CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "publications.parliament.uk",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8eafc06d8a6e9f9e',cH: 'UwYNyFFEk8tIcmZEX8Jgvqv5tDZeAEvG22Z6h2vw5eI-1733021237-1.2.1.1-qPYs1Yc10jKPYPYFrrZt2VKicoFyOSyIA79EKT8Ci9t2LSYhACskIqpbhpIjU96j',cUPMDTk: "\/pa\/cm199293\/cmhansrd\/1992-07-13\/Debate-1.html?__cf_chl_tk=cBAoO9qVWUHVM5L7U5ZsoNSeW02P4P1Ondf5QT3VAkU-1733021237-1.0.1.1-G_YhHAwZsn0yVC_sOWCu9qUy1pSA3h6mVw297rWHnGU",cFPWv: 'b',cITimeS: '1733021237',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/pa\/cm199293\/cmhansrd\/1992-07-13\/Debate-1.html?__cf_chl_f_tk=cBAoO9qVWUHVM5L7U5ZsoNSeW02P4P1Ondf5QT3VAkU-1733021237-1.0.1.1-G_YhHAwZsn0yVC_sOWCu9qUy1pSA3h6mVw297rWHnGU",md: "duWVcXz2WDuKEAy1qYgygiUjbBujm8WJCkcmxMPz84M-1733021237-1.2.1.1-V.jgaAJtGCuQaR39IPZgDAgQRNCB8Ib_p6iDxqUhzOf6kk7lHw32ZyhVzmRL2vXjfBsEhAXePYoVx2rm.mKDI3yh35R4rMX1SSeTkoOMSFz9i5wmCFDtvki2tJlWLzy9hzGc9XDXSxhFINkCUaXoP.EytMDwctGqQUEgkFSw.A3wqTjNXxOM2pT4QSzYtCtM.l4SCNN.E79g1OxhZVkdu9jBJWejMp0scZu82nNXM3FCrYTgfglgjQgKRzAFFRLDMjlha.0Usk59X9D9kA6pFv8DehggY_OmIwOxMT6LhCIZJdGg5q8Jh5OdMxOkS6j__70wOFUx2WEogpbl9CLGadI_Px7d3Yp6G8DAkSUqfxf7czsBjDP4tInYxZqFYctGFLXdRfLOmSS8lZYMaX0z2LshY23acTumW3YYNgaK9RaTYIxBHfdBFnmjnibpcMTqFLw2W4oMRLoQdYe1fRy0X76uBWeTynxlNdf5rQC3Ib3Kr9ZWhYJ6Fb6MAeQeWxW28tqqJ7sh6QLsbzFx75stEooInltXCvS7FLt8sdpb14BCvJB885t_1m.25eUDyobpNnpEwQPLRDl5JZFhf5a7ifdFPHnj.bzqw9vjX4NpYkUj1G09sP5DIME831ihGxM1xbsd0cqwkagG5.eVKsBqsU2BWjcshl5t1EPoxo7Ki6cL86CVcxgpZt4VEqSVsXPtJNdie.6cb97abMDX3TCZrMGp9HwLsjGByBChhQSbJ4vqmUokcXaMCfQDaB3bqs9GZTDzPvPAeBDGYe19D5afbrIpA34VE9jAalQXTp7HJS_XfByujKqJFIz_sBaz_PWFv2APx5BUXeXoLj9cdoGq59E..6eki1DN8AJe7mcR72_dvdQYzLoZNVbRrFM2Df9wFOXXZqnJBqaC9H.tBw83o6B6hp1RmLBHq25fHmVGVn03q5syfySpsrMSxZ5nyIEDA9uKQcMsPnAJ7fojwGwkryBy6RMFw5EK9IjoZY8OMrsRvp7FG2NhXP5aYoLd6kgRNLQECuo9U28LwD9FFiO_dlpUl9WLqu06tIlw_CVidDZpEJ_KNIIxOY.EbQjfV4fChDxpaOf.0eYzifXmmEZ5UAjuE2EtqRG18T5BvBZ6QdqwmB4FaKRQJFPTDGXnRY7.fiPobG4BOW9nBugwegXjWd9FjQCSYwvyzya5isNNyD2FUgD9sHxYyCYDp4C6yuBOWtcSNX13HSGNUvcT4Xpu9sSB8S6IRsQCvspaDG0PQme.hP0FpnOuIC1yFqUrxf.Kfk8UdhS4sVFhKsicZ1pioAT.8e2Ns3_G6yEP45d5ZSVJHF797jhr4n8.B1RRN4xAPhQU5kKO__xYa25Pdb36fkoVcL.RC4T8tdIrEnjHs4AYV_r5PTnD89sQRJJl42YbHOUJmooYcaJlsYfHwAnD_vMnwMe2X3KIsRBdgjHI07LpiO9K8MG0qFMq7qDuLx20tcecgPotAELhOGp0LSgYNYuv1bSqpErmccP5TRSLeCO_3nzxykFl4qK2nbmMNa1KtfQf5uCzj9sdMJtr3PUMZjD.6Jq41ZXRDO6T4rrYdva2Lt6zaItJpr9iKZEGwIjjov3kQaMRI3Ct01hvmkLYFiSHiZZACSPd0JY0pCDxkAeQ9ALk6B15TXxLvXhhE_Y4J4NgAVYX3H4gRBZ5QrxrpuwYWYP25xF6ibGQ_E8eLtTQwHKlkiajq0sxf8pcejJG9r_4kHeYUkrPV8_PnVT4N0_1A5eE_Yx7CgGi5nGK1ebshkwVkBJUh34FPfUku7F8kc7jLEv167QiN_h.ejigpnONFCZYhcuU3GGPGDYk8IQisZPRb6knCIgx_kIOMPwckxXnsroVU4Md6wHXH4oeFNbknf7bbtUiosc.uxoOGy2xeG1o6O7mv7_1Dp7VO2E0j771PB08CU.xQHRTpbxUVXheJkZ.RGCylqitpDd7eKx3vss0U6YrcqqYtiMcc7BKzW5lJiYxmwyE1qNjinRzlICAXyuIgPjoMHwNn6_UivHZ0hl1J2urSHocg6U3OHwxr5ODdsWzFvGhQP8cJkFalEajxa0C2exn_MVOXvIcRyIuOxYAIwXZyHhrXF8HnpGqcBwt_OpzvF5BMlCuokRczNbwJaOjDT4WDqwVJrXOhCsOirgUEGbFqLFyhpL0iuZ4HoE2D3a2LdFtXFyU5eE1hPjjSfCvC_nGyi1RGPZdPdL5CUFkpnW_IKk9JJ9IxP0frVWe5lOQEGmNCM9uQhbBkYxOqcdnNW9xJG4TLTB.FH8urmG.hJAunzRYlPYQpwPDP5qYVaUR.Mr2jaUIWf5opEJ8Ofp7Qr8CJZFXClVwQVRFxOnVrx5R.IQL67Kr2.iuahgdsG5TDA4B_ZhQ6eFJiQmD5J61c9yuMEQzHCDBzPfUeE3d0yuUg0f5qe18TLvgYvVccoonJc7leCpbEnGqZN1NfQ9oCAJeZ.OPP39btBfjYDpa5XccpInJqoWZgZ0CTbplRTCndC6xAM6sSi88uc5cmDRs.7PLqwl5JUa3KntufVc62XROBjcjW.mmO1OiB79xQdVviIBM3L22TBoZBKt0KzddUy2Bngu4BIOnFrc3zxunioBjMliwOmgilblHlXLYu7j1yCLgmVnzlBxZIkhp9PYsR03bmpkFUWLUNvtsJij97WB8ZPDSS.xO6C5iFj3cBxbPFyivII.UE_DsLZi9bOk6ViEUeClT4PBSHryuaD6MUZ9DEhb9CCdNZk3ZlgABbgM8Q8WPmJwsi3.YGPHNxjpmUoAQhyxv4FptM8uyo9mYhAptI7OGJRW7UwwUu6FfidmgWq211CCMS6EqGbgfgcZEMWTZseKFWkVmNOAuuR7wUBoW28554fbbH_wjf_K_X16pMBsYzvl4_48f24xistdYp_rHEqXo3_Q3eszE1FUh8hzPmIh7zFbglKhs2PS9Hr3qg9BERfb3QQ.AsAPAlHkOAjOBu6RcRzrxPMGSNfdsZv848iJ4OggMwqIdwkD3oCkePYfnC5eXVbu6eg",mdrd: "OcU4TWeW.pURgrybaovpTcVBHM9sm5fJtqPCCqw3Ku4-1733021237-1.2.1.1-4pGj8ATIFRMuhsEZCIPfL4y0P6l55SkpW_cWIqBGct3UF0A9vCGmCObuooZpy4x4HbsXnvYpVfwTF0NlYqW.vBZq_WFAl68qMgHUjuUkM445H5HwwfRZTwtJmWgXXYki7_mPePnKIPQa9d_34IGn3P.se39X7VYdfWMXKJ_Ny5iGtGQFNGXX8iVowIkKsRrLgMNJQ59.tHYfFWxXCMb1X5FQhcvp1QiUVpzcjvmolrQixaF8u0B9.14O5YDzQgtomym9s2_8xtyELg7.WhhTwZ9GLc9UyJ00R2iUkOeTYqUs4JDmvFviQAPZ355L3cNNa9V.80hXyn9lwHLTFg87mS97LTaNEwkxd6jBpws0PlpuQkJVCoBbzrXN8vmQsCBe9d7P.U5OmXPSrlAwuh5D6oSUYxj0RO1C2lG9lNtZ9OUoA2tpcPJ3KldqwMciMMZczJDrt.1JKp8OAN_lkG_k1Go8zRu7eYAVuiVCHsEb2ggBppMmjzQoiab0EqwOkC7HW_VYT1IBkOvfFGRG9ehj6C43qCxJHVGOHpMNV8USkL_U5zuFcfDT1rWCIX823SCM7oLXU4ibC4286XzHlNhnLm4g_rJTClk9VgbfuM6wvOm3FO4PfWfxkE7dN6ztcDq4_VmtAToFlKAHegh1xVlvGqWU5RbmYhoZsDJYPm1E2smbw9c1FAZhuZLVN.LR6fbACPdtcwArf5yS5_Up0DQPU4dVXdMm62Xoo1Izy.4_vfFWtQFruj9UTs.IpeQmiwJbUTcTSEDmA4JzwfYG.XkN38UmVNnTfRTetNeBTou_eAocuf11NQo_yzEsZVk9j.hdrWtR3qVXymP08Kk_siM5WsLFrnepOzEQYyiIzBCiI72fcuO2Q6eSW88ZmC7.A9KyEFHmCkPPDs9JYng.h0yqEUWHoejApltWwTv6ccdMCS22jDzpD8b_my1SsEltWCmmMEFQ45rVFwd7SHCJ5Fn3vaPib1Gl8tpeKgYnPVlgZ7HSyf7FJuhwIhQ12CB1w74tl6Zj.RKcKwap2rmxnVtG9Dq81JM5fUbOmHYkOjAD_P3J_c3vxnvEJlihKvJoMpEjkAVY9Y9dJ60WguNAma.KHZAfMFscbjUgxYD.E1vUe1QgMtZhHUfJ2NdjRhPg04zQuksw5HkV0yPeGNmxdc9HNVDjlP22KbyVUJkmo8FT76uF44RivQubCQk0KywtLnf9aMFrsoUkOl47KaEpR5g3o1J5dRPZ3FzZe0ptfQKpQaNTytq0fT31ybr0wnUUa1pVbhPwasOzwQkCNVg3Bw0QqGREF.DaMf_6.UznBAFZj.x7LTxjVtoWgmMpR36OpnRGXrNJmaFkxejRi7dVWc_WRQkP90gbyds9yk2TU0MALpjpsS3_i0TMs.JpklH4Sz.KlrFi6Dk1e1h5qWIqZ.zxrtMBhmGy2XuHBmk3CqDr0VUn3S8qT4Ok4v8NLDZ4BdyqUWlwX9Q5iESuQ85.y3asO4oPIgY.A2dI2xnRUuds44d.lX.5EDn1v6H4D3pqEwTxVW0fzoEqMgJQ8nIcaN82WL2EcG2VGnwAoyJ3e.W7x44no4dlDSABvh2iS8oGZciWI0uQN0Z_iTZ7jQ14lw5Cze5o528W1T_2CtQ.5zxz_0bBx0PW78ExQs_ClsxvQGTurlUv98JBEV0u4vrZs_U96izfKMma3IRSkkI1miYmjdWcor1Cgs2uk522GcHjJ5ZKNB0sxHk6CRHqsUeuy_3WjhoZ266CJrAIOBM7PPPpMPseOESoUtGXpjkB8E8VxI3.7wjAxsFhuuJ5FQ.uRcyYrpJAkLKCKVObyi4igCxAwjzeEVnAQgI3fEMk_01h0ra2.M7DHmdNkIkyDsx1gfSS93EawAg_YWkirPMQ3NfPWcGAV6fCbSo.2V3Z9mNJhBRHtfN3hBrO6hGhyOx8z71mMZpS2kTQrTC6r09xy_89gxU2_TB1cZyB_tAoqOdofOd8dFscFuWfP1Fp45Uqirafmg"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8eafc06d8a6e9f9e';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/pa\/cm199293\/cmhansrd\/1992-07-13\/Debate-1.html?__cf_chl_rt_tk=cBAoO9qVWUHVM5L7U5ZsoNSeW02P4P1Ondf5QT3VAkU-1733021237-1.0.1.1-G_YhHAwZsn0yVC_sOWCu9qUy1pSA3h6mVw297rWHnGU" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>