CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.americanprogress.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e75b380782a4021',cH: 'J7gbZR7RgljK3MFx0R8TAqVxw4XyIYZpEIliMvHu8uw-1732412533-1.2.1.1-HNw1gSc3T9fQYwmkn8dEemqYDoulvD8GkLdKnHFyAibwCqlKMg3_Bz.BkNveHm6O',cUPMDTk: "\/article\/the-tax-cuts-and-jobs-act-failed-to-deliver-promised-benefits\/?__cf_chl_tk=RYgGfEN4HPHXdlqUaL9W8ug2wPWev8RSLbk3zaX5pqw-1732412533-1.0.1.1-4qqFWJe546XrcDJOH2MDBZb7iGytTDfIS0wvkZcvIkQ",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732412533',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/article\/the-tax-cuts-and-jobs-act-failed-to-deliver-promised-benefits\/?__cf_chl_f_tk=RYgGfEN4HPHXdlqUaL9W8ug2wPWev8RSLbk3zaX5pqw-1732412533-1.0.1.1-4qqFWJe546XrcDJOH2MDBZb7iGytTDfIS0wvkZcvIkQ",md: "qs1GXNe9Qdwn7aNAROAx6zWKn75k4KEuyli6jitDqlw-1732412533-1.2.1.1-tvuSTns3XYAEThRuIrg7ATvfVtIrRJw9LqS5mzB0B1iqjtl0dpUrWgQypaiP5RyVbNyUjbm5jYXZJWwMX3UDuDUj.QTev4w4qXAaLw41NwThRimgDtATfgbcNMCGcBYAcP4fgOw57ORjiwNZdC2oBhYyjKzFK6efAoAUskmkiYFboQNIs0Pa7J6d64FY6yJ20IBnNYY45kchc_xl3Hpz_QjqpkYfzgWP3uT5QSwjasTtEf848f2gsY.Uc94Af7nBUkQWYVaB4JObR4rkfMU4_WGi_IONNJuyhRt3OJIxR74fOkeu_Bw2BmMdKIB2iCAbWeF4hQdcGexQFtFR3wsB0.44tAu7MNMazbWPwjC93Pzuv0UJQ00La.H3LBGVaIVhy8HHrC1ZDubQtiy.nz.9.5Z9p3NLp5aWXvN9KDwWvz4OfaAyVxXFDHYToaxf76t2GkHUQpbV1g9LTL7sjnB4YmaOj_tH4AUCHyYXA9r3i4OQo27jqg9OCmifRQgPHGJeLCeiUH0xZn5tj3BfURDmNVyi4UarvNq8tn3sCREG.4N3O2RC0IZHJuLTN3uaxxv9_EhjuVChw_OY.6rYzR4FLwWSs7w59ZfnPco3BnujwyO._b8y6FTj_7EL0TFSwI_RFRiaNZsALKMdNp4GTdLlVl5nwj_vgCluykX5j3GWvtnp4zifCKgeremT3mfqv.tknUJTC7HpIunTwOAF4_D15O83RbSpSTCUXJFp58kKcGIzqHbTRtkwb1aEaRjQabBm6IUDn4xafopi2PVN_P27f702kwYzPoSwKEd3hZsZWzOTOsmFEPeXV8SisYX_h4O4V.1tufbXD4nR8Rc_ukmPqGsGVOuKHMTgqkcaWLfFLqxRchMD3.OMN2xp7yN9_PTAnBpBSDtymlC9BESW4FUY9pnZpKN3i06iWulx0tjX69QBzqRVev0Roy_ZZuz8fs65izKzl6G9IRc2D1QUrirghLYao14GVJ2vDhO36liwn__TLFt3F0IXAL2FGW9j6pnl3_bZxUxHj0Ts86RVD911B49PZAyDv7kVcd6lWf_7FkmkSxLpgYVwkj3jE6u4sT675B7b8grchxYc3xyN4C69kUAnUxpRany.LGren3_OSu73XhTAA8VRtJKcQ2DPe0KuBzDws3F38rTjl_yW_zymbLTZHUxU3HUEiZUac1oaYE6F7TyM4oA95PdQY.tA_0lb4p.mKqeSD4kOzUKCxnxx3PGuRegosJXT3usGNSGHc8h5Vcola84d5sQkP7gB6dfoWNWOTIP0.WzkZM1.eZLrC823TZtSr43CKt_roYkVRwK89swGATb9qvM5JhJGnTYaSQrJuPlWqlbJowA3N2xSL50mGtocfPDAITPNv8qzkEj93OokirGXHKVa2dZj6WpcPVspdrPmfhgVT5EicIwIia3XyYIKjSTxjMEsgSEVyahrfaKL.DF5SsHPAb5TsTclC5lstOKdIMwtJrH150rnnIqquk1vc9cGufRJl4SvpeHcEs58goWRLghndkwZxJnSTRHX_Y4Mm7rb4KPLwuQqc0Eoli3wnSiZwr8gpW.5jJiWj75I0rHLZr7VRufYcGrIqBC5a8t7SzU8eeRif_iSYFmFlRr56dKG7gS.dIi2Y.1clFDIgnx.cTSVEpzqjFT6TIbwLk71lus.gKfSTuGq0n5Z1YltDx3icHEaoEHAC.rbgcQKncgVMdd6aota.N3VRLKSANC4dMVsPckkcVgW25sdfP9znnfY8Lp8YhTxvppHwBeB2hC140qLPVwe.cMPLQY13pwRyRodxPz0VmO0knyWkA2IUbCmbHNUKpu23V1mdZU6njDtOh9yqVzxfUdJif5k7HtNrMzpMnSAChCTCkiRS13lh3v.KUlur6E8co3GI5HXE4Ng_SP2p3E4pXbea26op_qoIGQTgMLANVev_YvmeQgZqQAFPiMvlJFulJsGGCVkCH01tvk7a0QieI9PgHSjEuUPn5n9iuLy0qpfyFYKetAt1yO3JC.Jz5Sde2XMKo.tqdNNb.r3usnu4tq_pOVRko1g4nhPEe7aIM1np9.9vPvUy4ZaOjQUkaUpULQ6mVSnkYC4QGthFWa7bQvbGnvtZkv8bpgp1gK_tt6DqjE4vorL_ULvXHYmbH5OIKBVTaOoRoOet6Wgix.kz1uiCD_6S.W70MmSVZZRurxc6pN2WjFlz_D495ej3BxsSExaAPb32FESwHA2zvkF64.8zotROVbT1sfNt3WgKmVl_5Sv2Ps9iJSiKPrIV2DrpuJYtCZgqBmE5B9I3GUyrziSzZonskIKVzqYJ51ycKrCBhBhlMhk_r3tQLjNPkviT4WzcEBZFQR.EdHiRVRCHxqROMaCMvZ9R_FhotrXwdnOT.yi.FsUMVaHtkNUNufvYzzL6KRD5zjQByeKA5y8mVu2k9STzAPtk0O0BwgAcdnFMc4BYg7_OoOfYKNkH9viUeW6M5Ve3SxeejV0iAGrrvy_VKiLwj6fdJcjiy4MlNpNn7x0yi7SGb8TOt3WfDaF3678UO5Q_0llhyLfokGRhz4tSMJCUbgOLPqR3bYM_VbtzOlwej_9VwxCMyb43wQn1jFxUACGy2K.biQyctApSgUPLns9st8.ACDIvHWFXpeXqngLuNwcxkdcbEe9Do0nT_qSTGAKAuHQ5HqK8sfKvWM0T.I3KcMTxjWi.qh.N4DG5U9MiZ4yr5jQrF4Y01K.4L8oASartHHISlZnBD51or_.SQSBp_arz8a90nTnsbA9fyyhtFbXLClsoJMKCjmurXNOepbmFUY.kT1gvP7ShrJeKu9vWzvamGrHAaAZNqXmQpy_J9V84JEFIKcbjTcfqfIU7WBRoWIuZjVQWtJy.nCBvBT59CuNU_UJaCcDi2wmT7nJmP_ePYKnu415VLdkLcpmBxv8VXhXfeV9QeFyfecBGeuQd13cDWITJ7VC6IcixuUFv4xU0lqejDvCCJRhlwbJYmFYCSs1JQBgRSwP_whl39YDlZPAI8udzh7MVRleEodXyyi1SSx6_LhkHSNMTJY6iiA3lFis91dhjPtQeB4S",mdrd: "5s13n1I3JsczQkVcB32e9meYisa4biraM9ujP.HqkWo-1732412533-1.2.1.1-4iUNVSVWCVYAdU3eCnEg3z9EaieFP3YJNkhOrupMv6IXJUmTZ29k11lngcMUwvok2od_eOdKB.Te0IZ12wDybZrs2toWVJDvKOESDt8HufRtYaF92Qv.vAYYb5tjIMabl5ZAvzZj2KnkdtygH_7pxKl92L.vnxNuWpAaRvDEIlkf1aYNpYa_aEimh3DJ.LYZc7Pee6ysEkwZY4O_qlpe0nKZgdGfnBsKjjPbn70zhdlKZ.dunT9.puEumjZo1qzJeelNLfEweFUg6pPvDEKxrgXhn5qRCJXL0T9osBCEMan7ViveOGsjHKkBppKlQ33agR6zz.Z6YiAia0p92CK9hoxUYg49wclzKhq47yj8AqQiMx4.1pYTk7InucEuWf3AboHvgSTcE2hw7Xsw5umZn4JjBWzpYJGUG0qCYBTzLZAjONgk6aK5WoNRJZRgTfjjF0VC9DQ_YcoLLh5AQ3ViyVaiCadEXQLBFt_uHIWe6NmI6GwIdzHH.sKAVI2M8cATCnscXiC3o0iMmihhQ5ktOEWWlb1t9SAZA8Re1VD89OD44E5NETIi7ZJ1Z60lJCsH2AT9zQPFcsqiLbl26ll.43MwTiQ6LbBt2ylAcAV7stDGoFYaUPgWL.b8DDRhkEEnFV_vaUFIp9wK4KGBjCVA.sDcg1Bih1UZIO.ZvM4qOzBPtV8sFjn8nwcBDKJ390JxMhnQ0.PUvw6.iuBOwpbHnLTsPVsSJc179y9CEOovDHnFIdzOcUBBAEOuvkusEJcXO9JeW0AypDU1gVh_VZRIjDBW0sJ4hBvLB15UebdWm6AmGBxQAXCogPadpMFbpiKkb6KfbjFutgJCB0cFzn30x3Z25teXwT8AmdO9FKrUmsGXzZ60ukFgSzHWyEbTFemVIMalZs6IdWiFWpEFLiJ4qE5td4PibQdvJ3Tl2p63BkVzZic4vOfpMn0aWwUe6wcbDDFCQtgmO68nrNks5bvflMwLhHTnCpIkC5ofGuc3Ofy7ap4pzfJuoLjW9jE83LRhiIOTgHZ4ktWcwmKj3fbnlYW30l9YNuJ7D1vQEV5oPSYgZ7uDUEhuC46dXj2kAp2QkXEssrFwesp39ZxzLg8qlXj0jTqxH1hxtDXIJUS0r_E_9QLoAP4dnBZTemCtJtzix9ILYqXIdUoj9tVfC8tYJWmuFoJVVtUst4w4N8MFeUST38Kzj4dZx8bBombwgB9sAwzJXxB4oUetmfh27PHGrjGzrFT2oaxEvO8Rv5ntaLJxC5KNurbNrQixty5yyWmIdTMrnfgDp.FzLXWsBj5WRW1g4uEOCSluQ5oqOBMlWDx3c9AtKFzC8wAQxHCUvCJaeMgqFrcFSLgnBrkfLqjeSz431utAaMpWibPmIPzf6qNUeQRoKXcdmK6RmxSr8unsuioZPuw5kAA97bs.H1IoI3bSgAd9KbLinhv0YvSrHoKdhXo6ZYrdWI._yjoO8SplNSHkxAwKhBaeM1uywVzVpYz3NptEWe0MVcyMrpOsWz451Zvy.TMXChLdrY5LZpuARu2wLlyNCxwgbfgadtrmtV7ZtQce9F3GRg4KuivlyacsxXC5dlwI.Vdrde3sHYL0Dtb42sQH2raxjVBnLIl8.5o9umDnCtMok_DYvvDX21OJOpoRdubgzYxt.d2QPuIEOM3bdsxC3DD76pL4BlD2Dlour45R4V2Wg2cQmgTRD7gfC2ivjRx8iGfZM4Zetpn1VasT3GTZj.1oXiBazeEVfuI4AXzB6P_hqpxJQwEB10psohnLkJSlNtmBzzNvdGomHNaGtvI1UkgBIP9.bfTDRyqSOX7z3IF115pRuW0.odl5yi9SbCCXaib7VKRdFRUmIECmYdmp4GGz8Vacv5RwD7t8XTQ_rBfu0v98NFLyFdL5TeUaa_Qp0gx9sAbaxU3BgL4jnhAD6FXsDJAZUJmw_5YT9j7CBJLqvG3ZuEowaugYtIyA0nlCf4.fyIXO2VDXnIeNt5mMm4kBXnBthIcSVw"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e75b380782a4021';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/article\/the-tax-cuts-and-jobs-act-failed-to-deliver-promised-benefits\/?__cf_chl_rt_tk=RYgGfEN4HPHXdlqUaL9W8ug2wPWev8RSLbk3zaX5pqw-1732412533-1.0.1.1-4qqFWJe546XrcDJOH2MDBZb7iGytTDfIS0wvkZcvIkQ" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>