CINXE.COM

<!doctype html><html lang="en"><head><meta charset="utf-8"/><link rel="shortcut icon" href="/favicon.ico"/><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1,shrink-to-fit=no"/><meta name="google-site-verification" content="VMXhD_A1271ozNQsmp536RpLjelAZxQ6ZHUF4EcTXiM"/><meta name="theme-color" content="#000000"/><link rel="manifest" href="/manifest.json"/><title>The Atlantic</title><base target="_parent"/><script defer="defer" src="/static/js/main.a32b1fb5.js"></script></head><body><noscript>You need to enable JavaScript to run this app.</noscript><div id="root"></div><script id="stripe-js" src="https://js.stripe.com/v3/" async></script><script type="text/javascript">window._vwo_code=window._vwo_code||function(){var e=!1,t=document,i={use_existing_jquery:function(){return false},library_tolerance:function(){return 2500},finish:function(){if(!e){e=!0;var i=t.getElementById("_vis_opt_path_hides");i&&i.parentNode.removeChild(i)}},finished:function(){return e},load:function(e){var i=t.createElement("script");i.src=e,i.type="text/javascript",i.innerText,i.onerror=function(){_vwo_code.finish()},t.getElementsByTagName("head")[0].appendChild(i)},init:function(){window.settings_timer=setTimeout("_vwo_code.finish()",2e3);var e=t.createElement("style"),i="body{opacity:0 !important;filter:alpha(opacity=0) !important;background:none !important;}",n=t.getElementsByTagName("head")[0];return e.setAttribute("id","_vis_opt_path_hides"),e.setAttribute("type","text/css"),e.styleSheet?e.styleSheet.cssText=i:e.appendChild(t.createTextNode(i)),n.appendChild(e),this.load("https://dev.visualwebsiteoptimizer.com/j.php?a=506588&u="+encodeURIComponent(t.URL)+"&f=1&r="+Math.random()),settings_timer}};return window._vwo_settings_timer=i.init(),i}()</script><script>!function(){!function(){for(var e,t="__tcfapiLocator",n=[],p=window;p;){try{if(p.frames.__tcfapiLocator){e=p;break}}catch(e){}if(p===window.top)break;p=p.parent}e||(!function e(){var n=p.document,a=!!p.frames.__tcfapiLocator;if(!a)if(n.body){var s=n.createElement("iframe");s.style.cssText="display:none",s.name=t,n.body.appendChild(s)}else setTimeout(e,5);return!a}(),p.__tcfapi=function(){var e,t=arguments;if(!t.length)return n;if("setGdprApplies"===t[0])t.length>3&&2===t[2]&&"boolean"==typeof t[3]&&(e=t[3],"function"==typeof t[2]&&t[2]("set",!0));else if("ping"===t[0]){var p={gdprApplies:e,cmpLoaded:!1,cmpStatus:"stub"};"function"==typeof t[2]&&t[2](p)}else"init"===t[0]&&"object"==typeof t[3]&&(t[3]=Object.assign(t[3],{tag_version:"V3"})),n.push(t)},p.addEventListener("message",(function(e){var t="string"==typeof e.data,n={};try{n=t?JSON.parse(e.data):e.data}catch(e){}var p=n.__tcfapiCall;p&&window.__tcfapi(p.command,p.version,(function(n,a){var s={__tcfapiReturn:{returnValue:n,success:a,callId:p.callId}};t&&(s=JSON.stringify(s)),e&&e.source&&e.source.postMessage&&e.source.postMessage(s,"*")}),p.parameter)}),!1))}(),function(){const e=10,t=["2:tcfeuv2","6:uspv1","7:usnatv1","8:usca","9:usvav1","10:uscov1","11:usutv1","12:usctv1"];window.__gpp_addFrame=function(e){if(!window.frames[e])if(document.body){var t=document.createElement("iframe");t.style.cssText="display:none",t.name=e,document.body.appendChild(t)}else window.setTimeout(window.__gpp_addFrame,10,e)},window.__gpp_stub=function(){var n=arguments;if(__gpp.queue=__gpp.queue||[],__gpp.events=__gpp.events||[],!n.length||1==n.length&&"queue"==n[0])return __gpp.queue;if(1==n.length&&"events"==n[0])return __gpp.events;var p=n[0],a=n.length>1?n[1]:null,s=n.length>2?n[2]:null;if("ping"===p)a({gppVersion:"1.1",cmpStatus:"stub",cmpDisplayStatus:"hidden",signalStatus:"not ready",supportedAPIs:t,cmpId:e,sectionList:[],applicableSections:[-1],gppString:"",parsedSections:{}},!0);else if("addEventListener"===p){"lastId"in __gpp||(__gpp.lastId=0),__gpp.lastId++;var i=__gpp.lastId;__gpp.events.push({id:i,callback:a,parameter:s}),a({eventName:"listenerRegistered",listenerId:i,data:!0,pingData:{gppVersion:"1.1",cmpStatus:"stub",cmpDisplayStatus:"hidden",signalStatus:"not ready",supportedAPIs:t,cmpId:e,sectionList:[],applicableSections:[-1],gppString:"",parsedSections:{}}},!0)}else if("removeEventListener"===p){for(var o=!1,r=0;r<__gpp.events.length;r++)if(__gpp.events[r].id==s){__gpp.events.splice(r,1),o=!0;break}a({eventName:"listenerRemoved",listenerId:s,data:o,pingData:{gppVersion:"1.1",cmpStatus:"stub",cmpDisplayStatus:"hidden",signalStatus:"not ready",supportedAPIs:t,cmpId:e,sectionList:[],applicableSections:[-1],gppString:"",parsedSections:{}}},!0)}else"hasSection"===p?a(!1,!0):"getSection"===p||"getField"===p?a(null,!0):__gpp.queue.push([].slice.apply(n))},window.__gpp_msghandler=function(e){var t="string"==typeof e.data;try{var n=t?JSON.parse(e.data):e.data}catch(e){n=null}if("object"==typeof n&&null!==n&&"__gppCall"in n){var p=n.__gppCall;window.__gpp(p.command,(function(n,a){var s={__gppReturn:{returnValue:n,success:a,callId:p.callId}};e.source.postMessage(t?JSON.stringify(s):s,"*")}),"parameter"in p?p.parameter:null,"version"in p?p.version:"1.1")}},"__gpp"in window&&"function"==typeof window.__gpp||(window.__gpp=window.__gpp_stub,window.addEventListener("message",window.__gpp_msghandler,!1),window.__gpp_addFrame("__gppLocator"))}();var e=function(){var t=arguments;typeof window.__uspapi!==e&&setTimeout((function(){void 0!==window.__uspapi&&window.__uspapi.apply(window.__uspapi,t)}),500)};if(void 0===window.__uspapi){window.__uspapi=e;var t=setInterval((function(){uspTries++,window.__uspapi===e&&uspTries<uspTriesLimit?console.warn("USP is not accessible"):clearInterval(t)}),6e3)}}()</script><script>!function(e,t,a,n,g){e[n]=e[n]||[],e[n].push({"gtm.start":(new Date).getTime(),event:"gtm.js"});var m=t.getElementsByTagName(a)[0],r=t.createElement(a);r.async=!0,r.src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=GTM-56LJR35",m.parentNode.insertBefore(r,m)}(window,document,"script","dataLayer")</script></body></html>