CINXE.COM

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en-US"><head><title>Just a moment...</title><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"><meta name="robots" content="noindex,nofollow"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1"><style>*{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}html{line-height:1.15;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;color:#313131;font-family:system-ui,-apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,Segoe UI,Roboto,Helvetica Neue,Arial,Noto Sans,sans-serif,Apple Color Emoji,Segoe UI Emoji,Segoe UI Symbol,Noto Color Emoji}body{display:flex;flex-direction:column;height:100vh;min-height:100vh}.main-content{margin:8rem auto;max-width:60rem;padding-left:1.5rem}@media (width <= 720px){.main-content{margin-top:4rem}}.h2{font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:500;line-height:2.25rem}@media (width <= 720px){.h2{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.5rem}}#challenge-error-text{background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding-left:34px}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){body{background-color:#222;color:#d9d9d9}}</style><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="390"></head><body class="no-js"><div class="main-wrapper" role="main"><div class="main-content"><noscript><div class="h2"><span id="challenge-error-text">Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue</span></div></noscript></div></div><script>(function(){window._cf_chl_opt={cvId: '3',cZone: "www.researchgate.net",cType: 'managed',cRay: '8e74040ba8b7ce81',cH: 'CZBjpVRvLmXvwJuFlpWJ8em4fu193R.ia1wIYL6VVlA-1732394861-1.2.1.1-seAkhjHHk2NoaS8RmnXO9zE5fOHhaJ.KnNPm5BovktbfMoBgtyGg8wQF1YH.K5_h',cUPMDTk: "\/publication\/234103786_Peer_review_is_not_based_on_evidence_but_on_tradition_and_good_intentions?__cf_chl_tk=GMuQt9Kj6eqzAjRMf9weByO1S7QVkhbRaT5IkRvOcI0-1732394861-1.0.1.1-AlX_srp5ioQ0HoBcPgnrzVLCB.W8lJwkhGLcPVkm1Z0",cFPWv: 'g',cITimeS: '1732394861',cTTimeMs: '1000',cMTimeMs: '390000',cTplC: 0,cTplV: 5,cTplB: 'cf',cK: "",fa: "\/publication\/234103786_Peer_review_is_not_based_on_evidence_but_on_tradition_and_good_intentions?__cf_chl_f_tk=GMuQt9Kj6eqzAjRMf9weByO1S7QVkhbRaT5IkRvOcI0-1732394861-1.0.1.1-AlX_srp5ioQ0HoBcPgnrzVLCB.W8lJwkhGLcPVkm1Z0",md: "EdQW0hwDzKuCyOgS47GHR9CJX9CLFIA46It7bJXb86Q-1732394861-1.2.1.1-GWq4OkE_OfIPL9LdetFx8F9hPpuHMo4Lz9kwteiq0a9HQ2TYmCrOJfk6a4G1BTiOAtwM5KR0n.bAzWXCkr9we2V.Q3BVKi9EtdYVY8sx7.4admE6Fx1_0ZrHVMmQ7ASHd0jxzyQNjgQP11cJgOrKXT31w5gphKI_0ooCB_Vfq_U8az00iWrXZjrdLxMcj8e_cJRdVodr.jdJVguE6yV_UCQPoUDYAeqiMRVW24Esi9UsO.YHvH.uMWhvM_T6f2ZRHo1nC1j2d6vIA1nnif4O0CVVLcwBeWVuTgU5Of0EoFNv1PEcaxuKWKegbISPFQ5u8OQxm1.pi_8yl_GRfi45syUuOWwZRzpD9kSDnq1pKhP6j4kk52Gb53heM3xlYn6T4KjjgofryDFSsOOH8IJm6sWNAb9pJ6Ij0l_mKoEevf_SQrjlTEFQRTBr2Pus0S5Gob8jVDG.KUHhCHDCFloEjk3xV_vclLgpAPcBSC_IzNjbr14Jvy.6bAQqdLdI._.cKm_0rV6q5jDUea.FzBRNBcOgmvDce3Gg4GgptOYXJAVCPcTlBtS7qIWwINqMf8yFbV8K.2VQ_hofY8iXhRmHOdoL8Kiqwoyt6cMFNe0xd1W68FjY_2vRlx8vdK7IGEfak7o37gk0X1IDEYXMVuHPr5C_f_qLrV1QZWQZ5ZbFUk31MsG764PoVyvEB.ReYwK0ASjeytgDfXSa8wfMjSgoNqG0PSf8322gGHdLhmbMiUW2Xi.CHUBazAuveiXtp_kleRCAGlTwOOjYAE2FLjP4vOeH3IGfm60IvDUkdTCrGfw1m0zY5FMcwCzt1ykHC7pfAepnsybpZJq_rYh77_syAzCDm0ouBKif2haCI_Z0GI3a9DrK36Ga6hkJU.Rfz9vCXfVVqHz5JiWSzHCkeotfxqmxyWmozrmExy611Ns4CP5Hg.Y0Mm5mVGA.tM2Jb8tzdoILAV1ksT7MXM7h3Ju8s1JaUrpEsbSDgba32cXAVc7sng5tA2IiAKdoStL6AQ7mfTMUw43swi5qoV6YqNaxketaTxNyJc.104nuUQfJWs7oI9dPb9gkojMO2uuHMXXMbs.Ct54gIiZ4AQuzHBLuKJ5wmhJxNCZ92_UaM2ZYdE9YnryjsiRP.vrl8ylBd.Ixk0wbeBD5RVfg2hA4Q0zpV28WC83lSV.Bz2HIVY0Ab0L901TL4w9_S1AxTRKsWovmrzBzVnwNKjmacb21Yjp5gNVTc6H66PJghR6XaIdud3BrPHphOu5ihoFY5h54m3G5bvVbuafxX5T3m1WWwm2.LZL50nbdCNRfGG8mbA6mms.vWM4hD6907a2KkhksZDPc0sQi_ujLlYTpdM8ScLua5QhEuGHDEs1S05RBbd4w15RBtOs8Ja.3AWJzyO7539N4aXJiIcWrh9zlU8zQjNs85PlPLrIhbSL2yHpxYxrVzTVN8PqcoMlqWpKl5JdKMTltsjFZa.coMtXEvX6gHzLA5dBtaOAbw3JMi3bcDlrIizwzMQpdtQp9GFEH9zOWvi.Ck5gyU6KlqOk.dT2_paNFhspA6KWJyRUHGg8fSo_70XMS3uEWZND_dYK0QchLRnVS0l92YheTjn6.xYRMJsUuA_.bnatQEHI9wWUBDSuRhCpzpW8IyTh7RIEFarQM41krGu65y_KabFkN1axewxUQ8r.NBfZfvCqWCn.X.epIVne_GyYafSRaH6IsFWDnxHgBHY88CHb7Y4zebe7eWgSpozCU0RPELqJT3JmlzIFeklgG9MV8i59ClEPoyF7y95NHoLneh2LTBFEyOFSF6SlIs7qEZRO3SmNNqp1ARR3gckpWy6Tl3Gt8kBZCPGrZjqxmTInCNrmFi.pVxwd90mMJqL_ZsEfKkzD1NgMzAosI8.W6BqaRQpCyndk9wysOl6vesJfZcfnFnr5XBSw01ZQK074oUHw9Daf3rZjMRtqbG4Uj2XqkMsSuDxdrzbnCmYTejnxon0Bvtom0ReqTHsyv7RLoFVVpFahW0OcP1XSyzI.NtoO0z3eNv0xA4TMfi7TYiPDhH6M5VssbdMpBlOPpwqQZqxn1zeLAh9O4ZwfAd0RL.GV6UI4q6xJbJltEZU.ob7IjiavNLrs6un3vFssFh0YoVvkaPpEma4gKjnW1HoxmaC29jjex1Pnfw2ynUKZdfY3f1hNjEdhbdZgmeZVCeV5YZKZtfraqlO4sosGObuJaKoKWqtq4tooOLVQP.yASfJEWgT4DUJ5sRga_6lZ3zav8DtiyD4HVEVKEv6HwhCNyTnVN0cqHTwMmfDpVrULB6VlDTvonlxNGDGS3tl_tMhOivTaKSjAnuK952BYFzWScJcAFrtQ3movqNaKpuUMQoLCkSK7Qqxv1Bwe9m4_RqytQ17v8o2q66N6aSjc7OKRf2XRNIGdQq36yhK7EkUC6DazX94JAZHTO9aqPT7139Ux_TXHgjJQKNteW5mw_fVzLfz6W2tna_r5giUp0v7K56fjp1CImXsu2Xlt7__SWhPhHoerr7Xw6pwxbccf6s7RPj5A7FdC6ppHmBj81WD_PxqiakxHGr3IOniTe8acNUbIQaL.4DfJauGCGcbuo4kJ54RNQc6uic2zo7dtDkkTh401KdN_hBA62NI9Vi93w1SvKS70CJ2Rgk_lTfxx7H2imJSTbdh7wLYDwEoJrPzyujgoenulHGpVhqIb41DBQRiAca9JKo_v90TXiMqGvbyqNLhCOfqXEY5vZTRBcOxT8V4q36PgQr7amVZSN2mvttKu7JpaWzrfW6bn3xtiWGiU8fnH8amhPzech2ySKpQnZGRKTiiAVgA1aeNGL0ESVpVlyvuGVA.UnBzxlI8wuh_Iei6gedF197nnWWL375xLEOdZipsayGg50SJ9GPvq.wydf070y6krcMI.f8eP_rNzZkhBbT7bjPI3J3Ejpe4RvTKZcBeWss_3rPnhhMXHqzRVIvKia_RVD6Xd1huI.gpPKnp8CnA6cXjWnV3TDU16ioPCqvIQ.268JB1U1koQCG35ucbCqMVyhhIH2AzO5cfNtraAEbOUfL8FqfyOXcjgT3M3WymFzsLbbxRLD41mxx4MrrUAeOOzv1g1dpp3k3SIbKkmjSdGVyy8f9fpY0WxgGxclkKcCgJWJq6DWP_YAZ7wDQYd.WG7OktMaI2EFEil0Gzc1Cw3Rth66TUMin1DvE0PkkDqWXKRjcjFXkPnuaA",mdrd: "CWbkMh2EqVvh2oYAosiTUIA_MpG9UQR_2HFm3sUdk2c-1732394861-1.2.1.1-RxRrbG7JqYGhtb92uYv.Yg303EqjJBVRm9o9wtwoIBsK0cw4ht5rOnfgJnkJ_9dUgqviZC9DqOuLu4Fn8TC7RL2oVTyYOIkUK2ZCu1i9fQESLOUMYf1_T2Q1H2scY3uUzQxwkpAayXsIFTXr.ALckLsZGNKS1mLxFElLGaR8M8.j9Xx7N.ljN1q.Mmm25CwgFR7BnBUGYXQPgCCQwGi9PP1Vkh2whuG8K3amclrTWCZkpJEtYGr_1Yvg03tjPiNj6ftdGri2tUvfY4xJb3PdytNNF.jtiULCiDYYstq09jD3SxZTJixuziFgHI7MolFEDThxAu.q0WjK6g6EcKrwMvQBExjEqtfeNI98WwGpzLqghE2WDR3aZwL0gQ2dwiN3ofQicb.6xCWhIub8uPikZdxwDvrDnZCn2_BfMnY0NRUFlS2XNNTzjm51SCaoV3RW58YmDqh.ogggj3p1eUFtp5asOcGGPxqhUWPREeGKHK.qcxrQjF_LLJXx7Vf2Ri.JmlAEOiiZyq02_5sCX3fYSjhuFT_2DOnbh.e51dXUT9aMbxSDr_tkTE3Edw7Dv6RvZr06UZkXNk5852hv4h83.kZoWFOjNfI9t84zzjyepYNmUCKOG99R6yOSjAQNEt5wmHjCio7RXEbBKzeir42fZSS8wOm7pVIaj_fELmLSzow4i9PcQYHxeGSuOmyozQyYy4kOarDmCfeDyIlTaOvBXo2KhQieoJNhGhuFV_OolQ_utzElg5Ltn7e_CHyF946XV1BooZgUSk0hDwCtr5flK6AnKH2V9jM7o6cSPymJYklF1TAGhbn5KG8UXpG66Aj2hZ_elmDVqUUUCRrgeM9wb5rAyYivZ69M4XyDYdwo2BFbLDPIwKp2O6W96zgf_Ma9vsItI3tHPj_AsUxWtDwCFInaD2NwozM5.dl4YHi7UWd5hvOdxGF9KggUg4HlHsleV8NIQfo48Or0Htl1YJGkqb8FO.T0R41rw_7p6IQMkVVQqkHvyEDv5sNx7qwOozfpNw4zY3gr9GEBglG2nDDnHff5aUkZ6wV6cbC3WvIJ2CJGPmOd7l7LgtfeJEaCGrXUX_bFFeQQqJtVS449tTRV3Hxk.XLMgqbZ.dbo_q60z2O.MzSzDftHAuWkMcPF4N51oFhzL7L21YyFhdWDtLEv.chRZmqBhNAi1EPaNm6.7qBUzVY.O4t_.xh6Yd6A8Tdmb3htX9Nqmm5_iUBX4UC6irCLxuBOynFFLbnIwwuKFsPG6g2UvdXURHVQerTrFvrrCu8MBE80ngr.AH7UfkcawHRcMYF1T0.BYgxAEiWQZZJoJ_3SKH7kB7Kc22xDuNdw.9XZ0EeSYIYj9ErDibQncR6IfnPm2CA6mk4wtXo9Ajps4PVmU3rpX1rRRC8eVzfz6ac_fm01yTbgvCNglc3CEc1VJfFqB3q3YkVXhk8tuJh5MKyf3PX.4qeSbs7EkIjUG_8Oy33UHV_PYaxVLd0Ca10lllDP.iDhXX6jMK0o1x9pwa205Cdab4OBEceeo1CXPHXNh.2hJ5ExnCHbkG4g.UBcgoXsdMtYq0PBlKQGa.prSp3GHYQW_rXXSkq2j6Zd5prOK5gEe7CYoI.vUXTTGrB2p_bLlH8JNCgfIzC255B0r1udBYWcUll4q5ZRa7J1cjMWI6IqVnk5qsC8XlVHl6f379rgZc5Ba1daK5YPtUiEie1NdN7G46Z9xpT0Qmv.vzQuNwU3qhI_1UoDYlZ3_9RxVKCZaMtcDbDexEw9sA8d6qqMNFdSBgo.bRhUi0htkcfoWl6kRWceb7czyGbhOXqlw.wFSKJH_MVy9TkEBiU3W5ztWpUlP_EmNFS0YVUhU0LqvloZGMF_S15VO8nMvbGy2bZPipSfbliVI_mqVUXxlUbhLKBp8Nopd1mrj7Enlqj46sMChB.q7FvvOMppsuTt4uPF0RmhSlNkLaFp3N4t.KFGTOY9QZOWfUta1iFe"};var cpo = document.createElement('script');cpo.src = '/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/g/orchestrate/chl_page/v1?ray=8e74040ba8b7ce81';window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash = location.hash === '' && location.href.indexOf('#') !== -1 ? '#' : location.hash;window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery = location.search === '' && location.href.slice(0, location.href.length - window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash.length).indexOf('?') !== -1 ? '?' : location.search;if (window.history && window.history.replaceState) {var ogU = location.pathname + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUQuery + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash;history.replaceState(null, null, "\/publication\/234103786_Peer_review_is_not_based_on_evidence_but_on_tradition_and_good_intentions?__cf_chl_rt_tk=GMuQt9Kj6eqzAjRMf9weByO1S7QVkhbRaT5IkRvOcI0-1732394861-1.0.1.1-AlX_srp5ioQ0HoBcPgnrzVLCB.W8lJwkhGLcPVkm1Z0" + window._cf_chl_opt.cOgUHash);cpo.onload = function() {history.replaceState(null, null, ogU);}}document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(cpo);}());</script></body></html>