CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.science.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e7b79e39a6d9cbf',cH: 'wGS5kWZa.UTONejOQLIye2ORc7TtjGoUCjowk6Fc9U4-1732473088-1.2.1.1-WNs6aZH0Omm_23qCLfG3j2KRTC2W.bApYjMG8OpdXVyT9FU7Hhy3IksKD16Ebhxg',cUPMDTk: "\/doi\/10.1126\/science.271.5247.348?__cf_chl_tk=yZHt9J2P7Md_vR7j9OBB2Y5DrAaQryJcA.E6RTN3bwk-1732473088-1.0.1.1-OjrPNhl22oJukEME7SHS0YNPkFF12MV7zzY_CIgqYPc",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732473088',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/doi\/10.1126\/science.271.5247.348?__cf_chl_f_tk=yZHt9J2P7Md_vR7j9OBB2Y5DrAaQryJcA.E6RTN3bwk-1732473088-1.0.1.1-OjrPNhl22oJukEME7SHS0YNPkFF12MV7zzY_CIgqYPc",md: "ZUxxn4.Bdkr0K5Hio0Vv00QJG4WGgmIcREsHsJ7RhJU-1732473088-1.2.1.1-IDzDgU_pfyRHWftAugrDRr00.tC.fh15wVj9TGfWukN_tjWwSioRhwn2Dp64Q35f998q4dUGCm9zTmxNVI2smQJ6zbq93epl1UegMzcaVDvmMUQ0ApFgdBHvfwlQpjU4KV0eV4EKVjf0b92ivaBa9NCNR4zXdDQx75sAYAADNVcO5GEM9tmU6Cp5lWfBNr0ThLAwNEgMVgxRq9VUCXZ61LYYrOWWuHwusRmaedsvM3poBOjtoI1m40MWC0w_fEnMTuhA8fnw9hMpa0yZg0G8kqCXjkhH02OUfBk2j44IQqMzGrQ9UOPLlhhlZSpY.6HUK5I00KNCTtgEdl85TI4nhnCJpy5dZT2gpvZfJGzidIB4ym4VlMo5wOpFlceQwymaUwgAkwEW7gYSZG7MqN5SBzNx3ouCeYcohy0fpGCoayoAnkcdajwN4sO_tkc0ZQ2fuooGBcHtwiBQOQobzexCEj4.Q1.9bcdktkR87XbOrPHyNlhfQrstrx6L4HsQRKM31MmzFb3M.QHoVq_wUpw3fLN7Z5aINlPLS9ijU4rD_qXpHqdr3UxxdGc9dbJrrEQ0dWnBFmAHJ4jpC41TxkJ4UjP6ZVA1HGH_Wfe_kDzuQWP17_PKQ_SR5aT3bGhyB2Z1R2.caKJbUFdidGvCVe1O0IswknA4W5yHY3Dzm4_KDocFatXbC8wGySzCluYeDOS1J4smQ49D0HQALMjLlvD6rNPn.Gl_KMlOR6mdJiew2aimky1nyrX8vDDWbVvuwGFslKjPRXcGoM5eZSIsh2KjC96cTA1I67eRR6Uiad1o5ffwMO.djCVzcpUAjW2CsNBtvIqKxk7sGgFlcZIOgdRYYqc2pIMnAjPgp7QETc5bNdJBqujC4DFPf.NB8SP9cu2y3uyNPmlK4Qa5CifUqAD2dUoIwwzcEk.bA_JjydtsCy37GdP.v6vDK5uXZhqqm1lBkft9vVfWX17JvoqbD7FQlErmyvL7v5VNmdYZoDfE7HElTf_1sxNOwC6AWXIk.HlRlhF_qJq1sPDPmBbIgg.sXNMGhAQzs_57cXsuT.iDPdty6TtmaRzpRHEdHlaA0nsbvXdqf_tkl5LumDqHolEinCt19x70UZTErUZwegtRUL3TuMqiPwLJ6tLCAKLCANSjqei8_AY_LWbzR819ATFOrL2L2VT32zS65EUThKndlVCGiaVHPUX6NizBho6SzY7UFY..PEFlxuefm7ucsT0ajMnahheAXVJ67CMYODYoXKtbLVAJTY6cxENxUwnogkKjU2P6.ZXf6ZfpX07iS7MKhExpDMkZNGr2ox86BvtlrYcoxYmPhNMI6AlSkPK6IrZ1nH3efcT9bQX0j.XrdSPPdRefzYoejoocahXqt_RlreKC0IdGUHeI6F4Jt4EslO7qSC9Mh.9d4tGlVyPj2r_ZligLS8cbdrfInQTxzssZgp3kpqXW.nWrE1gIeoAi9gkyDRTbUsk9nRNP0leQidv0fGOwlZkzX0uaupBo.RlqLDzx460FZpU08.RTP9KzQeRmWU7xYMMd1FJrmS09QbjVwHtWQdKtUa9pSF1YyjGM80tLF2rheYe9VB2CLjiaVVbOIXKCkv03tIJnbwGWjk5OFrobYbdorRds_XvmKM3v1p.U1kDxpzFLalzGXfESXjcmVuT3aASdj9lHKIW344e.ueESHwcgJVWH1wFmBJBOqvZzaDlHrwOzCyXvHExcstdwWLLRnWcUHwX9qz07hNxy5PuYMZNIaN3.6G82acdTWlMUEYmKf3.ETlQ13EyzKQj8s7EuOPBzNG3.dCtqHNp47K1mIqNneey.6zGboxUwtcIRIgXxoTtvCdnIQhd.QNB1l6QZk9XzFo8XDBV4Z5ZCDecM7_KiOI3TWeyf8g3iF07q0MqecGJjHajG1TKa6XmJn9hiPnP.uXGOKtuCzsCPk30mAHSKLkzxhroVn0_FS1qld2Q7_XaPFOEPdKk6ppVcsje6d3O8ZhZMerfnLxSyQO1_KACLp3lL4QCw4X5iUbW69VsqD.uWzFU5B0nw2cIaFnKnO6SU9jCHW7t_hXVSq8X3.bBDFiTVN1fe1qPgfdEoQQkEErfNdsDgiUftSqRsft0MJxPbwRFQT9RkaqOJhG0tGGKqr.LTdfIngEx50jk1OaUgBbK7LAAYvnVZaSc4m.JYx9PUJ2SnL1xZJrTIId5ARukg_gjXp78WKO.edXaUEQuvNfJDmcO8R6dkL0Ild6FspId9Gw8unnafukRkeruuYaPeF9X4UVUwYDTcdHJwMAaxoqrKQkCY90WJnpxKXbp.crvDYC_7jnMiXRWLk0Nj8ghtcT11DcZHW3nR.cc6DX9CQB9XLdUNyYAXHZ6DHU2sFW291WqluJzar.XSXrqOvFE_NftA7eb1rnAVZIMOwM5bRLxjg0PJyzcPc4PyX6z7e9HCldow_NXP6N_9ZUfv9tK4Aa0Kwq0qe5JfxHC6TX2TPZ_p8pGQQ.oJL2IZezaus53DxlUuD2dRgvkMJbJhaODN9BPRl_u8rMbvC1JC5OyutTumdL5fsSExbP8pV0orIzJGjxEFI4wQzAGkuF1oM12pZwYYVDc_HcG5qzR40Aeprk1Igmy1Q.lH.McvCYSXnxXQ.Hw6x9thYjMzMk4Ks5t76NxJiL7GAkrkIzBDo1j2LR8dcwmiyYJ.Gm12_tvOrixJIxI8UrNeKC2KNPV0YfeKQ5RPliB4CR.W.ovrVkN5AUkThs0nWyINOJCNXTAv2.WeU3fcT795bdvNHmz95qAn0XIpW5rsXKA8QZCoh8_SLntiXsq9AyTQ0uSp8nol2cZXXxXy7sD3UKmVjlhpySfazAQXm77uMoK1bIcP3hYf5uhQDf8pDTxEpfJpQyaKBAPUvVe7Bf0dKptTYSHvuYuyF9kPo966Q6jZICeoMNZkCNHKdbueU3dtzOCXT_UtP2UfrQDJ6MTpCBCDJO5UU6Wd9_vTgqP9a3scYMi9J.5obtYK1xMVPhFyb8Xs",mdrd: "Ja7cKOGhtC4bjXtJXdgbGX_6yl05B2is5jWYhJgSco8-1732473088-1.2.1.1-he5SsFYYR28TwzXggvbG0tOSeOi.u4wcwS3I7gPSIFf2WGbtXUI4qW2DQzNP5E00FlU74L6Z_MVl2Lt5xZ8vH8iQ_qkLAVFWh0KUAvxpMiQYt_jGLIoKwV5y8tl.vKZnnjv2xMk2gJSF26gZlE2qgg.B5irDJLlJUTzERUnZH4dfdGfwyM8xpnaQzO5Ty7r.K2hRXDstedhpJmq7mM48wbvLchRnBREFsk6ckfqhYh5hhRQXim2fIttf3YrdhPqBjkR.uxO45_09ANyXkmpxo7JZQ8n_aeQD6X6GW1.fv1pVJbQK1RnCoI99NIpKl99T187dPA6UmbO9MzS6m995Wg8LRCCcqTGLtiXxJeZXPy7JSbzBDbhPSAK2DjHDNHIVYciccSWPpUAgYXDbmaY9my_ldeWBW_C6e7PXg_6p2xxdCU_lY27zCprwQfkebmqk7agym9MqgCh4nFnV4qk5jukivID2ZcqP10ivgZ4eJUCKLuarRJ08salcmfZbmCqWTV.moCrYcYGnARW0PdX7bAxkm.ecauuUbxrEFJjyRB7qOpUmaoVv6IPlVpov51AocLy3pDOo9rqkXKAgTg3adrajU0neroePEp7zsFq9FN0467rMTt7Fqjf1JBRgG6h5aCLUuE2zZU9mU0mqvw6q.WTXIGrkL0g8upBut_71xEMOPSFpeE0IrWUh1sMuomjtRdxAf.Ura7p8gvygvbWOZT7tjdGaG7t4vToT8tAiQFMKBc84H4JwnzF0EvOJaH_5rjqg9rALX94hWl92..AYdJmOhsp.G1DSTiEtZw2KC9bOKdJrJJpqNnneRpsk1hJwdsDvveWGJa0Uq5ZmKrueuRLoEIPDTo5NTkhNNemlgi05gNnTXcoIVNxiwDtQzrg7IxbOH2AWcYv77..H287Me89L5cP9CI1z_Xq1m5oLqkgV_S8TOhOl4DMWPIQMjEU1IiXhuJlUiDjCZx3S7pDruXxHHM6gP4tfUERwPJYJHjzDpfz0PnPy_HLMH6xSf5TgVCdKuJOuNQfxUdJMV8y6XyRMtHhzw277E3EKKQKv5k.KADO2qS9MesNrF.k1lgWDjWIdEbZm88JWUcyPWgvfaUhE2igFbr.lShXaBJlki3oXZOJuXynLVg4F9mCmwy5v9MmKB5JL7Bc0gsCvFKJf565Cx0TNtRKzPHTT4SroFIv0T0iFBDhRO3DeF9xNUL8zP7reppRkTqQAt7oECBA.vd2FmngA4rf4vGkKrVdbyheFi8scjFmgtuDHVMwv.j5SdjB5kO_8h8bYDzfTyw_Tm14sZWvasRghvIXEt.CEldgcXdokkTu81cIXJLkuABT5oljZfej8utIV7df3DoQJpk3ZlPfQEQpFcG5u.QUO.XbnBI_Uy2ruQ_QTpY9AcvrAVAYHRx_VfIdJ6eHelvBfwTJUE56NEz8JHVXLzAwlUIVLwCnJRE.Mdhg4SLNtxoq3ROEVTQ2FLfGtOkkwBdTcHfi55kjTkd1ZHUKIj2RLb7YCVz0yi1j21YkHRiLBNvaO33eGCumlpm420El_3dOA2cSrryEhcuOCb9ThDOWWPV.UumWGngKDv5NliDGuewocmQDQiDg7M6fIxhd8.mAG0Ct6skPInT6whPA9e1OknO0ClKXmpBGZ_YyafUdjfqCbXc8abACU0jxvqNwgbone_ywyjp8PNTZDubSxtwsgATNfYMHbaIlHPu8dNiPIn9quH.9iOJLlsAnwfEgRer6ThUVKKdZKSanS13ysUsMRf_oeGNLEhpd9o9GFzfeaxhxo4CpjLFbw1fhmpglXHnhtPTnUMWaIHACOqMZzyoyrJtV8C4xsJeHbKDr84MkL2IXekwub0PGzLE0fMto0_hGTszykyrGKutdxEkhC9SI.bOnMzPhZ1Yh8TRZFE5HXJA7EgQPbj0yM_cQ3Qb_B3WD6.XYtpF7jsmnkJZvev0l3EGgd0g237qSgEXNtXS5s1FLg"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e7b79e39a6d9cbf';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/doi\/10.1126\/science.271.5247.348?__cf_chl_rt_tk=yZHt9J2P7Md_vR7j9OBB2Y5DrAaQryJcA.E6RTN3bwk-1732473088-1.0.1.1-OjrPNhl22oJukEME7SHS0YNPkFF12MV7zzY_CIgqYPc" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>