CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "philpapers.org",cType: 'managed',cRay: '92aa7afe7a61fce7',cH: 'XvUn0gWwZPpoiNxy4Jk1_X.Kryhyi5.ZVm_vw6XExsI-1743703382-1.2.1.1-57bKPx6JDW52UMNZL1zpW2XoIbPMbHZ1z699w7Px7ahuKPuqCl8cYHGtAJGxSgbp',cUPMDTk: "\/rec\/AUDTCD-2?__cf_chl_tk=8izcQl0zOKhuu8SSf5BNCS7xRn8QFddblkESpqyVH9k-1743703382-1.0.1.1-jYmJjg8Es5m0CwkesyhvoxlDbM1hL7_nfTXpcbzypZY",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1743703382',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/rec\/AUDTCD-2?__cf_chl_f_tk=8izcQl0zOKhuu8SSf5BNCS7xRn8QFddblkESpqyVH9k-1743703382-1.0.1.1-jYmJjg8Es5m0CwkesyhvoxlDbM1hL7_nfTXpcbzypZY",md: "reKtraOXs9PekvKYZyL0D1_l5cUkLSgGPl2FNNVvsn8-1743703382-1.2.1.1-lre.ei3..y33Q8AOlM4Oo9SDV1AdIjvffPhFuVx.dIMd_DThclYnSHtun2laVhx386rUppim1ChEDlNK9Clc.LmtJ8gPHTZ1_QqCN8a4oOExPvZZWDYzoxbA06h8qeAxyoLd40LnigYR2bSTKJggd7ZQG5DAw5HLEFqjGCMLTAdOpyvAbQDjNk138.g97EHBw.oXnZCpu0VpkyK17vEYZxQAfT0Zl1oeUGlT0DH4nWeqF6YCNnYEVFQ4UO3UlWoi08DR.GoHcxBmIo6qQzpMNC2dqrsH89s0IZMsN8lFIW5rPx4e4PLhG8BhfKpP6y3iWcD.ua5QfVQS8VbebwVtvSv5ExOpTOBx8.rX0JIGceY4vanLGii64Ik1CX0Lyx5ZYt8BXnjzXys.WNdgYUy.HwvzQKgU9I6ydwM_yU6M6rXsP_Z9RInW_9N18.DDYLeK3gn4M93NyHCNO9Sznex7iDhaD5AW4GlIdQthjogsp08jJ8PfkonFIIlzBsxMw.ol6NU7qkTMU_PvNP5gMNFAKtfhQUDVgQqXpm7y4uPRcBbBZud_ir5PKJwh.cjn0RGktfVcOYVyXCHQeR4VT3.6ubXYmGlrENqKT0Dda5pBdPNHCuaaj8CQJeHQsN.4rKm6Zk9WLWwxbUf9U_SGEO.hswJWYAGo0zdllMC9y9jNvgfvgwWoI6rk8zLu7dm7VmQPev8uMe2zHYlZqHF3f1P1PeEJEaUp2k6mGJNQTA25CVNUE_Ht.HW3BWuW09N3rrZshpUSWkdcuofXQnSKGiiiMRONWp3o7XcG1Edg4mJI0_z2AW01qTgi7wkl4fO39KttuPgqjl_87ns3_LQRI7cpoY3jQQgm0dntURHAq1I05M0wbXKMkwHa_gJNVhgUdJMgPev9Ulp6Dbi1cHfzx.qwPnn1coYtRw4DMlvyVSOBblKixuzEnhmCnD_itTUL2j_H94ttSJCKJixuzQCoKCXpWF_Y902kbZz3qvMi0SrVn1uW9yD1xpg2fhmNF8PMlKSvGwKlSMpccLmbVffCR2uDPFV3.HEbhddl_8yaRFPF79T0GUEoG0e3dvzHrTVgQCEy11fcsTESsxfiHrSA55X5lrZhe0_U6ioYA34jPXgZbWrPVhbehiavFh0rpOU3wP0RTAQXMJaEC8RRflwyZawoJ80t__zoQnFdBrC2qMpQoclMeUdm3es5DhLTdQT7vUVA",mdrd: "e59xoM_.ggr3GlpmRBlGcrPE2geikKcPIUWpcaYLwMU-1743703382-1.2.1.1-T8OaoV_IrJvBkk6GyUoWpC4oe8f6nX2a7l7dY65JXP8pB9uX5UCsntdDtwIITyc_EpDwF0wwBAzhwU_v5al8BlsxN2YQ8jXcWFSk8bS0QbEqHzxgJpXSkWwPLPjA53GbzU.tafD7ua0f8nEZapzT2evbU5ucXCdIXd2vrrsP6XVq5LrrpmRwvR5Wn87N2ItOLAkHhK7XURRZhwiO9HujuJZRF6X5eTeMbz_BOG6v8hKpoR69zGNcuY2K20R2aX1BIyU6KJsGlBr5.E1uG3Zew3UlKCYcw_JMWGXRYKMlR6MmLG_iP8JAX0GutFAkSZCLxGvCbaYnMWuBiHfLNet5mtFiDO8NG8JvWpHdtNdvfJXEBAXLKUT_jdzR7djRrZLa7SWvLBpMl0I4trP1XdCaHVCvRLqXaQQlk1s0_4cBFbL8AK13mhvvb7.tnR1vNBpejZrQTevBXj6Z2YNiAabDepgVYApnCYU55_huDXQmooGLuVl14jcpQV2cUJ9sxo_BzciDhadIVIjefp.GZfkCA.RfCgyIMseO4AOfQ.EURmZE75HTI2JzFdfbx.SnuBErtEcUi3Wch8au6BEXddENfoAqr2SkzZJs4jDyWh26Sw2gOxeKy59GXXh49saGdlFYVG9cb1Z8w7ovQ8nEpBx5B.1nDEUazfkeg5MSP.KcJ_odRmgPhH5SVDcqOi4m10uYdwliVD4GpH915kTvE2EkohbM7n7gmDx1CdyORVhPDGxzeIZm6fOk7N9wE_D6XhaOMhket.9BkIkDtElKEaksvTW7MMfZxZtgmRvjGJIqiL7DpzGczpXemOPFO0m8zwZVVPiD2uUV3IAp1oEYB0ZDycRLUF6cZ9n0E3H99tJhApgMUDAwCzFBiIzJudGL4OeW9hYj3M5n_HHf4oA3yTSLc0SxfrSsCpMOFyKgW4s3NqcQBJSxlHfXjmVFxyPaluKB9HpbDqBxomTplz7zuajpnw7Mb.32Fykc2t2QYt0Pcoy5JuRHPfVmbFDxbXkM4.comzD29IcEgLMRi5PoAkohIH_V8VjpY2OIeHyEd8TcpcKCxhb6E4Jsq0U8F11O7hv7KGSb.rCiWSjLUhMl43e8Gz6mv2piyJv5V2WBrqyA0M3GkeQNTdMYpiPJBN52ap_GO_aylf6lHP4tqBAD0bBAubW1NAQj5vfV.1Mi2XVxS5FMeSehVKpvBHvv_GX0YcoPmjwJgONgG8Ex_jR99UhpztU_iU463Ra22x30wWNZh2r8VxNHVCXJLc34X908uQN9zw6MyqMMrWPcd6PqIeSzwjLsAKnCiLnCAYt18O.OFU2SnnqpymG_NfdPl2ZAsn4nxfptyt64r88mwKOa0915xs.LlVC5NYcTTR9vkrlQuq.Q1l_DAym3yNVYBFJSb5Ysk7XcgauTKKLmeBovKoaO5YIY.EZ6KHK7shmJ0MDrwV1XNlGxH6q4iisVvQJoOtQgWHYUJtn8GSHe9tRq9FvRdeqRavRLAtsai7mvDodXGp7n08OwtZ8..rTZXelfoL5Bhi806S2IKZhLidS51.L21Rw8ZvSS_l.cqYCL9UYdfGETCJUWre4n6ZZ8iG.GJE2wwHV2TtCoeFw_H.sP.aJ43r5EOVT5hyqjdTsBSG2fV7jUvO4oD5zm_YDCauP7SGJJS09AlIpNoEwZcijBUN5lwn.cZl9qTbNLwVDrD7e2LTzJ.85YwvnTZZC0gK0WiWAVchwh0Ry_s.iGvRoZWKM_2H5ERnNozyrSIXKOrYFDDq0lSa4TBlzLcereGJLbDx6nMlvKtO9GVYxnSWLwb.6CpNoJjcYU8.jOBQwka_WMBCsFNJo8isZq99ieySScv_igpNdsOiUmYWJaF0PcF61N0HwgqCsPfG8r44Nuvn_8MFIUCgGcY1rQkDf1lukmrtJ3BvyOFdRQp.fddoV9pZK.uJ1R__X0ajouqyEhxGLVG9vJNGdpvl5kBxO7grvCkarsyXNbfaBnS1SKo_Wt4v8gYB3hz.RQ4mtErTiomHtF2XKLAM.8ydDisTTtQwTSqcQx"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=92aa7afe7a61fce7';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/rec\/AUDTCD-2?__cf_chl_rt_tk=8izcQl0zOKhuu8SSf5BNCS7xRn8QFddblkESpqyVH9k-1743703382-1.0.1.1-jYmJjg8Es5m0CwkesyhvoxlDbM1hL7_nfTXpcbzypZY" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>