CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.thebritishacademy.ac.uk",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8f042ea8b8b23ffc',cH: 'vJj4XRiqWUpl0dDK7PvAxhrzoOTqWgtNIxFfsZRG0Xc-1733906556-1.2.1.1-Af6vs2v4MkyfsTWn7PtXSo9LwsuuLpqEz_f.W_KILxiPcekUjmA0LN9od_WIbv4u',cUPMDTk: "\/pubs\/proc\/volumes\/index.html?__cf_chl_tk=_ShaB4MPaXC32mmVwRC0N7qp0oRGsGnugmKneTosF6k-1733906556-1.0.1.1-c4HJ7Vnk3DGH.9N90ahT4Ah4h5WQ56eP7RMn1vdgMz8",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1733906556',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/pubs\/proc\/volumes\/index.html?__cf_chl_f_tk=_ShaB4MPaXC32mmVwRC0N7qp0oRGsGnugmKneTosF6k-1733906556-1.0.1.1-c4HJ7Vnk3DGH.9N90ahT4Ah4h5WQ56eP7RMn1vdgMz8",md: "fIqvp309wHsW0AVwLlCwZ32Gr446aS6WaLJaFUAisKw-1733906556-1.2.1.1-cNOyrkmcghOyMD.kwUK5bnEobfiMJRx2xlYSBdNM5r.XNYT8prgbHKDAkeIXEw3tj5D4ETXAtM3yjX132HZVugjxI2aXZ6XayslypggwP0ETegAhlGua8wZq.h3JQQYS.poZDyagtt12ynJ1Iu8IJhqVT8QCo55Z2Na2miw2.7Czk.5oHkkv8SCDAI1DfxoZEtRNUdOh.LWFLTMFdwl1QonyLUYGpmioBdDCm5WbBNjbMYm1H6IWbhPY4_5zbO_nUMH9lneSta4CVpwt5GbMaym0TQamzy5ZFTG_llzL6I9O5l7cG64D53.eg3f_mb98PXF1BXrczXzQKplMthEwwGyelAWIiAduIfy8Szi6qEQPz_1WZHcI8Sww4LAMuRA4fA.5xrSVfqTemW9MTzmz8kO48GlG3HiN_YuFPx3uJ.RY.Ydg271VF0jkF4bpa9_DoeMsYG0_GWbzbLjWb3zD3oMf1z6wN8jDv4Ohcro_c70m4J_wvuIivzhDtSVTiG2t0FcvylHEFmuGGD4jsW.1tD_vVACGl_QWp68DttGQ3J6S3lDhqlJq8zgYAzLzUGBHIa4hN4BXcAbC1O1lMlqF5yvW1UzrJLwE_9xTbvZDfuTEU7ATeH70Q5MsqzjS..z3D33DtIMU9_iDS0R89lH0822munKKwnfysh8e6UxraG83._1Sx97dR2m13wSGTIaINx_kHf8MX1aAQsMg9.FhVn0W0BwnomnhPQ9U0gIypIs7LLl0NalVG.Zuw3l4XOzAekdSTQsR88V9_19rV07PO5WtkePM0bV9BNn8kNxvznI2TO.SxmjI6TNMKqk.yq2ArIqBNYiVH.b6d5l6mRaSQG.EhBddlAo6QqsrGM1ja5ZOXkslnoGVbmquBKWQBIIYOu4eVy3Sog7vwUiVWz.lUWM6n4MJST7FCnbuoeH7JaJWUPE1zWySXRYUO31vxI1snofceUB3cdW56p30Z1RNXH8lWAwiBRG4eVaEt_HF40.4ifUYg1jdFMHi9NDPr8y6zIaLKLE5Buee6Fp98XPqI4HPSCABq4NiInySI6wKkYAvfPeRrBbQ4IEZX.szY4JL7eZCIxiY4ktZ8NIa0yI7kW8e5llTUm1hDmvzuC0OpAWtT6XWz6SFY0u6q5SMYveov2FfI4XlQtJ0PVZRj9XiBcSms_5V3bpbV4D_kafqfMtla7RyN6h5M1TImOiokIptwWtEjooii60w0ye.6zdIhAMnVPCvhr5Z7Te69GoY3m9.dEI3xBfsXVkC.jfbUVFoIAujRkaPpUyYu2dnNv23mXYg6jvdLW2Gh_PCriwTMAJW.BHh.UJYRymn0F3VyD6xeTfqtsxdSW7p.67af35gzfmiPL4eC0RKitgZhTd426sp9TFXjz4JHSuazt1uB9kqGwYVIh6pxjNDd3I45LZpRNi7euFk0MLnrWHcf3Zb3sa04CWhblm9YvavOTOlCrycXid9dVISoPMr19fdbYSFEJIzB0s4SmpNTfI0XDFsYnX1TKVngn8pETpuV9ZK1xPe7_yDMF95IdB6OSnwgUi.BhDQvUmM.NnuWp4K2PMpJVnwcm0dfauaK277DHBmEoCXrIG86cIjA5ztFxd50JuddRJx68.8J4eomFrtdOzRPHsFi0DDa8BNZq07lp4aVbpVk1zyulAwtVPY6jhoxjUDDgALaztWrMr3yoroWkrmzNvHVaygiBTwALx8qsjs4V4UMXh.neeNPm77C9qtWDgweqfEvHgvG8u_tJWTxan0Iey_c9KES60CIhIAEi4JIIkIkGbsc2cOQGslIDrYmy5GhhM5lRBKXSZK18k2Yn3L2w7QxBOqJKQC8TWh2lDiEBwXzU5bXaKQBtsseLa4LFmCKcAibdunm521PpDtHjHWeruY6EIh1aDjIEJIRrETkp9KSDqiu.PaciXlKuqkdxmMS7XOD20fXcBLVlwsuMDWqkWCzuzgcBzYZN_2_E3Szq9g.ZUR3jPXX_IgMCmt31PtHV6C.n7aV5BajitplXedmgYNUmkbNYraXnX5hC78eYiYVVrEd5.hR1An53w1f5KMbCagOun0lpWxVHjDPqzGtIYTNMcIaCEEnwsjNKSR8sguB5aNR7hAIWnR67m19peedwalbRyNU2HFzHqLEwb_dJy70Ei5HVUOnw2RcQMJ2lUMCgKBpBtYc3cu1OBWAE4mI7DeBlsqZIc.sEHfpmD991txH9HVVTyz6DNZ3JL.oF5QPrKgjOYq1WBUCiPrGpO0EvipdG1xRqVV71K08f7zs_viOOxFl6UV6PX_HZNKRUwnQiuk7gkwFhXd4X7m5XjxRV_MzGMbgWG3SGfSo4hoy6pf59UHX5uZfl7.skW2M6MFRv53ZHiSGFT4q0cjmn.IfLvUeVXqIaCg.nNElkxIsT3_kaEhSUWH5i08SEJI1M_CsVPF1tOgnAruxWfNrpHknmrvXf1.pQZYfRp6vPdrst14sNOR1uWmytxuwd7USPFtUlxlR0sMXkm4ZIPApvzl5VhbqL58diw3DDUN1ZS99dzpL1pUgTn2qlOMlmRcOA4Oj5N1GzZBXx8nYuOkusvD0IDOTW9tmGZZ_AgNyDWJyAPz7P7vt7rGFwh3mobi8EWWtWDsTOpwfZUS5W.m8IjVTIGTQWoEIJYCmW52GTPil003mUH0f76fKsbUNU4RMbGSZP9v.VhQl5f47ECNyFwr2xrF_gOIjJMDmsC4gCHg5kuxS7wwbDC1nQnusX.3MRjLWw72j.lQcgu8wrMEnB1uitkPloOEk.3daprT.aiMayvMVydz2CfBRXAlC19h.pEGgXOXIOjbv3SfRU5NMELW3lUdLFdewPNeYuS_2QQu1sqHFQJRDJgInY88T4Ix_JeKIxNBz5MHODluHtsahqZ.8.CmIRQ57sCzy_8E.FXWprMFkjoMHK2ub0zTF0OwxYRNQ_IKnws7zuKM3OBKffvHbQ",mdrd: "ixWxp2ujLBzf8al4KSg4sXmzQeXrWle.aVs1tptEryU-1733906556-1.2.1.1-3cyssNpCk9kG3fBB_sgqp7u5yjW1WR90JodHYzFxKNOO2vyuUyHGNSIc1D9N1FBIKMFAIrNHTVL7TKq_4iXoH9n8qdMXJ0L.4CZk8GHK2EUzj.QDehzr_eBMw3nR9wT4G7CoEBwwFV5zEyuQAR213XQlmf2con_TA2z1CmJCt48pL9l9DvMqpEDhrB9ghQ5fgg3Bo2SEv_xTgWH6m6B6_IbsGENzXbvOE7r6qUZbb72Ai_0VsJuOI91UG9v3_Ki0Z9jz9FdiN8YS_bwfhuHoc26WY7D72mqjUD1l9ibmCJSe.uxsW7553p1d_OQB1lwbVQWSsbv50HOpaYf7MjwfGaljh7iWuP9RE2ndRFWfc2M83uhlzN0EYltB6.cFUPJBaaRABMFqyMjGySYw496NJSSPKwoR6S09WFj9VjAcVZYO15QedjY6NVNOkIALqIJeuJ3TYi9db._df492x3VHBQLXQFMqR0pLNLzagwMbXUjHJgB_2Hc8fNQGt2KUxhXy5pmidDANIE4SZen1t9Iv0eTu1UxJSEnpAMite8ZKF8pkLQPxG90WtO9gW7Pn8hLlEV00uLRiWB3qTQ3vVnpNTi.jVi1DMhFhIYmoYQjPxQUABv_cfQcpx2KYoIfHbVKFsGdXRboNSUDJ.7fvss5zahiDAFgQ3Zr_DsZi.T5q9.vcWZQfMNkRCmfKROTv5iId25pABCtudire94mlbIMpiIKCxAHa4kGYYGH63F5_XmxHe3mPcBn7jGh3qskL48VPuT5I0kUa3qEZ6zU0i.pYNhK978oLmMdJDb_inPdGHdeisWeioN0M0qjScyEjGdg3X8EgsPBObWLdfLHbM6z5n0u91Ik1OEgZAaGTuuHykrBOaAQ0k.pn8mbTCU21hAudMt4uLs7q.P3iGasMkV3OzG8SsNuZ.OU78LrtwIzpCz1nD3.nxFm1McxDr.mn0An5V0w7LO67Dy8kp5BRjGvtHlqUyHTYTJhGM0rwfd9.R8xoUP8Nd56auyU5JUxQMs5Wr2UGVKMax5xroJ3gZ7lmXwy3HevCpTza1rPAFOFWDf_WiIRuB3LEr1x_KjHinXEWJRsSYok6ui_73p4u8yXC.vsavE8iuSBZa_KMwQcV6kRFS24Zv_zyHoRHarNcGWn_7x1Zn72mJuyLpCivRiYPeh.5OzqdYS8krsL6zuXIFy8KnmAaXuCqBnfzwUGTkWV_XcNlHSwx189.V4BVx82Kx2QMrtneKyc7vYPU4UsaNnKjFRsIxrKKMxdRt39518V.ntFq4.Sycbg___uMpglhJpXl07Lqvi7brx.Pkekau8rd8Yev1ueNq.OQxOSbTfzq54rWE.HK3RwC6TNJEBfIy._RLEheWGiTth4AiKf1mJHzz3VKjPY9UNrncgRoUAWcC.ySojfy4pZ1_ljiR1SqOt.B_sT3RiouSWqdTiF8UJpYuAejRCyopYxrtyGqZhsaN0yksjKgbACwe70K8Mk.XPl0jmOnrUwuS1j3107EHnrz0v8L_Dh1O70.DCw6RPLwG9AINdualxMe5snQW.l4NkVMRaZ6E.nnUL6U5FW41gDk3hK15nHTMw0eW892Q3R18szx295ZHYIlFXfn3vuz30RnY2rsfq_Cy6SC2SbmP97fAlL8RX5o3UtCHaVYsly2Nvvb7tF4wPfm8XEi_Ke46Xd3O1RmZ1fyeoekucyCQltI34qUoipiKwWaxoysI7IX7RlBEV1KLz6IrNcOAvsAV1MIF3UUE1LOZVmQms2nw_esOCZ4ttIlzmAJ07j64pFLMs0A1dl6.C1Fia6bmd1IEtY0QhUD5Kfn.zHz9VwirjJGyZgeRIdKJx.qMlH5UBr1TLju9Mjcq7Krqz8SQG3N3Fpx2eimaifxiZz_7lVGxxFokWQSw6mXSj9dqdBbNnljOXeQVV4._FDiPbNFDJKBUA8j2BJVKQqKmVn9LDHxzvT5cm1DY5O6Hp_BKr.cHCyEYX_jmigPzO5nQVhoe1WezvD0Lt4nUUjyj6xbrRkpeoE"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8f042ea8b8b23ffc';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/pubs\/proc\/volumes\/index.html?__cf_chl_rt_tk=_ShaB4MPaXC32mmVwRC0N7qp0oRGsGnugmKneTosF6k-1733906556-1.0.1.1-c4HJ7Vnk3DGH.9N90ahT4Ah4h5WQ56eP7RMn1vdgMz8" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>