CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="120"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "publications.waset.org",cType: 'non-interactive',cRay: '9136af3c0bb75e40',cH: 'NCkp8nHyd3GIm1MpCKTYR3wG7fU6RdTglBEFJtnhY5g-1739804819-1.2.1.1-Ny0qHFd65X0lXCLmQ1tgJHe_C2.QR_hiGD__3L7Je_s1Gm85dtwYLLXcl5cbEVl3',cUPMDTk: "\/abstracts\/164196\/in-defense-of-impersonal-obligatoriness?__cf_chl_tk=Z3wf05CleMR1MUw3V4kYgnxaVukvWu5mTcXzP170Ts8-1739804819-1.0.1.1-_Cg8rP5db6qj2bJa0HCNK6m2aCDhQc9oBMcygxBzwFQ",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1739804819',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '120000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/abstracts\/164196\/in-defense-of-impersonal-obligatoriness?__cf_chl_f_tk=Z3wf05CleMR1MUw3V4kYgnxaVukvWu5mTcXzP170Ts8-1739804819-1.0.1.1-_Cg8rP5db6qj2bJa0HCNK6m2aCDhQc9oBMcygxBzwFQ",md: "mo7Fqu.NTKCg013wKdJFw7tmzaPIpkOlDelAeTN1raE-1739804819-1.2.1.1-bOnxun58XfyzG6Dy7i2oBtXwxrcped6XlvGFbgfFPCSmRgeTGCIMrJbvPn8u7rTcntXJwOyjWxK9fLCoC7sFDyZnRUOia5a4bkKwSkn8DqJeNhLsdjujmhZctIG7z2eYDYuaADf3BiGLZW0RzG2L3C4oHYXHWcGVG_Ztd7kLn2hGxvEFB.YjZw0cXCNNZra7a32Q1HCjMU8Ip2Fc439Nvm.9QwMh2XVCFwUrg4w_vUGOigpLwIHLNYc0ZgBEm0XJyXE2JQdD6sgQdqUFdLvtlY_tG4OlWu.RyYkwdXkWzuIpp5M2L.AkSFXi3zmZdRysWDlC2ujKlMRYIRGpMfpKe8_m.zOIkZ1p29sYAEG48DkowVmjDUlBxk6LN5c.afO_JwQNGft72H5G0ZbiJbB_lUDNjMXeeRsfogfDFEruvDvAiELIWO3jFzau6A5FbPVJIhVIGQkQ6AeFf3zScibCF9T6VI1KlJqit_c1I3rJEGZwG9hlr6VmrzF07PThNqbCIlwebejcO6fTmTBb75t3ZmZOkhca_wq_GZXp1sTfz6ne7tRcn2UyYUTPo5TqWzMsdOqrLQigKakkIcbYdZfhklOIGmrq8ruOi6S1Rsqfp8nsvyVV23xvfdHQ9Wd5gN2AyJ81Oj9oOmeDlpzjZAJAejOtB8_c5GjswgTTYX89_.CcFp1oTmCMCUVNXEtuwagv0AujbwbeXProKPjUQx4uHqi1.fZc4NeRaCMYvMNxqRnuS.DLCayWI0xw7pgRWg8WvRIkdt9NjFy8R4Sm44mNBk3MJwZYV2sH0eEUWVkI61ZOHFyREPTwdZUn6SudKCmDZvaqEm8xSdHRO0FwkwqBMBYFqfOboqYqlvuC0RNfKfxy8taJqZIZGejESjFwm1Pxu7FBrUXqXEI1XwactbbVv.giiZmt9kJXb.IJwMcBMOCvdvKEI0SOV3.Qgi0LoPE9F6Ubvo4G.Z8QhzlsEwb8K6ObbMN.x89Nk2B1GaGQtAG4lUvT6laesgF1AlHvHL2gLNdSntAlK8hNmPWJDL1iOZXw9rch4ag1W2qfvQKNf9YgzNk_CWESReup8LDGKgz8z_PDKM7dUCuZLT.cFmeHAS50ZPcCoQhG19A3lQZwZDmdC2HKDCE_rjIGuhcj0xIkOYeDD9NykS4zQ1Jpk7CSOGlVOlhwFyj2nf4whw3LhA9GSVsmQRMDolFge1dCSyxbBzq84eYkecAUia85pP48oWS5E1KGIh1kjnebax8UW8OaLhkHzLLsPLD3e0FmHCrVCQNW6b4Rtjo3x7K4PxTUSQPU2jeyScQYSmCb369rFVGVO43b8E6B0SeCumCeXTGR5K9Vcfq0nuJsB7MWHGtSpwZutAlgXicj4I7a36xGH9IRQy7hJMskEMlojihiWQaLKpOpm37C5HLI9QgR0YF5lBk.OLqRr5JM68uIvkA.1qksvjT2skgMJZTvFNpMLEsJs.9mTJG4XXmsghOsNSxpOOG4wN8.Il1B3_SwniinJs6EM5PjvuQ0vGk4dGlgBw0qzcYXBhnXKde9G6jkweTRcxlZAcWDF7GdSTKCgJobUji6Au9xT..Ji3IL3BqRBTjPQd.Hdu_n737wZdTekSF5x.A_lM.hePSwaGn8UWwQ2xdkogpr7gy10J0KeJocvkMPXw11M8LuKLXgIg8CSJplNJmF7iQynCISBcnRM2wOAlYnqW_zw1xrisKZXDmltamshkVXJsLTozAwzWH4OdwyUq2Q3EgdGvPdN1C16cb.iwMSLsdnpAhOYz08qDIEbN2X5HvtguhM73NnxYhWcNiR.5TOnI733RWCLs9VIQP1cRLFdYTb7pZQeHTCG0QURMr2I5Lpj4Ha4Tnr2e5OsTFDCXskNEABjXWWrNvfXG2EwTifgqvL0LLRpuaxAiizB_6GRD0GopnxFKOvC6aC6VdnQwCmRvMU3X3xRmRG2bi0rvk6LnEkE5nxIqTWeEeImBqj_S0ZepYs4jk4vbotnI663tQlaQejG0mdQm2MSZiF5Jc",mdrd: "yeEffLjWYa.U0WqUPlKMht1e8NOqlElDXl6MfGis8wg-1739804819-1.2.1.1-lbNpXhu0SUAqeI7dDwmsaIU1fzlrVO6PsDnYpujIfdkd63xe0JAGIrTSILIqNeYlRFZ5NC7VXNrcoVzYWpIpeR2vJkW33Xs4p1YziMG9zuTVlxbhpF65HNqvlEJyfNFoeA7jpDGlT_VyyhF5UTopQVuXyQskaa3ztcM1WmkkfjzQHGQlbcxrigKIYGp.hRnrrn9Zm1K6GwibbrFVdRpIt_1iNt16TgAtLXVtFEdo3X0IsgSXk1PihSHaNLHduX5N1KkkY5Wg9X0LNZhnaYGDJq1NXVa_FusCOYMH4XO0epLZMT0jPVu3leAxCvYL2zhH41yPZGNJIbZzr7wXkxRi0NYYOlJao8orAmvcSc0yYrM0dCj1P9FyJuQXi0PavLZUXRkR6DWl3UCj4v0npcK_6nbilexLYPkDquai2Bw3mC3yW1aRj3YZe4f30PD3XmwPtAQvT6zN3iiowW3ZCoP8LhCjWOr_y_99l20a3X9B3FpQYztlHin7ttrzW6L0zRlBo8gcKLQkW5zIpqAKLR_gPKGUFtu6hzKkELkbMAfGA2Pq4uSWo55yKf.RK8MJPN9G3UaMBZdNU9Da7xcds_CEMJfmktO_QtOJYh8Sny_svVMSD0ao.0YUVzBmfpP7xsPDycJtA5prlseCQp5dEwY8QgkyD2fjmdj83LTFwgcun_anMxUphkMZj.Sy4vgg4IVJCJBQcjL7modQ38Hf8UQvOPm7wvAmPO7hjjKboonSmBN_DW2UECSWFXnmRRwQBJDuImJpCjBvtEZvxpm5e9MLwBF7h7Rr0X774n71uV.WhVdSxPSkRnHskpCox6rByJfJt0TdsRqyUdLFVTu78R4EH7_NcAcbT0OhZ_rfYMyKN9IHstSB9r_mb1VN9_xU_PPidUshTLW5J6QRD9rk.9T8wXSl.keiAIdw3QdvXCvrh9zhvyuWhrH1Pn_5RecWBvir1GMi_IE3AEloJJSYFDZ6GyLxUQ3omvEzHRWji_CifRSCK1MgEbuTjJKwLBuWgkfWwREfwhC6bLAuNwBWDv2hDPJ8ZQDH9lSMuYfb6UWmMB0vODJsuaStuSbQcM5Id4FYE8qIuMKJpttVo78KK9brv_X0uWaaxQFef2ha7mEHZOJFExJszup8fj85jeSsvqei.1dUYSnZnsN0FWi9Kyc_HEo0rniKXx5txMHdP3wz3CMNBu_ZhIeUWeUYhaxE7ofNbWA51SU4wA4ZFN7qD0Mn0WYVdmsNL0u3DgU8.PjnVniYi6pIBdV82SJjnTV8NWrEk6c7G7PyrENAA93X_9h9lX131jLyaaCbz4KWi7fDli9YANWerX_Q4HgIT4c9UBsHdiP1eU3MiOvsPLQc7h0PBt5C808BPHz4hdkSbbtBjsig_8OZIclIQOWVIH3VB0SaI3eu1Hu4yVD_4aeYNkcZrG6OOQD01zpFJy25q9rdT7l2IhBR.GX0ycH7OexpiMB_Z6qVRxLylqbfvFk58vAIALgu0JoO1TZfykc7ESFz0XN0gNWixW1C6ZIN5peNwXsvYlm_cFPN3C7GgHrDtPPuZCOZY3r1bq1Uzqh9PgVAzwSUU6OFwkXIFV2TVKyhnvbR._6DbpkEYSnG9ZW_e0T_Kl8Yj9ARbPRgGZRzROvBKHtH_sDylWuXexHg3rzZcAQLjdz4_09OEEiIBh8iu4l1IQAG4VVXV9a5K3nksx2XJFxZljr3h5NfXHySKpIru.Wx5nLKEPwjEcqkrKD4SoC1QPd5R5u6vSfwMqZzOCcXnjaWOQHwH6XUXhyTrZFTmCYzX6rdmqGjLl2Kn7KBQFA3yxf6d8dtEGlHE2L9P2yKPxHyPaX7vFbTUmJQZK4wpFIpDPEt_Pb.G7.t8DxpTXTnVBBeEeZuBi02MGNVww7mLxf4R6Ix.2uWqABdJCAhHhymwKoANRxLoHd.XuDMJcXX9tRdb9buz6zz8qEraaCcheIpBCqLneAuTSw6Gk0GExSGs.h8nkWgimgFpdp84h5ZAw"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=9136af3c0bb75e40';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/abstracts\/164196\/in-defense-of-impersonal-obligatoriness?__cf_chl_rt_tk=Z3wf05CleMR1MUw3V4kYgnxaVukvWu5mTcXzP170Ts8-1739804819-1.0.1.1-_Cg8rP5db6qj2bJa0HCNK6m2aCDhQc9oBMcygxBzwFQ" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>