CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="120"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.annualreviews.org",cType: 'non-interactive',cRay: '8e759699de03ac9d',cH: 'dpxadFel5hcw0562NEGq1Z4xcyFwBPjFhluAo78zB.E-1732411350-1.2.1.1-iCEEBdmX_8hIie.5Y24LW8ajII.zr_7fE7CDS7DbWK1NKBGiixpAlQxyMEfA.4tg',cUPMDTk: "\/doi\/10.1146\/annurev-astro-081915-023441?__cf_chl_tk=9xTI9J7EkNpfJDWfzQURXJnzaTa5jk64rSvgTymI1Rk-1732411350-1.0.1.1-IDq1vmB0yEtXV5sqKDt8SjGMMRzZsQEmk4S2dmoPDi0",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732411350',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '120000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/doi\/10.1146\/annurev-astro-081915-023441?__cf_chl_f_tk=9xTI9J7EkNpfJDWfzQURXJnzaTa5jk64rSvgTymI1Rk-1732411350-1.0.1.1-IDq1vmB0yEtXV5sqKDt8SjGMMRzZsQEmk4S2dmoPDi0",md: "Aw5ahQvcyNXf8ZSxDcM1bM6vK5o8aNrClKE8oPM_pq0-1732411350-1.2.1.1-_8mfLQKOpyorRx4RJHiENsRyWs2EOaMpAK3xaU.pdchjXnS2DQJHhCrNHa3C2PgfrsjFqsWjcEJfnG1VnxJCAy8e2yDweG9jX8v.ZVpEAIQk1FUPyqNzZxBAUMSSv6HUpjprkMVr.YOODu36.ElCuIjnVomBpQ7POw4xPtC673K0ikdcPci5b2xTE6VQJSbMDb_T2nCMV3ZT3Jg_jXGtKCIZP.lY2s7X9SHIP76Dne1iPHJh46LDs31OKMcxYS5Ch0sgQzO33Nbin_Z9JllrseQXDBlSjpk.QnO9oq.rIzv7lVPqRrK..meeMcimHE1IvamffxVMz6jO_H9EO52EsRkJlOMFJG__wUf2ewBKBafLe8kvD.2VAnm.B5LBE701.yE7jvXGoWShZyV42PVZtCTT0U1GiuQFp_ZN5xD0jnLrjinxk5f84_N9LtBsxTafpwTLf19wN4yKcn78LjarBR.8Q2BS9tsy.5OTic7V3k_tVie09eyuMQVsiNO02ucS6JCUssdGXeLfpFao9sFfABj7CXyvxYB6_vazk6g9HbtX_4j67BPJomwjLlODZaoOQnVzmCGusMYdcuxSyytK5VgeUI7droYbdG8DwcS2HbX.2bvOry1JgRH1i_vv8Fq3w3kmPOPeNA1e3FxDy2s_DWKFVqccJApVzp5RJQBMTNq9NiGAa0x02TfludNLd1OvY7xJ9BcfATF1uaDpBhroJy3MZ2U5cV_NT13OU0n.8P_qcOdM92HC0G6UiLSAUcOiKuS.vqLF5vFCl0yGi511Y7JZo2oczN3XHu1nF4bYlZ1aDgPrStqsSc2L6QOctc0EZbT0UZdYfSRXeaAcz8K.kdWDue.YV2ccVWR96vuMY0rPVedQIDW8_l9JLyZq6fCgI.koCIs.BGSgnhsYMwTOrddYQ6cf_QTkOur7S_qPcyHvYD9FhHOqE5ZTUYFgeBvU1sSJ_Ck73k92DW8LLRbkqwJH_exZZXcgG6Yd.zqzFFmgmPmPnQ_kYDpkEXcIwshpyAEga7tTizv.zbKOTiUwVtLmtE7Jr_LQvDXb7_8o1LKc3lslbUp.f9fOjWg0i9bDvt1qFwHAHJGoVbJkX9adYca3WCOCxpWh9vlTghkcUJ.OLiVMjnXJbp._1Gw6lGMY_Ueqg7NYjH2hE3mgiELmDBcAWWzQnh6EJOaju5r6SCJTeeADNoVSb1FAEdsyoDhaddLAeTU.sUi0tazrmRxQWA3XEqmRozvqCJPMBG47TG2RO85cmzmLR_8q2lHmE5Ve.tVFjs6GQ6XoWn33gRpwUpeBwqEo2RkYChsKkymAfpYilBZxcWiq.SbS6R0oK5lm3cPIjxKmjPodIjatntH7SkCDDbRO2PWjBiLUHcvPZM3oVjlWyYaxl7jgkL3rOsxkGIMOhXd.b2ikFYvb__bk8H6Kps5LLEwNtnh.hR1sjkIkPeAYSXPYsHmZXQ9uzDyo8VFqpvdWLa7tFlWIvxwj99Efj_RD.JGU2VrgdljtDc2AQlmdNUq9vGdehk8eTxWTbucZffnYBB6gxzoDiDHSSYzlI1R73xhxE3EQy9rxf84ewFJXcKIfvgHuLaixHvtgPJgE7ZVr3mIsaxjEpwHzAp7YcagCftruR8dmf91ki8QQHiPuKArjpjPMT8OEaVG8f_sU21Ez1jsJoqEX7cRipn1uuQhQwHbWzw0FGQrE4F15tqCTnTbXegRfVrE9OVe2av7lEn7JJ7rHqg4IE1rdoRQzxHygCCrvS9LCmAJXnMsjxeqflfUyeHDo8lYFVgxHerYYat2aNAHndM2xKk5kmeb_1za9W.L.ht43eeO5iLLiPAefi.Lnk37vU3yyURkp97zdC7VNVUC06EoBXGwQNWMB9cKTqPJfbaeMVzOLl_ExjPzVCwQbb4m3jjF8sX6zvkT5nzMG53iugqbYAEnq1AmcvDqOs660MXLdaVBBVth.zuu7H9RbfSbGto5zpn6tWufM3NK2xjaXUqo8eYU39rrRQ8hmgQNV9NfDl60kHfDagRzboBYdFfMJ0QWslkcJ",mdrd: "DHFQoufw.et9iAaqC7gqabBwgdDff8c09UA6x63MG9A-1732411350-1.2.1.1-iBEn3xEe2DK3rBXgfwm1ku8tcvqmw0w3cafXxWTMdjb0H8J62p_52fi99p7Fkdl1fZrbO6JmZQofFkZq5cxDx.3BVfZnuLSauXguMhoZdo1w9Kyho59iAa4JSpaycttkwBw.pPnh.6WjRm.EoHJHNPaygNJj20.pjimBWrzXF3t5gUuWMMVcdi5W4nRiAMq4WUK77ehOyLGL7t771sDoUc4XlRih0sXF.KX4ww8NwAyP.87gtztE7MzSSaxZOTsm3NdGXYhXhTCglfhNXOtKvv3aK.ju530g.aFEJ4RQqG0VKWNx3Xr6I_jr4xlsCDAyZRx2UHLbGseILzzNRBlxzO7pWjMmmtBioVPA_xz2H_.i4Sr2wstNph5rKl2kTNhKhApFPbBouq4dZ3zYTXBeXYC8QdGrsSZTvvV5KnsIbZK2i_WHgMvA8coRhjqHCTodK0JETVD1hloaxmJcZnxEMMzf.naM_GXvemWe_jcjLYy5IC8Grt5vvwTQIzkmDTCEZA0L9jKNMjO9pAR4_UYPnRukmLi.RF3btlvTRSA3OGk9Bc47GYGSIbDqnmPGxWJf9zgYPZWS3.wGEZLkL000RB7ZxVAj1z0DQD1cnYmq4LE2IKoZJjCxd90cslGLaqFJFERs2VR4ILIkUl._b8eVNxkYXvehc3qYBjSgGAWcAPb3FPT1doBiE47mCQD4jrHaPUYr8_2khPJvxNGmGRkfK3.C3vROux43tFbidxFQiNH3MyG5iwERV2rjTM9mobTGL5tst38tOXDNryy09hiEBEuy209XhCPOB3ccOhV4Yd7wPPLPele2Yewo775BvCnPgQpKYhBPBH0MyK89o5BLLcIyJBRqG2cllOHJp59WYsvzgi0H5mA4I.2lWpSaAeJ8rsUmFZBgh9xWcj2AfZ3eVMotSPJ19aEg7ywm6Ue8sZw0JsST7lLDyHQTCTqXSORGBZFNdcqVwb1N5mRVRr1wdCtTL.ckOzvxzTgmSpI1mp0ePBHkJ1pDAPEzeornqoKul5KVY8QvrLLvFOGrqD0uBArpXr6L32rJuSomQwFpWnnpjZSYatUtzD9OfK6lO7EMgjRvNMYW2Sov3khSxtn3HFO5B3O1dYeKs2P5fefoAuTdP1OTiHkkmaJy.49oi5jOGqDkQFkUz9Z8cNzDniFhbXi_yYBiANUg6qViiRdKz3nAwrnB0C7VBbDsFeaLL_hoM1Ugif1V_U5qC1jyqU8_ANcfimyf32ZpMCfv6R3R0yf4NyQaiXbY6Ke6Wkgl8LtkFWVSJHjR6iF8IFmUzL4y6WZz5il_OuLwmEBtgifuYlmkLyrD0BfIaylxxpjPQSnO_0X3WWIvJmM.d3QUGGKk.w48xz5TD40CBqv_4J_W_Ua7yKNy2Qp34PLvQSaJ_1mOsAM_j8tIS.6auqAllp3wQL_rHsDwky1Lk5IszBF3dsBRbrdSHQ6X32IHpMu._0._DLBBB4sSpYoLCiAiNjoKas_RLrBJnK6k4qVTAklIVIM3CY_S2t3OcLJcmca9CNb_T4siyRkfDERd2BvZ3HmENEX0wuHH2CAAGFAuYafFtGexLz5bd5d8qIUhpdRYxs55B_vwiQp3hIOtm06_4VZiltdUTzkvLMJbqP1HOzmmCQE6ZYqGy3dk5sTG8JlNvDspkFvPiy.Bqu08a2vFYtQ3Zmk5sQfLqp58wgufA3VoZZvKNhKB7gI7r0BnLXwfY1ZWNxzAxAYjn797WLN3q.TAEDh3WAdOkEg2GhzWB6ogTQSEfLM9sbFN.45vNXziCSISUGwyo4Ecpx2oFxnORHbzbTWhqNzhKwx65vSPXpT88whD1gOJTMmRHtVH57HqxJyOpoENnkcc9Cm..E1_VmLSmUaSL.otnIykMNlijTiw9i.eivdP1nwmd5qPFzZOTkAipCcLytHmoApihPafsSzvedsRnPFXa4a4utAIses1iklSG2I_JKiC7XAg0ZRuQVZlKhYx0pVXi7KGwaf76qVLxg"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e759699de03ac9d';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/doi\/10.1146\/annurev-astro-081915-023441?__cf_chl_rt_tk=9xTI9J7EkNpfJDWfzQURXJnzaTa5jk64rSvgTymI1Rk-1732411350-1.0.1.1-IDq1vmB0yEtXV5sqKDt8SjGMMRzZsQEmk4S2dmoPDi0" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>