CINXE.COM

<!doctype html><html id=atomic class="NoJs Fz(62.5%) Pos(r) engadget desktop-lite bktengadget-US-en-US-def ua-ie ua-7.0" lang=en-US><head><script> window.performance.mark('PageStart'); (function(html){var c = document.documentElement.classList;c.add('JsEnabled', 'jsenabled');c.remove('NoJs');})(document.documentElement); /** * Empty darlaOnready method, to avoid JS error. * This can happen when Async Darla JS file is loaded earlier than Darla Proxy JS. * This method will be overridden by Darla Proxy */ window.darlaOnready = function() {}; </script><title>Engadget Masthead</title><meta http-equiv=content-type content="text/html; charset=utf-8"><meta http-equiv=x-dns-prefetch-control content=on><meta http-equiv=X-UA-Compatible content=chrome=1><meta name="oath:guce:consent-host" content="guce.engadget.com"><meta name="apple-mobile-web-app-status-bar-style" content="black" /><meta name="apple-touch-fullscreen" content="yes"/><meta name="application-name" content="Engadget" /><meta name="bitly-verification" content="f57da7265213" /><meta name="p:domain_verify" content="fb69533f2acad78bdd89abf093c35a28" /><meta property="fb:admins" content="11710688" /><meta property="fb:app_id" content="464864107046584" /><meta property="og:locale" content="en_US" /><meta property="fb:pages" content="5738237369" /><meta property="og:site_name" content="Engadget" /><meta name="msapplication-TileColor" content="#2B2D32"/><meta name="msapplication-TileImage" content="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/eng-e-558.png"/><meta name="msapplication-square150x150logo" content="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/eng-e-270.png"/><meta name="msapplication-square310x310logo" content="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/images/eng-e-558.png"/><meta name="msapplication-square70x70logo" content="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/eng-e-128.png"/><meta name="msapplication-wide310x150logo" content="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/eng-e-558x270.png"/><meta name="msapplication-notification" content="frequency=30;polling-uri=https://notifications.buildmypinnedsite.com/?feed=https://www.engadget.com/rss.xml&id=1;polling-uri2=https://notifications.buildmypinnedsite.com/?feed=https://www.engadget.com/rss.xml&id=2;polling-uri3=https://notifications.buildmypinnedsite.com/?feed=https://www.engadget.com/rss.xml&id=3;polling-uri4=https://notifications.buildmypinnedsite.com/?feed=https://www.engadget.com/rss.xml&id=4;polling-uri5=https://notifications.buildmypinnedsite.com/?feed=https://www.engadget.com/rss.xml&id=5; cycle=1"/><meta name="msvalidate.01" content="5ABD8A078F3356F3A6A8C8643C31FB8F" /><meta property="og:type" content="website"><meta http-equiv="content-type" content="text/html; charset=utf-8" /><meta name="twitter:site" content=`Engadget`><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1,minimum-scale=1"><meta name="conf:cjs:consent-host" content="guce.engadget.com"/><meta name="news_keywords" content="John Falcone, Valentina Palladino, Avery Ellis, Deputy editors, Executive editors" /><meta name="twitter:title" content="Engadget Masthead" /><meta property="og:title" content="Engadget Masthead" /><meta property="og:url" content="https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html" /><meta name="robots" content="max-image-preview:large"><meta name="twitter:description" content="Engadget's staff masthead." /><meta name="description" content="Engadget's staff masthead." /><meta property="og:description" content="Engadget's staff masthead." /><meta name="twitter:site" content="@engadget" /><meta name="twitter:dnt" content="on" /><meta property="og:type" content="article" /><meta property="og:site_name" content="Engadget" /><link rel="canonical" href="https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html" /><meta name="keywords" content="gear"><meta property="mrf:tags" content="keyword:gear" /><link rel="preload" href="https://s.yimg.com/ny/api/res/1.2/ZyvKnRkFXo2ZwQpCyXbBTg--/YXBwaWQ9aGlnaGxhbmRlcjt3PTk2MDtoPTQ4MA--/https://s.yimg.com/os/creatr-uploaded-images/2023-08/464d7520-3b83-11ee-bf7d-ee5f8cd1fdd0" as="image" /><meta name="twitter:image" content="https://s.yimg.com/ny/api/res/1.2/AkyTPnGWChUoTqNjePeIow--/YXBwaWQ9aGlnaGxhbmRlcjt3PTEyMDA7aD02MDA-/https://s.yimg.com/os/creatr-uploaded-images/2023-08/464d7520-3b83-11ee-bf7d-ee5f8cd1fdd0" /><meta name="twitter:image:src" content="https://s.yimg.com/ny/api/res/1.2/AkyTPnGWChUoTqNjePeIow--/YXBwaWQ9aGlnaGxhbmRlcjt3PTEyMDA7aD02MDA-/https://s.yimg.com/os/creatr-uploaded-images/2023-08/464d7520-3b83-11ee-bf7d-ee5f8cd1fdd0" /><meta property="og:image" content="https://s.yimg.com/ny/api/res/1.2/AkyTPnGWChUoTqNjePeIow--/YXBwaWQ9aGlnaGxhbmRlcjt3PTEyMDA7aD02MDA-/https://s.yimg.com/os/creatr-uploaded-images/2023-08/464d7520-3b83-11ee-bf7d-ee5f8cd1fdd0" /><meta property="og:image:width" content="1200" /><meta property="og:image:height" content="600" /><meta property="twitter:creator" content="@engadget" /><meta property="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image" /><link rel="shortcut icon" href="https://www.engadget.com/favicon.ico"><link rel="preload" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/fonts/Guardian-Text-Sans-Web-Regular.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin><link rel="preload" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/fonts/Guardian-Text-Sans-Web-Bold.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin><link rel="preload" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/fonts/Guardian-Egyptian-Web-Regular.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin><link rel="preload" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/fonts/Guardian-Egyptian-Web-Medium.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin><link rel="preload" href="https://s.yimg.com/cv/apiv2/engadget/us/fonts/Guardian-Text-Egyptian-Web-Regular.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin><link rel="preload" href="https://s.yimg.com/cv/apiv2/engadget/us/fonts/Guardian-Text-Egyptian-Web-Regular-Italic.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin><link rel="preload" href="https://s.yimg.com/cv/apiv2/engadget/us/fonts/Guardian-Text-Egyptian-LF-Web-Regular.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin><link rel="preload" href="https://s.yimg.com/cv/apiv2/engadget/us/fonts/Guardian-Text-Egyptian-LF-Web-Regular-Italic.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="//geo.yahoo.com"><link rel="preconnect" href="//geo.yahoo.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="//geo.query.yahoo.com"><link rel="preconnect" href="//geo.query.yahoo.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="//search.yahoo.com"><link rel="preconnect" href="//search.yahoo.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="//udc.yahoo.com"><link rel="preconnect" href="//udc.yahoo.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="//s.yimg.com"><link rel="preconnect" href="//s.yimg.com"><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="152x152" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/apple-touch-icon-152x152.png"/><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="57x57" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/apple-touch-icon-57x57.png"/><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="114x114" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/apple-touch-icon-114x114.png"/><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="120x120" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/apple-touch-icon-120x120.png"/><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="144x144" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/apple-touch-icon-144x144.png"/><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="60x60" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/apple-touch-icon-60x60.png"/><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="72x72" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/apple-touch-icon-72x72.png"/><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="76x76" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/apple-touch-icon-76x76.png"/><link rel="icon" type="image/png" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/favicon-16x16.png" sizes="16x16"/><link rel="icon" type="image/png" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/favicon-160x160.png" sizes="160x160"/><link rel="icon" type="image/png" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/favicon-32x32.png" sizes="32x32"/><link rel="icon" type="image/png" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/favicon-96x96.png" sizes="96x96"/><link rel="search" type="application/opensearchdescription+xml" href="https://search.engadget.com/opensearch.xml" title="Engadget" /><link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="Engadget" href="//www.engadget.com/rss.xml"/><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://s.yimg.com/dr/fp/css/fusion.atomic.f71f291881d53d90f6216c0ea27c05f8.css"><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://s.yimg.com/os/yc/css/bundle.c60a6d54.css"><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/art/css/desktopweb.15898aabba8f872866ed80401b538577.css"><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/art/css/engadgetweb.8b7e1796c6b12f70291f0435ac038104.css"><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/cprops/colors_1.1.27.min.css"><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/nel/css/tdv2-wafer-content-list.custom.888132cb49eb61157282573521d113fb.css"><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/engadget/mod/css/engad-header.custom.1884a2ba3b0d04ccce29a888c1ce2368.css"><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://s.yimg.com/kw/engadget/mod/css/engad-nav.custom.f293a96ffddf2142be339d8600014fce.css"><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/art/js/caas.b474e91ceab25eed94dfea60e82cfd41.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-loader-2.7.21.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/art/js/clusterSda.738b79e47ebce486951867a378f4ff26.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/art/js/clusterComments.20846888c0a2a68881b081934946bd6f.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/ss/analytics3.js"></script><script type="text/javascript">!function(){var e={1040:function(e){"use strict";function t(e){return(t="function"==typeof Symbol&&"symbol"==typeof Symbol.iterator?function(e){return typeof e}:function(e){return e&&"function"==typeof Symbol&&e.constructor===Symbol&&e!==Symbol.prototype?"symbol":typeof e})(e)}e.exports=function(){for(var e,n,a=[],s=window,r=s;r;){try{if(r.frames.__tcfapiLocator){e=r;break}}catch(e){}if(r===s.top)break;r=r.parent}e||(function e(){var t=s.document,n=!!s.frames.__tcfapiLocator;if(!n)if(t.body){var a=t.createElement("iframe");a.style.cssText="display:none",a.name="__tcfapiLocator",t.body.appendChild(a)}else setTimeout(e,5);return!n}(),s.__tcfapi=function(){for(var e=arguments.length,t=new Array(e),s=0;s<e;s++)t[s]=arguments[s];if(!t.length)return a;"setGdprApplies"===t[0]?t.length>3&&2===parseInt(t[1],10)&&"boolean"==typeof t[3]&&(n=t[3],"function"==typeof t[2]&&t[2]("set",!0)):"ping"===t[0]?"function"==typeof t[2]&&t[2]({gdprApplies:n,cmpLoaded:!1,cmpStatus:"stub"}):a.push(t)},s.addEventListener("message",(function(e){var n="string"==typeof e.data,a={};if(n)try{a=JSON.parse(e.data)}catch(e){}else a=e.data;var s="object"===t(a)&&null!==a?a.__tcfapiCall:null;s&&window.__tcfapi(s.command,s.version,(function(t,a){var r={__tcfapiReturn:{returnValue:t,success:a,callId:s.callId}};e&&e.source&&e.source.postMessage&&e.source.postMessage(n?JSON.stringify(r):r,"*")}),s.parameter)}),!1))}},5385:function(){"use strict";window.__gpp_addFrame=function(e){if(!window.frames[e])if(document.body){var t=document.createElement("iframe");t.style.cssText="display:none",t.name=e,document.body.appendChild(t)}else window.setTimeout(window.__gpp_addFrame,10,e)},window.__gpp_stub=function(){var e=arguments;if(__gpp.queue=__gpp.queue||[],__gpp.events=__gpp.events||[],!e.length||1==e.length&&"queue"==e[0])return __gpp.queue;if(1==e.length&&"events"==e[0])return __gpp.events;var t=e[0],n=e.length>1?e[1]:null,a=e.length>2?e[2]:null;if("ping"===t)n({gppVersion:"1.1",cmpStatus:"stub",cmpDisplayStatus:"hidden",signalStatus:"not ready",supportedAPIs:["2:tcfeuv2","5:tcfcav1","6:uspv1","7:usnatv1","8:uscav1","9:usvav1","10:uscov1","11:usutv1","12:usctv1"],cmpId:0,sectionList:[],applicableSections:[],gppString:"",parsedSections:{}},!0);else if("addEventListener"===t){"lastId"in __gpp||(__gpp.lastId=0),__gpp.lastId++;var s=__gpp.lastId;__gpp.events.push({id:s,callback:n,parameter:a}),n({eventName:"listenerRegistered",listenerId:s,data:!0,pingData:{gppVersion:"1.1",cmpStatus:"stub",cmpDisplayStatus:"hidden",signalStatus:"not ready",supportedAPIs:["2:tcfeuv2","5:tcfcav1","6:uspv1","7:usnatv1","8:uscav1","9:usvav1","10:uscov1","11:usutv1","12:usctv1"],cmpId:0,sectionList:[],applicableSections:[],gppString:"",parsedSections:{}}},!0)}else if("removeEventListener"===t){for(var r=!1,o=0;o<__gpp.events.length;o++)if(__gpp.events[o].id==a){__gpp.events.splice(o,1),r=!0;break}n({eventName:"listenerRemoved",listenerId:a,data:r,pingData:{gppVersion:"1.1",cmpStatus:"stub",cmpDisplayStatus:"hidden",signalStatus:"not ready",supportedAPIs:["2:tcfeuv2","5:tcfcav1","6:uspv1","7:usnatv1","8:uscav1","9:usvav1","10:uscov1","11:usutv1","12:usctv1"],cmpId:0,sectionList:[],applicableSections:[],gppString:"",parsedSections:{}}},!0)}else"hasSection"===t?n(!1,!0):"getSection"===t||"getField"===t?n(null,!0):__gpp.queue.push([].slice.apply(e))},window.__gpp_msghandler=function(e){var t="string"==typeof e.data;try{var n=t?JSON.parse(e.data):e.data}catch(e){n=null}if("object"==typeof n&&null!==n&&"__gppCall"in n){var a=n.__gppCall;window.__gpp(a.command,(function(n,s){var r={__gppReturn:{returnValue:n,success:s,callId:a.callId}};e.source.postMessage(t?JSON.stringify(r):r,"*")}),"parameter"in a?a.parameter:null,"version"in a?a.version:"1.1")}},"__gpp"in window&&"function"==typeof window.__gpp||(window.__gpp=window.__gpp_stub,window.addEventListener("message",window.__gpp_msghandler,!1),window.__gpp_addFrame("__gppLocator"))},1007:function(e,t,n){"use strict";n.r(t);var a=n(1040);n.n(a)()()},9476:function(){!function(){for(var e,t="__uspapiLocator",n=[],a=window;a;){try{if(a.frames[t]){e=a;break}}catch(e){}if(a===window.top)break;a=a.parent}e||(function e(){var n=window.document;if(!window.frames[t])if(n.body){var a=n.createElement("iframe");a.style.cssText="display:none",a.name=t,n.body.appendChild(a)}else setTimeout(e,5)}(),window.__uspapi=function(){for(var e=arguments.length,t=new Array(e),a=0;a<e;a++)t[a]=arguments[a];if(!t.length)return n;n.push(t)},window.addEventListener("message",(function(e){var t="string"==typeof e.data,n={};try{n=t?JSON.parse(e.data):e.data}catch(e){}var a=n.__uspapiCall;a&&window.__uspapi(a.command,a.version,(function(n,s){var r={__uspapiReturn:{returnValue:n,success:s,callId:a.callId}};t&&(r=JSON.stringify(r)),e&&e.source&&e.source.postMessage(r,"*")}),a.parameter)}),!1))}()}},t={};function n(a){var s=t[a];if(void 0!==s)return s.exports;var r=t[a]={exports:{}};return e[a](r,r.exports,n),r.exports}n.n=function(e){var t=e&&e.__esModule?function(){return e.default}:function(){return e};return n.d(t,{a:t}),t},n.d=function(e,t){for(var a in t)n.o(t,a)&&!n.o(e,a)&&Object.defineProperty(e,a,{enumerable:!0,get:t[a]})},n.o=function(e,t){return Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(e,t)},n.r=function(e){"undefined"!=typeof Symbol&&Symbol.toStringTag&&Object.defineProperty(e,Symbol.toStringTag,{value:"Module"}),Object.defineProperty(e,"__esModule",{value:!0})},function(){"use strict";n(9476);!window.document.documentMode&&(n(1007),n(5385))}()}();</script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://consent.cmp.oath.com/version/7.0.0/cmp.js" async></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/vzm/cs_1.6.6.js" async></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/nel/js/tdv2-wafer-utils.customErrorHandler.bcda778b736c3a054af62f437b536e78.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript">function e(e){var t=!(arguments.length>1&&void 0!==arguments[1])||arguments[1],c=document.createElement("script");c.src=e,t?c.type="module":(c.async=!0,c.type="text/javascript",c.setAttribute("nomodule",""));var n=document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];n.parentNode.insertBefore(c,n)}function t(t,c,n){var a,o,r;null!==(a=t.marfeel)&&void 0!==a||(t.marfeel={}),null!==(o=(r=t.marfeel).cmd)&&void 0!==o||(r.cmd=[]),t.marfeel.config=n,t.marfeel.config.accountId=c;var i="https://sdk.mrf.io/statics";e("".concat(i,"/marfeel-sdk.js?id=").concat(c),!0),e("".concat(i,"/marfeel-sdk.es5.js?id=").concat(c),!1)}!function(e,c){var n=arguments.length>2&&void 0!==arguments[2]?arguments[2]:{};t(e,c,n)}(window,2914,{} /*config*/);</script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/oa/consent.js" async></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/benji/benji-2.2.12.js" async></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-module-2.0.0.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/nel/js/spotIm.custom.SpotIMJAC.engadget.8b6399f02a6ac8140c1174d239105434.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-video-3.2.2.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-beacon-1.3.4.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-benji-1.2.0.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-scrollview-2.23.3.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-toggle-1.15.4.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-fetch-1.19.1.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-form-1.34.5.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-caas-1.36.6.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-lightbox-1.10.6.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-countdown-1.2.5.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-sticky-1.2.6.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-image-1.4.0.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/nel/js/tdv2-wafer-content-list.custom.c55065592f3316c637717d204a89a974.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/kw/engadget/mod/js/engad-footer.custom.dc4d352d0c6562c7b8b042870c3a4379.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-rapid-1.10.9.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-menu-1.3.5.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/kw/engadget/mod/js/engad-nav.custom.1e1d3917db5ddbd5924f7b152ae2e86d.js" defer></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/fp/js/react-wafer-featurebar.custom.default.95a7979b4c06295e22960043d003fb49.js" defer></script><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/c/5859222.caas-engadget_web.min.css"><script> (function () { var benjiConfig = {"i13n":{"_rid":"38jmiqhjk40tt","abk":"","colo":"sg3","mrkt":"us","p_sec":"us.engadget","partner":"none","site":"engadget","uh_vw":0,"navtype":"server","p_cpos":1,"p_hosted":"hosted","pcp":"Engadget","pct":"story","pd":"non_modal","pl2":"seamless-article","pstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pstaid_p":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pstcat":"business","pt":"content","redirect":"","ver":"article","dmi_consent":false,"_vuid":"GjIk7IRoQfc42zhu_Koxjw","contentcategorypath":"|","displayts":1600892458000,"authed":"0","ynet":"0","ssl":"1","spdy":"0","ytee":"0","mode":"normal","tpConsent":true,"adblock":"0","device":"desktop-lite","bot":"0","browser":"ie","app":"unknown","ecma":"default","environment":"prod","gdpr":false,"lang":"en-US","dir":"ltr","network":"broadband","os":"windows nt","region":"US","time":1732379581644,"tz":"Asia/Hong_Kong","usercountry":"HK","intl":"us","bucket":"engadget-US-en-US-def","designtype":"default","pageName":"deeplink","apptype":"","feature":["enableGAMAds","allowSendingDomainPathToNCP","articleRRModuleSlotsV1","caasEnableSingleSlotting","cluster","clusterLoadSpotImOnClick","disableCommentsMessage","disableReadMore","editorialUpsells","enableAdditionalPageContextParams","enableBodyAdSlotsNewMap","enableBodyAdSlotsOneSlot","enableInArticleAd","enableInlineConsent","enablePlayerCardRedesign","enableRRAdsSlots","enableRRTriggerOnViewport","enableSiteSections","enableSpotImClusterComments","enableSpotImRightRailAds","enableStickyRRAds","enableTaboolaAdsInEngadget","enableXrayEntityAboutFacts","filterNonGdprEmbeds","getCommerceModulesFromRmp","liveBlogPolling","clusterDesktopPostArticleAdsBgStyle"],"baseContentType":"story","contentType":"story","hashtag":["gear","internet"],"lmsid":"a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH","lpstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","lu":"0","spaceid":"1197802876"},"prebidSetting":{"pbConfig":{},"pbjs":{}},"positions":{"sda-INARTICLE-iframe":{"id":"sda-INARTICLE-iframe","kvs":{"loc":"mid_center"},"region":"index","size":[[960,540]]},"sda-LDRB-iframe":{"customSizeConfig":{"Horizon":true},"id":"sda-LDRB-iframe","kvs":{"loc":"top_center"},"region":"index","size":[[970,250],[728,90],[3,1]],"path":"/22888152279/${REGION}/${SITE}/ros/dt/${REGION}_${SITE}_ros_dt_top_center"},"sda-LDRB2-iframe":{"id":"sda-LDRB2-iframe","kvs":{"loc":"btm_center"},"region":"index","size":[[728,90],[970,250]],"path":"/22888152279/${REGION}/${SITE}/ros/dt/${REGION}_${SITE}_ros_dt_btm_center"},"sda-LREC-iframe":{"id":"sda-LREC-iframe","kvs":{"loc":"top_right"},"region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]],"path":"/22888152279/${REGION}/${SITE}/ros/dt/${REGION}_${SITE}_ros_dt_top_right"},"sda-LREC2-iframe":{"id":"sda-LREC2-iframe","kvs":{"loc":"mid_right"},"region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]],"path":"/22888152279/${REGION}/${SITE}/ros/dt/${REGION}_${SITE}_ros_dt_mid_right"},"sda-LREC3-iframe":{"id":"sda-LREC3-iframe","kvs":{"loc":"mid_right_2"},"region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]]}},"setting":{"refresh":{"duration":20,"requireUserAction":false,"sameSizeRefresh":true,"tabFocus":{"outOfFocusDuration":3}},"tracking":{"debug":true,"metrics":true,"performance":true},"lazyLoad":false,"taboolaSetting":{"pageType":"article","publisherId":"yahoo-engadget-network"}},"feature":{"enableEdgeToEdge":true}}; var locationContext = {"region":"US","usercountry":"HK","gdpr":false}; benjiConfig.setting = { ...benjiConfig.setting, consent: { allowFirstPartyAds: true, allowOnlyLimitedAds: false, allowOnlyNonPersonalizedAds: false, }, }; benjiConfig.i13n = { ...locationContext, ...benjiConfig.i13n, bka: '0', bkg: '', }; if (typeof window.benji !== 'undefined') { window.benji.start(benjiConfig); } else { window.benji = { config: benjiConfig, }; } })(); </script></head><body dir=ltr><noscript><img alt class=D(n) src=/_td_api/beacon/info?beaconType=noJSenabled&bucket=engadget-US-en-US-def&code=pageRender&device=desktop-lite&lang=en-US&pageName=deeplink&region=US&rid=38jmiqhjk40tt&site=engadget&t=1732379582050></noscript> <script id=wafer-db-config type=application/json> { "name": "article-server", "version": 1 } </script><script id=wafer-video-config type=application/json> {"playerScript":"https://s.yimg.com/rx/ev/builds/1.9.12/evplayer.js","config":{"useEVPlayer":true}} </script><script type=application/json class=wafer-state> { "colorTheme": "", "dedupUuids": "adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50", "geminiAds": { "geminiDedupeToken": "PHToken" }, "publisherBlobPageContext": "%7B%22lu%22%3A%220%22%2C%22pageType%22%3A%22content%22%2C%22site%22%3A%22engadget%22%2C%22appName%22%3A%22article%22%2C%22pageDesign%22%3A%22non_modal%22%2C%22pageContentType%22%3A%22story%22%2C%22ctopid%22%3A%221878000%3B1035500%3B10610989%22%2C%22hashtag%22%3A%22gear%3Binternet%22%2C%22wiki_topics%22%3A%22Avery_Ellis%3BNews_bureau%3BSocial_media%3BReport%22%2C%22lmsid%22%3A%22a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH%22%2C%22revsp%22%3A%22engadget_479%22%2C%22lpstaid%22%3A%22adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50%22%2C%22yctIds%22%3A%22yct%3A001000963%22%2C%22bucket%22%3A%22engadget-US-en-US-def%22%7D" } </script><script type=text/javascript> (function() { window.YAHOO = window.YAHOO || {}; window.YAHOO.context = { "apptype": "", "authed": "0", "browserName": "ie", "browserVersion": "7.0", "bucket": "engadget-US-en-US-def", "contentSite": "", "device": "desktop-lite", "errBeaconConfig": { "beaconPath": "_td_api/beacon/error", "site": "engadget" }, "feature": [ "enableGAMAds", "allowSendingDomainPathToNCP", "articleRRModuleSlotsV1", "caasEnableSingleSlotting", "cluster", "clusterLoadSpotImOnClick", "disableCommentsMessage", "disableReadMore", "editorialUpsells", "enableAdditionalPageContextParams", "enableBodyAdSlotsNewMap", "enableBodyAdSlotsOneSlot", "enableInArticleAd", "enableInlineConsent", "enablePlayerCardRedesign", "enableRRAdsSlots", "enableRRTriggerOnViewport", "enableSiteSections", "enableSpotImClusterComments", "enableSpotImRightRailAds", "enableStickyRRAds", "enableTaboolaAdsInEngadget", "enableXrayEntityAboutFacts", "filterNonGdprEmbeds", "getCommerceModulesFromRmp", "liveBlogPolling", "clusterDesktopPostArticleAdsBgStyle" ], "guid": "", "intl": "us", "lang": "en-US", "meta": { "categoryLabel": "Business", "commentsAllowed": false, "commentsCount": 0, "contentType": "story", "messageId": "", "replyId": "", "siteAttribute": "wiki_topics=\"Avery_Ellis;News_bureau;Social_media;Report\" ctopid=\"1878000;1035500;10610989\" hashtag=\"gear;1878000;1035500;10610989\" rs=\"lmsid:a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH;revsp:engadget_479;lpstaid:adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50;pt:content;pd:non_modal;ver:article;lu:0;pct:story\"", "tags": "John Falcone, Valentina Palladino, Avery Ellis, Deputy editors, Executive editors", "title": "Engadget Masthead", "url": "https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html", "uuid": "adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50", "xhrPathPrefix": "/nel_ms/_rcv/remote" }, "mode": "normal", "osName": "windows nt", "osVersion": "6.0", "partner": "none", "region": "US", "rid": "38jmiqhjk40tt", "site": "engadget", "tpConsent": true, "ynet": "0" }; }()); </script><header id=Header class="Pos(r) T(0) W(100%)"><div id=module-header class=wafer-rapid-module><div><div class="rwd-outer-container W(100vw) D(f) Jc(sa) H(80px) H(60px)!--xs" data-component="RWDContainer"><div class="rwd-inner-container W(1235px) W(980px)--lg W(640px)--md W(100%)--sm Mx(20px)--sm W(100%)!--md H(80px) H(60px)!--xs M(0)! Pstart(20px)--md Bxz(bb) Bgc(#fff) Bgc(engadgetSteelGray)--md Bdbc(engadgetGray) Bdbs(s)--md Bdbw(1px)--md D(f) Ai(c) Jc(sb) Pos(f)--md T(0)--md Z(2)--md"><div class="Whs(nw)"><div class="hamburger-nav-btn-container D(n) Mend(20px) D(ib)!--md Va(t)"><button class="P(0) Bgc(t) Bd(n) O(n) W(35px) H(35px) D(f) Ai(c) Jc(sa) Cur(p) has-click" aria-label="Menu for navigation opens a modal overlay" alt="Menu" data-drawer-target="hamburger" data-wf-drawer-state="open-left" data-component="HamburgerNavBtn" data-ylk="sec:header;subsec:menu;slk:hamburger;elm:logo;itc:0"><div class="hamburger Pe(n)"><div class="W(20px) H(2px) Bgc(white) Mb(3px)"></div><div class="W(20px) H(2px) Bgc(white) Mb(3px)"></div><div class="W(20px) H(2px) Bgc(white)"></div></div></button></div><a href="/" aria-label="Engadget " class="Td(n) D(ib)" data-ylk="sec:header;subsec:logo;slk:Engadget;elm:logo;itc:0"><div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetSteelGray) Stk(engadgetSteelGray) Fill(#fff)--md Stk(#fff)--md W(152px) W(120px)--xs Cur(p)" data-icon="logo-engadget"><v:shape style="height:33px; width:33px;" coordsize="1520,330" id="logo-engadget" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m0,241c0,257,13,270,30,270c30,270,150,270,150,270c150,270,150,240,150,240c150,240,30,240,30,240c30,240,30,210,30,210c30,210,148,210,148,210c164,210,180,197,180,181c180,181,180,182,180,182c180,182,180,123,180,123c180,107,165,91,148,91c148,91,30,91,30,91c14,91,0,107,0,123c0,123,0,241,0,241c0,241,0,241,0,241m150,180c150,180,30,180,30,180c30,180,30,120,30,120c30,120,150,120,150,120c150,120,150,180,150,180c150,180,150,180,150,180m551,90c551,90,432,90,432,90c416,90,400,106,400,122c400,122,400,241,400,241c400,241,400,240,400,240c400,256,416,270,432,270c432,270,550,270,550,270c550,270,550,300,550,300c550,300,430,300,430,300c430,300,430,330,430,330c430,330,551,330,551,330c567,330,580,316,580,300c580,300,580,122,580,122c580,106,567,90,551,90c551,90,551,90,551,90m550,240c550,240,430,240,430,240c430,240,430,120,430,120c430,120,550,120,550,120c550,120,550,240,550,240c550,240,550,240,550,240m320,90c320,90,231,90,231,90c215,90,200,106,200,122c200,122,200,270,200,270c200,270,230,270,230,270c230,270,230,120,230,120c230,120,320,120,320,120c336,120,350,135,350,152c350,152,350,270,350,270c350,270,380,270,380,270c380,270,380,152,380,152c380,119,353,90,320,90c320,90,320,90,320,90m750,240c750,240,630,240,630,240c630,240,630,151,630,151c630,135,646,119,663,119c663,119,750,119,750,119c750,119,750,269,750,269c750,269,780,269,780,269c780,269,780,122,780,122c780,106,768,90,752,90c752,90,663,90,663,90c630,90,600,119,600,152c600,152,600,241,600,241c600,257,617,270,633,270c633,270,685,270,685,270c712,270,740,259,750,240c750,240,750,270,750,270m1430,0c1430,0,1400,0,1400,0c1400,0,1400,270,1400,270c1400,270,1430,270,1430,270c1430,270,1430,120,1430,120c1430,120,1520,120,1520,120c1520,120,1520,90,1520,90c1520,90,1430,90,1430,90c1430,90,1430,0,1430,0m1010,241c1010,257,1019,270,1035,270c1035,270,1150,270,1150,270c1150,270,1150,300,1150,300c1150,300,1040,300,1040,300c1040,300,1040,330,1040,330c1040,330,1154,330,1154,330c1170,330,1180,316,1180,299c1180,299,1180,300,1180,300c1180,300,1180,122,1180,122c1180,106,1170,90,1154,90c1154,90,1035,90,1035,90c1019,90,1010,106,1010,122c1010,122,1010,241,1010,241c1010,241,1010,241,1010,241m1150,240c1150,240,1040,240,1040,240c1040,240,1040,120,1040,120c1040,120,1150,120,1150,120c1150,120,1150,240,1150,240c1150,240,1150,240,1150,240m950,90c950,90,834,90,834,90c818,90,800,106,800,122c800,122,800,241,800,241c800,241,800,240,800,240c800,256,818,270,834,270c834,270,980,270,980,270c980,270,980,0,980,0c980,0,950,0,950,0c950,0,950,90,950,90c950,90,950,90,950,90m950,240c950,240,830,240,830,240c830,240,830,120,830,120c830,120,950,120,950,120c950,120,950,240,950,240c950,240,950,240,950,240m1200,241c1200,257,1217,270,1233,270c1233,270,1350,270,1350,270c1350,270,1350,240,1350,240c1350,240,1230,240,1230,240c1230,240,1230,210,1230,210c1230,210,1352,210,1352,210c1368,210,1380,197,1380,181c1380,181,1380,182,1380,182c1380,182,1380,123,1380,123c1380,107,1368,91,1352,91c1352,91,1233,91,1233,91c1217,91,1200,107,1200,123c1200,123,1200,241,1200,241c1200,241,1200,241,1200,241m1350,180c1350,180,1230,180,1230,180c1230,180,1230,120,1230,120c1230,120,1350,120,1350,120c1350,120,1350,180,1350,180c1350,180,1350,180,1350,180e" ></v:shape></div></div><b class="D(n)">Engadget</b></a></div><div class="D(f)! D(n)!--md"><a href="https://oidc.engadget.com/login?dest=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.engadget.com&pspid=1197802876&activity=header" class="D(if) Ai(c) Ff($ff-primary) Fz(15px) Fz(400) C(engadgetFontDarkGray) C(engadgetFontBlack):h Td(n) Bxz(bb)" data-ylk="sec:header;subsec:account;slk:profile;elm:link;itc:0">Login</a></div><button class="P(0) Cur(p) Bd(n) Bgc(t) C(engadgetFontLightGray) wafer-toggle D(n)! D(b)!--md W(80px) W(60px)!--xs H(100%) Pos(r) Bdstarts(s)! Bdstartw(1px)! Bdstartc(engadgetGray)! srchBtn" data-component="IconButton" type="button" data-wf-toggle-class="click:toggle:active" data-wf-toggle-target="#search" aria-label="Search" title="Search"><div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontLightGray) Stk(engadgetFontLightGray) srchBtn:h_Fill(#fff) srchBtn:h_Stk(#fff) Cur(p)" data-icon="search"><v:shape style="height:20px; width:20px;" coordsize="240,240" id="search" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m90,30c57,30,30,57,30,90c30,123,57,150,90,150c123,150,150,123,150,90c150,57,123,30,90,30m227,227c223,231,217,231,213,227c213,227,139,153,139,153c126,164,109,170,90,170c46,170,10,134,10,90c10,46,46,10,90,10c134,10,170,46,170,90c170,109,164,126,153,139c153,139,227,213,227,213c231,217,231,223,227,227e" ></v:shape></div></div></button></div></div></div><script> window.performance.mark('header'); window.performance.measure('headerDone','PageStart','header'); </script></div><div id=module-engadgetNav class=wafer-rapid-module><div><nav class="Pos(r)" data-component="Nav"><div class="rwd-outer-container W(100vw) D(f) Jc(sa) Bgc(engadgetSteelGray) D(n)--md Bdbc(engadgetGray) Bdbs(s) Bdbw(1px)" data-component="RWDContainer"><div class="rwd-inner-container W(1235px) W(980px)--lg W(640px)--md W(100%)--sm Mx(20px)--sm D(f) Jc(sb) Ai(c)"><ul class="List(n) D(f) P(0) M(0) H(80px) Pos(r) Start(-25px)"><li data-component="NavItem" class=""><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) wafer-toggle C(engadgetFontLightGray) C(#engadgetWhiteSmoke):h menu-toggle Pos(r) Whs(nw) Mstart(5px) Mstart(0)!--md Bdts(s) Bdtw(1px) Bdtc(engadgetLightGray) Fz(16px)!--md H(65px)!--md Pstart(20px) P(10px)!--lg Lh(20px)--md" href="/reviews/" data-wf-toggle-class="click:toggle:active;click:toggle:Bgc(engadgetGray);click:toggle:C(white)" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:1;sec:navrail">Reviews<div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontGray) Stk(engadgetFontGray) Px(5px) Pt(3px) Cur(p)" data-icon="caret-down"><v:shape style="height:16px; width:16px;" coordsize="480,480" id="caret-down" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m242,332c242,332,369,204,369,204c377,197,377,184,369,176c362,168,349,168,341,176c341,176,242,275,242,275c242,275,143,176,143,176c135,168,123,168,115,176c107,184,107,197,115,204c115,204,242,332,242,332c242,332,242,332,242,332e" ></v:shape></div></div></a><ul data-component="SubNav" class="menu-options sub-nav Bxz(bb) D(n) active+D(f) Miw(200px) Fxd(c) Pos(a) T(100%) Bgc(engadgetGray) Px(0) Pt(10px) Pb(20px) Z(5001) Pos(r)!--md T(a)!--md Pt(0)!--md Mstart(5px) Pend(8px)"><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/best-tech/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Best in Tech</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/tag/hands-on/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Hands-On</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/reviews/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">View all Reviews</a></li></ul></li><li data-component="NavItem" class=""><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) wafer-toggle C(engadgetFontLightGray) C(#engadgetWhiteSmoke):h menu-toggle Pos(r) Whs(nw) Mstart(5px) Mstart(0)!--md Bdts(s) Bdtw(1px) Bdtc(engadgetLightGray) Fz(16px)!--md H(65px)!--md Pstart(20px) P(10px)!--lg Lh(20px)--md" href="/best-tech/" data-wf-toggle-class="click:toggle:active;click:toggle:Bgc(engadgetGray);click:toggle:C(white)" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:1;sec:navrail">Buying Guides<div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontGray) Stk(engadgetFontGray) Px(5px) Pt(3px) Cur(p)" data-icon="caret-down"><v:shape style="height:16px; width:16px;" coordsize="480,480" id="caret-down" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m242,332c242,332,369,204,369,204c377,197,377,184,369,176c362,168,349,168,341,176c341,176,242,275,242,275c242,275,143,176,143,176c135,168,123,168,115,176c107,184,107,197,115,204c115,204,242,332,242,332c242,332,242,332,242,332e" ></v:shape></div></div></a><ul data-component="SubNav" class="menu-options sub-nav Bxz(bb) D(n) active+D(f) Miw(200px) Fxd(c) Pos(a) T(100%) Bgc(engadgetGray) Px(0) Pt(10px) Pb(20px) Z(5001) Pos(r)!--md T(a)!--md Pt(0)!--md Mstart(5px) Pend(8px)"><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/audio/headphones/best-wireless-earbuds-120058222.html" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Best Wireless Earbuds</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/home/smart-home/best-robot-vacuums-130010426.html" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Best Robot Vacuums</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/computing/laptops/best-laptops-120008636.html" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Best Laptops</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/best-gaming-laptops-172033838.html" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Best Gaming Laptops</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/the-best-budgeting-apps-to-replace-mint-143047346.html" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Best Mint Alternatives</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/best-vpn-130004396.html" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Best VPN</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/best-bluetooth-tracker-140028377.html" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Best Bluetooth Trackers</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/best-tech/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">View all Buying Guides</a></li></ul></li><li data-component="NavItem" class=""><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) wafer-toggle C(engadgetFontLightGray) C(#engadgetWhiteSmoke):h menu-toggle Pos(r) Whs(nw) Mstart(5px) Mstart(0)!--md Bdts(s) Bdtw(1px) Bdtc(engadgetLightGray) Fz(16px)!--md H(65px)!--md Pstart(20px) P(10px)!--lg Lh(20px)--md" href="/gaming/" data-wf-toggle-class="click:toggle:active;click:toggle:Bgc(engadgetGray);click:toggle:C(white)" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:1;sec:navrail">Gaming<div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontGray) Stk(engadgetFontGray) Px(5px) Pt(3px) Cur(p)" data-icon="caret-down"><v:shape style="height:16px; width:16px;" coordsize="480,480" id="caret-down" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m242,332c242,332,369,204,369,204c377,197,377,184,369,176c362,168,349,168,341,176c341,176,242,275,242,275c242,275,143,176,143,176c135,168,123,168,115,176c107,184,107,197,115,204c115,204,242,332,242,332c242,332,242,332,242,332e" ></v:shape></div></div></a><ul data-component="SubNav" class="menu-options sub-nav Bxz(bb) D(n) active+D(f) Miw(200px) Fxd(c) Pos(a) T(100%) Bgc(engadgetGray) Px(0) Pt(10px) Pb(20px) Z(5001) Pos(r)!--md T(a)!--md Pt(0)!--md Mstart(5px) Pend(8px)"><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/gaming/playstation/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">PlayStation</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/gaming/nintendo/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Nintendo</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/gaming/xbox/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Xbox</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/gaming/pc/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">PC Gaming</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/gaming/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">All Gaming News</a></li></ul></li><li data-component="NavItem" class=""><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) wafer-toggle C(engadgetFontLightGray) C(#engadgetWhiteSmoke):h menu-toggle Pos(r) Whs(nw) Mstart(5px) Mstart(0)!--md Bdts(s) Bdtw(1px) Bdtc(engadgetLightGray) Fz(16px)!--md H(65px)!--md Pstart(20px) P(10px)!--lg Lh(20px)--md" href="/gear/" data-wf-toggle-class="click:toggle:active;click:toggle:Bgc(engadgetGray);click:toggle:C(white)" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:1;sec:navrail">Gear<div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontGray) Stk(engadgetFontGray) Px(5px) Pt(3px) Cur(p)" data-icon="caret-down"><v:shape style="height:16px; width:16px;" coordsize="480,480" id="caret-down" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m242,332c242,332,369,204,369,204c377,197,377,184,369,176c362,168,349,168,341,176c341,176,242,275,242,275c242,275,143,176,143,176c135,168,123,168,115,176c107,184,107,197,115,204c115,204,242,332,242,332c242,332,242,332,242,332e" ></v:shape></div></div></a><ul data-component="SubNav" class="menu-options sub-nav Bxz(bb) D(n) active+D(f) Miw(200px) Fxd(c) Pos(a) T(100%) Bgc(engadgetGray) Px(0) Pt(10px) Pb(20px) Z(5001) Pos(r)!--md T(a)!--md Pt(0)!--md Mstart(5px) Pend(8px)"><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/gear/amazon/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Amazon</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/gear/apple/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Apple</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/gear/google/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Google</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/gear/microsoft/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Microsoft</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/gear/samsung/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Samsung</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/gear/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">View all Gear</a></li></ul></li><li data-component="NavItem" class=""><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) wafer-toggle C(engadgetFontLightGray) C(#engadgetWhiteSmoke):h menu-toggle Pos(r) Whs(nw) Mstart(5px) Mstart(0)!--md Bdts(s) Bdtw(1px) Bdtc(engadgetLightGray) Fz(16px)!--md H(65px)!--md Pstart(20px) P(10px)!--lg Lh(20px)--md" href="/entertainment/" data-wf-toggle-class="click:toggle:active;click:toggle:Bgc(engadgetGray);click:toggle:C(white)" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:1;sec:navrail">Entertainment<div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontGray) Stk(engadgetFontGray) Px(5px) Pt(3px) Cur(p)" data-icon="caret-down"><v:shape style="height:16px; width:16px;" coordsize="480,480" id="caret-down" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m242,332c242,332,369,204,369,204c377,197,377,184,369,176c362,168,349,168,341,176c341,176,242,275,242,275c242,275,143,176,143,176c135,168,123,168,115,176c107,184,107,197,115,204c115,204,242,332,242,332c242,332,242,332,242,332e" ></v:shape></div></div></a><ul data-component="SubNav" class="menu-options sub-nav Bxz(bb) D(n) active+D(f) Miw(200px) Fxd(c) Pos(a) T(100%) Bgc(engadgetGray) Px(0) Pt(10px) Pb(20px) Z(5001) Pos(r)!--md T(a)!--md Pt(0)!--md Mstart(5px) Pend(8px)"><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/entertainment/tv-movies/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">TV & Movies</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/entertainment/music/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Music</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/entertainment/streaming/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Streaming</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/entertainment/youtube/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">YouTube</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/entertainment/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">View all Entertainment</a></li></ul></li><li data-component="NavItem" class=""><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) wafer-toggle C(engadgetFontLightGray) C(#engadgetWhiteSmoke):h menu-toggle Pos(r) Whs(nw) Mstart(5px) Mstart(0)!--md Bdts(s) Bdtw(1px) Bdtc(engadgetLightGray) Fz(16px)!--md H(65px)!--md Pstart(20px) P(10px)!--lg Lh(20px)--md" href="/tomorrow/" data-wf-toggle-class="click:toggle:active;click:toggle:Bgc(engadgetGray);click:toggle:C(white)" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:1;sec:navrail">Tomorrow<div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontGray) Stk(engadgetFontGray) Px(5px) Pt(3px) Cur(p)" data-icon="caret-down"><v:shape style="height:16px; width:16px;" coordsize="480,480" id="caret-down" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m242,332c242,332,369,204,369,204c377,197,377,184,369,176c362,168,349,168,341,176c341,176,242,275,242,275c242,275,143,176,143,176c135,168,123,168,115,176c107,184,107,197,115,204c115,204,242,332,242,332c242,332,242,332,242,332e" ></v:shape></div></div></a><ul data-component="SubNav" class="menu-options sub-nav Bxz(bb) D(n) active+D(f) Miw(200px) Fxd(c) Pos(a) T(100%) Bgc(engadgetGray) Px(0) Pt(10px) Pb(20px) Z(5001) Pos(r)!--md T(a)!--md Pt(0)!--md Mstart(5px) Pend(8px)"><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/science/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Science</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/science/space/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Space</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/ai/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">AI</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/science/robotics/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Robotics</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/transportation/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Transportation</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/tomorrow/" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">View all Tomorrow</a></li></ul></li><li data-component="NavItem" class=""><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetFontLightGray) C(#engadgetWhiteSmoke):h menu-toggle Pos(r) Whs(nw) Mstart(5px) Mstart(0)!--md Bdts(s) Bdtw(1px) Bdtc(engadgetLightGray) Fz(16px)!--md H(65px)!--md Pstart(20px) P(10px)!--lg Lh(20px)--md" href="/deals/" data-wf-toggle-class="false" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail">Deals</a></li><li data-component="NavItem" class=""><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetFontLightGray) C(#engadgetWhiteSmoke):h menu-toggle Pos(r) Whs(nw) Mstart(5px) Mstart(0)!--md Bdts(s) Bdtw(1px) Bdtc(engadgetLightGray) Fz(16px)!--md H(65px)!--md Pstart(20px) P(10px)!--lg Lh(20px)--md" href="/news/" data-wf-toggle-class="false" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail">News</a></li><li data-component="NavItem" class=""><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) wafer-toggle C(engadgetFontLightGray) C(#engadgetWhiteSmoke):h menu-toggle Pos(r) Whs(nw) Mstart(5px) Mstart(0)!--md Bdts(s) Bdtw(1px) Bdtc(engadgetLightGray) Fz(16px)!--md H(65px)!--md Pstart(20px) P(10px)!--lg Lh(20px)--md" href="/black-friday/" data-wf-toggle-class="click:toggle:active;click:toggle:Bgc(engadgetGray);click:toggle:C(white)" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:1;sec:navrail">Black Friday 2024<div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontGray) Stk(engadgetFontGray) Px(5px) Pt(3px) Cur(p)" data-icon="caret-down"><v:shape style="height:16px; width:16px;" coordsize="480,480" id="caret-down" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m242,332c242,332,369,204,369,204c377,197,377,184,369,176c362,168,349,168,341,176c341,176,242,275,242,275c242,275,143,176,143,176c135,168,123,168,115,176c107,184,107,197,115,204c115,204,242,332,242,332c242,332,242,332,242,332e" ></v:shape></div></div></a><ul data-component="SubNav" class="menu-options sub-nav Bxz(bb) D(n) active+D(f) Miw(200px) Fxd(c) Pos(a) T(100%) Bgc(engadgetGray) Px(0) Pt(10px) Pb(20px) Z(5001) Pos(r)!--md T(a)!--md Pt(0)!--md Mstart(5px) Pend(8px)"><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/deals/the-41-black-friday-tech-deals-worth-shopping-from-amazon-walmart-apple-anker-and-others-163039051.html" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Best Black Friday deals</a></li><li data-component="SubNavItem" class="menu-item D(b) Lh(40px) Whs(nw) Bgc(engadgetFontBlack):h"><a data-component="NavLink" class="D(if) H(100%) W(100%) Ai(c) Fz(18px) Lh(30px) Fw(700) Td(n) Bxz(bb) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Px(15px) Fw(400)!" href="/deals/black-friday-apple-deals-2024-the-best-apple-sales-on-ipads-airpods-apple-watches-and-macbooks-165143887.html" data-ylk="elm:navcat;itc:0;sec:navrail;subsec:sub" aria-hidden="true">Black Friday Apple Deals</a></li></ul></li></ul><div class="D(f) Ai(c)"><ul class="D(f) D(n)!--lg Ai(c) List(n) Pstart(0) Pend(25px) M(0)"><li data-component="SocialItem" class="Mstart(25px) socialLink"><a href="https://www.facebook.com/Engadget/" alt="Facebook" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" class="C(white)" data-ylk="sec:hl-viewer;slk:Facebook;elm:share;itc:0"><span class="D(n)">Facebook</span><div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontGray) Stk(engadgetFontGray) socialLink:h_Fill(#fff) socialLink:h_Stk(#fff) Cur(p)" data-icon="LogoFacebook"><v:shape style="height:24px; width:24px;" coordsize="320,320" id="LogoFacebook" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m128,304c128,304,128,169,128,169c128,169,94,169,94,169c94,169,94,120,94,120c94,120,128,120,128,120c128,120,128,79,128,79c128,46,148,16,194,16c212,16,226,18,226,18c226,18,225,63,225,63c225,63,211,63,196,63c179,63,176,71,176,85c176,85,176,120,176,120c176,120,226,120,226,120c226,120,224,169,224,169c224,169,176,169,176,169c176,169,176,304,176,304c176,304,128,304,128,304c128,304,128,304,128,304e" ></v:shape></div></div></a></li><li data-component="SocialItem" class="Mstart(25px) socialLink"><a href="https://twitter.com/engadget/" alt="Twitter" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" class="C(white)" data-ylk="sec:hl-viewer;slk:Twitter;elm:share;itc:0"><span class="D(n)">Twitter</span><div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontGray) Stk(engadgetFontGray) socialLink:h_Fill(#fff) socialLink:h_Stk(#fff) Cur(p)" data-icon="LogoTwitter"><v:shape style="height:24px; width:24px;" coordsize="240,240" id="LogoTwitter" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m139,108c139,108,213,23,213,23c213,23,196,23,196,23c196,23,131,97,131,97c131,97,80,23,80,23c80,23,20,23,20,23c20,23,98,134,98,134c98,134,20,223,20,223c20,223,38,223,38,223c38,223,106,145,106,145c106,145,160,223,160,223c160,223,220,223,220,223c220,223,139,108,139,108c139,108,139,108,139,108c139,108,139,108,139,108m115,135c115,135,107,124,107,124c107,124,44,36,44,36c44,36,71,36,71,36c71,36,122,107,122,107c122,107,130,118,130,118c130,118,196,211,196,211c196,211,169,211,169,211c169,211,115,135,115,135c115,135,115,135,115,135c115,135,115,135,115,135e" ></v:shape></div></div></a></li><li data-component="SocialItem" class="Mstart(25px) socialLink"><a href="https://www.youtube.com/user/engadget" alt="YouTube" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" class="C(white)" data-ylk="sec:hl-viewer;slk:YouTube;elm:share;itc:0"><span class="D(n)">YouTube</span><div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontGray) Stk(engadgetFontGray) socialLink:h_Fill(#fff) socialLink:h_Stk(#fff) Cur(p)" data-icon="LogoYoutube"><v:shape style="height:24px; width:24px;" coordsize="240,240" id="LogoYoutube" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m97,151c97,151,97,89,97,89c97,89,157,120,157,120c157,120,97,151,97,151c97,151,97,151,97,151m228,79c228,79,226,63,219,57c211,48,201,48,197,48c166,45,120,45,120,45c120,45,120,45,120,45c120,45,74,45,43,48c39,48,29,48,21,57c14,64,12,79,12,79c12,79,10,96,10,114c10,114,10,131,10,131c10,149,12,167,12,167c12,167,14,182,21,188c29,197,40,197,45,198c63,199,120,200,120,200c120,200,166,200,197,198c201,197,211,197,219,188c226,182,228,167,228,167c228,167,230,149,230,131c230,131,230,114,230,114c230,96,228,79,228,79c228,79,228,79,228,79e" ></v:shape></div></div></a></li></ul><button class="P(0) Cur(p) Bd(n) Bgc(t) C(engadgetFontLightGray) srchBtn" data-component="IconButton" type="button" id="searchBtn" aria-label="Search" title="Search"><div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontLightGray) Stk(engadgetFontLightGray) srchBtn:h_Fill(white) srchBtn:h_Stk(white) Cur(p)" data-icon="search"><v:shape style="height:20px; width:20px;" coordsize="240,240" id="search" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m90,30c57,30,30,57,30,90c30,123,57,150,90,150c123,150,150,123,150,90c150,57,123,30,90,30m227,227c223,231,217,231,213,227c213,227,139,153,139,153c126,164,109,170,90,170c46,170,10,134,10,90c10,46,46,10,90,10c134,10,170,46,170,90c170,109,164,126,153,139c153,139,227,213,227,213c231,217,231,223,227,227e" ></v:shape></div></div></button></div></div></div><nav id="fixed-nav" aria-hidden="true" data-component="FixedNav" class="Pos(f) T(0) Start(0) W(100%) Z(5000) TranslateY(-100%) Trsp(transform) Trsdu(0.5s) Trstf(eo)"><div class="rwd-outer-container W(100vw) D(f) Jc(sa) H(80px) Bgc(engadgetSteelGray) D(n)--md Bdbc(engadgetGray) Bdbs(s) Bdbw(1px)" data-component="RWDContainer"><div class="rwd-inner-container W(1235px) W(980px)--lg W(640px)--md W(100%)--sm Mx(20px)--sm Maw(1235px) Maw(980px)--lg D(f) Ai(c) Jc(sb)"><div class="D(f) Ai(c) H(100%)"><a href="/" alt="Engadget US" class="Td(n) Pend(50px)" data-ylk="sec:lnav;elm:logo;itc:0" aria-label="Engadget US"><div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(#fff) Stk(#fff) Cur(p)" data-icon="logo-engadget"><v:shape style="height:33px; width:33px;" coordsize="1520,330" id="logo-engadget" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m0,241c0,257,13,270,30,270c30,270,150,270,150,270c150,270,150,240,150,240c150,240,30,240,30,240c30,240,30,210,30,210c30,210,148,210,148,210c164,210,180,197,180,181c180,181,180,182,180,182c180,182,180,123,180,123c180,107,165,91,148,91c148,91,30,91,30,91c14,91,0,107,0,123c0,123,0,241,0,241c0,241,0,241,0,241m150,180c150,180,30,180,30,180c30,180,30,120,30,120c30,120,150,120,150,120c150,120,150,180,150,180c150,180,150,180,150,180m551,90c551,90,432,90,432,90c416,90,400,106,400,122c400,122,400,241,400,241c400,241,400,240,400,240c400,256,416,270,432,270c432,270,550,270,550,270c550,270,550,300,550,300c550,300,430,300,430,300c430,300,430,330,430,330c430,330,551,330,551,330c567,330,580,316,580,300c580,300,580,122,580,122c580,106,567,90,551,90c551,90,551,90,551,90m550,240c550,240,430,240,430,240c430,240,430,120,430,120c430,120,550,120,550,120c550,120,550,240,550,240c550,240,550,240,550,240m320,90c320,90,231,90,231,90c215,90,200,106,200,122c200,122,200,270,200,270c200,270,230,270,230,270c230,270,230,120,230,120c230,120,320,120,320,120c336,120,350,135,350,152c350,152,350,270,350,270c350,270,380,270,380,270c380,270,380,152,380,152c380,119,353,90,320,90c320,90,320,90,320,90m750,240c750,240,630,240,630,240c630,240,630,151,630,151c630,135,646,119,663,119c663,119,750,119,750,119c750,119,750,269,750,269c750,269,780,269,780,269c780,269,780,122,780,122c780,106,768,90,752,90c752,90,663,90,663,90c630,90,600,119,600,152c600,152,600,241,600,241c600,257,617,270,633,270c633,270,685,270,685,270c712,270,740,259,750,240c750,240,750,270,750,270m1430,0c1430,0,1400,0,1400,0c1400,0,1400,270,1400,270c1400,270,1430,270,1430,270c1430,270,1430,120,1430,120c1430,120,1520,120,1520,120c1520,120,1520,90,1520,90c1520,90,1430,90,1430,90c1430,90,1430,0,1430,0m1010,241c1010,257,1019,270,1035,270c1035,270,1150,270,1150,270c1150,270,1150,300,1150,300c1150,300,1040,300,1040,300c1040,300,1040,330,1040,330c1040,330,1154,330,1154,330c1170,330,1180,316,1180,299c1180,299,1180,300,1180,300c1180,300,1180,122,1180,122c1180,106,1170,90,1154,90c1154,90,1035,90,1035,90c1019,90,1010,106,1010,122c1010,122,1010,241,1010,241c1010,241,1010,241,1010,241m1150,240c1150,240,1040,240,1040,240c1040,240,1040,120,1040,120c1040,120,1150,120,1150,120c1150,120,1150,240,1150,240c1150,240,1150,240,1150,240m950,90c950,90,834,90,834,90c818,90,800,106,800,122c800,122,800,241,800,241c800,241,800,240,800,240c800,256,818,270,834,270c834,270,980,270,980,270c980,270,980,0,980,0c980,0,950,0,950,0c950,0,950,90,950,90c950,90,950,90,950,90m950,240c950,240,830,240,830,240c830,240,830,120,830,120c830,120,950,120,950,120c950,120,950,240,950,240c950,240,950,240,950,240m1200,241c1200,257,1217,270,1233,270c1233,270,1350,270,1350,270c1350,270,1350,240,1350,240c1350,240,1230,240,1230,240c1230,240,1230,210,1230,210c1230,210,1352,210,1352,210c1368,210,1380,197,1380,181c1380,181,1380,182,1380,182c1380,182,1380,123,1380,123c1380,107,1368,91,1352,91c1352,91,1233,91,1233,91c1217,91,1200,107,1200,123c1200,123,1200,241,1200,241c1200,241,1200,241,1200,241m1350,180c1350,180,1230,180,1230,180c1230,180,1230,120,1230,120c1230,120,1350,120,1350,120c1350,120,1350,180,1350,180c1350,180,1350,180,1350,180e" ></v:shape></div></div></a><div class="Pos(r) H(100%)"><button class="drawer-toggle wafer-toggle H(100%) Px(60px) BdX Bdc(engadgetGray) D(f) Ai(c) Bgc(t) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(#fff):h Fz(16px) Cur(p)" type="button" data-wf-toggle-class="click:toggle:active" aria-label="Sections" data-ylk="itc:0;sec:lnav;slk:Sections;elm:link">Sections<div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontGray) Stk(engadgetFontGray) drawer-toggle:h_Fill(#fff) drawer-toggle:h_Stk(#fff) Mstart(10px) Cur(p)" data-icon="caret-down"><v:shape style="height:20px; width:20px;" coordsize="480,480" id="caret-down" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m242,332c242,332,369,204,369,204c377,197,377,184,369,176c362,168,349,168,341,176c341,176,242,275,242,275c242,275,143,176,143,176c135,168,123,168,115,176c107,184,107,197,115,204c115,204,242,332,242,332c242,332,242,332,242,332e" ></v:shape></div></div></button><ul id="nav-drawer" data-component="Drawer" class="D(n) List(n) Fld(c) Ai(fs) Pos(a) W(100%) T(100%) Start(0) M(0) P(0) Pt(10px)! Pb(20px)! Bgc(engadgetGray) C(white) BdT Bdtc(engadgetLightGray)"><li class="Py(5px) Px(25px)"><a href="/reviews/" class="Fz(16px) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(white):h Td(n)" data-ylk="sec:lnav;elm:navcat;itc:0">Reviews</a></li><li class="Py(5px) Px(25px)"><a href="/best-tech/" class="Fz(16px) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(white):h Td(n)" data-ylk="sec:lnav;elm:navcat;itc:0">Buying Guides</a></li><li class="Py(5px) Px(25px)"><a href="/gaming/" class="Fz(16px) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(white):h Td(n)" data-ylk="sec:lnav;elm:navcat;itc:0">Gaming</a></li><li class="Py(5px) Px(25px)"><a href="/gear/" class="Fz(16px) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(white):h Td(n)" data-ylk="sec:lnav;elm:navcat;itc:0">Gear</a></li><li class="Py(5px) Px(25px)"><a href="/entertainment/" class="Fz(16px) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(white):h Td(n)" data-ylk="sec:lnav;elm:navcat;itc:0">Entertainment</a></li><li class="Py(5px) Px(25px)"><a href="/tomorrow/" class="Fz(16px) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(white):h Td(n)" data-ylk="sec:lnav;elm:navcat;itc:0">Tomorrow</a></li><li class="Py(5px) Px(25px)"><a href="/deals/" class="Fz(16px) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(white):h Td(n)" data-ylk="sec:lnav;elm:navcat;itc:0">Deals</a></li><li class="Py(5px) Px(25px)"><a href="/news/" class="Fz(16px) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(white):h Td(n)" data-ylk="sec:lnav;elm:navcat;itc:0">News</a></li><li class="Py(5px) Px(25px)"><a href="/black-friday/" class="Fz(16px) C(engadgetWhiteGray) C(white):h Td(n)" data-ylk="sec:lnav;elm:navcat;itc:0">Black Friday 2024</a></li></ul></div></div><div class="D(f) Ai(c) H(100%)"><div class="D(ib) Pend(20px)"><a href="https://oidc.engadget.com/login?dest=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.engadget.com&pspid=1197802876&activity=header" class="D(if) Ai(c) Fz(15px) Fz(400) C(engadgetFontGray) C(#fff):h Td(n) Bxz(bb)" data-ylk="sec:header;subsec:account;slk:login;elm:link;itc:0" aria-label="login">Login</a></div><button class="P(0) Cur(p) Bd(n) Bgc(t) C(engadgetFontLightGray) wafer-toggle BdStart! Bdc(engadgetGray)! W(80px) H(100%) srchBtn" data-component="IconButton" type="button" data-wf-toggle-class="click:toggle:active" data-wf-toggle-target="#search" aria-label="Search" title="Search"><div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontGray) Stk(engadgetFontGray) srchBtn:h_Fill(#fff) srchBtn:h_Stk(#fff) Cur(p)" data-icon="search"><v:shape style="height:20px; width:20px;" coordsize="240,240" id="search" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m90,30c57,30,30,57,30,90c30,123,57,150,90,150c123,150,150,123,150,90c150,57,123,30,90,30m227,227c223,231,217,231,213,227c213,227,139,153,139,153c126,164,109,170,90,170c46,170,10,134,10,90c10,46,46,10,90,10c134,10,170,46,170,90c170,109,164,126,153,139c153,139,227,213,227,213c231,217,231,223,227,227e" ></v:shape></div></div></button></div></div></div></nav><form id="search" data-component="Search" class="V(h) Pe(n) Op(0) Trsdu(0.2s) Trstf(eo) Pos(a) T(0) Start(0) W(100%) Pos(f)!--md H(80px) H(60px)!--xs Z(5001) Bgc(engadgetGray)" style="transition-property:opacity" action="https://search.engadget.com/search" aria-label="Search form"><div class="rwd-outer-container W(100vw) D(f) Jc(sa) H(100%) BdB Bdbc(engadgetFontGray)" data-component="RWDContainer"><div class="rwd-inner-container W(1235px) W(980px)--lg W(640px)--md W(100%)--sm Mx(20px)--sm D(f) Ai(c)"><button class="P(0) Cur(p) Bd(n) Bgc(t) C(engadgetFontLightGray) P(0) Pend(16px)! Bd(n) Bgc(t) C(engadgetFontLightGray)" data-component="IconButton" type="submit" aria-label="Search" title="Search" data-ylk="sec:nav;slk:vert-srch;elm:search;elmt:icon;itc:1"><div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontLightGray) Stk(engadgetFontLightGray) W(24px) H(24px) W(20px)--xs H(20px)--xs Cur(p)" data-icon="search"><v:shape style="height:24px; width:24px;" coordsize="240,240" id="search" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m90,30c57,30,30,57,30,90c30,123,57,150,90,150c123,150,150,123,150,90c150,57,123,30,90,30m227,227c223,231,217,231,213,227c213,227,139,153,139,153c126,164,109,170,90,170c46,170,10,134,10,90c10,46,46,10,90,10c134,10,170,46,170,90c170,109,164,126,153,139c153,139,227,213,227,213c231,217,231,223,227,227e" ></v:shape></div></div></button><input type="text" id="search-terms" name="p" class="Fz(22px) Fz(18px)--xs C(engadgetFontLightGray) C(engadgetFontLightGray)::ph Bgc(t) O(n) Bd(n) Fxg(1)" placeholder="What are you searching for?" autofocus="" required="" aria-autocomplete="both" aria-roledescription="combobox" aria-expanded="false" aria-label="Search"/><input type="hidden" name="fr" value="engadget"/><button class="P(0) Cur(p) Bd(n) Bgc(t) C(engadgetFontLightGray) wafer-toggle P(0) Cur(p) Bd(n) Bgc(t) C(engadgetFontLightGray) Mend(-4px) clsBtn" data-component="IconButton" id="searchCancelBtn" type="button" aria-label="Cancel" title="Cancel" data-wf-toggle-class="click:toggle:active" data-wf-toggle-target="#search"><div class="D(i)"><span><style>v\:shape { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><style>v\:shapetype { behavior:url(#default#VML); display:inline-block }</style><xml:namespace ns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" prefix="v" /></span><div class="D(ib) Fill(engadgetFontLightGray) Stk(engadgetFontLightGray) clsBtn:h_Fill(#fff) clsBtn:h_Stk(#fff) W(30px) H(30px) W(24px)!--xs H(24px)!--xs Cur(p)" data-icon="close"><v:shape style="height:48px; width:48px;" coordsize="480,480" id="close" strokecolor="undefined" fillcolor="undefined" path="m380,348c380,348,281,249,281,249c281,249,380,150,380,150c388,142,388,130,380,122c372,114,359,114,352,122c352,122,253,221,253,221c253,221,154,122,154,122c146,114,133,114,125,122c117,130,117,142,125,150c125,150,224,249,224,249c224,249,125,348,125,348c117,356,117,369,125,377c133,384,146,384,154,377c154,377,253,278,253,278c253,278,352,377,352,377c359,384,372,384,380,377c388,369,388,356,380,348c380,348,380,348,380,348e" ></v:shape></div></div></button></div></div><div class="W(100%) Bgc(engadgetGray) C(engadgetFontLightGray) Bdtc(engadgetBlack) Bdts(s) Bdtw(1px) D(f) Jc(sa)" style="transition:opacity .3s ease"><div class="rwd-outer-container W(100vw) D(f) Jc(sa)" data-component="RWDContainer"><div class="rwd-inner-container W(1235px) W(980px)--lg W(640px)--md W(100%)--sm Mx(20px)--sm D(f)"><div id="search-results" class="W(100%) Ov(a) Mah(330px)"></div></div></div></div></form></nav></div><script> window.performance.mark('engadgetNav'); window.performance.measure('engadgetNavDone','PageStart','engadgetNav'); </script></div></header><div class="Ov(h) Trs($adTranslate) HideBottomBar_H(0)"><div id="sda-LDRB-iframe" class=" Mt(20px) Mb(24px) Ta(c) Mx(a) Mih(90px) Pos(r) Z(9) Miw(728px)" data-content="Advertisement"><div class="sdaLite_D(n) D(f) Ai(c) Jc(c) Bgc(#f5f8fa) Fz(12px) C(#6e7780) Mx(a) H(90px) Pos(r) Z(9) W(728px)">Advertisement</div></div></div><div id=HeadlineSection class=Pos(r)><div id=module-featurebar class="wafer-rapid-module My(10px) Mah(68px) Maw(1260px) Miw(980px) Mx(a)"><script> window.performance.mark('featurebar'); window.performance.measure('featurebarDone','PageStart','featurebar'); </script></div><div id=module-engadgetTopTrendingBar class="wafer-rapid-module My(10px) Mah(68px) Maw(1260px) Miw(980px) Mx(a)"><div><section data-component="TrendingNowStream" id="TrendingNowStream"><div class="Mx(20px) Mt(16px)!--sm Mb(-16px)!--sm Mt(0)--lg Mb(0)--lg Mt(0)--xl Mb(33px)--xl D(f) Ai(c) Ovx(s) Ovs(touch) Pt(5px) Pstart(10px)--xl"><ul class="List(n) D(if) Jc(fs)--xl W(100%)--xl Jc(fs)--lg Ai(c) Fxs(0) H(54px)"><li class="Mb(10px) Mstart(2px)"><a class="sans Ov(h) Td(n) Whs(nw)" href="https://www.engadget.com/deals/amazon-black-friday-2024-deals-the-best-discounts-on-echo-speakers-ring-doorbells-and-kindles-worth-shopping-right-now-130003840.html" data-ylk="cpos:0;elm:hdln;elmt:ct;g:6ef4b9b3-3815-4aab-965c-c3d2857c6364;itc:0;sec:trending-now;slk:https://www.engadget.com/deals/amazon-black-friday-2024-deals-the-best-discounts-on-echo-speakers-ring-doorbells-and-kindles-worth-shopping-right-now-130003840.html"><div class="trendingNow-cont Fz(14px) Lh(20px) Fw(500) Mend(20px) Px(20px) Py(10px) H(20px) Bdc(#fff) Bds(s) Bdw(0.5px) Bdrs(8px) Ta(c)" style="box-shadow:0 2px 4px rgba(0,0,0,.2);transition:all .4s ease-in-out"><span class="C(#232a31)">Best Amazon device Black Friday deals</span></div></a></li><li class="Mb(10px) Mstart(2px)"><a class="sans Ov(h) Td(n) Whs(nw)" href="https://www.engadget.com/deals/black-friday-gaming-deals-2024-the-best-sales-on-video-games-consoles-accessories-and-more-144605738.html" data-ylk="cpos:1;elm:hdln;elmt:ct;g:350277de-9ed0-464e-843a-f5e7ea0403c5;itc:0;sec:trending-now;slk:https://www.engadget.com/deals/black-friday-gaming-deals-2024-the-best-sales-on-video-games-consoles-accessories-and-more-144605738.html"><div class="trendingNow-cont Fz(14px) Lh(20px) Fw(500) Mend(20px) Px(20px) Py(10px) H(20px) Bdc(#fff) Bds(s) Bdw(0.5px) Bdrs(8px) Ta(c)" style="box-shadow:0 2px 4px rgba(0,0,0,.2);transition:all .4s ease-in-out"><span class="C(#232a31)">Best Black Friday gaming deals</span></div></a></li><li class="Mb(10px) Mstart(2px)"><a class="sans Ov(h) Td(n) Whs(nw)" href="https://www.engadget.com/deals/black-friday-apple-deals-for-2024-the-best-apple-sales-on-airpods-ipads-macbooks-airtags-and-more-165143436.html" data-ylk="cpos:2;elm:hdln;elmt:ct;g:f4f61ff1-a408-456e-b25c-eaabd871d6c7;itc:0;sec:trending-now;slk:https://www.engadget.com/deals/black-friday-apple-deals-for-2024-the-best-apple-sales-on-airpods-ipads-macbooks-airtags-and-more-165143436.html"><div class="trendingNow-cont Fz(14px) Lh(20px) Fw(500) Mend(20px) Px(20px) Py(10px) H(20px) Bdc(#fff) Bds(s) Bdw(0.5px) Bdrs(8px) Ta(c)" style="box-shadow:0 2px 4px rgba(0,0,0,.2);transition:all .4s ease-in-out"><span class="C(#232a31)">Black Friday Apple deals 2024</span></div></a></li><li class="Mb(10px) Mstart(2px)"><a class="sans Ov(h) Td(n) Whs(nw)" href="https://www.engadget.com/deals/black-friday-tv-deals-for-2024-save-on-sets-from-samsung-lg-sony-hisense-and-more-161445637.html" data-ylk="cpos:3;elm:hdln;elmt:ct;g:d22ac1c9-00c2-45ef-bce1-15ecc2aebb42;itc:0;sec:trending-now;slk:https://www.engadget.com/deals/black-friday-tv-deals-for-2024-save-on-sets-from-samsung-lg-sony-hisense-and-more-161445637.html"><div class="trendingNow-cont Fz(14px) Lh(20px) Fw(500) Mend(20px) Px(20px) Py(10px) H(20px) Bdc(#fff) Bds(s) Bdw(0.5px) Bdrs(8px) Ta(c)" style="box-shadow:0 2px 4px rgba(0,0,0,.2);transition:all .4s ease-in-out"><span class="C(#232a31)">Black Friday 2024 TV deals</span></div></a></li><li class="Mb(10px) Mstart(2px)"><a class="sans Ov(h) Td(n) Whs(nw)" href="https://www.engadget.com/deals/the-45-black-friday-tech-deals-worth-shopping-from-amazon-walmart-apple-anker-and-others-163039558.html" data-ylk="cpos:4;elm:hdln;elmt:ct;g:200829a0-abbe-4933-bdbb-823abf891e97;itc:0;sec:trending-now;slk:https://www.engadget.com/deals/the-45-black-friday-tech-deals-worth-shopping-from-amazon-walmart-apple-anker-and-others-163039558.html"><div class="trendingNow-cont Fz(14px) Lh(20px) Fw(500) Mend(20px) Px(20px) Py(10px) H(20px) Bdc(#fff) Bds(s) Bdw(0.5px) Bdrs(8px) Ta(c)" style="box-shadow:0 2px 4px rgba(0,0,0,.2);transition:all .4s ease-in-out"><span class="C(#232a31)">Best Black Friday 2024 tech deals</span></div></a></li></ul></div></section></div><script> window.performance.mark('engadgetTopTrendingBar'); window.performance.measure('engadgetTopTrendingBarDone','PageStart','engadgetTopTrendingBar'); </script></div></div><div class=page-wrapper><div id=Masterwrap class="W(100%) Pos(r) Op(1) Reader-open_Op(0) Trs($pageTransition) Ov(v) cluster"><div id=Page class="D(f)! Fld(r) Fxw(w) Jc(sb) Ai(fs) Pos(r) Maw(1260px) Miw(980px) Miw(a)--md Mx(a) Px(20px) Z(1)"><main class="W(100%) postArticleAdsBgStyle" role=main><div id=caas-content-body><div class="" id=content-wrapper><div><div id=module-article><div class=wafer-caas data-comments-id=spotIm-conversations-module-wrapper data-wf-caas-type=renderedArticle data-wf-caas-uuid=adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50 data-wf-caas-wrapper=Page data-wf-caas-has-rightrail-ads=1 id=content-canvas><script class=wafer-caas-data type=application/json> {"adMeta":{"hashtag":"gear;internet","isSupplySegment":"false","lang":"en-US","region":"US","rs":"lmsid:a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH;revsp:engadget_479;lpstaid:adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50;pt:content;pd:non_modal;ver:article;pct:story","site_attribute":"wiki_topics=\"Avery_Ellis;News_bureau;Social_media;Report\" ctopid=\"1878000;1035500;10610989\" hashtag=\"gear;1878000;1035500;10610989\" rs=\"lmsid:a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH;revsp:engadget_479;lpstaid:adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50;pt:content;pd:non_modal;ver:article;lu:0;pct:story\"","spaceid":"1197802876","site":"engadget","enabled":false,"yctIds":"yct:001000963"},"alias":"ymedia-alias:shadow=about-202058266","authors":[{"name":"Engadget","alias":"engadget-editorial","title":"","description":"A collaboration between various members of the Engadget editorial team.","isCreator":false,"providerBrands":[],"id":"29844f40-dea0-11e7-af9d-8e8da89863e6","url":{"external":false,"link":"https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/engadget-editorial/"},"logo":{"size":{"original":{"width":160,"height":160,"url":"https://o.aolcdn.com/images/dims?image_uri=https%3A%2F%2Fo.aolcdn.com%2Fimages%2Fdims%3Fimage_uri%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fs.yimg.com%252Fos%252Fcreatr-uploaded-images%252F2021-05%252F87623ba0-b8b7-11eb-b7ce-b7f4d595eb4a%26compress%3D1%26progressive%3D1%26quality%3D75%26client%3Dhawkeye%26signature%3D8bdd92d146e3cd8d60a6076bed81607c0900edcc&compress=1&progressive=1&quality=75&client=hawkeye&signature=1cdc07d3473e22313a501e63334053e4e09396d1"},"resized":{"url":"https://s.yimg.com/ny/api/res/1.2/slRzrw1NhkwE.UdpXO0LEA--/YXBwaWQ9aGlnaGxhbmRlcjt3PTgwO2g9ODA-/https://o.aolcdn.com/images/dims?image_uri=https%3A%2F%2Fo.aolcdn.com%2Fimages%2Fdims%3Fimage_uri%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fs.yimg.com%252Fos%252Fcreatr-uploaded-images%252F2021-05%252F87623ba0-b8b7-11eb-b7ce-b7f4d595eb4a%26compress%3D1%26progressive%3D1%26quality%3D75%26client%3Dhawkeye%26signature%3D8bdd92d146e3cd8d60a6076bed81607c0900edcc&compress=1&progressive=1&quality=75&client=hawkeye&signature=1cdc07d3473e22313a501e63334053e4e09396d1","width":40,"height":40}}},"social":{"twitter":"engadget"}}],"canonicalSite":"engadget","canonicalUrl":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","categoryLabel":"Business","challengeTags":[],"commentsAllowed":false,"commentsCount":0,"contentMeta":{"adPostions":{"photos":{}},"bodySlots":{},"cover":null,"embeds":null,"hasEmbedAtBeginning":false,"hasEmbedAtEnd":false,"hasYahooVideo":false,"isLongArticle":false,"potentialSlots":0,"outstreamAdPosition":-1,"readMorePosition":-1,"totalParagraphs":0,"contentI13n":{}},"contentType":"story","description":"Engadget's staff masthead.","editorialPicksList":"","editorialTags":["gear"],"factualPollId":null,"finalUrl":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","hashtag":"","hasVideoList":false,"hasScribble":false,"hasXraySideRail":false,"hasYahooVideo":false,"hideAllAds":false,"hostedType":"hosted","redirectMetaData":{"originalId":null,"newId":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50"},"isAffilimateTest":false,"isAsideEligible":true,"isAutoblogArticle":false,"isBrandedContent":false,"isCreatorContent":false,"isImmersiveContent":false,"isOriginalContent":true,"isPersonalFinanceArticle":false,"isSeamlessBypass":true,"isEditorialPicksListOverridden":false,"isShoppable":false,"isSponsoredContent":false,"isWalmartSubnav":false,"keywords":"John Falcone, Valentina Palladino, Avery Ellis, Deputy editors, Executive editors","modifiedDate":"Wed, 23 Sep 2020 20:20:58 GMT","pageTitle":"Engadget Masthead","presentation":null,"previewLink":null,"providerId":["engadget_479"],"providerBrand":{"id":"c36243b2-a3ef-31ae-9ec9-256889535c05","brandId":"engadget","displayName":"Engadget","description":"","state":"","secondaryTypes":[],"socialAliases":[],"callToActionEnabled":false,"callToActions":[],"brandTheme":{},"sameAsAuthor":false,"isCreator":false,"brandUrl":null},"publisher":"Engadget","publishDate":"Wed, 23 Sep 2020 20:20:58 GMT","salientEntities":[],"searchNoIndex":false,"seamlessUrl":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","showEditorialPicksPlaceholder":false,"showPremiumPaywall":false,"isPremiumArticle":false,"sectionContentCategoryPath":"|","sectionItems":[],"spaceId":"1197802876","sponsoredContent":false,"sportsGameCategory":"","summary":"Engadget's staff masthead.","title":"Engadget Masthead","tpConsent":true,"type":"story","url":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","uuid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","videoPosition":"","VUID":"GjIk7IRoQfc42zhu_Koxjw"} </script><div class="caas caas-cc engadget allowSendingDomainPathToNCP cluster disableReadMore editorialUpsells enableAdSlotsNewMap enableAdSlotsOneSlot enableGAMAds enableGAMMomentsAds enableInlineConsent enablePlayerCardRedesign enableRRAdsSlots enableRRModuleSlotsV1 enableRRTriggerOnViewport enableSingleSlotting enableStickyAds enableVideoDocking enableXrayEntityAboutFacts exposeYctIds filterNonGdprEmbeds getCommerceModulesFromRmp liveBlogPolling noRapidClickClass showCommentsIconInShareSec siteSections" data-assets='[{"asset":{"value":"https:\u002F\u002Fs.yimg.com\u002Fzq\u002F_assets\u002Fcss\u002Fcommerce-content-caas.tailwind.0f57ba245b7d2841d1cc8f6577bcd965.css","name":"commerce-content-caas.tailwind"},"type":"css"},{"asset":{"value":"https:\u002F\u002Fs.yimg.com\u002Fzq\u002F_assets\u002Fcss\u002Fcommerce-content-caas.overwriteCaas.58b3a32b500f803ddfc290e1e56be0c4.css","name":"commerce-content-caas.overwriteCaas"},"type":"css"},{"asset":{"value":"https:\u002F\u002Fs.yimg.com\u002Fzq\u002F_assets\u002Fjs\u002Fcommerce-content-caas.copy.2100ef09c6cd71ed58154fed0fe86908.js","name":"commerce-content-caas.copy"},"type":"dynamic-js"},{"asset":{"value":"https:\u002F\u002Fs.yimg.com\u002Fzq\u002F_assets\u002Fjs\u002Fcommerce-content-caas.quickOverview.53e94ae1674d5814b037f11cef71ecaa.js","name":"commerce-content-caas.quickOverview"},"type":"dynamic-js"},{"asset":{"value":"https:\u002F\u002Fs.yimg.com\u002Fzq\u002F_assets\u002Fjs\u002Fcommerce-content-caas.score.4c442ba67a8df7c209915f86f44b2f3c.js","name":"commerce-content-caas.score"},"type":"dynamic-js"}]' data-device=desktop data-i18n='{"{date} at {time}":"{date} at {time}","{0} hr ago":"{0} hr ago","{0} min ago":"{0} min ago","{0} mins ago":"{0} mins ago","{0} Views":"{0} Views","INLINE_CONSENT_BLOCKED_3P_BUTTON_ALLOW":"Allow","LESS":"Less","LIVE_IS_OVER":"LIVE COVERAGE IS OVER","LOADING":"Loading","MORE":"More","NEW_UPDATE":"new update","NEW_UPDATES":"new updates","JUST_NOW":"Just now","RELOAD":"Click to reload with latest update","SEE {0} MORE":"See {0} more","SEE_LESS":"See less","SEE_MORE":"See more","SHOW_MORE":"Show more updates","TODAY":"Today","TRY_AGAIN":"Something went wrong. Try again","UPDATE":"update","UPDATES":"updates","VIDEO_A11Y_DISABLE_FULLSCREEN":"Full Screen, button, disabled, temporarily not available for screen reader users"}' data-lang=en-US data-tz=Asia/Hong_Kong data-params='{"features":{"allowSendingDomainPathToNCP":true,"cluster":true,"disableReadMore":true,"editorialUpsells":true,"enableAdSlotsNewMap":true,"enableAdSlotsOneSlot":true,"enableGAMAds":true,"enableGAMMomentsAds":true,"enableInlineConsent":true,"enablePlayerCardRedesign":true,"enableRRAdsSlots":true,"enableRRModuleSlotsV1":true,"enableRRTriggerOnViewport":true,"enableSingleSlotting":true,"enableStickyAds":true,"enableVideoDocking":true,"enableXrayEntityAboutFacts":true,"exposeYctIds":true,"filterNonGdprEmbeds":true,"getCommerceModulesFromRmp":true,"liveBlogPolling":true,"noRapidClickClass":true,"showCommentsIconInShareSec":true,"siteSections":true},"config":{"authorBylineCollapseLineCount":2,"commerceQuickOverviewLimit":5,"freezeOnLinkClick":true,"lazyOffsetY":1300,"livecoverage":{"defer":false},"imageCaptionCollapseLineCount":3,"slideshowCaptionCollapseLineCount":2,"uiShowPreviousButtonOnLoad":true,"prestigeScrollMarginTop":-72}}' data-space-id=1197802876 id=caas-art-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50><link rel=stylesheet type=text/css href=https://s.yimg.com/zq/_assets/css/commerce-content-caas.tailwind.0f57ba245b7d2841d1cc8f6577bcd965.css><link rel=stylesheet type=text/css href=https://s.yimg.com/zq/_assets/css/commerce-content-caas.overwriteCaas.58b3a32b500f803ddfc290e1e56be0c4.css><article role=article tabindex=-1 class=caas-container><script type=application/ld+json> {"@context":"http://schema.org","@type":"NewsArticle","mainEntityOfPage":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","headline":"Engadget Masthead","datePublished":"2020-09-23T20:20:58.000Z","dateModified":"2020-09-23T20:20:58.000Z","keywords":["John Falcone","Valentina Palladino","Avery Ellis","Deputy editors","Executive editors"],"description":"Engadget's staff masthead.","publisher":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Engadget","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","url":"https://s.yimg.com/kw/assets/engadget-amp-280x60.png","width":280,"height":60},"url":"https://www.engadget.com"},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Engadget","url":"https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/engadget-editorial/","jobTitle":""},"creator":{"@type":"Person","name":"Engadget","url":"https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/engadget-editorial/","jobTitle":""},"provider":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Engadget","url":"https://www.engadget.com/","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","width":313,"height":100,"url":"https://s.yimg.com/os/creatr-uploaded-images/2020-11/b1da0f90-244a-11eb-bfaf-e0fb13dde404"}},"image":{"@type":"ImageObject","url":"https://s.yimg.com/ny/api/res/1.2/AkyTPnGWChUoTqNjePeIow--/YXBwaWQ9aGlnaGxhbmRlcjt3PTEyMDA7aD02MDA-/https://s.yimg.com/os/creatr-uploaded-images/2023-08/464d7520-3b83-11ee-bf7d-ee5f8cd1fdd0","width":1200,"height":600},"thumbnailUrl":"https://s.yimg.com/ny/api/res/1.2/AkyTPnGWChUoTqNjePeIow--/YXBwaWQ9aGlnaGxhbmRlcjt3PTEyMDA7aD02MDA-/https://s.yimg.com/os/creatr-uploaded-images/2023-08/464d7520-3b83-11ee-bf7d-ee5f8cd1fdd0"} </script><script class=caas-timezone-config type=application/json> {"longForm":{"weekday":"short","day":"numeric","hour":"numeric","hourCycle":"h12","minute":"2-digit","month":"short","year":"numeric","timeZoneName":"short"},"shortForm":{"day":"numeric","month":"short","year":"numeric","weekday":"short"},"postDateLongForm":{"weekday":"short","day":"numeric","hour":"numeric","hourCycle":"h12","minute":"2-digit","month":"long","year":"numeric","timeZoneName":"short"},"postDateShortForm":{"hour":"numeric","hourCycle":"h12","minute":"2-digit","timeZoneName":"short"}} </script><script class=caas-yvideo-config type=application/json> {"videoDockingCfg":{"enableOnMuted":true,"enableOnScrollDown":true,"enableOnScrollUp":false,"fadeInAnimation":true,"height":92,"positionBottom":57,"positionLeft":-1,"positionRight":0,"positionTop":-1,"showInfoCard":false,"width":164}} </script><script class=caas-embedded-config type=application/json> {"twitter":{"timeout":5000}} </script><div class=caas-body-wrapper><button class="caas-button noborder caas-body-collapse-button" data-ylk="itc:1;slk:Read full article">Read full article<i></i></button><div class=caas-body-content><div class=caas-body-inner-wrapper><div class=caas-body-section><div class=caas-content data-wf-sticky-boundary=caas-body-section data-wf-sticky-offset="165px 10px" data-wf-sticky-target=.caas-share-buttons><div class=caas-content-wrapper><header class=caas-header><div class=caas-logo></div><div class=caas-title-wrapper><h1 id=caas-lead-header-undefined data-test-locator=headline>Engadget Masthead</h1></div></header><div><figure class="caas-figure caas-cover"><div class=caas-figure-with-pb style="max-height: 480px"><div><div class=caas-img-container style=padding-bottom:50%><img class=caas-img src=https://s.yimg.com/ny/api/res/1.2/ZyvKnRkFXo2ZwQpCyXbBTg--/YXBwaWQ9aGlnaGxhbmRlcjt3PTk2MDtoPTQ4MA--/https://s.yimg.com/os/creatr-uploaded-images/2023-08/464d7520-3b83-11ee-bf7d-ee5f8cd1fdd0 fetchPriority=high data-src=https://s.yimg.com/ny/api/res/1.2/ZyvKnRkFXo2ZwQpCyXbBTg--/YXBwaWQ9aGlnaGxhbmRlcjt3PTk2MDtoPTQ4MA--/https://s.yimg.com/os/creatr-uploaded-images/2023-08/464d7520-3b83-11ee-bf7d-ee5f8cd1fdd0></div></div></div></figure></div><div class=caas-body><h2 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=leadership><strong>Leadership</strong></h2><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=executive-editors>Executive editors</h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:1;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/aaron-souppouris/" data-ylk="slk:Aaron Souppouris;cpos:1;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Aaron Souppouris</a> — News and reports</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:2;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/john-falcone/" data-ylk="slk:John Falcone;cpos:2;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">John Falcone</a> — Reviews and buying advice</p></li></ul><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=team-leads>Deputy editors</h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:3;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/avery-ellis/" data-ylk="slk:Avery Ellis;cpos:3;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Avery Ellis</a> — Reports</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:4;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/nathan-ingraham/" data-ylk="slk:Nathan Ingraham;cpos:4;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Nathan Ingraham</a> — News</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:5;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/cherlynn-low/" data-ylk="slk:Cherlynn Low;cpos:5;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Cherlynn Low</a> — Reviews</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:6;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/valentina-palladino/" data-ylk="slk:Valentina Palladino;cpos:6;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Valentina Palladino</a> — Buying advice</p></li></ul><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=general-manager>General manager</h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p>Sarah Priestley</p></li></ul><h2 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=news-desk><strong>News desk</strong></h2><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=leads><strong>Leads</strong></h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:7;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/nathan-ingraham/" data-ylk="slk:Nathan Ingraham;cpos:7;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Nathan Ingraham</a> — Deputy editor, news</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:8;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/avery-ellis/" data-ylk="slk:Avery Ellis;cpos:8;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Avery Ellis</a> — Deputy editor, reports</p></li></ul><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=editors-and-senior-reporters>Editors and senior reporters</h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:9;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/karissa-bell/" data-ylk="slk:Karissa Bell;cpos:9;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Karissa Bell</a> — Social media</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:10;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/igor-bonifacic/" data-ylk="slk:Igor Bonifacic;cpos:10;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Igor Bonifacic</a></p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:11;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/jessica-conditt/" data-ylk="slk:Jessica Conditt;cpos:11;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Jessica Conditt</a> — Video games</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:12;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/daniel-cooper/" data-ylk="slk:Daniel Cooper;cpos:12;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Daniel Cooper</a> — International</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:13;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/cheyenne-macdonald/" data-ylk="slk:Cheyenne MacDonald;cpos:13;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Cheyenne MacDonald</a> — Weekend editor</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:14;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/mat-smith/" data-ylk="slk:Mat Smith;cpos:14;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Mat Smith</a> — UK bureau chief, newsletter editor</p></li></ul><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=contributing-reporters>Contributing reporters</h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:15;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/lawrence-bonk-01/" data-ylk="slk:Lawrence Bonk;cpos:15;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Lawrence Bonk</a></p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:16;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/sarah-fielding-01/" data-ylk="slk:Sarah Fielding;cpos:16;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Sarah Fielding</a></p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="elm:context_link;elmt:doNotAffiliate;cpos:17;pos:1" class="link " href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/danny-gallagher-931/" data-ylk="slk:Danny Gallagher;elm:context_link;elmt:doNotAffiliate;cpos:17;pos:1;itc:0;sec:content-canvas">Danny Gallagher</a></p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:18;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/kris-holt/" data-ylk="slk:Kris Holt;cpos:18;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Kris Holt</a></p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:19;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/mariella-moon/" data-ylk="slk:Mariella Moon;cpos:19;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Mariella Moon</a></p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:20;pos:1" href="https://engadget.com/about/editors/will-shanklin-1/" data-ylk="slk:Will Shanklin;cpos:20;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Will Shanklin</a></p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="elm:context_link;elmt:doNotAffiliate;cpos:21;pos:1" class="link " href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/anna-washenko/" data-ylk="slk:Anna Washenko;elm:context_link;elmt:doNotAffiliate;cpos:21;pos:1;itc:0;sec:content-canvas">Anna Washenko</a></p></li></ul><h2 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=reviews-and-buying-advice><strong>Reviews and buying advice</strong></h2><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=leads>Leads</h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:22;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/cherlynn-low/" data-ylk="slk:Cherlynn Low;cpos:22;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Cherlynn Low</a> — Deputy editor, reviews</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:23;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/valentina-palladino/" data-ylk="slk:Valentina Palladino;cpos:23;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Valentina Palladino</a> — Deputy editor, buying advice</p></li></ul><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=editors-and-senior-reporters><strong>Editors and Senior reporters</strong></h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:24;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/jeff-dunn/" data-ylk="slk:Jeff Dunn;cpos:24;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Jeff Dunn</a> — Buying advice</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:25;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/devindra-hardawar/" data-ylk="slk:Devindra Hardawar;cpos:25;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Devindra Hardawar</a> — Entertainment and PCs</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:26;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/sam-rutherford/" data-ylk="slk:Sam Rutherford;cpos:26;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Sam Rutherford</a> — Mobile and laptops</p></li><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:27;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/billy-steele/" data-ylk="slk:Billy Steele;cpos:27;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Billy Steele</a> — Audio and kitchen</p></li></ul><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=reporters>Reporters</h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:28;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/amy-skorheim/" data-ylk="slk:Amy Skorheim;cpos:28;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Amy Skorheim</a> — Buying advice</p></li></ul><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=contributing-reporters>Contributing reporters</h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p><a data-i13n="cpos:29;pos:1" href="https://www.engadget.com/about/editors/steve-dent/" data-ylk="slk:Steve Dent;cpos:29;pos:1;elm:context_link;itc:0;sec:content-canvas" class="link ">Steve Dent</a> — Cameras and drones</p></li></ul><h2 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=product-and-engineering><strong>Product and Engineering</strong></h2><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=head-of-product>Head of product</h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p>Justin Cauchon</p></li></ul><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=developers>Developers</h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p>Charles Lin</p></li><li><p>Seetharamakrishna Madamsetti</p></li></ul><h3 class=caas-jump-link-heading id=designer>Designer</h3><ul class="caas-list caas-list-bullet"><li><p>Justin Vachon</p></li></ul></div></div></div></div><aside class="caas-aside-section caas-slotted-aside"><div class=caas-sticky-sda><div class="caas-slotted-rr-sda wafer-managed"><div class=caas-docked-sda-container><div class="caas-da sticky-rr-ad"><div data-wf-benji-page-context='{"url":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","spaceid":"1197802876","site":"engadget","hashtag":"gear;internet","lmsid":"a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH","lpstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pt":"content","pd":"non_modal","pct":"story"}' data-wf-benji-wafer-config='{"updateI13n":true}' data-wf-benji-config='{"positions":{"LREC-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50":{"id":"LREC-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","inView":"onLoad","path":"/22888152279/us/eng/ros/dt/us_eng_ros_dt_top_right","region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]],"kvs":{"loc":"top_right"}}}}' data-wf-boundary=caas-da id=sda-LREC-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50 class="wafer-benji caas-sda-benji-ad" data-wf-trigger=onLoad data-wf-margin="400 0" data-hide-ad-string><div id=LREC-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50></div></div></div></div><div class=caas-docked-sda-container><div class="caas-da sticky-rr-ad"><div data-wf-benji-page-context='{"url":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","spaceid":"1197802876","site":"engadget","hashtag":"gear;internet","lmsid":"a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH","lpstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pt":"content","pd":"non_modal","pct":"story"}' data-wf-benji-wafer-config='{"updateI13n":true}' data-wf-benji-config='{"positions":{"LREC2-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50":{"id":"LREC2-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","inView":"onLoad","path":"/22888152279/us/eng/ros/dt/us_eng_ros_dt_mid_right","region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]],"kvs":{"loc":"mid_right"}}}}' data-wf-boundary=caas-da id=sda-LREC2-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50 class="wafer-benji caas-sda-benji-ad" data-wf-trigger=onLoad data-wf-margin="400 0" data-hide-ad-string><div id=LREC2-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50></div></div></div></div><div class=caas-docked-sda-container><div class="caas-da sticky-rr-ad"><div data-wf-benji-page-context='{"url":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","spaceid":"1197802876","site":"engadget","hashtag":"gear;internet","lmsid":"a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH","lpstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pt":"content","pd":"non_modal","pct":"story"}' data-wf-benji-wafer-config='{"updateI13n":true}' data-wf-benji-config='{"positions":{"LREC3-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50":{"id":"LREC3-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","inView":"onLoad","path":"/22888152279/us/eng/ros/dt/us_eng_ros_dt_mid_right","region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]],"kvs":{"loc":"mid_right_2"}}}}' data-wf-boundary=caas-da id=sda-LREC3-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50 class="wafer-benji caas-sda-benji-ad" data-wf-trigger=onLoad data-wf-margin="400 0" data-hide-ad-string><div id=LREC3-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50></div></div></div></div><div class=caas-docked-sda-container><div class="caas-da sticky-rr-ad"><div data-wf-benji-page-context='{"url":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","spaceid":"1197802876","site":"engadget","hashtag":"gear;internet","lmsid":"a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH","lpstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pt":"content","pd":"non_modal","pct":"story"}' data-wf-benji-wafer-config='{"updateI13n":true}' data-wf-benji-config='{"positions":{"LREC4-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50":{"id":"LREC4-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","inView":"onLoad","path":"/22888152279/us/eng/ros/dt/us_eng_ros_dt_mid_right","region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]],"kvs":{"loc":"mid_right_3"}}}}' data-wf-boundary=caas-da id=sda-LREC4-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50 class="wafer-benji caas-sda-benji-ad" data-wf-trigger=onLoad data-wf-margin="400 0" data-hide-ad-string><div id=LREC4-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50></div></div></div></div><div class=caas-docked-sda-container><div class="caas-da sticky-rr-ad"><div data-wf-benji-page-context='{"url":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","spaceid":"1197802876","site":"engadget","hashtag":"gear;internet","lmsid":"a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH","lpstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pt":"content","pd":"non_modal","pct":"story"}' data-wf-benji-wafer-config='{"updateI13n":true}' data-wf-benji-config='{"positions":{"LREC5-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50":{"id":"LREC5-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","inView":"onLoad","path":"/22888152279/us/eng/ros/dt/us_eng_ros_dt_mid_right","region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]],"kvs":{"loc":"mid_right_4"}}}}' data-wf-boundary=caas-da id=sda-LREC5-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50 class="wafer-benji caas-sda-benji-ad" data-wf-trigger=onLoad data-wf-margin="400 0" data-hide-ad-string><div id=LREC5-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50></div></div></div></div><div class=caas-docked-sda-container><div class="caas-da sticky-rr-ad"><div data-wf-benji-page-context='{"url":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","spaceid":"1197802876","site":"engadget","hashtag":"gear;internet","lmsid":"a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH","lpstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pt":"content","pd":"non_modal","pct":"story"}' data-wf-benji-wafer-config='{"updateI13n":true}' data-wf-benji-config='{"positions":{"LREC6-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50":{"id":"LREC6-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","inView":"onLoad","path":"/22888152279/us/eng/ros/dt/us_eng_ros_dt_mid_right","region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]],"kvs":{"loc":"mid_right_5"}}}}' data-wf-boundary=caas-da id=sda-LREC6-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50 class="wafer-benji caas-sda-benji-ad" data-wf-trigger=onLoad data-wf-margin="400 0" data-hide-ad-string><div id=LREC6-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50></div></div></div></div><div class=caas-docked-sda-container><div class="caas-da sticky-rr-ad"><div data-wf-benji-page-context='{"url":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","spaceid":"1197802876","site":"engadget","hashtag":"gear;internet","lmsid":"a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH","lpstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pt":"content","pd":"non_modal","pct":"story"}' data-wf-benji-wafer-config='{"updateI13n":true}' data-wf-benji-config='{"positions":{"LREC7-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50":{"id":"LREC7-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","inView":"onLoad","path":"/22888152279/us/eng/ros/dt/us_eng_ros_dt_mid_right","region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]],"kvs":{"loc":"mid_right_6"}}}}' data-wf-boundary=caas-da id=sda-LREC7-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50 class="wafer-benji caas-sda-benji-ad" data-wf-trigger=onLoad data-wf-margin="400 0" data-hide-ad-string><div id=LREC7-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50></div></div></div></div><div class=caas-docked-sda-container><div class="caas-da sticky-rr-ad"><div data-wf-benji-page-context='{"url":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","spaceid":"1197802876","site":"engadget","hashtag":"gear;internet","lmsid":"a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH","lpstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pt":"content","pd":"non_modal","pct":"story"}' data-wf-benji-wafer-config='{"updateI13n":true}' data-wf-benji-config='{"positions":{"LREC8-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50":{"id":"LREC8-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","inView":"onLoad","path":"/22888152279/us/eng/ros/dt/us_eng_ros_dt_mid_right","region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]],"kvs":{"loc":"mid_right_7"}}}}' data-wf-boundary=caas-da id=sda-LREC8-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50 class="wafer-benji caas-sda-benji-ad" data-wf-trigger=onLoad data-wf-margin="400 0" data-hide-ad-string><div id=LREC8-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50></div></div></div></div><div class=caas-docked-sda-container><div class="caas-da sticky-rr-ad"><div data-wf-benji-page-context='{"url":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","spaceid":"1197802876","site":"engadget","hashtag":"gear;internet","lmsid":"a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH","lpstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pt":"content","pd":"non_modal","pct":"story"}' data-wf-benji-wafer-config='{"updateI13n":true}' data-wf-benji-config='{"positions":{"LREC9-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50":{"id":"LREC9-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","inView":"onLoad","path":"/22888152279/us/eng/ros/dt/us_eng_ros_dt_mid_right","region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]],"kvs":{"loc":"mid_right_8"}}}}' data-wf-boundary=caas-da id=sda-LREC9-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50 class="wafer-benji caas-sda-benji-ad" data-wf-trigger=onLoad data-wf-margin="400 0" data-hide-ad-string><div id=LREC9-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50></div></div></div></div></div></div></aside></div></div></div></article></div></div><script type=text/javascript> (function(w) { var adsConfig = { clientPositionMeta: undefined, clientViewportAdFetchYOffset: undefined, clusterPositionMeta: {"addAutoEvent":true,"positions":[],"siteAttributes":"LREC=\"300x250;1x1\" LREC2=\"300x250;1x1\" MON=\"300x600;1x1\" geminifed=1"}, enableAdSlugText: undefined, enableAdditionalPageContextParams: undefined, enableGAMAds: undefined, enableGAMAdsCtrl: undefined, enableJac: undefined, pencilAdSections: {}, positions: {"BTNA":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-BTN","dest":"sda-BTN-iframe","fdb":1,"h":60,"id":"BTNA","metaSize":true,"w":120},"sfoptin":1},"BTNB":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-BTN-1","dest":"sda-BTN-1-iframe","fdb":1,"h":60,"id":"BTNB","metaSize":true,"w":120},"sfoptin":1},"BTNC":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-BTN-2","dest":"sda-BTN-2-iframe","fdb":1,"h":60,"id":"BTNC","metaSize":true,"w":120},"sfoptin":1},"BTND":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-BTN-3","dest":"sda-BTN-3-iframe","fdb":1,"h":60,"id":"BTND","metaSize":true,"w":120},"sfoptin":1},"COMMENTSWFPAD":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-COMMENTSWFPAD","dest":"sda-COMMENTSWFPAD-iframe","h":50,"id":"COMMENTSWFPAD","metaSize":true,"pos":"COMMENTSWFPAD","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":1,"resize-to":1},"w":320}},"FSRVY":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-FSRVY","dest":"sda-FSRVY-iframe","fr":"expIfr_exp","id":"FSRVY","supports":{"lyr":1}}},"HPSPON":{"filtered":1,"sfoptin":0},"INARTICLE":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-INARTICLE-base","dest":"sda-INARTICLE","fdb":1,"flex":{"h":{"min":10},"ratio":"1.78x1","w":{"min":10}},"h":211,"id":"INARTICLE","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":375},"sfoptin":1},"INBODYLDRB-1":{"meta":{"clean":"wafer-darla-clean-INBODYLDRB-1","dest":"wafer-darla-INBODYLDRB-1","fdb":1,"h":90,"id":"INBODYLDRB-1","metaSize":true,"pos":"LDRB","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":728},"sfoptin":1},"INBODYLDRB-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":90,"id":"LDRB","metaSize":true,"pos":"LDRB","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":728}},"INBODYLDRB-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":90,"id":"LDRB","metaSize":true,"pos":"LDRB","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":728,"doubleBuffering":false}},"INBODYLDRB2-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":90,"id":"LDRB","metaSize":true,"pos":"LDRB","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":728}},"INBODYLDRB2-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":90,"id":"LDRB","metaSize":true,"pos":"LDRB","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":728,"doubleBuffering":false}},"INBODYLDRB3-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":90,"id":"LDRB","metaSize":true,"pos":"LDRB","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":728}},"INBODYLDRB3-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":90,"id":"LDRB","metaSize":true,"pos":"LDRB","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":728,"doubleBuffering":false}},"INBODYLDRB4-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":90,"id":"LDRB","metaSize":true,"pos":"LDRB","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":728}},"INBODYLDRB4-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":90,"id":"LDRB","metaSize":true,"pos":"LDRB","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":728,"doubleBuffering":false}},"INBODYLREC-1":{"meta":{"clean":"wafer-darla-clean-INBODYLREC-1","dest":"wafer-darla-INBODYLREC-1","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"INBODYLREC-1","metaSize":true,"pos":"LREC","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300},"sfoptin":1},"INBODYLREC-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"LREC","metaSize":true,"pos":"LREC","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300}},"INBODYLREC-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":300,"id":"LREC","metaSize":false,"pos":"LREC","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300,"doubleBuffering":false,"flex":{"w":{"max":375}}}},"INBODYLREC2-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"LREC","metaSize":true,"pos":"LREC","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300}},"INBODYLREC2-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":300,"id":"LREC","metaSize":false,"pos":"LREC","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300,"doubleBuffering":false,"flex":{"w":{"max":375}}}},"INBODYLREC3-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"LREC","metaSize":true,"pos":"LREC","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300}},"INBODYLREC3-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":300,"id":"LREC","metaSize":false,"pos":"LREC","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300,"doubleBuffering":false,"flex":{"w":{"max":375}}}},"INBODYLREC4-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"LREC","metaSize":true,"pos":"LREC","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300}},"INBODYLREC4-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":300,"id":"LREC","metaSize":false,"pos":"LREC","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300,"doubleBuffering":false,"flex":{"w":{"max":375}}}},"INBODYMAST-1":{"meta":{"clean":"wafer-darla-clean-INBODYMAST-1","dest":"wafer-darla-INBODYMAST-1","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"INBODYMAST-1","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970},"sfoptin":1},"INBODYMAST-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970}},"INBODYMAST-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970,"doubleBuffering":false,"flex":{"w":{"max":1220,"min":960}}}},"INBODYMAST2-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970}},"INBODYMAST2-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970,"doubleBuffering":false,"flex":{"w":{"max":1220,"min":960}}}},"INBODYMAST3-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970}},"INBODYMAST3-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970,"doubleBuffering":false,"flex":{"w":{"max":1220,"min":960}}}},"INBODYMAST4-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970}},"INBODYMAST4-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-placeholder","dest":"sda-placeholder-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970,"doubleBuffering":false,"flex":{"w":{"max":1220,"min":960}}}},"LDRB":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-LDRB","dest":"sda-LDRB-iframe","fdb":1,"h":90,"id":"LDRB","metaSize":true,"pos":"LDRB","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":728},"sfoptin":1},"LDRB2":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-LDRB2","dest":"sda-LDRB2-iframe","fdb":1,"h":90,"id":"LDRB2","metaSize":true,"pos":"LDRB2","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":728},"sfoptin":1},"LDRB2-9":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-LDRB2-9","dest":"sda-LDRB2-9-iframe","fdb":1,"h":90,"id":"LDRB2-9","metaSize":true,"pos":"LDRB2-9","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":728},"sfoptin":1},"LREC":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-LREC","dest":"sda-LREC-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"LREC","metaSize":true,"pos":"LREC","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300},"sfoptin":1},"LREC2":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-LREC2","dest":"sda-LREC2-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"LREC2","metaSize":true,"pos":"LREC2","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300},"sfoptin":1},"LREC3":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-LREC3","dest":"sda-LREC3-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"LREC3","metaSize":true,"pos":"LREC3","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300},"sfoptin":1},"LREC3-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-LREC","dest":"sda-LREC-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"LREC","metaSize":true,"pos":"LREC","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300}},"LREC3-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-LREC","dest":"sda-LREC-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"LREC","metaSize":true,"pos":"LREC","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300,"doubleBuffering":false,"flex":{"h":{"max":312,"min":250},"ratio":"1.2x1","w":{"align":"center","max":375,"min":300}}},"sfoptin":1},"LREC4":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-LREC4","dest":"sda-LREC4-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"LREC4","metaSize":true,"pos":"LREC4","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300},"sfoptin":1},"LREC5":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-LREC5","dest":"sda-LREC5-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"LREC5","metaSize":true,"pos":"LREC5","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0},"w":300},"sfoptin":1},"MAST":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-MAST","dest":"sda-MAST-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970},"sfoptin":1},"MAST-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-MAST-DISPLAY","dest":"sda-MAST-DISPLAY","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970},"sfoptin":1},"MAST-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-MAST-NATIVE","dest":"sda-MAST-NATIVE","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970,"doubleBuffering":false,"flex":{"w":{"max":1220,"min":960}}},"sfoptin":1},"MAST2":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-MAST2","dest":"sda-MAST2-iframe","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970}},"MAST2-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-MAST2-DISPLAY","dest":"sda-MAST2-DISPLAY","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970},"sfoptin":1},"MAST2-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-MAST2-NATIVE","dest":"sda-MAST2-NATIVE","fdb":1,"h":250,"id":"MAST","metaSize":true,"pos":"MAST","supports":{"exp-ovr":0,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":970,"doubleBuffering":false,"flex":{"w":{"max":1220,"min":960}}},"sfoptin":1},"MOMENTS":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-MOMENTS-base","dest":"defaultdestMOMENTS","fdb":1,"flex":{"h":{"min":568},"ratio":"1x1.78","w":{"min":320}},"fr":"expIfr_exp","h":667,"id":"MOMENTS","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"resize-to":1},"w":375,"z":3}},"MON":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-MON","dest":"sda-MON-iframe","fdb":1,"h":600,"id":"MON","metaSize":true,"pos":"MON","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":300},"sfoptin":1},"MON2":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-MON2","dest":"sda-MON2-iframe","fdb":1,"h":600,"id":"MON2","metaSize":true,"pos":"MON2","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":300}},"NE1":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-NE1","dest":"sda-NE1-iframe","fr":"expIfr_exp","h":35,"id":"NE1","metaSize":false,"pos":"NE1","staticLayout":true,"supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":1},"w":970,"z":9}},"UMU":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-UMU","dest":"sda-UMU-iframe","fr":"expIfr_exp","h":32,"id":"UMU","metaSize":false,"pos":"UMU","staticLayout":true,"supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":1},"w":1220,"z":1000}},"WFPAD":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-WFPAD","dest":"sda-WFPAD-iframe","h":50,"id":"WFPAD","metaSize":true,"pos":"WFPAD","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":1,"resize-to":1},"w":320},"sfoptin":0},"WFPAD-DISPLAY-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-WFPAD-DISPLAY","dest":"sda-WFPAD-DISPLAY","h":50,"id":"WFPAD","metaSize":true,"pos":"WFPAD","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":1,"resize-to":1},"w":320,"flex":{"h":{"min":50}}},"sfoptin":0},"WFPAD-NATIVE-PH":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-WFPAD-NATIVE","dest":"sda-WFPAD-NATIVE","h":50,"id":"WFPAD","metaSize":true,"pos":"WFPAD","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":1,"resize-to":1},"w":320,"doubleBuffering":false,"flex":{"h":{"max":100,"min":80},"w":{"max":800,"min":300}}},"sfoptin":0},"WFPAD2":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-WFPAD2","dest":"sda-WFPAD2-iframe","h":50,"id":"WFPAD2","metaSize":true,"pos":"WFPAD2","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":1,"resize-to":1},"w":320}},"WIDGET":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-WIDGET","dest":"sda-WIDGET-iframe","fdb":1,"h":450,"id":"WIDGET","metaSize":false,"pos":"WIDGET","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1,"lyr":0,"resize-to":1},"w":750},"sfoptin":1},"WIDGETA":{"meta":{"clean":"sda-WIDGETA","dest":"sda-WIDGETA-iframe","fdb":1,"h":198,"id":"WIDGETA","metaSize":false,"pos":"WIDGETA","supports":{"exp-ovr":1,"exp-push":1},"w":758},"sfoptin":1},"XFPAD":{"filtered":1,"sfoptin":0}}, rotateIndexPageAds: undefined, rotation: {}, strings: {"advertisement":"Advertisement"}, videoPublisherBlob: "lu:0;lpstaid:adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50;yctIds:yct:001000963;bucket:engadget-US-en-US-def;pt:content;ver:article;pd:non_modal;pct:story", viewerEnableLRECForShowBodyAdsFalse: undefined, viewerGAMPositionMeta: undefined, viewerGeminiSMAdConfig: {}, viewerGeminiSMAdEnabled: undefined, viewerPositionMeta: undefined, viewerResetAutoEventOnClose: undefined, viewerSMAdEnabled: undefined, viewerViewportAdFetch: {}, viewerWfpad2AdEnabled: undefined, viewerWfpadAdEnabled: undefined, viewerWfpadInVideoEnabled: undefined, }; // expose adsConfig for homepage-viewer client if (!w.adsConfig) { w.adsConfig = adsConfig; } }(window)); </script><script id=wafer-caas-config type=application/json>{ "caasUrl": "https://www.yahoo.com/caas/content/article/", "contextParams": "device=desktop&lang=en-US&region=US&site=engadget&adidprefix=sda-&appid=engadget_web&features=allowSendingDomainPathToNCP,cluster,disableReadMore,editorialUpsells,enableAdSlotsNewMap,enableAdSlotsOneSlot,enableGAMAds,enableGAMMomentsAds,enableInlineConsent,enablePlayerCardRedesign,enableRRAdsSlots,enableRRModuleSlotsV1,enableRRTriggerOnViewport,enableRightRailTrendingModule,enableSingleSlotting,enableStickyAds,enableVideoDocking,enableXrayEntityAboutFacts,exposeYctIds,filterNonGdprEmbeds,getCommerceModulesFromRmp,liveBlogPolling,noRapidClickClass,removeDuplicateImage,showCommentsIconInShareSec,siteSections&bucket=engadget-US-en-US-def&bot=0&partner=none&hostname=www.engadget.com", "rightRailAdsAlignWithCover": true, "rightRailAdsAlignWithFirstParagraph": true, "stickyRightAdSpacing": 500, "stickyRightFirstAdSpacing": 300 }</script></div></div></div></div><div id=postArticle class="Pos(r) Mb($gridMargin) Mt(-20px) Pstart(106px) Pend(34%)"></div><div id="view-cmts-container-adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50" class="Pos(r) Mt(-63px)"><div id=module-spotIm class="wafer-rapid-module Pos(r) comments-block D(b)"><section id="spot-im-comments"><style> body.ow-modal-opened #spotIm-conversations-module-wrapper iframe { z-index: 11 !important; } .horizontalLayout .jac-container { margin: auto; width: 100% !important; } .horizontalLayout #spotIm-conversations-module-wrapper iframe { width: 100% !important; } </style><script type="application/json" class="wafer-state">{"spotIm":{"adPositions":"COMMENTSLREC,COMMENTSMON;COMMENTSLREC2,COMMENTSMON2;COMMENTSLREC3,COMMENTSMON3","conversationEnabled":false,"doNotUseshareWidth":true,"enableFocusProtection":false,"device":"desktop-lite","jacDomain":"https://openweb.jac.yahoosandbox.com","jacUrl":"https://jac.yahoosandbox.com/2.0.0/jac.js","launcherUrl":"https://launcher.spot.im/spot/","leftRailWidth":"","messages_cnt":3,"passiveReactionEnabled":true,"rightRailAdClasses":"da-spotim Ta(c)","showCommentCount":false,"showRightRailAds":true,"spotId":"sp_f76RE06N","stageSpotId":"sp_OhAqk0dS","url":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","useCase":"deeplink","useCaasBodyOffsetLeft":false,"useStageToken":false,"uuid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","wfDarlaConfig":{"addAutoEvent":true,"addCleanContainer":true,"enabled":true,"maxRetry":50,"meta":{"COMMENTSLREC":{"height":250,"width":300},"COMMENTSLREC2":{"height":250,"width":300},"COMMENTSLREC3":{"height":250,"width":300},"COMMENTSMON":{"height":600,"width":300},"COMMENTSMON2":{"height":600,"width":300},"COMMENTSMON3":{"height":600,"width":300}},"offsetX":"0","offsetY":"400"},"xhrPathPrefix":"/nel_ms/_rcv/remote"}}</script><div id="spotIm-conversations-module-wrapper"></div></section><script> window.performance.mark('spotIm'); window.performance.measure('spotImDone','PageStart','spotIm'); </script></div></div><div id=seamless-footer-wrapper class="wafer-fetch-container wafer-fetch Pos(r) Mih(1px) wafer-rapid-module Mt(10px) Mb(32px)" data-wf-timeout=5000 data-wf-retry-count=2 data-wf-trigger=viewport data-wf-cache-strategy=cacheFirst data-wf-cache-ttl=3600 data-wf-trigger-offset="600 0" data-wf-url=/eg_ms/_td/remote?m_mode=json&m_id=engadget-shared&ctrl=PrivacyFooter&module=footer&site=engadget&device=desktop-lite&lang=en-US&region=US&rid=38jmiqhjk40tt></div><div id="sda-LDRB2-iframe" class=" post-article-ad Ta(c) Mb(40px) Mx(a) Mih(90px) Py(20px) Pos(r) Z(9) Miw(728px)" data-content=""></div></main></div></div><div class="D(f)! Fld(r) Fxw(w) Jc(sb) Ai(fs) Pos(r) Maw(1260px) Miw(980px) Mx(a) Px(20px) Z(0) "><main class="W($mainColWidth) Mend($gridMargin)" role=main><div id="module-moreStories" class="wafer-rapid-module NoJs_D(n) Mb($gridMargin)"><div data-wf-state-body='{"m_id":"tdv2-wafer-content-list","ctrl":"Stream","m_mode":"json","config":{"enableRelativeLinks":false,"headerConfig":{"title":"LATEST_STORIES"},"headerEnabled":true,"imageSizes":{"default":"600x336","stream":"514x288,257x144","streamAds":"514x268"},"itemClasses":{"geminiDropdownClasses":"T(-2px) End(0)"},"itemConfig":{"hideItemImageWhenUnavailable":true,"showItemEmptyThumbnail":true,"showPlayIcon":true,"showProviderLogo":false},"layout":"stream","lazyLoadPubDate":true,"loadMoreTrigger":"viewport","ncpQueryParams":{"imageTags":"600x336,514x288,257x144","ntkEnabled":false,"adsPublisherUrl":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","dedupUuids":"[state.dedupUuids]","device":"desktop-lite","spaceId":"1197802876","uuid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","geminiDedupeToken":""},"useWaferCaas":false,"waferStickyOffset":"130px 10px","waferStickyTarget":"adsStream","listId":"79da37bf-b848-4028-9439-be5bd777b6b8","adMeta":{"disableAdFeedbackBeacons":true,"enableAdFeedbackV2":true,"enableAdLiteUpSellFeedback":true,"isMiniStream":true,"enableTaboolaAds":true,"taboolaPosition":{"mode":"stream-b","placement":"taboola-stream","region":"index","targetType":"mix"}},"ads":{"gemini":{"adsSlotsEnabled":true,"spaceId":1197802876}},"xhrPathPrefix":"/nel_ms/_rcv/remote","clientPageContext":"","pageContext":{"lu":"0","pageType":"content","site":"engadget","appName":"article","pageDesign":"non_modal","pageContentType":"story","ctopid":"1878000;1035500;10610989","hashtag":"gear;internet","wiki_topics":"Avery_Ellis;News_bureau;Social_media;Report","lmsid":"a0V0W00000HOQu8UAH","revsp":"engadget_479","lpstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","yctIds":"yct:001000963","bucket":"engadget-US-en-US-def"}}}' id=wafer-moreStories class="wafer-fetch-container wafer-fetch" data-wf-cache-strategy=networkFirst data-wf-replace=1 data-wf-retry-reset-for-state-change=2 data-wf-retry-count=2 data-wf-timeout=5000 data-wf-trigger=viewport data-wf-trigger-offset="600 0" data-wf-url=/nel_ms/_rcv/remote?m_id=tdv2-wafer-content-list&ctrl=Stream&module=moreStories&site=engadget&device=desktop-lite&lang=en-US&region=US&bucket=engadget-US-en-US-def&rid=38jmiqhjk40tt&m_mode=json><div class="pholder-bg wafer-fetch-error_D(n)"><div class=pholder><div class=ph-title></div><div class=ph-block></div></div><div class=pholder><div class="ph-title hidden"></div><div class=ph-block></div></div><div class=pholder><div class="ph-title hidden"></div><div class=ph-block></div></div><div class=pholder><div class="ph-title hidden"></div><div class=ph-block></div></div><div class=pholder><div class="ph-title hidden"></div><div class=ph-block></div></div><div class=pholder><div class="ph-title hidden"></div><div class=ph-block></div></div><div class=pholder><div class="ph-title hidden"></div><div class=ph-block></div></div><div class=pholder><div class="ph-title hidden"></div><div class=ph-block></div></div><div class=pholder><div class="ph-title hidden"></div><div class=ph-block></div></div><div class=pholder><div class="ph-title hidden"></div><div class=ph-block></div></div></div></div></div></main><aside id=AsideStream role=complementary class="W(300px) Pos(r) Z(0)"><div id=adsStream><div id="sda-LREC3-iframe" class=" Mb($gridMargin) Mt(25px) " data-content=""></div></div></aside></div></div><div class="Ov(h) Trs($adTranslate) HideBottomBar_H(0) Pos(r) Z(0)"></div><footer id=Footer class="Pos(r) W(100%)"><div id="module-footer" class="wafer-rapid-module NoJs_D(n)"><div data-wf-cache-ttl=3600 id=wafer-footer class="wafer-fetch-container wafer-fetch" data-wf-cache-strategy=cacheFirst data-wf-replace=1 data-wf-retry-reset-for-state-change=2 data-wf-retry-count=2 data-wf-timeout=5000 data-wf-trigger=viewport data-wf-trigger-offset="600 0" data-wf-url=/eg_ms/_td/remote?m_id=engad-footer&ctrl=Footer&module=footer&site=engadget&device=desktop-lite&lang=en-US&region=US&bucket=engadget-US-en-US-def&rid=38jmiqhjk40tt&m_mode=json><div class="pholder-bg wafer-fetch-error_D(n) grid"><div class=pholder><div class=ph-title></div><div class=ph-block></div></div></div></div></div></footer><script type=application/json id=spotim-config> {"config":{"conversationEnabled":true,"jacDomain":"https://openweb.jac.yahoosandbox.com","jacUrl":"https://jac.yahoosandbox.com/2.0.0/jac.js","launcherUrl":"https://launcher.spot.im/spot/","messages_cnt":3,"spotId":"sp_f76RE06N","stageSpotId":"sp_OhAqk0dS","useCaasBodyOffsetLeft":false,"xhrPathPrefix":"/nel_ms/_rcv/remote","adPositions":"COMMENTSLREC,COMMENTSMON;COMMENTSLREC2,COMMENTSMON2;COMMENTSLREC3,COMMENTSMON3","rightRailAdClasses":"da-spotim Ta(c)","showRightRailAds":true,"wfDarlaConfig":{"addAutoEvent":true,"addCleanContainer":true,"enabled":true,"maxRetry":50,"meta":{"COMMENTSLREC":{"height":250,"width":300},"COMMENTSLREC2":{"height":250,"width":300},"COMMENTSLREC3":{"height":250,"width":300},"COMMENTSMON":{"height":600,"width":300},"COMMENTSMON2":{"height":600,"width":300},"COMMENTSMON3":{"height":600,"width":300}},"offsetX":"0","offsetY":"400"},"initLauncherOnClick":true,"useCase":"seamless","doNotUseshareWidth":true,"enableGAMAds":true,"wfBenjiConfig":{"inView":"onLoad","kvs":{"loc":"mid_right_comments"},"offsetX":"0","offsetY":"0","pos":"COMMENTSLRECMON","region":"index","size":[[300,250],[300,600]],"path":"/22888152279/us/eng/ros/dt/us_eng_ros_dt_mid_right"}},"ctrl":"SpotImJACForEngadget","m_id":"spotIm","enabled":true} </script><script type="application/json" id="wafer-config">{"assetsLoaded":{"/aaq/art/css/deeplink.atomic.ltr.b0ff72321580f501d711e99fc9aba8ad.css":true,"/os/yc/css/bundle.c60a6d54.css":true,"/aaq/art/css/modules.atomic.ltr.b99ff00325ce5a1d45f23acbd158b48e.css":true,"/aaq/art/css/desktopweb.15898aabba8f872866ed80401b538577.css":true,"/kw/engadget/mod/css/tdv2-wafer-adfeedback.AdFeedbackAllComponents.atomic.ltr.f3b592877b516b3a106918443162b00e.min.css":true,"/aaq/nel/css/tdv2-applet-canvass.CanvassMessage.atomic.ltr.6b465a3b59770d1276df4f9c57a9b05f.min.css":true,"/aaq/art/css/engadgetweb.8b7e1796c6b12f70291f0435ac038104.css":true,"/aaq/nel/css/spotIm.SpotImJACForEngadget.atomic.ltr.5c12e46d3b7a53aff9d869c8059a7f56.min.css":true,"/aaq/cprops/colors_1.1.27.min.css":true,"/aaq/nel/css/tdv2-wafer-content-list.Stream.atomic.ltr.741a58671188f23c721078b307295f41.min.css":true,"/aaq/nel/css/tdv2-wafer-content-list.custom.888132cb49eb61157282573521d113fb.css":true,"/kw/engadget/mod/css/engad-footer.Footer.atomic.ltr.e39b68d7035436c964b34d52281accf4.min.css":true,"/kw/engadget/mod/css/engad-header.Header.atomic.ltr.882e3c5e0d1e80fe46ac7393495cfa83.min.css":true,"/kw/engadget/mod/css/engad-header.custom.1884a2ba3b0d04ccce29a888c1ce2368.css":true,"/kw/engadget/mod/css/engad-nav.Nav.atomic.ltr.4a7d720755042a4753f1175cd56b8c41.min.css":true,"/kw/engadget/mod/css/engad-nav.custom.f293a96ffddf2142be339d8600014fce.css":true,"/aaq/fp/css/react-wafer-featurebar.FeaturebarNew.atomic.ltr.1f38518fd23317c7e8f5c7313814f31b.min.css":true,"/kw/engadget/mod/css/engadget-shared.TrendingNow.atomic.ltr.79f84fd52f0891542989b7cb49fb3499.min.css":true,"/aaq/art/js/caas.b474e91ceab25eed94dfea60e82cfd41.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-loader-2.7.21.js":true,"/aaq/art/js/clusterSda.738b79e47ebce486951867a378f4ff26.js":true,"/aaq/art/js/clusterComments.20846888c0a2a68881b081934946bd6f.js":true,"/ss/analytics3.js":true,"/version/7.0.0/cmp.js":true,"/aaq/vzm/cs_1.6.6.js":true,"/aaq/nel/js/tdv2-wafer-utils.customErrorHandler.bcda778b736c3a054af62f437b536e78.js":true,"/oa/consent.js":true,"/aaq/benji/benji-2.2.12.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-module-2.0.0.js":true,"/aaq/nel/js/spotIm.custom.SpotIMJAC.engadget.8b6399f02a6ac8140c1174d239105434.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-video-3.2.2.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-beacon-1.3.4.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-benji-1.2.0.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-scrollview-2.23.3.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-toggle-1.15.4.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-fetch-1.19.1.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-form-1.34.5.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-caas-1.36.6.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-lightbox-1.10.6.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-countdown-1.2.5.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-sticky-1.2.6.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-image-1.4.0.js":true,"/aaq/nel/js/tdv2-wafer-content-list.custom.c55065592f3316c637717d204a89a974.js":true,"/kw/engadget/mod/js/engad-footer.custom.dc4d352d0c6562c7b8b042870c3a4379.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-rapid-1.10.9.js":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-menu-1.3.5.js":true,"/kw/engadget/mod/js/engad-nav.custom.1e1d3917db5ddbd5924f7b152ae2e86d.js":true,"/aaq/fp/js/react-wafer-featurebar.custom.default.95a7979b4c06295e22960043d003fb49.js":true,"/aaq/c/5859222.caas-engadget_web.min.css":true,"/aaq/wf/wf-core-1.65.1.js":true,"/aaq/c/08de5dc.caas-engadget_web.min.js":true}}</script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/wf/wf-core-1.65.1.js"></script><script type="text/javascript"> (function(win) { win.addEventListener && win.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded", function () { var s = win.document.createElement("script"); s.async = true; s.defer = true; s.src = "https://s.yimg.com/cx/pv/perf-vitals_3.5.0.js"; win.document.body.appendChild(s); }); })(window);</script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://s.yimg.com/aaq/c/08de5dc.caas-engadget_web.min.js"></script><script type=text/javascript> (function(w) { if (w.YAHOO && w.YAHOO.i13n && w.YAHOO.i13n.Rapid) { YAHOO.i13n.SPACEID = '1197802876'; var enableApvBeacon = true; var clientOnly = undefined; var rapidConfig = {"click_timeout":200,"keys":{"_rid":"38jmiqhjk40tt","abk":"","colo":"sg3","mrkt":"us","p_sec":"us.engadget","partner":"none","site":"engadget","uh_vw":0,"navtype":"server","p_cpos":1,"p_hosted":"hosted","pcp":"Engadget","pct":"story","pd":"non_modal","pl2":"seamless-article","pstaid":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pstaid_p":"adc296a1-bc49-3fc0-9561-a4aa54eabc50","pstcat":"business","pt":"content","redirect":"","ver":"article","dmi_consent":false,"_vuid":"GjIk7IRoQfc42zhu_Koxjw","contentcategorypath":"|","displayts":1600892458000},"perf_navigationtime":2,"test_id":"engadget-US-en-US-def","tracked_mods_viewability":{"module-moreStories":"home-strm","module-footer":"footer","module-engadgetNav":"nav","module-featurebar":"featurebar","module-engadgetTopTrendingBar":"trendingNow","close-button-section":"close-button","close-fauxdal":"close-button","module-article":"content-canvas","related-article-0":"content-canvas","related-article-1":"content-canvas","related-article-2":"content-canvas","related-article-3":"content-canvas","related-article-4":"content-canvas","related-article-5":"content-canvas","related-article-6":"content-canvas","module-spotIm":"cmmts","view-cmts-container":"view-cmnts-cta"},"viewability":true,"yql_host":"udc.yahoo.com","yql_path":"/v2/public/yql"}; rapidConfig.spaceid = YAHOO.i13n.SPACEID; if(typeof clientOnly !== 'undefined') { rapidConfig.client_only = clientOnly; } // beacon apv for mobile web if (enableApvBeacon) { rapidConfig.apv_callback = function(apvObj) { try { if ('1197802876' === YAHOO.i13n.SPACEID) { var img = new Image(); img.src = '/_td_api/beacon/error?beaconType=apv&sp=' + YAHOO.i13n.SPACEID + '&device=desktop-lite&intl=US&pixel_pos=' + apvObj.pixel_pos + '&scroll_dir=' + apvObj.scroll_dir; } } catch (e) {} }; } // ensure webworker is loaded from yaho.com cdn path YAHOO.i13n.WEBWORKER_FILE = '/__rapid-worker-1.2.js'; // setup rapid instance YAHOO.i13n.rapidInstance = w.rapidInstance = w.YAHOO.i13n.Rapid(rapidConfig); // expose rapid config for homepage-viewer client if (!w.rapidPageConfig) { w.rapidPageConfig = { rapidConfig: rapidConfig } } } }(window)); </script><script> (function(w) { w.YAHOO = w.YAHOO || {}; w.YAHOO.comscore = {"c14":-1,"enableTracking":true,"cs_fpdm":"*null"}; w._comscore = w._comscore || []; w._comscore.push({"c1":"2","c2":"7241469","c5":"1197802876","c7":"https://www.engadget.com/about-202058266.html","c14":-1}); var s = document.createElement('script'); var el = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; s.async = true; s.src = 'https://s.yimg.com/aaq/vzm/cs_1.6.6.js'; el.parentNode.insertBefore(s, el); }(window)); </script><noscript><img src="https://sb.scorecardresearch.com/p?c1=2&c2=7241469&c5=1197802876&c7=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.engadget.com%2Fabout-202058266.html&c14=-1"></noscript><script type=text/javascript src=https://s.yimg.com/nn/lib/metro/g/myy/advertisement_0.0.19.js></script><script type=text/javascript> (function(w) { var dabConfig = {"cookieDurationInDays":7,"detectionTimeout":300,"enableABPDetection":true,"enableDetection":true,"enableUBDetection":true,"positions":["sda-LDRB","sda-MAST"]}; var cookieName = 'thamba'; var thamba = false; var shouldCheckPosition = true; var cookieDuration = 10080; var pixelDetectUrl = "https://www.yahoo.com/px.gif"; var detectABP = function(daTrk) { var DPba=new function(){this.detect=function(px,callback){var detected=false;var checksRemain=2;var error1=false;var error2=false;if(typeof callback!="function")return;px+="?ch=*&rn=*";function beforeCheck(callback,timeout){if(checksRemain==0|| timeout>1E3)callback(checksRemain==0&&detected);else setTimeout(function(){beforeCheck(callback,timeout*2)},timeout*2)}function checkImages(){if(--checksRemain)return;detected=!error1&&error2}var random=Math.random()*11;var img1=new Image;img1.onload=checkImages;img1.onerror=function(){error1=true;checkImages()};img1.src=px.replace(/\*/,1).replace(/\*/,random);var img2=new Image;img2.onload=checkImages;img2.onerror=function(){error2=true;checkImages()};img2.src=px.replace(/\*/,2).replace(/\*/,random);beforeCheck(callback,250)}}; DPba.detect(pixelDetectUrl, function(usesABP) { if (usesABP) { var expires = new Date(); expires.setMinutes(expires.getMinutes() + cookieDuration); daTrk = '2'; w.wafer.utils.setCookie(cookieName, '2', {expires: expires, domain: location.hostname, path:'/'}); } // this fires rapid when we set cookie either 1 or 2 if ((!thamba && daTrk !== '0') && w.rapidInstance && w.rapidInstance.beaconEvent) { w.rapidInstance.beaconEvent("datrk", {pl1: daTrk}); } }); }; var ubDetection = function() { // primary check: create node has sensitive id on the fly const decoyId = 'my-ads'; const decoyNode = document.createElement('div'); decoyNode.setAttribute('id', decoyId); decoyNode.innerHTML = decoyId; document.body.appendChild(decoyNode); const decoyNodeIns = document.querySelector(`#${decoyId}`); if (decoyNodeIns && decoyNodeIns.offsetHeight === 0) { decoyNodeIns.remove(); return true; } decoyNodeIns.remove(); // additional check: check all necessary ad pos dimension if (shouldCheckPosition) { const { positions } = dabConfig; let adposNodeCount = 0; let hidenPosNodeCount = 0; for (const position of positions) { const adposNode = document.querySelector(`#${position}`); if (adposNode) { adposNodeCount += 1; if (adposNode.offsetHeight === 0) { hidenPosNodeCount += 1; } } } if (adposNodeCount > 0 && adposNodeCount === hidenPosNodeCount) { return true; } } return false; } var initABDetection = function() { var daTrk = '0'; var cExpiry = 0; var expires = new Date(); /* General AB Check */ var abSelector = document.getElementById('advertisement-thamba'); if (!abSelector) { daTrk = '1'; cExpiry = cookieDuration; } /* Specific AB Check */ if (dabConfig.enableUBDetection) { const isUBActive = ubDetection(); if (isUBActive) { daTrk = '1'; cExpiry = cookieDuration; } } expires.setMinutes(expires.getMinutes() + cExpiry); // Sets cookie if we have to clear (block -> non-blocked state) OR // set with value (non-block -> block state) if ((thamba && daTrk === '0') || (!thamba && daTrk === '1')) { w.wafer.utils.setCookie(cookieName, daTrk, {expires: expires, domain: location.hostname, path:'/'}); } // if (dabConfig.enableABPDetection && daTrk === '1') { // will uncomment when we can detect container collapsed if (dabConfig.enableABPDetection) { detectABP(daTrk); } }; w.wafer && w.wafer.utils && w.wafer.ready && w.wafer.ready(function () { setTimeout(initABDetection, dabConfig.detectionTimeout || 300); }); }(window)); </script><template id=wafer-lightbox-wrapper-template><div class=wafer-lightbox-wrapper tabindex=-1><div class=wafer-lightbox-content></div></div></template></body></html>