Strategic Competition

<!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en-us"> <head> <meta charset="utf-8"> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width" />    <meta name="description" content="Strategic competition between great powers drives CNA鈥檚 holistic analysis of tactical, operational, and strategic performance of U.S., Russian, Chinese forces. ">  <meta prefix="og: http://ogp.me/ns#" property="og:type" content="website" /> <meta prefix="og: http://ogp.me/ns#" property="og:url" content="https://www.cna.org/expertise/strategic-competition"> <meta prefix="og: http://ogp.me/ns#" property="og:title" content="Strategic Competition"> <meta prefix="og: http://ogp.me/ns#" property="og:description" content="Strategic competition between great powers drives CNA鈥檚 holistic analysis of tactical, operational, and strategic performance of U.S., Russian, Chinese forces. "> <meta prefix="og: http://ogp.me/ns#" property="og:image" content="https://www.cna.org/images/expertise/StrategicCompetition-2.jpg">  <meta property="twitter:site" content="@CNA_org"> <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"> <meta property="twitter:domain" content="https://www.cna.org/expertise/strategic-competition"> <meta property="twitter:title" content="Strategic Competition"> <meta property="twitter:description" content="Strategic competition between great powers drives CNA鈥檚 holistic analysis of tactical, operational, and strategic performance of U.S., Russian, Chinese forces. "> <meta property="twitter:image" content="https://www.cna.org/images/expertise/StrategicCompetition-2.jpg"> <title>Strategic Competition | CNA</title> <base href="https://www.cna.org:443/" />  <link rel="stylesheet" href="/stylesheets/cna-bulma.css?v=433"> <link rel="icon" href="/favicon.ico">   <script defer src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-HSCTXEFLKV"></script> <script defer src="https://www.cna.org/javascript/bundled.min.js"></script>  <meta name="google-site-verification" content="HVTzEcHdDTdRL-PaKSKJro-fx6mXsH8KqyHcFhU0SLQ" /> </head> <body class="expertiselanding "> <header> <div id="skip-to-content"> <a href="https://www.cna.org/expertise/strategic-competition#main-content">skip to main content</a> </div>   <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" style="display: none;"> <symbol id="article" viewBox="0 0 50 50"><title>Article</title><path d="M3,21.7c0-5.5,0-10.9,0-16.4C3,4.7,3,4,3.2,3.4c0.5-1.8,2.1-3,4.1-3c5,0,10.1,0,15.1,0c4.8,0,9.6,0,14.4,0 c2.2,0,3.8,1.4,4.1,3.5c0.1,0.9,0.1,1.8,0.2,2.6c0,1.8,0,3.6,0,5.5c0,3.6,0,7.2,0,10.9c0,1.2,0,2.4,0,3.7c0,0.8-0.3,1.5-0.9,2.1 c-4.7,4.6-9.4,9.3-14.1,13.9c-0.5,0.5-1,0.6-1.7,0.6c-5.5,0-11.1,0-16.6,0c-3.1,0-4.9-1.8-4.9-4.9C3,32.8,3,27.3,3,21.7z M5.3,21.8 C5.3,21.8,5.3,21.8,5.3,21.8c0,1.2,0,2.4,0,3.5c0,4.3,0,8.7,0,13c0,1.8,0.8,2.6,2.6,2.6c5.2,0,10.4,0,15.6,0c0.6,0,1.1-0.2,1.6-0.7 c1.3-1.3,2.7-2.6,4-3.9c3-2.9,6-5.9,8.9-8.8c0.4-0.4,0.6-0.9,0.6-1.4c0-0.8,0-1.6,0-2.4c0-6.3,0-12.5,0-18.8c0-1.5-0.7-2.2-2.2-2.2 c-9.7,0-19.4,0-29.2,0c-1,0-1.7,0.6-1.9,1.6C5.4,4.7,5.3,5.1,5.3,5.4C5.3,10.9,5.3,16.3,5.3,21.8z"/><path d="M27,50c0-0.5,0.1-1,0.1-1.4c0.1-1,0.2-2,0.4-3c0.1-0.6,0.5-1.2,0.9-1.6c2.9-2.9,5.7-5.7,8.6-8.6c1.1-1.1,2.2-2.2,3.3-3.3 c0.7-0.7,0.9-0.7,1.6,0c1,1,2.1,2.1,3.1,3.1c0.5,0.5,0.6,0.8,0,1.3c-4.2,4.2-8.4,8.4-12.6,12.5c-0.3,0.3-0.7,0.4-1.1,0.4 c-1.4,0.2-2.8,0.4-4.2,0.6C27.2,50,27.1,50,27,50z M28.8,47.3c0,0.7,0.2,1.1,0.7,1c0.9-0.2,1.9-0.4,2.6-1.1 c3.6-3.6,7.1-7.1,10.7-10.6c0.1-0.1,0.3-0.3,0.4-0.4c0.1-0.2,0.1-0.6,0-0.7c-0.5-0.6-1.1-1.1-1.7-1.7c-0.1-0.1-0.4,0-0.6,0 c-0.1,0.1-0.3,0.2-0.4,0.3C37,37.6,33.5,41,30.1,44.5C29.2,45.3,28.8,46.3,28.8,47.3z"/><path d="M45.4,27.6c0.4,0.2,0.8,0.3,1.1,0.6c0.7,0.7,1.5,1.4,2.1,2.1c0.3,0.3,0.6,0.7,0.6,1.1c0,0.4-0.2,0.9-0.4,1.2 c-0.6,0.7-1.3,1.4-2,2.1c-0.3,0.3-0.7,0.3-1,0c-1.2-1.2-2.4-2.4-3.6-3.6c-0.3-0.3-0.3-0.7,0-1c0.7-0.7,1.4-1.3,2.1-2 C44.6,28,45,27.9,45.4,27.6z"/><path d="M28.8,47.3c0.1-1,0.4-2,1.3-2.8c3.5-3.4,6.9-6.9,10.4-10.3c0.1-0.1,0.2-0.3,0.4-0.3c0.2-0.1,0.5-0.1,0.6,0 c0.6,0.5,1.2,1.1,1.7,1.7c0.1,0.1,0.1,0.5,0,0.7c0,0.2-0.2,0.3-0.4,0.4c-3.6,3.5-7.1,7.1-10.7,10.6c-0.7,0.7-1.7,0.9-2.6,1.1 C29,48.4,28.8,48,28.8,47.3z"/><path d="M21.8,18.3c3.4,0,6.9,0,10.3,0c0.3,0,0.7,0.1,1,0.2c0.3,0.1,0.5,0.4,0.4,0.8c-0.1,0.2-0.4,0.4-0.6,0.5 c-0.2,0.1-0.5,0.1-0.8,0.1c-6.8,0-13.6,0-20.4,0c-0.1,0-0.3,0-0.4,0c-0.7-0.1-0.9-0.3-0.9-0.8c0-0.5,0.3-0.7,0.9-0.8 c2.8,0,5.6,0,8.4,0C20.5,18.3,21.1,18.3,21.8,18.3C21.8,18.3,21.8,18.3,21.8,18.3z"/><path d="M21.8,26.6c-3.4,0-6.8,0-10.2,0c-0.2,0-0.4,0-0.5,0c-0.6-0.1-0.7-0.2-0.7-0.8c0-0.5,0.2-0.7,0.7-0.7c0.2,0,0.4,0,0.5,0 c6.2,0,12.3,0,18.5,0c0.8,0,1.5,0,2.3,0.1c0.2,0,0.5,0.1,0.6,0.2c0.2,0.2,0.3,0.5,0.3,0.7c0,0.2-0.3,0.4-0.5,0.5 c-0.2,0.1-0.4,0.1-0.7,0.1C28.7,26.6,25.3,26.6,21.8,26.6C21.8,26.6,21.8,26.6,21.8,26.6z"/><path d="M21.9,11.9c3.4,0,6.8,0,10.2,0c0.1,0,0.3,0,0.4,0c0.5,0,0.8,0.3,0.8,0.7c0,0.4-0.4,0.8-0.8,0.9c-0.2,0-0.3,0-0.5,0 c-4.5,0-9,0-13.5,0c-2.4,0-4.8,0-7.2,0c-0.1,0-0.2,0-0.2,0c-0.6-0.1-0.9-0.4-0.9-0.8c0-0.4,0.3-0.6,0.9-0.7c0.2,0,0.3,0,0.5,0 C15,11.9,18.5,11.9,21.9,11.9z"/></symbol> <symbol id="podcast" viewbox="0 0 50 50"><title>Podcast</title><path d="M43.26,28.33c.77-8.26-1.57-15-8.67-19.31C28,5,21.16,5.22,14.75,9.56s-8.61,11-7.89,18.64a1.28,1.28,0,0,0,1.4-.72,2.68,2.68,0,0,1,2.32-1.33c3.35-.26,4.68,1,4.55,4.35-.13,3.7,0,7.41,0,11.12C15.1,43.83,14,45,11.78,45a17.26,17.26,0,0,1-2.55-.38.55.55,0,0,1-.36-.25c-.63-1.28-2-1.41-3.07-1.91A7.47,7.47,0,0,1,3.62,30.2a3,3,0,0,0,1-2.43,29.69,29.69,0,0,1,.69-8.7A20.76,20.76,0,0,1,23,4.22,20.49,20.49,0,0,1,45.22,21a43.26,43.26,0,0,1,.27,7,2.47,2.47,0,0,0,.87,2,7.38,7.38,0,0,1,2.15,7.77,7.24,7.24,0,0,1-5.7,5.35,1.58,1.58,0,0,0-.8.6,3.18,3.18,0,0,1-2.65,1.42c-3.73.26-4.44-1.62-4.36-4.38.11-3.73,0-7.48,0-11.22,0-2.29,1.16-3.38,3.46-3.44,1.51,0,2.8.2,3.61,1.67C42.25,28.08,42.8,28.14,43.26,28.33Z"/></symbol> <symbol id="report" viewbox="0 0 50 50"><title>Report</title><path d="M15.29,13.45a1.32,1.32,0,0,0-.44.08,1.26,1.26,0,0,0-.36.24,1.15,1.15,0,0,0-.25.37,1.22,1.22,0,0,0-.08.43,1.26,1.26,0,0,0,.08.43,1.11,1.11,0,0,0,.25.36,1.09,1.09,0,0,0,.8.32H40.4a1.09,1.09,0,0,0,.8-.32,1.11,1.11,0,0,0,.25-.36,1.26,1.26,0,0,0,.08-.43,1.22,1.22,0,0,0-.08-.43,1.15,1.15,0,0,0-.25-.37,1.26,1.26,0,0,0-.36-.24,1.32,1.32,0,0,0-.44-.08Z"/><path d="M15.29,18.15a1.12,1.12,0,0,0-.44.09,1,1,0,0,0-.36.24,1,1,0,0,0-.25.36,1.26,1.26,0,0,0-.08.43,1.22,1.22,0,0,0,.08.43,1.15,1.15,0,0,0,.25.37,1.26,1.26,0,0,0,.36.24,1.32,1.32,0,0,0,.44.08H40.4a1.32,1.32,0,0,0,.44-.08,1.26,1.26,0,0,0,.36-.24,1.15,1.15,0,0,0,.25-.37,1.22,1.22,0,0,0,.08-.43,1.26,1.26,0,0,0-.08-.43,1,1,0,0,0-.25-.36,1,1,0,0,0-.36-.24,1.12,1.12,0,0,0-.44-.09Z"/><path d="M15.29,23.07a1.11,1.11,0,0,0-.44.08,1.24,1.24,0,0,0-.37.24,1.26,1.26,0,0,0-.24.36,1.12,1.12,0,0,0-.09.44,1.11,1.11,0,0,0,.09.43,1.26,1.26,0,0,0,.24.36,1.07,1.07,0,0,0,.37.24,1.11,1.11,0,0,0,.44.08H32.74a1.06,1.06,0,0,0,.43-.08,1,1,0,0,0,.37-.24,1.29,1.29,0,0,0,.25-.36,1.22,1.22,0,0,0,0-.87,1.29,1.29,0,0,0-.25-.36,1.12,1.12,0,0,0-.37-.24,1.06,1.06,0,0,0-.43-.08Z"/><path d="M8,1A4.43,4.43,0,0,0,3.6,5.4V44.6A4.43,4.43,0,0,0,8,49h36.7a1.07,1.07,0,0,0,.43-.09,1,1,0,0,0,.35-.24,1.07,1.07,0,0,0,.25-.35,1.32,1.32,0,0,0,.08-.44V2.13a1.26,1.26,0,0,0-.08-.43,1,1,0,0,0-.25-.35,1.12,1.12,0,0,0-.35-.25A1.26,1.26,0,0,0,44.74,1L8,1Zm3.78,7.47h31.8v38.3H11.8l0-38.3Z"/></symbol> <symbol id="summary" viewbox="0 0 50 50"><title>Summary</title><defs><style>.cls-1,.cls-2,.cls-3{fill:none;stroke:currentColor;stroke-miterlimit:10;}.cls-1,.cls-2{stroke-width:1.81px;}.cls-2{stroke-dasharray:3.34 3.34;}.cls-3{stroke-width:3.21px;}</style></defs><polyline class="cls-1" points="1.36 3.81 1.36 2 3.17 2"/><line class="cls-2" x1="6.51" y1="2" x2="44.89" y2="2"/><polyline class="cls-1" points="46.56 2 48.37 2 48.37 3.81"/><line class="cls-2" x1="48.36" y1="7.14" x2="48.36" y2="45.52"/><polyline class="cls-1" points="48.37 47.19 48.37 49 46.56 49"/><line class="cls-2" x1="43.22" y1="49" x2="4.84" y2="49"/><polyline class="cls-1" points="3.17 49 1.36 49 1.36 47.19"/><line class="cls-2" x1="1.36" y1="43.86" x2="1.36" y2="5.48"/><rect class="cls-1" x="1.36" y="21.28" width="27.72" height="27.72"/><line class="cls-3" x1="43.85" y1="5.62" x2="32.55" y2="18.46"/><polyline class="cls-3" points="32.55 9.44 32.55 17.96 41.89 17.82"/></symbol> <symbol id="quick-look-old" viewbox="0 0 50 50"><title>Quick Look</title><defs><style>.cls-1,.cls-2,.cls-3{fill:none;stroke:currentColor;stroke-miterlimit:10;}.cls-1,.cls-2{stroke-width:1.81px;}.cls-2{stroke-dasharray:3.34 3.34;}.cls-3{stroke-width:3.21px;}</style></defs><polyline class="cls-1" points="1.36 3.81 1.36 2 3.17 2"/><line class="cls-2" x1="6.51" y1="2" x2="44.89" y2="2"/><polyline class="cls-1" points="46.56 2 48.37 2 48.37 3.81"/><line class="cls-2" x1="48.36" y1="7.14" x2="48.36" y2="45.52"/><polyline class="cls-1" points="48.37 47.19 48.37 49 46.56 49"/><line class="cls-2" x1="43.22" y1="49" x2="4.84" y2="49"/><polyline class="cls-1" points="3.17 49 1.36 49 1.36 47.19"/><line class="cls-2" x1="1.36" y1="43.86" x2="1.36" y2="5.48"/><rect class="cls-1" x="1.36" y="21.28" width="27.72" height="27.72"/><line class="cls-3" x1="43.85" y1="5.62" x2="32.55" y2="18.46"/><polyline class="cls-3" points="32.55 9.44 32.55 17.96 41.89 17.82"/></symbol> <symbol id="quick-look" viewbox="0 0 1200 1200"><title>Quick Look</title><path d="m671.86 103.55c-48.609 84.188-121.6 210.66-186.05 322.22l-73.453 127.18-173.68-300.84c91.219-94.734 219.32-153.71 361.13-153.71 24.469 0 48.516 1.7344 72 5.1562z" fill-rule="evenodd" id="path2" /><path d="m1065.6 414.05h-518.95l173.81-301.03c157.55 39 285.84 152.53 345.19 301.03z" fill-rule="evenodd" id="path4" /><path d="m993.52 910.18c-30.984-53.672-116.62-201.98-185.95-322.08l-73.406-127.18h347.58c12.703 44.109 19.5 90.703 19.5 138.89 0 117.14-40.266 225-107.72 310.36z" fill-rule="evenodd" id="path6" /><path d="m527.81 1096.1c30.984-53.719 116.67-202.08 186.05-322.22l73.406-127.18 173.68 300.84c-91.219 94.734-219.32 153.71-361.13 153.71-24.469 0-48.516-1.7344-72-5.1562z" fill-rule="evenodd" id="path8" /><path d="m133.97 785.58h518.95l-173.81 301.03c-157.55-39-285.84-152.53-345.19-301.03z" fill-rule="evenodd" id="path10" /><path d="m206.11 289.45c30.984 53.672 116.62 201.98 185.95 322.08l73.406 127.18h-347.58c-12.703-44.109-19.5-90.703-19.5-138.89 0-117.14 40.266-225 107.72-310.36z" fill-rule="evenodd" id="path12" /></symbol> <symbol id="video" viewbox="0 0 50 50"><title>Video</title><defs><style>.cls-1{fill:none;stroke:currentColor;stroke-miterlimit:10;stroke-width:2.34px;}</style></defs><circle class="cls-1" cx="25.03" cy="25" r="23.33"/><path d="M37.27,26.75c1.67-1,1.67-2.54,0-3.5L20.43,13.53c-1.67-1-3-.18-3,1.75V34.72c0,1.93,1.36,2.72,3,1.75Z"/></symbol> <symbol id="newsfeed" viewbox="0 0 50 50"><title>Newsfeed</title><style type="text/css">.st0{fill:none;stroke:currentColor;stroke-width:3.4525;stroke-miterlimit:10;}</style><g> <path class="st0" d="M32.8,4.9C41.2,7.3,47.4,15,47.4,24.2c0,8.6-5.4,15.9-13,18.8"/> <path class="st0" d="M32.8,10.9c4.9,2.5,8.2,7.5,8.2,13.3c0,5.8-3.3,10.9-8.2,13.3"/> <path class="st0" d="M32.7,17.3c1.7,1.8,2.7,4.2,2.7,6.9c0,3.2-1.5,6.1-3.9,8"/></g><g> <path class="st0" d="M17.2,4.9C8.7,7.3,2.5,15,2.5,24.2c0,8.6,5.4,15.9,13,18.8"/> <path class="st0" d="M17.2,10.9c-4.9,2.5-8.2,7.5-8.2,13.3c0,5.8,3.3,10.9,8.2,13.3"/> <path class="st0" d="M17.3,17.3c-1.7,1.8-2.7,4.2-2.7,6.9c0,3.2,1.5,6.1,3.9,8"/></g><circle cx="25.3" cy="24.2" r="3.6"/></symbol> <symbol id="triangle" viewbox="0 0 50 25.4"><title>triangle</title><polygon points="24.9,24.6 1.2,0.9 48.6,0.9 "/></symbol> <symbol id="plus" viewbox="0 0 512 512"><title>plus sign</title><polygon points="289.391,222.609 289.391,0 222.609,0 222.609,222.609 0,222.609 0,289.391 222.609,289.391 222.609,512 289.391,512 289.391,289.391 512,289.391 512,222.609 "/></symbol> <symbol id="dropdown-arrow" viewbox="0 0 50 43.4"><title>dropdown arrow</title><path d="M24.9,43.4L0,18.6h49.8L24.9,43.4z"/><line fill="none" stroke-width="3" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-miterlimit="10" x1="15.4" y1="13.8" x2="34.3" y2="13.8"/><line fill="none" stroke-width="3" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-miterlimit="10" x1="15.4" y1="8.1" x2="34.3" y2="8.1"/><line fill="none" stroke-width="3" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-miterlimit="10" x1="15.4" y1="2.3" x2="34.3" y2="2.3"/></symbol> <symbol id="case-study" viewbox="0 0 50 50"><title>Case Study</title><path d="M10.9,0.8c-3.1,0-5.7,2.6-5.7,5.7v37.1c0,3.1,2.6,5.7,5.7,5.7h2.7V0.8H10.9z M16.6,0.8v48.4h26.8c0.4,0,0.8-0.2,1.1-0.4 c0.3-0.3,0.4-0.7,0.4-1.1V2.3c0-0.4-0.2-0.8-0.4-1.1c-0.3-0.3-0.7-0.4-1.1-0.4L16.6,0.8z M22.5,8.7H36c0.4,0,0.8,0.2,1.1,0.4 c0.3,0.3,0.4,0.7,0.4,1.1v6.9c0,0.4-0.2,0.8-0.4,1.1c-0.3,0.3-0.7,0.4-1.1,0.4H22.5c-0.4,0-0.8-0.2-1.1-0.4 c-0.3-0.3-0.4-0.7-0.4-1.1v-6.9c0-0.4,0.2-0.8,0.4-1.1C21.7,8.8,22.1,8.7,22.5,8.7L22.5,8.7z M24,11.7v3.9h10.5v-3.9H24z"/> </symbol> <symbol id="all" viewbox="0 0 50 50"><title>All</title><path class="st0" d="M46.3,12.9C42,5.6,34.6,1.3,26.8,0.8c-0.6,0-1.2,0-1.8,0c-3.9,0-8.1,1-12.1,3.2C1.3,10.7-2.7,25.6,4,37.3 c7.1,12.3,22.3,15.4,33.3,8.9C49,39.5,53,24.6,46.3,12.9z M40,7.8c1.9,1.6,3.6,3.6,4.9,5.9C47,17.3,48,21.3,48,25.3l-8.1-4.9 c0.3-1.2,0.5-2.5,0.7-3.6C41,13.3,40.9,10.2,40,7.8z M39,16.6c-0.1,0.9-0.3,1.9-0.5,3l-7.1-4.3l5.2-9.7C39.5,7.8,39,12.9,39,16.6z M24.1,25.4l-4.5,8.3L12,29c0.7-2.9,1.8-6,3.3-9L24.1,25.4z M16,18.6c0.3-0.6,0.6-1.1,1-1.7c1.4-2.2,2.9-4.2,4.6-5.8l7.8,4.7 L24.8,24L16,18.6z M25.4,26.2l8.4,5.2c-1.5,2.7-3.2,4.9-5.6,7.5L21,34.4L25.4,26.2z M26.2,24.8l4.5-8.2l7.5,4.5 C37.3,24,36.1,27,34.6,30L26.2,24.8z M35.2,4.8L30,14.4l-7.3-4.5c1.9-1.7,3.9-3.1,5.7-3.9C30.2,5.1,32.9,4.4,35.2,4.8z M25.1,2.3 L25.1,2.3c0.6,0,1.1,0,1.6,0c1.7,0.1,3.4,0.4,5,0.9c-1.3,0.2-2.6,0.7-4,1.3c-2.1,1-4.3,2.5-6.4,4.5l-6.8-4.1 C17.9,3.2,21.5,2.3,25.1,2.3z M12.9,5.8l7.2,4.4c-1.6,1.7-3.1,3.6-4.5,5.9c-0.3,0.5-0.6,1.1-1,1.7l-8.6-5.3 C7.8,9.9,10.1,7.6,12.9,5.8z M5.3,36.5c-2.1-3.7-3.1-7.6-3.1-11.6l7.9,4.8c-0.2,1.2-0.4,2.3-0.6,3.4c-0.4,3.6-0.2,6.9,0.7,9.3 C8.3,40.8,6.7,38.8,5.3,36.5z M2.4,23.1c0.3-3.3,1.3-6.5,2.9-9.3l8.6,5.3c-1.5,3-2.7,6-3.4,9L2.4,23.1z M11.2,33.3 c0.1-0.9,0.3-1.8,0.4-2.7l7.2,4.4l-5.2,9.7C10.8,42.2,11.2,37.1,11.2,33.3z M15.1,45.3l5.1-9.5l6.8,4.2c-1.8,1.7-3.6,3-5.4,3.9 C20,44.8,17.4,45.7,15.1,45.3z M18.2,46.9c1.4-0.3,2.8-0.8,4.3-1.6c2-1,4.1-2.5,6.1-4.4l7.3,4.5C30.1,48.3,23.8,48.7,18.2,46.9z M37.3,44.4l-7.7-4.7c1.9-2,4-4.8,5.5-7.5l9,5.5C42.4,40.4,40.1,42.6,37.3,44.4z M45,36.4l-9.1-5.6c1.6-3,2.8-6,3.6-8.9l8.4,5.1 C47.6,30.4,46.6,33.5,45,36.4z"/></symbol> <symbol id="search" viewBox="0 0 1200 1200"><title>Search</title><path d="m 823.68353,725.28 c 44.176,-62.547 70.129,-138.88 70.129,-221.28 0,-212.08 -171.92,-384 -384,-384 -212.08,0 -384,171.92 -384,384 0,212.08 171.92,384 384,384 77.633,0 149.89,-23.039 210.29,-62.648 l 237.07,237.07 c 28.062,28.062 73.40997,28.215 101.72997,-0.098 28.117,-28.117 28.113,-73.71096 0.098,-101.72996 z m -313.87,66.719 c -159.06,0 -288,-128.94 -288,-288 0,-159.06 128.94,-288 288,-288 159.06,0 288,128.94 288,288 0,159.06 -128.94,288 -288,288 z" /> </symbol> <symbol id="x-logo" viewbox="0 0 1200 1227"><title>X (Twitter)</title><path d="M714.163 519.284L1160.89 0H1055.03L667.137 450.887L357.328 0H0L468.492 681.821L0 1226.37H105.866L515.491 750.218L842.672 1226.37H1200L714.137 519.284H714.163ZM569.165 687.828L521.697 619.934L144.011 79.6944H306.615L611.412 515.685L658.88 583.579L1055.08 1150.3H892.476L569.165 687.854V687.828Z"/></symbol> <symbol id="facebook" viewbox="0 0 310 310"><title>Facebook</title><path id="XMLID_835_" d="M81.703,165.106h33.981V305c0,2.762,2.238,5,5,5h57.616c2.762,0,5-2.238,5-5V165.765h39.064 c2.54,0,4.677-1.906,4.967-4.429l5.933-51.502c0.163-1.417-0.286-2.836-1.234-3.899c-0.949-1.064-2.307-1.673-3.732-1.673h-44.996 V71.978c0-9.732,5.24-14.667,15.576-14.667c1.473,0,29.42,0,29.42,0c2.762,0,5-2.239,5-5V5.037c0-2.762-2.238-5-5-5h-40.545 C187.467,0.023,186.832,0,185.896,0c-7.035,0-31.488,1.381-50.804,19.151c-21.402,19.692-18.427,43.27-17.716,47.358v37.752H81.703 c-2.762,0-5,2.238-5,5v50.844C76.703,162.867,78.941,165.106,81.703,165.106z"/></symbol> <symbol id="linkedin" viewbox="0 0 310 310"><title>LinkedIn</title><path id="XMLID_802_" d="M72.16,99.73H9.927c-2.762,0-5,2.239-5,5v199.928c0,2.762,2.238,5,5,5H72.16c2.762,0,5-2.238,5-5V104.73 C77.16,101.969,74.922,99.73,72.16,99.73z"/> <path id="XMLID_803_" d="M41.066,0.341C18.422,0.341,0,18.743,0,41.362C0,63.991,18.422,82.4,41.066,82.4 c22.626,0,41.033-18.41,41.033-41.038C82.1,18.743,63.692,0.341,41.066,0.341z"/><path id="XMLID_804_" d="M230.454,94.761c-24.995,0-43.472,10.745-54.679,22.954V104.73c0-2.761-2.238-5-5-5h-59.599 c-2.762,0-5,2.239-5,5v199.928c0,2.762,2.238,5,5,5h62.097c2.762,0,5-2.238,5-5v-98.918c0-33.333,9.054-46.319,32.29-46.319 c25.306,0,27.317,20.818,27.317,48.034v97.204c0,2.762,2.238,5,5,5H305c2.762,0,5-2.238,5-5V194.995 C310,145.43,300.549,94.761,230.454,94.761z"/></symbol> <symbol id="youtube" viewBox="0 0 310 310"><title>YouTube</title><path id="XMLID_823_" d="M297.917,64.645c-11.19-13.302-31.85-18.728-71.306-18.728H83.386c-40.359,0-61.369,5.776-72.517,19.938 C0,79.663,0,100.008,0,128.166v53.669c0,54.551,12.896,82.248,83.386,82.248h143.226c34.216,0,53.176-4.788,65.442-16.527 C304.633,235.518,310,215.863,310,181.835v-53.669C310,98.471,309.159,78.006,297.917,64.645z M199.021,162.41l-65.038,33.991 c-1.454,0.76-3.044,1.137-4.632,1.137c-1.798,0-3.592-0.484-5.181-1.446c-2.992-1.813-4.819-5.056-4.819-8.554v-67.764 c0-3.492,1.822-6.732,4.808-8.546c2.987-1.814,6.702-1.938,9.801-0.328l65.038,33.772c3.309,1.718,5.387,5.134,5.392,8.861 C204.394,157.263,202.325,160.684,199.021,162.41z"/></symbol> <symbol id="bluesky" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><title>Bluesky</title><path d="M12 10.8c-1.087 -2.114 -4.046 -6.053 -6.798 -7.995C2.566 0.944 1.561 1.266 0.902 1.565 0.139 1.908 0 3.08 0 3.768c0 0.69 0.378 5.65 0.624 6.479 0.815 2.736 3.713 3.66 6.383 3.364 0.136 -0.02 0.275 -0.039 0.415 -0.056 -0.138 0.022 -0.276 0.04 -0.415 0.056 -3.912 0.58 -7.387 2.005 -2.83 7.078 5.013 5.19 6.87 -1.113 7.823 -4.308 0.953 3.195 2.05 9.271 7.733 4.308 4.267 -4.308 1.172 -6.498 -2.74 -7.078a8.741 8.741 0 0 1 -0.415 -0.056c0.14 0.017 0.279 0.036 0.415 0.056 2.67 0.297 5.568 -0.628 6.383 -3.364 0.246 -0.828 0.624 -5.79 0.624 -6.478 0 -0.69 -0.139 -1.861 -0.902 -2.206 -0.659 -0.298 -1.664 -0.62 -4.3 1.24C16.046 4.748 13.087 8.687 12 10.8Z" stroke-width="1" id="path16026" /> </symbol> <symbol id="threads" viewBox="0 0 878 1000"><title>Threads</title><path d="M446.7,1000h-0.3c-149.2-1-263.9-50.2-341-146.2C36.9,768.3,1.5,649.4,0.3,500.4v-0.7 c1.2-149.1,36.6-267.9,105.2-353.4C182.5,50.2,297.3,1,446.4,0h0.3h0.3c114.4,0.8,210.1,30.2,284.4,87.4 c69.9,53.8,119.1,130.4,146.2,227.8l-85,23.7c-46-165-162.4-249.3-346-250.6c-121.2,0.9-212.9,39-272.5,113.2 C118.4,271,89.6,371.4,88.5,500c1.1,128.6,29.9,229,85.7,298.5c59.6,74.3,151.3,112.4,272.5,113.2c109.3-0.8,181.6-26.3,241.7-85.2 c68.6-67.2,67.4-149.7,45.4-199.9c-12.9-29.6-36.4-54.2-68.1-72.9c-8,56.3-25.9,101.9-53.5,136.3c-36.9,45.9-89.2,71-155.4,74.6 c-50.1,2.7-98.4-9.1-135.8-33.4c-44.3-28.7-70.2-72.5-73-123.5c-2.7-49.6,17-95.2,55.4-128.4c36.7-31.7,88.3-50.3,149.3-53.8 c44.9-2.5,87-0.5,125.8,5.9c-5.2-30.9-15.6-55.5-31.2-73.2c-21.4-24.4-54.5-36.8-98.3-37.1c-0.4,0-0.8,0-1.2,0 c-35.2,0-83,9.7-113.4,55L261.2,327c40.8-60.6,107-94,186.6-94c0.6,0,1.2,0,1.8,0c133.1,0.8,212.4,82.3,220.3,224.5 c4.5,1.9,9,3.9,13.4,5.9c62.1,29.2,107.5,73.4,131.4,127.9c33.2,75.9,36.3,199.6-64.5,298.3C673.1,965,579.6,999.1,447,1000 L446.7,1000L446.7,1000z M488.5,512.9c-10.1,0-20.3,0.3-30.8,0.9c-76.5,4.3-124.2,39.4-121.5,89.3c2.8,52.3,60.5,76.6,116,73.6 c51-2.7,117.4-22.6,128.6-154.6C552.6,516,521.7,512.9,488.5,512.9z" id="path12844" /> </symbol> <symbol id="instagram" viewBox="0 0 1000 1000"><title>Instagram</title><path d="M295.42,6c-53.2,2.51-89.53,11-121.29,23.48-32.87,12.81-60.73,30-88.45,57.82S40.89,143,28.17,175.92c-12.31,31.83-20.65,68.19-23,121.42S2.3,367.68,2.56,503.46,3.42,656.26,6,709.6c2.54,53.19,11,89.51,23.48,121.28,12.83,32.87,30,60.72,57.83,88.45S143,964.09,176,976.83c31.8,12.29,68.17,20.67,121.39,23s70.35,2.87,206.09,2.61,152.83-.86,206.16-3.39S799.1,988,830.88,975.58c32.87-12.86,60.74-30,88.45-57.84S964.1,862,976.81,829.06c12.32-31.8,20.69-68.17,23-121.35,2.33-53.37,2.88-70.41,2.62-206.17s-.87-152.78-3.4-206.1-11-89.53-23.47-121.32c-12.85-32.87-30-60.7-57.82-88.45S862,40.87,829.07,28.19c-31.82-12.31-68.17-20.7-121.39-23S637.33,2.3,501.54,2.56,348.75,3.4,295.42,6m5.84,903.88c-48.75-2.12-75.22-10.22-92.86-17-23.36-9-40-19.88-57.58-37.29s-28.38-34.11-37.5-57.42c-6.85-17.64-15.1-44.08-17.38-92.83-2.48-52.69-3-68.51-3.29-202s.22-149.29,2.53-202c2.08-48.71,10.23-75.21,17-92.84,9-23.39,19.84-40,37.29-57.57s34.1-28.39,57.43-37.51c17.62-6.88,44.06-15.06,92.79-17.38,52.73-2.5,68.53-3,202-3.29s149.31.21,202.06,2.53c48.71,2.12,75.22,10.19,92.83,17,23.37,9,40,19.81,57.57,37.29s28.4,34.07,37.52,57.45c6.89,17.57,15.07,44,17.37,92.76,2.51,52.73,3.08,68.54,3.32,202s-.23,149.31-2.54,202c-2.13,48.75-10.21,75.23-17,92.89-9,23.35-19.85,40-37.31,57.56s-34.09,28.38-57.43,37.5c-17.6,6.87-44.07,15.07-92.76,17.39-52.73,2.48-68.53,3-202.05,3.29s-149.27-.25-202-2.53m407.6-674.61a60,60,0,1,0,59.88-60.1,60,60,0,0,0-59.88,60.1M245.77,503c.28,141.8,115.44,256.49,257.21,256.22S759.52,643.8,759.25,502,643.79,245.48,502,245.76,245.5,361.22,245.77,503m90.06-.18a166.67,166.67,0,1,1,167,166.34,166.65,166.65,0,0,1-167-166.34" transform="translate(-2.5 -2.5)" id="path14435" /> </symbol> <symbol id="right-arrow" viewBox="0 0 1200 1200"><title>Right Arrow</title> <path d="m9.3594 713.64h694.2c3.8242 0.035156 7.2539 2.3633 8.6953 5.9023 1.4414 3.5391 0.61719 7.6016-2.0938 10.297l-366.6 359.28c-2.8008 2.707-3.6328 6.8711-2.0859 10.449 1.5508 3.5781 5.1523 5.8203 9.0469 5.6289l343.44-9.4805c2.4414-0.015625 4.7773-1.0078 6.4805-2.7578l496.44-484.68c1.8711-1.8086 2.9258-4.3008 2.9258-6.9023 0-2.6016-1.0547-5.0898-2.9258-6.8984l-493.8-496.92c-1.8867-1.8398-4.4414-2.8359-7.0781-2.7578l-313.2 5.3984c-3.7734 0.082031-7.1367 2.3906-8.5664 5.8789-1.4336 3.4883-0.66016 7.4961 1.9648 10.203l331.8 341.64c2.6602 2.6758 3.4531 6.6875 2.0117 10.176-1.4414 3.4883-4.8359 5.7656-8.6133 5.7812h-681c-3.25-0.058594-6.4961-0.30078-9.7188-0.71875-2.6797-0.38281-5.3945 0.41406-7.4453 2.1875-2.0469 1.7734-3.2266 4.3438-3.2344 7.0508v221.88c0 2.4805 0.98438 4.8633 2.7422 6.6172 1.7539 1.7539 4.1367 2.7422 6.6172 2.7422z"/> </symbol> <symbol id="pressrelease" viewbox="0 0 1200 1200"><title>Press Release</title> <path d="m327.41 783.11c2.1211-0.62109 4.2891-1.2383 6.4531-1.8125l-119.62-298.46c-1.9883 1.1055-3.9336 2.1641-5.9219 3.1797-0.3125 0.17578-0.62109 0.30859-0.92969 0.44141l-117.28 47.594c-73.535 30.094-109.29 114.68-79.719 188.43l5.3008 13.172 5.2578 13.215c29.609 73.797 113.84 110.17 187.86 81.18l117.64-46.578c0.30859-0.13281 0.66406-0.26563 0.97266-0.35547z"/> <path d="m601.66 1026.5-107.82-66.418c-16.836-10.34-31.289-24.703-41.758-41.449l-77.555-123.91c-14.406 2.6523-27.93 5.832-40.434 9.457l-98.68 39.066 191.35 293.82c10.562 16.262 26.914 27.047 46.047 30.316 19.137 3.3125 38.137-1.4141 53.516-13.168l78.746-60.277c10.871-8.3516 16.707-20.945 16.043-34.602-0.71484-13.707-7.7852-25.684-19.449-32.84z"/> <path d="m907.5 589.51c-0.089844-0.17578-0.17578-0.35547-0.26172-0.53125l-72.785-181.58-72.562-181.14c-0.22266-0.39844-0.35547-0.79688-0.48438-1.1914l-45.605-113.75c-7.293-18.074-23.113-30.758-42.379-33.809-19.312-3.1367-38.27 3.9766-50.863 18.957-91.344 108.66-258.47 295.55-389.06 375.27 0.22266 0.39844 0.44141 0.83984 0.62109 1.2812l120.91 301.65c0.17578 0.44141 0.3125 0.92969 0.44141 1.3711 149.54-32.57 399.4-12.859 540.59 2.6094 19.402 2.1211 38.094-5.9219 49.891-21.477 11.797-15.512 14.492-35.574 7.2031-53.691z"/> <path d="m789.03 234.65 65.977 164.52 65.977 164.57c44.898-57.008 56.562-134.74 29.254-202.75-27.27-68.055-89.398-116.18-161.21-126.34z"/> <path d="m1106.5 298.33c-37.031-92.402-107.87-164.88-199.39-204.03-9.0156-3.8438-19.398 0.35547-23.199 9.3242-3.8438 8.9688 0.3125 19.355 9.2812 23.199 171.06 73.137 250.7 271.82 177.56 442.88-3.8438 8.9727 0.30859 19.355 9.2812 23.199 2.2969 0.97266 4.6406 1.4141 6.9805 1.4141 6.8516 0 13.391-4.0195 16.262-10.738 39.109-91.52 40.305-192.85 3.2266-285.25z"/> <path d="m880.9 155.64c-8.9688-3.8438-19.355 0.35547-23.199 9.3242-3.8438 8.9727 0.35547 19.355 9.3242 23.199 66.461 28.414 117.9 81.047 144.81 148.13 26.867 67.125 26.027 140.7-2.3867 207.17-3.8438 8.9727 0.35547 19.402 9.3242 23.199 2.2539 0.97266 4.5977 1.457 6.9375 1.457 6.8516 0 13.391-4.0195 16.262-10.738 32.125-75.168 33.055-158.34 2.6523-234.21s-88.559-135.36-163.73-167.53z"/> <path d="m933.35 33.008c-8.9688-3.8438-19.355 0.30859-23.199 9.2812-3.8438 8.9727 0.30859 19.355 9.3242 23.199 204.87 87.633 300.23 325.55 212.65 530.43-3.8438 8.9727 0.3125 19.398 9.2812 23.199 2.2969 0.97266 4.6406 1.457 6.9375 1.457 6.8945 0 13.391-4.0234 16.262-10.738 95.273-222.81-8.4414-481.55-231.25-576.82z"/> </symbol> <symbol id="externalreport" viewbox = "0 0 1200 1200"><title>External Report</title><path d="m 227.58241,724.8072 119.63275,-119.801 c 26.6243,-26.48386 61.83183,-42.58803 99.28077,-45.40091 37.44477,-2.81343 74.66567,7.84296 104.94684,30.04619 l 38.20952,-38.20951 C 567.31335,521.21085 556.57492,483.96214 559.39336,446.47983 562.21221,408.99196 578.398,373.76913 605.007,347.21436 L 724.808,227.5816 c 29.43301,-29.60125 69.45705,-46.24352 111.20386,-46.24352 41.74542,0 81.77086,16.64227 111.20804,46.24352 l 25.1963,25.19631 c 29.6013,29.43856 46.2435,69.46261 46.2435,111.20803 0,41.74542 -16.6422,81.77086 -46.2435,111.20386 l -119.63275,119.801 c -26.60901,26.51585 -61.82071,42.6367 -99.27521,45.45514 -37.45589,2.81343 -74.68235,-7.86465 -104.95101,-30.10042 l -38.20952,38.20951 c 22.33894,30.23112 33.07737,67.47983 30.25893,104.96214 -2.81885,37.48787 -19.00464,72.7107 -45.61364,99.26547 L 475.192,972.4154 c -29.43301,29.6012 -69.45705,46.2435 -111.20386,46.2435 -41.74542,0 -81.77086,-16.6423 -111.20804,-46.2435 l -25.1963,-25.19631 c -29.60125,-29.43856 -46.24352,-69.46261 -46.24352,-111.20803 0,-41.74542 16.64227,-81.77086 46.24352,-111.20386 z M 793.88407,535.92874 913.51683,416.45867 c 13.87736,-13.83927 21.67708,-32.62686 21.67708,-52.22384 0,-19.59697 -7.79958,-38.38888 -21.67708,-52.22801 l -25.35899,-25.35899 h -0.006 c -13.83384,-13.87736 -32.62686,-21.67708 -52.22383,-21.67708 -19.59698,0 -38.38888,7.79958 -52.22384,21.67708 L 664.07184,406.28059 h -0.006 c -13.91004,13.81215 -21.72019,32.6213 -21.68821,52.22383 -0.0869,11.59064 2.60167,23.03417 7.84297,33.37076 l 61.90274,-61.90275 c 10.69449,-9.55933 25.55504,-12.95397 39.34551,-8.98354 13.78504,3.97042 24.56643,14.75126 28.53616,28.53616 3.97043,13.79046 0.58117,28.65018 -8.98354,39.34551 l -61.73311,61.07126 c 13.80131,6.77301 29.37321,9.06502 44.543,6.55026 15.16422,-2.51477 29.16743,-9.70603 40.05185,-20.56334 z m -507.40229,352.22829 25.36456,25.36455 c 13.83384,13.87737 32.62686,21.67709 52.22383,21.67709 19.59698,0 38.38888,-7.79958 52.22384,-21.67709 L 535.92677,793.88883 h 0.006 c 13.91004,-13.81758 21.72019,-32.6213 21.68821,-52.22801 0.0869,-11.59064 -2.60167,-23.0286 -7.84297,-33.37075 l -61.90274,61.90274 c -10.69449,9.56476 -25.55505,12.95939 -39.34551,8.98897 -13.78504,-3.97585 -24.56643,-14.75126 -28.53616,-28.54173 -3.97043,-13.78504 -0.58117,-28.64601 8.98354,-39.3455 l 61.73311,-61.23394 c -13.74152,-6.97393 -29.35096,-9.38553 -44.55968,-6.89788 -15.20872,2.48765 -29.23139,9.75483 -40.03517,20.74827 L 286.4822,783.54376 c -13.87737,13.83926 -21.67708,32.62686 -21.67708,52.22383 0,19.59698 7.79957,38.38888 21.67708,52.22801 z" id="path3823" style="stroke-width:1.39045" /></symbol> </svg>  <nav id="navbar-main" class="navbar is-fixed-top is-transparent" role="navigation" aria-label="main navigation"> <div class="navbar-brand"> <a class="navbar-item" href="/"> <img src="/images/layout/cna_color.png" alt="CNA" width="126" height="46"> </a> <div class="nav-icons"> <form id="site-search" style="text-transform: uppercase;font-size: .75rem;" class="field has-addons" action="/search"> <input id="search-terms" name="terms" placeholder="Search" value="" type="text" class="input search-field" title="Search this site"> </form> <a role="button" class="navbar-icon navbar-search" aria-label="search" aria-expanded="false" data-target="site-search" data-field="search-terms" tabindex="0" style="font-size:1.5rem;">  <svg id="search-icon" class="svg-icon" alt="Search"> <use xlink:href="#search"></use> </svg>  <svg id="search-close-icon" class="svg-icon" alt="Close search" style="transform: rotate(45deg);"> <use xlink:href="#plus"></use> </svg> </a> <a role="button" class="navbar-icon navbar-burger burger" aria-label="menu" aria-expanded="false" data-target="site-navigation"> <span aria-hidden="true"></span> <span aria-hidden="true"></span> <span aria-hidden="true"></span> </a> </div> </div> <div id="site-navigation" class="navbar-menu"> <div class="navbar-start"> <div class="navbar-item has-dropdown is-hoverable">       <div class="navbar-link" tabindex="0">About Us</div> <div class="navbar-dropdown"> <a href="/about-us/what-is-cna" class="navbar-item" title="What is CNA"> What is CNA? </a> <a href="/about-us/leadership" class="navbar-item" title="Leadership"> Our Leadership </a> <a href="/about-us/our-experts" class="navbar-item" title="Our Experts"> Our Experts </a> <a href="/about-us/research" class="navbar-item" title="Research"> Our Approach to Research </a> <a href="/about-us/history" class="navbar-item" title="History"> A Brief History of CNA </a>  <a href="careers/community" class="navbar-item" > Community </a>  <a href="careers/diversity" class="navbar-item" > Diversity </a> <a href="/about-us/awards" class="navbar-item" title="Awards"> Service Award Recipients </a> </div> </div> <div class="navbar-item has-dropdown is-hoverable">       <div class="navbar-link" tabindex="0">Expertise</div> <div class="navbar-dropdown"> <a href="/expertise/civilian-harm" class="navbar-item" title="Civilian Harm"> Civilian Harm Mitigation </a> <a href="/expertise/data-and-architecture-management" class="navbar-item" title="Data and Architecture Management"> Data and Architecture Management </a> <a href="/expertise/domestic-safety-and-security" class="navbar-item" title="Domestic Safety and Security"> Domestic Safety and Security </a> <a href="/expertise/fleet-and-installation-readiness" class="navbar-item" title="Fleet and Installation Readiness"> Fleet and Installation Readiness </a> <a href="/expertise/force-readiness" class="navbar-item" title="Force Readiness"> Force Readiness </a> <a href="/expertise/future-fleet-concepts" class="navbar-item" title="Future Fleet Concepts"> Future Fleet Concepts </a> <a href="/expertise/global-security-environment" class="navbar-item" title="Global Security Environment"> Global Security Environment </a> <a href="/expertise/innovation-and-communications" class="navbar-item" title="Innovation and Communications"> Innovation and Communications </a> <a href="/expertise/plans-and-strategy" class="navbar-item" title="Plans and Strategy"> Plans and Strategy </a> <a href="/expertise/strategic-competition" class="navbar-item" title="Strategic Competition"> Strategic Competition </a> <a href="/expertise/tactics-and-operations" class="navbar-item" title="Tactics and Operations"> Military and first-responder tactics and operations analysis </a> </div> </div> <div class="navbar-item has-dropdown is-hoverable">       <div class="navbar-link" tabindex="0">Our Research</div> <div class="navbar-dropdown"> <a href="/our-research/our-reports" class="navbar-item" title="Our Reports"> Our Reports </a> <a href="/our-research/case-studies" class="navbar-item" title="Case Studies"> Our Case Studies </a> <a href="/our-research/cnai2" class="navbar-item" title="CNAi2"> CNAi2 </a> <a href="/our-research/explore-all" class="navbar-item" title="Explore All"> Explore All </a> </div> </div> <div class="navbar-item has-dropdown is-hoverable">       <div class="navbar-link" tabindex="0">Centers and Divisions</div> <div class="navbar-dropdown"> <a href="/centers-and-divisions/cna" class="navbar-item" title="CNA"> Center for Naval Analyses </a> <a href="/centers-and-divisions/ipr" class="navbar-item" title="IPR"> Institute for Public Research </a> </div> </div> <div class="navbar-item has-dropdown is-hoverable">       <div class="navbar-link" tabindex="0">Our Media</div> <div class="navbar-dropdown"> <a href="/our-media/newsroom" class="navbar-item" title="Newsroom"> Newsroom </a> <a href="/our-media/indepth" class="navbar-item" title="InDepth"> Blog </a> <a href="/our-media/podcasts" class="navbar-item" title="Podcasts"> Podcasts </a> <a href="/our-media/seminars" class="navbar-item" title="Seminars"> Seminars </a> <a href="/our-media/newsletters" class="navbar-item" title="Newsletters"> Newsletters </a> <a href="/our-media/press-releases" class="navbar-item" title="Press Releases"> News Releases </a> <a href="/our-media/in-the-news" class="navbar-item" title="In The News"> In The News </a> <a href="/our-media/videos" class="navbar-item" title="Videos"> Videos </a> </div> </div> <div class="navbar-item has-dropdown is-hoverable">       <div class="navbar-link" tabindex="0">Careers</div> <div class="navbar-dropdown"> <a href="/careers/working-at-cna" class="navbar-item" title="Working at CNA"> Working at CNA </a> <a href="/careers/why-cna" class="navbar-item" title="Why CNA"> Why CNA? </a> <a href="/careers/benefits" class="navbar-item" title="Benefits"> Benefits </a> <a href="/careers/internship" class="navbar-item" title="Internship"> Internship Program </a> <a href="/careers/community" class="navbar-item" title="Community"> Community </a> <a href="/careers/diversity" class="navbar-item" title="Diversity"> Diversity </a>  <a href="https://us62e2.dayforcehcm.com/CandidatePortal/en-US/CNA" target="_blank" class="navbar-item" > Open Positions </a> </div> </div> <div class="navbar-item has-dropdown is-hoverable">       <div class="navbar-link" tabindex="0">Contact</div> <div class="navbar-dropdown"> <a href="/contact/contact-us" class="navbar-item" title="Contact Us"> Contact Us </a> <a href="/contact/cna-contract-vehicles" class="navbar-item" title="CNA Contract Vehicles"> CNA Contract Vehicles </a> </div> </div> </div> </div> </nav>  </header> <main id="main-content" class="viewport"> <div class="expertise-splash" style="background-image:url('/images/expertise/StrategicCompetition-2.jpg');"> <h1>Strategic Competition </h1> </div> <div class="expertise-copy container"> <div data-sid="new-canvas_0" class="sie-new-canvas_0 se "> <p>As global power has shifted, CNA has flexed and expanded its analytical expertise to meet the needs of the Navy, Marine Corps and Department of Defense. Throughout these evolutions, we have maintained a constant focus on the nation’s most capable adversaries. Our approach to strategic competition is holistic, ranging from regional analysis to tactical evaluation.</p> <p>CNA scientists analyze operations and tactics across an ever-expanding range of warfare domains. Beyond the surface, air and undersea commands we have closely supported for decades, CNA is staying ahead of the latest threats with expertise in autonomy, artificial intelligence and the cyber domain. Our China Studies Program and Russia Studies Program are recognized leaders in strategic regional analysis. Great powers are constantly adapting. So is CNA.</p> </div> </div> <section id="capabilities" class="calls-to-action calls-3 featured-squares squares-3"> <div class="container"> <h2>Related Capabilities</h2> <div class="cta-container" style="grid-template-columns: repeat(3, 1fr);"> <div class="call-to-action"> <figure class="cta-image image is-square"> <img src="/images/capabilities/open-source-intelligence.svg" alt="Open-Source Intelligence" /> </figure> <div class="cta-title">Open-Source Intelligence</div> </div> <div class="call-to-action"> <figure class="cta-image image is-square"> <img src="/images/capabilities/operations-analysis.svg" alt="Operations Analysis" /> </figure> <div class="cta-title">Operations Analysis</div> </div> <div class="call-to-action"> <figure class="cta-image image is-square"> <img src="/images/capabilities/wargaming.svg" alt="Wargaming" /> </figure> <div class="cta-title">Wargaming</div> </div> <div class="call-to-action"> <figure class="cta-image image is-square"> <img src="/images/capabilities/exercise-evaluation.svg" alt="Exercise Evaluation" /> </figure> <div class="cta-title">Exercise Evaluation</div> </div> <div class="call-to-action"> <figure class="cta-image image is-square"> <img src="/images/capabilities/onsite-analysis.svg" alt="Onsite Analysis" /> </figure> <div class="cta-title">Onsite Analysis</div> </div> <div class="call-to-action"> <figure class="cta-image image is-square"> <img src="/images/capabilities/modeling-and-simulation.svg" alt="Modeling and Simulation" /> </figure> <div class="cta-title">Modeling & Simulation</div> </div> </div> </div> </section>  <div class="resources" >   <article class="cna-tile is-image image-overlay is-half graphic-tile" style=background-image:url(/images/Centers/CNA/SP3/SP3-RSP-RussianMilitary.jpg);> <a href="/reports/2021/08/russian-military-strategy-core-tenets-and-operational-concepts" target="_self"> <div class="text-overlay"> <span></span> <h2> <svg class="svg-icon test"> <use xlink:href="#report"></use> </svg> Russian MIlitary Strategy: Core Tenets and Operational Concepts </h2> <div class="description"><p>How have the theories and practices that underpin Russian military strategy evolved over time? CNA’s Russia Studies Program (RSP) examines this question and more in the latest study in the team’s look at the “Russian way of war.”</p></div> </div> </a> </article>   <div class="resource-list is-orange is-half" > <div class="listings ">   <article class="cna-tile text-tile" > <a href="/our-media/indepth/2020/10/the-evolution-of-russian-election-disinformation" target="_self"> <div class="text-overlay"> <h3> <svg class="svg-icon test"> <use xlink:href="#article"></use> </svg> <span> The Evolution of Russian Election Disinformation </span> </h3> <div class="description"><p>Kasey Stricklin discusses the evolution of Russian election disinformation</p></div> </div> </a> </article>  <article class="cna-tile text-tile" > <a href="/our-media/indepth/2021/01/new-life-for-new-start-is-a-first-step-for-nuclear-talks" target="_self"> <div class="text-overlay"> <h3> <svg class="svg-icon test"> <use xlink:href="#article"></use> </svg> <span> New Life for New START is a First Step for Nuclear Talks </span> </h3> <div class="description"><p>Madison Estes unpacks the significance of the Biden administration’s early move to accept Russia’s proposal to extend the New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (New START)</p></div> </div> </a> </article>  <article class="cna-tile text-tile" > <a href="/our-media/indepth/2021/10/new-roles-for-civil-affairs-forces" target="_self"> <div class="text-overlay"> <h3> <svg class="svg-icon test"> <use xlink:href="#article"></use> </svg> <span> New Roles for Civil Affairs Forces in a New World </span> </h3> <div class="description"><p>Emily Mushen looks at the emerging new roles for civil affairs forces in an era of strategic competition.</p></div> </div> </a> </article> </div>    </div>   <div class="resource-list is-orange is-half" > <div class="listings ">   <article class="cna-tile text-tile" > <a href="/our-media/indepth/2021/09/aukus-submarine-agreement" target="_self"> <div class="text-overlay"> <h3> <svg class="svg-icon test"> <use xlink:href="#article"></use> </svg> <span> Searching for Balance: Ally and Partner Expectations and the AUKUS Submarine Agreement </span> </h3> <div class="description"><p>Tamara Hemphill highlights the nuances competing interests among allies</p></div> </div> </a> </article>  <article class="cna-tile text-tile" > <a href="/our-media/podcasts/cna-talks/2021/11/maritime-sabotage" target="_self"> <div class="text-overlay"> <h3> <svg class="svg-icon test"> <use xlink:href="#podcast"></use> </svg> <span> The Strategic Value of Maritime Sabotage </span> </h3> <div class="description"><p>Alex Powell and Annaleah Westerhaug join John Stimpson to discuss their report, “Maritime Sabotage: Lessons Learned and Implications for Strategic Competition.”</p> <p></p></div> </div> </a> </article>  <article class="cna-tile text-tile" > <a href="/our-media/podcasts/cna-talks/2021/08/belt-and-road-through-afghanistan" target="_self"> <div class="text-overlay"> <h3> <svg class="svg-icon test"> <use xlink:href="#podcast"></use> </svg> <span> A Belt and Road Through Afghanistan? </span> </h3> <div class="description"><p>Brian Waidelich joins John Stimpson to discuss how China has a history of playing both sides in Afghanistan, and what to pay attention to in China’s response to post-US withdrawal Afghanistan.</p></div> </div> </a> </article> </div>    </div>  <article class="cna-tile is-image image-overlay is-half graphic-tile" style=background-image:url(/reports/2021/09/PLAsNewJointDoctrine.jpg);> <a href="/reports/2021/09/the-plas-new-joint-doctrine" target="_self"> <div class="text-overlay"> <span></span> <h2> <svg class="svg-icon test"> <use xlink:href="#report"></use> </svg> The PLA's New Joint Doctrine </h2> <div class="description"><h3>The Capstone of the New Era Operations Regulations System</h3> <p>Dr. David Finkelstein, Vice President of CNA’s China and Indo-Pacific Security Affairs division, examines the impact of joint doctrine the Chinese Communist Party issued to the People’s Liberation Army in late 2020.</p></div> </div> </a> </article>  <article class="resource-image cna-tile graphic-tile is-half" style=background-image:url(/reports/2020/02/ChinaPlaybookPageImage.jpg);> </article>  <article class="cna-tile is-orange is-half text-tile" > <a href="/centers-and-divisions/cna/cip/china-studies/information-environment" target="_self"> <div class="text-overlay"> <span></span> <h2> <svg class="svg-icon test"> <use xlink:href="#basicpage"></use> </svg> Global Disinformation, Misinformation, & Other Influence Efforts </h2> <div class="description"><p>Today’s global information environment poses numerous challenges for US national security. CNA helps policymakers and warfighters meet these challenges, including understanding disinformation and misinformation operations, mitigating vulnerabilities, and exploiting opportunities in this realm.</p></div> </div> </a> </article>       </div> <section class="content-rows"> </section> <section class="explore-more-bar"> <div class="container"> <div class="explore-interior"> <a class="explore-header" href="/our-research/explore-all?category=32&">Explore more</a> <div class="explore-icons has-4"> <a class="explore-content" href="/our-research/explore-all?category=32&schema=Article&"> <div class="circle-icon"> <svg class="svg-icon"> <use xlink:href="#article"></use> </svg> </div> <div class="content-type-label">Articles</div> </a> <a class="explore-content" href="/our-research/explore-all?category=32&schema=Podcast&"> <div class="circle-icon"> <svg class="svg-icon"> <use xlink:href="#podcast"></use> </svg> </div> <div class="content-type-label">Podcasts</div> </a> <a class="explore-content" href="/our-research/explore-all?category=32&schema=Quick-Look&"> <div class="circle-icon"> <svg class="svg-icon"> <use xlink:href="#quick-look"></use> </svg> </div> <div class="content-type-label">Quick Looks</div> </a> <a class="explore-content" href="/our-research/explore-all?category=32&schema=Report&"> <div class="circle-icon"> <svg class="svg-icon"> <use xlink:href="#report"></use> </svg> </div> <div class="content-type-label">Reports</div> </a> </div> </div> </div> </section> </main> <footer> <div id="footer-container" class="columns container"> <div id="logo-footer" class="column"> <a href="/"><img src="/images/layout/CNA_White.png" alt="CNA logo" width="173" height="61" /></a> </div> <div id="address" class="column">3003 Washington Boulevard Suite 200, Arlington Virginia 22201 | 703-824-2000</div> <div id="social-media" class="column"> <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/cna_162957" aria-label="LinkedIn" target="_blank">  <svg class="svg-icon"> <use xlink:href="#linkedin"></use> </svg> </a> <a href="https://x.com/CNA_org" aria-label="X (Twitter)" target="_blank">  <svg class="svg-icon"> <use xlink:href="#x-logo"></use> </svg> </a> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/user/VisionCNA" aria-label="YouTube" target="_blank">  <svg class="svg-icon"> <use xlink:href="#youtube"></use> </svg> </a> <a href="https://www.facebook.com/CNA.org" aria-label="Facebook" target="_blank">  <svg class="svg-icon"> <use xlink:href="#facebook"></use> </svg> </a> <a href="https://www.instagram.com/cna_org/" aria-label="Instagram" target="_blank"> <svg class="svg-icon"> <use xlink:href="#instagram"></use> </svg> </a> <a href="https://www.threads.net/@cna_org?xmt=AQGzPllDFgkvc6yvOa5lpyqX5lgWdo18A2X1_IVa5RpjIo8" aria-label="Threads" target="_blank"> <svg class="svg-icon"> <use xlink:href="#threads"></use> </svg> </a> <a href="https://bsky.app/profile/cna.org" aria-label="Bluesky" target="_blank"> <svg class="svg-icon"> <use xlink:href="#bluesky"></use> </svg> </a> </div> </div> <div id="copyright" class="content has-text-centered">Copyright &COPY; 2024 CNA All rights reserved</div> <div id="disclaimer" class="content has-text-centered" style="background-color: #000;color: #fff;font-size: .65rem;padding: 0 3rem;font-style: italic;"> <div class="container"> All media posted on our social media channels and/or our website are intended for a general overview and discussion of the subjects dealt with. CNA will accept no responsibility for any actions taken or not taken on the basis of this publication. All videos, podcasts, or any other media published or posted by CNA remain subject to our copyright and all applicable rights are reserved unless other ownership or license rights are acknowledged. </div> </div> </footer>  </body> </html>

CINXE.COM

Strategic Competition | CNA