CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "pubs.geoscienceworld.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '918ca8f38842ab62',cH: 'iT0U7T41bA6ve0aQcSIMpe2Tu9GvCM5_Uyk0tdl7N6s-1740706337-1.2.1.1-A4jvj53YnpIl0aGot_W7JRQyMq0D.b2Sltwnd99sTsveyaAcLoKDTwU5w3SYKb2o',cUPMDTk: "\/palaios\/article\/12\/4\/380-390\/99661?__cf_chl_tk=2gfABoMMoBFxL7AY.tShs8RscL1ookPfCEDD_45jfVM-1740706337-1.0.1.1-WIxcpT45yTQNcl6EdDSJSS1dFnDhknSq7euxS3CIJpQ",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1740706337',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/palaios\/article\/12\/4\/380-390\/99661?__cf_chl_f_tk=2gfABoMMoBFxL7AY.tShs8RscL1ookPfCEDD_45jfVM-1740706337-1.0.1.1-WIxcpT45yTQNcl6EdDSJSS1dFnDhknSq7euxS3CIJpQ",md: "75tv9B7O8aeHVFVHd3YXOzym.Qsn3r7DzuJqd4yFIww-1740706337-1.2.1.1-ilbeRlv0CIKsKFSg3G98sFOkwSKXS2YRBL7xZR2A9YfC1F0EWbZjSFPAEtcnTj2uqBQeqV2enqyf.8SG14sn_frG3yYBrcQ0yv3iryBtLZ331f5whKeZCOIXSOATYBlIo_.vGQRJgTS8ohDpAnd5kodmArU2.ubke5iWuVIKfxX4n1fR45q0HrVZyU7u30Hl2GQCab_FOIwhkG.CWKGPyfEG4_M5qq45fPG7JZD9YqHSeRcq.NExWjGj.KZXBVnIGaF7JNdKZx1duSRY2fXWxfTGLIqiLrfVcJPZDh5DUWAW4Xbs57gbrLl1gsaaTzLoeVJvzmWT8PptrTmO8R02LAagY7WtNi7qryAwFmaD1_.Qb04OruES7Ghys1Jm960bCAq1mV371DKD7jC6n_cGXLjAFJx4iC7hrPAMtX8rBxXMRjfJn_51L7cA_fDb1uklx9NsJhIvwG2vx7dAF3q9fOS_.kWX4.yYGb4gtFr1D50Cg5LRcnkJkBiyTNTpLlI6sjKn.K5Rs9C1SIhWMuH0KkMlIgJm3ax65WtS3D0PKS1RVRgmYUUsVr28WSo3gtg5SxN__zOMRi_SO5eWxLs_Zm0xMRg0.URrrj8mXcjTTWfrrJIQD2W.orV1rtCnKdFWuI6W2m3Mq0ciHekzGUuVQvGJ0J7wrl2Dr1NaFpqwX6PnUt.iF1LE4GceO7X0A23bueAk9bYa13GAKMMQw2Cj4YbKwH3q6b1BJHRqPOw9YitailT6kfaScssldMNXIkMkz.gQEZ44OMBamqsR7nu5CTagKRHywkFHN_4B.ukaSW9YpF9VUVzkcSgA7AvDbKqezYXZwEKarAIrDfIDrnGdrkRxZWQizjhMrEA_c5cg7qSgHXpV2LkPQfSM0YdBO6ZhBclv30Z9Iugr5XdUKWAgSWhY5ApoTlHXa79fa5ph0DoAusg1KhpDwq9wVW_DCCMXF2UvO48eVO5o0C.EciMH3gsrKFRGfV6TjwvSN_m.baaUPgMBm2QcCC8iZdVHoAHekL0wjV_MRMqKRo3zdc9P8uE4Ai.hLbBySOJbdoQ8DzDQ4nZ1B_XjjAKBuokVAEW83XEoWZtuuUVLhmzOEQF1XK7PbnLo3Z9DhgLoAK2wvW_lT3Cgdrx4q2KsQUZu1D9X5d8txqD0j0V47enEKDsX4iaOUmvurqz4_Ckr1QJTalbBjZ5BVg_CLvLBxbbsZXEaTlLgru8K1k_McD0wF0Hp_n6WP78Zc6dzyOwqtNDoMWiHng8cDBqjhEhieZE4Rs7ywH9TOWH5OyvYx5vGNF2fFjhBNBDH3L1lb.RixpHS3ckU5ZVep8NhgGoHbxLZNN5xsSceP.vUDfpctH2EvJslgXW4OeV7EqF.NVzv8.Ztk0p_hQ7dSgEjofkyMDKZI3XtM5FCmsPQkmjjSC.LRfFE.bpKJZ7rYoD4ohxyWbmqSOuRMVotucouziCDih466PKYUKAyy45h7xnRUxKZCbduSiPBfcI4e344WWQZbstTcfceoahG8NB44T8bjYbVLYzU.DxqjEZvxkE42C3dQoYcdv31tYYyxxZqaWSE3HT7Fzax5K3WNOQXwpOHV.mSxW3k29sYjP7G4bBEnmyoiN0VOaMrDCFH.vvm28ygCs4HtLnZgZ2IEx7HFYdg0TC9BvfPrvCiiqfOJslkOvp3LaIUCAfXaVYEN4ODVy3B3E6srX2buhTEdF6P1MG2He4cyF8XPTrMt_uVKLtxHcrYvwOncJeV1ki.vjst967cCPpggZirHqIfuuaXav7P8WdAgIGxYs.JmYCG02DES2pMpEaCc6W5puA5ZKRRTZ7loAM8tICGaKrfyAB.tHMU7TrgSOyEdgQcD7zxg2EdKF4RGzYCC.cXKqBlo8jIU3AI8_h7ol9hqejaRgwnAT8bHO9QdDyEv94VHF5x05Bg6op.Yo7HxF08uHAWCnlNBrVL8NJmsJAdU1nxmhqGGGraWQP6M1PoI4zoABnuUt5ViE9Txh8T0iJqV8jKnz3uh7NTmqYGeonqUFDbvJH_a8Z6WPP6XyF7mQ8ZwaXxjvun6WsEelUYh3ZMpysfeUO1CPWlqxgkQXNYxNLr3DNH.FqGqBkcLqZSgYhc3FrECFiMZuekohJhVUq_qg9kLAKV3aXKc1xL7e_CUYGvUqgKg5NGISyB7SYyQZNGm6d0WDrpXXjIZKciAGx.50tcfmler3TnipeM1b8eHRxgT4QV22orGKlpbbr1qgHRbAx_LSboDvIAd9TD1jxhiuiE1PZH9yWn801RVdYybxG.t.bz.wj7yWzQXdGXCfqmnuVYA5tKWbGRqpK0ihr1MEXEsgwN8TnN6RnbceLChPqrfQqlaAj4QGAhvxst9PMrFk7px8IrDVPiEaw8aWJrV2eBFS5sLdP.y5PXo9x0Wr3VtPyYBSBwPP.Ixa7ho82BlsnYZBYoAebP9w61PcMETyEYIYh__b82U9UyCCCe.6qucPk9BKN8v4e1PPNGZEQAevtBSLla32HNlOOkc3F5VGoAK2_l29Uz8RD5NOy_FJBuUIdgol.5A199OsmQKjw761_2HU893gH6TSm.Y9ajop3xKctSEtCOm5gqjcJ4bjVEpOK7QOquOpuP2tLI",mdrd: ".sn9b8F3JskG9TkqoBda5SVanjTQQ23wXr7BtsjDhSI-1740706337-1.2.1.1-p8Ahhd_3XcG7704FqLETP6fkW2S0zE.TdpXcWevGIqoSjIawufJnBhfgy8MLoYxoTOF9ExdWvicaZFD8zb0CUPlbNjf4oBvHwtcrYD4LmFPVwmxwnarrbdjODuAtNoxm.sulbh8l38x1USbLptzfMZI.xx7T11yRnRVtroPlY2.baM_FUtRSmERsnT1jCYvn0JQaqmWcQuXo5UM_1fjFb4WFf2XzKJunTeB0ZxU0gO2zggZizeNRrIUHrbnRqzoO3zuuXH0gOAuiNQFuMB19ZERq_8qcSI.oynrFIPuzAiyRrGfmc919UuZYpQFDqvO3YiOuUoR9n._lIZmj23aIOs_tGSBOdxINvFxfiRaHYLcuAtn3krgn9BSXZSblquu_klKTS.x3i0RBJZjaRY5Uw2mFkPV9mYdvAMqWfOezbEp7ymMFvdXmIlBfB_3qYPYZbZ1095wIV1pSiKbZI0cQHU.C6iy0SGwq8n3696G1YyTm9zuQEvDnLlNXuZMx.ND3Lc2SoeXhPF1uMq9A4hi.KEGpfAE_V521Ku0S82bK.wgG3mr3Ed8AcOcbNk03H_5jfUhB9dG6UUIQuklHPcXBxTl9U.9lJkomyTaKmd0k.99xD8UZL5AxbUXmLgIeBHjoCVDXgp7bH7_dso4nUDnprylUrfVcIYLaQWAc5xr30ZOqn1OuGYi5Fmt6ObAFIX.vVY8.fUg9RWrQoBEpskRTRihezN7EDfzI8IqkrS4tx1bqFrOlnnykG3BGE25PXn4ex4GZc6QRBcWsOSJuMrTD.aPf51.eFpjitwvgh_WoH5A8mgQb2reszKlAjHsBN_264da0vplSRiI1l_fPM33H4_9WPR4V9uuita5yS8pDuJQoFoBEaieweWD6CfbS.E2HrZ.0zizjpV4vS8EvaP6_k9sNpa7elQmeaZCffi7JIlD05Lk9Qi2QhX3YtxmHTnjR_YfIEB1gCbfELFh1pVIqebWdKpbZYEjaWLuHozOLEneblQxDnVwyaCdLgZx_GRn5zyKf1_QQ4744o1e0abfjicDnAH_swS0qrMIYDNfpqY8_.XXU24aGNQuy9PAlGKxS5y8wLEdeDj0BTbARYZS.FWemivNYP2GhYemBGdAAkIs8WvJK1x_lHzP2tmDlIoH7vRTnJMwqrJDaVeuXZKjzuzqBSfsmXRcp.gsXWIyHsrC.PwUGWDTDiqVf4ZSYikzzZsmwZ1lfjBm.cX_8hCyq9XLOT2222OoFkVTXAcjP0ACxLvmkFVewuCBdwQ2HpGf7VWsnTck3sJDbFc5h6ImFxB512iGYV3LOKGRlkyOgWqs0iwsx19aECDXPwV2P8hf0tAOL4QaOM8vSvJy_zrIljYBFkLtT3UeBuZqGF7pqR6L4U5eyRcGo0JsUMfSl1c1EE7m_GH.UYsN8ltA3Dr_Eal2qKZg.JuYdOy_IuzbmmtLs3Qv3GbK2gymILpsKCYh0U2oUdHFy7__zdVN5FgVsroSSvZrbN58q3_Jtbo3jvWYqp8YZDHfBFXyBWHKwWHV4vMIq1w6b6lCQFVDeT9UWbQAy5_DbdhovC8ZWecMI5nXFB1Tk8LZlsJ6tDdROuoA2nUvLh8V6SzOg3a7LaHODqlGfTR6zmKmjjVcZdxOhVTQP0.T0NR41ToZc1xdCGZ1.4pRegepfY9KO9DGrCvkbwb3Xk4.BTUzLIv.ggmeBVqdSessp.z..76GUrL1r1gcxVloyFT4aTObHsa87wv_4XPQLO_fuSufUD3o37oN8hu6SnOwy0SChMtfMIgJsf78UWxSVPqZQ91yTXvwtwkKcmilXN7b4cQNBun8a3RImnMOUlerd_M6FynXYAV6zmNLwV5q57G..VDU.fafq5cwE2c9DsMMutJuROAEUZTqXpNfzGNjwl4wrBYZLkoDjwQSVVitAOZSgd6eM9kjljbQMwFdd8p2Y.3EFQSLN9pyy1iKNTHzSb1VopxCyMBpPdMeMWhXQkgfi5z0ju2_kJkNDgw"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=918ca8f38842ab62';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/palaios\/article\/12\/4\/380-390\/99661?__cf_chl_rt_tk=2gfABoMMoBFxL7AY.tShs8RscL1ookPfCEDD_45jfVM-1740706337-1.0.1.1-WIxcpT45yTQNcl6EdDSJSS1dFnDhknSq7euxS3CIJpQ" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>