CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.science.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e9515e07c2bce61',cH: 'UTL2RsrY5bIFHu5ag_aXaDcWQ1Oi1GUOSqjgVEWwSv8-1732741621-1.2.1.1-aENRdT3NRo2uLhk.2.j.lvGGohyYXuQiAIfJFz8GKp5yybuBoyqax5zA4hVRXpT7',cUPMDTk: "\/doi\/10.1126\/science.1187145?__cf_chl_tk=tcxejfkjJisrw1WBoFnLDOX.EROLChud8UqBOfvA_qs-1732741621-1.0.1.1-Yty3d2zCtmxCOR5UVfauq.VqiSRflsbJSQRh78yEl70",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1732741621',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/doi\/10.1126\/science.1187145?__cf_chl_f_tk=tcxejfkjJisrw1WBoFnLDOX.EROLChud8UqBOfvA_qs-1732741621-1.0.1.1-Yty3d2zCtmxCOR5UVfauq.VqiSRflsbJSQRh78yEl70",md: "j19ba7o.lupwK.cKB_mn9pBTGQEPJQYH6W83AlTP8tg-1732741621-1.2.1.1-AW_CnWn.rT5tzYlXiptdsJ1ed7M7rpqp_8BXYfxbHXoOUDdqEp_w4r.pkXlqMTYGud879HHgyZt7FqpLAC1vwjIxaGpyc4qcoY4_9JImZTzRLNuIcxZF51nOZhn.WwkHmSc8qqIrhA1ybCx6Q4G3qOI0IFBoKeNdvbQM98c9Lmde4EImxmWJPaaxCoMmVToHCHpmIfQbIyqMrjSdvlNy2cDg1U629o8gM8ik5uzJd0pUkmMCzb3PKWVFS1kvjXXgnvrPMoRFGl0Ia72eLYXkQPk9taQc25VzlmnRDnHENXxnjIldmIOuusOCpGBO7pM_NNuIYACJH3yvaRk7L0wpaVlpOH5sjjZwp9kPrOgEtJ13IorrcnSdvaG2HbMmlT37utVUY3suQrhSW98mZGzutLRu.axqaNKdwtJThsQA7YujfjZjRlrQ9nsKJqzW.XCokiglmOczgKk8GPObveudanhiPcyZ.i9F8f24QwBYXVP.UX5kBaqxy3k8aDheU33TPEWcz6DW12cb9wvZsemRxV5ooZ2MNGxbJIOq9nq52k7SjmjztjJS8ChPZIUOGa5nU19n0pGWqoVPYcnQiOPuRRzHEjIFDd2ekS5DbvL4UFMuVTgyfZTnwyIaeLWA4cM6MwGGCZCMFV1g2x9L56lZZ4xB4GJp1cjk.96vXGJX8aeqPQmi8.IfIaAntDNR6YOzxja9x6lkH19CM4J0Y5SRh.Mnattw_AqlOgIY8B60_0jZzmeb1P.8mcYRoFayz8ng314WqrBSJNCmwMsQf_zkMBdt9_6fa6QRblr9nRdsPtqmWI9PNYrd.DgH4.I_MLOuFXvy.8.mPiaYIYLYVlHR0ZaZr38WwEcmEccFbaPfUL7Ta8oKc8pqKrklvDwcFfca2pVBS1pbk0Ia4eLrZen_TY7rPaJvE.5DSFSFgeA0njgBFRMEf4v03h9OarsAaQAOskJ9WNpMteOJtjc9xVG3CEOa3SPWhgqwbo8KZpaovQNdZmf0ELc4pyspe3b0GxIJUTYqemvlFxsKA3nooRbXHN96pfrfna1cVwp6rRXtw8CbXMfoDv6BZcVY.A2O09gcCmKBuHHgVhXUHxW0zJzb9cSejaBGhV9Fcfz0IGyJ0Ov9ZpJ5xR21UGRwTdYtrh9SqQGjhhgnARevxqirjfmEJeBGbmj.IypxIdvBeRBjqeTs61eYgH.PwCK_ouMLiyEH.QxRYXJW_pTRbu4RpNek1ONUfDvqw_PpKBfCtaF_hr3dKdQHDoqKFWkfi2glhVt.hZw.iL_gkwQUTqKt2I7J9nOTGmYR_5kVKu_vH_LsB1BjyzHQePdVHvO2pX7yX1eAxW7cyUXOtjBB8I76SZebiOqCsv_Or5kdAFsV2Y_E9yTwnJyIiIVYVoFy91zh9yaR9OMHPvCHpXnEXSk7QwlxwNbqX7uLWx1oPCndrHXnmYsvp_mFaKFUA0yjGz44RFeUrYoK7K.3XLC3m6xTHDqoSXVpf9rVflj59lzAaklPYWZt7mJpIcbgBOIoYTaIF3IWn5Qk27vd3Svc9IImiMMGH6h0fod8YdzuI5Z._QPDBvA8dkTjErgeasX1KKgtxSqqStQosuubfJC6pEv8F8vqQ7JhBf6fyeRoAvq8bjVYki2Wbcm_NmAg8NxhOsOyYn8fsAaw4OefckBcLGf6gcQHu201Qs_3Q0kQmfbWG5XOPdgAvL53shzjW0h97J4gJtv8jY1ZNOUWJZaG7jdt_M0xIvWmuKEAy_X.e.EpJvLnUTbdZSC0OUEpjPOj7kUPLvvcUYMlOlh2_FYpk4hP_vTDEqfb2i_fPEOtxO3nC700lTIHBe.0oYj8.GItNwxliQw0sw9XgacYj5PPUHn_NjOGvtGpmtmH_qRN6ali_k5zqVXbGPSBH0oXmCdTxWyF5yXnPqaDV6HnHV_XU5rWFQEgHMuLkeQr9PXAcqaGZG9h4eXSnfoRJizJECCu86p.8HY2gm84.4MX1WvIWxBLZGALG5zrkrQtRw7bxVbEoTR7FUc6keGXUsBNJ.YNRfUqAtLCO8KzPvVOvCXGNoQyUwAZY47UXRlVaRw7kMlGsybxIyLMb60WEsZZrfDcQrVLyIRZjcr9UwMNPFucQPDaUqGuMAbHH0UG6V0ip6SYCL62FGEusUdu4QzfFIY629b_ztOmcXJ_g_N_LKYYJQ2f41nSxo9RUUy2mXkqQ.AmYwKn9Z8sVBQUApZf59FmRULZyc6_Sw_Aylqq5CThC83s3CQzx_DEno6yLzukyt9HCCvXc1o6zc86NC4HTZAspTNymkUs1TViVe6MNIx6zv.ed8m8YGIhcFcfpdV1egNWztpvJi1lisR2V5j7ZVGEXgzoSM5CXJwlqq3q_bNmlE5ZR2RFnc_HQLnQXxdfiISwvAU4gwch5qGy3NayvelJ3e3HSNgBETuhT6Ot6o3Ln3IDPA1LIQvs0FqC.vVuFC7wbVLqDE9bK3XZg6EpoBmiHigG1aXCoHW4QE0va47sgviFl8n0JWq.W8DSzRxj5ft8tc.rTGbPsQS5_LSB9BsuvJMLy6ej43Z.skW.LDlJFTuz0W3Z6hBY0kMXcz8IM1K9QzKlpRO8z6U4GYiQvYB6v.tGe1v3P.mRgwnE3bxSsm.wo5PeKWxDJjryzB3URP36NvUIQ8HeWJ2Z.6bftxGQHm1DqwSjx0zLo1Y9xWbAbn3UxD62..x0NioM513jhVyalwc3VNix0fzSUgEE3D62j_BXt6v3aEMeMUIRYcylDVT7vl97y6StX1OkOLGNTNsSiLalprAFWVdjXRoIzi3AzNvWbz81YlczDQbGeAQYlFMGaMCmaL64jxfCx.SP_MxPqTQHVcRCdwm4k320SileSDE3ID9jsQjjwbeQYqCMUiG3z4AHBvXtovELGN5a1HZi9B9.PPh412AJuWE0qp3anavu7fGK2ssrR3dAaKJWDEzW8v5_cwwDuy0NHodxUeej3ZrMtUw",mdrd: "H4Lf42GAHI2HxzIOdepZ_Ra_u_lhJEc1NnZr1e_G8lA-1732741621-1.2.1.1-2SHxqmsXBkh4fl3Ep4uKBLU7fFHpUxYbPoJpiKMqhIj_vdcRaSZqW.ZXCF54vsW13EOA43lz6Q_ARyb7X6vZhosIvE6.tnjI6Luw3U.t9wtKN_oRq_brOQcjFmnyme1Lr3FmGwtrdblBi4wsMCJ1HcychmoVmJhkvPXjACqpzT.VKfj4dpYEFi5xmZhrlr6N9JqbwEqD7J6e4BDOSYiHWH1QS_af7TWqeDX_zEJsSTSc8wsCuO09nuuCazhq_nLKmZR14C.977M482Yuf.YgUSaQCpQZ_TKdTgDj0cbD.ZnnF7gQu18T0csEzuvrIn1_nRSoGQWMmrlWBQISLR3TbwSaJBXgDjODTfQmkRxCznzISXn_OVSo6tYw8julT9VP4gQlnTgObu8oFsIMFceZkPKMvZ10_lMVx3FPdVGVgQK9PPS5KGv8gULG_1ptHiAgeSDObBgF5ESZYWUNlxwij87.F_djfrr2sEiBWbgcJbmCovmnkI9SuUL45y99k7pMIExbTj1brKRPDeDpuyRjoCVGAFDVDwwZi_nSuKiyOSgXcWh6mxt5wqBUdWmrAljFiuzdWw1qhFNqxG_ycss74t7ttvliZn14RE1tgAY7ruDVU2_mkl3diHh9bJx0DknoyeTXzKQsr8kv8t1V1wIZyPhDo4vfnukHcMDioQj6mJf7Do.fCh0E6bXIbrbDWtp.kUGUSzc9E8.loFm.kNt7hy7_Tek1E3622zoK4ps.saq_m0AARiCHUbcJeJ95lkNOhPZ6GZziHQA3Buc4TgoCWOVAJB8a3c8ADYmVnfFzWXNnwFP_M46v2SincJ.KItcUXrIFX7uhDxBU8n9xOjBlDPeCi5rkcsYYrL9VHUCEIdbkb0ppRkzwEW8XA4wg2D3HFB6Yo50zJmP.OfXTQ2Uy95NHECPQGEA3amPMcOr8jwXH0yesjICv3lAbVDH5t8socc781JgZqSCeSf9b.7BEpkaIs1kiKaIalJiXCzKq4XAWsqHigEr1dia7kfMkETLH1yEJITJu9MEciUfsr15sIOHYVy64cxcnvltK88VnRczuKuLdkgnn_Z3z.dGg6gYpxQl5fZxJtOfvcx6gkqQku46Sb3z0LOSasIEz_eS7C9gQUNM0zr9SZuGgxPK5F_02o1F1hfbhOSgRK9Jf1yz6yvDf6QQ8QI7xT9F.UdMYPRpRwG0cH1blQ.H.baghIG0JnTxvqxrVkoH5FxvogRYmydSFG1Y0icz91DgfaVmCTwMx5dUKbHm0xExvq4TXBxULjkOOBw45788mMc6VUXGX6ndJWqai8O2uNFirT2UWVEAD_gb_7JaKINHQ6g9m1Gidvva..2CRl57tV4gmGFVNrna.PpvbneLO4YlIdz9ipKttj4_Fo0bPo33onMK6q1MMQY9vplLP3cbyuxC08r1z5RnTLFaCgAdDNPkj5Ympo1RTXlEJCZqqYdUfMw5ZiSpzvLLEeMrwO6YQO4EGKaPOSb5dXmf_IV0AFaaZQyoTovKGxAO3HTE2Y1OMZqXu0SMywebRY63ps09ZNEmSpwIY7Efvb4JPugeYrn4DcM0Qtyv3F9Oj6Yulj1kX_VPwRJfiWCDKsDojB6dBqoHi_voX05DelXN0t6fykuCEFjVLbXHHGs0by5HK8QclhFEd2k3xDZe4KRv5xPtKlqQ0tv8kX3DdVR3Aob_FM.G.g6SQUiOWyreYE8.9MzLEsZ2TiiUOoju5kviWg6IXnZl93JCTvnhfPyUk5CDx8Zc9nD.IkbewLabEecHS1Eq1qJ3vANdEGAoWqoSU0y0ZjcAseM6ZUmRvu1uoLVBrLcnHGE7pG2Lx7_MQ2KW1dDOKmlMS1N8zCbPzAMmyr4OgoXw7y_Ts_vphF4rFQDfifHJB5yYGV4KdH7GmdfesnNdRy69IP5VBHov1lkufL1dMtn2RELJbqc_2B4HngVvDjCg9Z8UIysW4MTzCI2BAHoTqgRq20hGxnH8kRw2EjamiSqqEbcxlnw"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e9515e07c2bce61';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/doi\/10.1126\/science.1187145?__cf_chl_rt_tk=tcxejfkjJisrw1WBoFnLDOX.EROLChud8UqBOfvA_qs-1732741621-1.0.1.1-Yty3d2zCtmxCOR5UVfauq.VqiSRflsbJSQRh78yEl70" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>