IETF Mail List Archives

<!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en"> <head> <meta charset="utf-8"> <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge"> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1"> <meta name="description" content="Search IETF mail list archives"> <title>IETF Mail List Archives</title> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://static.ietf.org/mailarchive/2.27.8/fontawesome/css/all.css"> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://static.ietf.org/mailarchive/2.27.8/mlarchive/css/bootstrap_custom.css"> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://static.ietf.org/mailarchive/2.27.8/mlarchive/css/styles.css"> </head> <body>  <div id="container"> <header class="navbar navbar-expand-md navbar-dark fixed-top px-3 py-0"> <div class="container-fluid"> <a class="navbar-brand p-0" href="/"> <img alt="IETF Logo" src="https://static.ietf.org/mailarchive/2.27.8/mlarchive/images/ietflogo-small-transparent.png"> <span class="navbar-text d-none d-md-inline-block"> Mail Archive </span> </a> <button class="navbar-toggler" type="button" data-bs-toggle="collapse" data-bs-target="#navbar-main" aria-controls="navbar-main" aria-expanded="false" aria-label="Toggle navigation"> <span class="navbar-toggler-icon"></span> </button> <div id="navbar-main" class="navbar-header collapse navbar-collapse"> <ul class="navbar-nav ms-auto"> <li class="nav-item d-none d-lg-inline"> <a class="nav-link" href="https://www.ietf.org/search/">Search www.ietf.org</a> </li> <li class="nav-item d-none d-lg-inline"> <a class="nav-link" href="https://datatracker.ietf.org">Search Datatracker</a> </li> <li class="nav-item d-none d-lg-inline navbar-text pipe"></li> <li class="nav-item dropdown"> <a class="nav-link dropdown-toggle" href="#" id="navbar-help" role="button" data-bs-toggle="dropdown" aria-haspopup="true" aria-expanded="false">Help</a> <div class="dropdown-menu" aria-labelledby="navbar-help"> <a class="dropdown-item" href="/arch/help/">Search Syntax</a> <a class="dropdown-item" href="/docs/api-reference/">API Reference</a> </div> </li> <li class="nav-item dropdown me-2"> <a id="nav-settings-anchor" class="nav-link dropdown-toggle" href="#" id="navbar-settings" role="button" data-bs-toggle="dropdown" aria-haspopup="true" aria-expanded="false">Settings</a> <ul class="dropdown-menu" aria-labelledby="navbar-settings"> <li><a id="toggle-static" class="dropdown-item" href="#">Turn Static Mode On</a></li> </ul> </li> <li class="nav-item"> <a class="nav-link" href="/oidc/authenticate/" rel="nofollow">Sign in</a> </li> </ul> </div>  </div>  </header>    <div id="content"> <div class="search-wrapper"> <div class="search-container"> <form id="id_search_form" name="search-form" action="search" method="get" data-lists="100all,100attendees,100companions,100-newcomers,101all,101attendees,101companions,101-newcomers,102all,102attendees,102companions,102-newcomers,103all,103attendees,103-newcomers,104all,104attendees,104-newcomers,105all,105attendees,105-newcomers,106all,106attendees,106companions,106-newcomers,107all,107attendees,108all,108attendees,108-newcomers,109all,109attendees,109-newcomers,110all,110attendees,110-newcomers,111all,111attendees,111-newcomers,112all,112attendees,112-newcomers,113all,113attendees,113-newcomers,114all,114attendees,114-newcomers,115all,115attendees,115-newcomers,116all,116attendees,116-newparticipants,117all,117attendees,117-newparticipants,118all,118attendees,118-newparticipants,119all,119attendees,119-newparticipants,120all,120attendees,120-newparticipants,121all,121attendees,121-newparticipants,16ng,2000,25years,3gpp-ietf-coord,3gv6,5gangip,67attendees,68attendees,69attendees,6band,6gip,6lo,6lo-fragmentation-dt,6lowapp,6lowpan,6tisch,6tisch-security,6tsch,70attendees,71attendees,72attendees,73attendees,74all,74attendees,75all,75attendees,76all,76attendees,77all,77attendees,78all,78attendees,79all,79attendees,80all,80attendees,81-1st-timers,81all,81attendees,82-1st-timers,822ext,82all,82attendees,83-1st-timers,84all,84attendees,85-1st-timers,85all,85attendees,86-1st-timers,86all,86attendees,87-1st-timers,87all,87attendees,88-1st-timers,88all,88attendees,89all,89attendees,89companions,90-1st-timers,90all,90attendees,90companions,91-1st-timers,91all,91attendees,91companions,92-1st-timers,92all,92attendees,92companions,92hackathon,93-1st-timers,93all,93attendees,93companions,94-1st-timers,94all,94attendees,94companions,95-1st-timers,95all,95attendees,95companions,95-mentees,95-mentors,96-1st-timers,96all,96attendees,96companions,96-mentors,96newcomers,97all,97attendees,97companions,97-mentors,97-newcomers,98all,98attendees,98companions,98-newcomers,98reg,99all,99attendees,99companions,99-newcomers,aaa,aaa-doctors,aaa-implementers,aac,aamm3migrationtest,abfab,abnf-discuss,accord,acct,ace,acme,actn,acvp,add,addr-select-dt,admin-discuss,adslmib,aeon,aft,agenda-tool,agentx,aggsrv,ai-control,aidc,alldispatch,alto,altoext,ancp,anima,anima-bootstrap,anima-signaling,ans-research,antitrust-policy,apn,appleip,appsdir,apps-discuss,apps-review,aqm,arc,architecture-discuss,arcing,arcmedia,ark,armd,arp222,art,asap,asdf,ason-routing,asrg,asrg-announce,atlas,atm,atoca,atommib,atompub,auth48archive,autoconf,avt,avtext,babel,banana,bcause,bec,beep,behave,bess,bfcpbis,bgmp,bgp,bgp-autoconf,bier,big-internet,bimi,bliss,blockchain-interop,bmwg,bnbsg,bof-srv6ops,bpf,bridge,bridge-mib,btns,bundled-domain-names,c310,c430,c431,cacao,caldav,call-home,calsch,calsify,can,captive-portals,capwap,carddav,caris-attendees,casm,cat,catnip,cats,cbor,ccamp,ccg,ccwg,cdi,cdni,cellar,certid,cfbl,cfrg,cga-ext,cgasec,channel-binding,charmib,charset,charter-tool,chassis,chirp,cicm,cidrd,cin,cip,clouds,clue,cmp-id,cna,cnit,cnrp,codec,codematch-develop,codesprints,codestand-develop,coin,collation,coma,coman,companions,conex,congress,conneg,core,core-parameters,cose,cosmogol,covidimpacts-workshop,crisp,criteria,crypto-panel,csky-idsubmit,cso,curdle,cuss,cwp,cwt-reg-review,dance,dane,danish,dart,datatracker-rqmts,dbound,dc,dclc,dcon,dcp,dcpel,dcrg-interest,dcrouting,dcrup,dd,decade,decnetiv,deepspace,detnet,detnet-dp-dt,detnet-edp-dt,dfs,dhcp,dhcpv6bis,dhcwg,diem,diffserv,diffserv-interest,digitalmap-yang,dime,din,dir-coord,discuss,disi,disman,dispatch,diversity,dix,dlnex,dlt-networking,dmarc,dmarc-report,dmm,dmsp,dna,dns-dir,dnsdir,dnsext,dnslb,dnsop,dnsoverhttp,dns-privacy,dnssd,dnssec-bootstrapping,doh,domainrep,domain-test,dots,drinks,driu,drums,dsfjdssdfsd,dsii,dtls-iot,dtn,dtn-interest,dtn-security,dtn-users,dyncast,e2ee,e2md,eai,eap,eapext,earlywarning,eat,ecm,ecn-in-quic,ecrit,ediint,edm,edu-discuss,edu-team,efficientnd-dt,ehip,e-impact,eligibility-discuss,emailcore,eman,eme,emo-dir,emserv-discuss,emu,end2end-interest,endymail,enterprise,entmib,enum,eodir,eppext,ericas,errata-design,esds,ethermib,etosat,event-streaming,evolving-documents,experiment-guidance,explicit-meas,extra,fax,fddi,fddimib,fdt,fecframe,fecframe-proto,feeds,find,flexip,forces,forces-protocol,frame,frnetmib,ftpext,fud,fun,gaia,gear,gen-art,gendispatch,geojson,geopriv,ggie,ghost,green,green-bof,grobj,grow,gsmp,hackathon,ham-ag,happy,harts,hash,hasmat,hiaps,hiccup,hip,hiprg,hipsec,hls-interest,hokey,homegate,homenet,homenet-babel-sec,homesec-dt,hops,hostmib,hostreq,hotrfc,hp-wan,hrpc,hr-rt,http,httpapi,http-auth,httpbisa,http-devops,http-grease,http-issues,httpmail,http-srv,http-state,httpstreaming,http-use,http-well-known,hubmib,humanresolvers,hybi,i18ndir,i18n-discuss,i18nrp,i2icf,i2nsf,i2rs,i2rs-proto-dt,iad20,iafa,ianabis,ianaplan,iasa20,ibnemo,icalendar,icar,iccrg,ice,icnrg,icnrg-harmonization,id-align,i-d-announce,ideas,ideas-discuss,ident,identity-discuss,id-event,idmr,idn,idna-update,idnet,idpr,idr,ids,idwg,ieee-ietf-coord,ieprep,iesg-agenda-dist,ietf,ietf108planning,ietf109-team,ietf-62,ietf72-1st-timers,ietf74-1st-timers,ietf75-1st-timers,ietf76-1st-timers,ietf77-1st-timers,ietf79-1st-timers,ietf80-1st-timers,ietf-822,ietf-ack,ietf-and-github,ietf-announce,ietf-announce-old,ietf-community-india,ietf-cycling,ietf-dkim,ietf-hub-bangalore,ietf-hub-boston,ietf-languages,ietf-meetings,ietf-mentees,ietf-mentoring-discuss,ietf-mentors,ietf-message-headers,ietfmibs,ietf-nomcom,ietf-outcomes,ietf-privacy,ietf-runners,ietf-sailors,ietf-smtp,ietf-sow,ietf-surveys,ietf-types,ifmib,igmp-mld-bis,ila,ilc,ima,imap,imap5,imapext,imrg,imss,independent,inip-discuss,insipid,int-area,int-dir,internetgovtech,inventory-yang,ioam,iola-conversion-tool,iola-wgcharter-tool,ion,iot-directorate,iot-onboarding,iotops,iotsi,ip1394,ipae,ipcdn,ipdvb,ipfix,iplpdn,ipngwg,ipoib,iporpr,ipoverib,ipp,ippcp,ippm,ippm-ioam-ix-dt,ipr-announce,iprp,ipr-wg,ips,ipsec,ipseckey,ipsp,ipsra,iptel,ipv6,ipv6-dir,ipv6mib,ipvbi,ire,irnss,irs-discuss,irtf-announce,irtf-discuss,irtf-mobility-charter,ischedule,isis,isis-wg,isms,isn,issll,its,it-test,itu+ietf,iucg,jcardcal,jmap,jose,jose-reg-review,json,json-canon,jsonpath,justfont,jwt-reg-review,kaml,karp,kem-combiners,keyassure,keyprov,keytrans,kink,kitten,krb-wg,l1vpn,l2cp,l2sm,l2tpext,l2vpn,l3sm,l3vpn,l4s-discuss,lager,lake,laminar,last-call,ldapbis,ldap-dir,ldapext,ledbat,ledger,lemonade,lime,lime-oam-model,link-relations,lisp,llc-consultation,lln-futures,lmap,loops,lp-wan,lsd,lsr,lsvr,ltans,ltru,lucid,lurk,lwip,madinas,magma,mailmaint,mailsec,maitai,malloc,manet,manet-dlep-rg,manet-dt,manycouches,maprg,marf,marid,marnew,martini,masque,mathmesh,mavs,mboned,mcast-wifi,mcic,mdnsext,mediactrl,media-feature-tags,media-feature-tags-archive,media-types,medup,megaco,mentoring-coordinators,messaging,meta-model,metaverse,mext,mhsds,mhtml,mib2rdml,mib-doctors,midcom,middisc,mif,mif-arch-dt,mile,mimemhs,mimi,mip4,mip6,mipshop,mipshop-mih-dt,mixer,mlcodec,mls,ml_testlist,mmox,mmusic,mobike,mobileip,mobopts,mod-discuss,model-t,modemmgt,modern,monami6,mops,moq,morg,mpls,mpls-interop,mpls-review,mpls-tp,mpowr,mpsnmp,mpvdapi,msec,msgtrk,msgway,msr6,mter,mtg-guests,mtgvenue,mtudisc,mud,multi6,multiformats,multimob,multimobsec-api,multipathtcp,multrans,namedroppers,nasr,nasreq,nat,nat66,nbs,ncrg,nea,nemo,nemops-interest,neotec,netconf,netconf-next-dt,netdata,netext,netfax,nethistory,netlmm,netmo,netmod,netmod-ver-dt,netrqmts,netslices,network-tokens,newprep,newsclips,newtrk,new-wg-docs,nfsv4,nfvcon,nfvrg,ngo,ngtrans,nipc,nir,njm,nmlrg,nmop,nmrg,nntp,nntpext,no-draft-expiry,noop,notifications,npp,nsaas,nscp,nsis,nsis-imp,ntdp,ntp,ntpwg,nvo3,nvo3-dt-encap,nwcrg,oam,oarh,oauth,oauth-ext-review,obscurity-interest,oda,off-path-bof,ogpx,ohai,ohttp,omcast,openpgp,openpgp-dt,openv6,opes,ops-area,opsarea-chairs,opsawg,opsec,ops-nm,opstat,orad,osids,osigen,ospf,ospf-manet,ospf-wireless-design,oud,p2pi,p2prg,p2psip,pals,pana,panic,panrg,patient,paw,paws,payload,pce,pcn,pcp,pdap,pearg,pem,peppermint,perc,perpass,pesci-discuss,pidloc,pier,pilc,pilots-ag,pim,pint,pip,pkix,pkng,plasma,plus,pm-dir,pmol,pmtud,pntaw,poised,poised95,policy,pop3,pop3ext,port-srv-reg,ports-team-internal,posh,ppm,pppext,ppsp,pqc,pq-dnssec,precis,prim,printmib,privacy-convey,privacydir,privacy-pass,privsec-discuss,problem,proto-team,provreg,proxies,psamp,psamp-text,pso-discuss,pwe3,pwg,pwot,qirg,qlog,qos_inband,qosr,quic,quic-issues,radext,radir,radius,rai,rai-discuss,ram,ranger,rap,rasprg,rats,raven,raw,rddp,rdma-cc-interest,reap,receipt,recentattendees,recipe,re-ecn,regext,remote-mentors,remoteui,renum,rescap,research-funding,resolverless-dns,restconf-next-dt,revampers,rfc6761bis,rfc-dist,rfced-future,rfc-interest,rfc-markdown,rfcplusplus,rfid,rfp-announce,rgchairs,rift,rip,ripv2,rmcat,rmon,rmt,rohc,rolc,roll,roll-bier-dt,rosa,routing-discussion,rpat,rpp,rps,rpsec,rreq,rrg,rrg-reboot,rsab,rserpool,rsn,rsvp,rsvp-dir,rswg,rtcweb,rtfm,rtg-bfd,rtg-dir,rtg-dt-encap-considerations,rtg-ooam-dt,rtg-open-source,rtgwg,rtg-yang-coord,rt-media-ng,rucus,rum,run,rwhois,saad,saag,sacm,sacred,sadcdn,safe,salud,sam,sami,sandbox-mailoutput,sasl,sat,sat-int,savi,savnet,scale,scap_interest,schc,scim,scitt,scone,scsn,sctp-impl,scuba-ag,sdn,sdwan-sec,seamoby,secauth,secdir,secdispatch,secmech,secret,secretariat-2012,secsh,sedate,send,settle,sfc,sframe,shara,shim6,shutup,sica,sidr,sidrops,siesta,sieve,sigtran,simple,sip,sipbrandy,sip-clf,sipcore,sip-http-events,sip-ops,sip-overload,sipp,sipping,sipping-emergency,sipping-tispan,siprec,sip-security,sixpac,skex,slim,smart,smartobjectdir,smartobject-interest,smartpowerdir,smartpower-interest,smds,smime,sming,sml,smtpext,snac,snanau,snmp,snmpconf,snmpsec,snmp-tlstm-reg-review,snmpv2,snmpv3,softwires,solace,sop,spam,spasm,spb-isis,speechsc,speermint,spfbis,spice,spirits,spkm,splices,spring,spud,spwg,srcomp,srv6ops,ssh,sshmgmt,ssh-reg-review,ssm,ssphwg,ssw-agenda-tool,stackevo,stackevo-discuss,status,stdguide,stevetest,stir,storagesync,storm,story-telling-ag,stox,straw,strint-attendees,stun,suit,sunset4,supa,svrloc,svt,swmp,syslog,t2trg,tae,tana,tao-discuss,tap,taps,tcmtf,tcpcrypt,tcpimpl,tcpinc,tcplw,tcpm,tcppep,tcpprague,tcpsat,tdd,teaching,teas,teas-3272bis-design-team,teas-ns-dt,techspec,teep,telnet,terminology,ternli,testlist,testlist-ietf,tewg,therightkey,thinosi,tictoc,tig-diagnostics,tigress,time,tip,tlp-interest,tls,tls-implementers,tls-reg-review,tmrg,tm-rid,tn3270e,tnfs,tofoo,tools-arch,tools-development,tools-discuss,tools-implementation,tools-team,toolstest2024101400,trade,trade.old,tram,trans,transport-nbi-dt,trigtran,trill,trunkmib,trust-router,tsig,tsv-area,tsv-art,tsvwg,tuba,tvr,txauth,tzdist,tzdist-bis,tzdist-service,ucp,udp35,ufmrg,unbearable,unwanted-trackers,upsmib,uri,uri-review,urlreg,urn,urn-nid,usefor,userdoc2,userglos,uswg,uta,uuidrev,v3,v4tov6transition,v4v6interim,v6ops,v6tc,vcarddav,vcon,venue-selection,vgmib,video-codec,videomgmt,vipr,vmeet,vnfpool,vnrg,vot,vpim,vpn4dc,vpn-dir,vrrp,vwrap,w3c-policy,web,webauthn-reg-review,webdav,webfinger,webpush,websec,webtransport,weirds,wellknown-uri-review,wgchairs,wgguide,widex,wimse,wish,witarea,wnils,woes,wpack,wpkops,wrec,x25mib,x400ops,xcon,xml2rfc,xml2rfc-dev,xml-mime,xml-sg-cmt,xmpp,xrblock,yaco-community-tool,yaco-idsubmit-tool,yaco-liaison-tool,yaco-nomcom-tool,yaco-wgchair-tracker,yam,yang,yang-doctors,yang-multicast,yang-sid-logistics,yc-announce,yot,zeroconf"> <div> <div class="input-group"> <input id="id_q" name="q" type="search" class="form-control typeahead" placeholder="Enter list name or search query..." spellcheck="false" > <div class="input-group-append"> <button class="btn btn-secondary" type="submit"> <span class="fa fa-search" aria-hidden="true"></span> </button> </div> </div> </div> </form> </div>  <div class="nav-outer"> <div class="nav-inner"> <ul class="navigation"> <li><a href="/arch/advsearch/">Advanced Search</a></li> <li><a href="/arch/browse/">Browse</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> </div>  </div>  <div class="footer"> <p class="small text-center">v2.27.8 | <a href="https://github.com/ietf-tools/mailarch/issues">Report a Bug</a> | <a href="mailto:tools-help@ietf.org">By Email</a> | <a href="https://status.ietf.org">System Status</a></p> </div> </div>  <script src="https://static.ietf.org/mailarchive/2.27.8/jquery/js/jquery-3.6.0.min.js" crossorigin="anonymous"></script> <script src="https://static.ietf.org/mailarchive/2.27.8/bootstrap-5.1.1-dist/js/bootstrap.bundle.min.js" crossorigin="anonymous"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://static.ietf.org/mailarchive/2.27.8/jquery.cookie/jquery.cookie.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://static.ietf.org/mailarchive/2.27.8/mlarchive/js/base.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://static.ietf.org/mailarchive/2.27.8/bootstrap3-typeahead/bootstrap3-typeahead.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://static.ietf.org/mailarchive/2.27.8/mlarchive/js/main.js"></script>  <script>(function(){function c(){var b=a.contentDocument||a.contentWindow.document;if(b){var d=b.createElement('script');d.innerHTML="window.__CF$cv$params={r:'8e94316c6a735f37',t:'MTczMjczMjI2NC4wMDAwMDA='};var a=document.createElement('script');a.nonce='';a.src='/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/scripts/jsd/main.js';document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(a);";b.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(d)}}if(document.body){var a=document.createElement('iframe');a.height=1;a.width=1;a.style.position='absolute';a.style.top=0;a.style.left=0;a.style.border='none';a.style.visibility='hidden';document.body.appendChild(a);if('loading'!==document.readyState)c();else if(window.addEventListener)document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded',c);else{var e=document.onreadystatechange||function(){};document.onreadystatechange=function(b){e(b);'loading'!==document.readyState&&(document.onreadystatechange=e,c())}}}})();</script></body> </html>

CINXE.COM

IETF Mail List Archives