CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 3.2//EN"> <HTML> <HEAD profile="http://a9.com/-/spec/opensearch/1.1/"> <META HTTP-EQUIV='Content-Type' CONTENT='text/html; CHARSET=utf-8'> <TITLE>BAILII - United Kingdom House of Lords Decisions</TITLE> <link rel="search" type="application/opensearchdescription+xml" href="https://www.bailii.org/opensearch.xml" title="Search BAILII" /> <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="Recent additions for United Kingdom House of Lords Decisions" href="https://www.bailii.org/rss/recent-accessions-uk_cases_UKHL.rss" /> <STYLE type="text/css"> @media screen { } @media print { #screenonly { display: none; } } </STYLE></HEAD> <BODY BGCOLOR="#FFFFFF" TEXT="#000000" LINK="#0044BB" ALINK="#FF0000" VLINK="#660099" MARGINHEIGHT=20 MARGINWIDTH=20> <P> <TABLE BORDER=0 WIDTH=100% CELLSPACING=2 CELLPADDING=2> <TR VALIGN="top"> <TD ALIGN="left" ROWSPAN=2 WIDTH=5%> <A HREF="/" TITLE="BAILII Home Page"><IMG ALT="BAILII" BORDER=0 SRC="/images/bailii_logo_small.jpg"></A></TD> <TD ALIGN="left" WIDTH=60%> [<A HREF="/">Home</A>] [<A HREF="/databases.html">Databases</A>] [<A HREF="http://www.worldlii.org/">World Law</A>] [<A HREF="/form/search_multidatabase.html">Multidatabase Search</A>] [<A HREF="/bailii/help/">Help</A>] [<A HREF="/bailii/feedback.html">Feedback</A>] </TD> </TR> <TR> <TD ALIGN="left"> <H1>United Kingdom House of Lords Decisions</H1> </TD> </TR> <TR> <TD COLSPAN=3> <HR> <SMALL><B>You are here:</B> <A HREF="/">BAILII</A> >> <A HREF="/databases.html">Databases</A> >> United Kingdom House of Lords Decisions </SMALL> <BR>URL: <I>https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKHL/</I> <HR> </TD> </TR> </TABLE> </P> [<a HREF="/recent-decisions.html">Recent Decisions</a>] [<a HREF="/bailii/help/cases.html">Help</a>] <hr> <h1> United Kingdom House of Lords Decisions </h1> <h3>Search this section</h3> <FORM METHOD="GET" ACTION="/cgi-bin/lucy_search_1.cgi"> <NOBR> <INPUT NAME="query" size="35" VALUE="" TYPE="TEXT"> <INPUT TYPE="hidden" NAME="results" VALUE="50"> <INPUT TYPE="SUBMIT" VALUE="Search" NAME="submit"> <INPUT TYPE="hidden" NAME="rank" VALUE="on"> <INPUT TYPE="hidden" NAME="callback" VALUE="on"> <INPUT TYPE="hidden" NAME="mask_path" VALUE="uk/cases/UKHL"> </NOBR> </FORM> <h3> Or browse titles beginning with ... <br> <blockquote> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-A.html">A</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-B.html">B</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-C.html">C</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-D.html">D</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-E.html">E</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-F.html">F</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-G.html">G</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-H.html">H</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-I.html">I</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-J.html">J</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-K.html">K</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-L.html">L</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-M.html">M</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-N.html">N</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-O.html">O</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-P.html">P</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-Q.html">Q</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-R.html">R</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-S.html">S</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-T.html">T</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-U.html">U</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-V.html">V</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-W.html">W</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-X.html">X</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-Y.html">Y</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-Z.html">Z</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/toc-other.html">other</a> </blockquote> </h3> <h3> Or browse the years ... <blockquote> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1709/">1709</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1710/">1710</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1711/">1711</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1712/">1712</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1713/">1713</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1714/">1714</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1715/">1715</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1716/">1716</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1717/">1717</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1718/">1718</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1719/">1719</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1720/">1720</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1721/">1721</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1722/">1722</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1723/">1723</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1724/">1724</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1725/">1725</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1726/">1726</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1727/">1727</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1728/">1728</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1729/">1729</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1730/">1730</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1731/">1731</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1732/">1732</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1733/">1733</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1734/">1734</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1735/">1735</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1736/">1736</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1737/">1737</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1738/">1738</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1739/">1739</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1740/">1740</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1741/">1741</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1742/">1742</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1743/">1743</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1744/">1744</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1745/">1745</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1746/">1746</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1748/">1748</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1749/">1749</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1750/">1750</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1751/">1751</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1753/">1753</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1754/">1754</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1755/">1755</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1756/">1756</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1757/">1757</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1758/">1758</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1759/">1759</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1760/">1760</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1761/">1761</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1762/">1762</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1763/">1763</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1764/">1764</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1765/">1765</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1766/">1766</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1767/">1767</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1768/">1768</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1769/">1769</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1770/">1770</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1771/">1771</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1772/">1772</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1773/">1773</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1774/">1774</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1775/">1775</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1776/">1776</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1777/">1777</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1778/">1778</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1779/">1779</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1780/">1780</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1781/">1781</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1782/">1782</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1783/">1783</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1784/">1784</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1785/">1785</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1786/">1786</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1787/">1787</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1788/">1788</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1789/">1789</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1790/">1790</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1791/">1791</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1792/">1792</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1793/">1793</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1794/">1794</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1795/">1795</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1796/">1796</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1797/">1797</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1798/">1798</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1799/">1799</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1800/">1800</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1801/">1801</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1802/">1802</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1803/">1803</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1804/">1804</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1805/">1805</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1806/">1806</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1807/">1807</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1808/">1808</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1809/">1809</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1810/">1810</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1811/">1811</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1812/">1812</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1813/">1813</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1814/">1814</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1815/">1815</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1816/">1816</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1817/">1817</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1818/">1818</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1819/">1819</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1820/">1820</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1821/">1821</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1822/">1822</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1823/">1823</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1824/">1824</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1825/">1825</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1826/">1826</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1827/">1827</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1828/">1828</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1829/">1829</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1830/">1830</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1831/">1831</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1832/">1832</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1833/">1833</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1834/">1834</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1835/">1835</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1836/">1836</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1837/">1837</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1838/">1838</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1839/">1839</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1840/">1840</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1841/">1841</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1842/">1842</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1843/">1843</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1844/">1844</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1845/">1845</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1846/">1846</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1847/">1847</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1848/">1848</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1849/">1849</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1850/">1850</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1851/">1851</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1852/">1852</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1853/">1853</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1854/">1854</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1855/">1855</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1856/">1856</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1857/">1857</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1858/">1858</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1859/">1859</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1860/">1860</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1861/">1861</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1862/">1862</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1863/">1863</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1864/">1864</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1865/">1865</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1866/">1866</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1867/">1867</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1868/">1868</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1869/">1869</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1870/">1870</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1871/">1871</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1872/">1872</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1873/">1873</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1874/">1874</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1875/">1875</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1876/">1876</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1877/">1877</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1878/">1878</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1879/">1879</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1880/">1880</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1881/">1881</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1882/">1882</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1883/">1883</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1884/">1884</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1885/">1885</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1886/">1886</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1887/">1887</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1888/">1888</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1889/">1889</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1890/">1890</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1891/">1891</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1892/">1892</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1893/">1893</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1894/">1894</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1895/">1895</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1896/">1896</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1897/">1897</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1898/">1898</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1899/">1899</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1900/">1900</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1901/">1901</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1902/">1902</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1903/">1903</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1904/">1904</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1905/">1905</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1906/">1906</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1907/">1907</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1908/">1908</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1909/">1909</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1910/">1910</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1911/">1911</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1912/">1912</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1913/">1913</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1914/">1914</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1915/">1915</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1916/">1916</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1917/">1917</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1918/">1918</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1919/">1919</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1920/">1920</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1921/">1921</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1922/">1922</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1923/">1923</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1924/">1924</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1925/">1925</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1926/">1926</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1927/">1927</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1928/">1928</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1929/">1929</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1930/">1930</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1931/">1931</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1932/">1932</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1933/">1933</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1934/">1934</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1935/">1935</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1936/">1936</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1937/">1937</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1938/">1938</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1939/">1939</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1940/">1940</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1941/">1941</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1942/">1942</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1943/">1943</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1944/">1944</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1945/">1945</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1946/">1946</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1947/">1947</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1948/">1948</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1949/">1949</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1950/">1950</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1951/">1951</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1952/">1952</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1953/">1953</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1954/">1954</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1955/">1955</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1956/">1956</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1957/">1957</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1958/">1958</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1959/">1959</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1960/">1960</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1961/">1961</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1962/">1962</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1963/">1963</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1964/">1964</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1965/">1965</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1966/">1966</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1967/">1967</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1968/">1968</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1969/">1969</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1970/">1970</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1971/">1971</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1972/">1972</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1973/">1973</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1974/">1974</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1975/">1975</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1976/">1976</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1977/">1977</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1978/">1978</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1979/">1979</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1980/">1980</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1981/">1981</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1982/">1982</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1983/">1983</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1984/">1984</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1985/">1985</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1986/">1986</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1987/">1987</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1988/">1988</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1989/">1989</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1990/">1990</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1991/">1991</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1992/">1992</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1993/">1993</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1994/">1994</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1995/">1995</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1996/">1996</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1997/">1997</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1998/">1998</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/1999/">1999</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/2000/">2000</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/2001/">2001</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/2002/">2002</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/2003/">2003</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/2004/">2004</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/2005/">2005</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/2006/">2006</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/2007/">2007</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/2008/">2008</a> <a href="/uk/cases/UKHL/2009/">2009</a> </blockquote> </h3> <H1>United Kingdom House of Lords</H1> <BLOCKQUOTE><h2> <font color="red">IMPORTANT INFORMATION</font></h2></center> <p>This database contains the full text of many decisions of the House of Lords handed down before 31 July 2009 </p> <p>The House of Lords was the UK's highest court of appeal until 30 July 2009. From 1 October 2009, the <a href="http://supremecourt.uk/index.html">Supreme Court of the United Kingdom</a> assumes jurisdiction on points of law for all civil law cases in the UK and all criminal cases in England and Wales and Northern Ireland. </p> <p>The Supreme Court Judgments on BAILII can be found here: <a href="/uk/cases/UKSC/">United Kingdom Supreme Court Judgments</a></p> </BLOCKQUOTE> <P> <HR> <SMALL> <p>© 2002 Crown Copyright</p> <B>BAILII:</B> <A HREF="/bailii/copyright.html">Copyright Policy</A> <B>|</B> <A HREF="/bailii/disclaimers.html">Disclaimers</A> <B>|</B> <A HREF="/bailii/privacy.html">Privacy Policy</A> <B>|</B> <A HREF="/bailii/feedback.html">Feedback</A> <B>|</B> <A HREF="/bailii/donors.html">Donors</A> <B>|</B> <A HREF="/bailii/appeal.html">Donate to BAILII</A> <BR>URL: <I>https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKHL/</I> </SMALL> </P> </BODY> </HTML>