CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="120"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "publications.waset.org",cType: 'non-interactive',cRay: '9133a480e977fce3',cH: 'zV.pzxpKt6AcmnnSm4dsL.nOOqNdIsquHGxMCEMtduY-1739772923-1.2.1.1-MsYPIZrS8RaWN5PBAHewosG5bc3A3yGm0k89O1n25uzN_y2SIw3eRc9_BLCFG4Um',cUPMDTk: "\/search?q=design%20science%20research&__cf_chl_tk=qQcz0UVR_alNCQ21pJZjofJIgMdZXZowZC7acw1orn0-1739772923-1.0.1.1-QePBOxXhOYAGdZ5I8asVg9U.8gcM3crlDlfO0Npz01Q",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1739772923',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '120000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/search?q=design%20science%20research&__cf_chl_f_tk=qQcz0UVR_alNCQ21pJZjofJIgMdZXZowZC7acw1orn0-1739772923-1.0.1.1-QePBOxXhOYAGdZ5I8asVg9U.8gcM3crlDlfO0Npz01Q",md: "z7eCc9Vlti3gHZOGNn3Bkle72Lf9HaaPcQea8E.wE1M-1739772923-1.2.1.1-mvZQXrhi9S4pa3YKoSSGW3n7qZtxWAUKaN0xuHxnzX7VKOcXtyv3a4MRH5ZUJSEuMVzQxa13dKQuWqs8LjVF1pGljzTuwsiigG2RqXej7RCCjnzIZhjZfqhQ.37MYz.uzPoU.u.iJ5ogbjMOgEMNyiID1kdgsGOTCOD3WyDC0VbsAVXTKiPWSh5.E1GkluIfx9OWrsQ5sVoxTAwRiYBx1U2o4V6kzNmE0DWAjERXA20aMg9mimu0QzmkpDAP_HXSuWb74FFDrPuyETYMdIG8jpyBrTdYG0Yk3j0KwiBlrLpeEYmkJ6fWVrn50eSgM4xoWB5sakmxrUyvQRLl2JUH0o.JiKaxH7VTeulFfpjvbkUPEtittkAE0vWLilB450q.sKQBW1rvoLlCsQC5iDwyEB35V3MABY6qW4WvpYTE8ee9seBbfWkhV1G.e45tfzliPwFrRJMf_pxQAzH83S.6UyUR8nj7sglkxPDcChD87mFhYB9Dvg8S2liDuazsh5JGUFsf5TgeB3DLJd5fwMnJznNeLmXQviPPBoHZV9vAnkg89TGPltZI9tnI8NMsBITmcKIDtLtmTPXxGD7IrKq3yoyp5HG8.0j1hR8sSJHgUdjRxqQhRkNgIn81iaJtBy1I2T9ylIg4mlsmNpiat3tYTKt_Lt6zS.frMr6qHOnYYSdF77hHQgH.rCHArfCDFOoNUkB4EDpkh2XG2ziyfcO7Pv159ZD2vGj_t7f4U3MpLNpT6.sLAFBwcWHxoe.vD4JJG_BAxYL4jsleMiiRerxfMCvh.Br87iHcHnnj_Yr1goViRID7HQedgXPZEocg7L_0ImVU9pngeT.GnOSV1z9GzOYEeY3RPIAknjT6vRuBgOBhGXHN4ydMSba42lq9UTVDZVaCZdvaN4O.V8Kbu4oce_hrzQ62TnpxfFbcDbYeyoeI4J88S8rWdr0Td_W0qJ4OZC9_397kz.9xkouRpttqJwUFoi0Cja0l_8.HnEvC.lKlSZslC5zH8JqyleHVnRf1G.FMB.uZ.lyzcb9XxijTgxaIoCie0Jl42pxbKv4sJVxfxNvAFLS0p67a1Ftms8w0ufaDbU.i7lwaC4FsHrwHYr84diMUv2GtXsPCjfBVjY9.jBqktsBUCH9zyDcBKM_HqihTnSJsQxUyOQJjL31D6vlR7xRRqm4GjevhA28s_We.lblL7Wxzl72C4agZI4Zd3_Mws0bJsKshA_5U9RL_yTcN1sSD4T9ngRb9HqhQgy3hb8rXvqgK1Iw9y1Sb0vjJ8ldn4TwYRcgWYgTYrDjOuyKKozgmoc78gATyPuPB2tSs79lHv7GObZ.mcAEB1b6LfNQrGyhF7BpWZAKrWIKApFJzKjXQIiq8mLWz5eglI4uyfEfCS9bERnPh1bbeHKiU3SDohXtba3eTjXMIgsCRYK8MhDXxuNSTw.VKIAv4czG8J8T3SwS_AS4yZdA4ZQF1mx3MznI_2tXMjLXcuS1U_Jc_PV3JEozykbUrMrtbUn3ZLgytvKIVSXM2SDXE7uZuOMgq4Dm.591u7zzVFGvn9go6uHQX5V6BL8VudoP5cvi0GHGh4KsBQ3Ek7NBI.woRI9opJWos3gXpv3Zu5NIJXTTrwmevCx7oF8yK_ekoNj5LuXO7vHaCP0HDxmY2Rdc5rImigHPeNjBnbmbXJuZCjU8fClK1XIpvDDQl_STZ73iGC6K2fCpy5aTkxRyThulmfqAUoNf39qTOMl4CD6R6Mf.uX.Kd5il9FM6IemIbA1F568jg0aqfwB8sjX96edkTz0_FM5x2j7aDvYkeFN40pyDa6V4szfnXD0LqdvaluyShF1ACvqQ1Xkn9MdkVbEnnoAHRQuDA8NHFx1lL16ShbPqITeFS1xmVYe7AuYoCIozqphUbekKPNLV3KjOZ6R_8bkwXNQeILE5.mqHmH4AJmrCeo9aTVkPNI3M6Nh2qDSw",mdrd: "XAICrW4Tbmrq2V9YX8juZLobqt.QGTT422HK6Kxkgyg-1739772923-1.2.1.1-MPWDcmcVFqFu1GeX0OxPnWnShwo61m1v5gvOH9WDskN5i93kh033RA_nfmBZvXhJZHg95qqEpnp0HCTZIa3rxBL8FVS4ns.4eeLd18V2YZ.6b0GDTvg5Q36CodJL4pE7_.tp_88QTZB_QEUDbC6Y6DViSUINkuxARjHT37iFIxgOZQqNqW50zekRVMpP6DU_kwjnTpBaX6UX62YwdChRSqODfFa5hinwMZrLHQ4052ommYm4GXmIKWNfAuJzrSGRYLNiX3uUtrF8i2VsEKuzgNmtJVZ2r6wj6BbjjJQ3jWlKl.lwPTvZGSGgY5EH_SLJBrnic08_veFzrq8L4Y6FAGWVQ.Qrl7tr1sBQEFBn6LxoK7XEo_otlnZ3uYXOw7nWZ5o4EZMzKQR3MQXGm_hr0HEyLTXQoU5BPpYXk1Vp7_jphY.RbS2GA9XewEWbUI5RYqT6lT0Wjc4VQSSpEVKGM6eJoAV1jTbLiztVL4oedZ7ONsj9YSMCO5mZQNnsa9v1dGbXIMwbXgaaDzacmVUVMO_KI.FysTn1tuUNcjC9u7I5ClJSnEKmHlmq.QvqfDJFAMMX5vtY2KCBbq8ynWl0LCjBqO1u4Bk_5DkE9Q5Yo9dbAtCIeceL28.sSN9ru3SI2EZoQp7rVg25n2Tn9OM4Wffi7xoR6YdQDlbEOKolRPAC5YabSjnIk1TLAT6BKh7uMFWfDYfYlUtm8pUqOU3fx9I3n90mbNsHiyHgvom3C6ube8xObgIf0LbUoEq7AVT2aci2odWfiM9Q9NLJzgnCJm_cTvKLngbwwzxekKK8ZI8WQrxkfAZG_Oz4qlnxqZw3_JJZ6ncp9XoCxFloPS3XgXDsDgDy_V859SF2Vf5yCYdxW2M.RNxKjUf9QGLiuOHuK66n6s7OXSIzYtFMuUdkr9pwReru8ebCBlJ6BiyMc2FUxyqR9QxAXa3JzvYr2CvaulZ6wrhzBkRypGqKXv0lCp1ta2AuWz3S7SOEwyg.GaHvvZXHOr.G0di4ENs_E7ivbrOUS8XY5RsO4zPLICiKh6ztShIWAoOJJGRPLbc9pE7Sq322foL1bwT6q.UzL9tVJMPSh5E9xULNcV4fOQa.bHqAMfpqIqM_MArfKmWScRL_qvC99vWB2XAbThyL1tClG2RpNMzXGS5k6dQpUmGigszkBcyB7p2Pw.nuTHiUbazdG2fFRYpJY7goCwvpiHOGp25x1huj8H.FfrsoKA_F6xgF0BVrFeCm4rs3Ynpefec1oTiQVN.gvrvcR3ErPne_ttsJHjAg1EhoalD9YiSSsmEZHAxSpiBOBhoIUrBLqW9FOTDK2Z3vEyinslR9_g0zWKLJ6I0ByCZFx8dXq88NlvIaHdfpEjFK96YcDdYdkRBQHDI6QEMpXG.u9uCloPsjwQrx_jTUadAdMOMmmKjpGPqZmFIu8tUx0iiWqGz.jH0iYAPygX6dVJvenKX1AyWONZ80Z.KPm8reEtrow3bWbwY1IP075TOJu30YMKyWAZVPgygIzs6_mCTxXJEYWFANNabc9GISpj7Dg8qANMxGYLnNW6sTmWljZKYON9gZnbnu6mQJDPZP5a6T1SH9wB08Yu91l4VvRtTXXU3BEPitv2ZQrzjSoW38gpK000UQaRohmR_E_kxkdS5rj6dyQZKikbldN1w.X80Vj_bfO3wFJ0yz2MzbGw_pxnxzYd20l05nEJhHkQLMPnFqh1_O2coIVm94dyyrNNl2x6OIS58zHZ5KohpFzpbRGXNXhyrkyC_NWsVPqPOqTGs3YdwFX8UeoMh7rgMoB8Q0pQdIWV91ee3kK6hyNIZBQCJ8TrPOz8ucTf3Kl9.sCksWklTlC7.x.FQTQLF9Bze_tJl_TOwL2NzYrp0hE_AXq2q32NG6hcMnkRvUSLkRyH_WWVujONgvaE8d21xdfdG1eAG4wSMGq.YLu6da8DP3UyocnPT2kbNvhvABzsLJHWYYcx9LDOkjT6tv77TFTJuZjrQ9UgneYA"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=9133a480e977fce3';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/search?q=design%20science%20research&__cf_chl_rt_tk=qQcz0UVR_alNCQ21pJZjofJIgMdZXZowZC7acw1orn0-1739772923-1.0.1.1-QePBOxXhOYAGdZ5I8asVg9U.8gcM3crlDlfO0Npz01Q" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>