class, which has opened a new stage of the pandemic. The CCP regime, serving as capitalist agents of world imperialism and the nexus between global finance capital and the Chinese working class, <a href="/en/articles/2022/12/06/pers-d06.html">clearly bears full responsibility</a> for its actions.</p><p>Also deeply implicated in this crime are the Western imperialist powers and their corporate media, which for over two years continuously demanded the lifting of Zero-COVID regardless of the social impacts.</p><p>Finally, every pseudo-left political party and publication that agitated against Zero-COVID without regard for the consequences shares in the guilt for this social crime.</p><h4>The Foxconn and “white paper” protests: Propaganda vs. reality</h4><p>After the CCP’s initial pivot away from Zero-COVID on November 11, official COVID-19 infections in China continued to climb and break new records. Not a single publication <a href="/en/articles/2022/11/18/pers-n18.html">outside of the <em>World Socialist Web Site</em></a> advocated for the reimplementation of Zero-COVID, let alone the extension of this elimination strategy throughout the world. Throughout these critical weeks in November, during which it was still possible to contain the growing outbreak, the entire pseudo-left remained silent, giving their tacit endorsement to this policy shift.</p><p>On November 22, a <a href="/en/articles/2022/11/24/brna-n24.html">major demonstration</a> involving thousands of workers was held at the notorious Foxconn sweatshop in Zhengzhou, the world’s largest plant producing Apple iPhones. The workers demanded to be paid the wages and bonuses they had been promised, while opposing the abuse of the “closed-loop system” in which an ongoing COVID outbreak was allowed to spread within the factory and workers were prevented from leaving. The workers were universally masked and did not demand an end to Zero-COVID.</p><p>The sentiments expressed by these protesters matched those of the majority of respondents to a <a href="https://chinadatalab.ucsd.edu/viz-blog/how-unpopular-is-covid-zero/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">poll conducted at the time</a>, which found that 58.5 percent of the Chinese population supported “adjustments on specifics” of the Zero-COVID policy, but not its scrapping. When Zero-COVID was ended by the CCP, only 11.9 percent of the population supported “large-scale adjustment” to the policy.</p><p>Ignoring these sentiments, the pseudo-left and bourgeois press soon lumped together the working class protests at Foxconn with the middle class, anti-Zero-COVID protests that took place following the fire in Ürümqi. Within days of the latter protests in late November, the pseudo-left tendencies broke their silence, universally hailing these “white paper” protests, in which protesters held blank pieces of paper meant to symbolize state censorship by the CCP.</p><figure class="relative ma0 overflow-hidden dn-p"><div class="relative overflow-hidden"><div class=""><img class="db relative center" loading="lazy" src="https://www.wsws.org/asset/0117e946-da0a-4ea5-8bfd-a00495f3c69a?rendition=image1280" style="max-height:100%"/></div></div><figcaption class="db avenir f7 f6-m lh-title black-60 tc pt3 ph3">"White paper" protesters in Beijing, Sunday, Nov. 27, 2022. <span className="black-40 nowrap" style="font-size:80%">[AP Photo/Ng Han Guan]</span></figcaption></figure><p>Many of the articles compared the “white paper” protests to the 1989 Tiananmen Square demonstrations, obscuring the class basis and orientation of these protests. The “white paper” protests involved no more than a few thousand youth whipped up in a right-wing, anti-public health frenzy. The Tiananmen Square protests united millions of workers, youth and peasants in rebellion against the pro-capitalist policies pursued by the CCP in the 1980s, and were motivated by socialist political convictions, including calls for the expansion of democratic rights.</p><p>One of the first such articles on the “white paper” protests was a November 28 piece written by Alex Callinicos for<em> Socialist Worker</em>, the outlet of the Socialist Workers Party (UK), which is the leading section of the IST. Callinicos is the international secretary and main theoretician of the SWP.</p><p>In his article, Callinicos presented the scrapping of Zero-COVID as inevitable, claiming that “genuine zero-Covid is impossible to achieve.” Justifying the government’s policy change, he wrote, “The discontent created by zero-Covid has reached a new level. On Wednesday last week workers at Foxconn’s giant assembly plant in Zhengzhou clashed with riot police... Then a fire in Urumqi, capital of Xinjiang province, killed ten people. The city has been in lockdown for three months, and zero-Covid was blamed for the deaths.”</p><p><em>Socialist Worker</em> published another brief article on the same day by Yuri Prasad, a longtime SWP member, which praised the “white paper” protests even while acknowledging that “lifting all Covid restrictions immediately in China would lead to 5 million hospitalisations and 1.55 million deaths.”</p><p>Also on November 28, the first extensive article on the situation in China appeared in <em>Izquierda Diario</em>, the publication of the dishonestly named Trotskyist Fraction—Fourth International (FT), one of the main international Morenoite tendencies<sup><a class="no-underline pointer" id="r1" href="#fn1" style="box-shadow:none">[1]</a></sup>. FT is most prevalent in Latin America, and particularly Argentina, where it leads the Frente de Izquierda y de los Trabajadores—Unidad, (FIT-U), which has four seats in the Chamber of Deputies.</p><p>The article, titled “China’s historic protests against Covid-zero open up new political situation,” was written by André Barbieri, a leader of the Brazilian section of FT, Movimento Revolucionário de Trabalhadores (MRT). Barbieri endorsed the protests, which he termed a “powerful show of popular anger” and “demonstrations in repudiation of the Covid-zero authoritarian confinements.”</p><p>Barbieri continued, “The movement against the Covid-zero policy, the central pillar of the directive advocated by Xi Jinping at the 20th Congress in October, is unprecedented since the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989.” Creating an amalgam between the middle-class protests centered on the universities and the Foxconn protests, he wrote, “The strike by Foxconn workers in Zhengzhou... was the undeniable spark of popular anger that spread across China.”</p><p>Throughout the past year in particular, the FT and <em>Izquierda Diario</em> have been among the <a href="/en/articles/2022/04/14/spai-a14.html">most vocal</a> pseudo-left tendencies <a href="/en/articles/2022/01/31/spai-j31.html">denouncing China’s</a> Zero-COVID public health program.</p><p>On December 2, the FT’s section in France, <em>Révolution Permanente</em> (RP), published a separate piece on the protests in China by Irène Karalis, titled, “In China, deeply political protests open a crisis for the regime.”</p><p>Denouncing lockdowns, mass testing and the isolation of infected patients, Karalis wrote incoherently, “Today, after a period when the pandemic was thought to have disappeared, the [Zero-COVID] restrictions continue to be in force [in China] to counter the wave caused by the Omicron variant and the inhabitants must be tested every two days.”</p><p>Only someone completely detached from the experience of the international working class, in particular health care workers who continue to be inundated by recurring waves of COVID-19 patients, could write that “the pandemic was thought to have disappeared.”</p><aside data-track-content="true" data-content-name="66% of article" data-content-piece="/en/articles/2023/03/23/ljwc-m23.html"></aside><p>Karalis falsely claimed that the fire in Ürümqi “was a result of the health restrictions in place, including the closing of the building’s doors, which prevented the inhabitants from escaping.” Contradicting her previous claim that the pandemic was over, Karalis acknowledged that the lifting of Zero-COVID would result in mass death. She cited <em>The Economist</em>, whose models indicated at the time that “infections would peak at 45 million a day. About 680,000 people would die, even if the vaccines remained strong and all these people received care.”</p><p>This outcome did not cause Karalis any qualms. “There is no guarantee, therefore, that the health situation is about to improve, quite the contrary. However, the health situation, in addition to affecting the political and social situation of the country, also affects the economic situation.” In this scenario, Karalis prioritized the “economic situation” over the mass infection and death of hundreds of thousands of people in China.</p><p>Significantly, Left Voice, the American section of FT, has not published a single statement on the lifting of Zero-COVID in China, simply reposting articles published in <em>Izquierda Diario</em>.</p><p>The other dominant Morenoite tendency, International Workers League—Fourth International (IWLfi), also endorsed the late November protests in China, publishing two articles on November 30, followed by four more in December.</p><p>The more extensive article published on November 30, “China experiences turbulent days of government defiance,” was written by Marcos Margarido. In 2016, Margarido ran for mayor of Campinas as a member of Partido Socialista dos Trabalhadores Unificado (PSTU), the largest Morenoite group in Brazil.</p><p>Margarido deepened the lies of Barbieri and Karalis, writing, “After nearly three years of restrictions, the experience of being quarantined at home with doors locked, or even welded shut, and building emergency exits blocked, is common for many Chinese across the country.” In the initial months of the pandemic, there were a handful of isolated instances in which people were locked in their homes during quarantines, but to say that this was ever “common” is a gross distortion.</p><p>Margarido went on to warn that “if the restrictions continue… the accumulated anger against the bureaucratic and dictatorial policy of combating COVID… may give rise to new and wider demonstrations.” After recognizing that lifting Zero-COVID would cause “a dizzying increase in cases,” as well as mass death dwarfing the horrors suffered under Jair Bolsonaro in Brazil, Margarido nevertheless supported this homicidal policy, with the cynical justification that “even the most entrenched dictatorship… cannot tame the cyclical crises of the capitalist system.”</p><p>The only statement published by the Committee for a Workers International (CWI) on the lifting of Zero-COVID in China was published on November 29. Denouncing China’s “harsh ‘zero Covid’ policies” and “often brutal reliance on crude lockdowns,” they endorsed the anti-Zero-COVID protests, which they portrayed as “a slow-burning resentment against the still draconian lock-down rules that exploded at the weekend.”</p><p>The International Socialist League (ISL) has issued no international statements on the lifting of Zero-COVID in China over the past four months. The only article published by a national affiliate of the ISL was a December 7 piece by Verónica O’Kelly of Alternativa Socialista-PSOL in Brazil. It began by praising the protests against Zero-COVID, which she characterized as “nothing more than extreme social control based on persecution and repression.”</p><p>After falsifying the character of the Foxconn and “blank paper” protests, O’Kelly wrote that Xi Jinping “was forced to give in and relax the measures of isolation and social distancing.” She concluded the piece by stating, “The revolutionaries of the world have the task of supporting and standing in solidarity with the brave Chinese people who are rising up. From LIS we are at the service of this important task.”</p><p>Numerous similar articles advancing the same denunciations of Zero-COVID and falsifications of what transpired in China in November were published in virtually every outlet of the international pseudo-left.</p><h4>Socialist Alternative protests against Zero-COVID alongside “a conservative pro-capitalist organization”</h4><p>The most unhinged and openly reactionary response to the lifting of Zero-COVID in China came from International Socialist Alternative (ISA)<sup><a class="no-underline pointer" id="r2" href="#fn2" style="box-shadow:none">[2]</a></sup>. It enthusiastically welcomed a policy of mass death in China, publishing multiple articles and even staging demonstrations in support of the anti-lockdown protests in China.</p><p>The ISA’s first article was written by Vincent Kolo and Li Yong and published on November 29. Headlined, “China’s Mass Revolt – Where Now?,” it denounced Zero-COVID “insanity,” declaring, “After three years of suffocating and unspeakably brutal ‘Zero Covid’ controls and lockdowns, people have reached breaking point.”</p><p>Kolo and Yong continued, “Demands for democratic rights and an end to dictatorship have combined with outrage against the dictatorship’s insanely unscientific insistence at any cost of killing off an unkillable virus.”</p><p>On November 30, Socialist Alternative member Mick Barry <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0RJPG0v62qA" target="_blank" rel="noopener">gave a speech in the Irish Parliament</a> (Dáil Éireann), stating in part:</p><blockquote><p>I want to express my solidarity and the solidarity of International Socialist Alternative with the young protesters in China... They are demanding freedom of speech, an end to a rigid and extreme COVID policy and for democratic rights.</p></blockquote><p>On December 3, the Socialist Alternative branch in New York City issued the tweet below announcing a protest they were organizing the following day.</p><div class="dn-p mv4 pr5-l"><div class="bg-black-05 pa3 pa4-m br4 center" style="max-width:550px"><div class="flex justify-center items-center mv2 mv3-m" style="height:480px"><img class="db mr3" src="/img/loading.gif"/><div class="avenir f7 f6-m black-60">Loading Tweet ...</div></div><div class="avenir f7 black-60 tc">Tweet not loading? <a class="black-60" href="https://twitter.com/user/status/1599139288389939200">See it directly on Twitter</a></div></div></div><p>This tweet and protest were roundly denounced, with many commenting that it was clearly coordinated with the US State Department. Among those listed as a “Co-organizer” was “Students for a Free Tibet,” which is publicly listed as receiving nine grants from the National Endowment for Democracy (NED) since 2016, totaling $480,810. The NED is known as the “second CIA” due to its deep connections to the US intelligence agencies.</p><p>Despite widespread criticism of the tweet announcing the protest, Socialist Alternative leader Kshama Sawant nevertheless shared it with her followers, thereby encouraging them to attend. Since sharing this tweet, <a href="https://twitter.com/search?q=(China%20OR%20COVID%20OR%20Zero-COVID)%20(from%3Acmkshama)%20until%3A2023-03-21%20since%3A2022-12-05&src=typed_query&f=top" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Sawant has kept silent</a> on the catastrophe that has unfolded in China and on the pandemic more broadly.</p><p>On December 7, the ISA posted a report on their rally in New York City, as well as similar rallies they organized in London and Taipei, titled, “Protests (Mostly) Suppressed In China But Crucially, Continue Outside.” Author Elan Axelbank, a member of the ISA section in England, Wales and Scotland, wrote:</p><blockquote><p>Our branch in New York City reports that many attendees had some degree of support for capitalism, as well as US and western imperialism. One of the sponsoring organizations was the Democratic Party of China, a conservative pro-capitalist organization of Chinese people living in the US but with no base inside China.</p></blockquote><p>Axelbank acknowledged that lifting Zero-COVID would kill masses of people, yet doubled down on ISA’s support for this homicidal policy, writing:</p><blockquote><p>... it is entirely possible that China could be hit by a major wave of Covid deaths in the winter months like Hong Kong earlier this year. Scientists and Covid experts estimate if zero-Covid is lifted, between 1.5 and 2 million people could die across the country, and some say more.</p><p>But in the new period opened up by the recent protests, full and long-lasting lockdowns like in Urumqi, lasting over 100 days, will be more and more difficult for the state to enforce... This is why the China/Hong Kong/Taiwan section of International Socialist Alternative has called for, beyond just ending zero-Covid, massive resources to build up and equip the healthcare system, stepping up the vaccination program, especially among the elderly, and immediately ending the ban on foreign mRNA vaccines.</p></blockquote><p>The ISA’s call for the CCP to expand health care and purchase mRNA vaccines, a line advanced by the entire Western media and many other pseudo-left tendencies, was an attempt to provide cover for their promotion of the ending of Zero-COVID. But the rapidity with which mass infections and deaths ripped through China was both foreseeable and foreseen, and the implementation of these limited demands would have done nothing to prevent this catastrophe.</p><p><em>To be continued.</em></p><div><section class="footnotes mw6-ns mw7-l center ph4 mt3 mt4-m overflow-hidden"><hr class="mb4"/><div class="relative" id="fn1"><a class="absolute db tr no-underline pointer" href="#r1" style="left:-2.25rem;width:2rem;box-shadow:none">[1]</a><p>FT was founded in 1998 after a series of splits following the death of the Argentine Pabloite Nahuel Moreno in 1987. Moreno oversaw <a href="/en/special/library/fi-14-2/02.html">decades of national opportunist policies</a> by various parties in Argentina and their international affiliates, and his successors have carried this mantle forward.</p></div><div class="relative" id="fn2"><a class="absolute db tr no-underline pointer" href="#r2" style="left:-2.25rem;width:2rem;box-shadow:none">[2]</a><p>ISA was formed in February 2020 as the result of a split from CWI centered on identity politics. Its most prominent national section is in the United States, whose member Kshama Sawant has been on the Seattle City Council since 2014. In the winter of 2020-21, Socialist Alternative sent a significant section of its membership, <a href="/en/articles/2021/03/02/salt-m02.html">including Sawant</a>, into the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), which operates directly within the imperialist Democratic Party</p></div></section></div><aside data-track-content="true" data-content-name="100% of article" data-content-piece="/en/articles/2023/03/23/ljwc-m23.html"></aside><aside class="dn-p relative mv4 _bt _bb" style="width:100vW;left:50%;right:50%;margin-left:-50vW;margin-right:-50vW"><div class="mw6 mw7-l center ph3 ph0-m avenir"><div class="cf bg-black-05 pa3 pa4-m br3"><div class="center w-100 "><div class="lh-title ph4-l mh3-l f4 f3-ns b black mb3"><span type="text-line">I want to participate in the work of the Global Workers’ Inquest</span></div><div><div class="_bg-black-05 _pa3 _pa4-ns" data-track-content="true" data-content-name="Mautic form 229" data-content-piece="/en/articles/2023/03/23/ljwc-m23.html"><style type="text/css"> .mauticform_wrapper { margin: 0 auto; white-space: normal; -webkit-user-modify: read-only; } .mauticform_wrapper > form { font-size: 13px; line-height: 1.2em; } .mauticform_wrapper > form h3 { height: auto; font-size: 24px; color: #000; line-height: 1.1em; background: none; padding: 0; margin-top: 0; } #form .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-checkboxgrp-row { display: flex; margin: 8px 0 8px 0; } .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-checkboxgrp-label { width: 100%; font-size: 1rem; line-height: 1.5em; color: #393C43; } .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-checkboxgrp-checkbox { width: 1.5rem; height: 1.5rem; font-size: 1rem; accent-color: #EC143B; margin: 0 12px 0 0; transform: scale(1.0); } .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-button-wrapper { margin-bottom: 0; } .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-button-wrapper .mauticform-button.btn-default { width: 100%; color: #fff; padding: 16px 24px; background: #CC0000; border: #cCC0000; font-size: 1rem; } .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-label { font-size: 1rem; display: block; font-weight: bold; margin-bottom: 8px; color: #050404; } .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-input, .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-selectbox, .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-textarea { font-size: 1rem; padding: 8px; } .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-input, .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-selectbox { height: 40px; } .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-message { font-size: 1.125rem; line-height: 1.5em; } .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-errormsg { font-size: 1rem; margin-top: 8px; } @media screen and (min-width: 48em) { .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-checkboxgrp-label { font-size: 1.125rem; } .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-button-wrapper .mauticform-button.btn-default { font-size: 1.125rem; } .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-input, .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-selectbox, .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-textarea { padding: 14px; } .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-input, .mauticform_wrapper > form .mauticform-selectbox { height: 48px; } } </style><div></div></div></div></div></div></div></aside></div><div class="pt1 pt2-m"><div class="dn-p relative pt3 mt4 bt bb b--black-40"><h1 class="dib bg-white pr3 avenir f7 _f6-l b black-60 ttu tracked-half pa0 ma0 absolute top-0 left-0" style="top:-0.5rem">Read more</h1><div class="relative z-0"><div class="absolute top-0 left-0 z-1 h-100" style="left:-2px;min-width:1rem;background:linear-gradient(270deg, rgba(255,255,255,0), rgba(255,255,255,1) 100%)"></div><ul class="list _flex pl0 pb3 _pb4-l mt0 mb0 overflow-y-hidden overflow-x-auto nowrap"><li class="dib v-top relative ph3 mv2 mv3-l ws-normal w-80 w-40-ns w-30-l "><a class="avenir f6 _f5 b black lh-title no-underline underline-hover" href="/en/articles/2022/12/20/pers-d20.html">Who is responsible for China’s COVID catastrophe?</a><div class="avenir f7 black-60 _ttu _tracked-half mt1 _mt2-l"><time dateTime="2022-12-20T05:36:24.000Z">20 December 2022</time></div></li><li class="dib v-top relative ph3 mv2 mv3-l ws-normal w-80 w-40-ns w-30-l bl bw1 b--black-10"><a class="avenir f6 _f5 b black lh-title no-underline underline-hover" href="/en/articles/2021/12/13/chin-d13.html">The misunderstood—and misrepresented—Zero COVID policy in China</a><div class="avenir f7 black-60 _ttu _tracked-half mt1 _mt2-l"><time dateTime="2021-12-13T05:45:57.000Z">13 December 2021</time></div></li><li class="dib v-top relative ph3 mv2 mv3-l ws-normal w-80 w-40-ns w-30-l bl bw1 b--black-10"><a class="avenir f6 _f5 b black lh-title no-underline underline-hover" href="/en/articles/2022/10/15/edfd-o15.html">The historical background of the COVID-19 pandemic and the fight for global elimination</a><div class="avenir f7 black-60 _ttu _tracked-half mt1 _mt2-l"><time dateTime="2022-10-15T02:55:11.000Z">14 October 2022</time></div></li></ul><div class="absolute top-0 right-0 z-1 h-100" style="right:-2px;min-width:1rem;background:linear-gradient(90deg, rgba(255,255,255,0), rgba(255,255,255,1) 100%)"></div></div></div><div class="dn-p _flex-ns flex-m mt4" styyle="[object Object]"><div class="w-20-m pr4-m mt3 mt0-m"><a class="db avenir f7 b black hover-black ttu tracked-half tc bg-black-05 pa3 br2 no-underline pointer grow" href="/en"><svg class="db center" version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="10 10 26 26" style="width:1rem;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="home"><polygon points="31,19.05 31,13 28,13 28,16.082 24.517,12.628 24.515,12.58 12.033,25 16,25 16,36 22,36 22,30 27,30 27,36 33,36 33,25 37,25"></polygon></g></svg></a></div><div class="w-50-m pr4-m mt3 mt0-m"><a class="db avenir f7 b white hover-white ttu tracked-half tc bg-black pa3 br2 no-underline pointer grow"></a></div><div class="w-50-m pr4-m mt3 mt0-m"><a class="db avenir f7 b white hover-white ttu tracked-half tc bg-blue bg-dark-red pa3 br2 no-underline pointer grow" href="/en/special/pages/contact.html"><span>Contact us</span></a></div></div><section class="dn-p related cf -center _ph5-ns _ph6-m _ph6-l mt4 mb4"><div class="_dib dn bb"><span class="dib avenir ttu b lh-solid pv2" style="font-size:0.75rem;letter-spacing:0.05em">Related Topics</span></div><div class="avenir f5 i lh-copy mb3">Find out more about these topics:</div><div class="_mt4"><a class="dib avenir f7 b lh-solid tracked-half black-80 hover-black _hover-bg-black-80 no-underline ba bw1 br2 b--black-80 pa2 mr3 mb3 grow" href="/en/topics/campaigns/global-workers-inquest-coronavirus-pandemic">The Global Workers' Inquest into the COVID-19 Pandemic</a><a class="dib avenir f7 b lh-solid tracked-half black-80 hover-black _hover-bg-black-80 no-underline ba bw1 br2 b--black-80 pa2 mr3 mb3 grow" href="/en/topics/event/coronavirus">The coronavirus pandemic</a><a class="dib avenir f7 b lh-solid tracked-half black-80 hover-black _hover-bg-black-80 no-underline ba bw1 br2 b--black-80 pa2 mr3 mb3 grow" href="/en/topics/internationalPoliticsCategory/pseudoleft">The Politics of the Pseudo-Left</a><a class="dib avenir f7 b lh-solid tracked-half black-80 hover-black _hover-bg-black-80 no-underline ba bw1 br2 b--black-80 pa2 mr3 mb3 grow" href="/en/topics/country/as-china">China</a><a class="dib avenir f7 b lh-solid tracked-half black-80 hover-black _hover-bg-black-80 no-underline ba bw1 br2 b--black-80 pa2 mr3 mb3 grow" href="/en/topics/continent/asia">Asia and the Pacific</a></div></section></div><section class="dn-p w-100" id="comments" name="comments"><style> .comments { width: 20rem; -webkit-overflow-scrolling: touch; } .comments-enter { right: -20rem; } .comments-enter.comments-enter-active { right: 0; transition: right 200ms ease-out ; } .comments-exit { right: 0; } .comments-exit.comments-exit-active { right: -20rem; transition: right 200ms ease-in; } @media screen and (min-width: 48em) { .comments { width: 27rem; } .comments-enter { right: -27rem; } .comments-exit.comments-exit-active { right: -27rem; } } @media screen and (min-width: 64em) { .comments { width: 32rem; } .comments-enter { right: -32rem; } .comments-exit.comments-exit-active { right: -32rem; } } </style><div class="comments fixed flex flex-column z-max top-0 right-0 h-100 bg-white b--black-10 shadow-2" style="right:-32rem"><div class="relative h-100 overflow-scroll"><div class="absolute top-0 left-0 pa2 hover-dark-red pointer"><svg version="1.1" id="Layer_1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" x="0px" y="0px" viewBox="0 0 48 48" style="width:2rem;fill:currentColor;enable-background:new 0 0 48 48" xml:space="preserve"><g id="remove"><path d="M27.195,23.996l5.648-5.648c0.221-0.222,0.221-0.585,0-0.806l-2.383-2.383c-0.221-0.221-0.583-0.221-0.805,0l-5.649,5.649 l-5.653-5.652c-0.222-0.221-0.584-0.221-0.805,0l-2.383,2.384c-0.222,0.22-0.222,0.582,0,0.806l5.652,5.651l-5.65,5.65 c-0.22,0.22-0.22,0.583,0,0.805l2.383,2.383c0.222,0.22,0.586,0.22,0.806,0l5.649-5.649l5.646,5.647 c0.221,0.221,0.585,0.221,0.806,0l2.384-2.384c0.22-0.22,0.22-0.583,0-0.806L27.195,23.996z"></path></g></svg></div><section class="pt4 pl4 pr4"></section></div></div></section></div></div></section></article></section><section id="index" class="dn-p"><div class="mw-75rem-l center avenir f6 ttu tracked pa3 bg-black-05 tc pointer ma4">Loading</div></section><noscript><img src="https://piwik.wsws.org/analytics/piwik/piwik.php?idsite=1&rec=1" style="border:0" alt=""/></noscript></main><footer class="mt5 mt3-p ph3 ph4-m"><div class="mw6-ns mw7-m _mw8-l mw-75rem-l _mw-100rem-xxl center bt pt4 pt3-p"><div class="dn-p pt4 tc"><a class="dib white hover-white br-100 pa2 mh2" href="https://www.facebook.com/wsws.org" target="_blank" style="width:2rem;height:2rem;background:#415086"><svg id="iconset-facebook" viewBox="0 0 18 18" width="100%" height="100%" style="fill:currentColor"><path d="M7.003 17l-.006-7H4l.006-3h2.997V4.995C7.003 2.408 8.457 1 10.808 1c1.126 0 1.91.082 2.192.12v2.877h-1.447c-1.278 0-1.526.597-1.526 1.472V7h2.866l-.403 3h-2.47l.007 7H7.003z"></path></svg></a><a class="dib white hover-white br-100 bg-black pa2 mh2" href="https://twitter.com/WSWS_Updates" target="_blank" style="width:2rem;height:2rem;background:#00A6E4"><svg id="iconset-twitter" viewBox="0 0 18 18" width="100%" height="100%" style="fill:currentColor"><path d="M12.077 2c-1.812 0-3.282 1.582-3.282 3.534 0 .277.03.547.085.806-2.728-.148-5.147-1.555-6.766-3.693a3.727 3.727 0 0 0-.445 1.777c0 1.226.58 2.308 1.46 2.942a3.093 3.093 0 0 1-1.49-.443v.045c0 1.712 1.13 3.14 2.634 3.465a3.07 3.07 0 0 1-1.483.06c.42 1.407 1.632 2.427 3.07 2.457-1.124.946-2.54 1.51-4.077 1.51A6.22 6.22 0 0 1 1 14.413 8.818 8.818 0 0 0 6.032 16c6.038 0 9.34-5.385 9.34-10.056 0-.153-.004-.306-.01-.457A6.98 6.98 0 0 0 17 3.657a6.2 6.2 0 0 1-1.885.557 3.51 3.51 0 0 0 1.443-1.956c-.634.405-1.337.7-2.085.858C13.875 2.43 13.023 2 12.077 2"></path></svg></a><a class="dib white hover-white br-100 bg-black pa2 mh2" href="https://www.instagram.com/worldsocialistwebsite/" target="_blank" style="width:2rem;height:2rem;background:#DA2B73"><svg id="iconset-instagram" viewBox="0 0 18 18" width="100%" height="100%" style="fill:currentColor"><path d="M9 .5H5.5c-1 0-1.5.3-2 .5-.6.2-1 .5-1.5 1-.5.4-.8 1-1 1.5-.2.5-.4 1-.4 2v7.2c0 1 .2 1.5.4 2 .2.6.5 1 1 1.5.4.6 1 1 1.5 1 .5.3 1 .5 2 .5h7.1c1 0 1.5-.2 2-.4.6 0 1-.4 1.5-1 .6-.3 1-.8 1-1.4.3-.5.5-1 .5-2V9 5.6c0-1-.2-1.5-.4-2 0-.6-.4-1-1-1.5-.3-.5-.8-.8-1.4-1-.5-.2-1-.4-2-.4H9M9 2h3.5l1.6.4c.5.2.7.4 1 .7l.7 1 .3 1.6v7c0 .8-.2 1.3-.3 1.6-.2.5-.4.7-.7 1-.3.3-.5.5-1 .7l-1.5.3H5.6c-.8 0-1.3-.2-1.6-.3L3 15l-.6-1-.3-1.5V9 5.7L2.5 4 3 3l1-.6L5.6 2H9"></path><path d="M9 11.8c-1.5 0-2.8-1.3-2.8-2.8 0-1.6 1.3-2.8 2.8-2.8 1.6 0 3 1.2 3 2.8 0 1.5-1.4 2.8-3 2.8m0-7C6.6 4.7 4.7 6.5 4.7 9c0 2.4 2 4.3 4.3 4.3 2.5 0 4.4-2 4.4-4.3 0-2.4-2-4.3-4.4-4.3M14.6 4.5c0 .6-.5 1-1 1-.6 0-1-.4-1-1 0-.5.4-1 1-1 .5 0 1 .5 1 1"></path></svg></a><a class="dib white hover-white br-100 bg-black pa2 mh2" href="https://www.youtube.com/SEPupload" target="_blank" style="width:2rem;height:2rem;background:#CE1312"><svg id="iconset-youtube" viewBox="0 0 18 18" width="100%" height="100%" style="fill:currentColor"><path d="M7 11V6l5 2.5L7 11zm9.8-5.6s0-1-.6-1.6c-.6-.6-1.3-.6-1.6-.6C12.4 3 9 3 9 3s-3.4 0-5.6.2c-.3 0-1 0-1.6.6-.5.5-.6 1.6-.6 1.6S1 6.6 1 8v1c0 1.4.2 2.6.2 2.6s0 1 .6 1.6c.6.6 1.4.6 1.8.6C4.8 14 9 14 9 14s3.4 0 5.6-.2c.3 0 1 0 1.6-.6.5-.5.6-1.6.6-1.6s.2-1.2.2-2.5V8c0-1.4-.2-2.6-.2-2.6z"></path></svg></a><a class="dib white hover-white br-100 bg-black pa2 mh2" href="https://www.wsws.org/rss/en.xml" target="_blank" style="width:2rem;height:2rem;background:#ff6600"><svg id="iconset-rss" viewBox="0 0 18 18" width="100%" height="100%" style="fill:currentColor"><path d="M2.4 12.7c1.3 0 2.4 1 2.4 2.4s-1 2.4-2.4 2.4C1 17.4 0 16.4 0 15c0-1.2 1-2.3 2.4-2.3"></path><path d="M0 6.7v3c4.3 0 7.8 3.5 7.8 7.7h3C11 11.4 6 6.7 0 6.7m0-6v3c7.7 0 14 6 14 13.7h3C17 8.2 9.5.6 0 .6"></path></svg></a><a class="dib white hover-white br-100 bg-black pa2 mh2" href="https://www.wsws.org/en/special/podcast.html" target="_blank" style="width:2rem;height:2rem;background:#bd3fe1"><svg id="iconset-podcast" viewBox="10 10 28 28" width="100%" height="100%" style="fill:currentColor"><path d="M30.85,22c0,0.667-0.097,1.328-0.289,1.963c-0.051,0.168-0.186,0.298-0.357,0.341c-0.04,0.01-0.081,0.015-0.122,0.015 c-0.131,0-0.259-0.052-0.354-0.146l-0.588-0.589c-0.123-0.123-0.173-0.301-0.133-0.471c0.097-0.403,0.142-0.757,0.142-1.112 c0-2.84-2.31-5.149-5.15-5.149S18.85,19.16,18.85,22c0,0.355,0.045,0.709,0.142,1.112c0.041,0.17-0.01,0.348-0.133,0.471 l-0.588,0.589c-0.095,0.095-0.223,0.146-0.354,0.146c-0.041,0-0.082-0.005-0.122-0.015c-0.171-0.043-0.306-0.173-0.357-0.341 C17.247,23.328,17.15,22.667,17.15,22c0-3.777,3.073-6.851,6.85-6.851S30.85,18.223,30.85,22z M24,11.149 c-5.983,0-10.85,4.867-10.85,10.851c0,1.766,0.445,3.528,1.287,5.096c0.075,0.14,0.211,0.235,0.367,0.259 c0.024,0.003,0.049,0.005,0.073,0.005c0.131,0,0.259-0.052,0.354-0.146l0.513-0.513c0.153-0.152,0.19-0.387,0.092-0.579 C15.191,24.848,14.85,23.423,14.85,22c0-5.045,4.104-9.149,9.15-9.149s9.15,4.104,9.15,9.149c0,1.423-0.341,2.848-0.986,4.121 c-0.098,0.192-0.061,0.427,0.092,0.579l0.513,0.513c0.095,0.095,0.222,0.146,0.354,0.146c0.024,0,0.049-0.002,0.073-0.005 c0.156-0.023,0.292-0.119,0.367-0.259c0.842-1.567,1.287-3.33,1.287-5.096C34.85,16.017,29.983,11.149,24,11.149z M25,26h-2 c-1.105,0-2,0.896-2,2l1,6c0,0,0.292,2,2,2s2-2,2-2l1-6C27,26.896,26.105,26,25,26z M24,19c-1.657,0-3,1.343-3,3s1.343,3,3,3 s3-1.343,3-3S25.657,19,24,19z"></path></svg></a><a class="dib white hover-white br-100 bg-black pa2 mh2" href="https://www.wsws.org/en/special/newsletter.html" target="_blank" style="width:2rem;height:2rem;background:#666"><svg id="iconset-newsletter" viewBox="10 10 28 28" width="100%" height="100%" style="fill:currentColor"><path d="M24,28L12,16h24L24,28z M24,30l-5-5l-7,7h24l-7-7L24,30z M30,24l6,6V18L30,24z M12,18v12l6-6L12,18z"></path></svg></a></div><div class="pa4 pa0-p"><small class="avenir f6 db tc">© 1998-2025 World Socialist Web Site. All rights reserved.</small><div class="dn-p avenir lh-copy tc mt3"><a title="Home" class="f6 dib ph2 link _white-60 dim pointer" href="/en">Home</a><a title="About" class="f6 dib ph2 link _white-60 dim pointer" href="/en/special/pages/icfi/wsws.html">About</a><a title="Contact" class="f6 dib ph2 link _white-60 dim pointer" href="/en/special/pages/contact.html">Contact</a><a title="Privacy Statement" class="f6 dib ph2 link _white-60 dim pointer" href="/en/special/privacy.html">Privacy Statement</a><a title="Privacy Settings" class="f6 dib ph2 link _white-60 dim pointer">Privacy Settings</a></div></div></div></footer></div></div><div id="modal"></div><script id="__NEXT_DATA__" type="application/json">{"props":{"pageProps":{"initialData":{"page":{"id":"4a897772-8dd7-4e59-a75e-c40c21d33297","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2023/03/23/ljwc-m23.html","language":"en","title":"The international pseudo-left and the lifting of Zero-COVID in China: Part 1","overline":"Accomplices to social murder","underline":"","authors":["Evan Blake"],"authorPages":[{"featuredImages":[],"channels":{"twitterHandle":"@evanblake17"},"name":"evan-blake.html","title":"Evan Blake","description":""}],"published":1679608282,"modified":1679832755,"keywords":["China","COVID-19","Zero-COVID","pseudo-left","Pabloism","International Viewpoint","Trotskyism","herd immunity","Jacobin","Stalinism","Maoism"],"description":"The pseudo-left’s hostility to public health and support for imperialism found sharp expression in their universal demand—echoing that of the Western corporate media and political establishment—that China abandon its Zero-COVID strategy.","template":"","comments":true,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1679832755,"hidePhotos":false,"contentData":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"This is the first part of a two-part article. Part two ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/af93820d-821f-46a0-866d-ef1e9a1e8104"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"af93820d-821f-46a0-866d-ef1e9a1e8104","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2023/03/24/ljwc-m24.html","title":"The international pseudo-left and the lifting of Zero-COVID in China: Part 2","overline":"Accomplices to social murder","underline":"","description":"The pseudo-left’s hostility to public health and support for imperialism found its sharpest expression in their demand—echoing that of the Western corporate media and political establishment—that China abandon its Zero-COVID strategy.","authors":["Evan Blake"],"published":1679690314,"modified":1679932832,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1679932832,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":{"license":"associated-press","author":"Andy Wong","authorLink":"","source":"","title":""},"created":1672786573,"id":"95b21f4d-498e-44d5-a826-db38889cf478","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":3000,"pixelYDimension":1688,"title":"The emergency ward of a hospital in China, January 3, 2023."}],"topics":[{"id":"1fdd1b45-9245-400f-8c01-1aae9d8db379"},{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f"},{"id":"198c15b9-fdf8-4a0d-b49e-6154bb33b290"},{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583"},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed"}]}],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"can be read here","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":".","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Since its outbreak more than three years ago, in January 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic has killed over 20 million people, disabled tens of millions more with Long COVID, pushed health care systems to the brink of collapse, exacerbated social inequality, and accelerated the outbreak of war in Ukraine, the antechamber to World War III.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"For the first time since World War II, life expectancy declined globally in 2020 and 2021. Despite US President Joe Biden’s claim that “the pandemic is over,” echoed by capitalist politicians throughout the world, this social catastrophe continues. Every week, there are nearly 100,000 excess deaths attributable to the pandemic globally, or roughly 1 million deaths every three months. With the ending of Zero-COVID in China and the worldwide scrapping of all mitigation measures that slow the spread of the coronavirus, it is mutating and evolving into new, potentially more dangerous variants.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"For the ruling class, the pandemic was seized upon as an opportunity to enrich itself and deepen its decades-long assault on the living conditions of the international working class. While refusing to implement the necessary public health measures to stop the transmission of the virus, in March 2020 the advanced capitalist governments passed unprecedented financial bailouts. As deaths rose by the millions, the collective fortunes of the corporate-financial pandemic profiteers increased by ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"trillions","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":".","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The ruling classes, anxious to suppress public health protocols that interfered with the capitalist production process from which surplus value and profit is derived, promoted ignorance, superstition and irrational fears of science, while whipping up far-right forces to agitate against lockdowns, mask-wearing, remote learning, and all other measures necessary to stop the pandemic. Their motto was: Better that several thousand workers in a factory should be infected than suffer one week of lost production time!","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"media"},{"key":"link","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/c6f6f484-b8bd-4808-86b8-ef95a9f42406"},{"key":"caption","value":""},{"key":"usecaption","value":"false"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"c6f6f484-b8bd-4808-86b8-ef95a9f42406","copyright":{"license":"associated-press","author":"Alex Brandon","authorLink":"","source":"","title":""},"created":1637548520,"title":"Then-President Donald Trump watches as White House coronavirus adviser and \"herd immunity\" promoter Dr. Scott Atlas speaks during a September 2020 news conference on the pandemic.","type":"image","path":"/media/photos/2021/11/22/b629286dfc4915d0a0598f6ff18863e973a33b00.jpg","pixelXDimension":2048,"pixelYDimension":1365}],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[]}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"For decades, the capitalist governments have viewed the gradual increase in life expectancy with dismay and alarm. The ability of the elderly to obtain subsidized medical care as they made it into their 70s, 80s and even 90s has been seen as a budgetary calamity.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"During the pandemic, the capitalist elites have viewed the deaths of “non-productive” elderly workers, as well as declines in life expectancy, as positive outcomes for reducing pension obligations and other social welfare spending. They have revived the eugenicist and Social Darwinist conceptions that dominated in ruling circles during the first half of the 20th century and motivated the Holocaust. The Nazi concept of ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"lebensunwertes Leben","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":", or “life unworthy of life,” is now applied to elderly and immunocompromised people left to die en masse.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Scientists have warned that climate change and unplanned urbanization are forcing animals to migrate outside their native habitats, bringing with them thousands of pathogens that have the potential to spill over into human populations, making future pandemics all but inevitable. But there is absolutely no indication that governments are seeking to prevent or prepare for this near-term danger. Just the opposite: to the extent that the ruling elites have drawn any lessons from the catastrophe of the past three years, it is that nature should be left to run its course, that the production process and financial interests of corporations should not be disrupted, and that the accumulation of profits and wealth must not be interfered with. The deaths of millions will be accepted as the “price of doing business” during future pandemics. The infamous words of former British Prime Minister Boris Johnson—“Let the bodies pile high”—will define public policy.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"For the working class, the pandemic has been a traumatic shock that has upended social life and revealed the brutality of class relations. It has accelerated and intensified the ongoing radicalization of workers globally, precipitating numerous struggles against the homicidal policies of the ruling elites. In the US, Canada, Italy and other countries, the belated lockdowns in March 2020 were only implemented after the working class mounted wildcat strikes, independent of the pro-capitalist unions, to save lives.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Beginning in China, growing opposition among workers forced several governments to implement comprehensive Zero-COVID policies in the early stages of the pandemic. Grounded in mass working class solidarity, these Zero-COVID policies were highly successful at saving lives. The death toll in China, New Zealand, Vietnam and other countries remained an infinitesimal fraction of that of the US and other imperialist powers. However, confronted with relentless pressure from global finance capital, these governments eventually lifted their Zero-COVID policies in 2021 and 2022, with catastrophic consequences in each country.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Throughout the pandemic, the International Committee of the Fourth International (ICFI) and the ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"World Socialist Web Site","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" have articulated the interests of the working class and advocated a ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/79976537-7188-43a4-8403-70f025a91032"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"79976537-7188-43a4-8403-70f025a91032","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2021/08/21/pers-a21.html","title":"The eradication of COVID-19 is the only way to stop the pandemic","overline":"","underline":"","description":"The global spread of the highly infectious Delta variant and the drive to fully reopen schools worldwide, despite the well-known risks to children, has made clear that the only viable strategy is the eradication of COVID-19 internationally.","authors":["Evan Blake","David North"],"published":1629513059,"modified":1629553022,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1629553022,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":null,"created":1629507596,"id":"ab320250-cf04-4fde-a4c7-f06484bcaaac","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":1600,"pixelYDimension":900,"title":"Clinical lab scientist Selam Bihon processes upper respiratory samples from patients suspected of having COVID-19 at the Stanford Clinical Virology Laboratory on Wednesday, Feb. 3, 2021, in Palo Alto, Calif. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)"}],"topics":[{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f"},{"id":"105b9ec2-0cdd-480d-9c55-6f806fa7b9bc"},{"id":"214d563b-bdc0-439e-8bcd-fbe76938e228"},{"id":"bf15baac-b92e-4007-95b1-f0dbdd8a374f"},{"id":"28cb2d89-f078-4ea8-9762-d2bd517b087c"},{"id":"ea69254c-a976-4e67-a79c-843202a10e55"},{"id":"b0e983c5-6e85-4829-a9fe-3c25f02c211f"}]}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"global public health strategy","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" to eliminate COVID-19 in every country. The WSWS has published over 5,000 articles on the pandemic during the past three years, analyzing every major scientific and political development related to the pandemic throughout the world.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"A markedly different response arose within substantial sections of the upper-middle class and political parties that express their interests. To a great extent, these social layers were able to isolate or work safely at home throughout 2020, with the pandemic generally viewed as a serious but only temporary disruption. Moreover, small business owners and self-employed professionals who received inadequate support during the initial lockdowns, as well as layers more heavily invested in the stock market, largely embraced the anti-lockdown propaganda pushed by the ruling class. Once vaccinated in early 2021, the affluent middle class was anxious to resume its pre-pandemic mode of wealth accumulation and amusement and proceed as if nothing too serious had happened.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The social interests and political conceptions of the affluent middle class are articulated by various political parties that comprise what the ICFI has defined as the “","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/3b8b0194-90cf-4daa-9b65-4731456243cc"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"3b8b0194-90cf-4daa-9b65-4731456243cc","type":"content","path":"/en/special/pages/pseudoleft.html","title":"The politics of the pseudo-left"}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"pseudo-left","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":".” This term is justified by the fact that these organizations have nothing in common—in terms of their political program, their practice and the social constituency to which they appeal—with what the term “left” has signified since the dawn of the socialist movement in the first half of the 19th century.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Some of these organizations retain—as a result of either a long-past historical association with Marxism and even Trotskyism or, more commonly, the most cynical opportunism—the words “socialism” and “workers” on their political calling cards. But this sort of false advertising does not determine the objective social content of their program and practice. The essential nature of these organization is defined by politics of personal identity, centered on race, ethnicity, nationality, gender and sexual orientation.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The focus of their activities, therefore, is not the class struggle, the development of socialist consciousness and the revolutionary overthrow of capitalism by the working class. Their “leftism” is, instead, aimed at achieving a broader distribution of wealth presently monopolized by the richest 1 or 2 percent of society. The social program of their “leftism” would be satisfied if a somewhat larger share of the money sloshing around at the top would be allowed to trickle down into the less fortunate layers of the wealthiest top 10 percent.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Included among the pseudo-left are the Pabloites of ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"International Viewpoint","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"; the Morenoite tendencies, led by Trotskyist Fraction—Fourth International (FT) and International Workers League—Fourth International (IWLfi); the state capitalists, led by International Socialist Tendency (IST); as well as International Marxist Tendency (IMT), Committee for a Workers’ International (CWI), International Socialist Alternative (ISA) and the International Socialist League (ISL). Prominent national pseudo-left groups include Syriza in Greece, Podemos in Spain, the Left Party in Germany, the Socialism and Liberty Party in Brazil and others.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The pseudo-left responded to the COVID-19 pandemic with a collective shrug. After ignoring the early signs of the developing global crisis in January-February 2020, starting in March 2020 they each published a few news articles monthly throughout the first year of the pandemic. Amid the roll-out of vaccines in 2021, they gradually stopped covering the pandemic altogether.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Over the past three years, these parties have collectively written just a few hundred articles on the pandemic. Not a single one has issued a programmatic statement outlining a scientific strategy to eliminate COVID-19 globally. As noted in a ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"https://twitter.com/useless_priest/status/1618566431398068227"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"recent Twitter thread","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":", they also maintain silence on the catastrophic impacts of Long COVID.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The pseudo-left’s hostility to public health and support for imperialism found its sharpest expression in their demand—echoing that of the Western corporate media and political establishment—that China abandon its Zero-COVID strategy. This reached a climax over the past four months, during which every pseudo-left tendency in the world supported this catastrophic policy shift in China.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"This essay will provide a representative sampling of the response of these organizations, ostensibly claiming to be on the left, socialist and even Trotskyist, to this latest manifestation of the greatest health crisis of modern history, in which they became the unabashed advocates of mass infection. It is a political biopsy, which exposes the malignant cells of a deeply sick and politically reactionary social milieu. This can be a laborious process because one is dealing with an alphabet soup of organizations, but there is no way around it. They must be identified and their positions memorialized. Their culpability in this social crime cannot be forgotten.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"h4","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Who is responsible for the lifting of Zero-COVID in China?","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"January 23, 2020 marked the beginning of the first Zero-COVID policy in the world, as 13 million people entered a citywide lockdown in Wuhan, China. This was soon expanded to all 15 other cities in Hubei province, affecting 57 million people in total. These lockdowns, unprecedented in world history, were combined with a program of regular mass testing, rigorous contact tracing, the safe isolation of infected patients, and travel restrictions and universal masking—public health measures that mankind had accumulated since the Black Death in the 14th century.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"media"},{"key":"link","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/f7050a62-f2b7-479c-9f6e-eac655146dbb"},{"key":"caption","value":""},{"key":"usecaption","value":"false"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"f7050a62-f2b7-479c-9f6e-eac655146dbb","copyright":{"license":"associated-press","author":"Sam McNeil, File","authorLink":"","source":"","title":""},"created":1679608031,"title":"In this April 15, 2020, file photo, government workers stand outside a blue tent used to coordinate transportation of travelers from Wuhan to designated quarantine sites in Beijing. ","type":"image","path":"/media/photos/2023/03/23/7f3d846f2833a598da7b3c5542304a201add11a2.jpg","pixelXDimension":3600,"pixelYDimension":2025}],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[]}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"After 76 days of immense self-sacrifice and determination by Chinese workers that led to the elimination of the coronavirus across China, on April 17, 2020, the lockdowns were lifted and daily life for the Chinese population returned to normal.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Public health officials and scientists in other countries who had been skeptical of the ability to eliminate COVID-19, including Dr. Michael Baker in New Zealand, watched what happened in China and decided to replicate this Zero-COVID program. This led to the elimination of the virus in many countries, particularly in the Asia-Pacific region. Whenever an outbreak of COVID-19 broke through border management systems, these same measures were able to quickly stop viral transmission.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Over the next two years, the political establishment and corporate media of the imperialist powers, above all the United States, continuously demanded the lifting of Zero-COVID wherever this policy was in place. Themselves guilty of killing millions of their citizens, they could not tolerate the living proof that mass infections and deaths were the unnecessary outcome of their socially criminal policies.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"In tandem with the concoction of the Wuhan Lab Lie—which falsely laid blame on China for deliberately or accidentally unleashing COVID-19 on the world—the Western media issued a steady stream of propaganda denouncing Zero-COVID, and, in particular, lockdowns as “authoritarian” and “anti-democratic,” libels later adopted by the pseudo-left.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) maintains an authoritarian regime. But the application of this term to its initial Zero-COVID policy towards the pandemic is false, intended to discredit essential and life-saving public health measures. Throughout the pandemic, the lockdowns were always ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/66dd3dbb-f0e8-4882-882b-b5f3501bd324"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"66dd3dbb-f0e8-4882-882b-b5f3501bd324","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2021/12/13/chin-d13.html","title":"The misunderstood—and misrepresented—Zero COVID policy in China","overline":"","underline":"","description":"One of the most striking facts about the pandemic is that China, the country from which SARS-CoV-2 first emerged, has suffered very few cases. This article is a detailed look at China’s Zero COVID policy.","authors":["a scientist"],"published":1639374357,"modified":1639421783,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1639421783,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":{"license":"cc-by-4.0","author":"Juukeihc","authorLink":"","source":"","title":""},"created":1639355140,"id":"9cd03bc9-8074-4fca-9f09-5bdbaa797b76","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":1280,"pixelYDimension":720,"title":"The central business district of Chongqing (Credit: Wikimedia, CC-BY-SA 3.0.)"}],"topics":[{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f"},{"id":"bf15baac-b92e-4007-95b1-f0dbdd8a374f"},{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583"},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed"}]}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"temporary and targeted","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":", contrary to the myth that cities were permanently shut down and cut off from access to necessary resources.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The inescapable problem of the Chinese response was the impossibility of applying Zero-COVID on a purely national scale. It was not possible to construct and maintain an impenetrable anti-COVID “Great Wall of China” that would prevent the incessant episodes of viral penetration from external sources. To this fundamental problem was the added economic impact upon China’s capitalist economy of imperialist pressure to abandon Zero-COVID.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Last October and November, Wall Street and the world’s major corporations exerted intense economic pressure on the CCP to lift Zero-COVID, with Apple, Google, Samsung, Microsoft and other companies threatening to shift production away from China unless even limited lockdowns and other basic public health measures were abandoned. At the same time, opposition to Zero-COVID mounted in the Chinese bourgeoisie and upper-middle class, whose wealth was increasingly impacted by these same measures. The CCP finally relented on November 11, ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/b5816158-5dda-406a-bda8-9a74741d83fd"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"b5816158-5dda-406a-bda8-9a74741d83fd","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2022/11/16/d485-n16.html","title":"Chinese Communist Party begins lifting Zero-COVID policy","overline":"","underline":"","description":"There is no scientific justification for this shift in policy, which is based solely on political and economic considerations.","authors":["Benjamin Mateus","Evan Blake"],"published":1668571781,"modified":1670009944,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1670009944,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":{"license":"associated-press","author":"Andy Wong","authorLink":"","source":"","title":""},"created":1668544577,"id":"c6f683c5-7e4e-4d70-b5c7-0ed1f63c27af","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":4000,"pixelYDimension":2250,"title":"Commuters wearing face masks walk rush to catch their trains at a subway station during the morning rush hour in Beijing on Monday, Nov. 14, 2022."}],"topics":[{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f"},{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583"},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed"}]}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"announcing 20 measures","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" that loosened every aspect of Zero-COVID, under conditions in which official infections were already surging across the country.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"On November 24, an apartment fire took place in Ürümqi which tragically claimed the lives of 10 people. Without any evidence, claims were made that the Zero-COVID policy was responsible. In reality, the neighborhood where the fire took place was ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/7098d842-dff3-43b9-ad02-39ccb187b630"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"7098d842-dff3-43b9-ad02-39ccb187b630","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2022/11/28/tspr-n28.html","title":"Apartment fire in China exploited to push for ending COVID restrictions","overline":"","underline":"","description":"The tragic death of ten people in a fire in a high-rise building in Xinjiang was caused not by COVID-19 restrictions, but the lack of adequate fire safety measures in the neighborhood.","authors":["Lily Zhao"],"published":1669619441,"modified":1669622364,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1669622364,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":{"license":"fair-use","author":"Chinese social media user","authorLink":"","source":"","title":""},"created":1669622170,"id":"fe2d2ef2-f060-4e13-9f04-9fb7f2fe5129","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":720,"pixelYDimension":405,"title":"Mobile phone footage of the apartment fire"}],"topics":[{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583"},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed"}]}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"not under strict lockdown","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":", and residents were not prevented from leaving their apartments and the building. Barriers that blocked a firetruck from reaching the building were installed before the pandemic, the product of poor city planning, not as part of a lockdown.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Nevertheless, the fire in Ürümqi prompted a series of choreographed anti-Zero-COVID protests at universities and cities across China, involving primarily upper-middle class students and no more than a few thousand protesters out of a population of 1.4 billion. After a ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/46594900-b96b-4b87-8891-bb3a1f76f8d2"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"46594900-b96b-4b87-8891-bb3a1f76f8d2","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2022/11/30/chin-n30.html","title":"China pushes lifting of Zero-COVID after anti-lockdown protests","overline":"","underline":"","description":"China’s National Health Commission yesterday called for an acceleration of measures to relax the Zero-COVID policy and vowed to “deal seriously” with local governments that fail to do so.","authors":["Peter Symonds"],"published":1669785167,"modified":1669837091,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1669837091,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":{"license":"associated-press","author":"Andy Wong","authorLink":"","source":"","title":""},"created":1663896570,"id":"a81da562-9e40-479a-b075-bca2c35644b0","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":6000,"pixelYDimension":3375,"title":"Residents wearing face masks line up to get their routine COVID-19 throat swabs at a coronavirus testing site in Beijing, Thursday, Sept. 22, 2022. (AP Photo/Andy Wong) "}],"topics":[{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f"},{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583"},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed"}]}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"veritable tsunami of news reports","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" and editorials in the Western press hailing these protests, on December 7 the CCP scrapped all remaining public health measures.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The abrupt abandonment of Zero-COVID had catastrophic consequences. Over 1 billion people are believed to have fallen ill in the country’s first wave of mass infection. While official figures are now entirely inaccurate, the health analytics firm Airfinity estimates that over 1.6 million people have likely died from COVID-19 since December 1, more than the three-year US death toll of over 1.1 million condensed into just four months. ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Contrary to the lies of the CCP that this will be a one-time “exit wave” which will return the country to a pre-pandemic “normal,” China is in fact now integrated in the global “forever COVID” ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/c834ebb5-da62-4847-ac15-299ae6b13c52"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"c834ebb5-da62-4847-ac15-299ae6b13c52","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2022/12/28/pers-d28.html","title":"China’s lifting of Zero-COVID and the ongoing dangers of the pandemic","overline":"","underline":"","description":"As the year 2022 draws to a close, a dangerous new stage of the COVID-19 pandemic has opened with the universal lifting of all measures that slow the spread of the coronavirus.","authors":["Evan Blake"],"published":1672202534,"modified":1672249888,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1672249888,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":{"license":"associated-press","author":"Andy Wong","authorLink":"","source":"","title":""},"created":1672195978,"id":"9c7b1db7-3218-4de7-9910-98f391a1dba5","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":3000,"pixelYDimension":1688,"title":"Morning rush hour in Beijing on December 20, 2022."}],"topics":[{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f"},{"id":"105b9ec2-0cdd-480d-9c55-6f806fa7b9bc"},{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583"},{"id":"ea69254c-a976-4e67-a79c-843202a10e55"},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed"},{"id":"b0e983c5-6e85-4829-a9fe-3c25f02c211f"}]}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"nightmare of perpetual waves","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" of mass infection, death, and debilitation with Long COVID.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The lifting of Zero-COVID in China amounts to a massive social crime against the Chinese and international working class, which has opened a new stage of the pandemic. The CCP regime, serving as capitalist agents of world imperialism and the nexus between global finance capital and the Chinese working class, ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/1d2b341a-55d9-4305-9981-34435146af51"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"1d2b341a-55d9-4305-9981-34435146af51","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2022/12/06/pers-d06.html","title":"Chinese Communist Party moves towards “herd immunity” policy","overline":"","underline":"","description":"Confronting economic crisis at home and under the conjoined pressures of international finance capital and the military provocations of US imperialism, the Xi government is scrapping China’s Zero-COVID policy that has saved millions of lives.","authors":["John Malvar"],"published":1670305953,"modified":1670349050,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1670349050,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":null,"created":1615007650,"id":"f4f2771f-1dcc-4189-bae7-fb63ac205d9f","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":1024,"pixelYDimension":576,"title":"People walk past a video screen displaying an image of Chinese President Xi Jinping at an exhibition in Beijing, March 1, 2019 [Credit: AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein]"}],"topics":[{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583"},{"id":"105b9ec2-0cdd-480d-9c55-6f806fa7b9bc"},{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f"},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed"}]}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"clearly bears full responsibility","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" for its actions.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Also deeply implicated in this crime are the Western imperialist powers and their corporate media, which for over two years continuously demanded the lifting of Zero-COVID regardless of the social impacts.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Finally, every pseudo-left political party and publication that agitated against Zero-COVID without regard for the consequences shares in the guilt for this social crime.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"h4","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The Foxconn and “white paper” protests: Propaganda vs. reality","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"After the CCP’s initial pivot away from Zero-COVID on November 11, official COVID-19 infections in China continued to climb and break new records. Not a single publication ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/5b733f38-4178-4e76-8393-daefbf3fa589"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"5b733f38-4178-4e76-8393-daefbf3fa589","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2022/11/18/pers-n18.html","title":"The disastrous implications of lifting Zero-COVID in China","overline":"","underline":"","description":"The objective laws of viral transmission mean that any shift away from a Zero-COVID elimination strategy carries with it the potential for the situation to quickly spiral out of control.","authors":["Evan Blake"],"published":1668751396,"modified":1668776434,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1668776434,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":{"license":"","author":"","authorLink":"","source":"","title":""},"created":1668733243,"id":"0c52ca37-900e-476b-b420-aeaa3c578a49","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":5630,"pixelYDimension":3166,"title":"People wearing face masks wait for COVID-19 tests at a coronavirus testing site in Beijing, Thursday, Nov. 17, 2022. (AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein)"}],"topics":[{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f"},{"id":"105b9ec2-0cdd-480d-9c55-6f806fa7b9bc"},{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583"},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed"}]}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"outside of the ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"World Socialist Web Site","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" advocated for the reimplementation of Zero-COVID, let alone the extension of this elimination strategy throughout the world. Throughout these critical weeks in November, during which it was still possible to contain the growing outbreak, the entire pseudo-left remained silent, giving their tacit endorsement to this policy shift.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"On November 22, a ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/cf265015-5107-4960-80f9-c9bd8111663e"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"cf265015-5107-4960-80f9-c9bd8111663e","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2022/11/24/brna-n24.html","title":"Anger erupts among workers at Foxconn plant in Zhengzhou, China","overline":"","underline":"","description":"“Foxconn is trash, they’re garbage, they’ve used military force to suppress the workers, many staff members got injured, and the Zhengzhou government is colluding with them in bullying ordinary workers.”","authors":["Peter Symonds"],"published":1669265702,"modified":1669268810,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1669268810,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":{"license":"fair-use","author":"@AnonymeCitoyen","authorLink":"https://twitter.com/AnonymeCitoyen/status/1595452363829035009","source":"","title":""},"created":1669265181,"id":"cbc64847-e22a-4e18-9998-8d0b41840378","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":1856,"pixelYDimension":1043,"title":"Workers clashing with security forces outside the iPhone factory in Zhengzhou, China. "}],"topics":[{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583"},{"id":"4da94d05-31b5-448d-abae-05785c05f07e"},{"id":"e4fa6eaa-c2f9-4612-a246-444409902a05"},{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f"},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed"}]}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"major demonstration","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" involving thousands of workers was held at the notorious Foxconn sweatshop in Zhengzhou, the world’s largest plant producing Apple iPhones. The workers demanded to be paid the wages and bonuses they had been promised, while opposing the abuse of the “closed-loop system” in which an ongoing COVID outbreak was allowed to spread within the factory and workers were prevented from leaving. The workers were universally masked and did not demand an end to Zero-COVID.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The sentiments expressed by these protesters matched those of the majority of respondents to a ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"https://chinadatalab.ucsd.edu/viz-blog/how-unpopular-is-covid-zero/"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"poll conducted at the time","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":", which found that 58.5 percent of the Chinese population supported “adjustments on specifics” of the Zero-COVID policy, but not its scrapping. When Zero-COVID was ended by the CCP, only 11.9 percent of the population supported “large-scale adjustment” to the policy.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Ignoring these sentiments, the pseudo-left and bourgeois press soon lumped together the working class protests at Foxconn with the middle class, anti-Zero-COVID protests that took place following the fire in Ürümqi. Within days of the latter protests in late November, the pseudo-left tendencies broke their silence, universally hailing these “white paper” protests, in which protesters held blank pieces of paper meant to symbolize state censorship by the CCP.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"media"},{"key":"link","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/0117e946-da0a-4ea5-8bfd-a00495f3c69a"},{"key":"caption","value":""},{"key":"usecaption","value":"false"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"0117e946-da0a-4ea5-8bfd-a00495f3c69a","copyright":{"license":"associated-press","author":"Ng Han Guan","authorLink":"","source":"","title":""},"created":1679604233,"title":"\"White paper\" protesters in Beijing, Sunday, Nov. 27, 2022.","type":"image","path":"/media/photos/2023/03/23/a14a57b1ecdee5900d99324636d2c4c8446408ec.jpg","pixelXDimension":8190,"pixelYDimension":4607}],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[]}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Many of the articles compared the “white paper” protests to the 1989 Tiananmen Square demonstrations, obscuring the class basis and orientation of these protests. The “white paper” protests involved no more than a few thousand youth whipped up in a right-wing, anti-public health frenzy. The Tiananmen Square protests united millions of workers, youth and peasants in rebellion against the pro-capitalist policies pursued by the CCP in the 1980s, and were motivated by socialist political convictions, including calls for the expansion of democratic rights.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"One of the first such articles on the “white paper” protests was a November 28 piece written by Alex Callinicos for","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" Socialist Worker","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":", the outlet of the Socialist Workers Party (UK), which is the leading section of the IST. Callinicos is the international secretary and main theoretician of the SWP.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"In his article, Callinicos presented the scrapping of Zero-COVID as inevitable, claiming that “genuine zero-Covid is impossible to achieve.” Justifying the government’s policy change, he wrote, “The discontent created by zero-Covid has reached a new level. On Wednesday last week workers at Foxconn’s giant assembly plant in Zhengzhou clashed with riot police... Then a fire in Urumqi, capital of Xinjiang province, killed ten people. The city has been in lockdown for three months, and zero-Covid was blamed for the deaths.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Socialist Worker","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" published another brief article on the same day by Yuri Prasad, a longtime SWP member, which praised the “white paper” protests even while acknowledging that “lifting all Covid restrictions immediately in China would lead to 5 million hospitalisations and 1.55 million deaths.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Also on November 28, the first extensive article on the situation in China appeared in ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Izquierda Diario","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":", the publication of the dishonestly named Trotskyist Fraction—Fourth International (FT), one of the main international Morenoite tendencies","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"reference"},{"key":"id","value":"1"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":". FT is most prevalent in Latin America, and particularly Argentina, where it leads the Frente de Izquierda y de los Trabajadores—Unidad, (FIT-U), which has four seats in the Chamber of Deputies.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The article, titled “China’s historic protests against Covid-zero open up new political situation,” was written by André Barbieri, a leader of the Brazilian section of FT, Movimento Revolucionário de Trabalhadores (MRT). Barbieri endorsed the protests, which he termed a “powerful show of popular anger” and “demonstrations in repudiation of the Covid-zero authoritarian confinements.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Barbieri continued, “The movement against the Covid-zero policy, the central pillar of the directive advocated by Xi Jinping at the 20th Congress in October, is unprecedented since the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989.” Creating an amalgam between the middle-class protests centered on the universities and the Foxconn protests, he wrote, “The strike by Foxconn workers in Zhengzhou... was the undeniable spark of popular anger that spread across China.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Throughout the past year in particular, the FT and ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Izquierda Diario","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" have been among the ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/3fe30a8a-f514-46dd-8c4f-d2d4217336a8"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"3fe30a8a-f514-46dd-8c4f-d2d4217336a8","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2022/04/14/spai-a14.html","title":"Spain Morenoite CRT denounce China’s “Zero COVID” strategy","overline":"","underline":"","description":"Throughout the pandemic the Morenoites have aligned themselves with the policy of the Socialist Party (PSOE)-Podemos government, putting profits ahead of lives.","authors":["Alice Summers"],"published":1649910189,"modified":1650178296,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1650178296,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":{"license":"","author":null,"authorLink":"","source":"","title":""},"created":1643601910,"id":"dccb7d44-6235-4dd9-898b-b145ad3b630a","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":1280,"pixelYDimension":719,"title":"A healthcare worker stands near a COVID-19 patient at the University Hospital of Torrejon in Torrejon de Ardoz, Spain, Tuesday, Oct. 6, 2020 [Credit: AP Photo/Manu Fernandez]"}],"topics":[{"id":"198c15b9-fdf8-4a0d-b49e-6154bb33b290"},{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f"},{"id":"83292efd-7c2f-4f87-8ce7-d61a7991b2ea"},{"id":"98406979-ff9a-4df4-9717-0316c2804c0a"},{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583"},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed"},{"id":"28cb2d89-f078-4ea8-9762-d2bd517b087c"}]}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"most vocal","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" pseudo-left tendencies ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/613e696a-8e0c-4782-ae77-3cf97f669669"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"613e696a-8e0c-4782-ae77-3cf97f669669","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2022/01/31/spai-j31.html","title":"Spanish Morenoites attack China’s “Zero COVID” strategy","overline":"","underline":"","description":"The Revolutionary Workers’ Current (CRT) is denouncing essential public health measures that allowed China to rapidly bring the pandemic under control.","authors":["Alice Summers"],"published":1643607276,"modified":1643639931,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1643639931,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":{"license":"","author":null,"authorLink":"","source":"","title":""},"created":1643601910,"id":"dccb7d44-6235-4dd9-898b-b145ad3b630a","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":1280,"pixelYDimension":719,"title":"A healthcare worker stands near a COVID-19 patient at the University Hospital of Torrejon in Torrejon de Ardoz, Spain, Tuesday, Oct. 6, 2020 [Credit: AP Photo/Manu Fernandez]"}],"topics":[{"id":"198c15b9-fdf8-4a0d-b49e-6154bb33b290"},{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f"},{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583"},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed"},{"id":"83292efd-7c2f-4f87-8ce7-d61a7991b2ea"},{"id":"98406979-ff9a-4df4-9717-0316c2804c0a"}]}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"denouncing China’s","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" Zero-COVID public health program.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"On December 2, the FT’s section in France, ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Révolution Permanente","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" (RP), published a separate piece on the protests in China by Irène Karalis, titled, “In China, deeply political protests open a crisis for the regime.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Denouncing lockdowns, mass testing and the isolation of infected patients, Karalis wrote incoherently, “Today, after a period when the pandemic was thought to have disappeared, the [Zero-COVID] restrictions continue to be in force [in China] to counter the wave caused by the Omicron variant and the inhabitants must be tested every two days.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Only someone completely detached from the experience of the international working class, in particular health care workers who continue to be inundated by recurring waves of COVID-19 patients, could write that “the pandemic was thought to have disappeared.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Karalis falsely claimed that the fire in Ürümqi “was a result of the health restrictions in place, including the closing of the building’s doors, which prevented the inhabitants from escaping.” Contradicting her previous claim that the pandemic was over, Karalis acknowledged that the lifting of Zero-COVID would result in mass death. She cited ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The Economist","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":", whose models indicated at the time that “infections would peak at 45 million a day. About 680,000 people would die, even if the vaccines remained strong and all these people received care.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"This outcome did not cause Karalis any qualms. “There is no guarantee, therefore, that the health situation is about to improve, quite the contrary. However, the health situation, in addition to affecting the political and social situation of the country, also affects the economic situation.” In this scenario, Karalis prioritized the “economic situation” over the mass infection and death of hundreds of thousands of people in China.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Significantly, Left Voice, the American section of FT, has not published a single statement on the lifting of Zero-COVID in China, simply reposting articles published in ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Izquierda Diario","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":".","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The other dominant Morenoite tendency, International Workers League—Fourth International (IWLfi), also endorsed the late November protests in China, publishing two articles on November 30, followed by four more in December.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The more extensive article published on November 30, “China experiences turbulent days of government defiance,” was written by Marcos Margarido. In 2016, Margarido ran for mayor of Campinas as a member of Partido Socialista dos Trabalhadores Unificado (PSTU), the largest Morenoite group in Brazil.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Margarido deepened the lies of Barbieri and Karalis, writing, “After nearly three years of restrictions, the experience of being quarantined at home with doors locked, or even welded shut, and building emergency exits blocked, is common for many Chinese across the country.” In the initial months of the pandemic, there were a handful of isolated instances in which people were locked in their homes during quarantines, but to say that this was ever “common” is a gross distortion.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Margarido went on to warn that “if the restrictions continue… the accumulated anger against the bureaucratic and dictatorial policy of combating COVID… may give rise to new and wider demonstrations.” After recognizing that lifting Zero-COVID would cause “a dizzying increase in cases,” as well as mass death dwarfing the horrors suffered under Jair Bolsonaro in Brazil, Margarido nevertheless supported this homicidal policy, with the cynical justification that “even the most entrenched dictatorship… cannot tame the cyclical crises of the capitalist system.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The only statement published by the Committee for a Workers International (CWI) on the lifting of Zero-COVID in China was published on November 29. Denouncing China’s “harsh ‘zero Covid’ policies” and “often brutal reliance on crude lockdowns,” they endorsed the anti-Zero-COVID protests, which they portrayed as “a slow-burning resentment against the still draconian lock-down rules that exploded at the weekend.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The International Socialist League (ISL) has issued no international statements on the lifting of Zero-COVID in China over the past four months. The only article published by a national affiliate of the ISL was a December 7 piece by Verónica O’Kelly of Alternativa Socialista-PSOL in Brazil. It began by praising the protests against Zero-COVID, which she characterized as “nothing more than extreme social control based on persecution and repression.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"After falsifying the character of the Foxconn and “blank paper” protests, O’Kelly wrote that Xi Jinping “was forced to give in and relax the measures of isolation and social distancing.” She concluded the piece by stating, “The revolutionaries of the world have the task of supporting and standing in solidarity with the brave Chinese people who are rising up. From LIS we are at the service of this important task.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Numerous similar articles advancing the same denunciations of Zero-COVID and falsifications of what transpired in China in November were published in virtually every outlet of the international pseudo-left.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"h4","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Socialist Alternative protests against Zero-COVID alongside “a conservative pro-capitalist organization”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The most unhinged and openly reactionary response to the lifting of Zero-COVID in China came from International Socialist Alternative (ISA)","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"reference"},{"key":"id","value":"2"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":". It enthusiastically welcomed a policy of mass death in China, publishing multiple articles and even staging demonstrations in support of the anti-lockdown protests in China.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The ISA’s first article was written by Vincent Kolo and Li Yong and published on November 29. Headlined, “China’s Mass Revolt – Where Now?,” it denounced Zero-COVID “insanity,” declaring, “After three years of suffocating and unspeakably brutal ‘Zero Covid’ controls and lockdowns, people have reached breaking point.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Kolo and Yong continued, “Demands for democratic rights and an end to dictatorship have combined with outrage against the dictatorship’s insanely unscientific insistence at any cost of killing off an unkillable virus.”","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"On November 30, Socialist Alternative member Mick Barry ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0RJPG0v62qA"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"gave a speech in the Irish Parliament","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" (Dáil Éireann), stating in part:","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"blockquote","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"I want to express my solidarity and the solidarity of International Socialist Alternative with the young protesters in China... They are demanding freedom of speech, an end to a rigid and extreme COVID policy and for democratic rights.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"On December 3, the Socialist Alternative branch in New York City issued the tweet below announcing a protest they were organizing the following day.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"tweet"},{"key":"tweet-id","value":"1599139288389939200"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"This tweet and protest were roundly denounced, with many commenting that it was clearly coordinated with the US State Department. Among those listed as a “Co-organizer” was “Students for a Free Tibet,” which is publicly listed as receiving nine grants from the National Endowment for Democracy (NED) since 2016, totaling $480,810. The NED is known as the “second CIA” due to its deep connections to the US intelligence agencies.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Despite widespread criticism of the tweet announcing the protest, Socialist Alternative leader Kshama Sawant nevertheless shared it with her followers, thereby encouraging them to attend. Since sharing this tweet, ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"https://twitter.com/search?q=(China%20OR%20COVID%20OR%20Zero-COVID)%20(from%3Acmkshama)%20until%3A2023-03-21%20since%3A2022-12-05\u0026src=typed_query\u0026f=top"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Sawant has kept silent","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" on the catastrophe that has unfolded in China and on the pandemic more broadly.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"On December 7, the ISA posted a report on their rally in New York City, as well as similar rallies they organized in London and Taipei, titled, “Protests (Mostly) Suppressed In China But Crucially, Continue Outside.” Author Elan Axelbank, a member of the ISA section in England, Wales and Scotland, wrote:","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"blockquote","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Our branch in New York City reports that many attendees had some degree of support for capitalism, as well as US and western imperialism. One of the sponsoring organizations was the Democratic Party of China, a conservative pro-capitalist organization of Chinese people living in the US but with no base inside China.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Axelbank acknowledged that lifting Zero-COVID would kill masses of people, yet doubled down on ISA’s support for this homicidal policy, writing:","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"blockquote","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"... it is entirely possible that China could be hit by a major wave of Covid deaths in the winter months like Hong Kong earlier this year. Scientists and Covid experts estimate if zero-Covid is lifted, between 1.5 and 2 million people could die across the country, and some say more.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"But in the new period opened up by the recent protests, full and long-lasting lockdowns like in Urumqi, lasting over 100 days, will be more and more difficult for the state to enforce... This is why the China/Hong Kong/Taiwan section of International Socialist Alternative has called for, beyond just ending zero-Covid, massive resources to build up and equip the healthcare system, stepping up the vaccination program, especially among the elderly, and immediately ending the ban on foreign mRNA vaccines.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"The ISA’s call for the CCP to expand health care and purchase mRNA vaccines, a line advanced by the entire Western media and many other pseudo-left tendencies, was an attempt to provide cover for their promotion of the ending of Zero-COVID. But the rapidity with which mass infections and deaths ripped through China was both foreseeable and foreseen, and the implementation of these limited demands would have done nothing to prevent this catastrophe.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"em","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"To be continued.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"footnotes"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"footnote"},{"key":"id","value":"1"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"FT was founded in 1998 after a series of splits following the death of the Argentine Pabloite Nahuel Moreno in 1987. Moreno oversaw ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/50b3529a-76a0-4fc2-a8b7-153b52aa6833"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"50b3529a-76a0-4fc2-a8b7-153b52aa6833","type":"libraryItem","path":"/en/special/library/fi-14-2/02.html","title":"No to Stalinism and the Popular Front! Build the Fourth International!"}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"decades of national opportunist policies","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":" by various parties in Argentina and their international affiliates, and his successors have carried this mantle forward.","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"footnote"},{"key":"id","value":"2"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"ISA was formed in February 2020 as the result of a split from CWI centered on identity politics. Its most prominent national section is in the United States, whose member Kshama Sawant has been on the Seattle City Council since 2014. In the winter of 2020-21, Socialist Alternative sent a significant section of its membership, ","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null},{"type":"element","tagName":"a","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"href","value":"workspace://SpacesStore/8affee0a-d6e5-4a4d-92fe-275f6db2128a"}],"data":[],"assets":[{"id":"8affee0a-d6e5-4a4d-92fe-275f6db2128a","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2021/03/02/salt-m02.html","title":"Socialist Alternative’s Kshama Sawant joins the DSA: The Democratic Party politics of the pseudo-left","overline":"","underline":"","description":"Socialist Alternative’s efforts to forge a closer alliance with the DSA is aimed at creating a new political trap and blocking the development of a genuine socialist movement of the working class.","authors":["Kayla Costa","Joseph Kishore"],"published":1614660344,"modified":1614725464,"liveUpdates":null,"showUpdated":null,"lastUpdated":1614725464,"featuredImages":[{"copyright":null,"created":1614654470,"id":"eef1dfb4-fc31-4fb4-b8d5-6dfe977da259","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":2000,"pixelYDimension":1125,"title":"City council member Kshama Sawant speaking in 2016. (Image credit: Flickr/Seattle City Council)"}],"topics":[{"id":"198c15b9-fdf8-4a0d-b49e-6154bb33b290"},{"id":"3f1db5b4-7915-4cef-a132-3b2e51f0728d"},{"id":"ea69254c-a976-4e67-a79c-843202a10e55"},{"id":"b0e983c5-6e85-4829-a9fe-3c25f02c211f"}]}],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"including Sawant","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":", into the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), which operates directly within the imperialist Democratic Party","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]}]}]}],"contentAssets":[{"id":"c6f6f484-b8bd-4808-86b8-ef95a9f42406","copyright":{"author":"Alex Brandon","authorLink":"","license":"associated-press","source":"","title":""},"created":1637548520,"imageDirectionHorizontal":"","path":"/media/photos/2021/11/22/b629286dfc4915d0a0598f6ff18863e973a33b00.jpg","pixelXDimension":2048,"pixelYDimension":1365,"title":"Then-President Donald Trump watches as White House coronavirus adviser and \"herd immunity\" promoter Dr. Scott Atlas speaks during a September 2020 news conference on the pandemic.","type":"image"},{"id":"f7050a62-f2b7-479c-9f6e-eac655146dbb","copyright":{"author":"Sam McNeil, File","authorLink":"","license":"associated-press","source":"","title":""},"created":1679608031,"imageDirectionHorizontal":"","path":"/media/photos/2023/03/23/7f3d846f2833a598da7b3c5542304a201add11a2.jpg","pixelXDimension":3600,"pixelYDimension":2025,"title":"In this April 15, 2020, file photo, government workers stand outside a blue tent used to coordinate transportation of travelers from Wuhan to designated quarantine sites in Beijing. ","type":"image"},{"id":"0117e946-da0a-4ea5-8bfd-a00495f3c69a","copyright":{"author":"Ng Han Guan","authorLink":"","license":"associated-press","source":"","title":""},"created":1679604233,"imageDirectionHorizontal":"","path":"/media/photos/2023/03/23/a14a57b1ecdee5900d99324636d2c4c8446408ec.jpg","pixelXDimension":8190,"pixelYDimension":4607,"title":"\"White paper\" protesters in Beijing, Sunday, Nov. 27, 2022.","type":"image"}],"relatedAssets":[{"id":"ee2196b6-7dd1-4864-8b96-da72b5f25029","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2022/12/20/pers-d20.html","title":"Who is responsible for China’s COVID catastrophe?","authors":["Evan Blake"],"published":1671514584,"description":"A tragedy of monumental proportions is unfolding across China as a result of the Chinese Communist Party lifting its Zero-COVID policy and embracing the “forever COVID” policy demanded by the US and European imperialist powers.","featuredImages":[{"id":"5da59dae-00e7-4a59-b53c-424b8667e021","pixelXDimension":6000,"pixelYDimension":3375,"imageDirectionHorizontal":""}]},{"id":"66dd3dbb-f0e8-4882-882b-b5f3501bd324","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2021/12/13/chin-d13.html","title":"The misunderstood—and misrepresented—Zero COVID policy in China","authors":["a scientist"],"published":1639374357,"description":"One of the most striking facts about the pandemic is that China, the country from which SARS-CoV-2 first emerged, has suffered very few cases. This article is a detailed look at China’s Zero COVID policy.","featuredImages":[{"id":"9cd03bc9-8074-4fca-9f09-5bdbaa797b76","pixelXDimension":1280,"pixelYDimension":720,"imageDirectionHorizontal":""}]},{"id":"f979ccc4-7bfd-41ba-883f-490c670191a4","type":"article","path":"/en/articles/2022/10/15/edfd-o15.html","title":"The historical background of the COVID-19 pandemic and the fight for global elimination","authors":["Evan Blake"],"published":1665802511,"description":"This report was given by Evan Blake to the Seventh Congress of the Socialist Equality Party (US) in support of the resolution titled “The COVID-19 pandemic and the fight for socialism” ","featuredImages":[{"id":"fe1b35b6-13b4-44a2-bd9c-caae6286ba82","pixelXDimension":3840,"pixelYDimension":2160,"imageDirectionHorizontal":""}]}],"featuredImages":[{"copyright":{"author":"Ng Han Guan","authorLink":"","license":"associated-press","source":"","title":""},"id":"0117e946-da0a-4ea5-8bfd-a00495f3c69a","imageDirectionHorizontal":"","pixelXDimension":8190,"pixelYDimension":4607,"title":"\"White paper\" protesters in Beijing, Sunday, Nov. 27, 2022."}],"socialTitles":[],"socialDescriptions":[],"socialFeaturedImages":[],"topics":[{"id":"1fdd1b45-9245-400f-8c01-1aae9d8db379","name":"global-workers-inquest-coronavirus-pandemic","path":"/topics/campaigns/global-workers-inquest-coronavirus-pandemic","title":"The Global Workers' Inquest into the COVID-19 Pandemic","description":"","hidden":null},{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f","name":"coronavirus","path":"/topics/event/coronavirus","title":"The coronavirus pandemic","description":"The WSWS is fighting to build a global movement of the working class to end the COVID-19 pandemic and save millions of lives. Read our coverage and get involved today.","hidden":false},{"id":"198c15b9-fdf8-4a0d-b49e-6154bb33b290","name":"pseudoleft","path":"/topics/internationalPoliticsCategory/pseudoleft","title":"The Politics of the Pseudo-Left","description":"","hidden":false},{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583","name":"as-china","path":"/topics/country/as-china","title":"China","description":"","hidden":false},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed","name":"asia","path":"/topics/continent/asia","title":"Asia and the Pacific","description":"","hidden":false}],"collections":[],"campaignAds":[null,null,{"id":"6f0eb50b-7848-4d2c-addd-c67d87323e9d","name":"6f0eb50b-7848-4d2c-addd-c67d87323e9d","position":"bottom","content":"\u003cplaceholder type=\"page-article-inline-mautic-form\" design=\"\" description=\"false\" heading=\"true\"\u003e\u003cplaceholder type=\"text-line\"\u003eI want to participate in the work of the Global Workers’ Inquest\u003c/placeholder\u003e\u003cplaceholder type=\"text-block\"\u003e\u003cp\u003eSome content\u003c/p\u003e\u003c/placeholder\u003e\u003cplaceholder type=\"mautic-form\" form-id=\"229\" html-id=\"\"\u003e\u003c/placeholder\u003e\u003c/placeholder\u003e","contentData":[{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"page-article-inline-mautic-form"},{"key":"design","value":""},{"key":"description","value":"false"},{"key":"heading","value":"true"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"text-line"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"I want to participate in the work of the Global Workers’ Inquest","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"text-block"}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"element","tagName":"p","content":null,"attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[{"type":"text","tagName":null,"content":"Some content","attributes":[],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":null}]}]},{"type":"element","tagName":"placeholder","content":null,"attributes":[{"key":"type","value":"mautic-form"},{"key":"form-id","value":"229"},{"key":"html-id","value":""}],"data":[],"assets":[],"children":[]}]}]}],"bookAds":[{"id":"bookad-default","name":"default","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-why-study-the-russian-revolution-vol-i-\u0026-vol-ii","name":"Why Study the Russian Revolution Vol I \u0026 Vol II","author":"the ICFI","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/wstrr_v1and2_front_cover_1.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/why-study-the-russian-revolution-vol-i-vol-ii-2/"}]},{"id":"bookad-arts","name":"arts","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-the-truth-behind-the-bankruptcy-of-detroit","name":"The Truth Behind the Bankruptcy of Detroit","author":"the Socialist Equality Party","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/truthdetroitfcover_300.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/the-truth-behind-the-bankruptcy-of-detroit/"}]},{"id":"bookad-correspo","name":"correspo","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-the-historical-\u0026amp;-international-foundations-of-the-partei-fur-soziale-gleichheit","name":"The Historical \u0026amp; International Foundations of the Partei fur Soziale Gleichheit","author":"the Socialist Equality Party","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/his_found_psg_300.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/the-historical-international-foundations-of-the-partei-fur-soziale-gleichheit/"}]},{"id":"bookad-editorials","name":"editorials","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-castroism-and-the-politics-of-petty-bourgeois-nationalism","name":"Castroism and the Politics of Petty-Bourgeois Nationalism","author":"Bill Vann","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/castroism-new300.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/castroism-and-the-politics-of-petty-bourgeois-nationalism/"},{"id":"bookaditem-in-defense-of-leon-trotsky-(second-edition)","name":"In Defense of Leon Trotsky (second edition)","author":"David North","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/idlt_300_5.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/in-defense-of-leon-trotsky-second-edition/"}]},{"id":"bookad-history","name":"history","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-the-frankfurt-school,-postmodernism-and-the-politics-of-the-pseudo-left:-a-marxist-critique","name":"The Frankfurt School, Postmodernism and the Politics of the Pseudo-Left: A Marxist Critique","author":"David North","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/frankfurt-school_300.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/the-frankfurt-school-postmodernism-and-the-politics-of-the-pseudo-left-a-marxist-critique/"}]},{"id":"bookad-ic-archive","name":"ic-archive","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-the-heritage-we-defend:-a-contribution-to-the-history-of-the-fourth-international","name":"The Heritage We Defend: A Contribution to the History of the Fourth International","author":"David North","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/heritage_2018.jpeg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/the-heritage-we-defend-30th-anniv-edition-a-contribution-to-the-history-of-the-fourth-international/"}]},{"id":"bookad-news","name":"news","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-the-tragedy-of-the-chinese-revolution","name":"The Tragedy of the Chinese Revolution","author":"Harold Isaacs","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/tragedy_chinese_rev_300.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/the-tragedy-of-the-chinese-revolution/"}]},{"id":"bookad-perspectives","name":"perspectives","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-a-quarter-century-of-war:-the-us-drive-for-global-hegemony-1990---2016","name":"A Quarter Century of War: The US Drive for Global Hegemony 1990 - 2016","author":"David North","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/qcw-cover_300_3.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/a-quarter-century-of-war-the-us-drive-for-global-hegemony-1990-2016/"}]},{"id":"bookad-philos","name":"philos","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-fundamental-problems-of-marxism","name":"Fundamental Problems of Marxism","author":"George V. Plekhanov","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/fundamental_prob_300_1.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/fundamental-problems-of-marxism/"}]},{"id":"bookad-science","name":"science","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-the-origin-of-the-family,-private-property-and-the-state","name":"The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State","author":"Frederick Engels","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/origin_of_the_family_300.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/the-origin-of-the-family-private-property-and-the-state/"}]},{"id":"bookad-workers","name":"workers","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-thirty-years-since-the-patco-strike","name":"Thirty Years Since the PATCO Strike","author":"Tom Mackaman","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/patco_300.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/thirty-years-since-the-patco-strike/"}]},{"id":"bookad-world","name":"world","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-the-historical-\u0026-international-foundations-of-the-sep,-sri-lanka","name":"The Historical \u0026 International Foundations of the SEP, Sri Lanka","author":"the Socialist Equality Party (Sri Lanka)","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/sri_lankan_perspectives_300.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/the-historical-international-foundations-of-the-socialist-equality-party-sri-lanka/"}]},{"id":"bookad-slsep","name":"slsep","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-the-historical-\u0026-international-foundations-of-the-sep,-sri-lanka","name":"The Historical \u0026 International Foundations of the SEP, Sri Lanka","author":"the Socialist Equality Party (Sri Lanka)","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/sri_lankan_perspectives_300.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/the-historical-international-foundations-of-the-socialist-equality-party-sri-lanka/"}]},{"id":"bookad-h-icfi","name":"h-icfi","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-the-gelfand-case","name":"The Gelfand Case","author":"Alan Gelfand","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/gelfand_1_300.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/the-gelfand-case-a-legal-history-of-the-exposure-of-us-government-agents-in-the-leadership-of-the-socialist-workers-party-vol-1/"}]},{"id":"bookad-mehring","name":"mehring","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-the-frankfurt-school,-postmodernism-and-the-politics-of-the-pseudo-left:-a-marxist-critique","name":"The Frankfurt School, Postmodernism and the Politics of the Pseudo-Left: A Marxist Critique","author":"David North","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/frankfurt-school_300.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/the-frankfurt-school-postmodernism-and-the-politics-of-the-pseudo-left-a-marxist-critique/"}]},{"id":"bookad-eu-right","name":"eu-right","items":[{"id":"bookaditem-why-are-they-back?-historical-falsification,-political-conspiracy,-and-the-return-of-fascism-in-germany","name":"Why Are They Back? Historical Falsification, Political Conspiracy, and the Return of Fascism in Germany","author":"Christoph Vandreier","image_url":"https://mehring.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/why_are_they_back300ppi.jpg","url":"https://mehring.com/product/why-are-they-back-historical-falsification-political-conspiracy-and-the-return-of-fascism-in-germany/"}]}],"legacyId":"4a897772-8dd7-4e59-a75e-c40c21d3329H","visibleTopics":[{"id":"1fdd1b45-9245-400f-8c01-1aae9d8db379","name":"global-workers-inquest-coronavirus-pandemic","path":"/topics/campaigns/global-workers-inquest-coronavirus-pandemic","title":"The Global Workers' Inquest into the COVID-19 Pandemic","description":"","hidden":null},{"id":"04d2a008-8cef-4928-9a38-86b205a7590f","name":"coronavirus","path":"/topics/event/coronavirus","title":"The coronavirus pandemic","description":"The WSWS is fighting to build a global movement of the working class to end the COVID-19 pandemic and save millions of lives. Read our coverage and get involved today.","hidden":false},{"id":"198c15b9-fdf8-4a0d-b49e-6154bb33b290","name":"pseudoleft","path":"/topics/internationalPoliticsCategory/pseudoleft","title":"The Politics of the Pseudo-Left","description":"","hidden":false},{"id":"9f392474-ffbe-41b6-96d1-494ff347d583","name":"as-china","path":"/topics/country/as-china","title":"China","description":"","hidden":false},{"id":"7b67caf8-9ef0-4069-b2d9-af2d885233ed","name":"asia","path":"/topics/continent/asia","title":"Asia and the Pacific","description":"","hidden":false}],"collection":{"collectionType":null,"collectionAttributes":[],"asset":{},"attributes":{}}},"navs":[{"name":"topnav","items":[{"name":null,"title":"Perspectives","path":"/topics/site_area/perspectives","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"World","path":"/topics/region/namerica","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Global class struggle","path":"/topics/site_area/workers","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Pandemic","path":"/topics/event/coronavirus","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Arts \u0026 Culture","path":"/topics/site_area/arts","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"History","path":"/topics/site_area/history","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Capitalism \u0026 Inequality","path":"/topics/socialIssuesCategory/ineq-us","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Anti-Imperialism","path":"/topics/militarismCategory/us-milit","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Videos","path":"/en/topics/site_area/videos","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Podcast","path":"/en/special/podcast","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Marxist Library","path":"/en/special/pages/library.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":"sep","title":"Socialist Equality Party","path":"/en/special/pages/sep/us/home.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"}]},{"name":"sepnav","items":[{"name":"sep","title":"Socialist Equality Party","path":"/en/special/pages/sep/us/home.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":"icfi","title":"International Committee of the Fourth International","path":"/en/special/pages/icfi/about.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":"history","title":"History of the Fourth International","path":"/en/special/pages/icfi/history.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":"wsws","title":"About the WSWS","path":"/en/special/pages/icfi/wsws.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":"iysse","title":"International Youth and Students for Social Equality","path":"/en/special/pages/iysse/about.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"}]},{"name":"oldhotnav","items":[{"name":null,"title":"2020 US elections","path":"/topics/internationalPoliticsCategory/govt-us","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Coronavirus pandemic","path":"/topics/event/coronavirus","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"SEP (US) presidential campaign","path":"/en/special/pages/sep/us/elections.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Free Julian Assange!","path":"/en/topics/mediaCategory/free-assange","items":[],"classes":"dib"}]},{"name":"metanav","items":[{"name":"home","title":"Home","path":"/","items":null,"classes":null},{"name":"search","title":"Search","path":"/updates","items":null,"classes":null},{"name":"clock","title":"Updates","path":"/updates","items":null,"classes":null},{"name":"user","title":"Profile","path":"/profile","items":null,"classes":null}]},{"name":"mainnav","items":[{"name":null,"title":"News \u0026 Analysis","path":"/","items":[{"name":null,"title":"Politics","path":"/topics/site_area/politics","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Perspective","path":"/topics/site_area/perspectives","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Workers Struggles","path":"/topics/site_area/workers","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Arts \u0026 Culture","path":"/topics/site_area/arts","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"History","path":"/topics/site_area/history","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Economy","path":"/topics/site_area/world","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Science","path":"/topics/site_area/science","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Philosophy","path":"/topics/site_area/philos","classes":null}],"classes":"dib dn-m"},{"name":null,"title":"Perspectives","path":"/topics/site_area/perspectives","items":[{"name":null,"title":"Socialist strategy","path":"/topics/_beta/socialist-strategy","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Perspectives","path":"/topics/site_area/perspectives","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"The politics of the pseudo-left","path":"/topics/internationalPoliticsCategory/pseudoleft","classes":null}],"classes":"dn dib-m"},{"name":null,"title":"World News","path":"/topics/site_area/news","items":[{"name":null,"title":"Socialist strategy","path":"/topics/_beta/socialist-strategy","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Inequality and the social crisis","path":"/topics/_beta/international-class-struggle","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"War and geopolitical conflict","path":"/topics/_beta/international-class-struggle","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"The Fight Against Fascism","path":"/topics/internationalPoliticsCategory/fight-against-fascism","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Immigrants and refugees","path":"/topics/economyCategory/eco-refu","classes":null}],"classes":"dn dib-xl"},{"name":null,"title":"Workers Struggles","path":"/topics/site_area/workers","items":[{"name":null,"title":"The Matamoros workers rebellion","path":"/topics/workersCategory/matamoros","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Los Angeles teachers strike","path":"/topics/workersCategory/la-teachers","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"The “Yellow Vest” protests in France","path":"/topics/newsCategory/yellow-vest-protests","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"The fight against the GM plant closures","path":"/topics/workersCategory/gm-closures","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"The Struggle at UPS","path":"/topics/workersCategory/us-UPS","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Autoworkers struggles","path":"/topics/workersCategory/na-auto","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Education in the US","path":"/topics/educationCategory/Education-US","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Amazon","path":"/topics/workersCategory/amazon","classes":null}],"classes":"dn dib-m"},{"name":null,"title":"Arts \u0026 Culture","path":"/topics/site_area/arts","items":[{"name":null,"title":"Film Reviews","path":"/topics/artsCategory/films","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Film Festivals","path":"/topics/artsCategory/ffests","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Interviews with Directors and Artists","path":"/topics/artsCategory/intviews","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Book Reviews","path":"/topics/artsCategory/book","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Art \u0026amp; Photographic Exhibitions","path":"/topics/artsCategory/exhibits","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Music Reviews","path":"/topics/artsCategory/music","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Theater and Dance","path":"/topics/artsCategory/theatre","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Art \u0026amp; Socialism – Lectures \u0026amp; Essays","path":"/topics/artsCategory/essays","classes":null}],"classes":"dn dib-l"},{"name":null,"title":"History","path":"/topics/site_area/history","items":[{"name":null,"title":"The 1917 Russian Revolution","path":"/topics/_beta/1917-russian-revolution/","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"History of the Fourth International","path":"/topics/historyCategory/h-icfi/","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Leon Trotsky","path":"/topics/historyCategory/h-trotsky/h","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Fascism \u0026amp; the Holocaust","path":"/topics/historyCategory/h-fascm","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"US History","path":"/topics/historySubCategory/h-uslab","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"The American Revolution","path":"/topics/historyCategory/American_Revolution/","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"1998 Lectures: Marxism and the Fundamental Problems of the 20th Century","path":"/topics/historyCategory/iss-98","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"2005 Lectures: Marxism and the Foundation of the Fourth International","path":"/topics/icfiCategory/h-ss2005/","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"This Week in History","path":"/topics/historyCategory/twih","classes":null}],"classes":"dn dib-l"},{"name":null,"title":"Economy","path":"/topics/site_area/world","items":[{"name":null,"title":"World Economy","path":"/topics/site_area/world/","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"European Economy","path":"/topics/economyCategory/European_Economy","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"US Economy","path":"/topics/economyCategory/econ-us","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Marxist political economy","path":"/topics/economyCategory/marxist-political-economy","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Questions and replies on Marxist economics","path":"/topics/lettersCategory/eco-corr","classes":null}],"classes":"dn"},{"name":null,"title":"Science","path":"/topics/site_area/science","items":[{"name":null,"title":"Human Genetics \u0026amp; Evolution","path":"/topics/scienceCategory/sc-evol","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"The Internet","path":"/topics/scienceCategory/sc-net","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Space Research \u0026amp; Astronomy","path":"/topics/scienceCategory/sc-astro","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Climate Change","path":"/topics/scienceCategory/sc-clim","classes":null}],"classes":"dn"},{"name":null,"title":"Philosophy","path":"/topics/site_area/philos","items":[{"name":null,"title":"The Enlightenment","path":"/topics/philosophyCategory/enlightment","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Existentialism and Post-modernism","path":"/topics/philosophyCategory/exist","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Religion","path":"/topics/philosophyCategory/eco-reli","classes":null}],"classes":"dn"},{"name":null,"title":"more...","path":"","items":[{"name":null,"title":"Politics","path":"/topics/site_area/news","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Arts \u0026 Culture","path":"/topics/site_area/arts","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Economy","path":"/topics/site_area/world","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Science","path":"/topics/site_area/science","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"History","path":"/topics/site_area/history","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Philosophy","path":"/topics/site_area/philos","classes":null}],"classes":"dn dib-m dn-l"},{"name":null,"title":"more...","path":"","items":[{"name":null,"title":"Politics","path":"/topics/site_area/news","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Economy","path":"/topics/site_area/world","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Science","path":"/topics/site_area/science","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Philosophy","path":"/topics/site_area/philos","classes":null}],"classes":"dn dib-l dn-xl"},{"name":null,"title":"more...","path":"","items":[{"name":null,"title":"Economy","path":"/topics/site_area/world","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Science","path":"/topics/site_area/science","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Philosophy","path":"/topics/site_area/philos","classes":null}],"classes":"dn dib-xl"}]},{"name":"hotnav","items":[{"name":null,"title":"Fourth International","path":"/en/special/pages/icfi/about.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Socialist Equality Party","path":"/en/special/pages/sep","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"IYSSE","path":"/en/special/pages/iysse/about.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"About the WSWS","path":"/en/special/pages/icfi/wsws.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Contact","path":"/en/special/pages/contact.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"},{"name":null,"title":"Donate","path":"/en/special/pages/donate.html","items":[],"classes":"dib"}]},{"name":"fullnav","items":[{"name":null,"title":"News \u0026 Commentary","path":null,"items":[{"name":null,"title":"Perspective","path":"/en/topics/site_area/perspectives","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"World","path":"/en/topics/region/namerica","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Global Class Struggle","path":"/en/topics/site_area/workers","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Pandemic","path":"/en/topics/event/coronavirus","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Arts \u0026 Culture","path":"/en/topics/site_area/arts","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"History","path":"/en/topics/site_area/history","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Capitalism \u0026 Inequality","path":"/en/topics/socialIssuesCategory/ineq-us","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Anti-Imperialism","path":"/en/topics/militarismCategory/us-milit","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Science","path":"/en/topics/site_area/science","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Browse articles by country","path":"/en/topics/countries","classes":null}],"classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Fourth International","path":null,"items":[{"name":null,"title":"International Committee of the Fourth International","path":"/en/special/pages/icfi/about.html","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"History of the Fourth International","path":"/en/special/pages/icfi/history.html","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Socialist Equality Party","path":"/en/special/pages/sep","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"About the WSWS","path":"/en/special/pages/icfi/wsws.html","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"WSWS Chronology","path":"/en/special/pages/chronology.html","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"International Youth and Students for Social Equality","path":"/en/special/pages/iysse/about.html","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Contact","path":"/en/special/pages/contact.html","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Donate","path":"/en/special/pages/donate.html","classes":null}],"classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Marxist Library","path":null,"items":[{"name":null,"title":"Browse online","path":"/en/special/pages/library.html","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Mehring Books","path":"https://www.mehring.com/","classes":null}],"classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"","path":null,"items":[{"name":null,"title":"Monthly archive","path":"/en/archive/recent","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"Newsletter","path":"/en/special/pages/newsletter.html","classes":null},{"name":null,"title":"RSS Feeds","path":"/en/special/rssfeeds.html","classes":null}],"classes":null}]}]},"messages":{"website.title":"World Socialist Web Site","website.description":"Published by the International Committee of the Fourth International (ICFI)","website.tagline":"Marxist analysis, international working class struggles \u0026 the fight for socialism","website.publisher.long":"International Committee of the Fourth International","website.publisher.short":"ICFI","website.party.long":"Socialist Equality Party","website.party.short":"SEP","website.party.logo":"/img/sep-logo.png","website.iysse.long":"International Youth and Students for Social Equality","website.iysse.short":"IYSSE","website.dateLong":"D MMMM YYYY","website.dateLongTime":"D MMMM YYYY, h:mm A","website.dateShort":"DD/MM/YYYY","website.dateMonthYear":"MMMM YYYY","website.dateYearOnly":"YYYY","website.timezoneOffset":"-5","dates.months.long01":"January","dates.months.long02":"February","dates.months.long03":"March","dates.months.long04":"April","dates.months.long05":"May","dates.months.long06":"June","dates.months.long07":"July","dates.months.long08":"August","dates.months.long09":"September","dates.months.long10":"October","dates.months.long11":"November","dates.months.long12":"December","dates.months.short01":"Jan","dates.months.short02":"Feb","dates.months.short03":"Mar","dates.months.short04":"Apr","dates.months.short05":"May","dates.months.short06":"Jun","dates.months.short07":"Jul","dates.months.short08":"Aug","dates.months.short09":"Sep","dates.months.short10":"Oct","dates.months.short11":"Nov","dates.months.short12":"Dec","languages.en":"English","languages.it":"Italian","languages.de":"German","languages.fr":"French","languages.es":"Spanish","languages.ta":"Tamil","languages.si":"Sinhala","languages.ru":"Russian","languages.pt":"Portuguese","shared.show":"show","shared.hide":"hide","header.menu":"Menu","header.search":"Search","header.feed":"News Feed","navigation.partyShort":"SEP","navigation.partyLong":"Socialist Equality Party","navigation.partyPath":"/en/special/pages/sep","navigation.menu":"Menu","navigation.language":"Language","navigation.home":"Home","navigation.profile":"Profile","navigation.latest":"Latest","navigation.videos":"Videos","navigation.library":"Marxist Library","navigation.search":"Search","navigation.about":"About","navigation.contact":"Contact","navigation.donate":"Donate","navigation.imprint":"Imprint","navigation.privacyStatement":"Privacy Statement","navigation.privacySettings":"Privacy Settings","frontpage.topStories":"Top Stories","frontpage.mostRecent":"Most recent","frontpage.fullArchive":"All latest news","frontpage.otherLanguages":"Other languages","frontpage.trendingTopics":"Trending topics","frontpage.party":"Socialist Equality Party","frontpage.international":"Fourth International","frontpage.more":"More from the SEP and ICFI","perspective.title":"Perspective","perspective.more":"Ealier Perspectives","perspectivebox.title":"Perspective","index.perspective":"Perspective","index.commentary":"Commentary","index.mostrecent":"Most recent","index.mostread":"Most read","index.mostcommented":"Most commented","index.newin":"Other languages","article.relatedTopics":"Find out more about these topics:","article.furtherReading":"Read more","article.viewComments":"View {0} comments","article.contact":"Contact us","article.comments.zeroComments":"Comment","article.comments.oneComment":"View {num} comments","article.originalTranslation":"Article originally published in {0} on {1}","article.parts.part1":"Part 1","article.parts.part2":"Part 2","article.parts.part3":"Part 3","article.parts.part4":"Part 4","article.parts.part5":"Part 5","article.parts.part6":"Part 6","article.parts.part7":"Part 7","article.parts.part8":"Part 8","article.parts.part9":"Part 9","archive.title":"Archive","archive.description":"The archive lists all articles that have been posted on the \u003cem\u003eWorld Socialist Web Site\u003c/em\u003e by date.","archive.latest":"Latest articles","archive.monthly":"Browse by month:","archive.year":"year","archive.month":"month","archive.selectYear":"Select year","archive.selectMonth":"Select month","book.buyLogo":"/img/mehring-logo.png","book.buyText":"This book is available for purchase from Mehring Books. Get your copy today.","book.buyButton":"Purchase from Mehring Books","book.buyNow":"Buy now","profile.title":"My profile","profile.bookmarks.title":"My reading list","profile.bookmarks.description":"All our articles you've \u003cstrong\u003ebookmarked\u003c/strong\u003e in this browser will automatically appear here.","profile.history.title":"My reading history","profile.history.description":"All our articles you've \u003cstrong\u003evisited\u003c/strong\u003e in this browser will automatically appear here.","topics.title":"All topics","topics.latest":"Latest articles","topics.search.placeholder":"Search term","topics.search.moreOptions":"More options","topics.search.lessOptions":"Less options","topics.search.moreResults":"Show more","topics.search.resultStats":"Found {0} results","topics.search.noResults":"No articles found","topics.search.labels.title":"Title","topics.search.labels.description":"Description","topics.search.labels.author":"Author","topics.search.labels.date":"Date","topics.search.labels.type":"Type","topics.search.labels.country":"Country","topics.search.labels.perspectives":"Perspectives","topics.search.labels.statements":"Statements","topics.search.labels.videos":"Videos","topics.browseByCountry":"Browse articles by country","tools.followus":"Follow us","tools.share":"Share","tools.tools":"Tools","tools.updates":"Latest updates","tools.languages.intro":"The \u003cem\u003eWorld Socialist Web Site\u003c/em\u003e is available in\u003cbr /\u003e20 different languages. Select your prefered language from the list below.","sepweb.getInvolved":"Get involved","sepweb.donate":"Donate","sepweb.donateHash":"donate","sepweb.updates":"Get updates","sepweb.updatesHash":"newsletter","sepweb.volunteer":"Volunteer","sepweb.volunteerHash":"get-involved","sepweb.next":"Next"}},"__N_SSP":true},"page":"/[locale]/articles/[...path]","query":{"locale":"en","path":["2023","03","23","ljwc-m23.html"]},"buildId":"bba5cf3e","isFallback":false,"gssp":true,"scriptLoader":[]}</script></body></html>